ML120130620
| ML120130620 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | San Onofre  |
| Issue date: | 10/28/2011 |
| From: | Division of Reactor Safety IV |
| To: | Southern California Edison Co |
| References | |
| 50-361/11-301, 50-362/11-301 | |
| Download: ML120130620 (369) | |
Text
Administrative Topics Outline Facility: SONGS Units 2 and 3 Date of Examination: 10/31/11 Examination Level RO Operating Test Number: NRC Administrative Topic Type Code* Describe Activity to be Performed (see Note) 2.1.23 Ability to perform specific system and integrated plant procedures during all modes Conduct of Operations of plant operation. (4.3)
M, R (RA1)
JPM: Manually Calculate Saltwater Cooling Flow (J295A).
2.1.25 Ability to interpret reference materials, such as graphs, curves, tables, etc. (3.9)
Conduct of Operations M, R (RA2)
JPM: Determine Time until Shutdown Cooling Required (J053A2).
2.2.12 Knowledge of surveillance procedures. (3.7)
Equipment Control M, R (RA3) JPM: Perform Reactor Coolant System Flow Rate Determination (J162A2).
Radiation Control - -
2.4.39 Knowledge of RO responsibilities in Emergency Plan emergency plan implementation. (3.9)
(RA4) D, S JPM: Activate Emergency Response Data System (J158A2).
NOTE: All items (5 total) are required for SROs. RO applicants require only 4 items unless they are retaking only the administrative topics, when all 5 are required.
- Type Codes & Criteria: (C)ontrol room, (S)imulator, or Class(R)oom (D)irect from bank ( 3 for ROs; for 4 for SROs & RO retakes)
(N)ew or (M)odified from bank ( 1)
(P)revious 2 exams ( 1; randomly selected)
SONGS NRC 2011 ES-301-1 RO Admin JPM Outline Rev d.doc
Administrative Topics Outline Task Summary RA1 The applicant will manually calculate Unit 3 Saltwater Cooling (SWC) Pump 3P-112 flow to support OPERABILITY evaluation per SO23-2-8, Saltwater Cooling System Operation, Attachment 6, SWC Flow Calculation. The critical steps include calculating differential pressures and flow based on provided readings. This is a modified bank JPM.
RA2 The applicant will complete SO23-12-11, EOI Supporting Attachments, Attachment 16, Determine Time Until Shutdown Cooling Required for Unit 3. The critical steps include determining time remaining until Shutdown Cooling is required for decay heat removal and the minimum cooldown rate required to establish Shutdown Cooling entry conditions before feedwater source inventory is depleted. This is a modified bank JPM.
RA3 The applicant will perform SO23-3-3.3, RCS Flow Rate Determination, Attachment 2, RCP P Flow Calculation on Unit 2 without access to the Plant Computer System. The critical steps include determining if Acceptance Criteria is met for Reactor Coolant System flow. This is a modified bank JPM.
RA4 The applicant will activate the Emergency Response Data System (ERDS) per SO23-VIII-30, Units 2/3 Operations Leader Duties and SO23-3-2.32, Critical Functions Monitoring System. The critical steps include accessing the Plant Computer System and demonstrating both methods for connecting to the Nuclear Regulatory Commission during an emergency. This is a bank JPM.
SONGS NRC 2011 ES-301-1 RO Admin JPM Outline Rev d.doc
ES-301 Administrative Topics Outline Form ES-301-1 Facility: SONGS Units 2 and 3 Date of Examination: 10/31/11 Examination Level SRO Operating Test Number: NRC Administrative Topic Type Code* Describe Activity to be Performed (see Note) 2.1.23 Ability to perform specific system and integrated plant procedures during all modes Conduct of Operations of plant operation. (4.4)
M, R (SA1)
JPM: Manually Calculate Saltwater Cooling Flow and Determine OPERABILITY (J295A).
2.1.25 Ability to interpret reference materials, such as graphs, curves, tables, etc. (4.2)
Conduct of Operations M, R (SA2)
JPM: Determine Time until Shutdown Cooling Required and Event Reportability (J053A2).
2.2.12 Knowledge of surveillance procedures. (4.1)
Equipment Control M, R JPM: Perform Reactor Coolant System Flow Rate (SA3)
Determination and Evaluate Technical Specifications (J162A2).
2.3.11 Ability to control radiation releases (4.3).
Radiation Control N, R (SA4) JPM: Calculate Dispersion Factor for Gaseous Release (New).
2.4.41 Knowledge of the emergency action level Emergency Plan thresholds and classifications (4.6).
N, R (SA5)
JPM: Classify an Emergency Plan Event (New).
NOTE: All items (5 total) are required for SROs. RO applicants require only 4 items unless they are retaking only the administrative topics, when all 5 are required.
- Type Codes & Criteria: (C)ontrol room, (S)imulator, or Class(R)oom (D)irect from bank ( 3 for ROs; for 4 for SROs & RO retakes)
(N)ew or (M)odified from bank ( 1)
(P)revious 2 exams ( 1; randomly selected)
Page 1 of 2 SONGS NRC 2011 ES-301-1 SRO Admin JPM Outline Rev d.doc
Administrative Topics Outline Task Summary SA1 The applicant will manually calculate Unit 3 Saltwater Cooling (SWC) Pump 3P-112 flow to support OPERABILITY evaluation per SO23-2-8, Saltwater Cooling System Operation, Attachment 6, SWC Flow Calculation. The critical steps include calculating differential pressures and flow based on provided readings, and determining OPERABILITY of the Saltwater Cooling System per SO23-2-8, Saltwater Cooling System Operation, Attachment 4, Saltwater Injection Temperature vs. Minimum Saltwater Flow. This is a modified bank JPM.
SA2 The applicant will complete SO23-12-11, EOI Supporting Attachments, Attachment 16, Determine Time Until Shutdown Cooling Required for Unit 3. The critical steps include determining time remaining until Shutdown Cooling is required for decay heat removal and the minimum cooldown rate required to establish Shutdown Cooling entry conditions before feedwater source inventory is depleted. The applicant will then assess notification requirements for the event in progress per SO123-0-A7, Notification and Reporting of Significant Events. This is a modified bank JPM.
SA3 The applicant will perform SO23-3-3.3, RCS Flow Rate Determination, Attachment 2, RCP P Flow Calculation on Unit 3 without access to the Plant Computer System.
The critical steps include determining if Acceptance Criteria is met for Reactor Coolant System flow. When calculations are complete, the applicant will evaluate surveillance results to determine if Technical Specification Limiting Conditions for Operations have been met. This is a modified bank JPM.
SA4 The applicant will calculate the dispersion factor for a Gaseous Release and determine if release is desirable per SO23-8-15, Radwaste Gas Discharge, Attachment 4, Determination of Current Weather Conditions. The critical steps include calculating a chi over Q (/Q) and evaluating current weather conditions prior to approving the release. This is a new JPM.
SA5 The applicant will determine the Recognition Category, Emergency Class, and Emergency Action Level per SO123-VIII-1, Recognition and Classification of Emergencies. The critical steps include determining the Recognition Category, Emergency Class, and Emergency Action Level using the newly formatted Hot and Cold Emergency Action Level Classification Charts. This is a new JPM.
Page 2 of 2 SONGS NRC 2011 ES-301-1 SRO Admin JPM Outline Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 Facility: SONGS JPM # NRC JPM RA1 Task #141258 K/A #2.1.23 4.3 / 4.4
Title:
Manually Calculate Salt Water Cooling Flow Examinee (Print):
Testing Method:
Simulated Performance: Classroom: X Actual Performance: X Simulator:
Alternate Path: Plant:
Time Critical:
READ TO THE EXAMINEE I will explain the Initial Conditions, which steps to simulate or discuss, and provide an Initiating Cue.
When you complete the task successfully, the objective for this JPM will be satisfied.
Initial Conditions: Given the following conditions:
- Unit 3 Salt Water Cooling Pump 3P-112, is being returned to service.
- There are 12 chain links visible at the Fish Elevator Screen Well.
Initiating Cue: The Control Room Supervisor directs you to PERFORM the following:
- CALCULATE Unit 3 Saltwater Cooling (SWC) Pump 3P-112 flow per SO23-2-8, Saltwater Cooling System Operation, Attachment 6, SWC Flow Calculation.
- START at Step 2.1.
Task Standard: Utilizing SO23-2-8, calculated 3P-112 Salt Water Cooling Pump flow.
Required Materials: SO23-2-8, Salt Water Cooling System Operation, Rev. 37.
Validation Time: 15 minutes Completion Time: ________ minutes Comments:
Result: SAT UNSAT Examiner (Print / Sign): Date:
Page 1 of 6 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM RA1 Rev f.docf
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 CLASSROOM SETUP EXAMINER:
PROVIDE the examinee with a copy of:
- SO23-2-8, Salt Water Cooling System Operation.
- Attachment 6, SWC Flow Calculation.
- CONTACT the Cognizant Engineer for SWC System to obtain EMONITOR Data.
- INITIAL through Step 1.3 and ENTER Data.
- Attachment 10, SWC Operation Limitations and Specifics.
Page 2 of 6 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM RA1 Rev f.docf
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1
- Check Mark Denotes Critical Step START TIME:
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-2-8, Attachment 6.
Perform Step: 1 Record Local Pump Discharge Pressure (Pa) for the affected train 2.1 Operating Pump:
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 2 At the Fish Elevator Screen Well on the Unit that the affected SWC 2.2 Train operating pump is housed in, COUNT the number of Chain Links between the water surface and the Deck (El. 16').
- Number of Chain Links (CL):_________
Standard: ENTERED 12 as the number of Chain Links between water surface and Deck.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 3 Convert Chain Links (CL) to Length (L):
2.3
- CL X 2 feet = Length (L) ft.
- L= __________ X 2 = _________ft.
Step 2.2 Standard: CONVERTED Chain Links (CL) to Length (L) for a length of 24 feet at Step 2.3.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 4 CALCULATE Actual Pump delta pressure (Pa):
2.4
- Pa = 2.25 X (Pa) + (L) - 5
- = 2.25 X ________ + ________ - 5 = ________ ft.
Step 2.1 Step 2.3 Standard: CALCULATED 55 feet as Actual Pump Pa at Step 2.4.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 3 of 6 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM RA1 Rev f.docf
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 5 CALCULATE Pump P (PC):
2.5 * (Pc) = (Pa) + [83 - (Pt)] + 5
- = ________ + [83 - (________)] + 5 = ________ ft.
Step 2.4 Step 1.3 Standard: CALCULATED 71 feet as Pump PC at Step 2.5.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 6 Determine calculated flow by using Saltwater Cooling Pump Curve in 2.6 Step 2.7.1. Use PC (Step 2.5) to find the corresponding flow.
- Calculated Flow _________ GPM Standard: DETERMINED Saltwater Cooling Pump calculated flow between 19,000 and 19,250 GPM at Step 2.6.
Terminating Cue: This JPM is complete.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 4 of 6 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM RA1 Rev f.docf
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 STOP TIME:
Page 5 of 6 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM RA1 Rev f.docf
Appendix C JPM CUE SHEET Form ES-C-1 INITIAL CONDITIONS: Given the following conditions:
- Unit 3 Salt Water Cooling Pump 3P-112, is being returned to service.
- There are 12 chain links visible at the Fish Elevator Screen Well.
INITIATING CUE: The Control Room Supervisor directs you to PERFORM the following:
- CALCULATE Unit 3 Salt Water Cooling Pump 3P-112 flow to support OPERABILITY evaluation per SO23-2-8, Salt Water Cooling System Operation, Attachment 6, SWC Flow Calculation.
- START at Step 2.1.
Page 6 of 6 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM RA1 Rev f.docf
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 Facility: SONGS JPM # NRC JPM RA2 Task #192221 K/A #2.1.25 3.9 / 4.2
Title:
Determine Time Until Shutdown Cooling Required Examinee (Print):
Testing Method:
Simulated Performance: Classroom: X Actual Performance: X Simulator:
Alternate Path: Plant:
Time Critical:
READ TO THE EXAMINEE I will explain the Initial Conditions, which steps to simulate or discuss, and provide an Initiating Cue.
When you complete the task successfully, the objective for this JPM will be satisfied.
Initial Conditions: Given the following information:
- Unit 3 is performing SO23-12-7, Loss of Forced Circulation / Loss of Offsite Power following a Reactor trip four (4) hours ago.
- SO23-12-11, EOI Supporting Attachments, Attachment 3, Cooldown and Depressurization have been started.
- 3LI-4357B, T-120 Condensate Storage Tank level is 54%.
- 3LI-3204-1, T-121 Condensate Storage Tank level is 32%.
- Representative Core Exit Thermocouple (REP CET) temperature is 470ºF.
- T-120 and T-121 are the only feedwater sources to the Steam Generators.
Initiating Cue: The Control Room Supervisor directs you to PERFORM the following:
- COMPLETE SO23-12-11, EOI Supporting Attachments, Attachment 16, Determine Time Until Shutdown Cooling Required for Unit 3.
- DETERMINE time remaining until Shutdown Cooling is required for decay heat removal per Steps 1 through 7.
- DETERMINE minimum cooldown rate required to establish Shutdown Cooling entry conditions before feedwater source inventory is depleted per Step 8.
Task Standard: Utilizing SO23-12-11 for Unit 3, determined time until Shutdown Cooling is required and calculated minimum cooldown rate required to establish Shutdown Cooling entry conditions before Feedwater Source Inventory is depleted.
Required Materials: SO23-12-11, EOI Supporting Attachments, Rev. 12.
Validation Time: 20 minutes Completion Time: ________ minutes Comments:
Result: SAT UNSAT Page 1 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM RA2 Rev e.doc
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 Examiner (Print / Sign): Date:
Page 2 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM RA2 Rev e.doc
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 CLASSROOM SETUP EXAMINER:
PROVIDE the examinee with a copy of:
- SO23-12-11, EOI Supporting Attachments.
- Attachment 16, Determine Time Until Shutdown Cooling Required.
Page 3 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM RA2 Rev e.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1
- Check Mark Denotes Critical Step START TIME:
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-12-11, Attachment 16.
Perform Step: 1 VERIFY Feedwater Source:
1 & 1a
- Verify T120 / T121 the only current feedwater source to S/Gs.
Standard: DETERMINED T120 / T121 are the only feedwater sources to the Steam Generators per the Initial Conditions.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 2 DETERMINE T-120 inventory:
2 & 2a
- DETERMINE T-120 inventory from Table 1, CONDENSATE STORAGE TANK INVENTORY:
- Gallons in T-120 = __________
Standard: DETERMINED T-120 inventory from Table 1, Condensate Storage Tank Inventory:
- T-120 @ 54% = 241,141 = 241,141 gallons Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 3 DETERMINE T-121 inventory:
3 & 3a
- DETERMINE T-121 inventory from Table 2, CONDENSATE STORAGE TANK INVENTORY:
- Gallons in T-121 = __________
Standard: DETERMINED Unit 3 T-121 inventory from Table 1, Condensate Storage Tank Inventory by interpolating between levels of 84% and 86%.
- T-121 @ 32% = 47,562 = 47,562 gallons Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 4 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM RA2 Rev e.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 4 DETERMINE Combined inventory from both Condensate Storage 4 Tanks:
- __________ = (Gallons in T-120)
- + __________ = (Gallons in T-121)
- __________ = (TOTAL T-120 / T-121)
Standard: DETERMINED Combined inventory from both Condensate Storage Tanks:
- 241,141 gallons = in T-120
- 47,562 gallons = in T-121
- 288,703 gallons = in T-120 & T-121 Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 5 DETERMINE additional Feedwater Source Inventory:
5 & 5a
- ENTER additional Feedwater Source Inventory (provided by Shift Manager / Operations Leader):
- Feedwater Source(s): __________
- TOTAL (Gallons): __________
Standard: DETERMINED additional feedwater source inventory = 0 gallons.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 6 DETERMINE total Feedwater Source Inventory:
6 & 6a
- ENTER combined volume of all sources:
- TOTAL T-120/T-121 (step 4): __________ Gallons
- TOTAL additional (step 5): + __________ Gallons
- TOTAL Combined = __________ Gallons Standard: DETERMINED total Feedwater Source Inventory = 288,703 gallons.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 5 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM RA2 Rev e.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 7 DETERMINE time remaining until Shutdown Cooling required for 7, 7a, 7b, & 7b.1) thru decay heat removal:
7b.3)
- DETERMINE number of hours reactor has been shutdown.
- _______ Hours
- Using Figure 3, REMAINING TIME S/Gs AVAILABLE AS HEAT SINK:
- PLOT Total Feedwater Source Inventory from step 6 on the left axis.
- PLOT across to the appropriate TIME REACTOR HAS BEEN SHUTDOWN curve (refer to step 7a - values may be interpolated between curves).
- PLOT down to determine the Time (hours) S/Gs remain available as a heat sink and SDC will be required.
__________ HR (from lower axis)
Standard: DETERMINED Reactor has been shutdown four (4) hours and then DETERMINED 27 +/- 0.5 hours5.787037e-5 days <br />0.00139 hours <br />8.267196e-6 weeks <br />1.9025e-6 months <br /> is time remaining until Shutdown Cooling is required.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 8 DETERMINE minimum cooldown rate required to establish SDC 8 & 8a entry conditions before Feedwater Source Inventory is depleted:
- CALCULATE T:
- Present REP CET: _______ ºF
- SDC entry: minus 375 ºF
- T = _______ ºF Standard: DETERMINED T = 470ºF - 375ºF = 95ºF T.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 6 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM RA2 Rev e.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 9 DETERMINE minimum cooldown rate required to establish SDC 8 & 8b entry conditions before Feedwater Source Inventory is depleted:
- CALCULATE minimum cooldown rate:
- T (step 8a) = _______ ºF
- Time (step 7b.3) _______ HR
- = _______ ºF/HR Standard: DETERMINED minimum cooldown rate = 95ºF / 27 +/- 0.5 hour5.787037e-5 days <br />0.00139 hours <br />8.267196e-6 weeks <br />1.9025e-6 months <br /> =
3.4 to 3.6ºF / hour.
Terminating Cue: This JPM is complete.
Comment: SAT UNSAT STOP TIME:
Page 7 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM RA2 Rev e.doc
Appendix C JPM CUE SHEET Form ES-C-1 INITIAL CONDITIONS: Given the following information:
- Unit 3 is performing SO23-12-7, Loss of Forced Circulation / Loss of Offsite Power following a Reactor trip four (4) hours ago.
- SO23-12-11, EOI Supporting Attachments, Attachment 3, Cooldown and Depressurization have been started.
- 3LI-4357B, T-120 Condensate Storage Tank level is 54%.
- 3LI-3204-1, T-121 Condensate Storage Tank level is 32%.
- Representative Core Exit Thermocouple (REP CET) temperature is 470ºF.
- T-120 and T-121 are the only feedwater sources to the Steam Generators.
INITIATING CUE: The Control Room Supervisor directs you to PERFORM the following:
- COMPLETE SO23-12-11, EOI Supporting Attachments, Attachment 16, Determine Time Until Shutdown Cooling Required for Unit 3.
- DETERMINE time remaining until Shutdown Cooling is required for decay heat removal per Steps 1 through 7.
- DETERMINE minimum cooldown rate required to establish Shutdown Cooling entry conditions before Feedwater Source Inventory is depleted per Step 8.
Page 8 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM RA2 Rev e.doc
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 Facility: SONGS JPM # NRC JPM RA3 Task #179879 K/A #2.2.12 3.7 / 4.1
Title:
Perform Reactor Coolant System Flow Rate Determination Examinee (Print):
Testing Method:
Simulated Performance: Classroom: X Actual Performance: X Simulator:
Alternate Path: Plant:
Time Critical:
READ TO THE EXAMINEE I will explain the Initial Conditions, which steps to simulate or discuss, and provide an Initiating Cue.
When you complete the task successfully, the objective for this JPM will be satisfied.
Initial Conditions: Given the following conditions:
- Unit 2 is in MODE 1.
- Reactor Coolant System Flow Rate must be determined to comply with Technical Specifications.
- The Plant Computer System (PCS) is NOT available.
- Data was collected on the previous shift during steady state conditions.
Initiating Cue: The Control Room Supervisor directs you to PERFORM the following:
- START at Step 3.1.3.
- DETERMINE if Acceptance Criteria is met at Step 4.1.
Task Standard: Utilizing SO23-3-3.3, performed RCP P Flow Calculation, calculated total core flow, and determined Acceptance Criteria was met.
Required Materials: SO23-3-3.3, RCS Flow Rate Determination, Rev. 6-3.
Validation Time: 20 minutes Completion Time: ________ minutes Comments:
Result: SAT UNSAT Examiner (Print / Sign): Date:
Page 1 of 6 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM RA3 Rev e.doc
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 CLASSROOM SETUP EXAMINER:
PROVIDE the examinee with a copy of:
- SO23-3-3.3, RCS Flow Rate Determination.
- INITIAL Section 1.0 of Attachment 2, RCP P Flow Calculation.
- COMPLETE Steps in Attachment 2 with the following data:
Step 3.1.1:
- P001 P AVG - 124 psid
- P002 P AVG - 119 psid
- P003 P AVG - 126 psid
- P004 P AVG - 121 psid ENSURE examinee has a calculator and a ruler.
Page 2 of 6 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM RA3 Rev e.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1
- Check Mark Denotes Critical Step START TIME:
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-3-3.3, Attachment 2.
Perform Step: 1 Calculate the average RCS cold leg temperatures (TC1 and TC2) using 3.1.3 & 3.1.3.1 data from Step 3.1.1, as follows:
- TC1 = Sum of all CPC Channels TC1RAW 4
Standard: CALCULATED TC1 using the data from Attachment 2, Step 3.1.1.
- TC1 = 542ºF Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 2 Calculate the average RCS cold leg temperatures (TC1 and TC2) using 3.1.3 & 3.1.3.2 data from Step 3.1.1, as follows:
- TC2= Sum of all CPC Channels TC2RAW 4
Standard: CALCULATED TC2 using the data from Attachment 2, Step 3.1.1.
- TC2 = 542ºF Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 3 Determine the density (TC1) of the RCS cold leg temperature TC1 using 3.1.4 Attachment 12:
- TC1 =__________ lbm/ft3 Standard: DETERMINED TC1, using TC1 and Attachment 12.
- TC1 = 47.3687 Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 4 Determine the density (TC2) of the RCS cold leg temperature TC2 from 3.1.5 Attachment 12:
- TC2 =__________ lbm/ft3 Standard: DETERMINED TC2, using TC2 and Attachment 12.
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 5 Calculate the Compensated Pump Average P(Pc) for RCP P-001 3.1.6 using the following formula:
Pavg (Step 3.1.2) X (46.654 lbm/ft3)
- Pc = TC1(Step 3.1.4)
Standard: CALCULATED Pc for RCP P001 using TC1 and data from Steps 3.1.2
& 3.1.4.
- Pc = 122 +/- 0.2 PSID Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 6 Calculate the Compensated Pump Average P(Pc) for RCP P-002 3.1.7 using the following formula:
Pavg (Step 3.1.2) X (46.654 lbm/ft3)
- Pc = TC2(Step 3.1.5)
Standard: CALCULATED Pc for RCP P002 using TC2 and data from Steps 3.1.2
& 3.1.5.
- Pc = 117 +/- 0.2 PSID Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 7 Calculate the Compensated Pump Average P(Pc) for RCP P-003 3.1.8 using the following formula:
Pavg (Step 3.1.2) X (46.654 lbm/ft3)
- Pc = TC1(Step 3.1.4)
Standard: CALCULATED Pc for RCP P003 using TC1 and data from Steps 3.1.2
& 3.1.4.
- Pc = 124 +/- 0.2 PSID Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 8 Calculate the Compensated Pump Average P(Pc) for RCP P-004 3.1.9 using the following formula:
Pavg (Step 3.1.2) X (46.654 lbm/ft3)
- Pc = TC2(Step 3.1.5)
Standard: CALCULATED Pc for RCP P004 using TC2 and data from Steps 3.1.2
& 3.1.5.
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 9 Calculate the total RCS volumetric flow rate (Qt) by summing the flow 3.1.10 for each RCP. Use Pc to determine the flow from the appropriate RCP P vs. Capacity Curves, and indicate attachment used:
Unit 2
- P-001 ________ gpm Att 3
+
- P-002 ________ gpm Att 4
+
- P-003 ________ gpm Att 5
+
- P-004 ________ gpm Att 6
- Qt = ________ gpm Standard: DETERMINED the flow for each pump as follows:
- 2P001 flow = 99,000 +/- 500 GPM using Attachment 3.
- 2P002 flow = 100,500 +/- 500 GPM using Attachment 4.
- 2P003 flow = 100,000 +/- 500 GPM using Attachment 5.
- 2P004 flow = 102,000 +/- 500 GPM using Attachment 6.
- Qt = 401,500 +/- 2000 GPM.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 10 This test is considered satisfactory if the RCS Total Volumetric Flow rate 4.1 in Step 3.1.10 is > 396,000 gpm.
- YES
- NO Standard: DETERMINED flow = 401,500 GPM +/- 2000 GPM and Acceptance Criteria is YES.
Terminating Cue: This JPM is complete.
Comment: SAT UNSAT STOP TIME:
Page 5 of 6 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM RA3 Rev e.doc
Appendix C JPM CUE SHEET Form ES-C-1 INITIAL CONDITIONS: Given the following conditions:
- Unit 2 is in MODE 1.
- Reactor Coolant System Flow Rate must be determined to comply with Technical Specifications.
- The Plant Computer System (PCS) is NOT available.
- Data was collected on the previous shift during steady state conditions.
INITIATING CUE: The Control Room Supervisor directs you to PERFORM the following:
- START at Step 3.1.3.
- DETERMINE if Acceptance Criteria is met at Step 4.1.
Page 6 of 6 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM RA3 Rev e.doc
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 Facility: SONGS JPM # NRC JPM RA4 Task #186280 K/A #2.4.39 3.9 / 3.8
Title:
Activate Emergency Response Data System (ERDS)
Examinee (Print):
Testing Method:
Simulated Performance: X Classroom:
Actual Performance: Simulator: X Alternate Path: Plant:
Time Critical:
READ TO THE EXAMINEE I will explain the Initial Conditions, which steps to simulate or discuss, and provide an Initiating Cue.
When you complete the task successfully, the objective for this JPM will be satisfied.
Initial Conditions: Given the following conditions:
- A SITE AREA EMERGENCY has been declared at Unit 2 due to a Steam Generator Tube Rupture on Steam Generator E-088.
Initiating Cue: The Shift Manager directs you to PERFORM the following:
- ACTIVATE the Emergency Response Data System (ERDS) per SO23-VIII-30, Units 2 / 3 Operations Leader Duties.
Task Standard: Referred to SO23-VIII-30 to activate the Emergency Response Data System (ERDS) then utilizing SO23-3-2.32, Attachment 1, activated the Emergency Response Data System using both methods described.
Required Materials: SO23-VIII-30, Units 2/3 Operations Leader Duties, Rev. 17.
SO23-3-2.32, Critical Functions Monitoring System, Rev. 13.
Validation Time: 5 minutes Completion Time: ________ minutes Comments:
Result: SAT UNSAT Examiner (Print / Sign): Date:
Page 1 of 5 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM RA4 Rev e.doc
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 SIMULATOR SETUP EXAMINER:
PROVIDE the examinee with a copy of:
- SO23-VIII-30, Units 2/3 Operations Leader Duties.
When identified, PROVIDE the examinee with a copy of:
- SO23-3-2.32, Critical Functions Monitoring System.
EXAMINER NOTE:
- This JPM will only be performed in the Simulator.
Page 2 of 5 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM RA4 Rev e.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1
- Check Mark Denotes Critical Step START TIME:
Examiner Note: The following step is from SO23-VIII-30, Step 6.1.1.12.
Perform Step: 1 Activation 6.1 & 6.1.1.12
- Within one (1) hour of an Alert or higher classification, activate Emergency Response Data System (ERDS) to NRC Operations Center in accordance with SO23-3-2.32.
Standard: REFERRED to SO23-VIII-30, Units 2 / 3 Operations Leader Duties, Step 6.1.1.12 and DETERMINED Emergency Response Data System (ERDS) activated per SO23-3-2.22, Critical Functions Monitoring System.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-3-2.32, Attachment 1, Section 2.14.
Examiner Note: There are two methods to activate the Emergency Response Data System. JPM Steps 2, 3 and 4 describe one method and JPM Steps 5 and 6 the other method. Both methods must be demonstrated.
Perform Step: 2 From the Main Menu, select REMOTE DISPLAYS, then SELECT 2.14.1.1 ERDS.
Standard: PERFORMED the following:
- CLICKED on the REMOTE DISPLAYS icon (critical).
- OBSERVED the REMOTE DISPLAYS page opens (not critical).
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 3 of 5 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM RA4 Rev e.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 3 From the Main Menu, select REMOTE DISPLAYS, then SELECT 2.14.1.1 ERDS.
Standard: PERFORMED the following:
- CLICKED on ERDS (critical).
- OBSERVED the ERDS CONTROL page opens (not critical).
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 4 Select either NRC Connection or NRC Disconnection.
2.14.1.3 Standard: PERFORMED the following:
- OBSERVED NRC Connection Request (not critical).
- CLICKED on CONNECT button (critical).
Comment: SAT UNSAT Examiner Note: Both methods must be demonstrated to activate the ERDS.
Perform Step: 5 From the Main Menu, select the NRC icon in the upper right corner of 2.14.1.2 the screen.
Standard: PERFORMED the following:
- CLICKED on the NRC Icon on the upper right corner of the Main Menu (critical).
- OBSERVED the ERDS CONTROL page opens (not critical).
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 6 Select either NRC Connection or NRC Disconnection.
2.14.1.3 Standard: PERFORMED the following:
- OBSERVED NRC Connection Request (not critical).
- CLICKED on CONNECT button (critical).
Terminating Cue: This JPM is complete.
Comment: SAT UNSAT STOP TIME:
Page 4 of 5 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM RA4 Rev e.doc
Appendix C JPM CUE SHEET Form ES-C-1 INITIAL CONDITIONS: Given the following conditions:
- A SITE AREA EMERGENCY has been declared at Unit 2 due to a Steam Generator Tube Rupture on Steam Generator E088.
INITIATING CUE: The Shift Manager directs you to PERFORM the following:
- ACTIVATE the Emergency Response Data System (ERDS) per SO23-VIII-30, Units 2 / 3 Operations Leader Duties.
Page 5 of 5 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM RA4 Rev e.doc
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 Facility: SONGS JPM # NRC JPM SA1 Task #337743 K/A #2.1.23 4.3 / 4.4
Title:
Manually Calculate Salt Water Cooling Flow and Determine OPERABILITY Examinee (Print):
Testing Method:
Simulated Performance: Classroom: X Actual Performance: X Simulator:
Alternate Path: Plant:
Time Critical:
READ TO THE EXAMINEE I will explain the Initial Conditions, which steps to simulate or discuss, and provide an Initiating Cue.
When you complete the task successfully, the objective for this JPM will be satisfied.
Initial Conditions: Given the following conditions:
JPM Cue Sheet #1
- Unit 3 Salt Water Cooling Pump 3P-112, is being returned to service.
- There are 12 chain links visible at the Fish Elevator Screen Well.
Initiating Cue: The Shift Manager directs you to PERFORM the following:
- CALCULATE Unit 3 Salt Water Cooling Pump 3P-112 flow to support OPERABILITY evaluation per SO23-2-8, Salt Water Cooling System Operation, Attachment 6, SWC Flow Calculation.
- START at Step 2.1.
Initial Conditions: Given the following conditions:
JPM Cue Sheet #2
- Unit 3 is in MODE 3.
- Spent Fuel Pool level is greater than 26 feet.
- Spent Fuel Pool temperature is 80ºF.
- The last Refueling Outage was 180 days ago.
- Saltwater Cooling System injection temperature from the Circ Water Data Logger is 69ºF.
- Train A Component Cooling Water Heat Exchanger Saltwater differential pressure is 10 PSID.
Page 1 of 9 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM SA1 Rev f.doc
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 Initiating Cue: The Shift Manager directs you to PERFORM the following:
- VERIFY Unit 3 Salt Water Cooling Pump 3P-112 OPERABILITY per SO23-2-8, Salt Water Cooling System Operation, Attachment 4, Saltwater Injection Temperature vs. Minimum Saltwater Flow.
- Based on calculated SWC flow from Cue Sheet #1, DETERMINE OPERABILITY.
- START at Step 2.1.2.
Task Standard: Utilizing SO23-2-8, calculated 3P-112 Salt Water Cooling Pump flow and determined OPERABILITY of Saltwater Cooling System.
Required Materials: SO23-2-8, Salt Water Cooling System Operation, Rev. 37.
Validation Time: 20 minutes Completion Time: ________ minutes Comments:
Result: SAT UNSAT Examiner (Print / Sign): Date:
Page 2 of 9 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM SA1 Rev f.doc
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 CLASSROOM SETUP EXAMINER:
PROVIDE the examinee with a copy of:
- SO23-2-8, Salt Water Cooling System Operation.
- Attachment 4, Saltwater Injection Temperature vs Minimum Saltwater Flow.
- Attachment 6, SWC Flow Calculation.
- CONTACT the Cognizant Engineer for SWC System to obtain EMONITOR Data.
- INITIAL through Step 1.3 and ENTER Data.
- Attachment 10, SWC Operation Limitations and Specifics.
Page 3 of 9 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM SA1 Rev f.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1
- Check Mark Denotes Critical Step START TIME:
Examiner Note: Provide the examinee with copy of JPM Cue Sheet #1.
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-2-8, Attachment 6.
Perform Step: 1 Record Local Pump Discharge Pressure (Pa) for the affected train 2.1 Operating Pump:
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 2 At the Fish Elevator Screen Well on the Unit that the affected SWC 2.2 Train operating pump is housed in, COUNT the number of Chain Links between the water surface and the Deck (El. 16').
- Number of Chain Links (CL):_________
Standard: ENTERED 12 as the number of Chain Links between water surface and Deck.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 3 Convert Chain Links (CL) to Length (L):
2.3
- CL X 2 feet = Length (L) ft.
- L= __________ X 2 = _________ft.
Step 2.2 Standard: CONVERTED Chain Links (CL) to Length (L) for a length of 24 feet at Step 2.3.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 4 CALCULATE Actual Pump delta pressure (Pa):
2.4
- Pa = 2.25 X (Pa) + (L) - 5
- = 2.25 X ________ + ________ - 5 = ________ ft.
Step 2.1 Step 2.3 Standard: CALCULATED 55 feet as Actual Pump Pa at Step 2.4.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 4 of 9 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM SA1 Rev f.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 5 CALCULATE Pump P (PC):
2.5 * (Pc) = (Pa) + [83 - (Pt)] + 5
- = ________ + [83 - (________)] + 5 = ________ ft.
Step 2.4 Step 1.3 Standard: CALCULATED 71 feet as Pump PC at Step 2.5.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 6 Determine calculated flow by using Saltwater Cooling Pump Curve in 2.6 Step 2.7.1. Use PC (Step 2.5) to find the corresponding flow.
- Calculated Flow _________ GPM Standard: DETERMINED Saltwater Cooling Pump calculated flow between 19,000 and 19,250 GPM at Step 2.6.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 5 of 9 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM SA1 Rev f.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 7 Calculations and Flow value determined in Sections 2.3 through 2.6 2.7 Independently Verified by:
Standard: DETERMINED independently verified calculations already N/A.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 8 Ensure the SWC System is Operable per Attachment 4.
2.8 Standard
REFERRED to Attachment 4 to verify SWC System OPERABILITY.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Examiner Note: Provide the examinee with copy of JPM Cue Sheet #2.
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-2-8, Attachment 4.
Perform Step: 9 Monitor SWC Injection Temperature using the Circ. Water Data Logger 2.1.2 associated with the Operating SWC Pump Intake.
Standard: DETERMINED SWC Injection Temperature from Initial Conditions and ADDED 1ºF to 69ºF.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 10 Determine which curve to use in Modes 1-4 2.2.1
- If all of the following are true, then use the applicable Normal Curve:
- Spent Fuel Pool level is 26'
- Spent Fuel Pool Temperature is 95ºF
- Time elapsed since the start of the last refueling outage is 45 days Standard: DETERMINED Unit was in MODE 3 and conditions for use of Normal Curve were met.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 6 of 9 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM SA1 Rev f.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 11 Determine which curve to use in Modes 1-4 2.2.1
- If all of the following are true, then use the applicable Normal Curve:
- Spent Fuel Pool level is 26'
- Spent Fuel Pool Temperature is 95ºF
- Time elapsed since the start of the last refueling outage is 45 days Standard: REFERRED to Saltwater Injection Temperature versus Minimum Saltwater Flow Normal Curve and determined minimum flow is 17,000 +/-
100 GPM.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Examiner Note: The following step is from SO23-2-8, Attachment 6.
Perform Step: 12 Ensure the SWC System is Operable per Attachment 4.
2.8 Standard
DETERMINED SWC System is OPERABLE.
Terminating Cue: This JPM is complete.
Comment: SAT UNSAT STOP TIME:
Page 7 of 9 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM SA1 Rev f.doc
Appendix C JPM CUE SHEET #1 Form ES-C-1 INITIAL CONDITIONS: Given the following conditions:
- Unit 3 Salt Water Cooling Pump 3P-112, is being returned to service.
- There are 12 chain links visible at the Fish Elevator Screen Well.
INITIATING CUE: The Shift Manager directs you to PERFORM the following:
- CALCULATE Unit 3 Salt Water Cooling Pump 3P-112 flow to support OPERABILITY evaluation per SO23-2-8, Salt Water Cooling System Operation, Attachment 6, SWC Flow Calculation.
- START at Step 2.1.
Page 8 of 9 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM SA1 Rev f.doc
Appendix C JPM CUE SHEET #2 Form ES-C-1 INITIAL CONDITIONS: Given the following conditions:
- Unit 3 is in MODE 3.
- Spent Fuel Pool level is greater than 26 feet.
- Spent Fuel Pool temperature is 80ºF.
- The last Refueling Outage was 180 days ago.
- Saltwater Cooling System injection temperature from the Circ Water Data Logger is 69ºF.
- Train A Component Cooling Water Heat Exchanger Saltwater differential pressure is 10 PSID.
INITIATING CUE: The Shift Manager directs you to PERFORM the following:
- VERIFY Unit 3 Salt Water Cooling Pump 3P-112 OPERABILITY per SO23-2-8, Salt Water Cooling System Operation, Attachment 4, Saltwater Injection Temperature vs. Minimum Saltwater Flow.
- Based on calculated SWC flow from Cue Sheet #1, DETERMINE OPERABILITY.
- START at Step 2.1.2.
Page 9 of 9 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM SA1 Rev f.doc
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 Facility: SONGS JPM # NRC JPM SA2 Task #192973 K/A #2.1.25 3.9 / 4.2
Title:
Determine Time Until Shutdown Cooling Required and Event Reportability Examinee (Print):
Testing Method:
Simulated Performance: Classroom: X Actual Performance: X Simulator:
Alternate Path: Plant:
Time Critical:
READ TO THE EXAMINEE I will explain the Initial Conditions, which steps to simulate or discuss, and provide an Initiating Cue.
When you complete the task successfully, the objective for this JPM will be satisfied.
Initial Conditions: Given the following information:
JPM Cue Sheet #1
- Unit 3 is in MODE 1.
- At 1307, Unit 3 recognized a common cause failure of BOTH Train A and Train B HPSI Pumps.
Initiating Cue: The Shift Manager directs you to PERFORM the following:
- DETERMINE the latest time the NRC Resident Inspector can be notified per SO123-0-A7, Notification and Reporting of Significant Events.
Initial Conditions: Given the following information:
JPM Cue Sheet #2
- Unit 3 is performing SO23-12-7, Loss of Forced Circulation / Loss of Offsite Power following a Reactor trip four (4) hours ago.
- SO23-12-11, EOI Supporting Attachments, Attachment 3, Cooldown and Depressurization have been started.
- 3LI-4357B, T-120 Condensate Storage Tank level is 54%.
- 3LI-3204-1, T-121 Condensate Storage Tank level is 32%.
- Representative Core Exit Thermocouple (REP CET) temperature is 470ºF.
- T-120 and T-121 are the only feedwater sources to the Steam Generators.
Initiating Cue: The SRO Operations Supervisor directs you to PERFORM the following:
- COMPLETE SO23-12-11, EOI Supporting Attachments, Attachment 16, Determine Time Until Shutdown Cooling Required for Unit 3.
- DETERMINE time remaining until Shutdown Cooling required for decay heat removal per Steps 1 through 7.
- DETERMINE minimum cooldown rate required to establish Shutdown Cooling entry conditions before feedwater source inventory is depleted per Step 8.
Task Standard: Utilizing SO123-0-A7, determined time for notification to the NRC. Utilizing SO23-12-11 for Unit 3, determined time until Shutdown Cooling is required, calculated minimum cooldown rate required to establish Shutdown Cooling entry conditions before Feedwater Source Inventory is depleted.
Page 1 of 9 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM SA2 Rev f.docf
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 Required Materials: SO23-12-11, EOI Supporting Attachments, Rev. 12.
SO123-0-A7, Notification and Reporting of Significant Events, Rev. 15.
Validation Time: 25 minutes Completion Time: ________ minutes Comments:
Result: SAT UNSAT Examiner (Print / Sign): Date:
Page 2 of 9 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM SA2 Rev f.docf
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 CLASSROOM SETUP EXAMINER:
PROVIDE the examinee with JPM Cue Sheet #1 and MAKE the following available in the classroom:
- SO123-0-A7, Notification and Reporting of Significant Events.
When JPM Cue Sheet #1 is completed, PROVIDE JPM Cue Sheet #2.
PROVIDE the examinee with JPM Cue Sheet #2 and a copy of:
- SO23-12-11, EOI Supporting Attachments.
- Attachment 16, Determine Time Until Shutdown Cooling Required.
ENSURE examinee has a calculator.
Page 3 of 9 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM SA2 Rev f.docf
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1
- Check Mark Denotes Critical Step START TIME:
Examiner Note: Provide the examinee with copy of JPM Cue Sheet #1.
Examiner Note: The following step is from SO123-0-A7, Attachment 1.
Perform Step: 1 DETERMINE event notification requirements per SO123-0-A7, Notification and Reporting of Significant Events.
Standard: DETERMINED Entry into LCO 3.0.3 or Immediate Shutdown Action requires a one (1) hour report to the NRC Resident Inspector.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Examiner Note: Provide the examinee with copy of JPM Cue Sheet #2.
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-12-11, Attachment 16.
Perform Step: 2 VERIFY Feedwater Source:
1 & 1a
- Verify T120 / T121 the only current feedwater source to S/Gs.
Standard: DETERMINED T120 / T121 are the only feedwater sources to the Steam Generators per the Initial Conditions.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 4 of 9 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM SA2 Rev f.docf
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 3 DETERMINE T-120 inventory:
2 & 2a
- DETERMINE T-120 inventory from Table 1, CONDENSATE STORAGE TANK INVENTORY:
- Gallons in T-120 = __________
Standard: DETERMINED T-120 inventory from Table 1, Condensate Storage Tank Inventory:
- T-120 @ 54% = 241,141 = 241,141 gallons Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 4 DETERMINE T-121 inventory:
3 & 3a
- DETERMINE T-121 inventory from Table 2, CONDENSATE STORAGE TANK INVENTORY:
- Gallons in T-121 = __________
Standard: DETERMINED Unit 3 T-121 inventory from Table 1, Condensate Storage Tank Inventory by interpolating between levels of 84% and 86%.
- T-121 @ 32% = 47,562 = 47,562 gallons Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 5 DETERMINE Combined inventory from both Condensate Storage 4 Tanks:
- __________ = (Gallons in T-120)
- + __________ = (Gallons in T-121)
- __________ = (TOTAL T-120 / T-121)
Standard: DETERMINED Combined inventory from both Condensate Storage Tanks:
- 241,141 gallons = in T-120
- 47,562 gallons = in T-121
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 6 DETERMINE additional Feedwater Source Inventory:
5 & 5a
- ENTER additional Feedwater Source Inventory (provided by Shift Manager / Operations Leader):
- Feedwater Source(s): __________
- TOTAL (Gallons): __________
Standard: DETERMINED additional feedwater source inventory = 0 gallons.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 7 DETERMINE total Feedwater Source Inventory:
6 & 6a
- ENTER combined volume of all sources:
- TOTAL T-120/T-121 (step 4): __________ Gallons
- TOTAL additional (step 5): + __________ Gallons
- TOTAL Combined = __________ Gallons Standard: DETERMINED total Feedwater Source Inventory = 288,703 gallons.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 8 DETERMINE time remaining until Shutdown Cooling required for 7, 7a, 7b, & 7b.1) thru decay heat removal:
7b.3)
- DETERMINE number of hours reactor has been shutdown.
- _______ Hours
- Using Figure 3, REMAINING TIME S/Gs AVAILABLE AS HEAT SINK:
- PLOT Total Feedwater Source Inventory from step 6 on the left axis.
- PLOT across to the appropriate TIME REACTOR HAS BEEN SHUTDOWN curve (refer to step 7a - values may be interpolated between curves).
- PLOT down to determine the Time (hours) S/Gs remain available as a heat sink and SDC will be required.
__________ HR (from lower axis)
Standard: DETERMINED Reactor has been shutdown four (4) hours and then DETERMINED 27 +/- 0.5 hours5.787037e-5 days <br />0.00139 hours <br />8.267196e-6 weeks <br />1.9025e-6 months <br /> is time remaining until Shutdown Cooling is required.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 6 of 9 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM SA2 Rev f.docf
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 9 DETERMINE minimum cooldown rate required to establish SDC 8 & 8a entry conditions before Feedwater Source Inventory is depleted:
- CALCULATE T:
- Present REP CET: _______ ºF
- SDC entry: minus 375 ºF
- T = _______ ºF Standard: DETERMINED T = 470ºF - 375ºF = 95ºF T.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 10 DETERMINE minimum cooldown rate required to establish SDC 8 & 8b entry conditions before Feedwater Source Inventory is depleted:
- CALCULATE minimum cooldown rate:
- T (step 8a) = _______ ºF
- Time (step 7b.3) _______ HR
- = _______ ºF/HR Standard: DETERMINED minimum cooldown rate = 95ºF / 27 +/- 0.5 hour5.787037e-5 days <br />0.00139 hours <br />8.267196e-6 weeks <br />1.9025e-6 months <br /> =
3.4 to 3.6ºF / hour.
Terminating Cue: This JPM is complete.
Comment: SAT UNSAT STOP TIME:
Page 7 of 9 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM SA2 Rev f.docf
Appendix C JPM CUE SHEET #1 Form ES-C-1 INITIAL CONDITIONS: Given the following information:
- Unit 3 is in MODE 1.
- At 1307, Unit 3 recognized a common cause failure of BOTH Train A and Train B HPSI Pumps.
INITIATING CUE: The Shift Manager directs you to PERFORM the following:
- DETERMINE the latest time the NRC Resident Inspector can be notified per SO123-0-A7, Notification and Reporting of Significant Events.
Page 8 of 9 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM SA2 Rev f.docf
Appendix C JPM CUE SHEET #2 Form ES-C-1 INITIAL CONDITIONS: Given the following information:
- Unit 3 is performing SO23-12-7, Loss of Forced Circulation / Loss of Offsite Power following a Reactor trip four (4) hours ago.
- SO23-12-11, EOI Supporting Attachments, Attachment 3, Cooldown and Depressurization have been started.
- 3LI-4357B, T-120 Condensate Storage Tank level is 54%.
- 3LI-3204-1, T-121 Condensate Storage Tank level is 32%.
- Representative Core Exit Thermocouple (REP CET) temperature is 470ºF.
- T-120 and T-121 are the only feedwater sources to the Steam Generators.
INITIATING CUE: The SRO Operations Supervisor directs you to PERFORM the following:
- COMPLETE SO23-12-11, EOI Supporting Attachments, Attachment 16, Determine Time Until Shutdown Cooling Required for Unit 3.
- DETERMINE time remaining until Shutdown Cooling is required for decay heat removal per Steps 1 through 7.
- DETERMINE minimum cooldown rate required to establish Shutdown Cooling entry conditions before Feedwater Source Inventory is depleted per Step 8.
Page 9 of 9 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM SA2 Rev f.docf
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 Facility: SONGS JPM # NRC JPM SA3 Task #189963 K/A #2.2.12 3.7 / 4.1
Title:
Perform RCS Flow Rate Determination And Evaluate Technical Specifications Examinee (Print):
Testing Method:
Simulated Performance: Classroom: X Actual Performance: X Simulator:
Alternate Path: Plant:
Time Critical:
READ TO THE EXAMINEE I will explain the Initial Conditions, which steps to simulate or discuss, and provide an Initiating Cue.
When you complete the task successfully, the objective for this JPM will be satisfied.
Initial Conditions: Given the following conditions:
- Unit 3 is in MODE 1.
- Reactor Coolant System Flow Rate must be determined to comply with Technical Specifications.
- The Plant Computer System (PCS) is NOT available.
- Data was collected on the previous shift during steady state conditions.
Initiating Cue: The Shift Manager directs you to PERFORM the following:
- START at Step 3.1.3.
- DETERMINE if Acceptance Criteria is met at Step 4.1.
- If applicable, RECORD any required Technical Specification CONDITION, REQUIRED ACTION, and COMPLETION TIME in the Comments Section of the Surveillance.
Task Standard: Utilizing SO23-3-3.3, performed RCP P Flow Calculation, calculated total core flow, determined Acceptance Criteria was NOT met, and identify Technical Specification Limiting Conditions for Operation.
Required Materials: SO23-3-3.3, RCS Flow Rate Determination, Rev. 6-3.
Unit 3 Technical Specification LCO 3.4.1, Amendment 212.
Unit 3 Licensee Controlled Specifications (Core Operating Limits Report), Rev. 0.
Validation Time: 25 minutes Completion Time: ________ minutes Comments:
Result: SAT UNSAT Examiner (Print / Sign): Date:
Page 1 of 7 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM SA3 Rev e.doc
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 CLASSROOM SETUP EXAMINER:
PROVIDE the examinee with a copy of:
- SO23-3-3.3, RCS Flow Rate Determination.
- INITIAL Section 1.0 of Attachment 2, RCP P Flow Calculation.
- COMPLETE Steps in Attachment 2 with the following data:
Step 3.1.1:
- P001 P AVG - 126 psid
- P002 P AVG - 125 psid
- P003 P AVG - 128 psid
- P004 P AVG - 124 psid MAKE the following available in the classroom:
- Unit 3 Technical Specifications.
- Unit 3 Core Operating Limits Report.
ENSURE examinee has a calculator and a ruler.
Page 2 of 7 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM SA3 Rev e.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1
- Check Mark Denotes Critical Step START TIME:
Examiner Note: Provide the examinee with copy of JPM Cue Sheet #1.
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-3-3.3, Attachment 2.
Perform Step: 1 Calculate the average RCS cold leg temperatures (TC1 and TC2) using 3.1.3 & 3.1.3.1 data from Step 3.1.1, as follows:
- TC1 = Sum of all CPC Channels TC1RAW 4
Standard: CALCULATED TC1 using the data from Attachment 2, Step 3.1.1.
- TC1 = 542ºF Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 2 Calculate the average RCS cold leg temperatures (TC1 and TC2) using 3.1.3 & 3.1.3.2 data from Step 3.1.1, as follows:
- TC2= Sum of all CPC Channels TC2RAW 4
Standard: CALCULATED TC2 using the data from Attachment 2, Step 3.1.1.
- TC2 = 542ºF Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 3 Determine the density (TC1) of the RCS cold leg temperature TC1 using 3.1.4 Attachment 12:
- TC1 =__________ lbm/ft3 Standard: DETERMINED TC1, using TC1 and Attachment 12.
- TC1 = 47.3687 Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 4 Determine the density (TC2) of the RCS cold leg temperature TC2 from 3.1.5 Attachment 12:
- TC2 =__________ lbm/ft3 Standard: DETERMINED TC2, using TC2 and Attachment 12.
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 5 Calculate the Compensated Pump Average P(Pc) for RCP P-001 3.1.6 using the following formula:
Pavg (Step 3.1.2) X (46.654 lbm/ft3)
- Pc = TC1(Step 3.1.4)
Standard: CALCULATED Pc for RCP P001 using TC1 and data from Steps 3.1.2
& 3.1.4.
- Pc = 124 +/- 0.2 PSID Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 6 Calculate the Compensated Pump Average P(Pc) for RCP P-002 3.1.7 using the following formula:
Pavg (Step 3.1.2) X (46.654 lbm/ft3)
- Pc = TC2(Step 3.1.5)
Standard: CALCULATED Pc for RCP P002 using TC2 and data from Steps 3.1.2
& 3.1.5.
- Pc = 123 +/- 0.2 PSID Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 7 Calculate the Compensated Pump Average P(Pc) for RCP P-003 3.1.8 using the following formula:
Pavg (Step 3.1.2) X (46.654 lbm/ft3)
- Pc = TC1(Step 3.1.4)
Standard: CALCULATED Pc for RCP P003 using TC1 and data from Steps 3.1.2
& 3.1.4.
- Pc = 126 +/- 0.2 PSID Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 8 Calculate the Compensated Pump Average P(Pc) for RCP P-004 3.1.9 using the following formula:
Pavg (Step 3.1.2) X (46.654 lbm/ft3)
- Pc = TC2(Step 3.1.5)
Standard: CALCULATED Pc for RCP P004 using TC2 and data from Steps 3.1.2
& 3.1.5.
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 9 Calculate the total RCS volumetric flow rate (Qt) by summing the flow 3.1.10 for each RCP. Use Pc to determine the flow from the appropriate RCP P vs. Capacity Curves, and indicate attachment used:
Unit 3
- P-001 ________ gpm Att 7
+
- P-002 ________ gpm Att 8
+
- P-003 ________ gpm Att 9
+
- P-004 ________ gpm Att 10
- Qt = ________ gpm Standard: DETERMINED the flow for each pump as follows:
- 3P001 flow = 95,000 +/- 500 GPM using Attachment 7.
- 3P002 flow = 96,500 +/- 500 GPM using Attachment 8.
- 3P003 flow = 92,500 +/- 500 GPM using Attachment 9.
- 3P004 flow = 97,000 +/- 500 GPM using Attachment 10.
- Qt = 381,000 +/- 2000 GPM.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 10 This test is considered satisfactory if the RCS Total Volumetric Flow rate 4.1 in Step 3.1.10 is > 396,000 gpm.
- YES
- NO Standard: DETERMINED flow = 381,000 GPM +/- 2000 GPM and Acceptance Criteria is NO.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 5 of 7 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM SA3 Rev e.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 11 RECORD any required Technical Specification CONDITION, REQUIRED ACTION, and COMPLETION TIME in the Comments Section of the Surveillance.
Standard: DETERMINED entry into Technical Specification LCO 3.4.1:
- CONDITION A - RCS flow rate not within limits;
- REQUIRED ACTION A.1 - Restore parameters to within limit;
- COMPLETION TIME - Within 2 hours2.314815e-5 days <br />5.555556e-4 hours <br />3.306878e-6 weeks <br />7.61e-7 months <br /> RECORDED in Comments Section of SO23-3-3.3.
Terminating Cue: This JPM is complete.
Comment: SAT UNSAT STOP TIME:
Page 6 of 7 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM SA3 Rev e.doc
Appendix C JPM CUE SHEET Form ES-C-1 INITIAL CONDITIONS: Given the following conditions:
- Unit 3 is in MODE 1.
- Reactor Coolant System Flow Rate must be determined to comply with Technical Specifications.
- The Plant Computer System (PCS) is NOT available.
- Data was collected on the previous shift during steady state conditions.
INITIATING CUE: The Shift Manager directs you to PERFORM the following:
- START at Step 3.1.3.
- DETERMINE if Acceptance Criteria is met at Step 4.1.
- If applicable, RECORD any required Technical Specification CONDITION, REQUIRED ACTION, and COMPLETION TIME in the Comments Section of the Surveillance.
Page 7 of 7 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM SA3 Rev e.doc
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 Facility: SONGS JPM # NRC JPM SA4 Task #187721 K/A #2.3.6 2.0 / 3.8
Title:
Calculate Dispersion Factor for Gaseous Release Examinee (Print):
Testing Method:
Simulated Performance: Classroom: X Actual Performance: X Simulator:
Alternate Path: Plant:
Time Critical:
READ TO THE EXAMINEE I will explain the Initial Conditions, which steps to simulate or discuss, and provide an Initiating Cue.
When you complete the task successfully, the objective for this JPM will be satisfied.
Initial Conditions: Given the following conditions:
- Wind direction is 200º at 10 meters.
- Temperature difference between 10 and 40 meters is minus (-) 0.30ºC.
- Wind speed is 10 miles per hour at 10 meters.
Initiating Cue: The Shift Manager directs you to PERFORM the following:
- CALCULATE the Dispersion Factor for Gaseous Release and determine if release is desirable per SO23-8-15, Radwaste Gas Discharge, Attachment 4, Determination of Current Weather Conditions.
- START at Step 2.2.1.
Task Standard: Utilizing SO23-8-15, calculated the dispersion factor for a gaseous release and determined that release was desirable.
Required Materials: SO23-8-15, Radwaste Gas Discharge, Rev. 19.
Validation Time: 15 minutes Completion Time: ________ minutes Comments:
Result: SAT UNSAT Examiner (Print / Sign): Date:
Page 1 of 6 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM SA4 Rev e.doc
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 CLASSROOM SETUP EXAMINER:
PROVIDE the examinee with a copy of:
- SO23-8-15, Radwaste Gas Discharge.
- Attachment 4, Determination of Current Weather Conditions.
- Attachment 8, Radwaste Gas Discharge Limitations and Specifics.
Page 2 of 6 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM SA4 Rev e.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1
- Check Mark Denotes Critical Step START TIME:
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-8-15, Attachment 4.
Perform Step: 1 Determine desirability of release based solely on wind direction.
2.2.1 Standard
DETERMINED wind direction is UNDESIRABLE; COMPLETED remaining steps of this Attachment.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 2 Record the following information EITHER from the CR Meteorological 2.2.2 Recorders OR from CFMS (PAGE 256) AND Enter in the appropriate spaces:
Standard: RECORDED Temperature difference as -0.30ºC; Wind speed as 10 MPH; Wind direction as 200º.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 3 of 6 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM SA4 Rev e.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 3 Determine the /Q value:
2.2.3 & 2.2.3.1
- Compare the value (A) from Step 2.2 to the following chart, Determine and Check the applicable value (D), and Enter on Step 2.2.3.2.
Standard: SELECTED Line 4 -0.45 < A < -0.15 with A = -0.30.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 4 Calculate current /Q value:
2.2.3.2 Standard: CALCULATED Current /Q value as 3.4E-6.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 4 of 6 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM SA4 Rev e.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 5 Compare the current (/Q) to the ODCM value of 4.8E-6.
2.2.4 Standard
COMPARED Current /Q of 3.4E-6 to ODCM /Q of 4.8E-6.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 6 Determine the desirability of release based on the current /Q values.
2.2.5 Standard
DETERMINED Current /Q of 3.4E-6 is 4.8E-6 and Conditions are DESIRABLE.
Terminating Cue: This JPM is complete.
Comment: SAT UNSAT STOP TIME:
Page 5 of 6 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM SA4 Rev e.doc
Appendix C JPM CUE SHEET Form ES-C-1 INITIAL CONDITIONS: Given the following conditions:
- Wind direction is 200º at 10 meters.
- Temperature difference between 10 and 40 meters is minus (-) 0.30ºC.
- Wind speed is 10 miles per hour at 10 meters.
INITIATING CUE: The Shift Manager directs you to PERFORM the following:
- CALCULATE the Dispersion Factor for Gaseous Release and DETERMINE if release is desirable per SO23-8-15, Radwaste Gas Discharge, Attachment 4, Determination of Current Weather Conditions.
- START at Step 2.2.1.
Page 6 of 6 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM SA4 Rev e.doc
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 Facility: SONGS JPM # NRC JPM SA5 Task #193840 K/A #2.4.41 2.9 / 4.6
Title:
Classify an Emergency Plan Event Examinee (Print):
Testing Method:
Simulated Performance: Classroom: X Actual Performance: X Simulator:
Alternate Path: Plant:
Time Critical:
READ TO THE EXAMINEE I will explain the Initial Conditions, which steps to simulate or discuss, and provide an Initiating Cue.
When you complete the task successfully, the objective for this JPM will be satisfied.
Initial Conditions: Given the following conditions:
- Both Units are in MODE 1.
- An earthquake was felt at the plant and confirmed by the National Earthquake Information Center.
- Unisolable piping within the cubicles for the Waste Gas Decay Tanks has ruptured.
- 2RE-7865, Unit 2 Plant Ventilation Stack Airborne Radiation Monitor is reading 8.5E+05 ci/sec.
- 3RE-7865, Unit 3 Plant Ventilation Stack Airborne Radiation Monitor is reading 3.6E+05 ci/sec.
Initiating Cue: The Shift Manager directs you to PERFORM the following:
- DETERMINE the Recognition Category, Emergency Class, and Emergency Action Level per SO123-VIII-1, Recognition and Classification of Emergencies.
Task Standard: Utilizing SO123-VIII-1, determined the Recognition Category, Emergency Class, and Emergency Action Level using the SONGS Emergency Action Level Hot &
Cold Classification Charts.
Required Materials: SO123-VIII-1, Recognition and Classification of Emergencies, Rev. 34.
EPP 123-1, SONGS Emergency Classification and Event Code Charts, Rev. 0.
Validation Time: 20 minutes Completion Time: ________ minutes Comments:
Result: SAT UNSAT Examiner (Print / Sign): Date:
Page 1 of 6 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM SA5 Rev e.doc
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 CLASSROOM SETUP EXAMINER:
PROVIDE the examinee with a copy of:
- SO123-VIII-1, Recognition and Classification of Emergencies.
Page 2 of 6 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM SA5 Rev e.doc
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 Page 3 of 6 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM SA5 Rev e.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1
- Check Mark Denotes Critical Step START TIME:
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO123-VIII-1, Attachment 1.
Perform Step: 1 DETERMINE Recognition Category designator from list below:
- 1.
- A Abnormal Rad Levels / Radiological Effluent
- C Cold Shutdown / Refueling System Malfunction
- E-H Events Related to Independent Spent Fuel Storage
- F Fission Product Barrier Degradation
- H Hazards and Other Conditions Affecting Plant Safety
- S System Malfunction Standard: REFERRED to SONGS Emergency Action Levels Hot and DETERMINED the following Recognition Category is applicable:
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 2 DETERMINE Emergency Class designator from list below:
- 2.
- U Notification of Unusual Event
- A Alert
- S Site Area Emergency
- G General Emergency Standard: IDENTIFIED Emergency Class designator as ALERT based on combined 2RE-7865 & 3RE-7865 Radiation Monitor readings.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 4 of 6 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM SA5 Rev e.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 3 DETERMINE Emergency Action Level numerical designator as follows:
- 3.
- MATCH event conditions with Emergency Action Levels listed in selected Recognition Categories and subcategories;
- Based on Emergency Class, FIND highest Emergency Action Level that is applicable AND NOTE two-digit Emergency Action Level designator.
Standard: PERFORMED the following:
- DETERMINED Emergency Action Level numerical designator as 1.1 (critical).
- DETERMINED combined designation for Event as AA1.1 (not critical).
Terminating Cue: This JPM is complete.
Comment: SAT UNSAT STOP TIME:
Page 5 of 6 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM SA5 Rev e.doc
Appendix C JPM CUE SHEET Form ES-C-1 INITIAL CONDITIONS: Given the following conditions:
- Both Units are in MODE 1.
- An earthquake was felt at the plant and confirmed by the National Earthquake Information Center.
- Unisolable piping within the cubicles for the Waste Gas Decay Tanks has ruptured.
- 2RE-7865, Unit 2 Plant Ventilation Stack Airborne Radiation Monitor is reading 8.5E+05 ci/sec.
- 3RE-7865, Unit 3 Plant Ventilation Stack Airborne Radiation Monitor is reading 3.6E+05 ci/sec.
INITIATING CUE: The Shift Manager directs you to PERFORM the following:
- DETERMINE the Recognition Category, Emergency Class, and Emergency Action Level per SO123-VIII-1, Recognition and Classification of Emergencies.
Page 6 of 6 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM SA5 Rev e.doc
ES-301 Control Room / In-Plant Systems Outline Form ES-301-2 Facility: SONGS Units 2 and 3 Date of Examination: 10/31/11 Exam Level: RO SRO(I) SRO (U) Operating Test No.: NRC Control Room Systems@ (8 for RO; 7 for SRO-I; 2 or 3 for SRO-U, including 1 ESF)
System / JPM Title Type Code* Safety Function S-1 004 - Chemical and Volume Control System (New) N, S 1 Perform an Emergency Boration Restoration S-2 013 - Engineered Safety Feature Actuation System EN, M, S 2 (J268)
Reset a Control Room Isolation Signal S-3 006 - Emergency Core Cooling System (J086S2) D, S 3 Pressurize a Safety Injection Tank (RO Only)
S-4 003 - Reactor Coolant Pump System (J027FS) A, L, M, S 4-P Start a Reactor Coolant Pump S-5 059 - Main Feedwater System (J221FS) A, M, S 4-S Reset Valid Reactor Trip Override S-6 022 - Containment Cooling System (J260FS) M, S 5 Place Containment Emergency Cooling in Service S-7 062 - AC Electrical Distribution System (J266FS) A, D, S 6 Perform a Drop and Pick up Transfer of Bus 2A06 S-8 073 - Process Radiation Monitoring System (J302S) D, S 7 Bypass Containment Purge Isolation Radiation Monitor In-Plant Systems@ (3 for RO; 3 for SRO-I; 3 or 2 for SRO-U)
P-1 015 - Nuclear Instrumentation System (J003) A, E, M, R 7 Place the EPPM in Service P-2 002 - Reactor Coolant System (J253) D, E 2 Align Remote Shutdown Panel During Security Event P-3 063 - DC Electrical Distribution System (New) E, N 6 Place the Swing Battery Charger in Operation 1 of 3 SONGS NRC 2011 ES-301-2 RO & SRO JPM Outline Rev d.doc
ES-301 Control Room / In-Plant Systems Outline Form ES-301-2
@ All RO and SRO-I control room (and in-plant) systems must be different and serve different safety functions; all 5 SRO-U systems must serve different safety functions; in-plant systems and functions may overlap those tested in the control room.
- Type Codes Criteria for RO / SRO-I / SRO-U (A)lternate path 4-6 / 4-6 / 2-3 (C)ontrol room (D)irect from bank 9/8/4 (E)mergency or abnormal in-plant 1/1/1 (EN)gineered safety feature - / - / 1 (control room system)
(L)ow Power / Shutdown 1/1/1 (N)ew or (M)odified from bank including 1(A) 2/2/1 (P)revious 2 exams 3 / 3 / 2 (randomly selected)
(R)CA 1/1/1 (S)imulator NRC JPM Examination Summary Description S-1 The applicant will perform an Emergency Boration restoration per SO23-13-11, Emergency Boration of the RCS / Inadvertent Dilution or Boration, Step 4, Emergency Boration Restoration. This is a new JPM under the Chemical and Volume Control System
- Reactivity Control Safety Function. (K/A 004.A2.14 - IR 3.8 / 3.9)
S-2 The applicant will perform a reset of Control Room Isolation Signal (CRIS) per SO23-3-2.22, Engineered Safety Features Actuation System Operation, Attachment 18, CRIS/TGIS Reset and Restoration. This is a modified bank JPM under the Engineered Safety Features Actuation System - Reactor Coolant System Inventory Control Safety Function. (K/A 013.A4.02 - IR 4.3 / 4.4)
S-3 The applicant will pressurize a Safety Injection Tank per SO23-3-2.7.1, Safety Injection Tank Operation. This is a bank JPM under the Emergency Core Cooling System -
Reactor Pressure Control Safety Function. (K/A 006.A1.13 - IR 3.5 / 3.7)
S-4 The applicant will start the fourth Reactor Coolant Pump (RCP) during a Plant Startup per SO23-3-1.7, Reactor Coolant Pump Operation. The alternate path occurs when a thrust bearing high temperature alarm is received. Annunciator 56C05 - RCP P003 THRUST BRG TEMP HI, requires an RCP trip which fails at CR-56 but is successful via the 6900 Volt Electrical Distribution System at CR-63. This is a modified bank JPM under the Reactor Coolant Pump System - Heat Removal from Reactor Core Safety Function.
(K/A 003.A4.06 - IR 2.9 / 2.9)
S-5 The applicant will reset a valid Reactor Trip Override (RTO) per SO23-9-6, Feedwater Control System Operation, Section 6.5, Feedwater Control System Operation During a Valid RTO. The alternate path occurs when Steam Generator level starts to rise due to a 2 of 3 SONGS NRC 2011 ES-301-2 RO & SRO JPM Outline Rev d.doc
ES-301 Control Room / In-Plant Systems Outline Form ES-301-2 setpoint failure after the RTO is reset. This is a bank JPM under the Main Feedwater System - Secondary System Heat Removal from Reactor Core Safety Function. This is a PRA significant action. (K/A 059.A2.11 - IR 3.0 / 3.3)
S-6 The applicant will place the Containment Emergency Cooling System in service following trip of the Containment Normal Chillers per SO23-1-4.1, Containment Emergency Cooling, Section 6.1, Placing the Containment Emergency Cooling System in Service.
When the Containment Cooling Actuation Signal fails to actuate, Containment Emergency Cooling is then placed in service per Section 6.5, Placing Containment Emergency Cooling System in Service on a Component Basis. This is a modified bank JPM under the Containment Cooling System - Containment Integrity Safety Function.
(K/A 022.A4.01 - IR 3.6 / 3.6)
S-7 The applicant will perform a Drop and Pick up Transfer of Bus 2A06 per SO23-6-2, Transferring 4 kV Buses, Section 6.11, Drop and Pick up Transfer of 1E 4 KV Buses. On failure of the opposite unit breaker to transfer, the Train B Emergency Diesel Generator (EDG) is selected to repower the bus. The alternate path occurs when the EDG Breaker fails to close upon Bus transfer due to a low-voltage interlock not being met. This is a bank JPM under the AC Electrical Distribution System - Electrical Safety Function.
(K/A 062.A4.07 - IR 3.1 / 3.1)
S-8 The applicant will bypass the Containment Purge Isolation System function for a Containment Purge Isolation Radiation Monitor to allow Chemistry to change filters per SO23-3-2.24.11, Containment Radiation Monitor System Operation and SO23-3-2.36, Radiation Monitor Data Acquisition System. This is a bank JPM under the Process Radiation Monitoring System - Instrumentation Safety Function.
(K/A 073.A4.02 - IR 3.7 / 3.7)
P-1 The applicant will place the Essential Plant Parameters Monitoring (EPPM) Panel in service following a Control Room Evacuation per SO23-13-2, Shutdown From Outside the Control Room, Attachment 4 (5), 21 (31) Duties. The alternate path occurs when local control is taken and the instrument indications start to oscillate. This is a modified bank JPM under the Nuclear Instrumentation System - Instrumentation Safety Function. This is a PRA significant action. (K/A 068.AA1.12 - IR 4.4 / 4.4)
P-2 The applicant will align the Remote Shutdown Panel during a Security Event per SO23-13-25, Operator Actions During Security Events, Attachment 3, Remote Shutdown Panel Actions For Security Event. This is a bank JPM under the Reactor Coolant System
- Primary System Heat Removal from Reactor Core Safety Function.
(K/A 2.4.28 - IR 3.2 / 4.1)
P-3 The applicant will energize Vital DC Bus D1 with B021, Swing Battery Charger per SO23-6-15, Operation of 125 VDC Systems, Attachment 16, B021, Swing Battery Charger, Operations. This is a new JPM under the DC Electrical Distribution System -
Electrical Safety Function. This is a PRA significant action.
(K/A 058.AA1.01 - IR 3.4 / 3.5) 3 of 3 SONGS NRC 2011 ES-301-2 RO & SRO JPM Outline Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 Facility: SONGS JPM # NRC JPM S-1 Task #141244 K/A #004.A2.14 3.8 / 3.9 SF-1
Title:
Perform an Emergency Boration Restoration Examinee (Print):
Testing Method:
Simulated Performance: Classroom:
Actual Performance: X Simulator: X Alternate Path: Plant:
Time Critical:
READ TO THE EXAMINEE I will explain the Initial Conditions, which steps to simulate or discuss, and provide an Initiating Cue.
When you complete the task successfully, the objective for this JPM will be satisfied.
Initial Conditions: Given the following conditions:
- Unit 2 is in a MODE 3 post-trip condition.
- An Emergency Boration was initiated for two stuck Control Element Assemblies.
- SHUTDOWN MARGIN has been verified by Reactor Engineering.
Initiating Cue: The Control Room Supervisor directs you to PERFORM the following:
- PERFORM an Emergency Boration Restoration per SO23-13-11, Emergency Boration of the RCS / Inadvertent Dilution or Boration.
- START at Step 4, Emergency Boration Restoration.
Task Standard: Utilizing SO23-13-11, restored the Emergency Boration portion of the Chemical and Volume Control System to a normal alignment. Stopped BAMU Pump P-174, closed and placed in AUTO 2HV-9247, Emergency Boration Block Valve, restored BAMU Pump recirculation capability, and closed and placed in AUTO 2FV-9253, Blended Makeup to VCT Block Valve.
Required Materials: SO23-13-11, Emergency Boration of the RCS / Inadvertent Dilution or Boration, Rev. 18-1.
Validation Time: 10 minutes Completion Time: ________ minutes Comments:
Result: SAT UNSAT Examiner (Print / Sign): Date:
Page 1 of 6 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-1 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 SIMULATOR SETUP MACHINE OPERATOR:
INITIALIZE to IC-243 or any MODE 3 Initial Condition and PERFORM the following:
- VERIFY an Emergency Boration in progress and ALIGNED as follows:
- BAMU Pump P-174 - RUNNING.
- BAMU Pump P-175 - RUNNING.
- 2HV-9247, Emergency Boration Block Valve - OPEN.
- 2HV-9240, BAMU Tank T-071 to Charging Pump Gravity Feed Valve - OPEN.
- 2HV-9235, BAMU Tank T-072 to Charging Pump Gravity Feed Valve - OPEN.
- EXECUTE the following malfunctions for two stuck CEAs:
- RD2102, CEA #21 Stuck in Full-Out position.
- RD5502, CEA #55 Stuck in Full-Out position.
EXAMINER:
PROVIDE the examinee with a copy of:
- SO23-13-11, Emergency Boration of the RCS / Inadvertent Dilution or Boration.
- Step 4, Emergency Boration Restoration.
Page 2 of 6 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-1 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1
- Check Mark Denotes Critical Step START TIME:
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-13-11, Step 4.
Perform Step: 1 ENSURE Emergency Boration terminated, as follows:
4.a & 4.a.1)
- ENSURE OPEN and in AUTO 2(3)LV-0227B, VCT MT-077 Outlet Valve.
Standard: VERIFIED 2LV-0227B, Volume Control Tank Outlet Block Valve red OPEN and amber AUTO lights lit.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 2 ENSURE Emergency Boration terminated, as follows:
4.a & 4.a.2)
- ENSURE STOPPED 2(3)MP-174, BAMU Pump.
Standard: DEPRESSED 2P174 (E) BAMU Pump STOP pushbutton and OBSERVED green STOP light lit.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 3 ENSURE Emergency Boration terminated, as follows:
4.a & 4.a.3)
- ENSURE STOPPED 2(3)MP-175, BAMU Pump.
Standard: VERIFIED 2P175 (W) BAMU Pump in STOP and OBSERVED green STOP light lit.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 4 ENSURE Emergency Boration terminated, as follows:
4.a & 4.a.4)
- ENSURE CLOSED 2(3)HV-9247, Emergency Boration Block Valve.
Standard: DEPRESSED 2HV-9247, Emergency Boration Block Valve CLOSE pushbutton and OBSERVED green CLOSE light lit.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 5 ENSURE Emergency Boration terminated, as follows:
4.a & 4.a.5)
- ENSURE 2(3)HV-9247, Emergency Boration Block Valve, in AUTO.
Standard: DEPRESSED 2HV-9247, Emergency Boration Block Valve AUTO pushbutton and OBSERVED amber AUTO light lit.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 3 of 6 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-1 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 6 ENSURE Emergency Boration terminated, as follows:
4.a & 4.a.6)
- ENSURE CLOSED and in AUTO 2(3)LV-0227C, RWST Gravity Feed to Charging Pump Suction Valve.
Standard: VERIFIED 2LV-0227C, RWT 2T006 Gravity Feed Valve green CLOSE and amber AUTO lights lit.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 7 ENSURE Emergency Boration terminated, as follows:
4.a & 4.a.7)
- ENSURE CLOSED 2(3)HV-9240, BAMU Tank MT-071 to Charging Pump Gravity Feed Valve Standard: VERIFIED 2HV-9240, BAMU Tank 2T071 Gravity Feed Valve green CLOSE light lit.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 8 ENSURE Emergency Boration terminated, as follows:
4.a & 4.a.8)
- ENSURE CLOSED 2(3)HV-9235, BAMU Tank MT-072 to Charging Pump Gravity Feed Valve.
Standard: VERIFIED 2HV-9235, BAMU Tank 2T072 Gravity Feed Valve green CLOSE light lit.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 9 ENSURE Emergency Boration terminated, as follows:
4.a & 4.a.9)
- ENSURE OPEN 2(3)HV-9236, BAMU Pump 2(3)MP-174 Recirculation Valve.
Standard: DEPRESSED 2HV-9236, 2P174 RECIRC to 2T071 OPEN pushbutton and OBSERVED red OPEN light lit.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 10 ENSURE Emergency Boration terminated, as follows:
4.a & 4.a.10)
- ENSURE OPEN 2(3)HV-9231, BAMU Pump 2(3)MP-175 Recirculation Valve.
Standard: DEPRESSED 2HV-9231, 2P175 RECIRC to 2T072 OPEN pushbutton and OBSERVED red OPEN light lit.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 4 of 6 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-1 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 11 ENSURE Emergency Boration terminated, as follows:
4.a & 4.a.11)
Standard: DEPRESSED 2FV-9253, Blended Makeup to VCT Block Valve AUTO pushbutton and OBSERVED green CLOSE and white AUTO lights lit.
Terminating Cue: This JPM is complete.
Comment: SAT UNSAT STOP TIME:
Page 5 of 6 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-1 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM CUE SHEET Form ES-C-1 INITIAL CONDITIONS: Given the following conditions:
- Unit 2 is in a MODE 3 post-trip condition.
- An Emergency Boration was initiated for two stuck Control Element Assemblies.
- SHUTDOWN MARGIN has been verified by Reactor Engineering.
INITIATING CUE: The Control Room Supervisor directs you to PERFORM the following:
- PERFORM an Emergency Boration Restoration per SO23-13-11, Emergency Boration of the RCS /
Inadvertent Dilution or Boration.
- START at Step 4, Emergency Boration Restoration.
Page 6 of 6 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-1 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 Facility: SONGS JPM # NRC JPM S-2 Task #186190 K/A #013.A4.02 4.3 / 4.4 SF-2
Title:
Reset a Control Room Isolation Signal Examinee (Print):
Testing Method:
Simulated Performance: Classroom:
Actual Performance: X Simulator: X Alternate Path: Plant:
Time Critical:
READ TO THE EXAMINEE I will explain the Initial Conditions, which steps to simulate or discuss, and provide an Initiating Cue.
When you complete the task successfully, the objective for this JPM will be satisfied.
Initial Conditions: Given the following conditions:
- Unit 2/3 Train A and B Control Room Isolation Signals (CRIS) have been actuated for testing.
Initiating Cue: The Control Room Supervisor directs you to PERFORM the following:
- RESET and RESTORE the Unit 2/3 Train A and B Control Room Isolation Signals (CRIS) per SO23-3-2.22, Engineered Safety Features Actuation Systems Operation, Attachment 18, CRIS / TGIS Reset and Restoration.
- START at Step 2.1.
Task Standard: Utilizing SO23-3-2.22, Attachment 18, reset the Train A and B Control Room Isolation Signal (CRIS) and restored the Control Room Ventilation System at 2CR-60 to a normal pre-CRIS alignment.
Required Materials: SO23-3-2.22, ESFAS Operation, Attachment 18, Rev. 23.
Validation Time: 15 minutes Completion Time: ________ minutes Comments:
Result: SAT UNSAT Examiner (Print / Sign): Date:
Page 1 of 7 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-2 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 SIMULATOR SETUP MACHINE OPERATOR:
INITIALIZE to IC-242 or any at power Initial Condition and PERFORM the following:
- EXECUTE both Channels of Control Room Isolation Signal (CRIS).
- ENSURE sufficient time has elapsed to allow all components to reposition.
EXAMINER:
PROVIDE the examinee with a copy of:
- SO23-3-2.22, Engineered Safety Features Actuation Systems Operation.
- Attachment 18, CRIS / TGIS Reset and Restoration.
- INITIALED and N/A as appropriate up to Step 2.0.
- INITIAL Steps 1.1 through 1.6.
- CHECK 1st box for Step 1.3.
- N/A Steps 2.2, 2.2.1, 2.2.2, 2.2.3 & 2.2.3.1.
Page 2 of 7 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-2 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1
- Check Mark Denotes Critical Step START TIME:
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-3-2.22, Attachment 18.
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-3-2.22, Step 2.1 and 2.4 Perform Step: 1 RESET CRIS actuation, as follows:
2.1 & 2.1.1
- MOMENTARILY DEPRESS Train A CRIS 2/3HS-7824J1 on panel L-104 and VERIFY Reset/Test light backlights.
Standard: MOMENTARILY DEPRESSED 2/3HS-7824J1, CRIS TR A RESET /
TEST on Panel 2L-104, Radiation Monitoring Panel and VERIFIED white RESET / TEST light backlights.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 2 RESET CRIS actuation, as follows:
2.1 & 2.1.2
- MOMENTARILY DEPRESS Train B CRIS 2/3HS-7825J2 on panel L-104 and VERIFY Reset/Test light backlights.
Standard: MOMENTARILY DEPRESSED 2/3HS-7825J2, CRIS TR B RESET /
TEST on Panel 2L-104, Radiation Monitoring Panel and VERIFIED white RESET / TEST light backlights.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 3 RESET CRIS actuation, as follows:
2.1 & 2.1.3
- VERIFY that K-9 (K-11) Train A(B) CRIS ESFAS Actuation Relays are not chattering, buzzing or humming (noises of distress will be very noticeable outside 2/3L104).
Standard: VERIFIED that K-9 and K-11 Train A and B CRIS ESFAS Actuation Relays are not chattering, buzzing or humming.
Examiner Cue: The relays are as you hear them.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 4 RESET CRIS actuation, as follows:
2.1 & 2.1.4
- VERIFY applicable annunciators on panel 60B and DAS (as applicable) have reset.
Standard: DEPRESSED RESET pushbutton and OBSERVED Annunciator 60B07
- CRIS ACTUATION has RESET on Control Room Panel 60B.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 3 of 7 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-2 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 5 RESTORE Train A Control Room Emergency HVAC to normal, as 2.4 & 2.4.1 follows:
- 3E-427 CR Cabinet Area ECU STOP Standard: VERIFIED 3E-427, CR Cabinet Area ECU in STOP and DETERMINED green STOP light lit.
Examiner Cue: Unit 3 has stopped 3E-427, CR Cabinet Area ECU.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 6 RESTORE Train A Control Room Emergency HVAC to normal, as 2.4 & 2.4.2 follows:
- 3HV-9738 CR Cabinet Area ECU E-427 Suction Damper CLOSED Standard: VERIFIED 3HV-9738, CR Cabinet Area ECU E427 Suction Damper in CLOSE and DETERMINED green CLOSE light lit.
Examiner Cue: Unit 3 has closed 3HV-9738, ECU E427 Suction Damper.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 7 RESTORE Train A Control Room Emergency HVAC to normal, as 2.4 & 2.4.3 follows:
- 2E-424 CR Cabinet Area ECU STOP Standard: DEPRESSED 2HS-9738-1, CR Cabinet Area ECU E424 (N) STOP pushbutton and OBSERVED green STOP light lit.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 8 RESTORE Train A Control Room Emergency HVAC to normal, as 2.4 & 2.4.4 follows:
- 2HV-9738 CR Cabinet Area ECU E-424 Suction Damper CLOSED Standard: VERIFIED 2HV-9738, CR Cabinet Area ECU E424 Suction Damper green CLOSE light lit.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 4 of 7 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-2 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 9 RESTORE Train A Control Room Emergency HVAC to normal, as 2.4 & 2.4.5 follows:
- A-207 CR Emer Ventilation Supply Unit STOP Standard: DEPRESSED 2/3HS-9760-1 CR Emergency Vent Supply Unit A207 (S)
STOP pushbutton and OBSERVED green STOP light lit.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 10 RESTORE Train A Control Room Emergency HVAC to normal, as 2.4 & 2.4.6 follows:
- FV-9761 CR Emer Vent Unit A-207 Damper CLOSED Standard: VERIFIED 2/3FV-9761, CR Emergency Vent Unit A Damper green CLOSE light lit when A207 STOPPED.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 11 RESTORE Train A Control Room Emergency HVAC to normal, as 2.4 & 2.4.7 follows:
- E-418 CR Emergency A/C Unit STOP Standard: DEPRESSED 2/3HS-9749-1 Unit 2 CR Emergency A/C Unit A E418 (S)
STOP pushbutton and OBSERVED green STOP light lit.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 12 RESTORE Train A Control Room Emergency HVAC to normal, as 2.4 & 2.4.8 follows:
- HV-9756 CR Outside Air Isolation Damper OPEN Standard: DEPRESSED 2/3HV-9756, Control Room Outside Air ISO Damper OPEN pushbutton and OBSERVED red OPEN light lit.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 13 RESTORE Train A Control Room Emergency HVAC to normal, as 2.4 & 2.4.9 follows:
- HV-9702 CR Air E-295 Discharge Damper OPEN Standard: DEPRESSED 2/3HV-9702, Control Room Air E295 DISCH Damper OPEN pushbutton and OBSERVED red OPEN light lit.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 5 of 7 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-2 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 14 RESTORE Train A Control Room Emergency HVAC to normal, as 2.4 & 2.4.10 follows:
- HV-9712 CR Air Recirc E-295 Suction Damper OPEN Standard: DEPRESSED 2/3HV-9712, Control Room Air Recirc E295 Suction Damper OPEN pushbutton and OBSERVED red OPEN light lit.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 15 RESTORE Train A Control Room Emergency HVAC to normal, as 2.4 & 2.4.11 follows:
- HV-9717 CR Outside Air Isolation Damper OPEN Standard: DEPRESSED 2/3HV-9717, Control Room Outside Air Isolation Damper OPEN pushbutton and OBSERVED red OPEN light lit.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 16 RESTORE Train A Control Room Emergency HVAC to normal, as 2.4 & 2.4.12 follows:
- HV-9769 CR Outside Air Isolation Damper OPEN Standard: DEPRESSED 2/3HV-9769, Control Room Outside Air ISO Damper OPEN pushbutton and OBSERVED red OPEN light lit.
Terminating Cue: Another operator will finish alignments. This JPM is complete.
Comment: SAT UNSAT STOP TIME:
Page 6 of 7 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-2 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM CUE SHEET Form ES-C-1 INITIAL CONDITIONS: Given the following conditions:
- Unit 2/3 Train A and B Control Room Isolation Signals (CRIS) have been actuated for testing.
INITIATING CUE: The Control Room Supervisor directs you to PERFORM the following:
- RESET and RESTORE the Unit 2/3 Train A and B Control Room Isolation Signals (CRIS) per SO23-3-2.22, Engineered Safety Features Actuation Systems Operation, Attachment 18, CRIS / TGIS Reset and Restoration.
- START at Step 2.1.
Page 7 of 7 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-2 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 Facility: SONGS JPM # NRC JPM S-3 Task #141245 K/A #006.A1.13 3.5 / 3.7 SF-3
Title:
Pressurize a Safety Injection Tank Examinee (Print):
Testing Method:
Simulated Performance: Classroom:
Actual Performance: X Simulator: X Alternate Path: Plant:
Time Critical:
READ TO THE EXAMINEE I will explain the Initial Conditions, which steps to simulate or discuss, and provide an Initiating Cue.
When you complete the task successfully, the objective for this JPM will be satisfied.
Initial Conditions: Given the following conditions:
- Unit 2 is in MODE 1.
Initiating Cue: The Control Room Supervisor directs you to PERFORM the following:
- START at Step 6.1.
Task Standard: Utilizing SO23-3-2.7.1, raised 2T-008, Safety Injection Tank pressure from 620 PSIA to 630 PSIA +/- 5 PSIA without exceeding 655 PSIA.
Required Materials: SO23-3-2.7.1 Safety Injection Tank Operation, Rev. 19-1.
Validation Time: 12 minutes Completion Time: ________ minutes Comments:
Result: SAT UNSAT Examiner (Print / Sign): Date:
Page 1 of 6 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-3 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 SIMULATOR SETUP MACHINE OPERATOR:
INITIALIZE to IC-244 or any at power Initial Condition and PERFORM the following:
EXAMINER:
PROVIDE the examinee with a copy of:
- SO23-3-2.7.1 Safety Injection Tank Operation.
- Section 6.1, Increasing SIT Pressure.
Page 2 of 6 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-3 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1
- Check Mark Denotes Critical Step START TIME:
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-3-2.7.1, Section 6.1.
Perform Step: 1 Ensure SIT pressure is 300 psia.
6.1.1 & 6.1.1.1
- If SIT pressure is < 300 psia, then go to Section 6.2.
Standard: OBSERVED 2PI-0312 and/or 2PI-0313, SIT Narrow Range Pressure 2T008 (Loop 1A) and DETERMINED pressure is greater than 300 PSIA.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 2 VERIFY SIT level is between 79.2% and 82.9% (NR). (Mark N/A if 6.1.2 already performing SO23-3-3.25, Attachment for SIT Level Change Log-Six Hour Monitoring.)
Standard: OBSERVED 2LI-0312 and 2LI-0313, SIT Narrow Range Level 2T008 (Loop 1A) and DETERMINED level between 79.2% and 82.9%.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 3 OPEN 2(3)HV-5434, SIT Nitrogen Supply Containment Isolation Valve, 6.1.3 and verify SIT Nitrogen header pressure is at least 610 psig (PI-5410).
Standard: PERFORMED the following:
- DEPRESSED 2HV-5434, SIT N2 Supply ISO Valve OPEN pushbutton and OBSERVED red OPEN light lit (critical).
- VERIFIED SIT Nitrogen header pressure > 610 PSIG on 2PI-5410, N2 Fill Line to SI Tanks Pressure (not critical).
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 3 of 6 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-3 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 4 RAISE pressure in one SIT at a time, as follows:
6.1.4 & 6.1.4.1
- OPEN the respective Nitrogen Supply Valve at CR-57.
N2 Supply SIT Pressure Instrument Valve 2(3)HV-9344 SIT T-008 PI-0312/P312 Standard: DEPRESSED 2HV-9344, SIT 2T008 (Loop 1A) N2 Supply Valve OPEN pushbutton and OBSERVED red OPEN light lit and pressure rising at 2PI-0312 and 2PI-0313, SIT Narrow Range Pressure 2T008 (Loop 1A).
Examiner Note: Annunciators 57B38 - PZR PRESS HI AND SIT T008 / T010 PRESS LO and 57B39 - SIT T008 PRESS HI / LO will clear as pressure rises.
SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 5 After achieving 620 - 650 psia, then CLOSE the Nitrogen Supply Valve.
6.1.4.2 Standard: DEPRESSED 2HV-9344, SIT 2T008 (Loop 1A) N2 Supply Valve CLOSE pushbutton when pressure is 630 PSIA +/- 5 PSIA and OBSERVED green CLOSE light lit.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 6 VERIFY SIT level is between 79.2% and 82.9% (NR). (Mark N/A if 6.1.4.3 already performing SO23-3-3.25, Attachment for SIT Level Change Log-Six Hour Monitoring.)
Standard: OBSERVED 2LI-0312 and 2LI-0313, SIT Narrow Range Level 2T008 (Loop 1A) and VERIFIED level between 79.2% and 82.9%.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 7 If additional SITs will be pressurized, then reperform Section 6.1.4.
6.1.5 Standard
DETERMINED that no additional SITs will be pressurized.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 4 of 6 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-3 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 8 CLOSE 2(3)HV-5434, SIT Nitrogen Supply Containment Isolation Valve
6.1.6 Standard
DEPRESSED 2HV-5434, SIT N2 Supply ISO Valve CLOSE pushbutton and OBSERVED green CLOSE light lit Terminating Cue: This JPM is complete.
Comment: SAT UNSAT STOP TIME:
Page 5 of 6 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-3 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM CUE SHEET Form ES-C-1 INITIAL CONDITIONS: Given the following conditions:
- Unit 2 is in MODE 1.
INITIATING CUE: The Control Room Supervisor directs you to PERFORM the following:
- START at Step 6.1.
Page 6 of 6 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-3 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 Facility: SONGS JPM # NRC JPM S-4 Task #192368 K/A #003.A4.06 2.9 / 2.9 SF-4P
Title:
Start a Reactor Coolant Pump Examinee (Print):
Testing Method:
Simulated Performance: Classroom:
Actual Performance: X Simulator: X Alternate Path: X Plant:
Time Critical:
READ TO THE EXAMINEE I will explain the Initial Conditions, which steps to simulate or discuss, and provide an Initiating Cue.
When you complete the task successfully, the objective for this JPM will be satisfied.
Initial Conditions: Given the following conditions:
- Unit 2 is in MODE 3.
- A heat up is in progress to the point of starting the 4th Reactor Coolant Pump P-003.
- All actions of SO23-3-1.7, Reactor Coolant Pump Operation, through Step 6.1.19 are complete.
- An Operator is stationed at the Reactor Coolant Pump (RCP) in Containment.
Initiating Cue: The Control Room Supervisor directs you to PERFORM the following:
- PLACE Reactor Coolant Pump P-003 in service per SO23-3-1.7, Reactor Coolant Pump Operation.
- START at Step 6.1.20.
Task Standard: Utilizing SO23-3-1.7, started Reactor Coolant Pump P-003 and tripped Reactor Coolant Pump P-003 when an thrust bearing high temperature condition was detected.
Required Materials: SO23-3-1.7, Reactor Coolant Pump Operation, Rev. 38-1.
SO23-15-56.C, 56C05 - CP P003 THRUST BRG TEMP HI, Rev. 23.
Validation Time: 15 minutes Completion Time: ________ minutes Comments:
Result: SAT UNSAT Examiner (Print / Sign): Date:
Page 1 of 9 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-4 Rev e.doce
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 SIMULATOR SETUP MACHINE OPERATOR:
INITIALIZE to IC-245 or any MODE 3 Initial Condition with RCS temperature > 400ºF and PERFORM the following:
- ACCESS Main Menu on PCS.
- SELECT Main Points.
- SELECT Point 1.
- POINT TYPE selected to Server Group.
- SELECT RCP 3 PARMS then SELECT Add, then OK.
- INSERT and TURN Key #38, CPC A Trip Bypass to ON.
- INSERT and TURN Key #42, CPC B Trip Bypass to ON.
- INSERT and TURN Key #46, CPC C Trip Bypass to ON.
- INSERT and TURN Key #50, CPC D Trip Bypass to ON.
- INSERT override 2HS-9161A - CR 56 - SO2 to OUT.
- INSERT override 2HS-9161A - CR 56 - SO1 to IN.
- INSERT override for Annunciator 56C05 10 seconds after starting RCP P-003.
EXAMINER:
PROVIDE the examinee with a copy of:
- SO23-3-1.7, Reactor Coolant Pump Operation.
- INITIALED through Step 6.1.19.
- INCLUDE Attachments 1, 2, and 16.
Page 2 of 9 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-4 Rev e.doce
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1
- Check Mark Denotes Critical Step START TIME:
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-3-1.7, Section 6.1.
Perform Step: 1 START one Oil Lift Pump by selecting the NORMAL mode.
6.1.20 Standard: DEPRESSED the NORMAL pushbutton on either 2HS-9111A, 2P003 Oil Lift Pump 2P264, or 2HS-9112A, 2P003 Oil Lift Pump 2P265 and OBSERVED amber NORMAL and red START lights lit.
Examiner Note: Annunciator 56C35 - RCP P003 OIL LIFT PRESS LO, will come in and reset. This is an expected alarm.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 2 ENSURE the second Oil Lift pump selected to STANDBY.
6.1.21 Standard: DEPRESSED the STANDBY pushbutton on either 2HS-9111A, 2P003 Oil Lift Pump 2P264 or 2HS-9112A, 2P003 Oil Lift Pump 2P265, whichever was not started in the previous step and VERIFIED amber STANDBY and green STOP lights lit.
Examiner Cue: Two minutes has elapsed.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 3 After the Oil Lift System has run approximately 2 minutes, then START 6.1.22 the ARRD Lube Oil Pump by selecting the NORMAL mode.
Standard: DEPRESSED the NORMAL pushbutton on either 2HS-9176, 2P003 ARRD Pump 2P403 or 2HS-9177, 2P003 ARRD Pump 2P404 and OBSERVED amber NORMAL and red START lights lit.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 4 ENSURE the second ARRD pump is available by selecting STANDBY 6.1.23 mode.
Standard: DEPRESSED the STANDBY pushbutton on either 2HS-9176, 2P003 ARRD Pump 2P403 or 2HS-9177, 2P003 ARRD Pump 2P404, whichever was not started in the previous step and VERIFIED amber STANDBY and green STOP lights lit.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 3 of 9 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-4 Rev e.doce
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 5 VERIFY the following alarms on Panel CR56 are reset prior to the start 6.1.24 & 6.1.24.1 thru of the associated RCP:
6.1.24.7
- RCP THRUST BEARINGS TEMP HI (56C03, 05, 07, and 09)
- RCP REVERSE ROTATION (56C14, 16, 18, and 20)
Standard: OBSERVED alarms on Panel CR-56 are RESET prior to starting RCP:
- 56C16 - RCP P003 REVERSE ROTATION
- 56C45 - RCP P003 ARRD LUBE OIL FLOW LO Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 6 Verify PCS Points selected in Step 6.1.9 are not in alarm.
6.1.25 Standard: OBSERVED RCP 2P-003 information on Plant Computer System and DETERMINED no alarms present.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 7 Verify RCP CONTROLLED BLEED-OFF FLOW (PCS) is reset or proper 6.1.26 RCP CBO flow for the existing RCS pressure.
Standard: VERIFIED RCP Controlled Bleed-Off Flow on Plant Computer System is RESET (Point ID F-160) or proper RCP CBO flow for the existing RCS pressure (~1.5 gpm).
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 4 of 9 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-4 Rev e.doce
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 8 Verify CCW SEAL HEAT EXCHANGER TEMPERATURE HI (PCS) 6.1.27 alarm is reset.
Standard: VERIFIED CCW Seal Exchanger temperature high alarm on Plant Computer System Point ID TE-9154 is RESET for RCP P-003.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 9 VERIFY the following final configuration:
6.1.28 & 6.1.28.1 thru
- One Oil Lift Pump selected to NORMAL.
6.1.28.4
- One Oil Lift Pump selected to Standby.
- One ARRD Pump selected to Normal.
- One ARRD Pump selected to Standby.
Standard: PERFORMED final configuration check:
- VERIFIED Oil Lift Pump, 2P264 or 2P265 amber NORMAL light lit.
- VERIFIED Oil Lift Pump, 2P264 or 2P265 amber STANDBY light lit.
- VERIFIED ARRD Pump, 2P403 or 2P404 amber NORMAL light lit.
- VERIFIED ARRD Pump, 2P403 or 2P404 amber STANDBY light lit.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 10 If Backfeeding Unit Aux Transformer (UAT) when in Modes 4 or 5, and a 6.1.29 UAT High temperature alarm is received, then ENSURE only one RCP is running on the associated bus.
Standard: DETERMINED Backfeeding via the Unit Auxiliary Transformer is NOT being performed as Unit 2 is in MODE 3.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 11 VERIFY the RCP Zero Speed lamp is illuminated.
6.1.30 Standard: OBSERVED 2SL-9110, Zero Speed Indication for RCP 2P003 white ZERO SPEED light lit.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 5 of 9 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-4 Rev e.doce
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 12 If another RCP is already running, then ENSURE it has been in service 6.1.31 for at least 5 minutes.
Standard: DETERMINED that all three running RCPs have been in service for greater than 5 minutes.
Examiner Cue: RCPs were running for more than 5 minutes.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 13 If this RCP start is associated with an idle loop, then COMMENCE 6.1.32 monitoring Nuclear Instrumentation and continue for approximately the first minute of pump operation.
Standard: DETERMINED that RCP 2P001 is running and the loop is NOT idle.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 14 ANNOUNCE pump start using local area page.
6.1.33 Standard: DIALED 429 on phone and ANNOUNCED Reactor Coolant Pump 2P003 start.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Examiner Note: Annunciator 50A51 - VIB & LOOSE PARTS MONITOR SYSTEM TROUBLE, will come in and reset. This is an expected alarm when starting the RCP.
Perform Step: 15 START the Reactor Coolant Pump and PERFORM the following:
6.1.34 & 6.1.34.1
- Verify motor amps stabilize between 470 and 800 amps.
Standard: DEPRESSED 2HS-9161A, 2P003 START pushbutton:
- OBSERVED red START light lit and green STOP light off.
- OBSERVED motor amps stabilized at ~700 amps on ammeter.
Examiner Cue: If an attempt is made to research cause of alarm, REPORT that the ARO is at 2L-194 verifying alarm was due to starting the RCP.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 6 of 9 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-4 Rev e.doce
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Examiner Note: The following steps represent the Alternate Path of this JPM.
Examiner Note: When referenced, PROVIDE a copy of Procedure 2 (ARP 56C05).
Perform Step: 16 Acknowledge annunciator 56C05 - RCP P003 THRUST BRG TEMP HI.
Standard: ACKNOWLEDGED annunciator 56C05 - RCP P003 THRUST BRG TEMP HI and REFERRED to 56C05 Annunciator Response Procedure and OBSERVED 2P003 2TI-0168, UPWARD THRUST BRG TEMPERATURE rising to ~250°F.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Examiner Note: The following steps are from Annunciator SO23-15-56C.05, Step 1.0.
Perform Step: 17 If Upward Thrust Bearing or Downward Thrust Bearing Temperature 1.1 & 1.1.1 reaches 225°F, then:
- TRIP the Reactor.
Standard: PERFORMED the following:
- DEPRESSED 2HS-9132-1 and 2HS-9132-4, REACTOR TRIP pushbuttons on CR-52 or
- DEPRESSED 2HS-9132-2, and 2HS-9132-3, REACTOR TRIP pushbuttons on CR-56.
Examiner Cue: Another operator will perform Standard Post Trip Actions, CONTINUE with the Annunciator Response Procedure.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Examiner Note: It is considered skill-of-the-craft to open an upstream breaker using the Annunciator Response Procedures or going directly to the breaker.
Perform Step: 18 If Upward Thrust Bearing or Downward Thrust Bearing Temperature 1.1 & 1.1.2 reaches 225°F, then:
Standard: DEPRESSED 2HS-9161A, 2P003 STOP pushbutton and OBSERVED green STOP light off, red START light lit.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 7 of 9 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-4 Rev e.doce
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 19 If Upward Thrust Bearing or Downward Thrust Bearing Temperature 1.1 & 1.1.2 reaches 225°F, then:
Standard: PERFORMED the following:
- DEPRESSED 2HS-1610A, RES AUX XFMR 2XR3 FDR BREAKER 2A0202 TRIP pushbutton and OBSERVED green TRIP light lit (critical).
Terminating Cue: This JPM is complete.
Comment: SAT UNSAT STOP TIME:
Page 8 of 9 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-4 Rev e.doce
Appendix C JPM CUE SHEET Form ES-C-1 INITIAL CONDITIONS: Given the following conditions:
- Unit 2 is in MODE 3.
- A heat up is in progress to the point of starting the 4th Reactor Coolant Pump P-003.
- All actions of SO23-3-1.7, Reactor Coolant Pump Operation, through Step 6.1.19 are complete.
- An Operator is stationed at the Reactor Coolant Pump (RCP) in Containment.
INITIATING CUE: The Control Room Supervisor directs you to PERFORM the following:
- PLACE Reactor Coolant Pump P-003 in service per SO23-3-1.7, Reactor Coolant Pump Operation
- START at Step 6.1.20.
Page 9 of 9 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-4 Rev e.doce
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 Facility: SONGS JPM # NRC JPM S-5 Task #185048 K/A #059.A2.11 3.0 / 3.3 SF-4S
Title:
Reset a Valid Reactor Trip Override Examinee (Print):
Testing Method:
Simulated Performance: Classroom:
Actual Performance: X Simulator: X Alternate Path: X Plant:
Time Critical:
READ TO THE EXAMINEE I will explain the Initial Conditions, which steps to simulate or discuss, and provide an Initiating Cue.
When you complete the task successfully, the objective for this JPM will be satisfied.
Initial Conditions: Given the following conditions:
- Unit 2 has tripped from full power due to a Turbine Generator fault.
- SO23-12-1, Standard Post Trip Actions, Step 15.b RNO, Reset RTO, is required.
- The Reactor Trip Override (RTO) was validated by another operator.
Initiating Cue: The Control Room Supervisor directs you to PERFORM the following:
- RESET the Reactor Trip Override per SO23-9-6, Feedwater Control System Operation, Section 6.5, Feedwater Control System Operation During a VALID RTO.
- START at Step 6.5.2, Reset the Valid RTO.
Task Standard: Utilizing SO23-9-6, reset Reactor Trip Override on both Steam Generators and then referred to SO23-13-24, Attachment 1, and controlled Steam Generator E-088 level when the Master Controller setpoint failed high.
Required Materials: SO23-9-6, Feedwater Control System Operation, Rev. 28.
SO23-13-24, Feedwater Control System Malfunction, Rev. 5-4.
Validation Time: 10 minutes Completion Time: ________ minutes Comments:
Result: SAT UNSAT Examiner (Print / Sign): Date:
Page 1 of 7 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-5 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 SIMULATOR SETUP MACHINE OPERATOR:
INITIALIZE to IC-243 or any 100% power IC and PERFORM the following:
- Manually TRIP the Reactor.
- SECURE one (1) Main Feedwater Pump.
When RTO is RESET, perform the following:
- EXECUTE malfunction FC05B, Steam Generator E-088 Setpoint Failure to 100%
on 180 second ramp.
MACHINE OPERATOR NOTE:
- ENSURE SO23-13-24, Attachment 1, Control Board Hard Card is clean after each JPM is performed.
EXAMINER:
PROVIDE the examinee with a copy of:
- SO23-9-6, Feedwater Control System Operation.
- Section 6.5, Feedwater Control System Operation During a VALID RTO.
Page 2 of 7 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-5 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1
- Check Mark Denotes Critical Step START TIME:
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-9-6, Section 6.5.
Examiner Note: This step resets Reactor Trip Override on Steam Generator E-089.
Perform Step: 1 Reset the Valid RTO, as follows:
6.5.2 & 6.5.2.1
- LOWER Master Controller FIC-1111 Setpoint to within 4% of actual S/G E-089 Level.
Standard: PERFORMED the following:
- DEPRESSED Master Controller 2FIC1111 (E089) to SELECT Setpoint then DOWN () arrow and ADJUSTED Master Controller to within 4% of actual level (critical).
- OBSERVED Annunciator 52A08 - FWCS SG1 E089 RTO is RESET or OBSERVED yellow RTO flag inside DCS SG for E-089 (not critical).
Comment: SAT UNSAT Examiner Note: This step resets Reactor Trip Override on Steam Generator E-088.
Perform Step: 2 Reset the Valid RTO, as follows:
6.5.2 & 6.5.2.2
- LOWER Master Controller FIC-1121 Setpoint to within 4% of actual S/G E-088 Level.
Standard: PERFORMED the following:
- DEPRESSED Master Controller 2FIC1121 (E088) to SELECT Setpoint then DOWN () arrow and ADJUSTED Master Controller to within 4% of actual level (critical).
- OBSERVED Annunciator 52A03 - FWCS SG2 E088 RTO is RESET or OBSERVED yellow RTO flag inside DCS SG for E-088 (not critical).
Standard: .
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 3 Reset the Valid RTO, as follows:
6.5.2.& 6.5.2.3
- After the RTO has reset, then SLOWLY simultaneously adjust both Master Controllers (FIC-1111/FIC-1121), setpoint to 55%
NR level, or as directed by the SRO Ops. Supv.
Standard: DEPRESSED Master Controller 2FIC1121 (E088) UP () arrow to ADJUST setpoint to 55%.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 3 of 7 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-5 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 4 Reset the Valid RTO, as follows:
6.5.2.& 6.5.2.3
- After the RTO has reset, then SLOWLY simultaneously adjust both Master Controllers (FIC-1111/FIC-1121), setpoint to 55%
NR level, or as directed by the SRO Ops. Supv.
Standard: DEPRESSED Master Controller 2FIC1111 (E089) UP () arrow to ADJUST setpoint to 55%.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Machine Operator: When RTO is RESET, EXECUTE malfunction FC05B, Steam Generator E-088 Setpoint Failure to 100% on 180 second ramp.
Examiner Note: The following steps represent the Alternate Path of this JPM.
Examiner Note: Examinee may use prompt and prudent actions to control level.
Perform Step: 5 Reset the Valid RTO, as follows:
6.5.2 & 6.5.2.4
- If the Steam Generator levels are not being properly controlled by DCS, then GO TO SO23-13-24, Feedwater Control System Malfunction.
Standard: DETERMINED Steam Generator levels are not being properly controlled by DCS and REFERRED to SO23-13-24, Feedwater Control System Malfunction.
Examiner Cue: The CRS directs you to use SO23-13-24, Attachment 1, Control Board Hard Card.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 4 of 7 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-5 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-13-24, Attachment 1, Flowchart.
Perform Step: 6 Determine Most Affected S/G Level Off-Program.
Standard: DETERMINED Steam Generator E-088 level RISING.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 5 of 7 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-5 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Examiner Note: When in MANUAL, selecting OUTPUT or observing the lumigraph bar for OUTPUT is sufficient to determine control of the valve.
Perform Step: 7 HIGH - Most Affected S/G Master Controller Output Lowering - NO - Place the Master Controller in MANUAL AND Lower Output Standard: DEPRESSED Master Controller 2FIC1121 (E088) MANUAL (M) pushbutton then to SELECT Output and DEPRESSED DOWN ()
arrow to ADJUST level to ~55%.
Terminating Cue: When applicant demonstrates control of Steam Generator level, this JPM is complete.
Comment: SAT UNSAT STOP TIME:
Page 6 of 7 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-5 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM CUE SHEET Form ES-C-1 INITIAL CONDITIONS: Given the following conditions:
- Unit 2 has tripped from full power due to a Turbine Generator fault.
- SO23-12-1, Standard Post Trip Actions, Step 15.b RNO, Reset RTO, is required.
- The Reactor Trip Override (RTO) was validated by another operator.
INITIATING CUE: The Control Room Supervisor directs you to PERFORM the following:
- RESET the Reactor Trip Override per SO23-9-6, Feedwater Control System Operation, Section 6.5, Feedwater Control System Operation During a VALID RTO.
- START at Step 6.5.2, Reset the Valid RTO.
Page 7 of 7 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-5 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 Facility: SONGS JPM # NRC JPM S-6 Task #186171 K/A #022.A4.01 3.6 / 3.6 SF-5
Title:
Placing the Containment Emergency Cooling System in Service Examinee (Print):
Testing Method:
Simulated Performance: Classroom:
Actual Performance: X Simulator: X Alternate Path: Plant:
Time Critical:
READ TO THE EXAMINEE I will explain the Initial Conditions, which steps to simulate or discuss, and provide an Initiating Cue.
When you complete the task successfully, the objective for this JPM will be satisfied.
Initial Conditions: Given the following conditions:
- Unit 2 is in MODE 1.
- Containment temperature is greater than 105°F and rising.
Initiating Cue: The Control Room Supervisor directs you to PERFORM the following:
- ALIGN Containment Emergency Cooling per SO23-1-4.1, Containment Emergency Cooling, Section 6.1, Placing the Containment Emergency Cooling System in Service.
- PLACE Containment Emergency Cooling System in service on a system level.
- START at Step 6.1.3.
Task Standard: Utilizing SO23-1-4.1 and SO23-2-17, manually initiated a Containment Cooling Actuation Signal (CCAS) and placed Containment Emergency Cooling System in service on a component basis following failure of the Containment Cooling Actuation Switches.
Required Materials: SO23-1-4.1, Containment Emergency Cooling, Rev. 16.
SO23-2-17, Component Cooling Water System Operation, Rev. 37.
Validation Time: 15 minutes Completion Time: ________ minutes Comments:
Result: SAT UNSAT Examiner (Print / Sign): Date:
Page 1 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-6 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 SIMULATOR SETUP MACHINE OPERATOR:
Execute IC-244 or any 100% power Initial Condition and PERFORM the following:
- EXECUTE remote functions CH56C & CH56D to secure Normal Containment Chillers.
- EXECUTE lesson plan to DISABLE all four (4) CCAS Actuation Switches.
EXAMINER:
PROVIDE the examinee with a copy of:
- SO23-1-4.1, Containment Emergency Cooling.
When requested, PROVIDE the examinee with a copy of:
- SO23-2-17, Component Cooling Water System Operation.
- Step 6.1, CCW ECU Return/SDCHX Outlet Valves Preferred Alignment.
Page 2 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-6 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1
- Check Mark Denotes Critical Step START TIME:
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-1.4.1, Section 6.1.
Perform Step: 1 ENSURE associated CCW Train is in service.
6.1.3 Standard
DETERMINED that both CCW Trains are in service by OBSERVING Train A and Train B CCW Pump START lights illuminated on CR-64.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Examiner Note: When requested, PROVIDE a copy of Procedure 2.
Examiner Note: SO23-1.4.1, Step 6.1.4 is performed using SO23-2-17, Step 6.1.
Examiner Note: The Non-Critical Loop is aligned to Train A, therefore, the Shutdown Cooling Heat Exchanger (SDCHX) Outlet Valve should be aligned to Train B. Each CCW Train has flow aligned through two Emergency Cooling Units (ECU). This configuration allows for flow balance between the Trains when both are in service.
Perform Step: 2 Ensure proper CCW Valve configuration per SO23-2-17, Section for 6.1.4 CCW ECU Return / SDCHX Outlet Valves Preferred Alignment.
Standard: REVIEWED SO23-2-17, Step 6.1, CCW ECU Return / SDCHX Outlet Valves Preferred Alignment and DETERMINED the following:
- PLANT STATUS:
- SDC IS OUT OF SERVICE on both Trains.
- CCW TRAIN STATUS:
- 2 in SERVICE (Train A and Train B).
- PREFERRED ALIGNMENT:
- 2 ECU Return Valves OPEN on Train A.
- 2 ECU Return Valves OPEN on Train B.
- 1 SDCHX Outlet Valve OPEN on Train B (Non-Critical Loop NOT aligned).
- 1 SDCHX Outlet Valve CLOSED on Train A (Non-Critical Loop aligned).
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 3 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-6 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 3 At CR-60, ENSURE by indication that the following CCW Motor 6.1.5 & 6.1.5.1 Operated Valves are OPEN:
- CCW to Containment Emergency Cooling Units:
- HV-6366, CCW to CNTMT ECU ME-401 Isolation Valve.
- HV-6370, CCW to CNTMT ECU ME-399 Isolation Valve.
- HV-6368, CCW to CNTMT ECU ME-400 Isolation Valve.
- HV-6372, CCW to CNTMT ECU ME-402 Isolation Valve.
Standard: At CR-60, VERIFIED OPEN the following CCW to Containment Emergency Cooling Units:
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 4 At CR-60, ENSURE by indication that the following Motor Operated 6.1.5.& 6.1.5.2 Valves are OPEN:
- CCW from Containment Emergency Cooling Units
- HV-6367, CCW from CNTMT ECU ME-401 Isolation Valve.
- HV-6371, CCW from CNTMT ECU ME-399 Isolation Valve.
- HV-6369, CCW from CNTMT ECU ME-400 Isolation Valve.
- HV-6373, CCW from CNTMT ECU ME-402 Isolation Valve.
Standard: At CR-60, VERIFIED OPEN CCW from Containment Emergency Cooling Units:
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 4 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-6 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 5 PLACE the Containment Emergency Cooling System in service on a 6.1.6 system level by manually initiating a Containment Cooling Actuation Signal using:
- HS-9138-1 and HS-9138-2 at CR56 or
- HS-9138-3 and HS-9138-4 at CR53.
Standard: DEPRESSED the following Containment Emergency Cooling System pushbuttons:
- 2HS-9138-1, CCAS MANUAL INITIATION and 2HS-9138-2, CCAS MANUAL INITIATION at CR-56 and/or
- 2HS-9138-3, CCAS MANUAL INITIATION and 2HS-9138-4, CCAS MANUAL INITIATION at CR-53.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 6 VERIFY the following Annunciators actuate:
6.1.7 & 6.1.7.1
- 57A07 - CCAS TRAIN A ACTUATION Standard: DETERMINED that Containment Emergency Cooling has NOT actuated and OBSERVED the following Annunciator dark:
- 57A07 - CCAS TRAIN A ACTUATION Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 7 VERIFY the following Annunciators actuate:
6.1.7 & 6.1.7.2
- 57B07 - CCAS TRAIN B ACTUATION Standard: DETERMINED that Containment Emergency Cooling has NOT actuated and OBSERVED the following Annunciator dark:
- 57B07 - CCAS TRAIN B ACTUATION Examiner Cue: The SRO Operations Supervisor directs you to align Containment Emergency Cooling on a component basis, starting at Step 6.5.4.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 5 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-6 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-1.4.1, Section 6.5.
Perform Step: 8 At CR-60, START the following fans as required:
6.5.4 & 6.5.4.1
- Containment Emergency Cooling Fans:
1st & 2nd bullets
- ME-401 (Train A)
- ME-399 (Train A)
Standard: DEPRESSED Train A Containment Emergency Cooling Fan START pushbuttons and OBSERVED red START lights lit:
- 2HS-9953-1, Containment ECU 2E399 (SW) and
- 2HS-9947-1, Containment ECU 2E401 (NW).
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 9 At CR-60, START the following fans as required:
6.5.4 & 6.5.4.1
- Containment Emergency Cooling Fans:
3rd & 4th bullets
- ME-400 (Train B)
- ME-402 (Train B)
Standard: DEPRESSED Train B Containment Emergency Cooling Fan START pushbuttons and OBSERVED red START lights lit:
- 2HS-9939-2, Containment ECU 2E400 (SE) and
- 2HS-9955-2, Containment ECU 2E402 (NE).
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 10 At CR-60, START the following fans as required:
6.5.4 & 6.5.4.2
- Containment Dome Air Circulator Fans:
1st & 2nd bullets
- MA-071 (Train A)
- MA-074 (Train A)
Standard: OBSERVED 2HS-9967-1, CNTMT Dome Air Circ Fan 2A074 (NE) red START light lit and DEPRESSED Train A Containment Dome Air Circulating Fan START pushbutton and OBSERVED red START light lit:
- 2HS-9965-1, CNTMT Dome Air Circ Fan 2A071 (NW).
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 6 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-6 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 11 At CR-60, START the following fans as required:
6.5.4 & 6.5.4.2
- Containment Dome Air Circulator Fans:
3rd & 4th bullets
- MA-072 (Train B)
- MA-073 (Train B)
Standard: DEPRESSED the following Train B Containment Dome Air Circulating Fan START pushbuttons and OBSERVED red START lights lit:
- 2HS-9966-2, CNTMT Dome Air Circ Fan 2A072 (SW) and
- 2HS-9968-2, CNTMT Dome Air Circ Fan 2A073 (SE).
Terminating Cue: The Radwaste Operator will verify Component Cooling Water flow to the Emergency Cooling Units. This JPM is complete.
Comment: SAT UNSAT STOP TIME:
Page 7 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-6 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM CUE SHEET Form ES-C-1 INITIAL CONDITIONS: Given the following conditions:
- Unit 2 is in MODE 1.
- Containment temperature is greater than 105°F and rising.
INITIATING CUE: The Control Room Supervisor directs you to PERFORM the following:
- ALIGN Containment Emergency Cooling per SO23-1-4.1, Containment Emergency Cooling, Section 6.1, Placing the Containment Emergency Cooling System in Service.
- PLACE Containment Emergency Cooling System in service on a system level.
- START at Step 6.1.3.
Page 8 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-6 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 Facility: SONGS JPM # NRC JPM S-7 Task #184468 K/A #062.A4.07 3.1 / 3.1 SF-6
Title:
Perform a Drop and Pickup Transfer of Bus 2A06 Examinee (Print):
Testing Method:
Simulated Performance: Classroom:
Actual Performance: X Simulator: X Alternate Path: X Plant:
Time Critical:
READ TO THE EXAMINEE I will explain the Initial Conditions, which steps to simulate or discuss, and provide an Initiating Cue.
When you complete the task successfully, the objective for this JPM will be satisfied.
Initial Conditions: Given the following conditions:
- Unit 2 is in MODE 3.
- Bus 2A06 is powered from Reserve Auxiliary Transformer 2XR2.
- Emergency Diesel Generator 2G003 is in Maintenance Lockout to support 1E Bus transfer.
- All Bus 2A06 loads are deenergized.
- Unit 2 and Unit 3 Switchgear Rooms are clear of personnel.
- All protective relays have been reset on Bus 2A06.
Initiating Cue: The Control Room Supervisor directs you to PERFORM the following:
- PERFORM a drop and pickup transfer of Bus 2A06 per SO23-6-2, Transferring of 4 kV Buses, Section 6.11, Drop and Pickup Transfer of 1E 4 kV Buses.
- TRANSFER Bus 2A06 from Reserve Auxiliary Transformer 2XR2 to Bus 3A06.
Task Standard: Utilizing SO23-6-2, performed a drop and pick up transfer of Bus 2A06 from Reserve Auxiliary Transformer 2XR2. Following a failure of the drop and transfer test, started the Train B Emergency Diesel Generator, adjusted voltage to allow breaker closure, and reenergized Bus 2A06.
Required Materials: SO23-6-2, Transferring of 4 kV Buses, Rev. 19.
Validation Time: 12 minutes Completion Time: ________ minutes Comments:
Result: SAT UNSAT Examiner (Print / Sign): Date:
Page 1 of 7 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-7 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 SIMULATOR SETUP MACHINE OPERATOR:
INITIALIZE to IC-246 or any Initial Condition and PERFORM the following:
- EXECUTE lesson plan to disable Automatic Transfer from Bus 2A06 to Bus 3A06 via the Tie Breaker (amber AUTO light is lit but MANUAL condition is active).
- PLACE 1639B2, Auto / Manual Switch in MANUAL.
- EXECUTE malfunction EG07B, 2G003 Preset AVR Voltage prior to starting 2G003, Emergency Diesel Generator @ 15% severity.
MACHINE OPERATOR NOTE:
- After each JPM, VERIFY Sync Key is in the NON-ESF SYNC MASTER position prior to performance by the next examinee.
EXAMINER:
PROVIDE the examinee with a copy of:
- SO23-6-2, Transferring of 4 kV Buses.
Page 2 of 7 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-7 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1
- Check Mark Denotes Critical Step START TIME:
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-6-2, Section 6.11.
Perform Step: 1 Review Attachment 1(2) for breaker sequencing.
6.11.1 Standard: REVIEWED Attachment 1, Unit 2 4 kV Bus Transfer Sequence and DETERMINED the sequence of breaker transfers is BUS 2A06 FROM 2XR2 TO BUS TIE occurs as follows:
- Breaker 3A0603, BUS TIE 3A06 to 2A06 FDR BKR, CLOSES.
- Breaker 2A0619, BUS TIE 2A06 to 3A06 FDR BKR, CLOSES.
- Breaker 2A0618, RES AUX XFMR 2XR2 FDR BKR, OPENS.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 2 Ensure the affected Switchgear Room is clear of all unnecessary 6.11.2 personnel and maintain it clear until after 4 kV bus transfer is complete.
Standard: DETERMINED both Switchgear Rooms clear of personnel per the Initial Conditions.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 3 Ensure sufficient Vital Busses are aligned to remain energized during 6.11.3 Bus transfer.
Standard: VERIFIED sufficient Vital Buses are aligned to remain energized during the Bus transfer.
Examiner Cue: The SRO Ops Supervisor reports sufficient Vital Buses are aligned.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 3 of 7 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-7 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 4 OPEN the RUNNING breaker and verify the automatic transfer occurs.
6.11.4 Standard: DEPRESSED 2HS-1637-2, RES AUX XFMR 2XR2 FDR Breaker 2A0618 OPEN pushbutton and OBSERVED green TRIP light lit and Annunciator 63C05 - 2A06 VOLTAGE LO in alarm.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 5 If transfer fails, then re-energize the 4kV Bus by performing one of the 6.11.4.1 following:
- Section 6.15
- Section 6.16
- Section 6.17 Standard: DETERMINED 2HS-1639A2, Bus Tie 2A06 to 3A06 FDR Breaker 2A0619 did NOT close and OBSERVED green TRIP light lit.
Examiner Cue: The SRO Ops Supervisor directs you to restore the Bus using Section 6.17 of SO23-6-2.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-6-2, Section 6.17.
Perform Step: 6 If power was lost to the 4 kV bus, and no supply breaker relayed on 6.17.1 overcurrent, then prior to re-energizing the bus, ENSURE OPEN all breakers supplying loads from the bus.
Standard: DETERMINED all breakers supplying loads from Bus 2A06 OPEN from Initial Conditions.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 7 Ensure the Diesel Generator is in Maintenance Lock-out.
6.17.2 Standard: DETERMINED Train B Emergency Diesel Generator key in MAINT position and OBSERVED white LOCKOUT RESET light out and Annunciator 63C07 - DIESEL GEN 2003 LOCKOUT RELAY TRIPPED lit.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 4 of 7 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-7 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 8 RESET all protective relays for the 4 kV bus to be energized.
6.17.3 Standard: DETERMINED all protective relays on Bus 2A06 RESET.
Examiner Cue: The SRO Ops Supervisor reports no protective relays have actuated in the Train B Switchgear Room.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 9 Ensure the affected Switchgear Room is clear of all unnecessary 6.17.4 personnel and maintain it clear until after 4 kV bus is energized.
Standard: DETERMINED Train B Switchgear Room clear of all unnecessary personnel and MAINTAINED it clear until after Bus 2A06 is energized.
Examiner Cue: The SRO Ops Supervisor reports all personnel are clear of Bus 2A06.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 10 Verify the Diesel Generator is available to accept load.
6.17.5 Standard: DETERMINED 2G003 Emergency Diesel Generator available for loading.
Examiner Cue: The SRO Ops Supervisor reports the Diesel Generator is available.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 11 Minimize loading to the 1E 4 kV bus to be energized by the Diesel 6.17.6 Generator.
Standard: READ and ACKNOWLEDGED that loading to Bus 2A06 by 2G003 Emergency Diesel Generator should be MINIMIZED.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 12 Evaluate effects on the Diesel Generator of the loading (immediate and 6.17.7 delayed loads) on the 1E Bus.
Standard: EVALUATED effects of loading 2G003 Emergency Diesel Generator on Bus 2A06.
Examiner Cue: The SRO Ops Supervisor reports the Diesel Generator can accept all loads.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 5 of 7 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-7 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 13 Remove the Diesel Generator from Maintenance Lock-out.
6.17.8 Standard: INSERTED Key #78 and TURNED 2HS-1770-2, Maintenance Lockout keyswitch to NORMAL for 2G003 Diesel Generator.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 14 START and LOAD the Diesel Generator by RESETTING the Lock-out 6.17.9 Relay.
Standard: DEPRESSED 2HS-1644-2, Mode Selector LOCKOUT RESET pushbutton and OBSERVED 2G003 Diesel Generator starts.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Examiner Note: The following steps represent the Alternate Path of this JPM.
Perform Step: 15 Adjust Diesel Generator output as required to establish the following:
6.17.10 & 1st bullet
- Voltage approximately 4360V AC.
Standard: OBSERVED 2EI-1651-2, Diesel Gen 2G003 Volts and DETERMINED voltage is low then:
- DEPRESSED 2HS-1648-2, Voltage Regulator RAISE pushbutton until voltage is 4154 to 4575 VAC.
- OBSERVED 2HS-1642-2, Generator Breaker 2A0613 red CLOSE light lit as voltage rises towards 4360 VAC.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 16 Adjust Diesel Generator output as required to establish the following:
nd 6.17.10 & 2 bullet
- Frequency approximately 60 Hz.
Standard: OBSERVED 2SI-1651-2, Diesel Gen 2G003 Frequency and VERIFIED Frequency is ~60 Hz.
Terminating Cue: This JPM is complete.
Comment: SAT UNSAT STOP TIME:
Page 6 of 7 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-7 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM CUE SHEET Form ES-C-1 INITIAL CONDITIONS: Given the following conditions:
- Unit 2 is in MODE 3.
- Bus 2A06 is powered from Reserve Auxiliary Transformer 2XR2.
- Emergency Diesel Generator 2G003 is in Maintenance Lockout to support 1E Bus transfer.
- All Bus 2A06 loads are deenergized.
- Unit 2 and Unit 3 Switchgear Rooms are clear of personnel.
- All protective relays have been reset on Bus 2A06.
INITIATING CUE: The Control Room Supervisor directs you to PERFORM the following:
- PERFORM a drop and pickup transfer of Bus 2A06 per SO23-6-2, Transferring of 4 kV Buses, Section 6.11, Drop and Pickup Transfer of 1E 4 kV Buses.
- TRANSFER Bus 2A06 from Reserve Auxiliary Transformer 2XR2 to Bus 3A06.
Page 7 of 7 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-7 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 Facility: SONGS JPM # NRC JPM S-8 Task #1413000 K/A #073.A4.02 3.7 / 3.7 SF-7
Title:
Bypass Containment Purge Isolation Radiation Monitor Examinee (Print):
Testing Method:
Simulated Performance: Classroom:
Actual Performance: X Simulator: X Alternate Path: Plant:
Time Critical:
READ TO THE EXAMINEE I will explain the Initial Conditions, which steps to simulate or discuss, and provide an Initiating Cue.
When you complete the task successfully, the objective for this JPM will be satisfied.
Initial Conditions: Given the following condition:
- Train A RIC-7804G1, Containment Purge Isolation Radiation Monitor, must be BYPASSED to allow Chemistry to change filters.
Initiating Cue: The Control Room Supervisor directs you to PERFORM the following:
- BYPASS Train A RIC-7804G1, Containment Purge Isolation Radiation Monitor per SO23-3-2.24.11, Containment Radiation Monitor System Operation, Attachment 4, Containment Radiation Monitors Bypass Operation.
- START at Step 2.1.
- Train A both 2R-7804G, Gas and 2R-7804P Particulate Monitors must be BYPASSED in the Data Acquisition System (DAS).
Task Standard: Utilizing SO23-3-2.24.11, bypassed the trip function of RE-7804G1, Containment Purge Isolation Radiation Monitor. Using SO23-3-2.36, bypassed the alarm functions of 2R-7804G, Gas and 2R-7804P Particulate Monitors.
Required Materials: SO23-3-2.24.11, Containment Airborne Radiation Monitor System Operation, Rev.21.
SO23-3-2.36, Radiation Monitor Data Acquisition System, Rev. 7.
Validation Time: 20 minutes Completion Time: ________ minutes Comments:
Result: SAT UNSAT Examiner (Print / Sign): Date:
Page 1 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-8 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 SIMULATOR SETUP MACHINE OPERATOR:
INITIALIZE to IC-245 or any Initial Condition and PERFORM the following:
- VERIFY Key #205, 7804 / 7807 Bypass Key is located in the Key Locker.
MACHINE OPERATOR NOTE:
- After each JPM, RETURN Key #205, 7804 / 7807 Bypass Key to the Key Locker.
EXAMINER:
PROVIDE the examinee with a copy of:
- SO23-3-2.24.11, Containment Airborne Radiation Monitor System Operation (Procedure 1).
- Attachment 4, Containment Radiation Monitors Bypass Operation.
- INITIAL and N/A as required through Step 1.4.
- Attachment 6, Limitations and Specifics.
- SO23-3-2.36, Radiation Monitor Data Acquisition System (Procedure 2).
- Section 6.4, Bypassing and Restoring RTP Chassis Monitor Alarms.
- Attachment 4, Radiation Monitor DAS Limitations and Specifics.
Page 2 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-8 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1
- Check Mark Denotes Critical Step START TIME:
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-3-2.24.11, Attachment 4.
Perform Step: 1 REMOVE the CPIS automatic actuation trip function from service by 2.1.1 positioning the NORMAL / BYPASS keyswitch to BYPASS.
- RIC-7804G1 (Train A) HS-7804B1 Standard: OBTAINED Key #205 from Key Locker and INSERTED into 2HS-7804B1, CPIS NORMAL BYPASS keyswitch and TURNED to BYPASS position.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 2 VERIFY the associated white RESET/TEST light extinguishes.
2.1.2 Standard
OBSERVED 2HS-7804L1, CPIS RESET / TEST switch white RESET /
TEST light off.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 3 VERIFY 57C40, CPIS AUTO ACTUATION BYPASSED, annunciates.
2.1.3 Standard
ACKNOWLEDGED Annunciator 57C40 - CPIS AUTO ACTUATION BYPASSED in alarm.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Examiner Note: When reference, PROVIDE a copy of Procedure 2.
Perform Step: 4 PLACE the monitor(s) in Alarm Bypass in DAS per SO23-3-2.36, 2.1.4 Section for Bypassing and Restoring MGPI Interfaced Monitor Alarms.
Standard: REFERRED to SO23-3-2.36, Radiation Monitor Data Acquisition System, Section 6.5, Bypassing and Restoring MGPI Interfaced Monitor Alarms.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 3 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-8 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-3-2.36, Section 6.5.
Examiner Note: The following steps will be repeated twice, once for 2R-7804G (gas) and once for 2R-7804P (particulate) as 2R-7804 is a dual channel Radiation Monitor.
Examiner Cue: The Shift Manager has temporarily suspended peer checking.
Perform Step: 5 Place an MGPI Interfaced Monitor in Alarm Bypass:
6.5.1 & 6.5.1.1
- Go to Monitor Page for the desired Rad Monitor.
Standard: From HOME page, CLICKED on 2R-7804 green dot, then CLICKED on green dot in Penetration Building Area.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 6 Place an MGPI Interfaced Monitor in Alarm Bypass:
6.5.1 & 6.5.1.2
- If the monitor has dual channels, then go to the Trend Screen for one of the monitor channels.
Standard: CLICKED on Trend Screen for either 2R7804G or 2R7804P.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 7 Place an MGPI Interfaced Monitor in Alarm Bypass:
6.5.1 & 6.5.1.3
- Select DETAILS on the Navigate Bar.
Standard: CLICKED on NAVIGATE Page, then DETAIL.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 8 Place an MGPI Interfaced Monitor in Alarm Bypass:
6.5.1 & 6.5.1.4
- Select the pull-down menu for UNIT MODE.
Standard: DEPRESSED down () arrow on UNIT MODE pull-down menu.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 4 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-8 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 9 Place an MGPI Interfaced Monitor in Alarm Bypass:
6.5.1 & 6.5.1.5
- Select ALM BYP to bypass the alarm.
Standard: CLICKED on ALM BYP to bypass alarm.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 10 Place an MGPI Interfaced Monitor in Alarm Bypass:
6.5.1 & 6.5.1.6
- Verify Alarm Level box indicates INST FAIL.
Standard: VERIFIED Alarm Level box reads INST FAIL.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 11 Place an MGPI Interfaced Monitor in Alarm Bypass:
6.5.1 & 6.5.1.7
- Verify the icon on the Home Screen has turned Light Blue, indicating Instrument Fail / Alarm Bypass.
Standard: CLICKED on NAVIGATE Page, then CLICKED on HOME page, and OBSERVED light blue icon for 2R-7804 lit.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Examiner Note: Either action will ACKNOWLEDGE Alarm Bypass Status change.
Perform Step: 12 Place an MGPI Interfaced Monitor in Alarm Bypass:
6.5.1 & 6.5.1.8
- Acknowledge the Alarm Bypass Status Change alarm on the Alarm Summary Page.
Standard: ACKNOWLEDGED the Alarm Bypass Status change:
- CLICKED on NAVIGATE page, then CLICKED on 2C ALMS page or 2C3 ALMS page, then CLICKED on ACK ALL.
- DOUBLE-CLICKED 2R-7804 Alarm Bypass Status.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 13 Place an MGPI Interfaced Monitor in Alarm Bypass:
6.5.1 & 6.5.1.9
- If monitor has dual channels, then repeat steps 6.5.1.1 through 6.5.1.8 for the other monitor channel.
Standard: REPEATED Steps 6.5.1.1 through 6.5.1.8 for the other 2R-7804 channel.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 5 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-8 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 14 Place an MGPI Interfaced Monitor in Alarm Bypass:
6.5.1 & 6.5.1.1
- Go to Monitor Page for the desired Rad Monitor.
Standard: From HOME page, CLICKED on 2R-7804 blue dot, then CLICKED on green dot in Penetration Building Area.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Examiner Note: If 2R7804G was initially selected, then 2R7804P will be bypassed and vice versa.
Perform Step: 15 Place an MGPI Interfaced Monitor in Alarm Bypass:
6.5.1 & 6.5.1.2
- If the monitor has dual channels, then go to the Trend Screen for one of the monitor channels.
Standard: CLICKED on Trend Screen for either 2R7804G or 2R7804P.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 16 Place an MGPI Interfaced Monitor in Alarm Bypass:
6.5.1 & 6.5.1.3
- Select DETAILS on the Navigate Bar.
Standard: CLICKED on NAVIGATE Page, then DETAIL.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 17 Place an MGPI Interfaced Monitor in Alarm Bypass:
6.5.1 & 6.5.1.4
- Select the pull-down menu for UNIT MODE.
Standard: DEPRESSED down () arrow on UNIT MODE pull-down menu.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 18 Place an MGPI Interfaced Monitor in Alarm Bypass:
6.5.1 & 6.5.1.5
- Select ALM BYP to bypass the alarm.
Standard: CLICKED on ALM BYP to bypass alarm.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 19 Place an MGPI Interfaced Monitor in Alarm Bypass:
6.5.1 & 6.5.1.6
- Verify Alarm Level box indicates INST FAIL.
Standard: VERIFIED Alarm Level box reads INST FAIL.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 6 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-8 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 20 Place an MGPI Interfaced Monitor in Alarm Bypass:
6.5.1 & 6.5.1.7
- Verify the icon on the Home Screen has turned Light Blue, indicating Instrument Fail/Alarm Bypass.
Standard: CLICKED on NAVIGATE Page, then CLICKED on HOME page, and OBSERVED light blue icon for 2R-7804 lit.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Examiner Note: Either action will ACKNOWLEDGE Alarm Bypass Status change.
Perform Step: 21 Place an MGPI Interfaced Monitor in Alarm Bypass:
6.5.1 & 6.5.1.8
- Acknowledge the Alarm Bypass Status Change alarm on the Alarm Summary Page.
Standard: ACKNOWLEDGED the Alarm Bypass Status change:
- CLICKED on NAVIGATE page, then CLICKED on 2C ALMS page or 2C3 ALMS page, then CLICKED on ACK ALL.
- DOUBLE-CLICKED 2R-7804 Alarm Bypass Status.
Terminating Cue: The CRS will implement actions of the ODCM. This JPM is complete.
Comment: SAT UNSAT STOP TIME:
Page 7 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-8 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM CUE SHEET Form ES-C-1 INITIAL CONDITIONS: Given the following condition:
- Train A RIC-7804G1, Containment Purge Isolation Radiation Monitor, must be BYPASSED to allow Chemistry to change filters.
INITIATING CUE: The Control Room Supervisor directs you to PERFORM the following:
- BYPASS Train A RIC-7804G1, Containment Purge Isolation Radiation Monitor per SO23-3-2.24.11, Containment Radiation Monitor System Operation, Attachment 4, Containment Radiation Monitors Bypass Operation.
- START at Step 2.1.
- Train A both 2R-7804G, Gas and 2R-7804P Particulate Monitors must be BYPASSED in the Data Acquisition System (DAS).
Page 8 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM S-8 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 Facility: SONGS JPM # NRC JPM P-1 Unit 2 Task #188351 K/A #068.AA1.12 4.4 / 4.4 SF-7
Title:
Place the EPPM in Service Examinee (Print):
Testing Method:
Simulated Performance: X Classroom:
Actual Performance: Simulator:
Alternate Path: X Plant: X Time Critical:
READ TO THE EXAMINEE I will explain the Initial Conditions, which steps to simulate or discuss, and provide an Initiating Cue.
When you complete the task successfully, the objective for this JPM will be satisfied.
Initial Conditions: Given the following conditions:
- The Control Room has been evacuated.
- SO23-13-2, Shutdown from outside the Control Room, Attachment 4, 21 Duties, has been completed through Step 5.1.3.
- Safe Shutdown Kit 21 is in your possession.
Initiating Cue: The Unit Supervisor directs you to PERFORM the following:
- PLACE the Essential Plant Parameters Monitoring (EPPM) Panel in service per SO23-13-2, Shutdown from Outside the Control Room, Attachment 4, 21 Duties.
- START at Step 6.0.
Task Standard: Utilizing SO23-13-2, Attachment 4, placed the Essential Plant Parameters Monitoring Panel in Service.
Required Materials: SO23-13-2, Shutdown from Outside the Control Room, Rev. 17-2.
Validation Time: 10 minutes Completion Time: ________ minutes Comments:
Result: SAT UNSAT Examiner (Print / Sign): Date:
Page 1 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM P-1 Unit 2 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 PLANT SETUP EXAMINER:
PROVIDE the examinee with a copy of:
- SO23-13-2, Shutdown from Outside the Control Room.
- Attachment 4, 21 Duties.
EXAMINER NOTE:
- PROVIDE a color copy of the power supply inside the EPPM.
Page 2 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM P-1 Unit 2 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1
- Check Mark Denotes Critical Step START TIME:
Perform Step: 1 Proceed to Essential Plant Parameters Monitoring Panel.
Standard: PROCEEDED to Essential Plant Parameters Monitoring Panel (EPPM) at Unit 2 45' Electrical Penetration Room.
Examiner Cue:
Comment: SAT UNSAT Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-13-2, Attachment 3.
Perform Step: 2 Connect headset to CKT No. 1 jack on cable tray support and establish 6.1 communications with the Unit 2 CRS.
Standard: CONNECTED headset to CKT No. 1 jack on cable tray support and ESTABLISHED communications with the Unit 2 CRS.
Examiner Cue: Unit 2 Control Room Supervisor is on the line.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Examiner Note: Use the provided picture of the inside of the cabinet.
Perform Step: 3 At EPPM (2L-411), verify the following 2 power supplies (inside rear 6.2 & 6.2.1 panel) closed with red and green lights illuminated:
- 2L-411PS01, EPPM Panel 2L411 Power Supply.
Standard: OPENED cabinet and VERIFIED 2L-411PS01, EPPM Panel 2L411 Power Supply red and green lights illuminated.
Examiner Cue: Both red and green power supply lights are lit.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 4 At EPPM (2L-411), verify the following 2 power supplies (inside rear 6.2 & 6.2.2 panel) closed with red and green lights illuminated:
- 2L-411PS02, EPPM Panel 2L411 Power Supply.
Standard: OPENED cabinet and VERIFIED 2L-411PS02, EPPM Panel 2L411 Power Supply red and green lights illuminated.
Examiner Cue: Both red and green power supply lights are lit.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 3 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM P-1 Unit 2 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 5 At EPPM (2L-411), verify the following 2 power supplies (inside rear 6.2 & 6.2.3 panel) closed with red and green lights illuminated:
- IF power is not indicated, THEN proceed to step 6.11. (Mark N/A if power is indicated.)
Standard: OBSERVED photograph and DETERMINED power was indicated and MARKED Step 6.2.3 N/A.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 6 Placing Thot and Tcold indication at the EPPM in service:
6.3 & 6.3.1
- Using Key No. 44, place 2HS-0111BX-1 in the LOCAL position on Panel 2L-411A.
Standard: INSERTED Key No. 44 into keylock and TURNED 2HS-0111BX-1 to LOCAL position on Panel 2L-411A.
Examiner Cue: The switch is in LOCAL.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 7 Placing Thot and Tcold indication at the EPPM in service:
6.3 & 6.3.2
- Using Key No. 44, place 2HS-0111BX-2 in the LOCAL position on Panel 2L-411A.
Standard: INSERTED Key No. 44 into keylock and TURNED 2HS-0111BX-2 to LOCAL position on Panel 2L-411A.
Examiner Cue: The switch is in LOCAL.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 4 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM P-1 Unit 2 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Examiner Note: The following step represents an Alternate Path of this JPM.
Perform Step: 8 If 2TI-0111BX oscillations are occurring, then cycle 2HS-0111BX-1 and 6.3 & 6.3.2.1 2HS-0111BX-2 in order to clean the contacts to obtain a stable reading.
Standard: PERFORMED the following:
- CYCLED handswitches 2HS-0111BX-1 and 2HS-0111BX-2 between LOCAL and CONT ROOM as required until TI-0111BX, Loop 1 Hot Leg Temp reading STABILIZED (critical).
- OBSERVED THOT reading (not critical).
Examiner Cue: The indication is oscillating.
Examiner Cue: When both handswitches are cycled one time, REPORT THOT indication is stable and reading 530°F.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 9 Placing Thot and Tcold indication at the EPPM in service:
6.3 & 6.3.3
- Using Key No. 44, place 2HS-0111BY-1 in the LOCAL position on Panel 2L-411A.
Standard: INSERTED Key No. 44 into keylock and TURNED 2HS-0111BY-1 to LOCAL position on Panel 2L-411B.
Examiner Cue: The switch is in LOCAL.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 10 Placing Thot and Tcold indication at the EPPM in service:
6.3 & 6.3.4
- Using Key No. 44, place 2HS-0111BY-2 in the LOCAL position on Panel 2L-411A.
Standard: INSERTED Key No. 44 into keylock and TURNED 2HS-0111BY-2 to LOCAL position on Panel 2L-411B.
Examiner Cue: The switch is in LOCAL.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 5 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM P-1 Unit 2 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Examiner Note: The following step represents an Alternate Path of this JPM.
Perform Step: 11 If 2TI-0111BY oscillations are occurring, then cycle 2HS-0111BY-1 and 6.3 & 6.3.4.1 2HS-0111BY-2 in order to clean the contacts to obtain a stable reading.
Standard: PERFORMED the following:
- CYCLED handswitches 2HS-0111BY-1 and 2HS-0111BY-2 between LOCAL and CONT ROOM as required until TI-0111BY, Loop 1A Cold Leg Temp reading STABILIZED (critical).
- OBSERVED TCOLD reading (not critical).
Examiner Cue: The indication is oscillating.
Examiner Cue: When both handswitches are cycled one time, REPORT TCOLD indication is stable and reading 510°F.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 12 Place the following handswitches in LOCAL:
6.4 & 6.4.1
- 2HS-0100F, PZR pressure Standard: PERFORMED the following:
- PLACED 2HS-0100F, PZR PRESSURE in LOCAL (critical).
- OBSERVED Pressurizer pressure on 2PI-0100A, PZR PRESS.
(not critical).
Examiner Cue: Pressurizer pressure is 2250 PSIA.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 13 Place the following handswitches in LOCAL:
6.4 & 6.4.2
- 2HS-0103A, PZR level Standard: PERFORMED the following:
- PLACED 2HS-0103A, PZR LEVEL in LOCAL (critical).
- OBSERVED Pressurizer level on 2LI-0103A, PZR LEVEL (not critical).
Terminating Cue: Pressurizer level is 38%. This JPM is complete.
Comment: SAT UNSAT STOP TIME:
Page 6 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM P-1 Unit 2 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM CUE SHEET Form ES-C-1 Page 7 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM P-1 Unit 2 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM CUE SHEET Form ES-C-1 INITIAL CONDITIONS: Given the following conditions:
- The Control Room has been evacuated.
- SO23-13-2, Shutdown from outside the Control Room, Attachment 4, 21 Duties, has been completed through Step 5.1.3.
- Safe Shutdown Kit 21 is in your possession.
INITIATING CUE: The Unit Supervisor directs you to PERFORM the following:
- PLACE the Essential Plant Parameters Monitoring (EPPM) Panel in service per SO23-13-2, Shutdown from Outside the Control Room, Attachment 4, 21 Duties.
- START at Step 6.0.
Page 8 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM P-1 Unit 2 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 Facility: SONGS JPM # NRC JPM P-1 Unit 3 Task #188351 K/A #068.AA1.12 4.4 / 4.4 SF-7
Title:
Place the EPPM in Service Examinee (Print):
Testing Method:
Simulated Performance: X Classroom:
Actual Performance: Simulator:
Alternate Path: X Plant: X Time Critical:
READ TO THE EXAMINEE I will explain the Initial Conditions, which steps to simulate or discuss, and provide an Initiating Cue.
When you complete the task successfully, the objective for this JPM will be satisfied.
Initial Conditions: Given the following conditions:
- The Control Room has been evacuated.
- SO23-13-2, Shutdown from outside the Control Room, Attachment 5, 31 Duties, has been completed through Step 5.1.3.
- Safe Shutdown Kit 31 is in your possession.
Initiating Cue: The Unit Supervisor directs you to PERFORM the following:
- PLACE the Essential Plant Parameters Monitoring (EPPM) Panel in service per SO23-13-2, Shutdown from Outside the Control Room, Attachment 5, 31 Duties.
- START at Step 6.0.
Task Standard: Utilizing SO23-13-2, Attachment 5, placed the Essential Plant Parameters Monitoring Panel in Service.
Required Materials: SO23-13-2, Shutdown from Outside the Control Room, Rev. 17-2.
Validation Time: 10 minutes Completion Time: ________ minutes Comments:
Result: SAT UNSAT Examiner (Print / Sign): Date:
Page 1 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM P-1 Unit 3 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 PLANT SETUP EXAMINER:
PROVIDE the examinee with a copy of:
- SO23-13-2, Shutdown from Outside the Control Room.
- Attachment 5, 31 Duties.
EXAMINER NOTE:
- PROVIDE a color copy of the power supply inside the EPPM.
Page 2 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM P-1 Unit 3 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1
- Check Mark Denotes Critical Step START TIME:
Perform Step: 1 Proceed to Essential Plant Parameters Monitoring Panel.
Standard: PROCEEDED to Essential Plant Parameters Monitoring Panel (EPPM) at Unit 3 45' Electrical Penetration Room.
Examiner Cue:
Comment: SAT UNSAT Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-13-2, Attachment 5.
Perform Step: 2 Connect headset to CKT No. 1 jack on cable tray support and establish 6.1 communications with the Unit 3 CRS.
Standard: CONNECTED headset to CKT No. 1 jack on cable tray support and ESTABLISHED communications with the Unit 3 CRS.
Examiner Cue: Unit 3 Control Room Supervisor is on the line.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Examiner Note: Use the provided picture of the inside of the cabinet.
Examiner Note: Procedure enhancement identified for Steps 6.2.1 and 6.2.2.
Perform Step: 3 At EPPM (3L-411), verify the following 2 power supplies (inside rear 6.2 & 6.2.1 panel) closed with red and green lights illuminated:
- 3L-411PS01, EPPM Panel 2L411 Power Supply.
Standard: OPENED cabinet and VERIFIED 3L-411PS01, EPPM Panel 3L411 Power Supply red and green lights illuminated.
Examiner Cue: Both red and green power supply lights are lit.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 4 At EPPM (3L-411), verify the following 2 power supplies (inside rear 6.2 & 6.2.2 panel) closed with red and green lights illuminated:
- 3L-411PS02, EPPM Panel 2L411 Power Supply.
Standard: OPENED cabinet and VERIFIED 3L-411PS02, EPPM Panel 3L411 Power Supply red and green lights illuminated.
Examiner Cue: Both red and green power supply lights are lit.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 3 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM P-1 Unit 3 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 5 At EPPM (3L-411), verify the following 2 power supplies (inside rear 6.2 & 6.2.3 panel) closed with red and green lights illuminated:
- IF power is not indicated, THEN proceed to step 6.11. (Mark N/A if power is indicated.)
Standard: OBSERVED photograph and DETERMINED power was indicated and MARKED Step 6.2.3 N/A.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 6 Placing Thot and Tcold indication at the EPPM in service:
6.3 & 6.3.1
- Using Key No. 44, place 3HS-0111BX-1 in the LOCAL position on Panel 3L-411A.
Standard: INSERTED Key No. 44 into keylock and TURNED 3HS-0111BX-1 to LOCAL position on Panel 3L-411A.
Examiner Cue: The switch is in LOCAL.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 7 Placing Thot and Tcold indication at the EPPM in service:
6.3 & 6.3.2
- Using Key No. 44, place 3HS-0111BX-2 in the LOCAL position on Panel 3L-411A.
Standard: INSERTED Key No. 44 into keylock and TURNED 3HS-0111BX-2 to LOCAL position on Panel 3L-411A.
Examiner Cue: The switch is in LOCAL.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 4 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM P-1 Unit 3 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Examiner Note: The following step represents an Alternate Path of this JPM.
Perform Step: 8 If 3TI-0111BX oscillations are occurring, then cycle 3HS-0111BX-1 and 6.3 & 6.3.2.1 3HS-0111BX-2 in order to clean the contacts to obtain a stable reading.
Standard: PERFORMED the following:
- CYCLED handswitches 3HS-0111BX-1 and 3HS-0111BX-2 between LOCAL and CONT ROOM as required until TI-0111BX, Loop 1 Hot Leg Temp reading STABILIZED (critical).
- OBSERVED THOT reading (not critical).
Examiner Cue: The indication is oscillating.
Examiner Cue: When both handswitches are cycled one time, REPORT THOT indication is stable and reading 530°F.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 9 Placing Thot and Tcold indication at the EPPM in service:
6.3 & 6.3.3
- Using Key No. 44, place 3HS-0111BY-1 in the LOCAL position on Panel 3L-411B.
Standard: INSERTED Key No. 44 into keylock and TURNED 3HS-0111BY-1 to LOCAL position on Panel 3L-411B.
Examiner Cue: The switch is in LOCAL.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 10 Placing Thot and Tcold indication at the EPPM in service:
6.3 & 6.3.4
- Using Key No. 44, place 3HS-0111BY-2 in the LOCAL position on Panel 3L-411B.
Standard: INSERTED Key No. 44 into keylock and TURNED 3HS-0111BY-2 to LOCAL position on Panel 3L-411B.
Examiner Cue: The switch is in LOCAL.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 5 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM P-1 Unit 3 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Examiner Note: The following step represents an Alternate Path of this JPM.
Perform Step: 11 If 3TI-0111BY oscillations are occurring, then cycle 3HS-0111BY-1 and 6.3 & 6.3.4.1 3HS-0111BY-2 in order to clean the contacts to obtain a stable reading.
Standard: PERFORMED the following:
- CYCLED handswitches 3HS-0111BY-1 and 3HS-0111BY-2 between LOCAL and CONT ROOM as required until TI-0111BY, Loop 1A Cold Leg Temp reading STABILIZED (critical).
- OBSERVED TCOLD reading (not critical).
Examiner Cue: The indication is oscillating.
Examiner Cue: When both handswitches are cycled one time, REPORT TCOLD indication is stable and reading 510°F.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 12 Place the following handswitches in LOCAL:
6.4 & 6.4.1
- 3HS-0100F, PZR pressure Standard: PERFORMED the following:
- PLACED 3HS-0100F, PZR PRESSURE in LOCAL (critical).
- OBSERVED Pressurizer pressure on 3PI-0100A, PZR PRESS.
(not critical).
Examiner Cue: Pressurizer pressure is 2250 PSIA.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 13 Place the following handswitches in LOCAL:
6.4 & 6.4.2
- 3HS-0103A, PZR level Standard: PERFORMED the following:
- PLACED 3HS-0103A, PZR LEVEL in LOCAL (critical).
- OBSERVED Pressurizer level on 3LI-0103A, PZR LEVEL (not critical).
Terminating Cue: Pressurizer level is 38%. This JPM is complete.
Comment: SAT UNSAT STOP TIME:
Page 6 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM P-1 Unit 3 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM CUE SHEET Form ES-C-1 Page 7 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM P-1 Unit 3 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM CUE SHEET Form ES-C-1 INITIAL CONDITIONS: Given the following conditions:
- The Control Room has been evacuated.
- SO23-13-2, Shutdown from outside the Control Room, Attachment 5, 31 Duties, has been completed through Step 5.1.3.
- Safe Shutdown Kit 31 is in your possession.
INITIATING CUE: The Unit Supervisor directs you to PERFORM the following:
- PLACE the Essential Plant Parameters Monitoring (EPPM) Panel in service per SO23-13-2, Shutdown from Outside the Control Room, Attachment 5, 31 Duties.
- START at Step 6.0.
Page 8 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM P-1 Unit 3 Rev d.doc
NRC Initial License Exam, SONGS Nov 2011 In Plant JPMs P-2 for Unit 2 and 3 Redacted Security Related Information Withhold from Public Disclosure in accordance with 10 CFR 2.390
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 Facility: SONGS JPM # NRC JPM P-3 Unit 2 Task #190141 K/A #058.AA1.01 3.4 / 3.5 SF-6
Title:
Place the Swing Battery Charger in Operation Examinee (Print):
Testing Method:
Simulated Performance: X Classroom:
Actual Performance: Simulator:
Alternate Path: Plant: X Time Critical:
READ TO THE EXAMINEE I will explain the Initial Conditions, which steps to simulate or discuss, and provide an Initiating Cue.
When you complete the task successfully, the objective for this JPM will be satisfied.
Initial Conditions: Given the following conditions:
- SO23-13-26, Loss of Power to an AC Bus, has been entered following a loss of power to Bus 2A04.
- Annunciator 63A52 - 2D1 CHARGER TROUBLE, is in alarm and will not reset.
- Response Not Obtained (RNO) actions of SO23-13-26, Step 7b, requires the Swing Battery Charger to be placed in service.
Initiating Cue: The Unit Supervisor directs you to PERFORM the following:
- PLACE the Unit 2 B021, Swing Battery Charger in operation per SO23-6-15, Operation of 125 VDC Systems, Attachment 16, B021, Swing Battery Charger, Operations.
- START at Step 2.1.1.
Task Standard: Utilizing SO23-6-15, placed the Unit 2 B021, Swing Battery Charger in operation on DC Bus 2D1.
Required Materials: SO23-6-15, Operation of 125 VDC Systems, Rev. 47.
Validation Time: 20 minutes Completion Time: ________ minutes Comments:
Result: SAT UNSAT Examiner (Print / Sign): Date:
Page 1 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM P-3 Unit 2 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 PLANT SETUP EXAMINER:
PROVIDE the examinee with a copy of:
- SO23-6-15, Operation of 125 VDC Systems.
- Attachment 16, B021, Swing Battery Charger, Operations.
EXAMINER NOTE:
- BRIEF the Shift Manager prior to entry (Protected Train).
- ENSURE applicant has a flashlight.
Page 2 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM P-3 Unit 2 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1
- Check Mark Denotes Critical Step START TIME:
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-6-15, Attachment 16.
Examiner Note: Unit 2 location of the Swing Battery Charger is Room 310-A.
Perform Step: 1 VERIFY OPEN B02100, Swing Battery Charger B021 AC Input Breaker.
2.1.1 Standard
VERIFIED 2B02100, Swing Battery Charger 2B021 AC INPUT BKR in OFF position.
Examiner Cue: The breaker is in OFF.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 2 VERIFY LOCKED OPEN B02101, Swing Battery Charger B021 DC 2.1.2 Output to D1 Battery.
Standard: VERIFIED LOCKED OPEN 2B02101, Swing Battery Charger 2B021 DC Output to 2D1 Battery.
Examiner Cue: The breaker is LOCKED OPEN.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 3 VERIFY LOCKED OPEN B02103, Swing Battery Charger B021 DC 2.1.3 Output to D3 Battery.
Standard: VERIFIED LOCKED OPEN 2B02103, Swing Battery Charger 2B021 DC Output to 2D3 Battery.
Examiner Cue: The breaker is LOCKED OPEN.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 3 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM P-3 Unit 2 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 4 ENSURE CLOSED the 125 VDC battery breaker:
2.1.4
- D101, Battery Bank B007 (DC Bus D1)
Standard: VERIFIED 125 VDC 2D101, Battery Bank 2B007 in ON position.
Examiner Cue: The battery breaker is in ON.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 5 VERIFY CLOSED D101S, Swing Batt Chgr B021 Iso Bkr to D1 Batt 2.1.5 B007.
Standard: VERIFIED 2D101S, Swing Batt Chgr 2B021 Iso Bkr to 2D1 Batt 2B007 CLOSED.
Examiner Cue: The breaker is ON.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 6 VERIFY CLOSED D301S, Swing Batt Chgr B021 Iso Bkr to D3 Batt 2.1.6 B009.
Standard: DETERMINED Step 2.1.6 is N/A.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Examiner Note: Motor Control Center BQ is located in Room 308A.
Perform Step: 7 VERIFY CLOSED Swing Battery Charger B021 Feeder Breaker:
2.1.7
- Unit 2: BQ-17 Standard: VERIFIED Swing Battery Charger 2B021 Feeder Breaker, Unit 2: BQ-17 in ON position.
Examiner Cue: The breaker is in ON.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 4 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM P-3 Unit 2 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 8 At the 125 VDC Distribution Panel, check the negative to ground, 2.1.8 positive to ground, and battery voltage.
Standard: At 125 VDC Distribution Panel, TURNED Ground Detector P & N knob to P GROUND, N GROUND, and BATTERY positions and OBSERVED negative to ground, positive to ground, and battery voltage.
Examiner Cue: When performed, REPORT the following:
- P-GROUND position reads 65 volts.
- N-GROUND position reads 65 volts.
- BATTERY position reads 130 volts.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 9 ENSURE B021, Swing Battery Charger, is selected to FLOAT.
2.1.9 Standard
VERIFIED 2B021, Swing Battery Charger Switch SELECTED to FLOAT position.
Examiner Cue: Switch is as you see it.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 10 Request Maintenance to adjust float potentiometer to minimize 2.1.10 transients.
Standard: DETERMINED Step 2.1.10 is N/A.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 5 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM P-3 Unit 2 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 11 CLOSE B02100, Swing Battery Charger B021 AC Input Breaker.
2.1.11 Standard: CLOSED 2B02100, Swing Battery Charger 2B021 AC Input BKR to ON position.
Examiner Cue: 90 seconds has elapsed. Voltage is 131 volts.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 12 After Output Voltage stabilizes (~90 seconds), then UNLOCK AND 2.1.12 CLOSE the Swing Battery Charger B021 DC Output to the selected Battery/DC Bus.
- D1: B02101 Standard: DETERMINED output voltage stabilized, INSERTED Key and UNLOCKED then CLOSED 2B02101, Swing Battery Charger 2B021 DC Output to 2D1 Battery.
Examiner Cue: The switch is UP.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 13 For the Charger placed in service, check Charger indications normal, as 2.1.13 & 2.1.13.1 follows:
- FLOAT indicating light ILLUMINATED.
Standard: VERIFIED green FLOAT indicating light is LIT.
Examiner Cue: FLOAT indicating light is green.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 14 For the Charger placed in service, check Charger indications normal, as 2.1.13 & 2.1.13.2 follows:
Examiner Cue: DC voltage is approximately 131 VDC.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 6 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM P-3 Unit 2 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 15 For the Charger placed in service, check Charger indications normal, as 2.1.13 & 2.1.13.3 follows:
- If voltage is not in desired band, then request Maintenance to adjust voltage as required. (May be performed during other voltage adjustments.)
Standard: VERIFIED voltage is in desired band.
Examiner Cue: Voltage is 132 volts.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 16 For the Charger placed in service, check Charger indications normal, as 2.1.13 & 2.1.13.4 follows:
Terminating Cue: DC ammeter reads 100 amps. This JPM is complete.
Comment: SAT UNSAT STOP TIME:
Page 7 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM P-3 Unit 2 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM CUE SHEET Form ES-C-1 INITIAL CONDITIONS: Given the following conditions:
- SO23-13-26, Loss of Power to an AC Bus, has been entered following a loss of power to Bus 2A04.
- Annunciator 63A52 - 2D1 CHARGER TROUBLE, is in alarm and will not reset.
- Response Not Obtained (RNO) actions of SO23-13-26, Step 7b, requires the Swing Battery Charger to be placed in service.
INITIATING CUE: The Unit Supervisor directs you to PERFORM the following:
- PLACE the Unit 2 B021, Swing Battery Charger in operation per SO23-6-15, Operation of 125 VDC Systems, Attachment 16, B021, Swing Battery Charger, Operations.
- START at Step 2.1.1.
Page 8 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM P-3 Unit 2 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 Facility: SONGS JPM # NRC JPM P-3 Unit 3 Task #190141 K/A #058.AA1.01 3.4 / 3.5 SF-6
Title:
Place the Swing Battery Charger in Operation Examinee (Print):
Testing Method:
Simulated Performance: X Classroom:
Actual Performance: Simulator:
Alternate Path: Plant: X Time Critical:
READ TO THE EXAMINEE I will explain the Initial Conditions, which steps to simulate or discuss, and provide an Initiating Cue.
When you complete the task successfully, the objective for this JPM will be satisfied.
Initial Conditions: Given the following conditions:
- SO23-13-26, Loss of Power to an AC Bus, has been entered following a loss of power to Bus 3A04.
- Annunciator 63A52 - 3D1 CHARGER TROUBLE, is in alarm and will not reset.
- Response Not Obtained (RNO) actions of SO23-13-26, Step 7b, requires the Swing Battery Charger to be placed in service.
Initiating Cue: The Unit Supervisor directs you to PERFORM the following:
- PLACE the Unit 3 B021, Swing Battery Charger in operation per SO23-6-15, Operation of 125 VDC Systems, Attachment 16, B021, Swing Battery Charger, Operations.
- START at Step 2.1.1.
Task Standard: Utilizing SO23-6-15, placed the Unit 3 B021, Swing Battery Charger in operation on DC Bus 3D1.
Required Materials: SO23-6-15, Operation of 125 VDC Systems, Rev. 47.
Validation Time: 20 minutes Completion Time: ________ minutes Comments:
Result: SAT UNSAT Examiner (Print / Sign): Date:
Page 1 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM P-3 Unit 3 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM WORKSHEET Form ES-C-1 PLANT SETUP EXAMINER:
PROVIDE the examinee with a copy of:
- SO23-6-15, Operation of 125 VDC Systems.
- Attachment 16, B021, Swing Battery Charger, Operations.
EXAMINER NOTE:
- BRIEF the Shift Manager prior to entry (Protected Train).
- ENSURE applicant has a flashlight.
Page 2 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM P-3 Unit 3 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1
- Check Mark Denotes Critical Step START TIME:
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-6-15, Attachment 16.
Examiner Note: Unit 3 location of the Swing Battery Charger is Room 310-E.
Perform Step: 1 VERIFY OPEN B02100, Swing Battery Charger B021 AC Input Breaker.
2.1.1 Standard
VERIFIED 3B02100, Swing Battery Charger 3B021 AC INPUT BKR in OFF position.
Examiner Cue: The breaker is in OFF.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 2 VERIFY LOCKED OPEN B02101, Swing Battery Charger B021 DC 2.1.2 Output to D1 Battery.
Standard: VERIFIED LOCKED OPEN 3B02101, Swing Battery Charger 3B021 DC Output to 3D1 Battery.
Examiner Cue: The breaker is LOCKED OPEN.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 3 VERIFY LOCKED OPEN B02103, Swing Battery Charger B021 DC 2.1.3 Output to D3 Battery.
Standard: VERFIED LOCKED OPEN 3B02103, Swing Battery Charger 3B021 DC Output to 3D3 Battery.
Examiner Cue: The breaker is LOCKED OPEN.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 3 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM P-3 Unit 3 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 4 ENSURE CLOSED the 125 VDC battery breaker:
2.1.4
- D101, Battery Bank B007 (DC Bus D1)
Standard: VERIFIED 125 VDC 3D101, Battery Bank 3B007 in ON position.
Examiner Cue: The battery breaker is in ON.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 5 VERIFY CLOSED D101S, Swing Batt Chgr B021 Iso Bkr to D1 Batt 2.1.5 B007.
Standard: VERIFIED 3D101S, Swing Batt Chgr 3B021 Iso Bkr to 3D1 Batt 3B007 CLOSED.
Examiner Cue: The breaker is ON.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 6 VERIFY CLOSED D301S, Swing Batt Chgr B021 Iso Bkr to D3 Batt 2.1.6 B009.
Standard: DETERMINED Step 2.1.6 is N/A.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Examiner Note: Motor Control Center BQ is located in Room 308A.
Perform Step: 7 VERIFY CLOSED Swing Battery Charger B021 Feeder Breaker:
2.1.7
- Unit 3: BQ-19 Standard: VERIFIED Swing Battery Charger 3B021 Feeder Breaker, Unit 3: BQ-19 in ON position.
Examiner Cue: The breaker is in ON.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 4 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM P-3 Unit 3 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 8 At the 125 VDC Distribution Panel, check the negative to ground, 2.1.8 positive to ground, and battery voltage.
Standard: At 125 VDC Distribution Panel, TURNED Ground Detector P & N knob to P GROUND, N GROUND, and BATTERY positions and OBSERVED negative to ground, positive to ground, and battery voltage.
Examiner Cue: When performed, REPORT the following:
- P-GROUND position reads 65 volts.
- N-GROUND position reads 65 volts.
- BATTERY position reads 130 volts.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 9 ENSURE B021, Swing Battery Charger, is selected to FLOAT.
2.1.9 Standard
VERIFIED 3B021, Swing Battery Charger Switch SELECTED to FLOAT position.
Examiner Cue: Switch is as you see it.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 10 Request Maintenance to adjust float potentiometer to minimize 2.1.10 transients.
Standard: DETERMINED Step 2.1.10 is N/A.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 5 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM P-3 Unit 3 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 11 CLOSE B02100, Swing Battery Charger B021 AC Input Breaker.
2.1.11 Standard: CLOSED 3B02100, Swing Battery Charger 3B021 AC Input BKR to ON position.
Examiner Cue: 90 seconds has elapsed. Voltage is 131 volts.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 12 After Output Voltage stabilizes (~90 seconds), then UNLOCK AND 2.1.12 CLOSE the Swing Battery Charger B021 DC Output to the selected Battery/DC Bus.
- D1: B02101 Standard: DETERMINED output voltage stabilized, INSERTED Key and UNLOCKED then CLOSED 3B02101, Swing Battery Charger 3B021 DC Output to 3D1 Battery.
Examiner Cue: The switch is UP.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 13 For the Charger placed in service, check Charger indications normal, as 2.1.13 & 2.1.13.1 follows:
- FLOAT indicating light ILLUMINATED.
Standard: VERIFIED green FLOAT indicating light is LIT.
Examiner Cue: FLOAT indicating light is green.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 14 For the Charger placed in service, check Charger indications normal, as 2.1.13 & 2.1.13.2 follows:
Examiner Cue: DC voltage is approximately 131 VDC.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Page 6 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM P-3 Unit 3 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM STEPS Form ES-C-1 Perform Step: 15 For the Charger placed in service, check Charger indications normal, as 2.1.13 & 2.1.13.3 follows:
- If voltage is not in desired band, then request Maintenance to adjust voltage as required. (May be performed during other voltage adjustments.)
Standard: VERIFIED voltage is in desired band.
Examiner Cue: Voltage is 132 volts.
Comment: SAT UNSAT Perform Step: 16 For the Charger placed in service, check Charger indications normal, as 2.1.13 & 2.1.13.4 follows:
Terminating Cue: DC ammeter reads 100 amps. This JPM is complete.
Comment: SAT UNSAT STOP TIME:
Page 7 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM P-3 Unit 3 Rev d.doc
Appendix C JPM CUE SHEET Form ES-C-1 INITIAL CONDITIONS: Given the following conditions:
- SO23-13-26, Loss of Power to an AC Bus, has been entered following a loss of power to Bus 3A04.
- Annunciator 63A52 - 3D1 CHARGER TROUBLE, is in alarm and will not reset.
- Response Not Obtained (RNO) actions of SO23-13-26, Step 7b, requires the Swing Battery Charger to be placed in service.
INITIATING CUE: The Unit Supervisor directs you to PERFORM the following:
- PLACE the Unit 3 B021, Swing Battery Charger in operation per SO23-6-15, Operation of 125 VDC Systems, Attachment 16, B021, Swing Battery Charger, Operations.
- START at Step 2.1.1.
Page 8 of 8 SONGS NRC 2011 JPM P-3 Unit 3 Rev d.doc
Appendix D Scenario Outline Form ES-D-1 Facility: SONGS 2 & 3 Scenario No.: 1 Op Test No.: October 2011 NRC Examiners: Operators:
Initial Conditions: 100% power MOL - RCS Boron is 980 ppm (via sample).
Turnover: Maintain steady-state power conditions.
Critical Tasks:
- Restore Flow to CCW Non-Critical Loop Prior to Exceeding Reactor Coolant Pump Operating Limits (Thrust Bearing Temperatures 225°F) per SO23-13-7, Loss of CCW / SWC.
- Manually Trip the Reactor Using Reactor Trip Pushbuttons Following Multiple CEA Drops per SO23-13-13, Misaligned or Immovable Control Element Assembly
- Manually Trip the Reactor by Deenergizing CEDM Motor Generators Following Reactor Protection System Failure per SO23-12-1, Standard Post Trip Actions.
Event No. Malf. No. Event Type* Event Description 1 RC24B I (RO, SRO) Pressurizer Spray Valve (PV-0100B) Fails 25% Open.
+10 min 2 SC01A C (BOP, SRO) Salt Water Cooling Pump (P-112) Shaft Seizure.
+20 min TS (SRO) 3 RD5603 R (RO) Control Element Assembly (CEA #56) Drops into Core.
+60 min N (BOP, SRO) Power Reduction for Dropped CEA.
TS (SRO) nd 4 RD0103 C (RO, SRO) 2 Control Element Assembly (#01) Drops into Core. Reactor Trip
+65 min Required.
5 RP22A-H C (RO/BOP) Reactor Trip Breakers Fail to Open Upon Manual Reactor Trip.
+65 min 6 RCP LP M (RO, BOP, SRO) Loss of Reactor Coolant Pump Buses 2A01 and 2A02.
+65 min Loss of Forced Circulation.
7 TC02A C (BOP) High Pressure Turbine Stop Valves (HV-2200A & HV-2200H) Fail
+65 min TC02H to Close.
8 FW23 C (BOP) Loss of Condenser Vacuum at 100% Severity.
+70 min 9 RP01O C (RO) Auxiliary Feedwater Pumps (P-141 & P-504) Fail to Start on
+70 min RP01P Emergency Feedwater Actuation Signal.
- (N)ormal, (R)eactivity, (I)nstrument, (C)omponent, (M)ajor, (TS)Technical Specifications Actual Target Quantitative Attributes 9 Total malfunctions (5-8) 3 Malfunctions after EOP entry (1-2) 4 Abnormal events (2-4) 1 Major transients (1-2) 2 EOPs entered/requiring substantive actions (1-2) 0 EOP contingencies requiring substantive actions (0-2) 3 Critical tasks (2-3)
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #1 Rev f.doc
Scenario Event Description NRC Scenario #1 SCENARIO
SUMMARY
NRC #1 The crew will assume the watch at 100% power with no scheduled activities per Operating Instruction (OI) SO23-5-1.7, Power Operations.
The first event is a Pressurizer Spray Valve that fails 25% open. The crew will respond per Annunciator Response Procedures (ARPs) and Abnormal Operating Instruction (AOI) SO23-13-27, Pressurizer Pressure and Level Malfunction. If pressure drops below 2025 PSIA, the SRO will refer to Technical Specifications.
When Pressurizer pressure is normal, the Train A Salt Water Cooling Pump will seize. This will require a transfer to Train B Component Cooling Water System per AOI SO23-13-7, Loss of Component Cooling Water (CCW) / Salt Water Cooling (SWC). The SRO will refer to Technical Specifications.
When CCW and SWC are restored, Control Element Assembly (CEA) #56 will drop into the core. Crew actions are per AOI SO23-13-13, Misaligned or Immovable Control Element Assembly, and include a power reduction as required per procedure. The crew will restore Reactor Coolant System Cold Leg temperature and then continue with a power reduction using AOI SO23-13-28, Rapid Power Reduction.
The SRO will refer to Technical Specifications.
When power has been lowered an additional 3% to 5%, a second CEA (#01) will drop into the core necessitating a manual Reactor Trip. An automatic trip is not initiated as this is not a Targeted CEA.
When the Reactor Trip pushbuttons are depressed, the Reactor Trip Circuit Breakers (RTCBs) will fail to open. This condition creates an Anticipated Transient Without Scram and is remedied by deenergizing 480 Volt Buses B15 and B16 on CR-63 which open the Control Element Drive Mechanism Motor Generator output contactors. The Reactor Trip is complicated by a loss of both Reactor Coolant Pump (RCP) Buses 2A01 and 2A02, High Pressure Turbine Stop Valves that fail to close, loss of Condenser Vacuum, and Motor Driven Auxiliary Feedwater Pumps that fail to start on an Emergency Feedwater Actuation Signal. The RTCBs will eventually open when a bona fide Reactor Protection System signal is received when RCPs are lost.
The crew will perform Emergency Operating Instruction (EOI) SO23-12-1, Standard Post Trip Actions (SPTAs) and then transition to EOI SO23-12-7, Loss of Forced Circulation / Loss of Offsite Power. The scenario is terminated when Natural Circulation is verified per EOI SO23-12-11, EOI Supporting Attachments, Floating Step 3 (FS-3), Monitor Natural Circulation Established.
Risk Significance:
- Failure of risk important system prior to trip: Pressurizer Spray Valve Failure Loss of Saltwater Cooling Pump
- Risk significant operator actions: Trip Reactor Due to 2nd Dropped Rod Deenergize Buses B15 and B16 Manually Trip Turbine Start MDAFW Pumps Following EFAS SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #1 Rev f.doc
Scenario Event Description NRC Scenario #1 MACHINE OPERATOR INSTRUCTIONS for SIMULATOR SETUP INITIALIZE to IC-230 NRC Scenario #1 and associated Setup File.
EVENT TYPE MALF # DESCRIPTION DEMAND INITIATING VALUE PARAMETER SETUP MF RP22A-H Reactor Trip Circuit Breakers fail to open (ATWS) CLOSE MF TC02A Turbine Stop Valve (HV-2200A) fails to close OPEN MF TC02H Turbine Stop Valve (HV-2200H) fails to close OPEN MF RP01O AFW Pump (P-141) fails to start on EFAS MF RP01P AFW Pump (P-504) fails to start on EFAS MF RCP LP Loss of RCP Buses 2A01 & 2A02 TRIP 1 MF RC24B Pressurizer Spray Valve PV-0100B fails open 25%
1 MF RC24B PV-0100B connector block removed at L-139 0%
NOTE: When connector block is removed, REDUCE malfunction to 0% to prevent future opening.
2 MF SC01A Salt Water Cooling Pump P-112 seized shaft SEIZURE 3 MF RD5603 CEA #56 Drops into Core / Power reduction DROP 4 MF RD0103 CEA #01 Drops into Core DROP 5 MF RP22A-H Reactor Trip Circuit Breakers fail to open (ATWS) CLOSE 6 MF RCP LP Loss of RCP Buses 2A01 & 2A02 TRIP 7 MF TC02A/H Turbine Stop Valves (HV-2200A/H) fail to close OPEN 8 MF FW23 Loss of Condenser Vacuum 100%
9 MF RP01O/P AFW Pumps (P-141/504) Fail to Start on EFAS SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #1 Rev f.doc
Scenario Event Description NRC Scenario #1 Machine Operator: EXECUTE IC-230 NRC Scenario #1 and SETUP file to align components.
ENSURE CVCS Blend Setpoints MATCH Shift Turnover Sheet.
CHANGE Operator Aid Tag #029 (CVCS) to reflect boron concentration.
VERIFY both Pressurizer Spray Valves in AUTO.
CIRCLE Unit 3 for Emergency Chillers E-335 & E-336 on CR-64.
CIRCLE Unit 3 for Motor Control Center BQ on CR-63.
VERIFY Channel Y Pressurizer Pressure and Level in service.
ENSURE Turbine Ramp Rate set to 100 MWe per minute.
PROVIDE procedures in progress, Shift Turnover, and Reactivity Management Guide to crew in Briefing Room:
- COPY of SO23-5-1.7, Power Operations, Section 6.1, Guidelines for Steady State Operation.
- LAMINATED COPY of SO23-5-1.7, Power Operations, Attachment 8, Power Maneuvering Guidelines PLACE the MOC copy of OPS Physics Summary Book on SRO Desk.
VERIFY CEA positions with ARO.
Control Room Annunciators in Alarm:
NONE SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #1 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 1 Event # 1 Page 5 of 31 Event
Description:
Pressurizer Spray Valve Fails Open Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Machine Operator: When directed, EXECUTE Event 1.
- RC24B, Pressurizer Spray Valve (PV-0100B) fails 25% open.
Indications Available:
50A14 - PZR PRESS HI / LO (+90 seconds from event initiation)
+2 min RO REFER to Annunciator Response Procedures (ARPs).
RECOGNIZE PZR Pressure Control malfunction and INFORM the SRO RO SO23-13-27 entry required.
SRO ENTER SO23-13-27, Pressurizer Pressure and Level Malfunction.
- IDENTIFY uncontrolled pressure change and GO to Step 3.
[Step 1 - YES ]
VERIFY Pressurizer Spray Valve PV-100B is NOT OPEN.
SRO/RO
[Step 3.a - NO]
RO * [RNO] GO to Step 3.c.
VERIFY Pressurizer Pressure is between 2225 & 2275 PSIA and stable.
SRO/RO
[Step 3.c - NO]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #1 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 1 Event # 1 Page 6 of 31 Event
Description:
Pressurizer Spray Valve Fails Open Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- [RNO] START and/or VERIFY PZR Backup and Proportional Heaters RO ENERGIZED.
- [RNO] DETERMINE PV-0100B, Pressurizer Spray Valve from Loop 1B, RO failed ~25% OPEN.
- [RNO] DETERMINE PV-0100B, Pressurizer Spray Valve will NOT RO CLOSE and GO to Step 3.f.
VERIFY PV-100A, Pressurizer Spray Valve from Loop 1A is NOT failed RO OPEN. [Step 3.f - YES]
VERIFY PV-100B, Pressurizer Spray Valve from Loop 1B is NOT failed RO OPEN. [Step 3.g - NO]
SRO/RO * [RNO] FAIL CLOSED PV-0100B, Pressurizer Spray Valve.
- [RNO] DIRECT the ARO to REMOVE connector block at Cabinet L-139, SRO/RO SPEC 200 Power Supply Cabinet, Nest 2, Slot 7. (HC-0100B).
Examiner Note: Removal of connector block is simulated by removing the malfunction.
RO VERIFY Pressurizer Pressure is controlled. [Step 3.h - YES]
M.O. Cue: If pressure drops below 2025 PSIA, REDUCE malfunction RC24B to 0% and REPORT to the Control Room that the connector block at Cabinet L-139, SPEC 200 Power Supply Cabinet, Nest 2, Slot 7 was removed.
SRO INITIATE notification to I & C. [Step 3.i - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #1 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 1 Event # 1 Page 7 of 31 Event
Description:
Pressurizer Spray Valve Fails Open Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior RO VERIFY Pressurizer Pressure signal has NOT failed high. [Step 3.j - YES]
VERIFY Pressurizer Pressure Control System is operating properly in AUTO.
[Step 3.k - YES]
VERIFY Pressurizer Spray was NOT initiated with T > 180°F.
[Step 3.l - YES]
Examiner Note: Tech Spec LCO 3.4.1 is entered if RCS pressure drops below 2025 PSIA.
+10 min SRO NOTIFY personnel & EVALUATE Technical Specifications. [Step 3.m - YES]
- LCO 3.4.1.A, RCS DNB (Pressure, Temperature, and Flow) Limits.
- CONDITION A - Pressurizer pressure or RCS flow rate not within limits.
- ACTION A.1 - Restore parameter(s) to within limit within 2 hours2.314815e-5 days <br />5.555556e-4 hours <br />3.306878e-6 weeks <br />7.61e-7 months <br />.
When Technical Specifications are addressed, or at Lead Examiner discretion, PROCEED to Event 2.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #1 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 1 Event # 2 Page 8 of 31 Event
Description:
Saltwater Cooling Pump Shaft Seizure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Machine Operator: When directed, EXECUTE Event 2.
- SC01A, Salt Water Cooling Pump (P-112) seized shaft.
Indications Available:
64A24 - SWC PUMP MOTOR BRG TEMP HI 64A41 - SWC PUMP TRAIN A OC (~10 seconds later) 64A15 - SWC TRAIN A FLOW HI / LO (~15 seconds later) 64A55 - SWC TRAIN A FLOW TROUBLE (~20 seconds later)
Saltwater Cooling Pump P-112 tripped indication
+30 secs BOP REFER to Annunciator Response Procedures (ARPs).
BOP DETERMINE that SWC Pump P-112 has tripped.
Examiner Note: The crew may respond per the ARPs but should enter SO23-13-7.
SRO ENTER SO23-13-7, Loss of Component Cooling Water / Salt Water Cooling.
- DETERMINE required actions based on loss of a single SWC Pump and GO to Step 14. [Step 1 - YES ]
SRO ENSURE CCW / SWC on the unaffected loop in service. [Step 14.a - YES]
SRO DIRECT transfer of CCW to Train B.
START CCW Pump P-026 and VERIFY that SWC Pump P-114 automatically BOP STARTS. [Skill of Craft]
Restore Flow to CCW Non-Critical Loop Prior to Exceeding Reactor Coolant CRITICAL TASK Pump Operating Limits (Thrust Bearing Temperatures 225°F) per SO23-13-7, STATEMENT Loss of CCW / SWC CRITICAL TASK BOP TRANSFER the CCW Non-Critical Loop to Train B. [Step 14.a.1) RNO - YES]
- DEPRESS and MAINTAIN DEPRESSED the OPEN pushbuttons for HV-6213 and HV-6219, Critical Loop B Supply and Return to NCL.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #1 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 1 Event # 2 Page 9 of 31 Event
Description:
Saltwater Cooling Pump Shaft Seizure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- When HV-6212 and HV-6218, Critical Loop A Supply and Return to NCL indicate CLOSED, then RELEASE the OPEN pushbuttons for HV-6213 and HV-6219.
TRANSFER Letdown Heat Exchanger to Train B CCW.
[Step 14.a.2) RNO - YES]
BOP VERIFY Train B Saltwater Cooling Pump P-114 in service. [Step 14.b - YES]
BOP VERIFY Train B CCW Loop normal parameters. [Step 14.c - YES]
VERIFY Train A and B Heat Exchanger high outlet temperature annunciators SRO/BOP
- RESET. [Step 14.d - YES]
BOP VERIFY Train A Saltwater Cooling flow restored. [Step 14.e - NO]
- [RNO] SECURE unnecessary loads on Train A.
SRO GO to Step 19. [Step 14.f - YES]
SRO/BOP ENSURE all system parameters restored to normal. [Step 19.a - YES]
M.O. Cue: When directed to investigate pump, WAIT 2 minutes and REPORT that P-112 motor has an odor of burnt insulation. When directed to investigate breaker, WAIT 2 minutes and REPORT breaker 2A0611 has overcurrent flags on Phases B and C SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #1 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 1 Event # 2 Page 10 of 31 Event
Description:
Saltwater Cooling Pump Shaft Seizure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
+10 min SRO NOTIFY personnel & EVALUATE Technical Specifications. [Step 19.b - YES]
- LCO 3.7.8.A - Saltwater Cooling System.
- CONDITION A - One SWC train inoperable.
- ACTION A - Restore SWC Train to OPERABLE status within 72 hours8.333333e-4 days <br />0.02 hours <br />1.190476e-4 weeks <br />2.7396e-5 months <br />.
When Train B CCW is aligned to the NCL and the Letdown Heat Exchanger, and Technical Specifications have been addressed, or at Lead Evaluators discretion, PROCEED to Event 3.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #1 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 1 Event # 3 Page 11 of 31 Event
Description:
Dropped Control Element Assembly #56 / Power Reduction for Dropped Rod Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Machine Operator: When directed, EXECUTE Event 3.
- RD5603, Dropped Control Element Assembly (CEA) #56.
Indications Available:
50A28 - CEA DEVIATION 50A36 - POWER DEPENDENT INSERTION LIMIT 50A37 - PRE-POWER DEPENDENT INSERTION LIMIT 50A38 - CEA GROUP DEVIATION 50A10 - CEDMCS CEA WITHDRAWAL PROHIBIT 56B06 - PPS CHANNEL 1 TROUBLE 56A03 - LOCAL POWER DENSITY HI CHANNEL TRIP 56A04 - DNBR LO CHANNEL TRIP 56A13 - LOCAL POWER DENSITY HI PRETRIP 56A14 - DNBR LO RPS PRETRIP 50A02 - COLSS ALARM CEA #56 yellow Rod Bottom Light indication Examiner Note: A dropped CEA requires the following procedure entries:
- SO23-13-13, Misaligned or Immovable Control Element Assembly (for the dropped CEA).
- S023-5-1.7, Power Operations (for the initial Turbine load reduction to restore TCOLD using Speed/Load Adjustment and later using Setpoint Adjustment to lower load to 85%).
- SO23-13-28, Rapid Power Reduction (guidance for reducing Reactor power to 85%).
- SO23-3-2.2, Makeup Operations (for borating the RCS).
- SO23-3-1.10, Pressurizer Pressure and Level Control (to force Pressurizer Spray flow).
- SO23-3-2.19, CEDMCS Operation, Section 6.12, Repetitive or Emergent Manual CEA Positioning (CEA operation).
RECOGNIZE that Regulating Group 4 CEA #56 has dropped and INFORM
+10 secs RO the SRO SO23-13-13 entry required.
SRO ENTER SO23-13-13, Misaligned or Immovable Control Element Assembly.
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-13-13, Misaligned or Immovable CEA.
VERIFY Special Test Exception 3.1.12, Low Power Physics Testing is NOT SRO in progress. [Step 1.a - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #1 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 1 Event # 3 Page 12 of 31 Event
Description:
Dropped Control Element Assembly #56 / Power Reduction for Dropped Rod Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior VERIFY that no more than one CEA is misaligned > 7 inches.
[Step 1.b - YES]
RO ENSURE CEDMCS Mode Selector Switch in OFF. [Step 1.c - YES]
RO VERIFY CEA misaligned. [Step 1.d - YES]
REDUCE Turbine load to restore RCS TCOLD to the pre-drop value per BOP SO23-5-1.7, Power Operations, Section for Turbine Load Change Using Speed / Load Adjustment. [Step 1.e - YES]
M.O. Cue: If sent to investigate CEDMCS, WAIT 3 minutes then REPORT no observable problems. If sent as I & C to investigate, WAIT 5 minutes then REPORT that the CEA estimated repair time cannot be determined.
SRO/RO VERIFY Reactor is critical. [Step 1.f - YES]
- RECORD initial and stabilized Reactor power levels in the NCO Log.
[Step 1.f.1) - YES]
Examiner Note: The SRO will hand off SO23-3-3.6, COLSS Out Of Service Surveillance, Attachment 1, DNBR Margin and Linear Heat Rate Limit Monitoring, to the Auxiliary Reactor Operator (ARO) or Work Process Supervisor (WPS).
Within 15 minutes, DIRECT monitoring of DNBR and LPD per SO23-3-3.6, SRO Attachment for DNBR Margin and Linear Heat Rate Limit Monitoring.
[Step 1.g - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #1 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 1 Event # 3 Page 13 of 31 Event
Description:
Dropped Control Element Assembly #56 / Power Reduction for Dropped Rod Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior DIRECT performance of Attachment 3, Misaligned CEA checklist.
[Step 1.h - YES]
SRO/RO VERIFY Reactor power greater than 50%. [Step 1.i - YES]
Examiner Note: The SRO should recognize that power reduction due to dropped CEA (~4%)
satisfies the 15 minute requirement to initiate a power reduction. The power reduction of 10% must be accomplished within 60 minutes.
Within 15 minutes of discovery, INITIATE Reactor power reduction per the SRO Table (shown above). [Step 2.a - YES]
- COMMENCE lowering Turbine load while maintaining RCS TCOLD per BOP SO23-5-1.7, Power Operations. [Step 2.a.1) - YES] on subsequent pages SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #1 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 1 Event # 3 Page 14 of 31 Event
Description:
Dropped Control Element Assembly #56 / Power Reduction for Dropped Rod Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- INITIATE boration and / or CEA insertion per SO23-3-2.2, Makeup Operations, to achieve target power level within 1 hour1.157407e-5 days <br />2.777778e-4 hours <br />1.653439e-6 weeks <br />3.805e-7 months <br /> and 45 minutes of RO rod drop time while maintaining power within requirements of table.
[Step 2.a.2).a) - YES]
- COMMENCE attempting to control ASI near full power ESI.
[Step 2.a.3) - YES]
SRO COMMENCE CEA recovery. [Step 3 - YES]
- REQUEST Reactor Engineering REPORT to Control Room.
[Step 3.a - YES]
- INITIATE recovery of CEA per Attachment 1, Restoration of CEA Operability and Alignment. [Step 3.b - YES]
Examiner Note: At this point the SRO will be awaiting field reports to restore the CEA.
Floor Cue: The Work Control Supervisor will complete the DNBR and LPD monitoring in accordance with SO23-3-3.6, COLSS Out Of Service Surveillance, Attachment 1.
Floor Cue: REPORT as the Shift Manager that I & C states the repair will be delayed. DIRECT the SRO to continue the downpower per AOI SO23-13-13.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #1 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 1 Event # 3 Page 15 of 31 Event
Description:
Dropped Control Element Assembly #56 / Power Reduction for Dropped Rod Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior SRO CONTINUE plant load reduction and plant monitoring. [Step 4 - YES]
- INITIATE monitoring Azimuthal Tilt on COLSS PID CV9008.
SRO/RO
[Step 4.a - YES]
SRO/RO
- DETERMINE Azimuthal Tilt has exceeded 0.03. [Step 4.b - YES]
- Within 2 hours2.314815e-5 days <br />5.555556e-4 hours <br />3.306878e-6 weeks <br />7.61e-7 months <br />, CHANGE the Azimuthal Tilt constants in the Core RO Protection Calculators (CPCs) per SO23-3-2.13, Core Protection /
Control Element Assembly Calculator Operation. [Step 4.b.1) - YES]
SRO/RO
- VERIFY Azimuthal Tilt 0.10. [Step 4.c - NO]
- [RNO] INITIATE Attachment 2.
- [RNO] IMPLEMENT ACTION requirements of Tech Spec LCO 3.2.3.
- NOTIFY personnel & EVALUATE Technical Specifications.
[Step 4.d - YES]
SRO EVALUATE Technical Specifications. [Step 4.d - YES]
- LCO 3.1.5.A, Control Element Assembly Alignment.
- CONDITION A - One Regulating CEA trippable and misaligned from its group by > 7 inches.
- ACTION A.1 - Initiate THERMAL POWER reduction in accordance with COLR requirements within 15 minutes.
- ACTION A.2 - Restore the misaligned CEA(s) to within 7 inches of its group within two (2) hours.
- LCO 3.2.1.B, Linear Heat Rate.
- CONDITION B - With COLSS not in service and any OPERABLE CPC local power density channel exceeding the LHR limit.
- ACTION B.1 - Initiate SR 3.2.1.2 within 15 minutes, AND,
- ACTION B.2 - Restore LHR to within limits within 4 hours4.62963e-5 days <br />0.00111 hours <br />6.613757e-6 weeks <br />1.522e-6 months <br />.
Examiner Note: Azimuthal Power Tilt (Tq) was measured at > 0.10 during validation. This value may vary somewhat depending on the time Tq is observed. The Technical Specification call should be adjusted as appropriate.
- LCO 3.2.3.B, Azimuthal Power Tilt (Tq).
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #1 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 1 Event # 3 Page 16 of 31 Event
Description:
Dropped Control Element Assembly #56 / Power Reduction for Dropped Rod Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- CONDITION B - Measured Tq > 0.03 and 0.10.
- ACTION B.1 - Adjust the Tq allowance in the CPCs to greater than or equal to the measured Tq within two (2) hours, AND,
- ACTION B.2 - Evaluate core design and safety analysis and determine that the core is acceptable for continued operation within 72 hours8.333333e-4 days <br />0.02 hours <br />1.190476e-4 weeks <br />2.7396e-5 months <br />, AND,
- ACTION B.3 - Establish appropriate operating restrictions and SRs within 72 hours8.333333e-4 days <br />0.02 hours <br />1.190476e-4 weeks <br />2.7396e-5 months <br />.
- LCO 3.2.3.C, Azimuthal Power Tilt (Tq).
- CONDITION C - Measured Tq > 0.10.
- ACTION C.1 - Adjust the Tq allowance in the CPCs to greater than or equal to the measured Tq within two (2) hours, AND,
- ACTION C.2 - Reduce THERMAL POWER to 50% RTP within four (4) hours, AND,
- ACTION C.3 - Reduce Linear Power Level - High trip setpoints to 55% RTP within 16 hours1.851852e-4 days <br />0.00444 hours <br />2.645503e-5 weeks <br />6.088e-6 months <br />, AND,
- ACTIONS C.4 and C.5 as appropriate.
- LCO 3.2.4.B, Departure from Nucleate Boiling Ratio (DNBR).
- CONDITION B - With COLSS not in service and DNBR outside the COLR specified limits using any OPERABLE channel.
- ACTION B.1 - Initiate SR 3.2.4.1 within 15 minutes, AND,
- ACTION B.2 - Restore DNBR to within limits within 4 hours4.62963e-5 days <br />0.00111 hours <br />6.613757e-6 weeks <br />1.522e-6 months <br />.
Examiner Note: The following BOP Steps are from SO23-5-1.7, Power Operations, Section 6.4, Turbine Load Change Using Speed / Load Adjustment. Using this Section, load will be reduced to restore TCOLD to ~ 542°F.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #1 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 1 Event # 3 Page 17 of 31 Event
Description:
Dropped Control Element Assembly #56 / Power Reduction for Dropped Rod Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior BOP Turbine Load Change Using Speed/Load Adjustment. [Section 6.4 - YES]
- If required, PERFORM a Reactivity Brief & Peer Check. [Step 6.4.1 - YES]
- INITIATE monitoring TCOLDAVG. [Step 6.4.2 - YES]
- ADJUST Turbine load as required to maintain TCOLD. [Step 6.4.3 - YES]
- DEPRESS HS-2210, Main Turbine Speed / Load Control, RAISE or LOWER pushbuttons for Coarse adjustment. [Step 6.4.3.1 - YES]
- ACTIVATE DCS Speed/Load Pushbuttons Box and ENSURE Rate is set at an acceptable MW/MIN value for Fine adjustment.
[Step 6.4.3.2 - YES]
- SELECT MODIFY.
- DEPRESS UP or DOWN buttons or +0.5 or -0.5 buttons.
- VERIFY Turbine load STABILIZES at Target value. [Step 6.4.4 - YES]
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-13-28, Rapid Power Reduction (RPR),
Attachment 2, RPR - 20% / hour. Using this Attachment, load will be reduced at a rate of 15% per hour to 85%.
RO/BOP PERFORM a Reactivity Brief. [Step 1.1 - YES]
SRO NOTIFY the Generation Operations Controller. [Step 1.2 - YES]
SRO INITIATE an MSR cooldown if load less than 750 MWe. [Step 1.3 - NO]
SRO INITIATE monitoring CV-9739, COLSS Raw T Power. [Step 1.4 - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #1 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 1 Event # 3 Page 18 of 31 Event
Description:
Dropped Control Element Assembly #56 / Power Reduction for Dropped Rod Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior SRO INITIATE forcing Pressurizer Spray flow. [Step 1.5 - YES]
INITIATE concurrently using a combination of Boration, CEA insertion, and SRO Turbine load reduction to achieve the targets of SO23-5-1.7. [Step 1.6 - YES]
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-3-1.10, Pressurizer Pressure and Level Control, Section 6.3, Forcing Pressurizer Sprays with RCS pressure > 1500 PSIA.
RO COMMENCE forcing Pressurizer Sprays. [Step 6.3.1 - YES]
- CONDUCT a Reactivity Brief. [Step 6.3.1.1 - YES]
- COMMENCE monitoring RCS pressure. [Step 6.3.1.2 - YES]
- VERIFY RCS pressure greater than 1500 psia. [Step 6.3.1.3 - YES]
- PLACE PZR Spray Valve Controller PV-100A in AUTO.
[Step 6.3.1.4 - YES]
- POSITION Backup Heaters to ON or AUTO as necessary to support PZR Spray Valve operation. [Step 6.3.1.5 - YES]
- LOWER PIC-0100, PZR Pressure Controller setpoint to 2225 PSIA.
[Step 6.3.1.6 - YES]
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-3-2.2, Makeup Operations, Section 6.3, Borating to the Charging Pump Suction.
RO Borating to the Charging Pump Suction: [Section 6.3 - YES]
- If required, PERFORM a Reactivity Brief. [Step 6.3.1 - YES]
- SELECT P-191, Charging Pump. [Step 6.3.2 - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #1 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 1 Event # 3 Page 19 of 31 Event
Description:
Dropped Control Element Assembly #56 / Power Reduction for Dropped Rod Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- ENTER ~5 GPM on FIC-0210Y, BAMU Flow Controller.
[Step 6.3.3 - YES]
- SELECT SET and ENTER 5 GPM. [Step 6.3.3.1 - YES]
- ENSURE FIC-0210Y in AUTO. [Step 6.3.3.2 - YES]
- SET FQIS-0210Y, Boration Counter, to ~200 GPM. [Step 6.3.4 - YES]
- SELECT MODIFY. [Step 6.3.4.1 - YES]
- ENTER 200 gallons in PRESET. [Step 6.3.4.2 - YES]
- SELECT SET PRESET. [Step 6.3.4.3 - YES]
- SELECT EXIT. [Step 6.3.4.4 - YES]
- SELECT BAMU Pump P-174 or P-175. [Step 6.3.5 - YES]
[Step 6.3.6 - YES]
- ENSURE HV-9257, BAMU to Charging Pump Suction Block, in AUTO.
[Step 6.3.7 - YES]
- COMMENCE monitoring plant parameters. [Step 6.3.8 - YES]
[Step 6.3.9 - AS REQD]
- SELECT HS-0210, Makeup Mode Selector, to BORATE.
[Step 6.3.10 - YES]
- SELECT MODIFY. [Step 6.3.10.1 - YES]
- SELECT BORATE. [Step 6.3.10.2 - YES]
- SELECT GO. [Step 6.3.10.3 - YES]
- CONFIRM boration stops automatically. [Step 6.3.11 - YES]
[Step 6.3.12 - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #1 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 1 Event # 3 Page 20 of 31 Event
Description:
Dropped Control Element Assembly #56 / Power Reduction for Dropped Rod Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-5-1.7, Power Operations, Section 6.3, Turbine Load Change Using Setpoint Adjustment. Using this Section, load will be reduced at the desired MWe / MIN rate.
BOP Turbine Load Change Using setpoint Adjustment. [Section 6.3 - YES]
- If required, PERFORM a Reactivity Brief & Peer Check. [Step 6.3.1 - YES]
- INITIATE monitoring TCOLD AVG. [Step 6.3.2 - YES]
- If raising load, then SET CVOL to about 10% above the final projected Flow Demand. [Step 6.3.3 - NO]
- ACTIVATE Turbine DCS Setpoints Box and SELECT MODIFY.
[Step 6.3.4 - YES]
- SET Demand to value (variable) and SELECT ENTER.
[Step 6.3.5 - YES]
- SET Rate to target ~3 MW/MIN value and SELECT ENTER.
[Step 6.3.6 - YES]
- SELECT P2 to INITIATE Turbine load change. [Step 6.3.7 - YES]
- VERIFY Turbine load stabilizes at Target value. [Step 6.3.8 - YES]
- RESTORE Rate to 100 MW/MIN and SELECT ENTER.
[Step 6.3.9 - YES]
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-13-13, Attachment 1, Restoration of CEA Operability and Alignment.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #1 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 1 Event # 3 Page 21 of 31 Event
Description:
Dropped Control Element Assembly #56 / Power Reduction for Dropped Rod Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
+40 min SRO COMMENCE CEA recovery. [Step 1 - YES]
- STATION dedicated operator at the CEA Control Panel. [Step 1.a - YES]
- VERIFY CEA position indications AGREE: [Step 2.b - YES]
- CHECK UEL and LEL lights. [Step 2.b.3) - YES]
- VERIFY one CEA has not been misaligned >7 inches for an unknown duration. [Step 2.c. - YES]
- REQUEST I & C department assistance. [Step 2.d - YES]
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-3-2.19, CEDMCS Operation, Section 6.12, Repetitive or Emergent Manual CEA Positioning.
- POSITION Group Select Switch to Group 6. [Step 6.12.1 - YES]
- If moving a single CEA, POSITION Individual CEA Selection Switch to RO CEA to be moved. [Step 6.12.2 - N/A]
- POSITION Mode Select Switch to MANUAL Group. [Step 6.12.3 - YES]
- VERIFY Group 6 indicator lamps are ILLUMINATED.
[Step 6.12.3.1 - YES]
- When CEA positioning completed, Mode Select Switch to OFF.
[Step 6.12.5 - YES]
When a 3% to 5% power reduction is completed, or at Lead Evaluators discretion, PROCEED to Events 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, and 9.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #1 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 1 Event # 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, & 9 Page 22 of 31 nd Event
Description:
2 Dropped CEA / Reactor Trip Circuit Breaker Failure (ATWS) / Loss of Reactor Coolant Pumps /
Loss of Condenser Vacuum / HP Turbine Stop Valves Failure / AFW Pumps Actuation Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Machine Operator: When directed, EXECUTE Events 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, and 9.
- RD0103, Dropped CEA #01.
- RP22A to H, Reactor Trip Circuit Breakers fail to open (ATWS).
- RCP LP, Loss of Reactor Coolant Pump Buses 2A01 and 2A02.
- FW23, Loss of Vacuum at 100% severity.
- TC02A & TC02H, HP Turbine Stop Valves fail to close.
- RP01O & RP01P, AFW Pumps P&141 / P-504 start failure on EFAS.
Indications Available:
Dropped CEA #01 indication on CRT Display (no alarm)
Lowering Pressurizer pressure Lowering RCS temperature
+10 secs RO RECOGNIZE second dropped CEA and manually INITIATE a Reactor trip.
SRO ENTER SO23-12-1, Standard Post Trip Actions.
Manually Trip the Reactor Using Reactor Trip Pushbuttons Following Multiple CRITICAL TASK CEA Drops per SO23-13-13, Misaligned or Immovable Control Element STATEMENT Assembly.
CRITICAL TASK RO MANUALLY TRIP the Reactor using REACTOR TRIP pushbuttons.
RO VERIFY Reactor Trip:
- VERIFY Reactor Trip Circuit Breakers (8) OPEN. [Step 1.a - NO]
RO * [RNO] MANUALLY TRIP the Reactor.
- DEPRESS HS-9132-2 and HS-9132-3 REACTOR TRIP pushbuttons on CR-56.
and
- DEPRESS HS-9132-1 and HS-9132-4 REACTOR TRIP pushbuttons on CR-52.
CRITICAL TASK Manually Trip the Reactor by Deenergizing CEDM Motor Generators Following STATEMENT Reactor Protection System Failure per SO23-12-1, Standard Post Trip Actions.
CRITICAL MANUALLY TRIP the Reactor by DEENERGIZING Load Centers B15 and TASK RO B16.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #1 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 1 Event # 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, & 9 Page 23 of 31 nd Event
Description:
2 Dropped CEA / Reactor Trip Circuit Breaker Failure (ATWS) / Loss of Reactor Coolant Pumps /
Loss of Condenser Vacuum / HP Turbine Stop Valves Failure / AFW Pumps Actuation Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior RO VERIFY Reactor Trip:
- VERIFY Reactor Trip Circuit Breakers (8) OPEN. [Step 1.a - NO]
RO * [RNO] DEENERGIZE Load Centers B15 and B16.
- DEPRESS HS-1691, Bus B15 TRIP pushbutton.
- DEPRESS HS-1707, Bus B16 TRIP pushbutton.
- VERIFY Reactor Power lowering and Startup Rate NEGATIVE.
[Step 1.b - YES]
- VERIFY maximum of one (1) Full Length CEAs NOT fully inserted.
[Step 1.c - YES]
SRO/RO DETERMINE Reactivity Control criteria satisfied.
BOP VERIFY Turbine Trip:
- [RNO] DEPRESS HS-2200XD, Turbine Emergency Trip pushbutton.
- VERIFY both Unit Output Breakers OPEN. [Step 2.b - YES]
SRO INITIATE Administrative Actions:
- INITIATE Attachment 4, Worksheet. [Step 3.a - YES]
BOP VERIFY Vital Auxiliaries functioning properly:
- VERIFY both 1E 4 kV Buses 2A04 and 2A06 ENERGIZED.
[Step 4.a - YES]
- VERIFY all 1E 480 V Buses 2B04, 2B24, 2B06, & 2B26 ENERGIZED.
[Step 4.b - YES]
- VERIFY all 1E DC Buses ENERGIZED. [Step 4.c - YES]
- VERIFY all Non-1E 4 kV Buses 2A03, 2A07, 2A08, & 2A09 ENERGIZED.
[Step 4.d - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #1 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 1 Event # 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, & 9 Page 24 of 31 nd Event
Description:
2 Dropped CEA / Reactor Trip Circuit Breaker Failure (ATWS) / Loss of Reactor Coolant Pumps /
Loss of Condenser Vacuum / HP Turbine Stop Valves Failure / AFW Pumps Actuation Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- VERIFY CCW Train B OPERATING and ALIGNED to Non-Critical Loop and Letdown Heat Exchanger. [Step 4.e - YES]
SRO/BOP DETERMINE Vital Auxiliaries criteria satisfied.
SRO/RO VERIFY RCS Inventory Control criteria satisfied:
- VERIFY PZR level between 10% and 70% and TRENDING to between 30% and 60%. [Step 5.a - YES]
- VERIFY Core Exit Saturation Margin 20°F: [Step 5.b - YES]
SRO/RO VERIFY RCS Pressure Control criteria satisfied:
- VERIFY PZR pressure between 1740 PSIA and 2380 PSIA, controlled and TRENDING to between 2025 & 2275 PSIA. [Step 6.a - YES]
RO VERIFY Core Heat Removal criteria satisfied:
- VERIFY at least one RCP operating. [Step 7.a - NO]
- [RNO] GO to Step 7.c.
- DETERMINE Core Exit Saturation Margin > 20°F. [Step 7.c - YES]
SRO/RO DETERMINE Core Heat Removal criteria NOT satisfied.
SRO/BOP VERIFY RCS Heat Removal criteria satisfied:
- VERIFY both SG narrow range levels > 21%. [Step 8.a - YES]
- VERIFY both SG narrow range levels < 80%. [Step 8.a - YES]
- VERIFY Feedwater available. [Step 8.a - NO]
Examiner Note: Auxiliary Feedwater Pumps P-141 and P-504 may have AUTO actuated depending on power level (and resultant SG shrink) at the time of trip.
BOP * [RNO] DEPRESS 8 EFAS pushbuttons to manually INITIATE EFAS.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #1 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 1 Event # 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, & 9 Page 25 of 31 nd Event
Description:
2 Dropped CEA / Reactor Trip Circuit Breaker Failure (ATWS) / Loss of Reactor Coolant Pumps /
Loss of Condenser Vacuum / HP Turbine Stop Valves Failure / AFW Pumps Actuation Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- DEPRESS HS-4707-1, P-141, AFW Pump START pushbutton.
- DEPRESS HS-4733-2, P-504, AFW Pump START pushbutton.
- VERIFY TCOLD between 540°F and 550°F. [Step 8.b - YES]
- VERIFY SG pressures between 960 and 1050 PSIA. [Step 8.c - NO]
Examiner Note: Atmospheric Dump Valves are opened due to a loss of Condenser vacuum.
- [RNO] If SG pressure > 1050 PSIA, then OPERATE Atmospheric Dump Valves to maintain between 960 and 1050 PSIA.
- DEPRESS HV-8419 OPEN / MODULATE pushbutton and controller A / M pushbutton to place in AUTO.
- DEPRESS HV-8421 OPEN / MODULATE pushbutton and controller A / M pushbutton to place in AUTO.
Examiner Note: A loss of Condenser vacuum will auto start P-054, Condenser Vacuum Pump.
This condition disrupts the flow through the Condenser Air Ejector Radiation Monitor and may cause a SECONDARY RADIATION HI alarm. The crew should use multiple indications to determine that a tube leak does NOT exist.
SRO/RO VERIFY Containment Isolation criteria satisfied:
- VERIFY Containment pressure < 1.5 PSIG. [Step 9.a - YES]
- VERIFY Containment Area Radiation Monitors NOT alarming or trending to alarm. [Step 9.b - YES]
- DETERMINE Secondary Plant Radiation Monitors alarming due to start of Condenser Vacuum Pump. [Step 9.c - YES]
VERIFY Containment Temperature and Pressure criteria satisfied:
SRO/RO
[Step 10 - YES]
- VERIFY Containment average temperature < 120°F. [Step 10.a - YES]
- VERIFY Containment pressure < 1.5 PSIG. [Step 10.b - YES]
SRO DIAGNOSE event in progress:
- VERIFY all Safety Function criteria per Attachment 4, Worksheet -
RECOVERED. [Step 11.a - NO]
- [RNO] COMPLETE Attachment 1, Recovery Diagnostics.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #1 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 1 Event # 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, & 9 Page 26 of 31 nd Event
Description:
2 Dropped CEA / Reactor Trip Circuit Breaker Failure (ATWS) / Loss of Reactor Coolant Pumps /
Loss of Condenser Vacuum / HP Turbine Stop Valves Failure / AFW Pumps Actuation Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- VERIFY Reactor Trip Recovery - DIAGNOSED. [Step 10.b - NO]
- [RNO] DETERMINE all RCPs STOPPED.
- INITIATE steps 12 through 16. [Step 11.c - YES]
Examiner Note: SO23-12-1, Standard Post Trip Actions, Steps 12 to 16, performed by the BOP are located at the end of the scenario. The following steps are from SO23-12-7, Loss of Forced Circulation / Loss of Offsite Power.
SRO ENTER SO23-12-12-7, Loss of Forced Circulation / Loss of Offsite Power.
SRO RECORD time of EOI entry __________. [Step 1 - YES]
SRO VERIFY Loss of Forced Circulation diagnosis:
- INITIATE SO23-12-10, Safety Function Status Checks. [Step 2.a - YES]
- INITIATE Foldout Page. [Step 2.b - YES]
- DIRECT performance of FS-3, Monitor Natural Circulation Established.
[Step 2.c - YES]
- VERIFY all Vital AC Instrument Buses AVAILABLE. [Step 2.d - YES]
- VERIFY both Buses of 1E 4160 AC power AVAILABLE.
[Step 2.e - YES]
- VERIFY all RCPs STOPPED. [Step 2.f - YES]
SRO INITIATE Administrative Actions:
- NOTIFY Shift Manger/Operations Leader of entry into SO23-12-7, Loss of Forced Circulation. [Step 3.a - YES]
- ENSURE Emergency Plan is initiated. [Step 3.b - YES]
- IMPLEMENT Placekeeper. [Step 3.c - YES]
- IMPLEMENT Time Dependent steps. [Step 3.d - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #1 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 1 Event # 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, & 9 Page 27 of 31 nd Event
Description:
2 Dropped CEA / Reactor Trip Circuit Breaker Failure (ATWS) / Loss of Reactor Coolant Pumps /
Loss of Condenser Vacuum / HP Turbine Stop Valves Failure / AFW Pumps Actuation Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior SRO VERIFY Electric Power Distribution:
- VERIFY Reserve Auxiliary Transformers ENERGIZED. [Step 4.a - YES]
- VERIFY all Non-1E 4160 V Buses ENERGIZED. [Step 4.b - YES]
- STOP unloaded Diesel Generators. [Step 4.c - NO]
SRO VERIFY CCW configuration. [Step 5 - YES]
- VERIFY at least one CCW Critical Loop in service [Step 5.a - YES]
- VERIFY CCW Pump aligned to Non-Critical Loop and Letdown -
operating. [Step 5.b - YES]
SRO IMPLEMENT Floating Steps. [Step 6 - YES]
SRO ESTABLISH Pressurizer Level Control: [Step 7 - YES]
- VERIFY Pressurizer level between 10% and 70% and TRENDING to between 30% and 60%. [Step 7.a - YES]
+25 min SRO ESTABLISH Pressurizer Pressure Control: [Step 8 - YES]
- VERIFY Pressurizer Pressure between 1740 PSIA and 2380 PSIA and TRENDING to between 2025 PSIA and 2275 PSIA. [Step 8.a - YES]
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-12-11, EOI Supporting Attachments, FS-3, Monitor Natural Circulation Established.
DETERMINE both Steam Generators OPERATING with Feedwater RO available. [Step a. - YES]
RO DETERMINE all Reactor Coolant Pumps STOPPED. [Step b. - YES]
RO DETERMINE both loops T less than 58°F. [Step c. - YES]
RO DETERMINE THOT and TCOLD NOT RISING. [Step d. - YES]
RO DETERMINE Core Exit Saturation Margin 20°F. [Step e. - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #1 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 1 Event # 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, & 9 Page 28 of 31 nd Event
Description:
2 Dropped CEA / Reactor Trip Circuit Breaker Failure (ATWS) / Loss of Reactor Coolant Pumps /
Loss of Condenser Vacuum / HP Turbine Stop Valves Failure / AFW Pumps Actuation Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior RO DETERMINE operating loop THOT and REPCET within 16°F. [Step f. - YES]
RO DETERMINE Reactor Vessel Level 100% (Plenum). [Step g. - YES]
When Natural Circulation is verified, or at Lead Evaluators discretion, TERMINATE the scenario.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #1 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 1 Event # 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, & 9 Page 29 of 31 nd Event
Description:
2 Dropped CEA / Reactor Trip Circuit Breaker Failure (ATWS) / Loss of Reactor Coolant Pumps /
Loss of Condenser Vacuum / HP Turbine Stop Valves Failure / AFW Pumps Actuation Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Examiner Note: These steps are performed by the BOP per SO23-12-1, Steps 12 through 16.
SRO/BOP INITIATE Attachment 5, Administrative Actions. [Step 12.a - YES]
SRO/BOP ENSURE a PA system announcement for Reactor Trip. [Step 12.b - YES]
BOP ENSURE the following loads restored:
- VERIFY Telecom 480 VAC Feeder Breaker - CLOSED.
[Step 13.a - YES].
- VERIFY Telecom 480 VAC Feeder Breaker - CLOSED.
[Step 13.b - YES].
- DETERMINE all Non-1E Buses - ENERGIZED [Step 13.c - YES].
- VERIFY B15 & B16 480 VAC Load Centers - ENERGIZED
[Step 13.d - NO].
- [RNO] VERIFY Annunciator 56A20, REACTOR TRIPPED CEDMCS DEENERGIZED - alarming.
- [RNO] VERIFY CEDM M/G Set Output - OPEN.
- [RNO] IF power is available, ENSURE B16 - ENERGIZED.
- DEPRESS HS-1707, Bus B16 CLOSE pushbutton.
- [RNO] IF power is available, ENSURE B15 - ENERGIZED.
- DEPRESS HS-1691, Bus B15 CLOSE pushbutton.
BOP VERIFY Main Turbine Coastdown:
- DETERMINE Extraction Steam Block Valves - CLOSED.
[Step 14.a - YES]
- DETERMINE Main Steam to Reheater Block, Bypass, Warmup, and Control Valves - CLOSED. [Step 14.a - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #1 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 1 Event # 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, & 9 Page 30 of 31 nd Event
Description:
2 Dropped CEA / Reactor Trip Circuit Breaker Failure (ATWS) / Loss of Reactor Coolant Pumps /
Loss of Condenser Vacuum / HP Turbine Stop Valves Failure / AFW Pumps Actuation Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- DETERMINE HV-2712A/B Bled Steam to Reheaters Block Valve -
CLOSED. [Step 14.a - YES]
- VERIFY Generator lowering - less than 24 kV. [Step 14.b - YES]
- VERIFY 99A26 - TURBINE LUBE OIL TEMP HI and 99A46 - TURBINE BRG OIL DRAIN TEMP HI Annunciators - RESET. [Step 14.c - YES]
- INITIATE SO23-10-2, Turbine Shutdown, Attachment for Unloading the Generator and Removing the Unit from Line. [Step 14.d - NO]
BOP ESTABLISH desired Condensate and Feedwater Status:
- ENSURE 3rd Point Heater Drain Pumps - STOPPED. [Step 15.a - YES]
- VERIFY Reactor Trip Override - RESET. [Step 15.b - NO]
- [RNO] DETERMINE MFW Pump NOT available to RESET RTO.
- MAINTAIN one MFW Pumps and three (3) Condensate Pumps -
OPERATING. [Step 15.c - NO]
- [RNO] STOP Condensate Pump P-053.
- ENSURE FIC-3294, Condensate Pump Miniflow Controller set for Condensate Pump configuration. [Step 15.d - YES]
- Three (3) Pumps - 9000 GPM.
- PLACE LV-3245, Condensate Drawoff Valve to DISABLE.
[Step 15.e - YES]
- VERIFY SO23-12-2, Reactor Trip Recovery, being implemented.
[Step 15.f - NO]
- [RNO] ENSURE HV-4053 & HV-4054, SG Blowdown Valves CLOSED and GO to Step 16.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #1 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 1 Event # 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, & 9 Page 31 of 31 nd Event
Description:
2 Dropped CEA / Reactor Trip Circuit Breaker Failure (ATWS) / Loss of Reactor Coolant Pumps /
Loss of Condenser Vacuum / HP Turbine Stop Valves Failure / AFW Pumps Actuation Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior BOP VERIFY Start-Up Range Channels:
- VERIFY both Start-Up Range Channels - OPERABLE. [Step 16.a - YES]
SO23-12-1, Standard Post Trip Actions, Steps 12 through 16 are complete.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #1 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Scenario Outline Form ES-D-1 Facility: SONGS 2 & 3 Scenario No.: 2 Op Test No.: October 2011 NRC Examiners: Operators:
Initial Conditions: 100% power MOL - RCS Boron is 980 ppm (via sample).
Turnover: Maintain steady-state power conditions.
Critical Tasks:
- Restore Flow to CCW Non-Critical Loop Within 10 minutes and Prior to Exceeding Reactor Coolant Pump Operating Limits (Thrust Bearing Temperatures 225°F) per SO23-13-26, Loss of Power to an AC Bus.
- Restore Feedwater Flow to At Least One Steam Generator Prior to Reaching 0% Wide Range Level in Both Steam Generators per SO23-12-1, Standard Post Trip Actions.
- Restore Power to a 1E 4160 Volt Bus per SO23-12-11, EOI Supporting Attachments, Attachment 24, Supplying 1E 4 kV Bus with Opposite Unit Diesel.
Event No. Malf. No. Event Type* Event Description 1 RC15B I (RO, SRO) Pressurizer Pressure Control Channel Y (PT-0100Y) Fails High.
+10 min 2 SG03C I (BOP, SRO) Steam Generator (E-088) Pressure Transmitter (PT-1023-3) Fails
+20 min TS (SRO) Low.
3 CV19 I (RO, SRO) Letdown Temperature Control Valve Transmitter (TT-0223) Fails
+25 min CVCS LP Low. Boronometer Valve (TV-0224A) Fails to Reposition.
4 ED03A C (RO, BOP, SRO) Overcurrent Trip of 1E 4160 Volt Bus 2A04.
+45 min TS (SRO) 5 PG24 M (RO, BOP, SRO) Loss of Offsite Power.
+50 min 6 RD5002 C (RO) Three (3) Stuck Control Element Assemblies.
+50 min RD6402 Loss of Reactivity Control, Emergency Boration Required.
RD7402 7 EG08B C (BOP) Train B Emergency Diesel Generator (G-003) Start Failure.
+52 min Station Blackout.
8 AFW LP C (BOP) Auxiliary Feedwater Pump (P-140) Fails to Start on Emergency
+55 min Feedwater Actuation Signal (EFAS). Loss of Feedwater Flow.
- (N)ormal, (R)eactivity, (I)nstrument, (C)omponent, (M)ajor, (TS)Technical Specifications Actual Target Quantitative Attributes 8 Total malfunctions (5-8) 3 Malfunctions after EOP entry (1-2) 3 Abnormal events (2-4) 1 Major transients (1-2) 2 EOPs entered/requiring substantive actions (1-2) 1 EOP contingencies requiring substantive actions (0-2) 3 Critical tasks (2-3)
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #2 Rev f.doc
Scenario Event Description NRC Scenario #2 SCENARIO
SUMMARY
NRC #2 The crew will assume the watch at 100% power with no scheduled activities per Operating Instruction (OI) SO23-5-1.7, Power Operations. When the Shift Turnover is complete, a Pressurizer Pressure Channel fails high. Actions are per Abnormal Operating Instruction (AOI) SO23-13-27, Pressurizer Pressure and Level Malfunction. The alternate controlling channel will be placed in service and Pressurizer Heaters will be restored to operation. If pressure drops below 2025 PSIA, the SRO will refer to Technical Specifications.
When Technical Specifications have been referenced, a Steam Generator Pressure Channel fails low.
The crew will respond per AOI SO23-13-18, Reactor Protection System Failure, and OI SO23-3-2.38, Digital Control System Operation. Steam Generator Pressure trips will be bypassed in the Reactor Protection System and the Feedwater Control System. The SRO will refer to Technical Specifications.
The next event is a low failure of the Letdown Temperature Control Valve (TCV) Transmitter. Letdown temperature quickly rises, causing a high temperature alarm, with a failure of automatic actions to isolate the Boronometer. The crew will respond per the Annunciator Response Procedures (ARPs) to manually satisfy the automatic actions and restore Letdown temperature to normal. The TCV will remain in MANUAL.
When Letdown temperature is stable, a loss of Train A 1E Bus 2A04 will occur due to an overcurrent trip and lockout. The crew will enter AOI SO23-13-26, Loss of Power to an AC Bus. Crew actions include placing a Charging Pump in service, transferring to the Train B Component Cooling Water System, initiating Train B Toxic Gas Isolation System, and starting a Containment Dome Air Circulating Fan. The SRO will refer to Technical Specifications.
When conditions are stable, a Loss of Offsite Power will occur. The crew will enter Emergency Operating Instruction (EOI) SO23-12-1, Standard Post Trip Actions (SPTAs), and perform actions to stabilize the plant. During the trip, three Control Element Assemblies will be stuck, Train B Emergency Diesel Generator (EDG) will fail to start, and the Turbine Driven Auxiliary Feedwater (TDAFW) Pump will fail to start on the Emergency Feedwater Actuation Signal (EFAS). The SRO will recognize a Loss of Reactivity Control, Station Blackout, and Loss of Feedwater requiring entry into EOI SO23-12-9, Functional Recovery.
The Loss of Feedwater event is remedied by manually starting P-140, TDAFW Pump. The Station Blackout cannot be remedied until power is available, therefore, reenergizing the 1E 4 kV Bus is a priority and is accomplished by cross connecting with the Unit 3 Train B Emergency Diesel Generator.
The Loss of Reactivity Control is remedied by Reactor power level lowering below 1x10-4% power. The crew may opt to initiate Emergency Boration when 1E Bus power is restored. The scenario is terminated when power is restored to Bus 2A06 and a Charging Pump and Component Cooling Water Train are returned to service.
Risk Significance:
- Failure of risk important system prior to trip: Loss of 1E 4160 Volt Bus 2A04
- Risk significant core damage sequence: Loss of Reactivity Control Station Blackout / Loss of Feedwater Flow
- Risk significant operator actions: Restore Flow to Non-Critical Loop Restore Power to 4160 Volt Bus 2A06 SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #2 Rev f.doc
Scenario Event Description NRC Scenario #2 MACHINE OPERATOR INSTRUCTIONS for SIMULATOR SETUP INITIALIZE to IC-230 NRC Scenario #2 and associated Setup File.
EVENT TYPE MALF # DESCRIPTION DEMAND INITIATING VALUE PARAMETER SETUP MF RD5002 Stuck Control Element Assembly #50 STUCK MF RD6402 Stuck Control Element Assembly #64 STUCK MF RD7402 Stuck Control Element Assembly #74 STUCK MF EG08B Train B EDG start failure 1 MF RC15B Channel Y PZR Pressure PT-0100Y failure 2500 PSIA 2 MF SG03C SG E-088 Pressure Channel PT-1023-3 failure 0 PSIA 2 RF RP51 PPS Door Open Annunciator 56B46 ON OPEN By Direction 2 RF RP54L Low SG-2 Pressure Channel C BYPASS 5 sec TD 2 RF RP54U High SG-1 DP EFAS-1 Channel C BYPASS 10 sec TD 2 RF RP54V High SG-2 DP EFAS-2 Channel C BYPASS 15 sec TD 2 RF RP51 PPS Door Open Annunciator 56B46 OFF CLOSE 20 sec TD 3 MF CV19 Letdown Temp. Control Valve TT-0223 fails low 0°F 3 LP CVCS LP CVCS TV-0224A fails to reposition AS IS 4 MF ED03A Train A Bus 2A04 overcurrent trip and lockout FAULT 4 RF RP51 PPS Door Open Annunciator 56B46 OPEN By Direction 4 RF RP52C Channel A Hi Local Power BYPASS 5 sec TD 4 RF RP52D Channel A Low DNBR BYPASS 10 sec TD 4 RF RP51 PPS Door Open Annunciator 56B46 CLOSE 15 sec TD 5 MF PG24 Loss of Offsite Power 6 MF RD5002 Stuck Control Element Assembly #50 STUCK 6 MF RD6402 Stuck Control Element Assembly #64 STUCK 6 MF RD7402 Stuck Control Element Assembly #74 STUCK SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #2 Rev f.doc
Scenario Event Description NRC Scenario #2 7 MF EG08B Train B EDG start failure 7 RF EG62A Unit 2 Train B 50.54.X switch CLOSE 7 RF EG62B Unit 2 Train B 50.54.X switch CLOSE 7 RF EG62C Unit 3 Train B 50.54.X switch CLOSE 7 RF EG62D Unit 3 Train B 50.54.X switch CLOSE 8 MF AFW LP TDAFW Pump P-140 EFAS start failure SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #2 Rev f.doc
Scenario Event Description NRC Scenario #2 Machine Operator: EXECUTE IC-230 NRC Scenario #2 and SETUP file to align components.
ENSURE CVCS Blend Setpoints MATCH Shift Turnover Sheet.
CHANGE Operator Aid Tag #029 (CVCS) to reflect boron concentration.
VERIFY both Pressurizer Spray Valves in AUTO.
CIRCLE Unit 3 for Emergency Chillers E-335 & E-336 on CR-64.
CIRCLE Unit 3 for Motor Control Center BQ on CR-63.
VERIFY Channel Y Pressurizer Pressure and Level in service.
ENSURE Turbine Ramp Rate set to 100 MWe per minute.
PROVIDE procedures in progress, Shift Turnover, and Reactivity Management Guide to crew in Briefing Room:
- COPY of SO23-5-1.7, Power Operations, Section 6.1, Guidelines for Steady State Operation.
- LAMINATED COPY of SO23-5-1.7, Power Operations, Attachment 8, Power Maneuvering Guidelines PLACE the MOC copy of OPS Physics Summary Book on SRO Desk.
VERIFY CEA positions with ARO.
Control Room Annunciators in Alarm:
NONE SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #2 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 2 Event # 1 Page 6 of 37 Event
Description:
Pressurizer Pressure Control Channel Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Machine Operator: When directed, EXECUTE Event 1.
- RC15B, Pressurizer Pressure Controlling Channel PT-0110Y fails high.
Indications Available:
50A04 - PZR PRESS DEVIATION HI / LO 50A14 - PZR PRESS HI / LO Pressurizer Heaters off Both Pressurizer Spray Valves full open
+30 secs RO REFER to Annunciator Response Procedures (ARPs).
RO DETERMINE which channel initiated the alarm using PR-100.
- RECOGNIZE Channel Y (PR-0100B) has failed high.
Examiner Note: RO may use prompt and prudent action to swap Channels. The next steps are from Annunciator Response Procedure 50A14 - PZR PRESS HI / LO.
DETERMINE controlling channel has failed and POSITION HS-0100A, RO Pressurizer Pressure Channel Select Switch to Channel X.
[Steps 1.1 & 1.1.1 - YES]
DETERMINE controlling channel has failed and INFORM the SRO RO SO23-13-27 entry required. [Steps 1.1 & 1.1.2 - YES]
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-13-27, Pressurizer Pressure and Level Malfunction.
SRO ENTER SO23-13-27, Pressurizer Pressure and Level Malfunction.
- IDENTIFY uncontrolled pressure change and GO to Step 3.
[Step 1 - YES ]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #2 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 2 Event # 1 Page 7 of 37 Event
Description:
Pressurizer Pressure Control Channel Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior DETERMINE Pressurizer Spray Valve is NOT STUCK OPEN.
SRO/RO
[Step 3.a - YES]
VERIFY Pressurizer pressure Channel Y between 2225 PSIA and 2275 SRO/RO PSIA. [Step 3.b - NO]
- [RNO] OBSERVE PR-0100A and DETERMINE Pressurizer pressure RO Channel X available.
- [RNO] POSITION HS-0100A, Pressurizer Pressure Channel Select RO Switch to Channel X.
SRO/RO VERIFY Pressurizer Pressure is stable. [Step 3.c - NO]
- [RNO] START and/or VERIFY PZR Backup and Proportional Heaters RO ENERGIZED.
RO * [RNO] DETERMINE Pressurizer Spray Valves - CLOSED.
RO DETERMINE normal Charging and Letdown - IN SERVICE. [Step 3.d - YES]
SRO GO to Step 3.i. [Step 3.e - YES]
SRO INITIATE notification to I & C. [Step 3.i - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #2 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 2 Event # 1 Page 8 of 37 Event
Description:
Pressurizer Pressure Control Channel Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior SRO/RO VERIFY Pressurizer Pressure signal has NOT failed high. [Step 3.j - NO]
- [RNO] OPERATE PZR Backup and Proportional Heaters as required by RO direction.
VERIFY Pressurizer Pressure Control System operating properly in AUTO.
[Step 3.k - YES]
RO VERIFY Pressurizer Spray NOT initiated with T > 180°F. [Step 3.l - YES]
Examiner Note: Technical Specification LCO 3.4.1 is entered if RCS pressure drops below 2025 PSIA.
+10 min SRO NOTIFY personnel & EVALUATE Technical Specifications. [Step 3.m - YES]
- LCO 3.4.1.A, RCS DNB (Pressure, Temperature, and Flow) Limits.
- CONDITION A - Pressurizer pressure or RCS flow rate not within limits.
- ACTION A.1 - Restore parameter(s) to within limit within 2 hours2.314815e-5 days <br />5.555556e-4 hours <br />3.306878e-6 weeks <br />7.61e-7 months <br />.
When Technical Specifications are addressed, or at Lead Examiner discretion, PROCEED to Event 2.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #2 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 2 Event # 2 Page 9 of 37 Event
Description:
Steam Generator E-088 Pressure Transmitter Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Machine Operator: When directed, EXECUTE Event 2.
- SG03C, SG E-088 Pressure Transmitter PT-1023-3 fails low.
Indications Available:
52A13 - FWCS TROUBLE 56A41 - SG2 E088 PRESS LO CHANNEL TRIP 56A44 - SG1 E089 PRESS > SG2 E088 ESFAS CH TRIP 56A51 - SG2 E088 PRESS LO PRETRIP 56A54 - SG1 E089 PRESS > SG2 E088 PRETRIP 56B26 - PPS CHANNEL 3 TROUBLE PI-1023A3, SG E088 Pressure Transmitter indication fails low
+30 sec RO/BOP REFER to Annunciator Response Procedures (ARPs).
RECOGNIZE Steam Generator E-088 Pressure Channel failure and BOP INFORM the SRO SO23-13-18 entry required.
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-13-18, Reactor Protection System Failure.
SRO ENTER SO23-13-18, Reactor Protection System Failure.
OBSERVE instrumentation for the affected channel and alternate redundant RO indications monitoring the same parameter to DETERMINE failure.
[Step 1.a - YES]
IDENTIFY SG E-088 Pressure Channel indication PI-1023-3 failure and GO SRO to Step 3. [Step 1.a - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #2 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 2 Event # 2 Page 10 of 37 Event
Description:
Steam Generator E-088 Pressure Transmitter Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior REFER to Attachment 10 and DETERMINE Functional Unit affected is SRO Steam Generator E-088 Pressure Transmitter PT-1023-3. [Step 3.a - YES]
DIRECT placing the Functional Unit in BYPASS per SO23-3-2.12, Reactor SRO Protection System Operation. [Step 3.b - YES]
PLACE Functional Unit in BYPASS per SO23-3-2.12, RPS Operation, ARO Section 6.3, Bypass Operation of Trip Channels. [Step 3.b - YES]
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-3-2.12, Reactor Protection System Operation, Section 6.3, Bypass Operation of Trip Channels.
VERIFY that the same bistable is not in BYPASS on any other Channel.
[Step 6.3.1 - YES]
ARO UNLOCK and OPEN the Bistable Control Panel. [Step 6.3.2 - YES]
Examiner Note: Trip BYPASS is performed by the Machine Operator and verified by the RO.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #2 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 2 Event # 2 Page 11 of 37 Event
Description:
Steam Generator E-088 Pressure Transmitter Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior M.O. Cue: When directed, EXECUTE the following remote functions:
RP51 = OPEN (PPS Door Open Annunciator 56B46)
RP54L = BYPASS (Low SG-2 Pressure Channel C)
RP54U = BYPASS (High SG-1 DP EFAS-1 Channel C)
RP54V = BYPASS (High SG-2 DP EFAS-2 Channel C)
DELETE RP51 (PPS Door Open Annunciator 56B46)
Examiner Note: Several Step 6.3.2 sub-steps cannot be performed in the Simulator.
OBSERVE Annunciator 56A49 - PPS CHANNEL 3 TRIP BYPASSED in RO alarm and amber BYPASS light on Channel C PPS Operator Module.
[Step 6.3.2.4 - YES]
RO LOG the Bypass and Reason in Control Operator Log. [Step 6.3.2.5 - YES]
SRO INITIATE a LCOAR or follow guidelines of SO123-0-A5. [Step 6.3.2.6 - YES]
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-13-18, Reactor Protection System Failure.
CONFIRM failure does NOT affect RPS/ESFAS Matrix Logic, RPS/ESFAS SRO Initiation Logic, RTCBs, RPS/ESFAS Manual Trip, or ESFAS Actuation Logic. [Step 3.c - YES]
VERFIY failure does NOT affect Feedwater Digital Control System.
SRO/BOP
[Step 3.d - NO]
- [RNO] DIRECT bypass of Steam Generator E-088 pressure transmitter per SO23-3-2.38, Digital Control System Operation.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #2 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 2 Event # 2 Page 12 of 37 Event
Description:
Steam Generator E-088 Pressure Transmitter Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Floor Cue: If not initiated, DIRECT SRO as Shift Manager to perform SO23-3-2.38 actions.
SRO EVALUATE Technical Specifications. [Step 3.e - YES]
- LCO 3.3.1.A, Reactor Protection System Instrumentation.
- CONDITION A - One or more Functions with one automatic RPS trip channel inoperable.
- ACTION A.1 - Place Channel in bypass or trip within 1 hour1.157407e-5 days <br />2.777778e-4 hours <br />1.653439e-6 weeks <br />3.805e-7 months <br />, AND,
- ACTION A.2 - Restore channel to OPERABLE status prior to entering MODE 2 following next MODE 5 entry.
- LCO 3.3.5.B, ESFAS Instrumentation.
- CONDITION B - One automatic trip channel inoperable for SG Pressure-Low or SG Pressure Difference-High for the EFAS function.
- ACTION B.1 - Place Functional Unit in bypass within 1 hour1.157407e-5 days <br />2.777778e-4 hours <br />1.653439e-6 weeks <br />3.805e-7 months <br />, AND,
- ACTION B.2 - Restore channel to OPERABLE status prior to entering MODE 2 following next MODE 5 entry.
CONFIRM failure did NOT involve a failed PPS Power Supply.
[Step 3.f - YES]
NOTIFY Shift Manager to PERFORM Administrative Actions.
[Step 3.g - YES]
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-3-2.38, Digital Control System Operation, Section 6.7, Bypassing Selected Feedwater Control Signals.
VERIFY affected instrument can be bypassed in Feedwater DCS.
[Step 6.7.1 - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #2 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 2 Event # 2 Page 13 of 37 Event
Description:
Steam Generator E-088 Pressure Transmitter Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior BOP PLACE Feedwater Control instrument in BYPASS: [Step 6.7.2 - YES]
- CONDUCT a Reactivity Brief. [Step 6.7.2.1 - YES]
- ACCESS Selected Signals screen for SG E-088. [Step 6.7.2.2 - YES]
- VERIFY SG E-088 Channel D signal is valid. [Step 6.7.2.3 - YES]
- SELECT BYPASS for Channel C SG pressure. [Step 6.7.2.4 - YES]
- VERIFY Channel C indicates BYPASS. [Step 6.7.2.5 - YES]
- VERIFY Channel D NOT in BYPASS. [Step 6.7.2.6 - YES]
- VERIFY Channel D output looks valid. [Step 6.7.2.7 - YES]
+10 min
- ENTER change into NCO Log. [Step 6.7.2.8 - YES]
When Technical Specifications are addressed, or at Lead Examiner discretion, PROCEED to Event 3.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #2 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 2 Event # 3 Page 14 of 37 Event
Description:
Letdown Heat Exchanger Temperature Control Valve Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Machine Operator: When directed, EXECUTE Event 3.
- CV19, Letdown Temperature Control Valve Transmitter (TT-0223) fails low.
- CVCS LP, Boronometer Control Valve (TV-0224A) fail to reposition.
Indications Available:
58A32 - LETDOWN HX OUTLET TEMP HI
+30 secs RO REFER to Annunciator Response Procedures (ARPs).
Examiner Note: The BOP may perform "prompt and prudent" actions to control Letdown temperature. This is allowed per SO123-0-A1, Conduct of Operations, Section 6.8, Procedure Use and Adherence, Step 6.8.3.
Examiner Note: The following steps are from Annunciator 58A32 - LETDOWN HX OUTLET TEMP HI.
RECOGNIZE Letdown Heat Exchanger outlet high temperature alarm and RO INFORM SRO ARP SO23-15-58.A, Annunciator 58A32 entry required.
SRO ENTER SO23-15-58.A, 58A32 - LETDOWN HX OUTLET TEMP HI.
ENSURE TV-0224B, Demineralizer Temperature Control Valve CLOSED on RO high temperature and AUTO ALIGNED to BYPASS position.
[Steps 1.1 & 1.1.1 - YES]
ENSURE TV-0224A, Boronometer Isolation Valve AUTO CLOSED on high RO temperature. [Steps 1.1 & 1.1.2 - NO]
- [RNO] DEPRESS 2TV-0224A, Boronometer Isolation Valve CLOSE pushbutton.
SRO CONTACT I & C to investigate cause of problem.
M.O. Cue: If I & C is contacted, REPORT a connector between the field and temperature controller must be replaced. Estimated Time of Repair is four hours.
ENSURE Letdown Heat Exchanger outlet temperature is < 130°F.
[Step 3.1 - NO]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #2 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 2 Event # 3 Page 15 of 37 Event
Description:
Letdown Heat Exchanger Temperature Control Valve Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- [RNO] ADJUST Controller to maintain desired Letdown HX Outlet temperature.
MONITOR Letdown Heat Exchanger outlet temperature at least twice per
+5 min RO Shift. [Step 4.1 - YES]
When CVCS control is restored, or at Lead Evaluators discretion, PROCEED to Event 4.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #2 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 2 Event # 4 Page 16 of 37 Event
Description:
Train A Bus 2A04 Overcurrent Trip and Lockout Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Machine Operator: When directed, EXECUTE Event 4.
- ED03A, Bus 2A04 overcurrent trip and lockout.
Indications Available:
63B05 - 2A04 VOLTAGE LO 63B06 - 2B04 / 2B24 VOLTAGE LO 63B25 - 2A04 SUPPLY BKR 2A0418 OC Multiple 1E 4160 Volt Bus related alarms
+30 sec RO/BOP REFER to Annunciator Response Procedures (ARPs).
RECOGNIZE low Bus 2A04 voltage and INFORM the SRO SO23-13-26 RO/BOP entry required.
SRO ENTER SO23-13-26, Loss of Power to an AC Bus.
- DETERMINE Bus 2A04 has lost power. [Step 4.1.1 - YES]
- PLACE Check Mark next to DEENERGIZED Bus 2A04.
[Step 4.1.2 - YES]
- GO to SO23-13-26, Attachment 1. [Step 4.1.3 - YES]
- IF more than one bus has lost power, THEN perform attachments and steps concurrently. [Step 4.1.4 - NO]
DIRECT performance of SO23-13-26, Loss of Power to an AC Bus, SRO Attachment 1, Loss of 1E 4 kV Bus.
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-13-26, Loss of Power to an AC Bus Attachment 1, Loss of 1E 4 kV Bus.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #2 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 2 Event # 4 Page 17 of 37 Event
Description:
Train A Bus 2A04 Overcurrent Trip and Lockout Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior VERIFY CCW Non-Critical Loop is aligned to an operating CCW Pump SRO
[Step 1.a - NO] and DIRECT starting of Train B CCW.
Restore Flow to CCW Non-Critical Loop Within 10 minutes and Prior to CRITICAL TASK Exceeding Reactor Coolant Pump Operating Limits (Thrust Bearing STATEMENT Temperatures 225°F) per SO23-13-26, Loss of Power to an AC Bus.
Elapsed Time: __________
CRITICAL TASK BOP TRANSFER the CCW Non-Critical Loop to Train B. [Step 1.a RNO - YES]
- DEPRESS and MAINTAIN DEPRESSED the OPEN pushbuttons for HV-6213 and HV-6219, Critical Loop B Supply and Return to NCL.
- When HV-6212 and HV-6218, Critical Loop A Supply and Return to NCL indicate CLOSED, then RELEASE the OPEN pushbuttons for HV-6213 and HV-6219.
BOP TRANSFER Letdown Heat Exchanger to Train B CCW. [Step 1.a RNO - YES]
When contacted, DETERMINE that loss of 2A04 is NOT due to fire in the 1E SRO Switchgear Room. [Step 1.b - YES]
M.O. Cue: When directed to investigate 2A0418 overcurrent, WAIT 3 minutes and REPORT an overcurrent flag on Phase B.
SRO VERIFY Overcurrent Annunciators are NOT alarming. [Step 1.c - NO]
- [RNO] DIRECT performance of SO23-6-9, 6.9 kV, 4 kV and 480 V Bus Feeder Faults.
- [RNO] DIRECT performance of SO23-13-26, Loss of Power to an AC Bus, Attachment 3, Equipment Actions for Loss of Bus A04.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #2 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 2 Event # 4 Page 18 of 37 Event
Description:
Train A Bus 2A04 Overcurrent Trip and Lockout Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-13-26, Loss of Power to an AC Bus, Attachment 3, Equipment Actions for Loss of Bus A04.
SRO EVALUATE Technical Specification LCO 3.8.9. [Step 2.1 - YES]
- LCO 3.8.9, Distribution Systems - Operating.
- CONDITION A - One AC electrical power distribution system inoperable.
SRO PERFORM the following associated actions: [Step 2.2 - YES]
- ENSURE Train B SWC Pump running. [Step 2.2.1 - YES]
Examiner Note: This is not Critical Task because the EDG will shut down on high cooling water temperature with 2B24 deenergized. This is considered a Non-Critical Trip which is bypassed if a SIAS had occurred.
- PLACE HS-1767-1, 2G002 Maintenance Lockout Switch in MAINT BOP position. [Step 2.2.2 - YES]
- Within 1 hour1.157407e-5 days <br />2.777778e-4 hours <br />1.653439e-6 weeks <br />3.805e-7 months <br />, DIRECT performance of SO23-3-3.23, Attachment for AC SRO Sources Verification for both Units. [Step 2.2.2 - YES]
- PLACE Makeup Mode Selector in MANUAL MODE and PLACE a RO Caution Tag next to Boration / Dilution HSI Panel [Step 2.2.3 - YES]
- SELECT MODIFY in Mode Selector window.
- ACTIVATE window and SELECT MANUAL.
- DIRECT restoring Battery Chargers to D1 and D3. [Step 2.2.4 - YES]
- DIRECT Channel A DNBR and LPD trips BYPASSED.
[Step 2.2.4.1) - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #2 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 2 Event # 4 Page 19 of 37 Event
Description:
Train A Bus 2A04 Overcurrent Trip and Lockout Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- DIRECT setting CEAC 2 INOP Flags in all CPCs by changing each CPC SRO Addressable Constant Point ID 062 to 2. [Step 2.2.4.2) - YES]
- DISPATCH operator to OPEN Channel A CPC Power Supplies to SRO REDUCE D1 Battery load. [Step 2.2.4.3) - YES]
M.O. Cue: MCC BQ is powered from Unit 3 (as circled on bakelite plate on CR-63).
- If MCC BQ is powered from Unit 2, ENSURE Train B CCW / SWC in RO/BOP service for Unit supplying Emergency Chiller ME-335. [Step 2.2.5 - NO]
- INITIATE Train B CRIS. [Step 2.2.5 - YES]
- ENSURE A-072 or A-073, Dome Air Circulating Fan RUNNING.
[Step 2.2.6 - YES]
Examiner Note: The following steps are time intensive and require significant local actions.
- DIRECT aligning P-10, Spent Fuel Pool Cooling Pump per SO23-13-23.
[Step 2.2.7 - YES]
- DIRECT aligning P-025, CCW Pump to Train B. [Step 2.2.8 - YES]
- DIRECT aligning P-018, HPSI Pump to Train B. [Step 2.2.9 - YES]
+20 min SRO
- DIRECT aligning Charging Pump P-191 to Train B. [Step 2.2.10 - YES]
When Technical Specifications and major Attachment 3 actions have been addressed, or at Lead Evaluators discretion, PROCEED to Events 5, 6, 7, and 8.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #2 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 2 Event # 5, 6, 7, & 8 Page 20 of 37 Event
Description:
Loss of Offsite Power / Three (3) Stuck Control Element Assemblies / Train B Emergency Diesel Generator Start Failure / Turbine Driven Auxiliary Feedwater Pump EFAS Start Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Machine Operator: When directed, EXECUTE Events 5, 6, 7, and 8.
- PG24, Loss of Offsite Power.
- RD5002, RD6402, & RD7402, Stuck CEAs #50, #64, & #74.
- EG08B, Train B Emergency Diesel Generator start failure.
- AFW LP, Auxiliary Feedwater Pump P-140 EFAS start failure.
Indications Available:
Numerous Loss of Offsite Power and Reactor Trip related alarms SRO DIRECT performance of SO23-12-1, Standard Post Trip Actions.
RO VERIFY Reactor Trip:
- VERIFY Reactor Trip Circuit Breakers OPEN. [Step 1.a - YES]
- VERIFY Reactor Power lowering and Startup Rate NEGATIVE.
[Step 1.b - YES]
- VERIFY maximum of one (1) Full Length CEAs NOT fully inserted.
[Step 1.c - NO]
SRO/RO DETERMINE Reactivity Control criteria NOT satisfied.
Examiner Note: The EOI Bases do NOT require Emergency Boration with 2 stuck CEAs if power has decayed below 1x10-4%. During validation, power was well below this threshold prior to restoration of Bus 2A06.
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-13-11, Emergency Boration of the RCS.
These actions cannot be performed until power is restored to Bus 2A06.
RO OPEN HV-9247, Emergency Boration Block Valve. [Step 2.c.1) - NO]
- [RNO] INITIATE Emergency Boration using Gravity Feed:
- [RNO] ENSURE HV-9247, Emergency Boration Block Valve -
CLOSED.
- [RNO] OPEN HV-9240, BAMU Tank MT-071 to Charging Pump Gravity Feed Valve.
- [RNO] OPEN HV-9235, BAMU Tank MT-072 to Charging Pump Gravity Feed Valve.
- [RNO] GO to Step 2.h.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #2 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 2 Event # 5, 6, 7, & 8 Page 21 of 37 Event
Description:
Loss of Offsite Power / Three (3) Stuck Control Element Assemblies / Train B Emergency Diesel Generator Start Failure / Turbine Driven Auxiliary Feedwater Pump EFAS Start Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior VERIFY OPEN HV-9240, BAMU Tank MT-071 and/or HV-9235, BAMU Tank MT-072 to Charging Pump Gravity Feed Valves. [Step 2.h.1) - NO]
CLOSE HV-9253, Makeup to VCT Valve, in MANUAL. [Step 2.h.2) - NO]
ENSURE Charging flow > 40 gpm. [Step 2.i - NO]
BOP VERIFY Turbine Trip:
- VERIFY both Unit Output Breakers OPEN. [Step 2.b - YES]
SRO INITIATE Administrative Actions:
- INITIATE Attachment 4, Worksheet. [Step 3.a - YES]
BOP VERIFY Vital Auxiliaries functioning properly:
- VERIFY both 1E 4 kV Buses 2A04 and 2A06 ENERGIZED.
[Step 4.a - NO]
- [RNO] DETERMINE Train A EDG in Maintenance Lockout.
- [RNO] DETERMINE Train B EDG did NOT start.
- VERIFY all 1E 480 V Buses 2B04, 2B24, 2B06, & 2B26 ENERGIZED.
[Step 4.b - NO]
- [RNO] DETERMINE Train A EDG in Maintenance Lockout.
- [RNO] If Train B Bus B26 DEENERGIZED, PLACE Train B EDG in Maintenance Lockout.
- INSERT key and TURN HS-1770-2 to MAINT position.
- INITIATE Attachment 2, Diesel Generator Follow-Up Actions.
- VERIFY all 1E DC Buses ENERGIZED. [Step 4.c - YES]
- VERIFY all Non-1E 4 kV Buses 2A03, 2A07, 2A08, & 2A09 ENERGIZED.
[Step 4.d - NO]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #2 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 2 Event # 5, 6, 7, & 8 Page 22 of 37 Event
Description:
Loss of Offsite Power / Three (3) Stuck Control Element Assemblies / Train B Emergency Diesel Generator Start Failure / Turbine Driven Auxiliary Feedwater Pump EFAS Start Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- [RNO] RESTORE power to buses as time and resources permits.
- VERIFY CCW Train OPERATING and ALIGNED to Non-Critical Loop and Letdown Heat Exchanger. [Step 4.e - NO]
- [RNO] START an available CCW Train (NO due to Station Blackout).
SRO/BOP DETERMINE Vital Auxiliaries criteria NOT satisfied.
SRO/RO VERIFY RCS Inventory Control criteria satisfied:
- VERIFY PZR level between 10% and 70% and TRENDING to between 30% and 60%. [Step 5.a - YES]
- VERIFY Core Exit Saturation Margin 20°F: [Step 5.b - YES]
RO VERIFY RCS Pressure Control criteria satisfied:
- VERIFY PZR pressure between 1740 PSIA and 2380 PSIA, controlled and trending to between 2025 PSIA and 2275 PSIA. [Step 6.a - NO]
- [RNO] DETERMINE PZR Pressure Control System is NOT restoring PZR pressure.
- [RNO] ENSURE Normal and Auxiliary Spray Valves CLOSED.
- [RNO] If Pressurizer pressure < 1740 PSIA, ENSURE SIAS / CCAS / CRIS actuated.
SRO/RO DETERMINE RCS Pressure Control criteria NOT satisfied.
RO VERIFY Core Heat Removal criteria satisfied:
- VERIFY at least one RCP operating. [Step 7.a - NO]
- [RNO] GO to Step 7.c.
- DETERMINE Core Exit Saturation Margin 20°F. [Step 7.c - YES]
SRO/RO DETERMINE Core Heat Removal criteria NOT satisfied.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #2 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 2 Event # 5, 6, 7, & 8 Page 23 of 37 Event
Description:
Loss of Offsite Power / Three (3) Stuck Control Element Assemblies / Train B Emergency Diesel Generator Start Failure / Turbine Driven Auxiliary Feedwater Pump EFAS Start Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior SRO/BOP VERIFY RCS Heat Removal criteria satisfied:
- VERIFY both SG narrow range levels > 21%. [Step 8.a - YES]
- VERIFY both SG narrow range levels < 80%. [Step 8.a - YES]
- VERIFY Feedwater available. [Step 8.a - NO]
- [RNO] DETERMINE EFAS-1 & EFAS-2 AUTO initiation.
Restore Feedwater Flow to At Least One Steam Generator Prior to Reaching CRITICAL TASK 0% Wide Range Level in Both Steam Generators per SO23-12-1, Standard Post STATEMENT Trip Actions.
CRITICAL DETERMINE EFAS initiated and manually START P-140, Turbine Driven TASK BOP Auxiliary Feedwater (TDAFW) Pump.
- DEPRESS HV-4716, P-140, TDAFW Pump START pushbutton.
- VERIFY TCOLD between 540°F and 550°F. [Step 8.b - YES]
- VERIFY SG pressures between 960 and 1050 PSIA. [Step 8.c - YES]
SRO/RO VERIFY Containment Isolation criteria satisfied:
- VERIFY Containment pressure < 1.5 PSIG. [Step 9.a - YES]
- VERIFY Containment Area Radiation Monitors NOT alarming or trending to alarm. [Step 9.b - YES]
- VERIFY Secondary Plant Radiation Monitors NOT alarming or trending to alarm. [Step 9.c - YES]
SRO/RO VERIFY Containment Temperature and Pressure criteria satisfied:
- VERIFY Containment average temperature < 120°F. [Step 10.a - YES]
- VERIFY Containment pressure < 1.5 PSIG. [Step 10.b - YES]
SRO DIAGNOSE event in progress:
- VERIFY all Safety Function criteria per Attachment 4, Worksheet -
RECOVERED. [Step 11.a - NO]
- [RNO] COMPLETE Attachment 1, Recovery Diagnostics.
- VERIFY Reactor Trip Recovery - DIAGNOSED. [Step 10.b - NO]
- [RNO] DETERMINE all RCPs STOPPED.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #2 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 2 Event # 5, 6, 7, & 8 Page 24 of 37 Event
Description:
Loss of Offsite Power / Three (3) Stuck Control Element Assemblies / Train B Emergency Diesel Generator Start Failure / Turbine Driven Auxiliary Feedwater Pump EFAS Start Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior BOP
- INITIATE steps 12 through 16. [Step 11.c - YES]
- IMPLEMENT EOI SO23-12-9, Functional Recovery, based on Loss of SRO Reactivity Control, Station Blackout, and Loss of Feedwater.
[Step 11.d - YES]
Examiner Note: SO23-12-1, Standard Post Trip Actions, Steps 12 to 16, performed by the BOP are located at the end of the scenario. The following steps are from SO23-12-9, Functional Recovery.
M.O. Cue: If SCE GCC is contacted for grid status, REPORT that cause of grid loss is unknown and field crews are investigating. 8 hour9.259259e-5 days <br />0.00222 hours <br />1.322751e-5 weeks <br />3.044e-6 months <br /> estimate on time to restore.
M.O. Cue: If Unit 3 status is requested, REPORT that Bus 3A06 is energized from EDG 3G003 and Bus 3A04 is energized from EDG 3G002.
SRO ENTER SO23-12-9, Functional Recovery.
SRO RECORD time of EOI entry __________. [Step 1.a - YES]
M.O. Cue: When SO23-12-9 is initiated, CALL as SDG&E GCC and REPORT that SONGS Switchyard appears to have several faults and will not be available until a crew can be dispatched to determine the problem. 8 hour9.259259e-5 days <br />0.00222 hours <br />1.322751e-5 weeks <br />3.044e-6 months <br /> estimate on time to restore.
SRO VERIFY Functional Recovery Diagnosis:
- INITIATE SO23-12-10, Safety Function Status Checks. [Step 2.a - YES]
- INITIATE Foldout Page. [Step 2.b - YES]
- DIRECT performance of FS-3, Monitor Natural Circulation Established.
- DIRECT performance of SO23-12-11, Attachment 8, Restoration of Offsite Power.
- DIRECT performance of SO23-12-11, Attachment 6, Diesel Generator Failure Follow-up Actions.
- DIRECT performance of SO23-12-11, Attachment 19, Non-1E DC Load Reduction.
- DIRECT performance of SO23-12-11, Attachment 9, Control Building Ventilation Emergency Actions.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #2 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 2 Event # 5, 6, 7, & 8 Page 25 of 37 Event
Description:
Loss of Offsite Power / Three (3) Stuck Control Element Assemblies / Train B Emergency Diesel Generator Start Failure / Turbine Driven Auxiliary Feedwater Pump EFAS Start Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- DIRECT performance of SO23-12-11, Attachment 20, Class 1E Battery Load Reduction.
- DIRECT performance of SO23-12-11, Attachment 24, Supply 1E 4 kV Bus with Opposite Unit Diesel.
- DIRECT performance of FS-18, Secondary Plant Protection.
[Step 2.c - YES]
M.O. Cue: If directed to sample SGs, WAIT 5 minutes and REPORT that E088 and E089 sample lines were frisked, and both have activity near background. If the SG sample valves are closed, REPORT that you are unable to establish sample flow.
M.O. Cue: When directed to initiate Non-1E DC Load Reduction, ACKNOWLEDGE and STATE you will report when complete.
M.O. Cue: When directed to initiate Class 1E Battery Load Reduction, ACKNOWLEDGE and STATE you will report when complete.
SRO INITIATE Administrative Actions:
- NOTIFY Shift Manager/Operations Leader of SO23-12-9 initiation.
[Step 3.a - YES]
- ENSURE Emergency Plan is initiated. [Step 3.b - YES]
- IMPLEMENT Placekeeper. [Step 3.c - YES]
- IMPLEMENT Time Dependent Steps. [Step 3.d - YES]
- VERIFY SIAS actuation REQUIRED. [Step 4.a - NO]
- [RNO] GO to Step 6.
SRO EVALUATE Immediate Safety Function Recovery Actions.
- VERIFY any Safety Function Recovery Attachments indicated by any optimal EOI. [Step 6.a - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #2 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 2 Event # 5, 6, 7, & 8 Page 26 of 37 Event
Description:
Loss of Offsite Power / Three (3) Stuck Control Element Assemblies / Train B Emergency Diesel Generator Start Failure / Turbine Driven Auxiliary Feedwater Pump EFAS Start Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior SRO
- INITIATE FR-2, Recovery-Vital Auxiliaries. [Step 6.b - YES]
- DETERMINE success path will be from Unit 3 EDG and IMPLEMENT SO23-12-11, Attachment 24.
- IMPLEMENT precautionary actions: [Step 6.c - YES]
- INITIATE Boration of greater than 40 GPM. [Step 6.c.1) - NO]
- DETERMINE all RCPs STOPPED. [Step 6.c.2) - YES]
- VERIFY ESDE NOT indicated. [Step 6.d - YES]
- VERIFY SGTR NOT indicated. [Step 6.e - YES]
- VERIFY LOFW NOT indicated. [Step 6.f - YES]
Examiner Note: Depending on timing, the BOP will either perform the 1st steps of SO23-12-11, Attachment 8 or go directly to SO23-12-11, Attachment 24 (which would be done when FR-2, Recovery-Vital Auxiliaries is directed by the SRO). The following steps are from SO23-12-11, EOI Supporting Attachments, Attachment 8, Restoration of Offsite Power.
DIRECT performance of SO23-12-11, Attachment 8, Restoration of Offsite SRO Power.
BOP VERIFY 220 kV Switchyard Status:
- VERIFY annunciators for Reserve Aux Transformers RESET.
[Step 1.a - YES]
- VERIFY any 220 kV section bus DEENERGIZED. [Step 2.a - YES]
- VERIFY System Separation alarm RESET. [Step 3.a - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #2 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 2 Event # 5, 6, 7, & 8 Page 27 of 37 Event
Description:
Loss of Offsite Power / Three (3) Stuck Control Element Assemblies / Train B Emergency Diesel Generator Start Failure / Turbine Driven Auxiliary Feedwater Pump EFAS Start Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior BOP ESTABLISH communication with one of the following:
BOP VERIFY SONGS Switchyard Status:
- VERIFY all 220 kV section buses DEENERGIZED. [Step 3.a - YES]
BOP ISOLATE Switchyard:
- ENSURE all SCE 220 kV circuit breakers OPEN or SWITCHED OUT.
[Step 4.a - YES]
BOP VERIFY 1E 4 kV Bus Status:
- VERIFY both 1E 4 kV Buses ENERGIZED. [Step 5.a - NO]
- [RNO] PERFORM the following for each 1E 4kV Bus.
- ENSURE 1E 4kV Bus tie breaker AUTO / MANUAL transfer switches in MANUAL.
- DEPRESS 2HS-1660B1 MANUAL pushbutton on Bus 2A04.
- DEPRESS 2HS-1639B2 MANUAL pushbutton on Bus 2A06.
- DEPRESS 3HS-1639B2 MANUAL pushbutton on Bus 3A06.
- DEPRESS 3HS-1660B1 MANUAL pushbutton on Bus 3A04.
(Unit 3 Bus 3A04 is NOT mimicked on the Simulator)
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 2 Event # 5, 6, 7, & 8 Page 28 of 37 Event
Description:
Loss of Offsite Power / Three (3) Stuck Control Element Assemblies / Train B Emergency Diesel Generator Start Failure / Turbine Driven Auxiliary Feedwater Pump EFAS Start Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- INITIATE Attachment 24, Supplying 1E 4 kV Bus with Opposite Unit Diesel.
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-12-11, EOI Supporting Attachments, Attachment 24, Supplying 1E 4 kV Bus with Opposite Unit Diesel.
DIRECT performance of SO23-12-11, Attachment 24, Supplying 1E 4 kV Bus SRO with Opposite Unit Diesel.
BOP EVALUATE Train to Energize. [Step 1 - YES]
- SELECT Unit 2 Train B 1E 4 kV Bus to energize and GO to Step 11.
[Step 1.a.2) - YES]
BOP EVALUATE energizing Unit 2 Train B.
- VERIFY Bus 3A06 energized by 3G003 Diesel Generator.
[Step 11.a - YES]
SRO/BOP OBTAIN approval of Shift Manager:
Floor Cue: When requested, AUTHORIZE use of 50.54(X) as Shift Manager.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #2 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 2 Event # 5, 6, 7, & 8 Page 29 of 37 Event
Description:
Loss of Offsite Power / Three (3) Stuck Control Element Assemblies / Train B Emergency Diesel Generator Start Failure / Turbine Driven Auxiliary Feedwater Pump EFAS Start Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- OBTAIN approval of Shift Manager to cross connect Train B using SRO 10 CFR 50.54(x) on both Units to supply 1E 4 kV Bus 2A06 with Bus 3A06 EDG. [Step 12.a.1) - YES]
- REQUEST SM initiates NRC notification within one hour regarding SRO/BOP actions per this attachment. [Step 12.a.2) - YES]
SRO/BOP ESTABLISH Initial Train B Configuration:
- NOTIFY opposite Unit SRO that automatic sequencing of ESF loads onto SRO/BOP opposite Unit 1E 4 kV Bus 3A06 will be blocked. [Step 13.a - YES]
[Step 13.b - YES]
- ENSURE 1E 4 kV Bus Tie breaker AUTO/MANUAL transfer switches BOP selected to MANUAL. [Step 13.c - YES]
- 2A0619 (2HS-1639B2) and 3A0603 (3HS-1639B2).
- ENSURE 1E 4 kV Bus Tie breakers open. [Step 13.d - YES]
- 2A0619 and 3A0603.
- ENSURE 2G003 Diesel Generator selected to MAINT position.
[Step 13.e - YES]
DIRECT performance of Train B Diesel Generator Cross-Tie Permissive SRO switch alignment on 50' Elevation.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #2 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 2 Event # 5, 6, 7, & 8 Page 30 of 37 Event
Description:
Loss of Offsite Power / Three (3) Stuck Control Element Assemblies / Train B Emergency Diesel Generator Start Failure / Turbine Driven Auxiliary Feedwater Pump EFAS Start Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior CONTACT the PPEO and INITIATE Unit 2 Train B Diesel Generator BOP Cross-Tie Permissive switch alignment on 50' Elevation.
- VERIFY feeder faults NOT indicated by relay flags on:
[Step 14.a.1) - YES]
- 2A0616 - Unit Aux Transformer
- 2A0618 - Reserve Aux Transformer
- 2A0619 - 2A06 Bus Tie
- 2A0613 - 2G003 EDG M.O. Cue: When asked, REPORT no feeder faults on breakers.
- DIRECT the PPEO to SELECT both Unit 2 Train B Diesel Generator BOP Cross-Tie Permissive switches on Fire Isolation Panel 2L-413 to 50.54X.
[Step 14.a.2) - YES]
- HS-5054XA2 and HS-5054XB2 M.O. Cue: When directed, PERFORM remote functions EG62A and EG62B and REPORT that the Unit 2 50.54X switches have been aligned.
CONTACT the PPEO and INITIATE Unit 3 Train B Diesel Generator BOP Cross-Tie Permissive switch alignment on 50' Elevation.
- VERIFY feeder faults NOT indicated by relay flags on:
[Step 14.b.1) - YES]
- 3A0603 - 3A06 Bus Tie M.O. Cue: When asked, REPORT no feeder faults on breaker.
- DIRECT the PPEO to SELECT both Unit 3 Train B Diesel Generator BOP Cross-Tie Permissive switches on Fire Isolation Panel 3L-413 to 50.54X.
[Step 14.b.2) - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #2 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 2 Event # 5, 6, 7, & 8 Page 31 of 37 Event
Description:
Loss of Offsite Power / Three (3) Stuck Control Element Assemblies / Train B Emergency Diesel Generator Start Failure / Turbine Driven Auxiliary Feedwater Pump EFAS Start Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- 3HS-5054XA2 and 3HS-5054XB2 M.O. Cue: When directed, PERFORM remote functions EG62C and EG62D and REPORT that the Unit 3 50.54X switches have been aligned.
BOP ESTABLISH final Train B configuration:
- VERIFY 3G003 Diesel Generator loading less than 3.4 MW.
[Step 15.a - YES]
- MAINTAIN 3G003 Diesel Generator loading STABLE.
[Step 15.b - YES]
- VERIFY Bus 2A06 NOT energized. [Step 15.c - YES]
- VERIFY Unit 2 overcurrent/ground alarms reset. [Step 15.d - YES]
- 63C15 - 2A06 SUPPLY BKR 2A0616 OC
- 63C25 - 2A06 SUPPLY BKR 2A0618 OC
- VERIFY 1E DC Bus voltages 2D2 and 3D2 greater than 108 VDC.
[Step 15.e - YES]
M.O. Cue: When asked, REPORT 3D2 voltage at 129 VDC.
- ENSURE 1E 4 kV Bus 2A06 supply breakers OPEN. [Step 15.f - YES]
- 2A0616 - Unit Aux Transformer
- 2A0618 - Reserve Aux Transformer
- ENSURE 1E 4 kV Bus A06 tie breakers OPEN. [Step 15.g - YES]
- 2A0619 - 2A06 Bus Tie
- 3A0603 - 3A06 Bus Tie SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #2 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 2 Event # 5, 6, 7, & 8 Page 32 of 37 Event
Description:
Loss of Offsite Power / Three (3) Stuck Control Element Assemblies / Train B Emergency Diesel Generator Start Failure / Turbine Driven Auxiliary Feedwater Pump EFAS Start Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior BOP
- ENSURE 1E 4 kV Bus 2A06 load breakers OPEN. [Step 15.h - YES]
- Emergency Chillers
- Containment Spray Pump
- HPSI Pump
- LPSI Pump
- AFW Pump
- CCW Pump
- VERIFY Train B Diesel Generator Cross-Tie Permissive Switches on BOP both Units are in the 50.54X position. [Step 16.a - YES]
- CLOSE Unit 3 Bus Tie breaker 3A0603. [Step 16.b - YES]
- VERIFY Unit 3 Diesel Generator 3G003 output breaker remains closed.
[Step 16.c - YES]
CRITICAL TASK Restore Power to a 1E 4160 Volt Bus per SO23-12-11, EOI Supporting STATEMENT Attachments, Attachment 24, Supplying 1E 4 kV Bus with Opposite Unit Diesel.
CRITICAL TASK BOP
- CLOSE Unit 2 Bus Tie breaker 2A0619. [Step 16.d.1) - YES]
- VERIFY Unit 2 1E buses 2A06 and 2B06 energized. [Step 16.d.2) - YES]
- VERIFY Unit 3 Train B EDG output breaker remains CLOSED.
[Step 16.e.1) - YES]
- VERIFY Unit 3 Train B EDG DROOP-IN light EXTINGUISHED.
[Step 16.e.2) - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #2 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 2 Event # 5, 6, 7, & 8 Page 33 of 37 Event
Description:
Loss of Offsite Power / Three (3) Stuck Control Element Assemblies / Train B Emergency Diesel Generator Start Failure / Turbine Driven Auxiliary Feedwater Pump EFAS Start Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior BOP
- VERIFY Unit 3 Train B EDG voltage ~4.36 kV. [Step 16.e.3) - YES]
- VERIFY Unit 3 Train B EDG frequency ~ 60 Hz. [Step 16.e.4) - YES]
- VERIFY Unit 2 Buses 2B06 and 2B26 ENERGIZED. [Step 16.e.5) - YES]
BOP VERIFY Unit 2 Train B 1E DC Bus D2 ENERGIZED. [Step 17) - YES]
BOP ESTABLISH 1E 4 kV Bus loads:
- START CCW Pump P-026 on Train B. [Step 18.a - YES]
- VERIFY Charging Pump P-192 starts on Train B. [Step 18.b - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #2 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 2 Event # 5, 6, 7, & 8 Page 34 of 37 Event
Description:
Loss of Offsite Power / Three (3) Stuck Control Element Assemblies / Train B Emergency Diesel Generator Start Failure / Turbine Driven Auxiliary Feedwater Pump EFAS Start Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior BOP
- VERIFY SWC Pump P-114 START on Train B. [Step 18.c - YES]
When Bus 2A06 is energized, or at the Lead Evaluators discretion, TERMINATE the scenario.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #2 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 2 Event # 5, 6, 7, & 8 Page 35 of 37 Event
Description:
Loss of Offsite Power / Three (3) Stuck Control Element Assemblies / Train B Emergency Diesel Generator Start Failure / Turbine Driven Auxiliary Feedwater Pump EFAS Start Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Examiner Note: These steps are performed by the BOP per SO23-12-1, Steps 12 through 16.
SRO/BOP INITIATE Attachment 5, Administrative Actions. [Step 12.a - YES]
SRO/BOP ENSURE a PA system announcement for Reactor Trip. [Step 12.b - YES]
BOP ENSURE the following loads restored:
- VERIFY Telecom 480 VAC Feeder Breaker - CLOSED.
[Step 13.a - NO].
- [RNO] DETERMINE HS-0800S2, Telecom 480 VAC Feeder Breaker - OPEN.
- [RNO] DEPRESS HS-0800S2 OVERRIDE and VERIFY Telecom 480 VAC Feeder Breaker - CLOSED.
- [RNO] VERIFY Unit 3 HS-0800S2, Telecom 480 VAC Feeder Breaker - CLOSED.
- VERIFY Telecom 480 VAC Feeder Breaker - CLOSED.
[Step 13.b - NO].
- [RNO] DETERMINE HS-0800N2, Telecom 480 VAC Feeder Breaker - OPEN.
- [RNO] DEPRESS HS-0800N2 OVERRIDE and VERIFY Telecom 480 VAC Feeder Breaker - CLOSED.
- [RNO] VERIFY Unit 3 HS-0800N2, Telecom 480 VAC Feeder Breaker - CLOSED.
- VERIFY all Non-1E Buses - ENERGIZED [Step 13.c - NO].
- [RNO] IF all Circulating Water Pumps are OFF, then CLOSE MSIVs.
- DEPRESS HV-8205 CLOSE pushbuttons for SG E-088.
- DEPRESS HV-8204 CLOSE pushbuttons for SG E-089.
- [RNO] OPERATE ADVs to maintain S/G pressure between 960 PSIA and 1050 PSIA.
- VERIFY B15 & B16 480 VAC Load Centers - ENERGIZED
[Step 13.d - NO].
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #2 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 2 Event # 5, 6, 7, & 8 Page 36 of 37 Event
Description:
Loss of Offsite Power / Three (3) Stuck Control Element Assemblies / Train B Emergency Diesel Generator Start Failure / Turbine Driven Auxiliary Feedwater Pump EFAS Start Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- [RNO] VERIFY Annunciator 56A20, REACTOR TRIPPED CEDMCS DEENERGIZED - alarming.
- [RNO] VERIFY CEDM M/G Set Output - OPEN.
BOP VERIFY Main Turbine Coastdown:
- DETERMINE Extraction Steam Block Valves - CLOSED.
[Step 14.a - NO]
- DETERMINE Main Steam to Reheater Block, Bypass, Warmup, and Control Valves - CLOSED. [Step 14.a - NO]
- DETERMINE HV-2712A/B Bled Steam to Reheaters Block Valve -
CLOSED. [Step 14.a - NO]
- VERIFY Generator lowering - less than 24 kV. [Step 14.b - YES]
- VERIFY 99A26 - TURBINE LUBE OIL TEMP HI and 99A46 - TURBINE BRG OIL DRAIN TEMP HI Annunciators - RESET. [Step 14.c - NO]
- INITIATE SO23-10-2, Turbine Shutdown, Attachment for Unloading the Generator and Removing the Unit from Line. [Step 14.d - NO]
BOP ESTABLISH desired Condensate and Feedwater Status:
- ENSURE 3rd Point Heater Drain Pumps - STOPPED. [Step 15.a - YES]
- VERIFY Reactor Trip Override - RESET. [Step 15.b - NO]
- [RNO] DETERMINE MFW Pump NOT available to RESET RTO.
- MAINTAIN one MFW Pumps and three (3) Condensate Pumps -
OPERATING. [Step 15.c - NO]
- ENSURE FIC-3294, Condensate Pump Miniflow Controller set for Condensate Pump configuration. [Step 15.d - NO]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #2 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 2 Event # 5, 6, 7, & 8 Page 37 of 37 Event
Description:
Loss of Offsite Power / Three (3) Stuck Control Element Assemblies / Train B Emergency Diesel Generator Start Failure / Turbine Driven Auxiliary Feedwater Pump EFAS Start Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- PLACE LV-3245, Condensate Drawoff Valve to DISABLE.
[Step 15.e - YES]
- VERIFY SO23-12-2, Reactor Trip Recovery, being implemented.
[Step 15.f - NO]
- [RNO] ENSURE HV-4053 & HV-4054, SG Blowdown Valves CLOSED and GO to Step 16.
BOP VERIFY Start-Up Range Channels:
- VERIFY both Start-Up Range Channels - OPERABLE. [Step 16.a - NO]
- [RNO] INITIATE SO23-3-2.15, Section for Start-Up Range Channel failure.
SO23-12-1, Standard Post Trip Actions, Steps 12 through 16 are complete.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #2 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Scenario Outline Form ES-D-1 Facility: SONGS 2 & 3 Scenario No.: 3 Op Test No.: October 2011 NRC Examiners: Operators:
Initial Conditions: 100% power MOL - RCS Boron is 980 ppm (via sample).
Turnover: Maintain steady-state power conditions.
Critical Tasks:
- Restore Flow to CCW Non-Critical Loop Within 10 minutes and Prior to Exceeding Reactor Coolant Pump Operating Limits (Thrust Bearing Temperatures 225°F) per SO23-13-7, Loss of CCW / SWC.
- Establish Stable Reactor Coolant System Temperature per SO23-12-11, EOI Supporting Attachments, FS-30, Establish Stable RCS Temperature during ESDE.
- Identify and Isolate the Most Affected Steam Generator Prior to Exiting SO23-12-5, Excess Steam Demand Event.
Event No. Malf. No. Event Type* Event Description 1 CC06B C (BOP, SRO) Component Cooling Water Pump (P-025) Overcurrent Trip.
+10 min CCW LP TS (SRO) Component Cooling Water Pump (P-024) Start Failure.
2 NI08C I (RO, SRO) Nuclear Instrument Linear Power Channel (JI-0002C) Low Failure.
+20 min TS (SRO) 3 FW23 R (RO) Partial Loss of Condenser Vacuum @ 3% Severity.
+45 min N (BOP, SRO) Perform a Turbine Load Reduction.
4 FC05B I (BOP, SRO) Steam Generator (E-088) Main Feedwater Master Controller
+55 min Setpoint Fails to 45% Level on 240 Second Ramp.
5 MS03A M (RO, BOP, SRO) Steam Generator (E-088) Main Steam Line Break Inside
+57 min Containment @ 0.5% Severity. ESDE Inside Containment.
6 K403B I (RO) Train B Safety Injection Actuation Signal Relay Failure.
+60 min 7 RP01M C (RO) Containment Spray Pump (P-012) Start Failure.
+65 min 8 MSIS LP C (BOP) Main Steam Isolation Signal Fails to Actuate.
+65 min
- (N)ormal, (R)eactivity, (I)nstrument, (C)omponent, (M)ajor, (TS)Technical Specifications Actual Target Quantitative Attributes 8 Total malfunctions (5-8) 3 Malfunctions after EOP entry (1-2) 4 Abnormal events (2-4) 1 Major transients (1-2) 2 EOPs entered/requiring substantive actions (1-2) 0 EOP contingencies requiring substantive actions (0-2) 3 Critical tasks (2-3)
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #3 Rev f.doc
Scenario Event Description NRC Scenario #3 SCENARIO
SUMMARY
NRC #3 The crew will assume the watch at 100% power with no scheduled activities per Operating Instruction (OI) SO23-5-1.7, Power Operations.
The first event is a trip of the running Component Cooling Water (CCW) Pump P-025. The crew will attempt to start the standby Train A CCW Pump P-024, however, this pump also fails to start. Operator actions are per Abnormal Operating Instruction (AOI) SO23-13-7, Loss of Component Cooling Water/Salt Water Cooling. The crew will transfer CCW to Train B along with the Non-Critical Loop and Letdown Heat Exchanger. The SRO will refer to Technical Specifications.
When the plant systems are stable, Linear Power Channel C will fail low. The crew will refer to AOI SO23-13-18, Reactor Protection System Failure / Loss of Vital Bus. The RO will determine the affected instrument by operating the Channel C Core Protection Calculator ROM Station. Once identified, the affected Channel C trips will be bypassed. The SRO will refer to Technical Specifications.
When the channel is bypassed, a partial loss of Condenser vacuum will occur. The crew will respond per the Annunciator Response Procedures (ARPs) and AOI SO23-13-10, Loss of Condenser Vacuum and lower power level until the Turbine Vacuum Limit is in the Area of Unrestricted Operation. Once power level is reduced, the source of the vacuum leak will be located and Condenser vacuum will be restored.
When plant parameters are stable, Steam Generator E-088 Master Controller Setpoint slowly fails to 45%. Entry into SO23-13-24, Feedwater Control System Malfunction is required. Steam Generator level control is restored by placing the Master Controller in MANUAL and will remain in this position until the Main Steam Line break occurs.
When control of level is established, a Main Steam Line break will occur inside Containment on Steam Generator E-088. The crew will enter Emergency Operating Instruction (EOI) SO23-12-1, Standard Post Trip Actions (SPTAs) and then transition to EOI SO23-12-5, Excess Steam Demand Event (ESDE).
Procedure entries include EOI SO23-12-11, EOI Supporting Attachments, Floating Step 30 (FS-30),
Establish Stable RCS Temperature during ESDE, which is required to stabilize Reactor Coolant System (RCS) temperature when E-088 dryout is reached or pressure lowers below 200 PSIG.
This scenario is complicated by a failure of Train B Safety Injection Actuation System valves to open, a Train A Containment Spray Pump start failure, and a Main Steam Isolation Signal that fails to actuate.
This scenario is terminated when RCS Cold Leg temperature has been stabilized per FS-30 and the affected Steam Generator isolated per SO23-12-5, Excess Steam Demand Event.
Risk Significance:
- Failure of risk important system prior to trip: Loss of Component Cooling Water
- Risk significant core damage sequence: ESDE Inside Containment
- Risk significant operator actions: Transfer CCW Non-Critical Loop Initiate Main Steam Isolation Signal Stabilize RCS Temperature during ESDE Isolate Steam Generator E-088 SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #3 Rev f.doc
Scenario Event Description NRC Scenario #3 MACHINE OPERATOR INSTRUCTIONS for SIMULATOR SETUP INITIALIZE to IC-230 NRC Scenario #3 and associated Setup File.
EVENT TYPE MALF # DESCRIPTION DEMAND INITIATING VALUE PARAMETER SETUP MF RP01M Containment Spray Pump (P-012) start failure 1 MF CC06B CCW Pump P-025 overcurrent trip TRIP 1 LP CCW LP CCW Pump P-024 start failure AS IS 2 MF NI08C Linear Power Channel C fails low 0% six 2 RF RP51 PPS Door Open Annunciator 56B46 ON OPEN By Direction 2 RF RP54A High Linear Power Channel C BYPASS 5 sec TD 2 RF RP54C High Local Power Density Channel C BYPASS 10 sec TD 2 RF RP54D Low DNBR Channel C BYPASS 15 sec TD 2 RF RP54N Loss of Load Channel C BYPASS 15 sec TD 2 RF RP51 PPS Door Open Annunciator 56B46 OFF CLOSE 20 sec TD 3 MF FW23 Loss of Condenser Vacuum 3%
4 MF FC05B E-088 MFW Master Controller Setpoint failure 45% 240 sec. ramp 5 MF MS03A ESDE inside Containment 0.5% 180 sec. ramp 5 MF MS03A ESDE inside Containment 2% UPON MSIS 6 MF K403B Train B SIAS relay failure 7 MF RP01M Containment Spray Pump (P-012) start failure 8 LP MSIS LP MSIS fails to actuate RF ED85 Non-Qualified Loads Restoration RESTORE By Direction SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #3 Rev f.doc
Scenario Event Description NRC Scenario #3 Machine Operator: EXECUTE IC-230 NRC Scenario #3 and SETUP file to align components.
ENSURE CVCS Blend Setpoints MATCH Shift Turnover Sheet.
CHANGE Operator Aid Tag #029 (CVCS) to reflect boron concentration.
VERIFY both Pressurizer Spray Valves in AUTO.
CIRCLE Unit 3 for Emergency Chillers E-335 & E-336 on CR-64.
CIRCLE Unit 3 for Motor Control Center BQ on CR-63.
VERIFY Channel Y Pressurizer Pressure and Level in service.
ENSURE Turbine Ramp Rate set to 100 MWe per minute.
PROVIDE procedures in progress, Shift Turnover, and Reactivity Management Guide to crew in Briefing Room:
- COPY of SO23-5-1.7, Power Operations, Section 6.1, Guidelines for Steady State Operation.
- LAMINATED COPY of SO23-5-1.7, Power Operations, Attachment 8, Power Maneuvering Guidelines PLACE the MOC copy of OPS Physics Summary Book on SRO Desk.
VERIFY CEA positions with ARO.
Control Room Annunciators in Alarm:
NONE SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #3 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 3 Event # 1 Page 5 of 34 Event
Description:
Train A Component Cooling Water Pump Trip / Train A Component Cooling Water Pump Start Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Machine Operator: When directed, EXECUTE Event 1.
- CC06B, CCW Pump P-025 overcurrent trip.
- CCW LP, CCW Pump P-024 start failure.
Indications Available:
64A21 - CCW PUMP TRAIN A OC 64A10 - CCW NON-CRITICAL LOOP RETURN FLOW LO 56C34/36/38/40 - RCP P001/P003/P004/P002 CCW FLOW LO Miscellaneous loss of CCW flow alarms
+30 secs BOP REFER to Annunciator Response Procedures (ARPs).
BOP RECOGNIZE CCW Pump P-025 has tripped.
SRO DIRECT starting Component Cooling Water Pump P-024.
BOP START Component Cooling Water Pump P-024.
- DEPRESS HS-6314-1, P-024, CCW Pump and REPORT pump will NOT start.
RECOGNIZE Train A CCW NOT available and INFORM the SRO BOP SO23-13-7 entry required.
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-13-7, Loss of CCW / SWC.
SRO ENTER SO23-13-7, Loss of Component Cooling Water / Saltwater Cooling.
- DETERMINE required actions based on loss of a single CCW Pump and GO to Step 2. [Step 1 - YES ]
SRO ENSURE CCW / SWC on the unaffected loop in service. [Step 2.a - NO]
SRO DIRECT transfer of CCW to Train B.
START CCW Pump P-026 and VERIFY that SWC Pump P-114 automatically BOP STARTS. [Skill of Craft]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #3 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 3 Event # 1 Page 6 of 34 Event
Description:
Train A Component Cooling Water Pump Trip / Train A Component Cooling Water Pump Start Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior SRO DIRECT transfer of Component Cooling Water Non-Critical Loop to Train B.
Restore Flow to CCW Non-Critical Loop Within 10 minutes and Prior to CRITICAL TASK Exceeding Reactor Coolant Pump Operating Limits (Thrust Bearing STATEMENT Temperatures 225°F) per SO23-13-7, Loss of CCW / SWC.
Elapsed Time: __________
CRITICAL TASK BOP TRANSFER the CCW Non-Critical Loop to Train B. [Step 2.b - YES]
- DEPRESS and MAINTAIN DEPRESSED the OPEN pushbuttons for HV-6213 and HV-6219, Critical Loop B Supply and Return to NCL.
- When HV-6212 and HV-6218, Critical Loop A Supply and Return to NCL indicate CLOSED, then RELEASE the OPEN pushbuttons for HV-6213 and HV-6219.
SRO DIRECT transfer of Letdown Heat Exchanger to Train B CCW.
BOP TRANSFER Letdown Heat Exchanger to Train B CCW. [Step 2.b - YES]
SRO DETERMINE P-025, CCW Pump NOT available. [Step 2.c - YES]
VERIFY E-335 / E-336, Emergency Chillers, ALIGNED to the operating SRO Loop. [Step 2.d - NO] (aligned to Unit 3)
SRO DETERMINE Shutdown Cooling is NOT in service. [Step 2.e - YES]
SRO VERIFY ECCS Systems NOT required. [Step 2.f - YES]
SRO GO to Step 19. [Step 2.g - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #3 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 3 Event # 1 Page 7 of 34 Event
Description:
Train A Component Cooling Water Pump Trip / Train A Component Cooling Water Pump Start Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior SRO/BOP ENSURE all system parameters restored to normal. [Step 19.a - YES]
+10 min SRO NOTIFY personnel & EVALUATE Technical Specifications. [Step 19.b - YES]
- LCO 3.7.7.A, Component Cooling Water System.
- CONDITION A - One CCW train inoperable.
- ACTION A.1 - Restore CCW train to OPERABLE status within 72 hours8.333333e-4 days <br />0.02 hours <br />1.190476e-4 weeks <br />2.7396e-5 months <br />.
M.O. Cue: If directed to open the DC power supply breaker for CCW Pumps P-024 & P-025, ACKNOWLEDGE the order but do not perform (Time restriction).
If directed to open the DC power supply breaker for the Train A ESF Pumps, ACKNOWLEDGE the order but do not perform (Time restriction).
If directed to transfer Emergency Chiller E-335/E-336 to Unit 3, ACKNOWLEDGE the order but do not perform (Time restriction).
If directed to transfer HPSI Pump P-018 from Train A to Train B, ACKNOWLEDGE the order but do not perform (Time restriction).
When Technical Specifications are addressed, or at Lead Examiner discretion, PROCEED to Event 2.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #3 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 3 Event # 2 Page 8 of 34 Event
Description:
Linear Power Channel Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Machine Operator: When directed, EXECUTE Event 2.
- NI08C, Linear Power Channel C Upper Detector amplifier fails to 0%.
Indications Available:
56A03 - LOCAL POWER DENSITY HI CHANNEL TRIP 56A04 - DNBR LO CHANNEL TRIP 56A13 - LOCAL POWER DENSITY HI PRETRIP 56A14 - DNBR LO RPS PRETRIP 56B26 - PPS CHANNEL 3 TROUBLE 56B21 - LINEAR POWER DEVIATION CHANNEL 3 HI / LO (in and out) 56C21 - CPC CHANNEL 3 SENSOR FAILURE Channel C Linear Power Range Recorders indicate ~63%
Channel C Local Power Density Margin reads 0 KW/FT Channel C DNBR Margin reads 0 DNBR
+1 min RO REFER to Annunciator Response Procedures (ARPs).
RECOGNIZE Power Range Channel C failure and INFORM the SRO RO SO23-13-18 entry required.
Floor Cue: Follow Annunciator 56C21 guidance to locate sensor that has failed.
REFER to SO23-3-2.13, Section for CPC/CEAC Sensor Failures and Auto RO Restart Codes. [Step 2.1 - YES]
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-3-2.13, Core Protection / Control Element Assembly Calculator Operation, Section 6.4, CPC/CEAC Sensor Failures and Auto Restart Codes.
RO IDENTIFY CPC/CEAC sensor failures per Attachment 1. [Step 6.4.1 - YES]
- DETERMINE the LAST FAILED POINT using one of the following:
- Failed Sensor Stack.
- Sensor Status.
- Auto Restart Codes.
- IDENTIFY failed Upper Channel C Power Range Detector (listed as Upper Excore Neutron Flux for CPC ID 416 in Attachment 1).
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-13-18, Reactor Protection System Failure.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #3 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 3 Event # 2 Page 9 of 34 Event
Description:
Linear Power Channel Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior SRO ENTER SO23-13-18, Reactor Protection System Failure.
OBSERVE instrumentation for the affected channel and alternate redundant RO indications monitoring the same parameter to DETERMINE failure.
[Step 1.a - YES]
IDENTIFY Linear Power Channel C JI-0002C failure and GO to Step 3.
[Step 1.a - YES]
REFER to Attachment 10 and DETERMINE Functional Unit affected is SRO Linear Power Channel C JI-0002C. [Step 3.a - YES]
DIRECT placing the Functional Unit in BYPASS per SO23-3-2.12, Reactor SRO Protection System Operation. [Step 3.b - YES]
PLACE Functional Unit in BYPASS per SO23-3-2.12, RPS Operation, ARO Section 6.3, Bypass Operation of Trip Channels. [Step 3.b - YES]
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-3-2.12, Reactor Protection System Operation, Section 6.3, Bypass Operation of Trip Channels.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #3 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 3 Event # 2 Page 10 of 34 Event
Description:
Linear Power Channel Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior VERIFY that the same bistable is not in BYPASS on any other Channel.
[Step 6.3.1 - YES]
ARO UNLOCK and OPEN the Bistable Control Panel. [Step 6.3.2 - YES]
Examiner Note: Trip BYPASS is performed by the Machine Operator and verified by the RO.
M.O. Cue: When directed, EXECUTE the following remote functions:
RP51 = OPEN (PPS Door Open Annunciator 56B46)
RP54A = BYPASS (High Linear Power Channel C)
RP54C = BYPASS (High Local Power Density Channel C)
RP54D = BYPASS (Low DNBR Channel C)
RP54N = BYPASS (Loss of Load Channel C)
DELETE RP51 (PPS Door Open Annunciator 56B46)
OBSERVE Annunciator 56A49 - PPS CHANNEL 3 TRIP BYPASSED in RO alarm and amber BYPASS light on Channel C PPS Operator Module.
[Step 6.3.2.4 - YES]
RO LOG the Bypass and Reason in Control Operator Log. [Step 6.3.2.5 - YES]
SRO INITIATE a LCOAR or follow guidelines of SO123-0-A5. [Step 6.3.2.6 - NO]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #3 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 3 Event # 2 Page 11 of 34 Event
Description:
Linear Power Channel Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-13-18, Reactor Protection System Failure.
CONFIRM failure does NOT affect RPS/ESFAS Matrix Logic, RPS/ESFAS SRO Initiation Logic, RTCBs, RPS/ESFAS Manual Trip, or ESFAS Actuation Logic. [Step 3.c - YES]
CONFIRM failure does NOT affect Feedwater Digital Control System.
[Step 3.d - YES]
+10 min SRO EVALUATE Technical Specifications. [Step 3.e - YES]
- LCO 3.3.1.A, Reactor Protection System Instrumentation.
- CONDITION A - One or more Functions with one automatic RPS trip channel inoperable.
- ACTION A.1 - Place Channel in bypass or trip within 1 hour1.157407e-5 days <br />2.777778e-4 hours <br />1.653439e-6 weeks <br />3.805e-7 months <br />, AND,
- ACTION A.2 - Restore channel to OPERABLE status prior to entering MODE 2 following next MODE 5 entry.
CONFIRM failure did NOT involve a failed PPS Power Supply.
[Step 3.f - YES]
NOTIFY Shift Manager to PERFORM Administrative Actions.
[Step 3.g - YES]
When Technical Specifications are addressed, or at Lead Examiner discretion, PROCEED to Event 3.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #3 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 3 Event # 3 Page 12 of 34 Event
Description:
Partial Loss of Condenser Vacuum / Turbine Load Reduction Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Machine Operator: When directed, EXECUTE Event 3.
- FW23, Partial Loss of Condenser Vacuum @ 3%.
Indications Available:
99B37 - VACUUM LO 99B46 - EXHAUST SPRAY WATER FLOW Indication of rising Main Condenser backpressure into the Area of Restricted Operation Slight drop in Main Generator MWe output Condensate Pump P-053 may AUTO START due to the secondary transient Vacuum Pump P-054 AUTO START
+1 min BOP REFER to Annunciator Response Procedures (ARPs).
DETERMINE that vacuum is degrading and the Main Turbine is operating in BOP the restricted area of SO23-5-1.7, Attachment 5, Turbine Vacuum Limitations and INFORM the SRO SO23-13-10 entry required.
SRO ENTER SO23-13-10, Loss of Condenser Vacuum.
Examiner Note: A loss of Condenser vacuum will cause P-054, Condenser Vacuum Pump, to start. This condition disrupts the flow through the Condenser Air Ejector Radiation Monitor and causes a SECONDARY RADIATION HI alarm. The crew should use multiple indications to determine that a tube leak does NOT exist.
BOP VERIFY Vacuum Pump P-054 automatically starts. [Step 1.a - YES]
- DECLARE RT-7870, Condenser process flow rate monitor SRO INOPERABLE and INITIATE a LCOAR/EDMR. [Step 1.a.1) - NO]
- Within one hour of a change in Condenser evacuation flow, PERFORM SRO SO23-3-3.21, Attachment for Shiftly Flow Estimates. [Step 1.a.2) - NO]
- INITIATE aligning S21313MU219, Hogger / SJAE Nozzle Manifold SRO Selector fully to the MP-054 position. [Step 1.a.3) - YES]
BOP After two minutes of operating, PLACE Vacuum Pump P054 in MANUAL.
- DEPRESS HS-3331A, P-054 MANUAL pushbutton. [Step 1.b - YES]
BOP VERIFY Gland Seal steam pressure > 2 psig on PI-2845. [Step 1.c - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #3 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 3 Event # 3 Page 13 of 34 Event
Description:
Partial Loss of Condenser Vacuum / Turbine Load Reduction Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior VERIFY Condenser backpressure is in area of Unrestricted Operation in BOP Attachment 3. [Step 1.d - NO]
SRO * [RNO] INITIATE Attachment 1 and GO to Step 2.
Examiner Note: Attachment 1, Potential Sources of Vacuum Loss; actions are performed in the Turbine Building.
INITIATE Attachment 1 and DISPATCH personnel to locate source of SRO/BOP vacuum leak.
RO VERIFY Reactor trip has not occurred. [Step 2.a - YES]
BOP VERIFY Turbine trip has not occurred. [Step 2.b - YES]
M.O. Cue: If crew is having trouble with Condenser vacuum, LOWER malfunction FW23, Condenser Vacuum leakage in 1% increments to 1%.
BOP REDUCE Turbine load as required. [Step 2.c - YES]
- MAINTAIN Backpressure in Area of Unrestricted Operation in Attachment 3.
- MAINTAIN Condenser T 25°F.
Examiner Note: The following BOP Steps are from SO23-5-1.7, Power Operations, Section 6.4, Turbine Load Change Using Speed / Load Adjustment. Using this Section, load may be reduced in small increments in an attempt to restore vacuum BOP Turbine Load Change Using Speed/Load Adjustment. [Section 6.4 - YES]
- If required, PERFORM a Reactivity Brief & Peer Check. [Step 6.4.1 - YES]
- INITIATE monitoring TCOLDAVG. [Step 6.4.2 - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #3 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 3 Event # 3 Page 14 of 34 Event
Description:
Partial Loss of Condenser Vacuum / Turbine Load Reduction Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- ADJUST Turbine load as required to maintain TCOLD. [Step 6.4.3 - YES]
- DEPRESS HS-2210, Main Turbine Speed / Load Control, RAISE or LOWER pushbuttons for Coarse adjustment. [Step 6.4.3.1 - YES]
- ACTIVATE DCS Speed/Load Pushbuttons Box and ENSURE Rate is set at an acceptable MW/MIN value for Fine adjustment.
[Step 6.4.3.2 - YES]
- SELECT MODIFY.
- DEPRESS UP or DOWN buttons or +0.5 or -0.5 buttons.
- VERIFY Turbine load STABILIZES at Target value. [Step 6.4.4 - YES]
Floor Cue: If asked, REPORT Condenser T is 22°F.
Floor Cue: As Shift Manager, ASK SRO their recommendation as to whether power descension should be performed. REPORT as Shift Manager to reduce load 15%
per hour per SO23-13-28, Rapid Power Reduction, Attachment 2.
RO NOTIFY Generation Operations Controller. [Step 2.d - YES]
M.O. Cue: If Unit 3 is asked about recent equipment changes, REPORT that there were no recent activities that could have resulted in Loss of Condenser Vacuum.
VERIFY loss of vacuum NOT result of equipment status changes on either SRO Unit. [Step 2.e - YES]
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-13-28, Rapid Power Reduction, Attachment 2, RPR - 20%/ Hour (to be performed at 15% per hour).
RO/BOP PERFORM a Reactivity Brief. [Step 1.1 - YES]
SRO NOTIFY the Generation Operations Controller. [Step 1.2 - YES]
SRO INITIATE an MSR cooldown if load less than 750 MWe. [Step 1.3 - NO]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #3 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 3 Event # 3 Page 15 of 34 Event
Description:
Partial Loss of Condenser Vacuum / Turbine Load Reduction Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior SRO INITIATE monitoring CV-9739, COLSS Raw T Power. [Step 1.4 - YES]
SRO INITIATE forcing Pressurizer Spray flow. [Step 1.5 - YES]
Examiner Note: The following RO steps are from SO23-3-1.10, Pressurizer Pressure and Level Control, Section 6.3, Forcing Pressurizer Sprays with RCS pressure > 1500 PSIA.
RO COMMENCE forcing Pressurizer Sprays. [Step 6.3.1 - YES]
- CONDUCT a Reactivity Brief. [Step 6.3.1.1 - YES]
- COMMENCE monitoring RCS pressure. [Step 6.3.1.2 - YES]
- VERIFY RCS pressure greater than 1500 psia. [Step 6.3.1.3 - YES]
- PLACE both PZR Spray Valve Controllers in AUTO. [Step 6.3.1.4 - YES]
- POSITION Backup Heaters to ON or AUTO as necessary to support PZR Spray Valve operation. [Step 6.3.1.5 - YES]
- LOWER PIC-0100, PZR Pressure Controller setpoint to 2225 PSIA.
[Step 6.3.1.6 - YES]
INITIATE concurrently using a combination of Boration, CEA insertion, and SRO Turbine load reduction to achieve the targets of SO23-5-1.7. [Step 1.6 - YES]
Examiner Note: The following RO Steps are from SO23-3-2.2, Makeup Operations, Section 6.3, Borating to the Charging Pump Suction.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #3 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 3 Event # 3 Page 16 of 34 Event
Description:
Partial Loss of Condenser Vacuum / Turbine Load Reduction Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior RO Borating to the Charging Pump Suction: [Section 6.3 - YES]
- If required, PERFORM a Reactivity Brief. [Step 6.3.1 - YES]
- SELECT P-191, Charging Pump. [Step 6.3.2 - YES]
- ENTER ~5 GPM on FIC-0210Y, BAMU Flow Controller.
[Step 6.3.3 - YES]
- SELECT SET and ENTER 5 GPM. [Step 6.3.3.1 - YES]
- ENSURE FIC-0210Y in AUTO. [Step 6.3.3.2 - YES]
- SET FQIS-0210Y, Boration Counter, to 300 GPM. [Step 6.3.4 - YES]
- SELECT MODIFY. [Step 6.3.4.1 - YES]
- ENTER 300 gallons in PRESET. [Step 6.3.4.2 - YES]
- SELECT SET PRESET. [Step 6.3.4.3 - YES]
- SELECT EXIT. [Step 6.3.4.4 - YES]
- SELECT BAMU Pump P-174 or P-175. [Step 6.3.5 - YES]
[Step 6.3.6 - YES]
- ENSURE HV-9257, BAMU to Charging Pump Suction Block, in AUTO.
[Step 6.3.7 - YES]
- COMMENCE monitoring plant parameters. [Step 6.3.8 - YES]
[Step 6.3.9 - AS REQD]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #3 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 3 Event # 3 Page 17 of 34 Event
Description:
Partial Loss of Condenser Vacuum / Turbine Load Reduction Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- SELECT HS-0210, Makeup Mode Selector, to BORATE.
[Step 6.3.10 - YES]
- SELECT MODIFY. [Step 6.3.10.1 - YES]
- SELECT BORATE. [Step 6.3.10.2 - YES]
- SELECT GO. [Step 6.3.10.3 - YES]
- CONFIRM boration stops automatically. [Step 6.3.11 - YES]
[Step 6.3.12 - YES]
Examiner Note: The following BOP Steps are from SO23-5-1.7, Power Operations, Section 6.3, Turbine Load Change Using Setpoint Adjustment.
+25 min BOP Turbine Load Change Using setpoint Adjustment. [Section 6.3 - YES]
- If required, PERFORM a Reactivity Brief & Peer Check. [Step 6.3.1 - YES]
- INITIATE monitoring TCOLDAVG. [Step 6.3.2 - YES]
- If raising load, then SET CVOL to about 10% above the final projected Flow Demand. [Step 6.3.3 - NO]
- ACTIVATE Turbine DCS Setpoints Box and SELECT MODIFY.
[Step 6.3.4 - YES]
- SET Demand to MW value (variable) and SELECT ENTER.
[Step 6.3.5 - YES]
- SET Rate to target ~3 MW/MIN value and SELECT ENTER.
[Step 6.3.6 - YES]
- SELECT P2 to INITIATE Turbine load change. [Step 6.3.7 - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #3 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 3 Event # 3 Page 18 of 34 Event
Description:
Partial Loss of Condenser Vacuum / Turbine Load Reduction Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- VERIFY Turbine load stabilizes at Target value. [Step 6.3.8 - YES]
- RESTORE the Rate to 100 MW/MIN and SELECT ENTER.
[Step 6.3.9 - YES]
Examiner Note: Crew may determine that Part Length CEA insertion is necessary for ASI control.
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-3-2.19, CEDMCS Operation, Section 6.12, Repetitive or Emergent Manual CEA Positioning.
- POSITION Group Select Switch to Group 6. [Step 6.12.1 - YES]
- If moving a single CEA, POSITION Individual CEA Selection Switch to RO CEA to be moved. [Step 6.12.2 - N/A]
- POSITION Mode Select Switch to MANUAL Group. [Step 6.12.3 - YES]
- VERIFY Group 6 indicator lamps are ILLUMINATED.
[Step 6.12.3.1 - YES]
- When CEA positioning completed, Mode Select Switch to OFF.
[Step 6.12.5 - YES]
M.O. Cue: After load is lowered 3% to 5%, REPORT a dry loop seal on a vacuum breaker and makeup is in progress, DELETE FW23, Condenser Vacuum Leak Malfunction.
Floor Cue: As Shift Manager, ASK SRO their recommendation as to whether power descension should continue, then CONCUR with securing down power.
When Condenser vacuum has stabilized, power reduction is completed, or at Lead Evaluators discretion, PROCEED to Event 4.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #3 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 3 Event # 4 Page 19 of 34 Event
Description:
Steam Generator E-088 Master Controller Setpoint Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Machine Operator: When directed, EXECUTE Event 4.
- FC05B, SG E-088 Master Controller Setpoint fails to 45% on 240 second ramp.
Indications Available:
52A02 - FWCS SG2 E088 LEVEL DEVIATION 53B23 - CONDENSATE FLOW BALANCE TROUBLE (~60 seconds later)
SG E088 Feedwater Control Valve modulating closed then opens as SG level stabilizes at 45%
SG E088 level lowering
+60 sec BOP REFER to Annunciator Response Procedures (ARPs).
RECOGNIZE E-088 Master Controller Setpoint lowering to 45% and BOP INFORM the SRO SO23-13-24 entry required.
Examiner Note: If not already done, the SRO should stop the down power.
Examiner Note: The BOP may perform "prompt and prudent" actions to control SG level. This is allowed per SO123-0-A1, Conduct of Operations, Section 6.8, Procedure Use and Adherence, Step 6.8.3.
SRO ENTER SO23-13-24, Feedwater Control System Malfunction.
- EVALUATE combination of Conditions to IDENTIFY failure mode and Steps to perform: [Step 1 - YES]
- Steam Generator level anomaly: GO to Attachment 1. [Step 1 - YES]
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-13-24, Feedwater Control System Malfunction, Attachment 1, Feedwater Control System Malfunction Flowchart.
BOP DETERMINE that SG E-088 level is LOW.
DETERMINE that SG E-088 Master Controller 2FIC-1121 output is BOP LOWERING.
BOP PLACE SG E-088 Master Controller in MANUAL and RAISE output.
Floor Cue: If required, REPORT as Shift Manager to maintain SG level at 67% in MANUAL.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #3 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 3 Event # 4 Page 20 of 34 Event
Description:
Steam Generator E-088 Master Controller Setpoint Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior BOP DETERMINE that SG E-088 Feed Control Valve is OPENING.
BOP DETERMINE that Main Feedwater Pumps K-005 and K-006 speed RISING.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #3 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 3 Event # 4 Page 21 of 34 Event
Description:
Steam Generator E-088 Master Controller Setpoint Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior SRO CONTACT I & C to investigate.
M.O. Cue: If contacted as I & C, REPORT the controller logic card appears to be the problem and the Master Controller must remain in MANUAL.
VERIFY SG E-088 level STABLE at or near program level with E-088 Master SRO Controller in MANUAL and GO to Section 3.
SRO/BOP VERIFY SG E-088 level remains stable. [Step 3.a - YES]
SRO/BOP MONITOR SG E-088 level. [Step 3.a.1) - YES]
BOP MONITOR Feedwater Control System performance. [Step 3.a.2) - YES]
BOP ADJUST SG E-088 level to maintain approximately 67%. [Step 3.a.3) - YES]
SRO CONTACT the Shift Manager. [Step 3.b) - YES]
SRO/BOP VERIFY EFAS has not actuated. [Step 3.c) - YES]
VERIFY Feedwater Control System is functioning properly with all
+10 min SRO/BOP components in AUTO. [Step 3.d - YES]
When SG level is restored, or at Lead Evaluators discretion, PROCEED to Events 5, 6, 7, and 8.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #3 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 3 Event # 5, 6, 7, & 8 Page 22 of 34 Event
Description:
Main Steam Line Break Inside Containment / Train B SIAS Relay Failure / Containment Spray Pump Start Failure / Main Steam Isolation Signal Actuation Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Machine Operator: When directed, EXECUTE Events 5, 6, 7, and 8.
- MS03A, SG E-088 Steam Line break inside Containment @ 0.5% severity.
- K403B, Train B SIAS relay failure.
- RP01M, Containment Spray Pump P-012 start failure.
- MSIS LP, Main Steam Isolation Signal (MSIS) fails to actuate.
Indications Available:
60A02 - CONTAINMENT HUMIDITY HI 60A12 - REACTOR CAVITY TEMP HI (~5 seconds later) 56A56 - CONTAINMENT SUMP LEVEL HI (~10 seconds later) 56A35 - CONTAINMENT PRESSURE HI PRETRIP (~30 seconds later)
Numerous Excess Steam Demand Event related alarms Examiner Note: The Steam Line break begins at 0.5% (~100,000 lbm/hr). When MSIS is manually actuated, the severity changes to 2.0% (~400,000 lbm/hr).
Examiner Note: The SRO may pull forward the actions of FS-30, Establish Stable RCS Temperature during ESDE. These steps are identified later in this scenario.
RECOGNIZE high Containment humidity with increasing Containment Sump
+1 min RO level and no corresponding radiation alarms.
RO OBSERVE RPS Pre-trips for CONTAINMENT PRESSURE HI.
SRO DIRECT a Reactor and Turbine trip.
RO/BOP Manually TRIP Reactor.
- DEPRESS Reactor Trip pushbuttons at CR-56 or CR-53.
SRO ENTER SO23-12-1, Standard Post Trip Actions.
RO VERIFY Reactor Trip:
- VERIFY Reactor Trip Circuit Breakers OPEN. [Step 1.a - YES]
- VERIFY Reactor Power lowering and Startup Rate NEGATIVE.
[Step 1.b - YES]
- VERIFY maximum of one (1) Full Length CEAs NOT fully inserted.
[Step 1.c - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #3 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 3 Event # 5, 6, 7, & 8 Page 23 of 34 Event
Description:
Main Steam Line Break Inside Containment / Train B SIAS Relay Failure / Containment Spray Pump Start Failure / Main Steam Isolation Signal Actuation Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior SRO/RO VERIFY Reactivity Control criteria satisfied.
BOP VERIFY Turbine Trip:
- VERIFY both Unit Output Breakers OPEN. [Step 2.b - YES]
SRO INITIATE Administrative Actions:
- INITIATE Attachment 4, Worksheet. [Step 3.a - YES]
BOP VERIFY Vital Auxiliaries functioning properly:
- VERIFY both 1E 4 kV Buses 2A04 and 2A06 ENERGIZED.
[Step 4.a - YES]
- VERIFY all 1E 480 V Buses 2B04, 2B24, 2B06, & 2B26 ENERGIZED.
[Step 4.b - YES]
- VERIFY all 1E DC Buses ENERGIZED. [Step 4.c - YES]
- VERIFY all Non-1E 4 kV Buses 2A03, 2A07, 2A08, & 2A09 ENERGIZED.
[Step 4.d - YES]
- VERIFY Train B CCW OPERATING and ALIGNED to Non-Critical Loop and Letdown Heat Exchanger. [Step 4.e - NO]
- [RNO] If CIAS actuated, STOP all RCPs and GO to Step 5.
SRO/BOP DETERMINE Vital Auxiliaries criteria satisfied.
SRO/RO VERIFY RCS Inventory Control criteria satisfied:
- VERIFY PZR level between 10% and 70% and TRENDING to between 30% and 60%. [Step 5.a - YES]
- VERIFY Core Exit Saturation Margin 20°F: [Step 5.b - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #3 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 3 Event # 5, 6, 7, & 8 Page 24 of 34 Event
Description:
Main Steam Line Break Inside Containment / Train B SIAS Relay Failure / Containment Spray Pump Start Failure / Main Steam Isolation Signal Actuation Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
SRO/RO VERIFY RCS Pressure Control criteria satisfied:
- VERIFY PZR pressure between 1740 PSIA and 2380 PSIA, controlled and TRENDING to between 2025 & 2275 PSIA. [Step 6.a - YES]
RO VERIFY Core Heat Removal criteria satisfied:
- VERIFY at least one RCP operating. [Step 7.a - NO]
- [RNO] GO to Step 7.c.
- DETERMINE Core Exit Saturation Margin > 20°F. [Step 7.c - YES]
SRO/RO DETERMINE Core Heat Removal criteria NOT satisfied.
BOP VERIFY RCS Heat Removal criteria satisfied:
- VERIFY both SG narrow range levels > 21%. [Step 8.a - NO]
- VERIFY both SG narrow range levels < 80%. [Step 8.a - YES]
- VERIFY Feedwater available. [Step 8.a - NO]
- [RNO] DETERMINE EFAS-1 & EFAS-2 AUTO initiation.
- VERIFY TCOLD between 540°F and 550°F. [Step 8.b - NO]
- [RNO] ENSURE Feedwater flow NOT excessive.
- [RNO] ENSURE Steam Bypass Control Valves CLOSED.
- [RNO] ENSURE Atmospheric Dump Valves CLOSED.
Examiner Note: Manual actuation of a Main Steam Isolation Signal (MSIS) was not deemed a Critical Task because the Containment Isolation Actuation Signal on high Containment pressure has already closed the Main Steam Isolation Valves.
- DEPRESS HS-9137-1 and HS-9137-2 MSIS pushbuttons on CR-56.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #3 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 3 Event # 5, 6, 7, & 8 Page 25 of 34 Event
Description:
Main Steam Line Break Inside Containment / Train B SIAS Relay Failure / Containment Spray Pump Start Failure / Main Steam Isolation Signal Actuation Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- DEPRESS HS-9137-3 and HS-9137-4 MSIS pushbuttons on CR-53.
- VERIFY SG pressures between 960 and 1050 PSIA. [Step 8.c - NO]
SRO/BOP DETERMINE RCS Heat Removal criteria NOT satisfied.
RO VERIFY Containment Isolation criteria satisfied:
- VERIFY Containment pressure < 1.5 PSIG. [Step 9.a - NO]
- OPEN Train B SIAS Valves:
- [RNO] ENSURE all RCPs STOPPED.
- VERIFY Containment Area Radiation Monitors NOT alarming or trending to alarm. [Step 9.b - YES]
- VERIFY Secondary Plant Radiation Monitors NOT alarming or trending to alarm. [Step 9.c - YES]
SRO/RO DETERMINE Containment Isolation NOT criteria satisfied.
RO VERIFY Containment Temperature and Pressure criteria satisfied:
- VERIFY Containment average temperature < 120°F. [Step 10.a - NO]
- [RNO] ENSURE proper functioning of Normal Containment Cooling.
- [RNO] ENSURE at least one Containment Dome Air Circulator OPERATING.
- VERIFY Containment pressure < 3.4 PSIG. [Step 10.b - NO]
- [RNO] ENSURE all RCPs STOPPED.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #3 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 3 Event # 5, 6, 7, & 8 Page 26 of 34 Event
Description:
Main Steam Line Break Inside Containment / Train B SIAS Relay Failure / Containment Spray Pump Start Failure / Main Steam Isolation Signal Actuation Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- [RNO] ENSURE all available Containment Emergency Cooling Units OPERATING.
- [RNO] DETERMINE Containment pressure > 14 PSIG.
- [RNO] ENSURE CSAS actuated.
- DEPRESS HS-9395-1, P-012, Containment Spray Pump START pushbutton.
- [RNO] ENSURE all available Containment Spray Header flows >
1600 GPM.
SRO/RO DETERMINE Containment Temperature and Pressure criteria NOT satisfied.
+15 min SRO DIAGNOSE event in progress:
- VERIFY all Safety Function criteria per Attachment 4, Worksheet -
RECOVERED. [Step 11.a - NO]
- [RNO] COMPLETE Attachment 1, Recovery Diagnostics.
- VERIFY Reactor Trip Recovery - DIAGNOSED. [Step 10.b - NO]
RO * [RNO] DETERMINE all RCPs STOPPED.
- INITIATE steps 12 through 16. [Step 11.c - YES]
- IMPLEMENT EOI SO23-12-5, Excess Steam Demand Event.
[Step 11.d - YES]
Examiner Note: SO23-12-1, Standard Post Trip Actions, Steps 12 to 16, performed by the BOP are located at the end of the scenario. The following steps are from SO23-12-5, Excess Steam Demand Event.
SRO ENTER SO23-12-5, Excess Steam Demand Event.
SRO RECORD time of EOI entry __________. [Step 1.a - YES]
SRO VERIFY ESDE diagnosis:
- INITIATE SO23-12-10, Safety Function Status Checks. [Step 2.a - YES]
- INITIATE Foldout Page. [Step 2.b - YES]
- DIRECT performance FS-30, Establish Stable RCS Temperature during ESDE.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #3 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 3 Event # 5, 6, 7, & 8 Page 27 of 34 Event
Description:
Main Steam Line Break Inside Containment / Train B SIAS Relay Failure / Containment Spray Pump Start Failure / Main Steam Isolation Signal Actuation Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- DIRECT performance of FS-7, Verify SI Throttle/Stop Criteria.
- DIRECT performance of SO23-12-11, Attachment 22, Non-Qualified Load Restoration.
- VERIFY ESDE diagnosis using Figure 1, Break Identification Chart.
[Step 2.c - YES]
[Step 2.d - YES]
M.O. Cue: If directed to sample SGs, WAIT 3 minutes and REPORT that E088 and E089 sample lines were frisked, and both have activity near background. If the SG Sample Valves are closed, REPORT that you are unable to establish sample flow.
SRO INITIATE Administrative Actions.
- NOTIFY Shift Manager/Operations Leader of SO23-12-5, Excess Steam Demand Event initiation. [Step 3.a - YES]
- ENSURE Emergency Plan is initiated. [Step 3.b - YES]
- IMPLEMENT Placekeeper. [Step 3.c - YES]
- IMPLEMENT Time Dependent Steps. [Step 3.d - YES]
- VERIFY SIAS actuation required. [Step 4.a - YES]
- DETERMINE Containment pressure greater than SIAS setpoint.
- ENSURE the following actuated: [Step 4.b - YES]
- SIAS / CCAS / CRIS
- RECORD time of SIAS: __________ [Step 4.c - YES]
BOP/RO
- STOP unloaded Diesel Generators. [Step 4.d - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #3 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 3 Event # 5, 6, 7, & 8 Page 28 of 34 Event
Description:
Main Steam Line Break Inside Containment / Train B SIAS Relay Failure / Containment Spray Pump Start Failure / Main Steam Isolation Signal Actuation Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- INITIATE SO23-12-11, Attachment 22, Non-Qualified Load Restoration.
BOP/RO
[Step 4.e - YES]
M.O. Cue: When directed to restore non-qualified loads, WAIT 2 minutes, then EXECUTE remote function ED85, Non-Qualified Loads Restoration. INFORM the Control Room that you have restored Non-Qualified Loads.
- VERIFY MSIS actuation required. [Step 4.f - YES]
- DETERMINE SG pressure < 740 PSIA.
- ENSURE MSIS actuated. [Step 4.g - YES]
- VERIFY CIAS actuation required. [Step 4.h - YES]
- DETERMINE Containment pressure > 3.4 PSIG.
- ENSURE CIAS actuated. [Step 4.i - YES]
- ENSURE SIAS actuated. [Step 4.j - YES]
RO ESTABLISH Optimum SI Alignment:
- ESTABLISH two train operation: [Step 5.a - YES]
- DETERMINE all available Charging Pumps OPERATING.
[Step 5.a.1) - YES]
[Step 5.a.2) - YES]
- VERIFY all Cold Leg flow paths ALIGNED. [Step 5.a.3) - YES]
- DETERMINE SI flow required AND indicated. [Step 5.a.4) - YES]
BOP DETERMINE MSIVs and MSIV Bypasses CLOSED. [Step 6 - YES]
SRO PREVENT Pressurize Thermal Shock:
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #3 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 3 Event # 5, 6, 7, & 8 Page 29 of 34 Event
Description:
Main Steam Line Break Inside Containment / Train B SIAS Relay Failure / Containment Spray Pump Start Failure / Main Steam Isolation Signal Actuation Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- DIRECT performance of FS-30, Establish Stable RCS Temperature During ESDE. [Step 7.a - YES]
- DIRECT performance of VERIFY FS-7, Verify SI Throttle/Stop Criteria.
[Step 7.b - YES]
DETERMINE RCP NPSH requirements of SO23-12-11, Attachment 30, not RO applicable. [Step 8 - YES]
Examiner Note: The following steps from SO23-12-11, EOI Supporting Attachments, FS-30, Establish Stable RCS Temperature during ESDE, will be performed when conditions are met. SO23-12-5 steps are continued later.
+20 min VERIFY SG least affected by ESDE, SG E-089, NOT isolated for SGTR.
[Step a - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #3 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 3 Event # 5, 6, 7, & 8 Page 30 of 34 Event
Description:
Main Steam Line Break Inside Containment / Train B SIAS Relay Failure / Containment Spray Pump Start Failure / Main Steam Isolation Signal Actuation Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior VERIFY most affected SG level E-088 - less than 50% WR.
[Step b - YES]
BOP PERFORM the following on least affected SG E-089: [Step c - YES]
- TRANSFER HV-8421, SG E-089 ADV to AUTO / MODULATE.
[Step c.1) - YES]
[Step c.2) - YES]
Examiner Note: During validation, Steam Generator E-088 reached 200 PSIA before wide range level indication was lost (dryout).
BOP VERIFY SG dryout on most affected SG E-088:
- DETERMINE RCS TCOLD - STABLE or RISING. [Step d.1) - NO]
- DETERMINE SG pressure - 200 PSIA. [Step d.2) - YES]
CRITICAL TASK Establish Stable Reactor Coolant System Temperature per SO23-12-11, E0I STATEMENT Supporting Attachments, FS-30, Establish Stable RCS Temperature during ESDE.
CRITICAL TASK BOP STABILIZE least affected SG E-089 pressure:
- VERIFY ADV on SG E-089 in AUTO / MODULATE. [Step e.1) - YES]
VERIFY RCS pressure is to the right of the Appendix E curve on Attachment RO 30, Post-Accident Pressure / Temperature Limits. [Step f - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #3 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 3 Event # 5, 6, 7, & 8 Page 31 of 34 Event
Description:
Main Steam Line Break Inside Containment / Train B SIAS Relay Failure / Containment Spray Pump Start Failure / Main Steam Isolation Signal Actuation Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior OPERATE Feedwater on SG E-089 to maintain between 40% and 80% NR.
[Step g - YES]
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-12-5, Excess Steam Demand Event.
BOP VERIFY Excess Steam Demand ISOLATED. [Step 9.a - NO]
- [RNO] GO to Step c.
SRO/BOP DETERMINE SG E-088 most affected Steam Generator. [Step 9.c - YES]
SRO ISOLATE Steam Generator E-088:
CRITICAL TASK Identify and Isolate Most Affected Steam Generator (ESDE) Prior to Exiting STATEMENT SO23-12-5, Excess Steam Demand Event.
CRITICAL TASK BOP
- ISOLATE Steam Generator E-088: [Step 10.a - YES]
- CLOSE / STOP SG E-088 components: [Step 10.a.1) - YES]
- DETERMINE HV-8205, Main Steam Isolation Valve CLOSED.
- DETERMINE HV-8203, Main Steam Isolation Valve Bypass CLOSED.
- DETERMINE HV-8419, Atmospheric Dump Valve CLOSED.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #3 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 3 Event # 5, 6, 7, & 8 Page 32 of 34 Event
Description:
Main Steam Line Break Inside Containment / Train B SIAS Relay Failure / Containment Spray Pump Start Failure / Main Steam Isolation Signal Actuation Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- DETERMINE HV-4048, Main Feed Isolation Valve CLOSED.
- DETERMINE HV-4730, Auxiliary Feedwater Valve CLOSED.
- DETERMINE HV-4714, Auxiliary Feedwater Valve CLOSED.
- DEPRESS HV-8201, P-140, Steam to Auxiliary Feedwater Pump CLOSE pushbutton.
- DETERMINE HV-4054, SG Blowdown Isolation Valve CLOSED.
- DEPRESS HS-4733-2, P-504, Auxiliary Feedwater Pump STOP pushbutton.
ENSURE HV-8419, SG E-088 ADV selected to MANUAL.
+30 min BOP
[Step 10.a.2) - YES]
When Steam Generator E-088 is isolated, or at Lead Evaluators discretion, TERMINATE the scenario.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #3 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 3 Event # 5, 6, 7, & 8 Page 33 of 34 Event
Description:
Main Steam Line Break Inside Containment / Train B SIAS Relay Failure / Containment Spray Pump Start Failure / Main Steam Isolation Signal Actuation Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Examiner Note: These steps are performed by the BOP per SO23-12-1, Steps 12 through 16.
SRO/BOP INITIATE Attachment 5, Administrative Actions. [Step 12.a - YES]
SRO/BOP ENSURE a PA system announcement for Reactor Trip. [Step 12.b - YES]
BOP ENSURE the following loads restored:
- VERIFY Telecom 480 VAC Feeder Breaker - CLOSED.
[Step 13.a - YES].
- VERIFY Telecom 480 VAC Feeder Breaker - CLOSED.
[Step 13.b - YES].
- VERIFY all Non-1E Buses - ENERGIZED [Step 13.c - YES].
- DETERMINE B15 & B16 480 VAC Load Centers - ENERGIZED
[Step 13.d - YES].
BOP VERIFY Main Turbine Coastdown:
- DETERMINE Extraction Steam Block Valves - CLOSED.
[Step 14.a - YES]
- DETERMINE Main Steam to Reheater Block, Bypass, Warmup, and Control Valves - CLOSED. [Step 14.a - YES]
- DETERMINE HV-2712A/B Bled Steam to Reheaters Block Valve -
CLOSED. [Step 14.a - YES]
- VERIFY Generator lowering - less than 24 kV. [Step 14.b - YES]
- VERIFY 99A26 - TURBINE LUBE OIL TEMP HI and 99A46 - TURBINE BRG OIL DRAIN TEMP HI Annunciators - RESET. [Step 14.c - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #3 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 3 Event # 5, 6, 7, & 8 Page 34 of 34 Event
Description:
Main Steam Line Break Inside Containment / Train B SIAS Relay Failure / Containment Spray Pump Start Failure / Main Steam Isolation Signal Actuation Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- INITIATE SO23-10-2, Turbine Shutdown, Attachment for Unloading the Generator and Removing the Unit from Line. [Step 14.d - NO]
BOP ESTABLISH desired Condensate and Feedwater Status:
- ENSURE 3rd Point Heater Drain Pumps - STOPPED. [Step 15.a - YES]
- VERIFY Reactor Trip Override - RESET. [Step 15.b - NO]
- [RNO] DETERMINE MFW Pump NOT available to RESET RTO.
- MAINTAIN one MFW Pumps and three (3) Condensate Pumps -
OPERATING. [Step 15.c - NO]
- ENSURE FIC-3294, Condensate Pump Miniflow Controller set for Condensate Pump configuration. [Step 15.d - YES]
- Three (3) Pumps - 9000 GPM.
- PLACE LV-3245, Condensate Drawoff Valve to DISABLE.
[Step 15.e - YES]
- VERIFY SO23-12-2, Reactor Trip Recovery, being implemented.
[Step 15.f - NO]
- [RNO] ENSURE HV-4053 & HV-4054, SG Blowdown Valves CLOSED and GO to Step 16.
BOP VERIFY Start-Up Range Channels:
- VERIFY both Start-Up Range Channels - OPERABLE. [Step 16.a - YES]
SO23-12-1, Standard Post Trip Actions, Steps 12 through 16 are complete.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #3 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Scenario Outline Form ES-D-1 Facility: SONGS 2 & 3 Scenario No.: 4 Op Test No.: October 2011 NRC Examiners: Operators:
Initial Conditions: 100% power MOL - RCS Boron is 980 ppm (via sample).
Turnover: Maintain steady-state power conditions.
Critical Tasks:
- Restore Component Cooling Water Flow Due to Train A Leakage Prior to Exiting SO23-13-7, Loss of Component Cooling Water / Saltwater Cooling.
- Initiate Emergency Boration for Two (2) Stuck Control Element Assemblies Prior to Exiting SO23-12-1, Standard Post Trip Actions.
- Restore Feedwater Flow to At Least One Steam Generator Prior to Reaching 0% Wide Range Level in Both Steam Generators per SO23-12-6, Loss of Feedwater.
Event No. Malf. No. Event Type* Event Description 1 RC15B I (RO, SRO) Pressurizer Pressure Control Channel Y (PT-0100Y) Fails Low.
+10 min 2 CC05A C (BOP, SRO) Train A Component Cooling Water Heat Exchanger (E-001) Tube
+20 min TS (SRO) Leak.
3 RP18 I (RO, SRO) Control Element Assembly Calculator #2 Failure.
+25 min TS (SRO) 4 MFW LP R (RO) Main Feedwater Pump (K-005 / P-063) Trip.
+45 min N (BOP, SRO) Initiate Rapid Power Reduction to 70%.
5 FW09D M (RO, BOP, SRO) Main Feedwater Pump (K-006 / P-062) High Vibration Trip.
+50 min FW09E 6 RD0602 C (RO) Two (2) Stuck Control Element Assemblies (#6 & #41) upon
+50 min RD4102 Reactor Trip. Emergency Boration Required.
7 2A07 LP C (BOP) Non-1E Bus 2A07 Fails to AUTO Transfer Upon Reactor Trip.
+51 min 8 FW02A C (BOP) Motor Driven AFW Pumps (P-141 / P-504) Shaft Seizure (post-trip).
+55 min FW02B Turbine Driven AFW Pump (P-140) Overspeed Trip (post-trip).
FW25 Loss of all Feedwater.
- (N)ormal, (R)eactivity, (I)nstrument, (C)omponent, (M)ajor, (TS)Technical Specifications Actual Target Quantitative Attributes 8 Total malfunctions (5-8) 3 Malfunctions after EOP entry (1-2) 3 Abnormal events (2-4) 1 Major transients (1-2) 2 EOPs entered/requiring substantive actions (1-2) 0 EOP contingencies requiring substantive actions (0-2) 3 Critical tasks (2-3)
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #4 Rev f.doc
Scenario Event Description NRC Scenario #4 SCENARIO
SUMMARY
NRC #4 The crew will assume the watch at 100% power with no scheduled activities per Operating Instruction (OI) SO23-5-1.7, Power Operations. When the Shift Turnover is complete, a Pressurizer Pressure Channel fails low. Actions are per the Annunciator Response Procedures (ARPs) and Abnormal Operating Instruction (AOI) SO23-13-27, Pressurizer Pressure and Level Malfunction. The alternate controlling channel will be placed in service and Pressurizer Heaters will be restored to operation. If pressure rises above 2275 PSIA, the SRO will refer to Technical Specifications.
When conditions are stable, a tube leak will develop on the Train A Component Cooling Water (CCW)
Heat Exchanger. The crew will respond per AOI SO23-13-7, Loss of Component Cooling Water /
Saltwater Cooling. Crew actions include transferring to the Train B Component Cooling Water System as well is attempting to isolate the Train A leakage. The SRO will refer to Technical Specifications.
When CCW actions are complete, a Control Element Assembly Calculator (CEAC) will fail. The crew will perform actions per the ARPs and OI SO23-3-2.13, Core Protection / Control Element Assembly Calculator Operation. The SRO will refer to Technical Specifications.
The next event is a trip of Main Feedwater Pump P-062. The crew will reference AOI SO23-13-28, Rapid Power Reduction. A Rapid Power Reduction is performed to reduce Main Turbine load to 70%.
Actions include a Boration to the Charging Pump suction per OI SO23-3-2.2, Makeup Operations and insertion of Control Element Assemblies per OI SO23-3-2.19, Control Element Drive Mechanism Control System Operation.
When power is stable at 70%, a second Main Feedwater Pump will trip requiring a manual Reactor trip.
The crew will enter Emergency Operating Instruction (EOI) SO23-12-1, Standard Post Trip Actions (SPTAs), and determine that two Control Element Assemblies have failed to insert and requiring an Emergency Boration.
The scenario is complicated with a failure of Non-1E Bus 2A07 to AUTO transfer on Reactor Trip. The Motor Driven Auxiliary Feedwater Pumps will operate for two minutes prior to tripping and the Turbine Driven AFW Pump will trip after five minutes rendering a total Loss of Feedwater Flow.
The crew will transition from EOI SO23-12-1, SPTAs, to EOI SO23-12-6, Loss of Feedwater. When the Reactor Coolant Pumps are secured in EOI SO23-12-6, the Turbine Driven Auxiliary Feedwater Pump overspeed trip will be reset per EOI SO23-12-11, EOI Supporting Attachments, FS-11, Reset P-140 Overspeed Trip.
The scenario is terminated when Auxiliary Feedwater System flow is restored to either Steam Generator.
Risk Significance:
- Failure of risk important system prior to trip: Train A CCW Heat Exchanger
- Risk significant core damage sequence: Loss of Feedwater Flow
- Risk significant operator actions: Transfer CCW Non-Critical Loop Emergency Borate Due to Stuck CEAs Restore Feedwater Flow to any Steam Generator SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #4 Rev f.doc
Scenario Event Description NRC Scenario #4 MACHINE OPERATOR INSTRUCTIONS for SIMULATOR SETUP INITIALIZE to IC-230 NRC Scenario #4 and associated Setup File.
EVENT TYPE MALF # DESCRIPTION DEMAND INITIATING VALUE PARAMETER SETUP MF FW02A P-141, Auxiliary Feedwater Pump shaft seizure TRIP RX TRIP MF FW02B P-504, Auxiliary Feedwater Pump shaft seizure TRIP RX TRIP MF FW25 P-140, Auxiliary Feedwater Pump overspeed TRIP RX TRIP MF RD0602 Stuck CEA #06 STUCK MF RD4102 Stuck CEA #41 STUCK 1 MF RC15B Channel y PZR Pressure PT-0100Y failure 2500 psia 2 MF CC05A Train A CCW HX (E-001) Tube Leak 100%
2 RF CC60 Train A HV-6225, CCW Surge Tank outlet valve CLOSE 3 MF RP18 Control Element Assembly Calculator #2 failure OFF 4 LP MFW LP Main Feedwater Pump (K-005 / P-063) trip TRIP 5 MF FW09D Main Feedwater Pump (K-006 / P-062) trip TRIP 5 MF FW09E Main Feedwater Pump (K-006 / P-062) trip TRIP 6 MF RD0602 Stuck CEA #06 STUCK 6 MF RD4102 Stuck CEA #41 STUCK 7 LP 2A07 LP Bus 2A07 fails to AUTO TRANSFER RX TRIP 8 MF FW02A P-141, Auxiliary Feedwater Pump shaft seizure TRIP RX TRIP post trip (PT) (120 seconds PT) 8 MF FW02B P-504, Auxiliary Feedwater Pump shaft seizure TRIP RX TRIP post trip (PT) (120 seconds PT) 8 MF FW25 P-140, Auxiliary Feedwater Pump overspeed TRIP RX TRIP post trip (PT) (300 seconds PT) 8 RF FW52 Reset TDAFW Pump P-140 overspeed trip RESET Upon direction 8 RF FW103 P-140 Throttle Valve MU122. CLOSE Upon direction SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #4 Rev f.doc
Scenario Event Description NRC Scenario #4 Machine Operator: EXECUTE IC-230 NRC Scenario #4 and SETUP file to align components.
ENSURE CVCS Blend Setpoints MATCH Shift Turnover Sheet.
CHANGE Operator Aid Tag #029 (CVCS) to reflect boron concentration.
VERIFY both Pressurizer Spray Valves in AUTO.
CIRCLE Unit 3 for Emergency Chillers E-335 & E-336 on CR-64.
CIRCLE Unit 3 for Motor Control Center BQ on CR-63.
VERIFY Channel Y Pressurizer Pressure and Level in service.
ENSURE Turbine Ramp Rate set to 100 MWe per minute.
PROVIDE procedures in progress, Shift Turnover, and Reactivity Management Guide to crew in Briefing Room:
- COPY of SO23-5-1.7, Power Operations, Section 6.1, Guidelines for Steady State Operation.
- LAMINATED COPY of SO23-5-1.7, Power Operations, Attachment 8, Power Maneuvering Guidelines PLACE the MOC copy of OPS Physics Summary Book on SRO Desk.
VERIFY CEA positions with ARO.
Control Room Annunciators in Alarm:
NONE SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #4 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 4 Event # 1 Page 5 of 31 Event
Description:
Pressurizer Pressure Control Channel Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Machine Operator: When directed, EXECUTE Event 1.
- RC15B, Pressurizer Pressure Controlling Channel PT-0110Y fails low.
Indications Available:
50A04 - PZR PRESS DEVIATION HI / LO 50A14 - PZR PRESS HI / LO Pressurizer Heaters on Examiner Note: If Pressurizer Heaters are left energized for an extended length of time, Annunciator 50A02 - COLSS ALARM will alarm and require additional actions listed at the end of this event. Specifically, Turbine load must be reduced by 5 MWe to clear the alarm.
+30 secs RO REFER to Annunciator Response Procedures (ARPs).
RO DETERMINE which channel initiated the alarm using PR-100.
- RECOGNIZE Channel Y (PR-0100B) has failed low.
Examiner Note: RO may use prompt and prudent action to swap Channels. The next steps are from Annunciator Response Procedure 50A14 - PZR PRESS HI / LO.
DETERMINE controlling channel has failed and POSITION HS-0100A, RO Pressurizer Pressure Channel Select Switch to Channel X.
[Steps 1.1 & 1.1.1 - YES]
DETERMINE controlling channel has failed and INFORM the SRO RO SO23-13-27 entry required. [Steps 1.1 & 1.1.2 - YES]
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-13-27, Pressurizer Pressure and Level Malfunction.
SRO ENTER SO23-13-27, Pressurizer Pressure and Level Malfunction.
- IDENTIFY uncontrolled pressure change and GO to Step 3.
[Step 1 - YES ]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #4 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 4 Event # 1 Page 6 of 31 Event
Description:
Pressurizer Pressure Control Channel Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior DETERMINE Pressurizer Spray Valve is NOT STUCK OPEN.
SRO/RO
[Step 3.a - YES]
VERIFY Pressurizer pressure Channel Y between 2225 PSIA and 2275 SRO/RO PSIA. [Step 3.b - NO]
- [RNO] OBSERVE PR-0100A and DETERMINE Pressurizer pressure RO Channel X available.
- [RNO] POSITION HS-0100A, Pressurizer Pressure Channel Select RO Switch to Channel X.
SRO/RO VERIFY Pressurizer Pressure is stable. [Step 3.c - NO]
- [RNO] If necessary, TRANSFER PIC-0100, Pressurizer Pressure RO Controller to MANUAL.
RO * [RNO] ADJUST output of PIC-0100 as necessary to maintain setpoint.
RO * [RNO] SECURE Pressurizer Heaters as required.
RO DETERMINE normal Charging and Letdown - IN SERVICE. [Step 3.d - YES]
Examiner Note: The next event should be started at this time since it takes a few minutes for CCW Surge Tank level to lower to the alarm setpoint.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #4 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 4 Event # 1 Page 7 of 31 Event
Description:
Pressurizer Pressure Control Channel Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior SRO GO to Step 3.i. [Step 3.e - YES]
SRO INITIATE a notification to I & C. [Step 3.i - YES]
SRO/RO DETERMINE Pressurizer Pressure signal NOT failed high. [Step 3.j - YES]
VERIFY Pressurizer Pressure Control System operating properly in AUTO.
[Step 3.k - YES]
RO VERIFY Pressurizer Spray NOT initiated with T > 180°F. [Step 3.l - YES]
Examiner Note: Technical Specification LCO 3.4.1 is entered if RCS pressure rises above 2275 PSIA.
+10 min SRO NOTIFY personnel & EVALUATE Technical Specifications. [Step 3.m - YES]
- LCO 3.4.1.A, RCS DNB (Pressure, Temperature, and Flow) Limits.
- CONDITION A - Pressurizer pressure or RCS flow rate not within limits.
- ACTION A.1 - Restore parameter(s) to within limit within 2 hours2.314815e-5 days <br />5.555556e-4 hours <br />3.306878e-6 weeks <br />7.61e-7 months <br />.
Examiner Note: The following steps are from Annunciator 50A02 - COLSS ALARM.
If COLSS ALARM is annunciated, LOWER Turbine load 5 MWe at 10 MWe /
BOP min to maintain power margin. [Step 1.1 - YES]
- As required, DEPRESS HS-2210 Main Turbine Speed / Load Control LOWER pushbutton. [Step 1.1 - YES]
If COLSS inoperability is suspected, REFER to Technical Specifications RO 3.2.1 and 3.2.4 for 15 minute ACTION requirements. [Step 1.2 - NO]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #4 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 4 Event # 1 Page 8 of 31 Event
Description:
Pressurizer Pressure Control Channel Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior If loss of TAVE program has occurred, REFER to 50A05 - T AVG HI.
[Step 1.3 - NO]
If at any time the COLSS (Primary and Backup) Computers fail, then initiate RO SO23-3-3.6, COLSS Out of Service Surveillance. [Step 1.4 - NO]
When Technical Specifications are addressed, or at Lead Examiner discretion, PROCEED to Event 2.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #4 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 4 Event # 2 Page 9 of 31 Event
Description:
Train A Component Cooling Water Heat Exchanger Tube Leak Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Machine Operator: When directed, EXECUTE Event 2.
- CC05A, Train A CCW Heat Exchanger tube leak @ 100% severity.
Indications Available:
64A26 - CCW SURGE TANK TRAIN A LEVEL HI/LO (time delay of ~ 2 to 5 min)
+2 min BOP REFER to Annunciator Response Procedures (ARPs).
M.O. Cue: When the CCW Surge Tank level low alarms, LOWER malfunction CC05B to 50%
severity to facilitate diagnosis of the event.
RECOGNIZE lowering Surge Tank level and INFORM the SRO SO23-13-7 BOP entry required.
Examiner Note: If Annunciator Response Procedure actions are followed, the crew will swap to Train B CCW without isolating Radwaste.
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-13-7, Loss of CCW / SWC.
SRO ENTER SO23-13-7, Loss of Complement Cooling Water / Saltwater Cooling.
- DETERMINE required actions based on lowering Surge Tank level and GO to Step 5. [Step 1 - YES]
BOP CLOSE the following valves to ISOLATE Radwaste. [Step 5.a - YES]
SRO/BOP VERFIY that the leak is isolated. [Step 5.b - NO]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #4 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 4 Event # 2 Page 10 of 31 Event
Description:
Train A Component Cooling Water Heat Exchanger Tube Leak Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- [RNO] GO to Step 5.c.
CRITICAL TASK Restore Component Cooling Water Flow Due to Train A Leakage Prior to STATEMENT Exiting SO23-13-7, Loss of Component Cooling Water / Saltwater Cooling.
CRITICAL TASK BOP PLACE Train B CCW/SWC in service. [Step 5.c - YES]
- DEPRESS HS-6324-2, CCW Pump P-026 START pushbutton.
SRO DIRECT transfer of Letdown Heat Exchanger to Train B.
BOP TRANSFER Letdown Heat Exchanger to Train B. [Step 5.d - YES]
SRO DIRECT transfer of CCW Non-Critical Loop to Train B.
BOP TRANSFER the CCW Non-Critical Loop to Train B. [Step 5.e - YES]
- DEPRESS and MAINTAIN DEPRESSED the OPEN pushbuttons for HV-6213 and HV-6219, Critical Loop B Supply and Return to NCL.
- When HV-6212 and HV-6218, Critical Loop A Supply and Return to NCL indicate CLOSED, then RELEASE the OPEN pushbuttons for HV-6213 and HV-6219.
SRO DIRECT securing CCW Pump P-025.
BOP STOP CCW Pump P-025 and SWC Pump P-112. [Step 5.f - YES]
M.O. Cue: If directed to rack out breaker for CCW Pump P-025, REPORT that it is in progress.
SRO DETERMINE ECCS is NOT required. [Step 5.g - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #4 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 4 Event # 2 Page 11 of 31 Event
Description:
Train A Component Cooling Water Heat Exchanger Tube Leak Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior DISPATCH PEO to CLOSE HV-6225, Train A CCW Surge Tank Outlet SRO/BOP Valve. [Step 5.h - YES]
M.O. Cue: If directed to close 2HV-6225, Train A CCW Surge Tank Outlet Valve, WAIT 3 minutes and EXECUTE remote function CC60.
BOP VERIFY Train A CCW Surge level STABLE. [Step 5.i - YES]
Examiner Note: If desired, EXIT this event once 2HV-6225, Train A CCW Surge Tank Outlet Valve is closed. Reference Technical Specifications at the end of the scenario.
M.O. Cue: If contacted to report status of Unit 3 CCW Surge Tank Level, REPORT that Train A CCW Surge Tank level is stable and unchanged.
M.O. Cue: When dispatched, WAIT two minutes and REPORT that no leakage can be found by the outside operator.
BOP CLOSE HV-6273, Train A CCW Surge Tank Makeup Valve. [Step 5.j - YES]
SRO/BOP DISPATCH personnel to locate source of leak. [Step 5.k - YES]
DETERMINE E-335 / E-336, Emergency Chillers, ALIGNED to Unit 3.
[Step 5.l - YES]
BOP INITIATE Attachment 1, CCW Emergency Makeup. [Step 5.m - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #4 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 4 Event # 2 Page 12 of 31 Event
Description:
Train A Component Cooling Water Heat Exchanger Tube Leak Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior VERIFY leak can be isolated OR leak is within the seismic makeup capacity BOP AND leak will not damage significant equipment. [Step 5.n - NO]
BOP EVALUATE placing affected loop in service. [Step 5.o - NO]
SRO GO to Step 19. [Step 5.p - YES]
SRO/BOP ENSURE all system parameters RESTORED to normal. [Step 19.a - YES]
+10 min SRO NOTIFY personnel & EVALUATE Technical Specifications. [Step 19.b - YES]
- LCO 3.7.7.A, Component Cooling Water System.
- CONDITION A - One CCW train inoperable.
- ACTION A.1 - Restore CCW train to OPERABLE status within 72 hours8.333333e-4 days <br />0.02 hours <br />1.190476e-4 weeks <br />2.7396e-5 months <br />.
When Technical Specifications are addressed, or at Lead Evaluators discretion, PROCEED to Event 3.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #4 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 4 Event # 3 Page 13 of 31 Event
Description:
Control Element Assembly Calculator (CEAC) Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Machine Operator: When directed, EXECUTE Event 3.
- RP18, CEAC #2 failure.
Indications Available:
56C42 - CEAC 2 FAILURE
+30 secs RO REFER to Annunciator Response Procedures (ARPs).
Examiner Note: The following steps are from Annunciator 56C42 - CEAC 2 FAILURE.
RO SELECT CEAC #2 display on CEA-CRT to VERIFY failure. [Step 1.1 - YES]
DETERMINE CEAC #2 failure and INFORM SRO SO23-3-2.13, entry RO required for CEAC/RSPT Erratic or INOP. [Step 1.2 - YES]
RO DETERMINE failure has NOT RESET:
- DEPRESS CEAC Fail Indicator Pushbutton on ROM Channel C.
[Step 1.3 - YES]
PERFORM CEA Verification once per 4 hours4.62963e-5 days <br />0.00111 hours <br />6.613757e-6 weeks <br />1.522e-6 months <br /> per SO23-3-3.25 Section for RO Reactivity Control Systems. [Step 2.1 - YES]
NOTIFY the Computer Technician to investigate CEAC #2 Channel failure.
[Step 2.1.1 - YES]
RO ENSURE the CEA-CRT is displaying CEAC #1. [Step 2.1.2 - YES]
Floor Cue: Once actions of ARP are complete, DIRECT SRO to evaluate Technical Specifications. Do not allow the RO to set CEAC INOP flags due to time constraints.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #4 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 4 Event # 3 Page 14 of 31 Event
Description:
Control Element Assembly Calculator (CEAC) Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior ENTER SO23-3-2.13, Core Protection / Control Element Assembly SRO Calculator Operation, Section for CEAC / RSPT Erratic or INOP.
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-3-2.13, Core Protection / Control Element Assembly Calculator Operation, Section 6.5, CEAC / RSPT Erratic or INOP.
SRO/RO Actions for Erratic or Failed CEAC / RSPT: [Step 6.5.1 - NO]
- SET CEAC INOP flags per Step 6.5.5 or 6.5.6. [Step 6.5.1.1 - NO]
+10 min SRO EVALUATE Technical Specifications.
- LCO 3.3.3.A, Control Element Assembly Calculator (CEAC).
- CONDITION A - One CEAC inoperable.
- ACTION A.1 - Perform SR 3.1.5.1 (CEA Verification) once per 4 hours4.62963e-5 days <br />0.00111 hours <br />6.613757e-6 weeks <br />1.522e-6 months <br />, AND
- ACTION A.2 - Restore CEAC to OPERABLE status within 7 days.
When Technical Specifications are addressed, or at Lead Examiner discretion, PROCEED to Event 4.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #4 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 4 Event # 4 Page 15 of 31 Event
Description:
Main Feedwater Pump Trip / Rapid Power Reduction Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Machine Operator: When directed, EXECUTE Event 4.
- FW LP, Main Feedwater Pump (K-005/P-063) trip.
Indications Available:
53B03 - MFWP / TURBINE P063 / K005 TRIP 52A13 - FWCS TROUBLE 52A02 - FWCS SG2 E088 LEVEL DEVIATION (~30 seconds later) 52A07 - FWCS SG1 E089 LEVEL DEVIATION (~30 seconds later)
Multiple Main Feedwater Pump trip alarms Examiner Note: A tripped MFW Pump requires the following procedure entries:
- SO23-13-28, Rapid Power Reduction (guidance for reducing Reactor power 30% in 5 minutes).
- SO23-3-2.2, Makeup Operations (for borating the RCS).
- SO23-3-1.10, Pressurizer Pressure and Level Control (to force Pressurizer Spray flow).
- SO23-3-2.19, CEDMCS Operation, Section 6.12, Repetitive or Emergent Manual CEA Positioning (CEA operation).
+10 secs BOP REFER to Annunciator Response Procedures (ARPs).
DETERMINE Main Feedwater Pump P-063 trip and INFORM SRO BOP SO23-13-28 entry required.
SRO ENTER SO23-13-28, Rapid Power Reduction.
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-13-28, Rapid Power Reduction.
SRO DETERMINE conditions for Rapid Power Reduction (RPR). [Step 1 - YES]
- RPR due to a Main Feedwater Pump Trip, INITIATE Attachment 1.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #4 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 4 Event # 4 Page 16 of 31 Event
Description:
Main Feedwater Pump Trip / Rapid Power Reduction Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior SRO NOTIFY the Manager, Plant Operations. [Step 2 - YES]
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-13-28, Rapid Power Reduction (RPR),
Attachment 1, RPR - 30% in 5 Minutes.
DEPRESS all EFAS Actuation pushbuttons once to INITIATE EFAS.
RO/BOP
[Step 1.1 - YES]
CREW Concurrently PERFORM the following steps: [Step 1.2 - YES]
SRO DIRECT initiation of the Alternate Boration.
- OPEN HV-9247, Emergency Boration Valve, per the Reactivity Brief.
RO Total Gallons __________ Time __________ [Step 1.2.1 - YES]
- START a second Charging Pump. [Step 1.2.1.1 - YES]
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-3-2.2, Makeup Operations, Section 6.9, Alternate Boration Using BAMU Pump through HV-9247.
RO CONDUCT a Reactivity Brief. [Step 6.9.1 - YES]
- COMMENCE periodically changing Boronometer setpoints.
[Step 6.9.1.1 - NO] (This action is performed in the CR hallway.)
- COMMENCE monitoring plant parameters. [Step 6.9.1.2 - YES]
RO ENSURE all Makeup Operations STOPPED. [Step 6.9.2 - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #4 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 4 Event # 4 Page 17 of 31 Event
Description:
Main Feedwater Pump Trip / Rapid Power Reduction Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- SELECT Alternate BORATION. [Step 6.9.3.1 - YES]
- SELECT CONFIRM (~400 gallons). [Step 6.9.3.2 - YES]
- SELECT GO. [Step 6.9.3.3 - YES]
- ENSURE two Charging Pumps are running. [Step 6.9.3.4 - YES]
- When Alternate Boration has timed out (4.33 minutes), VERIFY HV-9247 CLOSED. [Step 6.9.3.5 - YES]
- SELECT CANCEL. [Step 6.9.3.6 - YES]
- OPERATE Charging Pumps per SRO direction. [Step 6.9.3.7 - YES]
Examiner Note: The following steps continue from Attachment 1, RPR - 30% in 5 Minutes.
- ENSURE all available Condensate Pumps running or START BOP Condensate Pump P-053. [Step 1.2.2 - YES]
- INITIATE Attachment 4 for Turbine Load change. [Step 1.2.3 - YES]
- INSERT CEAs as required per SO23-3-2.19. [Step 1.2.4 - YES]
- INSERT Group 6 to 105 inches or as established in Reactivity Brief.
[Step 1.2.4.1 - YES]
RO/BOP INITIATE monitoring CV-9739, COLSS Raw T Power. [Step 1.3 - YES]
CREW INITIATE monitoring TCOLD AVG between 542°F and 545°F. [Step 1.4 - YES]
- If TCOLD AVG > 545°F, PAUSE Turbine load reduction until temperature BOP within band. [Step 1.4.1 - YES]
CREW RESET the EFAS Cycling Relays. [Step 1.5 - YES]
- VERIFY Steam Generator levels STABLE or RISING. [Step 1.5.1 - YES]
- VERIFY Steam Generator low-level alarms RESET. [Step 1.5.2 - YES]
- VERIFY Feedwater Control Valves < 100% OPEN and controlling level.
[Step 1.5.3 - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #4 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 4 Event # 4 Page 18 of 31 Event
Description:
Main Feedwater Pump Trip / Rapid Power Reduction Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- When directed by the SRO, DEPRESS all EFAS Actuation pushbuttons a RO/BOP second time to RESET the Cycling Relays. [Step 1.5.4 - YES]
BOP INITIATE SO23-2-2, Section for On-Line Operation of P-053. [Step 1.6 - NO]
NOTIFY Generation Operations Controller and LOG notification.
[Step 1.7 - YES]
INITIATE Forcing PZR Spray flow using two valves per SO23-3-1.10.
[Step 1.8 - YES]
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-3-1.10, Pressurizer Pressure and Level Control, Section 6.3, Forcing Pressurizer Sprays with RCS pressure > 1500 PSIA.
RO COMMENCE forcing Pressurizer Sprays. [Step 6.3.1 - YES]
- CONDUCT a Reactivity Brief. [Step 6.3.1.1 - YES]
- COMMENCE monitoring RCS pressure. [Step 6.3.1.2 - YES]
- VERIFY RCS pressure greater than 1500 psia. [Step 6.3.1.3 - YES]
- PLACE both PZR Spray Valve Controllers in AUTO. [Step 6.3.1.4 - YES]
- POSITION Backup Heaters to ON or AUTO as necessary to support PZR Spray Valve operation. [Step 6.3.1.5 - YES]
- LOWER PIC-0100, PZR Pressure Controller setpoint to 2225 PSIA.
[Step 6.3.1.6 - YES]
BOP INITIATE a Manual Runback for Turbine load change.
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-13-28, Rapid Power Reduction, Attachment 4, Turbine Load Change Using Manual Runback.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #4 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 4 Event # 4 Page 19 of 31 Event
Description:
Main Feedwater Pump Trip / Rapid Power Reduction Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior BOP ENSURE only the Frequency Loop in service. [Step 1.1 - YES]
BOP INITIATE Turbine Manual Runback. [Step 1.2 - YES]
- SELECT INITIATE / CANCEL in Manual Runback box. [Step 1.2.1 - YES]
- SELECT INITIATE RUNBACK {P2} in Confirm Manual Runback window.
[Step 1.2.2 - YES]
- MAINTAIN Confirm Manual Runback window OPEN to allow cancelling the RUNBACK quickly {P3} if needed. [Step 1.2.2.1 - YES]
- To re-open, SELECT INITIATE / CANCEL. [Step 1.2.2.1 - AS REQD]
- CANCEL and INITIATE the Manual Runback as required to MAINTAIN TCOLD between 542°F and 545°F. [Step 1.2.3 - YES]
- SELECT P2 to INITIATE Turbine load change. [Step 1.2.4 - YES]
- VERIFY Turbine load stabilizes at the target value. [Step 1.2.5 - YES]
BOP MONITOR Turbine Load Using Speed/Load Change. [Section 1.3 - YES]
- ADJUST Turbine load as required to maintain TCOLD. [Step 1.3.1 - YES]
- DEPRESS HS-2210, Main Turbine Speed / Load Control, RAISE or LOWER pushbuttons for Coarse adjustment. [Step 1.3.1.1 - YES]
- ACTIVATE DCS Speed/Load Pushbuttons Box and ENSURE Rate is set at an acceptable MW/MIN value for Fine adjustment.
[Step 1.3.1.2 - YES]
- SELECT MODIFY.
- DEPRESS UP or DOWN buttons or +0.5 or -0.5 buttons.
- VERIFY Turbine load stabilizes at the Target value. [Step 1.3.2 - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #4 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 4 Event # 4 Page 20 of 31 Event
Description:
Main Feedwater Pump Trip / Rapid Power Reduction Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-3-2.19, CEDMCS Operation, Section 6.12, Repetitive or Emergent Manual CEA Positioning.
- POSITION Group Select Switch to Group 6. [Step 6.12.1 - YES]
- If moving a single CEA, POSITION Individual CEA Selection Switch to RO CEA to be moved. [Step 6.12.2 - N/A]
- POSITION Mode Select Switch to MANUAL Group. [Step 6.12.3 - YES]
- VERIFY Group 6 indicator lamps are ILLUMINATED.
[Step 6.12.3.1 - YES]
- When CEA positioning completed, Mode Select Switch to OFF.
+15 min RO
[Step 6.12.5 - YES]
When power level is stable at approximately 70%, or at Lead Evaluators discretion, PROCEED to Event 5.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #4 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 4 Event # 5 Page 21 of 31 Event
Description:
Main Feedwater Pump Trip on High Vibration Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Machine Operator: When directed, EXECUTE Event 5.
- FW09D, Main Feedwater Pump (K-006/P-062) high vibration.
- FW09E, Main Feedwater Pump (K-006/P-062) high vibration.
Indications Available:
53A15 - MFWP P062 SUCTION PRESS LO PRETRIP 53B03 - MFWP / TURBINE P062 / K005 TRIP (~10 seconds later)
+10 secs BOP REFER to Annunciator Response Procedures (ARPs).
BOP RECOGNIZE Main Feedwater Pump P-062 trip.
SRO/RO DIRECT a manual Reactor Trip.
+30 secs RO/BOP Manually TRIP Reactor.
- DEPRESS Reactor Trip pushbuttons at CR-56 or CR-53.
- DEPRESS HS-9132-2 and HS-9132-3 REACTOR TRIP pushbuttons on CR-56.
- DEPRESS HS-9132-1 and HS-9132-4 REACTOR TRIP pushbuttons on CR-52.
When Reactor and Turbine are tripped, or at Lead Evaluators discretion, PROCEED to Events 6, 7, and 8.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #4 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 4 Event # 6, 7, & 8 Page 22 of 31 Event
Description:
Two Stuck Control Element Assemblies / Bus 2A07 Auto Transfer Failure / Loss of Feedwater Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Machine Operator: When directed, EXECUTE Events 6, 7, and 8.
- RD0602 & RD4102, Stuck CEAs #06 & #41
- 2A07 LP, Non-1E Bus 2A07 fails to AUTO transfer.
- FW02A, P-141, Auxiliary Feedwater Pump shaft seizure @ 120 seconds.
- FW02B, P-504, Auxiliary Feedwater Pump shaft seizure @ 120 seconds.
- FW25, P-140, Auxiliary Feedwater Pump overspeed trip @ 300 seconds.
Indications Available:
Numerous Reactor Trip related alarms SRO DIRECT performance of SO23-12-1, Standard Post Trip Actions.
RO VERIFY Reactor Trip:
- VERIFY Reactor Trip Circuit Breakers OPEN. [Step 1.a - YES]
- VERIFY Reactor Power lowering and Startup Rate NEGATIVE.
[Step 1.b - YES]
- VERIFY maximum of one (1) Full Length CEAs NOT fully inserted.
[Step 1.c - NO]
SRO/RO DETERMINE Reactivity Control criteria NOT satisfied.
CRITICAL TASK Initiate Emergency Boration for Two (2) Stuck Control Element Assemblies STATEMENT Prior to Exiting SO23-12-1, Standard Post Trip Actions.
CRITICAL TASK RO * [RNO] COMMENCE Emergency Boration at greater than 40 gpm.
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-13-11, Emergency Boration of the RCS.
RO OPEN HV-9247, Emergency Boration Block Valve. [Step 2.c.1) - YES]
START either BAMU Pump. [Step 2.c.2) - YES]
- DEPRESS P-174, BAMU Pump START pushbutton.
- DEPRESS P-175, BAMU Pump START pushbutton.
CLOSE HV-9236, BAMU Pump P-174 Recirculation Valve. [Step 2.d - YES]
CLOSE HV-9231, BAMU Pump P-175 Recirculation Valve. [Step 2.e - YES]
CLOSE HV-9253, Makeup to VCT Valve, in MANUAL. [Step 2.f - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #4 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 4 Event # 6, 7, & 8 Page 23 of 31 Event
Description:
Two Stuck Control Element Assemblies / Bus 2A07 Auto Transfer Failure / Loss of Feedwater Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior GO to Step 2.i. [Step 2.g - YES]
ENSURE Charging flow > 40 gpm. [Step 2.i - YES]
RECORD time of Emergency Boration initiation __________. [Step 2.i - YES]
DETERMINE Reactivity Control criteria satisfied (with Emergency Boration in SRO/RO progress).
BOP VERIFY Turbine Trip:
- VERIFY both Unit Output Breakers OPEN. [Step 2.b - YES]
SRO INITIATE Administrative Actions:
- INITIATE Attachment 4, Worksheet. [Step 3.a - YES]
BOP VERIFY Vital Auxiliaries functioning properly:
- VERIFY both 1E 4 kV Buses 2A04 and 2A06 ENERGIZED.
[Step 4.a - YES]
- VERIFY all 1E 480 V Buses 2B04, 2B24, 2B06, & 2B26 ENERGIZED.
[Step 4.b - YES]
- VERIFY all 1E DC Buses ENERGIZED. [Step 4.c - YES]
- VERIFY Non-1E 4 kV Buses 2A03, 2A08, & 2A09 ENERGIZED.
[Step 4.d - YES]
- VERIFY Non-1E 4 kV Bus 2A07 ENERGIZED. [Step 4.d - NO]
- [RNO] RESTORE power to Bus as time and resources permits.
- VERIFY CCW Train B OPERATING and ALIGNED to Non-Critical Loop and Letdown Heat Exchanger. [Step 4.e - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #4 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 4 Event # 6, 7, & 8 Page 24 of 31 Event
Description:
Two Stuck Control Element Assemblies / Bus 2A07 Auto Transfer Failure / Loss of Feedwater Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior SRO/BOP DETERMINE Vital Auxiliaries criteria satisfied.
SRO/RO VERIFY RCS Inventory Control criteria satisfied:
- VERIFY PZR level between 10% and 70% and TRENDING to between 30% and 60%. [Step 5.a - YES]
- VERIFY Core Exit Saturation Margin 20°F: [Step 5.b - YES]
SRO/RO VERIFY RCS Pressure Control criteria satisfied:
- VERIFY PZR pressure between 1740 PSIA and 2380 PSIA, controlled and TRENDING to between 2025 & 2275 PSIA. [Step 6.a - YES]
SRO/RO VERIFY Core Heat Removal criteria satisfied:
- VERIFY at least one (1) RCP OPERATING. [Step 7.a - YES]
- VERIFY Core Loop T (THOT - TCOLD) < 10°F. [Step 7.b - YES]
- VERIFY Core Exit Saturation Margin 20°F. [Step 7.c - YES]
Examiner Note: RCS Heat Removal is NOT satisfied due to loss of MFW and AFW.
BOP VERIFY RCS Heat Removal criteria satisfied:
- VERIFY both SG narrow range levels > 21%. [Step 8.a - NO]
- VERIFY both SG narrow range levels < 80%. [Step 8.a - YES]
- VERIFY Feedwater available. [Step 8.a - NO]
- [RNO] ENSURE EFAS-1 & EFAS-2 actuated.
- VERIFY TCOLD between 540°F and 550°F. [Step 8.b - YES]
- VERIFY SG pressures between 960 and 1050 PSIA. [Step 8.c - YES]
SRO/BOP DETERMINE RCS Heat Removal criteria NOT satisfied.
SRO/RO VERIFY Containment Isolation criteria satisfied:
- VERIFY Containment pressure < 1.5 PSIG. [Step 9.a - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #4 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 4 Event # 6, 7, & 8 Page 25 of 31 Event
Description:
Two Stuck Control Element Assemblies / Bus 2A07 Auto Transfer Failure / Loss of Feedwater Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- VERIFY Containment Area Radiation Monitors NOT alarming or trending to alarm. [Step 9.b - YES]
- VERIFY Secondary Plant Radiation Monitors NOT alarming or trending to alarm. [Step 9.c - YES]
SRO/RO VERIFY Containment Temperature and Pressure criteria satisfied:
- VERIFY Containment average temperature < 120°F. [Step 10.a - YES]
- VERIFY Containment pressure < 1.5 PSIG. [Step 10.b - YES]
+15 min SRO DIAGNOSE event in progress:
- VERIFY all Safety Function criteria per Attachment 4, Worksheet -
RECOVERED. [Step 11.a - NO]
- [RNO] COMPLETE Attachment 1, Recovery Diagnostics.
- VERIFY Reactor Trip Recovery - DIAGNOSED. [Step 10.b - NO]
RO * [RNO] ENSURE at least one (1) RCP in each loop STOPPED.
- INITIATE steps 12 through 16. [Step 11.c - YES]
Examiner Note: SO23-12-1, Standard Post Trip Actions, Steps 12 to 16, performed by the BOP are located at the end of the scenario. The following steps are from SO23-12-6, Loss of Feedwater.
SRO ENTER SO23-12-6, Loss of Feedwater.
SRO RECORD time of EOI entry __________. [Step 1 - YES]
SRO VERIFY Loss of Feedwater diagnosis:
- INITIATE SO23-12-10, Safety Function Status Checks. [Step 2.a - YES]
- INITIATE Foldout Page. [Step 2.b - YES]
- DIRECT performance of FS-11, Reset P-140 Overspeed Trip.
- ENSURE EFAS-1 and EFAS-2 actuated. [Step 2.c - YES]
- VERIFY Loss of Feedwater diagnosis. [Step 2.d - YES]
[Step 2.d.1) - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #4 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 4 Event # 6, 7, & 8 Page 26 of 31 Event
Description:
Two Stuck Control Element Assemblies / Bus 2A07 Auto Transfer Failure / Loss of Feedwater Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- VERIFY Pressurizer level STABLE or RISING. [Step 2.d.2) - YES]
- VERIFY Pressurizer pressure STABLE or RISING. [Step 2.d.3) - YES]
- VERIFY SG E-088 pressure > 740 PSIA and STABLE or RISING.
[Step 2.d.4) - YES]
- VERIFY SG E-089 pressure > 740 PSIA and STABLE or RISING.
[Step 2.d.5) - YES]
M.O. Cue: One minute after entering SO23-12-6, INFORM the SRO scaffolding was moved in AFW Pump Room and P-140, Turbine Driven Auxiliary Feedwater Pump was inadvertently tripped. The linkage appears to be undamaged.
SRO INITIATE Administrative Actions:
- NOTIFY Shift Manger/Operations Leader of entry into SO23-12-6, Loss of Feedwater. [Step 3.a - YES]
- ENSURE Emergency Plan is initiated. [Step 3.b - YES]
- IMPLEMENT Placekeeper. [Step 3.c - YES]
- IMPLEMENT Time Dependent steps. [Step 3.d - YES]
RO ENSURE all RCPs stopped. [Step 4.a - YES]
BOP CLOSE SG Blowdown and Sample valves. [Step 5.a - YES]
- DEPRESS HV-4054, SG E-088 Blowdown Valve CLOSE pushbutton.
- DEPRESS HV-4058, SG E-088 Sample Valve CLOSE pushbutton.
- DEPRESS HV-4053-2, SG E-089 Blowdown Valve CLOSE pushbutton.
- DEPRESS HV-4057, SG E-089 Sample Valve CLOSE pushbutton.
SRO IDENTIFY available equipment: [Step 6 - YES]
- VERIFY AFW Pump available with overspeed trip NOT RESET and GO BOP to Step 7. [Step 6.a - YES]
BOP ESTABLISH AFW Flow to At Least One Steam Generator:
- VERIFY AFW Pump NOT operating. [Step 7.a - YES]
- VERIFY P-140 NOT tripped on overspeed. [Step 7.b - NO]
- [RNO] INITIATE FS-11, Reset P-140 Overspeed Trip.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #4 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 4 Event # 6, 7, & 8 Page 27 of 31 Event
Description:
Two Stuck Control Element Assemblies / Bus 2A07 Auto Transfer Failure / Loss of Feedwater Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- DETERMINE AFW Pump P-140 available. [Step 7.c - YES]
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-12-11, EOI Supporting Attachments, FS-11, Reset P-140 Overspeed Trip.
BOP VERIFY P-140 tripped on overspeed. [Step a - YES]
DEPRESS HV-4716, P-140 Steam Supply Valve OVERRIDE and CLOSE BOP pushbuttons. [Step b - YES]
M.O. Cue: When directed to reset P-140, DELETE malfunction FW25, then EXECUTE remote function FW52, Reset Overspeed Trip. REPORT overspeed trip on P-140 RESET.
PEO RESET HV-4716 locally. [Step c - YES]
SRO DETERMINE FS-11, Reset P-140 Overspeed Trip, is complete.
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-12-6, Loss of Feedwater.
- VERIFY AFW Pump P-140 Discharge Valves CLOSED. [Step 7.d - NO]
- DEPRESS HV-4705, P-140 Discharge Valve CLOSE pushbutton.
- DEPRESS HV-4706, P-140 Discharge Valve CLOSE pushbutton.
Examiner Note: HV-4705 and HV-4706 will not close if SG level is < 21%. If so, an outside operator will close the manual discharge valve for P-140 (MU122).
M.O. Cue: If required, EXECUTE remote function FW103 for closing P-140 Throttle Valve MU122.
- DEPRESS HV-4716, P-140 AFW Pump OPEN pushbutton. [Step 7.e -
BOP YES]
[Step 7.f - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #4 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 4 Event # 6, 7, & 8 Page 28 of 31 Event
Description:
Two Stuck Control Element Assemblies / Bus 2A07 Auto Transfer Failure / Loss of Feedwater Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- Steam Generator E-088 - either HV-4714 or HV-4730.
- Steam Generator E-089 - either HV-4715 or HV-4731.
- OVERRIDE and OPEN Motor Driven AFW Pump (P-141 / P-504)
BOP Discharge Bypass Valves to 35% open. [Step 7.g - NO]
M.O. Cue: If required, THROTTLE OPEN AFW using remote function FW103, P-140 Throttle Valve MU122. 25% open is approximately equal to 130 GPM per Steam Generator.
Restore Feedwater Flow to At Least One Steam Generator Prior to Reaching CRITICAL TASK 0% Wide Range Level in Both Steam Generators per SO23-12-6, Loss of STATEMENT Feedwater.
CRITICAL * [RNO] THROTTLE P-140 AFW Pump Discharge Valve as TASK BOP necessary to maintain flow between 130 and 150 GPM.
- MAINTAIN reduced AFW flow for 5 minutes. [Step 7.h - YES]
+30 min BOP
- RAISE total AFW flow to greater than 400 GPM. [Step 7.i - YES]
When feedwater is restored to both Steam Generators, or at Lead Evaluators discretion, TERMINATE the scenario.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #4 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 4 Event # 6, 7, & 8 Page 29 of 31 Event
Description:
Two Stuck Control Element Assemblies / Bus 2A07 Auto Transfer Failure / Loss of Feedwater Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Examiner Note: These steps are performed by the BOP per SO23-12-1, Steps 12 through 16.
SRO/BOP INITIATE Attachment 5, Administrative Actions. [Step 12.a - YES]
SRO/BOP ENSURE a PA system announcement for Reactor Trip. [Step 12.b - YES]
BOP ENSURE the following loads restored:
- VERIFY Telecom 480 VAC Feeder Breaker - CLOSED.
[Step 13.a - YES].
- VERIFY Telecom 480 VAC Feeder Breaker - CLOSED.
[Step 13.b - YES].
- VERIFY Non-1E Bus 2A07 - ENERGIZED. [Step 13.c - NO].
- [RNO] TRANSFER Non-1E 4kV Bus 2A07 to Reserve Auxiliary Transformer.
- SELECT 2/3HS-1627A, NON-1E Synchroscope to ON
- DEPRESS SYNC pushbutton for Breaker 2A0703.
- PLACE Breaker 2A0703 Mode Selector in MANUAL.
- DEPRESS Breaker 2A0703 CLOSE pushbutton.
- DETERMINE B15 & B16 480 VAC Load Centers - ENERGIZED
[Step 13.d - YES].
BOP VERIFY Main Turbine Coastdown:
- DETERMINE Extraction Steam Block Valves - CLOSED.
[Step 14.a - YES]
- DETERMINE Main Steam to Reheater Block, Bypass, Warmup, and Control Valves - CLOSED. [Step 14.a - YES]
- DETERMINE HV-2712A/B Bled Steam to Reheaters Block Valve -
CLOSED. [Step 14.a - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #4 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 4 Event # 6, 7, & 8 Page 30 of 31 Event
Description:
Two Stuck Control Element Assemblies / Bus 2A07 Auto Transfer Failure / Loss of Feedwater Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- VERIFY Generator lowering - less than 24 kV. [Step 14.b - YES]
- VERIFY 99A26 - TURBINE LUBE OIL TEMP HI and 99A46 - TURBINE BRG OIL DRAIN TEMP HI Annunciators - RESET. [Step 14.c - YES]
- INITIATE SO23-10-2, Turbine Shutdown, Attachment for Unloading the Generator and Removing the Unit from Line. [Step 14.d - NO]
BOP ESTABLISH desired Condensate and Feedwater Status:
- ENSURE 3rd Point Heater Drain Pumps - STOPPED. [Step 15.a - YES]
- VERIFY Reactor Trip Override - RESET. [Step 15.b - NO]
- [RNO] DETERMINE MFW Pump NOT available to RESET RTO.
- MAINTAIN one MFW Pumps and three (3) Condensate Pumps -
OPERATING. [Step 15.c - NO]
- [RNO] DETERMINE two (2) Condensate Pumps - OPERATING.
- ENSURE FIC-3294, Condensate Pump Miniflow Controller set for Condensate Pump configuration. [Step 15.d - YES]
- Two (2) Pumps - 6000 GPM.
- PLACE LV-3245, Condensate Drawoff Valve to DISABLE.
[Step 15.e - YES]
- VERIFY SO23-12-2, Reactor Trip Recovery, being implemented.
[Step 15.f - NO]
- [RNO] ENSURE HV-4053 & HV-4054, SG Blowdown Valves CLOSED and GO to Step 16.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #4 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 4 Event # 6, 7, & 8 Page 31 of 31 Event
Description:
Two Stuck Control Element Assemblies / Bus 2A07 Auto Transfer Failure / Loss of Feedwater Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior BOP VERIFY Start-Up Range Channels:
- VERIFY both Start-Up Range Channels - OPERABLE. [Step 16.a - YES]
SO23-12-1, Standard Post Trip Actions, Steps 12 through 16 are complete.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #4 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Scenario Outline Form ES-D-1 Facility: SONGS 2 & 3 Scenario No.: 5 Op Test No.: October 2011 NRC Examiners: Operators:
Initial Conditions: 100% power MOL - RCS Boron is 980 ppm (via sample).
Turnover: Maintain steady-state power conditions. Pump the Containment Normal Sump.
Critical Tasks:
- Manually Initiate Reactor Trip Following Reactor Protection System Failure Within One Minute of Entry into SO23-12-1, Standard Post Trip Actions.
- Establish Minimum Safety Injection Flow Prior to Exiting SO23-12-1, Standard Post Trip Actions.
- Establish Stable Reactor Coolant System Temperature per SO23-12-11, EOI Supporting Attachments, FS-30, Establish Stable RCS Temperature during ESDE.
- Identify and Isolate the Most Affected Steam Generator Prior to Exiting SO23-12-11, EOI Supporting Attachments, Attachment 29, Isolation of Steam Generator with ESDE.
Event No. Malf. No. Event Type* Event Description 1 N (RO, SRO) Pump Containment Normal Sump for Return to Service Testing of
+10 min Containment Sump Pump (P-008).
2 SG05F I (BOP, SRO) Steam Generator (E-089) Narrow Range Level (LT-1113-2) Fails
+20 min TS (SRO) Low.
3 RC16B I (RO, SRO) Pressurizer Level Control Channel Y (LT-0110-2) Fails High.
+35 min PZR LP TS (SRO) 1E 480 Volt Pressurizer Heater Bank Overcurrent Trip.
4 NSW LP C (BOP, SRO) Nuclear Service Water Pump (P-139) Overcurrent Trip.
+40 min Nuclear Service Water Pump (P-138) Auto Start Failure.
5 OBE LP Operating Basis Earthquake (OBE) Without Main Feedwater Pump
+41 min Trip.
6 TU08 I (RO) Inadvertent Turbine Trip.
+41 min RP15 Automatic Reactor Trip Failure.
RP24A-D Diverse Scram System / ATWS Trip Failure.
RC19 Failed Fuel Upon Reactor Trip.
7 RC03 M (RO, BOP, SRO) Small Break Loss of Coolant Accident at 300 GPM.
+43 min MS03B Steam Generator (E-089) Steam Line Break Inside Containment.
8 RP01H C (BOP) Component Cooling Water Pump (P-026) Start Failure on SIAS.
+45 min Manual Start Required.
9 EC08DA C (RO) Train A HPSI Pump (P-018) Overcurrent Trip. Train B HPSI Pump
+45 min RP01C (P-019) Start Failure on SIAS. Manual Start Required.
- (N)ormal, (R)eactivity, (I)nstrument, (C)omponent, (M)ajor, (TS)Technical Specifications SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #5 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Scenario Outline Form ES-D-1 Actual Target Quantitative Attributes 9 Total malfunctions (5-8) 4 Malfunctions after EOP entry (1-2) 2 Abnormal events (2-4) 2 Major transients (1-2) 1 EOPs entered/requiring substantive actions (1-2) 1 EOP contingencies requiring substantive actions (0-2) 4 Critical tasks (2-3)
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #5 Rev f.doc
Scenario Event Description NRC Scenario #5 SCENARIO
SUMMARY
NRC #5 The crew will assume the watch at 100% power per Operating Instruction (OI) SO23-5-1.7, Power Operations. Scheduled activities include performance of Return-to-Service testing of Containment Sump Pump P-008 per OI SO23-2-16, Operation of Waste Water Systems.
When the Containment Sump is pumped, a Steam Generator Level Transmitter will fail low. The crew will determine level instrument failure per Annunciator Response Procedures (ARPs), enter Abnormal Operating Instruction (AOI) SO23-13-18, Reactor Protection System Failure, and be required to bypass the failed signal using SO23-3-2.38, Digital Control System Operation. The SRO will refer to Technical Specifications.
When bypassing is complete, the controlling Pressurizer Level Channel will fail high. Actions are per the ARPs and AOI SO23-13-27, Pressurizer Pressure and Level Malfunction. This event is complicated by a Train B 1E Pressurizer Heater overcurrent trip. The SRO will refer to Technical Specifications.
Once Technical Specifications are addressed, the running Nuclear Service Water (NSW) Low Pressure Pump will trip. The standby NSW High Pressure Pump will fail to AUTO start and require manual actions as outlined in the Annunciator Response Procedures.
When NSW flow is restored, an Operating Basis Earthquake will occur which is immediately followed by an inadvertent Turbine trip. The Reactor will fail to trip upon Turbine trip and require manual actions by the crew. A Small Break Loss of Coolant Accident, failed fuel, and an Excess Steam Demand Event (ESDE) inside Containment are initiated when the Reactor is manually tripped.
The crew will enter Emergency Operating Instruction (EOI) SO23-12-1, Standard Post Trip Actions (SPTAs), and then transition to EOI SO23-12-9, Functional Recovery. Recovery actions include entry into EOI SO23-12-11, EOI Supporting Attachments, Attachment 29, Isolation of Steam Generator with ESDE, and FS-30, Establish Stable RCS Temperature during ESDE.
This scenario is complicated by failure of the Train B Component Cooling Water and High Pressure Safety Injection Pumps to automatically start upon a Safety Injection Actuation Signal (SIAS).
Additionally, the Train A High Pressure Safety Injection Pump (P-018, Swing Pump) will overcurrent trip upon SIAS.
The scenario is terminated when Steam Generator E-089 is isolated per SO23-12-11, EOI Supporting Attachments, Attachment 29, Isolation of Steam Generator with ESDE.
Risk Significance:
- Failure of risk important system prior to trip: Loss of Train B 1E Pressurizer Heaters
- Risk significant core damage sequence: Inadvertent Turbine Trip with Reactor Trip Failure Small Break LOCA with ESDE
- Risk significant operator actions: Initiate Manual Reactor Trip Start Train B Component Cooling Water Pump Start Train B High Pressure Safety Injection Pump Isolate Steam Generator E-089 SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #5 Rev f.doc
Scenario Event Description NRC Scenario #5 MACHINE OPERATOR INSTRUCTIONS for SIMULATOR SETUP INITIALIZE to IC-230 NRC Scenario #5 and associated Setup File.
EVENT TYPE MALF # DESCRIPTION DEMAND INITIATING VALUE PARAMETER SETUP MF EC08DA HPSI Pump P-018 overcurrent trip TRIP MF RP01C HPSI Pump P-019 start failure MF RP01H CCW Pump P-026 start failure on SIAS MF RP15 Reactor Trip failure OPEN MF RC19 Failed Fuel 1% RX TRIP MF RC03 Small Break LOCA @ 300 GPM 6% RX TRIP MF MS03B ESDE Inside Containment on E-089 1% RX TRIP 1 - - Pump Containment Normal Sump with P-008 2 MF SG05F SG (E-089) NR Level (LT-1113-2) failure 0%
2 RF RP51 PPS Door Open Annunciator 56B46 ON OPEN By Direction 2 RF RP53G Low SG-1 Level Channel B BYPASS 5 sec TD 2 RF RP53I High SG-1 Level Channel B BYPASS 10 sec TD 2 RF RP53U High SG-1 DP EFAS-1 Channel B BYPASS 15 sec TD 2 RF RP51 PPS Door Open Annunciator 56B46 OFF CLOSE 20 sec TD 2 RF RP68A DEFAS-1 at L-034 BYPASS By Direction 3 MF RC16B PZR Level Channel Y (LT-0110-2) failure 100%
3 LP PZR LP Pressurizer Heater Bank overcurrent trip O/C TRIP 20 sec TD 4 LP NSW LP Nuclear Service Water Pump overcurrent trip TRIP 4 LP NSW LP Nuclear Service Water Pump start failure 5 MF OBE LP Seismic Event without MFW Pump trip 6 MF TU08 Inadvertent Turbine Trip 6 MF RP15 Reactor Trip failure 6 MF RP24A Channel A ATWS / DSS failure SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #5 Rev f.doc
Scenario Event Description NRC Scenario #5 6 MF RP24B Channel B ATWS / DSS failure 6 MF RP24C Channel C ATWS / DSS failure 6 MF RP24D Channel DATWS / DSS failure 6 MF RC19 Failed Fuel 1% RX TRIP 7 MF RC03 Small Break LOCA @ 300 GPM 6% RX TRIP 7 MF MS03B ESDE Inside Containment on E-089 1% RX TRIP 8 MF RP01H CCW Pump P-026 start failure on SIAS 9 MF EC08DA HPSI Pump P-018 overcurrent trip TRIP 9 MF RP01C HPSI Pump P-019 start failure RF ED85 Non-Qualified Loads Restoration RESTORE By Direction SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #5 Rev f.doc
Scenario Event Description NRC Scenario #5 Machine Operator: EXECUTE IC-230 NRC Scenario #5 and SETUP file to align components.
ENSURE CVCS Blend Setpoints MATCH Shift Turnover Sheet.
CHANGE Operator Aid Tag #029 (CVCS) to reflect boron concentration.
VERIFY both Pressurizer Spray Valves in AUTO.
CIRCLE Unit 3 for Emergency Chillers E-335 & E-336 on CR-64.
CIRCLE Unit 3 for Motor Control Center BQ on CR-63.
VERIFY Channel Y Pressurizer Pressure and Level in service.
ENSURE Turbine Ramp Rate set to 100 MWe per minute.
PROVIDE procedures in progress, Shift Turnover, and Reactivity Management Guide to crew in Briefing Room:
- COPY of SO23-5-1.7, Power Operations, Section 6.1, Guidelines for Steady State Operation.
- LAMINATED COPY of SO23-5-1.7, Power Operations, Attachment 8, Power Maneuvering Guidelines PLACE the MOC copy of OPS Physics Summary Book on SRO Desk.
VERIFY CEA positions with ARO.
Control Room Annunciators in Alarm:
NONE SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #5 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 5 Event # 1 Page 7 of 35 Event
Description:
Pump Containment Normal Sump Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Machine Operator: REPORT as Electrical Maintenance standing by at Motor Control Center 2BF-08 for P-008, Containment Sump Pump Return-to-Service testing.
Indications Available:
56A46 - CONTAINMENT SUMP PUMP P008 RUNNING (when P-008 is started)
Examiner Note: The Containment Normal Sump will be pumped approximately 5% to 10% to support Return-to-Service testing of Containment Sump Pump P-008.
DIRECT pumping of Containment Normal Sump per SO23-2-16, Operation SRO of Waste Water Systems, Section 6.20, Pumping the Containment Normal Sump.
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-2-16, Operation of Waste Water Systems, Section 6.20, Pumping the Containment Normal Sump. Steps 6.20.1 and 6.20.2 are N/A.
INITIATE pumping Containment Sump to the Radwaste Sump, as follows:
[Step 6.20.3 - YES]
- OBTAIN Radwaste Operator concurrence to pump to the Radwaste Sump. [Step 6.20.3.1 - YES]
- OPEN HV-5803, Sump Pump Containment Isolation Valve.
[Step 6.20.3.2 - YES]
- OPEN HV-5804, Sump Pump Containment Isolation Valve.
[Step 6.20.3.3 - YES]
- OPEN HV-7911, Nuclear Service Water to Containment.
[Step 6.20.3.4 - YES]
- START Containment Sump Pump P-008. [Step 6.20.3.5 - YES]
- DEPRESS HS-5801B, P-008 START pushbutton.
- VERIFY Annunciator 56A46 - CONTAINMENT SUMP PUMP P008 RUNNING. [Step 6.20.3.6 - YES]
M.O. Cue: REPORT as Electrical Maintenance that P-008 operation is satisfactory and pumping can be secured if desired.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #5 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 5 Event # 1 Page 8 of 35 Event
Description:
Pump Containment Normal Sump Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior When Containment Sump has been lowered 5% to 10%, PERFORM the
+5 min RO following: [Step 6.20.4 - YES]
- STOP Containment Sump Pump P-008. [Step 6.20.4.1 - YES]
- DEPRESS HS-5801B, P-008 STOP pushbutton.
- VERIFY 56A46 - CONTAINMENT SUMP PUMP P008 RUNNING, Annunciator RESET. [Step 6.20.4.2 - YES]
- CLOSE HV-7911, Nuclear Service Water to Containment.
[Step 6.20.4.3 - YES]
- CLOSE HV-5803, Sump Pump Containment Isolation Valve.
[Step 6.20.4.4 - YES]
- CLOSE HV-5804, Sump Pump Containment Isolation Valve.
[Step 6.20.4.5 - YES]
When Containment Normal Sump is lowered 5% to 10%, or at Lead Examiner discretion, PROCEED to Event 2.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #5 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 5 Event # 2 Page 9 of 35 Event
Description:
Steam Generator E-089 Narrow Range Level Transmitter Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Machine Operator: When directed, EXECUTE Event 2.
- SG05F, SG E-089 Level Transmitter LT-1113-2 fails low.
Indications Available:
52A13 - FWCS TROUBLE 56A24 - SG1 E089 LEVEL LO CHANNEL TRIP 56A34 - SG1 E089 LEVEL LO PRETRIP 50A56 - ATWS / DEFAS TROUBLE 56B16 - PPS CHANNEL 2 TROUBLE 2LI-1113-2, SG E089 Narrow Range Level Transmitter indication fails low Examiner Note: Annunciator 50A56 - ATWS / DEFAS TROUBLE is a DEFAS-1 related alarm.
The DEFAS-1 Cabinet is NOT modeled in the Simulator.
M.O. Cue: When bypassing of DEFAS-1 is requested, REPORT the ARO will perform and EXECUTE remote function RP68A, DEFAS-1 L-034 BYPASS.
+30 sec RO/BOP REFER to Annunciator Response Procedures (ARPs).
RECOGNIZE Steam Generator E-089 Level Channel failure and INFORM BOP the SRO SO23-13-18 entry required.
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-13-18, Reactor Protection System Failure.
SRO ENTER SO23-13-18, Reactor Protection System Failure.
OBSERVE instrumentation for the affected channel and alternate redundant RO/BOP indications monitoring the same parameter to DETERMINE failure.
[Step 1.a - YES]
IDENTIFY SG E-089 Level Channel indication LI-1113-2 failure and GO to SRO Step 3. [Step 1.a - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #5 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 5 Event # 2 Page 10 of 35 Event
Description:
Steam Generator E-089 Narrow Range Level Transmitter Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior REFER to Attachment 10 and DETERMINE Functional Unit affected is SRO Steam Generator E-089 Level Transmitter LT-1113-2. [Step 3.a - YES]
DIRECT placing the Functional Unit in BYPASS per SO23-3-2.12, Reactor SRO Protection System Operation. [Step 3.b - YES]
PLACE Functional Unit in BYPASS per SO23-3-2.12, RPS Operation, ARO Section 6.3, Bypass Operation of Trip Channels. [Step 3.b - YES]
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-3-2.12, Reactor Protection System Operation, Section 6.3, Bypass Operation of Trip Channels.
VERIFY that the same bistable is not in BYPASS on any other Channel.
[Step 6.3.1 - YES]
ARO UNLOCK and OPEN the Bistable Control Panel. [Step 6.3.2 - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #5 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 5 Event # 2 Page 11 of 35 Event
Description:
Steam Generator E-089 Narrow Range Level Transmitter Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Examiner Note: Trip BYPASS is performed by the Machine Operator and verified by the RO.
M.O. Cue: When directed, EXECUTE the following remote functions:
RP51 = OPEN (PPS Door Open Annunciator 56B46)
RP53G = BYPASS (Low SG-1 Level Channel B)
RP53I = BYPASS (High SG-1 Level Channel B)
RP53U = BYPASS (High SG-1 P EFAS-1 Channel B)
DELETE RP51 (PPS Door Open Annunciator 56B46)
Examiner Note: Several Step 6.3.2 sub-steps cannot be performed in the Simulator.
OBSERVE Annunciator 56A39 - PPS CHANNEL 2 TRIP BYPASSED in RO alarm and amber BYPASS light on Channel B PPS Operator Module.
[Step 6.3.2.4 - YES]
RO LOG the Bypass and Reason in Control Operator Log. [Step 6.3.2.5 - YES]
SRO INITIATE a LCOAR or follow guidelines of SO123-0-A5. [Step 6.3.2.6 - NO]
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-13-18, Reactor Protection System Failure.
CONFIRM failure does NOT affect RPS/ESFAS Matrix Logic, RPS/ESFAS SRO Initiation Logic, RTCBs, RPS/ESFAS Manual Trip, or ESFAS Actuation Logic. [Step 3.c - YES]
VERFIY failure does NOT affect Feedwater Digital Control System.
SRO/BOP
[Step 3.d - NO]
- [RNO] DIRECT bypass of Steam Generator E-089 Level Transmitter per SO23-3-2.38, Digital Control System Operation.
Floor Cue: If not initiated, DIRECT SRO as Shift Manager to perform SO23-3-2.38 actions.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #5 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 5 Event # 2 Page 12 of 35 Event
Description:
Steam Generator E-089 Narrow Range Level Transmitter Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior SRO EVALUATE Technical Specifications. [Step 3.e - YES]
- LCO 3.3.1.A, Reactor Protection System Instrumentation.
- CONDITION A - One or more Functions with one automatic RPS trip channel inoperable.
- ACTION A.1 - Place Channel in bypass or trip within 1 hour1.157407e-5 days <br />2.777778e-4 hours <br />1.653439e-6 weeks <br />3.805e-7 months <br />, AND,
- ACTION A.2 - Restore channel to OPERABLE status prior to entering MODE 2 following next MODE 5 entry.
- LCO 3.3.5.A, ESFAS Instrumentation.
- CONDITION A - One or more Functions with one automatic ESFAS trip channel inoperable.
- ACTION A.1 - Place Functional Unit in bypass or trip within 1 hour1.157407e-5 days <br />2.777778e-4 hours <br />1.653439e-6 weeks <br />3.805e-7 months <br />, AND,
- ACTION A.2 - Restore channel to OPERABLE status prior to entering MODE 2 following next MODE 5 entry.
CONFIRM failure did NOT involve a failed PPS Power Supply.
[Step 3.f - YES]
NOTIFY Shift Manager to PERFORM Administrative Actions.
[Step 3.g - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #5 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 5 Event # 2 Page 13 of 35 Event
Description:
Steam Generator E-089 Narrow Range Level Transmitter Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-3-2.38, Digital Control System Operation, Section 6.7, Bypassing Selected Feedwater Control Signals.
VERIFY affected instrument can be bypassed in Feedwater DCS.
[Step 6.7.1 - YES]
BOP PLACE Feedwater Control instrument in BYPASS: [Step 6.7.2 - YES]
- CONDUCT a Reactivity Brief. [Step 6.7.2.1 - YES]
- ACCESS Selected Signals screen for SG E-089. [Step 6.7.2.2 - YES]
- VERIFY SG E-089 Channel D signal is valid. [Step 6.7.2.3 - YES]
- SELECT BYPASS for Channel B SG level. [Step 6.7.2.4 - YES]
- VERIFY Channel B indicates BYPASS. [Step 6.7.2.5 - YES]
- VERIFY Channel D NOT in BYPASS. [Step 6.7.2.6 - YES]
- VERIFY Channel D output looks valid. [Step 6.7.2.7 - YES]
+10 min
- ENTER change into NCO Log. [Step 6.7.2.8 - YES]
When Channel is bypassed, or at Lead Examiner discretion, PROCEED to Event 3.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #5 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 5 Event # 3 Page 14 of 35 Event
Description:
Pressurizer Level Control Channel Failure / Train B Pressurizer Heater Bank Trip Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Machine Operator: When directed, EXECUTE Event 3.
- RC16B, PZR Level Controlling Channel Y LT-0110-2 fails high.
- PZR LP, Pressurizer Heater Bank overcurrent trip (20 second time delay).
Indications Available:
50A22 - PZR LEVEL ERROR HI 50A12 - PZR LEVEL ERROR HI-HI 50A27 - PZR HEATERS TRAIN B OVERRIDE / NOT IN AUTO (when Train B 1E PZR Heater trips) 50A34 - PZR BACKUP HEATER OC (when Train B 1E PZR Heater trips) 50A02 - COLSS ALARM (alarm comes in if Heaters are left on and RCS pressure rises)
Letdown flow increasing 2LI-0110A2, Hot Calibrated Pressurizer Level indication failed high Examiner Note: If Pressurizer Heaters are left energized for an extended length of time, Annunciator 50A02 - COLSS ALARM will alarm and require additional actions listed at the end of this event. Specifically, Turbine load must be reduced by 5 MWe to clear the alarm.
+1 min RO REFER to Annunciator Response Procedures (ARPs).
RO OBSERVE minimum Charging flow and maximum Letdown flow.
Examiner Note: RO may use prompt and prudent action to place Channel in MANUAL. The following steps are from Annunciator 50A12 - PZR LEVEL ERROR HI-HI.
DEPRESS A / M pushbutton on LIC-0110, PZR Level Controller, to PLACE RO PZR Level Control in MANUAL. [Step 1.1 - YES]
INITIATE SO23-13-27, Pressurizer Pressure and Level Malfunction.
[Steps 1.1.1 - YES]
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-13-27, Pressurizer Pressure and Level Malfunction.
SRO ENTER SO23-13-27, Pressurizer Pressure and Level Malfunction.
- IDENTIFY uncontrolled level change and GO to Step 2.
[Step 1 - YES ]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #5 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 5 Event # 3 Page 15 of 35 Event
Description:
Pressurizer Level Control Channel Failure / Train B Pressurizer Heater Bank Trip Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior DETERMINE Letdown and Charging are NOT responding as desired and RO PERFORM the following (as applicable): [Step 2 - YES]
- DEPRESS the A / M button on LIC-0110, PZR Level Controller, and PLACE PZR Level Control in MANUAL. [Step 2.a - YES]
- As required, START Charging Pumps to MATCH Letdown flow as closely as possible. [Step 2.b - YES]
- ADJUST LIC-0110, PZR Level Controller, to MATCH Letdown and Charging flows. [Step 2.b.1) - YES]
- SECURE PZR heaters as necessary to control Pressurizer pressure.
[Step 2.c - YES]
- VERIFY normal Charging and Letdown in service. [Step 2.d - YES]
- VERIFY Level Channel indications LI-0110A1, LI-0110A2, and LI-103 reading the same. [Step 2.e - NO]
- [RNO] GO to Step 2.h.
- TRANSFER to the OPERABLE level channel:
- VERIFY Level Channel X (LI-0110X) READING within program band by OBSERVING lumigraph. [Step 2.h.1) - YES]
- POSITION HS-0110, PZR Level Channel Select Switch, to Channel X. [Step 2.h.2) - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #5 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 5 Event # 3 Page 16 of 35 Event
Description:
Pressurizer Level Control Channel Failure / Train B Pressurizer Heater Bank Trip Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- ADJUST LIC-0110 output to MATCH actual level (middle column) with Pressurizer Level Setpoint (left column) to within 2%.
[Step 2.h.3) - YES]
- When level is within 2%, DEPRESS A / M pushbutton to TRANSFER LIC-0110, PZR Level Controller to AUTO. [Step 2.h.4) - YES]
- DEPRESS HS-0100C, PZR LO-LO Level Heater Cutout Channel Selector Level Transmitter X. [Step 2.h.5) - YES]
Examiner Note: Procedure enhancement will be submitted to address 1E and Non-1E Heaters.
- VERIFY Non-1E PZR Heaters have NOT tripped.
[Step 2.h.6) - NO]
- [RNO] RESET all PZR Non-1E Backup and Proportional Heaters.
- [RNO] OPERATE PZR Non-1E Backup and Proportional Heaters per SRO direction.
- OPERATE Charging Pumps as directed by SRO. [Step 2.h.7) - YES]
- VERIFY Pressurizer Level Control System operating in AUTO within band of Attachment 3. [Step 2.h.8) - YES]
- GO to Step 2.k. [Step 2.i - YES]
- ENSURE LIC-0110 in AUTO. [Step 2.k - YES]
Examiner Note: Technical Specification LCO 3.4.1 is entered if RCS pressure rises above 2275 PSIA.
+10 min SRO NOTIFY personnel & EVALUATE Technical Specifications. [Step 2.l - YES]
- LCO 3.4.9.B, Pressurizer.
- CONDITION B - One required group of pressurizer heaters inoperable.
- ACTION B.1 - Restore required group of pressurizer heaters to OPERABLE status within 72 hours8.333333e-4 days <br />0.02 hours <br />1.190476e-4 weeks <br />2.7396e-5 months <br />.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #5 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 5 Event # 3 Page 17 of 35 Event
Description:
Pressurizer Level Control Channel Failure / Train B Pressurizer Heater Bank Trip Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- 3.3.11.A, Post Accident Monitoring Instrumentation (PAMI).
- CONDITION A - One or more functions with one required channel inoperable.
- ACTION A.1 - Restore required channel to OPERABLE status within 30 days.
- LCO 3.4.1.A, RCS DNB (Pressure, Temperature, and Flow) Limits.
- CONDITION A - Pressurizer pressure or RCS flow rate not within limits.
- ACTION A.1 - Restore parameter(s) to within limit within 2 hours2.314815e-5 days <br />5.555556e-4 hours <br />3.306878e-6 weeks <br />7.61e-7 months <br />.
Examiner Note: The following steps are from Annunciator 50A34 - PZR BACKUP HEATER OC.
DISPATCH Operator to Penetration Building to check for SPECIFIC RO CAUSES listed in Section 2.0. [Step 1.1 - YES]
OPERATE Backup Heaters to compensate for PZR Heater loss.
[Step 1.2 - YES]
REFER to SO23-6-9, Section for MCC Feeder Circuit Relay/Guidelines for RO Resetting Tripped Breakers. [Step 1.3 - NO]
RO NOTIFY SRO to review Technical Specification LCO 3.4.9. [Step 3.1 - YES]
Examiner Note: The following steps are from Annunciator 50A02 - COLSS ALARM.
If COLSS ALARM is annunciated, LOWER Turbine load 5 MWe at 10 MWe /
BOP min to maintain power margin. [Step 1.1 - YES]
- As required, DEPRESS HS-2210 Main Turbine Speed / Load Control LOWER pushbutton. [Step 1.1 - YES]
If COLSS inoperability is suspected, REFER to Technical Specifications RO 3.2.1 and 3.2.4 for 15 minute ACTION requirements. [Step 1.2 - NO]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #5 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 5 Event # 3 Page 18 of 35 Event
Description:
Pressurizer Level Control Channel Failure / Train B Pressurizer Heater Bank Trip Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior If loss of TAVE program has occurred, REFER to 50A05 - T AVG HI.
[Step 1.3 - NO]
If at any time the COLSS (Primary and Backup) Computers fail, then initiate RO SO23-3-3.6, COLSS Out of Service Surveillance. [Step 1.4 - NO]
When Technical Specifications have been addressed, or at Lead Evaluators discretion, PROCEED to Event 4.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #5 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 5 Event # 4 Page 19 of 35 Event
Description:
Nuclear Service Water Pump Overcurrent Trip Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Machine Operator: When directed, EXECUTE Event 4.
- NSW LP, Nuclear Service Water LP Pump P-139 overcurrent trip.
Indications Available:
61A32 - NUCLEAR SERVICE WATER PUMP PRESS LO 61A33 - NUCLEAR SERVICE WATER PUMP PRESS LO-LO 61A43 - NUCLEAR SERVICE WATER PUMP OC P-139, Nuclear Service Water Pump double brilliant STOP light on 2/3HS-7903
+30 sec BOP REFER to Annunciator Response Procedures (ARPs).
RECOGNIZE Nuclear Service Water Low Pressure Pump P-139 overcurrent BOP trip and INFORM the SRO ARP SO23-15-61.A2 - 61A43 entry required.
DIRECT performance of SO23-15-61.A2, 61A43 - NUCLEAR SERVICE SRO WATER PUMP OC.
Examiner Note: The following steps are from Annunciator 61A43 - NUCLEAR SERVICE WATER PUMP OC. The Nuclear Service Water Pumps are differentiated as low pressure and high pressure due to impeller sizing characteristics.
BOP START standby Nuclear Service Water Pump. [Step 1.1 - YES]
- DEPRESS HS-7902, P-138, Nuclear Service Water High Pressure Pump START pushbutton.
- OBSERVE PI-7934, NSW System pressure RISING.
DETERMINE P-139 Nuclear Service Water Low Pressure Pump tripped.
+5 min BOP
[Step 2.1 - YES]
- DISPATCH operator to CHECK 2B03-11 breaker. [Step 2.2 - YES]
- PERFORM actions of SO23-6-9, 6.9 KV, for KV, and 480 V Buses and Feeder Faults, Section for MCC Feeder Circuit Fault Relay / Guidelines for Resetting Tripped Breakers and/or Thermals. [Step 2.2 - NO]
When Nuclear Service Water is returned to normal, or at Lead Examiner discretion, PROCEED to Events 5 and 6.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #5 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 5 Event # 5&6 Page 20 of 35 Event
Description:
Earthquake / Inadvertent Turbine Trip / Reactor Trip Failure / Failed Fuel Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Machine Operator: When directed, EXECUTE Events 5 and 6.
- OBE LP, Seismic OBE without Main Feedwater Pump trip.
- TU08, Inadvertent Turbine Trip (~30 second time delay).
- RP15, Reactor Trip failure.
- RP24A/B/C/D, Diverse Scram System / ATWS Trip failure.
- RC19 Failed Fuel upon Reactor trip (1% severity).
Indications Available:
61C21 - SEISMIC RECORDING SYSTEM ACTIVATED 61C22 - OPERATING BASIS EARTHQUAKE DETECTED Numerous Seismic related alarms Numerous tank level alarms due to sloshing The following alarms occur ~30 seconds later:
99A24 - TURBINE TRIP RELAY TRIPPED 56A25 - LOSS OF LOAD CHANNEL TRIP
+10 secs RO/BOP REFER to Annunciator Response Procedures (ARPs).
RECOGNIZE Operating Basis Earthquake and INFORM the SRO SO23-13-3 RO/BOP entry required.
RECOGNIZE inadvertent Turbine Trip and INFORM the SRO Reactor Trip
+30 secs RO required.
Examiner Note: If only one set of Reactor Trip pushbuttons is depressed only four (4) Reactor Trip Circuit Breakers will OPEN. This meets the RNO actions of Standard Post Trip Actions, Step 1.
Manually Initiate Reactor Trip Following Reactor Protection System Failure CRITICAL TASK Within One Minute of Entry into SO23-12-1, Standard Post Trip Actions.
STATEMENT Elapsed Time: __________
CRITICAL TASK RO/BOP MANUALLY TRIP the Reactor.
- DEPRESS Reactor Trip pushbuttons at CR-56 or CR-53.
- DEPRESS HS-9132-2 and HS-9132-3 REACTOR TRIP pushbuttons on CR-56.
- DEPRESS HS-9132-1 and HS-9132-4 REACTOR TRIP pushbuttons on CR-52.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #5 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 5 Event # 5&6 Page 21 of 35 Event
Description:
Earthquake / Inadvertent Turbine Trip / Reactor Trip Failure / Failed Fuel Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
+2 min SRO ENTER SO23-12-1, Standard Post Trip Actions.
When Reactor is manually tripped, or at Lead Evaluators discretion, PROCEED to Events 7, 8, and 9.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #5 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 5 Event # 7, 8, & 9 Page 22 of 35 Event
Description:
Small Break LOCA / ESDE Inside Containment / Train B Component Cooling Water & High Pressure Safety Injection (HPSI) Pumps Start Failure on SIAS / Train A HPSI Pump Overcurrent Trip Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Machine Operator: VERIFY Events 7, 8, and 9 have EXECUTED.
- RC03, Small Break Loss of Coolant Accident @ 300 GPM (6% severity).
- MS03B, SG E-089 Steam Line Break inside Containment (1% severity).
- RP01H, CCW Pump P-026 fails to start on SIAS.
- EC08DA, Train A HPSI Pump P-018 overcurrent trip.
- RP01C, Train B HPSI Pump P-019 fails to start on SIAS.
Indications Available:
Numerous Reactor Trip / LOCA / ESDE related alarms Examiner Note: The SRO may pull forward the actions of FS-30, Establish Stable RCS Temperature during ESDE. These steps are identified later in this scenario.
SRO DIRECT performance of SO23-12-1, Standard Post Trip Actions.
RO VERIFY Reactor Trip:
- VERIFY Reactor Trip Circuit Breakers OPEN. [Step 1.a - YES]
- VERIFY Reactor Power lowering and Startup Rate NEGATIVE.
[Step 1.b - YES]
- VERIFY maximum of one (1) Full Length CEAs NOT fully inserted.
[Step 1.c - YES]
SRO/RO VERIFY Reactivity Control criteria satisfied.
BOP VERIFY Turbine Trip:
[Step 2.a - YES]
- VERIFY both Unit Output Breakers OPEN. [Step 2.b - YES]
SRO INITIATE Administrative Actions:
- INITIATE Attachment 4, Worksheet. [Step 3.a - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #5 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 5 Event # 7, 8, & 9 Page 23 of 35 Event
Description:
Small Break LOCA / ESDE Inside Containment / Train B Component Cooling Water & High Pressure Safety Injection (HPSI) Pumps Start Failure on SIAS / Train A HPSI Pump Overcurrent Trip Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior BOP VERIFY Vital Auxiliaries functioning properly:
- VERIFY both 1E 4 kV Buses 2A04 and 2A06 ENERGIZED.
[Step 4.a - YES]
- VERIFY all 1E 480 V Buses 2B04, 2B24, 2B06, & 2B26 ENERGIZED.
[Step 4.b - YES]
- VERIFY all 1E DC Buses ENERGIZED. [Step 4.c - YES]
- VERIFY all Non-1E 4 kV Buses 2A03, 2A07, 2A08, & 2A09 ENERGIZED.
[Step 4.d - YES]
- VERIFY CCW Train A OPERATING and ALIGNED to Non-Critical Loop and Letdown Heat Exchanger. [Step 4.e - NO]
BOP * [RNO] DETERMINE CIAS actuated, STOP all RCPs, & GO to Step 5.
SRO/BOP DETERMINE Vital Auxiliaries criteria satisfied.
RO VERIFY RCS Inventory Control criteria satisfied:
- VERIFY PZR level between 10% and 70% and TRENDING to between 30% and 60%. [Step 5.a - NO]
- [RNO] ENSURE Pressurizer Level Control System operating in AUTO to restore Pressurizer level.
- VERIFY Core Exit Saturation Margin 20°F: [Step 5.b - YES]
SRO/RO DETERMINE RCS Inventory Control criteria NOT satisfied.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #5 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 5 Event # 7, 8, & 9 Page 24 of 35 Event
Description:
Small Break LOCA / ESDE Inside Containment / Train B Component Cooling Water & High Pressure Safety Injection (HPSI) Pumps Start Failure on SIAS / Train A HPSI Pump Overcurrent Trip Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Examiner Note: Starting either HPSI Pump meets the Critical Task requirements.
CRITICAL TASK Establish Minimum Safety Injection Flow Prior to Exiting SO23-12-1, Standard STATEMENT Post Trip Actions.
DEPRESS HS-9394-2, P-019, Train B HPSI Pump START pushbutton.
CRITICAL TASK RO and/or DEPRESS HS-9392-1, P-017, Train A HPSI Pump START pushbutton.
RO VERIFY RCS Pressure Control criteria satisfied:
- VERIFY PZR pressure between 1740 PSIA and 2380 PSIA, controlled and TRENDING to between 2025 PSIA and 2275 PSIA. [Step 6.a - NO]
- [RNO] DETERMINE PZR Pressure Control System is NOT restoring PZR pressure.
- [RNO] ENSURE Normal and Auxiliary Spray Valves CLOSED.
- [RNO] If Pressurizer pressure < 1740 PSIA, ENSURE SIAS / CCAS / CRIS actuated.
SRO/RO DETERMINE RCS Pressure Control criteria NOT satisfied.
RO VERIFY Core Heat Removal criteria satisfied:
- VERIFY at least one RCP operating. [Step 7.a - NO]
- [RNO] GO to Step 7.c.
- DETERMINE Core Exit Saturation Margin > 20°F. [Step 7.c - YES]
SRO/RO DETERMINE Core Heat Removal criteria NOT satisfied.
BOP VERIFY RCS Heat Removal criteria satisfied:
- VERIFY SG E-088 narrow range level > 21%. [Step 8.a - YES]
- VERIFY SG E-089 narrow range level > 21%. [Step 8.a - NO]
- VERIFY both SG narrow range levels < 80%. [Step 8.a - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #5 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 5 Event # 7, 8, & 9 Page 25 of 35 Event
Description:
Small Break LOCA / ESDE Inside Containment / Train B Component Cooling Water & High Pressure Safety Injection (HPSI) Pumps Start Failure on SIAS / Train A HPSI Pump Overcurrent Trip Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- VERIFY Feedwater available. [Step 8.a - NO]
- [RNO] DETERMINE EFAS-1 & EFAS-2 AUTO initiation.
- VERIFY TCOLD between 540°F and 550°F. [Step 8.b - NO]
- [RNO] ENSURE Feedwater flow NOT excessive.
- [RNO] ENSURE Steam Bypass Control Valves CLOSED.
- [RNO] ENSURE Atmospheric Dump Valves CLOSED.
- [RNO] If MSIS has actuated and cooldown is terminated, STABILIZE RCS temperature for lowest RCS TCOLD.
- VERIFY SG pressures between 960 and 1050 PSIA. [Step 8.c - NO]
SRO/BOP DETERMINE RCS Heat Removal criteria NOT satisfied.
RO VERIFY Containment Isolation criteria satisfied:
- VERIFY Containment pressure < 1.5 PSIG. [Step 9.a - NO]
- [RNO] ENSURE all RCPs STOPPED.
- VERIFY Containment Area Radiation Monitors NOT alarming or trending to alarm. [Step 9.b - NO]
- VERIFY Secondary Plant Radiation Monitors NOT alarming or trending to alarm. [Step 9.c - YES]
SRO/RO DETERMINE Containment Isolation NOT criteria satisfied.
RO VERIFY Containment Temperature and Pressure criteria satisfied:
- VERIFY Containment average temperature < 120°F. [Step 10.a - NO]
- [RNO] ENSURE proper functioning of Normal Containment Cooling.
- [RNO] ENSURE at least one Containment Dome Air Circulator OPERATING.
- VERIFY Containment pressure < 3.4 PSIG. [Step 10.b - NO]
- [RNO] ENSURE SIAS / CIAS / CCAS / CRIS actuated.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #5 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 5 Event # 7, 8, & 9 Page 26 of 35 Event
Description:
Small Break LOCA / ESDE Inside Containment / Train B Component Cooling Water & High Pressure Safety Injection (HPSI) Pumps Start Failure on SIAS / Train A HPSI Pump Overcurrent Trip Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- [RNO] ENSURE all RCPs STOPPED.
- [RNO] ENSURE all available Containment Emergency Cooling Units OPERATING.
- [RNO] DETERMINE Containment pressure > 14 PSIG.
- [RNO] ENSURE CSAS actuated.
- [RNO] ENSURE all available Containment Spray Header flows >
1600 GPM.
SRO/RO DETERMINE Containment Temperature and Pressure criteria NOT satisfied.
SRO DIAGNOSE event in progress:
- VERIFY all Safety Function criteria per Attachment 4, Worksheet -
RECOVERED. [Step 11.a - NO]
- [RNO] COMPLETE Attachment 1, Recovery Diagnostics.
- VERIFY Reactor Trip Recovery - DIAGNOSED. [Step 10.b - NO]
RO * [RNO] DETERMINE all RCPs STOPPED.
- INITIATE steps 12 through 16. [Step 11.c - YES]
Examiner Note: SO23-12-1, Standard Post Trip Actions, Steps 12 to 16, performed by the BOP are located at the end of the scenario. The following steps are from SO23-12-9, Functional Recovery.
SRO ENTER SO23-12-9, Functional Recovery.
SRO RECORD time of EOI entry __________. [Step 1.a - YES]
SRO VERIFY Functional Recovery Diagnosis:
- INITIATE SO23-12-10, Safety Function Status Checks. [Step 2.a - YES]
- INITIATE Foldout Page. [Step 2.b - YES]
- DIRECT performance of FS-7, Verify SI Throttle / Stop Criteria.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #5 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 5 Event # 7, 8, & 9 Page 27 of 35 Event
Description:
Small Break LOCA / ESDE Inside Containment / Train B Component Cooling Water & High Pressure Safety Injection (HPSI) Pumps Start Failure on SIAS / Train A HPSI Pump Overcurrent Trip Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- DIRECT performance of FS-3, Monitor Natural Circulation Established.
- DIRECT performance of SO23-12-11, Attachment 22, Non-Qualified Load Restoration.
[Step 2.c - YES]
M.O. Cue: If directed to sample SGs, WAIT 5 minutes and REPORT that E-088 and E-089 sample lines were frisked, and no elevated activity was detected. If the SG sample valves are closed, REPORT that you are unable to establish sample flow.
SRO INITIATE Administrative Actions:
- NOTIFY Shift Manager/Operations Leader of SO23-12-9 initiation.
[Step 3.a - YES]
- ENSURE Emergency Plan is initiated. [Step 3.b - YES]
- IMPLEMENT Placekeeper. [Step 3.c - YES]
- IMPLEMENT Time Dependent Steps. [Step 3.d - YES]
SRO/RO VERIFY ESF Actuation:
- VERIFY SIAS actuation required. [Step 4.a - YES]
- DETERMINE Pressurizer pressure less than SIAS setpoint.
- DETERMINE Containment pressure greater than 3.4 PSIG.
- DETERMINE Containment Area Radiation Monitors in alarm.
- ENSURE the following actuated: [Step 4.b - YES]
- SIAS / CCAS / CRIS SRO/RO
- RECORD time of SIAS: __________ [Step 4.c - YES]
- VERIFY CIAS actuated. [Step 4.d - YES]
- STOP unloaded Diesel Generators. [Step 4.e - YES]
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 5 Event # 7, 8, & 9 Page 28 of 35 Event
Description:
Small Break LOCA / ESDE Inside Containment / Train B Component Cooling Water & High Pressure Safety Injection (HPSI) Pumps Start Failure on SIAS / Train A HPSI Pump Overcurrent Trip Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior pushbutton.
- INITIATE SO23-12-11, Attachment 22, Non-Qualified Load Restoration.
[Step 4.f - YES]
M.O. Cue: When directed to restore non-qualified loads, WAIT 2 minutes, then EXECUTE remote function ED85, Non-Qualified Loads Restoration. INFORM the Control Room that you have restored Non-Qualified Loads.
- [RNO] DETERMINE all RCPs STOPPED.
RO * [RNO] INITIATE FS-3, Monitor Natural Circulation Established.
RO ESTABLISH Optimum SI Alignment:
- ESTABLISH two train operation: [Step 5.a - YES]
- DETERMINE all Charging Pumps OPERATING.
[Step 5.a.1) - YES]
[Step 5.a.2) - NO]
- [RNO] If not running, DEPRESS HS-9392-1 P-017, Train A HPSI Pump START pushbutton.
- VERIFY all Cold Leg flow paths ALIGNED. [Step 5.a.3) - YES]
1250 PSIA. [Step 5.a.4) - YES]
SRO EVALUATE Immediate Safety Function Recovery Actions:
- VERIFY any Safety Function Recovery Attachments indicated by any optimal EOI. [Step 6.a - NO]
- [RNO] GO to Step c.
- IMPLEMENT precautionary actions: [Step 6.c - YES]
- DETERMINE Emergency Boration of > 40 GPM INITIATED.
[Step 6.c.1) - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #5 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 5 Event # 7, 8, & 9 Page 29 of 35 Event
Description:
Small Break LOCA / ESDE Inside Containment / Train B Component Cooling Water & High Pressure Safety Injection (HPSI) Pumps Start Failure on SIAS / Train A HPSI Pump Overcurrent Trip Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- DETERMINE all RCPs STOPPED. [Step 6.c.2) - YES]
- VERIFY ESDE NOT indicated. [Step 6.d - NO]
- [RNO] INITIATE SO23-12-11, Attachment 29, Isolation of Steam Generator with ESDE.
- [RNO] INITIATE FS-30, Establish Stable RCS Temperature During ESDE.
- VERIFY SGTR NOT indicated. [Step 6.e - YES]
- VERIFY LOFW NOT indicated. [Step 6.f - YES]
Examiner Note: The following steps from SO23-12-11, EOI Supporting Attachments, FS-30, Establish Stable RCS Temperature during ESDE, will be performed when conditions are met.
VERIFY SG least affected by ESDE, SG E-088, NOT isolated for SGTR.
[Step a - YES]
VERIFY most affected SG level E-089 - less than 50% WR.
[Step b - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #5 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 5 Event # 7, 8, & 9 Page 30 of 35 Event
Description:
Small Break LOCA / ESDE Inside Containment / Train B Component Cooling Water & High Pressure Safety Injection (HPSI) Pumps Start Failure on SIAS / Train A HPSI Pump Overcurrent Trip Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior BOP PERFORM the following on least affected SG E-088: [Step c - YES]
- TRANSFER HV-8419, SG E-088 ADV to OVERRIDE then OPEN then AUTO / MODULATE. [Step c.1) - YES]
[Step c.2) - YES]
Examiner Note: During validation, Steam Generator E-089 reached 200 PSIA before wide range level indication was lost.
BOP VERIFY SG dryout on most affected SG E-089: [Step d - YES]
- DETERMINE RCS TCOLD - STABLE or RISING. [Step d.1) - NO]
- DETERMINE SG pressure - 200 PSIA. [Step d.2) - YES]
CRITICAL TASK Establish Stable Reactor Coolant System Temperature per SO23-12-11, E0I STATEMENT Supporting Attachments, FS-30, Establish Stable RCS Temperature during ESDE.
CRITICAL TASK BOP STABILIZE least affected SG E-088 pressure: [Step e - YES]
- VERIFY ADV on SG E-088 in AUTO / MODULATE. [Step e.1) - YES]
VERIFY RCS pressure is to the right of the Appendix E curve on Attachment RO 30, Post-Accident Pressure / Temperature Limits. [Step f - YES]
OPERATE Feedwater on SG E-088 to maintain between 40% and 80% NR.
[Step g - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #5 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 5 Event # 7, 8, & 9 Page 31 of 35 Event
Description:
Small Break LOCA / ESDE Inside Containment / Train B Component Cooling Water & High Pressure Safety Injection (HPSI) Pumps Start Failure on SIAS / Train A HPSI Pump Overcurrent Trip Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-12-11, EOI Supporting Attachments, Attachment 29, Isolation of Steam Generator with ESDE.
SRO IDENTIFY most affected Steam Generator. [Step 1 - YES]
SRO/BOP
- IDENTIFY most affected Steam Generator as E-089. [Step 1.a - YES]
- NOTIFY Shift Manager of most affected Steam Generator E-089.
[Step 1.b - YES]
SRO VERIFY RCS Heat Removal Path: [Step 2 - YES]
- DETERMINE FS-30, Establish Stable RCS Temperature During ESDE SRO/BOP already performed. [Step 2.a - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #5 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 5 Event # 7, 8, & 9 Page 32 of 35 Event
Description:
Small Break LOCA / ESDE Inside Containment / Train B Component Cooling Water & High Pressure Safety Injection (HPSI) Pumps Start Failure on SIAS / Train A HPSI Pump Overcurrent Trip Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
[Step 2.b - YES]
SRO ISOLATE Excess Steam Demand:
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #5 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 5 Event # 7, 8, & 9 Page 33 of 35 Event
Description:
Small Break LOCA / ESDE Inside Containment / Train B Component Cooling Water & High Pressure Safety Injection (HPSI) Pumps Start Failure on SIAS / Train A HPSI Pump Overcurrent Trip Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Identify and Isolate the Most Affected Steam Generator Prior to Exiting CRITICAL TASK SO23-12-11, EOI Supporting Attachments, Attachment 29, Isolation of Steam STATEMENT Generator with ESDE.
CRITICAL TASK BOP
- ISOLATE Steam Generator E-089: [Step 3.a - YES]
- CLOSE / STOP SG E-089 components: [Step 3.a.1) - YES]
- DETERMINE HV-8204, Main Steam Isolation Valve CLOSED.
- DETERMINE HV-8202, Main Steam Isolation Valve Bypass CLOSED.
- DETERMINE HV-8421, Atmospheric Dump Valve CLOSED.
- DETERMINE HV-4052, Main Feed Isolation Valve CLOSED.
- DETERMINE HV-4731, Auxiliary Feedwater Valve CLOSED.
- DETERMINE HV-4715, Auxiliary Feedwater Valve CLOSED.
- DEPRESS OVERRIDE then CLOSE pushbuttons for HV-8200, P-140, Steam to Auxiliary Feedwater Pump.
- DETERMINE HV-4053, SG Blowdown Isolation Valve CLOSED.
- DETERMINE HV-4057, SG Water Sample Isolation SG Water Sample Isolation Valve CLOSED. (May be opened for sampling.)
- DEPRESS OVERRIDE then STOP pushbuttons for HS-4707-1, P-141, Auxiliary Feedwater Pump.
+30 min BOP ENSURE HV-8421, SG E-089 ADV selected to MANUAL. [Step 3.a.2) - YES]
When Steam Generator E-089 is isolated, or at Lead Evaluators discretion, TERMINATE the scenario.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #5 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 5 Event # 7, 8, & 9 Page 34 of 35 Event
Description:
Small Break LOCA / ESDE Inside Containment / Train B Component Cooling Water & High Pressure Safety Injection (HPSI) Pumps Start Failure on SIAS / Train A HPSI Pump Overcurrent Trip Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Examiner Note: These steps are performed by the BOP per SO23-12-1, Steps 12 through 16.
SRO/BOP INITIATE Attachment 5, Administrative Actions. [Step 12.a - YES]
SRO/BOP ENSURE a PA system announcement for Reactor Trip. [Step 12.b - YES]
BOP ENSURE the following loads restored:
- VERIFY Telecom 480 VAC Feeder Breaker - CLOSED on Unit 3.
[Step 13.a - YES].
- VERIFY Telecom 480 VAC Feeder Breaker - CLOSED on Unit 3.
[Step 13.b - YES].
- DETERMINE all Non-1E Buses - ENERGIZED [Step 13.c - YES].
- DETERMINE B15 & B16 480 VAC Load Centers - ENERGIZED
[Step 13.d - YES].
BOP VERIFY Main Turbine Coastdown:
- DETERMINE Extraction Steam Block Valves - CLOSED.
[Step 14.a - YES]
- DETERMINE Main Steam to Reheater Block, Bypass, Warmup, and Control Valves - CLOSED. [Step 14.a - YES]
- DETERMINE HV-2712A/B Bled Steam to Reheaters Block Valve -
CLOSED. [Step 14.a - YES]
- VERIFY Generator lowering - less than 24 kV. [Step 14.b - YES]
- VERIFY 99A26 - TURBINE LUBE OIL TEMP HI and 99A46 - TURBINE BRG OIL DRAIN TEMP HI Annunciators - RESET. [Step 14.c - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #5 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 5 Event # 7, 8, & 9 Page 35 of 35 Event
Description:
Small Break LOCA / ESDE Inside Containment / Train B Component Cooling Water & High Pressure Safety Injection (HPSI) Pumps Start Failure on SIAS / Train A HPSI Pump Overcurrent Trip Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- INITIATE SO23-10-2, Turbine Shutdown, Attachment for Unloading the Generator and Removing the Unit from Line. [Step 14.d - NO]
BOP ESTABLISH desired Condensate and Feedwater Status:
- ENSURE 3rd Point Heater Drain Pumps - STOPPED. [Step 15.a - YES]
- VERIFY Reactor Trip Override - RESET. [Step 15.b - NO]
- [RNO] DETERMINE MFW Pump NOT available to RESET RTO.
- MAINTAIN one MFW Pumps and three (3) Condensate Pumps -
OPERATING. [Step 15.c - NO]
- ENSURE FIC-3294, Condensate Pump Miniflow Controller set for Condensate Pump configuration. [Step 15.d - YES]
- Three (3) Pumps - 9000 GPM.
- PLACE LV-3245, Condensate Drawoff Valve to DISABLE.
[Step 15.e - YES]
- VERIFY SO23-12-2, Reactor Trip Recovery, being implemented.
[Step 15.f - NO]
- [RNO] ENSURE HV-4053 & HV-4054, SG Blowdown Valves CLOSED and GO to Step 16.
BOP VERIFY Start-Up Range Channels:
- VERIFY both Start-Up Range Channels - OPERABLE. [Step 16.a - YES]
SO23-12-1, Standard Post Trip Actions, Steps 12 through 16 are complete.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #5 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Scenario Outline Form ES-D-1 Facility: SONGS 2 & 3 Scenario No.: 6 Op Test No.: October 2011 NRC Examiners: Operators:
Initial Conditions: ~4% power MOL - RCS Boron is 1450 ppm (via sample).
Turnover: Place Auxiliary Feedwater System in Standby and raise Reactor power from 4% to 18%.
Critical Tasks:
- Reduce Reactor Coolant System THOT to less than 530°F Prior to Exiting SO23-12-4, Steam Generator Tube Rupture.
- Manually Actuate Safety Injection and Containment Cooling Actuation Signals Prior to Exiting SO23-12-4, Steam Generator Tube Rupture.
- Isolate the Ruptured Steam Generator Prior to Exiting SO23-12-4, Steam Generator Tube Rupture.
Event No. Malf. No. Event Type* Event Description 1 N (BOP, SRO) Place Auxiliary Feedwater System in Standby.
+10 min 2 R (RO) Raise Reactor Power from 4% to 18% in Preparation for Turbine
3 RC11A I (RO, SRO) Reactor Coolant System Loop 1 THOT (TT-0111X1) Fails High.
+40 min 4 TP02B C (BOP, SRO) Turbine Plant Cooling Water Pump (TPCW) P-120 Trip.
+45 min TP08A TPCW Pump P-119 Auto Start Failure. Manual Start Required.
5 CS05A TS (SRO) Refueling Water Storage Tank Level Transmitter (LT-0305-1) Fails
+50 min Low.
6 SG06B C (RO, SRO) Steam Generator Tube Leak (E-089) at ~10 GPM.
+55 min TS (SRO) 7 SG06B M (RO, BOP, SRO) Steam Generator Tube Rupture (E-089) at ~300 GPM.
+60 min 8 ED06R C (BOP) 1E 480 Volt Buses 2B06 and 2B26 Feeder Breaker Ground
+60 min Overcurrent.
9 SIAS LP I (RO) Safety Injection (SIAS) and Containment Cooling Actuation Signals
+65 min CCAS LP (CCAS) Fail To Automatically Actuate. Manual Actuation Required.
- (N)ormal, (R)eactivity, (I)nstrument, (C)omponent, (M)ajor, (TS)Technical Specifications Actual Target Quantitative Attributes 7 Total malfunctions (5-8) 2 Malfunctions after EOP entry (1-2) 2 Abnormal events (2-4) 1 Major transients (1-2) 1 EOPs entered/requiring substantive actions (1-2) 0 EOP contingencies requiring substantive actions (0-2) 3 Critical tasks (2-3)
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #6 Rev f.doc
Scenario Event Description NRC Scenario #6 SCENARIO
SUMMARY
NRC #6 The crew will assume the watch with Reactor power at 4% per Operating Instruction (OI) SO23-5-1.3.1, Plant Startup from Hot Standby to Minimum Load. The Steam Bypass Control System is in operation controlling Reactor Coolant System temperature.
When Shift Turnover is complete, the Auxiliary Feedwater System will be placed in Standby per OI SO23-2-4, Auxiliary Feedwater System Operation. When the Auxiliary Feedwater Pumps are secured, a power increase to 18% using CEAs and Reactor Coolant System Dilution with entry into MODE 1 will be performed.
When power has been raised 3% to 5%, a Reactor Coolant System (RCS) Loop 1 THOT Channel will fail high. Actions are per Abnormal Operating Instruction (AOI) SO23-13-27, Pressurizer Pressure and Level Malfunction. Actions include transferring to an OPERABLE channel, changing the input to the TAVE program, and restoring Pressurizer level.
When Pressurizer level is restored, the running Turbine Plant Cooling Water (TPCW) Pump will trip. The crew will respond per the Annunciator Response Procedures (ARPs) and start the standby TPCW Pump.
When plant conditions are stable, a Refueling Water Storage Tank Level Transmitter fails low. The crew will reference AOI SO23-13-18, Reactor Protection System Failure, and place the failed unit in BYPASS.
The SRO will refer to Technical Specifications.
The next event is a Steam Generator E-089 Tube Leak. Entry into AOI SO23-13-4, Reactor Coolant Leak, will direct the crew to identify the source and quantity of leakage. The SRO will refer to Technical Specifications and based on leakage indications, will direct a Reactor Trip and entry into Emergency Operating Instruction (EOI) SO23-12-1, Standard Post Trip Actions (SPTAs).
When the Reactor is tripped, a Steam Generator Tube Rupture will occur. The event is complicated with a loss of 1E 480 Volt Buses 2B06 and 2B26 and a failure of the Safety Injection Actuation (SIAS) and Containment Cooling Actuation Signals (CCAS). Both signals must be manually initiated from the Control Room and the Train B Emergency Diesel Generator placed in Maintenance Lockout.
Actions to cooldown and isolate the Steam Generator are performed per EOI SO23-12-4, Steam Generator Tube Rupture. During the cooldown, all Reactor Coolant Pumps must be secured and Natural Circulation verified per EOI SO23-12-11, EOI Supporting Attachments, FS-3, Monitor Natural Circulation Established. The scenario is terminated when Reactor Coolant System THOT is lowered below 530°F, the ruptured Steam Generator is isolated, and Natural Circulation is verified.
Risk Significance:
- Failure of risk important system prior to trip: Steam Generator Tube Leak
- Risk significant core damage sequence: Steam Generator Tube Rupture
- Risk significant operator actions: Loss of 1E 480 Volt Buses 2B06 & 2B26 Manually Actuate SIAS & CCAS Lower RCS THOT below 530°F Isolate Ruptured Steam Generator SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #6 Rev f.doc
Scenario Event Description NRC Scenario #6 MACHINE OPERATOR INSTRUCTIONS for SIMULATOR SETUP INITIALIZE to IC-231 NRC Scenario #6 and associated Setup File.
EVENT TYPE MALF # DESCRIPTION DEMAND INITIATING VALUE PARAMETER SETUP MF SG06B SGTR (E-089) at 300 GPM 1.0% RX TRIP MF ED06R 2B06 & 2B26 Feeder Breaker ground overcurrent 100% RX TRIP 1 - - Place Auxiliary Feedwater System in Standby 2 - - Raise Reactor Power from 4% to 18%
3 MF RC11A RCS Loop 1 THOT (TT-0111X1) fails high 625°F 4 MF TP02B TPCW Pump (TPCW) P-120 overcurrent trip FAULT 4 MF TP08A TPCW Pump P-119 auto start failure 5 MF CS05A RWST Level Transmitter (LT-0305-1) fails low 0%
5 RF RP51 PPS Door Open Annunciator 56B46 OPEN By Direction 5 RF RP52T RWST Level Transmitter LT-0305-1 BYPASS 5 sec TD 5 RF RP51 PPS Door Open Annunciator 56B46 CLOSE 10 sec TD 6 MF SG06B SG Tube Leak (E-089) at ~10 GPM 0.05%
7 MF SG06B SGTR (E-089) at ~300 GPM 1.0%
8 MF ED06R 2B06 & 2B26 Feeder Breaker ground overcurrent 100% RX TRIP 9 MF SIAS LP SIAS fails to AUTO actuate 9 MF CIAS LP CIAS fails to AUTO actuate RF ED85 Non-Qualified Loads Restoration RESTORE By Direction SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #6 Rev f.doc
Scenario Event Description NRC Scenario #6 Machine Operator: EXECUTE IC-231 NRC Scenario #6 and SETUP file to align components.
ENSURE CVCS Blend Setpoints MATCH Shift Turnover Sheet.
CHANGE Operator Aid Tag #029 (CVCS) to reflect boron concentration.
CHANGE Operator Aid Tag #005-9 (AFW T-120/121 alignment) to AUTO MAKEUP for both T-120 and T-121.
VERIFY forcing Pressurizer Spray flow with Backup PZR Heaters ON.
CIRCLE Unit 3 for Emergency Chillers E-335 & E-336 on CR-64.
CIRCLE Unit 3 for Motor Control Center BQ on CR-63.
ENSURE Steam Generator level is controlled at 50% to 55%.
PLACE Steam Generator Level on TREND at the 22 PCS Monitor.
ENSURE HV-3354, Condenser Overboard Valve CLOSED.
ENSURE AFW Cross-Connect Valves indicate CLOSED on Feedwater DCS.
ADJUST Hotwell levels as necessary to minimize nuisance alarms.
PROVIDE procedures in progress, Shift Turnover, and Reactivity Management Guide to crew in Briefing Room:
- MARKED UP copy of SO23-5-1.3.1, Plant Startup from Hot Standby to Minimum Load INITIALED as appropriate through Step 6.7.1.
- MARKED UP copy of SO23-5-1.7, Power Operations, Attachment 9, Power Maintenance and Change Calculation.
- MARKED UP copy of SO23-2-4, Auxiliary Feedwater System Operation, Section 6.3, Stopping Auxiliary Feedwater Pumps, with Steps 6.3.1, 6.3.3.2, and 6.3.4 N/A.
- MARKED UP copy of SO23-3-2.18, Steam Bypass Control System Operation, Section 6.9, Transfer SBCS to Local Auto Setpoint Operation with SBCS Operating.
- LAMINATED COPY of SO23-5-1.7, Power Operations, Attachment 8, Power Maneuvering Guidelines.
ENSURE MOC copy of OPS Physics Summary Book on SRO Desk.
VERIFY CEA positions (Group 6 @103 and PLCEAs @115).
Significant Control Room Annunciators in Alarm:
50A02 - COLSS ALARM 50A07 - SBCS DEMAND PRESENT 56A30/40/50/60 - LOSS OF LOAD CHANNEL 1/2/3/4 TRIP DISABLED 63E10 - SCE CB TRIP 99A24 - TURBINE TRIP RELAY TRIPPED 99B01 - GENERATOR TRIP 99B19 - VACUUM PROTECTION PLC TROUBLE Numerous low power condition alarms SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #6 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 6 Event # 1 Page 5 of 32 Event
Description:
Place Auxiliary Feedwater System in Standby Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Machine Operator: If necessary, REPORT as SM to secure AFW System prior to raising power.
DIRECT performance of SO23-2-4, Auxiliary Feedwater System Operation, SRO Section 6.3, Stopping Auxiliary Feedwater Pumps.
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-2-4, Auxiliary Feedwater System Operation, Section 6.3, Stopping Auxiliary Feedwater Pumps.
PLACE the AFW System in STANDBY per SO23-2-4, Section 6.3, Stopping BOP AFW Pumps. [Step 6.3 - YES]
- SECURE P-140, Turbine Driven AFW Pump. [Step 6.3.1 - N/A]
- ENSURE the following valves are CLOSED: [Step 6.3.2 - YES]
- DETERMINE HV-4713, P-141 to E-089 DISCH Valve CLOSED.
- DETERMINE HV-4706, P-140 to E-089 DISCH Valve CLOSED.
- DETERMINE HV-4712, P-504 to E-088 DISCH Valve CLOSED.
- DETERMINE HV-4705, P-140 to E-088 DISCH Valve CLOSED.
- DETERMINE HV-4762, P-504 to E-088 DISCH Bypass Valve CLOSED.
- DETERMINE HV-4763, P-141 to E-089 DISCH Bypass Valve CLOSED.
- DEPRESS HV-4731, AFW to E-089 Isolation Valve CLOSE pushbutton.
- DETERMINE HV-4715, AFW to E-089 Isolation Valve CLOSED.
- DEPRESS HV-4714, AFW to E-088 Isolation Valve CLOSE pushbutton.
- DETERMINE HV-4730, AFW to E-088 Isolation Valve CLOSED.
- STOP all Auxiliary Feedwater Pumps. [Step 6.3.3 - YES]
- DEPRESS HS-4733-2, P-504 AFW Pump STOP pushbutton.
[Step 6.3.3.1 - YES]
- DEPRESS HS-4707-1, P-141 AFW Pump STOP pushbutton.
[Step 6.3.3.1 - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #6 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 6 Event # 1 Page 6 of 32 Event
Description:
Place Auxiliary Feedwater System in Standby Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- If required, DEPRESS HV-4716, P-140 TDAFW Pump CLOSE pushbutton. [Step 6.3.3.2 - N/A]
- ISOLATE Nitrogen and SECURE Auto Makeup Level Control.
+10 min BOP
[Step 6.3.4 - YES] (handoff to Work ProcessSupervisor)
When Auxiliary Feedwater is secured, or at Lead Evaluators discretion, PROCEED to Event 2.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #6 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 6 Event # 2 Page 7 of 32 Event
Description:
Power Ascension to 18%
Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-5-1.3.1, Plant Startup from Hot Standup to Minimum Load, Section 6.7, Entry into MODE 1.
VERIFY Requisite Steps 6.2, 6.3, 6.5, and 6.6 in SO23-5-1.3.1 completed.
+1 min SRO
[Step 6.7.1 - YES]
SRO/RO CONTINUE power increase and LOG entry into MODE 1. [Step 6.7.1 - YES]
- LOG entry into MODE 1. [Step 6.7.1.1 - YES]
ENSURE the guidelines of Attachment 5 are being followed.
SRO/RO
[Step 6.7.3 - YES]
COMMENCE targeting CPC Pseudo Hot Pin per Shift Turnover.
SRO/RO
[Step 6.7.4 - YES]
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-3-2.19, CEDMCS Operation, Section 6.12, Repetitive or Emergent Manual CEA Positioning.
- POSITION Group Select Switch to Group 6. [Step 6.12.1 - YES]
- If moving a single CEA, POSITION Individual CEA Selection Switch to RO CEA to be moved. [Step 6.12.2 - N/A]
- POSITION Mode Select Switch to MANUAL Group. [Step 6.12.3 - YES]
- VERIFY Group 6 indicator lamps are ILLUMINATED.
[Step 6.12.3.1 - YES]
- When CEA positioning completed, Mode Select Switch to OFF.
[Step 6.12.5 - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #6 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 6 Event # 2 Page 8 of 32 Event
Description:
Power Ascension to 18%
Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-5-1.3.1, Plant Startup from Hot Standup to Minimum Load, Section 6.8, MODE 1 Entry to 20% RX Power.
SRO VERIFY Step 6.7 completed. [Step 6.8.1 - YES]
INCREASE power by Boron Dilution per SO23-3-2.2 and / or CEA withdrawal RO/BOP per SO23-3-2.19 as directed by the SRO. [Step 6.8.2 - YES]
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-3-2.2, Makeup Operations, Section 6.5, Dilution Makeup Mode.
RO Dilution Makeup Mode: [Section 6.5 - YES]
- If required, PERFORM a Reactivity Brief. [Step 6.5.1 - YES]
- DETERMINE Shutdown Bank A is withdrawn. [Step 6.5.2 - YES]
- DETERMINE Boration Saturation of Ion Exchanger NOT in progress.
[Step 6.5.3 - YES]
- DETERMINE all Reactor Coolant Pumps OPERATING. [Step 6.5.4 - YES]
- ADJUST Boronometer setpoints as required. [Step 6.5.5 - NO]
- ENSURE 66.5 GPM on FIC-0210X, Dilution Flow Controller.
[Step 6.5.6 - YES]
- SELECT SET and VERIFY 66.5 GPM. [Step 6.5.6.1 - YES]
- ENSURE FIC-0210X in AUTO. [Step 6.5.6.2 - YES]
- SET FQIS-0210X, Dilution Counter, to 80 GPM. [Step 6.5.7 - YES]
- SELECT MODIFY. [Step 6.5.7.1 - YES]
- ENTER 80 gallons in PRESET. [Step 6.5.7.2 - YES]
- SELECT SET PRESET. [Step 6.5.7.3 - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #6 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 6 Event # 2 Page 9 of 32 Event
Description:
Power Ascension to 18%
Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- SELECT EXIT. [Step 6.5.7.4 - YES]
[Step 6.5.8 - YES]
- VERIFY PW Pump P-200 or P-201 in AUTO. [Step 6.5.9 - YES]
- COMMENCE monitoring plant parameters. [Step 6.5.10 - YES]
- If required to lower VCT level, DIVERT to Radwaste.
[Step 6.5.11 - AS REQD]
[Step 6.5.12 - AS REQD]
- SELECT HS-0210, Makeup Mode Selector, to DILUTE:
[Step 6.5.13 - YES]
- SELECT MODIFY. [Step 6.5.13.1 - YES]
- SELECT DILUTE. [Step 6.5.13.2 - YES]
- SELECT GO. [Step 6.5.13.3 - YES]
- CONFIRM Dilution stops when desired volume added: [Step 6.5.14 - YES]
- CONFIRM Dilution stops automatically. [Step 6.5.14.1 - YES]
- SELECT CANCEL. [Step 6.5.14.2 - YES]
- SELECT AUTO. [Step 6.5.14.3 - YES]
- SELECT EXIT. [Step 6.5.14.4 - YES]
+20 min
- PERFORM the following when Dilution completed: [Step 6.5.15 - YES]
[Step 6.5.15.1 - YES]
[Step 6.5.15.2 - YES]
- ENSURE HV-9209, VCT Vent Valve CLOSED. [Step 6.5.15.3 - YES]
- DETERMINE Blend Setpoint NOT changed.
[Step 6.5.16 - YES]
When power is raised 3% to 5%, or at Lead Evaluators discretion, PROCEED to Event 3.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #6 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 6 Event # 3 Page 10 of 32 Event
Description:
Reactor Coolant System Loop 1 THOT Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Machine Operator: When directed, EXECUTE Event 3:
- RC11A, Loop 1 narrow range THOT TT-0111X1 fails to 625°F.
Indications Available:
50A02 - COLSS ALARM 50A05 - TAVG HI 50A15 - HOT LEG LOOP 1 TEMP HI Letdown lowers to minimum RCS Loop 1 narrow range THOT TI-0111AX indication pegged high Examiner Note: If Pressurizer Heaters are left energized for an extended length of time, Annunciator 50A02 - COLSS ALARM will continue to alarm and require additional actions listed at the end of this event. Specifically, Turbine load must be reduced by 5 MWe to clear the alarm.
+30 sec RO REFER to Annunciator Response Procedures (ARPs).
RO OBSERVE maximum Charging flow and minimum Letdown flow.
RECOGNIZE THOT failure and INFORM the SRO AOI SO23-13-27 entry RO required.
Examiner Note: RO may use prompt and prudent action to place Channel Y in MANUAL and secure two (2) Charging Pumps. The following steps are from Annunciator 50A15 - HOT LEG LOOP 1 TEMP HI.
DETERMINE Charging and Letdown Systems NOT responding as desired.
[Step 1.1 - YES]
DEPRESS A / M pushbutton on LIC-0110, PZR Level Controller, to PLACE RO PZR Level Control in MANUAL. [Step 1.1.1 - YES]
INITIATE SO23-13-27, Pressurizer Pressure and Level Malfunction.
[Steps 1.1.2 - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #6 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 6 Event # 3 Page 11 of 32 Event
Description:
Reactor Coolant System Loop 1 THOT Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-13-27, Pressurizer Pressure and Level Malfunction.
SRO ENTER SO23-13-27, Pressurizer Pressure and Level Malfunction.
- IDENTIFY uncontrolled level change and GO to Step 2.
[Step 1 - YES ]
DETERMINE Letdown and Charging are NOT responding as desired and RO PERFORM the following (as applicable): [Step 2 - YES]
- DEPRESS the A / M button on LIC-0110, PZR Level Controller, and PLACE PZR Level Control in MANUAL. [Step 2.a - YES]
- STOP Charging Pumps to MATCH Letdown flow as closely as possible.
[Step 2.b - YES]
- ADJUST LIC-0110, PZR Level Controller, to MATCH Letdown and Charging flows. [Step 2.b.1) - YES]
- SECURE PZR heaters as necessary to control Pressurizer pressure.
[Step 2.c - YES]
- VERIFY normal Charging and Letdown in service. [Step 2.d - YES]
- DETERMINE Level Channel indications LI-0110A1, LI-0110A2, and RO LI-103 reading the same. [Step 2.e - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #6 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 6 Event # 3 Page 12 of 32 Event
Description:
Reactor Coolant System Loop 1 THOT Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- VERIFY Pressurizer level is NOT lowering due to a valid RCS leak.
SRO/RO
[Step 2.f - YES]
- GO to Step 2.j. [Step 2.g - YES]
- DIRECT transfer of Pressurizer Level Remote Setpoint. [Step 2.j - YES]
- ENSURE Controller alarms ACKNOWLEDGED. [Step 2.j.1) - YES]
- SELECT (TAG) to Page 2 on LIC-0110 controller and OBSERVE RO IN1 displayed. [Step 2.j.2) - YES]
- NOTE displayed PZR level. [Step 2.j.2).a - YES]
- DEPRESS SEL pushbutton to display IN2. [Step 2.j.3) - YES]
- NOTE displayed PZR level. [Step 2.j.3).a - YES]
- DETERMINE IN2 will be selected to control PZR level.
[Step 2.j.4) - YES]
- DISPLAY PZR level Remote Setpoint currently selected and RO DEPRESS SEL until Selected Indicating Light is extinguished. [Step 2.j.5) - YES]
- SELECT new Remote Setpoint. [Step 2.j.6) - YES]
- To select IN1, DEPRESS the LOWER () pushbutton once.
[Step 2.j.6).a - NO]
- To select IN2, DEPRESS the RAISE () pushbutton once.
[Step 2.j.6).b - YES]
- SELECT (TAG) to Page 1 on controller. [Step 2.j.7) - YES]
- Manually ADJUST output (right column) until actual level (middle RO column) is matched with generated setpoint (left column).
[Step 2.j.8) - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #6 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 6 Event # 3 Page 13 of 32 Event
Description:
Reactor Coolant System Loop 1 THOT Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- When within 2%, DEPRESS A / M pushbutton to transfer LIC-0110 RO to AUTO. [Step 2.j.9) - YES]
- OBSERVE Letdown flow and pressure to ensure no unusual RO oscillations. [Step 2.j.10) - YES]
- RESTORE PZR Heaters as required to control RCS pressure.
[Step 2.j.11) - YES]
- OPERATE Charging Pumps as directed by SRO. [Step 2.j.12) - YES]
- TRANSFER HS-8430, SBCS Quick Open Block Tavg Selector BOP Switch to the non-affected loop. [Step 2.j.13) - N/A]
- ENSURE LIC-0110, Pressurizer Level Controller in AUTO.
[Step 2.j.13) - N/A]
+10 min SRO
- NOTIFY Shift Manager of event. [Step 2.j.14) - N/A]
When PZR level control is normal, or at Lead Examiner discretion, PROCEED to Event 4.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #6 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 6 Event # 4 Page 14 of 32 Event
Description:
Turbine Plant Cooling Water Pump Overcurrent Trip and Auto Start Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Machine Operator: When directed, EXECUTE Event 4.
- TP02B, TPCW Pump P-120 overcurrent trip.
- TP08A, TPCW Pump P-119 auto start failure.
Indications Available:
99A31 - TPCW PUMP OC 99A41 - ISO PHASE BUS HX FLOW LO 99A51 - TPCW PUMP OOS / NOT IN AUTO 99A12 - TPCW PRESS LO-LO 99A17 - TPCW SURGE TANK OUTLET VALVE CLOSED TPCW P120 will trip and P119 remains in standby
+10 sec BOP REFER to Annunciator Response Procedures (ARPs).
REPORT P-120, TPCW Pump has tripped and DETERMINES P-119, TPCW BOP Pump has NOT AUTO started.
Examiner Note: BOP may use prompt and prudent action to start the standby Turbine Plant Cooling Water Pump.
Examiner Note: The following steps are from Annunciator 99A31 - TPCW PUMP OC.
BOP ENSURE Standby TPCW Pump has AUTO started. [Step 1.1 - NO]
- DEPRESS HS-6940, P-119 TPCW Pump START pushbutton.
SRO CONTACT Maintenance to determine cause of failure.
+5 min SRO DISPATCH PEO to check TPCW Pump and Breaker.
M.O. Cue: If sent to check TPCW Pump P-120 and breaker, REPORT that there is an overcurrent flag at the breaker, and the pump appears normal. If sent to check P-119, REPORT that there is no apparent problem at the pump or breaker.
When TPCW is restored, or at Lead Examiner discretion, PROCEED to Event 5.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #6 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 6 Event # 5 Page 15 of 32 Event
Description:
Refueling Water Storage Tank Level Transmitter Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Machine Operator: When directed, EXECUTE Event 5.
- CS05A, RWST Level Indication LT-0305-1 fails low.
Indications Available:
56A27 - RWST LEVEL LO ESFAS CHANNEL TRIP 56A37 - RWST LEVEL LO PRETRIP 56B06 - PPS CHANNEL 1 TROUBLE 2LI-0305-1, RWT 2T006 LEVEL indication failed low
+1 min RO REFER to Annunciator Response Procedures (ARPs).
RECOGNIZE Refueling Water Storage Tank Level Channel failure and RO INFORM the SRO SO23-13-18 entry required.
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-13-18, Reactor Protection System Failure.
SRO ENTER SO23-13-18, Reactor Protection System Failure.
OBSERVE instrumentation for the affected channel and alternate redundant RO indications monitoring the same parameter to DETERMINE failure.
[Step 1.a - YES]
IDENTIFY RWST Level Channel indication LI-0305-1 failure and GO to SRO Step 3. [Step 1.a - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #6 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 6 Event # 5 Page 16 of 32 Event
Description:
Refueling Water Storage Tank Level Transmitter Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior REFER to Attachment 10 and DETERMINE Functional Unit affected is SRO RWST Level Transmitter LT-0305-1. [Step 3.a - YES]
DIRECT placing the Functional Unit in BYPASS per SO23-3-2.12, Reactor SRO Protection System Operation. [Step 3.b - YES]
PLACE Functional Unit in BYPASS per SO23-3-2.12, RPS Operation, ARO Section 6.3, Bypass Operation of Trip Channels. [Step 3.b - YES]
Examiner Note: If desired, the Steam Generator Tube Leak (Event 6) can be started at this time.
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-3-2.12, Reactor Protection System Operation, Section 6.3, Bypass Operation of Trip Channels.
VERIFY that the same bistable is not in BYPASS on any other Channel.
[Step 6.3.1 - YES]
ARO UNLOCK and OPEN the Bistable Control Panel. [Step 6.3.2 - YES]
Examiner Note: Trip BYPASS is performed by the Machine Operator and verified by the RO.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #6 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 6 Event # 5 Page 17 of 32 Event
Description:
Refueling Water Storage Tank Level Transmitter Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior M.O. Cue: When directed, EXECUTE the following remote functions:
RP51 = OPEN (PPS Door Open Annunciator 56B46)
RP52T = BYPASS (Low RWST Level Channel A)
DELETE RP51 (PPS Door Open Annunciator 56B46)
OBSERVE Annunciator 56A29 - PPS CHANNEL 1 TRIP BYPASSED in RO alarm and amber BYPASS light on Channel A PPS Operator Module.
[Step 6.3.2.4 - YES]
RO LOG the Bypass and Reason in Control Operator Log. [Step 6.3.2.5 - YES]
SRO INITIATE a LCOAR or follow guidelines of SO123-0-A5. [Step 6.3.2.6 - NO]
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-13-18, Reactor Protection System Failure.
CONFIRM failure does NOT affect RPS/ESFAS Matrix Logic, RPS/ESFAS SRO Initiation Logic, RTCBs, RPS/ESFAS Manual Trip, or ESFAS Actuation Logic. [Step 3.c - YES]
CONFIRM failure does NOT affect Feedwater Digital Control System.
[Step 3.d - YES]
SRO EVALUATE Technical Specifications. [Step 3.e - YES]
- LCO 3.3.5.B, Engineered Safety Features Actuation System Instrumentation.
- CONDITION B - One automatic trip channel inoperable for RWST Level-Low for the RAS function.
- ACTION B.1 - Place Functional Unit in bypass within 1 hour1.157407e-5 days <br />2.777778e-4 hours <br />1.653439e-6 weeks <br />3.805e-7 months <br />, AND,
- ACTION B.2 - Restore channel to OPERABLE status prior to entering MODE 2 following next MODE 5 entry.
CONFIRM failure did NOT involve a failed PPS Power Supply.
[Step 3.f - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #6 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 6 Event # 5 Page 18 of 32 Event
Description:
Refueling Water Storage Tank Level Transmitter Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior NOTIFY Shift Manager to PERFORM Administrative Actions.
+10 min SRO
[Step 3.g - YES]
When Technical Specifications have been evaluated, or at Lead Evaluators discretion, PROCEED to Event 6.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #6 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 6 Event # 6 Page 19 of 32 Event
Description:
Steam Generator E-089 Tube Leak Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Machine Operator: When directed, EXECUTE Event 6.
- SG06B @ 0.05%, SG E-089 Tube Leak at ~10 GPM.
Indications Available:
60A46 - SECONDARY RADIATION HI
+2 to 3 min RO/BOP REFER to Annunciator Response Procedures (ARPs).
RECOGNIZE increasing Secondary Radiation levels and INFORM the SRO BOP SO23-13-14 entry required.
ENTER SO23-13-14, Reactor Coolant System Leak, Step 4, Primary to SRO Secondary leakage.
Examiner Note: The following steps are from SO23-13-14, Reactor Coolant System Leak.
EVALUATE plant conditions against the following to Identify leak location and SRO/RO Procedural Steps to perform: [Step 1 - YES]
- DETERMINE Annunciator 60A46 - SECONDARY RADIATION HI in alarm and GO to Step 4. [Step 1 - YES]
RO VERIFY PZR level NOT lowering. [Step 4.a - NO]
- [RNO] ENSURE all available Charging Pumps in AUTO.
VERIFY PZR level NOT lowering with all available Charging Pumps RO OPERATING. [Step 4.b - YES]
RO VERIFY PZR level STABLE. [Step 4.c - YES]
RO VERIFY VCT level is maintained within program band. [Step 4.d - YES]
M.O. Cue: If directed to sample SGs, WAIT 3 minutes and then REPORT that SG sample lines were frisked and E-089 has elevated radiation levels with E-088 at background.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #6 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 6 Event # 6 Page 20 of 32 Event
Description:
Steam Generator E-089 Tube Leak Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior VERIFY Steam Generator tube leak is greater than 150 GPD and increasing SRO/RO at greater than 30 GPD/hr. [Step 4.e - YES]
Examiner Note: As the SRO follows the guidance of SO23-13-14 for a Steam Generator Tube Leak, they never reach the point where a Technical Specification call is made.
LCO 3.4.13.B is listed here for reference following scenario completion.
SRO EVALUATE Technical Specifications.
- CONDITION B - Primary to secondary LEAKAGE not within limit.
- ACTION B.1 - Be in MODE 3 within six (6) hours, AND
- ACTION B.2 - Be in MODE 5 within 36 hours4.166667e-4 days <br />0.01 hours <br />5.952381e-5 weeks <br />1.3698e-5 months <br />.
SRO PERFORM the following: [Step 4.f - YES]
- DETERMINE Reactor power less than 35%. [Step 4.f.1 - YES]
- DIRECT a Reactor Trip and ENTRY into SO23-12-1, Standard Post Trip Actions. [Step 4.f.1.a - YES]
+5 min RO/BOP Manually TRIP Reactor.
- DEPRESS HS-9132-2 and HS-9132-3 REACTOR TRIP pushbuttons on CR-56.
and/or
- DEPRESS HS-9132-1 and HS-9132-4 REACTOR TRIP pushbuttons on CR-52.
When the Reactor is tripped, or at Lead Examiner discretion, PROCEED to Events 7, 8, and 9.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #6 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 6 Event # 7, 8, & 9 Page 21 of 32 Event
Description:
Steam Generator E-089 Tube Rupture / Loss of 480 V Bus / Safety Injection and Containment Cooling Actuation Signals Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Machine Operator: When directed, EXECUTE Events 7, 8, and 9.
- SG06B, Steam Generator Tube Rupture (E-089) at 300 GPM.
- ED06R, 480 Volt Buses 2B06 & 2B26 feeder breaker ground overcurrent.
- SIAS / CCAS LP, SIAS and CCAS Actuation Signals fail to auto actuate.
Indications Available:
Numerous Reactor Trip related alarms SRO DIRECT performance of SO23-12-1, Standard Post Trip Actions.
RO VERIFY Reactor Trip:
- VERIFY Reactor Trip Circuit Breakers OPEN. [Step 1.a - YES]
- VERIFY Reactor Power lowering and Startup Rate NEGATIVE.
[Step 1.b - YES]
- VERIFY maximum of one (1) Full Length CEAs NOT fully inserted.
[Step 1.c - YES]
SRO/RO VERIFY Reactivity Control criteria satisfied.
BOP VERIFY Turbine Trip:
- VERIFY both Unit Output Breakers OPEN. [Step 2.b - YES]
SRO INITIATE Administrative Actions:
- INITIATE Attachment 4, Worksheet. [Step 3.a - YES]
BOP VERIFY Vital Auxiliaries functioning properly:
- VERIFY both 1E 4 kV Buses 2A04 and 2A06 ENERGIZED.
[Step 4.a - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #6 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 6 Event # 7, 8, & 9 Page 22 of 32 Event
Description:
Steam Generator E-089 Tube Rupture / Loss of 480 V Bus / Safety Injection and Containment Cooling Actuation Signals Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- VERIFY 1E 480 V Buses 2B04 & 2B24 ENERGIZED. [Step 4.b - YES]
- VERIFY 1E 480 V Buses 2B06, & 2B26 ENERGIZED. [Step 4.b - NO]
- [RNO] If Train B Bus B26 DEENERGIZED, PLACE Train B EDG in Maintenance Lockout.
- INSERT key and TURN HS-1770-2 to MAINT position.
- INITIATE Attachment 2, Diesel Generator Follow-Up Actions.
- VERIFY all 1E DC Buses ENERGIZED. [Step 4.c - YES]
- VERIFY all Non-1E 4 kV Buses 2A03, 2A07, 2A08, & 2A09 ENERGIZED.
[Step 4.d - YES]
- VERIFY CCW Train A OPERATING and ALIGNED to Non-Critical Loop and Letdown Heat Exchanger. [Step 4.e - YES]
SRO/BOP DETERMINE Vital Auxiliaries criteria satisfied.
RO VERIFY RCS Inventory Control criteria satisfied:
- VERIFY PZR level between 10% and 70% and TRENDING to between 30% and 60%. [Step 5.a - NO]
- [RNO] ENSURE Pressurizer Level Control System operating in AUTO to restore Pressurizer level.
- VERIFY Core Exit Saturation Margin 20°F: [Step 5.b - YES]
SRO/RO DETERMINE RCS Inventory Control criteria NOT satisfied.
RO VERIFY RCS Pressure Control criteria satisfied:
- VERIFY PZR pressure between 1740 PSIA and 2380 PSIA, controlled and TRENDING to between 2025 PSIA and 2275 PSIA. [Step 6.a - NO]
- [RNO] DETERMINE PZR Pressure Control System is NOT restoring PZR pressure.
- [RNO] ENSURE Normal and Auxiliary Spray Valves CLOSED.
- [RNO] If Pressurizer pressure < 1740 PSIA, ENSURE SIAS / CCAS / CRIS actuated.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #6 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 6 Event # 7, 8, & 9 Page 23 of 32 Event
Description:
Steam Generator E-089 Tube Rupture / Loss of 480 V Bus / Safety Injection and Containment Cooling Actuation Signals Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior SRO/RO DETERMINE RCS Pressure Control criteria NOT satisfied.
SRO/RO VERIFY Core Heat Removal criteria satisfied:
- VERIFY at least one (1) RCP OPERATING. [Step 7.a - YES]
- VERIFY Core Loop T (THOT - TCOLD) < 10°F. [Step 7.b - YES]
- VERIFY Core Exit Saturation Margin 20°F. [Step 7.c - YES]
SRO/BOP VERIFY RCS Heat Removal criteria satisfied:
- VERIFY both SG narrow range levels > 21%. [Step 8.a - YES]
- VERIFY both SG narrow range levels < 80%. [Step 8.a - YES]
- VERIFY Main or Auxiliary Feedwater AVAILABLE. [Step 8.a - YES]
- VERIFY TCOLD between 540°F and 550°F. [Step 8.b - YES]
- VERIFY SG pressures between 960 and 1050 PSIA. [Step 8.c - YES]
RO VERIFY Containment Isolation criteria satisfied:
- VERIFY Containment pressure < 1.5 PSIG. [Step 9.a - YES]
- VERIFY Containment Area Radiation Monitors NOT alarming or trending to alarm. [Step 9.b - YES]
- VERIFY Secondary Plant Radiation Monitors NOT alarming or trending to alarm. [Step 9.c - NO]
SRO/RO DETERMINE Containment Isolation criteria NOT satisfied:
SRO/RO VERIFY Containment Temperature and Pressure criteria satisfied:
- VERIFY Containment average temperature < 120°F. [Step 10.a - YES]
- VERIFY Containment pressure < 1.5 PSIG. [Step 10.b - YES]
SRO DIAGNOSE event in progress:
- VERIFY all Safety Function criteria per Attachment 4, Worksheet -
RECOVERED. [Step 11.a - NO]
- [RNO] COMPLETE Attachment 1, Recovery Diagnostics.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #6 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 6 Event # 7, 8, & 9 Page 24 of 32 Event
Description:
Steam Generator E-089 Tube Rupture / Loss of 480 V Bus / Safety Injection and Containment Cooling Actuation Signals Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- VERIFY Reactor Trip Recovery - DIAGNOSED. [Step 10.b - NO]
RO * [RNO] ENSURE at least one (1) RCP in each loop STOPPED.
- INITIATE steps 12 through 16. [Step 10.c - YES]
- IMPLEMENT EOI SO23-12-4, Steam Generator Tube Rupture.
[Step 10.d - YES]
Examiner Note: SO23-12-1, Standard Post Trip Actions, Steps 12 to 16, performed by the BOP are located at the end of the scenario. The following steps are from SO23-12-4, Steam Generator Tube Rupture.
SRO ENTER SO23-12-4, Steam Generator Tube Rupture.
SRO RECORD time of EOI entry __________. [Step 1.a - YES]
- INITIATE SO23-12-10, Safety Function Status Checks. [Step 2.a - YES]
- INITIATE Foldout Page. [Step 2.b - YES]
- DIRECT performance of FS-7, Verify SI Throttle/Stop Criteria.
- DIRECT performance of SO23-12-11, Attachment 22, Non-Qualified Load Restoration.
- DIRECT performance of FS-3, Monitor Natural Circulation Established.
- VERIFY SGTR diagnosis using Figure 1, Break Identification Chart.
[Step 2.c - YES]
- INITIATE sampling of both Steam Generators for radioactivity and boron.
[Step 2.d - YES]
M.O. Cue: If directed to sample SGs, WAIT 3 minutes and then REPORT that E-089 has elevated radiation levels based on frisk of sample lines.
SRO INITIATE Administrative Actions:
- NOTIFY Shift Manager/Operations Leader of SO23-12-4, Steam Generator Tube Rupture initiation. [Step 3.a - YES]
- ENSURE Emergency Plan is initiated. [Step 3.b - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #6 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 6 Event # 7, 8, & 9 Page 25 of 32 Event
Description:
Steam Generator E-089 Tube Rupture / Loss of 480 V Bus / Safety Injection and Containment Cooling Actuation Signals Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- IMPLEMENT Placekeeper. [Step 3.c - YES]
- IMPLEMENT Time Dependent Steps. [Step 3.d - YES]
CRITICAL TASK Reduce Reactor Coolant System THOT to less than 530°F Prior to Exiting STATEMENT SO23-12-4, Steam Generator Tube Rupture.
CRITICAL TASK SRO DIRECT lowering RCS THOT to less than 530°F:
BOP/RO
- ENSURE one RCP in each loop - STOPPED. [Step 4.a - YES]
- INITIATE lowering THOT to less than 530°F using SBCS. [Step 4.b - YES]
- DEPRESS HV-8423 Permissive MANUAL pushbutton.
- PLACE HV-8423 Controller in LOCAL and OPEN valve 35%.
- DEPRESS HV-8425 Permissive MANUAL pushbutton.
- PLACE HV-8425 Controller in LOCAL and OPEN valve 35%.
- As required, RESET SG Low Pressure setpoints during cooldown.
RO/BOP
[Step 4.c - YES]
- DEPRESS SG Low Pressure Setpoint RESET pushbutton on Reactor Protection System ROMs for Channels A, B, C, and D.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #6 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 6 Event # 7, 8, & 9 Page 26 of 32 Event
Description:
Steam Generator E-089 Tube Rupture / Loss of 480 V Bus / Safety Injection and Containment Cooling Actuation Signals Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Examiner Note: During validation, the following was observed:
- SIAS did not occur until the cooldown was in progress.
Examiner Note: When SIAS has actuated, the following steps are performed.
- VERIFY SIAS actuation required. [Step 5.a - YES]
- DETERMINE PZR pressure less than SIAS setpoint.
[Step 5.a.1) - YES]
- ENSURE SIAS / CCAS / CRIS actuated: [Step 5.b - NO]
CRITICAL TASK Manually Actuate Safety Injection and Containment Cooling Actuation Signals STATEMENT Prior to Exiting SO23-12-4, Steam Generator Tube Rupture.
CRITICAL TASK RO/BOP
- DETERMINE SIAS and CCAS NOT actuated.
- DEPRESS HS-9135-3 and HS-9135-4 SIAS MANUAL INITIATION pushbuttons on CR-53, and/or
- DEPRESS HS-9135-1 and HS-9135-2 SIAS MANUAL INITIATION pushbuttons on CR-56.
- DEPRESS HS-9138-3 and HS-9138-4 CCAS MANUAL INITIATION pushbuttons on CR-53, and/or
- DEPRESS HS-9138-1 and HS-9138-2 CCAS MANUAL INITIATION pushbuttons on CR-56.
- RECORD time of SIAS: __________ [Step 5.c - YES]
- STOP unloaded Diesel Generators. [Step 5.d - YES]
- DETERMINE Train B EDG in MAINT LOCKOUT.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #6 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 6 Event # 7, 8, & 9 Page 27 of 32 Event
Description:
Steam Generator E-089 Tube Rupture / Loss of 480 V Bus / Safety Injection and Containment Cooling Actuation Signals Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- INITIATE SO23-12-11, Attachment 22, Non-Qualified Load Restoration.
[Step 5.e - YES]
M.O. Cue: When directed to restore non-qualified loads, WAIT 2 minutes, then EXECUTE remote function ED85, Non-Qualified Loads Restoration. INFORM the Control Room that you have restored Non-Qualified Loads.
- VERIFY Containment pressure less than Instrument Air pressure.
SRO/RO
[Step 5.f - YES]
- OVERRIDE and OPEN HV-5388, Instrument Air to Containment and RO ENSURE HV-5343, Excess Flow Check Valve OPEN. [Step 5.g - YES]
RO ESTABLISH Optimum SI Alignment:
- ESTABLISH two train operation: [Step 6.a - YES]
- DETERMINE Train A Charging Pumps OPERATING.
[Step 6.a.1) - YES]
[Step 6.a.2) - YES]
- DETERMINE Train A Cold Leg flow paths ALIGNED.
[Step 6.a.3) - YES]
- DETERMINE SI flow required AND indicated. [Step 6.a.4) - YES]
SRO IDENTIFY E-089 as affected SG:
- EVALUATE SG radioactive release indications - rising. [Step 7.a - YES]
- SG Blowdown monitors. [Step 7.a.1) - YES]
- SG sample results. [Step 7.a.2) - YES]
- Main Steam Line monitors. [Step 7.a.3) - YES]
- EVALUATE indications on E-089: [Step 7.b - YES]
- SG level rising when not feeding. [Step 7.b.1) - YES]
[Step 7.b.2) - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #6 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 6 Event # 7, 8, & 9 Page 28 of 32 Event
Description:
Steam Generator E-089 Tube Rupture / Loss of 480 V Bus / Safety Injection and Containment Cooling Actuation Signals Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- Steam/feed flow prior to trip NOT normal. [Step 7.b.3) - YES]
- DETERMINE E-089 is affected SG. [Step 7.c - YES]
- OPERATE MFW to maintain Steam Generator E-089 level > 40% AND BOP RCS cooldown less than 100°F. [Step 7.d - YES]
- NOTIFY Shift Manager / Operations Leader that E-089 is affected SG.
[Step 7.e - YES]
SRO VERIFY heat removal by least affected Steam Generator E-088:
- VERIFY electric AFW Pump OPERATING. [Step 8.a - NO]
- [RNO] DETERMINE Main Feedwater Pump OPERATING and GO to Step c.
- DETERMINE SG E-088 available for continued heat removal.
[Step 8.c - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #6 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 6 Event # 7, 8, & 9 Page 29 of 32 Event
Description:
Steam Generator E-089 Tube Rupture / Loss of 480 V Bus / Safety Injection and Containment Cooling Actuation Signals Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior SRO ISOLATE most affected Steam Generator E-089:
- ENSURE RCS THOT less than 530°F. [Step 9.a - YES]
CRITICAL TASK Isolate the Ruptured Steam Generator Prior to Exiting SO23-12-4, Steam STATEMENT Generator Tube Rupture.
CRITICAL TASK BOP
- ISOLATE Steam Generator E-089: [Step 9.b - YES]
- CLOSE / STOP SG E-089 components: [Step 9.b.1) - YES]
- DEPRESS HV-8204, Main Steam Isolation Valve CLOSE pushbuttons.
- DETERMINE HV-8202, Main Steam Isolation Valve Bypass CLOSED.
- DETERMINE HV-8421, Atmospheric Dump Valve CLOSED.
- DEPRESS HV-4052, MFW Isolation Valve CLOSE pushbuttons.
- DETERMINE HV-4731, AFW Valve CLOSED.
- DETERMINE HV-4715, AFW Valve CLOSED.
- DEPRESS HV-8200, P-140, Steam to AFW Pump CLOSE pushbutton.
- DEPRESS HV-4053, SG Blowdown Valve CLOSE pushbutton.
- DETERMINE P-141, AFW Pump STOPPED.
- RECORD time of SG isolation __________. [Step 9.b.2) - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #6 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 6 Event # 7, 8, & 9 Page 30 of 32 Event
Description:
Steam Generator E-089 Tube Rupture / Loss of 480 V Bus / Safety Injection and Containment Cooling Actuation Signals Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- ENSURE HV-8421, Steam Generator E-089 Atmospheric Dump Valve in MANUAL. [Step 9.b.3) - YES]
- INITIATE closure of 1301MU1258 or 1301MU1001, Main Steam Drain Isolation Valves. [Step 9.b.4) - YES]
+30 min SRO
- INITIATE FS-28, Monitor Isolated SG. [Step 9.c - YES]
When Steam Generator E-089 is isolated, or at the Lead Evaluators discretion, TERMINATE the scenario.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #6 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 6 Event # 7, 8, & 9 Page 31 of 32 Event
Description:
Steam Generator E-089 Tube Rupture / Loss of 480 V Bus / Safety Injection and Containment Cooling Actuation Signals Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior Examiner Note: These steps are performed by the BOP per SO23-12-1, Steps 12 through 16.
SRO/BOP INITIATE Attachment 5, Administrative Actions. [Step 12.a - YES]
SRO/BOP ENSURE a PA system announcement for Reactor Trip. [Step 12.b - YES]
BOP ENSURE the following loads restored:
- VERIFY Unit 2 Telecom 480 VAC Feeder Breaker - CLOSED.
[Step 13.a - NO].
- [RNO] VERIFY Unit 3 HS-0800S2, Telecom 480 VAC Feeder Breaker - CLOSED.
- VERIFY Unit 2 Telecom 480 VAC Feeder Breaker - CLOSED.
[Step 13.b - NO].
- [RNO] VERIFY Unit 3 HS-0800N2, Telecom 480 VAC Feeder Breaker - CLOSED.
- DETERMINE all Non-1E Buses - ENERGIZED [Step 13.c - YES].
- DETERMINE B15 & B16 480 VAC Load Centers - ENERGIZED
[Step 13.d - YES].
BOP VERIFY Main Turbine Coastdown:
- DETERMINE Extraction Steam Block Valves - CLOSED.
[Step 14.a - YES]
- DETERMINE Main Steam to Reheater Block, Bypass, Warmup, and Control Valves - CLOSED. [Step 14.a - YES]
- DETERMINE HV-2712A/B Bled Steam to Reheaters Block Valve -
CLOSED. [Step 14.a - YES]
- VERIFY Generator lowering - less than 24 kV. [Step 14.b - YES]
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #6 Rev f.doc
Appendix D Operator Action Form ES-D-2 Operating Test : NRC Scenario # 6 Event # 7, 8, & 9 Page 32 of 32 Event
Description:
Steam Generator E-089 Tube Rupture / Loss of 480 V Bus / Safety Injection and Containment Cooling Actuation Signals Failure Time Position Applicants Actions or Behavior
- VERIFY 99A26 - TURBINE LUBE OIL TEMP HI and 99A46 - TURBINE BRG OIL DRAIN TEMP HI Annunciators - RESET. [Step 14.c - YES]
- INITIATE SO23-10-2, Turbine Shutdown, Attachment for Unloading the Generator and Removing the Unit from Line. [Step 14.d - NO]
BOP ESTABLISH desired Condensate and Feedwater Status:
- ENSURE 3rd Point Heater Drain Pumps - STOPPED. [Step 15.a - YES]
- DETERMINE Reactor Trip Override - RESET. [Step 15.b - YES]
- MAINTAIN one MFW Pumps and three (3) Condensate Pumps -
OPERATING. [Step 15.c - YES]
- ENSURE FIC-3294, Condensate Pump Miniflow Controller set for Condensate Pump configuration. [Step 15.d - YES]
- Three (3) Pumps - 9000 GPM.
- PLACE LV-3245, Condensate Drawoff Valve to DISABLE.
[Step 15.e - YES]
- VERIFY SO23-12-2, Reactor Trip Recovery, being implemented.
[Step 15.f - NO]
- [RNO] ENSURE HV-4053 & HV-4054, SG Blowdown Valves CLOSED and GO to Step 16.
BOP VERIFY Start-Up Range Channels:
- VERIFY both Start-Up Range Channels - OPERABLE. [Step 16.a - NO]
- [RNO] INITIATE SO23-3-2.15, Section for Start-Up Range Channel failure.
SO23-12-1, Standard Post Trip Actions, Steps 12 through 16 are complete.
SONGS 2011 NRC Sim Scenario #6 Rev f.doc
ES-301 Transient and Event Checklist Form ES-301-5 Facility: SONGS 2 and 3 Date of Exam: 10/31/11 Operating Test Number: 1/2/3/4/5 E
SCENARIOS A V P E SONGS #3 SONGS #1 SONGS #2 SONGS #4 SONGS #5 P N L T MINIMUM(*)
T I CREW CREW CREW CREW O C T POSITION POSITION POSITION POSITION T A Y A S A B S A B S A B S A B N P R T O R T O R T O R T O L R I U T E O C P O C P O C P O C P RX - 0 1 1 0 NOR - 0 1 1 1 SROU-1 I/C 1,2,3,4 4 4 4 2 MAJ 5 1 2 2 1 TS 2,4 2 0 2 2 RX - - - 0 1 1 0 NOR - 3 1 2 1 1 1 SROI-1 I/C 1,3,4,6 1,2,4 2,3,4 10 4 4 2 MAJ 5 5 7 3 2 2 1 TS - 1,2 2,3 4 0 2 2 RX 3 - - 1 1 1 0 NOR - - 3 1 1 1 1 SROI-2 I/C 1,4,5,9 1,2,3,4 1,2,4 11 4 4 2 MAJ 6 5 5 3 2 2 1 TS - 2,4 1,2 4 0 2 2 RX - - - 0 1 1 0 NOR 3 - 1 2 1 1 1 SROI-3 I/C 1,2,4 1,2,3,4 3,6,9 10 4 4 2 MAJ 6 5 7 3 2 2 1 TS 2,3 2,4 - 4 0 2 2 RX - - 3 1 1 1 0 NOR 3 - - 1 1 1 1 SROI-4 I/C 1,2,4 1,2,3,4 2,6,7 10 4 4 2 MAJ 6 5 5 3 2 2 1 TS 2,3 2,4 - 4 0 2 2 RX - 3 - 1 1 1 0 NOR 3 - 1 2 1 1 1 SROI-5 I/C 1,2,4 2,6,7 2,3,4 9 4 4 2 MAJ 6 5 7 3 2 2 1 TS 2,3 - 2,3 4 0 2 2 RX 3 - - 1 1 1 0 NOR - 3 1 2 1 1 1 SROI-6 I/C 1,4,5,9 1,2,4 2,3,4 10 4 4 2 MAJ 6 5 7 3 2 2 1 TS - 1,2 2,3 4 0 2 2 RX 3 - - 1 1 1 0 NOR - 3 1 2 1 1 1 SROI-7 I/C 1,4,5,9 1,2,4 2,3,4 10 4 4 2 MAJ 6 5 7 3 2 2 1 TS - 1,2 2,3 4 0 2 2 Page 1 of 3 SONGS NRC 2011 ES-301-5 Transient and Event Checklist Rev c.doc
ES-301 Transient and Event Checklist Form ES-301-5 Facility: SONGS 2 and 3 Date of Exam: 10/31/11 Operating Test Number: 1/2/3/4/5 E
SCENARIOS A V P E SONGS #3 SONGS #1 SONGS #2 SONGS #4 SONGS #5 P N L T MINIMUM(*)
T I CREW CREW CREW CREW O C T POSITION POSITION POSITION POSITION T A Y A S A B S A B S A B S A B N P R T O R T O R T O R T O L R I U T E O C P O C P O C P O C P RX - - 3 1 1 1 0 NOR 3 4 - 2 1 1 1 SROI-8 I/C 1,2,4 1,2,3 2,6,7 9 4 4 2 MAJ 6 5 5 3 2 2 1 TS 2,3 2,3 - 4 0 2 2 RX - - - 0 1 1 0 NOR - 3 1 2 1 1 1 RO-1 I/C 2,4,7,8 1,4,8 3,6,9 10 4 4 2 MAJ 5 5 7 3 2 2 1 TS - - - 0 0 2 2 RX - - - 0 1 1 0 NOR - 3 - 1 1 1 1 RO-2 I/C 1,3,4,6 1,4,8 2,4,8 10 4 4 2 MAJ 5 5 7 3 2 2 1 TS - - - 0 0 2 2 RX - - - 0 1 1 0 NOR 3 - 1 2 1 1 1 RO-3 I/C 2,5,7,8 2,4,7,8 3,6,9 11 4 4 2 MAJ 6 5 7 3 2 2 1 TS - - - 0 0 2 2 RX - - - 0 1 1 0 NOR 3 - - 1 1 1 1 RO-4 I/C 2,5,7,8 1,3,4,6 2,4,8 11 4 4 2 MAJ 6 5 7 3 2 2 1 TS - - - 0 0 2 2 RX 3 - - 1 1 1 0 NOR - - - 0 1 1 1 RO-5 I/C 1,4,5,9 2,4,7,8 2,4,8 11 4 4 2 MAJ 6 5 7 3 2 2 1 TS - - - 0 0 2 2 RX - - - 0 1 1 0 NOR 3 - - 1 1 1 1 RO-6 I/C 2,5,7,8 1,3,4,6 2,4,8 11 4 4 2 MAJ 6 5 7 3 2 2 1 TS - - - 0 0 2 2 Page 2 of 3 SONGS NRC 2011 ES-301-5 Transient and Event Checklist Rev c.doc
ES-301 Transient and Event Checklist Form ES-301-5 Facility: SONGS 2 and 3 Date of Exam: 10/31/11 Operating Test Number: 1/2/3/4/5 E
SCENARIOS A V P E SONGS #3 SONGS #1 SONGS #2 SONGS #4 SONGS #5 P N L T MINIMUM(*)
T I CREW CREW CREW CREW O C T POSITION POSITION POSITION POSITION T A Y A S A B S A B S A B S A B N P R T O R T O R T O R T O L R I U T E O C P O C P O C P O C P RX - - - 0 1 1 0 NOR - 3 1 2 1 1 1 RO-7 I/C 2,4,7,8 1,4,8 3,6,9 10 4 4 2 MAJ 5 5 7 3 2 2 1 TS - - - 0 0 2 2 RX - - - 0 1 1 0 NOR 3 3 1 3 1 1 1 RO-8 I/C 2,5,7,8 1,4,8 3,6,9 10 4 4 2 MAJ 6 5 7 3 2 2 1 TS - - - 0 0 2 2 RX 3 - 1 1 1 0 NOR - - 0 1 1 1 RO-9 I/C 2,6,7 2,4,8 6 4 4 2 MAJ 5 7 2 2 2 1 TS - - 0 0 2 2 Instructions:
- 1. Check the applicant level and enter the operating test number and Form ES-D-1 event numbers for each event type; TS are not applicable for RO applicants. ROs must serve in both the at-the-controls (ATC) and balance-of-plant (BOP) positions; Instant SROs must serve in both the SRO and the ATC positions, including at least two instrument or component (I/C) malfunctions and one major transient, in the ATC position. If an Instant SRO additionally serves in the BOP position, one I/C malfunction can be credited toward the two I/C malfunctions required for the ATC position.
- 2. Reactivity manipulations may be conducted under normal or controlled abnormal conditions (refer to Section D.5.d) but must be significant per Section C.2.a of Appendix D. (*) Reactivity and normal evolutions may be replaced with additional instrument or component malfunctions on a 1-for-1 basis.
- 3. Whenever practical, both instrument and component malfunctions should be included; only those that require verifiable actions that provide insight to the applicants competence count toward the minimum requirements specified for the applicants license level in the right-hand columns.
Page 3 of 3 SONGS NRC 2011 ES-301-5 Transient and Event Checklist Rev c.doc
ES-301 Competencies Checklist Form ES-301-6 Facility: SONGS 2 & 3 Date of Examination: 10/31/11 Operating Test Number: 1/2/3/4/5 Applicants SROU-1 SROI-1 SROI-2 Competencies SCENARIO SCENARIO SCENARIO 2 2 3 5 1 2 3 Interpret/Diag-1,2,3,4, 1,3,4, 1,2,3, 2,3,4, 1,3,4,5, 1,2,3,4, 1,2,3, nose Events 5 5,6 4,5 6,7 6,9 5 4,5 and Conditions Comply With 1,3,4, 1,3,4,5, and Use ALL 5,6 ALL ALL 6,9 ALL ALL Procedures (1)
Operate 1,3,4, 1,3,4,5, Control Boards N/A 5,6 N/A N/A 6,9 N/A N/A (2)
Communicate 1,2,3,4, 1,3,4,5 and ALL 5,6 ALL ALL 6,8,9 ALL ALL Interact Demonstrate Supervisory ALL N/A ALL ALL N/A ALL ALL Ability (3)
Comply With and Use Tech. 2,4 N/A 1,2 2,3 N/A 2,4 1,2 Specs. (3)
Notes:
(1) Includes Technical Specification compliance for an RO.
(2) Optional for an SRO-U.
(3) Only applicable to SROs.
SONGS NRC 2011 ES-301-6 Competencies Checklist Rev c.doc
ES-301 Competencies Checklist Form ES-301-6 Facility: SONGS 2 & 3 Date of Examination: 10/31/11 Operating Test Number: 1/2/3/4/5 Applicants SROI-3 SROI-4 SROI-5 Competencies SCENARIO SCENARIO SCENARIO 1 2 4 1 2 3 1 3 5 Interpret/Diag-1,2,3,4, 1,2,3,4, 1,3,4 1,2,3,4, 1,2,3,4, 2,3,5, 1,2,3,4, 2,3,5, 2,3,4, nose Events 5,6 5 ,5,6 5,6 5 6,7 5,6 6,7 6,7 and Conditions Comply With 1,3,4 2,3,5, 2,3,5, and Use ALL ALL
,5,6 ALL ALL 6,7 ALL 6,7 ALL Procedures (1)
Operate 1,3,4 2,3,5, 2,3,5, Control Boards N/A N/A
,5,6 N/A N/A 6,7 N/A 6,7 N/A (2)
Communicate 1,2,3 1,2,3,5, 1,2,3,5, and ALL ALL ,4,5, ALL ALL 6,7,8 ALL 6,7,8 ALL 6
Interact Demonstrate Supervisory ALL ALL N/A ALL ALL N/A ALL N/A ALL Ability (3)
Comply With and Use Tech. 2,3 2,4 N/A 2,3 2,4 N/A 2,3 N/A 2,3 Specs. (3)
Notes:
(1) Includes Technical Specification compliance for an RO.
(2) Optional for an SRO-U.
(3) Only applicable to SROs.
SONGS NRC 2011 ES-301-6 Competencies Checklist Rev c.doc
ES-301 Competencies Checklist Form ES-301-6 Facility: SONGS 2 & 3 Date of Examination: 10/31/11 Operating Test Number: 1/2/3/4/5 Applicants SROI-6 SROI-7 SROI-8 Competencies SCENARIO SCENARIO SCENARIO 1 3 5 1 3 5 1 3 4 Interpret/Diag-1,3,4,5, 1,2,3 2,3,4 1,3,4,5, 1,2,3, 2,3,4, 1,2,3,4, 2,3,5, 1,2,3, nose Events 6,9 ,4,5 ,6,7 6,9 4,5 6,7 5,6 6,7 4,5 and Conditions Comply With 1,3,4,5, 1,3,4,5, 2,3,5, and Use 6,9 ALL ALL 6,9 ALL ALL ALL 6,7 ALL Procedures (1)
Operate 1,3,4,5, 1,3,4,5, 2,3,5, Control Boards 6,9 N/A N/A 6,9 N/A N/A N/A 6,7 N/A (2)
Communicate 1,3,4,5 1,3,4,5 1,2,3,5, and 6,8,9 ALL ALL 6,8,9 ALL ALL ALL 6,7,8 ALL Interact Demonstrate Supervisory N/A ALL ALL N/A ALL ALL ALL N/A ALL Ability (3)
Comply With and Use Tech. N/A 1,2 2,3 N/A 1,2 2,3 2,3 N/A 2,3 Specs. (3)
Notes:
(1) Includes Technical Specification compliance for an RO.
(2) Optional for an SRO-U.
(3) Only applicable to SROs.
SONGS NRC 2011 ES-301-6 Competencies Checklist Rev c.doc
ES-301 Competencies Checklist Form ES-301-6 Facility: SONGS 2 & 3 Date of Examination: 10/31/11 Operating Test Number: 1/2/3/4/5 Applicants RO-1 RO-2 RO-3 Competencies SCENARIO SCENARIO SCENARIO 2 3 5 2 3 5 1 2 5 Interpret/Diag-2,4,5, 1,3,4, 3,6,7, 1,3,4, 1,3,4, 2,4,5, 2,3,5,6, 2,4,5, 3,6,7, nose Events 7,8 5,8 9 5,6 5,8 6,7,8 7,8 7,8 9 and Conditions Comply With 2,4,5, 1,3,4, 1,3,6, 1,3,4, 1,3,4, 2,3,5,6, 2,4,5, 1,3,6, and Use 7,8 5,8 7,9 5,6 5,8 2,4,7,8 7,8 7,8 7,9 Procedures (1)
Operate 2,4,5, 1,3,4, 1,3,6, 1,3,4, 1,3,4, 2,4,6, 2,3,5,6, 2,4,5, 1,3,6, Control Boards 7,8 5,8 7,9 5,6 5,8 7,8 7,8 7,8 7,9 (2)
Communicate 2,4,5, 1,3,4, 1,3,5, 1,2,3,4, 1,3,4, 2,4,5, 2,3,4,5, 2,4,5, 1,3,5, and 6,7,8 5,8 6,7,9 5,6 5,8 6,7,8 6,7,8,9 6,7,8 6,7,9 Interact Demonstrate Supervisory N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A Ability (3)
Comply With and Use Tech. N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A Specs. (3)
Notes:
(1) Includes Technical Specification compliance for an RO.
(2) Optional for an SRO-U.
(3) Only applicable to SROs.
SONGS NRC 2011 ES-301-6 Competencies Checklist Rev c.doc
ES-301 Competencies Checklist Form ES-301-6 Facility: SONGS 2 & 3 Date of Examination: 10/31/11 Operating Test Number: 1/2/3/4/5 Applicants RO-4 RO-5 RO-6 Competencies SCENARIO SCENARIO SCENARIO 1 2 5 1 2 4 1 2 5 Interpret/Diag-2,3,5,6, 1,3,4, 2,4,5, 1,3,4,5, 2,4,5, 2,4,5, 2,3,5,6, 1,3,4, 2,4,5, nose Events 7,8 5,6 6,7,8 6,9 7,8 7,8 7,8 5,6 6,7,8 and Conditions Comply With 2,3,5,6, 1,3,4, 1,3,4,5, 2,4,5, 2,4,5, 2,3,5,6, 1,3,4, and Use 7,8 5,6 2,4,7,8 6,9 7,8 7,8 7,8 5,6 2,4,7,8 Procedures (1)
Operate 2,3,5,6, 1,3,4, 2,4,6, 1,3,4,5, 2,4,5, 2,4,5, 2,3,5,6, 1,3,4, 2,4,6, Control Boards 7,8 5,6 7,8 6,9 7,8 7,8 7,8 5,6 7,8 (2)
Communicate 2,3,4,5, 1,2,3,4, 2,4,5, 1,3,4,5 2,4,5, 2,4,5, 2,3,4,5, 1,2,3,4, 2,4,5, and 6,7,8,9 5,6 6,7,8 6,8,9 6,7,8 6,7,8 6,7,8,9 5,6 6,7,8 Interact Demonstrate Supervisory N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A Ability (3)
Comply With and Use Tech. N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A Specs. (3)
Notes:
(1) Includes Technical Specification compliance for an RO.
(2) Optional for an SRO-U.
(3) Only applicable to SROs.
SONGS NRC 2011 ES-301-6 Competencies Checklist Rev c.doc
ES-301 Competencies Checklist Form ES-301-6 Facility: SONGS 2 & 3 Date of Examination: 10/31/11 Operating Test Number: 1/2/3/4/5 Applicants RO-7 RO-8 RO-9 Competencies SCENARIO SCENARIO SCENARIO 2 3 5 1 3 5 3 5 Interpret/Diag-2,4,5, 1,3,4, 3,6,7 2,3,5,6, 1,3,4, 3,6,7, 2,3,5, 2,4,5, nose Events 7,8 5,8 ,9 7,8 5,8 9 6,7 6,7,8 and Conditions Comply With 2,4,5, 1,3,4, 1,3,6 2,3,5,6, 1,3,4, 1,3,6, 2,3,5, and Use 7,8 5,8 ,7,9 7,8 5,8 7,9 6,7 2,4,7,8 Procedures (1)
Operate 2,4,5, 1,3,4, 1,3,6 2,3,5,6, 1,3,4, 1,3,6, 2,3,5, 2,4,6, Control Boards 7,8 5,8 ,7,9 7,8 5,8 7,9 6,7 7,8 (2)
Communicate 1,3,5 2,4,5, 1,3,4, 2,3,4,5, 1,3,4, 1,3,5, 1,2,3,5, 2,4,5, and 6,7,8 5,8
,6,7, 6,7,8,9 5,8 6,7,9 6,7,8 6,7,8 9
Interact Demonstrate Supervisory N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A Ability (3)
Comply With and Use Tech. N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A Specs. (3)
Notes:
(1) Includes Technical Specification compliance for an RO.
(2) Optional for an SRO-U.
(3) Only applicable to SROs.