ML19317D396
| ML19317D396 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Oconee  |
| Issue date: | 11/11/1974 |
| From: | Purple R US ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION (AEC) |
| To: | Goller K US ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION (AEC) |
| Shared Package | |
| ML19317D391 | List: |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 7911270671 | |
| Download: ML19317D396 (1) | |
Text
_ - _ -
,,I w p.s.e
,,y,;. ~/>-
}' M W C ~ '
. V % 's " ~~LES ~ Y '
+ A t h'O= -
?-%
A
,g.-
~-
o u
E"KKDISTRIBUTION Docket File G+#
. NOV 111974
' L cal PDR
%l 9 3.f 7,/
OR-1 Reading
~,
i D.e o. A Q; ; a : ~ ~ ~a,7 ; -
LMCDonough di
.c u s f l?
7 o
'M Docket No.;50.269
~
_SMSheppard' TJCarterf
'I
- y 3.ge ' v 5A, & ; r
?/
,4
_.2
.R0 (3)c" Qii. m " L'd sa s 7.;
, 3
..g,,,_
o 7
- y <-
r 0GC
'W i
M Xy'U, s g.*e4s;_ Q,.
/,
re g g'#
/
Karl R. Coller,~ Assistant Director for Operating Reactors, L
+, +
QL
^4
' DUKE POWER REQUEST TO WITHHOLD PROPRIETARY DOCUMENT, " PROGRAM FOR INSERTION q. '
':). OF ZIRCONIUM OIIDE SPACERS INNOCONEE 1,~ BATCH 4" FROM PUBLIC DISCLOSURE ^
- y -
.. i e
,L
.w
. y
- w e.
o
.n
,..x
~ -
J-f _ J ?.a.a.-By letters _ dated August.27land_ October 23, 1974, 1
~ Duke P'ower Co=pany 3
r 4 A... dsabaitted responses, to ' oar lJulyj 23,1974 req' uest for' additional infor--
C-
..."mation'in' connection with their submittal of June 18, 1974, concerning.
fiM.~ # the'prc' gram ror the"indertiini of zirconium oxide' spacers;in Oconee 1,7
~
.s-
[.
[ Batch 4, fuel' assembly', 'and requested that' this information, furnished-
~
by Rabaook & Wilcox, be~ vithheld from public disclosure.
s c,.. ; %,,,pc, 1-6
.Thbe$ son' for' vithholdins; this material was stated to be that the.infor-
~ mation reveals data or material concerning Babcock & Wilcox or customer.,
4 fdude,d res'earch"orl development plans or programs of present or potential' c'
'f competitive. advantage to Babcock & Wilcox.
~
~
~
+
^
O. W: N
'Ra
- e. m.._re_r.e -viewe.d,,...
+
?
i
,W hai
- 11. m A-inttempt, to, achiev.the 'daat prisented in the forementioned letters.
In an
'M 1
- 3.
- s.14 ;;
e e an effective balance between legitimate' concerns,for '
_ ~
^~' I ~ protection 'of Babcock & Wilcox's competitive position and the right of P f.
~
~ ~ h'5 pu' blic. to be fully apprised as to the operation ~ of the Oconee 1 ' plant, t
~
~
ve' have concluded that Duke Power Company has made a sufficient showing ~
that Babcock & Wilcox's interest could be adversely affected by _ disclosure of,th'e information contained in the proprietary report.. We have also con-
~
cluded that sufficient information is contained in nonproprietary documents
- a in the public record of Docket No. 50-269 to advise an interested member of 'the~ public on the' operation 'of the' Oconee 1 plant 'and applicable safety
' considerations.
1
.E
.m, 4
s
~y
~
~
In view lof' the foregoing,.I have determined that disclosure of the infor-i'.
nation contained in the above' referenced document is'not required in the l
public~
terest nor by 10 CFR Part 9, and that it should, therefore, be
.I
_ withhel,from public, disclosur'e pursuant to 2.790(b) of.10 CFR Part 2.
g
. Originni signed by.: y, m 2
.W.
y
.~
hMA ?[
A ' 4'
' ' 7 l
?.S :
' "f '
y i 3
. Fi d '
Y Robert A. Purple 1 ', " ~
J
> ;g
.3:p
,,~
u
-v-m
.[,,.-yl*
I
] 'C '
[* ;^p n
.O Operating Reactors Branch #1 l
Robert A. Purple, Chief
+
j
_.e
, ;. ;f '
~
Directorate of Licensing
-- s >
lf'g " 7 W 75 " '
i 7911270 f
- m. -..
.O L cDon gh:d :
j I
,.v.....-
RAPurple' I
+
aw i
d 'pa'rs e' 11/ 7/ 74'm.
' 11/n /74 '
~
.,e-
,.L
[ Fons ABC.)la (Rev. P.53) Mod 0240
.,J *-
- v. s. oovaa==s=7 eaeum.e orrecas sen su.v.e m.
2 i
,s
,..+.
~ x l.
O O
g
,[
4%
DISTRIBUTION Docket File AEC PDR SEP 19 B74
~
Local PDR Docket No. 50-269.~
LMcDonough 7
OR-1 Reading ~
T 4).s ' c
.P
/
'^,,
g
.,s T-SMSheppard l
- ' 2 '
,,,~
- 3.. ~y.<n
?'^
.s
..;;A 5- ' ' TJCarter
. ACRS (16)
Karl R. Coller,..' - *.
J
. a.y, f: '
C t :y,7
.s Assistant Director for, Operating Raaetors, L,.D (3)?. h. 0GC((K,,
R as
=n
'L'~
.a :, e,
1..
/
DUKE POWER REQUEST to WITHHOLD PROPRIETARY p0CUMENT, "PRDGRAM F
,. OF ZlRCONIUM OIfDE SPACERS IN OCONEE 1, 4" FROM PUBLIC DISCIASURE -
' Le.
. * \\ :. '
~
By lattar dated Adgust~
]ou_rJuly23fl974' 27, 1974, Duka Power Company su.bmitted respons.es to quest for, additional info;mation ~in connection with -
their' submittal of m_
~
18," 1974l'concernin<, the~ program for the insertion - s.-
[ [ "s' 'of'aiCconium'exide sp ers in 0conseil. Ea' ch' 4 fuel assembly, and-
' IredueNed that"this held from }ublic disclosrnation,' furnishel by Babcock & Wilcox. be with-
~
~
~
~
~
s
^
'c#
- y.y;,
p 7
The reason for withholding
,7
~
^
3L
~ mation' reveals data'or" mate is material was stated to be that 'the infor-
=
~
funded reseArch or developman 1 concerning Babcock & Wilcox or customer.
competitive ~ ~ advantage' to Babco plans or programs' of present 'or potential
~
& Wilcox.,~~
~:
n_
3.,
av..
3 ;c w - 4 s. 'O+
A 4
s We have reviewed the data presents 2:.
, O attempt"to achieve ^an effectivebe in the 'foremention,ed letter.
~
In ani n -
4..M( yrotectilon"of' Babcock ~& Wildox's ' coup titia betseen legitimata concerns ve'poition and the right of the~
. ;C publie ~ to be ~ fully' apprised^as"t3 tho' s
"' " ;we hav'Nchacluded that' Duke' Power Comp eration'of 'the Oconee 1 platit, e a
that Babcock & Wilcox's~ interest could be has' made'a aufficient showing ', -
of the information ~ contained in the propri dversely affected by disclosure cluded that sufficient information is conta ry report. We have also c'on- % 3,.
in' the ~public record ' f Docket No. 50-269 to ed in nonproprietary documents '
o
'~
of the public on the op~eration of the Oconee 1 vise an interested member
~
E lant 'and applicable safety.
considerations.
s -
n, 1'
J.-
~v In view of the foregoing, I have determined that d 1 motion contained in the above ' referenced document j s not required in the i closure of the infor =
N
~
i public interest'nor by 10 CFR Part 9 ' and that it abo
^
withheldj from p(blic ' disclosure pursu, ant to,2.790(b) 'ofN10 CFR Part 2.d, therefore
./]
^,
/ i. L%
- c.,,
i n;
[7 s
1 Ro
, A. P..
'~dy
~
r Robert A. Purple, Chief m
, -j e operating Reactors Branch #1
' ' y '
~
Directorate of Licensing h'
~
.l
~
' orrece e L:0R 1,...
.L:0R-
' ouama e >
C gh dC..RAPurple _
od.> 9L9L 7.4, _.
9lll174 ~
v Feese ABC.)IO (Rev,7-53J AECM 0240 $
<s W u. s. novannasamt enswrine orricas son.sa.-e n..
A
.at t
_-