ML19330A490

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Forwards Response to NRC 800425 Ltr Re Effect of Dc Power Supply Failure on ECCS Performance.Plant Design Assumptions on GE Analysis Are Conservative Re Facility
ML19330A490
Person / Time
Site: Duane Arnold NextEra Energy icon.png
Issue date: 07/23/1980
From: Root L
IES UTILITIES INC., (FORMERLY IOWA ELECTRIC LIGHT
To: Harold Denton
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
LDR-80-200, NUDOCS 8007280377
Download: ML19330A490 (12)


Text

i Iowa Electric Light and Pbwer Company July 23, 1980 LDR-80-200 Mr. Harold R. Denton, Director Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555

Dear Mr. Denton:

This letter and enclosure are the response to Mr. Thomas Ippolito's letter dated April 25, 1980 concerning the effect of a DC power supply fail-ure on ECCS performance.

The information in the enclosure confirms the conclusions of the GE generic analysis referenced in Mr. Ippolito's letter. The plant design assumptions assumed in the GE analysis are conservative with respect to the Duane Arnold Energy Center.

Very truly yours, Larry D. oot Assistant Vice President Nuclear Generation LOR /RFS/mz enclosure cc: R. Salmon D. Arnold L. Liu S. Tuthill K. Meyer D. Mineck J. Van Sickel K. Eccleston (NRC)

File: A-107a, LC800425 80072809l mnw . m . w wmm m . m

ATTACHMENT 1 WORST CASE ECCS SYSTEM AVAILABILITY REQUEST

' Confirm the conclusion of the GE referenced study regarding the minimum ECCS equipment availability with a DC power failure. Include in your response a list of ECCS equipment that would be available for large and small (1) re-circulation loop discharge breaks, and (2) recirculation loop suction breaks.

The listing of equipment available should take into account not only DC power supply failure, but also the loss of equipment due to water spillage.

RESPONSE

Power supplies for all applicable ECCS equipment have been reviewed to determine the effect of a DC power failure. Table 1 indicates which power supplies are used for this ECCS equipment. Table 2 is a listing of available eqmipment given a DC power failure in either Division 1 or Division 2. No equipment loss is expected due to water spillage because the recirculation line break occurs inside of containment. All ECCS equipment is located outside containment. Table 2 does not distinguish between recirculation loop discharge breaks and suction breaks because this does not affect equipment availability.

Our review concludes that the plant design assumptions, which were used as the basis for GE's study, reflect the worst ECCS availability combinations for a DC power failure at DAEC. Based on these conclusions, Iowa Electric agrees that the conclusions reached by GE relative to a non-LPCI modified plant are applicable ':o DAEC.

p

  • u TAIME 1 . -

IGER SIPitIES AftWritG ECG EUllittt2fr 10R G)RE SIHAY, IOf-f9ESSJRE tDRE IRJtX ION T (14tm SYS"lut),

M3D MtU IEEMESSIZATIGi SYS'11M Bjui[nent Rjullament Ibwer Control Ibwer Riuirunent thscription R&srher 6Tvision I Division 11 Division I Division II Itsnatks Auto <bprm surization valve SV-4400 1D13 (de) 1D23 (de) 1D13 (de) 1023 (de)

SV-4402 1013 (de) 1D23 (de) 1D13 (de) 1D23 (de)

Auto deprmsurization valve Auto (Uprmsurization valve SV-4405 1D13 (de) 1023 (de) 1D13 (de) 1023 (dc)

SV-4406 1D13 (Jc) ID23 (de) 1013 (de) ID23 (de)

Auto dermsurization valve IP-211A lA3 (ac) 1D13 (de)

Core stray gasnp .

1Dll (dc)

IP-211B 1A4 (ac) 1D23 (dc)

Core spray [asup 1D21 (dc)

Core spray System I suction valve K)-2100 1834 (ac) 1834 (ac) m-2120 1844 (ac) 1D44 (ac)

Core spray Systein 11 suction valve Core spray System I main isolation valve 70-2147 1834 (ac) 1834 (ac)

K)-2146 1844 (ac) 1844 (ac)

Core stray System 11 noin isolation valve N)-2117 1D34 (ac) 1D11 (de)

Core stray System I trboanl valve PO-2137 1844 (ac) ID21 (de)

Core spray System II trixwn! valve Core spray System I mininnsa flw laypass valve #0-2104 1034 (ac) 1834 (ac)

PO-2124 1844 (ac) 1844 (ac)

Core spray System 11 mininnan flow bytuss valve Core stray System I test trytuss valve K)-2112 1834 (ac) 1D11 (de)

K)-2132 1844 (ac) 1921 (de)

Core s[ ray System II test byguss valve Core spray Systein I outtxuni valve M)-2115 1834 (ac) IDil (de) to-2135 1044 (ac) ID21 (de)

Core sgray System II outixuni valve Rater sutply [wp IP-ll?A 189 (ac) 1Dll (de)

IP-117B IB20 (ac) 1D21 (dc)

Riter sugply [xsip IP-ll?C 189 (ac) 1D11 (dc)

Riter suiply [wp IP-ll7D 1B20 (ac) 1D21 (de)

Riter sugply [xsip

-~

  • 7 Paje 2 of 6 ,

Td21g I (cratirml)

Iljul[ ment _ Djulp2at_nt. Iower Control Itwer .

Djulgaigr3 fpscription t&mber Division I Division II Division I Division Ii ihsmarts Travelirvj screen drive notor A IP-36A 1891 (ac) 1891 (ac) i lt-368 1821 (ac) 1891 (ac)

  • Travelirvj screen drive untor B Travelirvj screen wash pmp A IP-ll2A 1891 (ac) IDil (dcl Travelirvj screen wsh psip B IP-ll2B 1821 (ac) ID2L (dc)

Screen wash psip tozzle slutof f valve M)-2902 IB91 (ac) 1891 (ac)

Screen wash pag > runzle stutof f valve M)-2903 1B21 (ac) 1821 (ac)

Screen wash w t.r strainer IS-85A 1891 (ac) 1891 (ac)

IS-858 1821 (ac) 1821 (ac)

Screen wsh wter strainer M)-2910A 1891 (ac) 1891 (ac)

Screen wash wter strainer valve K)-2910B 1821 (ac) 1821 (ac)

Screen wash wter strainer valve Drmryency m vice wter guip IP-99A 1832 (ac) 1Dll (de)

IP-998 1842 (ac) 1D21 (de)

Dimmjency wrvice wter psip SV-1956A 1832 (ac) 101 'dct Die:tyercy mtvice wter paic solenoid valve '

SV-1956B 1842 (ac) 1D21 (de)

Dismjency mrvic' wter purp tuletioid valve Drasyency mtvice wwr psip solenoid valve SV-2080 1832 (ac) ID11 (de)

LV-2001 1842 (ac) ID21 (de)

Dreryency mtvice wter paic solenoid valve MJ-2039A 1832 (ac) 1832 (ac)

WIl ,

water inlet to anlers valve M)-20390 1842 (ac) 1832 (ac)

Wll water inlet in (nolers valve Wil water return valve M)-2077 1832 (ac) IDil (dc)

M)-2078 1842 (ac) ID21 (de)

Wil water return valve i<csidual 1 :at re.sivwal (luut) psip IP-229A lA3 (ac) IDl3 (dc)

IP-229B 1A4 (ac) ID23 (de) 15114 psip IP-229C 1A3 (ac) 1D13 (dc)

I4 fit pup IP-2290 1A4 (ac) 1D23 (dc) idut [nstp

{s Paje 3 of 6' r .

Tabli 1, pr% anxxil .

RIul lment ji) uipment Ihr Control Itwer D Wists I Divislosi 'I'i Division I DTvWs If iksmarts hju,igament. fwrigion 94 miner ~ .

14tn reactor leal spray isolation valve (irdeoard) 90-1900 1834 (ac) 1834 (ac) leut r: actor leaf stray isolation valve (outtxant) 70-1901 1D42 (de) ID42 (dc) laut stat 4mi coolinj isolation valve (irboant) 90-1908 1834 (ac) 1834 (ac) letR statam coolinj isolation valve (outboard) 60-1909 1D42 (dc) ID42 (de) 14tR disdiattje to riskaste isolation valve (outixurd) 90-1937 1D42 (dc) ID42 (dc) leut disdiattje to rakaste isolation valve (irixard) 90-1936 1834 (ac) 1834 (ac) 90-1935 1844 (ac) 1D23 (de) 14ut logi A minimma flw bypass valve 141R locp B minimum flow bylass valve 70-2009 1834 (ac) IDl3 (de) leut sanple line valve W-1972 M6 (ac) Mti (ac)

SV-2051 M s (ac) ids (ac)

Idut sanele line valve SV-1973 Ids (ac) les (ac) 14ut sample line valve SV-2052 Mti (ac) ids (ac) f404 sanple line valve W-1963 1023 (de) ID23 (de) 111CI inlet [ressure mntrol solernid valve SV-1964 1023 (de) ID23 (dc)

IIICI inlet [rmsure control soleroid valve 14Dt to reactor core isolatinj coolinj (RCIC) pressure control W-1966 1D23 (de) ID23 (de) solenoid valve illCI inlet gressure control enlenoid valve SV-2033 1013 (de) 1D13 (de)

W-2034 1D13 (de) ID13 (de)

IllCI inlet tressure cnitrol uolenoid valve 14th to ICIC presure control solenoid valve SV-203 1D13 (de) 1D13 (de) 14tn loop A cmtdirvient coolinj volve 70 -2000 1834 (ac) IDl3 (de) 30-1902 1B44 (ac) 1D23 (de) latit Icxp B contaitsiment cooliraj valve 141H lorp A contairanent coolinj rujulator valve 70-2001 1D34 (ac) IDl3 (dc) 70-1903 1844 (ac) ID23 (de) laut loop D contaissa s.t cuolirvj rojulator valve

Paje4off- ,

Tabt ,I (o :ninst) pluiptent. D1uinient Etust _

Qantrol Iber nauipmsnt Description Mader Division I Division II Division I Division II flesnarks .

IB34A (ac) IB34A (ac) 1013 (de) 1D23 (de) 14"1 lup A disdarge to Icw-pressure coolant injection (!JCI) MF2003 valve (irboard)

M)-1905 1844A (ac) IB'1A (ac) ID13 (de) ID23 (de) 14'l toty B disdurge to 1101 valve (irboard)

NF2004 IB34A (ac) IB34A (ac) 1D13 (de) ID23 (de) 143 lotp A disdurge to 1101 valve (outbaan.1)

MF1904 IB44A (ac) IB44A (ac) 1D13 (de) 1D23 (de) 14 A lotp B disdarije to IICI valve (outboard)

M)-2005 1834 (ac) 1D13 (de)

I4m loop A test. isolation valve M)-1932 1844 (ac), ID23 (de) 14'2 lorp B test isolation valve M)-2006 1834 (ac) ID13 (de) lem lorp A test to tonus valve MF1933 1844 (ac) ID23 (dc) fem locy B test to tonas valve M)-2007 1834 (ac) IDl3 (de) 14m locp A test to tonia valve M)-1934 1844 (ac) ID23 (dc)

Mm lorp B test to torus valve 14m cross' lu-p leater valve M)-2010 1B34 (ac) 1834 (ac)

M)-2069 1834 (ac) 1834 (ac) 14 04 Icxp A naintenarre isolation valve ~

M)-1989 1844 (ac) 1B44 (ac) tem locp B arointenance isolation valve M)-2038 1B34 (ac) 1D13 (de)

M m lamp A drain to torus valve MF1970 1B44 (ac) 1D23 (de) lam Icxp B drain to torus valve M)-2036 1834 (ac) ID13 (de) fem Icxp A drain to recirculation valve M)-1 % 7 . 1B44 (ac) ID23 (de) 14m Icap B drain to recirculation valve M)-2029 1834 (ac) 1B34 (ac)

I4m leat exdursjer A siell intet valve M)-1939 1844 (ac) 1844 (ac)

Idut insat exdanjer B stell intet valve 14m teat exd.orsjer A stell ustlet valve M)-2031 1834 (ac) 1834 (ac)

K)-1941 1844 (ac) 1844 (ac)

Idut imeat exdorvjer B stcll cutlet valve MF2030 1834 (ac) ID13 (de) laut Icx;p A tmat exdussjer Imuss valve M)-1940 1844 (ac), ID23 (de)

I4m loty B lesat exdursjer byguss valve

Paje 5 of Tzel a ! L eincat) tiguigment. Hjulpnent nur (bntrol Ruer niuipnent Descrirtion t&sder _ Division I Division II Division I Division II shanarks .

M"1 leat exdarger A vent valve to-2044A IG34 (ac) 1834 (ac) tem teat exdiarner A vent valve to-2044B 1834 (ac) 1834 (ac)

HR leat exdareer a vent valve to-1949A IB44 (ac) 1844 (ac)

M2 teat exdwger B vent valve to-1949B 1844 (ac) 1B44 (ac) les PP IP-229A stutdwn cooliin valve 60-2011 1834 (ac) 1834 (ac)

HR if IP-2290 slutdwn coolis.; valve to-1912 1844 (ac) IB44 (ac)

M2 PP IP-229C slutdwn molisv) valve PO-2016 1834 (ac) ,

1834 (ac) 14R PP IP-229D stutdwn coolisq valve 60-1920 1844 (ac) 1844 (ac)

MR PP IP-229A suction valve to-2012 1834 (ac) 1834 (ac)

Mut PP IP-229B suction valve to-1913 1844 (ac) IB44 (ac)

Mut PP IP-229C suction vulve M)-2015 1834 (ac) 1834 (ac)-

M54 lY IP-229D six: tion valve 70-1921 1B44 (ac) IB44 (ac)

ME service wter purp IP-22A lA3 (ac) 1D13 (de)

MDt service wter gainp IP-22B 1A4 (ac) 1D23 (de) lent service wter pap IP-22C IA3 (ac) 1D13 (de)

ME service wter pinp IP-22D 1A4 (ac) 1D23 (de) faut lorp u leat exdareer service wter discharge valve to-1947 1844 (ac) ID23 (dc)

ME locp A imat exdiarger service wter discha:Tje valve PO-2046 1834 (ac) 1D13 (de) liigtr-pressure cwlant injection (IUCI) roon coolirg'tmit IV-AC-14A 1834 (ac) 1834 (ac)'

1110I rotn omlire unit IV-AC-14B 1B44 (ac) 1844 (ac)

MR rum moliry asilt IV-AC-Il 1B44 (ac) 1844 (ac) 14D1 run cxx>liry trait IV-AC-12 1834 (ac) 1834 (ac) luut service wter piip rcxn air sayply fhn IV-SP-56A 1836 (ac) 1836 (ac)

Mut service wter psop roon air andy fan IV-SP-568 IB46 (ac) IB46 (ac)

p .

Pm}e 4 of G .

T<dilm I (cc-t int s t ) .

Equipntent n a uipient ther Omtrol Rmer n auirienznt ihsscription Emier Divistor. I Division 11 Division I Division II hunaria ,

C3 service wter pap roon air aqply solenokl valve W-7538A IBM (ac) IBM (ac) l .

Cet service wter pmp suon air agply solenoid valves W-753BB IBM (ac) IBM (ac)

M3 service wter panp roon air surply solernkl valve W-7539A IB M (ac) IBM (ac)

H3 service wter pap rcxis air aqqdy solenoid valve W-75398 IBM (ac) IBM (ac)

M'3 service wter parp roon air mudy soleroLI valve W-7536 IBM (ac) IBM (ac)

Mut service wter psip rcun air su[ ply solenoLI valve W-7537 IBM (ac) IBM (ac)

Intake structure erknin staply finn W-W -50 1891 (ac) IDil (de)

Intake structure rein sugply fan W- W -51 1821 (ac) ID21 (de)

IV441-52A 1821 (ac) 1821 (ac)

Inttke strticture tnit feater W-tal-52C 1821 (ac) 1821 (ac)

Intake structure init feater IV4RI-52E 1821 (ac) 1821 (ac)

Intake structure asilt feater W-441-521 1B01 (ac) 1821 (ac)

Intake stnicture init teater W 4El-528 1891 (ac) 1891 (ac)

Intake structure asilt feater IV4El-52D 1891 (ac) 1891 (ac)

Intake structure tanit leater Iv4Al-52r 1B91 (ac) 1891 (ac)

Intake structure init feater IV-Iti-531 1891 (ac) 1891 (ac)

Intake structure teilt luater Reactor rucirculatiry pop discharge lefpass valve M N 629 IB3M (ac) IB3 M (ac) ID13 (de) ID23 (de) leector ncirculatirn parp discharge trypass valve M)-4630 IB44A (ac) IB44A (ac) 1D13 (de) ID23 (de)

M H 627 IB34A (ac) IB34A (ac) ID13 (de) 1D23 (de)

Reactor recirculatire pmp discharge valve Reector recirculatiro psip diuciarye valve MH628 IB4 R (ac) 1844 (ac) IDl3 (de) 1D23 (de) l l

l L - . - - - - - - - - - - - - - _ _ - . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

TABIE 2

('

ESSENPIAL ICUIINENT AVAIIABLE EOLIINIE LOSS T DC PNER Icss of Icss of Division II Division I EtIuiptent Description dc Power dc Power Auto depressurization valve SV-4400 SV-4400 Auto depressurization valve SV-4402 SV-4402 Autio depressurization valve SV-4405 SV-4405 Auto depressucization valve SV-4406 SV-4406 Core spray (CS) pmp 1P-211A 1P-211B CS system suction valve m -2100 m -2120 CS system nain isolation valve m-2147 m -2146 CS systen inboard isolation valve m -2117 m-2137 CS systen minimum flow bypass valve m -2104 m -2124

(

i CS system test bypass valve m -2112 m-2132 CS system outboard isolation valve m -2115 m -2135 Water supply pmp IP-ll7A 1P-ll7B Water supply pung 1P-ll7C 1P-ll7D Travelirg screen drive notor 1F-36A 1F-36B Traveling screen wash punp 1P-ll2A 1P-ll2B Screen wash pung nozzle shutoff valve m -2902 m -2903 Screen wash water strainer 1S-85A IS-85B Screen wash water strainer valve m -2910A m-2910B Emergency service water pung 1P-99A 1P-998 Emergency service water puup valve ,

SV-1956A SV-1956B Emergency service water pung valve SV-2080 S"-2081 1 Well water inlet to coolers valve m-2039A m -2039B Wall water return valve m -2077 m ,2078

Table 2 (continued) Paga 2 of 4 Ims of Irss of Division I

(. RIuignent Descriotion Division II de Power dc Power Residual beat removal (RHR) punp 1P-229A 1P-229B RER puup IP-229C 1P-229D RHR reactor head spray isolation valve bO-1900 FO-1901 BHR shutdown cooling isolation valve 30-1908 bO-1909 RHR discharge to waste isolation valve 50 -1936 50 -1937 RHR loop minimun flow bypass valve 30 -2009 bO-1935 RER sample line valve SV-1972 SV-1973 RHR sample line valve SV-2051 SV-2052 High-pressure coolant injection (HPCI) SV-2033 SV-1963 to RHR pressure reduction valve HPCI to RHR pressure reduction valve SV-2034 SV-1964 RHR to reactor core isolation cooling SV-2037 SV-1966 (RCIC) pressure reduction valve RHR contalment stray valve MD-2000 50 -1902 RHR contairment spray regulai.ing valve 50 -2001 50 -1903 RHR discharge to low-pressure coolant 50 -2003 30 -2003 injection (LPCI)

RHR discharge to LPCI BO-1905 to-1905 RER discharge to LPCI 20 -2004 50 -2004 RHR discharge to LPCI PO-1904 50 -1904 RHR test isolation valve 50 -2005 FO-1932 RHR test to torus valve 50 -2006 FO-1933 RHR test to torus valve FO-2007 50-1934 RER cross locp heMer valve 30-2010 Note 1 RER loop maintenance isolation valve 50 -2069 50-1989 l

RHR drain to torus valve 50 -2038 30-1970

Table 2 (continued) Pags 3 of 4 Icss of Ioss of t Division II Division I dc Power dc Power C Ebuipment Description FRR to RCIC isolation valve f0-2036 co-1967 RER heat exdanger inlet valve 20 -2029 BC-1939 RER heat exdarger cutlet valve 30-2031 PC-1941 RHR heat excharger bypass to-2030 bO-1940 RHR heat exchanger vent valve bO-2044A bO-1949A RHR heat exdarger vent valve 20-2044B FO-19498 RHR pmp suction header valve PO-2011 50 -1912 RHR pmp suction header valve 50 -2016 PO-1920 BHR ptmp suction frm torus 50 -2012 PO-1913 RHR pump suction frm torus 30 -2015 50 -1921 BHR service water pmp 1P-22A 1P-22B

' RHR service water pmp 1P-22C 1P-22D RER heat exchanger service water 30 -2046 30-1947 discharge valve HPCI rom cooling unit N-AC-14A IV-AC-148 RER roon ecoling unit IV-AC-12 IV-AC-ll RHR service water pmp roon fan IV-SF-56A IV-SF-56B l RHR service water pmp roon supply valve SV-7538A SV-7538B RHR service water pmp roon supply valve SV-7539A SV-7539B RHR service water pmp roon supply valve SV-7536 SV-7537 Intake structure main supply fan IV-SF-50 IV-SF-51 Intake structure unit heater IV4E-52B IV4E-52A Intake structure unit heater IV-OH-52D IV4E-52C Intake structure unit heater IV4E-52F IV4E-52E Intake structure unit heater IV4E-52H IV4E-523

O e Table 2 (contirmed) Page 4 of 4 Icss of Icss of Division II Division I ac vower O muit aent Description de 90wer Reactor recirculating ptznp discharge m-4629 m -4629 bypass valve Reactor recirculatirq 'ptznp discharge E -4630 m -4630 bypass valve Reactor recirculating ptznp discharge m -4627 m-4627 valve Reactor recirculating pump discharge m -4628 m-4628 valve

Note 1: Valve MO-2010 is keylocked in the cpen Ersition and provides the fiowpath for LPCI systen cperation of either Division 1 or Division 2.

1

(~

.