ML17296B293

Summary of 810225 Meeting W/Bechtel & Util in Phoenix, Az Re Initial Design Review of Fire Protection Sys

ML17296B293
Person / Time
Site:	Palo Verde
Issue date:	03/06/1981
From:	Kerrigan J Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
To:	Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
NUDOCS 8103180002
Download: ML17296B293 (8)

Text

MAR 6

~98~

CE 1

'I I Docket Nos.:

STN 50-528/529/530 APPLICANT:

Arizona Public Service Company FACILITY:

Palo Verde, Units 1, 2, and 3

SUMMARY

OF INDEPENDENT DESIGN REVIEW (IDR) MEETING OF THE FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM An IDR meeting of the Fire Protection System was held on February 25, 1981 in Phoenix, Arizona.

A transcript of the meeting is scheduled to be available on March 11, 1981.

Representatives of Bechtel discussed the general design of the system followed by a presentation on the conformance of the design with regu-latory requirements.

Schedules and work plans for "future tasks" (control room fire evaluation, RCP lube oil system, train and channel separation study) were also presented.

The NRC partiCipants (after caucusing) informally recommended that a follow-up IDR board meeting be established to address the fire protec-'ion systems scheduled to be designed at a future date.

The NRC stated that it was our opinion that the "future tasks" included such a significant portion of the scope of NRC's review of the fire protection system that those "future tasks" would need to be fully addressed before an SER could be written.

The NRC observers also commented on the control room fire evaluation criteria being used by -Bechtel.

Janis Kerrigan, Project Manager Licensing Branch 83 Division of Licensing CC:

F.

Rosa P.

Check D.

Ross R. Ferguson V. Benaroya V. Noonan R. Vollmer R. Tedesco D. Eisenhut H.

LaGow H. Denton 8>03 Z80008 OFFICE/

SURNAME)

DATEP DL: LBA'3 DL:

~ ~ ~ I'Ill tOo ~ ~ ~

FM

'/g/81

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ olal ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

NRC FORM 318 110/80) NRCM 0240 OFFlCIAL RECORD COPY 6 USGPO: 198~29.824 '

~

~

tttQ~>>( I;<.".~II Q

p~f,'h g~)~R ~hyPAa m/

g~p 4 <<N>> ~

4 t '4 h

4 R t 4

4 Ry>>

~

1<<

ll 440 4

~

4

'I ~ 4' O'

4 1 ~

~ 4

' ll H

4 I

HQ 4.

)C

~

~ t

~ ~

~

Rl

=, ~

~ 4 44 I,*

4 It R

~ I 4

4 4

4 It4

~

~ \\

'4 '94,h 4'

~ 'I II

~

-3 t

4 ~

~,

I 4 44

~ t-4 4

~'

~ 4

~

4 I ltto f 4

4 4

4

~ 4 I

~ ~

4 "p '

4 it<<4 4 ~ CH 4

~

4 4 4

.I 4

4 4

t 4

CI <<

~ ht R

4 I

~

4

'I H

4 ah.,<<'.

I 4

I' 4

4" 4

<<I II <<<<4 I" Ctl I

4

~ 4 'I

~ 4 Rt

~

I 4

~

t,

~ 4

~ '

P

~

NIP.B 6

198>

NLL'TI i'IO Sliiil)RI?Y I) I STI? IBU'I'()l!

t)ucke t F i 1 I'IRC f'Dl?

Local PDR T I C/I'IS IC/Tera II!?R '?cadi ng LB/l 3 Readi n(J ll. I)ento>>

Case D.

I'.ise>>hu t P,. I'urp'Ie B.,).

Youngbl ood A. Sch:fencer F. Iliraglia J.

Nilier G. Lainas R. Vollmer J.

P. Knight R.

Bosnak F. Schauer R.

E. Jackson Project Itanager

'Attorney, GELD J.

Lee OIE,,(3)

ACRS (SO)

R. Tedesco Janis Kerrigan HRC Parti ci pants:

G. Harri'son 0.

Chopra',

bcc:

Applicant 8 Service List G.

V.

S.

V.

~Z.

1I.

D.

R.

H.

D.

P

~

I?.

0.

F.

H.

IJI ~

R.

T.

L.

T.

H.

J.

S.

H.

T.f'.

D.

II.

R.

C

~

K.

G.

A.

D.

J.

D.

P.

D.

Lear hoonan Palvl i ck I

~

I)0 >>a 1'oy a I?o~ztoczy lfaas s I'(1 1 or Bal 1 ard Regan f?oss Check Sat terfield Parr Rosa Butler Kreger ffouston fiurphy Rubenstein Speis Johnston S tol'z Ilanauor G-mimi 1 1 Hurley S(.f) r ve(lor Sk()vl)(ilt Fr>>>> t l)a er Be't'I ln(Jer Kll ') el tin'( (Jll I:0>>

Thadani Tondi Kramer Vassallo Col 1 ins Ziemann

1(,'

~C gI ~ ~~uuc fp0

+4*4+

UNITEDSTATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMIVIISSION WASHINGTON, O. C. 20S 5

MAR 6

1~81 Docket INos.:

STN 50-528/529/530 APPLICANT:

Arizona Public Service Company FACILITY:

Palo Verde, Units 1, 2, and 3

SUMMARY

OF INDEPENDENT DESIGN REVIEW (IDR) MEETING OF THE FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM An IDR meeting of the Fire Protection System was held on February 25, 1981 in Phoenix, Arizona.

A transcript of the meeting is scheduled to be avai.lable on March 11, 1981.

Representatives of Sechtel discussed the general design of the system followed by a presentation on the conformance of the design with regu-latory requirements.

Schedules and work plans for "future tasks" (control room fire evaluation, RCP lube oil system, train and channel separation study) were also presented.

The NRC participants (after caucusing) informally recoIIImended that a fo1low-up IDR board meeting be established to address the fire protec-tion systems scheduled to be designed at a future date.

The NRC stated that it was our opinion that the "future tasks" included such -a significant portion of the scope of NRC's review of the fire protection system that those "future tasks" would need to be fully addressed before an SER could be written.

The NRC observers also commented on the control room fire evaluation criteria being used by Bechtel.

gl

. Janis Kerrigan, Project'anager Licensing Branch f3=

Division of Licensing

r

'jij

MAR 8 I98I,-

Nr.

E-. E.

Van Brunt, Jr.

Vice President - Construction Projects Arizona Public Service Company P. 0. Box 21666

Phoenix, Arizona 85036 CC:

Arthur C. Gehr, Esq.

Snell

& Wilmer 3100 Valley Center

Phoenix, Arizona 85073 Charles S. Pierson Assistant Attorney General 200 State Capitol 1700 West Washington Phoenix, Arizona 85007 David N. Barry, Esq.,

Senior Counsel Charles R. Kocher, Esq., Assistant Counsel Southern California Edison Company P. 0.

Box 800

Rosemead, California 91770 Or. Stanley L. Dolins Assistant Director Energy Programs (OEPAD)

Office of the Governor 1700 Hest Washington Executive Tower - Room 507

Phoenix, Arizona 85007 William Prinm Assistant Attorney General Bataan Memorial Building Santa Fe, New Mexico 87503 Resident inspector Palo Verde/NPS U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission c/o TTL/LGX Luke Air Force Base, Arizona 85309 lls. Patricia Lee Hou'rihan 6413 S. 26th Street Phoenix, Arizona 85040

tgR18 55 I