ML19344A061

Recommends Approval of Licensee Request for Relief from Section XI of ASME Code Re Inservice Insp Requirements. Evaluation Encl

ML19344A061
Person / Time
Site:	Crystal River
Issue date:	10/17/1977
From:	Knight J Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
To:	Goller K Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
Shared Package
ML19344A062	List: ML19344A061
References
MS-71-12, NUDOCS 8003160036
Download: ML19344A061 (7)

Text

.

9

-~_

jm_77 g7jg gg gg

- ~ _-

.3

,, y 3,,;,

f

g._,;-

w.:;

L2c.X

" ' m;. gn:,. 3 y;Wr L

,_y_

. m.

7,

~~ 2 5 F W %; E e + u, n%. X ;D~ih M w :&:n.q ~

. sa

- - @.g-:,i x.. ;-gg.v..

-x -

p gg. ;- ;_

y

~~

u k k %.u s

,. G A x :; w;p-.wn.w;m1m -

~

L GCT 171977 4

4 DocketNo.:5b-302

~

t z

~

~

MS 71-1R A

a:

r MEMORANDUiNOR: ' r,.-R. Goller, Assistant Director for Operating Reactors i

Division of. Operating Reactors i

FRCM:-

J. P. Knight, Assistant Director for Engineering I

CRYSTAL RIVER UNIT MO. 3 (CL) REQUEST FOR P.ELIEF FCDM SUNECT:

CERTAIM ASME CODE SECTIO!i X: It4ERVICE INSPECTION l

REQUIREMENTS - TAC 4540 (T;38)

Pica: Narae: Crystal River Unit No. 3 (OL)

Occhet Nudeer:

W:2 FKii!ty Operating Licena: DPR-2 i

l Resconsible Brant.h and Project !!anager:

' m 4; C. ' telson i

Gescrf ption of Request: Review and evaluat.2 tne Hennsee's request for relief tren certain requimments of the ASME Section XI Code on inservice Luection as describad in licensea's letter dated April 14, 1977. Also, provide, as a w rcpriate,

[

.a ::arcty evaluation sun;'orting cny relief that i

. fr2y be granted frcc: the requircrents of Section XI.

l Review Branch: Materials' Engineering Branch Reviewer:.Fe B. Litton

7. ~c. - -

~

. Target Completion Cate:; June TS,1977,

l

-1 Review Status:= Completo, M ~ '.. A. 4.> A

~

s 1

v

. A

.fi, l' '[.7'.Y -. ' [ ' ' I

...,..s l

.o.~

The Materials Integrity Section of the Materials EngineeringiBranch has: '

r reviewed the request for ' relief free certain ASME Code,1974 Edition. -

including Sw.er 1975 Addenda;:inservics inspection requireents for the:

Crystal River Unit Co. 3 facil!tyk.lRespenses to cur questions. of..

~

"7 1The responses were c.onsid,eredlin#o.secevaluation. -

- 6:

15, 1977.

June S.1977, were provided by~thellicensee f(letteridated. July l

w

~. -

_,m ym

.-m.

,e y -

Te.reco trend app' royal [of the prop"osedTalternate examinations in lieu ofi h!,[ A'

._.4

~

'Section XI ASME Coda 7cquirements fof the caponents~for which relief was" 1t:is curludgmentithat the alternate: examinations will-...,,e ;n.

recuested. 1 7

provide an ad4q'uate level of assurance of' cccponent integrity during~ ths:T C Z~

' initial inservice-inspection period:Wec M-M -

"-- M G 4rc k -

~

7_ A. 4,;@;.u 7 y,D ;t '~0

. n 5

N

• ,f gy-w;;;..

>x

. q o n v

= -

nya u.:.=ww;g q. :wx=yw: maw.x g j G

j n,wa L

6L 80031Gu0 % Q

men _:.

n

. =.-

~., n

.n

.. _ n. ;.. :.

,e-.

- ~m g~ n, 4.nannm, m.n.,w.._,e,w w. w,_..m.m..n.e~m.n,.m.n.s;...e,e. m,:

w u

nm

~.

w...

,- m m

...w m w @.n't.9 & h ht;nA.N:th.w w O. & LW >"$

' &.f**.- f;N A**h-Sihy4*'**%:. wik 'p.i br.#f1mWS4 p !w.L. str, & ;;J 4:v k':,4-n.~w-p*~n#F.S &:h. W,

g 4.~ m ses: 7.+.4 %_w mD.Q sn; % % % 3 rue,.n k:ysu s:p M y,, W.-, w W h u w.rs n

- a r g a,:m p' ya w.;'a*u g.g w. n. -.uw;q f.,]_.;N m. m. w.., r m g.y*.. mb,

fw ;n ~. s.- w.

m.

- - - nme.

.,. u -

w."> u*' m.*,,,y. >W w v*.::m n.;

w

}

ney ;.

9 w

p.y w.y y

• z +.p.y _,3,.+y;;qe yy

m. Aq:- fy,;Q;;

,. ~:3..,x %.i.p,. q.

p

.;. m.~ <..

' ikw."-l 1 ; q'-l

-Q.,G.' % ~; y A,

.- g'

~,.~n aw. - n: a.,,. _ x e. :,.

.r,,.-

-.,,.9 y.~.a.~. >.

u

- 7....

.y /g

-a.--

m m ;. x+...

. ua<y.m., +., ~,... s :

m.x.

,_p _y, ;,,- a,,.,.w rw m,

,a

-.. - ~

.z

.a m,.-

w 7a...-

3..

.M, s

~ a.,-

w

. ~ '.

~-

=

er(m, y;;cy- -.

m:n;p:: - ;;.~.7 3 -::

nm^,p 7.cp' ;,'.:,

=m

-..y.;>,r_. c m e

-- y s

.,., m..=,-c. m e.. n.,.,: n,..,+., =n;. c. c. m g, w-

..=.

.n

.,.....w--.

g %.

- mn a.-.. _.,.

m..~n m.+

mc. t.,..,.. ~

n w

r e _...,

r,..~

- y, m..w..

r

p. m 7.. y n.

.=

~.

n

... ~. z.n. -.

.., ~.,...

,+ ~.

u.r.

.s 1 In.,our evaluation, eachirequest".for~ relief 4from Section XI requiremen.ts

...~

. ' was'reviwed and evaluated as a separate request'..-Our evaluation ~.is "a ttached..

- a

~. n k_ $.- _

%3

.a m y yn n

4,

.s y e

.w.%.-

g 3,

.wu. %,e n_,

~

x x_

T z,;.

,...,g,. c~ g-J.ewm,,;vw., a, (.a x M. s..W,s m.q%

,,o,u

/.4;p,

.nn

. :.x.g., r# es.

3,y

, s > ?.. m% ; C M R;5 -n :..

m a,

. yp,g.

7.,., m.fg.&.w%. j & ~.y ~ ' %%m., :.s ;;;fy% M.#.,A.J ys.W,htcA u

.n M:,

xWa

,. n

. - % 11. eg y,. %, ;

- P. : Knig

~

s 9 < tw%,,s e Q.u < pfor Engineering * *,..o x

..s

, ~'

' in. ?

^

~ ~

J Division.of" Systems safety c

y, W.. :.ge. Of_fice.of! Nuclear R.eactor Remlation

~,T, E 'T,

,., x s

,' i -

Enclosure:

a - '

n As stated

n...

v s >.

,n n

g Distribution-

. m cc w/ encl:1 R. J.'Mattson, DSS Docket File (50-302)-

V. Stalloc DOR'

-NRR Reading' File

- D. G. Eisenhut, DDR

. MTEE Reading File D. B. Yassallo, DF V H

.- -.RE 1,1-2 J. Stolz. DP!F t

. A. Angelo. OPM

.n. n. o >da r n.n.

nel s

n ov C. Helson, 00R

~-

.R. K. Irarm., CGR..

J. P. Knight,:D55..

- R;:J.'Bosnak,' DSS - ^

?

4 4

lS..S.~Pawlicki.~0SS '

U.~Potapovs.cDSS A-

=

n H. L Conrad N SS' J'

~

• HTR. Hu N DSS.IE n+M.. _', C ~. w

,m. '.~

6_,. ' =., <

a

v. ~,

i.W. J.'Co.llins E.

.s..

{.^ Sh00s 00R"x.. u.m,u m's.;;;(~w' % y:.Q y'r;,y,,;'{ l gW C4..7. ~.,-

w

n. J~t. y -.

2 i

4 v

~-

• fy^t; q '

c.; J D,,

a

.. ~ C s., ~

00 Q _

W.p ' D e.?

.~k_Q se.

,y a..

y w

e,.

e.-

g

' <-4.

,t wr

-r....

..w

. y,.. ';h,.a. m,j.

• '2-

,. j.l N._ g.g f f nQ '*. '.,..

que.r.

^;y e

.Q.'. l4 ~..$.,, l ' 3'Wi,

v' ;.y ' s s

ex.n.w...&,

Q4 Kff

- n$ C e, e ".

v,.

- u oo u ?~

n.

y't '.l,.,. +. n y....f Q Q.* Q :". m& &f.;

' y *'.,'

,.+[

?,q.i,

- # y.k f lw.'tQ y t,. -Q,c*f._,, **f ? ' '(YQ

n., $%. * ;

4 _;p:. ),u h.A b* 6,, Q L f,';* O ?,..

• L 4A

.,Q,g, ); :

gj,

y.,

R W;;.y o,q,

'E

, a_

g

,, e j;,.,

.q.,.

~ y 4.; 9.p n,.,

c f,

~:x,a,,CC_w/O enc W i y.p gJ..~f fn.q y q Q,

-='

'<a,

.. ~

.i$.#

$[

'd**e' M

' ie

'.)

. e

.h_ ' J*% c,.

,.,,,.g 94

,p 3

..,,q.,

..g.'-,,w 16 4.i.'

• W. G. Mcdonald, HIPC C " M c, "

'v ev-

• JD$ f..... ) -

_. ~.

. ~.

~.

,g,~--.#d."n_

1, 5 Y l'M.

• 'M,', :V'\\ * ~

95'

.4% AlW p

.f.,..,&y' "., '

f 61 %e

-& h

&f f a*.

• W^*O

.;S.#.f',*e'>

m' 3..e.. < y

7. ? z@~f M,M3_%.7 s."up f % f..' $. q %, -. a. pyy =o,,n'u m; u

.

)

$ ape

x.A. q

~g'. 4 f

.v

-. W

. g.^;. W n.:e

~. -

L

.y.

n n.2 n r~

m.

-m

?.r a:: :

o w ';;y n y-. - i<j=n.

,ma

,,"::4 y f t.z

' w w:

.: M r:

.m. ' 3 ' S -.v..cuv.www +. e*-

--*..c;--

w W c.

k > V.. +.sv.. ;;;n-., a W.a,',.eL:m.t>gns

..y.. a.k h.:. _.r,*

a.,,..' %.,;% A6 sA,.,

a.

m..,

-f

-... u.

. wh a

1

,.a a:-

, sww,ap.e.n..:. :ct '*.m-w - j 4

!r - -

.L

.u, n

• 1,.(...*y e. p.+*,?.Q.,*,LG

.. ~. v >.. s.-

..- - ; u ~,,~,,

7i

,?

- r :..

g..,-.. 5*W.1.a,>.95*xt;<;Vs *ts_.f W

p.. ~.-

..?

L$

-r r.

w

-m.a*

g4e,

s, :-

h

.[ k '

a F

.-,,,)

?

w N.= h. - -.-..\\

^T L J. '*j m T, y gw; g & ~ W.,'Y,m[.,.. f y ^' a. Wr., N.:' h C lT.M3 U* 3.s.' YQa - i f $. 'y*"k " Qs

1. -l>~ * ~. ^h J~Q.+

(Y

.. s m.%,.,

, ~...,6.

'* b, !

[

e"'..m

~s

.m.

.M

~ag

,q

-.,s',, w.,.

.y e, m p s ?

-,d'.+.

4 f

1 n : ~. '}

, -u..,,...

+

.c>

. a w

s -+ w.w nwy J.,m.m-.?

3 m

q y,..a ~ : ~.

s c

.m,.

1 u

~.

v.,,

., p.n.

..,m. q. y '

....,y r agq -

j.m tQ-- m ;

y':'

. _, '* ;...W -

y

f.3 { f f Q*

a qs

~;

y

._e,..

o "g, - a., DSh

. DSS

'S s

• + v JB a.'.

+_m..=,

=---

• • as,.<

,, gh.-

~.-.-

obs 6:.

.+h.

e. r.. ~. = -

t aw..,.vy w.a m

m.

~'

h6.

.*v=.

-4

• w..

.lkckU

$b b1kE$kQkk'@'

s.

.s

~

YoueepNhek O

• I I

a hMYNb5 Bh$bh$$5kTkbh$W1 g,g e.

-er

$ h..] h 7 Y Yff$/775 Y8 5 hgs.y A pg,.*WdtNb..

g_

p 'N.

8 3 gDk

_.]p,

-*4.

g, g

• <o,.4

-.t g'_l q$ D.,.

ef.--

-*O.

1

.,Mr.

4g

.. c &x1,%[,$*f"[

- 6. <.*~'"%' t'MM",L,,, w. s. sov.,U.nus cenemywee cryptaMe?e - easweas,Om.1 ". ;',1 T... ' p&e.sh g'7M

-5' E".P' e-f_

,,g

'.C 3GC 38W d-4mx n$19 (M.wa),es. ~~:.

.s:. &

w es:,.. m.maa.nws mn ma..

m