ML16162A511
| ML16162A511 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Oconee  |
| Issue date: | 01/09/1984 |
| From: | Suermann J Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8401200010 | |
| Download: ML16162A511 (29) | |
Text
January 9, 1984 Dockets Nos. 5b-269, 50-270 and 50-287 LICENSEE: Duke Power Company (DPC)
FACILITY: Oconee Nuclear Station, Units Nos. 1, 2 and 3
SUBJECT:
SUMMARY
OF MEETING HELD ON SEPTEMBER 6, 1983 WITH DPC TO DISCUSS EXEMPTION REQUEST FOR SITING OF THE OCONEE EOF The meeting was held to allow DPC the opportunity to present its arguments to the NRC staff in support of a request for siting relief of the Oconee Emergency Operations Facility (EOF).
The attendees list and a a copy of the meeting agenda utilized are enclosed.
DISCUSSION Using the enclosed agenda as an outline, representatives of Duke Power Company presented their arguments in support of their June 3, 1983 request to be exempted from the location requirements of the EOF for Oconee Nuclear Station. In lieu of the requirement to locate the EOF between 10 and 20 miles from the station, DPC proposes to locate the EOF for Oconee at the General Office of DPC in Charlotte, North Carolina (some 125 air miles from the station). DPC would continue to locate the Joint News Center at the Oconee site.
DPC's main argument was that both communications and State/local interfaces would be conducted more effectively out of the proposed Charlotte location than out of a site which may be geographically closer to the site but is severely hampered in its communications and sheltering capabilities (due to existing commercial reasons over which DPC has no control).
The State of South Carolina Emergency Preparedness representatives in attendance were not opposed to DPC's proposed exemption and saw no problem with DPC's proposal provided the planned expanded communications system would work as designed and would not be less effective than present communication capabilities with the State are. The State Department of Health and Environmental Control representative indicated that the EOF location was immaterial so long as the necessary information is transmitted to the department for it to fulfill its role.
8401200010 840109 PDR ADOCK 05000269 F
-2 The NRC staff noted with interest the very thorough presentation made by the DPC staff and felt the exchange of information among all parties present increased the understanding of exactly what the exemption entails and why DPC feels the Charlotte location is preferred. The NRC staff informed DPC that although the staff would be preparing a position on the merits of the request the final decision on the DPC request would be the subject of a vote by the Commissioners.
The NRC staff expects to have the draft Commission paper prepared in January 1984. DPC requested to be informed as to the staff's position on their request and also to make a presentation to the Commissioners before the request is voted on. The project manager anticipates being able to provide a summary of the staff's position (the Commission paper itself may not be released) to DPC when the paper is final and will also advise DPC of the time frame in which the Commission expects to vote so that DPC may formally request permission from the Commission to make a presentation on their behalf. The DPC representatives were advised, however, that to date similar requests to meet with the Commissioners by other licensees have been denied and that an exemption request closely paralleling the Oconee request (namely, one for the Point Beach site) has also been denied.
John F. Suermann, Project Manager Operating Reactors Branch No. 4 Division of Licensing
Enclosures:
As stated cc w/enclosures:
See next page ORB#4:DL<P_
JSuermann;ef O1/9/84
Duke Power Company cc w/enclosure(s):
Mr. William L. Porter Duke Power Company P. 0. Box 33189 422 South Church Street Office of Intergovernmental Relations Charlotte, North Carolina 28242 116 West Jones Street Raleigh, North Carolina 27603 Honorable James M. Phinney County Supervisor of Oconee County Walhalla, South Carolina 29621
,1r. James P. O'Reilly, Regional Administrator U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Region II 101 Marietta Street, P1N, Suite 2900 Atlanta, Georgia 30303 Heyward G. Shealy, Chief Bureau of Radiological Health South Carolina Department of Health and Environmental Control Regional Radiation Representative 2600 Bull Street EPA Region IV Columbia, South Carolina 29201 345 Courtland Street, N.E.
Atlanta, Georgia 30308 Mr. J. C. Bryant Senior Resident Inspector U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Route 2, Box 610 Seneca, South Carolina 29678 Mr. Robert B. Borsum Babcock & Wilcox Nuclear Power Generation Division Suite 220, 7910 Woodmont Avenue Bethesda, Maryland 20814 Manager, LIS NUS Corporation 2536 Countryside Boulevard Clearwater, Florida 33515 H.
Michael McGarry, III, Esq.
DeBevoise & Liberman 1200 12th Street, N.W.
Washington, D. C. 20036
MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 6, 1983 OCONEE EOF EXEMPTION REQUEST NRC DPC J. Suermann G. Vaughn E. Williams, Jr.
R. Gill W. Paulson R. Glover R. Van Niel M. Cartwright C. Jennings State of South Carolina P. Lunsford, Emergency Preparedness Division S. Finklea, Department of Health & Environmental Control
DUKE POWER COMPANY PRESENTATION TO NRC STAFF SEPTEMBER 6, 1983 "OCONEE EOF LOCATION EXEMPTION REQUEST" I.
REVIEW & BACKGROUND ON THE REQUEST FOR EXEMPTION - R. L. GILL II. PROPOSED EOF FACILITIES, FUNCTIONS, COMMUNICATIONS - R. M. GLOVER III.
STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA PERSPECTIVE - P. LUNSFORD, H. SHEALY IV. PUBLIC INFORMATION ASPECTS - M. CARTWRIGHT V.
RECOVERY MANAGER'S VIEWS AND.CLOSING REMARKS - G. E. VAUGHN
CHRONOLOGY OF EVENTS
- DECEMBER 17, 1982 - GENERIC LETTER 82-33 EMERGENCY OPERATION FACILITY REQUIREMENTS PROVIDED
- JUNE 3, 1983 - DUKE SUBMITTAL EXEMPTION REQUESTED TO LOCATION REQUIREMENTS OF EOF FOR OCONEE
- SEPTEMBER 6, 1983 - DUKE/NRC MEETING
NEW UCTNTER-DUKE. STATE, ifV S C
ENT ER S
COARLOTTE NC GENERAL OFFICE CMC NEARSITE TO)SCEER-VRALL MAN AGEMENT COORDINATION OF RAD. & ENV. ASSESSMENT
-DETERMINE PROTECTIVE ACTION RECOMMENDATIONS
-TECHNICAL COORDINATION WITH FEDERAL. STATE, AND LOCAL
-OCONEE NUCLEAR STATION (STATE TECHNICAL LIASON PRESECNT)
PICKENS COUNTY EOC CLEMSON ARMORY (STATE FORWARD EOC-FEOC)
DUKE LIASON PRESENT COLUMBIA (Li IS-C. STATE EOC I
FUNCTIONS OF THE CMC
- OVERALL MANAGEMENT
-COORDINATION OF RAD. & ENV.
ASSESSMENT
-RECOMMEND PUBLIC PROTECTIVE ACTIONS
-COORDINATE ACTIVITIES WITH FEDERAL, STATE, & LOCAL
FUNCTION OF THE NEWS CENTER COORDINATE ACTIVITIES WITH FEDERAL STATE, & LOCAL (PUBLIC INFORMATION)
DUKE POWER COMPANY EMERGENCY RESPONSE FACILITIES OCONEE NUCLEAR STATION FIGURE H-3 OCONEE NUCLEAR STATION NEARSITE RESPONSE FACILITIES GENERAL LAYOUT KEOWEE RIVER HIGHWAY 130 HIGHWAY 183 OCONEE TRAINING CENTER PARKING LOT OCONEE VISITORS DAM HELECOPTER CENTER LANDING AREA PARKING METEOROLOGIC &
MICROWAVE TOWER 230 KV SWITCH YARD UNIT 1 REACTOR 500 KV SWITCH YARD UNIT 2 REACTOR UNIT 3 REACTOR TURB. BUILDING REVISION 9 JUNE 15, 1983 H -10
DUKE POWER COMPANY GENERAL OFFICE RESPONSE FACILITIES FIGURE H-8 McGUIRE/CATAWBA CMC GENERAL OFFICE BUILDING LAYOUT-CHARLOTTE, N. C.
MINT STREET DUKE POWER DUKE ELECTRIC POWER CNTER BUILDING I
CHURCH STREET I.
LL PARKING WACHOVIA CENTER TRYON STREET REVISION 9 JUNE 15, 1983
DUKE POWER COMPANY RAL OFFICE RESPONSE FACILITIES RECOVERY MANAGER/SCHEDULING & PLANNING OFFICE WACHOVIA CENTER - ROOM 1010 FIGURE H-12 21 2'
DOOR BLACKBOARD TELEHONES:
- 1. DEDICATED LINE - STATE(S)
PHONE
- 2. RINGDOWN - TSC STORAGE
- 3. CENTREX TO TSC
- 4. MANAGERS TO GROUPS
- 5. STATE/COUNTY - RINGDOWN
- 6. SCH./PLN. LINES C
- 7. "RED PHONE" R
E 0
N ai ea ca o
A 0
36' (5743~ O oM
(
tj7951)O Io I 0
00 I-n oz I
S I
-P O
-z (X-5731 X7 C4 a a
H -
UN) 15 1 0
Th SCEUL F/LNNN 7
O O R V I IOu 0
-10 UE1,18
WC-1 LAYOUT FOR EMERGENCIES (OFFSITE RAD. COORDINATOR'S GROUP)
HPN PHONE 6150 STATE(S)
REPRESENTATIVE(S) 4 TABLES
@22' x 8' SPECIAL ASSISTANCE
/'
COORDINATOR fA 15 ROLLABOUT
- 6265 SCHAIRS 6265 STACK
- 7578 (DEDICATED DOSE ASSESSMENT CHAIRS LINE TO TSC)
STACK 19 STACK STACK ECHAIRS CHAIRS DOSE ASSESSMENT COORDINATOR ALTERNATE OFFSITE RAD. COORDINATOR
- 3578 LAB ANALYSIS COORDINATOR 3141
- FIELD MONITORING COORDINATOR RADIO RADIO OPERATOR 7*
NOTE: RADIO EQUIPMENT IS STORED IN NOTE: THE LARGE MAP FOR FIELD ROOM WC-2364. BRING IT DOWN MONITORING IS STORED IN TO 1222 FOR USE WC-2364.
DUKE POWER COMPANY GENERAL OFFICE RESPONSE FACILITIES FIGURE H - 14 McGUIRE/CATAWBA CMC NRC - STATE(S) - COUNTIES-CONFERENCE ROOM WACHOVIA CENTER, ROOM 1488 00000 00000 S
373-2689 373-7405 0 O O 373-7406 O
O O
14 FT.
00000 00000 30 FT.
REVISION 9 JUNE 15, 1983 H - 21
DUKE POWER COMPANY GENERAL OFFICE RESPONSE FACILITIES FIGURE H-13 McGUIRE/CATAWBA CMC TECHNICAL SUPPORT OFFICE WACHOVIA CENTER, ROOM 1704 C O SPKR. PHONE 373-5177, -5235 -5236 21CHAIRS 00 00 0 0 0
4 TABLES 0
0 12 FT.
0 0
0 23 FT.
ROOM 2390- RADIOLOGICAL SUPPORT - GENERAL OFFICE RESPONSE LOCATION WACHOVIA CENTER 0 000 0
00 0
0 0
'0 SPKR.
PHONE 373-O 7790 0
0 373-544 13FT 0 0 00 0 000 21 CHAIRS 4 TABLES 25 FT.
REVISION 9 JUNE 15, 1983 H - 20
DUKE POWER COMPANY GENERAL OFFICE RESPONSE FACILITIES FIGURE H - 11 ADMINISTRATION & LOGISTICS OFFICE, ROOM 0925 O
0 0
0 373-3122 O
SPKR.
11 FT.
PHONE 373-3121 Or373-3123 O
00 0
1 TABLE 10 CHAIRS 15 FT.
REVISION 9 JUNE 15, 1983 H-18
DUKE POWER COMPANY GENERAL OFFICE RESPONSE FACILITIES FIGURE H-9 McGUIRE/CATAWBA CMC ELECTRIC CENTER ROOMS DESIGNATED FOR EMERGENCY USE
- 0. J. MILLER AUDITORIUM CRISIS NEWS CENTER FOR CONFERENCE ROOM EC 3-32:
McGUIRE & CATAWBA NUCLEAR STATIONS DESIGN & CONSTRUCTION GROUP BLACKBOARD 30 CHAIRSo 0,
0 0-14'--.W46620 PODIUJM&
0 053041 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 o 0 0
a O
5' 530517 aaa 0
4662, 5304, 5305 a
0 0 0 0000000 0
0 1F o
M SPKR. PHONE 4662, 5304. 5305 000 1T 25' o
o o
o o
322 CHAIRS 373-2637 373-7946 373-2628 373-2633 373-2638 373-7947 373-2629 373-2634 373-2639 373-7948 373-2630 373-2635 373-2620 373-2632 373-2631 373-2636 373-2641 373-2642 REVISION 9 H
-16JUNE
- 15. 19R3
o m (0
0 z
CORPORATE n'
t HEADOUARTERS C R IS IS A
NEWS-RECOVERY ADINISTION DIRECTOR MANAGER AND LOGISTICS ADMII SSTRATION MANAGER DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION RADIOLOGICAL TECHNICAL SUPPORT SUPPORT SUPPORT RADIOLOGICAL MMANAGER COORDINATOR 2i mQFFSIT E
C L
C 0
RADIOLOGICAL m
(nm COORDIAOR NUCLEAR STATION MANAGER
- -CORPORATE POLICY INPUT
FACILITIES TO CONSIDER FOR COMMUNICATIONS PLANNING
-CHARLOTTE CMC
-PICKENS COUNTY EOC S.C. FEOC
-RADIO STATION WFBC
INDEPENDENT COMMUNICATIONS SYSTEM MICROWAVE BELL DUKE RADIO S.C. RADIO WFBC PICKENS COUNTY 04t
-0O OCONEE COUNTY S
- 0
- 0
.9 9S.
C. FEOC e
ONS NEWS CENTER 0 o 0**q* 0e
DUKE MICROWAVE SYSTEM
- WFBC 1 CHANNEL S. S. S.
PICKENS COUNTY 1 CHANNELS. S. S.
1 CHs*
SL S.
O E CCHARLOTTE CMC 1 CHANNEL "SELECTIVE S. C. FEOC gSIGNALING SYSTEM" ONS NEWS CENTER
SOUTHERN BELL SYSTEM
-OPEN BELL LINE WFBC 6 LINES PICKENS COUNTY 8 LINES OCONEE COUNTY 7 LINES 7e LINESNE S. C. FEOC 13 LINES ONS NEWS CENTER
DUKE RADIO SYSTEM DUKE RADIO (DIRECT)
DUKE RADIO WFBC (VIA Mw)
PICKENS COUNTY CHARLOTTE CMC OCONEE COUNTY
-C S.C.
FEOC ONS NEWS CENTER
S. C. RADIO SYSTEM WFBC CHARLOTTE CMC ONS NEWS CENTER
ADVANTAGES OF A CENTRALIZED CMC RAPID MANNING / PROMPT RESPONSE MERGES MGMT. & TECHNICAL STAFFS IMMEDIATE ACCESS TO UPPER LEVEL CORP. MGMT.
ELIMINATES HABITABILITY PROBLEMS PERSONNEL ARE MORE FAMILIAR WITH FACILITIES LONG TERM PERFORMANCE IMPROVED DATA COMMUNICATIONS ENHANCED IMPROVED OVERALL COMMUNICATIONS CAPABILITY
COMMtNICATIONS NEEDS RELIABLE PRIMARY & BACKUP COMMUNICATIONS BETWEEN:"
PRIMARY BACKUP TSC DATA COORD.
DUKE BELL
& CMC MICROWAVE WMC& COUNTIES (SSS)
BELL UPDATES)
DUKE RADIO MC & FEOC OPEN BELL (SSS)
JPDATES)
LINE BELL DUKE RADIO
COMMNICATIONS NIEDS RELIABLE PRIMARY & BACKUP COMMUNICATIONS BETWEEN:"
PRIMARY BACKUP RECOVERY MANAGER BELL DUKE RADIO
& COUNTY DIRECTORS DUKE MICROWAV (SSS)
FIELD MONITORING DUKE RADIO BELL TO COORDINATOR & FIELD CMC OR TSC TEAMS CMC & NEWS CENTER DUKE OPEN BELL MICROWAVE LINE DHEC REP. &
OPEN BELL LINE DUKE SEOC/FEOC MICROWAVE DUKE RADIO
COMMINICATIONS N DS RELIABLE PRIMARY & BACKUP COMMUNICATIONS BETWEEN:"
PRIMARY BACKUP TSC& CMC STAFFS DUKE BELL MICROWAVE EMERGENCY DUKE BELL OORDINATOR &
MICROWAVE ECOVERY MANAGER ECOVERY MANAGER &
OPEN BELL DUKE RADIO TATE DIRECTOR LINE DUKE MICROWAVE SELECTIVE SIGNALING SYSTEIV (SSS)
MEETING
SUMMARY
DISTRIBUTION Licensee: Duke Power Company (DPC)
- Copies also sent to those people on service (cc) list for subject plant(s).
Docket File NRC PDR L POR ORB#4 Rdg Project Manager; J. Suermann JStolz SGrimes (Emerg. Preparedness only)
OELD NSIC ELJordan, IE JM-Taylor, IE ACRS (10)
NRC Meeting
Participants:
W. Paulson R. Van Niel E. Williams, Jr.
State of South Carolina P. Lunsford, Emergency Preparedness Division S. Finklea, Department of Health & Environmental Control DPC Meeting Particiants:
G. Vaug'hn R.. Glover M. Cartwright
- 2. Jennings