ML17054B847
| ML17054B847 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Nine Mile Point  |
| Issue date: | 08/22/1985 |
| From: | Haughey M Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8509030035 | |
| Download: ML17054B847 (34) | |
Text
I 8 REGy
+4 0
P Cy 0
C 0
t UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION WASHINGTON, D. C. 20555
++*++
AUG 2 2 1985 Docket No. 50-410 APPLICANT:
Niagara Mohawk Power Corporation (NMPC)
FACILITY:
Nine Mile Point Nuclear Station, Unit 2 (NMP-2)
SUBJECT
SUMMARY
OF MEETING WITH NMPC CONCERNING THE LICENSING STATUS OF NINE MILE POINT 2
AND NMPC ORGANIZATIONAL CHANGES On August 7, 1985, the NRC staff met with representatives from Niagara Mohawk in Bethesda, Maryland to discuss the licensing status of Nine Mile Point 2 and organizational changes in the Niagara Mohawk NMP-2 staff.
Enclosure 1
contains the agenda and information provided by Niagara Mohawk during that meeting.
Mr. C. V. Mangan has assumed the position of Senior Vice President.
Additional changes in the Niagara Mohawk NMP-2 organization as indicated in Enclosure 1 will occur following fuel load and represent the transition from MAC to Niagara Mohawk in the NMP-2 organization.
Work on the NMP-2 technical specifications (tech specs) is ongoing.
The first draft tech specs have been issued.
Niagara Mohawk intends to pursue the 24 month surveillance schedule following fuel load.
Niagara Mohawk's SCRAM reduction program for NMP-2 may necessitate deviations from the standard tech specs which will need to be discussed with the NRC staff reviewers on instru-mentation and control.
Niagara Mohawk also discussed section 6 of the tech specs on administrative controls.
Niagara Mohawk would like this section of the tech specs to be consistent with NMP-1 tech specs.
Consistency with NMP-1 tech specs in this area however, would necessitate deviations from the standard tech specs.
Niagara Mohawk has recently submitted additional information on the issue of secondary containment bypass leakage.
Conflicting vacation schedules have prohibited comunication between the NRC staff reviewer and the SWEC engineers.
Therefore any concerns with this submittal have not yet been identified.
Niagara Mohawk has requested NRC approval of the use of the Visual Weld Acceptance Criteria for Structural Welding at Nuclear Power Plants (VWAC)
Revision 2 submitted by the Nuclear Construction Issues Group.
Niagara Mohawk was requested to submit FSAR changes by letter to allow the NRC staff to review this issue for NMP-2 specifically.
Revisions to FSAR Chapter 14 were sent out from Niagara Mohawk on August 6, 1985 and should be received shortly.
8509030035 850822i pDR
~noc~c, 050op~R A
l
The NRC staff has denied Niagara Mohawk's exemption request concernino Type C testing of the.TIP ball valves.
Niagara'ohawk stated they would be submittir g a second exemption request concerning reverse flow testing of the TIP ball valves.
The NRC staff stated an exemption may not be needed if Niagara Mohawk could show the reverse flow testing was at least as conservative as the normal flow testing.
Niagara Mohawk stated future submittals of FSAR amendments would contain a
key to help identify the basis for the FSAR change.
The key would be broken down as follows 1) 2 3
Changes made in response to NRC requests.
Correction of errors, inconsistences, etc.
Niagara Mohawk initiated changes a)
Non-Safety Related b)
Safety Related i) affect SER ii) do not affect SER Niagara Mohawk plans to submit final as-built drawings in January.
Niagara-Mohawk presently has in place a verification program to help catch errors and inconsistencies and correct them early rather than making major changes to the FSAR shortly before licensing.
Niagara Mohawk offered to make a presentation on the verification program at a future meeting.
During the meeting Gr. Butler recommended Niagara Mohawk submit exemption requests as early as possible in order to allow time to facilitate environ-mental assessments.
The following NRC reorganization was discussed.
Niagara Mohawk expressed concern that the forthcoming reorganization could affect the progress of the licensing review for NMP-2.
Niagara Mohawk was assured that the NRC staff would make every effort to minimize any negative effects of the reorganization on the licensing process.
The NRC staff expressed concern about the progress of the preservice and inservice inspection programs (PSI/ISI) and the inservice testing program
( IST) for NMP-2.
Following the meeting representatives of Niagara Mohawk met with the NRC staff to discuss what was needed for the IST program.
A meeting on the PSI/ISI program was held on August 5, 1985.
Also following the meeting representatives met with NRC review staff in the area of instrumentation and control.
The recent submittal on the RCIC seal-in was d'iscussed.
t
In addit'.on, the location in the FSAR of responses to SER confirmatory 1ssuts in the area of instrumentation and control was discussed.
Enclosure 2 contains a list of meeting attendees.
Enclosures:
As stated Nary F.
Haug e
, Project Hanager Licensing Branch l<o.
E Division of Licensing cc:
See next, page
Hr. B. G. Hooten Niagara Mohawk Power Corporation ine tii le Point Nuclear Sta1ion Unit 2 CC-hr. Troy B. Conner, Jr.,
Esq.
Conner 8 Wetterhahn Suite 1050 1747 Pernsylvania
- Avenue, N.W.
Washington, D.C.
20006 Richard Goldsmi'th Syracuse University College of Law E. I. White Hall Campus
- Syracuse, New York 12223 Ezra I.
Oialil'ssistant Attorney General Envirormental Protection Bureau New York State Department of Law 2 World Trade Center l(ev,'ork, IIew York 10047 Resident Inspector Nine Ilile Point Nuclear Power Station P. 0.
Box 99
- Lycoming, New York 13093 l'ir. John W. Keib, Esq.
Niagara Mohawk Power Corporal.ion 300 Erie Boulevard West
- Syracuse, New York 13202 Iir. James Linville U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Region I
631 Park Avenue King of Prussia, Pennsylvania 19406 Norman Rademacher, Licensing Niagara I<ohawk Power Corporation 300 Erie Boulevard West
- Syracuse, New York 13202 Regional Administrator, Region I U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 631 Park Avenue King of Prussia, Pennsylvania 19406
1
~
AGEND-A 1.
ORGANIZATION ki i Q4 i<R ~'ECHNICAL SPECIFICATION STATUS k
SECONDARY CONTAINMENT"BYPASS" LEAKAGE
'4.
VISUAL WELD ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA CHAPTER 14 - STARTUP TEST 6.
7.
RESUBHI TTAL OF TIP BALL VALVES:
i.
NRC ORGANIZATION IMPACT
'I i ~
Ji ll',
J J
For Augus't'7, 1985.NRC'.Meeti'n'g'.
h in'ethesda'aryland J
1 JJ l
~
E
~ i
ORGANIZATIONAND STAFFING Nine -Mile Point Nuclear Generation Site Organization GENERAL SUPT.
,T. PERKINS (SRO)
NMP 1
- STA. SUPT.
T. ROMAN SITE CHEM/RAD SUPT.
E. LEACH SITE MAINT.SUPT.
K. DAHLBERG NMP2 STA. SUPT.
R. ABBOTT (SRO) 0 I
SITE TECH. SUPT.
W. OREWS (SRO)
SITE TRG. SUPT.
R. ZOLLITSCH (SRO) 7 NIAGAPA 0 MOHAWK
VICE PRESIDENT NUCLEAR ENGINEERING AND LICENSING EXECUTIVE SECRETARY ASSISTANT TO V.P.
MANAGER NUCLEAR TECHNOLOGY MANAGER COMPLIANCE AND VERIFICATION MANAGER NUCLEAR STAFF MANAGER NUCLEAR E
IN NG MANAGER MGR.
MGR.
FUELS 5 PLANT CONSULT.
LICENSING PRODUCTIVITY CORPORATE HEALTH PHYSICIST M R.
MGR.
MGR.
ADM IN.
'DIRECTOR COST 'ECORDS SERVICES TRAINING MGR.
MGR.
MGR.
DESIGN DESIGN PROJS.
UNIT 1 UNIT 2
MANAGER COMPLIANCE 8 VERIFICATION e
o)
LEAD ENGINEER SITE LEAD ENGINEER ENGINEERING AUDITS c eer LEAD ENGINEER CORPORATE rause ENGINEERS ENGINEERS ENGINEERS
MANAGER-NUCLEAR TECHNOLOGY
~
1 cze
)
MANAGER CONSULTING k)
CORPORATE HEALTH PHYSICIST arpea)
MANAGER LICENSING g~'aaTnick)*
~ A
~a MANAGER FUELS 4 PLANT PRODUCTIVITY LEAD ENGINEER LEAD ENGINEER NUCLEAR SUPPORT CONCEPTUAL PROGRAMS ASSESSMENT enson LEAD LEAD ENGR.
LEAD LEAD ENGR.
LEAD ENGR.
ENGINEER SAFETY ENGINEER NUCLEAR SAFETY PLANT LICENSING EVALUATION FUEL ANALYSIS PRODUCTIVITY W1l~fl 1 ki )
ENGINEERS ENGINEERS HEALTH PHYSIC ISTS ENGINEERS ENGINEERS ENGINEERS ENGINEERS ENGINEERS
%nit 2 Staff 6/24/85
MANAGER NUCLEAR STAFF SERVICES MANAGER COST Pf.
Goya) )*
MANAGER ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES TRAINING DIRECTOR MANAGER RECORDS LEAD LEAD LEAD ENGR.
ENGR.
ENGR.
BUDGETS 8)
COST ASSUR.
ESTIMATES COST CONT.
LEAD LEAD ENGR.
ENGR.
OFF ICE PROCED./
ADMIN.
ADMIN.
REPORTS PLANNING
(~fiies)
LEAD ENGR.
INFORMATION SERVICES SUPERVISOR RECORDS MANAGEMENT oyner ASST..
OFFICE ADMIN.
(Layer)
ENGINEERS ENGINEERS ENGINEERS CLERKS
'ENGINEERS ENGINEERS ENGINEERS ENGINEERS ENGINEER CLERKS
+ Un)t 2 Staff 6/24/8S
MANAGER NUCLEAR ENGINEERING (C.
D. Terry)*
MANAGER PROJECTS 1*
MANAGER DESIGN UNIT 1 k)
~ <f a'ANAGER DESIGN UNIT 2 d)*
PROJECT LEAD ENGR.
LEAD ENGR.
LEAD ENGR.
LEAD ENGR.
LEAD ENGR.
LEAD ENGR.
LEAD ENGR.
LEAD ENGR.
LEAD ENGR.
LEAD ENGR.
MGR. (S)
CONCEPTUAL SCHEDULE MECHANICAL C/S ELECTRICAL MODS.
MECHANICAL C/S ELECTRICAL MODS.
IAAF A.
g ~~ L~til. ~ ~y~~ 1
~y NEEDED)
ENGRS.
ENGRS.
ENGRS.
ENGRS.
ENGRS.
DES B/C DES B/C DES B/C OTHER OTHER OTHER ENGRS.
ENGRS.
ENGRS.
ENGRS DES B/C DES B/C DES B/C OTHER OTHER OTHER ENGRS.
- Unit 2 Staff 6/24/85
~
~
TECHNICAL SPECIFICATION STATUS 1.
Hajor meeting is ongoing 2.
Everything has been reviewed at least once Issues outstanding include such things as 24 month surveillance schedule SCRAM reduction program Section 6 administrative controls
SECONDARY CONTAINMENT BYPASS LEAKAGE 1.
NMPC has submitted (7/26/85) analysis 2.
Status of NRC resolution'P YISUAL HELD ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA I.
NMPC has submitted (7/26/85) our position 2.
NMPC will follow generically approved program 3.
Need NRC letter saying that it is acceptable
~
~
STARTUP TESTING PROGRAM CHAPTER 14 l.
NHPC submitted program 8/06/85 2.
Mould like meeting to resolve differences RESUBHITTAL OF TRAVERSING IN-CORE PROBE BALL VALVES 1.
NHPC will resubmit an alternate exemption request to Type C Test in reverse direction
7 HlAGAPA U MOHAWK NIAGARA MOHAWK POWER CORPORATION/300 ERIE BOULEVARDWEST SYRACUSE N Y 13202/TELEPHONE (315) 474-1511 Hr. Walter Butler, Chief Licensing Branch No.
2'.S.
Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555
Dear Hr. Butler:
Re:
Nine Nile Point Unit 2 Docket No. 50-410 Enclosed is our proposed revision to Chapter 14 of the FSAR.
We have had several informal telephone conversations with your staff concerning the scope of the revision.
We anticipate incorporating this material in the FSAR in a future amendment,
- however, we request a meeting with your staff in the next 30 days.
We expect that all outstanding questi'ons can be resolved during this
- meeting, which will facilitate an expeditious review by your staff and keep the Unit 2 testing program on schedule.
In order to assist your review we have provided a complete version of Chapter 14 except for those Tables which have been deleted.
The deleted Tables are:
14.2-2 thru 14.2-24, 14.2-26, 35, 37, 45, 66, 67, 70, 83, 84, 85, 87, "88, 89, 90, 91, 92, 93, 94, 96, 97, 98, 99,
- 111, 124,
- 127, 130, 205, 222, 229,
- 301, 401 and 402.
Also included in this package are draft revised responses to guestions 640.06, 640.08, 640.11, 640.13, 640.19, 640.22, 640.34, 640.34-2, and 640.35.
In addition we have included the appropriate revised pages of Table 1.8-1.
During our previous discussions, your staff raised some concerns regarding the adequacy of some of our proposed test'acceptance criteria.
We believe that we understand your concerns and we are working on revising these areas.
We will be prepared to present and discuss
.our proposed acceptance criteria during the review meeting with your staff.
Very truly yours, C. V. Hang Senior: Vice President GW/rla Enclosures xc:
R. A. Gramm, NRC Resident Inspector Project File (2)
I
Enclosure 2
Yieeting with Niagara Mohawk on Nine Mile Point 2
August 7, 1985 Name W. Butler M. Haughey C. V. Mangan A. Zallnick N. Rademacher P. Francisco D. Hill E.
Adensam IST meetin onl
- 0. Rothberg J.
Page Or anization NRC, Licensing Branch Chief NRC, Licensing Project Manager NMPC, Senior Vice President NMPC, Licensing Manager NYiPC, Licensing NMPC, Licensing NNPC, Licesning NRC, Licensing Branch Chief NRC NRC Instrumentation and Control Meetin onl R. Kendall M. Yost K. Desai M.
W. Hodges NRC EG8G, Idaho, Inc.
NRC NRC
In addition, the location in the FSAR of responses to SER confirmatory issues in the area of instrumentation and control was discussed.
Enclosure 2 contains a list of meeting attendees.
Enclosures:
As stated cc:
See next page 0&pioal sKgaed bye Mary F. Haughey, Project Manager Licensing Branch No.
2 Division of Licensing DISTRIBUTION
~ Docket Fi~le NRC PDR Local PDR PRC System NSIC LBk'2 Reading Bordenick, OELD WButler MHaughey EHylton LBP2/DL PM MHaughey:lb 08/g5/85 LBP2/DL/BC WButler 08/(IQ/85
I I'