ML14176A384
| ML14176A384 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Robinson  |
| Issue date: | 04/14/1988 |
| From: | Lo R Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8804200300 | |
| Download: ML14176A384 (22) | |
Text
DISTRIBUTION Docket No. 50-261 See attached sheet LICENSEE:
Carolina Power & Light Company (CP&L)
FACILITY:
H. B. Robinson 2
SUBJECT:
MEETINGCSUMMNY ONERVIEW A THE H B ROBINSON STEAM ELECTRIC PLAN, UNI 2 -
MARCH 22, 198A The subject meeting was held between Gus Lainas, Elinor Adensam, Ronnie Lo of NRR and the on-site management staff of the licensee for Robinson. The purpose of the meeting was for the licensee to introduce the key management personnel and brief the NRR staff on the status of the Robinson facility. A copy of the viewgraphs used by the licensee is attached as Attachment 1.
The licensee presented an overview of the operations at Robinson with special emphasis in the following areas: (1) Programs for equipment enhancement, (2) Programs for personnel enhancement, and (3) management actions to improve performance.
Operation at Robinson is currently restricted to 60% power because of Safety Injection System vulnerability to single failure of the electrical distribution system. The presentation included a discussion of the licensee's plan to resolve this situation for operations at higher power levels.
The meeting was followed by a plant tour by the NRR staff. The agenda of the tour is attached (Attachment 2).
Ronnie Lo, Project Manager Project Directorate II-1 Division of Reactor Projects I/II
Attachment:
As stated cc:
See next page OFFICIAL RECORD COPY OFC
- PM:PD21:D PR:D:b 21/DRPR NAME :RLo:clh
- EAdensam DATE :4/1L/88
- 4/)88 804200300 880414 PDR ADOCK 05000261 P
PDR _ _
Mr. E. E. Utley Carolina Power & Light Company H. B. Robinson 2 cc:
Mr. R. E. Jones, General Counsel Mr. Dayne H. Brown, Chief Carolina Power & Light Company Radiation Protection Branch P. 0. Box 1551 Division of Facility Services Raleigh, North Carolina 27602 Department of Human Resources 701 Barbour Drive Raleigh, North Carolina 27603-2008 Mr. McCuen Morrell, Chairman Darlington County Board of Supervisors Mr. Robert P. Gruber County Courthouse Executive Director Darlington, South Carolina 29535 Public Staff -
NCUC P.O. Box 29520 Mr. H. A. Cole Raleigh, North Carolina 27626-0520 Special Deputy Attorney General State of North Carolina P.O. Box 629 Raleigh, North Carolina 27602 Mr. D. E. Hollar Associate General Counsel Carolina Power and Light Company P.O. Box 1551 Raleigh, North Carolina 27602 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Resident Inspector's Office H. B. Robinson Steam Electric Plant Route 5, Box 413 Hartsville, South Carolina 29550 Regional Administrator, Region II U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Suite 2900 101 Marietta Street Atlanta, Georgia 30303 Mr. R. Morgan General Manager H. B. Robinson Steam Electric Plant Post Office Box 790 Hartsville, South Carolina 29550 Mr. Avery Upchurch, Chairman Triangle J Council of Governments 100 Park Drive Post Office Box 12276 Research Triangle Park, NC Bu7709
PRESENTATION TO NRR MARCH 22, 1988 ROBINSON NUCLEAR PROJECT 0
OBJECTIVE o
FOR THE NEXT FEW MINUTES WE WILL PROVIDE AN OVERVIEW TO ADDRESS THE CHALLENGES, THE CORRECTIVE ACTION REQUIREMENTS AND THE IMPEDIMENTS FOR ACHIEVING OPERATIONAL EXCELLENCE AS THEY RELATE To EQUIPMENT, PERSONNEL, AND LEADERSHIP.
PRESENTATION TO NRR MARCH 22, 1988 ROBINSON NUCLEAR PROJECT EQUIPMENT o
STEAM GENERATOR TUBE LEAKS REPLACED STEAM GENERATOR TUBE BUNDLES CONDENSER INTEGRAL TUBE SHEETS REMOVED ALL COPPER FROM SECONDARY PLANT CONDENSER TUBES, FEEDWATER HEATER TUBES MOISTURE SEPARATOR REHEATER TUBES CONDENSATE AND HEATER DRAIN PUMP IMPELLERS FULL FLOW CONDENSATE DEMINERALIZATION ON LINE INSTRUMENTATION CHEMISTRY CONTROL EPRI GUIDELINES o
WASTE STREAM PROCESSING SELECTIVE DEMINERALIZATION EXPOSURE REDUCTION RADWASTE REDUCTION
PRESENTATION TO NRR MARCH 22, 1988 ROBINSON NUCLEAR PROJECT EQUIPMENT 0
REACTOR VESSEL PRESSURIZED THERMAL SHOCK PART LENGTH SHIELDED ASSEMBLIES o
Low PRESSURE TURBINE ROTOR CRACKING FULLY INTEGRAL ROTORS 0
EROSION/CORROSION CONTROL ACTION PLAN DEVELOPED 1985 SURRY INCIDENT EPRI REPORT NSAC 112 COMPUTER PROGRAM PREDICTS WORST AREAS ISSUED DECEMBER -
1987 (IN REVIEW NOW) 0 ELECTRICAL DISTRIBUTION SAFETY SYSTEM FUNCTIONAL INSPECTION DESIGN BASIS RECONSTITUTION CURRENT OUTAGE
PRESENTATION TO NRR MARCH 22, 1988 ROBINSON NUCLEAR PROJECT EQUIPMENT o
SERVICE WATER 500 FT. IN '88 OUTAGE 0
DIESEL GENERATORS BLOWERS VOLTAGE REGULATOR OBSOLETE AVAILABILITY OF PARTS 0
VALVE PACKING PREVENTIVE MAINTENANCE LIVE LOAD PACKING 27 IN PLACE 185 IN 1988 0
FARLEY SAFETY INJECTION SYSTEM CRACK INSPECT IN '88 OUTAGE
PRESENTATION TO NRR MARCH 221 1988 ROBINSON NUCLEAR PROJECT EQUIPMENT 0
NORTH ANNA TUBE RUPTURE DOUBLED INSPECTION SAMPLE FOR EACH GENERATOR 0
PLANT AGING EFFECT (1965 DESIGN)
UPGRADE VS. MAINTAIN DESIGN BASIS RECONSTITUTION
PRESENTATION TO NRR MARCH 22, 1988 ROBINSON NUCLEAR PROJECT PERSONNEL o
TRAINING MET MINIMUM STANDARDS ACCREDITED BY INSTITUTE OF NUCLEAR POWER OPERATIONS MAINTENANCE, RADIATION PROTECTION, ENVIRONMENTAL CHEMISTRY, OPERATIONS TOTAL OF 10 CATEGORIES SUPERVISORS AND ENGINEERS SYSTEM TRAINING SITE SPECIFIC SIMULATOR 30 SRO's WITH 85.7% PASS RATE AND 16 RO'S WITH 85.7% PASS RATE SINCE 1985 SRO LICENSED OR EQUIVALENT TRAINED STAFF AND MANAGEMENT 14 PROJECT MANAGEMENT - 200 PARTICIPANTS TOTAL QUALITY FUNDAMENTALS -
99% SITE PERSONNEL
PRESENTATION TO NRR MARCH 22, 1988 ROBINSON NUCLEAR PROJECT PERSONNEL 0
DISCIPLINE OF OPERATIONS OLDER PLANT FOSSIL BACKGROUND CODE OF ETHICS LEADER IN THE INDUSTRY TEAM EFFORT BY THREE NUCLEAR SITES HIGHLY VISIBLE 0
INDIVIDUAL ACCOUNTABILITY DECONTAMINATION CREW (6)
NONCONFORMANCE REPORTS (IDENTIFICATION OF DEFICIENCIES)
NON QA/QC PERSONNEL IDENTIFIED -
60% IN 1987 QUALITY CHECK 47 IN 1987 0
CONTRACTOR DEPENDENCE STEAM GENERATOR REPLACEMENT -
1984 REDUCE BY 54% IN 5 YEARS
PRESENTATION TO NRR MARCH 22, 1988 ROBINSON NUCLEAR PROJECT PERSONNEL o
LIMITED PROFESSIONAL GROWTH POTENTIAL DOWNSIZING 0
TRAINING/EDUCATION SPECIALIZED COMPONENT TRAINING DIESEL GENERATOR MAINTENANCE EMERGENCY RESPONSE INFORMATION SYSTEM OPERATOR DEGREE PROGRAM WITH THE UNIVERSITY OF MARYLAND INCREASE EXPERIENCE DEPTH ROTATIONAL SLOTS INPO PARTICIPATION PEER EVALUATIONS OF OTHER PLANTS 0
CONTINUED REDUCTION OF PERSONNEL ERRORS HUMAN PERFORMANCE SYSTEMS POSITIVE DISCIPLINARY ACTION COMPLACENCY
PRESENTATION TO NRR MARCH 22, 1988 ROBINSON NUCLEAR PROJECT LEADERSHIP 0
PROCEDURES WERE MARGINAL EXTENSIVE PROCEDURAL ENHANCEMENTS 0
PLANT CLEANLINESS WAS DEFICIENT REDUCED CONTAMINATED FLOOR SPACE 0
LIMITED SUPERVISORY INVOLVEMENT REQUIRED ROUTINE TOURS o
OUTAGE EXECUTION WAS MARGINAL FORMALIZED OUTAGE MANAGEMENT ORGANIZATION FORMALIZED SCHEDULING 0
HIGH CUMULATIVE SITE EXPOSURE As Low As REASONABLY ACHIEVABLE (ALARA) REVIEWS o
LIMITED PREVENTIVE MAINTENANCE ASSIGNED PM CREWS -
NOW AT 33%
GOAL IS TO EXCEED INDUSTRY AVERAGE IN 1988 o
MARGINAL ROOT CAUSE ASSESSMENT CAPABILITY PROJECT MANAGEMENT TRAINING TOTAL QUALITY FUNDAMENTALS TRAINING
PRESENTATION TO NRR MARCH 22, 1988 ROBINSON NUCLEAR PROJECT LEADERSHIP 0
IMPROVEMENT IN PERFORMANCE MONITORING REPETITIVE FAILURES DETECTION DATA PROCESSING ESCALATION OF PROBLEM AREAS 0
IMPROVEMENT IN PERFORMANCE TRIP REDUCTION RELIABILITY CENTERED MAINTENANCE EQUIPMENT DATA BASE DEVELOPMENT TRENDING SINGLE FAILURE POINTS IDENTIFICATION TOTAL QUALITY PROFESSIONALISM
PRESENTATION TO NRR MARCH 22, 1988 ROBINSON NUCLEAR PROJECT LEADERSHIP o
IMPROVEMENT IN COMMUNICATIONS NRC TEAM INSPECTIONS HIGHLY FOCUSSED -
TECHNICAL 0
INDUSTRY SHARE EXPERIENCES 0
CORPORATE -
BRUNSWICK -
HARRIS ROUTINE INFORMATION EXCHANGES 0
INSTITUTE OF NUCLEAR POWER OPERATIONS NUCLEAR PLANT RELIABILITY DATA SYSTEM
100 CAPACITY FACTOR AND AVAILABILITY FACTOR 90 EU CAPACITY FACTOR C, so AVAIL.
N 40-FACTOR T
30 0,
- 7417, 76 77 78 79 80 81 88 63 84 85 86 87 YEAR
35 CRITICAL TRIPS R
7 n71 72 7
u7 7U 78 77 83 6
M0M 25AA
9 IAUNS 40 N
U30 M
B R
10 0
8 7 80 81 83 84 85 8
87 YEAR
600 NONCONFORMANCE REPORTS N
TOTAL NCR S U
GA IDENTIFIED E
UPLANT R 20o
.IDENTIFIED 10 1,77 78 79 80 81 82 03 64 B
6 87 YEAR 78 79 so as.e...
3000 TOTAL EXPOSURE R0 2000 Eoo M:
1000 goo 4
11 7,
73 7475 78 77 787-0 83 84 as a
120000 1ecooo- -
RADWASTE SHIPPED C
60000 F
E40oooo-E 20000 7
7
.73 74 75 76 77 78 83 64 85 67
H. B. ROBINSON NRR VISIT MARCH 22-23, 1988 AGENDA March 22, 1988 1:30 p.m.
Arrive Onsite 1:30 -
2:00 Meet with Resident Inspectors 2:00 -
3:00 Entrance meeting (Room 122 EOF)
Introduction -
Guy P. Beatty, Jr., Vice President -
Robinson Nuclear Project Discussion -
Dick Morgan, General Manager -
H. B. Robinson Success Factors -
Based on Historical and Future Perspectives Equipment Challenge Personnel Performance Leadership Processes Plans for return to 100% power -
Bill Flanagan, Manager - Design Engineering 3:00 -
3:30 Badging (in Room 122) 3:30 -
5:00 Breaker Demonstation (Room 122)
Molded case breaker DB-50 breaker EOF/TSC Tour -
Dick Morgan
- SPDS Demonstration Simulator -
Charlie Bethea, Manager -
Training PEM:88-1460
March 23, 1988 0800 a.m.
Meet Room 122 for Plant Tour 0800 -
1130 Plant Tour -
Dick Morgan, General Manager Steam Generator Tomb ISFSI (Dry Fuel Storage)
Dedicated Shutdown (DS) Diesel DS Station (Turbine Bldg.)
E1-E2/Safeguards area DB-50/molded Case Breaker Application SI Logic Cabinets Station Batteries Control Room SPDS AFW Pumps Motor Driven Steam Driven Rad Waste Demineralizers DS Station (Charging Pump Room)
Service Water Piping (Sleeves)
AFW ABT Diesel Generators SI Pumps Spent Fuel Building 1130 -
1200 Exit (Room 122) 1200 Depart Site PEM:88-1460
MEETING
SUMMARY
DISTRIBUTION:
Docket File NRC PDR Local PDR PD21 r/f E. Adensam Project Manager Ronnie Lo J. Hopkins L. P. Crocker OGC-B E. Jordan J. Partlow NRC Participants ACRS (10) cc:
Licensee/Applicant Service List kh