Text

Order (Adopting Jointly Proposed Transcript Corrections; Rejecting the State of New York Proposed Corrections)
	ML16034A197
Person / Time
Site:	Indian Point
Issue date:	02/03/2016
From:	Lawrence Mcdade; Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
To:	;
	SECY RAS
References
	50-247-LR, 50-286-LR, ASLBP 07-858-03-LR-BD01, RAS 50886
	Download: ML16034A197 (50)
	v • d • e

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD Before Administrative Judges:

Lawrence G. McDade, Chairman Dr. Michael F. Kennedy Dr. Richard E. Wardwell In the Matter of Docket Nos. 50-247-LR and 50-286-LR ENTERGY NUCLEAR OPERATIONS, INC. ASLBP No. 07-858-03-LR-BD01 (Indian Point Nuclear Generating Units 2 and 3) February 3, 2016 ORDER (Adopting Jointly Proposed Transcript Corrections; Rejecting the State of New Yorks Proposed Corrections)

On January 8, 2016, Entergy Nuclear Operations Inc. (Entergy), the NRC Staff, the State of New York (New York), and Riverkeeper, Inc. (Riverkeeper) jointly submitted proposed transcript corrections for the evidentiary hearing held on November 16-19, 2015.1 New York also proposed corrections to which Entergy and the NRC Staff object, and which Riverkeeper supports.2 The Board adopts the parties jointly proposed transcript corrections and rejects those corrections proposed solely by New York. The Board reviewed an audio file of the portion of the hearing in dispute, and the transcript accurately reflects the speakers statements. Should New York wish to pursue the matter, the State may file a motion to correct the record.

1 Letter from Counsel for Entergy Nuclear Operations, Inc., to Lawrence G. McDade, Chairman, Dr. Michael F. Kennedy, and Dr. Richard Wardwell, Atomic Safety and Licensing Board (Jan. 8, 2016).

2 Id., attach., Hearing Transcript Errata Sheet at 46.

If New York wishes to pursue this option, it should submit a motion, accompanied by an affidavit from the witness attesting to the fact that the proposed revisions accurately reflect the witness position. Absent an extension granted by the Board, this motion must be filed no later than February 15, 2016.

In accordance with 10 C.F.R. § 2.327(d), the Board has attached an appendix of all corrections to the November 16-19, 2015 transcripts to this order, which shall be included in the record of this proceeding. Pursuant to 10 C.F.R. § 2.327(d), the Office of the Secretary will make the necessary physical corrections in the official transcript, so that it will incorporate the changes ordered.

The Board also notes that the evidentiary record for Track 2 contentions is not being closed at this juncture. An order closing the evidentiary record for Track 2 contentions will issue at a later date.

It is so ORDERED.

FOR THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD

/RA/

Lawrence G. McDade, Chairman ADMINISTRATIVE JUDGE Rockville, Maryland February 3, 2016

APPENDIX TO THE TRANSCRIPT PURSUANT TO 10 C.F.R. § 2.327(d)

Proceeding Name: Entergy Nuclear Operations, Inc. (Indian Point Generating Units 2 and 3)

Docket Nos.: 50-247-LR and 50-286-LR ASLBP No.: 07-858-03-LR-BD01 Contentions: NYS-25, NYS-26B/RK-TC-1B, and NYS-38/RK-TC-5 Hearing Date(s): November 16-19, 2015 ACCEPTED CORRECTIONS:

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 4757 brian.lusignan@ag.ny.gov john.sipos@ag.ny.gov n/a lisa.kwong@ag.ny.gov mihir.desai@ag.ny.gov 4761 10-11 Administrative Judges with the Administrative Judges with the Chairman ASLB, paid ASLB panel Lawrence McDade 4763 21 Mr. Dr. Dr. Richard Lahey 4764 9 swear you swear you in Chairman Lawrence McDade 4766 22-23 Richard Coldren, Electric Property Richard Coldren, Intellectual Richard Coldren Counsel for Westinghouse Property Counsel for Westinghouse 4769 12 729 726 Chairman Lawrence McDade 4769 17 729 726 none 4773 12 cracking. And may or cracking, which may or Chairman Lawrence McDade 4774 5 state State John Sipos 4774 18 state State John Sipos 4774 20 state State John Sipos 4775 8 state State John Sipos 1

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 4775 9 state State John Sipos 4776 25 state State John Sipos 4778 10 MS. SUTTON MS. BRANCATO n/a 4778 18 witness question Chairman McDade 4783 18 application at Union application at Indian Alan Cox 4786 24 aging managements aging management Allen Hiser 4788 10 we issued REIs we issued RAIs Judge Michael Kennedy 4789 6 regulatory information summary regulatory information summary Alan Cox and of the REIs and of the RAIs 4789 11-12 were addressed as REIs to Entergy were addressed as RAIs to Entergy Judge Michael Kennedy 4789 21-22 were not addressed through REIs were not addressed through RAIs Alan Cox 4789 23 If a particular REI If a particular RAI Judge Michael Kennedy 4790 1-2 Are the responses to REIs tracked Are the responses to RAIs tracked Judge Michael Kennedy 4790 3-4 responses to REIs are submitted responses to RAIs are submitted Alan Cox 4792 10-11 we are doing, as you all described we are doing as GALL described Alan Cox the program if we say were the program. If we say were consistent consistent 4792 15-16 aging effect, methods that are aging effect methods that are Alan Cox defined the same acceptance defined, the acceptance criteria criteria 4793 7 We took If we took Alan Cox 4793 20-21 Mr. Cox is youd like to answer, Mr. Cox if youd like to answer, Judge Michael what would then be an what then would an enhancement Kennedy enhancement be be 4793 22 enhancement be, in the enhancement in the Judge Michael Kennedy 2

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 4795 7 the applicant site the applicants site Dr. Allen Hiser 4795 13 ask them at REI, ask them an RAI, Dr. Allen Hiser 4798 12-13 So but we did use So we did use Jeffrey Poehler 4799 23 this internal staff guidance this interim staff guidance Judge Richard Wardwell 4800 1-2 When the main The main Dr. Allen Hiser 4803 14 reissues reissued Alan Cox 4804 18 version version 2 Dr. Allen Hiser 4805 5-6 So you know we should, our So you know we should verify Dr. Allen Hiser program their program 4806 3 say that they program say that the program Alan Cox 4807 12 is does Judge Michael Kennedy 4808 11 critical elements are described critical elements that are described Dr. Allen Hiser 4808 25 But Entergy has a process Entergy has a process Alan Cox 4809 3-5 Identify what the commitment is? Identify what the commitment is. Alan Cox When it has to be done? Whos When it has to be done. Whos responsible for doing it? responsible for doing it.

4809 6-7 to ensure that, if it gets to ensure that it gets accomplished Alan Cox accomplished 4809 19 had an REI had an RAI Alan Cox 4809 24-25 that particular REI, or REIs. that particular RAI, or RAIs. Alan Cox 4810 8 when we completed all of when we complete all of Alan Cox 4810 14-15 want to say all, license no want to say all license renewal Alan Cox commitments because theres a commitments because theres a few of them are not due few of them that are not due 4811 21 which is 50 59. which is 50.59. Jack Strosnider 4812 8 It would verify that the It would verify the completion Dr. Allen Hiser completion 3

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 4814 1 based on an industry guidance based on industry guidance Alan Cox 4814 2-3 NEI 9904, which is an industry NEI 99-04, which is an industry Alan Cox guideline guideline 4816 1 time limited aging analysis time-limited aging analyses Alan Cox 4816 9 So the, do I So, do I Judge Michael Kennedy 4816 14-15 And thats the material that, is that And, is that the material Judge Michael Kennedy 4816 20 report is indicated as report is included as Alan Cox 4818 18 staff believes sufficient staff believes is sufficient Dr. Allen Hiser 4818 20 So we look for sufficient So we look for a sufficient Dr. Allen Hiser 4819 14 for AMPs, that applicant AMPs for AMPs, for applicant AMPs Dr. Allen Hiser 4821 6 the critically characteristics the critical characteristics Judge Michael Kennedy 4823 7 is over all these documents there is over all these documents Jack Strosnider 4823 18-19 put through 50.59 evaluation. So put through a 50.59 evaluation. So Jack Strosnider all the way down to those all the way down to those implemented implementing 4833 10-11 MR. POEHLER: Thats it. CHAIRMAN McDADE: Thats n/a Would you like to use this in it. Would you like to use this in answering the TLA question, Mr. answering the TLAA question, Mr.

Cox? Cox?

4833 16 involve system involve systems Alan Cox 4834 3 10 CFR 54.4 bravo 10 CFR 54.4(b) bravo Alan Cox 4834 14 contentions and the Track 2 contentions, the Track 2 Alan Cox contentions contentions, 4834 21-22 becomes the tie. Thats the becomes the time-limited Alan Cox assumption. assumption 4835 20-21 little I, little two I, little, I, ii, and little (i), little (ii), little (i), (ii), and Judge Michael iii. So a TLAA fits in one of those (iii). So a TLAA fits in one of Kennedy bins, I, ii, or iii? those bins, (i), (ii), or (iii)?

4836 14 accordance with the single I there accordance with the single (i) there Alan Cox 4

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 4836 17 not actionable not actual Alan Cox 4836 23-24 or in lieu of single I, we credit or in lieu of single (i), we credit Alan Cox triple I triple (iii) 4839 4 you could say that it was a single I you could say that it was a single Alan Cox (i) 4839 14 I dont see how you get a single I I dont see how you get a single (i) Judge Richard Wardwell 4839 20 the adequacy of the COB analysis the adequacy of the CLB analysis Dr. Allen Hiser 4839 23 double I double (ii) Dr. Allen Hiser 4840 2 TLAA could possibly fall within I TLAA could possibly fall within Judge Richard (i) Wardwell 4840 12 the single I the single (i) Alan Cox 4840 20 on single I analysis on single (i) analysis Alan Cox 4841 25 I had viewed I as I had viewed (i) as Chairman Lawrence McDade 4842 3 ii is (ii) is Chairman Lawrence McDade 4842 17 100 transient 100 transients Alan Cox 4843 8-9 then it would be an I then it would be an (i) Judge Richard Wardwell 4843 16 That would be double I. That would be double (ii). Judge Richard Wardwell 4844 1-2 Either I or double I took place. Either (i) or double (ii) took place. Judge Richard Wardwell 4853 10 The input value of The input value of 100 Dr. Allen Hiser 4856 7 assumption assumption Dr. Allen Hiser 4856 8-9 input value input value Dr. Allen Hiser 5

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 4857 8 Generated some questions Weve generated some questions Judge Richard Wardwell 4857 12-13 the entire panel for 25 ceded the entire panel for 25 is seated Judge Richard Wardwell 4857 20 Dont think you need I dont think you need Judge Richard Wardwell 4860 4 efficiencies inefficiencies Judge Richard Wardwell 4862 15 pre-file pre-filed Judge Richard Wardwell 4863 18-19 any pressure or boundary any pressure boundary Judge Richard component such as reactor components, such as reactor Wardwell pressure vessels. pressure vessels.

4866 11 53 issues 5-3 issues Dr. Richard Lahey 4871 1 Ill answer it again. Ill ask it again. Judge Richard Wardwell 4873 10 the applicant site the applicants site Allen Hiser 4876 13 research document research documented Judge Richard Wardwell 4876 24 Entergys Testimony 116 Entergys Testimony 616 Judge Richard Wardwell 4880 9 ARC ExpressScribe NRC Chairman Lawrence McDade 4881 13 So when the industry, So when the industry issued its Jeffrey Poehler report, 4885 23 Entergys RVI? Entergys RVI AMP? Judge Richard Wardwell 4886 14 Exhibit 496-NL-12-037 Exhibit 496, NL-12-037 Judge Richard Wardwell 6

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 4887 15 Jeffrey Poehler, the Jeffrey Poehler, for the Jeffrey Poehler 4887 21-22 No, it approves basically our No, it approved, basically our Jeffrey Poehler safety evaluation, approved safety evaluation approved 4887 24 I should, aging I should say, aging Jeffrey Poehler 4890 18 MRP-27-A MRP-227-A Jeffrey Poehler 4891 2 227-A MRP-227-A Jeffrey Poehler 4894 8 MRP 17096 WCAP 17096 Dr. Allen Hiser 4895 21 evaluations that supports MRP- evaluations that support MRP-227 Nelson Azevedo 227 4896 23 degradation such as tracking degradation such as cracking Jeffrey Poehler 4898 8 Section 11 Section XI Jeffrey Poehler 4898 25 Section 11 Section XI Jeffrey Poehler 4901 22-23 primary expansion existing primary, expansion, existing Jeffrey Poehler programs programs, and 4902 4 EPRI MRP submitted EPRI submitted Jeffrey Poehler 4902 10-11 so, no, yes, we didnt just accept so no. Yes, we didnt just accept Jeffrey Poehler 4904 4 sitements items Judge Richard Wardwell 4904 8 what these ALIs are what these A/LAIs are Judge Richard Wardwell 4905 8 theyre AMP their AMP Judge Richard Wardwell 4906 17 more components under primary more components in the primary Dr. Allen Hiser 4906 22 through the ALIs through the A/LAIs Judge Richard Wardwell 7

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 4908 19 adequacies of the RVI. adequacies of the RVI AMP. Judge Richard Wardwell 4909 5 evaluation of degradation of evaluation of degradation Judge Richard mechanisms mechanisms Wardwell 4909 8 that identify that identified Judge Richard Wardwell 4909 12 provides Aging Management provides aging management Judge Richard Wardwell 4910 6 Richard Lahey. [DELETE] Dr. Richard Lahey 4914 9 you have a vary distorted you can have a very distorted Dr. Richard Lahey geometry geometry 4914 24 the Clovis bolts the Clevis bolts Chairman Lawrence McDade 4915 20 cores corrosion Dr. Richard Lahey 4916 6 actuative accident Dr. Richard Lahey 4917 9 usable useful Dr. Richard Lahey 4918 1 XI.1M16A XI.M16A Judge Richard Wardwell 4918 3 earlier, 2011/04 earlier, 2011-04 Judge Richard Wardwell 4920 3 Respect I guess. No respect I guess. Barry Gordon 4920 10 required by, by the water required by the water Barry Gordon 4921 8 the material the materials Barry Gordon 4921 12-13 hyrdozine in there which hydrazine in there which consumes Barry Gordon consumes, it consumes oxygen oxygen 4922 4 look at their alloy 600 look at their Alloy 600 Barry Gordon 8

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 4923 17 gained on though from gained from Judge Richard Wardwell 4923 22 corrosion and cracking corrosion cracking Dr. Richard Lahey 4924- lines MR. COX: . . . vessel internals. [DELETE 13 LINES OF TEXT; Alan Cox, 4925 22 -9 REDUNDANT TO TEXT AT Chairman CHAIRMAN MCDADE: . . . isnt PAGE 4924, LINES 9-21] Lawrence McDade that correct 4926 7 a effective an effective Chairman Lawrence McDade 4928 8 ALIs A/LAIs Judge Richard Wardwell 4931 23 that once the fatigue will that fatigue will Dr. Richard Lahey 4932 21 real snap with real snap Dr. Richard Lahey 4933 10 withstand withstood Dr. Richard Lahey 4934 3 Loft Program LOFT Program Dr. Richard Lahey 4934 5 cool geometry coolable geometry Dr. Richard Lahey 4934 10 not looking at just a not looking at a Dr. Richard Lahey 4934 23 only works with everything only works if everything Dr. Richard Lahey 4937 7 propagation of the propagation characteristics of the Dr. Richard Lahey 4937 13 the element stress the ultimate stress Dr. Richard Lahey 4939 11 normal transience normal transients Judge Richard Wardwell 4940 6 it will break it will not break Dr. Richard Lahey 4940 11-12 the stress strains the stress-strains Dr. Richard Lahey 4940 14 transience transients Judge Richard Wardwell 9

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 4940 17 transience transients Judge Richard Wardwell 4940 20 See, bottom line See, the bottom line Dr. Richard Lahey 4941 2 NRC with on top NRC on top Dr. Richard Lahey 4941 9-10 its issue its one issue Dr. Richard Lahey 4944 5 thermohydraulics thermal-hydraulics Dr. Richard Lahey 4944 19 systematic effects synergistic effects Judge Richard Wardwell 4947 14 it related to stress relaxation, the It is related to stress relaxation, the Dr. Randy Lott loss is corroding both loss of bolt load.

4947 17 assumption performance Dr. Randy Lott 4947 24 A threaded fastener. That is A threaded fastener that is Dr. Randy Lott 4949 11-12 effectively its CUF equals 1 effectively its CUF equals 1 value Dr. Randy Lott value of an decreasing of any decreasing 4950 1 they we Dr. Randy Lott 4950 11 durability under embrittled durability of embrittled Judge Richard Wardwell 4950 17 was released data was research data Dr. Randy Lott 4953 22 design bay design basis Gary Stevens 4954 23 some of the local loads some of the LOCA loads Gary Stevens 4957 11 The Staff believe that no cracks The Staff believes that there are no Dr. Allen Hiser under cracks under 4958 12 components that has failed components that have failed Dr. Allen Hiser 4959 22 Gedankenexperiment Gedanken experiment Dr. Richard Lahey 4959 24 Gedankenexperiment Gedanken experiment Dr. Richard Lahey 10

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 4960 19 to .5 to .9 Dr. Richard Lahey 4960 21 .99 At a CUFen of .99 Dr. Richard Lahey 4960 24 CUF of 1 CUFen of 1 Dr. Richard Lahey 4961 1 CUF CUFen Dr. Richard Lahey 4961 9-10 My belief is CUF is 1.0 or less My belief is if the CUF is 1.0 or Dr. Allen Hiser less 4961 12 I think your likely incipient to I think youre likely to have an Dr. Allen Hiser have a incipient 4963 6 Stainless is not Stainless steel is not Dr. Allen Hiser 4963 16 fluencies fluences Dr. Allen Hiser 4964 8 If no crack, If theres no crack, Dr. Allen Hiser 4964 16 under an influence under a fluence Judge Richard Wardwell 4965 2 But we can down that But we can compute that Dr. Allen Hiser 4967 20 characterizable in science and characterizable in the sense of Dr. Randy Lott 4967 22 theres no way to know theres no need to know Dr. Randy Lott 4967 23 analyze a crack analyze a cracked Dr. Randy Lott 4968 4 value, standard Dr. Randy Lott 4968 13 the local loads the LOCA loads Dr. Randy Lott 4973 19 Its the second Its a second Dr. Richard Lahey 4973 24 could either do it delta function could do it with a Dirac delta Dr. Richard Lahey function 4975 25 it's a local load it's a LOCA load Dr. Richard Lahey 4976 11 JUDGE KENNEDY: Your Honor, DR. LAHEY: Your Honor, n/a 4977 3 the normal local the normal LOCA Dr. Richard Lahey 11

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 4980 17 ticket in the ticket item in the Dr. Richard Lahey 4980 22 in core in the core Dr. Richard Lahey 4981 20 were talking about, the ability of were talking about is the ability of Dr. Randy Lott the component the component 4983 4-5 limited to the baffle former and limited to the baffle, former, and Dr. Randy Lott baffle former bolts baffle-former bolts 4983 16 crack, crack, form a crack crack. A crack from a crack. Dr. Randy Lott 4983 17 comes into place comes into play Dr. Randy Lott 4984 2 Jeff Strosnider Jack Strosnider Jack Strosnider 4984 8 theres no fracture in theres no crack in Jack Strosnider 4985 23-24 I want to add to that is that I want to add that is that Jack Strosnider 4986 12 like the candy cane like a candy cane Jack Strosnider 4986 14 elastic plastic fraction mechanics elastic-plastic fracture mechanics Jack Strosnider 4987 2 uni-axle uniaxial Jack Strosnider 4989 16 Allen Alan Alan Cox 4991 7 ASME code section 3 ASME code section III Jack Strosnider 4991 13 license removal license renewal Jack Strosnider 4993 12 strength gets brighter strength gets higher Jack Strosnider 4997 14 PT 27 MRP 227 Gary Stevens 4998 10 irradiation on crack irradiation effects on crack Gary Stevens 5004 16 brian.lusignan@ag.ny.gov john.sipos@ag.ny.gov n/a lisa.kwong@ag.ny.gov mihir.desai@ag.ny.gov 5006 24 dont what dont know what Judge Michael Kennedy 12

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 5007 18 Kanaski Kanasaki Dr. Richard Lahey 5009 7 That being one of them One of them being Dr. Randy Lott 5010 2 fast meter fast breeder Dr. Randy Lott 5010 19-21 well find theres, A, a limited well find that there is a limited Dr. Randy Lott number of materials of the number of materials in the internals which have CUF values internals which have CUF values calculated are irradiated calculated that are irradiated 5011 10 Jerry Stevens Gary Stevens Gary Stevens 5012 11 MRP 210 MRP-210 Dr. Randy Lott 5012 24 Debra Deborah Deborah Brancato 5013 18 MRP 227 MRP-227 Judge Richard Wardwell 5014 22 highly rated components highly irradiated components Dr. Randy Lott 5016 9 looked looking Judge Richard Wardwell 5017 4-5 to generation of the S-N curve to generate the S-N curve Dr. Randy Lott 5025 4 eight age relating degradation eight age-related degradation Judge Richard Wardwell 5027 2 good idea good item Dr. Randy Lott 5037 1 event events Dr. Richard Lahey 5037 13 Loft experiment LOFT experiment Dr. Richard Lahey 5038 15 Dr. Lot, Dr. Lott, Chairman Lawrence McDade 5040 8 on a science on the science Dr. Richard Lahey 5041 2 thermohydraulics thermal-hydraulics Dr. Richard Lahey 5041 3 crud CRUD Dr. Richard Lahey 13

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 5041 7 during transience during transients Dr. Richard Lahey 5041 8 FN CUFen Dr. Richard Lahey 5041 13 working in it working on it Dr. Richard Lahey 5042 13 now you now that you Dr. Richard Lahey 5044 13 DoE, USNR, DOE, USNRC, Judge Richard Wardwell 5047 14 or placed around are placed around Jeffrey Poehler 5050 8 NUREG-6909 NUREG/CR-6909 Dr. Randy Lott 5054 6 fraction wave rarefraction wave Nelson Azevedo 5055 16 it would crack it could crack Dr. Richard Lahey 5057 12 accident mode accident load Dr. Randy Lott 5057 25 Section 3 Section III Judge Richard Wardwell 5058 19 Section 3 Section III Nelson Azevedo 5059 1 Section 3 Section III Timothy Griesbach 5059 18 Section 3 Section III Nelson Azevedo 5059 22 Section 11 Section XI Nelson Azevedo 5061 21 which are LI600 which are Alloy 600 Nelson Azevedo 5063 1 weaken for various weaken by various Dr. Richard Lahey 5065 21 strength the penetrations straightened the penetrations Nelson Azevedo 5065 23 both LI600 both Alloy 600 Nelson Azevedo 5066 6 both LI600 both Alloy 600 Nelson Azevedo 5066 12 thats what it was going thats what I was going Nelson Azevedo 14

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 5066 15 one times ten to 17 one times ten to the 17th Nelson Azevedo 5067 1 NL12-037 NL-12-037 Judge Richard Wardwell 5067 2 2037 is the Inspection Plan to 037 is the Inspection Plan Judge Richard Wardwell 5067 7 inspection inspections Judge Richard Wardwell 5068 7 Section 11 Section XI Dr. Randy Lott 5069 3 Section 11 Section XI Bob Dolansky 5070 6 your Table your Tables Judge Richard Wardwell 5070 7 plan shows plan show Judge Richard Wardwell 5074 4 confidence that, that interval confidence that that interval Judge Richard Wardwell 5077 13 SCR SER Dr. Allen Hiser 5077 25 weve doing all weve been doing all Judge Richard Wardwell 5078 5 SCR SER Dr. Allen Hiser 5083 2 means to be me means to me Dr. Richard Lahey 5089 2 MRP MR. POEHLER: n/a 5091 23 if you exam 75 percent if you examine 75 percent Jeffrey Poehler 5093 20 0.04 inch size 0.044 inch size Jeffrey Poehler 5095 1 core valve girth weld core barrel girth weld Jeffrey Poehler 5095 8 at the head, the shank area at the head-to-shank area Jeffrey Poehler 5095 25 have been changed to be have been judged to be Jeffrey Poehler 15

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 5097 2 Why I dont I Why dont I Judge Richard Wardwell 5101 6 Section 11 Section XI Bob Dolansky 5101 14 log lug Dr. Randy Lott 5105 23 Thats one of the reason Thats one reason Dr. Randy Lott 5105 24 out is because out because Dr. Randy Lott 5109 15 EPRI 228 EPRI MRP-228 Chairman Lawrence McDade 5109 22 with Mr. Laheys with Dr. Laheys Judge Richard Wardwell 5115 17 confused then confused about then Chairman Lawrence McDade 5116 6 is you increase the is, as you increase the Dr. Alan Hiser 5118 24 the Icone paper the ICONE paper Dr. Richard Lahey 5119 16 high flux reader reactor high flux breeder reactor Dr. Richard Lahey 5121 10 Their difference The difference Dr. Richard Lahey 5121 17 disagree what that disagree with that Dr. Richard Lahey 5123 6 the sooner they the soonest they Dr. Richard Lahey 5124 1-2 transience and cycles, thereby transients and cycles, thereby Judge Richard assuring that fatigue usage from assuring that fatigue usage from Wardwell actual plant transience actual plant transients 5128 9 LRISG LR-ISG Jeffrey Poehler 5129 10 7207 7027 Tim Griesbach 5129 11 7207 7027 Dr. Randy Lott 5130 17 WCAP-170986 WCAP-17096 Dr. Randy Lott 16

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 5130 18 well be calling methodology what we called methodology Dr. Randy Lott 5132 3 if they are if there are Dr. Richard Lahey 5141 11 the reactor the reactor Judge Richard Wardwell 5141 12 to managing the to manage the Judge Richard Wardwell 5141 20 acceptance criteria. acceptance criteria. Judge Richard Wardwell 5143 6 Letter 12- letter NL Bob Dolansky 5144 22 that, I believe that, I believe Judge Richard Wardwell 5145 3 failed RVP internals failed RPV internals Judge Richard Wardwell 5145 4 degraded core cooling. degraded core cooling. Judge Richard Wardwell 5147 17 sufficient degraded sufficiently degraded Dr. Richard Lahey 5148 8 -- have Entergy -- having Entergy Dr. Richard Lahey 5154 14 extended conditions extent of conditions Nelson Azevedo 5160 15 NL12-037 NL-12-037 Judge Richard Wardwell 5163 5 than some than for some Dr. Richard Lahey 5163 24 again NL12-037 Attachment again NL-12-037 Attachment Judge Richard Wardwell 5170 11 is not magnetic is non-magnetic Barry Gordon 17

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 5172 22-25 you get this diffuseness reaction, you get this diffusionless reaction Barry Gordon which you get martensite in the where you get martensite in the Austenitic stainless steel. Part of it Austenitic stainless steel. Part of it will be transfer will transform 5179 19 NUREG 7184 NUREG/CR-7184 Judge Richard Wardwell 5180 11 NUREG 7181 NUREG/CR-7184 Judge Richard Wardwell 5184 22 above the MRPA 175 screening above the MRP-175 screening Judge Richard Wardwell 5189 15 high ferric high ferrite Judge Richard Wardwell 5189 23 high ferric provide high ferrite provide Judge Richard Wardwell 5202 15 the ferric the ferrite Judge Richard Wardwell 5203 19 the 8M the CF-8M Dr. Allen Hiser 5203 25 high ferric content high ferrite content Judge Richard Wardwell 5207 11 can imaging the aging can imagine the aging Alan Cox 5210 16 these such there such Judge Richard Wardwell 5211 8 in our file in our filed Dr. Randy Lott 5212 24 of ferric content of ferrite content Judge Richard Wardwell 5214 9 is ferric content is ferrite content Judge Richard Wardwell 5214 25 NUREG/CR--7185 NUREG/CR-7185 Judge Richard Wardwell 18

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 5215 15 or the IASCC or IASCC Judge Richard Wardwell 5218 20 changes need to changes needed to Judge Richard Wardwell 5219 3 can occur to either irradiation can occur due to either irradiation Jeffrey Poehler 5220 4 your understand that your understanding that Judge Richard Wardwell 5221 2 ferric content ferrite content Judge Richard Wardwell 5221 6 have a linkage within have leakage within Dr. Richard Lahey 5221 25 higher ferric higher ferrite Judge Richard Wardwell 5222 20 a couple other ones a couple of other ones Jeffrey Poehler 5223 16 to ferric content to ferrite content Judge Richard Wardwell 5223 21 ferric content ferrite content Dr. Randy Lott 5227 19 in make sure in making sure Chairman Lawrence McDade 5228 18 within a subset examination with a subsequent examination Judge Richard Wardwell 5231 4 It is document in It is documented in Dr. Allen Hiser 5237 24 of time about of times about Jack Strosnider 5238 9 whatever approvals they make whatever conditions they make Jack Strosnider 5240 15 that actual what that actually what Bob Dolansky 5241 1 what needed whats needed Judge Richard Wardwell 19

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 5260 23 managing the manage the Judge Richard Wardwell 5265 10 that had failed that it had failed Jeffrey Poehler 5266 10 I think technical basis I think the technical basis Dr. Allen Hiser 5266 12-13 that annotation of license renewal. the application for license renewal. Dr. Allen Hiser 5273 6 that Im believe that I believe Dr. Randy Lott 5275 4 EPRI 191 and EPRI MRP-191 and Dr. Richard Lahey 5275 16 molybdenum contact grade molybdenum content grade Judge Richard Wardwell 5275 25 The lower cast of The lower, non-cast of Dr. Randy Lott 5278 9 a ferric content a ferrite content Judge Richard Wardwell 5282 19 Action Level Action Item Judge Richard Wardwell 5283 16 formation provided by Entergy information provided by Entergy Judge Richard Wardwell 5284 10 that its the that the Judge Richard Wardwell 5285 3 didnt even screen-in it didnt even screen-in Jeffrey Poehler 5288 5 DR. LAHEY DR. LOTT n/a 5288 8 DR. LAHEY DR. LOTT n/a 5288 11 DR. LAHEY DR. LOTT n/a 5291 17 PWROG14-048 PWROG 14-048 Dr. Randy Lott 5292 5 testing composed o? testing composed of? Judge Richard Wardwell 20

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 5324 16 brian.lusignan@ag.ny.gov john.sipos@ag.ny.gov n/a lisa.kwong@ag.ny.gov mihir.desai@ag.ny.gov 5328 17 Steam Generators Materials Steam Generators and Materials Kenneth Karwoski 5330 5 started start Chairman Lawrence McDade 5332 19 MPR-227 MRP-227 Chairman Lawrence McDade 5335 25 if there any lessons if there are any lessons Bob Dolansky 5337 13 MPR-227 MRP-227 Chairman Lawrence McDade 5338 1-2 point to us point us to Chairman Lawrence McDade 5338 14 VWR-VIP-2015-025 BWR-VIP-2015-025 Dr. Randy Lott 5338 19 document does site document does cite Dr. Randy Lott 5338 23 higher cast material say inside 184 higher cast material considered in Dr. Randy Lott 7184 5340 17-18 for a fatigue in radiation for fatigue and irradiation Dr. Richard Lahey 5343 4 stressors stresses Dr. Randy Lott 5343 22 for on Dr. Richard Lahey 5343 25 It First Dr. Richard Lahey 5344 1 truly impact truly an impact Dr. Richard Lahey 5344 15 to show and Dr. Richard Lahey 5344 23 version of the track code version of the TRAC code Dr. Richard Lahey 5344 15 to show and Dr. Richard Lahey 5344 25 its W Cobra slash its W Cobra slash TRAC Dr. Richard Lahey 21

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 5346 10 track code TRAC code Dr. Richard Lahey 5347 2 And then use And they use Dr. Richard Lahey 5347 5 full leg full cold leg Dr. Richard Lahey 5348 3 local loads LOCA loads Dr. Richard Lahey 5350 23-24 see if, it would have see if it would have Judge Richard Wardwell 5355 21 static statically or centrifugally statically or centrifugally Tim Griesbach 5357 7 were to do its were to do its Dr. Allen Hiser 5358 20 a days a little change a days and a little change Judge Richard Wardwell 5358 23-24 I want you let you know I want to let you know Judge Richard Wardwell 5364 14 enlighten us at to what enlighten us as to what Judge Michael Kennedy 5364 20 Section 3 Section III Mark Gray 5364 21 3222.4(e)[5] 3222.4(e)(5) Mark Gray 5367 9 Section 3 Section III Mark Gray 5369 18 Section 3 Section III Mark Gray 5370 3 Section 3 Section III Mark Gray 5373 19 theyre there are Nelson Azevedo 5374 14 Theres an SM Theres an Sn Nelson Azevedo 5377 11 LOCA stress local stress Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5379 10 eluded to alluded to Mark Gray 5380 5 Section 3 Section III Mark Gray 22

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 5380 17 Section 3 Section III Mark Gray 5383 12 talked about Fen talk about Fen Dr. Richard Lahey 5384 10 different transients attract different transients are tracked Mark Gray 5384 21 analyzing cycles analyzed cycles Mark Gray 5385 14 life is tied an life is tied to an Mark Gray 5387 22 Mr. Gray eluded Mr. Gray alluded Alan Cox 5389 2 the CUF the CUFen Alan Cox 5389 6 environmental crushing environmental correction Alan Cox 5390 17 Mr. Cox eluded to Mr. Cox alluded to Judge Michael Kennedy 5391 8 RTLAAs TLAAs Dr. Allen Hiser 5391 21 10 CFR 5055(a) 10 CFR 50.55a Jack Strosnider 5391 24 Section 3 Section III Jack Strosnider 5392 9 cum and usage cumulative usage Jack Strosnider 5393 24 metal fatigue amp metal fatigue AMP Judge Michael Kennedy 5394 2 Whats specific GALL AMP What specific GALL AMP Judge Michael Kennedy 5394 6 Its amp Its the AMP Alan Cox 5394 13 amp AMP Judge Richard Wardwell 5394 21-22 title of the amp is not, M1 title of the AMP is X.M1 Ching Ng 5397 10 operating blocks from the plant operating logs from the plant Nelson Azevedo 5398 8 amp AMP Judge Michael Kennedy 23

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 5398 13 amp AMP Judge Michael Kennedy 5399 13 does contain do contain Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5400 22 referring to refer to Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5402 23 going overload going to overload Judge Michael Kennedy 5403 23 carbon scale carbon steel Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5404 3 scale steel Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5404 22 correlate the light correlate the line Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5405 5-6 So when they say that the CUFen So when they say what the CUFen Dr. Joram is, and this is, this Hopenfeld 5406 11 ratio of light and air ratio of life in air Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5407 21 evaluating evaluates Gary Stevens 5408 10 kinds of evaluation. kinds of evaluations. Gary Stevens 5409 2 for point that for pointing that Gary Stevens 5409 6 Section 3 Section III Gary Stevens 5409 15 the factor 3 the factor of 3 Gary Stevens 5410 11 that it bounds that bounds Gary Stevens 5411 22 We confusing two We are confusing two Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 24

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 5412 8 that we talked that we talked about Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5412 13 30 or 40 years -- 30 or 40 years ago -- Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5415 12 bringing to our attention bringing it to our attention Judge Michael Kennedy 5419 4 a failure or a crack to initiate a failure or a crack initiation Gary Stevens 5420 8 One is I cant touch One that I cant touch Gary Stevens 5421 8 Now another we can Now another item we can Gary Stevens 5421 18 so much as, so long as so long as Gary Stevens 5422 16-17 conservatism, if there is some conservatism is, there is some Gary Stevens 5425 2-3 Section 3 Section III Mark Gray 5425 6 Find an element analysis Finite element analysis Mark Gray 5427 24 your pre-file testimony your pre-filed testimony Judge Michael Kennedy 5428 9 pre-file testimony pre-filed testimony Judge Michael Kennedy 5429 11 in decreased by they decreased by Dr. Richard Lahey 5434 10 ASME code In the ASME code Gary Stevens 5434 19 low probably events. low probability events. Gary Stevens 5437 2 going longer going on longer Dr. Richard Lahey 5437 16 their the Dr. Richard Lahey 5437 25 inclusive inconclusive Dr. Richard Lahey 5438 5 so its like Dr. Richard Lahey 5438 12 say that we have the data say that the data Dr. Richard Lahey 25

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 5440 10 thats theres that theres Judge Michael Kennedy 5442 14 one of the implicitly one of them implicitly Gary Stevens 5442 20 on strengthened materials on the strength of materials Gary Stevens 5444 4-5 10 to the 4th, 10 to the 5th cycle. 10 to the 4th, 10 to the 5th cycles. Gary Stevens 5444 7 the data stands the data spans Gary Stevens 5445 15 stress-strain curve or a stress-strain curve for a Dr. Richard Lahey 5446 11 that would a complement where that a component material Gary Stevens material 5446 19 you got to understand youve got to understand Dr. Richard Lahey 5447 23-24 Significant bloating of structures, Significant loading of structures, Dr. Richard Lahey impulsive bloating of structures impulsive loading of structures 5449 2 And the clarify And to clarify Chairman Lawrence McDade 5449 9 Were They are Dr. Randy Lott 5451 3 I needed a couple I need a couple Judge Michael Kennedy 5451 6 miss one nor ask you that miss one or ask you one that Judge Michael Kennedy 5456 10 conservatism in that conservatism in them Dr. Richard Lahey 5456 16-17 end of light for end of life for Dr. Richard Lahey 5457 9 the question of how conservative the question is how conservative Dr. Richard Lahey 5459 12-13 the partial, so if you, partial the partials, that is, the partial Dr. Richard Lahey derivative derivatives 5459 19-20 the partial of F at function, respect the partial of F with respect to Dr. Richard Lahey to 26

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 5460 15 partial of I square R partial of I squared R Dr. Richard Lahey 5460 24 your resister your resistor Dr. Richard Lahey 5461 14 its nothing magic? its nothing magic. Dr. Richard Lahey 5462 20-21 have this 0.25 arranging CUF have this 0.25 error in CUF Dr. Richard Lahey 5465 6 the 21 or six point the 21 Dr. Richard Lahey 5467 18 so thats 0.2. But in fact, at 0.3 so thats point (2). But in fact, at Dr. Richard Lahey point (3),

5467 25 when you get to 0.3 when you get to point (3) Dr. Richard Lahey 5468 16 its not longer conservatisms its no longer conservative Dr. Richard Lahey 5468 20 to so Dr. Richard Lahey 5473 5 you can do estimate Dr. Richard Lahey 5474 11 how you determine how you determine it Dr. Richard Lahey 5474 23 go in heat go to a heat Dr. Richard Lahey 5476 20-21 I think it was a 0.7, Havana 0.7 I think it was a CUFen of 0.7 Dr. Richard Lahey 5477 4 trust the results trust that the results Dr. Richard Lahey 5477 21-22 they could use, the WESTEMS they could use the WESTEMS Dr. Richard Lahey code is really code, which is really 5477 24 did my first job had my first job Dr. Richard Lahey 5478 7 they do it they could do it Dr. Richard Lahey 5479 8 autoclave an autoclave Dr. Richard Lahey 5479 8 So they put So they used Dr. Richard Lahey 5479 17 sub-shielding self-shielding Dr. Richard Lahey 5479 18 sub-shielding self-shielding Dr. Richard Lahey 27

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 5481 6 indicate of indicative of Judge Richard Wardwell 5487 12 be a responsibility be a possibility Mark Gray 5488 21 as NRC staff. of NRC staff. Gary Stevens 5491 19 during the light. during the life. Dr. Richard Lahey 5495 25 larger ones larger loads Dr. Richard Lahey 5497 5 CUFen less than a CUFen less than Dr. Richard Lahey 5503 22 understand understanding John Sipos 5505 17 will not be shot will not be shy Chairman Lawrence McDade 5507 6 from for Dr. Richard Lahey 5507 20 thermal couple thermocouple Dr. Richard Lahey 5508 11 thermal shot thermal shock Dr. Richard Lahey 5510 9 E V Dr. Richard Lahey 5512 20 coarse spray core spray Dr. Richard Lahey 5513 25 choose big choose a big Dr. Richard Lahey 5515 18 law Law Dr. Richard Lahey 5518 17 here here Brian Harris 5518 18 here here Brian Harris 5520 23 how do you talk how do you take Chairman Lawrence McDade 5521 8 Fen type FEM type Dr. Richard Lahey 5521 11 remarkable remarkably Dr. Richard Lahey 5522 7 Fen codes FEM codes Dr. Richard Lahey 28

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 5523 14 This demonstrative This demonstrative exhibit Raphael Kuyler 5526 13 thermal couple thermocouple Dr. Richard Lahey 5526 18 thermal couple thermocouple Dr. Richard Lahey 5526 22 thermal couple thermocouple Dr. Richard Lahey 5527 9 thermal couple thermocouple Judge Michael Kennedy 5529 13 thermal couple thermocouple Mark Gray 5529 21-22 new reg CR6260 NUREG/CR-6260 Mark Gray 5533 25 developed in developed flow in Mark Gray 5537 7 transients, why we fast transients, we Mark Gray 5546 1 IF If Judge Michael Kennedy 5553 9 that a level that to a level Gary Stevens 5555 16 Or quite frankly, if you Quite frankly, you Dr. Richard Lahey 5556 20 Is As Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5557 22 get the from get from Dr. Hopenfeld 5559 12 CFT CFD Mark Gray 5561 17-18 thermal couple thermocouple Judge Michael Kennedy 5562 10 NRC Bulletin 8811 NRC Bulletin 88-11 Mark Gray 5562 15-16 NRC Bulletin 8811 did use NRC Bulletin 88-11 did use Mark Gray thermal couple measurements thermocouple measurements 5562 16 thermal couple thermocouple Mark Gray 5562 20 thermal couple thermocouple Mark Gray 29

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 5565 7 temperature differences temperature difference Mark Gray 5565 14 spectrum or events spectrum of events Mark Gray 5566 1 thermal couple thermocouple Mark Gray 5566 7 thermal couple thermocouple Judge Michael Kennedy 5566 8 thermal couple thermocouple Mark Gray 5566 15 thermal couple thermocouple Dr. Richard Lahey 5566 19 thermal couple thermocouple Dr. Richard Lahey 5566 22 thermal couple thermocouple Dr. Richard Lahey 5567 7 thermal couple thermocouple Dr. Richard Lahey 5567 13 thermal couple thermocouple Judge Michael Kennedy 5567 19 thermal couple thermocouple Judge Michael Kennedy 5569 13 thermal couple thermocouple Dr. Richard Lahey 5577 3 use lose Dr. Richard Lahey 5581 8 as it needs to and as it needs to be and Mark Gray 5581 16 apply a consistent apply it consistent Mark Gray 5583 8-9 analysis or the instance analysis, for instance, Mark Gray 5585 3 DR. LAHEY JUDGE KENNEDY n/a 5588 13-14 still in a close session still in a closed session Chairman Lawrence McDade 5589 16 they added up they are added up Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5590 16 Section 3 Section III Mark Gray 30

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 5590 23 those sites those cites Chairman Lawrence McDade 5591 12-13 New Yorks state 349 New York State 349 Nelson Azevedo 5591 24 that think Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5595 19-20 in a radiation embrittlement and irradiation embrittlement Chairman Lawrence McDade 5596 5 in a and Chairman Lawrence McDade 5602 23 the code designed the Code designed Mark Gray 5603 1 Section 3 Section III Mark Gray 5603 16 Section 3 Section III Mark Gray 5604 1 K sub E KE Mark Gray 5604 5 allowed to that then allowed to exceed that, then Mark Gray 5604 7 with KE with KE Mark Gray 5605 17 thats I changed it thats why I changed it Chairman Lawrence McDade 5607 23-24 the tendency of 55A 10 CFR 50.55a Jack Strosnider 5609 24 environmental adjusted environmentally adjusted Chairman Lawrence McDade 5610 18 Dr. Leahy Dr. Lahey Chairman Lawrence McDade 5612 6 once again to the elastic once we get to the elastic Nelson Azevedo 5612 13-14 I was involved with was to I was involved with was the Nelson Azevedo pressurize a spray piping pressurizer spray piping 5612 17 plastic analyses were very plastic analyses which are very Nelson Azevedo expensive expensive 31

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 5613 11 Dr. Leahy Dr. Lahey Chairman Lawrence McDade 5613 18 identify if you wish, the CUF end identify it if you wish, the CUFen Dr. Richard Lahey 5615 9 end of life or the extended end of life for the extended Dr. Richard Lahey 5616 9 many years. many years ago. Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5617 10 conservative is immediate tells conservative immediately tells you Dr. Joram you that what are that what Hopenfeld 5618 8 And what I mean a synergy, And what I mean by a synergy is, Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5618 9 symmetry synergy Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5619 11 trying to this trying to do this Judge Michael Kennedy 5624 22 Section 3 Section III Gary Stevens 5625 25 And where I can And while I can Gary Stevens 5627 20 unstable at 8,00 BTU unstable at 8,000 BTU Dr. Richard Lahey 5629 5 number of that you repeat number that you repeat Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5629 20-21 beginning, the CUFen are beginning, how the CUFens are Dr. Joram calculated calculated Hopenfeld 5629 25 measurements temperature measurements of temperature Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5632 3 ECC system ECC systems Dr. Richard Lahey 5632 4 coolant system coolant systems Dr. Richard Lahey 5632 23 about the FEN about the Fen Judge Michael Kennedy 32

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 5633 23 To part For part Chairman Lawrence McDade 5634 4 FEN values Fen values Judge Michael Kennedy 5634 12 DR. LAHEY JUDGE KENNEDY n/a 5635 7 using what the new regs using what the NUREGs Mark Gray 5636 2 Theyre a different There are a different Mark Gray 5636 6 because theyre a because there are a Mark Gray 5638 14 And deterministic approach A deterministic approach Mark Gray 5643 14 address hat comment address that comment Judge Richard Wardwell 5645 10 that Dr. Leahy that Dr. Lahey Judge Richard Wardwell 5645 14 that Dr. Leahy that Dr. Lahey Chairman Lawrence McDade 5646 12 wide used widely used Dr. Richard Lahey 5646 14 mothing nothing Dr. Richard Lahey 5647 1 CUF N depends CUFen depends Dr. Richard Lahey 5647 2 partial of CUF N with partial of CUFen with Dr. Richard Lahey 5647 4-5 partial of CUF N with partial of CUFen with Dr. Richard Lahey 5647 22 wide used widely used Dr. Richard Lahey 5649 25 Dr. Leahy Dr. Lahey Jack Strosnider 5651 16 9595 95/95 Jack Strosnider 5651 22 all the founding all the bounding Jack Strosnider 5651 25 9999 99/99 Jack Strosnider 33

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 5652 2 9595 95/95 Jack Strosnider 5653 24 one idea to do one way to do Dr. Richard Lahey 5654 7 affect the CUF end affect the CUFen Dr. Richard Lahey 5655 16 regulation regulations Gary Stevens 5656 12 one of the those one of those Gary Stevens 5657 6 new Reg CR6260 NUREG/CR-6260 Gary Stevens 5657 10 And Ill put it in, And Ill put it as, Gary Stevens 5657 21 that we have is that what we have is Gary Stevens 5661 5 oxygen you extract oxygen for the transient Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5661 15 they specified look, if you dont they specifically said look, if you Dr. Joram know what it is, heres a dont know what it is, heres a Hopenfeld guideline, use Form 4 guideline, use .4 5662 24 exponential equation Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5662 25 And this is true. And this isnt true. Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5667 24 In a BWE In a BWR Alan Cox 5669 4 five ppd five ppb Nelson Azevedo 5670 4 reference in new reg CR6909 reference in NUREG/CR-6909 Mark Gray 5670 24 new regs from Argonne NUREGs from Argonne Mark Gray 5671 7 In new reg CR6815 In NUREG/CR-6815 Mark Gray 5671 8 where the new reg where the NUREG Mark Gray 5671 10 strain rate oxygen and temperature strain rate, oxygen, and Mark Gray values temperature values 34

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 5671 12 quote that new reg quote that NUREG Mark Gray 5671 16 amplitude temperature and amplitude, temperature, and Mark Gray dissolved oxygen and dissolved oxygen in 5671 20 temperature is below its temperature is below its Mark Gray 5671 24 new reg reinforces NUREG reinforces Mark Gray 5671 25 the new reg the NUREG Mark Gray 5672 10 in new reg CR6906 in NUREG/CR-6909 Gary Stevens 5672 15 NPR47 MRP-47 Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5672 18 NPR 47 MRP-47 Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5673 8 all kind of reactions all kinds of reactions Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5673 16 NRP47 MRP-47 Gary Stevens 5674 11 new reg CR6583 NUREG/CR-6583 Gary Stevens 5675 16 thermal couple thermocouple Chairman Lawrence McDade 5675 18 DR. LAHEY MR. GRAY n/a 5675 19 thermal couple thermocouple Dr. Richard Lahey 5678 24 brian.lusignan@ag.ny.gov John.Sipos@ag.ny.gov n/a Lisa.Kwong@ag.ny.gov Mihir.Desai@ag.ny.gov 5681 11 came from the LAR came from the LRA Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5683 5 in account into account Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 35

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 5685 19-20 This is one example. This is one example I gave you Chairman I gave you yesterday about the yesterday about the Fen. Lawrence McDade Fen.

5686 16 they refuse the original they reduce the original Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5686 21 Adjusted it lower They adjusted it lower Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5687 3 in especially would it especially would Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5688 2 you assume number of you assume a number of Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5689 15 wrongly so even wrongly did so even Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5689 18 component started falling components started falling Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5690 24 forth that cause forth that causes Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5692 4 Has to base It has to be based Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5692 12 attacks on the experts attacks and the experts Kathryn Sutton 5693 15 Dr. Lahey bring an issue Dr. Lahey brings an issue Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5694 14 affects the initiation time the initiation time Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5694 16 Section 11 Section XI Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5695 20 concentration the same. concentration is the same. Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 36

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 5696 18 you had bout those you had about those Judge Michael Kennedy 5697 14 and subtracted the minimum and subtract the minimum Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5697 17 yes. It affects Yes, it affects Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5699 4 both that past both the past Mark Gray 5700 3 a dimensionalist parameter a dimensionless parameter Mark Gray 5703 3 Section 3 Section III Nelson Azevedo 5704 1 Section 11 Section XI Jack Strosnider 5705 13 suggesting the number suggesting is that the number Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5705 14 ASME code will the ASME code will Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5705 23 with the whole LAR, with the whole LRA Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5705 25 in the original LAR in the original LRA Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5711 14 Section 11 Section XI Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5711 15-16 the way are described by Dr. -- the way they are described by Dr. Dr. Joram Chopra Hopenfeld 5711 21 stress corrosion occurring stress corrosion is occurring Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5712 6 fatigue like fatigue life Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5713 8 of the ACRS a whole of the ACRS asked a whole Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 37

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 5715 10 cracking, metal cracking, and metal Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5716 17-18 fraction mechanic fracture mechanics Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5716 21 they doing theyre doing Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5717 24 synergistically mean synergistically means Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5722 1 addressing the Fen should be addressing the Fen, that it should Dr. Joram corrected by stress be corrected for stress Hopenfeld 5722 2 corrosion crack corrosion cracking Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5722 8 literature that say literature that says Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5722 10 Fen was not the Fen was not adjusted for the Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5723 6 LI-600 Alloy 600 Nelson Azevedo 5724 3 actually experienced at the plant have actually experienced at the Judge Richard plant Wardwell 5729 10-11 avoid that at all possible avoid that if at all possible Judge Richard Wardwell 5732 6 go directly to outside go directly outside Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5735 24 which I Can find which I can find Mark Gray 5737 24 Section 1073 Section 10.7.3 Mark Gray 5739 6 thermal couples thermocouples Mark Gray 5739 19 a I mentioned before as I mentioned before Mark Gray 38

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 5741 2-3 thermal coupling thermocouples Chairman Lawrence McDade 5741 10 thermal couple data thermocouple data Mark Gray 5741 21 CN PAFN 0921 CN-PAFM-09-21 Mark Gray 5742 3-4 give us general life here give us a general idea here Chairman Lawrence McDade 5742 6 MB 3228 NB 3228 Mark Gray 5742 11 MB 3228 NB 3228 Mark Gray 5742 13 MB 3228 NB 3228 Mark Gray 5742 20-21 analysis of MB 3200, MB 3228.5 analysis of NB 3200, NB 3228.5 Mark Gray 5742 22 K-E Ke Mark Gray 5748 11 As you know form As you know from Chairman Lawrence McDade 5753 18 theres an indication Theres an indication Chairman Lawrence McDade 5754 9 may not be the correct work may not be the correct word Dr. Allen Hiser 5756 25 includes then doing includes them doing Chairman Lawrence McDade 5758 2 5059 50.59 Alan Cox 5758 16 time to renewal timely renewal Sherwin Turk 5758 22-23 time to renewal timely renewal Sherwin Turk 5759 11 this is This is Jack Strosnider 5760 11 5059 50.59 Jack Strosnider 5761 6 It basically when Its basically when Mark Gray 5761 10 MB 3222.4(e)(5) NB 3222.4(e)(5) Mark Gray 39

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 5762 22 your pre-file your pre-filed Chairman Lawrence McDade 5763 1 Dr. Hopenfeld, Can you Dr. Hopenfeld, can you Judge Richard Wardwell 5763 16 that was accounted that was accounted for Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5763 25 judgement judgment Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5764 22 injuring judgments engineering judgments Dr. Richard Lahey 5770 20 renewed license may be a renewed license may be Dr. Allen Hiser 5771 8 The concept provide The concept provides Chairman Lawrence McDade 5771 13 can assume based cant assume based Chairman Lawrence McDade 5772 11 they did for IP3 they did for IP2 Chairman Lawrence McDade 5772 14 reasonable insurance. reasonable assurance. Chairman Lawrence McDade 5773 6 you raises is you raise is Chairman Lawrence McDade 5774 12 Mr. Dolansky, Can Mr. Dolansky, can Chairman Lawrence McDade 5775 3-4 with open case letters such as an with lower case letters such as an o Bob Dolansky O or a C or an E, not something or a c or an e, not something with with like a P or a Q that has a tail like a p or a q that has a tail 5776 17 Section 11 Section XI Bob Dolansky 5776 23 SPR-LR SRP-LR Chairman Lawrence McDade 40

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 5777 2 SPR SRP Bob Dolansky 5777 23 SPR-LR SRP-LR Chairman Lawrence McDade 5777 24 8.1-6 to 8.1-7 A.1-6 to A.1-7 Chairman Lawrence McDade 5778 9 Entergy pre-file Entergy pre-filed Bob Dolansky 5781 15 thru-wall crack through-wall crack Jack Strosnider 5785 2 analysis of a thru crack analysis of a through crack Dr. Richard Lahey 5788 16 And as you know, it -- And as you know -- Dr. Richard Lahey 5789 5 MR. LOTT DR. LOTT n/a 5789 8 repot report Dr. Randy Lott 5789 11 taken undertaken Dr. Randy Lott 5789 17 we do not predict we did not predict Dr. Randy Lott 5789 25 consider LOCA forces on the consider LOCA forces on the Dr. Randy Lott failed --the divider failed structure -- the divider 5790 3 on the -- that would be afforded on the structure -- that would be Dr. Randy Lott afforded 5793 2 nave have Chairman Lawrence McDade 5793 20 I, you know As, you know Dr. Richard Lahey 5799 3 exp0lain explain Chairman Lawrence McDade 5799 7 It was a It had a Barry Gordon 5799 9-10 didnt have an optimized didnt have as optimized Barry Gordon microstructure as the thermally- microstructure as the thermally-treated tubes are treated tubes 41

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 5802 4 said really when said earlier when Bob Dolansky 5803 20 cold warping is cold working is Chairman Lawrence McDade 5804 11 usually loose usually lose Dr. David Duquette 5805 25 properties across plate properties across the plate Dr. David Duquette 5808 23 US experience U.S. experience Dr. David Duquette 5809 19 any cracks form there any cracks form they Dr. David Duquette 5810 18 reactor that was put generator that was put Dr. David Duquette 5810 22 any evidence in that any evidence of that Dr. David Duquette 5811 10 have been so far have been performed so far Dr. David Duquette 5811 19 cold warp layer cold work layer Dr. David Duquette 5811 20 cold warp layer cold work layer Dr. David Duquette 5817 20 in the US fleet in the U.S. fleet Dr. David Duquette 5834 9 you gave me on to look you gave me was to look Dr. Richard Lahey 5834 10 thermal couple thermocouple Dr. Richard Lahey 5836 5 my shock yesterday my statement yesterday Dr. Richard Lahey 5836 15 because of these two because of the two Dr. Richard Lahey 5837 2-3 thermal coupled thermocouple Dr. Richard Lahey 42

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 5837 16 thermal couple thermocouple Dr. Richard Lahey 5838 4 on the center itself on the sensor itself Dr. Richard Lahey 5838 20 thermal couple thermocouple Dr. Richard Lahey 5839 3 thermal couples thermocouples Judge Michael Kennedy 5839 9 thermal couple thermocouple Judge Michael Kennedy 5840 12 thermal couple thermocouple Judge Michael Kennedy 5840 18 thermal couple thermocouple Mark Gray 5840 19 thermal couples thermocouples Mark Gray 5842 8-9 thermal couple thermocouple Mark Gray 5844 4 thermal couple thermocouple Judge Michael Kennedy 5845 18 thermal couple thermocouple Mark Gray 5845 20 infinite decimal infinitesimal Mark Gray 5845 23 thermal couple thermocouple Mark Gray 5846 5 thermal couple thermocouple Mark Gray 5848 4-5 use of thermal couple data use of thermocouple data Judge Michael Kennedy 5850 11 coarse spray line nozzle core spray line nozzle Dr. Richard Lahey 5851 25 RDDs RTDs Nelson Azevedo 5856 15 your pre-file testimony your pre-filed testimony Chairman Lawrence McDade 5862 18 brand now. brand new. Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 43

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 5865 14 accelerator corrosion accelerated corrosion Nelson Azevedo 5865 20-21 accelerator corrosion accelerated corrosion Nelson Azevedo 5865 23 accelerator corrosion accelerated corrosion Nelson Azevedo 5866 4 Section 3 Section III Nelson Azevedo 5866 6 flow accelerator corrosion, thats flow accelerated corrosion, thats Nelson Azevedo designed to a P31.1 designed to a B31.1 5866 22 around the band around the bend Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5866 24 around the band around the bend Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5867 1 factors that has to be factors that have to be Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5867 2 Another affect Another effect Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5867 7 they accept -- they escaped -- Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5871 7 not reach 1.0 not reached 1.0 Alan Cox 5871 18 least 10001 if we put least 1.0001 if we put Dr. Joram Hopenfeld 5872 19 I don want I dont want Judge Michael Kennedy 5880 22 New York in that New York at that John Sipos 5881 19 commissioner Commissioners John Sipos 5887 8-9 What the statement was made What the statement made Dr. Joram yesterday, all this was taken in the yesterday, was that all this was Hopenfeld code taken into account in the code 44

Page Line Now Reads Should Read Witness/Speaker 5889 25 primary waters, not for the primary water, not for the Nelson Azevedo secondary waters secondary water 5892 23 for checking up here for trekking up here John Sipos 45

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION In the Matter of )

)

ENTERGY NUCLEAR OPERATIONS, INC. ) Docket Nos. 50-247-LR

) and 50-286-LR (Indian Point Nuclear Generating, )

Units 2 and 3) )

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that copies of the foregoing ORDER (Adopting Jointly Proposed Transcript Corrections; Rejecting the State of New Yorks Proposed Corrections) have been served upon the following persons by Electronic Information Exchange.

U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Edward L. Williamson, Esq.

Office of Commission Appellate Adjudication Beth N. Mizuno, Esq.

Mail Stop O-7H4M David E. Roth, Esq.

Washington, DC 20555-0001 Sherwin E. Turk, Esq.

ocaamail@nrc.gov Brian Harris, Esq.

Mary B. Spencer, Esq.

U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Anita Ghosh, Esq.

Office of the Secretary of the Commission Christina England, Esq.

Mail Stop O-16C1 Catherine E. Kanatas, Esq.

Washington, DC 20555-0001 Joseph Lindell, Esq.

hearingdocket@nrc.gov John Tibbetts, Paralegal U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Office of the General Counsel Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel Mail Stop O-15D21 Mail Stop T-3F23 Washington, DC 20555-0001 Washington, DC 20555-0001 edward.williamson@nrc.gov beth.mizuno@nrc.gov; sherwin.turk@nrc.gov; Lawrence G. McDade, Chair brian.harris.@nrc.gov; Administrative Judge david.roth@nrc.gov; mary.spencer@nrc.gov lawrence.mcdade@nrc.gov anita.ghosh@nrc.gov; christina.england@nrc.gov; Richard E. Wardwell catherine.kanatas@nrc.gov; Administrative Judge joseph.lindell@nrc.gov; richard.wardwell@nrc.gov john.tibbetts@nrc.gov Michael F. Kennedy OGC Mail Center Administrative Judge OGCMailCenter@nrc.gov michael.kennedy@nrc.gov William B. Glew, Jr.

Alana Wase, Law Clerk Organization: Entergy alana.wase@nrc.gov 440 Hamilton Avenue, White Plains, NY 10601 wglew@entergy.com Julie Reynolds-Engel, Law Clerk Julie.Reynolds-Engel@nrc.gov

Docket Nos. 50-247-LR and 50-286-LR ORDER (Adopting Jointly Proposed Transcript Corrections; Rejecting the State of New Yorks Proposed Corrections)

Elise N. Zoli, Esq. Melissa-Jean Rotini, Esq.

Goodwin Proctor, LLP Assistant County Attorney Exchange Place, 53 State Street Office of Robert F. Meehan, Boston, MA 02109 Westchester County Attorney ezoli@goodwinprocter.com 148 Martine Avenue, 6th Floor White Plains, NY 10601 Daniel Riesel, Esq. mjr1@westchestergov.com Victoria Shiah Treanor, Esq.

Adam Stolorow, Esq. Bobby Burchfield, Esq.

Natoya Duncan, Paralegal Matthew Leland, Esq.

Counsel for Town of Cortlandt Emre Ilter, Esq.

Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C. McDermott, Will and Emery LLP 460 Park Avenue 500 North Capitol Street NW New York, NY 10022 Washington, DC 20001 driesel@sprlaw.com; vtreanor@sprlaw.com bburchfield@mwe.com astolorow@sprlaw.com; nduncan@sprlaw.com mleland@mwe.com eilter@mwe.com Kathryn M. Sutton, Esq.

Paul M. Bessette, Esq. Matthew W. Swinehart, Esq.

Martin J. ONeill, Esq. Covington & Burling LLP Raphael Kuyler, Esq. 1201 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW Brooke McGlinn, Esq. Washington, DC 20004 Grant Eskelsen, Esq. mswinehart@cov.com Ryan Lighty, Esq.

Lesa G. Williams-Richardson, Legal Secretary Manna Jo Greene, Environmental Director Doris Calhoun, Legal Secretary Steven C. Filler Mary Freeze, Legal Secretary Peter A. Gross Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, LLP Hudson River Sloop Clearwater, Inc.

1111 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW 724 Wolcott Ave.

Washington, DC 20004 Beacon, NY 12508 ksutton@morganlewis.com mannajo@clearwater.org; martin.oneill@morganlewis.com stephenfiller@gmail.com; rkuyler@morganlewis.com; peter@clearwater.org lescher@morganlewis.com bmcglinn@morganlewis.com Andrew Reid, Esq.

sraimo@morganlewis.com Organization: Hudson River Sloop geskelsen@morganlewis.com Clearwater, Inc.

rlighty@morganlewis.com Springer & Steinberg, P.C.

lrichardson@morganlewis.com 1600 Broadway, Suite 1200 dcalhoun@morganlewis.com Denver, CO 80202 mfreeze@morganlewis.com lawyerreid@gmail.com Ramona Cearley, Secretary Richard Webster, Esq.

Riverkeeper, Inc. Public Justice, P.C.

20 Secor Road For Hudson River Sloop Clearwater, Inc.

Ossining, NY 10562 1825 K Street, NW, Suite 200 rcearley@riverkeeper.org Washington, D.C. 20006 rwebster@publicjustice.net 2

Docket Nos. 50-247-LR and 50-286-LR ORDER (Adopting Jointly Proposed Transcript Corrections; Rejecting the State of New Yorks Proposed Corrections)

Michael J. Delaney, Esq. John J. Sipos, Esq.

Director, Energy Regulatory Affairs Lisa S. Kwong, Esq.

NYC Department of Environmental Protection Brian Lusignan, Esq.

59-17 Junction Boulevard Mihir Desai, Esq.

Flushing, NY 11373 Assistant Attorneys General mdelaney@dep.nyc.gov Teresa Manzi, Legal Assistant Siobahn Blank, Legal Assistant Office of the Attorney General Robert D. Snook, Esq. of the State of New York Assistant Attorney General The Capitol, State Street Office of the Attorney General Albany, New York 12224 State of Connecticut john.sipos@ag.ny.gov 55 Elm Street lisa.kwong@ag.ny.gov P.O. Box 120 brian.lusignan@ag.ny.gov Hartford, CT 06141-0120 mihir.desai@ag.ny.gov robert.snook@po.state.ct.us teresa.manzi@ag.ny.gov siobahn.blank@ag.ny.gov David A. Repka, Esq.

Victoria Hsia, Esq. Kathryn M. DeLuca, Esq.

Carlos L. Sisco, Paralegal Laura Heslin, Esq.

Winston & Strawn Assistant Attorneys General 1701 K Street NW Office of the Attorney General Washington, DC 20006 of the State of New York drepka@winston.com 120 Broadway, 26th Floor vhsia@winston.com New York, New York 10271 CSisco@winston.com kathryn.deluca@ag.ny.gov laura.heslin@ag.ny.gov Sean Murray, Mayor Kevin Hay, Village Administrator Village of Buchanan Municipal Building 236 Tate Avenue Buchanan, NY 10511-1298 smurray@villageofbuchanan.com administrator@villageofbuchanan.com

[Original signed by Brian Newell ]

Office of the Secretary of the Commission Dated at Rockville, Maryland this 3rd day of February, 2016 3