ML18066A306
| ML18066A306 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Palisades  |
| Issue date: | 06/18/1998 |
| From: | Hager J CONSUMERS ENERGY CO. (FORMERLY CONSUMERS POWER CO.) |
| To: | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML18066A305 | List: |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 9810020401 | |
| Download: ML18066A306 (239) | |
Text
{{#Wiki_filter:* Palisades Nuclear Plant Steam Generator Tube Inservice Inspection PALISADES NUCLEAR PLANT STEAM GENERATOR TUBE INSERVICE INSPECTION
- UTILITY:
PLANT: Consumers Energy Palisades Nuclear Plant AUTHOR: John Hager Steam Generator & Heat Exchanger Engineer June 18, 1998
- ( 9810020401 980924 PDR ADOCK 05000255 :1 G PDR ~
' \
I 1
- Palisades Nuclear Plant TABLE OF CONTENTS Steam Generator Tube Inservice Inspection TITLE PAGE ........................................................ 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 1.0 PURPOSE ...................................................... 5 2.0 ORIGINAL STEAM GENERATOR INSPECTION SCOPE FOR 1998 REFUELING OUTAGE
............................................................... 5 2.1 Bobbin Coil Inspection . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 2.2 Plus Point RPC Top of Tubesheet Inspection . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 2.3 Low Row U Bend Plus Point RPC Inspection . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 2.4 Free Span Bobbin Coil Inspection . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 2.5 Tube Plug Inspection . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 2.6 Secondary Side Inspection I Sludge Lancing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 2.7 Data Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 3.0 STEAM GENERA TOR INSPECTIONS COMPLETED . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 3.1 Bobbin Coil Inspection ........................................... 7 3.2 Plus Point RPC Top of Tubesheet Inspection . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 3.3 Low Row U Bend Plus Point RPC Inspection . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8 3.4 Free Span Bobbin Coil Inspection . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8 3.5 Tube Plug Inspection ............................................. 9 3.6 Secondary Side Inspection I Sludge Lancing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9 3.7 Data Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10 4.0 STEAM GENERA TOR INSPECTION SUMMARIES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11 4.1 Steam Generator Eddy Current Summaries From Preservice Inspection To 1996 Refueling Outage . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11 4.1.1 Preservice Inspection . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11 4.1.2 1992 To 1996 Refueling Outages .............................. 12 4.2 Steam Generator Eddy Current Summary 1998 Refueling Outage ....... 13 4.2.1 Steam Generator E-50A . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13 4.2.2 Steam Generator E-50B . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13 4.3 Steam* Generator Secondary Side Inspection Summary From Preservice Inspection To 1996 Refueling Outage .............................. 15 4.3.1 Preservice Inspection . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15 4.3.2 1992 Refueling Outage . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15 4.3.3 1993 Refueling Outage ...................................... 15
- 4.3.4 1995 Refueling Outage . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16 2
- Palisades Nuclear Plant 4.3.5 Steam Generator Tube Inservice Inspection 1996. Refueling Outage . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16 4.4 Steam Generator Secondary Side Inspection Summary 1998 Refueling Outage ........................................................ 17 5.0 ASSESSMENT OF POTENTIAL DEGRADATION MECHANISMS ......... 18 5.1 Steam Generator Tube Inspection Techniques . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18 5.2 Acquisition Technique Sheets and Analysis Technique Sheets . . . . . . . . . 19 5.3 Damage Mechanism Categories . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20 5.3.1 Wear . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20 5.3.2 lntergranular Attack I Outside Diameter Stress Corrosion Cracking (IGA I ODSCC) ................................................. 22 5.3.3 Primary Water Side Stress Corrosion Cracking (PWSCC) . . . . . . . . . . 22 5.3.4 Pitting .................................................... 23 5.3.5 Thinning . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23 5.3.6 Manufacturing Burnish Marks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23 5.3.7 Dents ..................................................... 23 5.3.8 Dings ..................................................... 24 5.3.9 Possible Loose Parts ....................................... 24 6.0 DISCUSSION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25 7.0
SUMMARY
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26 8.0 APPENDIX . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 28 8.1 Definitions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 28 8.1.1 Active Damage Mechanism . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 28 8.1.2 Defective Tube . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 28 8.1.3 Dent ...................................................... 28 8.1.4 Distorted Tube Support Plate Signal . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 28 8.1.5 Eddy Current Test . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 28 8.1.6 Foreign Object Search And Retrieval . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29 8.1. 7 lntergranular Attack I Outside Diameter Stress Corrosion Cracking . 29 8.1.8 Manufacturing Burnish Marks . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29 8.1.9 Non Destructive Examination . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29 8.1.10 Pitting .................................................... 29 8.1.11 Possible Loose Parts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29 8.1.12 Preservice Inspection . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29 8.1.13 Primary Water Stress Corrosion Cracking . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 30 8.1.14 Sludge .................................................... 30 8.1.15 Volumetric . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 30 8.1.16 Wear ..................................................... 30 8.2 Acronyms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 30 3
- Palisades Nuclear Plant Steam Generator Tube lnservice Inspection 8.3 Three Letter NOE Codes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 31 9.0 ATTACHMENTS ................................................ 31 Attachment 1 , "Steam Generator E-50A Tubesheet Maps" Attachment 2 , "Steam Generator E-50A Indications" Attachment 3 , "Steam Generator E-508 Tubesheet Maps" Attachment 4 , "Steam Generator E-508 Indications"
- 4
- 1.0 Palisades Nuclear Plant PURPOSE Steam Generator Tube Inservice Inspection It is the intent of this Steam Generator Tube lnservice Inspection to provide all the information required to meet the NRC post refueling outage twelve month reporting requirements of Palisades Technical Specification 6.6.9b. The specific information is identified below:
- 1. Number and extent of tubes inspected is located in section 3.1 Bobbin Coil Inspections, 3.2 Plus Point RPC Top of Tubesheet Inspection, and 3.3 Low Row U Bend Plus Point RPC Inspection.
- 2. Location and percent wall-thickness penetration for each indication of an imperfection is located in section 4.2 Steam Generator Eddy Current Summary REFOUT 98.
- 3. Identification of tubes plugged is located in section 4.2 Steam Generator Eddy Current Summary REFOUT 98.
2.0 ORIGINAL STEAM GENERATOR INSPECTION SCOPE FOR 1998 REFUELING OUTAGE 2.1 Bobbin Coil Inspection Perform a 20.7% random full length Bobbin Coil tube inspection of 1637 tubes in Steam Generator E-50A. A total of 1499 tubes were not tested since baseline. Also included are 77 tubes in the next 60 Effective Full Power Months (EFPM) Bobbin program, 44 tubes with previous indications, 5 tubes added to complete 20% of the high row tubes, and 2 tubes with possible loose parts (PLP)s. This completes the EPRI PWR Steam Generator Examination Guidelines: Revision 5 for 100% inspection of all tubes in a rolling 60 EFPM. Perform a 21.8% random full length Bobbin Coil tube inspection of 1722 tubes in Steam Generator E-50B. A total of 1449 tubes were not tested since baseline. Also included are 130 tubes in the next 60 EFPM Bobbin program, 78 tubes with previous indications, and 65 tubes to encompass plugged tubes in the batwing region. A bent batwing was found in the 1996 refueling outage, the cause was determined to be initial assembly. This completes the EPRI PWR Steam Generator Examination Guidelines: Revision 5 for 100% inspection of all tubes in a rolling 60 EFPM .
- 5
- Palisades Nuclear Plant 2.2 Plus Point RPC Top of Tube Sheet Inspection Steam Generator Tube lnservice Inspection Perform a 22.5% Plus Point Rotating Pancake Coil (RPG) inspection in Steam Generator E-50A at the hot leg top of tubesheet transition of 1637 tubes in the random sample program, 140 tubes were added to encompass stay rod locations (this area was identified as a high residual stress area and more susceptible to stress corrosion cracking), and 4 tubes were added to encompass tube R128 C105. This tube was plugged and stabilized in the 1996 refueling outage for a volumetric indication, a 49% wear scar believed to be caused by a loose object on the tubesheet.
Perform a 58.1 % Plus Point RPG inspection in Steam Generator E-508 at the hot leg top of tubesheet transition of 4599 tubes in Steam Generator E-508 for tubes not previously examined. This completes the EPRI PWR Steam Generator Examination Guidelines: Revision 5 for 100% inspection of all tubes in a rolling 60 EFPM. There are 4437 tubes are in the random sample program, 159 tubes were added to encompass the stay rod locations (this area was identified as a high residual stress area and more susceptible to stress corrosion cracking), and 3 tubes were added for trackable
- 2.3 anomalies (TRA)s .
Low Row U Bend Plus Point RPC Inspection Perform a 20% Plus Point RPG inspection in Steam Generator E-50A of 24 tubes in the Row 1&2 U Bends. Perform an 80% Plus Point RPG inspection in Steam Generator E-508 of 96 tubes. This completes the EPRI PWR Steam Generator Examination Guidelines: Revision 5 for 100% inspection of all tubes in a rolling 60 EFPM. 2.4 Free Span Bobbin Coil Inspection Our plan for 1998 is to have the Non Destructive Examination (NOE) Level Ill Analyst review all previous non quantifiable indications (NQl)s and manufacturing burnish marks (MBM)s indications in the freespan areas. Any areas that appear questionable be examined using a qualified Plus Point RPG method. 2.5 Tube Plug Inspections Perform a visual inspection of all tubes plugs in both hot and cold legs of
- Steam Generators E-SOA and E-508 using a quality assurance (QA) 6
. I
- Palisades Nuclear Plant Steam Generator Tube Inservice Inspection examiner. Plugs will be examined for signs of leakage, such as boron rings or moisture.
2.6 Secondary Side Inspection I Sludge Lancing Palisades will not perform any secondary side work during the 1998 refueling outage, including sludge lancing or Foreign Object Search and Retrieval (FOSAR).
- 2. 7 Data Analysis Westinghouse will perform an on-line network primary and secondary analysis of all eddy current data. All data analysis utilized for both primary and secondary will use the Westinghouse designed UNIX based ANSER Acquisition and Analysis System.
3.0 STEAM GENERA TOR INSPECTIONS COMPLETED 3.1 Bobbin Coil Inspection
- The Bobbin Coil inspection program was completed as outlined in the initial scope. Inspection results are as follows:
Table 1: Bobbin Coil Inspection 1998 SIG Tubes To Tests Tests Analyzed Retests Percent Inspect Acquired and Completed Completed E-50A 1637 1637 1637 0 100% E-508 1722 1722 1722 0 100% 3.2 Plus Point RPC Top of Tubesheet Inspection The Plus Point RPC program for Steam Generator E-50A was expanded twice. The first volumetric indication puts the Plus Point RPC program into a C-2 inspection category for the first expansion. This results in an additional 2S tubes to be examined in this steam generator, increasing the initial scope from 22.5% to 67.5%. A second volumetric indication found in the initial expansion puts the Plus Point RPC program into a C-2 inspection category for the second expansion. This results in an additional 4S tubes to be examined in this steam 7
- Palisades Nuclea!" Plant Steam Generator Tube Inservice Inspection geneJator, increasing the initial scope from 67.5% to 100%. Palisades Technical Specification Table 6.5.8-1, "Steam Generator Tube Inspection" was used for the basis for the expansions.
The Plus Point RPC program for Steam Generator E-50B was expanded once. A circumferential indication puts the Plus Point RPC program into a C-2 inspection category. This results in an inspection of all remaining tubes in the steam generator, expanding the initial scope from 58.1 % to 100%. EPRI PWR Steam Generator Examination Guidelines: Revision 5, Table 3-2, "Expansion of the Steam Generator Tube Inspection from the Periodic Sample for Cracks" was used as the basis for the expansion. The Plus Point RPC Top of Tubesheet inspection program inspection results are as follows: Table 2: Plus Point RPC Top of Tubesheet Inspection 1998 SIG Tubes To Tests Tests Analyzed Retests Percent Inspect AcQuired and Completed Completed
- E-50A E-50B 3.3 7906 7910 7906 7910 7906 7910 Low Row U Bend Plus Point RPC Inspection 0
0 100% 100% The Low Row U Bend Plus Point RPC inspection program was completed as outlined in the initial scope. Inspection results are as follows: Table 3: Low Row U Bend Plus Point RPC Inspection 1998 SIG Tubes To Tests Tests Analyzed Retests Percent Inspect AcQuired and Completed Completed E-50A 24 24 24 0 100% E-50B 96 96 96 0 100% 3.4 Free Span Bobbin Coil Inspection An extensive history review was performed both prior to and during the Bobbin Coil inspection. All freespan indications reported by Bobbin Coil were reviewed in baseline history. If the indication showed no significant change 8
- Palisades Nuclear Plant Steam Generator Tube Inseryice Inspection from.. 1990 preservice inspection baseline to the present, it was reported as MBM with a comment to designate that it was reviewed in history. Those indications which either could not be detected or showed a change from baseline history were reported as an I code (NQI) and RPC plus Point tested.
During this inspection only one indication in the freespan was reported as an I code and showed no degradation when tested with Plus Point RPC. The result of the Bobbin indications resolved to a NDE MBM code as nonrepairable status by history review is as follows: Steam Generator E-50A 167 MBMs over 116 tubes Steam Generator E-508 373 MBMs over 271 tubes 3.5 Tube Plug Inspection In Steam Generator E-50A 313 tube plugs were inspected. Of the 313 tube plugs, 309 plugs were the Combustion Engineering rolled plugs manufactured from lnconel-690 and 5 plugs were the Westinghouse lnconel-690 expanded mechanical type. In Steam Generator E-508 309 tube plugs were inspected. All 309 plugs
- 3.6 were the Combustion Engineering rolled plugs manufactured from lnconel-690.
All steam generator plugs examined showed no visible signs of leakage. Secondary Side Inspection I Sludge Lancing A FOSAR inspection was not scheduled in REFOUT 98 but was completed on both steam generators due to PLPs. The FOSAR inspection was completed using Palisades Steam Generator procedure SSS 2.4.4, "Remote Examination and Removal of Foreign Objects from Steam Generator Secondary Side." No sludge lancing was completed. A total of 30 PLPs were identified in Steam Generator E-50A by RPC Plus Point eddy current testing (ET). A total of 36 PLPs were identified in Steam Generator E-508 by RPC Plus Point ET. The FOSAR inspection included the periphery tubes and tubelanes of the hot and cold legs of both steam generators and all the PLPs next to the volumetric indications. In E-50A, no PLPs were observed next to the 3 volumetric indications. The hot and cold legs periphery of the annulus region (between the tubes and the shell of the steam generator) on top of the tubesheet were remotely examined using FOSAR. Sludge, scale and one piece of sludge rock were
- observed during the video inspection. The one piece of sludge rock was 9
- Palisades Nuclear Plant Steam Generator Tube Inservice Inspection identified at tube position R 97 C26 on the hot leg side. During the extraction attempt only pieces of the sludge rock were able to be removed. The sludge rock broke off small pieces each time it was grasped by the extraction tool.
The sludge rock was not able to be removed and logged on the PLP tubesheet map for the refueling outage in 1999 review. During the refueling outage of 1999 sludge lancing should remove this sludge rock. In E-508, the hot and cold legs periphery of the annulus region (between the tubes and the shell of the steam generator) on top of the tubesheet were remotely examined using FOSAR. Sludge, scale and one piece of sludge rock were observed during the video inspection. A PLP was observed and removed from next to the volumetric indication at tube R 1 C60 on the hot leg side. The PLP was identified as sludge rock and has the consistency of sandstone. It is not believed that this piece of sludge rock is responsible for the volumetric indication due to the soft sandstone consistency. The high number of PLPs in each steam generator is due to a lack of sludge lancing. Sludge, scale, and sludge rock all have ferromagnetic properties and appear as a PLP indication during ET. Sludge lancing will be recommended to remove sludge, scale, and sludge rock .
- 3. 7 Data Analysis Data analysis and data acquisition were performed using Westinghouse ANSER software using Palisades Steam Generator procedure DAT-GOD-001, "Data Analysis Guidelines." The data was collected using ROSA robots, Tetrad TC6700 testers, and with dual probe pushers in the hot and cold legs of both steam generators. ROSA operation is performed per Palisades Steam Generator procedure MRS 2.3.2 PAL-25, "ROSA Ill Operating Procedure." The hot legs were tested first and the ROSAs were moved to the cold legs to finish testing in each steam generator. Primary and secondary production analysis, resolution analysis, and data management were performed by Westinghouse using Palisades Steam Generator procedure DAT-MGT-001, "Supertubin Data Management Guidelines." Data room operations was conducted at the Westinghouse Waltz Mill Service Center.
The data was transferred from Palisades electronically by a T-1 line to Waltz Mill. All data was collected and sent to both an optical disk at the acquisition station here on site and hard drives at Waltz Mill. Primary and secondary analysts were located in separate work areas at all times to ensure independent analysis .
- 10
- Palisades Nuclea~ Plant Steam Generator Tube Inservice Inspection All data analysis was performed in accordance with Palisades Steam Generator procedure MRS 2.4.2 PAL-42, "Palisades Steam Generator Data Analysis Techniques" and Palisades Analysis Technique Sheets (ANTS)
PAL-A-198 through PAL-E-198. Data was collected in accordance with Palisades Steam Generator procedure MRS 2.4.2, "Eddy Current Inspection of Preservice and lnservice Heat Exchanger Tubing," and Palisades Acquisition Techniques Sheets (ACTS) PAL-01-198 through PAL-08-198. 4.0 STEAM GENERATOR INSPECTION SUMMARIES 4.1 Steam Generator Eddy Current Summaries From Preservice Inspection To 1996 Refueling Outage 4.1.1 Preservice Inspection The steam generators that are currently in use at Palisades Nuclear
. Plant, are replacement Combustion Engineering (CE) steam generators and were installed in the fall of 1990. The tube material is SB-163 lnconel (lnconel 600) with a 0.75 inch outside diameter and 0.042 inch tube wall thickness. Each steam generator is designed with 8219 tubes .
- The preservice inspection indicated no active degradation mechanisms present within the steam generators prior to service. However, a number of manufacturing type indications were found in the free span of the tubing. To confirm these indications, several tubes were removed and evaluated to determine the cause of the eddy current responses. It was verified that these responses were caused by the manufacturing process of removing slight imperfections with a buffing tool. This causes slight tube wall thinning in these areas. Of those identified, none exceeded the ~40% through wall plugging criteria required by Palisades Technical Specifications. These indications are classified as MBMs and will be tracked in history each refueling outage.
Prior to the installation of these steam generators CE advised Consumers Energy that the area around the center stay cylinder region was potentially susceptible to fretting wear at the bat wing locations. This region was preventatively plugged by CE prior to delivery of the steam generators. A total of 308 tubes were preventatively plugged in Steam Generator A and 309 tubes in Steam Generator B. After initial service Steam Generator A was designated Steam Generator E-50A and Steam Generator B was designated Steam Generator E-508 .
- 11
- Palisades Nuclear Plant 4.1.2 _ 1992 To 1996 Refueling Outages Steam Generator E-50A Steam Generator Tube Inservice Inspection A history of tube plugging for each refueling outage (REF OUT) for the replacement Steam Generator E-50A is as follows: -
Table 5: Steam Generator E-50A Tube Plugging 1992-1996 IREFOUT I SIG I Row IColumn I Location I Reason For Plugging I 1992 E-50A No Tubes Plugged 1993 E-50A 137 94 DBC 41% Wear 1995 E-50A No Tubes Plugged 1996 E-50A 128 105 TSH Loose Part Wear (VOL) 1996 E-50A 116 125 TSH Loose Part Wear (VOL) 1996 E-50A 34 51 TSH Axial Indication
- 1996 E-50A 1 54 Steam Generator E-508 U-8end Axial Indication A history of tube plugging for each REF OUT for the replacement Steam Generator E-508 is as follows:
Table 6: Steam Generator E-508 Tube Plugging 1992-1996 IREFOUT I SIG I Row I Column I Location I Reason For Plugging I 1992 E-508 No Tubes Plugged 1993 - E-508 No Tubes Plugged 1995 E-508 No Tubes Plugged 1996 -E-508 No Tubes Pluaaed
- 12
- Palisades Nuclear Plant 4.2 4.2.1 Steam Generator Tube Inservice Inspection Steam Generator Eddy Current Summary 1998 Refueling Outage
- Steam Generator E-50A Eddy current testing has identified eight tubes for plugging. Three tubes were volumetric indications, a result of loose part wear. The volumetric indications formed a triangle around a PLP. The PLP was not found during FOSAR inspection. One tube was from wear exceeding the
;;:40% plugging criteria, at vertical strap VS-6. Four tubes were preventively plugged, ;;:30% and <40% at vertical straps VS-6 and VS-7. Steam generator tube plugging is accomplished using Palisades Steam Generator procedure MRS 2.3.2, "Mechanical Plugging of Steam Generator Tubes." A listing of tube plugging for the 1998 refueling outage is as follows:
Table 7: Steam Generator E-50A Tube Plugging 1998 IREFOUT I SIG I Row I Column I Location I Reason For Plugging I 1998 E-50A 95 52 VS6 30% Wear, Preventively
- 1998 1998 1998 E-50A E-50A E-50A 135 138 136 66 77 95 VS6 VS7 VS6 36% Wear, Preventively 39% Wear, Preventively 31 % Wear, Preventively 1998 E-50A 98 117 VS4 40% Wear 1998 E-50A 115 126 TSH Loose Part Wear (VOL) 1998 E-50A 117 126 TSH Loose Part Wear (VOL) 1998 E-50A 116 127 TSH Loose Part Wear (VOL)
After five cycles of operation, 13 additional tubes in Steam Generator E-50A have been plugged. This brings the total of plugged tubes in Steam Generator E-50A to 321 tubes and 7898 active tubes. 4.2.2 Steam Generator E-508 Eddy current testing identified three tubes for plugging. One tube was a volumetric indication, near the periphery and was associated with a PLP. The PLP was removed during FOSAR extraction. It had the consistency of sandstone and was not considered the cause of the 13
- Palisades Nuclear Plant Steam Generator Tube Inservice Inspection
_wear. One tube was from wear exceeding the ~40% plugging criteria, at the diagonal. One tube had a circumferential crack. The circumferential crack was the result- of underexpansion at the tubesheet. This tube did not exceed any of the EPRI guidelines for In-situ pressure testing. The tube did have a stabilizer installed in the hot leg prior to plugging. The tube was premarked in accordance to Palisades Steam Generator procedure MRS 2.2.2, "Steam Generator Tubesheet Marking." A history of tube plugging for REFOUT 98 is as follows: Table 8: Steam Generator E-508 Tube Plugging 1998 IREFOUT I SIG I Row I Column I Location I Reason For Plugging I 1998 E-508 1 60 TSH Loose Part Wear (VOL) 1998 E-508 100 139 D8H 40% Wear 1998 E-508 123 106 TSH Circumferential Indication After five cycles of operation, 3 additional tubes in Steam Generator E-508 have been plugged. This brings the total of plugged tubes in
- Steam Generator E-508 to 312 tubes and leaves 7907 active tubes.
Table 9: Steam Generator Support Structure Nomenclature IAbbreviation I Su~~ort Structure I D8H Diagonal Strap-Hot Side D8C Diagonal Strap -Cold Side TSC Top of Tubesheet-Cold Side TSH Top of Tubesheet-Hot Side VS4 Fourth Vertical Strap VS5 Fifth Vertical Strap VS6 Sixth Vertical Strap VS? Seventh Vertical Strap Upon completion of the 1998 refueling outage the Palisades replacement steam generators have completed the initial 60 effective
- 14
- Palisades Nuclear Plant Steam Generator Tube Inservice Insoection
_full power months of operation and 100% inservice baseline eddy current testing. 4.3 Steam Generator Secondary Side Inspection Summaries Preservice Inspection To 1996 Refueling Outage 4.3.1 Preservice Inspection The Steam generators that are currently in use at Palisades Nuclear Plant, are replacement steam generators and were installed in the fall of 1990. The preservice inspection indicated there was no active degradation mechanisms present within the steam generators prior to service. 4.3.2 1992 Refueling Outage In the 1992 refueling outage a tube sheet cleaning was performed on both steam generators. The sludge pile weight removed from Steam
*Generator E-50A was 14 pounds. The sludge pile weight removed from Steam Generator E-508 was 16 pounds. After performing the tube
- sheet cleaning on each steam generator, a visual inspection was done to verify the effectiveness of the cleaning. A FOSAR video inspection was performed after the tube sheet cleaning. Seven (7) objects were observed in Steam Generator E-50A. These objects included one wire and six (6) pieces of scale, which were removed. One object was observed and removed in Steam Generator E-508. The overall condition of the tubes at the tube sheet displayed no external wear due to foreign objects. The tubes showed no signs of scale build up.
4.3.3 1993 Refueling Outage In the 1993 refueling outage a tube sheet cleaning was performed on both steam generators. The sludge pile weight removed from Steam Generator E-50A was 13.5 pounds. The sludge pile weight removed from Steam Generator E-508 was 14 pounds. A FOSAR inspection was performed on both steam generators. Two (2) objects (one object was identified as wire) were identified and removed from Steam Generator E-50A. Two (2) objects (one object was wire) were identified and removed from Steam Generator E-508. Approximately 200-300 fine pieces of wire were removed. This wire was identified as wire from the moisture separator baskets. The overall condition of the tubes and secondary side displayed no external wear due to foreign objects. The
- tubes showed no sign of scale build up .
15
- Palisades Nuclear Plant 4.3.4 _1995 Refueling Outage Steam Generator Tube Inservice Inspection In REFOUT 95 a tube sheet cleaning was performed on both steam generators. The sludge pile weight removed from Steam Generator E-50A was 6 pounds. The sludge pile weight from Steam Generator E-508 was 4 pounds. A FOSAR was performed on both steam generators. Small particles were removed from Steam Generator E-50A. Nothing was found in Steam Generator E-508. An upper bundle inspection was performed on Steam Generator E-50A only, to observe the condition of the upper secondary side. There was no sludge or other type of deposits found in the upper secondary side. A video probe was used to record the inspections and retrievals.
4.3.5 1996 Refueling Outage In the 1996 refueling outage areas of inspection included the upper steam drum area, steam dryers, moisture separators, recirculation and feedwater distribution piping, and upper bundle tube support plates. The 1996 refueling outage also included a video inspection within the tube bundles and FOSAR on both steam generators. Sludge lance
- cleaning and bundle flushing were performed on both steam generators. The sludge pile weight removed from Steam generator E-50A was 82.5 pounds. The sludge pile weight removed from Steam Generator E-508 was 83.5 pounds. Six (6) passes were completed on each steam generator. The additional weight of the sludge pile removed is attributed to the additional passes and upper bundle flush.
A FOSAR inspection found small metal slag particles and a flexatallic gasket segment at R132 C105 hot leg in Steam Generator E-50A. The FOSAR inspection found sludge rock at R89 C20 cold leg and a bundle of wire bristles at R126 C50 cold leg in Steam Generator E-508. All objects were removed from both steam generators. Tubes R 128 C 105 and R116 C125 were plugged due to volumetric indications at the top of the tube sheet transition due to loose part wear. FOSAR inspection also identified a bent batwing in Steam Generator E-508. After further study and review it was concluded that the bent batwing was already existing after installation of the replacement steam generator and was a result of assembly. Post sludge lancing inspection of both steam generators showed the tube sheet annulus and tube lanes to be clean of sludge. The inspection recorded by a video probe, showed the secondary side of both steam generators to be clean, free from wear with no signs on degradation .
- 16
Palisades Nuclear Plant Steam Generator Tube lnservice Inspection 4.4 Steam Generator Secondary Side Inspection Summary 1998 Refueling Outage A FOSAR inspection was not scheduled in REFOUT 98 but was completed on both steam generators due to PLPs. No sludge lancing was completed. A total of 30 PLPs were identified in the hot leg side of Steam Generator E-50A by RPC ET. A total of 36 PLPs were identified in the hot leg side Steam Generator E-508 by RPC ET. In E-50A, no PLPs were observed next to the 3 volumetric indications. The hot and cold legs periphery of the annulus region (between the tubes and the shell of the steam generator) on top of the tubesheet were remotely examined using FOSAR. Sludge, scale and one piece of sludge rock were observed during the video inspection. The one piece of sludge rock was. identified at tube position R 97 C26 on the hot leg side. During the extraction attempt only pieces of the sludge rock were removed, it crumbled like a piece of sandstone. The sludge rock broke off small pieces each time it was grasped by the extraction tool. The sludge rock was not able to be removed and logged on the PLP tubesheet map for the refueling outage in 1999 review. During the refueling outage of 1999 sludge lancing should remove
- this sludge rock .
In E-508, the hot and cold legs periphery of the annulus region (between the tubes and the shell of the steam generator) on top of the tubesheet were remotely examined using FOSAR. Sludge, scale and one piece of sludge rock were observed during the video inspection. A PLP was observed and removed from next to the volumetric indication at tube R1 C60 on the hot leg side. The PLP was identified as sludge rock and has the consistency of sandstone. It is not believed that this piece of sludge rock is responsible for the volumetric indication due to the soft sandstone consistency .
- 17
- 5.0 Palisades Nuclea!" Plant ASSESSMENT OF POTENTIAL DEGRADATION MECHANISMS 5.1 Steam Generator Tube Inspection Techniques Steam Generator Tube Inservice Inspection To disposition steam generator tube degradation in accordance with the repair limits in Palisades Technical Specifications and 10 CFR Part 50 Appendix B the inspection process must be capable of:
- 1) detecting indications of tube degradation,
- 2) characterizing the indications, and
- 3) accurately sizing the depth of degradation.
Palisades uses the requirements in the American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME) Code, Sections XI and V, 1989 edition and NRC Regulatory Guide 1.83, "lnservice Inspection of Pressurized Water Reactor Steam Generator Tubes" as the basis for sizing techniques. EPRI Steam Generator Examination Guidelines: Revisions 3 through 5, Appendix H, "Qualification Data Sets" and qualifications completed by Consumers Energy provide support for sizing degradation specific mechanisms. Within Table 10, " Palisades Steam Generator Possible Degradation Mechanisms," is a list of degradation mechanisms by examination type and location, the authorized probe, the Palisades qualified eddy current techniques Acquisition Technique Sheets (ACTS), the EPRI qualified technique, and detection/sizing criteria .
- 18
- Palisades Nuclear Plant Steam Generator Tube Inservice Inspection Table 10: Palisades Steam Generator Possible Degradation Mechanisms I Examination Type Degradation Authorized Probe Palisades EPRI Detection/
Mechanism I ACTS Qualified Sizing Exam Type Number Techniques Wear At Anti- EC610LLMC PAL-01,02 ETSS#96004 Yes/Yes Vibration Bars, EC590LLMC Vertical Straps & Flow Baffles I Bobbin Coil General Pitting I EC610LLMC PAL-01,02 ETSS#96005 Yes/Yes Bobbin Coil EC590LLMC IGA/ODSCC Within EC610LLMC PAL-01,02 ETSS#96007 Yes/No The Free Span I EC590LLMC Bobbin Coil ODSCC Tubesheet +PT610-115-36-S80 PAL-03 ETSS#96404 Yes/No
- Expansion For Dented & Nondented Support Plates I Cecco & Plus Point RPC CECC05 PAL-08 ETSS#96904 Yes/No PWSCC Tubesheet +PT610-115-36-S80 PAL-03 ETSS#96510 Yes/No Expansion For CECC05 PAL-08 ETSS#96902 Yes/No Dented & Nondented Support Plates I Cecco & Plus Point RPC PWSCC Within The M+PT-580-MRPC-FH PAL-04 ETSS#96511 Yes/No Short Radius B-580-MRPC/FH-52PH PAL-05 U Bends I Plus Point RPC 5.2 Acquisition Technique Sheets and Analysis Technique Sheets Palisades Acquisition Technique Sheets (ACTS) and Analysis Technique Sheets (ANTS) list all analysis and acquisition parameters to be used for the
- eddy current inspection. These ACTS and ANTS are referenced in 19
- Palisades Nuclear Plant Steam Generator Tube Inservice Insnection Pali$ades Steam Generator procedure MRS 2.4.2 PAL-42, "Steam Generator Data Analysis Techniques." The following listing corresponds to the Palisades ACTS and ANTS numbers to be used for these probe types:
- 1. PAL-01, Used for Bobbin Probe for ACTS PAL-01-198 and PAL-02-198, ANTS PAL-A-198.
- 2. PAL-02, Used for Bobbin Probe for ACTS PAL-01-198 and PAL-02-198, ANTS PAL-A-198.
- 3. PAL-03, Used for 3 Coil Plus Point RPC ( with .115" pancake and
.080" HF pancake) for ACTS PAL-03-198 and ANTS PAL-B-198.
- 4. PAL-04, Used for U Bend Single Mag Bias Plus Point for ACTS PAL-04-198 and ANTS PAL-C-198.
- 5. PAL-05, Used for U Bend Single .11 O" Pancake Coil for ACTS PAL-05-198 and ANTS PAL-D-198.
- 6. PAL-06, Used for U Bend Single Non-Mag Bias Plus Point for
- 7.
ACTS PAL-06-198 and ANTS PAL-C-198 (used for contingency only). PAL-08, Used for dented intersections for ACTS PAL-08-198 and ANTS PAL-E-198 (used for contingency only). 5.3 Damage Mechanism Categories At Palisades, the following eddy current techniques are referenced for possible use during steam generator inspections: 5.3.1 Wear For wear at the anti-vibration bars, vertical and diagonal straps and flow baffles, sizing is accomplished using the 550/150 differential mix and 300/150 absolute mix of the bobbin probe. A calibration curve for amplitude vertical maximum is determined based on the applicable standards replicating the mechanism type and quantity. The calibration curve uses a three (3) point curve of 0%, 30% and 50% wear scars. To date, all wear scar indications have been reported within this range. This EPRI sizing qualification is based on 64 sample data points. The samples ranged in depth from 4% to 78% through-wall depth . 20
- Palisades Nuclear Plant Steam Generator Tube Inservice Inspection Thirteen tubes have been plugged at Palisades for wear indication.
Eleven tubes were plugged for wear in Steam Generator E-50A and two tubes were plugged for wear in Steam Generator E-50B. Tube R 128 C 105 also had a stabilizer installed as a result or wear detected by eddy current examination. Vertical Strap Wear The summary of tubes with Vertical Strap Wear is as follows (highest percentage per tube): Table 11: Vertical Strap Wear 1998 I S/G I # Tubes <20% I # Tubes 20-29% I # Tubes 30-39% I # Tubes ~ 40% I I E-50A I 57 9 4 1 E-50B 103 I 9 I 0 I 0 I
- Diagonal Bar Wear The summary of tubes with Diagonal Bar Wear is as follows (highest percentage per tube):
Table 12: Diagonal Bar Wear 1998 I S/G I# Tubes <20% I # Tubes 20-29% I #Tubes 30-39% I #Tubes~ 40% I 11 1 0 0 I E-50A I E-50B 3 I 1 I 0 I 1 I Eggcrate Support Plate Wear Two tubes, R135 C66 in Steam Generator E-50B and R135 C92 in Steam Generator E-50B, which were reported as distorted support indications (DSl)s from Bobbin were Plus Point RPG tested and will be reported as wear (WAR). Both indications were at the top support plate 08G on the cold leg. The indications were sized by Bobbin using the EPRI qualified method of sizing with a voltage curve from the Strap Wear Standard. R135 C66 was sized at 15% at 08C+0.86 in. and 17% 21
- Palisades Nuclear Plant Steam Generator Tube Inservice Inspection at 08C-1.00 in. The two indications in R135 C66 showed no change
- from the 1993 to the 1998 refueling outage inspections. R 135 C92 was sizes at 9% at 08C+0.83 in. The indication showed no change from the 1995 to the 1998 refueling outage inspections.
All of the remaining DSls reported by Bobbin at supports, 15 in Steam Generator E-50A and 14 in Steam Generator E-50B were RPC Plus Point tested and found to have no reportable degradation. They were subsequently changed to distorted support signal (DSS) on Bobbin for tracking in future inspections. 5.3.2 lntergranular Attack/Outside Diameter Stress Corrosion Cracking (IGA/ODSCC) Palisades plugs this tube degradation indication type on Plus Point RPC detection and is not qualified to size the degradation indication. Palisades has one tube in Steam Generator E-50B with a circumferential crack. The circumferential crack was the result of underexpansion at the tubesheet. Westinghouse Engineering indicated that this tube did not exceed any of the EPRI guidelines for In-situ pressure testing. A stabilizer was installed in the hot leg before tube plugging. Palisades has two tubes with percent indications reported by Bobbin at the eggcrate support plates which have been determined not to be IGA/ODSCC degradation. The two tubes are R70 C53 in Steam Generator E-50A with an 8% indication at the third support cold leg and R135 C66 in Steam Generator E-508 with a 17% indication at the eighth support cold leg. These tubes were eddy current tested by Plus Point RPC during the 1998 refueling outage inspection to better characterize the condition of the tube. R70 C53 will be reported as a DSS and showed no change from the 1995 to the 1998 refueling outage inspections. R 135 C66 will be reported as WAR and referenced in the previous section under Eggcrate Support Plate Wear. 5.3.3 Primary Water Side Stress Corrosion Cracking (PWSCC) Palisades plugs this tube degradation indication type on Plus Point RPC detection and is not qualified to size the degradation indication. Palisades has had two axial indications in Tubes R34 C51 at the top of the tube sheet and R1 C54 in the U bend region. Both axial indications 22
- Palisades Nuclel\r Plant Steam Generator Tube lnservice Inspection
_appeared to be inner diameter (ID) initiated and both are in Steam Generator E-50A. Both of these tubes were plugged during the 1996 refueling outage and a structural integrity assessment performed by Westinghouse Engineering determined that no stabilization or in-situ pressure testing was necessary for these two indications. 5.3.4 Pitting This degradation has not been found at Palisades to date and correspondingly no calibration curve is necessary for sizing. 5.3.5 Thinning This degradation has not been found at Palisades to date and correspondingly no calibration curve is necessary for sizing. 5.3.6 Manufacturing Burnish Marks Palisades does have some MBMs and these indications were confirmed with tube pulls at Palisades during preservice activities. These indications were never sized. They are confirmed with a history review and if not found, they are Plus Point RPC tested, which is capable of confirming the marks. Upon completion of the initial Bobbin baseline eddy current testing during the 1998 refueling outage, a history review was completed. The result of the Bobbin indications resolved to nonrepairable status by history review is as follows: Steam Generator E-50A 167 MBMs over 116 tubes Steam Generator E-508 373 MBMs over 271 tubes 5.3.7 Dents Palisades does not have any dents in the replacement steam generators. No dents in the Palisades replacement steam generators have been found that conform to the EPRI PWR Steam Generator Examination Guidelines, Revision 5 definition of a dent, which is defined in this EPRI document (Appendix F), as "a local reduction (plastic deformation) in the tube diameter due to a buildup of corrosion products (magnetite)". 23
- Palisades Nuclea! Plant Steam Generator Tube Inseryice Inspection
_Denting is and will be monitored for during bobbin coil examination. If any bobbin coil indications are confirmed with Plus Point RPC testing as a degradation, then we will expand the denting scope to 20% random sample of all dented tubes. 5.3.8 Dings During the assembly of Palisades replacement steam generators, some minor dings occurred. Dings in the Palisades replacement steam generators have been found that conform to the EPRI PWR Steam Generator Examination Guidelines, Revision 5 definition of a ding, which is defined in this EPRI document (Appendix F), as "a local reduction (plastic deformation) in the tube diameter caused by manufacturing, support plate shifting, vibration or other mechanical m~ans". This resulted in 294 tubes with dings in Steam Generator E-50A and 94 tubes with dings in Steam Generator E-508. These dings were identified with bobbin coil examination during the preservice inspection. In approximately 6 tubes, dings exist in the stainless steel eggcrate support plate area. The dings are within the vertical strap area in approximately 95% of the dinged tubes. Palisades has very few dings that occur in the support plate, free span, and diagonal bar areas. Dings are monitored during bobbin coil examination. If any bobbin coil indications are confirmed with Plus Point RPC testing as a degradation, then we will expand the ding scope to 20% random sample of all dinged tubes. During the 1998 refueling outage, 98 of 294 dings in E-50A, 37 of 94 dings in E-508 and 3 of 6 dings at support plates were examined by bobbin coil. No changes have been seen in the dings during inservice baseline reviews using random sampling. Based on this sample, Palisades believes that ding magnitudes are not increasing. 5.3.9 Possible Loose Parts During t~e 1998 refueling outage four tubes were plugged as a result of loose part wear, the three volumetric indications in Steam Generator E-50A and the volumetric indication in Steam Generator E-508. In addition there were 30 PLPs reported in Steam Generator E-50A and 36 PLPs reported in Steam Generator E-508. All of these were
- reported at or near the top of the tubesheet on the hot leg side with the 24
- Palisades Nuclear Plant Steam Generator Tube lnservice Insoection
_majority reported using Plus Point RPG testing. Other than the four volumetric indications which were plugged, none of the reported PLP indications showed signs of degradation. The high number of PLPs in each steam generator is due to a lack of sludge lancing. Sludge lancing will be recommended prior to ET, to remove sludge, scale, and sludge rock. Sludge, scale, and sludge rock all have ferromagnetic properties and appear as a PLP indication during ET. A FOSAR inspection was performed in the hot and cold legs of both steam generators at the top of the tubesheet in the peripheral area. Only sludge rock was found, which crumbled when recovered. It is difficult to distinguish between a loose part and sludge with eddy current. The PLPs were conservatively reported for tracking during subsequent inspections. 6.0 DISCUSSION Palisades uses a Palisades Steam Generator Procedure MRS 2.4.2 PAL-42,
- "Steam Generator Eddy Current Data Analysis Techniques" to:
1. 2. Assure that the NOE Level Ill Analyst evaluates eddy current data accurately and consistently at Palisades. Provide a description of Palisades steam generators, a report on their operating history, an overview of their operating history, and an overview of the industry's operating experience with CE steam generators.
- 3. Provide information concerning EPRI Appendix H qualified eddy current techniques, wherein all inspection variables and reporting criteria are referenced in Palisades ACTS, Palisades ANTS, and in the Palisades Probe Authorization Letter.
Appendix C of MRS 2.4.2 PAL-42 refers to qualified techniques. Palisades Steam Generator procedure MRS 2.4.2 GEN-35, "Eddy Current Inspection of Preservice and lnservice Heat Exchanger Tubing," requires a Probe Authorization Letter from the vendor which must be approved by the Palisades Steam Generator Program Engineer. This letter:
- 1. Lists all probes used for the inspection,
- 25
- Palisades Nuclear Plant 2.
Steam Generator Tube Inservice Inspection
-States the status of Appendix H qualification for each probe or coil by each type of known degradation mechanism which occurred at Palisades, and
- 3. States any known degradation mechanism which has occurred in similar steam generators types.
EPRI Steam Generator Examination Guidelines: Revision 5, are incorporated into MRS 2.4.2 PAL-42 and are the basis for probe selection for degradation mechanisms. 7.0
SUMMARY
Palisades uses documented NOE methods listed in Palisades ACTS and ANTS for possible degradations in steam generator examination regions. This documentation is referenced in Palisades procedure MRS 2.4.2 PAL-42, "Steam Generator Eddy Current Data Analysis Technique." The technical basis for the acceptability of techniques used is provided by and modeled after EPRI Steam Generator Examination Guidelines: Revision 5, Appendix H, "Performance Demonstration For Eddy Current Examination."
- The basis for application of the sizing techniques is the conduct of the examinations under the Palisades Quality Assurance Program following the requirements of Sections XI and V of the American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME) Code, 1989 Edition, and Regulatory Guide 1.83, "lnservice Inspection of Pressurized Water Reactor Steam Generator Tubes". Additional support for sizing degradation specific mechanisms is provided by EPRI Steam Generator Examination Guidelines: Revision 5, Appendix H, "Qualification Data Sets" and qualifications performed by Consumers Energy.
Palisades has a history of leaving tubes inservice which have indications based on sizing only for the degradation mechanism for wear. MBMs and denting indications are indications already identified during the preservice ET examination and can be monitored during Bobbin coil examination; confirmed and characterized by Plus Point RPC testing. Sizing guidelines are in accordance with EPRI PWR Steam Generator Examination Guidelines: Revision 5. The number of indications which meet this criteria do not constitute an Active Damage Mechanism in either steam generator when compared to the criteria set forth in EPRI Steam Generator Examination Guidelines, Revision 5. Palisades does have an Active Damage Mechanism per EPRI Steam Generator Examination Guidelines, Revision 5. The Active Damage Mechanism is the result
- . of finding one or more new indications of degradation, including cracks, which 26
Palisades Nucle@r Plant Steam Generator Tube lnservice Inspection exceed th_e repair limit in one cycle of operation. In the 1996 refueling outage two axial indications and two volumetric indications were found in Steam Generator E-50A which had not been seen before. In the 1998 refueling outage three volumetric indications were found in Steam Generator E-50A and one volumetric indication and one circumferential crack was found in Steam Generator E-508 also not seen previously. To date, no degradation has been detected on the Palisades steam generator secondary side. Palisades replacement steam generators have stainless steel eggcrate supports which are less susceptible to corrosion. This observation was reported in the Combustion Engineering Owners Group (CEOG) Report CE NPSD-1092, "Evaluation of Degraded Secondary Internals Operability Assessment." Visual inspections have noted no flow accelerated corrosion (FAC) or other damage mechanism on the secondary side after a review by the Steam Generator and FAC Program Engineers .
- 27
- 8.0 8.1 Palisades Nuclear Plant APPENDIX Definitions Steam Generator Tube lnservice Inspection 8.1.1 Active Damage Mechanism An active damage mechanism is:
- 1. A combination of ten or more new indications of degradation
(~20% through wall) and previous indications of degradation which display an average growth rate equal to or greater than 25% of the repair limit per cycle in any one steam generator, or
- 2. One or more new or previously identified indications of degradation, including cracks, which display a growth greater than or equal to the repair limit in one cycle of operation.
8.1.2 Defective Tu be A tube containing an imperfection of such severity that it exceeds the
- 8.1.3 plugging limit.
Dent A local reduction (plastic deformation) in the tube diameter due to a buildup of corrosion products (magnetite). 8.1.4 Distorted Tube Support Plate Signal A support signal which forms abnormally. 8.1.5 Eddy Current Test A nondestructive test method that is based on the generation of eddy currents in a conductive material that is used to ( 1) detect and measure steam generator tube wall degradation and (2) monitor tube damage precursors such as denting .
- 28
- Palisades Nuclear Plant 8.1.6
- Foreign Object Search And Retrieval Steam Generator Tube Inservice Inspection A visual inspection of the steam generator secondary side using remote equipment for foreign object location and retrieval equipment for foreign object removal.
8.1.7 lntergranular Attack I Outside Diameter Stress Corrosion Cracking Corrosive attack of grain boundaries in materials with no preferential (stress related) orientation, with intergranular cracking of tubes which is a result of complex interactions between stress, environment and material. 8.1.8 Manufacturing Burnish Marks A tube condition where localized tube imperfections were removed in the tubing mill or fabrication shop by buffing ans are detectable due to the effects of cold working and localized wall thinning. 8.1.9 Non Destructive Examination Testing of material involving investigative methods (ie, ultrasound, radiography, eddy current) without causing destruction to the material being tested. 8.1.10 Pitting A localized attack on a tube resulting from non uniform corrosion rates caused by the formation of local corrosion cells. 8.1.11 Possible Loose Parts Possible foreign objects (metal) or sludge material detected on the secondary side of steam generator tubes during eddy current analysis as a result of having ferromagnetic properties. 8.1.12 Preservice Inspection A preservice 100% eddy current inspection of both steam generators. The preservice inspection checks for active degradation and manufacturing type indications. Also at this time tubes in high potential wear areas are preventively plugged . 29
- Palisades Nuclear Plant 8.1.13 Steam Generator Tube Inservice Insoection Primary Water Stress Corrosion Cracking Stress corrosion cracking on the reactor coolant side (inside) of steam generator tubes.
8.1.14 Sludge An accumulation of magnetic particulate matter.found on the secondary side of the steam generator in low flow areas. 8.1.15 Volumetric Indications of volumetric wall loss when using rotating coil techniques indicative of general localized thinning, pitting wear or impingement. 8.1.16 Wear The loss of tube material caused by excessive rubbing of the tube against its support structure, a loose part or another tube .
- 8.2 Acronyms I Acron~m I Com~ound Term I ACTS Acquisition Technique Sheets ANTS Analysis Technique Sheets ASME American Society of Mechanical Engineers CE Combustion Engineering CEOG Combustion Engineering Owner's Group EFPM Effective Full Power Months EPRI Electric Power Research Institute ET Eddy Current Testing FAC Flow Accelerated Corrosion FOSAR Foreign Object Search And Retrieval IGA lntergranular Attack 29
- Palisades Nuclear Plant I Acron~m NOE I Comeound Term Non Destructive Examination Steam Generator Tube Inservice Inspection I
ODSCC Outside Diameter Stress Corrosion Cracking PSI Preservice Inspection PWR Pressure Water Reactor PWSCC Primary Water Stress Corrosion Cracking QA Quality Assurance RPC Rotating Pancake Coil 8.3 Three Letter NOE Codes IThreeCodeLetter NOE Term I I OSI Distorted Support Indication DSS Distorted Support Signal MBM Manufacturing Burnish Mark NQI Non Quantifiable Indication PLP Possible Loose Part TRA Trackable Anomaly VOL Volumetric WAR Wear 9.0 ATTACHMENTS Attachment 1 , "Steam Generator E-50A Tubesheet Maps" Attachment 2 , "Steam Generator E-50A Indications" Attachment 3 , "Steam Generator E-508 Tubesheet Maps" Attachment 4 , "Steam Generator E-508 Indications"
- 31
Palisades May 1998 Refuel Steam Generator Eddy Current Inspection Supertubin Data Management Report User's Guide The following explains the format of the data as displayed in the Supertubin Report hard copies. ROW and COL (COLUMN) Tube identifier numbers - an X- Y coordinate system. CE-B - COMPLETED BEGIN TEST Tube location where the test actually began. CE-E - COMPLETED END TEST Tube location where the test actually ended. PROBE Diameter of probe used for the test. TYPE Characters representing the type of probe used. Please see the table in this report for probe descriptors used during this inspection. IND - INDICATION Character codes and numerics that represent the analysis results of the data for the tube. Please refererence the Analysis Guidelines for three letter code descriptions. LOCN - LOCATION. The location in the tube where the indication is referenced from. INCH1
- Page 1 Of 2 Westinghouse Electric Company Supertubin Data Managemer:it 05/15/98 8:11 AM
Palisades May 1998 Refuel Steam Generator Eddy Current Inspection Supertubin Data Management Report User's Guide Distance in inches above or below the location where the indication is referenced from. INCH2 Typically the distance above or below INCH1 that a particular indication extends, such as a permeability variation extending along a length of a tube. CHAN - CHANNEL Describes the data channel used in reporting the indication. VOLTS The voltage reported by the analyst as referenced to a standard.
- DEG - DEGREES TAPE The angle of the indication as reported by the analyst.
_ The data set where the raw eddy current data was collected to. COMMENTS Additional remarks which enhance the information contained in the other fields of the record. LOCATION TERMS DESCRIPTION Please reference the Analysis Guidelines for descriptions of locations referenced during this inspection .
- Page 2 Of 2 Westinghouse Electric Company Supertubin Data Management 05115/98 8:11 AM
Palisades May 1998 Refuel Steam Generator Eddy Current Inspection
- . Probe Type Summary For Probes Used During May 1 998 Refuel ACTS# Probe Type Supertubin Designation PAL-01-198 EC610LLMC EC PAL-02-198 EC590LLMC PAL-03-198 ZP610PP115S80 ZP ZP590PP115S80 PAL-04-198 UP580UBMPP UP
!{
CPAL-A HOT LEG BOBBIN PROGRAM Palisades May 1998 CPAL 2530 ACTS # PAL-01-198 PROBE(S):EC610LLMC,EC590LLMC, EC580LLMC X 1637 TEST FULL LENGTH
- 25 STAY ROD a 313 PLUGGED TUBE APERTURE CAflD 165 160 155 150 145 140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 I I IAliaA ~&U~I 01!1 1 ---i£1l'91e ure carl!.l!l 0 0 0 a ox 1b x o o o x cb x x x x o x 135 I I I I I I I I I I I I _ X __ __ 0 X * * * *
- __ X X __ 0 *0 _ ~- l ,,.,/!
X x x x X**X 0 o o ~x A
*
- x **
XX** x *
- x A.
**X*
x x x
- A.
- X**X A. x~x A '
0 o
*XO 0 I 1 1 Ap 130 1 I 1 t I I I I I I I 0 X X *
- __ * *
- __ * *
- X __ * * *
- e
- X
- X _
x,.... <t> u
- u x x * * * * * ... x * * *
- x * "" * * ,.
- x * * ... 0 *0 130 0 0 *
- X * *
- I~
- X * * *
- X * * *
- X * * * * * * *
- X * * *
- X * * *
- X * * *
- X * * * *
- 0 0 125 I I I I I I I I I __ X
- X
- X *
- X
- X * * *
- X *- *
- X X _* X * *
- 0 _
0 Q 0 0 X
- 0 X 0 0 X 0 X 0 0 0 0 X 0 n X 0 O X .n. 0 X O O O O X .._. Q 125 x
- x* * * * *
- x*
- x * * * * *
- x* * * * * * * * * *
- x* * * * *
- x * * *
(b 0 * * *
- x
- x* * * * *
- x** x 12 I I I I I I I I _0 __ * * * * * * * . * * * *
- e * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- 0 I I 120 Q Q "' 0 n. X 0 0 0 '"' 0 X 0 '"' 0 0 I'\" 0 X 0 0 0 0 X 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 t '"' X 0 0 0 n 0 X 0 r. Q 0 D x ** X *** * * *x* X** * *X * **X * * * **X *x* * * *** X** x * ***
- X *
- x **X *** * * *x* X** *
- XO * .
115 I I I I *1 I I ...... X
- X * * *
- X
- X *
- X
- X * * *
- X
- X *
- X
- X * * *
- X
- X
- 0 115 0 ...... x
- x * * *
- x
- x *
- x 1t>
- x x*
- x * * * * *
- x* x* * *
- x* * *
- x* * **
- x x * *
*x* * * ** * ** x
- x*
- x
- x*
- x *
- x
- x * *
*
- x
- x *
- x * * * * * * *
- x * * *
- x * * *
- x0
*
- x
- x *
- x I I I I I I I _ * * *
- X * * *
- X * *
- __
- X
- __ * *
- X * * * * * * *
- X * * *
- X
- __ *
- 0 110 110 x o-* * ** * * * * **x * ** * * * * * ::x *** * -*.
* * * *"* x * * *'"'* * * * * **** .....
* ** *x* * * *** * * *'"'x * *** ** . .* . .*. .x. .*. . . . .* . * *""*
- x 0 x
105 1 I I I I I 1POX * * *
- X * * *
- X
- X * * * * *
- X *
- X
- X 41
* *
- X * * *
- X * ~- * * *
- X
- X * * ~- 111 X * * *
- X * * *
- X
- X * * * * *
- X *
- X
- X * * *
- X
- X
- O X 105
"' x *
- x
- x * * ...:
- x
- x *
- x
- x * * *
- x * ... x *
- x
- x * * *
- x
- x *
- x
- x 0
o
- X**X
*X**
**X*
* *
- X**X o * * *
*X**
**X*
***X
*X**
**X*
X**X
*XO D
l I I I I 0 * * .. * *
- X
- __ * *
- X * * * * * * *
- X * .* * * .*
- X * ** * * **
- X
- o * ,
- X ** * * * ** * * ** * *
- X .....
100 lOQ I) x* x* Cl
- Cl x* * *
- x*
..,
- Cl ,,. * *
*
- x
- X* x **
* ,,. Cl
* *
- x
- x X*
Cl Cl
- x *
- x Cl
- x *
- Cl X
*
- x
- Cl x* * *
- x*
- Cl * *
- x *
- X
*
- Cl
*
- x
- Cl n
- X x *
- x X *
- x *
- X 0
I I I I I 0 X
- X *
- X
- X * ** * *
- X
- __ X *
- X
- X * * *
- X
- X *
- X
- X * * *
- X
- X *
- X
- X *
- 95 u * *
- x * * *
- x * ... * *
- x
- x --n: * * * * * * * * * * * *
- x * .. * *
- x * * *
- x * * * * - 95 x * * *
- x *
- x * * * *
- x * * *
- x * * *
- x * * *
- x * * * * * * *
- x
- 0 * *
- 0 * * * * *
- 0 1 I 1 1 0 O*X*
X**X
*.X**
**X*
X**X
*X**
**X*
X**X
*X**
**X*
X**X 0 0 gQ Q
- e X
- Cl Cl Cl X Cl Cl Cl Cl X Cl Cl Cl Cl Cl Cl Cl
- n X
- Cl Cl , : Cl X Cl ,,. Cl Cl ' ' Cl X Cl ,., Cl Cl Cl Cl !, Cl Cl
- n Cl Cl Cl Cl Cl n X
- Cl 0 90 0 ** x* x* * *
- x* * *
- x* * ** x
- x* * * * *
- x ** x
- x* * *
- x* x ** x * * * * *
- x* x* * *
- x* * *
- x* * ** x
- x* * * * *
- x ** x
- x* * *
- x* x ** x **** ' ** x x 1:b 85 I I l I _ **X* X**X *X** **X* X**X *X** **X* ***X *X** **Xe X**X *X** **
85 x
- 0 0......
° *
- x *
* * *x** *
*x* * * *x
- x* * * * *
- x*
- x
- x* * * *x* ***x **** *
- x* x* * * *x** *
*x* * * *x
- x* * * * *
- x
*
- x *x* * *
- x* x* * * * * * * *
- x* x 0
1 1 ~x* * * *** x.*x .x.* *.x. x**~ *** * * *x* ~.* *
- x.* *.x * * *.x *x*. x*** x.*x .x.* *.x. x*.x *** * * *** x.* *
- x.* *.~ * * *.x *x* * * *** x0 _
80 80 D .... *
* *
- x * * *
- x * * *
- x * * *
- x.... * * * * * * * * ...x * * *
- x * * *
- x * * *
- x * * * * * * *
- x * * * * * * * *
- x * *
** x ** ** * **
- x* * *
- x* * *
- x* * *
- x * * * * * * *
- x* *0 X**
h X * ** ** X* *
**a X**X
**** *X*~*
***X **X*~
**** **** *X *X * ** ** X* X *X * **X *
- X* *X ** **X ***X * **X **** X * ** ** X*X 75 1 I X**X * * * **X* ****
- h X**~**X* X**X *X** **X*** X**X *X** **X* X**X *X** **X* X**X *X** **X* b 75 0 **** **** **** **** **** **** ***o **** **** **** **** **** **** **O 1 1 _0 x *.* * * *x* x.* *
- x.* *.x * * *.x *x* * * *** x.*x .x.* *.~. x**~ *** * * *x* x.* *
- x.* *.x * * *.x *x** .~_.* x.*x .~.* ** x. x*.x *** * * *x* x.*. 0
*.*.lk.*.* ~.
70 70
......, * ..... x * * * * * * * * ..
- x * * *
- x * * * .... * * * *
- It. x * * *
- x * *
- n.
- x * ... * * * .. x ... * * * * * .. * *
- x * *
- x ....
0 o.x x.* *
- x.* *.x * * *.x *** * * *** x.* *
- x.* *.x * * *.x *** * * *** x.* *
- x.* *.x * * *.x *.* * * *** x.* *
- x **** x * * *** *.* * * *.x x.* *
- x 0 65 I I - * * * -* * * * *
- X * * * *
- X * * *
- X * * * ** X * *
- __ * * * * * .* X * * * *-
- X * * *
- X * * * ,
- X * * * ... * * * *
- __ X _ 65 j ..._.
- x
- H
- Cl
- x * .n x *
- x R
- x
- Cl *
- x
- x * '* x
- x
- To * *
- x
- U x 0
- x Cl x *
- Cl
- x
- x Cl *
- x
- x
- wo Cl *
- x Cl fl. x "--" 0 I I 0 ox* * ** x * ** * ** k. **
- x*
- x-* ** * ** ** x ** * * ** --x ** ** * ** x
- x* * ** ** * **
- x **
- x* ** x ** * * ** x ** x* * ** .x * ** * ** *
- x*
- x ** * **
* * ** * * ** x ** ** * ** x
- X*
- x **
- X*
- x ** * * ** x ** x* * ** x * ** * ** **
- x*
- X* *
- x ** o c' LI 60 60 X
- 0 Q
- x * * * * ,.,
- X
- x *Cl n Cl *
- x *
- x
.,., * * '"'
- 0
- x *X** * **
- x *
* .n. n * )(
- x *
- x
.,,
- Cl * *
- x * *
- n *
- e
* )(
- x * * *
- x * * *
- x * * *
- x * )( * * * * *
- x.,. * * )(
- x *
- x ro
- Cl ** 0 )(
- x 0
*
- x *
)( n *
- Cl x
- 0 0
* * ** X X u ***
- X **X *X* * * *X* X** X * ***
- X **** *x * * *
- x
- X * * ***
- X **X *x* * * *x* X** x * ** * * * *
- x ** *
- x* * * *x * * *
- x
- X * * ***
- x **X *x*
- o_
55 I l .... X * * *
- X
- X *
- 1 55 0
x* * *
- x
- x* * * * *
- x* * *
- x* * *
- x
- x*
- x * *
- 0 *
- x* x* * *
- x* * *
- x * * *
- x
- x* * * * *
- x*
- x * * * * *
- x
- x*
- x * * * * *
- x
- x* * *
- x* * *
- x* * *
- x
- x * * * * *
- x *
- x
- x * * * ""'0 1 1 o
- x x
- __
* * * * * * *
- x * ..* * * * * *-x * * * * ..* * * * * *.x
- x * * * * *
- x *
- x * .** * * *
- x_ * * *
- _*_
- a
- a 1:1 a a
- 1
- a * *
- x * * ** ** ***x *x** * **
- x *
- x * * * * *
- x
- x * * "'* * * * * *
- x * * * *
- e x* * *o 50 - *. .. ** ** ** ** ~ ~II~ ~ - ** 50 0
- x * * ** x * * * * * * *
- x * * *
- x * * * * )( * * ** x
- 0 * * * * *
- x * * *
- x * * *
- x *
- Cl
- Cl a a Cl Cl Cl a a Cl 1 Cl Cl Cl Cl lb
- Cl *
- x
- x * * ** x * * * * * * *
- x * * *
- x
- x ** x * * ** x * * * *
- e *
- x * * * * )( * *
- fl x
* * ~- * *
- x
- n a Cl a a 11 a a a a a a a a 1 a a a a 1~ a a a a 45 1 1o
- x
- x x *
- x X
* *
- x x
- X
- x
- X
*
- x *
- X x
X
- x
- x
- X
- x
- x *
- X
- ct Cl U Cl a a Cl
-wi- --... -w -~ -...- ---w ..
a a I Cl Cl lb Cl - a I
*
- x *
- Cl X x
X
- x *
*
- x
- x
- X
- x
- x*
X x
- x *
- x x
- X x
- X X
*
- x
- XO l 45 0 cb * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- a a 11 c a 11 a a a 1:1 a a a a a * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- 40 x
- x ~-
- _* * * * ~*
- x * ~* * *
- x
- x *
- x * * * * *
- x * ~* fl * * ~- * *_ 1m ~a~ a a~a~1* ~a~ a a~ a~ 1 a a a a ' a~ a~ 1 1 er a a a x *
- x * * * * * * *
- x * * * * ~
- x * * ~- * * *
- x
- x *
- __ * * * * ~*
- x * ~ * * * * ~
- 40 0 *
- x
- x * * :* * * :* * ** : x : :.. * : * * ; * : : * : * * : * ; : x : * * : * : ~* : x * :* * ; 1~ ~a; a 1 a; a; 11; a~ a a; a~ 1 ; a; Cl 1 ~ a; a; 1 ; a; a 1 * * * ~
- x * * *- * * * * ~ *
- x * :* * * * * ~
- x * * :* * * * * **
- x * * * * *
- x * * * * * - cD 1 _o *
- x * * *
- x * * * * * * ~-
- JC * * *
- x * * *
- x * * *
- x * ~- * * * * *
- x * * *
- x
- Cl *b a a a a a Cl a a 11 Cl a a a a a a a 1 a a a a 12 a a a a 1 a Cl a a 1 * *
- x * ~- * * * * *
- x * * *
- x * * *
- x* * * * * * * * * * * :.
- x * * *
- x * * .*
- x
- 1b _
35 - . * . .. ** - - - - - ** - - - -, .. x .. x x x ~ 35 0 * * * * * * *
- x
- x * * * * *
- x *
- x
- x * * *
- x
- x *
- x * * * * *
- x
- x * * *
- x
- c 1 ~ ca a a 1a a a a ,aaaa1aaaa x *
- x * * * * * *
- a x * * *
- x * * * * * * *
- x
- x * * * * * * *
- x * * * * *
- X I *0 * * * ~ * * *
- X * * * * * * * * ~ * *
- o ~ * * * * ~ * * * * ~ * * * * * * * * ~
- o * * ~ * ~Ill~ Cl~ a Cl lb Cl Cl Cl Cl * *
- X * * * * . * * * * ~ * * * * ~ * * *
- X* o *
- X * * * * * * *
- X* * *
- X* * *
- X* 0 I~ ... a...
3 30 0 "'o * -"" * * * "' X * * * ** o * * ... * *
- X * * *
- X -* * * * ** * - Cl .... Cl X * * *
- X * * * * .. * * .. * *
- X * * * *
- X * * *
- X X* * *
- X* X*
- X * * * * *
- X* X* *
- 0 X* *
- 0 X* * *
- X e X* * * * *
- X*
- X
- X
- D Ill a a a Cl a a~ I * *
- X
- X* * * * *
- X*
- X
- X* * *
- X* X* * * *
- o * *
- X* X* * *
- X*
- e
- X*
- 0 25 I X * * *
- X * * *
- X
- X *
- X
- X * * *
- X
- X Cl C Cl '1
- X * * *
- X
- X *
- X
- X * * *
- X
- X *
- X 0 25 0 *
- X
- 0
* * * * * *
- X * * *
- X *
- a
- X 0
*
- Cl - I
- X * * *
- X * * *
- X * * * * * *
- 0
- X * *
- 0 X * * *
- X
- X
- X * * * * * ** X
- X * * *
- X * * *
- X * * *
- X
- X * * * * *
- X
- X
- X
- Cl I * *
- X
- X * * * * *
- X *
- X
- X * * *
- X
- X *
- X * * * * * * *
- X * *
- X
- o *
- X *
- 0 x * -- * * * * * * *
- x * * *
- x * * .... 0 x * -- * * --
- x .. *
- x * --
- 20 0 --
- o-r;;* ..
X*** 0 X**
**X*
--~";- .. 7-....
X**X
."'-. . . . . oho--.-- **--.------;-...-------,\----;-.... **a
*X** **X* X o
OX**
**X*
-.#\,.--- . -.-......
0 --
- X**X
*X**
* *..* -*-- *** **X*
- x * --
- X**X
* --
- x
.-- ** -o
- 0 20 0X* *X * *
- X * *****
- X **X *X* * * *X* X** X * ** *
- X *** O 0 ** * * * ** *
- X* *X * *
- X * *** **X *X* *X* X O 15 I * *
- X * * *
- X ...... X * *
- X * *
- X * *
- X * *
- 15 x *
- x --
- x * * * . -.
- x
- x *
- x
- x * '"' * *
- x * ... . . . x * ,,. * *
- x
- x *
- x
- x * * *
- x
- x *
- x *-
0* **** **** **** **** **** **O 0 **** **** **** **** **** ***O lO Q X * * *
- X* X0
- X * *
- e
- w *
- X* X* * *
- X* * *
- X* * *
- X * * * * * * *
- X *
- XI) ~
- X* * * * * * ~ *
- X
- X* * * * ~
- X*
- e e * * *
- e )( e X* e e * ~ * * *
- X*
- Cl Q 10 t... * * * * *
- x * ' * *
- x * * *
- X * * *
- x
- o cD * * * * .. * * * * * .. * *
- x * * *
- x * .. o *
- x * ...
<v X *
- X 111 X * * *
- X
- X *
- X * )( * * *
- X * * * *
- X
- X *
- X
- X * * *
- X
- X *
- X
- X 5
<P
- x* * * *x* ***x **** * * *
- x* * * *x* * * *x* ***x **** * * :.
- x * * :: (D * * * * * * *
- x* * *
- x* * *
- x* ***x **** **** x* * * *x* * *
- x* ** *x 5
cp x * *0 x
- x * * *
- x
- x *
- x
- x * * *
- x *- * * *
- x
- x *
- x * * * * *
- x * ... x *
- x
- x
* * *<DX * * *
- X * * * * * * *
- X * * *
- X (D X * * *
- X * * *
- X * * *
- X * * * * * * *
- qirt00:20 'I0I- '(!) I I~ Cl X 0 OO O 0 O 0 0 O 0 X CD O 0 O 0 0 O OO C' X 0 OO ll 0 X 0 O O 0 X OW 0 O 0 X CD O 0 O 0 0 O 0 O CD X 0 O 0 <0 OO O 0 a O 0 O Cl X 0 O O CD OX O O 1D O OX O O OO X <DO O O O O O OO cD XO O O OX 0 O O O OX O cD O O OX
'"' ° "' ° "~_:_*~~:'"~ ':,.~ m "' no '"' '°' " '" " "' " " " '° " '° " " " "
~- -;,~ I
* ....0 N 0
N 0 0 0 0
~
0
~
0 "' 0 0 0 0 N 0 N Iii l!i !!l-!li l~-!!l-!!l,; !!l-11 P.i-fii lli !!l i m!-J !!l-Pli-1~ 'i:ii-111IIPll11 "' 0
!!ii !Ii !j fii !!l fii Pll I lli !!l I'll !!l I~ Ill !!l !!l !!l I Ill lli fii Ill i !!l lli Ill !!l I l!i >< >< x. xx>< !JI l~ x ><Iii >< l< x fii x x * !Iii x >< x; ( x >< >< !!l ,... rr.i_l!!i._li_fii_:-- .-x :c !!l_lli ..-_:--1~_!ll_!!l Pli_!!l_I _ lli_l'll fii_lli_ l_!!l XX !!l_I _!!l_111 !!l__ .... ~m-x-n-,.-....... xx:c . . . -........ . -x ,~-><-PJ ......-.......w;c-!ii->< g-m-111-X>cx !l-1 PJ >< *:i. . x-1~ . 11 "'"'
Pll Ill !ll !!l I~ Ill >< .- !!l ir.I ..- Ir.I .- * .- .- .- Ill lj !!l lli I.a !!ii : C Iii Iii !li !ll I !JI !Ii Ill F:.i I) l!I l!il Ii !!l !!ii ..- !!l Pl ..- .- l!il *
- _... _... ..- _...
- rr.I !!l .- _..... I Ill 1!11 !ii Ill I Ill I'll f.i rJ I~ l!il !!l !'JI !!l
><><><XI' XX X Xl~ )(;XX l()CXX.-*X>< XX C Ila X XX: >< X lli XlCX XX ~ - . .- .-- .---- .-- * .- - - -- --- --- -- ....
(,!\ 0 l!i !I !!l fii * .- !!l !!l ...- I- !li l!i _..... _...... * !ll ..- I'll !ll
!I _... .- ..- i ..- ..- Ill Ill I Ii !!l !!l Iii !~ -t -t fii !!l Ii Ill Ir.I
- Iii X ..- ..- ! >< Pll X !!l I Iii X _... X I ..- .- X Ill l~ Ill Ill ..- X *
- X !ll !!l 1!i )~ Ii X -t > -I>< !!l >< Ill 0
!Ii !!l !!l l!'.i * !!l !li .- ..- Ii .- 111 _..... ..- II .,..... ..- !!l _.... * .- !!l _... _..... * * .- .- ...- Pll *
- Ill !!ii !!l Ir.I I~ -t -t Pli !!l I I Ill !Ii
- '. !ll !' Ii PA_.-.-.,.....**..- Ii r.i !!l * !!l .- !!l !!l -
- Ill !!l !!l ....- !I !!l rr.1 ..- .- l .- _..... ..- .- I~ !!l fii !!l ::-t Ii l!'i_ II !i _!!l I P:.I
"'Iii Ill Ii Ill !ll ........ I ........ Iii .... .... ........ Ill I !!l ............ - ..... Ill ........... Ii .... !!l .... I'll Ii ........... !!l !li J !!l fii !!l !!l IP !!l !!l Ill
!!l !li !!l !!l I- !!l ..- ..- fii !i ..- !!l !!l .- * * ..- Iii _..... ..- * * ..- _..... Ill .- Ii PJi F:.i _... Ill * ..- ..- !!l !!l Ii .- !!l !!l fii I !!l !!l !!l !!l 1i !!l Ila X !i !Iii .- X ..- ic ..- .- _... ><
- X !Ii .- I'll l C ..- X _.. Ill 11 X !!l X .- * ...- X Iii ><. ..- ....- X ...- : c !!l !ll !!l >< lb >< !!l !!l !!l : c
~-~-'1J s_~_.. .. ~_...... ......__.., Iii ............ .,,,.,.. ~m__.- ~__.... f~ ..-,,., r:. -:'"_..:.m_P:i,,., m. . _:'"_rJ .....-~_... .. ,,, ...... ,,,_~_1~_~_r:. r:._ta_!~_,._m ~- ~
0 x x x x I~ X><XXl~X ....... XX ~xxx.-*xxxx c...-xxx: x x !!l XlfcXXXX- XX><><*>< !!l xx:ic Ill !!l 1i !Ii ..- !li Iii ! ..- ..- .- !!l I Ila Ii XX-*.- !!l !i !!l * * ...- .- .- ...- * * .- !!l ..- !!l * *XX_... !!l * * ..- _..... _..... !!l I !!l !li Ill Ill I Pli II !'J l!i !!l D Pl I~ ..- _.. Ill ..- !i .- .- _..... !!l l<
- X Ill .- I~ !!l !I !!l !!l * * ...- .- !!l ..- *
- _..... !!l X
- liC !!l _.. !!l !!l *
- _.. .- !!l Ill Iii 111 la Ill X ..- .- I X .- _... ..- lb ..- !li XX I F:.i .- X Pll
- Ill .- Ill .- I X ..- ..- Ill :f< XX.-..- I .- Ill X !!l * !!l X !!l Ill I !!l !!l Pll !!l
!' !!l Ill !li X I~ fii ~ --*-- -- 1-. .- --- ~---- - "- - ---- - ~ r.ii fl U P:i fi f.i !':ii I fl:; ,,.- .,,,.. _,, !~ ...... ,,.,,.. ~ ,......-, ,...,. __. r.i ,...... I ,...... l!'J .....- _,.. I r. ....... .....- l!!"J ~ ,......-PJ PJ l!!"J ... .,,,., _....,...... PJ .. : ......- PJ r:.-Ill....I Pa PJ PJ-ti-,~-tta x x x x
- x >< >< >< )( x >< >< x: c x ><xx* x x xx: ><xx x: c >< x >< x *><xx x: ( x x x x
- x >< >< x
- x >< x >< "'""
Ill !!l Ii !!l _.,... .- *
- Pli !i Ill 1!i *
- llil _..... -t -t I~ 11i1 !!l _... Iii _..... ..- Ill !li !!l ..- Ill Ill I~ !li .- Ill _..... * ..- ...- _.. !!l * .- !!l ..- lli I 12 -t Pli !!l II -t -t
!!l!lilli!!l**.- ....... ..-.-.*!ll.-...-l!il ~>-t.-lll* ...-..-r,i....-.*ra.-!ll.- *.-..-.-.-u...-11il.-!!l .-..-111.-.*.-l!i!!l-t i'!!!l!!l-t-t 1 ~ - - - - ' - - - 1- .... - .... - .... ~ Ill Ill Ill l!il * * .- Iii Ii _... 1i _:.:.:. fii _... * -t !!l .- .- !~ .- Ill ,... !!l * .- .- !!l .- I ..- ..- ..--p:,j I~ !!l .- .- .- * * ..- ..- ..- !!l-1,-r.i Ill .- -t ~ !!l-!li -t -i ~ ~ I'll - ""
0 I'll Ill I~ PJi !!l !!l _... * ..- ..- ,... Pli *
- _.. !!l ...- ..- I _... Ill _. .- Ii ..- !!l !!l Iii _..... Iii .- fii .I-..-..-_.....- Ii _.. _... .- ..- * * !!l !!l !li ..- * .- -t l!il !!l I~ -t -t !!l !!l *.
><><><><I XXXXllCX.-XX)i<XXX..-)iCXXXXl< !!l x x x :
- x x !!l XliCXXXX Ii XXXXllC><.-xX*><X>< !!l : . x x x
~ P.a_P'.i_,~-~-~ . . . . ,. ,., . . . . . . . . . P:iil ~.:* ...... rt PJ_....... .... ~_l'll .............. ~~~-!iii:'" fi_Pi ............... 1--- ...... PJI ~ ..,,,..,. .. P3 ...... ~_...... ~ ..................... __... ....... p;j ,_PJ_l~_rJ_PJ Pa_--1_ < .... ~ l!i-lli-l~-111-X_.. !!l ** x 11 x.--1 .-x..-x.: r.i-..- x _;.l< r;-_:. !ll-x I.><-_;._;.;.,~ ..:.x.- .- .:;. !!l X-S lb..->< S :.(,;_;.,... X-......-l~-lll-fii lll-X:.-x Iii N
l!i !!l Ill !!l * * ..- fii ..- .- *
- Iii _..... .- Ir.I Ii ..- ..- ..- _.... * * ..- !!l !!l !!l
- _.. Ill l!i !!l
- Ill ..- !!l ..- !Ii .- .- !!l .- * * !!l !!l ..- !li I- Iii ...- ..- _... * * ..- ..- _... lli !I !ll !!l < !ll I "'
r.I !!l lj !!l Ei ..- !!l i !ll ..- ..- !!l * * !li !!l Iii Ill I Ill .- Ill !!l Ii !li ..- ..- ..- * ..- _. _... !!l * * .- ..- _..... ..- * * !li ..- _..... !ll Ii !!l !!l !!l ..- * * .- !!l .- _.. * * .- Ill Ill Ill I Ill !!l !!l
,... _?<_?<><_?<*><><><xi~>< x ><_>< i<x x xx'~-><'."< xx: c x_x ><_><: c x_x >< xi:c_.x ><xx: cx_x x ~..?lx >< x_x_:~_x xx>< i~ ><xx_:<_:le><_
N-- -* ~* - - 1-* - --1-* -- -- 0 !!l !!l !ll !Ji *
- X * >< .- * * !li ..- !!l _..... * * ..- !!l ..- ..-
- Iii ..- _..... X X _.... .- ,..- *
- 1".ii ..- !ll !!l I~ _... I'll .- !!l i !!l X
- X 1i !!l 1".ii !JI !!l I~ __.. _... ..- 1".ii * * !!l !!l !!l !!l :C * ><
!!l !ll II !Ii I .- >< _. ..- 1i lli .- .- !ll !' . - . - .-_..
!!l >< Ii fii !!l .- >< lC Iii !!l !!l >< I X .- ..- ..- : C ..- X !!l .- !j XX X .- ...- X _... X. * !!l !!l X _. :iC ..- l!il !!l X
- X !!l _.. Pl < !!l X fii !!l *
- X .- >< !!l ! !!l XX X I~
I~ .- ..- ..- !!l l< .- .,..... !li _.... I !!l !!l Iii llil
,..l".ii!!llli!ll_l!l..-...-.*!!lfiil".iifii**l!ll'Jl..-.-.*111..-!!l...-Olll!!llli..-11!!l.-..-.- * .-...-..-fii i!!l..-.-!!lt !!l_!!l.-..-1 .-..-111...-~*!!l111...-..-1 !!l!ll!ll_111~
- _... Ii ..- Ill *
- _... _.. X !!l * * !!l !!l fii X * * !!l _... _.,... !I !!l !'I !!l Ill I >< fii
~ - ~ - - - ~ 1- - -~~ - ** - "' l!i !Ji I~ !!l l!i lli l".ii *
- _..... .- _..... l".ii I !I !!l ...- ..- * * ..- !!l I'll .- *
- Ill ..- ..- ..- I !!l .- Ii !!l * ..- l".ii ..- !!l Ii .- .- ..- !!l I~ ..- ...- ..- ..- * * ...- .- _..... !!l *
- _.. -t ...- .- I !!l !!l l!ll l!i Iii Iii
!!l IJ I'll r.i * * ..- !!l .- .- *
- Ii ..- .- Iii * * .- .- !li Ill .!- .- !ll Pli .- i l".ii .- !'.ii ..-
- _... _..... !!l ..- !I ..- ..- !!l ..- I !!l !!l I'll .- * * !!l ..- ..- .- Iii .- ..- Ill -t I_..... 11'.l ,_ l".ii I !!l !!l X !!l "'
!!ll".ii*!l><!!ll'.ii 1x.-x..-.* ....... x...-x1 ....... .-x.-ic.-!!lfii><I x.-..-.-:icr;x..--1:.11x..-x-1-*...-x..-x-*!!l..-xr.1i<-t>-t><1 Xlli!!ll!llliC-t>< ,_. llil !li Pll_!!l_l~_!!l_!!l !!l_!!l ~...-_:--..-..-11 .-..-11 .-,*,-..- fii_lli_ i !!l .-~_:--_1 !!l ..- !!l l".ii *,_Ill~ .-111 -t-t..-_:-- ,,_!!l Iii.-..- * .-..-.--1 1.- Pll .- !!l I -t !!l -t-t ~ .......
b -x-><x->t:'c_x_x ><-><*x-xxxll<x x x-x-:lexx x-x-icx x x-x-:exx x x:~-xxxx :<xx x-x ik-x x x x cxx x x i
- x x x-x-.c x x x x
- 0 Ill !!l Iii llil !!l l".ii !!l !I Ill -t -t I'll I !!l !!l !ll !!l I !!l ..- ..- ..-
!ll Pli !!ii !!l I Pl !!l l!ll !!l ~ l!i !!l !!l !!l Ii I'll !!l _. !!l I~ !!l l".ii !!l _... II .- !!l ...- ..-
!!l lli !!l ..-
- l".ii ...- ..- ..-
- l".ii .- !li !!l Iii ...- .- Ill -t I ,... !!l !!l ..- Ii !!l !!l .- .- * * ..- -t ..- .- *
- PJi l".ii -t -t * -t "Cl !!l
,..!!lx1i !!l lll><_Plil_'.~!!l_Pli r;_x_1_><_!!l !!l_:'"_'.~_x ....... ..- ** x...-x!!l_ ..-xl!I><: !!l_:--x_:--i<fii !!l Pli><- xr.1.-!!l:~!!l-><!ll l".ii*"><l'llx.-.*!!l><!!lx ~xxxx
..- ..- !li .- Iii ..- !!l .- l!i i .- .- !!l !ll
- _..... !!l !!l X * .- ..- .- .- ! !!l .- _.... !!l I -t Pl -t X
- X
....0 0
-!!l- l"J 1!11 Ill-Ill-, !!l !'< Ill-!J-, ...- Ill _... !Si.: r.i _;. S ..--**-,j _... _... _...-1 l"J-_... !li !li *
- _;. p;i ~ _...-. * ...- Pli !!l XI - Iii-!li _;. II~*_..._... -t _... I -_;.!Si !li-r.i-;,1:1 XX XX
"' xll<x !!l xxi~xxx...-* !li x x x : ..-xxx c x x . - x
- x x x x .
- x x x x
- x . - x x l l < x x x !!l l x x x x : !!l xxxi~xx r.i !li !!l I l!I !li X >< I !!l .- .- Pli !i I'll ...- !'ll Pli *
- _... !!l !!l !!l I~ XX !li _... * * !li !!l _.... !II *
- _... Pli !!l .- *
- Ill .- _... X li< Pli -t > -t * * .- l'lil Pli Pli "i:I "Cl "Cl !!l !li g
a a a a 11
- a a a ...- .- Pli ...- * - !!l !li !!ii .-
- _... .- x * * . .- . .- Pli ...- !li .- .- !li * * ...- !!l !li ...- 1~ x
- x ...- 1-t ...- !ll ...- 1 Ill Pl "ti "ti 11 !li !li
;-"'*1:.1~.~-Hl*"'111-t-r!ll-m-_...-ii-r-!ll*1-:~..:.*"P.i+-~~~*fli::Hi1"'.-H><xHt<H!!l-5.---~i"-""!li~l"JM"~-!!l-1=1ttt-1t!!l-t-ii-1:1'*1:.1'51- g
--+---t----1--+---aa-j-E1-a-j-E1-1tti-E1-a-1-:1-a-111-a-1_-:1-a~='"',~ca- -a-fl-r-_...*""!li-!li.-t.-.~!!l"'...-Hli.-H><:;...1-t!i:;H-11!li-.r.-*-;!!l*111H><x~1:t-i~
... ~.~~-....
=!li.... .... 1 1 111 1
= -~- =!li.,,...
=!li--
a a a a 1 a a a a Ii !li !li ...- ...- .- .- 111 .- 1 !li ...- !ii ...- *
- 1!11 l!i a ...- - * ...- !li .- .- 11 ...- ...- !!l !!l * * !ii .- _... ...- -
- Pli !li !li !li 1~ !!l !li !li Pli O a ** a a a a., a a x x CXXXXlCXXXX)i(XXXX:<XX><X*X><x><:cxxxx*XXXXlCXXX><lic><><><
a a 1 a a a a 1 !li ...- .- ...- * ...- !li .- .- 1 .- .- .- .- * * .- ..- ...- .- 1 .- ..- .- .- * * .- ...- !Ii Iii * * !!l ...- .-- .- * * ...- !!l !!l !li 1~ !!l Pii !!l !!l
== ----* * -* * --~ *- - - *=* -- ==I== ==*...,ID "'"' a 1 a a a a 1 a ...- !!l !!l * * !!l !!l ...- x * ...- .- x !!l * * !!l !!l !!l .- * >< ...- !li ...- c .- ...- !li Pli * * ...- ...- x ...- 1 !li x !li !!l Ii !!l !!l 1!11 x a a a 11 a a a a 11 .- .- ...- ...- * * .- !!l .- !!l * !li !!i !!l _.... 1 !!l .- .- !!l 1i .- .- .- !!l 1~ !!l Iii .- !!l * ...- .- ...- .- 1 !!l !!l !!l !!l 1i >< !!l !!l a "'
a 1 a a a a 1 a !!l .- !!l 1 .... 11 ...- !li *
- ri !!l !!l !!l * * .- Pli .- ...- - * !!l 111 .- .- 11 Pli !I ...- !!l * * .- ...- ...- !Ii ! !ll ...- !!l !!l Ii !!l !!l !!l !!l O !!l a a a II a a a a :c !!l x x x :c xx.- ><l!C>< xx>< *x x x x
--1-- ---- - . - -- -- *1- x . - x x li<><>< x r.a l~ x x XXH !!l x x x ll<x xx><
- -- . .- ---- --1--
~--+---+--!----+----t--+---Ela-!-El-a-l-El-ltt'El-a-lll-a-lll-a-&-a-8'1-flli-!!l'ilit--!ll~.~-__,_!!l~licf!i'!!l.-'-.-,.P- b ....._~_....,...~!!l+....
~!'j'-fil+-'.--!-lt!!l~.~.... ..,.-_tt,;-ii-!!l~.~!!l.,.,..!!l-fl-i- 1~...-,,-_!!l11t-!!l-....
~.+~~-~lli-.-h*+_....__!!l""till;ttlir.-11a!!l-.!!l-1_~!!l-1_1ttt~-1t!!l-1_:t-!!l-11t!!l-flt-!!l~
....fi__ -,-'.... ....-*4"° 1
a a a a 11 a a a x 1 x !!l !!l !!l : c ...- x .- !!l 1i x ...- x ...- * * ...- x ...- x. ...- ...- x ...- lie.-...- m x -
- x ...- 111 !!l : c !!l x Pli !!l 1~ x a a a a a a n ...- .- !!l ...- - !!l .- ...- Pli 1~ .- !li !!l ...- 1 ...- .- !!l .- - * !!l !!l .- ...- 1 ...- !!l ...- ...- * ...- !Ii ...- !!l 1 !!l "ti !!l !!l I~ !!l x !!l Iii a a a_a_1 a a a ...- 1 --::_ !!l ...- Pli - ...- Pli .- ...- *
- Pli ...- !!l ...- 1 ...- .- !!l ...- * * ...- 1!11 .- !!l * .- !!l !!l !!l - * .- !!l !I "ti ' !!l !!l !!l !!l 1~ !!l "'
"'"' aaa-a-11-a-aa.- *...-..-::... ....-1 .-!!l.-!!l-*...-!!lX!!l x!!l...-1:.111...-..-..-..- * ...-!!li-.Pi1i.-...-xx 'lll!!l!!lPliOr>>"'
a a II a a a a a a a a 1 a a a ...- 1 !!l x !ll x. a a II a_a a a 1 !ll..-.-...-.*!ll !!l a Ill !!l .- * !!l !!l Iii .- r.1 !!l !!l l!i * * .- x * >< ...- ..- Ill ...- * .- ..- .- !ll
..- ..- x !li =~ !li .- .- x: x r.1 !!l ..- ic.,..... x ..- 111 *
- x !!l x ..- 11 ..- x x x 1 1111 l!I x !!l 111 r.i-*1!1 !ll ., .... 1.-.-x...-. Pli !!l..-_111 ..-Pli Ill Pli 10.,....._...lli !!l I ><!!l lli 12_11i_!!l_lli PJ_><,,,
!!l lli ..- l!ll : c * >< Pli !ll 1~ !ll !li P.il Pli
- Ii m
0 a a 1 a a a a 1i !!l xxxi~xx..-x:icxxxx. x x x x : c x Ill xx: ex-xx !!l iicx-xx-x:~ !!l-xx-x'iex->< 1.1 >< 0 a a a a O a a a Ill 11 !!l ....... !!l ..- - - Pli Pli .- ..- 11i Pli Pli .,..... Pli - .- !ll ..- !!l 1i !!l ...- 111 .- * * ...- .- Pli ..- - * ..- ,. .,..... .- l Pli !!l !li x i x a a 1 a a a a 11 !li !!l ....... Pli !i Ill PJ Pli !!l * !li .- Pli ...- .- .- ...- m .,..... - * !!l !!l I'll .- *
- Ill Ii .- ..- * .- lli !!l ...- -
- Pli .- lli !!l IR !!l !!l x x
~ "' a-:-:-::=:=::-:-:::_:=:=::-: 1 a a a 1~ a a a a ic x Plii xx: c ..- x x x -
- x x x....... c xx.- x IC x -t >< x a 1 a a a a II a ..- .- .-
~=:-:~*:::~; :C::: 4::::i~::e::~'=:: :-:~~:::=:=:a-:
!ll Plii .- .- 1 .- !li ...- Pli * - !!l .- !!l ...- - .,..... !!l 12 -t ~ -t .- !li ..- ~ -t !!l L!iil .- -
- Pl !!l Pli ...- 11i !!l !!l 111 Pli
..- x x x 1i x >< x !!ii : x x !!l x * * ~ x 12 x x
a a a a 1 a a a ...- * * ....... ..- !ll ..- 1 ....... .- ....... ..-
- Pli ..- ..- !!l 1 lli ..- ..- .- 1~ -t -t -t I'll * - ..- .- -t ..- ** .- ...- ..- .,..... 1 Pli lli !!l !!l Iii l'li Pli !!l
~--f---l--~--+---+--~:=11-1=11-1l-l-E1--1-lft=1-i:l-ll~E-llrlllo~-a--~&-"-!>El~~,.{.--!ii!-< __ Pi.\;1>E-1_!i-l~.~-11+l-Sl-)~fi.-ll~"'1-+~-~.--l>Et5""~~~=e-f.~-'-1il!-,,-'-l"""~*"~-ll--~=iflo~-!I--~~-~
a 1~ a a a a 1 a a ....... x.
- lli Pli ra .,..... 11 !li !!l !!l ..- * ...- !ll ..- ....- * .,..... !!l ..- .,..... * -t -t .- Ill * - ..- .,..... .- !!l 1~ ..- Pli .- ..- -
- Ill ..- x !!l Iii !!l x !!l 0 0 a a a a 11 a a a a.* ....... .-....- !!l * ..- ..- !!l ....... - * .- ....- !!l r.1 .1- ..- ....... !!l ..- * * !!l Pli !!l -to !!l !!l ..- !!ii * - !li .- *..- ...- -
- Ill !li !!l ..-
- Pli Pli !!l !!l 1~
a a I~ a a a a I ax x x * !!l XXXl( xx...- x:c x xx><-*><>< xx)( x..-xx <><>< x..- *xx>< X)C ....... XX>< liCX >< 1 a a a a 1 a a a ....- Iii !!l !ll ..- Pli !!l .- !!l ...- 11 >< x Pli 111 .i- !ll ..- !!l ..- 1 .- ..- !!l ..-
- Iii ..- "ti x * ...- ..- ...- l!I. * ..- .- a ..- - 1111 !!ii !Ii I'll lie
~ --+---1--~l--!!l-l><-s-='l'Ae =,1+£1'1'A-DX-&><--.X-t-El-!H~-E1-!l-1-1-Pli*X-11-*....-'"1)1effl=i-'l'A-l'l=i---*!!l-Er-
=x~-4: 15 --xi-s-.... ~*s--.
r-1.... =!ll.-J:C:><XHX-l>k.-H-l!iilJl_,...:~.~X-!ll-+><-.... -f&.-'""""'x+!!l~.~if-1114,,-*~-....5-="'Cl'1:XH><XH:-li1<1'<lir::l!ii!!l~.+.c.., __~x'o--H,~!ix-l-!i.-~-f"!!l_!ll_:t!ei-!ll-li-rx-f!l-x-IIl--!!l-!1-i-1-- ~ x Pli I '!'A !ll !!l !!l Iii X !ll !ll .-
- Ill !ll !ll .- I~ .- !!l !ll !!l Ii !li !ll ..- X * !!l .- ..- ..- * !ll ..- ..- _. I~ !ll ..- ..- ..- '"Cl X ..- ..- * * ..- !!l .- !ll *
- Iii !Ji !!l Pli I~ l!I lli
!!l Ii II I'll Ill !!l I !!l Pli !Ii !li - * .- ..- ..- _..... !~ !!l ..- !!l .- * * ..- ..- _..... !ll **..-"Cl..- !ll Iii .- .- ..- ..- I .- _.... ..- .- *..-..-"Cl..- Iii ..- .- *..- l!I .- Ill !!l Ii I II !!l !!l !!l
"'_ _ _ _:c_x_x x_x_:<_x_xx_x_:ic_x '."< x:-c_:c x x x x lf_>< x ><_>< ic ><_?< x _:c_:ic >< xxx_:cx xxx:i.: x x x x ex xx_x_:IC x x x x:c x x x x fc_?< w 0 -!!l-!!l !!l-!'ll-li_!i_!!l !!l_!!l_l_l!ll-!!l IJ_lli_l_!li.-..-.- * ..-!!l,..-!!l-*..-.-.--!!l ,,,...-!!ii Pli-"'CI:._..,...;._..- !!l !!l !!l,... ** ,....,.....PJi-;. ** ,...!ll,...,... .- . . . . 1.1..--11 ll-!ll ll'i_5_1_!!l_ "'0
!!l X I 0 !!l >< !!l
- Iii !ll !!l >< !~ >< .- .- !ll
- I'll X .- ..- - X Ill X .- Iii .- X ,- X _..... _.... X ..- * ! I .- _. X Ii X !!l ..- .- * !ll >< !ll .- * >< !I :>e Iii 1g _... X !ll >< i !!l !!ii X
!!l !!l !ll !ll Ii !ll !ll II !ll I Pll !ll ..- ..- Iii ..- ..- .- .- I II !!l .- Pli * * ...- ..- !ll !ll - * ..- !!l ..- ..- I l!ll Iii .- ..- Ii ..- _... ..- .- * ...- ..- ..- ..- l !!l ..- l!ll _... * * !lil ..- _... _.. !i !li llil !!l !ll I~
~ :::::::: ~ :::=~~:: ~: :-:-:-: ::: ::::**::;:I~
!!l !!l !!l !!l
- Ill ..- !!l _.....
; : : : '.~::;:::::: :=:: : : : : :~ :-: : : ::: : :-:
..- !ll ..- ..- * * ..- .- _..... .- I .- II X !ll Iii lli ..- Ill _..... * * !!l .- Ill ...- : ..- 1!11 !!l .- II !!l ...- .- l!l I !!l .- ..- .- l !li !!l lli _..... *
- Ill .- _... Ii Ii I'll !!l !!l !!ii
!lll'll: !!lfii..-..- ..-lllx...-1 ..-x...-!!l .,...,...,....,.....*l!i.-..--x. l'llfii!!l!!l .-x!!l ........ x..- ....... !!l *111..-.-x*..-!!lx..- *.-!!l.--!iiO><!!ll'lll!i Pl I'll Ii P.il !!l I ..- ..- .- !ll *.- !!l !!l fii I~ Ill a !!l !!l * * ..- .- ...- .- I~ !!l !:l .- I'll .- ..- Ill I'll *
- _..... !!l I'll I'll * !!l _..... ..- _..... I~ .- Ill .- .- * ..- _... !Ii ..- * !!l I'll Pli I'll I I Iii Ii rl (JI- - - - - - * - - - - - - * - - - ** - - - - - - - - * - - -- -
0 XX X-X-l( XX X-X: CX XX-X; C>< X XX: ex X X-X-:~ XX X X-l~-X-X X )(-; ( X-X X X-*X >< X-X: ex XX X lC-X X X-X: CXX ><-x)~x-X 0
!!l I'll I El fl ..- X) C.- .- _.. l!i - !!l ..- ..- 1!i - I'll ..- ..- ..- I .- XX_.....**..-..-..-..- !I _.. !!l ..- .- I~ !!l !!l _... Ill )~ X ..- .- !!l !!l ..- Ii I'll I _... !!l lli fii I~ I'll Ill XX i
!!l !!l I'll I'll ** >< * >< Ii
!ll X I !!l _... >< X lie.-.-.-><
- X !!l ..- _..... * .-
....... !!l .... ....
- ca !!l Iii l'li II ca fii .... ><
- x ............ 0 !!l I'll .... !!l I Ill ........ !!l Ii !!l >< * >< I 15 ........ !!l ................. .- Ii Ii Ill I'll l~ * )(
X .- .-
- XX X ..- Ii !!l X !!l X ll ..- fii X _.. fc .- !!l ..- X l >< !!l ..- !!l
- llil ><..-Iii
- x ..- :< !l! 0 !!l X >< X
,c,. -
°' !!l-PJ-1 -!li-.- !ll-llil ** ..-.- Ill-_;. !l-Pll-_;. .- fli
,,-fli-fj 1- -
ti-Ill..-,...-_;. ;.-l'i-_.....,...-D * ..- ..- _;. !!l-*; ,...-:_.:. ..- !!l * .-.- ..-..--.. ..- fii !!l-:_.:.
><XX>< Ii><>< x x:c )( !!l >< )(: )(><><I'll: x x x )(*Iii XX><* xx...-x: ><><><>< lj x x x x :cx..-x>< :ex><>< l!I l!I Pli I lli .- ..- ..- Ii Ill ..- ..- ..- ! .- !!l !!l .- *
- _... .- l!I ..- I- !li .- .- I'll * !!l !!l .- !ii
- Ill !!l _..... ..-
fii ,..._.....__.I -I'll !!l Ill Ill Ill ..- llil .- .- .- ..- ..- ..- Ii .- Iii .- .- Ii El !!l II Iii 0 !!l I'll
* >< x )( Xl~
l!ll
!li !!l Iii !'ii ..... !!l .... ....
- llil .... a .... Ii l!i Pl PJ Iii - * >< !li !ll x ......... I'll !!l I'll .- ........ !!l I .... !!l !!l .... !i I'll .... .... .... * .................. !!l fii a llil I~ !!l !li !Ii l!i t-3 *-l
.t>o-- .. -
o-fj-~ r:. ri !~,.....-m
........... ! 151-_;,......-511 I ,,.. ............ r;tt ........... f.i.,.,,,.._,,.,,, . . ,,.....,.,,,.. ...... .,..,.._.Pi-Pii,,......,,..l!i
!iil,.....~ ...... ,~.,,...._......,,.-_;.I ,,_,....._..,.....U-~-1'4 ti....
13:tr:a Iii ril: 0 0 0 tp
!li Ill I !li !!l ..- El
- xxxx*xxxx 111 .- ..- !!l - * .- _..... ...- ...- * ..- 111 I'll ....- * * .- .- !li ..- I~ !!l .- I'll _...
x x x x cxxxxic.-1!1 x x : i c x x x x
- x x x x w !!l !!l I l_!!l_:-- .- .- I !!l ..- !!l !li * * .- ..- .-_r:J !B ..-_:-- Iii_:-- I ..- Iii ..- ..- * * !li .- _..... !!l * * !!l ..- .- _... * ..- .- ..- .- !j _..... ..- !!l !!l Ii Ill l!i a fii I Ill I'll Ill !!l
"'!!l_X_I !!l...-x ....... :c-;.l!il !!l><* x..-..--;. *...-x.--.-1 X!!lX!ll~ ..-x.-x1i-r:.i;.x-..-'i~-;.!!l !!l-x- x.-..--P:ii~-!!l-><l'll_!!l_l1X-!!l fii Ill ..- .- * ..- .- fii Iii Ii !!l .- .- _... I~ ..- ..- I'll I'll I !li !!l II Ill Ii xxxx*xxxx:cxxxxicxxxx: xx i 0 8
()
!li !!l !li PJ
- I'll !!ii Ill Ii * * ..- ..- _..... .- !!l .- .- !!l * * .- .- .- _.. Ill .- l!i ..- !~ .- llil .- !!l * !!l .- _..... .- * !!l !!l !!l !!l I .- !!l !!l I'll !i Iii !!l !ll X t:"'
I'll fii I !!l !!l ..- ..- I~ .- .- .- !!l * !!l ..- .- _... * .- _... Ill ..- I !!l !!l lli !!l I~ .- _..... .- !!ii * * ..- llil ..- !!l I~ !!l .- .- !!l
- _..... !!l Pli Ill I~ I'll !!l !!l !!l I 13
>< !!l x_x 1.-xxx1 _x ....... x...-:cxx...- !!l :cx...-xx*.:--_xxx- xx..-x cxx.-x x !!l ><_><_ -t I'll x_><_li_?<_?<><
~s-!!l-&-_!lis-l!l!lblli--"".~.... ~!!l~..... - .... ~"lli,r111.,....-,-\"-.--..... ~:,,,..~*~xH':ll..-,.,_.-..,....+.~.... """'.-~.... ,,,_....~_r_tt.rl!ll-e-llil-PJil-l'll'""""'fii~-~-~
....-fl_i-.--m-x~*~~:<-.-,_,_~llil5..-...,.~!!l,..,,~.... ""'"!!l'-'1'!!l'-lli!!l-l'll~~~>--1-t~!!l~-r!!l~-~1~~-r-!!l-tli---tli----1--+---t---i-~-r--r--~
lli lli C fil X _... I'll I >< _..... X _.. Ii ..- XX X
- _.... !!l X !!l : C Pli lli !!l X
- X Ill Ill Pli *XX..-_... I X !!l X Iii Ii !JI X > X Ii -t fii ><
!!l !!l !!l lli *
- Ii .- fii lli ! ..- .- .- llil * * )( .- El !!l * .- .- ..- ..- * * .- _..... !!l .- Ii.-.-_.. X I Ea I'll lli .- * !!l !!l !ll !!l ~ -t Iii -t .-t l'll!!l ilif;i!li!!l* ..-a.-..-.*..-..-..-....-. !!l!!ll3_.....I l!il...-1311-*.--t-t..-.*..-,-..-.- *..-13l'll!!l0!li!!l-tlll !i>><
D N 0 "'"' ""0 0 0 "'"' "' 0 "'"'
~
0
~
0 "'"' "' 0
....0 ....0 ....
N
....N ....
""0 0
"' 0
"' 0 i
CPAL-A HOT LEG U-BEND +POINT PROGRAM Palisades May 1998 CPAL 2530 ACTS # PAL-04-198 PROBE:UP580UBMPP e U 24 TEST 05C THROUGH 05H
- 25 STAY ROD a 313 PLUGGED TUBE APERTURE CARD 165 160 155 150 145 140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 ~o~o o~o~ ~o~o 0000 0 Aft Av~Hebl@ on 13 5 0 0 o0 o o * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * **o
""l.'9'5 a.pad*
~
are Fl>
~!~~
..di
""O\r\!I 0 * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- 0
... 0 * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- 0 130 0
...... d:> 0.
- o:i~
* * * *+*
- 0 00
- 0 130 125
- 0 o~ ~ 125 oo~ ** o.
- 0-:-00
* * * .ro_
m 120 120 Ov* .~o
- 0
_oar** *
- Cl>
o_ 115 115 J~:.
.-': 0 0 110 0 o-= 110 00
- 00
- cb **
- 0 105
- 0 105 00 * :<Jloo_
0
- 100 100
<P. :- 0 95
_ a~. * : 0 cji _ 95 oo. 00 0 *
- 0 90 90 85 oo.
o d> 0 T * *
* *~Och 85 00
- 0. *o_
80 75 o~ . 0
*
- oa, 60 75 00 *.~o 70
_o* o_ 70 0 o,.
.oo ot:
- 65 65 0
60
-: odi 60 00
- 0.
55 _o 0 ..
~a~ala~a~~~a~ *
- 0 o_
55 50 50 o* *a*a ~Cl Cl Cl CICI Cl Cl Cl Cl:* Cl
- 0 45 o9<
0
- k Cl
* ,j,Clcil:lci Cl~CI Cl Cl Cl cil:lci_ CICICICI l:lcil:lci CICICICl.~CICI * * .
o_
*
- 0 cb 45 xmaa-a-I--c1- cil:lciCl~l:lcil:lci
*
- Cl Cl D Cl
- _ _ Cl_CI Cl_CI 40 40 cw1:3- ei~~CI 35 0
0 ClaCla Cl _Cl_CI Cl mCICICICI Cl Cl CICICICI Cl Cl CICICICI Cl CICICICI Cl _ _ Cl_CI CICICICI Cl_CI_ Cl: *
* :I_ 35 Cl~ClwClwij'wClwCI ~~. Cl 0 0
_o * * *
- CICICICI Cl Cl 1- -Cl~C~~~;a
- o_
30 0 0
. ';~
0 Cl_CI Cl.CICICI
""Cl" Cl CID Cl :
Cl Cl -
- 0 30
. 0 Cl Cl 25 25 20 0
0 0
- Cl
- 0 Cl "1* 0
- 0
.oo 20 0
o. 00 0 0
- 00
. 0 0
15 0 * * : ct 0 o; * * *o o_ 15 10 0
** * * **.a
- 0 -=
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * -o 0
10 5
- a
- 0 *
- Q aoou ouoo ouoo oooo UoUu uouo oooo ouoo Uooo ouoolloooo oooo 165 160 155 150 145 140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 65 80 75 70 65 60 Uooo aooo oooo oooo oouo oooo oooo ouuo oolJo oouo oooolluoou 55 so 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 / I
--*, _, .* --- WestinghouseEleclricCo.-NSDST98 06/11/1998 08:41:28 G~ oo;)_Ot/01- 0 I
CPAL-A HOT LEG SPECIAL INTEREST +POINT PROGRAM
-.. ~
Palisades May 1998 CPAL 2530 ACTS # PAL-03-198 PROBE(S) :ZP610PP115S80, ZP590PP115S80
- 8 7
4 3 1 TEST 08H -/+ 2 INCHES 1 TEST 07H -/+ 2 INCHES 1 TEST 04H -/+ 2 INCHES 1 TEST 03H -/+ 2 INCHES L~\F)~~u!lD\Ri~ 2 1 TEST 02H -/+ 2 INCHES .
- 25 STAY ROD c 313 PLUGGED TUBE
©!A\JJ~)
165 160 155 150 145 140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 BO 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 la o 0 ~ 0 o 0 o9o 0 o 0 ~ 0 o 0 o9o o 13.~UOOI ~\;11&.lUliOO@lic~ tQJ\7\
. ...Ir o.oo~oo_
o __ ¢> o *T* * + * *T* * + o o o_ 135 o-:. ~
~
.. ¢ [41,Q'~Lr'ttlWli& ©rnl:'©,
0 0010000
* \f" ..**
v
',o, Q
130 00
.-. © **
ov t> '-'. * . ovQ 0
.oo
- 0 130 125 o:o:
O~* ' o-o
- 0 125 120
_o * **** cp 0 120 o-. .-voo 115 o0 i **
- 0
*o<f>o,...
,vo 115 qio;.
cb. * **so
- 0 110 110 ov 00 00 *
.-. cb ** *.oo 105
_o
- 00 * .* * : <P 0 o _
105 100 100 95 J:: 0
* : 0 ©'""'
95 0 0 0 * .oo 0
- 90 90
- 0 ch 0
- OT** *
- 0 <D 85 o- * *
- 00 85 0 **
0 *o_ 80 ov0 80 75 o;: 'o 75 00 0 _o* 70 00 *
- 2: * .+. ' I , . 0
' : 00 70
~
65 65 ( 0( 60 60 00
- 0
_o
- 55
_o o' . c_c_icca_:_~.:c
- 0-e-0 55 50 0 * .i. . c ::~::~:~~~~~~~:~:~~
a Cl a 0-e-0 50 45 0 CJ Cl CJ
- 2. 45 cp: .
*~~~:~~;~~~~=~~~~;~~~~~~~~~;~~~~i::~~
0
- 0
** <D 40 40
*-;-a-a:a-a-;-a-a:a-a-;-a-a:a-a-;-a-a~*
,aa a_aceca__ceca a_a aceca a cecaa a ceca a a__ceca ceca ,
l.
..l . f .l 0
_o a_a a_a_ f f 35 _o 0
* . : ~:~~~~+~a~al --II -w-j~a~:~~~~~+:
a
- .3:. ...... * . 0 35
.... ...... ... ~
30 30 0 0
- ~;~:~ I I I --1 I I~:~;f . . . ..
0 0 25 0 0 0
* .;:I I I I I I I -;;.
- 4.
- 0
- 0 25 20 20 0
0 ; 00 I I I I I I 00 0
.e-0 15 15 0 * >bo o; *
- 0
.... .... .... .... .... .... oe-0 10 10 0
0 0 Vt* 0
%.o .o ta .o .i. o 5 * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- 0 5
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- 0 * * * * *
- 0
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- 0 l l l l
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- 0 aooo oooo oooo oooo oooo oooo oooo oooo oooo oooo oooo oooo 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 oto o o oto o o oto o o oto o o of o o 165 160 155 150 145 140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 BO 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5
...... -~ ... Westinghouse Electric Co.* NSD srn8 06/11/1998 09:12:42 q~/ oOoJot(rJ/-()5--, ~
CPAL-A ..... COLD LEG SPECIAL INTEREST +POINT PROGRAM Palisades May 1998 CPAL 2530 ACTS # PAL-03-198
- 25 STAY ROD PROBE(S) :ZP610PP115S80, ZP590PP115S80 a 313 PLUGGED TUBE
- 8 1 TEST oac -/+ 2 INCHES 5 1 TEST OSC -/+ 2 INCHES 4 3 TEST 04C -/+ 2 INCHES 3 1 TEST 03C -/+ 2 INCHES j "
2 4 TEST 02C -/+ 2 INCHES 1 l TEST OlC -/+ 2 INCHES APERTURE CARD 165 160 155 150 145 140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 '~""'K~ Oril o0 o0 0 o0 o IA.I<&"" j.\'ij8' ~B 135 o * * *
- O O o o o 14.~eu 1 5 C rd o0 o o * * * * ** * * * *** ** * **o J:\
~~
J. e\f\l.Ui'I!
- 0 0 * * * * * * *
- 0 130
. . . a"'. ****
- o * *
- 0 o __ 130 125 rbo-o-
~<boo**
0 0 -r~
.+. 0 00
- 0
- 0 0~00 125 o~ T * * * * * * : ** <f> 0 120 0
cp *
"V
_o 0 iii * *
- 4
* *:oo
* *
- cp 0 120 115 115 bo: * -:so
*
- 0 110
"""ct>
00 o~
- 4.
00
** 00 110 105 105 00 * .'f.*.*J*.*.f.*.*J*.*.1.*.*J*.*.t.*.*m
- T 0 0 ......
0 *
*:o <b 100 100 95 00*
,__o'P:* ** 0 00 95 0 *
- 0 90 90 0
ct 0
- 00
* *
75 00 Do 70
~o*
..*
- ft o_ 70 65
~
0 *
.oo 65 o;: . .~o lD
.... * : 0
- ft 60 60 00 .~o 55
_o 0 55 0
- 0 50
_o ILCllCICICl_ILCI o_ 50
* * .-Cl-Cl~Cl~Cl-~-Cl-CI~* * *1 0
0 ~~:~:!:~:~~~:~:!:~:~~Cl:CI~ "o_ 45
. t"cia;.;a;a~a;~;.;a;a~a;a;.;a;a 45
~
dJ. Cl *
*:Q~Cl~Cl!Cl~Cl~~~Cl~Cl!Cl~Cl~~~Cl~Cl!Cl~CI~ ~:~Cl 0 0 *20<t>
40 0 *;;-a-a:a-a-;-a-a:a-a-;-a-a:a-a- -a-a:*
- CICICICI CICICICI CICICICI CICICICI CICICICI CICICICll CICICICI **
- i 40 35
_o Cl Cl_CI _ _ Cl_CI
*.:~a;a;i1i;a;aT Cl Cl Cl Cl I I -i1i;a;a Cl Cl_ Cl Cl Cl_CI_
a-a-+
- Cl .
- 2:
35 30 0 0 * . -~l:'al:'adi I a Cl CICl~CI Cl
- 0 o_ 30 0 :;*;:a -Cl-Cl:.
Cl Cl Cl Cl
- 0 25 0
0 0 0 Cl! Cl
- Cl
- OCI Cl -
-= ..0
. 0 0
.oo 25 20 20 0
- 0 0
- 0
.. .. .... .... .... ... . o~.
00
~- . .~
15 15 0
- 0 0 0
* *
- 0 0 * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- 0 * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- 0 10 10
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- 0 * * * *
- 0 * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- 0
. . o. o. o. o. o. o. o. o. o. o. o. o. o. o. o. o. o. o. o. o. o. o.
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- 0 * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
... .t ... 'i' .. .t .o..o"i"o .o..t.o..o'i"o .o..t.o..o'i'o .o..t.o..o'i"o .o..t.o..o 5 * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- 0 5
0
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- 0 CIOOO 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
~o 0 o 0 go 0 o o 0 o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 165 160 155 150 145 140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 05 BO 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 Westinghouse Electric Co. - NSD ST98 06/11/1998 09:13:18 0~( oo;;.o'-{or- CJ(o~. ,.# _..-.
CPAL-A HOT LEG BOBBIN PROGRAM AS TESTED ~ Palisades May 1998 CPAL 2530
\ 1637 TUBE TESTED TEC THROUGH TEH
- 25 STAY ROD a 313 PLUGGED TUBE
!APERTU~\E CA~D Ai~@ ~~fiQIQill@ @ill\
165 160 155 150 145 140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 ao 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 ApeiiUlf@ Qaiu:@l o\~ 0 \ 0 oj*o 0 o\~\\\\ r n .:'I -: ,:l :- : . f\' ., ........ ... ...
. a O \ ~ o
\,t..o \T* * ._*,*J*,\ o_ 135 135
',~,'
~, : '
Do~o\<jlo\_
- r \:o:
\; :,t,, .:-r: . , .
, J, , 0 0 0 \ \
,O~\*\~*: :*~*1*'*~ *.*.}.:\:~~*** \ *, L o, : \ : . .\ ..\\ ..
130
' ' 130 i . : . , t : , : * .i: * : *: , -: , '"'t**:-0.j'Oo
. :\:*f*:\:+*.:,1.:.~i.:*:* 1\
0 9 9 * * \ * * .'
- 0
.. \ .. .. .. . .. 'i*,* .....
' * * * . * ' 0
. .!.*.:. l :- \..!.'*..* ...
\:*
- 125 t . t. *.. :-;-~ . ...'f:-\--:. .;-!*;.:'--:t:.:'
125
\~o\
\
0 0
\
\
\
. \
... -t -... . .\ . .. . \-:
. . \.
\
0,
~o, 120
<jl 0 .. \ * \ .. ~1\--=-'f"\-
--'~*\*:\ .*.* *.\. \***+:\*.]-.*\~ *.*, . .
- -t : . ( ~-1,:-.-, . *\ .......
- 1* * - \ . :
. . .. ,\:*I*,\, :..
\ ~
- e\e*
0 . *
.*\*
\
\ \
\
\ \
\
** 0
* \. 0 '!
120 115
.~,-t- *-,I 0
<ti.,. \
- *1* *-*i'-
\
*1*,- I -,-t-,. ' : :. .. . *'***I*.\. . : . . .
\ *** , *.**** ,
\
\
\ \ \ \ \ ...
.. *,*:.:*,a
\ *
' - I -'
'0 115
\*,* \* *J* \
\
.. . . . \ \ \
. \
- r: : : .... .. .... . :.*, ... ...
\ 0 **
* *
- 0 4 I' *
.. .::~:r-: :~T: ~: :f : : ; : n::~r:-~-: ~ t : .. ," ... ..... I ... .. ....
*,* e *,_I 1. e 1\e \ *,* _e,e_
- e, 0 110 110 o- ' *
- r * ------ * *:*:t~'*\*
\ \
.. *\*.1.*\* 0
\
\
0 \ ** .' \ \ \ .\. \ \ \ \ \o 105
\
\
. . ,-;. . **-\1****1**
. . , . ..... . **1,-**;-,-.t
. , ... . ,. . .. . -,-;***\
\
* \ ** J **** :
\ . .
\ .
- J' *
..\ ... ... .*,*t***\
\ '. .
.. .... . .. .. . \-:.. . . .... ... \ . : ...: .
\ \ .. . ,\:*t.. *'*
\
\
105
\ . . . '.. l .... * * * \ t : , ,
- l * : -: t , * , , I*,*. . . .. ... .
- J'
- 00 \ \ \ \
. \ ~ \ '
( 100
~
0
- f \ *.. *,* ... *,*
- * ' * \ * \ - * - ** * * - \ - ' * - *
- 1 * - ' -
\
* \
\ .. .. .
\
\ \'
\
\ - '
\ \
* \
\
* *
- 1 *
\ \
0 \.
'\
100 n-;-* .*
\ \ ' \
\
\ * *
- 0'
\ ..t ,,. ... ... .. :. : : :. . ..: .. ... i' .. .. . :: . .: \ : .... .. ...... ...... .* l * *
. \
- 1*
- 95 1
' . :.: .,\ ..* 1* ..* .,* :.. *.* 1*.\.
0
. *.*,1.~.*+:.*.1,*.: \
\
\
0 \ *
\ \ \ \
\
' \
\
\
\ ** l' * \ **
95
\ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ 00
, :- , t : -:
- 1* : , : t , * :
- I.,.. .. .. . . \ . . . .. . \-: *\*:1:*\* ..
\
00* ,
~
.... .\ .. .. \ . ... . . \ .. *1*. .,,,..
0 * \ ' \
- I' * \ ' '
- 0
*\*.f.-,*
* *
- l * * * * *
- 1 * * * ' * * ' *
- 1
- 90 90 0.1**'\'
0 *
\-:... \
*,*.l**,* *.*,t.~.:1*.*.1,.*.~ :,*. .. \
. . \
* *I *
}
\
... \
. . . . \ . .
\
.. \
- \: \
.\ ... ...\ . .. . . . .
. \ ' 0
\
. \ \
* ,I' *
\ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ * * . * \1J
. .... o,.\ .,'1****1****1\***f-,
.,\**1* . ...
**.*. ,*.\ ., ... ...... ... . ... .. . .. : : . .: : ..... . .
85 85
*'** : : . .: : . :-. ~ .****!***,* .. . . .
0-"<;;;T, 0 ** \
\
\
\ \ \ \ \ \
\
\ \
~ ... \
\ \
\0
*.1* *
\ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \o_
... .. ... .. .... .... \ .. ...... .. ... . . ..... .... .... .. <..\ . . .: : ... .. .... .... \ .. :...: : : .
\ \ -*-*
- _ \ _ , . G t . ' ./'
' \
80
- 1. ....
80
\ \ \ \ \ * * .J' 0
\ \ \ ' 0 ** \ \*:a
\ * *
- 0 \
\ \ 0 **
\ \
75
' i . . I . . .. .. ..\ .... ... .. ..... .....
\ *-* *-*\.* .. \ \ \ \ \
\
\ \ '
.. ...\ \ \ \
\ ' \ \
\
.. .. ~. .
\
\
.... \ *** cp
\ ** \ dl 75
. \ \
. . . \ \
. \
.. \
\ \ \
\ \
... . . \
- J * *
. . : : . .. ... \ \
... \ 0 0 \ * * ,* * * \ \ \
\ \ \
. . ~ \
. ~ *** 10'
- 0 \
- 70 0, * * * *..* * , *
\
. ~
\
\ * ,I
\
\
\ . : .:
\
. ,-.1**
\
**1,**-\1*,*
\
\
\
\
. *\**. . 1 .. *,*
\
. \
\
.: . . \-:.... :\o- 70 00: \
* \
0 *
\
\ \ \
. \
.. \
.. . 1, ** \ *
\
.:.* :*.* . . *.: ., .. * * \
- 41 \
. \
\ \
.. ....\\ ... ... .. .:.\ ... .: : .....' .,-o. . . . \ \
-* .\ . ... ..... ...... ....... .: : ..*.* \ ... . : : .
\ \ \ \ \ \
' \
. J.**'**i\***i*,**1*
' 65 65 cp ** . . ,...
\ \ \
i *~a~;~a~a ~ ~ ~ f ~ ~ ;-~ ~ ~ 1**., .** J **** 0 : \ : ' \ 45 .... ..: .. \ .. \ \ \ ~ \ \ \ . . ' \ ' ,~ . -, .. .-t .-...' \ 45 \ * .r
- J.
* \ \ * ,I' * \ \ \ \ \ \ * *.*.f,e*\e _J' * ~ **CID *,
- _ _ a_a a_a CICI a a ; a- a a a a a_a a a aaa a __ a a_aa a_a a a: a \ :
a a__a a_a a \ ** \ ~ \ \ \ * ~ \ \ \ ** \ 0 <ti 40 ~ 0 t . .. ** \. \. ' \ . . ... *~*:f:*,* ... . . \. ' \ \ \-: \ * ,* a aaaa a- ~a aaaa a -Cl"'~a-a~li""'ci:*** aaaa aaaa aaaa *** \ * *'**l**.* \-: \ . \ ~' . . ... \ .'. \ 40 .. ... . ..,...... ,........ ..... *\.* * .r * \ 35 ~0 o* .. \ . . . : : . ** \ . \ \ . :\'>f<'. \ ' ~ .... .. ,\.*~aa~adi _a_a a a a a __ a_a a_a_ % -+ * *-\ * \ ' \ \ \ . . ... . \:*!**:\.]\ 35 \ \ \ \: \ \ . ... . . ... .. ' . . . . .. . \ ... . . . \ \ \ ~ \ \ ' , \:a;i:a~a~iji~a~a --Iii - a- a a- a a aa aaaa ' * ' \ ,a \ \ \ \ .. \ ' \ \ . **~*To \ .. . ..... . . ' . ~ \ ~ ~ \
- I' * \ \
30 \ .. . : \ : . .. . ..
- 0. * .I' *
.. . .. . . *1 .:. :. ..... .. .. .... \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ : :.\ \ \ .. \ . ,.* a ; a a a 0 0 _Cl_CI a;; a a a_a a:\ * ** \ \ . . \ . *1* j' * . .. .... .. . .. ... \ . \ \ ... \ . \ \ --o---1. \ : .\ * \ *
- J* * . . \ .
. . ... .*,*.l**,* \ \ . \ *\*.t:-,* \o 30 25 \ 0 ~: \ .' \ \ \ *,I" \ \ . \ .. ... ... \ .. \~Cl\ \
- a a aa
- q. *** \ : :
-ljl - * - \ . \ * .:J * \ .. ...... .: : . :.. ~ . .. ... \ \ \ \ \
- J' * \ ..
~ :- ~ . .. * * > * ~00 .. 0 0 25 0 \ * \ \ * \ *
- I' * \ \ * ** J' *
*i * . l* ...,*.. .. \ \
- \
- 1* * \. \
. \ \ \ \ . . .\ .. . . \ . 20 ~ . : . * .. 20 0 ** ' \' .. . .. * '0 . \' \' \ . : . .. . . . \ :0
- 0
- J' *
* * .r * \ \ \ \
- j'
- 0 * \
o\ 00
- \ :
- I *
\ \ \ \ \ .... . . \ \ . \ \
- _I' *
\ \ \ \ \ \
- 1\ **
.. .. . . : : . . : : :a 0 \ ** ,.* 15 0\ * \ \ \ \ \ . . . : .: .. . : : ..... . \ \ \ \ * ,I * * \ *
- r* * \ \
~ \ \ ... °cbo _\ ~, 0\ . .. \ '
- I' * \:.:
\ \ \ \ ..- . - ..- .- ... . \ . ..... \ \ \ - \ \ \ \ \ \ \ 15 . . . . .. .,- .. .. \ . : . 0 \: * \
- I * \
\
- a *
.. . \ 0, 10 - ~- \ \ ., ... *,* \ \ * \ \
- 0 '(
,*.* *\** **\* *\** **\* \ ***\ .\:* ***\ **.*. \*.\ *\*. .*,* \,*, ,*.: *\** .*,* 10 . .. .:.* . :.*\ .. ( *.:. , ** a 5 ., *** *,* *.*, *'**'**'* ,*.\ *:* . . * * \
- 0o0o * \ * * *
\** . ** \ * (b * ** \ ., ... , .. 0 o 0 o *o 0 o 0 *~* \.*, ct> * \
- diooo~ ~ 0;
'* \ \ ~ .. \ ~ \ ~ bo~o;*~o 0 o \;o~ ;\;o l>O~\~ ~O~\ \* \ \ 5 a'o 0 0 o 0 o o 0 o\ 0 O O O <D \ 0 O 0 1b co O \ O O O 0 \ 0 OOO \ C 'o 0 o 0 C \ ; 0 O CD; \ 0 c 0; \ 0 O0 \ 165 160 155 150 145 140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 60 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 ' ... Westinghouse Electric Co. - NSD ST98 08/11/1998 10:33:05 q-'i( (;o~()ff0(- 0 7 ;. C~L~.A TUBES WITH VOLUMETRIC INDICATIONS ..,, <. c* Palisades May 1998 CPAL 2530 v 3 TUBE WITH VOLUMETRIC INDICATION
- 25 STAY ROD
- c 313 PLUGGED TUBE p . \"§)~f319h BIT5l~
u-u L! t.'-= L~- LI \1,~ \nl lS ©L~~t\] 165 160 155 150 145 140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 ?0 15 10 5 I 0 ~o~o o~o~ ~o~o 0 0 0 0 0 t~O@© b'1S'lnfirn[]~~ @!Tu 135 .35 ""'nlif?f"'\ P"r-.r'fif* 0 0 o 0 o o o G~lb)@u ~~..111 ~ \Sf ~(9.!Li. '9J Q 0 e
- O O O O e e e e * *
- e G Q
~ 0 * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- 0 ......
130 o~Qiu * * +*, * *
- j * * *
- t * * *
- j * * *
- t ** * * .---;-
- l * - ,-*.---;-----;--l--;-* * - j .~o 00 130
_¢lo~,* j *, *, l. - * * , l , , , , , ,
- 0
- 0 125 125 o~o Do"'()"
- 0 120
_oo * **** <P 0 ...... 120 6~. - V .. : * "-"oo v *** *** cp 0 115 l .. o~**
- 0
'o 0 115 110 110 o~ 0 0 * .oo b 0 ** 105 000 * . l 0 ** 1'00 . . . 105 100 100 95 _J:- .~o * : 0 cb 95 oo. 00 0 *
- 0 90 90 b 0 **
- 0
*
- 0 0
85 * *
- 00 85 oo.
o' 'o_ 80 80 .~o 75 0 i .. * : 0 <D 75 00 * * <f'o 70 _o' o_ 70 65 0 0 .oo 65 60 00 J:: .~o * : 0 <b **
>>>> POSITIVE I.D. ESTABLISHED<<<<< I 117 126 TSH TSH 610-ZP VOL TSH .07 .00 2 .26 91 105 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 117 126 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - * * - - - - * - * - - - - - - - -
- IRETEST FOR POSITIVE I. D.
117 126 TSH TSH 610-ZP DIM TSH 205.00 .00 0 115.00 61 105 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 117 126 TSH TSH 610-ZP PIO TSH .00 .00 2 .21 109 147 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 117 126 -------------------------------------------------------------1>>>>> POSITIVE I.D. ESTABLISHED<<<<< 116 127 TEC TEH 610-EC NOD 1 17 I 116 127 TSH TSH 610-ZP VOL TSH .00 .00 2 1.14 35 55 IRESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 116 127 - - - - - - - - - - - - - * * * - * - - - - - - - * * * * -.- - - - - - - - * * - - - - - * * - - - * - - - * - - - - - - IRETEST FOR POSITIVE I. D. 116 127 TSH TSH 610-ZP DIM TSH 225.00 . 00 0 115.00 59 55 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 116 127 TSH TSH 610-ZP PIO TSH .07 .00 2 .79 79 147 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 116 127 -------------------------------------------------------------1>>>>> POSITIVE I.D. ESTABLISHED<<<<< +----+----+---+---+------+---+---~--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------~ PAGE TOTAL TUBES 3 CPAL-A LISTING OF SPECIAL INTEREST +POINT RESULTS
- Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION:
+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ May-98 COMMENTS 14-May-98 23:59 32 7 o2c 02C 610-ZP NDF 02C - . 92 . 00 2 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 32 7 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03H 29.36 . 00 6 1 .40 86 33 IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 32 7 TEC TEH 610-EC INA 03H 28 .21 .00 6 33 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 32 7 TEC TEH 610-EC DSS 02C - .92 . 00 M1 .28 107 33 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 32 7 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 41 J I 42 7 02C 02C 610-ZP NDF 02C .92 .. 00 2 2 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 42 7 TEC TEH 610-EC DSS 02C .90 . 00 M1 .29 79 33 JRESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 42 7 TSH TSH 610-ZP ABO 1 41 I 42 7 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 61 I I 48 7 01C 01C 610-ZP NDF 01C 1. 03 . 00 2 2 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 48 7 TEC TEH 610-EC DSS 01C 1. 03 .00 M1 .59 133 33 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 48 7 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 41 1 I 21 28 TEC TEH 610- EC DSS 04H -.27 .00 M1 .26 122 35 JRESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 21 28 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT VS4 - .67 .00 M1 0. 10 357 35 I 21 28 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 43 I 21 28 04H 04H 610-ZP NDF 04~ - . 28 .00 59 J I 32 37 TEC TEH 610-EC DSS 03H .95 .00 M1 .44 134 37 JRESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 32 37 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04C 6.98 . 00 3 .60 68 37 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 32 37 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~ - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 32 37 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 45 I 32 37 03H 03H 610-ZP NDF 03H . 78 . 00 59 I I 112 37 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT 08H .99 .00 M1 3.49 174 35 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 112 37 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT 08H - . 06 . 00 M1 3.33 177 35 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 112 37 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT DBH .88 .00 M1 7.32 176 35 I 112 37 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT DBH .26 . 00 M1 8.36 173 35 I 112 37 TSH TSH 610-ZP ABO 43 1 112 37 08H 08H 610-ZP NDF 08H - .03 .00 59 I 112 37 08H 08H 610-ZP NDF 08H .90 .00 59 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 112 37 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 61 I I 114 37 08C 08C 610-ZP NDF 08C .68 .00 2 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 114 37 TEC TEH 610-EC 14 DBH .00 .00 M2 .39 35 JRESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 114 37 TEC TEH 610-EC 20 VS2 - . 76 .00 M2 .69 35 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 114 37 TEC TEH 610-EC oss oac .68 . 00 M1 .23 96 35 JRESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 114 37 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 43 J I 70 53 03C 03C 610-ZP NDF 03C - .03 .00 2 2 JRESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 70 53 TEC TEH 610-EC DSS 03C - .03 .00 M1 .38 96 5 JRESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 70 53 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 47 I I 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EC DSS 07H - .14 .00 M1 .48 138 9 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EC 11 VS1 .00 . 00 M2 .21 9 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+---- .-+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ JROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ PAGE TUBES 9 CPAL*A LISTING OF SPECIAL INTEREST +POINT RESULTS Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 14-May-98 23:59 +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+-----------------------~--------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EC 8 VS1 - . 72 . 00 M2 .20 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EC 20 VS2 1 .13 .00 M2 .65 9 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EC 8 VS2 - . 72 .00 M2 .20 9 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EC 6 VS4 - .61 . 00 M2 .14 9 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EC 14 VS6 .75 .00 M2 .39 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EC 36 VS6 - .69 .00 M2 1. 84 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 135 66 -------------------------------------------------------------l+CUSTOMER DECISION TO PLUG 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EC PIO VS6 -.66 .00 M2 2.13 27 I>>>>> POSITIVE I.D. ESTABLISHED<<<<< 135 66 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 49 135 66 07H 07H 610-ZP NDF 07H - . 20 .00 59 106 73 04C 04C 610-ZP NDF 04C .46 .00 2 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 106 73 TEC TEH 610-EC DSS 04C .46 . 00 M1 .45 47 9 IRESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 106 73 TSH TSH 610-ZP INA TSH .00 . 00 10 49 I RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION I 68 79 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT 02H .88 . 00 M1 5. 38 172 9 I 68 79 TSH TSH 6.1 0 -ZP NOD 49 1 68 79 02H 02H 610-ZP NDF 02H .79 .00 59 I I 130 107 02C 02C 610-ZP NDF 02C .95 .00 2 2 I RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 130 107 TEC TEH 610-EC TIU 13 I 130 107 TEC TEH 610-EC DSS 02C .95 .00 M1 .28 91 15 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 130 107 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 51 I I 60 121 02C 02C 610-ZP NDF 02C .76 .00 2 2 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 60 121 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT VS3 .68 .00 M1 6. 64 173 15 I 60 121 TEC TEH 610-EC DSS 02C .88 . 00 M1 .29 99 15 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 60 121 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 55 I I 116 121 04C 04C 610-ZP NDF 04C .96 .00 2 2 IRESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 116 121 TEC TEH 610-EC DSS 04C .93 . 00 M1 .38 101 15 IRESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 116 121 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 55 I I 120 121 05C 05C 610-ZP NDF 05C . 81 :oo 2 2 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 120 121 TEC TEH 610-EC DSS 05C .84 .00 M1 .53 144 15 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 120 121 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 55 I I 111 130 04C 04C 610-ZP NDF 04C - .16 .00 2 2 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 111 130 TEC TEH 610-EC DSS 04C - .30 :OO M1 .31 55 17 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 111 130 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDO 1 55 I +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+--- .. -+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ PAGE 2 TOTAL TUBES 16 CPAL-A LISITNG OF ALL PERCENT INDICATIONS Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 3: 5 +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I 50 7 TEC TEH 610-EC 11 vs3* - .96 . 00 M2 . . 36 33 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 50 7 TEC TEH 610-EC 28 VS5 - .95 .00 M2 1.25 33 I I I I 77 16 TEC TEH 610-EC 11 VS4 - . 74 .00 M2 .32 35 I I I I 44 19 TEC TEH 610-EC 6 VS4 .84 . 00 M2 . 17 35 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I I I 48 19 TEC TEH 610-EC 14 VS4 - .80 . 00 M2 . 46 35 I I 48 19 TEC TEH 610-EC 10 VS4 .91 . 00 M2 . 29 35 I I I I 84 19 TEC TEH 610-EC 7 VS4 - . 85 .00 M2 .20 35 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 84 19 TEC TEH 610-EC 7 VS4 .78 .00 M2 .20 35 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 84 19 TEC TEH 610-EC 6 VS5 .93 .00 M2 .17 35 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I I I 44 21 TEC TEH 610-EC 11 VS4 - .58 .00 M2 .35 35 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 44 21 TEC TEH 610-EC 13 VS4 .75 .00 M2 .42 35 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I I I 68 21 TEC TEH 610-EC 6 VS4 - . 79 . 00 M2 . 17 35 I I 68 21 TEC TEH 610-EC 7 VS4 .90 . 00 M2 . 22 35 I I I I 35 I 88 21 TEC TEH 610-EC 8 VS4 - .88 .00 M2 .25 I I I 94 25 TEC TEH 610-EC 3 VS4 - . 97 .00 M2 .11 35 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I I I 96 25 TEC TEH 610-EC 15 VS4 .90 . 00 M2 . 48 35 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I I I 99 26 TEC TEH 610-EC 7 VS4 - . 79 .00 M2 .20 35 I I I I 100 27 TEC TEH 610-EC 5 VS4 1. 08 .00 M2 .16 35 I I 100 27 TEC TEH 610-EC 9 VS4 - .64 . 00 M2 . 27 35 I I I I 95 30 TEC TEH 610-EC 13 VS4 .93 . 00 M2 . 41 35 I I 95 30 TEC TEH 610-EC 15 VS4 -.79 .00 M2 .47 35 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I I 104 31 TEC TEH 610-EC 7 VS4 .91 .00 M2 .21 35 I 104 31 TEC TEH 610-EC 7 VS4 - . 88 .00 M2 .21 35 I I 106 31 TEC TEH 610-EC 10 VS6 1.02 .00 M2 .31 35 I 106 31 TEC TEH 610-EC 11 VS6 -.84 .00 M2 .34 35 I I 108 33 TEC TEH 610-EC 8 VS4 .89 . 00 M2 . 22 37 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 108 33 TEC TEH 610-EC 12 VS4 - .97 . 00 M2 . 37 37 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I I 114 37 TEC TEH 610-EC 14 DBH .00 . 00 M2 . 39 35 RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION I 114 37 TEC TEH 610-EC 20 VS2 - . 76 .00 M2 .69 35 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I I 110 39 TEC TEH 610-EC 6 VS2 .92 .00 M2 . 19 35 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I *+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENlS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ PAGE TUBES 19 CPAL-A LISITNG OF ALL PERCENT INDICATIONS Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 3: 5 +- - - -+- -- -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - _._ - --+-- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -.- - - - - -+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - -- -+- - - -+- - - ---+- - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ 117 40 TEC TEH 610-EC 8 VS4 - . 79 .00 M2 .24 35 42 41 TEC TEH 610-EC 8 VS4 .95 .00 M2 .24 35 42 41 TEC TEH 610-EC 12 VS4 -1.00 .00 M2 .37 35 48 41 TEC TEH 610-EC 15 VS4 - .95 .00 M2 .47 35 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 48 43 TEC TEH 610-EC 9 VS4 .94 .. 00 M2 . 21 5 I 48 43 TEC TEH 610-EC 18 VS4 - .81 .00 M2 .53 5 I I 44 49 TEC TEH 610-EC 20 VS4 - . 58 .00 M2 .51 27 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EC 10 VS2 -1.04 .00 M2 .23 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EC 10 VS4 .92 .00 M2 .25 5 I 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EC 22 VS4 - . 83 .00 M2 .74 5 I 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EC 30 VS6 1.06 .00 M2 1 .30 5 !+CUSTOMER DECISION TO PLUG 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EC 23 VS6 - . 75 .00 M2 .80 5 I I 46 53 TEC TEH 610-EC 12 VS4 .84 .00 M2 .30 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 46 53 TEC TEH 610-EC 13 VS4 . - .83 .00 M2 .35 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I
- 46 55 TEC TEH 610-EC 8 VS4 .81 .00 M2 .17 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I
72 61 TEC TEH 610-EC 8 VS5 - .65 .00 M2 .21 7 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 82 61 TEC TEH 610-EC 11 VS3 - . 71 .00 M2 .29 7 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EC 11 VS1 .00 .00 M2 .27 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EC 8 VS1 - . 72 .00 M2 .20 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EC 20 VS2 1.13 .00 M2 .65 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EC 8 VS2 -. 72 .00 M2 .20 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EC 6 VS4 -.61 .00 M2 .14 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EC 14 VS6 .75 .00 M2 .39 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EC 36 VS6 -.69 .00 M2 1.84 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 135 66 -------------------------------------------------------------!+CUSTOMER DECISION TO PLUG I 100 67 TEC TEH 610-EC 20 VS6 - . 79 .00 M2 .66 7 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 132 67 TEC TEH 610-EC 7 VS2 - .91 .00 M2 .12 9 I I 134 67 TEC TEH 610-EC 11 VS4 -.85 .00 M2 .27 9 I 134 67 TEC TEH 610-EC 18 VS7 .98 .00 M2 .53 9 I 134 67 TEC TEH 610-EC 20 VS7 - . 72 .00 M2 .67 9 I I 48 69 TEC TEH 610-EC 15 VS4 .82 .00 M2 .43 9 I I 126 69 TEC TEH 610-EC 16 VS4 .83 .00 M2 .48 9 I +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB GEE PROBE IND LOG INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +- -- -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - -- -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ PAGE 2 TUBES 35 CPAL-A LISITNG OF ALL PERCENT INDICATIONS Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 3: 5 +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+-- -+- - - -- -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - -- -+- - -+-- - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I I I 134 69 TEC TEH 610-EC 13 VS7 .91 .00 M2 .35 9 I I I I 135 72 TEC TEH 610-EC 11 VS1 - .94 .00 M2 .27 9 I I 13s 72 TEC TEH 610-EC 7 VS1 .BB .00 M2 .16 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I I I 131 72 TEC TEH 610-EC 17 VS6 - .68 .00 M2 .51 9 I I 131 72 TEC TEH 610-EC 7 DBC 1 .12 .00 M2 .17 9 I I I I 130 73 TEC TEH 610-EC 8 VS? .96 .00 M2 .19 9 I I I I 130 75 TEC TEH 610-EC 10 DBH 2.02 .00 M2 .26 9 I I I I 133 76 TEC TEH 610-EC 7 VS1 .B3 .00 M2 .15 9 I I 133 76 TEC TEH 610-EC 12 VS6 .B7 .00 M2 .30 9 I I I I 131 76 TEC TEH 610-EC 9 VS4 - .80 .00 M2 .23 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I I I 136 77 TEC TEH 610-EC 12 DBC 1. 70 .00 M2 .30 9 I I I I 130 77 TEC TEH 610-EC 30 VS6 -.B7 .00 M2 1.31 9 I I 130 77 TEC TEH 610-EC 39 VS7 1 .09 .00 M2 2.19 9 !+CUSTOMER DECISION TO PLUG I 130 77 TEC TEH 610-EC 19 VS7 - .68 .00 M2 .62 9 I I 138 77 TEC TEH 610-EC 10 DBC .82 .00 M2 .25 9 I I 130 77 TEC TEH 610-EC 17 DSC -1.48 .00 M2 . 50 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I I I 133 78 TEC TEH 610-EC 17 VS1 - .66 .00 M2 .52 9 I I 133 78 TEC TEH 610-EC 9 VS4 .79 .00 M2 . 21 9 I I 133 78 TEC.TEH 610-EC 8 VS6 .88 .00 M2 .19 9 I I I I 135 78 TEC TEH 610-EC 18 VS6 .93 .00 M2 .56 9 I I I I 131 78 TEC TEH 610-EC 8 VS4 .94 .00 M2 .19 9 I I 137 78 TEC TEH 610-EC 8 VS4 - . 77 .00 M2 .19 9 I I I I 130 79 TEC TEH 610-EC 16 DBH 2.13 .00 M2 .45 9 I I I I 130 B1 TEC TEH 610-EC 11 DBH 2.01 .00 M2 .29 9 I I 130 B1 TEC TEH 610-EC 13 VS6 1 .10 .00 M2 .36 9 I I 130 B1 TEC TEH 610-EC 1B VS6 - .69 .00 M2 . 58 9 I I I I 01 B4 TEC TEH 610-EC 13 VS4 .92 .00 M2 .34 9 I I I I 130 B5 TEC TEH 610-EC 6 VS7 .98 .00 M2 .13 9 I I 130 B5 TEC TEH 610-EC 6 DBC -1.77 .00 M2 .14 9 I I I I 98 91 TEC TEH 610-EC 19 VS2 .B5 .00 M2 .55 11 I I 98 91 TEC TEH 610-EC 17 VS4 - .B3 .00 M2 .46 11 I +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+-----------------------------~--------------------+ PAGE 3 TUBES 52 CPAL-A LISITNG OF ALL PERCENT INDICATIONS Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 3: 5 +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ /ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPE/ COMMENTS +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+-- -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - -- --+- - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ 134 91 TEC TEH 610-EC 9 VS? - . 90 .00 M2 .21 11 134 91 TEC TEH 610-EC 13 DBC 1.63 .00 M2 .30 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 138 91 TEC TEH 610-EC 10 VS1 .88 .00 M2 .22 11 I 138 91 TEC TEH 610-EC 21 DBC -1 .91 .00' M2 .65 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 138 91 TEC TEH 610-EC 10 DBC 1.17 .00 M2 .24 11 I 138 91 TEC TEH 610-EC 10 DBC 1.79 .00 M2 .24 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 132 93 TEC TEH 610-EC 10 VS2 .63 .00 M2 .23 11 I I 135 94 TEC TEH 610-EC 10 VS6 1 .01 .00 M2 .22 11 I 135 94 TEC TEH 610-EC 7 VS? - . 76 .00 M2 .14 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 135 94 TEC TEH 610-EC 12 DBC -1. 88 .00 M2 . 27 11 /RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 136 95 TEC TEH 610-EC 31 VS6 .98 .00 M2 1.34 11 /+CUSTOMER DECISION TO PLUG 136 95 TEC TEH 610-EC 14 VS? .81 .00 M2 .35 11 I 136 95 TEC TEH 610-EC 13 DBC -1.84 .00 M2 .32 11 I I 135 96 TEC TEH 610-EC 23 VS6 .98 .00 M2 .74 11 I 48 97 TEC TEH 610-EC 12 VS4 .92 .00 M2 .28 11
- 134 134 93 93 97 TEC TEH 610-EC 97 TEC TEH 610-EC 104 TEC TEH 610-EC 104 TEC TEH 610-EC 11 VS1 6 VS2 14 VS4 12 VS6
.66 .66 - .52 .94 .00 .00 .00 .00 M2 M2 M2 M2 .29 .13 .38 .30 13 13 13 13 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 98 107 TEC TEH 610-EC 16 VS2 .72 .00 M2 .47 15 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 98 107 TEC TEH 610-EC 15 VS4 - . 80 .00 M2 .41 15 98 107 TEC TEH 610-EC 17 VS6 .93 .00 M2 .50 15 125 108 TEC TEH 610-EC 5 VS1 - .67 .00 M2 .14 15 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 125 108 TEC TEH 610-EC 10 VS4 - . 78 .00 M2 .28 15 125 108 TEC TEH 610-EC 11 VS4 .66 .00 M2 .28 15 113 110 TEC TEH 610-EC 29 VS4 - . 81 .00 M2 1 . 16" 15 126 113 TEC TEH 610-EC 18 VS1 - .81 .00 M2 .57 15 126 113 TEC TEH 610-EC 10 VS4 - .89. .00 M2 .26 15 54 115 TEC TEH 610-EC 4 VS4 - . 76 .00 M2 .12 15 90 115 TEC TEH 610-EC 5 VS2 - .89 .00 M2 .14 15 90 115 TEC TEH 610-EC 6 VS6 - .67 .00 M2 .17 15 102 115 TEC TEH 610-EC 5 VS2 -.80 .00 M2 .15 15 +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+----------------*----------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPE/ COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ PAGE 4 TUBES 68 CPAL-A LISITNG OF ALL PERCENT INDICATIONS Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 3: 5 +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ [ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPE[ COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ 98 117 TEC TEH 610-EC 19 VS2 .* - . 08 .00 M2 .57 15 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 98 117 TEC TEH 610-EC 40 VS4 .92 .00 M2 2.29 15 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 98 117 -------------------------------------------------------------[RETEST FOR POSITIVE I.D. 98 117 TEC TEH 610-EC 18 VS6 -.78 .00 M2 .53 15 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 102 121 TEC TEH 610-EC 12 VS4 - . 89 .00 M2 .33 15 I I 93 130 TEC TEH 610-EC 4 VS2 .91 .00 M2 .12 17 I 93 130 TEC TEH 610-EC 8 VS2 - . 70 .00 M2 .18 17 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 93 130 TEC TEH 610-EC 7 VS4 -.80 .00 M2 .19 17 I 93 130 TEC TEH 610-EC 19 VS4 .97 .00 M2 . 58 17 I I 107 130 TEC TEH 610-EC 3 VS2 - .48 .00 M2 .11 17 fRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 98 137 TEC TEH 610-EC 7 VS2 - .63 .00 M2 .21 17 fRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 98 137 TEC TEH 610-EC 23 VS4 .89 .00 M2 .80 17 I I 68 139 TEC TEH 610-EC 10 VS3 - . 77 .00 M2 .25 19 I 68 139 TEC TEH 610-EC 15 VS5 .90 .00 M2 .40 19 I I 40 147 TEC TEH 610-EC 11 VS4 -.65 .00 M2 .28 19 I 40 147 TEC TEH 610-EC 5 VS4 -.14 .00 M2 .14 19 fRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ fROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEf COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ PAGE 5 TOTAL TUBES 74 CP~-A- POSSIBLE LOOSE PARTS WJ Palisades May 1998 CPAL 2530 X 30 POSSIBLE LOOSE PART AT TOP OF TUBESHEET HOT LEG
- 25 STAY ROD a 313 PLUGGED TUBE 160 155 150 145 140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 so 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5
~W3~Wl1ftuJ~t'E o 0 o a...,,.- o_~coo~t~o~of o~o~t~o~of oooolo_ * * * * * * * * * * .~o~ o0 13~~~[QJ 0 *
- 0 * * * * * * * * *
- 0 0
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- 0 0 0
';' u\l;,~ ~~sififiooR ©\JO o oq *
- X* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- XX * * * * * * * * *
- o * * *
* *
- o oo
- oa I~ ~\~~irl!MU@
~J _. -:: ~("':'\r;;i~ 1 ~1Jv.J1\ ~_:. . . ., *************** ~z1r 01 a.a * . . .***. * * *** . . *. . *. . x*.* x* .. *.* . . **.* . * ... *.* . . *.* e.* * * *** *** * * *** o.oo ............................ *. a ... dl 0:. 0 T* 0 . x. *. .~o
- 0
( 120 0 ** 1 0 115 0-*n x .-o
- 0
- 0 110
...... ...h.o w 0 *
- 0* * *.*
\* * .
- v
- 00
** 00 105 ~o 00 . x. .." x:
- I * "'*
qio ' o ... D:* 100 .-o 0 ~ ** : x 95 0 oo:*
- n 00
- 0 90 mo
- x
- 0 0 T* * ** 0 o~
* *
- 00 85 0 *
~o* 'o~ 80 .-o 00 oE *
- 01>
Po 75 _o* o_ 70 ~ 0 * * * * *~~ 65 J:: .~o 'o D 60 00 ** <jl 0 0 o~ 0 _o* :a:cla~c: .. c_*. ... 0 o~ 55 50 * * ;-c-Cl~CI *Cl- ;c;c:
- c *.
0 0 ,*~~:~:,:~:~~~:~: Cl Cl Cl_CI __ Cl Cl_CI Cl m* 0 OT* * . * *cc;;;c;c~c;c;;;c;c c;c;;;c;c~cc *, 0 ..~ 45 *~~c~c!c~c~~~c~c!c~cc Cl Cl ~Cl! Cl~ Cl~~~ Cl ~Cl
- I 40 40 0 *-;-D-Cl:Cl-Cl-;-Cl-Cl:Cl-Cl- *-c-c:c-c-~-c-c~* (
*CI CICICICI CICICICI CICICICI CICICICI CICICICI CICICICI Cl CICl'j'
- c c_c __ c_c c c c c Cl Cl __ Cl_CI Cl~CI-35~
( 30 ~ . ....*l****r o*r * * * . .. .l.. . * * '* * *
- X*
- I * *
- c~c;c;~~c;c
* * ~~~Cl~CI -iji;c~Cl~Cl~Cl~I+
- Cl~~Cl~CI
- Cl
- 0 0
e-- 35 30 0 *;;~c; -Cl-Cl:. Cl Cl *. 0 Cl Cl Cl Cl Cl
- 0 o~ .**
.J--,2. Cl - 25 0
- Cl lb *** . x* a- 25 20 I
- 0 Cl 0
* *x 0 0 20 0 **
- 0 0
- 0 00 00 0 0 15 -\--e * ~ 15 0 >j,O o~ *
- 0 10 i 0
~% ... OB- 10 ti 0 0 0 *i' . t .. i .. 0 5 0 c o 0 0 o 0 oto o i o oto o i o oto o i o oto o i o oto o i o o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ** t %0000 0 * * * "i' . *
- t
- cooo oooo oooo oooo oooo oooo oooo oopo ooooloooo b;o;o
*
- t **
*
- i.. *
- t **
0 5 165 160 155 150 145 140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 95 90 85 t~. .. Westinghouse Eleetric Co. ** NSD ST98 06/11/1998 09:30:58 q<?t oo'Jot.(Of- ( D CPAL-A LISTING OF POSSIBLE LOOSE PARTS Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 14-May-98 19:28
- +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+
IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ 22 17 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .34 .00 10 .54 85 109 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION COMMENTS 23 18 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .42 .oo 10 .47 86* 107 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96 25 TEC TEH 610-EC 15 VS4 .90 .00 M2 .48 35 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96 25 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .41 .00 7 1 .23 88 41 RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 97 26 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .46 .00 7 1.28 88 71 RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 121 94 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .32 .00 10 .86 95 97 123 94 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .52 .00 10 .50 87 95 120 95 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .34 .oo 10 .72 89 97 105 98 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .14 .00 10 .68 87 131 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 102 99 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH 1 .18 .00 10 .52 84 133 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 127 102 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH 2.01 . 00 10 .86 96 95 I 126 103 TEC TEH 610-EC NDD 13 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 126 103 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .07 .00 10 .63 100 51 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 128 103 TEC TEH 610-EC NDD 13 128 103 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .07 .00 10 .88 96 51 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 18 105 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .29 .00 10 .29 89 99 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 130 105 TEC TEH 610-EC NDD 13 130 105 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .34 .00 10 .16 92 51 RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 132 105 TEC TEH 610-EC NDD 13 132 105 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .15 .00 10 .44 90 51 RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 129 106 TEC TEH 610-EC NDD 13 129 106 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .07 .00 10 .67 94 51 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 127 110 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH 1.08 .00 10 1 .10 98 99 129 110 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .56 .00 10 1. 03 98 99 110 111 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .17 .. 00 10 .87 96 101 100 113 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .63 .00 10 .52 98 99 102 113 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH 1.64 .00 10 .98 98 135 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+--- - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+
- PAGE TUBES 22
CPAL-A LISTING OF POSSIBLE LOOSE PARTS
- Palisades May 1998 Refuel
[ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LDC INCH1 PAL -A/2530 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS INSPECTION: +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ DEG TAPE[ +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ [' May-98 COMMENTS 14-May-98 19: 29 I 114 113 TSH.TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .26 .00 10 .58 94 99 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I I I 116 113 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .18 .00 10 .59 94 99 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I I I 95 116 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .18 .DO 10 . 77 97 99 I I I I 89 118 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .39 .00 10 .81 94 99 I I I I 115 126 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .12 .00 10 1.12 102 105 I I 115 126 TSH TSH 610-ZP VOL TSH .01 .00 2 1.05 68 105 [RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION I 115 126 -------------------------------------------------------------[RETEST FOR POSITIVE I.D. I 115 126 TSH TSH 610-ZP DIM TSH 380.00 .00 0 115.00 69 105 [RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION I 115 126 TSH TSH 610-ZP PID TSH .00 .00 2 .82 68 147 [RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION I 115 126 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - [>>>>> POSITIVE I. D. ESTABLISHED <<<<< I I I 99 130 TEC TEH 610-EC PLP TSH 2.77 .00 8 .52 188 17 [RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION I 99 130 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH 2.19 .00 10 . 58 89 55 [RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION I I I 107 130 TEC TEH 610-EC PLP TSH .69 .00 8 . 71 320 17 [RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION I 107 130 TEC TEH 610-EC 3 VS2 - .48 .00 M2 .11 17 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 107 130 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .35 .00 10 .35 198 55 [RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION
- I I I 109 130 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .21 .00 7 2.39 275 103 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I I I 32 143 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .18 .00 10 .93 91 155 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION
+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ [ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LDC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPE[ COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ PAGE 2 TOTAL TUBES 30 CPAL~A TUBES WITH MANUFACTURING BUFF MARKS _-,_.. Palisades May 1998 CPAL 2530 M 116 TUBE WITH MANUFACTURING BUFF MARK
- 25 STAY ROD c 313 PLUGGED TUBE 165 160 155 150 145 140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 le 90 85 80 o 0 m 0 o 0 o9o 0 o 0 ~ 0 o 0 o9o o 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5
- ~~~~1f[l]~~
_o_ct> ** o *T* * + * *T* * + o o 0 130 !,;\(?If} 135 0 0 o (Do* o
- 0 0 o~
."'()7~oooomo T o ~ - 130 ~[%J.LL-"-- 130 o0 * (D 1~ I 0 0 a ,r;.., fltt..:.rt(o\ ~ Ii w1~1 ~~ - lr.,11 - hihQiu@ t I QJ fL 0 * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- o * * * *
- 0 ~U0W ,Vr..3..1 I I t 1 - - 4J * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- 0 - /12 . ~ ~(= L~
to . . . o . . . 1 * . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . * * * . * . . * . .~~J~L~tn\fte ~~ o ..f' 125 * * * * * * * * *
- 0 * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- o o0
- 0. * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * !
0 * * * * * * * * * * * * ** * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- 0
.* 1\1.. 120 120 115 _ o 0 l~':'- *M
- 1\1
- M: *\:700
*
- di 0 -
115 ¢~7* * "o ** 0 0 - cb
- 110
- cb 00 o"
- M: : M: ...
~*
- M*
00
- 0
- 0 110 105 105 00 M *
- di
- 0
- oo_
100 100 (!) "'o cp:
- 95 0 *:ocb_
95 0 00* .oo 90 0 di 0 0 * * *M . ** ~ 0 dJ 90 85 o= * *
- 00 85 0
- 80 0 :~o -
.~o 80 75 0 1*. * : 0 cb 75 00 M 70 _o' . . 70 65 ( 0 0 ** * * * .."'o .oo 65 0 *:Om 60 00
- M: . : M: M M di 0 60 0 *M
. *M
- M* 0 55 55 OM* M M M M M 'o 50
- 0. ... * ,1 * * *M : M: .:.e1.:.clc~c.:_~.:_c *M o_ 50 0 M: M: c c c c c c c c c c ;--c-~c~* *~cccc~ccc~ ~ccc cccc cc~c c c c**
- M*
.... . M: .... 0 45 0°M* 'M . M M . * *1..
- M*
0 45 M *
- lj1 **
- c-Ci~f?c;i;c
- 40 0
- M* .. . ~~c~,~~~~~c~~c :M *
- 0 ch 40
- fc~c~ ~c~c cccc M
. .. :M:. .:t 0 ~,c_c_ 35 - 0 . ,c;i;c~I ~~IM* c c cccc c . M 35 30
- 0. 111 0 e .I,*
. ....* : M: M*
- M
* * * ~~~~~~~- - I I I- -c~a~~c * ... M' .: M:-**
- M'
* : M: 0 o_ 30 0
- M: ~:~~~~ r~~~r : M : M: 0 25 0 *M : I I I I --,
l r!I . M M' . 0 25
- r.
.*.t.*.*l*.*.t.*occl I I I 0 0 20 o-. +.*I*.+ M *1*. +. *l*. +.*I*.+ 1 * * * * * * *
- 0 M: * : M : M: 00 20 0 0 0
* ** * * * * * * *M *M * * * ** * *** * *** * ***M* ** * * * *** * * * ** ** * * * * ***** ** * * *****O *o 0 o*0 * **** *** * * ** * ** * ** * * *** * * * * *M* * * * * * * * * * * *
- M**M*
- O* **** ******* 0 15 " * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- rt * * * * . ! * *
- M * * * * * .. * *
- M 15 10
- M M
- ~o o~
M ..
- 1\1'
- rh
- 0
~ 10 M .* r\1 .* 0 0 ~( ( Ill M
- M'
- M*
0 5 ,M,*1*,*.1.*.*+*.*.1.* *j*,*.1.*.*+*.*.1*.*.* 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 cM o o o ~ o o~o o ~ o~o~o o ~ o o~o M ~ o M 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0000~0000 * * * .i. . 0000
- 0 m* * *
- 1. * -,- * +* . ' . 1. ' . * +* . * . 1. * .
- i *. ' .1* ' .
- i ' .*.1* * . ' 111 * *
- oooo~cooo~oooo~oooo~oooo~oooM oooo~oooo Mooo~oooo~oooo 00~0 0
0 5 165 160 155 150 145 140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 Westinghouse Electric Co.* NSD ST9B 0611111998 10:38:25 Q, '?! oo(}o c{rJ/ ~II CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MANUFACTURING BUFF MARKS .Palisades M~y 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 0:19 +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+------------------------------*--------------------+ \ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPE\ COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+---------------------.-----------------------------+ I I 32 7 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03H 29.36 .00 6 1 .40 86 33 \HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I I I 3 10 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM TSC 19. 78 .00 3 .69 78 35 \RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 3 10 -------------------------------------------------------------\HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I I I 11 10 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02C 36.28 .00 6 2.09 65 35 \HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I I I 16 13 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02C 36.69 .00 3 .85 104 35 \RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 16 13 -------------------------------------------'-----------------\HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I I I 22 13 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03C 10.80 .00 3 .60 123 35 \RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 22 13 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - --- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - \HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I I I 28 13 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03H 35.98 .00 3 .82 110 35 \RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 28 13 -------------------------------------------------------------\HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 28 13 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03C 17.74 .00 6 1 .92 69 35 \RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 28 13 -------------------------------------------------------------\HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I I I 17 16 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04H 15.66 .00 3 .BO 98 35 \RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 17 16 -------------------------------------------------------------\HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I
- i I I
45 45 2 16 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 05H 19 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04C
- 19. 36 16.68
. 00 16 -------------------------------------------------------------\HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED .00 3 6 . 47 92 35 \RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 3.02 81 I 31 \HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I I I 18 19 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02C 20.33 .00 6 1.52 69 35 \RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 18 19 -------------------------------------------------------------\HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 18 19 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01C 22.36 .00 3 .50 123 35 \RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 18 19 -----'-------------------------------------------------------\HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I I I 26 19 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04C 7.17 .00 3 .69 103 35 \RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 26 19 -------------------------------------------------------------\HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I I I 34 19 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM TSH 9.34 .00 6 1.53 66 35 \RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 34 19 ---------------------------------------------------'---------\HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 34 19 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01H 7.90 .00 3 .53 100 35 \RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 34 19 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -, - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - \HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 34 19 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM TSC 15.72 .00 6 1.48 75 35 \RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 34 19 -------------------------------------------------------------\HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I I I 48 19 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03C 35.81 .00 6 2.00 71 35 \RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 48 19 -------------------------------------------------------------\HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I I I 80 19 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 05H 10.53 .00 3 ,75 118 35 \RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 80 19 -------------------------------------------------------------\HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I I +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ \ROW COL CEB GEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS *DEG TAPE\ COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ PAGE TUBES 15 CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MANUFACTURING BUFF MARKS INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 0:19 .Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+------------~-------------------------------------+ INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPE! COMMENTS IROW ~OL. CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+--:---+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ 22 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM TSC 1 .76 .00 3 .77 67 35 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 1 15 22 *-------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 15 I I 22 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04H 26.49 .00 3 .45 122 35 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 1 59 22 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 59 22 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 05C 13.31. .00 3 .73 113 35 \RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 59 22 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 1 59 I I .00 3 1.02 68 35 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 12 25 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03H 4.88 25 -------------------------------------------------------------\HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 12 I I 28 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02H 6.27 .00 3 .58 41 35 \RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 45 28 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 45 I I TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04H 4.05 .00 6 2.46 77 25 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 2 31 I 2 31 -------------------------------------------------------------\HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I I TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03H 31 .31 .00 3 .56 120 35 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 22 31 22 31 -------------------------------------------------------------\HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03H 3.42 .00 3 .42 113 35 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 22 31 22 31 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I I e: I 26 26 31 31 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02H 28.38 .00 3 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03C 12.15 .00 3 .30 105 35 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION .38 108 35 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 26 31 26 31 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I I I TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02C 11 .10 .00 3 .40 79 35 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 40 31 40 31 -------------------------------------------------*-----------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I I I TEC TEH 610-EC MBM VS3 6.15 .00 3 .46 88 35 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 54 31 54 31 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I I I 2.19 80 35 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 34 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03C 4.67 .00 6 \ 11 34 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 11 .89 108 35 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 34 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02C 19.06 .00 3 I 11 34 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 11 I I .35 65 37 \RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 34 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01H .'oo 3 \ 39 34 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -*- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 39 I I .45 36 37 \RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 37 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01C 25.51 .00 3 I 6 37 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 6 I I 37 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04H 31 .83 .00 3 .46 45 37 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 8 37 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 8 I I .55 50 37 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 16 37 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01C 28.68 .00 3 +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+
- INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPE! COMMENTS
!ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ TUBES 28 PAGE 2 CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MANUFACTURING BUFF MARKS
- Palisades May 1998 Refuel I 16 CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 PAL -A/2530 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS INSPECTION:
DEG TAPEI May-98 37 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED COMMENTS 15-May-98 +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ jROW COL +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ 0:19 I I 18 37 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM TSC 6.47 .00 3 .72 99 37 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 18 37 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I I 28 37 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03H 25.68 .00 3 .50 94 37 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 28 37 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 28 37 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 05H 2.49 .00 3 .42 107 37 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 28 37 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I I 30 37 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03C 8.30 .00 3 .27 93 37 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 30 37 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I I 32 37 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04C 6.98 .00 3 .60 68 37 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 32 37 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I I 46 37 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03H 10.06 .00 3 .57 77 37 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 46 37 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I I 48 37 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM TSC 21.37 .00 3 .41 70 37 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 48 37 -----------------------*--------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I I I 45 40 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02C 6.14 .00 3 .44 88 35 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 45 40 ---'---------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 45 40 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02C 25.34 .00 3 .51 125 35 jRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 45 40 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 45 40 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM TSC 4.44 .00 3 .61 88 35 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 45 40 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 32 43 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04C 14.82 .00 .3 .77 112 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 32 43 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 32 43 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01C 5.50 .00 3 .69 120 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 32 43 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 32 43 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01C 6.21 .00 3 .60 97 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 32 *43 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 54 43 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01H 26.42 .00 3 .99 109 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 54 43 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 56 43 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 06H 7.42 .00 6 1 .90 73 5 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 56 43 -------------------------------~-----------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 106 43 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03C 36.36 .00 3 .66 63 5 jRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 106 43 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 15 46 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03C 7.03 .00 3 .44 63 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 15 46 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPE! COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ PAGE 3 TUBES 41 CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MANUFACTURING BUFF MARKS
- Palisades May 1998 Refuel IND LDC INCH1 PAL -A/2530 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS INSPECTION:
+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE DEG TAPEI +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ 35 46 TEC JEH 610-EC MBM 01C 24.95 .00 6 May-98 .96 72 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION COMMENTS 15-May-98 0:19 35 46 ___ : _________________________________________________________ !HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 35 46 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01C 26.52 .00 6 .88 70 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 35 46 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 51 46 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01H 31.08 .00 6 1.78 81 3 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 51 46 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 87 46 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02C 18.34 .00 6 1.17 86 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 87 46 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 8 49 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01H 26.67 .00 6 1.55 67 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 8 49 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 8 49 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04H 21 .17 .00 6 1 .60 79 3 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 8 49 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 8 49 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03C 29.53 .00 6 1.06 70 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 8 49 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 22 49 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01H 8.26 .00 6 .46 71 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 22 49 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 30 49 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02H 1.80 .00 3 .29 96 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 30 49 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 30 49 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02H 7.77 .00 3 .53 101 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 30 49 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 30 49 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02H 6.26 .00 3 .57 105 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 30 49 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 30 49 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02C 35.40 .00 3 .31 84 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 30 49 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 32 49 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04C 16.34 .00 3 .57 105 3 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 32 49 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 32 49 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04C 24.62 .00 3 .54 87 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 32 49 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 118 49 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04C 11. 74 .00 3 .43 83 5 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 118 49 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 5 52 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04H 16.58 .00 3 .46 94 5 IR.ESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 5 52 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 8 55 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04H 21.09 .00 3 .81 53 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 8 55 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 16 55 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03H 1.43 .00 6 1.37 90 5 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 16 55 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 26 55 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM TSH 2.74 .00 3 .79 97 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - --+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - - - - -- - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LDC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ PAGE 4 TUBES 52 ~1 I CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MANUFACTURING BUFF MARKS
- Palisades May 1998 Refuel IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 PAL -A/2530 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS INSPECTION:
DEG TAPEI +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ 26 55 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED May-98 COMMENTS 15-May-98 0:19 +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ 26 55 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM TSH 6.49 .00 3 .64 116 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 26 55 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 26 55 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01H 23.36 .00 3 .57 108 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 26 55 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 26 55 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01H 16.61 .00 6 .84 63 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 26 55 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 118 55 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01H 10.02 .00 6 1.41 71 7 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 118 55 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 59 58 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02C 27.33 .00 3 .77 112 7 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 59 58 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 28 61 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04H 1.88 .00 3 .70 93 7 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 28 61 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 42 61 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02C 13.93 .00 3 .95 103 7 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 42 61 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 33 64 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01H 13.13 .00 3 .44 104 7 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 33 64 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 33 64 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01H 8.21 .00 3 .89 114 7 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 33 64 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 33 . 64 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01H 6.97 .00 3 .67 121 7 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 33 64 --------:*---------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 54 67 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02H 5.29 .00 6 1.98 72 7 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 54 67 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 58 67 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 05C 1.26 .00 3 .51 113 7 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 58 67 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 58 67 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04C 7.43 .00 3 .39 99 7 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 58 67 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 74 79 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 06C 27.75 .00 3 .84 72 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 74 79 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -_- - - - - - - - - IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 118 85 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM VS2 20.93 .00 6 .88 79 9 !HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 118 85 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 06C 7.22 .00 6 2.09 76 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 118 85 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -*- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 105 88 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04C 33.12 .00 6 1.46 80 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 105 88 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 56 91 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 05C 11.55 .00 3 .49 125 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 56 91 --------------------------------------------------***--------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I +----+----+---+---+-~----+---+---+--------+--------+----+----- **---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+-----------*--------------------------------------+ PAGE 5 TUBES 64 CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MANUFACTURING BUFF MARKS
- Palisades May 1998 Refuel IROW COL 116 CEB GEE PROBE 91 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM VS1 IND LOG INCH1 8.59 PAL -A/2530
.00 6 INSPECTION: DEG TAPEI May-98 1.58 79 11 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION COMMENTS 15-May-98 0:19 +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+-- -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - -- - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+-- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ INCH2 CHAN VOLTS +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ':' - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ I 116 91 - - - - - - : - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -*- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - .- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I I I 120 91 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02C 9. 55 . 00 3 . 74 11 0 11 rRESUL T OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 120 91 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I I I 130 91 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 06H 15.12 .00 6 1.41 74 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 130 91 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 130 91 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04C 25.95 .00 6 1.71 60 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 130 91 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I I I 135 94 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM TSH 10.78 .00 3 .40 94 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION .I 135 94 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I I I 52 97 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM TSH 12.76 .00 6 1 .32 69 11 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 52 97 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I I I 108 97 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 05H 17.04 .00 3 .89 93 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 108 97 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 108 97 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 05H 25.59 .00 3 1.16 99 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 108 97 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I I I
- 28 103 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01H 31 .51 .00 3 .42 84 29 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 28 103 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I I I 51 106 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM TSH 11.84 .00 3 .65 105 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 51 106 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 51 106 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02H 26.25 .00 6 2.01 76 13 jRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 51 106 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 51 106 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 05H 12.87 .00 3 1.21 102 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 51 106 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 51 106 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 05C 8.17 .00 6 1.89 72 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 51 106 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I I I 48 109 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03H 26.08 .00 3 .78 72 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 48 109 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED
- I I I 108 109 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02H 20.90 .00 6 2.44 79 15 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 108 109 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 108 109 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 05H 1.79 .GO 6 2.40 71 15 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 108 109 -------------------------------'-----------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I I I 44 115 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03H 32.10 .00 3 .67 108 15 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 44 115 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I I I 23 118 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03C 14.51 .00 3 .66 111 17 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 23 118 -------------------------------------------------******------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I I I
+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ IROW COL CEB GEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS
- +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+
PAGE 6 TUBES 76 CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MANUFACTURING BUFF MARKS
- Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 0:19
+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ JROW COL CEB GEE PROBE IND LOG INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEJ COMMENTS +- - --+- - - -+- - -+-- -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - -- -+- - --+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ 2 121 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM TSC 25.14 .00 3 .59 113 25 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 2 121 -------------------------------------------------------------JHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 14 121 TEC TEH 61 0- EC MBM 01 H . 2.08 .00 3 1 .03 113 17 JHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 44 121 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04H 11.62 .00 3 .92 116 15 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 44 121 -------------------------------------------------------------JHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 44 121 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04H 12.52 .00 3 1.13 107 15 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 44 121 -------------------------------------------------------------JHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 46 121 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 05H 11 .66 .00 3 .96 115 15 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 46 121 -------------------------------------------------------------JHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 56 121 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03H 32.41 .00 3 .72 115 15 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 56 121 -------------------------------------------------------------JHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 5 124 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02H 21 .99 .00 6 2.31 73 17 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 5 124 -------------------------------------------------------------JHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 2 127 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM TSC 11 .69 .00 3 .73 124 25 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 2 127 -------------------------------------------------------------JHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 58 127 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04H 31 .89 .00 3 .64 120 17 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 58 127 -------------------------------------------------------------JHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 104 127 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04H 9.73 .00 6 1 .56 68 17 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 104 127 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 18 133 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM TSC 3.07 .00 3 .60 99 17 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 18 133 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 32 133 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02H 23.91 .00 3 .33 74 17 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 32 133 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 32 133 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02H 20.84 .00 3 .43 99 17 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 32 133 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 32 133 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02H 10.78 .00 3 .35 96 17 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 32 133 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 32 133 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02H 9.26 .00 3 .47 89 17 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 32 133 -------------------------------------------------------------JHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 46 133 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01H 33.26" .00 3 .51 99 17 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 46 133 -------------------------------------------------------------JHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 46 133 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02H 19.06 .00 3 .56 68 17 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 46 133 -------------------------------------------------------------JHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 46 133 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03H 24.03 .00 3 .48 93 17 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 46 133 ---------------'---------------------------------------------JHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 46 133 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04H 16.38 .00 3 .35 50 17 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 46 133 -------------------------------------------------------------JHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - + - - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - _, - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ JROW COL CEB GEE PROBE IND LOG INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEJ COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ PAGE 7 TUBES 87 CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MANUFACTURING BUFF MARKS
- Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 0:19
+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ !ROW COL CEB GEE PROBE IND LOG INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPE! COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ 46 133 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04H 20.84 .00 3 .46 98 17 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 46 133 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -.- - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 33 136 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM TSH 2.56 .00 3 .28 96 17 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 33 136 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 30 139 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03C 25.46 .00 3 .62 107 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 30 139 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 30 139 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02C 37.26 .00 3 .68 81 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 30 139 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 34 139 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03H 35.67 .00 3 .90 116 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 34 139 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 40 139 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04H 4.77 .00 3 .54 112 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 40 139 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 40 139 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03C 11. 23 . 00 3 . 39 109 19 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 40 139 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 48 139 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM VS4 24.57 .00 3 .77 79 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 48 139 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I
- 54 139 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM VS5 16.30 .00 3 1.67 66 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 54 139 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I
3 142 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03H 5.39 .00 3 .79 116 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 3 142 -----------------------------------------------------:-------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 15 142 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04C 29.71 .00 3 .61 112 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 15 142 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 27 142 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01H 33.11 .00 3 .27 93 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 27 142 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 8 145 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01H 3.75 .00 6 2.11 73 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 8 145 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 30 145 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02C 23.84 .00 3 1.14 100 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 30 145 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 30 145 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02C 29.91 .00 3 .65 84 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 30 145 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -*- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 50 145 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03H 27.22 .00 3 .47 70 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 50 145 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 50 145 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02C 25.32 .00 3 .35 101 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 50 145 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 9 148 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02C 36.50 .00 3 .92 119 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPE! COMMENTS !ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOG INCH1 INCH2 +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ PAGE 8 TUBES 100 CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MANUFACTURING BUFF MARKS Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 O: 19 +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ jROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LDC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPE! COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ 9 148 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 17 148 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02H 32.42 .00 3 .64 79 19 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 17 148 ---------------------------*--------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 21 148 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02H 35.69 .00 3 .88 121 19 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 21 148 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 21 148 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03H 33.79 .00 3 .71 115 19 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 21 148 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 21 148 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03H 30.10 .00 3 1.07 111 19 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 21 148 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 41 148 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02C 11 .20 .00 3 .45 87 19 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 41 148 -------------------------------------------------------------HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 12 151 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01C 29.18 .00 3 .84 52 19 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 12 151 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 18 151 .TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04C 35.66 .00 3 .77 112 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 18 151 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 26 151 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02H 2.19 .00 3 .55 58 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 26 151 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 26 151 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM TSC 22.66 .00 3 .62 106 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 26 151 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 46 151 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM TSH 9.70 .00 3 .65 116 21 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 46 151 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 46 151 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02H 6.30 .00 3 .41 106 21 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 46 151 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 46 151 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03C 19.23 .00 3 .54 114 21 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 46 151 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 50 151 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01C 34.55 .00 3 1.14 109 21 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 50 151 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 54 151 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01H 29.31 .00 6 2.24 77 21 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 54 151 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 46 157 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02H 5.99 .00 3 .44 117 21 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 46 157 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 54 157 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM TSC 13.74 .00 3 .41 113 21 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 54 157 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 9 160 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04H 14.07 .00 3 1.25 121 21 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 160 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 9 160 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04H 12.39 .00 3 .60 117 21 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - --+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - _: _- - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ jROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LDC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - ---+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - --- - - - - - - - -- - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ PAGE 9 TUBES 112 CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MANUFACTURING BUFF MARKS Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 0:19 +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ JROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LDC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEJ COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ 9 160 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 33 160 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04H 35.02 .00 3 .48 86 21 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 33 160 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 2 163 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04H -1 .54 .00 3 .57 101 25 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 2 163 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 4 163 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03H 18.48 .00 3 .83 112 21 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 4 163 --------------------------------------------------------C----JHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 4 163 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04H 36.96 .00 3 .82 113 21 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 4 163 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 12 163 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03H 7.31 .00 3 .49 107 21 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 12 163 --------------------------------------------------c*---------JHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ JROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEJ COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ PAGE 10 TOTAL TUBES 116 C!?AL~A TUBES WITH DENTS AND/OR DINGS . -~ Palisades May 1998 CPAL 2530 D 98 TUBE WITH DENT AND/OR DING
- 25 STAY ROD D 313 PLUGGED TUBE 16S 160 lSS lSO 14S 140 13S 130 12S 120 llS 110 lOS 100
_o_$c 9s 1 0 o~o 90 0s o ~ o o~o o ~ ao 0 0 T*o*o+o.0 0 T*o*o+o 0 o 0 o_ 7s 70 6S 60 SS 50 45 40 35 30 2S 20 lS 10 s APERTURE 135 o~ . * ** *1* * *-; * * *; ** *1* * * *; ** *r*"()"' * * * "r 0 0 0 1 eARD 1 * * * * * * * * * *
- Cl *
- 130 .... o o-.<p.- * *- * + * * * * *
- a o o_
130 0 o* ** ** * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- o' o 0 A i G.ft.
ft-ugall~llll@...a ... ""alleYRV ""In ~ O* **** **** **** **** **** ***O A9V A...atJAii 125 * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- o Aw~rture \:tim~
Cl
- 0 0
0 "t" 0 * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- l' *.' l' .**1* * 'l'
- l"*
- 1* ** 1* * *l** *** 1** *-* 'l' -* *1* *. 'l'.* *** 1**.*1 *.* *.* *1 ** ~-----;-l---;-<>o 0 * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- 0 ....
120 120 o"" * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- 0
_ o a<P. m *** **** **** **** **** **** **** ***e * * * * * * *
- ljl a
115 110 - : o"' * * *1 * 'f .*.*1** * 'f. * **1** *1 .-.*
- l * . *
'f .. *
- l * . *
*f ,*,
- 1*** *
*1 . * .
- 1-.-.l.
* **1** * * * *1* * .*t*. * *1 ,vo * *
- Do 0
115 110 o~ 00
- 00 105
- © ** *.oo lOS 00 * :qioo~ _o
- 100
- D: .:-o 100
_o %* 95 . *,0¢ 95 oo. 1j1~00 90 tho OT**** 0 * . ! D.*
- D ..
** :D o* D .. *.;a
- 0
~ct> 90 as 0 o' 0..,,. .* !) 00 o_ as ao J:* . * ""'o *
- 0¢ 80 75 75 00 * *<Po 70
_o* o: .* ..oo o_ 70 0 0 65 6S %* .~o * : 0 cb 0 60 00 D:
- D .
- D*
** ct> 0 60 55 _o' . a . __
- i
- a_*
*D
- D*
. o_ SS so _o 0 _c_clc_a *a*cijrccac ccc~ijr~a~*c**
- D* 0 o_
so 0 .~~~a~c!c~c~ ~c~a!a~~~~~c~c 0 45 0 0 4S
- b. cca;l:c:a~c~a~ijr~c~c;i;cc*,
* : ~ cb 40 0 0 . ~;~a Cece ceca DCCC CCC c a a __ a_c c c cc~c!c~c~~~a~c!c~a~~cc~c w*a: Ci wc-~--.:i-wa: cw cc a c
- D*
D
- rl1. :i 40 35
_o 0 0
- ~~:~:;~a~al I Il:ii;::~:;:l :- .: . .
- 1j1
- c D: * . . I.
.*D.-. .
- D * * !I* * ** 1h *
- j~ *
- o 0 o_
35 30 0 . . D ... *
- Wi
- D
~-: ~ * : +~-~~ I I I I I I-;~ ~ ~ ::::~ * *0* *I e I
- D o' [). o,. r. .
- D* . 0 30
*D .
- 1b *
- D* 'o
- D * * !.I *
. o*
- D*
- D*
- I.
- D* *
- D*
- D*
..- . ..- . D: ** . -.. . .-. ..,.-.. o 0 D *
- I D 25
.. ::;~I I I . 0 2S I I I I ...;;::: .*'* . . o, D Ill D D D ,o 20 0 0
- 0: : D : D:
- l~' *
- D*
-
- D* ~.
- 1h *
- D* *D D
- D* 0 o 20 0
':' . ;~ 0 I I I I I I 1°~;~ 0 0 15 0 0 *
- di 0 o; *
- 0 o_
15 10 10 5 0 0 0 ~:. .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 0 0 ** t . 'i' . t .. i .. t . 'i .. t . 'i* . t . 'i" . t . 0 e t t t s t t t t 0 t t t t t 0 G t t t t 0
- t t t t
0 0 aooo oooo oooo oooo oooo oooo oooo oooo oooo oooo oooo oooo % 0000 cooo 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 165 160 155 150 14S 140 135 130 125 120 115 110 lOS 100 95 90 85 BO 75 70 65 60 5S so 4S 40 35 30 25 20 lS 10 5 ,- ' .11;.._ Westinghouse Electric Co. - NSD STll8 06111/1998 10:35:28 q: ;4 ! 73 9 I I 20 103 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT VS4 .97 .00 M1 1~ - *70 29 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION +- - --+-- --+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+-- -+- - ----- -+-- ------+- - - -+- - - - . - -+- - - - +-:.. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ IROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOL-3 JEG TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--.------+--------+----+----. -*---+----+----------~---------------------------------------+ PAGE 3 TUBES 70 CPAL-A LISTING OF DENTS AND DINGS
- Palisades May 1998 Refuel
/ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 PAL -A/2530 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS INSPECTION: DEG TAPE/ +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ May-98 COMMENTS 15-May-98 0:23 +- - --+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+-- -+- - -+- -- - -- - -+- --- -- - -+-- - -+-- - - --+- - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - -+ 27 106 TEC TEH .61 0- EC ONT VS4 - . 92 . 00 M1 1O. 78 171 29 35 ro6 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT VS4 - . 69 .00 M1 7.47 171 29 87 106 TEC TEH 610-EC ONG 03C 9.87 .00 10. 38 179 13 133 106 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT DBC .78 . 00 M1 5.96 176 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 20 109 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT VS4 1 .03 .00 M1 s. 36 112 29 I I 24 109 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT VS4 .so .00 M1 4.98 171 29 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 26 109 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT VS4 .51 . 00 M1 12. 89 171 29 I I 21 112 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT VS4 - . 75 .00 M1 21 .49 170 29 I I 29 112 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT VS4 - .69 .00 M1 6.81 171 29 I I 89 112 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT VS6 .85 . 00 M1 7. 97 172 15 I I 20 115 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT VS4 1. 00 .00 M1 6.26 174 17 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I I 26 115 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT VS4 .56 .00 M1 6.59 174 17 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION .: I I 28 115 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT VS4 .56 .00 M1 5.80 174 17 I I I I 27 118 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT VS4 - . 74 .00 M1 7.78 173 17 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I I I 59 118 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT VS3 - . 79 .00 M1 6.61 173 15 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I I I 26 121 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT VS4 .48 .00 M1 5.80 173 17 I I I I 60 121 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT VS3 .68 . 00 M1 6. 64 173 15 I I I I 29 124 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT VS4 - .68 .00 M1 8.99 173 17 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I I I 57 124 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT VS3 - .81 . 00 M1 8. 88 173 15 I I I I 22 127 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT VS4 .57 .CO M1 14.69 172 17 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I I I 26 127 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT VS4 .40 .00 M1 5.90 173 17 I I I I 26 133 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT VS4 .48 . 00 M1 5 .. 8 , 74 17 I I I I 88 139 TEC TEH 610-EC ONG 05C 4.33 . 00 7.
- 81 19 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I I I 24 14.5 TEC TEH 61.0- EC ONT VS4 .65 . 00 M1 6. v
- 74 19 I
+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+----. *---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ !ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS C~G TAPE! COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------*---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ PAGE 4 TUBES 94 CPAL-A LISTING OF DENTS AND DINGS Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 I NS PE CTI ON : May-98 15-May-98 0:24 +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ !ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPE! COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+------------------------------------------~-------+ 26 145 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT VS4 .43 .00 M1 5.93 173 19 22 151 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT VS4. .59 .00 M1 8.82 171 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 26 151 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT VS4 .56 .00 M1 8.03 172 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 22 157 TEC TEH 610-EC. ONT VS4 . 81 .00 M1 17. 01 170 21 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 24 157 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT VS4 .86 .00 M1 6.49 169 21 I +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - --- - - - - - - - - - -+ !ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPE! COMMENTS +- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ PAGE 5 TOTAL TUBES 98 CPAL-A TUBES PLUGGED DURING MAY 1998 REFUEL -. Palisades May 1998 CPAL 2530 X 8 TUBE PLUGGED DURING MAY 1998 REFUEL
- 25 STAY ROD
- c 313 PLUGGED TUBE
,-, r.:-r.:.:ircf*~ril ~Fl!'? 165 160 155 150 145 140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 l./\~1J::: ~;J-~ u i'-~~)l-'n.J!C c o 0 c~ 0 o 0 o o 0 o 0 o 0 oXo'~o o I~ 0\ jw1fl-) 1 1 1 1 I I I I I I _0 _ ' 0 * * * * ' *
- 0 0 0 _ ~ I I I I I I I I I I I 13 s \:-::? :~-~b u1l l-::)
135 000 o o o* *.....* * * * * * * ** ** ** * * * * ** * * * '-'o"o' **001 o 0 ) * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- 0 0 130 I I I I l 0
..... -.. 0 o -* ,~ -* * *
- 0,....
* -* o o0 I I I I I I I I I I II I l I I 130 ff']""© ~~wnnoon(:, [Qlrli ~.l. c=J 12~1~P.,rQn11Lr\.~1 l'G0l70J 0 * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- 0 ~
125 ... o * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- o ...
o._...o...... * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- o-o 120 0
0 0 t
- 0
(~ 0
- 0 120 x . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . * . . . * . . . * * . . . . * * . . . . . . * . . . . . . . . * * . . . . . . * . * . * . * . . *. 0 115 X-- l * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- o * * * * .to 115 110
%~1 0 * * *i *
- 1* *i *
- 1 * *
- i*
- 1*
- f *
- 1 * *I*
- 1 * *!*
- 1 *
- f *
- 1 *
- f *
- l *
- f * -
0 0 0 0 110 0 -0 * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- 0 0 * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- 0 0 * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- 0 105 * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- 0 105 00
- h 00 100 0
I)='.
- x: . 0 100 95
_o . *
- 0 ch 95 00* 00 0 *
- 0 90 90 0
di 0 * *~Och 85 o""' * *
- 00 85 0
- o'
- o_
80 0 r.* . .~o *
- 0 cb 80 75 75 00 ©o 70 0
0 ** 0 .*~O O_ 70 65 65 "'o 60 55 o' Cl
- 10 5
165 0 0 CIOOO 160 o 0 o 0 155 0 o o 0 150 o o 0 0 145 0 o o o o 0 140 0 0 135 0 o 0 o o 130 0 o 0 125 0 o o o0 o0 0 120 115 0 o 0 o 110 o 0 o
- ct 0 0
0 0 0 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 o; 1* 60 o0 o0 55 0 o0 o 50 0 0 0 0 45 0 o0o 40 0 0 o0 35 0 o0 o 30 0 0 0 0 25 0 o0o 20 0 0 0 0 15 0 o0 0 10 o0 o0 5 0 o0 o 0 .,. Westinghouse Electric Co.* NSD ST98 08111/1998 10:34:18 q ¥10DfJ0{0!- I 3 .. CPAL-A TUBES PLUGGED DURING MAY 1998 REFUEL
- Palisades May 1998 Refuel I DATE ROW COL CEB GEE PROBE PAL IND LOG INCH1
-A/2530 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS INSPECTION: +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ DEG TAPEI +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ May-98 15-May-98 COMMENTS 0:47 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EC 10 VS2 -1.04 .00 M2 .23 5 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EC 10 VS4 .92 . 00 M2 .25 5 I 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EC 22 VS4 - . 83 .00 M2 .74 5 I 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EC 30 VS6 1.06 .00 M2 1.30 5 !+CUSTOMER DECISION TO PLUG 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EC 23 VS6 - . 75 .00 M2 .80 5 I 95 52 TEC TEH 610"EC PID VS6 .74 .00 M2 1.16 39 I>>>>> POSITIVE I.D. ESTABLISHED<<<<< 95 52 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 47 I 96-Nov 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EL 11 VS2 -1.15 .00 M2 .89 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EL 15 VS4 - .77 .00 M2 1.38 8 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EL 17 VS6 -.60 .00 M2 1.68 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EL 25 VS6 .94 .00 M2 3.02 8 I 96-Nov 95 52. TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 1 26 I 95-Jul 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EL 18 VS4 -.95 .00 11 1.58 26 I 95-Jul 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EL 24 VS6 .83 .00 11 2.34 26 I 95-Jul 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EL 16 VS6 -.97 .00 11 1.37 25 I 93-Jun 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EP PI VS4 -.88 .00 M1 .35 74 6 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 93-Jun 95 52 -------------------------------------------------------------IRETEST - TEST WITH WEAR SCAR STANDARD IN-LINE 93-Jun 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EP 23 VS4 -1.01 .DO M2 .56 33 I 93-J un 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EP 17 VS6 -1.02 .00 M2 .29 33 I 93-Jun 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EP 26 VS6 .84 .00 M2 .79 33 I 93-Jun 95 52 TSH TSH RPG-ER NDD 36 I
- 135 135 135 135 135 135 66 66 66 66 66 66 TEC TEH 610-EC DSS 07H TEC TEH 610-EC 11 VS1 TEC TEH 610-EC TEC TEH 610-EC 20 VS2 TEC TEH 610-EC TEC TEH 610-EC 8 VS1 8 VS2 6 VS4
- .14 .00 - . 72 1.13 - . 72 - .61 .00 M1 .DO M2 .00 M2 .OD M2 .DO M2 .00 M2 .48 138 .27 .20 .65 .20 .14 I 9 IRESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EC 14 VS6 .75 .00 M2 .39 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EC 36 VS6 - .69 . 00 M2 1.84 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 135 66 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - I+CUSTOMER DECISION TO PLUG 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EC PID VS6 -.66 .DO M2 2.13 27 I>>>>> POSITIVE I.D. ESTABLISHED<<<<< 135 66 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 49 135 66 07H 07H 610-ZP NDF 07H - .20 .DO 59 96-Nov 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EL 12 VS1 .37 . 00 M2 1 .04 7 96-Nov 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EL 21 VS2 1.09 . 00 M2 2.27 7 96-Nov 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EL 15 VS6 1.16 .oo M2 1.35 7 96-Nov 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EL 33 VS6 - .60 .DO M2 4.83 7 96-Nov 135 66 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 1 25 95-Jul 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EL 9 VS1. - .36 .00 11 .69 33 95-Jul 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EL 13 VS2 .98 .00 11 1.09 33 95-Jul 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EL 24 VS6 - .69 .OD 11 2. 51 33 92-Mar 135 66 TEH TEC 610-EP NDD 20
- 1. 38 77 TEC TEH 61 0 - EC 30 VS6 -.87 .00 M2 1.31 9 138 77 TEC TEH 610-EC 39 VS7 1. 09 .00 M2 2.19 9 !+CUSTOMER DECISION TO PLUG 138 77 TEC TEH 610-EC 19 VS7 - .68 .OD M2 .62 9 I
+--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+-------------------------------------~------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOG INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS
- +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+
PAGE TUBES 3 CPAL-A TUBES PLUGGED DURING MAY 1998 REFUEL ~alisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 0:47 +----.----+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB GEE PROBE IND LOG INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--.------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ 138 77 TEC TEH 610-EC 10 DBC .B2 .00 M2 .25 9 138 77 TEC TEH 610-EC INF DBC 2.23 .00 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 138 77 TEC TEH 610-EC 17 DBC -1.4B .00 M2 .50 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 138 77 *TEC TEH 610-EC PIO VS7 .B6 .00 M2 2.25 27 I>>>>> POSITIVE I.D. ESTABLISHED <<<<< 138 77 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 1 49 96-Nov 138 77 TEC TEH 610-EL 30 VS6 - .83 .00 M2 4.01 5 96-Nov 138 77 TEC TEH 610-EL 34 VS7 .74 .00 M2 5.0B 5 96-Nov 138 77 TEC TEH 610-EL 17 VS7 - .77 .00 M2 1.70 5 96-Nov 138 77 TEC TEH 610-EL 17 DBC 2.23 .00 M2 1.6B 5 96-Nov 138 77 TEC TEH 610-EL 14 DBC -1 .06 .00 M2 1.29 5 96-Nov 138 77 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 24 95-Jul 138 77 TEC TEH 610-EL 24 VS6 -1 .01 .00 11 2.56 11 95-Jul 138 77 TEC TEH 610-EL 29 VS7 .68 .oo 11 3.21 11 95-Jul 138 77 TEC TEH 610-EL 14 VS7 - .95 .00 11 1.35 11 95-Jul 138 77 TEC TEH 610-EL 14 DBC -1.64 .00 11 1.06 11 95-Jul 138 77 TSH TSH 620-ZC NOD 54 95-Jul 138 77 TS.H TSH 61 0 -ZR NOD 72 136 95 TEC TEH 610-EC 31 VS6 .9B .00 M2 1.34 11 +CUSTOMER DECISION TO PLUG 136 95 TEC TEH 610-EC* 14 VS7 . B1 .00 M2 .35 11 136 95 TEC TEH 610-EC 13 DBC -1 .B4 .00 M2 .32 11 136 95 TEC TEH 610-EC PIO VS6 .90 .00 M2 1.19 39 >>>>> POSITIVE I.D. ESTABLISHED <<<<< 136 95 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 1 51 96-Nov 136 95 TEC TEH 610-EL 27 VS6 1.11 .00 M2 3.42 5 96-Nov 136 95 TEC TEH 610-EL 1B VS7 .B3 .00 M2 1. 77 5 96-Nov 136 95 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 23 95-Jul 136 95 TEC TEH 610-EL 21 VS6 .97 .00 11 2.20 13 95-Jul 136 95 TEC TEH 610-EL 12 VS7 .B5 .00 11 1.20 13 93-Jun 136 95 TEC TEH 610-EP PI VS6 .73 .00 M1 .75 106 12 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 93-Jun 136 95 ------------------------------------------------------------- RETEST - TEST WITH WEAR SCAR STANDARD IN-LINE 93-Jun 136 95 TEC TEH 610-EP PI VS7 .B4 . 00 M1 .45 160 12 jRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 93-Jun 136 95 TEC TEH 610-EP 23 VS6 .B6 .00 M2 .56 33 I 93-Jun 136 95 TEC TEH 610-EP 17 VS7 .60 .00 M2 .29 33 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 9B 117 TEC TEH 610-EC 19 VS2 - . OB .00 M2 .57 15 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9B 117 TEC TEH 610-EC 40 VS4 .92 .00 M2 2.29 15 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9B 117 ------------------------------------------*------------------!RETEST FOR POSITIVE I.D. 9B 117 TEC TEH 610-EC INR VS6 .70 .00 M2 15 jRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9B 117 TEC TEH 610-EC INR VS6 -.OB .00 M1 15 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 98 117 TEC TEH 610-EC 1B VS6 -. 7B .00 M2 .53 15 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9B 117 TEC TEH 610-EC PIO VS4 .93 .00 M2 2.45 27 j>>>>> POSITIVE I.D. ESTABLISHED <<<<< 9B 117 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 55 I 96-Nov 98 117 TEC TEH 610-EL 19 VS2 . 14 .00 M2 2.10 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 9B 117 TEC TEH 610-EL 31 VS4 1 .05 .00 M2 4.31 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 9B 117 TEC TEH 610-EL 19 VS6 . 71 .00 M2 1.96 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 9B 117 TEC TEH 610-EL 18 VS6 - .OB .00 M2 1.91 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 9B 117 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 21 I I +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPE\ COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ PAGE 2 TUBES 6 CPAL-A TUBES PLUGGED DURING MAY 1998 REFUEL
- Palisades May 1998 Refuel I DATE ROW COL 115 126 CEB CEE PROBE TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH PAL IND LOC INCH1
-A/2530 .12 INCH2 .00 10 INSPECTION: CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPE[ 1.12 102 105 [ May-98 15-May-98 COMMENTS 0:47 +- - - - - - - -+- -- -+- - - -+-- -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- -- - - - --+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- -- - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ +- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+-- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ 115. 126 TSH TSH 610-ZP VOL TSH .01 .00 2 1 .05 68 105 [RESULT OF LEAD.ANALYST RESOLUTION 115 126 ----------------------------------------------,--------------[RETEST FOR POSITIVE I.D. 115 126 TSH TSH 610-ZP DIM TSH 380.00 .00 0 115.00 69 105 [RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 115 126 TSH TSH 610-ZP PID TSH .00 .00 2 .82 68 147 [RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 115 126 -------------------------------------------------------------[>>>>>POSITIVE I.D. ESTABLISHED<<<<< 96-Nov 115 126 TSH TSH 610-ZR TRA TSH -.01 .00 4 1.73 138 52 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 92-Mar 115 126 TEH TEC 610-EP NDD 5 I I 117 126 TSH TSH 610-ZP VOL TSH .07 .00 2 .26 91 105 [RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 117 126 -------------------------------------------------------------[RETEST FOR POSITIVE I.D. 117 126 TSH TSH 610-ZP DIM TSH 205.00 . 00 0 1f5.00 61 105 [RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 117 126 TSH TSH 610-ZP PID TSH .00 .00 2 .21 109 147 [RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 117 126 -------------------------------------------------------------[>>>>> POSITIVE I.D. ESTABLISHED<<<<< 96-Nov 117 126 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 1 52 93-Jun 117 126 TEC TEH 610-EP 1'JDD 17 116 127 TEC TEH 610-EC NDD 17 116 127 TSH TSH 610-ZP VOL TSH .00 .00 2 1.14 35 55 [RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 116 127 -------------------------------------------------------------*[RETEST FOR POSITIVE I.D. 116 127 TSH TSH 610-ZP DIM TSH .225.00 .00 0 115.00 59 55 [RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 116 127 TSH TSH 610-ZP PID TSH .07 .00 2 .79 79 147 [RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 116 127 ---------------------------------~---------------------------[>>>>>POSITIVE I.D. ESTABLISHED<<<<< 96-Nov 116 127 TSH TSH 610-ZR TRA TSH .00 .00 4 .69 103 52 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPE[ COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ PAGE 3 TOTAL TUBES 8 CPAL-'A UNSCHEDULED TUBES TESTED r! Palisades May 1998 CPAL 2530 X 7 TUBE TESTED FULL LENGTH FROM THE HOT LEG WITH BOBBIN PROBE e 25 STAY ROD a 313 PLUGGED TUBE ,-*r l~U21~~Lf'(}J)Ut@: ~ 1'[\ ["~rn-1 ~..r'--3.JIJ~ Ali~~i 1~~t7 t:.:fiiltE.il5J~~ GT~ n - -- \j ",,, [(r "'<> rod' 165 160 155 150 145 140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 A\p'\!'.-' l\Ll.L '"" '00~ 19. 0 _~c 0 o~t~o~ojo~o~t~o~ojo 0 o 0 0 135 135 o~ 130 o~ ..... 0 0010000
- f * *.*
** .I. * *"C:l"'cpoooo<Po * ~ 0 - 0 130 0
- 00 0 * * 'I'.
- 0 0
125 o:o: 0~00 125 00 * * **** <P 0 ...... 120 o~. *:ao :b 120 115 qio;- o 0 l':' 0 .~o 115
- 0 di. * *
- 0 110 o~
110 0
- 00
- 0 D0 * *
- 0 105
_o 00 * .* Do o_ 105 100 100 95 J:: * '-J * : 0 0 <D 95 oo: 00 0 *
- 0 90 90
- 0 rh 0 o T. *
*
- 0 85 oo: 00 85
_o' :o . . 80 J:- . .~o *
- 0¢ 80 75 75 00 ** cp 0
_o o_ 70 ~ 0 *
- x. :~~
70 65 0 D~ * * ~o *
- 0 di 65 60 60 00 * * <f>o
_o' o_ 55 _o 0 C_CllC~Cl~~~CI* . . 0 o_ 55 50 50 0 ~~~~+~~~~:~~~~~~~* ~~cc 0 45 0( 0 ' ccc -;- Cece CCC c:c--- CCC -c-c:c c CCC C c C * *
- 0 0
45 * :~~c~c c~c~ __ c~c~ ~c~c ( c_c _ _ c_c 40 40 35 _o 0 * ;-c-c:c-c-;-c-cic-c-;-c-c c cccc cccc cccc cccc cccc c c - c -- c c c c c c c c c-c-;-c-c cccc ccccl!I, c c c_c_di x: ( 35 -c-cic_c_r+. ~~~~~~:~c~c o' Cl Cl Cl cT
- c 0
_o
- c ~c~c'
- 30 0 * . ;~
- Cl Cl c c. cccc
---c-c l'
- 0 0
30 25 20 0 0 0 0 'oc c c c c 0 0
- oo 0
25 20 0
- x:
- 00 0 0
- o~. .
0 15 ~. ~ o, O~* * : di 0 o; *
- 0 o_
15 10 10 ~f. * -If&. x* 0 0 * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- 0
.. .'i' . . .~ .. . 'i' .. .~ . ..'i' ...~ ... 'i' ...t...'i'xooo t . .. .~ cooo ...t... 5 * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- 0 5
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- 0 0 cooo 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 165 160 155 150 145 140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5
\ Westinghouse Electric Co. - NSD ST98 06/1111998 13:14:25 q~(oo:;;.o'{or-/t./ CPAL-A UNSCHEDULED TUBES TESTED Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 11:49 +----+----+---+---+------+---+---~--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ jROW COL CEB GEE PROBE IND LOG INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I I 2 9 TEC TEH 6io-Ec NDD 31 I I 38 19 TEC TEH 610-EC NDD 35 I *1.~ 19 TEC TEH 610-EC NDD 35 I I 80 19 TEC TEH. 610-EC MBM 05H 10.53 .00 3 .75 118 35 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 80 19 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I I I 7 58 TEC TEH 610-EC NDD 7 I I I I 18 157 TEC TEH 610-EC NDD 21 I I I I 10 163 TEC TEH 610-EC NDD 21 I +----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ jROW COL CEB GEE PROBE IND LOG INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +- - - -+- _, - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -*- - -+ PAGE TOTAL TUBES 7 C~AL~ Palisades May 1998 CPAL 2530 A 267 03/90; RP B 40 03/90; RP STAB HL; RP CL c 1 03/90; TP WP HL; RP STAB CL E 3 ll/96;MP NX908SHK F 1 11/96;STAB & MP NX9088HK HL MP CL NX9088HK G 8 05/98; MP NX9982HK
- 25 STAY ROD 165 160 155 150 145 140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 OO>OOOO>OOOO>OOGo 1 ~o 80 75 0
70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 APERru** RE 135 I I I I I I I I I I I I :;O:;I O * * * * * *
- 0 0 0 - ftJrj, b~
0 0o0 o o* * ** * * " * * ** ** ** * ** * ** * * * *0 *... 10o0 ) VAHradP ::,p 0 <!> * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- 0 0
,..... 0 * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- 0 -
130 130 .i.. 0 - O -
- o O* * * " * *
- o
- 0 0
- Oo A ll A m$(Q) Anaa*i,,.ii..Ra ft ft 1W(gl1:JrnQ;iu11& ve" lt"1!.a"!l ri "
125 1 I I l I t I I I I ,... , . . . ~ o t. . . . * *
- 0 e * * *
- 0 -
0 ...... 0 A ~I) ue ~ 'b:f'8n M' t * *1*-*-;-*-*1*-.-t-*-*1*-.-t-*-*1*-*-1-.-. * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- 0 0 * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * (~
120 115 G
- o"*-;
- 0 G _G,..,[ * * *
- e e e
e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e 0 e e e e 0 e 0 Q *to 120 115 m 0~t * * * * ~ * * *
- f * * *
- j * * *
- f * * *
- j * * *
- f * * *
- j * * *
- f * * *
- l * * *
- f * * *
- j * * *
- f * * *
- j * * *
- t****j *. *. t. *.
- j * :oo 110 - ' 'o 110 105 bo * ..
00* 00
- 0
- 0 105 00 * *: f 0 0 _
_o
- 100 of:: : G: ..".- . .
....... 0 100 95 . *
- 0 d>
95 00* 00 0 *
- 0 90 90 cb 0
*
- 0 0 * ** 0 cb 85 o~
* *
- 00 85 0
- o* *o_
80 80 75 00 ot'.- 0 * : 0 cb 75 70 - 0. 70 0 0 ** * * **;**le* ;*o
- 0 65 60 0
h. . 0 ** om 65 60 00 (!Jo 55 o' o_ 55 0 .0 . . i ... *1 . .
- A:A A~A: :A:*
0 0 50 0 AAAA AAt*AAA** AAAA 0 50 45 0 0 cb ** *.A.A.A A.A *
- A.A A AiAAAA*
AAAA *
- 0 0
{ 45 40 A.A *
- A.A 40 0
0 0 AiflAAAAIAAAA 35 0 A~A~A~A~A~A 35 30 o' 0 * *!I!A!A;0a9sj ** A.AnB \ \ 0 10s2:i!A!A' nA.A E
- 0 0
30 ~ 9 0
- ~f~: I I I I I 1°::;4: . 0 0 0 25 - 25 0
0 ** * * *B ib *** 20 0 * *oB 0
- 00 20 o\l; .. .. '..... '.. ... ".. ..'.. .. .
0
- .:-j-:.: I: :J~
00 0 o, 0 15 ;-a-- I I I I I I I I 15 0 0 10 r~.... oe-0 10 t ....t .... i... .t ... 'i' ...t ...'i' ...t ...'i' .. .t...'i' . ..t ... 0 f * 'i' t * 'i'
- t * 'i'
- t * 'i' t * 'i"
- t * 'i' 5 5 0
0 0 0 0 Ao o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o o E o 0 o o o~o 0 o 0 o o 0 o 0 0 o 0 o o 0 o 0 0 o 0 o o 0 o 0 0 o 0 o o 0 o 0 165 160 155 150 145 140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 60 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 Westinghouse Electric Co. -NSD ST98 06/11/1998 09:13:51 ~ ~t OoJol(O f-/) Palisades May 1998 Refuel Steam Generator Eddy Current Inspection Indication Array Report Users' Guide INDICATION DISTRIBUTION REPORT This report is composed of two formats, MOST SEVERE INDICATION, and ALL FINAL INDICATIONS. The first category counts the WORST indication in each tube by leg. Therefore, each tube-leg can have a maximum count of one even if the tube has more than one indication present in that leg. Leg is divided into hot and cold. Hot leg is the section of tube from the tube end hot leg to the top support cold leg. Cold leg is the section of tube from the tube end cold leg to the top support cold leg. Which indication is WORSE than all others in a given tube is determined by a selectable INDICATION HIERARCHY. For example, if a tube has a DI (distorted indication) and an 89% indication in the hot leg, 89% is WORSE than a DI indication if 89% was set to a higher code value. In this case the category 80-89% would be incremented by one in the hot leg column. The second category, ALL FINAL INDICATIONS, counts all indications in each tube leg and attempts to eliminate redundant calls for the same location. Example: If *a tube has a DI and an 89% indication in the hot leg from one tape, and on another tape for this tube these indications were called again at nearly the same locations, the program will count two total indications in the tube, not four. It recognizes that there are only two separate indications. In this case both the 80-89% category and the DI category would be incremented by one in the hot leg
- column.
In both formats, MOST SEVERE INDICATION, and ALL FINAL INDICATIONS, there are three columns. CUMULATIVE shows all indications found since tape one - the beginning of the job. INCREMENTAL shows (if it is being used) all indications found since the last time this report was run. CUMULATIVE REPORTABLE shows all CUMULATIVE indications that are REPORTABLE. REPORTABLE is a term from the NRC Regulatory Guide 1.83 July, 1975 Rev. 1 "In Service Inspection of Pressurized Water Reactor Steam Generator Tubes". It refers to a class of indications from 20% to 100% inclusive. INDICATIONS VS. LOCATION FOR FINAL INDICATIONS This report references the frequency of indication occurrence against the locations of the indications. Example: If a DI indication has a count of three shown in the 3H (3 TSP HL) column, it means that three tubes had that indication exactly at 3H or referenced to 3H (3H + INCHES). This report eliminates redundant calls .
- Page 1 of 2 05/15/98 8:09 AM
Palisades May 1998 Refuel Steam Generator Eddy Current Inspection
- Indication Array Report Users' Guide INDICATIONS VS. PROBE FOR FINAL INDICATION This report references the frequency of indication occurrence against the probe sizes the tube data was collected with. This report eliminates redundant calls.
ALL CALLS VS. LOCATION (INCLUDES MULTIPLE TESTS) This report references the frequency of all database calls (terms), not just indications, against the locations of these calls. Example: If a ONT (DENT) term count of three is shown in the 3H (3 TSP HL) column it means that three tubes had that term exactly at 3H or referenced to 3H (3H + INCHES). This report DOES NOT eliminate redundant calls. This means if the same tube was tested on two separate tapes and a DENT was called at the 2H support plate on each tape, the ONT field will show two DENTS in the 2H column for this tube. This report is provided to describe the frequency of all analysis calls made during the inspection. ALL CALLS VS. PROBE (INCLUDES MULTIPLE TESTS) This report references the frequency of all database calls (terms), not just indications, against the probe sizes the tube data was collected with. This report DOES NOT eliminate redundant calls. Example: Assume a tube was tested on two separate tapes and a DENT was called at the 2H support plate on each tape. If the two tapes were collected with a . 720 probe then the . 720 column would show two counts. If the two tapes were collected with different probe sizes, the respective probe size columns would receive one count each. *
- Page 2 of 2 05/15/98 8:09 AM
SG - A INDICATION DISTRIBUTION REPORT 5-1 5-1 998 10: 57 Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A /2530 Inspection: May-98
- Most Severe Indication Per Tube Most Severe Indication Per Tube Leg Hot & Cold Legs All Final Indications (Includes Multiple Tests)
Cum. Iner. Cum. Rep. cumulative Incremental Cum. Reportable Cumulative Incremental Cum. Reportable Indication Hot Cold Hot Cold Hot Cold Hot Cold Hot Cold Hot Cold TRA DSS 2 3 3 3 DTS FSS LPS NQS INF 22 12 INR 28 28 36 3 PLP 27 27 32 MBM 113 69 58 98 69 MMB VOL 3 3 3 ADR
- NQI LPI
- OSI DTI PI
- WAR 1-19 60 60 121 20-29 9 9 9 9 12 12
- 30-39 4 4 4 4 5 5
- 40-49 1
- 50-59
- 60-69
- 70-79
- 80-89
- 90-99 100 SAI MAI
- SCI
- MCI MMI Total 245 0 14 203 61 0 0 14 0 333 87 0 0 18 0 "Incremental' reflects data since the last shift report only. "Final" indications exclude multiple tests.
- Reportable indication
- ~
~ Indication Vs. Location for Final Indications 5-1 5-1 998 10 : 57 Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A /2530 Inspection: May-98 Hot & Cold Legs TSH 01H 02H 03H 04H 05H 06H 07H DBH VS1 VS2 VS3 DSS 2 INF 6 2 2 3 INA 24 3 5 2 PLP 32 MBM 8 18 19 19 20 7 2 VOL 3 1-19 4 10 15 3 20-29 2 30-39 40-49 Indication Vs. Location for Final Indications 5-15-1998 10:57 Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A /2530 Inspection: May-98 Hot & Cold Legs VS4 VS5 VS6 VS7 DBC 08C 06C 05C 04C 03C 02C 01C TSC DSS 1 INF 4 2 2 6 INR 2 2 PLP MBM 2 4 12 13 18 9 11 VOL 1-19 54 3 14 8 10 20-29 4 1 3 .. 30-39 4 40-49 Indication vs. Probe for Final Indications 5-15-1998 10:57 Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A /2530 Inspection: May-98 Hot & Cold Legs 610 RPC DSS 6 INF 34 INA 17 22 PLP 2 30 MBM 167 VOL 3 1-19 121 20-29 12 30-39 5 40-49 -i All Calls Vs. Location (Includes Multiple Tests) 5-15-1998 10:57 Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A /2530 Inspection: May-98 Hot & Cold Legs TSH 01H 02H 03H 04H 05H 06H 07H 08H DBH VS1 VS2 NOD 9262 PIO 3 ONT 2 2 2 ONG 2 NDF 2 DIM 3 NTE OXP 2 DSS 2 DTS RBD 73 AND 9 RWS TIU 23 INF 1 6 2 2 3 INA 24 3 5 2 PLP 32 MBM 8 18 19 19 20 7 2 VOL 3 20-29 2 30-39 40-49 *~'\1 1 All Calls Vs. Location (Includes Multiple Tests) 5-15-1998 1O:57 Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A /2530 Inspection: May-98 Hot & Cold Legs VS3 VS4 VS5 VS6 VS7 DBC 00c 06C 05C 04C 03C 02C 01C TSC NOD PIO 3 ONT 6 74 2 2 ONG 2 2 2 NDF 1 3 4 DIM NTE OXP DSS 3 4 DTS RBD AND RWS TIU INF 4 2 2 6 INA 2 2 PLP MBM 2 4 12 13 18 9 11 VOL 20-29 4 3 30-39 4 40-49 All Calls Vs. Probe (Includes Multiple Tests) 5-15-1998 1O:57 Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A /2530 Inspection: May-98 Hot & Cold Legs 610 RPC NDD 1355 7907 PID 5 3 ONT 93 ONG 11 NDF 17 DIM 3 NTE OXP 3 DSS 15 DTS RBD 15 58 AND 8 RWS 2 TIU 23 INF 34 INA 17 22 PLP 2 30 MBM 167 VOL 3 20-29 12 30-39 5 40-49 'i ') CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MAY 1998 REFUEL INDICATIONS WITH ALL HISTORY Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 0:38 +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPE[ COMMENTS +- -------+- ---+- ---+- --+- --+- ---- -+- - -+- - -+- -------+- -- --- --+- ---+- --- --+- --+- ---+- -- -----------------------------------------------+ 9 4 TEC TEH 610-EC INA 05H 14.01 .00 M1 33 9 4 TEC TEH 610-EC ONG DBH 15.86 .00 11.09 175 33 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 4 TSH TSH 610-ZP RBD 41 I 9 4 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 61 I 96-Nov 9 4 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 74 I 93-Jun 9 4 TEC TEH 610-EP ONT 05H 14.02 .00 M1 9.40 175 35 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 23 4 TSH TSH 610-ZP INA TSH .47 .00 6 65 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 23 4 TSH TSH 610-ZR TRA TSH .47 .00 4 .77 202 73 \RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 93-Jun 23 4 TEC TEH 610-EP MBM DBH 6.44 .00 1 .56 155 35 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 93-Jun 23 4 TEC TEH 610-EP DNT VS4 - .86 .00 M1 7 .16 175 35 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 25 4 TSH TSH 610-ZP INA TSH .54 .00 6 65 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 25 4 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 73 I 92-Mar 25 4 TEH TEC 610-EP NDD 21 I I 24 5 TSH TSH 610-ZP INA TSH .00 . 00 69 [RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 96-Nov 24 5 TSH TSH 610-ZR TRA TSH .56 . 00 4 1 .48 208 73 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 95-Jul 24 5 TEC TEH 610-EL DNT VS4 . 74 .00 11 5.57 184 37 I 95-Jul 24 5 TSH TSH 620-ZC NOD 62 I I 32 7 02C 02C 610-ZP NDF 02C - .92 .00 2 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 32 7 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03H 29.36 .00 6 1.40 86 33 [HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 32 7 TEC TEH 610-EC INA 03H 28.21 .00 6 33 \RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 32 7 TEC TEH 610- EC DSS 02C - .92 .00 M1 .28 107 33 [RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 32 7 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 41 I 96-Nov 32 7 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 74 I 90-Apr 32 7 TEC TEH 610- A MBM 03H 28.20 .00 99 I I 50 7 TEC TEH 610-EC 11 VS3 - .96 .00 M2 .36 33 \RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 50 7 TEC TEH 610-EC 28 VS5 - .95 .00 M2 1.25 33 I 50 7 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 1 41 I 96-Nov 50 7 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 73 I I 3 10 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM TSC 19. 78 . 00 3 .69 78 35 \RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 3 10 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 3 10 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 41 96-Nov 3 10 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 73 11 10 TEC TEH 610-EC INA 03C -4.30 .00 M1 35 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 11 10 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02C 36.28 .00 6 2.09 65 35 HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 11 10 TSH TSH 610-ZP RBD 41 11 10 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 61 96-Nov 11 10 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 73 90-Apr 11 10 TEC TEH 610- A MBM 03C -4.30 . 00 99 16 13 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02C 36.69 .00 3 .85 104 35 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPE\ COMMENTS +- - - - - - - -+- -- -+- - - -+- --+- - -+- - - - - -+- --+- --+- ------ -+- - - -- - - -+- - - -+- ---- -+- - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+
- PAGE TUBES 9
-Ii CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MAY 1998 REFUEL INDICATIONS WITH ALL HISTORY Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 0:38 +- - - -- - - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- -- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - --+-- - - - - - -+- - - -+-- -- - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -- - - - - - - - - - --- - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - -- - -+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - -- - --+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - -- - -+-- -+- - - -+- - - -- - - - - --- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ 16 13 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 16 13 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 41 I 96-Nov 16 13 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 76 I I 22 13 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT VS4 1.03 .00 M1 6.05 174 35 I 22 13 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03C 10.80 .00 3 .60 123 35 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 22 13 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 22 13 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 1 41 I 96-Nov 22 13 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 76 I I 26 13 TEC TEH 610-EC INR TSH 4.47 .00 5 35 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 26 13 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT VS4 .39 .00 M1 8.18 174 35 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 26 13 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 41 I 96-Nov 26 13 TSH TSH 610-ZR MBM TSH 4.47 .00 4 .62 73 76 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 28 13 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03H 35.98 .00 3 .82 110 35 \RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 28 13 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 28 13 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT VS4 .48 .00 M1 5.97 175 35 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 28 13 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03C 17.74 .00 6 1.92 69 35 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 28 13 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 28 13 TEC TEH 610-EC INF 03C 16.40 .00 3 35 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 28 13 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 41 I 96-Nov 28 13 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 76 I I 90-Apr 28 13 TEC TEH 610- A MBM 03C 16.40 .00 99 I I 71 14 TSH TSH 610-ZP INR TSH 2.22 .00 65 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 96-Nov 71 14 TSH TSH 610-ZR TRA TSH 2.22 .00 4 1.67 195 38 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 95-Jul 71 14 TEC TEH 610-EL NOD 37 I 95-Jul 71 14 TSH TSH 620-ZC NOD 62 I I 17 16 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04H 15.66 .00 3 .80 98 35 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 17 16 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 17 16 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 41 I 96-Nov 17 16 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 87 I I 45 16 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 05H 19.36 .00 3 .47 92 35 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 45 16 -------------'-----------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 45 16 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 41 I 96-Nov 45 16 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 75 I I 71 16 TSH TSH 610-ZP INA TSH 1.28 .00 71 jRESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 96-Nov 71 16 TSH TSH 610-ZR TRA TSH 1.57 .00 4 2. 18 202 38 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 93-Jun 71 16 TEC TEH 610-EP NOD 31 I I 77 16 TEC TEH 610-EC 11 VS4 - . 74 .00 M2 .32 35 I 77 16 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 41 I 96-Nov 77 16 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 38 I I +- - - - - - - -+- -- -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -- -+- - - - :- - - -+- - - -+- -- - - -+-- -+- -- -+- - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - -- - -- -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+-- -+- - - -+- - --- - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ PAGE 2 TUBES 18 CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MAY 1998 REFUEL INDICATIONS WITH ALL HISTORY Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 0:38 +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPE! COMMENTS +- -- - - - - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -- -+-- - - - -- -+- ---+- - - -- -+- - -+- - - -+-- - --- - - - - - - - -- - - -- - - -- ---- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- -+ 22 17 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .34 .00 10 .54 85 109 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 22 17 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 76 I 92-Mar 22 17 TEH TEC 610-EP NOD 21 I I 23 18 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .42 .00 10 .47 86 107 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 23 18 TEC TEH 610-EL ONT VS4 -.78 .00 M1 11.41 174 16 96-Nov 23 18 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 31 96-Nov 23 18 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 76 2 19 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04C 16.68 .00 6 3.02 81 31 HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 2 19 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 41 96-Nov 2 19 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 77 96-Nov 2 19 05C 05H 580-ZB. NOD 98 90-Apr 2 19 05C TEC 610- A MBM 04C 16.40 .00 99 18 19 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02C 20.33 .00 6 1.52 69 35 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 18 19 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 18 19 TEC TEH 610-EC INA 02C 19.27 .00 M1 35 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 18 19 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01C 22.36 .00 3 .50 123 35 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 18 19 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 18 19 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 1 41 96-Nov 18 19 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 76 90-Apr 18 19 TEC TEH 610- A MBM 02C 19.30 .00 99
- 96-Nov 26 26 26 26 26 19 19 19 19 19 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT VS4 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04C TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD
.36 7 .17 .00 M1 .00 3 10.02 174 35 .69 103 35 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 1 41 76 34 19 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM TSH 9.34 .00 6 1.53 66 35 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 34 19 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 34 19 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01H 7.90 .00 3 .53 100 35 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 34 19 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 34 19 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM TSC 15. 72 .00 6 1.48 75 35 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION ~ 34 19 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 34 19 TSH TSH 610-ZP RBD 41 .34 19 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 61 96-Nov 34 19 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 76 90-Apr 34 19 TEC TEH 610- A MBM TSH 9.10 .00 99 90-Apr 34 19 TEC TEH 610- A MBM TSC 15.50 .00 99 44 19 TEC TEH 610-EC 6 VS4 .84 .00 M2 .17 35 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION .44 19 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 41 96-Nov 44 19 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 75 48 1.9 TEC TEH 610-EC 14 VS4 -.80 .00 M2 .46 35 48 19 TEC TEH 610-EC 10 VS4 .91 .00 M2 .29 35 +- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ I DATE ROW COL CEB GEE PROBE IND LOG INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPE! COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+
- PAGE 3 TUBES 25
CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MAY 1998 REFUEL INDICATIONS WITH ALL HISTORY Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 0:38 +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ 48 19 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03C 35.81 .00 6 2.00 71 35 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 48 19 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 48 19 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 41 I 96-Nov 48 19 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 76 I I 80 19 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 05H 10.53 .00 3 . 75 118 35 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 80 19 - - - - - - - - - --- - - - - - -- - - - -- - - - --- - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - --- - - -- -- - - - - HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 80 19 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 1 71 96-Nov 80 19 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 38 96-Nov 80 19 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 72 93-Jun 80 19 TEC TEH 610-EP NDD 31 90-Apr 80 19 TEC TEH 610- A MBM 05H 9.40 .00 99 84 19 TEC TEH 610-EC 7 VS4 - . 85 .00 M2 .20 35 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 84 19 TEC TEH 610-EC 7 VS4 .78 .00 M2 .20 35 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 84 19 TEC TEH 610-EC 6 VS5 .93 .00 M2 .17 35 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 84 19 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 41 96-Nov 84 19 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 38 81 20 TSH TSH 610-ZP INR TSH .40 .00 71 RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 96-Nov 81 20 TSH TSH 610-ZR TRA TSH .40 .00 4 .68 202 38 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 95-Jul 81 20 TEC TEH 610-EL NDD 1 37 I 95-Jul 81 20 TSH TSH 620-ZC NDD 62 I I 44 21 TEC TEH 610-EC 11 VS4 - .58 .QO M2 .35 35 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 44 21 TEC TEH 610-EC 13 VS4 .75 .00 M2 .42 35 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 44 21 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 1 41 I 96-Nov 44 21 TEC TEH 610-EL 10 VS4 - .48 .00 M2 . 77 9 I 96-Nov 44 21 TEC TEH 610-EL 16 VS4 .77 .00 M2 1.38 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 44 21 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 30 I I 68 21 TEC TEH 610-EC 6 VS4 - .79 .00 M2 .17 35 I 68 21 TEC TEH 610-EC 7 VS4 .90 .00 M2 .22 35 I 68 21 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 1 41 I 96-Nov 68 21 TEC TEH 610-EL 16 VS4 .78 .00 M2 1.49 9 I 96-Nov 68 21 TEC TEH 610-EL 11 VS4 - . 98 .00 M2 .87 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 68 21 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 1 29 I I 88 21 TEC TEH 610-EC 8 VS4 - . 88 .00 M2 .25 35 I 88 21 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 41 I 96-Nov 88 21 TEC TEH 610-EL 8 VS4 - .61 .00 M2 .68 16 I 96-Nov 88 21 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 29 I I 15 22 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM TSC 1. 76 .00 3 .77 67 35 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 15 22 -------------------------------------------------------------IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 15 22 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 41 I 96-Nov 15 22 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 78 I I +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ PAGE 4 TUBES 33 CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MAY 1998 REFUEL INDICATIONS WITH ALL HISTORY Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 0:38 +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEJ COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ 59 22 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04H 26.49 .00 3 .45 122 35 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 59 22 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 59 22 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 05C 13.31 .00 3 .73 113 35 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 59 22 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 59 22 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 41 I 96-Nov 59 22 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 78 I I 12 25 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03H 4.88 .00 3 1.02 68 35 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 12 25 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 12 25 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 43 I 96-Nov 12 25 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 78 60 25 TEC TEH 610-EC NOD 1 35 60 25 TSH TSH 610-ZP INA TSH - .41 .00 5 41 RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 96-Nov 60 25 TSH TSH 610-ZR TRA TSH - .41 . 00 4 2.76 168 78 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 94 25 TEC TEH 610-EC 3 VS4 - . 97 . 00 M2 .11 . 35 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 94 25 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 41 96-Nov 94 25 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 39 96 25 TEC TEH 610-EC 15 VS4 .90 .00 M2 .48 35 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96 25 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .41 .00 7 1.23 88 41 RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 96-Nov 96 25 TSH TSH 610-ZR TRA TSH .39 .00 4 1.71 324 39 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 97 26 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .46 .00 7 1.28 88 71 RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 96-Nov 97 26 TSH TSH 610-ZR TRA TSH .41 .00 4 2.13 328 39 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 92-Mar 97 26 TEH TEC 610-EP NOD 1 23 99 26 TEC TEH 610-EC ONG DBH 1.64 .00 6. 78 182 35 99 26 TEC TEH 610-EC 7 VS4 - . 79 .00 M2 .20 35 99 26 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 1 43 96-Nov 99 26 TEC TEH 610-EL ONT 07H 26.75 .00 1 7.39 193 8 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 99 26 TEC TEH 610-EL 11 VS4 - .92 .00 M2 .93 8 96-Nov 99 26 TSH TSH 6f0-ZR NOD 29 95-Jul 99 26 TEC TEH 610-EL ONT DBH 2.31 . 00 9 7.72 172 37 95-Jul 99 26 TEC TEH 610-EL 8 VS4 -1 .07 . 00 11 .72 37 95-Jul 99 26 TSH TSH 620-ZC NOD 1 60 100 27 TEC TEH 610-EC 5 VS4 1.08 .00 M2 .16 35 100 27 TEC TEH 610-EC 9 VS4 - .64 . 00 M2 .27 35 100 27 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 43 96-Nov 100 27 TEC TEH 610-EL 8 VS4 - .54 .00 M2 .67 8 96-Nov 100 27 TEC TEH 610-EL 12 VS4 1.24 .00 M2 1.07 8 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 100 27 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 29 45 28 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02H 6.27 .00 3 .58 41 35 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 45 28 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 45 28 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 43 +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEJ COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+
- PAGE 5 TUBES 41
CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MAY 1998 REFUEL INDICATIONS WITH ALL HISTORY Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 0:38 +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+-- - -+- - --- -+- - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ I 96-Nov 45 28 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 78 91 28 TSH TSH 610-ZP INR TSH .12 .00 71 I RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 96-Nov 91 28 TSH TSH 610-ZR TRA TSH .12 .00 4 2.72 191 39 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 92-Mar 91 28 TEH TEC 610-EP NDD 1 24 I I 92 29 TSH TSH 610-ZP INR TSH .01 .00 73 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 96-Nov 92 29 TSH TSH 610-ZR TRA TSH .01 .00 4 1.89 184 39 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 95-Jul 92 29 TEC TEH 610-EL NDD 37 I 95-Jul 92 29 TSH TSH 620-ZC NDD 60 I I 95 30 TEC TEH 610-EC 13 VS4 .93 .00 M2 .41 35 I 95 30 TEC TEH 610-EC 15 VS4 -.79 .00 M2 .47 35 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 95 30 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 1 43 I 96-Nov 95 30 TEC TEH 610-EL 17 VS4 -.72 .00 M2 1.62 8 96-Nov 95 30 TEC TEH 610-EL 19 VS4 1.15 .00 M2 1.96 8 96-Nov 95 30 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 29 2 31 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04H 4.05 .00 6 2.46 77 25 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 2 31 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 2 31 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 43 96-Nov 2 31 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 78 96-Nov 2 31 05C 05H 580-ZB NDD 98
- 96-Nov 22 22 22 22 22 22 31 31 31 31 31 31 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03H 31.31 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03H 3.42 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD
.00 .00 3 3 .56 120 35 .42 113 35 43 87 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 26 31 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02H 28.38 .00 3 .30 105 35 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 26 31 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 26 31 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT VS4 .48 .00 M1 10.93 174 35 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 26 31 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03C 12.15 .00 3 .38 108 35 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 26 31 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 26 31 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 43 96-Nov 26 31 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 78 40 31 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02C. 11.10 .00 3 .40 79 35 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 40 31 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 40 31 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 43 96-Nov 40 31 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 78 54 31 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM VS3 6.15 .00 3 .46 88 35 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 54 31 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 54 31 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 43 I 96-Nov 54 31 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 78 I +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+
- PAGE 6 TUBES 49
CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MAY 1998 REFUEL INDICATIONS WITH ALL HISTORY Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 0:38 +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB GEE PROBE IND LOG INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPE! COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ 90-Apr 54 31 TEC TEH 610- A MBM VS2 5.90 .00 99 104 31 TEC TEH 610-EC 7 VS4 .91 .00 M2 .21 35 104 31 TEC TEH 610-EC 7 VS4 -.88 .00 M2 .21 35 104 31 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 43 96-Nov 104 31 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 72 106 31 TEC TEH 610-EC 10 VS6 1.02 .00 M2 .31 35 106 31 TEC TEH 610-EC 11 VS6 - .84 .00 M2 .34 35 106 31 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 1 43 96-Nov 106 31 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 87 108 33 TEC TEH 610-EC 8 VS4 .89 .00 M2 .22 37 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 108 33 TEC TEH 610-EC 12 VS4 - .97 .00 M2 .37 37 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 108 33 TSH TSH 610-ZP RBD 43 108 33 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 61 96-Nov 108 33 TEC TEH 610-EL 13 VS4 1.00 .00 M2 1.17 8 96-Nov 108 33 TEC TEH 610-EL 11 VS4 - .57 .00 M2 .88 8 96-Nov 108 33 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 28 11 34 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03C 4.67 .00 6 2.19 80 35 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 11 34 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 11 34 TEC TEH 610-EC INF 02C 17.86 .00 3 35 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 11 34 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02C 19.06 .00 3 .89 108 35 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 11 34 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 11 34 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 43 96-Nov 11 34 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 80 90-Apr 11 34 TEC TEH 610- A MBM 02C 17.90 .00 99 39 34 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01H 7.15 .00 3 .35 65 37 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 39 34 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 39 34 TEC TEH 610-EC DNT VS4 - . 78 .00 M1 6.18 176 37 39 34 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 43 96-Nov 39 34 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 80 6 37 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01C 25.51 .00 3 .45 36 37 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 6 37 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 6 37 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 45 96-Nov 6 37 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 80 8 37 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04H 31.83 .00 3 .46 45 37 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 8 37 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 8 37 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 45 I 96-Nov 8 37 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 80 I I 16 37 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01C 28.68 .00 3 .55 50 37 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 16 37 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 16 37 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 45 I +- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+-- -+- - -+- - - -- - --+- - -- - - --+- - - -+- --- --+---+- - - -+- --- - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - --- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOG INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPE! COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ PAGE 7 TUBES 57 CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MAY 1998 REFUEL INDICATIONS WITH ALL HISTORY Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 0:38 +- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - --+- - - - - - --+--- -+- - --- -+- - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - -+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I 96-Nov 16 37 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 80 18 37 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM TSC 6.47 .00 3 .72 99 37 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 18 37 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 18 37 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 45 I 96-Nov 18 37 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 80 I 90-Apr 18 37 TEC TEH 610- A MBM TSC 6.20 .00 99 I I 28 37 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03H 25.68 .00 3 .50 94 37 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 28 37 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 28 37 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 05H 2.49 .00 3 .42 107 37 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 28 37 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 28 37 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT VS4 .37 .00 M1 6.24 178 37 I 28 37 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 1 45 I 96-Nov 28 37 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 80 I I 30 37 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03C 8.30 .00 3 .27 93 37 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 30 37 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 30 37 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 45 I 96-Nov 30 37 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 80 I I 32 37 TEC TEH 610-EC DSS 03H .95 .00 M1 .44 134 37 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 32 37 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04C 6.98 .00 3 .60 68 37 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 32 37 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 32 37 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 45 I 32 37 03H 03H 610-ZP NDF 03H . 78 . 00 59 I 96-Nov 32 37 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 80 I I 46 37 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03H 10.06 .00 3 .57 77 37 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 46 37 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 46 37 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 45 I 96-Nov 46 37 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 72 I I 48 37 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM TSC 21.37 .00 3 .41 70 37 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 48 37 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 48 37 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 45 I 96-Nov 48 37 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 71 I I 114 37 00c 00c 610-ZP NDF 00c .68 .00 2 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 114 37 TEC TEH 610-EC 14 DBH .00 .00 M2 .39 35 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 114 37 TEC TEH 610-EC 20 VS2 - . 76 .00 M2 .69 35 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 114 37 TEC TEH 610-EC DSS 08C .68 .00 M1 .23 96 35 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 114 37 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 43 I 96-Nov 114 37 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 71 I I 110 39 TEC TEH 610-EC 6 VS2 .92 .00 M2 .19 35 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 110 39 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 47 I 96-Nov 110 39 TEC TEH 610-EL 13 VS2 1.21 .00 M2 1.12 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION + - - - - - - - -*+ - - - - + - - - - + - - - + - - - + - - - - - - + - - - + - - - + - - - - - - - - + - - - - - - - - + - - - - +- - - - - - + - - - + - - - - + - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - + I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEJ COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ PAGE 8 TUBES 65 CPAL-A LISTING O.F ALL MAY 1998 REFUEL INDICATIONS WITH ALL HISTORY Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 0:38 +- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- -- - - -- -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- -- - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - --- - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - --- - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPE[ COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ 96-Nov 110 39 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 28 45 40 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02C 6.14 .00 3 .44 88 35 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 45 40 -------------------------------------------------------------[HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 45 40 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02C 25.34 .00 3 .51 125 35 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 45 40 -------------------------------------------------------------[HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 45 40 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM TSC 4.44 .00 3 .61 88 35 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 45 40 -------------------------------------------------------------[HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 45 40 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD *1 47 I 96-Nov 45 40 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 82 I I 117 40 TEC TEH 610-EC DNT VS1 1 .05 .00 M1 13.05 176 35 I 117 40 TEC TEH 610-EC 8 VS4 - . 79 .00 M2 .24 35 I 117 40 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 1 47 I 96-Nov 117 40 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 70 I I 42 41 TEC TEH 610-EC 8 VS4 .95 .00 M2 .24 35 I 42 41 TEC TEH 610-EC 12 VS4 -1 .00 .00 M2 .37 35 I 42 41 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 47 I 96-Nov 42 41 TEC TEH 610-EL 10 VS4 .91 .00 M2 .83 10 I 96-Nov 42 41 TEC TEH 610-EL 15 VS4 - .86 .00 M2 1.42 10 I 96-Nov 42 41 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 28 I 41 TEC TEH 610-EL 11 VS4 - . 80 .00 11 1.13 12 I 95-Jul 42 95-Jul 42 41 TSH TSH 620-ZC NOD 62 I 95-Jul 42 41 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 68 I-I 48 41 TEC TEH 610-EC 15 VS4 - .95 .00 M2 .47 35 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 48 41 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 47 I 96-Nov 48 41 TEC TEH 610-EL 15 VS4 - . 81 .00 M2 1.42 10 I 96-Nov 48 41 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 28 I 95-Jul 48 41 TEC TEH 610-EL 12 VS4 - .94 .00 11 (17 12 I 95-Jul 48 41 TSH TSH 620-ZC NDD 62 I 32 43 TEC TEH 610-EC DNT VS4 .90 .00 M1 5. 86 171 5 32 43 TEC TEH 610-EC INF 04C 13. 79 .00 3 5 32 43 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04C 14.82 .00 3 . 77 112 5 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 32 43 - - - - - - - - - - -- - - -- - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 32 43 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01C 5.50 .00 3 .69 120 5 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 32 43 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 32 43 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01C 6.21 .00 3 .60 97 5 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 32 43 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - -- - - - " - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 32 43 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 47 96-Nov 32 43 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 82 90-Apr 32 43 TEC TEH 610- A MBM 04C 13.80 .00 99 48 43 TEC TEH 610-EC 9 VS4 .94 .00 M2 .21 5 48 43 TEC TEH 610-EC 18 VS4 - .81 .00 M2 .53 5 48 43 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 47 +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEj COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+
- PAGE 9 TUBES 71
CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MAY 1998 REFUEL INDICATIONS WITH ALL HISTORY Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/253D INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 D:38 +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ 96-Nov 48 43 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 82 54 43 TEC TEH 610-EC INF 01H 25.11 .OD 3 5 54 43 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01H 26.42 .00 3 .99 109 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 54 43 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 54 43 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 47 I 96-Nov 54 43 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 82 I 9D-Apr 54 43 TEC TEH 610- A MBM 01H 25.10 .00 99 I I 56 43 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 06H 7.42 .00 6 1.90 73 5 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 56 43 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 56 43 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 47 96-Nov 56 43 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 82 90-Apr 56 43 TEC TEH 610- A MBM 06H 6.40 .00 99 106 43 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03C 36.36 .00 3 .66 63 5 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 106 43 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -.- - - - - - - - - HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 106 43 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 1 47 96-.Nov 106 43 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 70 15 46 TEC TEH 610-EC DSS 03H .03 .00 6 2.11 47 3 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 15 46 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 15 46 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03C 7.03 .00 3 .44 63 3 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 15 46 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 15 46 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 47 96-Nov 15 46 TEC TEH 610-EL MBM 03H -.14 .00 M1 .47 64 10 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 15 46 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 96-Nov 15 46 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 28 95-Jul 15 46 TEC TEH 610-EL 18 03H - .03 .00 9 .44 136 7 95-Jul 15 46 TSH TSH 620-ZC NOD 1 64 93-Jun 15 46 TEC TEH 610-EP DIN 03H - .09 .00 M1 .32 85 7 RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 93-Jun 15 46 TSH TSH RPC-ER NOD 36 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 93-Jun 15 46 03H 03H RPC-ER NOD 1 36 92-Mar 15 46 TEH TEC 610-EP 30 03H .00 .OD M1 .68 132 32 90-Apr 15 46 TEC TEH 610- A 22 03H .00 .DO M1 99 35 46 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01C 24.95 .OD 6 .96 72 3 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 35 46 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 35 46 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01C 26.52 .00 6 .88 70 3 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 35 46 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 35 46 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 1 47 96-Nov 35 46 TSH TSH 61 0- ZR NOD 82 51 46 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01H 31.08 .00 6 1.78 81 3 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 51 46 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 51 46 TEC TEH 610-EC INF 01H 29.70 .00 6 3 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 51 46 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 47 I 96-Nov 51 46 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 20 I +- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -- -+- -- - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+-- - - -- - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +- - - - - - - -+- -- -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - -- - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- -- - - -+- - -+- - - -+--- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - --+
- PAGE 10 TUBES 77
CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MAY 1998 REFUEL INDICATIONS WITH ALL HISTORY Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 0:38 +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ 95-Jul 51 46 TSH TSH 620-ZC NOD 65 90-Apr 51 46 TEC TEH 610- A MBM 01H 29.70 .00 99 87 46 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT VS6 .38 . 00 M1 6.93 173 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 87 46 TEC TEH 610-EC ONG VS6 -1.96 .00 6.91 181 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 87 46 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02C 18.34 .00 6 1.17 86 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 87 46 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 87 46 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 47 I 96-Nov 87 46 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 27 I 95-Jul 87 46 TSH TSH 620-ZC NDD 58 I I 8 49 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01H 26.67 .00 6 1.55 67 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 8 49 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 8 49 TEC TEH 610-EC INF 04H 20.02 .00 3 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 8 49 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04H 21.17 .00 6 1.60 79 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 8 49 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 8 49 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03C 29.53 .00 6 1.06 70 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 8 49 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 8 49 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 47 I 96-Nov 8 49 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 82 I 90-Apr 8 49 TEC TEH 610- A MBM 04H 20.00 .00 99 I I 22 49 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01H 8.26 .00 6 .46 71 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 22 49 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 22 49 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 47 I 96-Nov 22 49 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 82 I I 30 49 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02H 1 . 80 . 00 3 . 29 96 3 -1 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 30 49 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 30 49 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02H 7.77 .00 3 .53 101 3 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 30 49 -------------------------------------------------------------1.HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 30 49 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02H 6.26 .00 3 .57 105 3 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 30 49 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 30 49 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02C 35.40 .00 3 .31 84 3 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 30 49 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 30 49 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 47 96-Nov 30 49 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 82 32 49 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT VS4 .63 . 00 M1 6.01 173 3 32 49 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04C* 16.34 .00 3 .57 105 3 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 32 49 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 32 49 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04C 24.62 .00 3 .54 87 3 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 32 49 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 32 49 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 1 47 96-Nov 32 49 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 82 44 49 TEC TEH 610-EC RWS VS4 - .64 .00 M2 .59 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 44 49 TEC TEH 610-EC 20 VS4 - .58 .00 M2 . 51 27 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION +- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+
- PAGE 11 TUBES 83
*~ j 'I CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MAY 1998 REFUEL INDICATIONS WITH ALL HISTORY Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 0:38 +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB GEE PROBE IND LOG INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI .COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ 44 49 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 47 96-Nov 44 49 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 86 118 49 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04C 11 .74 .00 3 .43 83 5 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 118 49 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 118 49 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 47 I 96-Nov 118 49 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 67 I I 5 52 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04H 16.58 .00 3 .46 94 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 5 52 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 5 52 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 47 I 96-Nov 5 52 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 83 I I 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EC 10 VS2 -1. 04 .00 M2 .23 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EC 10 VS4 .92 .00 M2 .25 5 I 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EC 22 VS4 -.83 .00 M2 .74 5 I 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EC 30 VS6 1.06 .00 M2 1.30 5 !+CUSTOMER DECISION TO PLUG 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EC 23 VS6 - . 75 .00 M2 .80 5 I 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EC PID VS6 .74 .00 M2 1.16 39 I>>>>> POSITIVE I.D. ESTABLISHED <<<<< 95 52 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 47 I 96-Nov 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EL 11 VS2 -1.15 .00 M2 .89 8 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EL 15 VS4 - . 77 . 00 M2 1.38 8 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EL 17 VS6 - .60 .00 M2 1.68 8 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EL 25 VS6 .94 .00 M2 3.02 8 96-Nov 95 52 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 1 26 95-Jul 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EL 18 VS4 -.95 .00 11 1.58 26 95-Jul 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EL 24 VS6 .83 .00 11 2.34 26 95-Jul 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EL 16 VS6 -.97 .00 11 1.37 26 93-Jun 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EP PI VS4 -.88 .00 M1 .35 74 6 RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 93-Jun 95 52 ------------------------------------------------------------- RETEST - TEST WITH WEAR SCAR STANDARD IN-LINE 93-Jun 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EP 23 VS4 -1.01 .00 M2 .56 33 93-Jun 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EP 17 VS6 -1 .02 .00 M2 .29 33 93-Jun 95 52 TEC TEH 610-EP 26 VS6 .84 .00 M2 .79 33 93-Jun 95 52 TSH TSH RPG-ER NDD 1 36 46 53 TEC TEH 610-EC 12 VS4 .84 .00 M2 .30 5 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 46 53 TEC TEH 610-EC 13 VS4 - . 83 .00 M2 .35 5 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 46 53 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 157 96-Nov 46 53 TEC TEH 610-EL 12 VS4 .94 .00 M2 1.01 10 96-Nov 46 53 TEC TEH 610-EL 15 VS4 -1. 03 . 00 M2 1.40 10 96-Nov 46 53 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 110 95-Jul 46 53 TEC TEH 610-EL 13 VS4 - .60 .00 11 1.24 6 95-Jul 46 53 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 77 95-Jul 46 53 TSH TSH 620-ZC NDD 84 8 55 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04H 21.09 .00 3 .81 53 5 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 8 55 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 8 55 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 47 +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB GEE PROBE IND LOG INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ PAGE 12 TUBES 88 -~.
- \~
CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MAY 1998 REFUEL INDICATIONS WITH ALL HISTORY Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 0:38 +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB GEE PROBE IND LOG INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPE[ COMMENTS +- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -- -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- ---- -+- - -+- - - -+- - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ 96-Nov 8 55 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 84 I I 16 55 TEC TEH 610-EC INF 03H .47 .00 M1 5 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 16 55 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03H 1.43 .00 6 1.37 90 5 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 16 55 -------------------------------------------------------------[HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 16 55 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 47 [ I 96-Nov 16 55 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 83 j I 90-Apr 16 55 TEC TEH 610- A MBM 03H .40 .00 99 j I I I 26 55 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM TSH 2.74 .00 3 .79 97 5 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 26 55 -------------------------------------------------------------[HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 26 55 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM TSH 6.49 .00 3 .64 116 5 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 26 55 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - [HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 26 55 TEC TEH 610-EC INF 01H 15.62 .00 3 5 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 26 55 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01H 23.36 .00 3 .57 108 5 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 26 55 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 26 55 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01H 16.61 .00 6 .84 63 5 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 26 55 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 26 55 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT VS4 .41 .00 M1 5.25 355 5 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 26 55 TSH. TSH 610-ZP NDD 47 I 96-Nov 26 55 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 86 I 90-Apr 26 55 TEC TEH 610- A MBM 01H 15.60 .00 99 I 90-Apr 26 55 TEC TEH 610- A MBM TSH 2.70 .00 99 I I 46 55 TEC TEH 610-EC 8 VS4 .81 .00 M2 .17 5 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 46 55 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 157 I 96-Nov 46 55 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 111 I I 118 55 TEC TEH 610-EC INF 01H 8.72 .00 3 7 \RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 118 55 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01H 10.02 .00 6 1.41 71 7 \RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 118 55 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 118 55 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 47 I 96-Nov 118 55 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 87 I 90-Apr 118 55 TEC TEH 610- A MBM 01H 8.70 .00 99 I I ~ 59 58 TEC TEH 610-EC INF 02C 26.31 .00 3 7 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 59 58 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02C 27.33 .00 3 .77 112 7 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 59 58 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 59 58 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 47 I 96-Nov 59 58 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 110 I 90-Apr 59 58 TEC TEH 610- A MBM 02C 26.30 .00 99 I I 28 61 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04H 1.88 .00 3 .70 93 7 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 28 61 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 28 61 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 153 I 96-Nov 28 61 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 112 I I 42 61 TEC TEH 610-EC INF 02C 12.67 .00 3 7 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB GEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPE\ COMMENTS +- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - -- - - - -+- - - -+- - --- -+- - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ PAGE 13 TUBES 95 CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MAY 1998 REFUEL INDICATIONS WITH ALL HISTORY Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 0:38 +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPE[ COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ 42 61 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02C 13.93 .00 3 .95 103 7 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 42 61 -------------------------------------------------------------[HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 42 61 TSH TSH 610--ZP NDD 153 I 96-Nov 42 61 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 110 I 90-Apr 42 61 TEC TEH 610- A MBM 02C 12.70 .00 99 I I 72 61 TEC TEH 610-EC 8 VS5 - .65 .00 M2 .21 7 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 72 61 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 49 I 96-Nov 72 61 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 66 I I 82 61 TEC TEH 610-EC 11 VS3 - . 71 .00 M2 .29 7 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 82 61 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 49 I 96-Nov 82 61 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 65 I I 33 64 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01H 13.13 .00 3 .44 104 7 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 33 64 -------------------------------------------------------------[HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 33 64 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01H 8.21 .00 3 .89 114 7 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 33 64 -------------------------------------------------------------[HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 33 64 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01H 6.97 .00 3 .67 121 7 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 33 64 -------------------------------------------------------------[HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 33 64 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 153 I 96-Nov 33 64 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 103 I 96-Nov 33 64 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 105 I 95-Jul 33 64 TSH TSH 620-ZC NOD 84 I I 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EC DSS 07H -.14 .00 M1 .48 138 9 [RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EC 11 VS1 .00 .00 M2 .27 9 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EC 8 VS1 - . 72 .00 M2 .20 9 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EC 20 VS2 1.13 .00 M2 .65 9 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EC 8 VS2 - . 72 .00 M2 .20 9 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION -135 66 TEC TEH 610-EC 6 VS4 - .61 .00 M2 .14 9 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EC 14 VS6 .75 .00 M2 .39 9 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EC 36 VS6 - .69 .00 M2 1.84. 9 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 135 66 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - +CUSTOMER DECISION TO PLUG 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EC PIO VS6 - .66 .00 M2 2.13 27 >>>>> POSITIVE I.D. ESTABLISHED <<<<< 135 66 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 49 135 66 07H 07H 610-ZP NDF 07H - .20 .00 59 96-Nov 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EL 12 VS1 .37 . 00 M2 1.04 7 96-Nov 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EL 21 VS2 1.09 .00 M2 2.27 7 96-Nov 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EL 15 VS6 1.16 .00 M2 1.35 7 96-Nov 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EL 33 VS6 - .60 .00 M2 4.83 7 96-Nov 135 66 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 25 95-Jul 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EL 9 VS1 -.36 .00 11 .69 33 95-Jul 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EL 13 VS2 .98 .00 11 1.09 33 95-Jul 135 66 TEC TEH 610-EL 24 VS6 -.69 .00 11 2.51 33 92-Mar 135 66 TEH TEC 610-EP NOD 20 54 67 TEC TEH 610-EC INF 02H 4.19 .00 3 7 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPE[ COMMENTS +- - - - - - - -+- -- -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - -- - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ PAGE 14 TUBES 100 CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MAY 1998 REFUEL INDICATIONS WITH ALL HISTORY Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 0:38 +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- --+- - - - - - - -+- -- - - - --+- - - -+- - -- - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ 54 67 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02H 5.29 .00 6 1.98 72 7 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 54 67 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 54 67 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 47 96-Nov 54 67 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 103 90-Apr 54 67 TEC TEH 610- A MBM 02H 4.20 .00 99 58 67 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 05C 1.26 .00 3 .51 113 7 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 58 67 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 58 67 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04C 7.43 .00 3 .39 99 7 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 58 67 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 58 67 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 47 96-Nov 58 67 TSH TSH 610-2;R NOD 103 100 67 TEC TEH 610-EC 20 VS6 -.79 .00 M2 .66 7 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 100 67 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 49 96-Nov 100 67 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 63 132 67 TEC TEH 610-EC 7 VS2 - .91 .00 M2 .12 9 132 67 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 49 96-Nov 132 67 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 63 95-Jul 132 67 TEC TEH 610-EL NOD 34 134 67 TEC TEH 610-EC 11 VS4 - .85 .00 M2 .27 9 134 67 TEC TEH 610-EC 18 VS7 .98 .00 M2 .53 9 134 67 TEC TEH 610-EC 20 VS7 -.72 .00 M2 .67 9 134 67 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 49 96-Nov 134 67 TEC TEH 610-EL 13 VS4 - .97 .00 M2 1.11 7 96-Nov 134 67 TEC TEH 610-EL 19 VS7 -.87 .00 M2 1. 92 7 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 134 67 TEC TEH 610-EL 17 VS7 .87 .00 M2 1.69 7 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 134 67 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 25 95-Jul 134 67 TEC TEH 610-EL 12 VS4 - .93 .00 11 .95 34 95-Jul 134 67 TEC TEH 610-EL 11 VS7 - .96 .00 11 .90 34 95-Jul 134 67 TEC TEH 610-EL. 10 VS7 .99 .00 11 .77 34 48 69 TEC TEH 610-EC 15 VS4 .82 .00 M2 .43 9 48 69 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 49 96-Nov 48 69 TEC TEH 610-EL 17 VS4 1. 55 .00 M2 1.66 11 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 48 69 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 103 126 69 TEC TEH 610-EC 16 VS4 .83 .00 M2 .48 9 126 69 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 1 49 96-Nov 126 69 TEC TEH 610-EL 15 VS4 .88 .00 M2 1.46 7 96-Nov 126 69 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 25 134 69 TEC TEH 610-EC 13 VS7 .91 .00 M2 .35 9 134 69 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 1 49 96-Nov 134 69 TEC TEH 610-EL 18 VS7 .86 .00 M2 1.79 5 96-Nov 134 69 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 25 +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ PAGE 15 TUBES 107 CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MAY 1998 REFUEL INDICATIONS WITH ALL HISTORY Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 0:38 +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- --+- - - - - -+-- -+- - -+- - - ---- -+- - - - - - --+- - - -+- - -- - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ 95-Jul 134 69 TEC TEH 610-EL 13 VS7 .96 .00 11 1.13 34 93 70 TSH TSH 610-ZP INA TSH .03 .00 89 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 96-Nov 93 70 TSH TSH 610-ZR TRA TSH .08 .00 4 1.22 17 63 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 93-Jun 93 70 TEC TEH 610-EP NOD 10 93-Jun 93 70 TSH TSH RPC-ER NOD 36 135 72 TEC TEH 610-EC 11 .VS1 - .94 .00 M2 .27 9 135 72 TEC TEH 610-EC 7 VS1 .88 .00 M2 .16 9 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 135 72 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 49 96-Nov 135 72 TEC TEH 610-EL 14 VS1 - . 77 .00 M2 1.30 5 96-Nov 135 72 TEC TEH 610-EL 12 VS1 .69 .00 M2 1. 01 5 96-Nov 135 72 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 25 95-Jul 135 72 TEC TEH 610-EL 9 VS1 - .96 . 00 11 .73 34 95-Jul 135 72 TEC TEH 610-EL 10 VS1 1.11 .00 11 . 81 34 93-Jun 135 72 TEC TEH 610-EP NOD 10 137 72 TEC TEH 610-EC 17 VS6 - .68 .00 M2 .51 9 137 72 TEC TEH 610-EC 7 DBC 1.12 .00 M2 .17 9 137 72 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 49 96-Nov 137 72 TEC TEH 610-EL 13 VS6 - .60 .00 M2 1.15 5 96-Nov 137 72 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 25 95-Jul 137 72 TEC TEH 610-EL 8 VS6 - .56 .00 11 .64 33 96 73 TEC TEH 610-EC NOD 9 96 73 TSH TSH 610-ZP INA TSH .00 .00 10 49 RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 96-Nov 96 73 TSH TSH 610-ZR TRA TSH .oo .00 4 .77 163 61 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 106 73 04C 04C 610-ZP NDF 04C .46 .00 2 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 106 73 TEC TEH 610-EC DSS 04C .46 .00 M1 .45 47 9 RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 106 73 TSH TSH 610-ZP INA TSH .00 .00 10 49 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 96-Nov 106 73 TSH TSH 610-ZR TRA TSH .00 .00 4 .44 117 61 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 130 73 TEC TEH 610-EC 8 VS7 .96 .00 M2 .19 9 I 130 73 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 1 49 I 96-Nov 130 73 TEC TEH 610-EL 12 VS7 .80 .00 M2 1. 00 5 I 96-Nov 130 73 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 25 I 95-Jul 130 73 TEC TEH 610-EL 10 VS7 .83 .00 11 .84 34 I I 138 75 TEC TEH 610-EC 10 DBH. 2.02 .00 M2 .26 9 I 138 75 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 1 49 I 96-Nov 138 75 TEC TEH 610-EL 10 DBH 2.06 . 00 M2 .83 5 I 96-Nov 138 75 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 25 I 95-Jul 138 75 TEC TEH 610-EL 8 DBH 2.05 . 00 11 .63 33 I 95-Jul 138 75 DBH DBH 580-ZU WAR DBH 1.67 . 00 2 4.48 161 10 I 95-Jul 138 75 DBH DBH 580-ZU WAR DBH -3.54 . 00 3 16.01 111 10 I I 133 76 TEC TEH 610-EC 7 VS1 .83 .00 M2 .15 9 I +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+
- PAGE 16 TUBES 115
CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MAY 1998 REFUEL INDICATIONS WITH ALL HISTORY Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 0:38 +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEJ COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ 133 76 TEC TEH 610-EC 12 VS6 .87 .00 M2 . 30 9 133 76 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 1 49 96-Nov 133 76 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 61 95-Jul 133 76 TEC TEH 610-EL NDD 34 92-Mar 133 76 TEH TEC 610-EP NDD 20 137 76 TEC TEH 610-EC 9 VS4 - . 80 .00 M2 .23 9 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 137 76 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 49 96-Nov 137 76 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 61 95-Jul 137 76 TEC TEH 610-EL NDD 33 136 77 TEC TEH 610-EC 12 DBC 1. 70 .00 M2 .30 9 136 77 TEC TEH 610-EC INF DBC -1 .43 .00 9 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 136 77 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 1 49 96-Nov 136 77 TEC TEH 610-EL 18 DBC -1.43 .00 M2 1 .86 5 96-Nov 136 77 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 1 24 95.-Jul 136 77 TEC TEH 610-EL 12 DBC 1.65 .00 11 .87 11 95-Jul 136 77 TEC TEH 610-EL 12 DBC 1. 71 .00 11 .96 26 95-Jul 136 77 TSH TSH 620-ZC NOD 54 138 77 TEC TEH 610-EC 30 VS6 - . 87 .00 M2 1.31 9 138 77 TEC TEH 610-EC 39 VS7 1.09 .00 M2 2.19 9 J+CUSTOMER DECISION TO PLUG 138 77 TEC TEH 610-EC 19 VS7 - .68 .00 M2 .62 9 I 138 77 TEC TEH 610-EC 10 DBC .82 .00 M2 .25 9 I 138 77 TEC TEH 610-EC INF DBC 2.23 .00 9 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 138 77 TEC TEH 610-EC 17 DBC -1 .48 .00 M2 . 50 9 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 138 77 TEC TEH 610-EC PIO VS7 .86 .00 M2 2.25 27 J>>>>> POSITIVE I.D. ESTABLISHED <<<<< 138 77 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 49 96-Nov 1'30 77 TEC TEH 610-EL 30 VS6 - . 83 .00 M2 4.01 5 96-Nov 138 77 TEC TEH 610-EL 34 VS7 .74 .00 M2 5.08 5 96-Nov 138 77 TEC TEH 610-EL 17 VS7 - .77 .00 M2 1. 70 5 96-Nov 138 77 TEC TEH 610-EL 17 DBC 2.23 .00 M2 1.68 5 96-Nov 138 77 TEC TEH 610-EL 14 DBC -1 .06 .00 M2 1 .29 5 96-Nov 138 77 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 24 95-Jul 138 77 TEC TEH 610-EL 24 VS6 -1 .01 .00 11 2.56 11 95-Jul 138 77 TEC TEH 610-EL 29 VS7 .68 .00 11 3.21 11 95-Jul 138 77 TEC TEH 610-EL 14 VS7 - .95 .00 11 1.35 11 95-Jul 138 77 TEC TEH 610-EL 14 DBC -1.64 .00 11 1.06 11 95-Jul 138 77 TSH TSH 620-ZC NOD 54 95-Jul 138 77 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 72 133 78 TEC TEH 610-EC 17 VS1 -.66 . 00 M2 .52 9 133 78 TEC TEH 610-EC 9 VS4 .79 .00 M2 .21 9 133 78 TEC TEH 610-EC 8 VS6 .88 .00 M2 .19 9 133 78 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 1 49 96-Nov 133 78 TEC TEH 610-EL 15 VS1 -.29 .00 M2 1.40 5 96-Nov 133 78 TEC TEH 610-EL 8 VS4 .06 .00 M2 .66 5 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 133 78 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 24 I +--------+----+----+---+---+------+-:-+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEJ COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ PAGE 17 TUBES 119 CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MAY 1998 REFUEL INDICATIONS WITH ALL HISTORY Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 0:38 +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ 95-Jul 133 78 TEC TEH 610-EL 15 VS1 - .03 .00 11 1 .28 34 95-Jul 133 78 TEC TEH 610-EL 10 VS4 .80 .00 11 .80 34 92-Mar 133 78 TEH TEC 610-EP NOD 20 135 78 TEC TEH 610-EC 18 VS6 .93 .00 M2 .56 9 135 78 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 49 96-Nov 135 78 TEC TEH 610-EL 18 VS6 .88 .00 M2 1. 78 5 96-Nov 135 78 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 24 95-Jul 135 78 TEC TEH 610-EL 14 VS6 .79 .00 11 1.22 33 137 78 TEC TEH 610-EC 8 VS4 .94 . 00 M2 .19 9 137 78 TEC TEH 610-EC 8 VS4 - . 77 .00 M2 .19 9 137 78 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 49 96-Nov 137 78 TEC TEH 610-EL 10 VS4 1.37 .00 M2 .86 5 96-Nov 137 78 TEC TEH 610-EL 14 VS4 - . 72 .00 M2 1.24 5 96-Nov 137 78 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 24 95-Jul 137 78 TEC TEH 610-EL 7 VS4 1.08 .00 11 .57 33 95-Jul 137 78 TEC TEH 610-EL 9 VS4 - . 76 .00 11 .76 33 93-Jun 137 78 TEC TEH 610-EP NOD 11 74 79 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 06C 27.75 .00 3 .84 72 9 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 74 79 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 74 79 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 49 96-Nov 74 79 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 57 138 79 TEC TEH 610-EC 16 DBH 2.13 .00 M2 .45 9 138 79 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 49 96-Nov 138 79 TEC TEH 610-EL 13 DBH 2.20 . 00 M2 1.19 5 96-Nov 138 79 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 1 24 95-Jul 138 79 TEC TEH 610-EL 9 DBH 2.32 .00 11 . 71 34 95-Jul 138 79 DBH DBH 580-ZU WAR DBH 2.05 .00 2 6.22 161 70 138 81 TEC TEH 610-EC 11 DBH 2.01 .00 M2 .29 9 138 81 TEC TEH 610-EC 13 VS6 1.10 .00 M2 .36 9 138 81 TEC TEH 610-EC 18 VS6 -.69 .00 M2 .58 9
- 138 81 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 49 96-Nov 138 81 TEC TEH 610-EL 8 DBH 2.09 .00 M2 .67 5 96-Nov 138 81 TEC TEH 610-EL 16 VS6 1.00 .00 M2 1.52 5 96-Nov 138 81 TEC TEH 610-EL 16 VS6 - . 71 .00 M2 1.57 5 96-Nov 138 81 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 24 95-Jul 138 81 TEC TEH 610-EL 8 DBH 1.99 .00 11 .62 34 95-Jul 138 81 TEC TEH 610-EL 9 VS6 1.09 .00 11 .72 34 95-Jul 138 81 TEC TEH 610-EL 18 VS6 - .53 .00 11 1.60 34 95-Jul 138 81 DBH DBH 580-ZU WAR DBH 1. 81 .00 2 6.52 164 70 81 84 TEC TEH 610-EC 13 VS4 .92 .00 M2 .34 9 81 84 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 49 96-Nov 81 84 TEC TEH 610-EL 11 VS4 .91 .00 M2 .94 6
+--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+
- PAGE 18 TUBES 125
11 I CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MAY 1998 REFUEL INDICATIONS WITH ALL HISTORY Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 0:38 +- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+-- -+- - - - - -- -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- -- - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LDC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I 96-Nov 81 84 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 24 118 85 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM VS2 20.93 .00 6 .88 79 9 HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 118 85 TEC TEH 610-EC INF 06C 6.19 .00 3 9 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 118 85 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 06C 7.22 .00 6 2.09 76 9 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 118 85 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 118 85 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 1 51 96-Nov 118 85 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 55 90-Apr 118 85 TEC TEH 610~ A MBM 06C 6.20 .00 99 90-Apr 118 85 TEC TEH 610- A MBM VS2 20.50 .00 99 138 85 TEC TEH 610-EC 6 VS7 .98 .00 M2 .13 9 138 85 TEC TEH 610-EC 6 DBC -1. 77 .oo M2 .14 9 138 85 TEC TEH 610-EC INF DBC 1. 80 .00 M2 9 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 138 85 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 51 96-Nov 138 85 TEC TEH 610-EL 13 DBC 1. 80 .00 M2 1.19 5 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 138 85 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 1 24 95-Jul 138 85 TEC TEH 610-EL 7 DBC -1. 53 .00 11 .57 34 105 88 TEC TEH 610-EC INF 04C 32.42 .00 3 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 105 88 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04C 33.12 .00 6 1.46 80 9 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 105 88 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 105 88 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 51 / 96-Nov 105 88 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 56 / 90-Apr 105 88 TEC TEH 610- A MBM 04C 32.40 .00 99 / I 56 91 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 05C 11 .55 .00 3 .49 125 11 /RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 56 91 -------------------------------------------------------------/HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 56 91 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 51 I 96-Nov 56 91 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 59 I I 98 91 TEC TEH 610-EC 19 VS2 .85 . 00 M2 .55 11 I 98 91 TEC TEH 610-EC 17 VS4 - . 83 . 00 M2 .46 . 11 I 98 91 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 1 51 I 96-Nov 98 91 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 1 53 I I 116 91 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM VS1 8.59 .00 6 1.58 79 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 116 91 -------------------------------------------------------------/HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 116 91 TEC TEH 610-EC INF VS6 8.60 .00 3 11 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 116 91 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 51 I 96-Nov 116 91 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 55 I 90-Apr 116 91 TEC TEH 610- A MBM VS6 8.60 .00 99 I I 120 91 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02C 9.55 .00 3 .74 110 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 120 91 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 120 91 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 51 I 96-Nov 120 91 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 55 I I +- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - --- -+-- -+- - - -+- - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPE/ COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ PAGE 19 TUBES 133 CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MAY 1998 REFUEL INDICATIONS WITH ALL HISTORY Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 0:38 +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPE! COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ 130 91 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 06H 15.12 .00 6 1.41 74 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 130 91 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 130 91 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04C 25.95 .00 6 1.71 60 11 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 130 91 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 130 91 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 51 96-Nov 130 91 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 55 95-Jul 130 91 TEC TEH 610-EL MBM 06H 15.09 .00 .18 94 33 95-Jul 130 91 TEC TEH 610-EL MBM 04C 25.99 .00 .42 33 90-Apr 130 91 TEC TEH 610- A MBM 04C 25.00 .00 99 134 91 TEC TEH 610-EC 9 VS? - .90 .00 M2 .21 11 134 91 TEC TEH 610-EC 13 DBC 1.63 . 00 M2 .30 11 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 134 91 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 51 96-Nov 134 91 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 55 95-Jul 134 91 TEC TEH 610-EL NDD 34 138 91 TEC TEH 610-EC 10 VS1 . 88 .00 M2 . 22. 11 138 91 TEC TEH 610-EC 21 DBC -1.91 .00 M2 .65 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 138 91 TEC TEH 610-EC 10 DBC 1 .17 .00 M2 .24 11 I 138
- 91 TEC TEH 610-EC INF DBC -1. 20 .00 M2 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 138 91 TEC TEH 610-EC 10 DBC 1. 79 . 00 M2 .24 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 138 91 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 51 I 96-Nov 138 91 TEC TEH 610-EL 13 VS1 .83 .00 M2 1.11 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 138 91 TEC TEH 610-EL 14 DBC -1. 20 .00 M2 1 .32 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 138 91 TEC TEH 610-EL 15 DBC 2.03 .00 M2 1.34 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 138 91 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 23 I 95-Jul 138 91 TEC TEH 610-EL 10 VS? 29.40 .00 11 .75 34 I 93-Jun 138 91 TEC TEH 610-EP NOD 34 I I
132 93 TEC TEH 610-EC INF VS1 .91 . 00 M2 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 132 93 TEC TEH 610-EC 10 VS2 .63 .00 M2 .23 11 I 132 93 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 51 I 96-Nov 132 93 TEC TEH 610-EL INF VS1 .84 .00 M2 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 132 93 TEC TEH 610-EL 17 VS2 1.00 .00 M2 1.65 5 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 132 93 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 23 I 95-Jul 132 93 TEC TEH 610-EL 11 VS1 .84 .00 11 .94 33 I I 121 94 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .32 . 00 10 .86 95 97 I 96-Nov 121 94 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 1. 53 I 92-Mar 121 94 TEH TEC 610-EP NOD 19 I I 123 94 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .52 .00 10 .5o 87 95 I 96-Nov 123 94 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 53 I 92-Mar 123 94 TEH TEC 610-EP NOD 19 J I 135 94 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM TSH 10.78 .00 3 .40 94 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 135 94 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 135 94 TEC TEH 610-EC 10 VS6 1.01 .00 M2 .22 11 I +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEJ COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+---------.-----------------------------------------+
- PAGE 20 TUBES 139
CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MAY 1998 REFUEL INDICATIONS WITH ALL HISTORY Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 0:38 +- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- -- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- -- - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+-- -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPE! COMMENTS +- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ 135 94 TEC TEH 610-EC 7 VS7 - . 76 .00 M2 .14 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 135 94 TEC TEH 610-EC 12 DBC -1 .88 .00 M2 .27 11 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 135 94 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 51 I 96-Nov 135 94 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 53 I 95-Jul 135 94 TEC TEH 610-EL NDD 33 I I 120 95 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .34 . 00 10 .72 89 97 I 96-Nov 120 95 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 54 I 95-Jul 120 95 TEC TEH 610-EL NDD 14 I 95-Jul 120 95 TSH TSH 620-ZC NDD 54 I I 136 95 TEC TEH 610-EC 31 VS6 .98 .00 M2 1.34 11 +CUSTOMER DECISION TO PLUG 136 95 TEC TEH 610-EC 14 VS7 . 81 .00 M2 .35 11 136 95 TEC TEH 610-EC 13 DBC -1. 84 .00 M2 .32 11 136 95 TEC TEH 610-EC PID VS6 .90 .00 M2 1.19 39 >>>>> POSITIVE. I.D. ESTABLISHED <<<<< 136 95 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 51 96-Nov 136 95 TEC TEH 610-EL 27 VS6 1.11 .00 M2 3.42 5 96-Nov 136 95 TEC TEH 610-EL 18 VS7 .83 .00 M2 1. 77 5 96-Nov 136 95 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 23 95-Jul 136 95 TEC TEH 610-EL 21 VS6 .97 .00 11 2.20 13 95-Jul 136 95 TEC TEH 610-EL 12 VS7 .85 .00 11 1.20 13 93-Jun 136 95 TEC TEH 610- EP PI VS6 . 73 . 00 M1 . 75 106 12 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 93-Jun 136 95 ------------------------------------------------------------- RETEST - TEST WITH WEAR SCAR STANDARD IN-LINE 93-Jun 136 95 TEC TEH 610-EP PI VS7 .84 .00 M1 .45 160 12 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 93-Jun 136 95 TEC TEH 610-EP 23 VS6 .86 .00 M2 .56 33 93-Jun 136 95 TEC TEH 610-EP 17 VS7 .60 .00 M2 .29 33 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 135 96 TEC TEH 610-EC 23 VS6 .98 .00 M2 .74 11 135 96 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 1 51 96-Nov 135 96 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 54 95-Jul 135 96 TEC TEH 610-EL INR VS6 1 .09 .00 11 .47 13 93-Jun 135 96 TEC TEH 610-EP PI VS6 .97 . 00 M1 .38 128 12 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 93-Jun 135 96 ------------------------------------------------------------- RETEST - TEST WITH WEAR SCAR STANDARD IN-LINE 93-Jun 135 96 TEC TEH 610-EP 19 VS6 .94 .00 M2 .39 33 48 97 TEC TEH 610-EC 12 VS4 .92 .00 M2 .28 11 48 97 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 51 96-Nov 48 97 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 87 52 97 TEC TEH 610- EC MBM TSH . 12. 76 . 00 6 1 . 32 69 11 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 52 97 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 52 97 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 51 I 96-Nov 52 97 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 60 I 90-Apr 52 97 TEC TEH 610- A MBM TSH 12.30 .00 99 I I 104 97 TEC TEH 610-EC INR 04H .20 .00 M1 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 104 97 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 51 I 96-Nov 104 97 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 53 I +- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- --- - - --+- - - .. - - - -+- - - -+- - - - --+- - -+- - - -+- - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPE! COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+
- PAGE 21 TUBES 145
CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MAY 1998 REFUEL INDICATIONS WITH ALL HISTORY Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 0:38 +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ 90-Apr 104 97 TEC TEH 610- A MBM 04H .20 .00 99 108 97 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 05H 17. 04 .00 3 .89 93 13 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 108 97 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 108 97 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 05H 25.59 .00 3 1.16 99 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 108 97 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 108 97 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 51 I 96-Nov 108 97 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 53 I I 134 97 TEC TEH 610-EC 11 VS1 .66 .00 M2 .29 13 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 134 97 TEC TEH 610-EC 6 VS2 .66 . 00. M2 .13 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 134 97 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 1 51 I 96-Nov 134 97 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 53 I 95-Jul 134 97 TEC TEH 610-EL NDD 33 I I 105 98 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .14 .00 10 .68 87 131 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 105 98 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 53 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 93-Jun 105 98 TEC TEH 610-EP NOD 12 I 93-Jun 105 98 TSH TSH 620-ER NDD 37 I I 102 99 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH 1 .18 .00 10 .52 84 133 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 102 99 TEC TEH 610-EL NOD 4 I 96-Nov 102 99 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 22 I I 111 102 TSH TSH 610-ZP INA TSH .25 .00 95 [RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 96-Nov 111 102 TEC TEH 610-EL NDD 4 I 96-Nov 111 102 TSH TSH 610-ZR TRA TSH .24 .00 4 1.56 182 22 [RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION I 127 102 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH 2.01 .00 10 .86 96 95 I 96-Nov 127 102 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 40 92-Mar 127 102 TEH TEC 610-EP NDD 19 28 103 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01H 31.51 .00 3 .42 84 29 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 28 103 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 28 103 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 51 96-Nov 28 103 TSH TSH.610-ZR NDD 89 126 103 TEC TEH 610-EC NDD 13 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 126 103 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .07 .00 10 .63 100 51 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 126 103 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 1 40 128 103 TEC TEH 610-EC NDD 13 128 103 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .07 .00 10 .88 96 51 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 128 103 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 1 40 93 104 TEC TEH 610-EC 14 VS4 - . 52 .00 M2 .38 .13 93 104 TEC TEH 610-EC 12 VS6 .94 .00 M2 .30 13 93 104 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 1 51 +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPE! COMMENTS +- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+-- -+- - - - -- - -+-- - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+-- -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+
- PAGE 22 TUBES 155
CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MAY 1998 REFUEL INDICATIONS WITH ALL HISTORY Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 0:38 +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB GEE PROBE IND LOG INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ 96-Nov 93 104 TEC TEH 610-EL 15 VS4 - .40 .00 M2 1 .48 4 96-Nov 93 104 TEC TEH 610-EL 12 VS6 1.00 .00 M2 1.09 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 93 104 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 22 I 95-Jul 93 104 TEC TEH 610-EL 14 VS4 - .82 .00 11 1.29 15 I 95-Jul 93 104 TSH TSH 620-ZC NDD 53 I I 127 104 TSH TSH 610-ZP INA TSH .04 .00 3 51 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 96-Nov 127 104 TSH TSH 610-ZR TRA TSH .04 .00 4 3.69 168 27 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 92-Mar 127 104 TEH TEC 610-EP NDD 19 I I 18 105 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .29 .00 10 .29 89 99 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 18 105 TEC TEH 610-EL NDD 12 I 96-Nov 18 105 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 10 I I 130 105 TEC TEH 610-EC NDD 13 I 130 105 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .34 .00 10 .16 92 51 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 96-Nov 130 105 TEC TEH 610-EL NDD 1 4 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 130 105 TSH TSH 610-ZR PLP TSH .37 .00 7 .34 331 22 I 95-Jul 130 105 TEC TEH 610-EL NDD 33 I I 132 105 TEC TEH 610-EC NDD 13 I 132 105 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .15 .00 10 .44 90 51 RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 96-Nov 132 105 TEC TEH 610-EL NDD 1 4 96-Nov 132 105 TSH TSH 610-ZR PLP TSH .37 .00 7 .32 151 22 95-Jul 132 105 TEC TEH 610-EL NDD 33 51 106 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM TSH 11.84 .OD 3 .65 105 13 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 51 106 ----------------------------------~-------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 51 106 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02H 26.25 .00 6 2.01 76 13 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 51 106 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 51 106 TEC TEH 610-EC-INF 02H 24.80 .00 6 13 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 51 106 TEC TEH 610-EC INF 05H 11.61 .00 6 13 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 51 106 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 05H 12.87 .OD 3 1.21 102 13 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 51 106 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 51 106 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 05C 8.17 .00 6 1.89 72 13 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION ~ 51 106 -----------------------~------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 51 106 TEC TEH 610-EC INF 05C 7.11 .00 6 13 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 51 106 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 51 96-Nov 51 106 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 46 90-Apr 51 106 TEC TEH 610- A MBM 05C 7.10 .DO 99 90-Apr 51 106 TEC TEH 610- A MBM 05H 11 .60 .DO 99 90-Apr 51 106 TEC TEH 610- A MBM 02H 24.80 .00 99 90-Apr 51 106 TEC TEH 610- A MBM TSH 11.30 .DO 99 127 106 TSH TSH 610-ZP INA TSH .14 .00 3 51 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 96-Nov 127 106 TSH TSH 610-ZR TRA TSH .14 .OD 4 1.41 178 27 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 92-Mar 127 106 TEH TEC 610-EP NDD 19 I I +- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - -- - - -+- - - -- - - -+- - --+-- - -- -+- - -+- - - -+- -- -- -- - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ I DATE ROW COL CEB GEE PROBE IND LOG INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+-- -- - - - -+- - --+- - - -- -+- - -+- - - -+- - --- - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ PAGE 23 TUBES 162 ,If CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MAY 1998 REFUEL INDICATIONS WITH ALL HISTORY Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 0:38 +- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - -- - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - -- - --- - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ 129 106 TEC TEH 610-EC NOD 1 13 129 106 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .07 .00 10 .67 94 51 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 129 106 TSH TSH 610-ZR TRA TSH .43 .00 4 1.40 17 27 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 93-Jun 129 106 TEC TEH 610-EP NOD 16 I I 133 106 TEC TEH 610-EC INA 04H 37.95 .00 1 13 I 133 106 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT DBC .78 .00 M1 5.96 176 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 133 106 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 51 I 96-Nov 133 106 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 21 I 95-Jul 133 106 TEC TEH 610-EL NOD 1 33 I 92-Mar 133 106 TEH TEC 610-EP ONG 04H 37.56 .00 3 5.09 100 20 I I 98 107 TEC TEH 610-EC TIU 13 I 98 107 TEC TEH 610-EC 16 VS2 .72 .00 M2 .47 15 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 98 107 TEC TEH 610-EC 15 VS4 - .80 .00 M2 .41 15 98 107 TEC TEH 610-EC 17 VS6 .93 .00 M2 .50 15 98 107 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 51 96-Nov 98 107 TEC TEH 610-EL 16 VS2 1.03 .00 M2 1.57 4 96-Nov 98 107 TEC TEH 610-EL 13 VS4 - . 75 .00 M2 1.24 4 96-Nov 98 107 TEC TEH 610-EL 14 VS6 .79 .00 M2 1 .30 4 96-Nov 98 107 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 1 22 95-Jul 98 107 TEC TEH 610-EL 10 VS2 .56 .00 11 .92 15 95-Jul 98 107 TSH TSH 620-ZC NOD 52 125 108 TEC TEH 610-EC TIU 13 125 108 TEC TEH 610-EC 5 vsi - .67 .00 M2 .14 15 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 125 108 TEC TEH 610-EC 10 VS4 - . 78 .00 M2 .28 15 125 108 TEC TEH 610-EC 11 VS4 .66 .00 M2 .28 15 125 108 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 53 96-Nov 125 108 TEC TEH 610-EL 18 VS1 -.66 .00 M2 1.84 4 96-Nov 125 108 TEC TEH 610-EL 13 VS4 1 .07 .00 M2 1.23 4 96-Nov 125 108 TEC TEH 610-EL 12 VS4 - .52 .00 M2 1.13 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 125 108 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 1 22 I I 20 109 TEC TEH 610-EC ONT VS4 1.03 . 00 M1 8.36 112 29 I 20 109 TSH TSH 610-ZP INA TSH .14 . 00 10 53 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 96-Nov 20 109 TSH TSH 610-ZR TRA TSH .14 . 00 4 1.47 155 90 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 48 109 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03H 26.08 .00 3 .78 72 13 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 48 109 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 48 109 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 53 I 96-Nov 48 109 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 48 I I 108 109 TEC TEH 610-EC TIU 13 I 108 109 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02H 20.90 .00 6 2.44 79 15 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 108 109 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 108 109 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 05H 1.79 .00 6 2.40 71 15 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 108 109 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED +- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - -- - -+- - -+- --+- -- - -- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+--- -- -+- - -+- - - -+-- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- -- - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+-- - - - -+- --+- - --+- - - --- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ PAGE 24 TUBES 168 CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MAY 1998 REFUEL INDICATIONS WITH ALL HISTORY Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 0:38 +- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- -- - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - -- -+- - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - --- -+- -- - - - --+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - ---- - -+ 108 109 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 53 96-Nov 108 109 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 47 122 109 TEC TEH 610-EC TIU 13 122 109 TEC TEH 610-EC NDD 15 122 109 TSH TSH 610-ZP INA TSH .00 .00 53 RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 96-Nov 122 109 TSH TSH 610-ZR TRA TSH .00 .00 4 2.75 178 47 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 83 110 TSH TSH 610-ZP INA TSH -.15 .00 99 RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 96-Nov 83 110 TSH TSH 610-ZA TRA TSH -.12 .00 4 1.77 162 47 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 95-Jul 83 110 TEC TEH 610-EL NDD 1 16 95-Jul 83 110 TSH TSH 620-ZC NDD 52 109 110 TSH TSH 610-ZP INA TSH -2.50 . 00 99 RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 96-Nov 109 110 TSH TSH 610-ZR TRA TSH -2.50 .00 4 8.03 172 47 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 92-Mar 109 110 TEH TEC 610-EP NDD 1 7 113 110 TEC TEH 610-EC TIU 13 113 110 TEC TEH 610-EC 29 VS4 -.81 .00 M2 1.16 15 113 110 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 53 96-Nov 113 110 TEC TEH 610-EL 26 VS4 -.95 .00 M2 3.15 4 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 113 110 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 1 22 I 95-Jul 113 110 TEC TEH 610-EL 24 VS4 -1.07 .00 11 2.61 15 I 93-Jun 113 110 TEC TEH 610-EP PI VS4 -1 . 05 . 00 M1 . 88 88 16 I RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 93-Jun 113 110 ------------------------------------------------~------------!RETEST - TEST WITH WEAR SCAR STANDARD IN-LINE 93-Jun 113 110 TEC TEH 610-EP 25 VS4 -.96 .00 M2 .73 33 I I 127 110 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH 1.08 .00 10 1 .10 98
- 99 I 96-Nov 127 110 TSH TSH 610-ZR TRA TSH 1.07 .00 7 .50 152 56 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 92-Mar 127 110 TEH TEC 610-EP NDD 0 I I
129 110 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .56 .00 10 1 .03 98 99 I 96-Nov 129 110 TSH TSH 610-ZR TRA TSH .62 .00 7 .46 151 56 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 93-Jun 129 110 TEC TEH 610-EP NDD 16 I I 110 111 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .17 .00 10 .87 96 101 I 96-Nov 110 111 TEC TEH 610-EL NDD 1 4 I 96-Nov 110 111 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 22 I I 109 112 TSH TSH 610-ZP INA TSH .24 .00 99 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 96-Nov 109 112 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 47 I 96-Nov 109 112 TSH TSH 610-ZR TRA TSH .20 .00 4 2.06 206 48 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 92-Mar 109 112 TEH TEC 610-EP NDD 1 I I 113 112 TEC TEH 610-EC INA TSH 3.08 .00 3 15 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION . J 113 112 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 1 53 I I 96-Nov 113 112 TSH TSH 610-ZR MBM TSH 3.08 .00 4 .57 117 47 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I I +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+--- - - -- -+-- -- - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+
- PAGE 25 TUBES 178
CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MAY 1998 REFUEL INDICATIONS WITH ALL HISTORY Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 0:38 +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB GEE PROBE IND LOG INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPE! COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ 100 113 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .63 .00 10 .52 98 99 96-Nov 100 113 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 50 95-Jul 100 113 TEC TEH 610-EL NOD 15 95-Jul 100 113 TSH TSH 620-ZC NOD 53 102 113 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH 1.64 .00 10 .98 98 135 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 102 113 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 50 95-Jul 102 113 TEC TEH 610-EL NOD 15 95-Jul 102 113 TSH TSH 620-ZC NOD 53 95-Jul 102 113 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 73 114 113 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .26 .00 10 .58 94 99 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 114 113 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 49 95-Jul 114 113 TEC TEH 610-EL NOD 15 95-Jul 114 113 TSH TSH 620-ZC NOD 52 95-Jul 114 113 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 72 116 113 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .18 .00 10 .59 94 99 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 116 113 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 1 50 I 95-Jul 116 113 TEC TEH 610-EL NOD 15 I 95-Jul 116 113 TSH TSH 620-ZC NOD 53 I I 126 113 TEC TEH 610-EC 18 VS1 - . 81 .00 M2 .57 15 126 113 TEC TEH 610-EC 10 VS4 - .89 .00 M2 .26 15 126 113 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 53 96-Nov 126 113 TEC TEH 610-EL 13 VS1 - .49 .00 M2 1.26 4 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 126 113 TEC TEH 610-EL 14 VS4 -1. 29 .00 M2 1.29 4 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 126 113 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 22 95-Jul 126 113 TEC TEH 610-EL 11 VS1 -.79 .00 11 1 .01 15 95-Jul 126 113 TEC TEH 610-EL 7 VS4 - .94 .00 11 .63 15 95-Jul 126 113 TSH TSH 620-ZC NOD 1 53 95-Jul 126 113 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 73 18 115 TEC TEH 610 - EC INA 04H 7 .10 .00 6 17 18 115 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 55 96-Nov 18 115 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 88 90-Apr 18 115 TEC TEH 610- A MBM 04H 7.10 .00 99 44 115 TEC,TEH 610-EC INA 03H 31.39 .00 6 15 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 44 115 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03H, 32.10 .00 3 . 67 108 15 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 44 115 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 44 115 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 55 I 96-Nov 44 115 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 49 I 90-Apr 44 115 TEC TEH 610- A MBM 03H 31.40 .00 99 I I 54 115 TEC TEH 610-EC 4 VS4 - . 76 .00 M2 .12 15 I 54 115 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 1 55 I 96-Nov 54 115 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 49 I +- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - --+- --+- - -+- -- - -- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+--- -+-- - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ---- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOG INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPE! COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+---~--+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+
- PAGE 26 TUBES 186
CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MAY 1998 REFUEL INDICATIONS WITH ALL HISTORY Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 0:38 +- - - - -- - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- -- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+-- - - - - - -+-- - -+- ---- -+- - -+- - --+- - - - - - - -- - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ 90 115 TEC TEH 610-EC 5 VS2 - . 89 .00 M2 .14 15 90 115 TEC TEH 610-EC 6 VS6 - .67 .00 M2 .17 15 90 115 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 55 96-Nov 90 115 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 50 102 115 TEC TEH 610-EC 5 VS2 - .80 .00 M2 .15 15 102 115 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 55 96-Nov 102 115 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 49 95 116 TSH TSH 610,ZP PLP TSH .18 .00 10 .77 97 99 96-Nov 95 116 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 1 50 93-Jun 95 116 TEC TEH 610-EP NOD 16 93-Jun 95 116 TSH TSH 620-ER NOD 37 98 117 TEC TEH 610-EC 19 VS2 - .08 .00 M2 .57 15 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 98 117 TEC TEH 610-EC 40 VS4 .92 .00 M2 2.29 15 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 98 117 -------------------------------------------------------------!RETEST FOR POSITIVE I.D. 98 117 TEC TEH 610-EC INR VS6 .70 .00 M2 15 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 98 117 TEC TEH 610-EC INR VS6 -.08 .00 M1 15 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 98 117 TEC TEH 610-EC 18 VS6 - . 78 .00 M2 .53 15 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 98 117 TEC TEH 610-EC PIO VS4 .93 . 00 M2 2.45 27 I>>>>> POSITIVE I.D . ESTABLISHED <<<<< 98 117 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 1 55 I 96-Nov 98 117 TEC TEH 610-EL 19 VS2 .14 .00 M2 2.10 4 jRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 98 117 TEC TEH 610-EL 31 VS4 1.05 .00 M2 4.31 4 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 98 117 TEC TEH 610-EL 19 VS6 . 71 .00 M2 1.96 4 jRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 98 117 TEC TEH 610-EL 18 VS6 - .08 .00 M2 1.91 4 jRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 98 117 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 21 I I 23 118 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03C 14.51 .00 3 .66 111 17 jRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 23 118 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 23 118 TEC TEH 610-EC INR 03C 13.41 .00 3 17 jRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 23 118 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 1 55 I 96-Nov 23 118 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 41 I 90-Apr 23 118 TEC TEH 610- A MBM 03C 13.40 .00 99 I I 89 118 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .39 .00 10 . 81 94 99 I 96-Nov 89 118 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 1 41 I 93-Jun 89 118 TEC TEH 610-EP NOD 17 I I 2 121 TEC TEH 610-EC RBD 17 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 2 121 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM TSC 25.14 .00 3 .59 113 25 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 2 121 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 2 121 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 55 I 96-Nov 2 121 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 87 I 96-Nov 2 121 05C 05H 580-ZB NOD 98 I I 14 121 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01H 2.08 .00 3 1.03 113 17 !HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEJ COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ PAGE 27 TUBES 193 CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MAY 1998 REFUEL INDICATIONS WITH ALL HISTORY Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 0:38 +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEJ COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ 14 121 TEC TEH 610-EC INF 01H .80 .00 3 17 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 14 121 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 1 55 I 96-Nov 14 121 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 88 I 90-Apr 14 121 TEC TEH 610- A MBM 01H .80 .00 99 I I 44 121 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04H 11.62 .00 3 .92 116 15 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 44 121 -------------------------------------------------------------JHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 44 121 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04H 12.52 .00 3 1.13 107 15 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 44 121 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 44 121 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 55 I 96-Nov 44 121 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 43 J 90-Apr 44 121 TEC TEH 61 O- A MBM 04H 11 . 30 . 00 99 J I 46 121 TEC TEH 610-EC INA 05H 11.00 .00 M1 15 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 46 121 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 05H 11 .66 .00 3 .96 115 15 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 46 121 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - JHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 46 121 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 55 J 96-Nov 46 121 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 43 J 90-Apr 46 121 TEC TEH 610- A MBM 05H 11.00 .00 99 J I 56 121 TEC TEH 610-EC INA 03H 31.10 .00 6 15 J 56 121 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03H 32.41 .00 3 .72 115 15 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 56 121 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 56 121 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 55 J 96-Nov 56 121 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 43 J 90-Apr 56 121 TEC TEH 610- A MBM 03H 31.10 .00 99 J I 102 121 TEC TEH 610-EC 12 VS4 - .89 .00 M2 .33 15 I 102 121 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 1 55 I 96-Nov 102 121 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 01 I I 5 124 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02H 21.99 .00 6 2.31 73 17 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 5 124 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 5 124 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 55 J 96-Nov 5 124 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 93 J I 115 126 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .12 .00 10 1.12 102 105 J 115 126 TSH TSH 610-ZP VOL TSH .01 .00 2 1.05 68 105 JRESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 115 126 -------------------------------------------------------------JRETEST FOR POSITIVE I.D. 115 126 TSH TSH 610-ZP DIM TSH 380.00 .00 0 115.00 69 105 JRESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 115 126 TSH TSH 610-ZP PID TSH .00 . 00 2 .82 68 147 JRESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 115 126 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - J>>>>> POSITIVE I. D. ESTABLISHED <<<<< 96-Nov 115 126 TSH TSH 610-ZR TRA TSH -.01 .00 4 1.73 138 52 JRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 92-Mar 115 126 TEH TEC 610-EP NDD 5 J I 117 126 TSH TSH 610-ZP VOL TSH .07 .00 2 .26 91 105 JRESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 117 126 -------------------------------------------------------------JRETEST FOR POSITIVE I.D. 117 126 TSH TSH 610-ZP DIM TSH 205-00 .00 0 115.00 61 105 JRESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEJ COMMENTS +- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+-- -+-- - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+-- - -+- -- -- -+- - -+- - - -+-- - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ PAGE 28 TUBES 200 1 CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MAY 1998 REFUEL INDICATIONS WITH ALL HISTORY Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 0:38 +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+-------------------------------------~------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB GEE PROBE IND LOG INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPE! COMMENTS +- -------+-- --+- ---+- --+- --+- ---- -+- - -+- - -+- ----- --+- -------+-**- --+- -----+- --+- ---+- -------------- ------------------ ---------------- -+ 117 126 TSH TSH 610-ZP PIO TSH .00 .00 2 .21 109 147 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 117 126 -------------------------------------------------------------!>>>>> POSITIVE I. D. ESTABLISHED <<<<< 96-Nov 117 126 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 1 52 93-Jun 117 126 TEC TEH 610-EP NOD 17 2 127 TEC TEH 610-EC RBD 1 17 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 2 127 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM TSC 11.69 .oo 3 .73 124 25 jRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 2 127 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 2 127 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 55 I 96-Nov 2 127 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 93 I 96-Nov 2 127 05C 05H 580-ZB NOD 98 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 96-Nov 2 127 05C 05H 580-ZB NOD 100 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 2 127 05C 05H 580-ZB NOD 102 I I 58 127 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04H 31.89 .00 3 .64 120 17 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 58 127 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 58 127 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 55 I 96-Nov 58 127 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 91 I 90-Apr 58 127 TEC TEH 610- A MBM 04H 30.90 .00 99 I I 104 127 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04H 9.73 .00 6 1. 56 68 17 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 104 127 -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - --- --- - -- - - -- - - -- ------- -- - - - - - - --- - - - - - - - --- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 104 127 TEC TEH 610-EC INA 04H 8.59 .00 6 17 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 104 127 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 1 55 96-Nov 104 127 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 51 90-Apr 104 127 TEC TEH 610- A MBM 04H 8.60 .00 99 116 127 TEC TEH 610-EC NOD 17 116 127 TSH TSH 610-ZP VOL TSH .00 .00 2 1.14 35 55 RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 116 127 ---- ------- --- - ----- --- ---------------------------------- ---- RETEST FOR POSITIVE I.D. 116 127 TSH TSH 610-ZP DIM TSH 225.00 .00 0 115.00 59 55 RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 116 127 TSH TSH 610-ZP PIO TSH .07 .00 2 .79 79 147 RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 116 127 -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - ------- - - - -- -- - -- -- --- - -- - -- - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - >>>>> POSITIVE I.D. ESTABLISHED <<<<< 96-Nov 116 127 TSH TSH 610-ZR TRA TSH .00 .00 4 .69 103 52 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 93 130 TEC TEH 610-EC 4 VS2 .91 .00 M2 .12 17 93 130 TEC TEH 610-EC 8 VS2 -.70 .00 M2 .18 17 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 93 130 TEC TEH 610-EC 7 VS4 -.80 .00 M2 .19 17 93 130 TEC TEH 610-EC 19 VS4 .97 .00 M2 .58 17 93 130 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 1 57 96-Nov 93 130 TEC TEH 610-EL 19 VS4 .93 .00 M2 1.97 4 96-Nov 93 130 TEC TEH 610-EL 11 VS4 -.88 .00 M2 .97 4 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 93 130 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 1 21 95-Jul 93 130 TEC TEH 610-EL 14 VS4 .84 .00 11 1.38 21 93-Jun 93 130 TEC TEH 610-EP PI VS4 .95 .00 M1 .72 117 19 RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 93-Jun 93 130 - -- - - - - -- --- - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - -- -- - --- - - -- - - --- - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - RETEST - TEST WITH WEAR SCAR STANDARD IN-LINE 93-Jun 93 130 TEC TEH 610-EP 24 VS4 .84 .00 M2 .62 33 +- ------ -+- - - -+- -- -+- --+- --+- --- --+- --+- --+- ----- --+-- -- ----+- ---+-- ----+- --+- ---+- ---- -- ------------ ---------------------- ---------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB GEE PROBE IND LOG INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEJ COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+
- PAGE 29 TUBES 206
CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MAY 1998 REFUEL INDICATIONS WITH ALL HISTORY Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 0:38 +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPE[ COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ 99 130 TEC TEH 610-EC PLP TSH 2. 77 .00 8 .52 188 17 [RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION I 99 130 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH 2.19 .00 10 .58 89 55 [RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION I 96-Nov 99 130 TSH TSH 610-ZR TRA TSH 2.13 .00 4 1.47 177 51 I I I I 107 130 TEC TEH 610-EC PLP TSH .69 .00 8 .71 320 17 [RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION I 107 130 TEC TEH 610-EC 3 VS2 - .48 .00 M2 .11 17 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 107 130 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .35 .00 10 .35 198 55 [RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION I 96-Nov 107 130 TSH TSH 610-ZR TRA TSH .39 .00 4 3.02 149 51 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I I I 109 130 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .21 .00 7 2.39 275 103 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 96-Nov 109 130 TSH TSH 610-ZR TRA TSH .32 .00 4 3. 77 332 51 I I 92-Mar 109 130 TEH TEC 610-EP NDD 1 4 I I I I 32 131 TSH TSH 610-ZP INR TSH .85 .00 2 141 [RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION I 96-Nov 32 131 TSH TSH 610-ZR TRA TSH .85 .00 4 1.31 133 91 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 95-Jul 32 131 TEC TEH 610-EL MBM 05C 3.33 .OD 1 .29 149 19 I I 95-Jul 32 131 TSH TSH 620-ZC NDD 46 I I I I 18 133 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM TSC 3.07 .00 3 .60 99 17 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 18 133 -------------------------------------------------------------[HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 18 133 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 57 I I 96-Nov 18 133 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 93 I I I I I 32 133 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02H 23.91 .00 3 .33 74 17 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 32 133 -------------------------------------------------------------[HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 32 133 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02.H 20.84 .00 3 .43 99 17 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 32, 133 -------------------------------------------------------------[HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 32 133 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02H 10. 78 .00 3 .35 96. 17 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 32 133 -------------------------------------------------------------[HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 32 133 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02H 9.26 .00 3 .47 89 17 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 32 133 ----------------------------------------*--------------------[HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 32 133 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 57 I I 96-Nov 32 133 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 93 I I I I 46 133 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01H 33.26 .00 3 .51 99 17 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 46 133 -------------------------------------------------------------[HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 46 133 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02H 19.06 .00 3 .56 68 . 17 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 46 133 -------------------------------------------------------------[HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 46 133 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03H 24.03 .00 3 .48 93 17 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 46 133 -------------------------------------------------------------[HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 46 133 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04H 16.38 .00 3 .35 50 17 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 46 133 -------------------------------------------------------------[HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 46 133 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04H 20.84 .00 3 .46 98 17 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I 46 133 -------------------------------------------------------------[HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED I 46 133 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 57 I I 96-Nov 46 133 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 94 I I I I 33 136 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM TSH 2.56 .00 3 .28 96 17 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION I +- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- -- - - -+- - -+-- -+- - -- - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPE[ COMMENTS +- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -- -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+-- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ PAGE 30 TUBES 213 -l CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MAY 1998 REFUEL INDICATIONS WITH ALL HISTORY Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 0:38 +- -- - - - - -+- - - -+- - - -+-- -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - -- - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ I DATE ROW COL CEB GEE PROBE IND LOG INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPE! COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ 33 136 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 33 136 TEC TEH 610-EC INA 04H 25.13 . 00 3 17 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 33 136 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 57 I 96-Nov 33 136 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 20 I 95-Jul 33 136 TSH TSH 620-ZC NOD 92 I 90-Apr 33 136 TEC TEH 610- A MBM 04H 24.70 .00 99 I I 98 137 TEC TEH 610-EC 7 VS2 - .63 . 00 M2 .21 17 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 98 137 TEC TEH 610-EC 23 VS4 .89 .00 M2 .80 17 I 98 137 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 57 I 96-Nov 98 137 TEC TEH 610-EL 16 VS4 .00 .00 M2 1. 71 3 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 98 137 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 20 I 95-Jul 98 137 TEC TEH 610-EL 12 VS4 .78 .00 11 1.03 22 I 95-Jul 98 137 TSH TSH 620-ZC NOD 46 I 95-Jul 98 137 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 72 I I 30 139 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03C 25.46 .00 3 .62 107 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 30 139 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 30 139 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02C 37.26 .00 3 .68 81 19 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 30 139 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 30 139 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 57 I 96-Nov 30 139 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 96 I 90-Apr 30 139 TEC TEH 610- A MBM 03C 24.50 .00 99 [ I 34 139 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03H 35.67 .00 3 .90 116 19 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 34 139 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 34 139 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 57 I 96-Nov 34 139 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 96 I I 40 139 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04H 4.77 * .00 3 .54 112 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 40 139 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 40 139 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03C 11.23 .00 3 .39 109 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 40 139 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 40 139 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 57 [ 96-Nov 40 139 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 96 [ I 48 139 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM VS4 24.57 .00 3 .77 79 19 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 48 139 -------------------------------------------------------------[HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 48 139 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 57 [ 96-Nov 48 139 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 96 [ I 54 139 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM VS5 16.30 .00 3 1.67 66 19 [RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 54 139 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 54 139 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 57 I 96-Nov 54 139 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 94 j I 68 139 TEC TEH 610-EC 10 VS3 -.77 .00 M2 .25 19 I 68 139 TEC TEH 610-EC 15 VS5 .90 .00 M2 .40 19 j +- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ I DATE ROW COL CEB GEE PROBE IND LOG INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPE! COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+
- PAGE 31 TUBES 220
CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MAY 1998 REFUEL INDICATIONS WITH ALL HISTORY Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 0:38 +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +- - - -- - - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - -- - - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- -- -- -+- - -+-- - -+- - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - --+ 68 139 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 57 96-Nov 68 139 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 89 3 142 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03H 5.39 .00 3 .79 116 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 3 142 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 3 142 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 155 I 96-Nov 3 142 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 96 I I 15 142 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04C 29.71 .00 3 .61 112 19 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 15 142 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 15 142 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 161 I 96-Nov 15 142 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 96 I I 27 142 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01H 33.11 .00 3 .27 93 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 27 142 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 27 142 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 161 J 96-Nov 27 142 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 96 I I 32 143 TSH TSH 610-ZP PLP TSH .18 .00 10 .93 91 155 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 32 143 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 95 I 95-Jul 32 143 TEC TEH 610-EL NDD 22 I 95-Jul 32 143 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 72 I I 95-Jul 32 143 TSH TSH 620-ZC NDD 84 I 8 145 TEC TEH 610-EC INF 01H 2.44 .oo 3 19 I 8 145 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01H 3.75 .00 6 2.11 73 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 8 145 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 8 145 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 163 I 96-Nov 8 145 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 95 I 90-Apr 8 145 TEC TEH 610- A MBM 01H 2.40 .00 99 I I 30 145 TEC TEH 610-EC INF 02C 22.80 .00 3 19 I 30 145 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02C 23.84 .00 3 1.14 100 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 30 145 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 30 145 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02C 29.91 .00 3 .65 84 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 30 145 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 30 145 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 161 96-Nov 30 145 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 95 90-Apr 30 145 TEC TEH 610- A MBM 02C 22.80 .00 99 50 145 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03H 27.22 .00 3 .47 70 19 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 50 145 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 50 145 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02C 25.32 .00 3 .35 101 19 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 50 145 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 50 145 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 159 96-Nov 50 145 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 96 40 147 TEC TEH 610-EC 11 VS4 - .65 .00 M2 .28 19 +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+
- PAGE 32 TUBES 228
CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MAY 1998 REFUEL INDICATIONS WITH ALL HISTORY Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 0:38 +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB GEE PROBE IND LOG INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +- - - - - - - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - - - -+- - - - -- - -+- - - -+- - -- - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - --- - -+ 40 147 TEC TEH 610-EC 5 VS4 - .14 .00 M2 .14 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 40 147 TEC TEH 610-EC INF VS4 -1.22 .00 M1 19 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 40 147 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 159 I 96-Nov 40 147 TEC TEH 610-EL 10 VS4 -1. 22 .00 M2 .83 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 96-Nov 40 147 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 20 I I 9 14B TEC TEH 610-EC INF 02C 35.45 .00 3 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 14B TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02C 36.50 .00 3 .92 119 19 I RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 14B -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 9 148 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 165 I 96-Nov 9 14B TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 106 I 90-Apr 9 148 TEC TEH 610- A MBM 02C 35.50 . 00 99 I I 17 14B TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02H 32.42 .00 3 .64 79 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 17 148 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 17 148 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 163 I 96-Nov 17 148 TSH TSH 610 -ZR NOD 97 I I 21 148 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02H 35.69 .00 3 .BB 121 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 21 148 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 21 148 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03H 33.79 .00 3 .71 115 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 21 148 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 21 148 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03H 30.10 .00 3 1.07 111 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 21 148 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 21 14B TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 159 I 96-Nov 21 14B TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 97 I 90-Apr 21 14B TEC TEH 610- A MBM 03H 29.10 .00 99 I 90-Apr 21 14B TEC TEH 610- A MBM 03H 32.60 .00 99 I I 41 14B TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02C 11 .20 .00 3 .45 87 19 IRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 41 14B -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 41 14B TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 161 I 96-Nov 41 148 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 97 I I 73 14B TSH TSH 610-ZP INR TSH .10 .00 2 161 !RESULT OF LEAD ANALYST RESOLUTION 96-Nov ~ 73 14B TSH TSH 610-ZR TRA TSH .10 .00 4 1.08 129 90 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 92-Mar 73 148 TEH TEC 610-EP NOD 1 31 I I 12 151 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01C 29.1B .00 3 .84 52 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 12 151 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - IHISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 12 151 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 165 I 96-Nov 12 151 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 101 I I 18 151 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04C 35.66 .00 3 .77 112 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 18 151 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 1B 151 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 165 I 96-Nov 18 151 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 101 I I +- -- - - - - -+- - - -+- - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - - -+- - -+- - -+- - - - -- - -+- - -- - - - -+-- - -+- - -- - -+- - -+- - - -+- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - ------ - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ PAGE 33 TUBES 236 CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MAY 1998 REFUEL INDICATIONS WITH ALL HISTORY Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 0:38 +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPE! COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ 26 151 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02H 2.19 .00 3 .55 58 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 26 151 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 26 151 TEC TEH 610-EC DNT VS4 .56 .00 M1 8.03 172 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 26 151 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM TSC 22.66 .00 3 .62 106 19 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 26 151 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 26 151 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 165 J 96-Nov 26 151 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 109 J I 46 151 TEC TEH 610-EC INF TSH 9.02 .00 3 21 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 46 151 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM TSH 9.70 .00 3 .65 116 21 jRESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 46 151 ------------------------------------------------'.------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 46 151 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02H 6.30 .00 3 .41 106 21 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 46 151 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 46 151 TEC TEH 610-EC INF 03C 18.10 .00 3 21 J 46 151 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03C 19.23 .00 3 .54 114 21 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 46 151 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 46 151 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 163 96-Nov 46 151 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 106 90-Apr 46 151 TEC TEH 610- A MBM 03C 18.10 .00 99 90-Apr 46 151 TEC TEH 610- A MBM TSH 9.00 .00 99 50 151 TEC TEH 610-EC INF 02C 5.55 .00 3 21 50 151 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01C 34.55 .00 3 1 .14 109 21 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 50 151 HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 50 151 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 163 96-Nov 50 151 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 101 90-Apr 50 151 TEC TEH 610- A MBM 02C 5.50 .00 99 54 151 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 01H 29.31 .00 6 2.24 77 21 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 54 151 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 54 151 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 163 I 96-Nov 54 151 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 106 I I 46 157 TEC TEH 610-EC OXP TSH .11 .00 83.32 21 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 46 157 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 02H 5.99 .00 3 .44 117 21 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 46 157 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 46 157 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 167 I 96-Nov 46 157 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 104 I I 54 157 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM TSC 13.74 .00 3 .41 113 21 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 54 157 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 54 157 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 167 I 96-Nov 54 157 TSH TSH 610-ZR NDD 104 I I 9 160 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04H 14.07 .00 3 1.25 121 21 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 160 -----------~-------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 9 160 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04H 12.39 .00 3 .60 117 21 !RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 9 160 -------------------------------------------------------------!HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPE! COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ PAGE 34 TUBES 242 -~ CPAL-A LISTING OF ALL MAY 1998 REFUEL INDICATIONS WITH ALL HISTORY Palisades May 1998 Refuel PAL -A/2530 INSPECTION: May-98 15-May-98 0:38 +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ 9 160 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 169 96-Nov 9 160 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 106 33 160 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04H 35.02 .00 3 .48 86 21 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 33 160 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 33 160 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 169 96-Nov 33 160 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 99 2 163 TEC TEH 610-EC INF 03H 36.10 .00 1 25 2 163 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04H -1.54 . 00 3 .57 101 25 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 2 163 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 2 163 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 1 163 96-Nov 2 163 05C 05H 580-ZB NOD 100 96-Nov 2 163 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD* 106 90-Apr 2 163 05C TEH 580- A MBM 03H 36.10 .00 99 4 163 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03H 18.48 .00 3 .83.112 21 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 4 163 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 4 163 TEC TEH 610-EC INF 04H 17.60 .00 21 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 4 163 TEC TEH 610-EC INF 04H -3.50 .00 21 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 4 163 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 04H 36.96 .00 3 .82 113 21 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 4 163 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 4 163 TSH TSH 610-ZP NOD 165 96-Nov 4 163 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 106 90-Apr 4 163 05C TEH 610- A MBM 03H 17.60 .00 99 90-Apr 4 163 05C TEH 610- A MBM 05H -3.50 .00 99 12 163 TEC TEH 610-EC MBM 03H 7.31 .00 3 .49 107 . 21 RESULT OF DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION 12 163 ------------------------------------------------------------- HISTORY REVIEW PERFORMED 12 163 TSH TSH 610-ZP NDD 1 169 96-Nov 12 163 TSH TSH 610-ZR NOD 109 +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ I DATE ROW COL CEB CEE PROBE IND LOC INCH1 INCH2 CHAN VOLTS DEG TAPEI COMMENTS +--------+----+----+---+---+------+---+---+--------+--------+----+------+---+----+--------------------------------------------------+ PAGE 35 TOTAL TUBES 246 Palisades May 1998 Refuel Steam Generator Eddy Current Inspection
- Supertubin Data Management Report User's Guide The following explains the format of the data as displayed in the Supertubin Report hard copies.
ROW and COL (COLUMN) Tube identifier numbers - an X-Y coordinate system. CE-B - COMPLETED BEGIN TEST Tube location where the test actually began. CE-E - COMPLETED END TEST Tube location where the test actually ended. PROBE
- TYPE Diameter of probe used for the test.
Characters representing the type of probe used. Please see the table in this report for probe descriptors used during this inspection. IND - INDICATION Character codes and numerics that represent the analysis results of the data for the tube. Please refererence the Analysis Guidelines for three letter code descriptions. LOCN - LOCATION. The location in the tube where the indication is referenced from. INCH1
- Page 1 Of 2 Westinghouse Electric Company Supertubin Data Management
. 05/15/98 8: 11 AM Palisades May 1998 Refuel Steam Generator Eddy Current Inspection
- Supertubin Data Management Report User's Guide Distance in inches above or below the location where the indication is referenced from.
INCH2 Typically the distance above or below INCH1 that a particular indication extends, such as a permeability variation extending along a length of a tube. CHAN - CHANNEL Describes the data channel used in reporting the indication. VOLTS The voltage reported by the analyst as referenced to a standard.
- DEG - DEGREES TAPE The angle of the indication as reported by the analyst.
The data set where the raw eddy current data was collected to. COMMENTS Additional remarks which enhance the information contained in the other fields of the record. LOCATION TERMS DESCRIPTION Please reference the Analysis Guidelines for descriptions of locations referenced during this inspection .
- Page 2 Of 2 Westinghouse Electric Company Supertubin Data Management
. 05/15/98 8:11 AM _j Palisades May 1998 Refuel Steam Generator Eddy Current Inspection
- Probe Type Summary For Probes Used During May 1998 Refuel ACTS# Probe Type Supertubin Designation PAL-01-198 EC610LLMC EC PAL-02-198 EC590LLMC PAL-03-198 ZP610PP115S80 ZP ZP590PP115S80 PAL-04-198 UP580UBMPP UP
CPAL-8 HOT LEG BOBBIN PROGRAM ..... "=-:.& .. Palisades May 1998 CPAL 2530 ACTS # PAL-01-198 PROBE(S) :EC610LLMC,EC590LLMC, EC580LLMC X 1717 TEST FULL LENGTH \ 5 TEST OSH THROUGH TEH 111 25 STAY ROD c 309 PLUGGED TUBE 165 160 155 150 145 140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 x o 0 x xx o (~ o 0 ox*~ xx 0 o o x so 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5
- neR TU.RE
.rr& 13cARD I I I I I I I J I I I I _ 0 1p X __
- X * ..
- __ X *
- 0 0 X _ .. ft 135 x 0 x- * - x - *
- x .. *
- x * * * *
- x - 0 .. ,~ 0 ,, ~
~ XOO X*** **** **** **000 " 130 _ x 0 * . x *** X .. ** x
- X * **X * * * **X *** * * *x* X .. ** * * ..X*O O o -J 0 n er>.... * *
- x n. * * * * * * *
- x * * * ...
- x *., *
- 0 x OX*X **X* X**X *X** **X* X**X 0 0 * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- 0 "
125 _ _o
- x * * * ..
- x
- x *
- x
- x * * *
- x *~ * *
- x *.
- x 1 ~ A'l(l~iU~IQiu @n o; x; *** x
- x * * * * :*
- x*
- x
- x* * * *x* * *
- x * * * * *
- x* x * * :*
- x * * * *x* :* *
- x o ; o 0 Ae ~...sr..n::v.!i
... a o * * ...x * * * *..,..* * * * * **** * * * * * .x. * * * * * * * *
- x * * * *. * * *
- x *
* * ** **
- x
* * * * * * * * * * .o A Ftt9fiU\f0 \YP'r9i\P..t.i!:l ~ 120 to-. x * * * ,-, x* , .- x , , , -, x ,-. .-. x ,- * , , x -, , .-, .*, * ,- x , , *o0
- 0. x*
- x * * * * *
- x* x* * *
- x* * *
- x* * *
- x
- x* * * * *
- x*
- x * * * * *
- x* x*
- x * *
- x ()
115 ~ . x;. x x o x x x x x l *
- x *
- i'
- x
- Xj* * ' *
- x *tx * '
- t
- x
*
- x
- x 0
'f' x x
- t '
x *
- I* *
- xj* x * * * * *tx * ' x
- x
- x
- t
*x *
- x
- x *
- 0
'i"
- x~
- f x ' * ~Xt* * '
- t. * ' * *tx~x x
- x .....
- 0 115
~ii ~ii ~ ~ ~"' X
- X
- X *
- __ *
- i
- T
.
- i\ ii * ' *
- X* X* * 'T * .;; *
- __ *
- iC * 'T * *
- I
- Xi
- Jiit. * * * ** oi *
- T e X * .; * <> X*
- T
- X 110 110 o~
o 0 x* x . x x x x x x x *x
- x xx .. ~. x x
x x x x
- x x
x x
- x x ox
'x o 0 105 00 x x x x . . x x x , x x x x x x x . x x x x u ~ x x x x
- x x x x x x Po 105 100 x
- qi:*
- x
~. x x
- x.
~. x ~ x x x ~
- x. x x
- 0 x
x x x x x x .; . x x x x x x ..x x 0 .xo 0 100 95 ;x x
90 x x
- x x x x x x x x x x x
- x
. ..-o 85 85 x- x x x x x x x x x x x x 0 ~o' x x x x x x x x x x x x ~ :- x x x . x x x x x x x x x x .. ~ x x x x x x x x x x ~ 00 x_ 80 D: *x .. .. 80
- x x x x x x x x x x x x x ~ x x
- x *x x x x x
- x"o 75 0 x x x
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x * : x* x x x . x x x x x ** cp 0 75 00 ... o. x x x x x x x ...... 0 ~ x ~ . x x x x x ...x x x x x ... x x ~. x x .-.x x x 0 70 70 -;,- x
- x x *x x x x 65 ox.x
- x * ~-x *x x *x x x .
- x. x x
x x x x x x x x *** x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x *x x x x x x x
- x x
x x .oo .. -.-.....,o 65 60 of:~. ox . .. ~. x x *x . ~ x x x ... x . ~ x x x ~. x x .-.x x x x x x x x
- x*
x x x x x x x x x x x
- x
**Oct> x cp 60 x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x * *** x _o' x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x~ 55 55 0 x x x x x x x x x x x x x,*t*xxx1xxxx x I * ..x * ..* _Cl x _Cl x
- x Cl Cl* Cl x XCl~X.l.*
x x x x x x .. x x x x x x x-xo 50 _o x ~ x x x x x .. X x ~. x x .. . x .. . x ..o~ 50 ..x x .. x .. iii - Cl - Cl~ Cl - Cl - 45 x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x: x x x x x x
- x~xl~:~:,:~:~~~:~: ~;~;i;~;=f :x:. x x x
x x x x x x x x .. H x x ..... "x ,_ x x x x x x x x x
- x 0 0 45 x x x x x x x x~*ix~c;;;c;c~c;c;;;c;c c;c~~~c~c~c~ x; x x x :..
x .. . . : ~. di x **
- 1* * :
- x
- x 'o x
- 40 OTX 0
0 x x x . .. x *x x x x x x x x x x. ~ ~ ft x x x x x X~~~Cl~Cl!Cl~Cl~~~Cl~Cl!Cl~CICI CICl~Cl!CI~ Cl ~~~Cl~CI *;x-;wClwCl:ClwClw;wClwCl:ClwClw wClwCl:ClwCl-;-Cl-CI x-. ' XCI CICICICI CICICICI CICICICI CICICICI CICICICI CICICICI CICICICll xx. x ._.* ~ x x x xx x x x x ~. x x x x x X *
- XI x
- t 40 35
_o x x . x x x x .. x x x x x x x x x_c c_c __ c_c c c *=;~~:;:;~;c;c c c Cl Cl __ Cl_CI Cl_Cl_I x -11i;c;c~c;c;1 x x
- x x
x x x x x x x
- x x 35 A
x 30 x 0 x .. x x x x x. x x x x x x x ,, * .. x _ ~ a a Cl~~Cl~CI X~* .. ~. x x . x x x - ~ ~. . ~ x x x x x 0 0 *30 ~:~:: X ox. x. x x x x x x x x :x:;iii;:; n x
- 0 x x x x x x* x x x x x
- x x x x x x o" x x x x x x x x_c!c x x x x x x x x 25 25 x x x-c -. x*
- x x x x x x 0
.Cl . :xo 0 x x x x xx Cl x x x x x x x x 20 0 0 0 x x
- x x
x x x x x x x x *x x . x x ~ x
- 0 00 x
I o"* x x .._.. x~. ~. x x x . x x x ~. x ~. x ~ x .. x x x* x x * -.-*.o .xo 20 x x . x x x 0 x x x x . x x x x x x .-.. x x x x x
- x 15 15 o' x x
x x x x x x x x x x
- x x
x x 0 o~ x x x x x x x x x x x x *:* x .x~ ~ x x x x x *XO,.., 10 x X
- l .x .*1*,
X .X.l. *,*;;,x,'i'*'*;;*~Xl .x * . * . .* .* x .* . .x' .'f' .X x x .~ 0 "%
- x*
. . Xj* . .xf. .' .*jx .* .l .x ."t' .x x x x x x x. 0 10 5 x
- t
* * * *i x*
- x
- x*
- 0000 \000 0\00 i . x tOOOX
* -*
- x 0000
* . xi ..... ; .* -
- ixXOOO x *
- 0000 0000 x .
- t x
- i . x i * . xi *
*
- x OXOO OOXO OOOX x
0000 x*0 X t**, tu* X * * * *x* *
- x iX * **
- X
*X** ; *.***1x-.-t-x-*r*-x-t-.-.i.**. 00\0 OOOX 0000 0000 XOOO OXOO OOXO OOOX 0000 0000 XOOO D;x;o X *
- X
**X* +
- Xl*
- i *
- I X
***X t *'ix ** x 0 x 0 5 165 160 155 150 145 140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 ao 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 ,._ ,,,.. Westinghouse Electric Co. - NSD ST98 06/11/1998 14:22:45 q<r( oo~ot{of-/ ft; ~ CPAi:-B COLD LEG BOBBIN PROGRAM Palisades May 1998 CPAL 2530 ACTS # PAL-01-198 PROBE(S) :EC610LLM,EC590LLMC, EC580LLMC \ 4 TEST OSC THROUGH TEC (TESTED FROM HOT LEG)
- 25 STAY ROD c 309 PLUGGED TUBE 16S 160 lSS 150 14S 140 135 130 12S 120 ll5 llO lOS 100 9S 90 8S 80 75 70 6S 60 S5 50 4S 40 35 30 2S 20 15 10 5 lo o 0 ~ 0 o 0 o~o 0 o 0 m 0 o 0 o9o o
_o_© o *T* * * * *T*
- f o o o_ -
*I* .* .* . 135 - - 0-=----:--= ** : * * * * . * . . * * * * . . * * * . * * . :o:'l>ooo 1b '\ rrl~.:hroJ~u'lUJ\ :1-]1-c:: * . .* .* . (1l~l1~1J-:.'~ ut~\LS 130 1 I I I I I j I I I I .+.. 0 0 °-r- * *i*
- I . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
- I - oo'ch.
- T.
- 0 0
0 0 -:-0 o 0 0 0 J'..\J I-;;:..; b' L1 130,fA~@ ru l1.. .' - ._, ,.' t* \....n ~ LI lJ 12S 12S 0~ * * * * * * * * - .- .... --;- ---;----;-- - * * ---;- - * * * .--.., * * * * * *
- 0 ~ 0
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- 0 o * * * * * * * * . * * * . * * * . . . . . . * * * * * * * * ,.,,..1. ,, f ri n~r1r=-. ryl/')
1 120 I I I I l I I I - O * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- 0,... f::;,., flOO"b L~..:\gQLUUl'.d.IU~ ~JU 1..
o """* * * * * * .*. . . o 0 .. - ~, f~J:~,.il.1£f!J'.i ..-!\ re;.. 1 Qn...,2"1 -'1C!U QJ 0 o * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * <) 0 //' ... L:::. ...,;J llS 0 - * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * .... 0 llS * * * * * * * * * * * .* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
- 0
% * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * ..
- 0 llO -= llO 00* 00
,_ 0 *
- 0
_ w * *
- 0 lOS lOS 00 * :Do 0
- o~
100 r:: .~o 100 9S _o . * : 0 <D 9S oo. 00 0 *
- 0 90 90 di 0 *
- 0 8S 0
o"'* ** 0 di 8S 0 00 _o' *o_ 80 7S of:* . * .,., 0 *
- 0 di 80 75 00 70 o*
. * * . 70 6S 0 0 ** .oo 6S ~* """o 0 0 60 60 00 0 SS _o 0 55 so -&o 0 *~C c_c c C.C_ c 0 o_ so ~~~~ c c c c c c c c 0
- c-~ct *
- c~~~~~c~c 1 Cl Cl Cl
- 0 4S o _b
- 0
** .i c-.:r Cl c Cl c ~~~~ ;~;~: x~ ;~ ~~l~ ~-~ ~ %~ ~ ~ ~
- 0 0
E 45 40 *- _Cl Cl 40 *~c w-~w 3S _O 0 0 * . Cl Cl c Cl c c c~c~ c c c c ~~~~ ~~~~: ~~~~ ~c~c c~c~ ~~~~:* Xe ..- c c c c ~. c c *
- i 0 3S 0 * *
- Cl
- CJ Cl 1- -c~c~c~; *
- c-c:*
30 Cl 0-B 30 0 * *~
- Cl c c Cl c Cl cccc . 0 0 C_ 0 2S 0
0 0 * *oc c -=y-:. 0 0
- oo 2S i'.
20 ~ 20 0
- 0 0
- 0 00 00 j
0 *
- 0 c
.i-lS
- I *. Q 15
**.**I**
- 0 -
- I * * .f *
- l * * * * *
- 0 I I I I I I 00
~ -I - A 10 . ~r I CD I I I I ' 0 . . . . o. o. o. o. o. o. o. o. o. o. o. o. o. o. o. o. o. o. o. o. 5 * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * .. .. * .. * * .. * .. * .. * .. * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * .. i .. t . 'i* . t .. i .. 0000 \000 0\00 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 0000 * * ~ * .. i .. t .. i .. t .. i .. * * * . * * * * *
- 0 )
ct> 0 o\o o o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0v 0 0 5 16S 160 1S5 lSO 145 140 135 130 12S 120 llS llO 105 100 9S 90 8S 80 7S 70 6S 60 SS so 4S 40 35 30 2S 20 lS 10 s Westinghouse Electric Co. - NSD ST98 06111/1998 14:32:42 C1 o(Oo:2ol(O( -- /1 ""- CPAL-B ~_- ..... -... HOT LEG TOP OF TUBESHEET +POINT PROGRAM ~ Palisades May 1998 CPAL 2530 ACTS # PAL-03-198 PROBE(S) :ZP610PP115S80, ZP590PP115S80 X 7910 TEST TSH -/+ 2 INCHES
- 25 STAY ROD c 309 PLUGGED TUBE 165 160 155 150 145 140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100 95 90 85 80 75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 . . RE 135 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 __ .. t .. v::xt.v::x:::~::x::l!t.x::x::):::x::x:r.x::l!::t::l! .. l!.L .. 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 ."Par:i£RTU 130 I I I I I I I I I I .. XJ. l! :: JI:: X:: JI:: JI J: JC:: X:: J: :: JC :: JC:£ X:: X:: X:: X:: JC ZJI;; X;; Jl :; JI:; X:£ l! :: JI :: X:: JI:: JI J: X:: X.. X.. I I I I I I I I I 1CARD 125 I I I I I I I I .. X.. XH:: X:: X:: X:: U X:: X:: X:: X:: Xal X:: X:: X:: X:: H X:: X:: X:: X:: X:ll X:: X:: X:: X:: X:+: X:: X:: X:: X:: U X:: X:: X.. X.. I I I I I I I I I .. 'SCf j.\;ijl!ftUta\bfi @Iii)
~11'N~WfllJl\f~ CtSlffi 120 I I I I I I I I .. 11 :: ll' mll':: ll':: 'Ir:: ll' :: ll' T. ll' :: ll':: 'j(:: ll':: ll' mll:: ll' :: 'j( :: ll' :: ll' T. ll :: ll':: 'j( :: ll' :: ll ~: l!:: l!:: l'.:: l! :: 11 T. ll :: l!:: 1: :: ll:: l! T. 11:: ll':: 'j( :: ll :: l! mll :: ll:: Jr:: ll.. I I I I I I 120 115 I I I I I I I u 11 :: ll T. 11:: 11:: )[ :: 11 :: ll T. 11 :: 11 :: 'J1:: ll:: ll a: ll :: 11:: 'I!:: 11:: 11 a: ll:: ll:: ]( :: l!:: l! T. 11:: 11:: l! =ll :: JH: 11:: ll :: ::: :: ll :: ll :r. l!:: l!:: x :: ll :: JC :1: ll =ll :: x :: ]{ =)( ;: x :: ll :: ll'. =ll.. I I I I I I I 115 110 I I I I I I .. l! :r. ll:: ll:: x :: ll:: )( ml! :: ll =x:: l! :: ll T. l!:: )( :: r =l! :: l! J: ll :: ll :: x :: l! =ll ;: l! :: )( :: )[ :: l! :: ll a:)( :: x:: x:: J( :: ll :r. J( :: )( :: )[ :: x:: l! a: ll :: )[ :: ]( :: JI :: JI :r. ll :: ll :: x :: J( :: x :r. x :: ll :: x .. I I I I I 110 105 1 1 1 1 1 x;;x;;J1;;x;;J1;;xEJ1;;l!;;x;;x;;J1Ex;;J1;;x;;J1;;l!EX;;J1-x;;x;;x:r.x;;x;;x;;x;;J1:r.x;;x;;x;;x;;xzx;;x;;x;;JC;;xT*;;x;;x;;*;;xzx;;*;;x;;x;;***;;*;;Jt;;x;;*z*;;x;;1 1 1 1 1 105 100 1 1 1 1 1 !x::x::x::x::xmx::x::x::x::xmx::x::x::x::x:+:x::x::x::x::xxx::x::x::x::xmx::x::x::x::xxx::x::x::x::xsx::x::x::x::x:+:x::x::x::x::x:x::x::x::x::xxx::x::x::x::x:+:x::x .. 1 1 1 1 100 95 1 1 1 1 x=w::l!::xmx;;x;;w;;x;;x:r.x;;x;;w;;x=J1:r.x;;y;;x;;x;;xmx;;x;;'ll;;x;;xEx;;x;;l!;;x;;J1:r.11;;y;;r;;y;;y:r.y;;J1;;l!;;J1::llEx;;x;;~;;J1;;xzx;;x;;'l!;;x;;xxx;;x;;'l!;;J(;;J1EJ(;;J1;;x;;J1;;11Ex 1 1 1 1 95
- 90 I a5 1 ao 1 75 1 I
1 1 1 1 1 1 I I 1 I :: JI :: JI :r. JI:: JI :: x :: JI:: JI!¥. ll :: JI::)[ :: x :: ll a: JI :: JI :: x :: J( :: x :r. JI:: JI:: x :: l! :: x ::: J( :: J( :: )[ :: )( :: J(::: )(::JI::)[:: JI:: JI l: J( :: JI:: ll' :: J( :: J( a: J( :: J( :: x :: J( :: J( J: J( :: J( :: I :: J( :: J( a: J( :: J( :: x :: )( :: )( :1: J( :: x :: x :: J( :: J( ;i; )( :; x ;; x :: x :: _x1x::x::1::x:xxx:x::x:x::xxx::x:1:x::xzx:x::x::x::xxx::x::x::x::xzx::x::~::x::xxx:x::x::x::xzx:x:x::x:xxx:x::x::x::xzx::x:x::x:x:x:x:x:x::xxx::x:x::x:xxx::x::1.. ix::x=x::J1nllmx;;x;;x;;x;;x2y;;x;;x::x;;xmx;;x;;x;;x;;xzx;;x;;x;;x;;xmx::x=x::x;;xmx;;x;;x=x::xzx;;x::x::x;;xzx;;x::x;;x;;*zx;;y;;x;;x;;xzx;;x;;x;;x;;xxx::J1;;x;;x::xzJ1;;J1;;~;;J1;;xEx;;x =x::x::xzx;;x;;x::x;;xzx;;*;;x::x::xzx;;J1;;x;;x;;x:r.x;;J1;;x;;*;;xz*;;x;;x;;x;;xzx;;x;;x;;x;;xEx;;x;;1;;x;;J1Ex;;x;;x;;x;;x:r.x;;x;;x;;x;;xzx;;x;;x;;*;;xzx;;x;;x=x=*zx;;x;;x;;x=xzx;;x=x;;x=x;; I 1 .. 1 I 1 1 I 1 1 1 90}}