ML17342A782
| ML17342A782 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Turkey Point  |
| Issue date: | 07/21/1987 |
| From: | Varga S Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | Woody C FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT CO. |
| Shared Package | |
| ML17342A783 | List: |
| References | |
| RTR-NUREG-0737, RTR-NUREG-737 NUDOCS 8707240211 | |
| Download: ML17342A782 (12) | |
See also: IR 05000250/1987008
Text
UNITED STATES
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
WASHINGTON, D. C. 20555
July
21<. 1987
Docket Nos.
50-250/251
Florida Power
and Light Company
ATTN:
IIr. C. 0.
Woody, Group Vice President,
Nuclear Energy Department
Post Office Box 14000,
JNE,
Juno
Beach, Florida
33408-0420
Gentlemen:
SUBJECT:
INSPECTION REPORT
HOS. 50-250/87-08
and 50-251/87-08
Enclosed is the report of the team inspection
conducted
by t1r. S.
D. Alexander
and other
NRC represeIItatives
during the period of March 2-6,
1987 at your
engineering offices in Juno Beach, Florida and at the Turkey Point Nuclear
Generating Station of activities authorized
by NRC License
Nos.
and
The team's findings were discussed
with members of your staff at the
conclusion of the inspection.
The inspectors
reviewed your implementation of
a program
as required by
10 CFR 50.49 for establishing
and maintaining the
environmental qualification (Eg) of electrical
equipment within the scope of
Within these
areas,
the inspection consisted of review of
selected
procedures
and records,
examination of selected
plant equipment,
interviews of personnel,
and other observations
by the inspectors.
The inspectors
determined
thai: you have
implemented
a program to meet the
requirements
of 10 CFR 50.49 except for certain deficiencies identified in the
enclosed
inspection report.
Five of these deficiencies,
summarized
in
Appendix A, are classified
as Potential
Enforcement/Unresolved
Items
and will
be referred to the
NRC Region II Office for further action.
These
items
related to Raychem shrinkfit sleeve insulation in unqualified configurations,
failure to show similarity between tested
3N tape splice insulation
and that
installed
and potentially improper level of qualification, operation of the
plant between
March and October of 1985 with unqualified Texaco Marfak grease
in Limitorque motorized valve actuators,
and lack of traceability to Eg
documentation
of two field-run cables to Limitorque valve actuators
due to
improper cable tag
numbers
and absence
of other identifying cable markings
within the the actuator.
87072402ii 87072i"
- DOCK 05000250
8
l
b
r,.
, ~
Florida Power
and Light Company
- 2-
July 21I
1987
Twelve additional concerns
were classified
as
Open Items,
and
a future
NRC
inspection will review your actions concerning
them.
Details of all the
deficiencies
and concerns
are discussed
in the enclosed
inspection report.
Your corrective actions regarding the identified deficiencies
and concerns
should not be delayed
pending either
a future
NRC inspection or further action
by the
NRC Region II Office.
We are available to discuss
any questions
you may have concerning this
inspection.
Si
ere ly,
n
o
a ga>
ivision of React
Office of Nuclear
s ector
r Projects I/II
actor Regulation
Enclosures:
l.
Appendix A: Potential
Enforcement/Unresolved
Items
2.
Inspection Report
Nos. 50-250/87-08,
50-251/87-08
(23 pages)
CC:
J.
W. Dickey,
Vice President for Operations
florida Power
8 Light Co.
JNE,
JB,
Nuclear Engineering
Department
Post-Office
Box 14000
Juno
Bea'ch, Florida
33408-0420
C. ll. Wethy, Site Vice President
Turkey Point Nuclear
Plant
Post Office Box 029100
Miami, Florida
33102
C. J. Baker, Plant Manager
Turkey Point Nuclear Plant
Post Office Box 029100
Miami, Florida
33102
G.
E. Regal,
Corporate
Eg Coordinator
Florida Power
8 Light Co.
JNE,
JB,
Post Office Box 14000
Juno Beach, Florida
33408-0420
J.
K. Hays, Director of Nuclear
Licensing
Florida Power
8 Light Co.,
JNE,
JB,
Post Office Box 14000
Juno
Beach, Florida
33408-0420
R. Gouldy, Turkey Point Licensing
florida Power
5 Light Co.
JNE, JB,
Post Office Box 14000
Juno Beach, Florida
33408-0420
Harold F. Reis,
Esquire
Newman and Holtzinger, P.C.
1615
L Street,
N.W.
D.C.
. 20036
ter. Jack
Shreve
Office of the Public Counsel
Room 4, Holland Building
Tallahassee,
32304
1
0
Florida Power
and Light Company
3
July 21,
1987
cc:
(continued)
'Norman A. Coll, Esquire
Steel,
Hector and Davis
4000 Southeast
Financial
Center
Hiami, Florida
33131-2398
Hr.
C.
H. Wethy, Vice President
Turkey Point Nuclear Plant
Florida Power
and Light Company
Post Office Box 029100
Hiami, Florida
33102
Hr. H. R. Stierheim
County Hanager of Hetropolitan
Dade County
Hiami, Florida
33130
Resident
Inspector
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory
Commission
Turkey Point Nuclear Generating
Station
Post Office Box 57-1105
Hiami, Florida
33257-1185
Jacob
Daniel
Nash
Office of Radiation Control
Department of Health and
Rehabilitative
Services
1317 Winewood Boulevard
Tallahassee,
32399-0700
Intergovernmental
Coordination
and Review
Office of Planning
and Budget
Executive Office of the Governor
The Capitol Building
Tallahassee,
32301
Administrator
Department of Environmental
Regulation
Power Plant Siting Section
State of florida
2600 Blair Stone
Road
Tallahassee,
32301
Regional Administrator, Region II
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission
Suite
2900
101 Harietta Street
Atlanta, Georgia
30323
Hartin H. Hodder,
Esquire
1131
NE, 86th Street
Hiami, Florida
33138
Joette
Lorion
7269
SW, 54th Avenue
Hiami, Flor ida
33143
Hr. Chris J. Baker, Plant Hanager
Turkey Point Nuclear
Plant
Power
and Light Company
P.O.
Box 029100
Hiami, Florida
33102
Attorney General
Department of Legal Affairs
The Capitol Building
Tallahassee,
32304
0
Florida Power and Light Company
4-
July
211
l987
DISTRIBUTION:
':70H
OGC-Bethesda
ACRS( 10)
Docket Files (50-250,251)
DRIS Reading
PD22 Reading
VIB Reading
RStarostecki
JPartlow
BGrimes
UPotapovs
SAlexander
RWilson
HWalker,
SVarga
GLainas
EJordan
HWalker
DGHcDonald Jr
t~iYost,
INEL
WCarpenter,
INEL
JStoffel,
INEL
JSherman,
INEL
DBeahm,
INEL
tlJacobus,
SHL
JGrossman,
SHL
DKing, SNL
REGION II DISTRIBUTION'
son>>
AHerdt, C:EB,
TConlon,
C:PSS,
EB
ARuff, PSS,
EB
Ntlerriweather,
PSS,
EB
BWilson,
SC:PS2C,
RPB2,
~See previous
page for concurrences.
D. R. Brewer,
U.S.
NRC
Resident
Inspector
Turkey Point Nuclear
Generating Station
P. 0.
Box 57-1185
Niami, Florida
33257-1185
NAME :SAlexander*
0
DATE :7/16/87
- UPotapovs*
- 7/16/87
t
s hoff
- /IP/87:7/tq/87
7n
rtlow
/87
~
~
N
.
cDonald
gL u
DATE :7/+0/87
- 7/
enstein
- G
/87
- 7
as
/87
ga:
87
4
1
ll
I
t
II
r
l
II
N
rr
y ~ lf/f
E
0
Florida Power and Light Company
DISTRIBUTION:
OGC-Bethesda
ACRS(10)
Docket Files (50-250,251)
DRIS Reading
PD22 Reading
VIB Reading
RStarostecki
JPartlow
BGrimes
UPotapovs
SAlexander
RWilson
HWalker,
SVarga
GLainas
EJordan
HWalker
DGtlcDonald Jr
t'iYost,
INEL
WCarpenter,
IHEL
JStoffel,
INEL
JSherman,
IHEL
DBeahm,
INEL
llJacobus,
SHL
JGrossman,
SHL
DKing, SHL
July 2lI 1987
REGION II DISTRIBUTION:
1
SOll g
AHerdt, C:EB,
TConlon,
C:PSS,
EB
ARuff, PSS,
EB
NYierrIweather,
PSS,
EB
BWilson,
SC:PS2C,
RPB2,
- See previous
page for concurrences.
D. R. Brewer,
U.S.
HRC
Resident
Inspector
Turkey Point Nuclear
Generating Station
P.
0.
Box 57-1185
Miami, Florida
33257-1185
NNiE :SAlexander*
DATE:7/16/87
- UPotapovs*
- 7/16/87
I
s
off
rtlow
- /l7/87:7/tl/87:7A
/87
~
~
cDonald
aL u enstein
DATE :7/IP/87
- 7/ 0/87
as
7
/87
~
~
Q W
ga:
87
~
~
i
I.
APPENDIX A
Potenti a 1 Enforcement/Unreso
1 ved Items
As
a result of the equipment qualification inspection
performed during the
period of Harch 2-6,
1987 at the Florida Power
and Light Company's
(FPEL) Juno
Beach engineering offices and the Turkey Point nuclear Generating Station
(PTN),
the following items
have
been referred to the
NRC Region II office as Potential
Enforcement/Unresolved
Items.
(References
in parentheses
at the end of each
item cite the pertinent paragraphs
in the inspection report.)
1.
Contrary to paragraphs
(f) and (k) of 10 CFR 50.49 and sections
5.2.2
and
5.2.6 of the
DOR Guidelines,
FP&L could not show that field-run cables to
two Limitorque motorized valve actuators
(HOVs)
(Tag Nos.
HOV-3-880B and
hlOV-4-880B) were qualified in that they were not traceable
to qualified
cable
because
they had incorrect cable tag numbers
and
no other identify-
ing markings in the
HOV.
(paragraph
4.5. 1, Item 50-250,251/87-08-01)
2.
Contrary to paragraphs
(f) and (k) of 10 CFR 50.49
and sections
5.2.2 and
5.2.6 of the
DOR Guidelines,
Raychem splice insulation sleeves for
qualified solenoid-operated
valves
(SOVs)
(Tag Nos.
SOV-4-2914,
2916 and
2918) were not installed in a condition similar to that in which they were
tested
in that the splices for SOY-4-2914 and
2916 had insufficient over-
lap over wire insulation
and were installed over the
SOV pigtails'raided
jacket.
One splice for SOY-4-2918 was bent beyond minimum tested
bend
radius
and was also installed over
a braided pigtail jacket.
(paragraphs
4.2.1
and 4.5.2,
Item 50-251/87-08-02)
3.
Contrary to paragraphs
(f) and (k) of 10 CFR 50.49
and sections
5.2.2
and
-5.2.6 of the
DOR Guidelines,
Limitorque valve actuators
required to be
qualified at
PTN were not in an installed condition similar to that in
which they were tested after the
10 CFR 50.49 qualification deadline of
Harch 31,
1985 and until the units were shut
down before the Generic Letter
.85-15 deadline of November 30,
1987 in that
FPSL did not have assurance
that the Texaco Harfak grease
which had
been
added to actuator
main gear
cases
was tested with the actuators
or, if not, that it was qualified
separately.
(paragraph 4.2.3,
Item 50-250,251/87-08-03)
4.
Contrary to paragraphs
(f) and (k) of 10 CFR 50.49
and sections
5.2.2
and
5.2.6 of the
DOR Guidelines,
the qualification documentation
package for
3H Scotch 23/Scotch
70 tape insulation systems
in severe
temperature
and
humidity environment service did not establish similarity between tested
and installed splices.
(paragraph
4.4.2,
Item 50-250,251/87-08-04)
5.
Contrary to paragraph
( 1) of 10 CFR 50.49, the claimed qualification level
of the
3H Scotch 23/Scotch
70 tape splice insulation system authorized for
current use at
PTN was the
DOR Guidelines;
whereas,
FPSL did not have
assurance
that this type of splice could not be used
on equipment, required
to be qualified to
10 CFR 50.49 requirements.
(paragraph 4.2.3,
Item
50-250,251/87-08-05)
t
t%