ML17037B843
| ML17037B843 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Nine Mile Point, Susquehanna, Columbia, Limerick, LaSalle, Zimmer, Shoreham, Bailly File:Long Island Lighting Company icon.png |
| Issue date: | 07/27/1976 |
| From: | Miner S Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| Download: ML17037B843 (22) | |
Text
p,S I
I 0
+p
/
REPp i>>
~o 0OIt
~O
- <<+
Docket Nos:
Applicants:
UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION WASHINGTON, D. C. 20666 JuL P'(
l976 50-322, 50-352 II 50-353, 50-358
50- 67, 50-373 50 374 p 50 387 8E 50 388'0 397 4 I 0 Long Island Lighting Co., Philadelphia Electric, Cincinnati Gas and Electric Co., Northern Indiana Public Service Co.,
Commonwealth Edison, Pennsylvania Power and Light Co., Washington Public Power Supply System and Niagara Mohawk Power Corporation Facll,ities:
Shoreham Nuclear. Power.- Station Unit No. I, Limerick, Generating Station Units No;,I'and No. 2; William H.
Zimmer Nuclear Power Station, Unit I, Bailly Generating
, Station Nuclear No. I,'aSalle County Station Units No.
I and No. 2, Susquehanna Steam Electric Station Units No.
I and No. 2, WPPSS Nuclear Project No. 2, Nine Mlle Point Nuclear Station,Unit No.
2
SUMMARY
OF MEETING HELD ON MAY 20,
- 1976, INCLUDING FOLLOW-UP ACTIONS WITH MARK II OWNERS REPRESENTATIVES A meeting was held on May 20, 1976 between representatives of the Mark II owners, the General Electric Company and the staff to discuss and agree on methods for making the "Mark II Containment Dynamic Forcing Function" report (DFFR)
NEDO 21061 and NEDE 2106IP more generic and specific so that the documents could be reviewed to a much greater ex-tent on a generic basis, applicable to all Mark II contalnments.
The attendees list is enclosed (enclosure I).
The representatives of the Mark II owners group stated that it was their intention that the DFFR should provide a generic method of analysis and generic loads subject to unique plant configuration, that ail owners would use.
The report was then discussed ln detail to assure complete understanding of what was included in the report and to establish where revisions to the reports would be required to address staff concerns.
The Mark II owners representatives agreed to revise the report to in-clude information discussed during the detail review.
To assure there was complete agreement and understanding on what was to be inclu-ded in the revision, Brent Shelton, the chairman of the Mark II owners group, agreed to provide the staff in about a week, a summary of the meeting, the items to be included in the revised DFFR and the date when the revised document wil I be submitted.
On May 24, 1976 the applicant's meeting summary was provided (enclosure 2).
The staff reviewed the applicant's meeting summary and on June 22, 1976 provided Mr. trent Shelton, the chairman of the owners group the following clarifying Information:
t I
~
'E I
1 c
JUL 8 7 ]976 The updated DFFR shoul d include:
I.
The rationale for the location and number of therrnocouples used to measure high temperature steam condensatlon loads.
This will represent the minimum Instrumentatlon requirements within,the pool.
2.
A determination as to whether the main steam line or recirculation line break is more severe for both BWR-4 and 5 reactor designs.
3.
The following information on combining lateral loads on multiple downcomers:
a.
All downcomer combinations presented ln the DFFR will be evaluated by each plant;
- and, b.
The statistical approach used for determining multiple down-comer loads if less than a maximum load of 8.0 KIPS is used.
4.
A reference within the,DFFR to all applicable German data as presented within NEDE 2'I078P and NEDO 2I078.
5.
Appropriate input selections specified for all analytical models presented within the report.
Examples of the input selections will include selection of the vent-flow factor and velocity factor used within the slug pool swell model.
These load criteria will also include specifications of the required relief valve combinations.
6.
The basis upon which the pool swell velocity is determined.
Specifically, the value of vent area to pool area ratio will be given as well as the basis for selection.
7.
The analytical quencher model used for development of relief valve loads revised to reflect the most current model'.
In addition, the confidencb level will be presented along with the basis of selection.
8.
A revised discussion concerning the ramshead relief valve loads and reference made to the applicable GE topical reports to reflect the most current analytical model available.
~
U 1h
J'ljL 3Y 1976 After reviewing the above information, Brent'Shelton, on June 29, l976 agreed that the clarifying Information was consistant with:his'meeting sumnary and. wil.l be provided ln the revised DFFR.
The r'evised'DFFR will be.submitted on September I, l976.
C Other topics discussed during the meeting were as follows:
I.
4T test report will be submitted about June I, l976 (recetved June 9,
l976)
Y 2.
The staff will have the opportunity of reviewing and, if necessary, requeqtlng additional information on the EPRI test reports.
However, the Mark II owners feel that the EPRI test will not be an important item fn the overall Mark II containment program.
Sydney Min r, Project Manager Light Water Reactors Branch No.
3 Division of Project 'Management
Enclosure:
List of Attendees
~ II q,
'eiL',l
<,c:
(.ommonwua 1 th Edi son Cooip~ny ATTN:
Mr'. By'ron Lee, Jr.
Vice President P. 0.
Box 767 Chicago, Illinois 60690 Richard E. Powell, Esq.
Isham, Lincoln & Beale One First National Plaza, Suite 2400 Chicago, Illinois 60670 Pehnsylvania'Power hand Light company ATTN: 'r.
Norman W. Curtis Vice President
- Engineering and Construction 2 North Ninth Street Allentown, Pennsylvania 18101 Mr. Earle M. Mead Project Manager Pennsylvania Power
& Light Company 2 North Ninth Street Allentown, Pennsylvania 18101 Gerald Charnoff, Esquire Shaw, Pittman, Potts, Trowbridge
& Madden Barr Building 910 17th Street, N.W..
Washington, D.
C.
20006 Mr. William E; Barberich Licensing Engineer Pennsylvania Power
& Light Company 2 North Ninth Street'llentown, Pennsylvania 18101 Northern Indi ana Publ i c Servi ce Company ATTN:
Mr. H.
P. Lyle, Vice President Electric Production
& Engineering 5265 Hohman Avenue
- Hammond, Indiana 46325 Meredith Hemphill, Jr,,
Esq.
Assistant General Counsel Bethlehem Steel Corporation Martin Tower Bethlehem, Pennsylvania 18016 Wi 1 1 i am *H. Ei chhorn, Esq.
- Schroer, Eichhorn
& Morrow 5243 Hohman Avenue
- Hammond, Indiana 46230 Mr. Edward W. Osann,
'Jr.'olfe, Hubbard, Leydid, Voit &
- Osann, Ltd.
Suite 4600 One IBM Plaza Chicago, Illinois 60611 Marvin N. Berm, Esq; Special Assistant Attorney General 134 North LaSalle Street Suite 2222 Chicago, Illinois '60602 Robert J. Vollen, Esq.
109 North Dearborn Street Chicago, Illinois 60602 Philadelphia Electric Company ATTN:
Edward G. Bauer, Jr.
Vice President
& General Counsel'301 Market Street Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19101 Troy B. Conner, Jr.,
Esq.
Conner
& Knotts 1747 Pennsylvania
- Avenue, N.
WE Washington, D. C.
20006 W. William Anderson, Esq.
Deputy Attorney General Room 512, Main Capitol Bldg.
'Harrisburg, Pennsyl vani a 17120 Frank R.
Cl okey, Esq.
Special Assistant Attorney General Room 219, Towne House Apartments P'. 0.
Box 2063 Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17105 Honorable Lawrence Coughlin House of Representatives Congress of the United States Washington, D. C.
20515
0 A
~ w P
'I
~
4r'
JUL RV 1976 cc:
Roger B. Reynolds, Jr.,
Esq.
Cont.
324 Swede Street Norristown, Pennsylvania 19401 Willard C. Hetzel, Esq.
312 Main Street East Greenvi lie, Pa.
18041 Lawrence Sager, Esq.
Sager
& Sager Associates 45 High Street Pottstown, Pennsylvania 19464 Mr. Joseph A.
Smyth Assistant County Solicitor County of Montgomery Courthouse Norristown, Pennsylvania 19404 Mr. Eugene J. Bradley Philadelphia Electric Company Associate General Counsel 2301 Market Street Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19101 Washington Public Power Supply System ATTN:
Mr. J. J. Stein Managing Director 301 Fifth Avenue P. 0.
Box 968
- Richland, Washington 99352 Richard g. guigley, Esq.
Washington Public Power Supply System P.
0.
Box 968
- Richland, Washington 99352 The Cincinnati Gas and Electric Company ATTN:
Mr. Earl A. Borgmann Vice President
- Engineering P.
0.
Box 960 Cincinnati, Ohio 45201 Mr. Wil,liam J.
Moran General Counsel The Cincinnati Gas
& Electric Company P. 0.
Box 960 Cincinnati, Ohio 45201 Mr,. William G. Porter, Jr.
Porter, Stanley, Arthur and P 1 att 37 West Broad Street
- Columbus, Ohio 43215 Mr. Robert Killen, Chairman of the Board and Chief Executive Officer The Dayton Power and Light Company P. 0.
Box 1034 Dayton, Ohio 45401 J.
Robert Newlin, Counsel The Dayton Power
& Light Company P. 0.
Box 1034 Dayton; Ohio 45401 Mr. James D. Flynn, Manager Licensing and Environmental Affairs The Cincinnati Gas
& Electric Company P. 0.
Box 960 Cincinnati, Ohio 45201 Mr. J.
P.
Fenstermaker Senior Vice President
- Operations Columbus and Southern Ohio Electric Company 215 North Front Street
- Columbus, Ohio 43215 Mr. David B. Fankhauser.,
PhD
~ 3569 gine Mife Road Cincinnati, Ohio 45230 Ms. Mari B. Snell 5284 Edmonson Road, Apt. 903 Nashville, Tennessee 37211 Stephen T. Sonneville, Chairman Greater Cincinnati Citizens Solid Waste Project 6628 Afton Avenue Cincinnati, Ohio 45213 Thomas A. Luebbers, Esq.
Cincinnati City Solicitor Room 214, City Hall Cincinnati, Ohio 45202 Mr.. Stephen Schumacher Miami Valley Power Project P. 0.
Box 252 Dayton, Ohio 45401
If I
~
JUL 27 1976 cc:
Timothy S.
Hogan, Jr.,
Chairman Cont.
Board of Clermont County Commissioners 50 Market Street Clermont County Courthouse
- Batavia, Ohio 45103 1
Niagara Mohawk Power Corporation ATTN:
Mr. Gerald K.
Rhode Vice President
- Engineering 300 Erie Boulevard West
- Syracuse, New York 13202 Arvin E. Upton, Esquire
- LeBoeuf, Lamb, Leiby 5 MacRae 1757 N Street, N.
W.
Washington, D.
C.
20036 Mr. Richard Goldsmith Syracuse University College of Law E. I. White Hall Campus
- Syracuse, New York 13210 Dr. William E.
Seymour Staff Coordinator New York State Atomic Energy Council New York State Department of Commerce 99 Washington Street
- Albany, New York 12210 Anthony 2.
- Roisman, Esquire Berlin, Roisman 5 Kessler 1712 N Street N.
W.
Washington, D.
C.
20036 Long Island Lighting Company ATTN:
Mr. Andrew W. Wofford Vice President 175 East Old Country Road Hicksville, New York 18101 Edward M. Barrett, Esq.
General Counsel Long Island Lighting Company 250 Old Country Road
- Mineola, New York 11501 Edward J.
- Walsh, Esq.
General Attorney Long Island Lighting Company 250 Old Country Road
- Mineola, New York 11501 Mr. Thomas Burke Project Manager Shoreham Nuclear Power Station P. 0.
Box 618 Wading River, New York 11792 Dr. William E.
Seymour Staff Coordinator New York State Atomic Energy Council New York State Department of Coranerce 99 Washington Street
- Albany, New York 12210
Enclosure 1
ATTENDEES MARK II CONTAINMENT MEETING -
MAY 20, 1976 NRC/LWR-3 NRC NRC NRC NRC GE GE GE S&L, CECo CECo S. Miner J. Kudrick T; Su,,
C. Anderson G. Lainas D. Ditmore A. Smith F. Frauenholz R. Crawford B. Shelton D. Galle
h
Enclosure 2
May 24, 1976
Subject:
'5-20-76 Meeting with NRC
Purpose:
To discuss making the Mark II DFFR more generic and specific.
Attendance:
Sydney Miner, NRC Fritz Frauenholz, GE Ray Crawford, SkL Brent Shelton, CECo Dana C. Ditmare,GE helen Smith, GE Denny Galle,'ECo J.A. Kudrick, NRC T.M. Su, NRC C.J.
- Anderson, NRC Summary:
- 1. It was agreed that the DFFR could be made more generic and. specific, and in general all owners wanted a generic approach to the DFFR. It was pointed out by the owners that there may be some plant unique conditions that would require a deviation from the DFFR.
Such deviations would not be done frivolously.
2.
At the meeting it appeared that a generic load basis could be developed for all items except the lateral loads on multiple downcomers due to geometry consid-erations of the bracing systems.'e agreed to give further thought to this item.
It was also not obvious how the ramshead and Quencher load basis could be made more generic but we agreed to further review these items.
A meeting may be required to discuss the following:
a)
Ramshead load criteria.
b)
New Quencher model.
c)
Common confidence level for Mark II Quencher.
d)
Mark II vs Mark III Quencher confidence"levels.
4.
DAR~s should make any deviations from the DFFR explicit.
I T
5.
DFFR questions will go to all owners for generic response back through GE.
All owners will reference the response on their dockets.
DAR questions will go to the individual Utilitywith a copy to B. R. Shelton.
6.
The NRC stated that an in-plant quencher test will be.
required.
If Caorso becomes unavialable for any reason a new test bed will have to be found.
D~PI"R U d t The Nark II owners an'd GE will86'&.iver the foll'owing in an update to the DFFR.
1-.
Criteria for number and location of thermocouples used to measure high temperature steam condensation phenomena.
2.
Clarify whether the main steam or recirc line break is more severe for the B3'K 4's and 5's.
If possible include a criteria for combining lateral loads on multiple downcomers.
4.
Reference the German data, NEDE and NEDO 21078.
5.
Remove the options for various load criteria.
6.
Clarify whether avg or worst case Uent area/pool area is used to determine pool swell velocity.
7.
Add revised quencher model and confidmce limits.
- 8. Revise the Ramshead section discussion and reference the GE topical NEDO as much as possible.
9.
Include a document roadmap and summary as follows:
a)'olumn 1 -- List and description of loads.
b) column 2 Numerical load value or criteria summary.
'c) column 3 --Load basis, whether analytical or test and reference.
Include an example in the body of DFFR if no load value can be given in summary table.
d) column 4 -- Any future confirming test or models.
I rl I
F l
P'
10.
B. R. Shelton was 'r'equested to advise, S. Minor of a schedule for the above by May 28th.
B. R. Shelton Chairman BRS/kak cc: Sydney Minor NOTE:
k With respect to item 10:
All owners concurred to the DFFR update described, herein.
The schedule for completion of the update and filing with the NRC is no later than 9-1-76.
g g~~g
r
~
~
"j I,
~
MEETING
SUMMARY
DISTRIBUTION Oocket File NRC PDR Local POR TIC ACRS (16)
IE (3)
OELD NRR Reading LWR-3 File B.
Rusche E.
Case R.
Boyd R.
DeYoung D. Skovholt J. Stol z K ~
Kniel
- 0. Parr D. Vassallo R. Clark T. Speis P. Collins C.
Heltemes R.
Houston S.
Varga J. Miller F. Williams R.
Heineman H. Oenton D. Muller W. Butler D.
R.
J.
S.
P.
T.
z.
V.
G.
T.
V.
Ross Tedesco Knight Pawlicki Sihweil Check Novak Rosztoczy Benaroya Lainas Ippolito Moore R." Vol 1 mer M. Ernst W.
Gammil 1 G.
B,.
D.
Knighton Youngblood Regan Bunch J:,Collins W;
'Kreger'.
Balla'rd M. Spangler
, J.
Stepp
'.. Hulman H. Smith M. Rushbrook (3)
Project Manager NRC Participants
",)
I
'e
(
I