ML18019A691
| ML18019A691 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Harris  |
| Issue date: | 03/20/1986 |
| From: | Zimmerman S CAROLINA POWER & LIGHT CO. |
| To: | Harold Denton Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| GL-84-16, NLS-86-082, NLS-86-82, NUDOCS 8603250167 | |
| Download: ML18019A691 (11) | |
Text
~a 4
REGULATOR FORMATION DISTRIBUTION S EM (RIDS)
A'CCESSION NBR: 8603250167.
DQC. DATE: 86/03/20 NOTARIZED:
NO DOCKET 0 FACIL: 50-400 Shearon Harris Nuclear Power Plant>
Unit ii Carolina 05000400 AUTH. NAME AUTHOR AFFILIATION ZIMMERMAN>S. R.
Carolina Power 5 Light Co.
RECIP. NAME RECIPIENT AFFILIATION DENTON> H. R.
Qffice of Nuclear Reactor Regulationi Director (post 851125
SUBJECT:
Submits addi info re adequacy of shift operating experiencei in response to Generic Ltr 84-ib h SER License Condition 5.
Program ei 1 1 be implemented to include personnel v/previous PWR operating experience.
DISTRIBUTION CODE:
M003D COPIES RECEIUED: LTR ENCL SIZE:
TITLE: Operator Requalification Program NOTES: Application for permit reneeel filed.
05000400 RECIPIENT ID CODE/NAME PWR-A PD2 PD COPIES LTTR ENCL 1
1 RECIPIENT ID CODE/NAME BUCKLEY> B COPIES LTTR ENCL 1
1 INTERNAL:
N HFIB F LE 04 02 EXTERNAL: 24X NRC PDR NRR/DHFT/MTB RGN2 LPDR NSIC 03 05 1
1 1
1 1
1 1
TOTAL NUMBER OF COPIES REQUIRED:
LTTR 10 ENCL 10
hAVVgfVVVI 6$
fC PiQK
.'<t~'f J gL ~,>(>>
(4h "
Si'V.IW1 'l
%4.> a.
<<tP, f
~a '
V'lh, I f".V
'i'hi2'0 '6 I
I",Qghh 1
~ Vf
)f
~ ~
GJl4 'I SC I t(V I ~
~,VPPVl l'
~
t "I,V a 4 9h~ ~.iPV Vfi'~ha i"'~ VA t VfPy 9
"<<)
Vt OliOD V
tf ~C;hid'P <a VV~'I
. I
I 'h L f+j f0 hf v
V V')AIV."I
'PV"
. 'p Jffg.
II Vp f
/)I I II
~
~ Ita 8l.h.
'7 D
~-
Carolina Power & Light Company MAR 3 0 1986,',
SERIAL: NLS-86-082 Mr. Harold R. Denton, Director Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT UNIT NO.
1 DOCKET NO.50-000 ADEQUACYOF ON SHIFT OPERATING EXPERIENCE
Dear Mr. Denton:
Carolina Power R Light Company (CPRL) hereby submits additional information concerning the adequacy of on shift operating experience at the Shearon Harris Nuclear Power Plant (SHNPP).
This information is submitted in response to Generic Letter 80-16 and Safety Evaluation Report (SER) License Condition No. 5. In the SER, the NRC stated that each shift crew would have to include or be supplemented with personnel with previous licensed experience at commercial facilities of similar design. At the time the SER was published (December 1983); the NRC would accept either utilitypersonnel as part of the shift or on shift advisors.
The NRC position was modified in Generic Letter 80-16 to the extent that the use of non-licensed individuals with previous commercial experience would not be acceptable for SHNPP.
In discussions with the NRC staff, CPttt:L understands that the personnel selected to fulfillthe requirement for on shift experience must obtain an SRO license for SHNPP and either have (1) six months previous experience with an SRO license or (2) 12 months previous experience with an RO license.
Individuals with fewer months of experience willbe evaluated on a case-by-case basis.
The purpose of this response is to identify those individuals which willbe relied upon at SHNPP and why CPRL finds them qualified to satisfy the experience recommendations provided by the NRC.
Carolina Power R Light Company willimplement a program of including personnel on shift with previous PWR operating experience during the initial months of operation.
The program willbegin when the unit first enters Mode 3 following fuel load and willcontinue for six months.
Periods of time when the plant is in cold shutdown for longer than seven days willnot be counted toward the six month total.
Table 1 (attached) identifies the-experience levels of the individuals currently holding the position of shift foreman at SHNPP and additional individuals that willbe relied upon for the NRC "on shift experience" recommendation.
While two of the shift foremen have commercial BWR experience instead of PWR experience; it is important to note the depth of this experience since it is a valid indicator of technical and leadership skills.
Furthermore, the shift foreman maintains ultimate responsibility for shift operations, as required by Technical Specifications, even though an additional individual on the shift may be used to satisfy the NRC recommendation for previous PWR experience.
8603250i67 860320 PDR ADQCK 05000400 E
PDR 411 Fayettevilte Street o P. O. Box 1551 o Raleigh, N. C. 27602
+oo9
/i
~
l u
F
~
Mr. Harold R. Denton Page 2 Five of the individuals identified below with PWR experience satisfy the specific time requirements set forth by the NRC, the sixth individual (Mr. H. Carter) must be evaluated considering the additional experience obtained at H. B. Robinson while as an unlicensed operator and the experience gained while as a member of the SHNPP staff.
Mr. Carter's experience at CPRL's Robinson plant covers a period of four years and two months.
This includes 0 1/2 months during the fall of 1982 and winter of 1983 when he was temporarily transferred back to the Robinson plant and participated in shift operations as a Control Operator.
During this entire time interval, the Robinson facility was in commercial operation.
The training and experience obtained during Mr. Carter's non-licensed and control operator training included performing and participating in equipment operations that would not be part of a cold license program.
These activities included (1) control of secondary plant equipment (e.g., generator synchronization and loading; feedwater and condensate system operation) for the 170 Mwe fossil Robinson Unit 1; (2) movement of spent fuel in the Fuel Handling Building in support of three separate refueling outages at Unit 2; (3) qualification on all of the Technical Specification surveillance tests required for safety-related equipment for Unit 2 (e.g.,
emergency diesel generator start and load testing, safety injection pump testing); and (0) 080 hours9.259259e-4 days <br />0.0222 hours <br />1.322751e-4 weeks <br />3.044e-5 months <br /> of in control room on-the-job training prior to taking the NRC RO exam.
In addition to this in-plant experience, Mr. Carter has received a total of four months of simulator training as a result of the training program for the Robinson RO license and the SHNPP SRO license.
In addition to this experience, the performance and leadership displayed by Mr. Carter during the SHNPP SRO license program and the pre-operational testing phase (including the hot functional testing) at SHNPP demonstrate to CPdcL management that Mr. Carter is a mature and capable operator.
Mr. Carter willbe used to provide the previous PWR experience for either Mr. Briney or Mr. Matthews.
In summary, CPRL has proposed a program which is consistent with the NRC's recommendations.
The individuals with previous experience willprovide added depth until other cold licensed personnel have gained experience in hot operations of the SHNPP. If you have any additional questions or require additional information, please contact me.
Yours very truly, SRZ/JHE/ccc (3526NLU)
Attachment S R.
erman Manager Nuclear Licensing Section Cco Mr. B. C. Buckley (NRC)
Mr. L. Crocker (NRC)
Mr. G. F. Maxwell (NRC-SHNPP)
Dr. J. Nelson Grace (NRC-RII)
Mr. Travis Payne (KUDZU)
Mr. Daniel F. Read (CHANGE/ELP)
Wake County Public Library Mr. Wells Eddleman Mr. 3ohn D. Runkle Dr. Richard D. Wilson Mr. G. O. Bright (ASLB)
Dr. 3. H. Carpenter (ASLB)
Mr. 3. L. Kelley (ASLB)
Mr. H. A. Cole
ATTACHMENT TABLE I Name D. Batton E. Brooks R. Garner J. Digby C. Briney C. Matthews H. Carter W. Barmann NOTE I Position 2 SF SF SF SF SF SF SF SCO~
License - Months SRO-60 SRO- 08 SRO-12 SRO - 36 SRO- 01 SRO-IO RO'- 0.5 RO-12
~Faciiit HBR HBR HBR TP BSEP M-I HBR HBR Comments A,L A,L A,T A,T T
T A,L A,L HBR H. B. Robinson Unit 2; 700 Mwe PWR (3-loop Westinghouse)
TP Turkey Point Units 3 and 0; 728 Mwe (each) PWR (3-loop Westinghouse)
BSEP Brunswick Steam Electric Plant Units I and 2; 790 Mwe (each BWR)
M-I Millstone Unit I; 600 Mwe BWR NOTE 2 SF Shift Foreman SCO Senior Control Operators The responsibilities of the shift foreman are listed in the FSAR, Chapter 13.0, Section 13.1.2.2.3,3.. The normal duty station for the SF and SCO is in the Main Control Room.
The responsibilities of the SCO include assisting the shift foreman on duty in maintaining proper logs and records, performing required periodic, special and routine tests, evaluating plant conditions to ensure conformances to established regulations, and conducting "on shift" training and retraining programs.
The SCO also assumes the duties of the shift foreman until properly relieved by authority in case the shift foreman should become incapacitated.
Detailed resumes of the individuals holding shift foreman positions are currently included in the FSAR, Section 13.1.2 or are attached to this response.
Details of Mr. Barmann's experience are provided below in Note 0.
NOTE 3 A
Relied on for previous commercial PWR experience.
L Currently SRO licensed at SHNPP.
T Currently in training for SRO license at SHNPP.
(3526NLU/ccc)
NOTE 0 Mr. Barmann has been employed by CPRL since November 1978. Mr. Barmann's experience involves work at two of CPRL's nuclear plants, H. B. Robinson Unit 2 (HBR) and SHNPP.
Mr. Barmann worked as an auxiliary operator at HBR from November 1978 until June 1981.
In June'981, he received an RO license at HBR and worked as a control operator.
In June 1982, Mr. Barmann was transferred to SHNPP.
Mr. Barmann willbe working as the senior control operator on a shift with shift foremen who have previous navy nuclear experience and has previous SRO and RO experience in a commercial BWR. Prior to coming to CPdcL, Mr. Barmann served six years in the U.S. Navy where he was qualified as a nuclear electrical operator (electricians mate).
NOTE 5 For individuals with SRO license experience, the previous RO license experience is not shown in this table but is indicated in the referenced resumes.
(3526NLU/ccc )
RESUME CLARENCE MATTHEWS SHIFT FOREMAN EDUCATIONAND TRAINING:
A.
Murphy High School Atlanta, Georgia, 1967 B.
Obtained Reactor Operator License in June 1979 C.
Obtained Senior Reactor Operator License in May 1982 EXPERIENCE:
July 1967 - October 1967:
Material Handler, Evans Fleet Service, Atlanta, Georgia January 1968 - September 1968:
Banquet Waiter, Regency Hyatt House, Atlanta, Georgia September 1968 September 1975:
Nuclear Electricians'ate Second Class (E5),
U.S. Navy September 1975 - April 1981:
Plant Equipment Operator, Millstone Unit 1, Waterford, Connecticut April 1981 - July 1982:
Control Operator, Millstone Unit 1, Waterford, Connecticut July 1982 August 1983:
Senior Control Operator, Millstone Unit 1, Waterford, Connecticut August 1983 June 1980:
Senior Control Operator - Nuclear Operations Department, Shearon Harris Nuclear Power Plant, New Hill, North Carolina June 1980:
Shift Foreman Harris Nuclear Project Department, Shearon Harris Nuclear Power Plant, New Hill, North Carolina (3526NLU/ccc )
~
~
RESUME HAMER L. CARTER SHIFT FOREMAN BIRTH DATE:
November 5, 1909 EDUCATIONAND TRAINING:
Dillon High School, Dillon, South Carolina, 1968 Francis Marion College, Florence, South Carolina, 1970, Completed Three Years in Undergraduate Math PROFESSIONAL AFFILIATIONSAND ACHIEVEMENTS:
None.
EXPERIENCE PRIOR TO 3OINING CPRL:
09/69-06/75:
B. C. Moore and Sons, Darlington, South Carolina Store Manager 06/75-05/77:
Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, Florence, South Carolina Salesman 05/77-11/78:
Segars Chevrolet and Cadillac Company, Hartsville, South Carolina - Car Salesman EXPERIENCE WITH CPRL:
11/20/78:
Employed as a helper (Harris Training Complement) in the Harris organization temporarily assigned to the H. B. Robinson plant, Hartsville, South Carolina.
07/28/79:
Promoted to an AuxiliaryOperator B in the Harris organization temporarily assigned to the H. B. Robinson plant, Hartsville, South Carolina.
Ol/20/81:
Promoted to an AuxiliaryOperator A in the Nuclear Operations Department at the Harris plant located in New Hill, North Carolina, temporarily assigned to the H. B. Robinson plant, Hartsville, South Carolina.
08/02/82:
Received NRC RO license for H. B. Robinson plant, Unit 2, Hartsville, South Carolina.
08/28/82:
Transferred as an AuxiliaryOperator A to the Nuclear Operations Department at the Shearon Harris Nuclear Power Plant located in New Hill, North Carolina.
09/18/82:
Promoted to a Control Operator in the Nuclear Operations Department at the Shearon Harris Nuclear Power Plant located in New Hill, North Carolina.
09/03/83:
Reorganization:
Department renamed Harris Nuclear Project.
(3526NLU/ccc )
10/13/80:
Promoted to a Senior Control Operator - "in training" in the Plant Operations Unit, Harris Plant Section of the Harris Nuclear Project Department.
08/31/85:
Promoted to Shift Foreman - Nuclear in the Plant Operations Unit, Harris Plant Operations Section of the Harris Nuclear Project Department.
01/86:
Received NRC SRO license for SHNPP.
(3526NLU/ccc)
~ '
l