ML19351D185
| ML19351D185 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 09/19/1980 |
| From: | NRC COMMISSION (OCM) |
| To: | |
| References | |
| REF-10CFR9.7 NUDOCS 8010090171 | |
| Download: ML19351D185 (11) | |
Text
-
W ~" U. R h d TORY CO E SSION
/
d 6 /
COMMISSION MEE1ING t
N In Oba Ma & ~ cf:
PUBLIC MEETING AFFIRMATION SESSION 80-41 i
i l
OAS: Seotember 19, 1980 PACES:
1-8 AT:
Washington, D.
C.
e
(~
ALDERSOX REPORTLTG f-l 400 vi g
'a Ave., 5.W. Waddm p=:, c.
C.
200:4 d
(
Talach=ne: (20 } 554-7245 8010090/7l*
fo cfg M,7
+
1 1
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 2
NUCLEAR REGUATORY COMMISSION 3
4 PUBLIC MEETING S
AFFIRMATION SESSION S0-41 6
7 8
Nuclear Requistery Commission 9
Commissioners' Conference Room 10 1717 H Street, N.
W.
11 Washington, D.
C.
12 13 Friday, September 19, 1980 14 The Commission met, pursuant to notice, at 2:24 15 p.m.
16 BEFORE:
17 JOHN F. AHEARNE, Chairman of the Commission 18 VICTOR GILINSKY, Commissioner 19 PETER A.
BRADFORD, Commissioner 20 JOSEPH HENDRIE, Commissioner 21 NRC STAFF PRESENT:
ZZ LEONARD BICXWIT, General Councel 23 24 SAMUEL J. CHILK, Secretary 25 I
I ALDERSON REPORTING COMPANY, INC.
i i
l DISC Z E.
Sia is an unofficial ::2:se:1p: of a aaning of da Uni:ad Sca:as Nuclaar ?.ag.:la: cry Cc dssion held en September 19, 1980 in he Cc e sion's officas a: 1717 E St:se:, N. '4.,'4 ashing:=n, D. C.
La maa:ing ras open :s pubi d - a :a:danca and cbsa:racien.
31s ::anscripe has c: baan :aviaved, corrac:ad, er edi:ad, and 1: =ay con:21s i=accuracias.
)
na :ranscripe is 1::andad sola17 for gn=aral d #::=a 1:nal purposas.
As providad by 10 CT3. 9.103,1: is zo: par.. of da f=r=al or infor.a1 :sec:d of decisien of -la ma::s:s disc =: sad.
Impressicus of op -d en in -lis ::anscrig: dc o: nacassari;.7 d
raflac: f1=al da:a.~~=:1cus or baliads.
No pland1=g : c:har paper =ay be. filed.wi.h -la Cc-- d =sien i= any pr:candd g as -la I
- ssul: of or add:assed :o a=7 s:2: aman: or ar;r=en: :=n.21:ad 4
harais, excape as tha. Commissica say an: hor 1:a.
~
D**y) "D'T[
ooJu of.2.h a
e G
2 1
212CII2I1EE 2
CHAIRMAN AHEARNEs The Commission meets this 3 afternoon to work its way through a number of items that are 4 on its business agenda, and so with that I will turn to the 5 secretary to lead us through a series of items.
Some will 6 be strict affirmations.
Scme may end up being a discussion 7 of the -- before tne vote.
What I propose is that those we 8 can affirm directly, we will do; those that it looks like we 9 are going to have to have a little discussion, we will then M postpone until we finish those that we can affirm.
11 Sam?
12 MR, CHILK:
Ihe first one is a SECY-90-358 dealing 13 with the ra;ulation of --
14 CHAIRMAN AHEA3NEs Let's have the subpoena first.
15 MR. CHIlX:
I am sorry.
The Commission 16 unanimously approved a request from the director of INE to 17 be granted an extension of his subpoena authority.
Would 18 you please affirm your votes?
19 (A chorus of ayes.)
20 CHAIRMAN AHEARNE:
Thank you.
21 COMMISSIONER 3RADFORD:
Someone is going to get it 22 in the next five minutes.
23 (General laughter.)
24 CHAIRMAN AHEARNE.
John, would you tell Vic Stelic 25 we have approved his subpoena authority?
ALDERSON REPORTING COMPANY, INC.
~.
r 3
1 MR. CHILK:
SEC Y-3 C -2 5 8, regulation of 2 plutonium-238 powered cardiac pacemakers.
The Commission 3 unanimously approved a Federal Register notice announcing 4 the withdrawal of the proposed regulation changes for 5 routine use of the pacemakers.
6 Chairman Ahearne provi:ded comments which will be 7 forwarded to the sta f f.
8 Would you please affirm your votes?
9 (A chorus of ayes.)
10 MR. CHILK:
The next paper is SECY-80-236, 11 issuance of a final rule on licensing requirements for the 12 storage of spent fuel in independent spent fuel storage 13 installations.
14 The Commission unanimously approved the 15 publication of a Federal Segister notice as it was revised 16 by a draft staff requirement memo with which all offices 17 have concurred.
Would you please affirm your votes?
18 (A chorus of ayes.)
19 MR. CHILK:
All right.
20 SECY-A-80-121, reconsideration for a motion of 21 hydrogen control order and further options for dealing with 22 hydrogen control.
The Commission is evenly divided on 23 vnether to grant the UCS motion for reconsideration.
24 Chairman Ahearne and Commissioner Hendry vote to 25 deny the motion.
Commissioners Gilinsky and Bradford vo te ALDERSON REPORTING COMPANY, INC.
~
r u
1 to grant the motion.
Eecause a majority of the Commission 2 does not f avor granting the motion, it is de nied.
The 3 Commission decision will come out-in an order. a copy of 4 which you have seca, to which will be attached the separate 5 views of Chairman Ahearne and Commissioner Hendrie and 6 Commissioner Gilinksy and Commissioner Bradford when those 7 views are final.
8 Would you please affirm your votes?
9 COMMISSIONER GILINSKY.
I prefer to vote on it, 10 but I would like an opportunity to touch up my remarks.
Is 11 that understood?
12 MR. CHILK4 Yes, sir, that is right.
13 CHAIRMAN AHEARNE:
Any particular time period?
14 COMMISSIONER GILINSKY I am just responding to 15 Sam's succestion.
16 CHAIRMAN AHEARNE:
Ckay, fine.
Sure.
l 1
17 MR. CHILKs Will you please affirm your votes?
18 CHAIRMAN AHEARNE:
Sam, I did not do what you 19 asked me to do at the beginning, so I guess -- I am not sure 20 -- I quess we had better vote to hold on less than one 21 week 's notice for additional affirmation items.
H COMMISSIONER BRADFORD:
Other than those on which 23 one week 's notice was given?
24 CHAIRMAN AHEARNE:
Tha t is right.
25 (A chorus of ayes.)
ALDERSON REPORTING COMPANY, INC.
5 1
MR. CHIL 4 Ih e ne xt one is SECY-8 0-382, denial of 2 a petition to amend the S-3 table.
The Commission in this 3 action is again split two to two.
The Chairman and 4 Commissionet uendrie would deny the motion.
Commissioners 5 Gilinsky and Bradford wou'ld grant the motion.
Since a 6 majority does not favor granting it, the petition is 7 denied.
There has been a new order which the general 8 counsel prepared hurriedly just before the meeting.
9 (General laughter.)
10 MR. CHILKs It will cover this situation.
11 I would ask you to affirm your votes subject to 12 your looking at the rulemaking, if you want to make some 13 changes.
14 COMMISSIONER GILINSKY4 What were those last words?
15 (General laughter.)
16 (A chorus 0f ayes.)
17 MR. LHILK:
The next one is SECY-80-385, which 18 concerns amendments to 10 CFR Part 2 concerning discipline 19 in adjudicatory proceedings.
The Commission has unanimously
)
I 20 approved the Federal Register notice, which included a l
21 compromise -- portions of it which were worked out 22 yesterday.
Would you please affirm your votes?
23 (A chorus of ayes.)
24 MR. CHILK:
A-80-ll7, NFS Erwin hearing, order l
l f
25 denying the stay.
The Commission is evenly divided on I
ALDERSON REPORTING COMPANY, INC.
i
e
~
e 1 whether to grant NETC petition.
Chairman Ahearne and 2 Commissioner Hendrie vote to deny the request; Bradford and 3 Gilinsky vote to approve it.
Since the majority of 4 Commissioners did not vote for it, the petition is 5 effectively denied.
6 The Chairman has provided separate views which 7 vill be attached to the order.
8 Would you please affirm your votes?
9 (A chorus of ayes.)
10 COMMISSIONER GILINSKYs It is all en how you ask 11 the question.
12 (General laughter.)
13 MR. CHILK Your words, not mine.
~4 The next one is80-415, amendment proposed i
15 amendmen t to 10 CFR Part 20 on disposal of certain H-3 and 16 C-14 wastes, in which the Commission has unanimously 17 approved publication of the Federal Register notice.
18 Commissioner Bradf ord provided some comments which will be 19 forva,Med to the staff.
20
'Jould you please a ffirm your votes ?
21 (A chorus of ayes.)
22 MR. CHILK4 80-u03, amendments to 10 CFR Part 2, 23 concerning responses in support of motions for summary 24 disposition.
The Commission unanimously approved 25 publication in the Federal Recister amendments to 10 CFR ALoERSON REPORTING COMPANY, INC.
l
~
7 1 Section 2749.
2 Would you please affirm your votes?
3 (A chorus of ayes.)
4 3R. CHILK The, ICE subpoenas again, 5 SECY-A-90-124, request for adjudicatory hearing on order to 6 show cause by the director of ICE in the Houston Lighting 7 and Power Cise, South Texas Projects 1 and 2.
8 The Commission has unanimously denied a request to 9 the Citizens Concerned About Nuclear Power and the Citizens 10 for Equitable Utilities on an order to show cause.
The 11 order has been approved by all of you.
There will be 12 separate views by each of you attached.
13 (A chorus of syes.)
14
.MR. CHILK 80-336 A, petition f or lea ve to 15 intervene and request for a hearing on export of nuclear 16 reactors to South Korea.
The Commission voted three to one, 17 with Commissioner Bradf ord dissenting to approve the 18 proposed export and deny the petiricn.
The orders have been 19 approved by each of you, axcept I have not heard in this 20 instance specifically f or Commissioner Gilinsky.
21 COMMISSIONER GILINSKYs Put me down as concurring Zt in the re sul t.
23 MR. CHILKs Would you please affirm your vote?
24 (A chorus of ayes.)
25 MR. CMILKs S0-7C, Commission opinion on certified ALoSRSON REPORTING COMPANY, INC.
a S
1 question in the Elsck Fox proceeding, 10 CFR, Part 50, 2 Appendix I.
The Commission by a th ree to one vote with the 3 Chairman discanting approver the OGC recommendation in Black 4 Fox.
The Chairaan's separate views will be attached.
5 Would you please a ffirm your votes ?
6 (A chorus of ayes.)
7 MR. CHILK4 I have one other item which deals with 8 8Cc392, a final rulemaking on burial of small amounts of 9 radionuclides in which s majority of the Commission has 10 responded to; Commissioner Gilinsky has not yet responded 11 to..
I don't know whether he is prepared to do so in this 12 meeting.
I would ask what your pleasure is.
13 COMMISSIONER BRADFORD:
Are the ones who 14 responded --
15 MR. CHILK They have approved.
16 COMMISSIONER GILI:iSKY:
I just -
put ne down as 17 spproving.
18 MB. CHILK Would you please affirm your votes?
19 (A chocus of ayes.)
2 MR. CHILK That concludes the affiruation session.
i 21 (Whereupon, at 2 :3 2 p.m., the meeting was j
ZZ concluded.)
23 24 25 ALCERSON REPORTING COMPANY, INC.
e MUCIIAR REGUI,ATORY CD!CCSSION This is 0 certify tha: tae a;;achec proceecings ':ef:re the COMMISSION MEETING L. the nat.er Of: PUBLIC MEETING - AFFIRMATION SESSION 80-41 Cate Of ?receeding: September 19, 1980 Cocke Nu=cer:
Place cf ?r:ceecing: Washington, D.
C.
..e
.a na.
.s... -.<.s.
1.-
..n. s
.a
.... a. r.,,
a.-
- nerecf for the ft's Of -he
- ==isst:n.
David S. Parker Official.ie;ceter (Ty;ec}
s M id 5 = - 4 4 4 %.,.
,n e
l l
--. -.