ML12355A072

NRR E-mail Capture - FW: ME6818 - DAEC NFPA-805 Adoption - Record of Revisions to RAI Items, Expected Response Schedule, Participants List for Meetings on 17-18 December 2012

ML12355A072
Person / Time
Site:	Duane Arnold
Issue date:	12/19/2012
From:	Feintuch K Division of Operating Reactor Licensing
To:	Swenzinski L NextEra Energy Duane Arnold
References
TAC ME6818
Download: ML12355A072 (6)

Text

NRR-PMDAPEm Resource From: Feintuch, Karl Sent: Wednesday, December 19, 2012 4:08 PM To: Swenzinski, Laura Cc: Robinson, Jay; Harrison, Donnie; Litkett, Bernard; Pearson, Alayna; Hyslop, JS

Subject:

FW: ME6818 - DAEC NFPA-805 adoption - Record of revisions to RAI items, expected response schedule, Participants list for meetings on 17-18 December 2012 Attachments: RAI due dates.xlsx.xlsx.xlsx The information that follows is a combined record of the attendance and results of the meetings conducted.

NRC Participant PRA Mtg 12/17, 1000-1200 FP Mtg 12/18, 1100-1130 PRA Mtg 12/18, 1130-1200 ET ET ET Karl Feintuch, DORL X X X Steve Dinsmore, PRA X X Donnie Harrison, PRA X X Bernard Litkett, FP X Alayna Pearson, FP X Jay Robinson, FP X X JS Hyslop, PRA X DAEC Participant PRA Mtg 12/17, 1000-1200 FP Mtg 12/18, 1100-1130 PRA Mtg 12/18, 1130-1200 ET ET ET Laura Swenzinski X Jim Lechner X Andy Ratchford X (Kleinsorg Group)

Brad Hopkins X Russ Severson X Roy Hanson X Gary Ellis X Vinny Rubano X Laura Swenzinski X X Andy Ratchford X X (Kleinsorg Group)

Russ Severson X X Gary Ellis X X Vinny Rubano X X Brad Hopkins X X Mike Saunders (Erin X X Engg)

The information that follows affirms the schedule for expected responses and provides clarification to identified RAI items. A bullet mark indicates forthcoming information. Please proceed with the information provided.

RAI Response Schedule 1

The attached schedule is acceptable. For identification purposes in other documents, items due on January 11, 2013 are also identified as Round 2 RAI items and items due either February 12, 2013, or March 6, 2013, are also identified in other documents as either Round 2 (more) items, Round 3 items, and 60-day response items, or 90-day response items, as when discussing originally intended due dates.

The following RAI changes and decisions resulted from the conference calls held on 17-18 December 2012, regarding TAC No. ME6818, DAECs adoption of NFPA-805:

Fire Protection Engineering RAI 13 Fire Protection Engineering (FPE) RAI 13, item c, as it appears in an email message of November 8, 2012, sent 4:03 PM from Karl Feintuch to Laura Swenzinski, is modified as a result of the conference call on 18 December 2012 to be:

c. The Transition Report stated that the design will be based on FAQ 08-0046 (ADAMS Accession No. ML093220426) and will meet the FAQ guidance such as: sensitivity, equipment voltage restrictions, and fast versus slow acting devices in regard to fire growth. In light of your revised approach to not use FAQ 08-0046, describe how the application of an incipient detection system will be integrated with this revised approach (NUREG 6850 Appendix L, credit for defense in depth only, etc.).

For reference purposes the changes in text are described below:

The Transition Report stated that the design will be based on FAQ 08-0046 (ADAMS Accession No. ML093220426) and will meet the FAQ guidance such as: sensitivity, equipment voltage restrictions, and fast versus slow acting devices in regard to fire growth. In light of your revised approach to not use FAQ 08-0046, However, the FAQ 08-0046 was not written for panels in the Control Room D describe how the application of an incipient detection system will be integrated with the this revised approach (NUREG 6850 Appendix L, credit for defense in depth only, etc.) the requirements of FAQ 08-0046.

The following RAI items originally appeared in an email message of December 5, 2012, sent 12:23 PM from Karl Feintuch to Laura Swenzinski:

Probabilistic Risk Assessment (PRA) RAI 06.01 (and others, where understanding locations is important to understanding your responses)

To support the conference discussions DAEC supplied a sketch which would be helpful to include with your RAI responses and consider incorporating the following improvements:

1. Account for labeling of areas, rooms, doorways, features in the text of your responses with the same labeling on your sketch.

2. To simplify locating features that you discuss, consider adding a map grid (one alpha axis and one numeric axis) so you can refer to located at sketch position B-4 type descriptions. This may be valuable where exact labeling is impractical or where you are referring to different parts of the same room or different areas with the same name.

Before transmitting your response to us review your sketch and descriptions for sensitivity marking if they meet appropriate criteria.

PRA RAI 08.01 In part a. delete the third paragraph beginning and ending with: This is not a stated guidance would not be met.

PRA RAI 11.01

• A revision to part a. will be forthcoming when released.

2

PRA RAI 31.01 For your response please review Table G-1 and supply all MSOs for CIVs.

PRA RAI 35.01

• A revision will be forthcoming when released. The revision replaces sensitivity analysis with analysis PRA RAI 47.01 Change the text to address typos and incorrect reference:

In part c. the reference should be to Section 3.5.2.2, as in the items preamble. The citation of 3.5.5.5 is erroneous.

In part d. fevelopment should be development.

PRA RAI 69 All references to sensitive electronics should be to electronics 3

Hearing Identifier: NRR_PMDA Email Number: 565 Mail Envelope Properties (Karl.Feintuch@nrc.gov20121219160800)

Subject:

FW: ME6818 - DAEC NFPA-805 adoption - Record of revisions to RAI items, expected response schedule, Participants list for meetings on 17-18 December 2012 Sent Date: 12/19/2012 4:08:01 PM Received Date: 12/19/2012 4:08:00 PM From: Feintuch, Karl Created By: Karl.Feintuch@nrc.gov Recipients:

"Robinson, Jay" <Jay.Robinson@nrc.gov>

Tracking Status: None "Harrison, Donnie" <Donnie.Harrison@nrc.gov>

Tracking Status: None "Litkett, Bernard" <Bernard.Litkett@nrc.gov>

Tracking Status: None "Pearson, Alayna" <Alayna.Pearson@nrc.gov>

Tracking Status: None "Hyslop, JS" <JS.Hyslop@nrc.gov>

Tracking Status: None "Swenzinski, Laura" <Laura.Swenzinski@nexteraenergy.com>

Tracking Status: None Post Office:

Files Size Date & Time MESSAGE 5390 12/19/2012 4:08:00 PM RAI due dates.xlsx.xlsx.xlsx 13933 Options Priority: Standard Return Notification: No Reply Requested: No Sensitivity: Normal Expiration Date:

Recipients Received:

DAEC NFPA 805 RAI RESPONSE DATES RAI SUBMITTAL DATE CATEGORY #

SSA 5.01 1/11/2013 FPE 11 1/11/2013 FPE 12 1/11/2013 FMOD 2.01 1/11/2013 FMOD 04.01 1/11/2013 FMOD 05.01 1/11/2013 FMOD 07 1/11/2013 PRA 04.01 1/11/2013 PRA 62 1/11/2013 PRA 63 1/11/2013 PRA 64 1/11/2013 PRA 02.01 2/12/2013 PRA 06.01 2/12/2013 PRA 10.01 2/12/2013 PRA 12.01 2/12/2013 PRA 14.01 2/12/2013 PRA 16.01 2/12/2013 PRA 20.01 2/12/2013 PRA 31.01 2/12/2013 PRA 32.01 2/12/2013 PRA 39.01 2/12/2013 PRA 41.01 2/12/2013 PRA 43.01 2/12/2013 PRA 44.01 2/12/2013 PRA 47.01 2/12/2013 PRA 48.01 2/12/2013 PRA 55.01 2/12/2013 PRA 57.01 2/12/2013 PRA 58.01 2/12/2013 PRA 60.01 2/12/2013 PRA 65 2/12/2013 PRA 67 2/12/2013 PRA 68 2/12/2013

DAEC NFPA 805 RAI RESPONSE DATES RAI SUBMITTAL DATE CATEGORY #

PRA 70 2/12/2013 PRA 71 2/12/2013 PRA 73 2/12/2013 PRA 74 2/12/2013 PRA 75 2/12/2013 PRA 77 2/12/2013 PRA 78 2/12/2013 PRA 79 2/12/2013 PRA 80 2/12/2013 PRA 81 2/12/2013 PRA 01.01 3/6/2013 PRA 08.01 3/6/2013 PRA 11.01 3/6/2013 PRA 35.01 3/6/2013 PRA 66 3/6/2013 PRA 69 3/6/2013 PRA 72 3/6/2013 PRA 76 3/6/2013 FPE 13 3/6/2013 SSA 1.01 3/6/2013