ML15043A377
| ML15043A377 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | SHINE Medical Technologies |
| Issue date: | 02/06/2015 |
| From: | Bynum R Shine Medical Technologies |
| To: | Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| Lynch S | |
| References | |
| SHINE, SHINE.SUBMISSION.8, SHN.PSAR.P, SHN.PSAR.P.3 | |
| Download: ML15043A377 (22) | |
Text
Chapter 19 - Environmental Review Table of Contents SECTION
19.6 CONCLUSION
S Table of Contents Section Title Page
19.6 CONCLUSION
S.................................................................................................19.6-1 19.6.1 UNAVOIDABLE ADVERSE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS............................19.6-1 19.6.2 RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN SHORT-TERM USES AND LONG-TERM PRODUCTIVITY OF THE ENVIRONMENT....................................................19.6-13 19.6.3 IRREVERSIBLE AND IRRETRIEVABLE COMMITMENTS OF RESOURCES .................................................................................................19.6-15 SHINE Medical Technologies 19.6-i Rev. 0
Chapter 19 - Environmental Review List of Tables List of Tables Number Title 19.6.1-1 Construction-Related Unavoidable Adverse Environmental Impacts 19.6.1-2 Operations-Related Unavoidable Adverse Environmental Impacts 19.6.3-1 United States Inventories for Minerals Used in Construction SHINE Medical Technologies 19.6-ii Rev. 0
Chapter 19 - Environmental Review List of Figures List of Figures Number Title None SHINE Medical Technologies 19.6-iii Rev. 0
Chapter 19 - Environmental Review Acronyms and Abbreviations Acronyms and Abbreviations Acronym/Abbreviation Definition ac. acre BMP best management practice ha hectare kg kilogram LOS level of service NOx nitrogen oxides OSHA Occupational Safety and Health Administration ROI Region of Influence SH State Highway SHINE SHINE Medical Technologies, Inc.
SWPPP Storm Water Pollution Prevention Plan US U.S. Highway WDNR Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources WHS Wisconsin Historical Society SHINE Medical Technologies 19.6-iv Rev. 0
Chapter 19 - Environmental Review Unavoidable Adverse Environmental Impacts CHAPTER 19
19.6 CONCLUSION
S 19.6.1 UNAVOIDABLE ADVERSE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS Unavoidable adverse impacts are predicted adverse environmental impacts that cannot be avoided and for which there are no practical means of further mitigation. This section considers unavoidable adverse impacts from construction and operation of the proposed SHINE Medical Technologies, Inc. (SHINE) facility.
19.6.1.1 Unavoidable Adverse Environmental Impacts of Construction Construction impacts and measures and controls available to reduce or eliminate impacts are discussed in detail in Section 19.4. As described in the section, all impacts are SMALL, as they are either not detectable or are minor compared to the availability of the affected resources.
Table 19.6.1-1 summarizes construction-related impacts that result in a measurable loss or permanent change in resources, the mitigation and control measures available to reduce those impacts, and the remaining unavoidable adverse impacts after mitigation and control measures are applied. For many of the impacts related to construction activities, the mitigation measures are referred to as best management practices (BMPs). Typically, these mitigation measures are based on the types of activities that are to be performed. The mitigation measures are implemented through permitting requirements, and plans and procedures developed for the construction activities.
Unavoidable adverse impacts from construction of the SHINE facility include changing land use on 25.67 acres (ac.) (10.39 hectares [ha]) of agricultural/cultivated crop land to industrial facilities, the conversion of prime farmland and farmland of statewide importance to industrial land, and partial obstruction of views of the existing landscape. Since there are no streams, ponds, or water bodies present on the SHINE site, potential construction-related impacts to water resources are limited to off-site impacts associated with runoff and siltation.
Impacts to agricultural/cultivated crop land from construction of the facility are mitigated by returning lands within the site boundary that surround the interior developed areas to either cultivated fields or restored native landscapes upon completion of construction. To minimize impacts to visual resources, landscaping of the site along U.S. Highway 51 (US 51) street frontage and bordering access road will be performed. Open spaces around the facility structures are vegetated with cool-season lawn and shrub borders. Impacts from stormwater runoff are mitigated with stormwater management plans and BMPs during construction.
Construction activities also temporarily impact 14.54 ac. (5.88 ha) of agricultural lands used for the construction parking area, construction material staging or lay down area, and water and sewer line installation. Temporary impact areas are either returned to agriculture or restored with either cool-season grasses or native prairie.
Construction activities result in unavoidable localized increases in air emissions and noise.
Activities associated with the use of construction equipment may result in varying amounts of dust, air emissions, noise, and vibration that may potentially impact both on-site workers and off-site residents of the community. Potential noise impacts also include traffic noise associated with the construction workforce traveling to and from the SHINE site, particularly during shift SHINE Medical Technologies 19.6-1 Rev. 0
Chapter 19 - Environmental Review Unavoidable Adverse Environmental Impacts changes. Emissions from construction activities and equipment are minimized through implementation of mitigation measures, including proper maintenance of construction equipment and vehicles. Posted speed limits, traffic control and administrative measures, such as staggered shift hours, will reduce traffic noise during the weekday business hours. By implementation of mitigation measures, emissions and noise impacts associated with construction activities are temporary and localized at and near the SHINE site.
19.6.1.2 Unavoidable Adverse Environmental Impacts of Operations Operational impacts and measures and controls available to reduce or eliminate impacts are discussed in detail in Section 19.4. As described in the section, all impacts are SMALL, as they are either not detectable or are minor compared to the availability of the affected resources.
Table 19.6.1-2 summarizes operations-related impacts that result in a measurable loss or permanent change in resources, the mitigation and control measures available to reduce these impacts, and the remaining adverse impacts after mitigation and control measures are applied.
As indicated in Table 19.6.1-2 most of the adverse impacts are either avoidable or negligible after mitigation and control measures are considered.
Unavoidable adverse impacts from operation of the SHINE facility include a change to the viewshed, potential storm water runoff to the intermittent stream or Rock River, and infrequent bird collisions with buildings. Minor visual impacts to the viewshed will occur as a result of the main building and exhaust vent stack. However, the surrounding viewshed includes light industrial development, therefore impacts are minor. Stormwater runoff during plant operation is controlled through a vegetated on-site detention swale. Infrequent bird collisions with buildings at the SHINE facility and associated structures may result in some bird mortality. Most buildings on the SHINE site have a relatively low profile, therefore effects on bird populations from collisions with buildings is minimized.
The operation of the SHINE facility will result in a slight degradation in the level of service (LOS) at the signalized intersection of US 51 and State Highway (SH) 11. Specifically, the westbound SH 11 to southbound US 51 left-turning movement is affected during the morning peak hour.
This condition is easily mitigated by optimizing the signal timing for this turning movement, which will improve the LOS to its existing level.
19.6.1.3 Summary of Adverse Environmental Impacts from Construction and Operations Tables 19.6.1-1 and 19.6.1-2 indicate that all of the adverse environmental impacts associated with the new facility construction and operation are SMALL and are further reduced through the application of mitigation and control measures.
Most of the impacts from construction and operation are SMALL due to design features that result in lower levels of impacts, BMPs that control and mitigate emissions and discharges to air and water, use of agricultural/cultivated crop lands that were previously altered or disturbed, and applicable federal and state permitting requirements designed to protect humans and biota.
These SMALL impacts generally have no detectable adverse impacts or only minor adverse impacts.
SHINE Medical Technologies 19.6-2 Rev. 0
Chapter 19 - Environmental Review Unavoidable Adverse Environmental Impacts Table 19.6.1-1 Construction-Related Unavoidable Adverse Environmental Impacts (Sheet 1 of 6)
Unavoidable Adverse Environmental Element Adverse Impact Mitigation Measure Impacts Land Use and Visual Construction of new facility will permanently Construction activities comply with all relevant A total of 25.67 ac. (10.39 ha) of agricultural/
Resources impact 25.67 ac. (10.39 ha) of agricultural/ federal, state, and local regulatory cultivated crop land is lost.
cultivated crop land. requirements, including BMPs and stormwater management plans to control erosion and Amount of prime farmland or farmland of Impacts include conversion of prime farmland runoff. statewide importance lost is minor in context and farmland of statewide importance to of region.
industrial land. Impacts to agricultural/cultivated crop land are mitigated by returning lands within the site boundary that surround the interior developed areas to cultivated fields or restored native landscapes or cool-season grasses upon construction completion.
Partial obstruction of views of the existing Visual impacts are minimized through A minor change in existing landscape is landscape. landscaping of the site. Open spaces around expected.
the facility structures are vegetated with cool-season lawn and shrub borders.
Temporary impact of 14.54 ac. (5.88 ha) of Temporary impact areas are either returned to Some localized short-term impacts to agricultural lands used for construction agriculture or restored with either cool-season temporary impact areas are expected.
parking area, construction material staging or grasses or native prairie.
lay down area, and water and sewer line installation.
SHINE Medical Technologies 19.6-3 Rev. 0
Chapter 19 - Environmental Review Unavoidable Adverse Environmental Impacts Table 19.6.1-1 Construction-Related Unavoidable Adverse Environmental Impacts (Sheet 2 of 6)
Unavoidable Adverse Environmental Element Adverse Impact Mitigation Measure Impacts Geologic Resources Potential local adverse impacts due to Geologic resources at the site are the same Unavoidable adverse environmental impacts excavation and other construction related throughout the region and do not include any are not anticipated.
activities. unique or rare geological resources.
No mitigation measures beyond compliance with local building codes are anticipated as no significant impacts due to large scale or local hazards are identified.
Water Use All public water supplies in Rock County are Water and sewer utility lines will be installed Unavoidable adverse environmental impacts sourced from groundwater. Additional needs by the City of Janesville in support of the are not anticipated.
during construction are identified and are overall TIF development on the north side of satisfied under existing system capacities. the site. No additional upgrades or mitigation measures are expected.
Water Quality Potential impacts are limited to off-site areas BMPs will be used in accordance with the Unavoidable adverse environmental impacts and are associated with runoff and siltation Storm Water Pollution Prevention Plan are not anticipated.
into roadside swales. (SWPPP) as required by the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources (WDNR) to prevent sediment runoff and subsequent siltation in off-site areas during construction.
Terrestrial Ecology Wildlife potentially affected by construction, Area is routinely disturbed for agriculture and Unavoidable adverse environmental impacts includes bird, mammal, and/or herpetofauna there are no water resources on-site, therefore are not anticipated.
species. wildlife use of the site is low.
SHINE Medical Technologies 19.6-4 Rev. 0
Chapter 19 - Environmental Review Unavoidable Adverse Environmental Impacts Table 19.6.1-1 Construction-Related Unavoidable Adverse Environmental Impacts (Sheet 3 of 6)
Unavoidable Adverse Environmental Element Adverse Impact Mitigation Measure Impacts Terrestrial Ecology, There is a potential for bird collisions with Based on findings of NUREG-1437, the Unavoidable adverse environmental impacts contd man-made structures such as cranes and effects of avian collisions with man-made are not anticipated.
buildings during construction. structures occur at very low frequencies.
Artificial lighting could create or exacerbate an For any nighttime construction, BMPs such as Unavoidable adverse environmental impacts avian-collision hazard if tall cranes are shielding and appropriate directional lighting are not anticipated.
illuminated during nighttime construction. are used to mitigate the hazards to wildlife associated with artificial nighttime illumination.
Potential impacts to state or federal Consultation identified state and federally Unavoidable adverse environmental impacts threatened/endangered species or species of listed species in the region, however none on are not anticipated.
special concern identified within the region. the SHINE site.
None of the listed species were observed on-site during field reconnaissance surveys.
Sensitive species located in off-site riparian areas could be affected indirectly during construction via stormwater runoff from the site. The use of appropriate BMPs during construction combined with the distance to the nearest off-site areas minimizes impacts to any protected species.
Aquatic Ecology Potential impacts are limited to off-site areas BMPs will be used in accordance with the Unavoidable adverse environmental impacts associated with runoff and siltation into the SWPPP as required by the WDNR to prevent are not anticipated.
small intermittent stream and Rock River. sediment runoff and subsequent siltation in receiving streams during construction.
SHINE Medical Technologies 19.6-5 Rev. 0
Chapter 19 - Environmental Review Unavoidable Adverse Environmental Impacts Table 19.6.1-1 Construction-Related Unavoidable Adverse Environmental Impacts (Sheet 4 of 6)
Unavoidable Adverse Environmental Element Adverse Impact Mitigation Measure Impacts Socioeconomics There is a minor potential increase in the local Estimated population increases are relatively Unavoidable adverse environmental impacts population and associated increased demand small compared to the population in the ROI. are not anticipated.
for local public services, schooling, housing, Increases in local tax revenues support and land. increased services. Specific measures and controls are not needed as impacts are minor.
Potential impacts in traffic infrastructure and Construction-related traffic does not affect the Unavoidable adverse environmental impacts patterns due to increased traffic from level of service anywhere in the transportation are not anticipated.
construction-related vehicles. infrastructure and no modifications to the infrastructure are necessary.
Human Health Potential impacts to the general public and BMPs including dust control plans are Minor localized increases in air emissions will construction workforce include dust and other implemented during construction to minimize occur, mostly at and near the SHINE site.
air emissions during construction. fugitive dust.
Radiation Exposure Potential adverse impacts to the general Exposure is minimized through safe handling Unavoidable adverse environmental impacts public and construction workforce from the procedures and robust Radiation Protection are not anticipated.
construction and handling of isotope and ALARA Programs.
production equipment and supplies.
Air Quality Activities associated with the use of BMPs and dust control plans are used for Minor localized increases in air emissions will construction equipment may result in varying controlling fugitive dust. occur, mostly at and near the SHINE site.
amounts of dust, air emissions, noise, and vibration and may potentially impact both on- Proper maintenance of construction Detectable changes to local meteorology are site workers and off-site residents of the equipment and vehicles is used to control air not anticipated.
community. emissions.
SHINE Medical Technologies 19.6-6 Rev. 0
Chapter 19 - Environmental Review Unavoidable Adverse Environmental Impacts Table 19.6.1-1 Construction-Related Unavoidable Adverse Environmental Impacts (Sheet 5 of 6)
Unavoidable Adverse Environmental Element Adverse Impact Mitigation Measure Impacts Air Quality, contd Painting, coating and similar operations also Contractors, vendors, and subcontractors will Unavoidable adverse environmental impacts generate emissions from the use of volatile adhere to appropriate federal and state are not anticipated.
organic compounds. occupational health and safety regulations.
On-site equipment use and traffic due to Potential air quality impacts are limited as the Unavoidable adverse environmental impacts construction activities can result in local project is in an attainment area and is largely are not anticipated.
increases in emissions. surrounded by agricultural fields and other undeveloped areas.
Noise Potential impacts due to increase in noise On-site noise level exposure is controlled Unavoidable adverse environmental impacts levels from construction equipment, including through appropriate training, personnel are not anticipated.
to nearby residences, churches, and protective equipment, periodic health and recreational areas. safety monitoring, and industry good practices.
Noise levels from equipment are expected attenuate rapidly between the site and the nearest sensitive noise receptors.
Potential increase in traffic noise associated Posted speed limits, traffic control and Potential noise impacts are intermittent and with construction workforce traveling to and administrative measures, such as staggered limited primarily to shift changes.
from the SHINE site, particularly during shift shift hours reduces traffic noise during changes. weekday business hours.
Environmental There is potential for adverse impacts to low- Populations classified as low income are Unavoidable adverse environmental impacts Justice income and minority populations. distant from the site not impacted by the are not anticipated.
SHINE facility.
SHINE Medical Technologies 19.6-7 Rev. 0
Chapter 19 - Environmental Review Unavoidable Adverse Environmental Impacts Table 19.6.1-1 Construction-Related Unavoidable Adverse Environmental Impacts (Sheet 6 of 6)
Unavoidable Adverse Environmental Element Adverse Impact Mitigation Measure Impacts Historic and Cultural No adverse impacts on cultural or historic A Phase I study was performed and the Unavoidable adverse environmental impacts Resources resources have been identified. Wisconsin Historical Society (WHS) reviewed are not anticipated.
the findings and indicated that no further consultation is needed.
SHINE Medical Technologies 19.6-8 Rev. 0
Chapter 19 - Environmental Review Unavoidable Adverse Environmental Impacts Table 19.6.1-2 Operations-Related Unavoidable Adverse Environmental Impacts (Sheet 1 of 4)
Element Adverse Impact Mitigation Measure Unavoidable Adverse Environmental Impacts Land Use and Visual Visual impacts as a result of the main building The majority of the facility structures have a Minor impacts to viewscape will occur, Resources and exhaust vent stack. relatively low profile. The exhaust vent stack however the surrounding viewshed includes will extend to 96 feet (29 meters) above grade. similar light industrial development, therefore No mitigation is required. impacts are small.
Geologic Resources Potential impacts from sediment erosion at the The primary soils present at the site are Unavoidable adverse environmental impacts site. classified as slightly erodible and the are not anticipated.
secondary soils are classified as moderately erodible. No mitigation is required.
Water Use Potential impact on water supply for the region The City of Janesville has determined the Unavoidable adverse environmental impacts based on demand from SHINE facility. current system has more than enough are not anticipated.
capacity to support the increase in demand.
No mitigation is required.
Water Quality Potential impacts from stormwater runoff to A vegetated on-site detention swale is used to Mitigation measures in combination with the the intermittent stream or Rock River. control stormwater runoff. distance to the water bodies will minimize runoff and siltation to off-site areas.
Terrestrial Ecology Possible exposure of terrestrial fauna and Herbicides are applied per an integrated pest Unavoidable adverse environmental impacts flora to herbicides due to vegetation management plan and applicable permit/BMP are not anticipated.
management practices may occur. requirements.
Infrequent bird collisions with buildings Most buildings on the SHINE site have a Effects on bird populations from collisions with resulting in mortality can occur. relatively low profile, minimizing bird collisions. buildings are minimized and are not anticipated to be significant.
SHINE Medical Technologies 19.6-9 Rev. 0
Chapter 19 - Environmental Review Unavoidable Adverse Environmental Impacts Table 19.6.1-2 Operations-Related Unavoidable Adverse Environmental Impacts (Sheet 2 of 4)
Unavoidable Adverse Environmental Element Adverse Impact Mitigation Measure Impacts Aquatic Ecology Potential impacts from stormwater runoff to A vegetated on-site detention swale is used to Mitigation measures in combination with the the off-site intermittent stream or Rock River. control storm water runoff. distance to the water bodies will minimize runoff and siltation to off-site receiving streams.
Socioeconomics An increase in the Region of Influence (ROI) Adequate housing, school capacity, water Unavoidable adverse environmental impacts population of 0.08 percent will occur to supply and water treatment capacities exist to are not anticipated.
support the operations workforce, potentially accommodate minor population increase; impacting social services. therefore, mitigation is not required.
Potential beneficial impacts to tax revenues to There is an increase in tax revenues collected Unavoidable adverse environmental impacts Janesville and Rock County. by county and regional taxing authorities are not anticipated.
which does have beneficial impacts.
No mitigation is required.
Increased traffic along US 51 coming from the Traffic impacts are mitigated by optimizing the By optimizing signal timing at the intersection, north, resulting in a slight decrease in LOS at signal timing at the intersection to the LOS for the intersection is improved to its the intersection of US 51 and SH 11 during accommodate a greater turning movement existing level.
morning peak hour. from westbound SH 11 to southbound US 51.
Human Health Potential pathways of public exposure to Control systems to minimize potential Unavoidable adverse environmental impacts chemicals include air, land, and water. exposure to the public include conveyance of are not anticipated.
all wastewater produced from the facility to the City of Janesville wastewater treatment facility, use of swales to control off-site runoff, erosion control measures, and air emission controls.
SHINE Medical Technologies 19.6-10 Rev. 0
Chapter 19 - Environmental Review Unavoidable Adverse Environmental Impacts Table 19.6.1-2 Operations-Related Unavoidable Adverse Environmental Impacts (Sheet 3 of 4)
Unavoidable Adverse Environmental Element Adverse Impact Mitigation Measure Impacts Radiation Exposure Potential adverse impacts to the general Site shielding design of the buildings Unavoidable adverse environmental impacts public and operations workforce from isotope minimizes radiation exposure of the public are not anticipated.
production and associated waste. outside the buildings. Exposure of the workforce is minimized through compliance with OSHA standards.
Air Quality Increased vehicle emissions and dust from the The volume of traffic during operations is Unavoidable adverse environmental impacts commuting workforce and routine deliveries considerably lower than during construction. are not anticipated.
to/from the SHINE facility. Vehicles are largely limited to paved areas, reducing the emissions of fugitive dust.
Emissions from the natural gas-fired boiler Emissions of nitrogen oxides (NOx) from the No impacts exceed the primary ambient air and heaters. boiler are controlled using low-NOx burners, quality standards that are established to which produces lower NOx emissions during protect public health; therefore unavoidable adverse environmental impacts are not the combustion process.
anticipated.
Emissions from the heaters are controlled using combustion controls and properly designed and tuned burners.
Noise Noise generated during operations relates The number of work-related trips is minor Unavoidable adverse environmental impacts primarily to vehicular movements associated relative to the existing traffic flow on US 51 are not anticipated.
with employees and deliveries. and does not result in notable increased noise emissions.
External noise emissions from the SHINE Operational noise from the facility is primarily Unavoidable adverse environmental impacts facility during operation may impact limited by the walls and other physical barriers are not anticipated.
surrounding sensitive noise receptors. of the facility itself.
SHINE Medical Technologies 19.6-11 Rev. 0
Chapter 19 - Environmental Review Unavoidable Adverse Environmental Impacts Table 19.6.1-2 Operations-Related Unavoidable Adverse Environmental Impacts (Sheet 4 of 4)
Unavoidable Adverse Environmental Element Adverse Impact Mitigation Measure Impacts Environmental No adverse impacts on minority or low-income Level of impact is comparable for all Impacts to low income and minority Justice populations have been identified. populations and mitigation is not required. populations are not anticipated.
Historic and Cultural No adverse impacts on cultural or historic A Phase I study was performed and the WHS Unavoidable adverse environmental impacts Resources resources have been identified. reviewed the findings and indicated that no are not anticipated.
further consultation is needed.
SHINE Medical Technologies 19.6-12 Rev. 0
Chapter 19 - Environmental Review Relationship Between Short-Term Uses and Long-Term Productivity of the Environment 19.6.2 RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN SHORT-TERM USES AND LONG-TERM PRODUCTIVITY OF THE ENVIRONMENT This Environmental Report focuses on the analyses and resulting conclusions associated with the environmental impacts from activities during the new plant construction and operation at the SHINE site. These activities are considered short-term uses for purposes of this section. In this section, the long-term is considered to be initiated with the conclusion of new facility decommissioning at the SHINE site. This section includes an evaluation of the extent that the short-term uses preclude any options for future long-term use of the SHINE site.
19.6.2.1 Construction of the SHINE Facility and Long-Term Productivity Subsection 19.6.1.1 summarizes the potential unavoidable adverse environmental impacts of construction and the measures proposed to reduce those impacts. Some SMALL adverse environmental impacts could remain after all practical measures to avoid or mitigate them are taken. However, none of these impacts represent long-term effects that preclude any options for future use of the SHINE site.
The acreage disturbed during construction of the facility is larger than that required for the actual structures and other ancillary facilities because of the need for construction parking areas, and construction material staging and laydown areas. Preparation of these on-site areas coupled with noise from construction activities, may displace some wildlife and alter existing vegetation.
Once the new facility is completed, the areas not needed for operations are returned to agricultural land or restored with either cool-season grasses or native prairie.
Construction of the SHINE facility includes the installation of water and sewer lines that connect the facility to the City of Janesville water supply system. This additional infrastructure will be available and beneficial to any future use of the SHINE site after decommissioning.
Noise emitted by some construction activities increases the ambient noise levels on-site and in adjacent off-site areas. During construction, the workforce is protected from excessive noise levels by adherence to the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) requirements within high noise environments. There are no effects on the long-term productivity of the SHINE site as a result of these impacts.
Construction traffic increases the volume of traffic on local roads, but does not have an adverse impact on the LOS. Consequently, no modifications to the traffic infrastructure are necessary and there are no effects on long-term productivity.
Facility construction has beneficial socioeconomic effects on the local area such as new construction-related jobs, local spending by the construction workforce, and payment of taxes within the area and region. The in-migration of the construction and operation workforce support the expansion of existing small businesses or locations for new small businesses that might serve SHINE and its employees. The beneficial impacts from the in-migration of the construction workforce and indirect economic output and employment resulting from construction expenditures to the communities within the region of influence (ROI) cease once construction is complete. However, the changes that are the result of increased tax revenues continue throughout the operational life of the facility.
SHINE Medical Technologies 19.6-13 Rev. 0
Chapter 19 - Environmental Review Relationship Between Short-Term Uses and Long-Term Productivity of the Environment Construction of the SHINE facility will have no impacts on populations identified as minority or low-income as minority populations are lacking within the region around the SHINE site, and low income populations are limited to isolated areas in the center of Janesville. Therefore, there are no effects on the long-term productivity of the SHINE site as a result of impacts on environmental justice.
19.6.2.2 Operation of the SHINE Facility and Long-Term Productivity Subsection 19.6.1.2 summarizes the potential unavoidable adverse environmental impacts of operation and the measures proposed to reduce or eliminate those impacts. Some SMALL adverse environmental impacts could remain after all practical measures to avoid or mitigate them are taken. However, none of these impacts represent long-term effects that preclude any options for future use of the SHINE site.
The SHINE site is located in an area that has previously been disturbed for agricultural use and is currently zoned for industrial use as an amendment to the Tax Increment Financing No. 35 Project Plan. Therefore, operation of the new facility represents a continuation of the planned land use. Once the facility is decommissioned to Nuclear Regulatory Commission standards, the land could be available for other industrial or non-industrial uses.
During operation, noise levels are expected to decrease to ambient levels as facility-generated noise is limited by the walls and other physical barriers of the facility itself. Operation of the new facility will slightly increase air emissions from the boiler and stacks. The equipment is operated in accordance with applicable federal, state, and local regulations, and is not expected to result in any long-term decrease in regional air quality. Preliminary modeling shows that for all pollutants except for the 1-hour nitrogen oxides (NOx), the maximum concentrations are below the Significant Impact Level.
Operation of the SHINE facility will have a comparable impact on all populations in the region around the site. No impacts are expected to either minority or low income populations as minority populations are lacking within the region around the SHINE site, and low income populations are limited to isolated areas in the center of Janesville. Therefore there are no long-term effects to environmental justice that preclude any options for future use of the SHINE site.
19.6.2.3 Summary of the Relationship Between Short-Term Use and Long-Term Productivity The impacts resulting from the SHINE facility construction and operation result in both adverse and beneficial short-term impacts. The principal short-term adverse impacts are SMALL residual impacts (after mitigation measures are implemented) to land use, terrestrial ecology, local traffic, and air quality. There are no long-term impacts to the environment. The principal short-term benefits are the creation of additional jobs, additional tax revenues, and improvements to local infrastructure. The principal long-term benefit is the continued availability of the improved infrastructure and potential benefits from increased tax revenues after facility decommissioning.
The short-term impacts and benefits and long-term benefits do not affect long-term productive use of the SHINE site.
SHINE Medical Technologies 19.6-14 Rev. 0
Chapter 19 - Environmental Review Irreversible and Irretrievable Commitments of Resources 19.6.3 IRREVERSIBLE AND IRRETRIEVABLE COMMITMENTS OF RESOURCES This subsection describes the expected irreversible and irretrievable environmental resource commitments used in the new facility construction and operation. The term irreversible commitments of resources describes environmental resources that are potentially changed by the new facility construction or operation and that could not be restored at some later time to the resources state prior to construction or operation. Irretrievable commitments of resources are generally materials that are used for the new facility in such a way that they could not, by practical means, be recycled or restored for other uses.
19.6.3.1 Irreversible Environmental Commitments of Resources Irreversible environmental resource commitments resulting from the new facility, in addition to the materials used for radioisotope production are described in the following sections.
19.6.3.1.1 Land Use The land used for the SHINE facility is not irreversibly committed because once SHINE ceases operations and the facility is decommissioned in accordance with Nuclear Regulatory Commission requirements, the land supporting the facilities could be returned to other industrial or nonindustrial uses. There is no storage or disposal of radioactive and nonradioactive wastes at the site. Medical isotopes are not stored for any significant time period as these items are transported to clients as quickly as possible. Irradiated enriched uranium is not an issue as the facility cleans up and recycles this material rather than storing spent nuclear fuel. Approximately 26 ac. (10.5 ha) of prime farmland or farmland of statewide importance on the SHINE site could be irreversibly converted to developed land or experience surface soil damage during temporary use such that the soil properties responsible for the prime farmland designation would be irreversibly damaged.
19.6.3.1.2 Hydrologic Resources The new facility requires water from the Janesville Water Utility to use for construction, isotope production, potable water, fire protection, and facility heating and cooling. The City of Janesville provides water supply for both public drinking and fire protection through groundwater wells. The average estimated water usage by the SHINE facility during operations is 6070 gallons (22,977 L) per day and a consumptive water use of 1560 gallons (5905 L) per week. According to the city of Janesville, the total pumping capacity of its eight groundwater wells is 29 Mgd (109.8 Mld).
Average water usage is about 11 Mgd (41.6 Mld). Accordingly, the excess capacity of the Janesville water supply system is approximately 18 Mgd (68.1 Mld). Because there is excess capacity within the Janesville water supply system, there are no indirect effects associated with the demand from the SHINE facility. There are no direct impacts to water quality or hydrology from the SHINE facility; therefore there will be no irreversible impacts.
19.6.3.1.3 Ecological Resources Long-term irreversible losses of terrestrial biota are not anticipated. Subsequent to the completion of construction, floral and faunal resources are expected to recover in areas that are not affected by on-going operations. Floral resources at the site and in the region are limited to agricultural/cultivated crop plants. Losses of fauna due to operations are primarily attributable to SHINE Medical Technologies 19.6-15 Rev. 0
Chapter 19 - Environmental Review Irreversible and Irretrievable Commitments of Resources bird collisions with buildings at the facility as wildlife occurrence on the site is relatively infrequent. There are no wetlands or water bodies located at the SHINE site.
All water for the SHINE facility is provided by the Janesville Water Utility, therefore, water supply intake or cooling water intake structures on the Rock River are not needed. Thus, there are no operational impacts associated with impingement or entrainment of aquatic biota. Furthermore, the SHINE facility does not discharge directly into the Rock River or any other nearby water body thus, avoiding any impacts associated with pollutant or thermal discharges to aquatic resources.
In addition, a vegetated on-site detention swale is used to control stormwater runoff which, when combined with the distance to the nearest off-site water bodies minimizes runoff and siltation to off-site receiving streams.
19.6.3.1.4 Socioeconomic Resources No irreversible commitments will be made to socioeconomic resources because they are reallocated for other purposes once the facility is decommissioned.
19.6.3.1.5 Historic and Cultural Resources No known historic or cultural resources are irreversibly altered due to the SHINE facility.
19.6.3.1.6 Air Quality Dust and other emissions, such as vehicle exhaust, are released to the air during construction activities. Implementation of controls and limits at the source of emissions on the construction site result in reduction of impacts off-site. The dust control program reduces dust due to construction activities to minimize dust reaching site boundaries. Specific mitigation measures are discussed in Subsection 19.4.2.1.1. During operations, emissions will be a product of vehicle exhaust, isotope production, and fuel combustion resulting in very low levels of gaseous pollutants and particulates released from the facility into the air. Contractors, vendors, and subcontractors are required to adhere to appropriate federal and state occupational health and safety regulations to protect workers from adverse conditions, including air emissions.
Emissions during operations are in compliance with applicable Federal and State regulations, minimizing their impact on public health and the environment.
19.6.3.1.7 Irretrievable Commitments of Resources Irretrievable commitments of resources during new plant construction are generally similar to that of any small-scale medical facility construction project. Unlike previous industrial construction, asbestos and other materials considered hazardous are not used or are used sparingly and in accordance with safety regulations and practices. Materials consumed during the construction phase are shown in Table 19.2.0-1. These materials are irretrievable unless they are recycled at decommissioning. Additionally, approximately 24,587 gallons of diesel fuel (as a bounding assumption all fuel is assumed to be diesel) is expected to be used on an average monthly basis (Subsection 19.2.0). Use of construction materials in the quantities associated with the facility has a SMALL impact with respect to the availability of such resources.
SHINE Medical Technologies 19.6-16 Rev. 0
Chapter 19 - Environmental Review Irreversible and Irretrievable Commitments of Resources During operations, the main resource that is irreversibly and irretrievably committed is the uranium used as the source for the molybdenum isotope. The amount of uranium that SHINE will require on an annual basis and over the lifetime of the operating license (assuming a 30-year operating license) is very small when compared to the amount consumed by other users and the total global supply of uranium. The World Nuclear Association studies of supply and demand of uranium indicate that a total of 5,327,200 metric tons of uranium were available in 2011, representing an 80-year supply of uranium at current market prices based on known resources (World Nuclear Association, 2012). This could increase to a 200-year supply as market prices rise and other conventional sources of uranium are used. Therefore, the uranium that is used to generate the medical radioisotopes has a negligible impact with respect to the long-term availability of uranium worldwide.
The inventories of minerals used in the construction of power plants, as tabulated by the U.S.
Census Bureau for 2000, 2008, and 2009, are shown in Table 19.6.3-1. The table also provides estimated inventories for 2010. Aluminum supplies have dropped since 2000 from 3,688,000 metric tons in 2000 to 1,727,000 metric tons in 2009 and have remained reasonably stable from 2009 to 2010. The supply of most other minerals has remained reasonably stable since 2000, with only minor fluctuations in availability during 2008 to 2010. The reasonably stable supply of minerals suggests that they will continue to be available for the foreseeable future in response to demand.
While a given quantity of material consumed during new facility construction and operation at the SHINE site is irretrievable, except for materials recycled during decommissioning, the impact on their availability is SMALL.
SHINE Medical Technologies 19.6-17 Rev. 0
Chapter 19 - Environmental Review Irreversible and Irretrievable Commitments of Resources Table 19.6.3-1 United States Inventories for Minerals Used in Construction Year Minerals 2000 2008 2009 2010 Inventory in 1000 Metric Tons by Year Aluminum 3688 2658 1727 1720 Copper 1450 1310 1180 1120 Lead 449 399 406 385 Titanium 300 200 200 200 Zinc 796 748 710 699 Inventory in Million Metric Tons by Year Iron Ore 61 54 28 50 Portland Cement 84 83 62 61 Masonry Cement 4 3 2 2 Construction Sand and Gravel 1120 1040 844 760
Reference:
US Census Bureau, 2012 SHINE Medical Technologies 19.6-18 Rev. 0