ML112490411
| ML112490411 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Millstone  |
| Issue date: | 07/22/2011 |
| From: | NRC Region 1 |
| To: | Dominion Resources |
| JACKSON D RGN-I/DRS/OB/610-337-5306 | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML110030662 | List: |
| References | |
| TAC U01832, 50-423/11-302 50-423/11-302 | |
| Download: ML112490411 (10) | |
Text
Written Exam Question Attributes Written Exam Question Attributes Questions asked by candidates during the written exam I Question Candidate I I Question I Reply ~
I~~------
Number Proctor 85 I'm not sure what this uestion is askin . I Royce Given the conditions in the stem, what action will the procedure direct the US to take 37 S~ 2 i I
Is this question asking what will happen after the crew takes more I I I actions, or right after the second failure?
Royce Right after the second failure 1---
50 1\c){ I don't think "Auto-after-sto~:orrect ~.
Royce Do your best with information given I I
93 5&>1 Question sa~s Eower is 38%. Is~ower still 38%? I Royce Yes I
15 i 5Rc>l£ I made a transppsition error. Is this how to mark the change?
, Royce Yes (lined out initial answer, initialed the lineout, and circled the desired answer) 24 ~<<oZ Can I have steam tables forthis;cquest~1 Royce Do your best with information given I 1
r- .~------.--
i I
69 S~o c:. The procedure doesn't address the change, or there is a specific II i precaution Erohibiting the change?
I ,
I Ro ce . The rocedure doesn t address t~e change
~--------------------~
i 73 5~O 'Z. Is this asking what the next two procedurally directed actions are?
+-1~.-
Royce Iyes i L 98 i .sJ<o z.. Does answer "C" imEl~ other actions, such as re-la!ching the valve?
i Royce "C" is saying the crew needs to start a new discharge.
I 77 siZv Z-. I want to make sure this event is happening fairly quickly; that there I i hasn't been a long time between the actions.
Royce No long delay has occurred -
Page 2 of2
Questions asked by candidates during the written exam
! Question i Candidate / ! Question / Reply Number Proctor r-~---,~--------,r-~-. .~------------~~---------
'--13_____I--~_O_Z~___+_-Is-t-h-e-re-a-nything wrong with invelter 1_?______
. Royce There are no electrical problems with inverter 1 (Clarification r-_____I--______~r-o-v-id-e-d-t-o-a-l-l-ca-n-d-id-a-t-es.--on--W_h_it_e__b_o_ar_d~)_____________~
! 68 5 ~o I..{ Do I assume the re uired flowrate is an acceptance criterion?
Ro ce Yes 24 Can I have steam tables Royce Do our best with information given
~~_8_-_ _--t---=S:....;R..:..C~I_ _+--Is_t-:-h_is~trying to tie the alarm with the s stem res onse?
Royce This is a two-part question: How will the system respond, and how i can the RO monitor level.
81 .:sR(j~_ I Can I get a steam table?
Royce Do your best with information given 42 .s Ro I The question says the plant cooled down to 550°F. Can I assume it is still at 550°F?
Royce Yes i 47 ~O 2. Am I to assume initial bus voltage was 133 Volts?
I Royce Do your best with information giyen I
'60 R,() '2.. When the question asks what are the immediate effects, does it I mean what automatic actions occur?
Royce Yes 62 ~o! Is this the control room radiation monitor?
I
! Royce Yes I
, 58 sRv z- Is the channel failure due to a detector failure?
i Royce Yes I r74 i Rot What does the MIDS acronym stand for?
Moveable Incore Detector System I
Royce I
86 5KPI I'd like steam tables for this question Royce i Do your best with information given Page 1 of2
Seating Chart
("HIT" Training Room, Simulator Training Building)
(Old Connecticut Yankee Simulator Room) r- ._
Rest Room ISRO :1£6 I r;;; -Ii 4 .
I I
~z. ~
I i SRO lit I IRO I SRO iJ S I ISRO*$3 ~
ISRO ill.. I IRO fI::( ~
Door Proctor Desk I
The door at the entrance was closed, and marked with a Sigel. A cone with a sign was placed just outside the door.
Written Exam Performance Analysis Results (See attached table)
Fifty-six questions had at least one applicant miss the question.
Of the twenty-six questions missed by more than one applicant, fi)urteen had more than one distractor chosen.
Five RO questions and two SRO question were missed by half or more ofthe applicants. They are dispositioned below:
Question 6: This question is technically accurate, but was difficult, requiring the candidates to analyze four abnormal indications for the charging pump. This was recognized as a difficult, but technically correct question during the exam validation. No changes to training material are required.
Question 18: This question is technically accurate, but was difficult, testing the effect of grid voltage changes on MY ARs and Main Generator amps. It was verified that the information was covered in GFS training material. No changes to training materia.l required.
Question 24: This question is technically accurate, but was diffi.;::ult due to testing the basis of a step in a Yellow Path procedure. No changes to training material required.
Question 26: This question is technically accurate. The validators did not consider this question particularly difficult. Question tested basis for operating one RCP in E-l. The distractors included true statements that did not answer the basis for RCPs in this condition. It was verified that the training material adequately covered the topic.
Question 54: This question is technically accurate, but was difficult, requiring the candidates to determine whether an instrument air compressor could be re-started without the LOP signal being reset in the EOPs. This was recognized as a difficult, but technically correct question during the exam validation. No changes to training material are required.
Question 55: This question is technically accurate, but was difficult, testing component response during to simulated and actual inputs during slave relay testing. This was recognized as a difficult, but technically correct question during the exam validation. No changes to training material are required.
Question 86: This question is technically accurate, but was difficult, testing plant response to terminating Safety Injection in ECA-3.3 (Tube Rupture without pressure control). It also tested SI reinitiation criteria in ECA-3.3, which are not the standard SI Reinitiation criteria in the EOP network. This was recognized as a difficult, but technically correct question during the exam validation. No changes to training material are required.
Question 98: This question was difficult, testing actions required if a liquid waste discharge automatically isolates during a discharge, and sample results show no unexpected activity in the tank. The procedure allows recommencing the discharge. Candidates chose the conservative action of issuing a new discharge permit, or the actions required if the associated radiation monitor is out of service.
All 8 candidates were remediated on all of these questions by providing a handout with associated references, and discussing the question in detail during the examination review.
Millstone 3 2011 NRC RO Ucense Exam Answer Sheet NAME: 6)C~ A"..Ayc," DATE:
QUESTION ANSWER CHOICE QUESTION 1
2 -* e B B
ff C '
C D
Df
@7 27 A B 3
4 A
A B' C
C D
28 29 A
A
- e B
C C
D 5
[f]
A
~.
B ~ D 30 A
- C D
~
C' D 31 A B C 7
8 9
A B
B B II c C
D D
D 32 33 34 A
tJ B C C
D)
D B C D 10 11 12 A
A A
e B
B C
C C
D
~
35 36 37 A
A B
- e
- A t If B C
C DI D
13 ~ B C I D' 38 A C D 14 15 A
A B
B (
~
ci D
39 40 AI A
B B **
C D
16 17 *~
B B
c c
D D
41 42 AI A
B B ** D D
[}]J 19 * *e A
FJJ,J-ft B
C D D
43 44
- e A
B B
C' D D
20 21 22 A
A A'
B B
B **
c D
D 45 46 47 A
A
- B c
c D
D D
C' 23 25 A'
A BI B
cl c
c D
Dfll 48 49 50 A
AI A
B B
cI c
C D
Sheet 1 of 2
Millstone 3 2011 NRC SRO License Exam Answer Sheet NAME: DATE:
SRO QUESTION ANSWER CHOICE QUESTION ANSWER CHOICE 51 52 A
A *-
B C 0 0'
'76 77 A
A B
B I C C
- e 53 A If A
B B
c¥6 C~'
78 79 Air A *B C
C 0
e 55 AU't C ec 01 80 A AI *
- C 0 56 A B 0 81 B C 57 A
- e B I
-e 82 A ,
B If C 0 58 B C 0' 83 B 0 c' A' 59 A BI 84 B 0 60 B II C 0 85 AI C 0 61 A
- e C 0 C§ * - ' Bf C rl o {f 62 A' B 0 87 A B 0 63 64 65 A
A At i B
- e C C
0 0
0 88 89 90 A
A A I I
B B
B C'
~
o, 0
66 67 68 A
A B
B B\I
- c C
0 0'
91 92 93
~
A' A
4t If _
Bl C
Cl C
0 0
0 69 A
- *B I cl Of 94 A B ~
0 70 CIf 0 95 A B 0 71 ~ B C 0 96 A I B C ~
72 73 74 A
A A
B B J1 C
C C
0 [§ 97 99 **
B B
B' C
C C
III 0
0 0
I 75 A B
- 0 Sheet 2 of 2 1100 A I B C
Millstone 3 2011 NRC RO License Exam Answer Sheet NAME: lkv (
DATE: 7p¢/
-* e QUESTION ANSWER CHOICE QUESTION ANSWER CHOICE 2
1 B B
C C
D D
26 27 *
- A B
B C D D
3 4
A A B C
C D 28 29 A
A
- e B
C C
D 5
6 A
A B
- -C D
D
- 30
- 31 A
A e
B C
C D
~
7 8
A B
B C D
D
- 32 33 -*
A tI B C C
D D
9 B C D :34 B C D 10 11 12 A
A A
- B B
C C
C
~
D 35 36 37 A
A A
B
- e
- B C
C D D
13 ~ B C D 38 A C D 14 15 A
A B B ~
C D 39 40 A
A B
B **
C D
16 17 *- B B
C C
D D
41 42 A
A B
B ** D D
18 19 * *e A
B B
C D D
43 44
- e A
B B
C D D
20 21 22 A
A A
B B
B **
C D
D 45 46 47 A
A B
C C
C D
D D
23 24 A
- B C
C D
D 48 49 A
A B
C C
- D 25 A B C
- Sheet 1 of 2 50 A B C
Millstone 3 2011 NRC SRO License Exam Answer Sheet NAME: [~y DATE: 1 [-,5/ If
/ SRO QUESTION ANSWER CHOICE QUESTION ANSWER CHOICE 51 52 A
A *B C
4t D
D
~r6
~r7 A
A B
B C
C e 53 54 A
A B
B C
C
~ J8 J9 A
A *B C
C e D
55 56 A
- e C D D
80 81 A
- C D
- *e A B A B C 57 A B C 82 B C D 58
- e B C D 83 A B D 59 A B C 84 A B D 60 61 ** e A
B C C
D D
85 86 A
- - B C
C D
D 62 A B D 87 A B D 63 64 65 A
A A
B
- C C
D D
D 88 89 90 A
A A
B B
B
~
C D
D 66 67 68 A
A B
B B
- C C
D D
91 92
!93
- A A
4t B
It c
C c
D D
D 69 A
- C D 94 A B ~
D 70 B C D 95 A B D 71 ~ B C D 96 A B C ~
72 73 74 A
A A
B B
C C
C D
97 98
'99 **
B B
B C
C C
D D
D 75 A B
- D Sheet 2 of 2 100 A B C