ML083430012
| ML083430012 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Calvert Cliffs  |
| Issue date: | 12/03/2008 |
| From: | Will Smith Hurst Technologies Corp |
| To: | Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| CCNUFC, TAC MD9554, TAC MD9555 CCN-IC-02004, Rev 0 | |
| Download: ML083430012 (17) | |
Text
ENCLOSURE (2)
BG&E Calculation CA00800, "Total Loop Uncertainty for the Plant Computer's Determination of Main Feedwater Pump Discharge Pressure,"
Revision 1 Calvert Cliffs Nuclear Power Plant, Inc.
December 3, 2008
CALCULATION COVER SHEET (Attachment 19)
ESP No.: ES200100656-000 Supp No.: 000 Rev. No.: 0000 Page Iof 14 INITIATION (Control Doc Type - DCALC)
DCALC No.: CA00800 REVISION No.: I VENDOR CALCULATION (CHECK ONE): [ YES El No RESPONSIBLE GROUP: I & C ENGINEERING RESPONSIBLE ENGINEER: DvORAK, D. A.
CALCULATION ENGINEERING El Civil ED Instr& Controls 0l Nuc Engrg DISCIPLINE: E] Electrical El Mechanical El Diesel Gen Project
[ Life Cycle Mngmt E] Reliability Engrg E] Nuc Fuel Mngmt Q Other.
Title:
TOTAL LOOP UNCERTAINTY CALCULATION FOR THE PLANT COMPUTER'S DETERMINATION OF MAIN FEEDWATER PUMP DISCHARGE PRESSURE Unit 0 UNIT 1 ED UNIT2 El COMMON Proprietary or Safeguards Calculation '"] YES 0 NO Comments: NONE Vendor Cale No.: CCN-IC-02004 REVISION No.: 0 Vendor Name: HURST TECHNOLOGIES, CORP.
Safety Class (Check one): [I SR E] AQ 0 NSR There are no assumptions that require Verification during walkdown: AIT # N/A This calculation SUPERSEDES: NONE REVIEW AND APPROVAL:
RESPONSIBLE ENGINEER: HURST TECHNOLOGIES, CORP. DATE:
INDEPENDENT REVIEwER: 1_
- DATE:
APPROVAL: /--) - DATE:
OR (for Vendor Calcs)
OWNER ACCEPTANCE REVIEWER: _. DATE: __
/X
BG&E Calculation CA00800, Revision 1 TOTAL LOOP UNCERTAINTY CALCULATION FOR THE PLANT COMPUTER'S DETERMINATION OF MAIN FEEDWATER PUMP DISCHARGE PRESSURE For Calvert Cliffs Nuclear Power Plant Units I & 2 Calculation No. CCN-IC-02004 Revision 0 Prepared By Hurst Technologies, Corp.
Project: CCNUFC Client: Constellation Nuclear Calvert Cliffs Nuclear Power Plant 1650 Calvert Cliffs Parkway Lusby, Maryland 20657-4702 Prepared By: W.Robert Smith Date: Ie/fo *t Checked By: Date: NO-- 0r--
A ýk Reviewed By: Date: io-tco-C"-z Approved By: Date: \X ar Oo Page 2 of 14 CCN-IC-02004 Revision 00 Revision Page 2 of 14
BG&E Calculation CAOO800, Revision 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS CALCULATION COVER SHEET............................................................. I 1.0 PURPOSE ................................................................................... 5 2.0 COMPONENT-LISTING.................................................................. 5 3.0 FIGURES.................................................................................... 5 4.0 METHOD-OF ANALYSIS................................................................. 5 5.0 DESIGN-INPUTS .......................................................................... 6 6.0 ASSUMPTIONS .......................................................................... 11
7.0 REFERENCES
............................................................................ 11 8.0 IDENTIFICATION OF COMPUTER CODES......................................... 12 9.0 CALCULATION ......................................................................... 13
10.0 CONCLUSION
S ...................................................................... 14 ATITACHMENT A Excerpt from Rosemnount Manual 2 pages Page 3 of 14 CCN-IC-02004 Revision 00 Revision Page 3 of 14
BG&E Calculation CA00800, Revision 1 RECORD OF REVISIONS Rev. Date Pages Involved Description Originator 0 5/13/94 All Initial Issue E. R. Kreahling
- 1. 5/21/02 All Reformat calculation W. R. Smith Page 4 of 14 CCN-IC-02004 Revision 00 Revision Page 4 of 14
BG&E Calculation CA00800, Revision I 1.0 PURPOSE The purpose. of this calculation is to determine the total uncertainty of the Main Feedwater Pump Discharge Pressure indication on the plant computer. The calculation will also determine total device uncertainty for the loop transmitters and for the plant computer. Uncertainties are determined only for normal plant operating conditions. This calculation applies to Unit I and to Unit 2.
2.0 COMPONENT LISTING This calculation applies to the following instruments:
Pressure Differential Transmitters 1-PT-4490 1-PT-4495 2-PT-4490 2-PT-4495 Plant Computer Point ID's P4490 P4495 3.0 FIGURES 3.1 Loop Block Diagram MAIN FEEDWATER TO PLANT DISCHARGE COMPUTER PRESSURE TRANSMITrER 4.0 METHOD OF ANALYSIS This calculation is performed in accordance with ES-028, Instrument Loop Uncertainty / Setpoint Methodology. This calculation utilizes the Square Root Sum of the Squares (SRSS) methodology when all variables are random, independent and normally distributed.
This calculation determines device uncertainties for the main feedwater pump discharge pressure transmitters, 1(2)PT-4490 and 1(2)PT-4495, and the device uncertainty of their respective plant computer point ID's. The device.
uncertainties are used to calculate the associated loop uncertainty with respect to the final output device, which is the plant computer.
Revision 00 Page 5 of 14 CCN-IC-02004 Revision Page 5 of 14
BG&E Calculation CA00800, Revision I 5.0 DESIGN INPUTS 5.1 FEEDWATER PUMP DISCHARGE PRESSURE SENSOR CONSIDERATIONS TAG NUMBER: 1-PT-4490 17.7]
1-PT-4495 2-PT-4490 2-PT-4495 MANUFACTURER: ROSEMOUNT [7.2]
MODEL NUMBER: 3051CG-5A22A1AB4 [7.2]
SPAN: 2000 PSIG [7.2]
5.1.1 Per References 7.1, the Reference Accuracy for a range code 5 transmitter with a turn down ratio of less than 10:1 is +/- 0.075% Span. Therefore, the sensor Reference Accuracy (RAs) is given as:
RAs = 0.075% Span 5.1.2 Per the Master Calibration Data Sheets (Reference 7.2), the Sensor Setting Tolerance is +/- 0.25 % Span. Therefore:
STs = +/- 0.25 % Span 5.1.3 For conservatism, and to provide flexibility in the choice of test equipment, the Sensor Measurement and Test Equipment Effect (MTEs) is set equal to the Setting Tolerance (STs) of the sensor. Therefore, MTEs = +/- 0.25% Span Page 6 of 14 CCN-IC-02004 Revision .0 Revision .0 Page 6 of 14
BG&E Calculation CA00800, Revision I 5.1.4 Per Reference 7. 1, the Sensor Stability, or Drift term (DRs) is given as + 0.25%
of Upper Range Limit (URL) for 5 years, and the URL for this transmitter is 2000 PSID. Per Reference 7.3, the maximum calibration interval is 30 months, which is bounded by the specification interval. Per Reference 7.2, the sensor calibrated span is 2000 PSI. Therefore, the Sensor Drift (DRs) is given as:
DRs = +/- (o.2sX2000 PSID)] %Span L2000 PSID j DRs = +/- 0.25% Span 5.1.5 Since the transmitters addressed in this calculation are gage pressure transmitters, there is no sensor static pressure effect (SPEs). Therefore:
SPEs = N/A 5.1.6 Per Reference 7.1, the Sensor Power Supply Effects (PSEs) are given as less than + 0.005% span per 1 Volt change. Per reference 7.3, the power supplies for the sensors are regulated to within +5 VDC. Therefore, the sensor Power Supply Effect (PSEs) is given as:
PSEs = + (0.005% Span / VDC) (5 VDC)
PSEs = + 0.025% Span Per Reference 7.3, uncertainties less than +/- 0.05% are considered negligible, therefore:
PSEs = N/A Page 7 of 14
.CCN-IC-02004 CCN-IC-02004 Revision 00 Revision Page 7 of 14
BG&E Calculation CA00800, Revision I 5.1.7 Per Reference 7.1, the Sensor Temperature Effect (TEs) is given as +/-0.0125%
Upper Range Limit (URL) plus 0.0625% Span per 50'F change.. Per Reference 7.4, the maximum and minimum temperature of the turbine building (12ft elevation) are 123°F and 60°F (design minimum). Therefore, the maximum change in temperature (AT) from calibration to operating temperature is 63°F.
The calibrated span of these sensors is 2000 PSIG (reference 7.2) and the URL is 2000 PSIG (reference 7.1). Therefore, the Sensor Temperature Effect (TEs) is given as:
TEs = +/-((0.0125%
- 2000) + 0.0625% Span (63 AT)
Tý 2000 PSI 50 AT)]
TEs = +/- 0.09% Span Page 8 of 14 CCN-IC-02004 CCN-IC-02004 Revision 0 Revision 0 Page 8 of 14
BG&E Calculation CA00800, Revision 1 5.2 PROCESS MEASUREMENT EFFECT CONSIDERATIONS Per Reference 7.8, these transmitters are located 85 inches below the process pipe tap. Per Reference 7.2, a + 3 PSIG offset is calibrated into these transmitters. Per Reference 7.3, the minimum calibration temperature is 68*F. Per Reference 7.3, Process Measurement Effect is a single sided bias (PMEb) calculated using the following equation:
PMEb -
A2000 (hO,-Pc),100%
k.144 Span))
where, h = height of sensing line
= 85 inches = 7.08 feet pN = sensing line fill fluid density during normal operation
= 61.87048 Ibm/ft3 @ 123"F, 1100 psia Pc = sensing line fill fluid density during calibration
= 62.53402 Ibm/ft3 @ 68"F, 1100 psia NOTE: The factor 144 is used to convert from lbf/ft2 to lbf/in 2 . At standard gravity, Ibm may be replaced with lbf.
Therefore, PMEb = -0.00 16% Span Per Reference 7.3, uncertainty terms that are < 0.05% Span have a negligible effect on calculation results, and may therefore be disregarded. Thus:
PMEb = N/A Revision 00 Page 9 of 14 CCN-IC-02004 Revision Page 9 of 14
BG&E Calculation CA00800, Revision I 5.3 PLANT COMPUTER CONSIDERATIONS DEVICE: Computer Products, Inc. [7.5]
DAS Multiplexer Plant Computer POINT ID NUMBER: P4490 [7.7]
P4495 SPAN: 0 to 1.28 VDC [7.5]
5.3.1 Per Reference 7.5, the reference accuracy of the computer is given as
+/- 0.12626 % Span. For conservatism, this calculation will use a value of
+/- 0.15 % Span for the computer Reference Accuracy term (RAc). Therefore, RAc +0.15 %Span 5.3.2 Per Assumption 6.1, the computer setting tolerance (STc) is equal to the value of the computer reference accuracy, RAc. Therefore, STc =_0.15 %Span 5.3.3 For conservatism, and to provide flexibility in the choice of test equipment, the computer Measurement and Test Equipment Effect (MTEc) is set equal to the Setting Tolerance (STc) of the computer. Therefore, MTEc + 0.15 %Span 5.3.4 Per Reference 7.5, the computer temperature effect is given as +/- 0.50 % Range per 100 0 F. Per Reference 7.5, the range of the computer is 0 to 1.28 volts and the span is 0.2 to 1.0 volts. The computer is located adjacent to the control room and is considered to have the same temperature profile as the control room. Per Reference 7.6, the maximum AT for the control room envelope is given as 100 F.
Thus, the computer Temperature Effects (TEc) are given as:
TEe = +/- 1(0.50% Span)(1.28 volts)/(0.8 volts)](10 0 F/100°F)
TEc =_ 0.08%Span 5.3.5 Per Reference 7.5, the computer Power Supply Effect (PSEc) is not applicable.
Therefore, PSEc = N/A CCN-IC-02004 Revision 0 Page 10 of 14
BG&E Calculation CA00800, Revision I 5.3.6 Per Reference 7.5, the computer Drift uncertainty (DRc) is given as +/- 0.05 %
Range for a period of 6 months. Expressing the drift term in
% Span yields a drift value of+/- 0.08 % Span for a period of 6 months (0.05%*(1.28/0.8)). The drift for a period of 30 months is calculated per Reference 7.3. Therefore, the computer Drift uncertainty (DRc) is given as:
DRc = +/-:[(30 months/6 months)*(0.08 % Flow Span)"]'r DRc =+/-0.18% Span 6.0 ASSUMPTIONS 6.1 Computer Setting Tolerance (STc) is assumed to be bounded by the conservative value used for computer reference accuracy (Section 5.3.1).
7.0 REFERENCES
7.1 BGE Vendor Technical Manual VTM # 12904-017, Model 3051C Smart Pressure Transmitter, Revision 4 Rosemount, Inc. Manual 00813-0100-4001, "Model 3051 Smart Pressure Transmitter Family", August 1996 (Excerpts in Attachment A) 7.2 BGE Master Calibration Date Sheets:
COMPONENT REVISION I-PT-4490 2 I-PT-4495 2 2-PT-4490 2 2-PT-4495 3 7.3 Calvert Cliffs Engineering Standard ES-028, "Instrument Loop Uncertainty and Setpoint Methodology", Revision 1.
7.4 ES-014, "Summary Of Ambient Environmental Conditions", Revision 1 UFSAR Chapter 9, Table 9-18, Revision 26 7.5 BGE Calculation 1-90-174i Revision 0, "Device Uncertainty Calculation; Plant Computer; 4-20 Input Points" 7.6 OI-22F, "Control Room and Cable Spreading Rooms Ventilation", Revision 22.
Page iiofl4 CCN-IC-02004 Revision 0 Revision 0 Page I11 of 14
BG&E Calculation CA00800, Revision I 7.7 Loop Diagrams BGE Drawing 60920 Sh. 15, Rev. 6 BGE Drawing 60920 Sh. 15A, Rev. 6 BGE Drawing 62622 Sh. 15, Rev. 4 BGE Drawing 62622 Sh. 15A, Rev. 4 7.8 Drawing, 12507A-0001 "Feedwater Pump Discharge", Revision 21 Drawing, 13519A-0001 'Teedwater Pump Discharge", Revision 15 Drawing, 13519A-0002 "Feedwater Pump Discharge", Revision 12 8.0 IDENTIFICATION OF COMPUTER CODES None CCN-IC-02004 Revision 0 Page 12 of 14
BG&E Calculation CA00800, Revision 1 9.0 CALCULATION 9.1 TOTAL DEVICE UNCERTAINTIES 9.1.1 SENSOR TOTAL DEVICE UNCERTAINTY The normal uncertainties associated with the sensor (normal TDUs) are calculated as follows:
TDUs=+/- VRAs' + STs' +MTEs' + DRs" +TEs 2 TDUs = +/-0.45% Span 9.1.2 PLANT COMPUTER TOTAL DEVICE UNCERTAINTY The normal uncertainties associated with the computer point (normal TDUc) are as follows:
TDUc=:+/- VRAc' +STc' +MTEc 2 +DRc 2 +TEc' TDUc = +/- 0.33% Span 9.2 TOTAL LOOP UNCERTAINTIES 9.2.1 TOTAL LOOP UNCERTAINTY AT TRANSMITTER OUTPUT The total loop uncertainty at the transmitter output (TLUs) is equal to the Total Device Uncertainty 6f the sensor (TDUs). Results are presented in units of %
Span and PSIG (based on a span of 2000 PSIG).
TLUs = TDUs = +/- 0.45% Span TLUs (PSIG) +/-0.45% Span
- 2000 PSIG 100% Span +/- 9.00 PSIG 9.2.2 TOTAL LOOP UNCERTAINTY AT PLANT COMPUTER The total loop uncertainty at the plant computer (TLUc) is determined by combining the Total Devices Uncertainties for the sensors and the plant computer as follows. Results are presented in units of % Span and PSIG (based on a span of 2000 PSIG).
TLUC = +/- -FTDUsz +TDUc2 %Span TLUc = +/- 0.56% Span TLUc (PSIG) - +/- 0.56% Span
BG&E Calculation CA00800, Revision 1
10.0 CONCLUSION
S This calculation has determined the following Total Device Uncertainty values:
10.1 Feedwater Discharge Pressure Transmitters (Span = 2000 PSIG)
TDUs = - 0.45% Span = +/- 9.00 PSIG 10.2 Plant Computer Points for Feedwater Pump Discharge Pressure (Span = 2000 PSIG)
TDUc = +/-0.33% Span = +/- 6.60 PSIG This calculation has determined the following Total Loop Uncertainty value:
10.3 Plant Computer Indication of Feedwater Pump Discharge Pressure (Span = 2000 PSIG)
TLUc = +/-0.56% Span 11.20 PSIG Page 14 ofl4 CCN-IC-02004 Revision 0 Revision 0 Page 14 of 14
BG&E Calculation CA00800, Revision I ATTACHMENT A Page 1 of 2 00813-0100-4001 English August 1996 Model 3051 Smart Pressure Transmitter Family ROSEMOUNT" MEASUREMENT FISHER-ROSEMOUNTf Managing The Process Better:
CCN-IC-02004 Revision 0
BG&E Calculation CA00800, Revision I ATTACHMENT A Page 2 of 2 Rosemount Inc.
Temperature Umits (continued) Performance Specifications Process Atatmosphedc pressures and above. (Zero-basedspans. referenceconditons, silicone oil fill. 316 SST isolatingdiaphragms,4-20 mA analogoutput, and digit! film values TABLE S.Model 3051 Temperature Limits. equal to the span setpoints.)
Silicone Fill SensoPq with Coplanar Range Accuracy with Traditional Flange :.40to 300'F(-40 to 149 *)'Z *0.075% of span.
with Level Range 12 Horizontal Mount -40 to 250 F (-40Oto 121 *C)0 ' :0.100% of span for Model 3051CD Range 1.
Vertical Mount -40 to 300 *F (-40 to 149 'Q wtth Model 305 Integral Manifold -40to 300 'F (-40to 1 49 *)ro Note Inert Fil Sen$oa") j0 to 185 "F (-18 to 85 "C)Ox') For spans less than 10:1 (15:1 for Model 3051CD Range 1) rangedown, accuracy =
DC.Iiticne200w') 1-40 to 375 'F (-40 to191 -C) +/-[o.025 + 0.005( Rn)]% of Span Inernl 1-6O to 350F (-46 to 177 C)
Neobee M-200) 10 to 375 "F (-18 to 191 "C)
Ambient Temperature Effect per 50 OF (28 *C)
+/-(0.0125% URL + 0.0625% span) spans from 1:1 to 10:1.
- illoone Fill Sensorl) t-40 to 250*F (-40 to 12 1*C)M
+/-0.025%UR + 0.125% span) spans from 10:1 to 10 0:1.
inert Fin Sensor2 ) 1-22 to 250"F (-W to 121"C)m Range 1: :(0.1% URL + 0.25% span).
Static Pressure Effect (Model 3051CD only)
SPicone Fill Serosa art 1-40 to 250'F (-40to 121 OC)() Zero Error (can be calibrated out at line pressure)
Inert Fil Sensor') 10 to 18S *F (-18 to 85 "C)W +/-0.1% of URI/1,000 psi (6.9 MPa) for line pressures from 0 to 2,000 psi (0 to 13.7 MPa).
t0.2%of URL/1,000 psi (6.9 MPa) for line Sylthentre XLT 1-100 to 300 'F (-73 to 149 'C) pressures above 2,000 psi (13.7 MPa).
D.C. Silicone 7040s) 160 to 600 "F (15 to 315 -C) Range 1: +/-10.25% of URI/1,000 psi (6.9 MPa).
D.C. Silicone 200 1-40 to 400 IF (.-40 to 205 "C) Span Error*
Inert 1-50 to 3W5*F (--4S to 177 1C) :0.2% of reading/1,000 psi (6.9 MPa).
Glycerin and Water 0 o20- -8t 93 'C) :0.4% of reading/I,000 psi (6.9 MPa) for Range 1.
Neobse M-200 10 to 400 IF (-18 to 205 *C)
- Range 4 and5: See manual forcalibrationprocedure.
Propylene Glycol and Wa*er 10 to 2C0 -F (-18 to 93 "C)
Sytenm SW0 1-50 to 400 IF(-45 to 205 *C) Total Performance" 1-4EW"
+/-0.25% ofspan for +/-50 'F (28 'C)temperature (1) Process temperaturesabove 185 `F (85 *CQrequirederating the changes, up to 1,000 psi (6.9 MPa) line pressure, ambientlimits by a 1.5:1 ratio (0.6:1 ratio for Mode32051H).
(2) 220 *F(104 C) limit In vacuum service; from 1:1 to 6:1 rangedown.
130 'F (54 1C) forpressuresbelow 0.5 psia. " Total Pidormanceis based on the combined orrorsof referenco (3) 160 *F(71 1C) Imit in vacuum service. accuracy.ambienttamperatureeffect andspan line pressure effect (4) Not availablefor Model 305 ICA.
(5) UpperimnitIs for seat assembliesmounted away from the Stability Improved!
transmitterwith the use of capillades. +/-0.25% of TRL for 5 years.
Range 1: +/-0.2% ofURL for 1year.
Humidity Limits Mounting Position Effect 0-100% relative humidity.
Zero shifts up to 2.5 inuT 20 (0.62 kPa), which can be Turn-on Time calibrated out. No span effect.
Performance within specifications less than 2.0 seconds after power is applied to transmitter.
Volumetric Displacement Less than 0.005 in 3 (0.08 cm3).
Damping Analog output response to a step input change is user-selectable from 0 to 36 seconds for one time constant. This software damping is in addition to sensor module response time.
15 Rcvision 0 CCN-IC-02004 Revision 0