ML19319D426

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Forwards Draft Hydrologic Engineering Questions for Discussion at 730125 Meeting W/Util,Resulting from Inadequate Response to Amend 23 Questions
ML19319D426
Person / Time
Site: Crystal River Duke Energy icon.png
Issue date: 01/24/1973
From: Harold Denton
US ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION (AEC)
To: Deyoung R
US ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION (AEC)
References
NUDOCS 8003170560
Download: ML19319D426 (6)


Text

-

,,,,,__g.~--~ (

,g_

.,, ~

,g

..g v- - c.m..my ;gy 7',,,y.

n,,....,

- l-P DISTRIRITIOlk : O. -

~

... i ;.

fj'

_.:.0~~'"*g 2.

"b

':-Dockat :F1.1.e 50-302 oe w - %

- -a. w+ 2 g.

',m,

,; n %.,, ~.-.. -., %

2 S

L

++a-x m

w-o e,

- ;L:AD 33...1~'.....v'

~

~

' :+- ~

~

L:3A'e.

1...,.,

.,0 s e,,

.,m., <;.

Richard C. DcYoung, Ascictant Director for PR'n, L 1rGROLOGIC UI;GI =RI::0 CG: EES FOR DISct.0GICT AT JA':UAE7 25, lef/3 FIITIE0 '417d AFFLICMIT PIANT r.A* : ~ Crystal River-LICE 23IPG STAGE: OL DOCKET I! UMBER: 50-302 4

IGSPO!!SIBLE BF.ANCH:~ PWR Branch //h RIQUESTED COMPLE'.' ION DATDs HA APFLICAN'IE ESPOEE I:AIS NECESSARY FOR HEXT ACTIOi. &GTD 0:1 /20JZCT: ?A DESCRIPTICII 0F RSSPC22: ' IIA IGVIEW STATUS: Site Analysis branch (Hy.irolcipd - Avaiting Inforectice Encloe'r1 are dr:1't hJdrologie qu:cti-us for dia"uscien ' tith th" applicent at the achedula t January T.5,1973 meetir.J, an ' are nm;cenitated by :ne in eplete end inco: rect enr. ors e wateua q".cr.ticus $n Anwndment 23 Tha qumicna constitute our anan of. cccc-n imorain va cnd cur censultant, (CE20),rittprecocca hurrLnn: prober tion of t.hc facility inaA..:.ta as te.; wla 1.

w,W

.. a.

.o y, J l.1V 'l Eur:1d I;. Danten. Asci.,tcn: hr::ctor for Site 3snaty Directorate of Li:2ncing

Enclosure:

fi statsi v/o enclosure D

ngb

\\r oo o

ec A. Glombussa.

S. Hanauer o

=

W. & Donald J. Hendrie ces v/enclocure C.L:cc L L. Slas, L

A. Schw2ncer.

H.'Fau m er

E. lianins -

TN L S AY HEE'i 3 R Jachovahie CERC

..- q -1/ 2 -< '

L. G. F+an l

l

'.wli,v le

'7

_. F@.:..W,...

l I<-p ere omcz,

l!

}

-l

-en: Jab WPia?mi. ll-~----------------------p----ERZe ten -

- }-~

6.-

,n, -

,,,,,,w,

- - - - - - - - ~ - -

. e.

1TE,]

...1......./.. a......1. /..., /

r J

...'.1.

.w-/73-Form AEC.)La 48tev.9-33) AK.4 4244

    • e s a--to-stess-g usMs
aus --.

+

W.e., 4 c

.1

~

,1./dvid,,<C.

., n

.n.,,sou uiLI. 2aG

..+2itie 2".

C'v.o~ 'u"us R i < c.n'

'ou'C~.c~n" 3 *)v.u'.R "r ze".".u

- - ~

n Ur~' 3, Doc. no. 50 302 1.

Section 2.L.2, modified by A=endment 23, indicates that the facility will 'ce allcwed to operate for hurricanes less severe than the procac, e tazi=um hurricane W, h.s),. cut snat :ne plant w,22 o

.. a ce shut-down fcr core severe hurricanes up to and including the F.G.

Provide the follcwir.g information for events less severe than the

v..rz..

.a u.g v y t. w g e..a.

4. A..*y c a. $ n e e. A 4.
2. w..O e.s m.eg v,,.2 % a.

.>..a. n 2.n.t. 2w.7.g.y e

a w v. m

.a w

w.

-.".. '. 5. w" w r.

'a' #. '

~ ~ * *

..g yg

.o n. J..C n, 6 % f.'.

'C"'a'*..*'.'.*

o w~ ~ ^

  • yg. a. v.' a....m. ' 3 w.

a A..s.,., a *., z...

m..-

w N

cy.c4 s,n.s.:

-p

. n. Cv.. 2, w -

~v~

4..,...

O3 0,.,../. 2 a 4

o

...3

...w.

w..

w.

w 4. w c.

w v...

(o\\

c.

..2 e e..,. C.o

,.,. a.s. 3

-Ca,.a C,,.

,m) e w, O.,..

.a c.

.. u ~C..,. s.

...a..,

- a p...

COA u

w.

w v

.v

e., o.,.,

,9.

.L

%,a.

a.p.

,a.

. u

,7

... a n. -.,

..x~~

.,..a..u....

v ~

2..,.a.,. u..e..

.p w.

ou u.

+v s

e y

v c.,4.wp

.'v w e 4...

4

.v.a

  • g e,. A.

e +. w. a.. - w,,, n

...j

.,g-m,,2..,...o o,/ e y

gw w.

- p s.

3

.. o

-.4 p u..

A e.

.-.3 es,.4...

v..,.,.4,,,.a.

A. a. 2.C,.

bm

,0 a.. 4 e.,

.. e m.a. C.

w.. < wa..

v.

.u..

.v..

y 2

thCSe Cadsed'07 & 2.'O[ (Gee 3 'Celcw.).

o. t

,.,,,s,

o-.,a-e

, a..a

. o v e s os.... r..

..c.. u, a a.ee..a.e,-

a. %

e

..ww..

s..

m.

>. m s

u.

eceponents necessary for safe cperation (see Safety-Guide 29).

c.,uy a,.,.v...

.. C..a.z u.. c. - u.,.. : s.s,n.

W., 8

-u, y 4.. u..

., u. a.-

w.~.3..

f

..a

.4 y

..s s

.,..+

,.a.v.D~.~.... >... m

.p..~ %.. 2 n. '.:. 2. ; :

g..e.s.v e' a

hA

%eep.

.~

1; c..,..n Q,.r n

.s.

m b.

w CL w w e.

g.

V-k

.a w. J,. e.. w a. m.. J,.g 4

.,.,V

v..J

..,. 3 J

1.

m.4m m

.eJ J

e4 2 a a e w..,j

,.4. g.. J g

gn.*w g....%

+

ge p av.

. w..... v..J p G4

...u. w s

e u

.,4

.e %. 4,.....a...

  1. ..,,,.1 w.. e 1 a..,.#..... A.4 - J, e

.%..b c,3

,.e. g, J

4.,

ww

..... sg v.

w..w

  1. 2w 3

y ob w

.....g D**

' T3[

m.

~

a.

n N

n ac_

2,.

u... m..

i.

...v-~..

a e". a. ra. -> an s..c.e a.

  1. o -.*... '. *..

s k

,,r... e,a s,o"..d ' ',. d c..a-2.

operation would be allowed, up to and~ including EG cor.liticns

( s a.e ' k a.' cw,),

'.da,... ' ^s* a'.'. u.o s e a.'a * - ra. ' a

a. #.

r"s.u.a.a, S

e*

]

a

.s systens, at.d cc.penents necessary to assure maintenance of s >..".+ 4Cw.. C ndie'G.o.

D d. o C"ua a- -ha a 'C '..'. 4 " o' e n *..

s. ~ ' '+' *v"u ". a.,

u.

4.

v.

ws oc.,,.>e a,ta.2..c a..a.a.,..e4,

. o.w4 h a.. a. d.

a,,,.aoe,, a a v.

.s

.u cc,cne..e v

e..

..u consecuences of hurricanes up to and includin-those of EE e

severity (see 3 below).

C-,..,.

... L. ;.

., %, o. a. ~-..e e.m. a.,. a..,....,. a-,.e.,w..

.,.r, u4 v.

vu u.

.. 3 s..-

. 3 s.

La.. e,. (I n.W.w /,

j...,. n.S

a. f.

a.

C+

- > a.

~'..m.

a-..

o

..<u..

r a a. a.e 5. a. a.

ve.

w..

u.b

.n L

n..

  • n.ya.

y e. a.,> 2 ~ *

s. ~< * %..s p.-

a.. A. 3. % a gg.'n,.4

. h o, g g.,

n..t,.a.:..... y a.. A 2

...a, a

..--j o

.6

.v.

3 v

4.am~

C'.'w*e~".^.a.'*.'..'.*.

e...s

.,, u. o.

v. 2.,o.e.

e

~ s....'

. y. 7. -

sN 3.:=,. 4.. u..- ~. 3.;

.v..-....C..a-4.,. 4

.e.

. w 4.,.,.w.

g4+4

~v..e

.., 4 ti4 4

2 o....

4.

,., '. a. bot *.. c

>'e'...--".i...~,..'4.,

.a _3 w ". m.

4 a-e'e..=.. a..Ns a..

.*. =...

.. ~.

c,, a, v a.. a.a. o c,.

a-u a

,a, -..

.,,,a.

.a.e.

a. n.

a<<.-,.

... m o..

m.

1,

a. 4 % e d bu, c : a.+...s~

ra..' ~ rda. d. a.. '. - " M.' '. c. d

.e o.>,,

. e -

a scg..~= a.

  • J.J.

-a.m c..a a

9 e c a*

u"*.* 7 +'

,pe~

m#

  • a e,* o 1.
  • Ja.a.

a 3

mp e..,e -c-

...a

.r

.a o

m.

c..

m v.

stati ns, an initial rise of 0.6 feet shculd te assumed for the

,. e e. o.~

.z a.

s.< o e.

m... s co a..<.<c

<a-..c ec..- u.,..-a. d a.~....,,,< c c.o.

.u....

i factors which eculd cause a EG, such as indicated en page 7 cf e..,,g s....,., L.,g,..ya.a

.u m

a, o.,

D... ra.u..,. r

+v. a A <, + g. w v a g,. a gg es,.. e n a A.

m.3 wo v

..ae j

2.

. s.a. :... a.

z W.

..u%

.a f

D l

.s c

h wo c

.b 13 1

t

m 3-i b.

Hurricane wind speed adjustments, when the s cra is apprcaching cicsely to shore,-are discussed in the referencei and HG 7-97 Appendix 2e.

However, surface wind speei reduc icns at two miles offshore wculd produce more conservative surge estimates than wculd the selected -hree mile value.

If reference can 'ce made, however, to documented evidence that wini speed reducticns can be assumed further offshore, this less cor.-

servat,.ve assumpt,cn wcu.ua be acceptaa.e.

.-,...,.., r... a c,. s,,. :.,.. ~

_a.

n....

c,,....o->..a...

.m...2

. v..

m..

n.z.<.,

y m. _~ < c a +v : c.., n. e. s..._a n a,

p...- - g.. a... ::
n...:a. n. n..,

s.-

=gge.a c..

.u.p.

m.

v.

4

.e. 0,4.4 w

9 wo 4

%.3s %ep

e. v-u,,,..4 4 v.. c.. SUw.eay..r 4 w e -.,

p

.e...

n. a --~

o o w..

e.

o 2.

. 3,..,.. a -

.g a 4 g a..,.

v. cu.

u' c' a"u'. "y

  1. ..*.. a~

c" ". ' "._' u#

"o S. "g"a.**.*..*.~;".,

of v s. e *.-.M.

4* 5 *

3. E..g.p., v e g

M,

  • 2.4.)
  • E.
  • .a.,.*..

s 2 **

  • = h.. g P

1 M.E E. M,,. O. y v... C y-..

-.p

.w..

v v.

j v.

..v

% e c...%.s u,.

a.r.

2 o. r A_.

v i,.

i.v...w.,e...

  • I

-er;

.s.. A :... w

+

A 1.. o 4,- e.. e.

c.%., a v'..,. g

-o.

p

.c.a.n m

me v..

.a w

.w w,

aL u.

. v4 -

w..

w v._,

g.

p [

  • ! p.,.g *.._ C.

O,.O,,. *I.b.

.","*A'

( w, r g..,v C,.a. 4

. v=,,e...s.

N c., J *

  • b..a aw..

.w G

.p y, ; -

'.," f., +..c.. ~ A u.. p

. C,.,. e < o,. -

eA

.1 c.. e..

a. 3 2
e....

.v.

._,.s a.

9.-

~' c

_=v -c.

1e'. e

  • a a o-b a c~ *4 cn =.~u"n "i c,t,'

o. y u.~a.~ =. ~ a

.v.

v.

m

.e 4>

- ee o

a._. _ e. 4 o

_x 4... w4 4 s m.s v_

a.,-4ca.,

., es, A

. s ay v

(20 knots), and includes a two foot water level reducticn for a

ak."u' a+e e.. c.'

  • .*..a.

.c o-.

d o. "< a ~.

a -

-^ v'.da.

ye....a.

'. ' o c 4.'. 3.-

..s

- - e... s.t, e. a...,

e.,. A.

e..:.,...

(~

,. e e n. a e... ),

e.. a., n e. v a.:.. A 2

.,.c. 71 v..a. 2.

. + :.

.~,

4:......

a a c C C _ n. a... a.

w... a.a.o..

a.e w.

c,,.

c. c vs. -, _ g.a..

-s....

a..

a_

nJ...p.,.,/,.

o.

m

,4 i

~

structure, systen and component identified in question 2 above. Discuss the applicability of ycur model studie.s. for estinating runup for the more severe water levels and.tave conditiens discussed herein.

v ~.,. c..r ~. _, a. <. 3 a..=

a

.o.v L.

=. r c v..= a. r.u..a. ~ ~...a.

1.u

a..

...+..+. vn. _

a s

v m

o.

service water pumps.

5 Provide documentation that the soil-cement embankment protecticn you prepcse is adequate to withstand the static and dynamic

. > e...

r

,_e.,.

a.,. _, o.,,.. -... a c., -.

2.. ; 2..,, e a.

cv-.m. e. 3..,,, c, v.

a c er

.2 2..

m.

s....-

in questien 3 above, if re:uired to rrevent a less cf functicn of s

o on c.. c.,. a., ~..._.,.

, a...

_a,

,...:.o-.

i_:tz.eo.

v.

s u,,o..., g. _ a-m,, ;

reference to other ccastal fr.cilities which ha'te e:gerienced 1 m o.-2...,.,_,.,_,ao.,.

.s..o. c.-,,,,., v a _-.a. _.t.,.

c c..a_2..cne,

.,_ n_a

_u..v..,,.

v

_ o m.,,._ 4 u c.. o... e. 4,, e c, o,m 4,

e...,

. o

.o.,,u _..,,.,.

..o3..,. 2.

-.,.a e.

... s v u u,..

,a..,.,....

w.,... u.__,,

.o ->,,-,_

uz <,.

a...<.s.,,,,.;,

.c,,.,.

..,e-n a,

..a v...

.y..

-. v o s,u

,. n. v,.1.,..,,o v4.s..s ~=.d. wa".a.

c v a."+..p '..a.7 o ' *...e a ", u.'a~_ =_..

o av.,.

~.,.s, s.s.

a,

a. a.

a..,_,.._a..a

,,o.]..

e... 4.- 4.,,

j

..4,-..--a -aa

_ m o.

v.

cenpenents necessarv for safe operation > and those required for s

cold shutdown and maintenance thereof to withstand the fclieving:

a.

Failures cf units 1 and 2 facilities, or any other ncn-c a. m.] e., 4.. 4

4.., s.

.,,.,..,,u. ~ c.,: e n, ro. w... 4.,

..g o.

o 4...

..s.

..a.-_.

D**

3' cc v.

a t

I r

I N

k

,q 5

b.

Rainfall and spray, either assceinted with severe hurricar.es, or independently thereof.

For instance, d,iscuss the ability of site drainage, including the roofs of safe /-

related structures and exterior penetrations, to safely :cre or pass runoff without a less of functicn.

\\

D**

  • ' D

' T

.S...m em

_e-

.