ML19329D535

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Summary of Exceptions & Brief Re ASLB Recommendations That CP Be Conditioned Requiring Further Hearing on Containment Spray Use as Iodine Absorber.No Reasonable Basis Shown in Board Decision for Imposition of Recommendation
ML19329D535
Person / Time
Site: Crystal River Duke Energy icon.png
Issue date: 10/14/1968
From: Hadlock G
US ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION (AEC)
To:
References
NUDOCS 8003160134
Download: ML19329D535 (3)


Text

p M

t<

.a p,rj s

,y,e s

..u..,

, (,,

cn 11Is.

. u..., '. /v.

.A ei.g s

/g-Q.O s

~

.2*

.;. /

r.;,

%/

.s.

.,.,/

f*

.. '....,... s.. 0, w

s'.'.d.

C.% t.',..

S.

s.

  1. . er-f' e

.,,.,...,g*,:

t m

ww..,,y c. S.u.N 1,,,)

.e..

a N

..y

~qs.,.;.: ;

,, y m..

.w.

\\ s. s

"~... -

f1 r.;f f%>

l'y

.'l,

\\N N. T,-.}bM.. I. / '

/

s v.

g'w s l -

p/*f

- u

~-

i 3...

... -.. ~.

.t w.A

.w

.......s a.,w

.s w...

.s G. sV

..n

5 s is..g.

s.s 3

4 a

\\ w. j,,G s
s........ s

....J w.

s

.m

. O' w,

4....,

n.

..w.

.....v. Ov. t.,., -w.., C

.e

..w-...

...., O,r,...CI l \\. v-..y S m. -.,

..e...,

.C.

h rt n.

w Sc

.L,.. c.4 Cw..'c.:.

.u..s

%.,o

, A r

  • .1.e s. :: s.

e a.

u.. a.S c. C --, p..:.

e.

...a v

.w

.w 4

ri

. S w,...g c. O. A c'.# c'.'.

' w' 'a O "

...w. Co s.

4. n c,

4,.

,.Cw.o.

a..:C

......w e

-..wo..

w Corporation for f s Crys::.1 River fccility be conditioned :o requira

.J.,..t.

L.., :.

.L.. J w d.., 0 'o c CcVc.1 cped Cw...

...e p.e,,.k..,

p wpws.g*A

...w.

w..

w

.a 6

.. w w a

- u..

, C' uw. a usc v.:. c..a.,. -

. w w.. < V u.,

in.u.e w.o.,:

w....

S,,.., s.

. O.

.w

. a

.u

. w :..

y.us u..a w,o. S e.

O.:

n.Ss w.,:-COO.,on.

..;dv.s....

.e.:a.

~

u........<.,d.

.... w s...w......

.v c.w w.

There is no conc:ovarsy cacng the par:ics to the procacding ccncern-in; the propcsad ccn:cinzen: spray systa=.

~ha rdc rd d.:vcloped in :he pro ecding is adequate to support the cw..s.....;.

p2..t..

...,, < < o...,.. vi s. 2. o. a~

a.

.2

.a s....,.

p e.s ;2...

w..

w.1.. a

..v c'c sec:.n 3 3. 35 - f the Consisaica's regulations. It includas :

L

,,w...<....a.. sp.,y gyg.c.

m-.2 a.,.,

. ccs w a.,......<...,:.

.u..:

.w

. y n..

, for.its 6:s.3. : d c d.2:ailad descriptic.. cf the resecrch cnd develop-nant pro:.r-c.rn. w S v..he n-licant e.nd i:s contree:or to establish 3

r/

.:hu. M y W." -::;

s v

.'.2 ical cdditive as en iodine absorbcr, as

. cIl as ;h 3. e

>C.:..y ced conp. ibility of :1 c additiva under accidcn:

Mg 89 0M

-.=.. :

Q

.?:

3..

,_~

s

. conditions. lIf the research cnd develop =cnt progrc: fails :o catablish that :he chemical additive is acceptable, the cpplican:

vill instalf charcoal filcars for that purpose.

The Conmission's es:chlished proce.duras are adequa:c to carry out

~

the apparent intent of the board's recommen'cacions withou; i=posi-

ion of a condition in the cons:ruction permit; Pursuant :o :hese procedurcs, the information developed by.the research and develop-ment program will be incorporated in :he applica:1on for an operating license. ~ If the Commissicn for any recsca determines that c fur:hcr a

hearing is desirabic, or any interested person rdques:s a hearing, a further hecring can be held at ths: t isc. '

The basis for the board's reconmendatica is its interpretation of unspecified reports by :he Oak Ridge National Laboratory and others of s:udies of the use of containment sprcys for iodine reduction.

The bocrd did not request ec =en t frc :he parties concerning these repor:s. 'laile :hese reports point up =at:crs which mus:

- be considered in the evalus:1on of contain=cnt sprays, they do not of thceselves establish that con cinnent sprays are no: cffective as iodine absorbers. In cny event, the =ctters raised in the repor:s are the subjec: of the proposed research and develop =cn:

- program.

k e

W e

3

~

L 0

p

".h' use of a cher;ical addi:1ve in can:sinnen: sprcys ia r.r,.

c.cv coneap:. It has been proposed and.? proved in seversi re:er.:

c.pplica: ions. Xorcover, che proposed Crys:al River facili:y u.

ider.:ical :o :he Me:ropoli:c.n Edison fccility in which ;i.e s r.ce 6

eaenical.ddicive is proposed for use es an todinc abscr : ir.

he containten: spray. Cor.strue:1cn of :he Mc:ropoli:r.n iact.

facili:y was approved by an a:omic safe:y and licensing Scar:.

In an ini:isi decistor. d::cd May 16, 1968. It becanc the final dccision of the Concission on July 1,196S.

In our view, there is no recsonabic basis shown in the board's ini:ial decisica for i=posi:icn of the recc= mended condition.

Respec: fully sub c.1::cd, s

e

/ f',.'p.

.s

/

~ :..s.. i..,e :./

- /

.]

d

=

l Cerald F. Hadlock

\\

Co.sc b AZC Rc;ula:ory Staff Dr.:ad a: la:hesda, Maryland

.;is 14:h day of Oc:ober,1963.

s

+

s i4

-