ML20005G603

Forwards 891211 Enforcement Conference Summary Re Insp Repts 50-424/89-30 & 50-425/89-35.Issues Discussed Related to Protection of Safeguards Matl & Adequate Assessment.List of Attendees & Meeting Handouts Encl

ML20005G603
Person / Time
Site:	Vogtle
Issue date:	01/02/1990
From:	Ebneter S NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION II)
To:	Hairston W GEORGIA POWER CO.
References
NUDOCS 9001190400
Download: ML20005G603 (8)

See also: IR 05000424/1989030

Text

{{#Wiki_filter:m y . s 1 - . . ry.g ,; qagal '

- , py . byggj / . , , . . - .. ' .. ,.

y agg gg :*gy. . i lJAN 02i1990 ' ' ' [M N $; DockehNosf50-424, 50-425. > -o i

P.

$ ~ License Nos~xNPF-68,,NPF-81^- " m_ , ..s ? < O, , $/S >Ge'o'rgia lower'Companyi ~ ' };. M 1 ATTN: ~ Mr.LW. G. Hairston, III M %:; ? Senior:Vice President - 3] ll:' . Nuclear 0perationsy ' - ' P.10.1BoxX1295 ~' s,s vny ; J~ i Bi rmi n'g ham ,1 AD 35201 [ I@

Genilemen:

ea M $1;BJECTO ENFORCEMENT CONFERENCE SUMMARY :

(NRC INSPECTION REPORT NOS. 50-424/89-30 AND 50-425/89-35)-

' it This :41etter refers:: tot he: Enforcement Conference . held at our' request on t m 1 " December;: 11, n1989, The issues discussed at 'this conference related to Pret::tionJofi Safeguards: Material; and Adequate Assessment. Your pres'entation l " , 1was, effective: in161arifyingf the reasons for ~ the ' apparent violations 'and' .in- delineating planned corrective actions, A list of attendees and a copy of. '

. your handout'are Eenclosed. -Ve are' continuing our review of these issues: to - ~ 'determino;the appropriate enforcement action. .. 4 y .; JIniaccordance.with.Section 2.7901of the NRC's " Rules of Pra::tice," Part 2, j ~ ~ , Title 10, Code-of Federal- Regulations, a . cop: of this letter and its enclosures L

will.be placed in the NRC-Public Document: Room,

j 1 Sincerely, j & r ' j e n1 d ator 'l Enclosures: ' 1. List'of ~ Attendees '2.- Handout ,

cc :w/enci :-

R..P. Mcdonald Executive Vice President-Nuclear . Operations , i ' Georgia Power Company P 0. Box 1295 . Birmingham, AL 35201 (cc w/encls: cont'd - See page 2) , 9001190400 900102 hDR ADOCK 05000424 gh

.

POC l1 ZE6I ~~ wu _ 3

- - - . - e..a~ n.,y w . y <- , 7 , s > h[2 3.I[.) h, b - ' ' m . . ' - ' i,.,. '5 F j[ (Georhia PowerLCompany/ ^ 2: LJAN 021990 .; n bi -< , s s , p'y , 3 ' L< a: , /nw t

(ccw/encls:l cont'd)-

? M

C. ; K'., McCoy .

U ' .. Vice President-Nuclear, ! & , 7' ' Georgia! Power Company ?ms ~P 0.' 12951 . ,

,

3Binningham,- AL 35201L s , . .Gl . B' ckhold, 'Jr. . . .. ! o , ' F. ' General Manager, Nuclear Operation: , ., Rs -Georgia Power Company 'l " < 'w , L iPEO.K1600

. . . - WN .Waynesboro-GAL.30830 . 3 J.y. A.L Baileys ' 4 - Manager-Licensing a c 7 Georgia Power; Company- - SP. O. Box 1295~. . tBirmingham, AL 35201 '> , ? , '

BLW.(Churchill',~ Esquire

~ - Chaw,1Pittman Potts, and Trowbridge ' . ' 2300 N' Street, ffW' . ' -

- . . M iWashington,;D.{C.' 20037 -t ?J.;E. Joiner, Esquire , Troutman," Saders', Lockerman,- and .] '

Ashmore.

. ' 11400 Candler Building , , ' L127;Peachtree. Street, NE ' Atlanta,t GA M 30303 [- m cD. K'irklarid, III, . Counsel . ! < "f L0ffice of the Consumer's. . Utility Council ' ' , Suite 225, 32 Peachtree Street, NE ' ' t . !. Atlanta. GA 30302- e

0ffice of Planning and8 Budget

M' -Room'615B ' "

270-Washington Street, SW

4'

Atlantai GA 30334~

( Office of the: County Comissioner ' Burke County Comission. . 'Waynesboro, GA' 30830 ,, (cc w/encls: cont'd - See page 3) ' ' j / - ) $ p i-

__ g _ _ _ . . . y gr n$)Ti; ;y?;l4!*C , , h y :$Q i%lhp. y s -' >+; n ' k,;4fM ' A Georgia Power Company 3 @$ JAN 021980 kiw 1 (ccw/encls: cont'd) , J. Leonard Ledbetter, Director ,

c> ,

Environmental Protection Division ~ ' Department of Natural Resources 205 Butler Street, SE, Suite 1252 m Atlanta, GA 30334 ,, W Attorney General Law Department .w 132 bdicial Building R Atlanta. GA 30334 State of Georgia bec w/encls: E. Reis. 0GC J. Hopkins, NRR K. Brockman, RII A. Herdt, NRR Document Control Desk , NRC Resident Inspector + - U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission

P. O. Box 572 Waynesboro, GA 30830 m _ _ = = .__ ... Y RII:DRSS RII:DRSS I: RSS T. RSS RII: RSS 7 - Q - [ fyf DThNpTon:jc /'t4J man re v ine PSt r 12/[8/89 \\12/\\(/89 12//f/89 12//9 /89 12 g/89 b Rll I RII: RI RII): RP RII#P /n ?O o . _: KBrockman AHerpt Q , eyes G 'nkins Ji og - 12/'p) /89 1261/89 jl2/y7/S9 /.L @ g/yy() n m - 4 . . _

yp W R - - , g .

,y

y ;* > 9c , b. M. n. ' MY', > . , p4 e i ENCLOSURE-l w LIST-0F ATTENDEES L O.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission ' ' Li Reyes, Director, Division'of Reactor Projects (DRP), RII- _ -

G. Jenkins, Director, Enforcement and.. Investigation Coordination Staff

(EICS),RII " 'D. Collins, Chief, Emergency Preparedness Radiation and Protection Branch (EPRP)', Division'of Radiation _ Safety and Safeguards (DRSS), RII -D. Goddard, Regional Counsel, RII . A..Herdt,-Chief,'_ Reactor Projects Branch 3, DRP, RII

K..Brockman, Chief, Reactor Projects Section 3B, RII

V B. Cline, Chief, Nuclear Matt. rial _ Safety and Safeguards Branch (NMSS), , ' Division Radiation of Radiation Safety- and Safeguards (DRSS), RII +' D.;McGuire, Chief, Safeguards Section_(SS), NMSS, DRSS, RII' G.oTodd, Enforcement' Investigation-Specialist, EICS,-RII A',' Tillmarh Safeguards Inspector,.SS, NMSS, DRSS 0.'Thomps r , Safegtiards Inspector, SS, NMSS, DRSS= R. Aiello, Resident' Inspector, Plant Vogtle 'D. Matthews, Director, PDII-3, NRR -J. Hopkins,, Project Manager,.NRR -

R. Rosano, Senior Enforcement Specialist, NRR

o ' Georgia Power Company R. Mcdonald, Executive:Vice President-Nuclear Operations W._Hairston, III,' Senior Vice President-Nuclear'0perations C. McCoy, Vice President-Nuclear G. Bockhold, General Manager, Nuclear Operations A. Mosbaugh, Assistant General Manager, Plant Support, Vogtle C.' Stinespring, Manager, Plant Administration

C. Kitchent, Acting Security Manager, Vogtle - 1 . . . . . . . J

,, .z - --m en+,.: ., lyi.w:+. ' y. c < 7-* ??;: 4. ~ '

' ]. . . ? ')' , !; & . - ENCLOSURE-2 ' 'w... . I,'. [ 4. t, , LACK 0F PERIMETER ASSES 58ENT ' 4? , , . o.' EVENT DESCRIPT! W - y .., o; PREVIOUS VIOLAT!GI L o CAUSE OF REPEAT .. l . 4 - l 'i ! H o' . CORRECTIVE ACTINS TO PREVENT RECURRENCE ,; ' 1 '. r- I p l l I 1. ^ i , . ' '

! L .i. i 1. 1- 1' .l

i- -f ' 1 .. l 1 1 3 ]. i ? ^ -

. . .

. , , , . . - .-. . - - --. .. . 7- - . . . .. _ -. & , y :- , .- . . l ' , -m. . , . , - , L [- ~ LO55_GE_lAFE00ARP$ 00GUIM1 1 p.' , . j 1: l' > . 0 i. . , 1. I i l o= EVENT DESCRIPT!W o . PREV!OUS VIOLATIWS AND CORRECTIVE ACTIW5 , o' - 900T CAUSE W RECENT EVENTS

p ... , l o CORRECTIVE ACTIW S TO PREVENT RECURRENCE , P f .. > $ e -3 -4 .-w 4 -.- y - .r-, -e ,w-, . .--w,-.-re-.e. ... - - =w- ,,. - - - - . -- -ewe. . --- - - - - * - - - - - - - - - - - m- - -- -- - -----*

, , . . _ _ _ _ _ . . . _ _ . _. . . _ _ _ .. , + . ,,, t

s,

4

- .-g,., . 3,y . . . , 1 . sr ' Af - q . . .. -' .,. p, ,- 1 . .. } Y$ ' e

f , i ? ' RECENT SAFEGUARDS EVENTS ' 10- ,Eme:.:: snit ,- l:.T[[:' . :2:i:s.:'- . .+ a .v. wn , l wgx ". ", ., w. .y. , . , ,, , .....: .. . \\

q:.:.v. a. . .x.w."

1- O~.l' . x. ::x::. . . - ,. . g". .a..v. .a. .n. .x. . .x. . w

yy . . . . . . . , . . . . . .

5

:$.$..:'.: . :p:s

, , .. x.vh.. . . .v.,.... x..:s"y. "x..x..x. vyx. =:x. . . x. a .a. . v '0:vXiEE0EMX'.

xxa u.v.

p*= w.wa.g.v."." v:a: v.m - O _ v.w w. .v.. . .n .a( :w ,9:v.":.v . v.x. n. ..... . :. ... . . .w. a3 .

. 4..:.:yy". a.w. 3.v.

.a a? .. ... ..

My No. of Events

v($s$a"ha"q"s:N[."g xqws. x' y,:. 0 fuG "v..v.av.gn.. . 's:x::gs.y..w:v. .. .x:a . a .:x v ' a.x:::x: >:4.:avx w,x.;p::hv<a,

,

. a. xx . w.:A ... 3 xa. x .. 4= . xxx .. . ' vux.g:n.wxx.'qs " . ..v ...:., af.:q'xx:.y":x"qw . wg~.xh:v.w:.":gv xx ::.:n. :a

, w"

.. . . .y:x w >:DE.&hx xx:hy vu . v:. . .w 'u. ....xxxxx:hh. . - vo g:.w: xxx:.w::x: '. . ..:x:xy,

.g:xx:nawn.?":. '."::..". :.:.x:. :

..v. c. .:xn. ~ , v...... " .

Ff:GOE. '. .?" / E

A. . . . A. . . . . . . . . . . . . ' MEE7. EG ".:"... 'E9p"w"0XMX . , wq. awaws. ?a :x '. .. ...:. . '. ' ' ... , xy:v.v. . :. ~s< w.aN " .: 2- , .5..:xxxx" wqyxt: w"g":. . ' ::w. . . xx::. .. . ' " ' w.g's ' w :". w w. .' . x " - ":" a:q.ws".."2.x. w. . . . .w .. . ' .Ee 1:ss . ,. vasq:a ' a '. .w 'a x4.',. . x " .

. xt:. x"n "

.

, ,:.a:w.wg:a.

y: . x y. . :a eee:22:sW:va-#:::: .;::st'.:,,h.. ye:.

.l .:v..x. ,:1"* .. %.:: :.i?M.,iis.:is:s. ..1.$.:.5...E.. *;F

. +g e - . :: . . . .i . .. .:<:." f:a.f!?ist.s.,.

. "'!; i Yis

$:. :.k..::.i. :lisi:::E .: 5 : 2 ....,.:. . . . . x. v.

=

, . .: h.. .:: . . .. . .. .. . . . . . . . . . .. ..x... ,. . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . .

4..:. .

... .. . . " " < . .

. .. ' ' ' ' """ ' ' '" 0 - I I I I I I 4th Qtr- 1st Qtr 2nd Qtr 3rd Qtr 4th Qtr 1988 1989 IS89 1989 1989 . , s. - . . . m -r---.

- . , ;- , ~ ,,1-,.

1. _ w " , . . - . .. e - c . ,- , ? l p. '1_ . 4 I t . $ i . i 'iI . _.i: UNIT 2 SECURITY BREACHES " 5-

• .

L. 4- 3- h @ No of incidents 2- < e ' 1 '- -1-

. . u . . . . l $$"::' . ' n. :::- . . . . . .3. 3..:.:.:.39:e . q:.:. .. . . .. , ,, - . , . . .. . . . , . . . , . , , ..... . ' , *. :.;.:h:."- ,y;3'//h'h* , . II

-

w .;e. ""

0 ". - i i- . . i .i i i . . iii - . . . - . . . . . JAN ' FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC 1989 Li. . -

. - . - . . - . . . . . }}