ML090690320

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search

NRC Comments on Draft Licensee-Developed (Millstone Power Station, Unit 2) Exam (Written & Operating Tests) (Folder 2)
ML090690320
Person / Time
Site: Millstone Dominion icon.png
Issue date: 11/17/2008
From: Caruso J
Operations Branch I
To: Jane Spence
Dominion Nuclear Connecticut
Hansell S
Shared Package
ML082600232 List:
References
50-336/09-301, TAC U01634 50-336/09-301
Download: ML090690320 (57)


Text

Millstone Unit 2 RO EXAM 45 day Page 4

MI 75 10 F

0 50 7 1 40.50%

B

)r 50-60%

Modtfied=

required Exams=

0 (WH)

H H

F Psychometric YIN Job-Link Dlst

~ t n u t ~ a BIMIN NRC B

B B

un,ts Q=WA Back-0 only UlUS 8 Explanallon be DL0 with prov~ded Dlstanors plaus~ble glven Cho~ce justrficatlon lndlcate 3 0 However condrt~on IS Act~on 1 wh~ch specfies In revlse just~flcatlon explarn 0 correct revlse andtcate

1) pmhib~ts repostttontng d rntsposttloned >

hrs Removedrefwence andrev~sed "C -

1) typo ~n Chorce lustficatton
1) '8" dtstractor plaus~ble HPSl start ~n Cholce D plaus~ble HPSl In Chodces B dtscnmfnattng requlre applicant thtnk stgnal wlll autornattcally baslc informat~on know e~ther pzr c1714 psla of4

>4 pslg mth abddy block pzr

<I850 psla psla dmpp~ng setpolnts In justfy elthw af Modrfwd stern commenfs RO EXAM 2 LOD 3

Flaws 4 Job Content Flaws 5 Other 6

Stern Focus Cred ward SRO 71 2

X Y

Y U

1)Appears to reference do not appear to be the TS 2)

C seems to 3 entry acceptable covered by 3 1 3 1 A

MODE 3 next 6 hours6.944444e-5 days <br />0.00167 hours <br />9.920635e-6 weeks <br />2.283e-6 months <br /> Need to to also 3 3 entry not

Also, to AOP-2556 (not TS 3 1 3 affected rod 2

72 F

2 Y

M S

73 F

2 Y

S D

74 3

X Y

M U

not for pump to PTL

2) not as pump PTL. 3) and C not as they to a

SlAS be generated Very to SlAS generated by 2 of 4 press OR 2 cntmt press 42 lo on 3 of 4 press Stem states press at 375 and on event cntmt press steady, pzr press Applicant would have to forget the SlAS and the status of the SlAS block order to these choices and all answer choices to address 1

Y S

Nocomments Total 75 2 0 9

0 1

2 3

1 0

0 0

3 3

71 75 Sum 38 U

Bank=

25 16 UNSAT 36 480%

E M

23 42 Enhancement 74 98 7%

S N

New =

23 17 SATISFACTORY NRC 75 Total graded 71 21 3%

UNSAT 45 day Page

401-9

__L_

r n

/:

/I

> c [ 7 / 3 7 /=-?

P & r -, 7,,

y w L J r

/-

Q#

requ~red.

identify application KA demonstration conditions" B

(1 Y

U T/F KIA UIEIS U

U simuiator

actlons, w~ndow identify which
3.

Itl

2.

(1-5)

Psychometric Ref Req k?

TIF B/M/N Ez;

  1. I Q=WA Y

SROonly Y

80 Millstone Unit 2 SRO ES 76

7.
7. Explanation LOD too low Distractors not distracting. This basic rule of usage should be well ingrained from training and probably tested during op test dynamics. Could raise LOD by providing some parameter problem such that distractors more plausible. Revised stem to increase LOD and revised distractors to be more plausible
1) Unnecessarily wordy stem. Delete refererence to SM taking
2) Stem details are dressing in that all the choices direct restoring "the PORV to operable. No diagnosis required No expectation to PORV is affected. Could just say "Unit is in MODE PORV is stuck open with pressure below setpoint, what TS action is 1

LOK (FIH)

H 1.8

3.

Flaws Stem Focus 4 Job Content Flaws Y

Cues Minutia

6.

N N

5. Other N

units N

Partial Back -

ward N

3) Direct lookup with reference provided.. 4) NOT SRO only because operability call already made, RO should be able to straight-forward TS calls with references provided. 5) NOT a match. Although stem provides conditions to support diagnosis, none of the answer choices require use of this information, Further, none of choices support of ability to "understand how operator actions and directives affect plant and system Replaced Q new Q accpetable.

mean soonest action, or least severe action. or fewest number of steps required. 3) Choice is a second correct answer.

revised to address comments Y

81 N

N

1) Unsat because this is a list of choices. No stem is required Q and replaced 45 Day Page 1 A