ML19319A797

Grants Util & Vendor Request to Withhold from Disclosure Util 770831 Rept, Response to NRC Request for Info on Reactor Vessel Matl Surveillance Program, (Ref 10CFR2.790)

ML19319A797
Person / Time
Site:	Oconee
Issue date:	12/07/1977
From:	Schwencer A Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
To:	Parker W DUKE POWER CO.
References
NUDOCS 7912130742
Download: ML19319A797 (3)

Text

. _..

W Q*54c6g i : A9 M&yp.. g.qygg.yggW)@;gQg%y'skll&g&@g[

my-py gf IhMI M f W W @ h,;l $ $. & p g & gJ.

f~

7TEiM fh WW.

? QQGM?

.&% 4N e mm.wW W

.g3,Jg. a

.gy..

pn-m g :% wm: L_

,%,gb<M,k, n % W ' ' y._%pg p o.., ;.,Ws

.s H m..m,mwn <.

n':~n e+.-:.n.~~ :.~. <:y>::

..Q:. b. '.f.

%W a:.

4.

.: u. ~, ~..,.- w n.-

sq w

,DEC.....B77cw we;:

.. s..;3 ;:u....

. +

u s.

,.w y wno

~

a A m. w w ; a ; n'-

Mqw m

at e

s~

r

w..

e i ~ y. ~. :p}lm. N wy :, xs e:w. prm,' g n y n c nIsTR se e~

cep;

)n ; q.

p u

_.:.m:

m NRC PDR

)>- a,,,..

y ;a.9. s ;,.a.... er w ~, - ;- _.~w-

~ a.cc: (

s:L.

q, q,.c.;w.. I W 'w 2

x. s a m. a-. -

-- g en, u,

U.2:'.

n..F.., :..:..c : s.

O

" 7 M W7 x A., 50-270 N e g % g g y M v% %,n$ L?PDR~(*}4.M. W !.V.N L..

yv 1

EtL W

..c

-> gqggyg;gqy-

-2 Z 'y $.: :A':V5t llos e Q v s r i s

e s

s.

. gpy u,;

NG E

5 KRGoller:M HSmitW c

~., ~ g.and. 50-287 g ~; g? W D :

n c

p., cp.ypo 7tf;.TJCarterfEGrayf File -

~ j, g

s.

.~

w,.. p

,.g m _ g -

v.. c ASchwencer',.'

Duke' Power CompanyGY;L DNeighbor,sw j

]{ '

~

7. pu g g p _.y ;g~.s GZwetzig y y p,g-

?

.s 7

h 4Vfce'Presidiat75 team ProdustionX.f3 J.S.ysRDiggs

. - MATTNdMr." William D.; Parker. Jr; t a',.._

.m g.ggg s

v!Wc MOI &E,(5)Y;m.S@My

.W SSheppardyy g

' Ju

"'"422_ South Church (StreetNU M A-4 Post Office Box:2178 NWM g' i M F.

Y<

.DEf senhut W WF.

^"

~

iCharlottes North: Carolina *2824EZ '.: ms < f JCooke, OELD q. ;

R, eE i

d?

7 WFJRBucnanan' i

AT entlemenR4JDf6M@a/F GM M ; Z@ y j W W Y h 2TBAbernathy ; ~

. M G

ME m*

m, O:ACRS -(16).&

,a.

M Mh

. 9 M,e w..m.

u-.

f.

8y. yourra,pplf'catiea_ dated l August 31M 1977sJou sutmitted('

a. m w.

~ w n

x; 5

y each for Oconee.1, 2,6 nd a

PM!nformation en.ReactorsYessell.Meterial Survelliance Program and re-t N? N

- ' quested that-1t;be withheld from public-disc 1osure pursuant,tc.:10 CFR: "

1

2.790c ;Youriletter. also enclosed an affidavit by Mr. James H. ; Taylor i of the Babcoct & Wilcox Compaay (S&W) dated August. 12,;1977.;in. support 1

l

. m,. a withholding request u g, w c.8 a.3 2

. of the n R N e h. a/ 9 l %.c w;y~_.; u y, y g.i, J

Mx-m., - \\

s w 4.. a, m. y a 36. m-a-w

.u c :o y q c -;:

ym.~ ;...

~.

>a

'B&W'; :r(easonsifor requesting that'the data' be withheld fren'public dis-

.V, s

f g

. closure were that the.information was' developed at considerable cost to

' them over?a three year period;11t is.not available in open literature 4

or elsewhere.on the'open market.'and.the market potential for thisf,/

technology'has a significant' dollar value;'therefore, its" disclosure - -.c

~ is 'likely:.ta cassefsabstantial harm to B&W's competitive position.F f

We have review _e.f.# ;', s q..::n ' w.- ~..

, p... - y :

me.2. =

.c,.

j 3

msv-

~.

3-d yourf application, the materialg.and the. affidavit based- ?;

~.

on the requirements.and. criteria etc10lCFR12.790 and have detersiped - ' -. 9;.

r E.,.c.that the:above-meetioned_' documents sceghtito be'sithheld contain' trade ~ ~ t l l

WNsecrets.or privileged commerci.al'.or financ,.,%n.f.ormatioiA Me.

J.c.- M..

~

ia M a~

.n~j ; Gt ; '

w.,

)g m,gkG >.^f-&f. j' y H,

&.,Q:Q. Q & ' Q. a,.g j*-: R *, 3~%'

.~ n. n..

a n

.....g^

l F

e~ vp@%s$We havefalse fhand atcthis

+(Je cr time' that 7theAght'shthe~ publictto'he lfW1Ty Jg:l 3

f,apprisedgthoce'~pl' ~ ishiciffe'icogrle;tarpiWtails regardingithe7M.G JM l g reacter.;essed.

av surve111ance program'does.netieutweigh the. " 9. M 1

^

Y Tdemonstreted3encerslfbrfyrstection':of. Batt*fcompetitive posittenEcon. %iF !

1 :9.DMsfeerableTdeta11s5e(thersubjectiprogras"trelavailableTin;the Pubite< G 3F1

[t vgggocusest"RoenitalTapisel:Re' ports BAW-1%W(Revistemidated October 1973).

~

% F f and 3806101004 (dated February 1975) entitled]Reacter1 Vessel heteriak t E @,.,,h. e M M p W d. % m.

, V.s Surveillance _ Program.".y,$. @.,., @m

?-

t e m.

.;, m., 4, ;.y *s.thq,,b..

, ~. - <

m

.c m-J g..g g ". 4 c.g

,;.M,

,g.

,;y, g

s; q,

s.y;g w

.,.m wm,

.-n.

s.

m. a.x,y o. y.

y,

r

y

,~.

,ra w x,-*yh-.,.x,.%g

#--sg V,, ~

.s.

. s.p,m y _,

w.

. - +

+

--e r.

.. ; m :: x 8.. 4 4,g e.if

,.- n2 6 'q%s. - - [%p Cs' h,

w

s...*u

. '7,M.Y.

~ g m u'~.,.+ s; w. 4 e.' *Q', \\,+

wa' m* E* 4..

...s 1

f 4 t

a.*,

x :. j +

t'..

g

,L f sp

.t

... o w y ~.c.1 x%.o g z.,

-w.+

a, 9 e w w. m.n u., w m Ntw 4. ; nw. ~. s w

W.

. m.wW,..v.. - i,, p 1

• y; - t o eW - myc w-- e;....

7 - t,.. % y : %y.4.,,. - y Y

.67

[

7, M $ a.M,e

• M '

,y*

4 $),,. e, f f

h* l:[kf&&f,&&&,0?.

MAal*&j f

• 7ede # f N

• Wee?$EL45'. dessM Y.W.<

g *y 3 y y:

7 o ;;;+ w

> 6. ;i'..

O w".*

~ E.<. # ~.$ j . =

• 7 w.

F e.n u n o y y 7

.n.-w w~, .e- ~u.;,.c.v+w ., n.. kmg k h hh hh[ f h,w$ h~~.'3h' f ^ %q ww w eh.,y, MDuke Pimer Company 2N/tWYEWWF~My$,. w.. w,m # w y o m., s. - 7 w a. m$ , g. m m..,. ~.s,. %a,,m m.g.9m v. a n a ;.. _ gen u. a.m g x . m m.a ..MfW f ~ Y w yQ: w. ..,.n ~ %. m% $w.+:# $ %c~Q,m.,w 2 2. W.#...;;:x.4,c. mnw&W?!%h+N MW m W n x.,%. .~r.,.~.., ..m ..... n.n r . ~, yu x ,. +w , n m...e. x x,. ~~.n....~. e.

. g n

. w. We therefore approve your; request for> ithholding pursuant ~ to"Section' = ;O,jA e w w 22.7W of 10 CFR Part 2 and:are withholding the information:on reac. torx ..M. J . isvessel material. surveillance, program from public inspection as pro-# $5 - pr1etary.. y a. . y.au v.%, '

-. a / n.s: sg.

JJ Om.;, s;% y ,,,q.w . - ~pmg; g..- ;g. m*. g w s, a. 6 s - .e ..c. Withholding from pub 1fcfinspection shall _not affect the right, if;anyr,[ of~ persons properly.and directly concerned to inspect the documents.., 9: If.the need arises, we may send copies of this information. to our i _ s consultants werking in this~ area. We will.,of' course, assure;that. ~ *& -the consu_1tants have'sfgned the appropriate-agreements for handling. . n.. @w > proprietary datak ( " f x.. 'mZ Th.. O.n, g &w e.S T? .w, '.v.. -,. ~ s ~. . x.,n.... .? ,,n: .m....-. ,qn .,.g.s.,. 4 x .3 4 LIf the basis for~ withholding:this information from public inspection " y' ,C .N should change in the. future such that(thel information could;then be y'.J. made available~ for publi.c; inspection, you should promptly notify tite 4~ NRC. . s M Q. a 4* v. . - ~ ~ m ,.. - L *':y. 'r.-- N,, iSincerely,. o.. + .s. -:w _ q 7. h *Q ,.~w' f e.- *, s. 6- ?._ .,,t.A'.- ',#..,_,so.4.- ^^ p ,a 9 , j.. a - 2 4 4 e -g m _ t, 4 ,4, .n. i;. .T .A:. G_'-*._. ~.A.:Schwencer, Chlef r i m qi;.s 9:f

Operating-Reactors Branch'#1

~ ,. ; 7 fi' f E : Division o?c0perating Reactors. ~ '* w Mg,. ? J

s. ;J xy

', F ~ , s ~ t i C

• ccf. See next.pagei ? f gs v -

s r 1 , q',..'#'..

• • J f

g a. . m, s . 4.=, -

a,

.1 e 3 t v +i, u _m ..e s .~. 3,A. % ~ ^ ' ~

f m - 2 tV... + -

N.g a ,4 . ~, -, ~.^..4 + ..,m .,g... w ~ k; m, ". c. . ~. , /y... ^ .~.s -;y em,. y ;m(g;g W A. m., s. 3 f- .:. m.

• v;

. x, *,4 f,- .. p e r. ..c ;w n. : e w., e.4 ,,. ~ ed,;. p-g.3 g,. w,s .,., _..a.p. Q v... /v. s....y, as, n-i .. ~, m &n. : % @, m %. n &. p; n: d d n i. a. g e% w.' s. m. M %n., .n-m .m ..n. a pc rm w i WM ErWRM..^" +L -l.L ~..A p a.mnen.w ' N M,;;- w r y @m u y m n. an ' J 3 $' N:. c:. e. m$ n, M M M M S. h ! % N M ' b, .&w. .,u m wws x of r n QY M em nm.w%w, w w4:%p >; - . n [n n .ymem.v e=m-mm as. ..g;sy m.m:s,. w y - a . @h,w *p$: n.:.a.. >L ;. u.- a ,e t.c.%., y.-W, y C 1 4. 4 :.L..Y.,,b.m + b. #..' ~..a. y r ,' < pWMs. w n%.,.v.a m.y %...,,A.%~-..., c .%s..@ %.. v ~. . +g t,, g -. o. l ~ N,V ,2..A y.W. s,'e;..m.m a.m ms_4 t N ,q.g w.M .,, w.,n,. a u o,m.,. 4.s.,. %m -n ea c -s .. w - ~ u-w. ai.~ s s s W~p.u.y2W 5, c# y M,..y WW:W y;ype.f myl '.a t.. n.:?e. w y 3 p.R.. d.. A -.khN if;;g.lM&W.... NC:WW M ~ w . s.. c + v ~ .- 9 e. .s. n ~....gw. ss w +. .-,...c.~.,m. w+ n ~ %u.. - vj .,3- +,. l p (e .s e + ~ m,-e,.. y p.. L..

q

,, : y e .u y g - g .,.i q ,.3 .. m e;.,, v,z.y,.. %.

- ~ u g.n

. ~ u -g; n.n ..e. m.- 9 -r ~ .,. s.

x..,

,4

.mn OpgR; ORBdl

DOR -

ORI}(1 u0QR1 GAII-0T:,00R$ :OE1.D J N C-ORBdgpR .am w 4 Kggs;rmt; 'SSieppEd 'DNYgNod thsefituit?.V EJCg6ke: ? ASchweker: _. g,[ 11//d/77" 11/14 /772 ? 11/M/77~ { 11M7Mii, Y / l/77 1 $10 h . N SS N. _ O h n.._ .w.e_ - n- _4.w.n>... b[ %%.ww : mms.:..a;,. k.a.;M ma.'Mk..,44.,GM2C'u:,c1W + %

o 9 t-o Duke Power Company December 7, 1977 cc: Mr. William 1. Porter Duke Power Company P. O. Box 2178 422 South Church Street Charlotte, North Carolina 28242 J. Michael McGarry, III, Esq. DeBevoise & Laberman 700 Shoreham Building 806-15th Street, N.W. Washington, D.C. 20005 Oconee County Library 201 South Spring Street Walhalla, South Carolina 29691 Mr. James H. Taylor Manager of Licensing Nuclear Power Generation Division P. O. Box 1260 Lynchburg, Virginia 24505 .l S w + - w g ammie-n .,--a w d %.we ,e ,-c.w. -.,------..---e w}}