ML071360096

Steam Generator Tube Inspection Report

ML071360096
Person / Time
Site:	Palo Verde
Issue date:	05/03/2007
From:	Hesser J Arizona Public Service Co
To:	Document Control Desk, NRC/NRR/ADRO
References
102-05698-JHH/DFH 2-SR-2006-001-00
Download: ML071360096 (38)

Text

Technical Specification 5.6.8 LA% A subsidiaryof Pinnacle West Capital Corporation John H. Hesser Mail Station 7605 Palo Verde Nuclear Vice President Tel: 623-393-5553 P0 Box 52034 Generating Station Nuclear Engineering Fax: 623-393-6077 Phoenix, Arizona 85072-2034 102-05698-JHH/DFH May 03, 2007 ATTN: Document Control Desk U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555-0001

Subject:

Palo Verde Nuclear Generating Station (PVNGS) Unit 2 Docket No. STN 50-529, License No. NPF-51, Steam Generator Tube Inspection Report Attached please find Special Report 2-SR-2006-001-00 prepared and submitted pursuant to Technical Specifications (TS) Reporting Requirement 5.6.8. This report discusses steam generator tube plugging in Unit 2 during its 1 3 th refueling outage.

By copy of this letter and the enclosure, this Special Report is being provided to the NRC Region IV Administrator and the PVNGS Resident Inspector.

No commitments are being made to the NRC by this letter.

If you have any questions, please contact Ray E. Buzard at (623) 393-5317.

Sincerely, JHH/REB/DFH/gat Attachment cc: (with attachment)

B. S. Mallett NRC Region IV Regional Administrator M. T. Markley NRC NRR Project Manager G. G. Warnick NRC Senior Resident Inspector for Palo Verde A member of the STARS (Strategic Teaming and Resource Sharing) Alliance Callaway

• Comanche Peak 9 Diablo Canyon 9 Palo Verde e South Texas Project e Wolf Creek A40'-/7

Attachment Unit 2 - 1 3 th Refueling Outage Steam Generator Eddy Current Examination Special Report No. 2-SR-2006-001-00

Attachment Unit 2 - 1 3 th Refueling Outage Steam Generator Eddy Current Examination Special Report No. 2-SR-2006-001-00

M U

Palo Verde Nuclear Generating Station UNIT2 U2R13 ARIZONA PUBLIC SERVICE P. O. BOX 52034 PHOENIX, AZ 85072 Prepared by: Date: '1-26-0 b

Reviewedby: -1 o *-/* Date: /

(I Approved by: Report Date: t' eO.-7 Commercial Service Date: 9-19-86

INDEX 1.0

SUMMARY

2.0 ORIGINAL EXAMINATION PLAN 3.0 CONDITION MONITORING ASSESSMENT 4.0 EXAMINATION RESULTS 5.0 EXAMINATION TECHNIQUES and EQUIPMENT 6.0 REPAIR TECHNIQUES and EQUIPMENT APPENDIX A - TUBE SUPPORT DIAGRAM, LEGEND, and CODES APPENDIX B - SG 21

SUMMARY

DATA SHEETS APPENDIX C - SG 22

SUMMARY

DATA SHEETS APPENDIX D - PLI and PLP DATA SHEETS APPENDIX E - PLUG HISTORY and TUBE PLUG MAPS APPENDIX F - FORM NIS - 1

UNIT 2 STEAM GENERATOR EDDY CURRENT U2 R13 Refueling Outage 1.0 Summary This report is intended to satisfy the requirements of PVNGS Technical Specification 5.6.8 for the submittal of a Steam Generator Tube Inspection Report. The steam generator (SG) eddy current examination for the 13th refueling outage in Unit 2 (U2R13) was conducted during October 2006.

Mode 4 entry for Unit 2 Cycle 14 was entered on November 7, 2006. The initial examination plan, for both steam generators, is listed in Table 1. This table summarizes the examinations performed for each of the various categories, examination types, extents, and the number of tubes or tube locations completed.

Based on a 100% eddy current examination of both steam generators, the only active damage mechanism identified was volumetric tube degradation (fretting wear) resulting from tube to tube support interaction.

The examinations resulted in a total of 14 tubes being plugged in SG 21, and 17 tubes being plugged in SG 22. A description of the plugging history for these replacement steam generators is contained in Appendix E along with tube plug maps illustrating the plug locations for this outage.

2.0 Original Examination Plan The original examination plan was developed based on the "PVNGS Steam Generator Degradation Assessment" as specified in PVNGS Procedure 81DP-9RCO1 and required by NEI 97-06. In addition, possible damage mechanisms were reviewed along with the specific requirements set forth in Procedure 73TI-9RC01 and the PVNGS Technical Specifications. The examination plan is summarized in Table 1 of this report.

3.0 Condition Monitoring Assessment Per the Steam Generator Program, as defined in PVNGS Procedure 81DP-9RC01, a condition monitoring evaluation was conducted by PVNGS Engineering. The results indicated that the steam generator tube integrity performance criteria were satisfied for Unit 2 Cycle 13. All defects exceeding the Technical Specification repair limits or the PVNGS Administrative Plugging criteria were removed from service. The only tubes exceeding PVNGS Technical Specification and Administrative plugging limits were found in a region around the stay cylinder and at either the Batwing (BW) or Vertical Strap (VS3) supports (see Appendix A). This active degradation mechanism is denoted as BWSC in the plugging data sheets provided in Appendix E.

The eddy current results were reviewed with respect to the steam generator performance criteria specified in PVNGS Technical Specification 5.5.9. No tubes were found to exceed the performance criteria integrity limits. The examination results were also compared to pre-outage predictions. The U2 Cycle 13 Operational Assessment had predicted a maximum though-wall depth for Batwing related tube degradation of 48% based on a beginning of cycle (BOC) value of 18%. The deepest indication found during U2R13 was a 49% wear (as measured by Plus Point) in Tube R43C1 12 in SG 22. As such, the prediction was fundamentally accurate and the 20% administrative plugging criterion applied to Batwing degradation in the Stay Cylinder Region was validated.

Although not identified as active degradation, it should be noted that four (4) tubes were preventatively plugged as a consequence of foreign objects. Three (3) tubes in SG 22 were plugged based on wear indications attributed to a foreign object. Both eddy current and FOSAR (visual inspection) results indicated that the object was removed and no longer at the location. The wear indications were classified as volumetric indications (SVIs) and the affected tubes were preventatively plugged and staked (See Table 2). The fourth location was in SG 21. Eddy current examination revealed a potential foreign object (PLP) on a periphery tube (R58C7) in the free-span above the 08C tube support. No tube degradation (wear) was identified. The location could not be accessed for visual confirmation. PVNGS elected to preventatively plug and stake the affected tube as a conservative measure.

The condition monitoring assessment concluded that no tube integrity issues existed in the Unit 2 steam generators, and based on an overall comparison of projected versus actual results for Cycle 13, there were no identified cycle length limitations for U2 Cycle 14. No in situ pressure tests or tube pulls were performed nor required. As such, the Condition Monitoring Assessment concluded that there were no Mode 4 entry restraints.

4.0 Examination Results A summary of the bobbin and rotating coil (RC) examination results is located in Table 2 of this report. In addition, Appendix A contains a reference drawing of steam generator support locations.

The summary data sheets of Appendices B and C list all tubes in each steam generator with indications expressed as a percent wall thickness reduction, or as an analysis code. Appendix D contains summary data sheets for tubes classified as possible loose parts.

5.0 Examination Techniques and Equipment The eddy current examinations were performed by Westinghouse Electric Company using Zetec MIZ-70 digital data acquisition instrumentation or the Core Star OMNI 200 instrumentation.

Westinghouse Anser acquisition software was utilized with both systems. The following frequencies were used for the tube examinations:

Bobbin Coil RC 500 KHz 300 KHz 300 KHz 200 KHz 100 KHz 100 KHz 35 KHz 35 KHz

Notes: For bobbin coil examinations these frequencies were utilized in both differential and absolute modes.

All tubing was examined with Zetec manufactured bobbin coil probes and Zetec RC style probes.

Bobbin probes manufactured by Core Star and TRC were also utilized. Probe diameters were 0.540" to 0.610". Plus Point RC probes were used for the detection and characterization of the volumetric indications. Data acquisition in both steam generators was facilitated by using Westinghouse Pegasys fixtures configured with either a quad or dual guide tube in each of the hot and cold legs.

Fiber optic cable was used from containment to the data acquisition room located at the PVNGS North Annex. Primary and secondary analysis was all performed on site. The Primary and Secondary Resolution Analysts, Independent Review Analysts, and data management were also located at PVNGS in the North Annex. Westinghouse provided the data acquisition and primary data analysis. Anatec International, Inc. provided the secondary data analysis.

Each individual from Westinghouse and Anatec International, Inc. who performed data analysis was required to complete and pass a PVNGS site specific Eddy Current Data Analysis Course as well as an associated performance examination with at least an 80% proficiency. All individuals performing data analysis were also required to have Qualified Data Analyst (QDA) certification.

6.0 Repair Techniques and Equipment All repairswere performed utilizing the Westinghouse mechanical rolled plug. The plugs were installed in accordance with the PVNGS work control process utilizing the Pegasys fixtures and associated remote plugging equipment.

TABLE 1 EXAMINATION

SUMMARY

SCOPE DESCRIPTION SG 21 SG 22 Exam Description Extents Scope Scope FULL LENGTH TEC-TEH 12355 12354 BOBBIN HOT STRAIGHT SECTION TEH-08H 261 319 BOBBIN

• COLD STRAIGHT SECTION TEC-08C 278 206 BOBBIN

• HOT STRAIGHT VARIOUS 34 31 RC HOT U & SQUARE BEND VARIOUS 91 68 RC COLD STRAIGHT VARIOUS 57 315 RC COLD U & SQUARE BEND VARIOUS 15 19 RC Notes:

1.

• Bobbin examinations were not performed on the short radius U-bends

TABLE 2 INDICATION

SUMMARY

DAMAGE STEAM GENERATOR STEAM GENERATOR MECHANISM 21 22 WEAR 0%- 100% 56 83 PLUGGED (13) (13)

Possible Loose Parts PLI 0 0 PLP 19 I1 PLUGGED (1) (0)

Volumetric Indications SVI/MVI 0 4 PLUGGED (0) (3)

• PREVENTATIVE (0) (1) **

PLUGGED U2R13 (14) (17)

TOTAL PLUGGED / % (33 / 0.3%) (37 / 0.3%)

NOTES

1. Numbers in (X) are tubes numbers plugged in each category

2. The above represent the numbers of tubes; not indications

3.

• 3 tubes were plugged based on PLP wear. No loose part was identified at the location

4. ** 1 tube was plugged to install a stabilizer adjacent to a plugged, but not stabilized Batwing stay cylinder tube.

APPENDIX A TUBE SUPPORT DIAGRAM, LEGEND, and ANALYSIS CODES

PVNGS Steam Generator REPLACEMENTS Center of 08H to 08C Row I - 17.415 Row 2 - 19.736 Row 3 - 22.056 Row 4 - 24.377 Row 5 - 26.698 Row 6 - 29.019 I I

LEGEND ROW: Indicates the row number of a given tube.

COL: Indicates the column number of a given tube.

VOLTS: Indicates the peak-to-peak voltage of a given indication response.

DEG: The measured phase angle of a given indication response.

IND: Indicates the analysis code or PCT for percent PCT: The percent through the tube wall of a given indication CHN: Indicates the channel used to measure and evaluate the referenced indication LOCN: Gives indication location at INCH1 to INCH2 relative to known landmarks such as supports, vertical straps, and batwings. Typical location codes are as follows:

1. 1 Vertical Strap .......................... VS1

1. 1 Batwing .................................... BW 1

1. 1 Support Plate in Hot Leg .......... 01H

1. 7 Support Plate in Cold Leg ............. 07C Top Tube Sheet Cold Leg .................. TSC Tube End Hot Leg .............................. TEH Tube End Cold Leg ............................ TEC CRLEN: Indicates the flaw length BEGT and ENDT: Indicates the beginning and end of the test; together they document the examination extent PDIA: Documents the probe diameter PTYPE: The last two characters indicates the probe type used for examination MF-bobbin coil mid-frequency (Zetec)

WR-bobbin coil mid-frequency (Westinghouse Replaceable)

SF-bobbin coil spring flex HP or HZ-RC +point solid body FP or FZ-RC +point,. 115 flexible MZ- +point flexible modular MB-RC mag bias +point PH-RC +point HF and MF flexible for UBends CAL: Indicates calibration number L: Indicates the leg the examination was conducted from COM: This comment field is utilized to document the UTIL1 and UTIL2 sizing measurements and APS Level III comments

Analysis CODES:

Absolute Drift ..................................................................... A DI Apex Anom aly .................................................................... APA After Pressure Test .............................................................. APT Bad Data ............................................................................ BDA Bulge ................................................................................... BLG Deposit ................................................................................ DEP Dent from History ............................................................... DN H Dent ..................................................................................... DNT Distorted Support Signal W ith Indication ........................... DSI DSI from History ................................................................ DSH Distorted Top of Tubesheet With Indication ....................... DTI Geom etric Indication ...................................................... G EO ID Chatter ........................................................................... IDC Indication N ot Found .......................................................... IN F Indication N ot Reportable ................................................... IN R Location N ot Correct .......................................................... LN C M ultiple Volum etric Indication ........................................... MVI N o Detectable Defect .......................................................... N DD N o Discontunity Found ....................................................... N DF Non-Quantifiable Indication .......................... NQI N o Tube Sheet Expansion ................................................... N TE Obstructed ........................................................................... OBS Previous Bobbin Call .......................................................... PBC Positive Identification ......................................................... PID Positive Identification Verified ........................................... PIV Possible Loose Part with Indication .................................... PLI Possible Loose Part ............................................................. PLP Previous RC Call ................................................................. PRC Possible Support Anom aly .................................................. PSA Possible Support Indication ................................................ PSI Retest W ith 3 coil Probe ................................................. R3C Retest Identification Check ................................................. RID Retest with M agnetic Bias RC Probe .................................. RM B Single Volum etric Indication .............................................. SVI Sludge ................................................................................. SLG To Be Plugged .................................................................... TBP Util2 CODES:

Batwing W rapper Bar W ear ................................................ BW W Change .......................................................................... CH Data Quality Acceptable ..................................................... DQA History Review ............................................................... HR Inside Diam eter ............................................................... ID NEW ................................................................................... N EW No Change ..................................................................... NC N o Loose Part Present ......................................................... N LP Manufacturing Induced Groove .......................................... M IG Manufacturing Abnorm ality ................................................ LAP Outside D iam eter .......................................................... OD Pit like indication ................................................................ PIT Stake ............................................................................... SK Senior Level III Review ................................................. SR Tube to Tube W ear ............................................................. TTW Volum etric Inside Diameter ................................................ VID

APPENDIX B STEAM GENERATOR 21

SUMMARY

DATA SHEETS

36 - t1 PerCentl Calts Palo Verde 2 UZR13 PV63.: :006160L ,I420.Z'S6 081:90:43 RON ....COL . .......... VOLTS ÷....CEO. .... TNO. ....PER . CNN INCHI LOCN *..........÷......... INCMZ* ORLEN BEG? ENDT PDIA PTYPI CAL L CON 4..... ---.. ..... . ........ *....-. ..... 9...... . ...... 4....... .***---..1

,& s 06 116 Ds" 5 PI V33 -. 79 TEC TEN .619 =.AO 14 N 1 58 69 38 115 DaO 11 P11 3101 81 TIC TEN .010 -'BA.C 5o NJ 58 69 64 75 PCT 10 P3 BU1 86 Gem4 V,3 .580 TPUF" 76 NI 64 71 30 104 DO! 10 PI V33 35 TEC TEN .010 ZA4.C 56 NJI 64 71 1 11 73 PCT 16 P3 V33 .53 Vt3 V83 .590 ZPUFP 76 NjI 37 8s 3: 130 DO! 10 P1 Buz - B0 TEC TIN .010 48AZC a N jI 37 00 7"1 64 PCT 13 P3 8442 -1 09 008C W3 .560 ZPUF: 80 Cj 33 82 .26 116 0D3 11 P1 8N41 -. 89 TEC TEN1 .010 3.BACC 8 NJI 33 82 1 L1 68 PCT 18 P3 B101 -. 99 984 '483 .580 :PUF: 76 HICOAI 35 82 .25 125 D3! 1 P1 Bal 1 07 TEC TEN .010 Z3A4C B Hg 35 82 80 73 PCT 1i Pa Bail 52 SON V23 .580 -"PUF" 7 NJI 34 as 50 170 DO! 21 P1 B941 -1 00 TEC TIN .010 47AZ 8 aN 34 83 .39 117 DO! 14 P1 BaIl 04 TEC TEN .619 8 s "1 34 83 1.83 66 PCT 24 P3 Bail - 8, 084 VW33 .580 ZPUF. 76 Nj 134 83 1 8C 69 PCT 24 P3 Bil 91, 0854 W83 .580 ZPUFr 70 NjI 36 85 1 95 102 DO! 43 P1 8l1 - 87 TEC TEN .619 'BA.C 7 NJI 38 85 3 48 63 PCT 38 P3a 91 -0 5 085 .33 .500 T.PUF' 70 NJI 4L 88 .34 110 D3O 13 PL 811 -. 98 TEC TEN .019 ZA84C B NJ I 41 80 1.98 83 PCT 15 P3 B9I - 87 094 .#3 .580 ZPUF: 70 NI 42 80 36 110 DO! 14 P1 V43 85 TEC TEN .6109 ZBA.C NjI 45 8a 1.52 09 PCT 21 P3 V33 83 403 V33 .580  :-PUF; 70 NJI 46 87 .3 1260 D31 13 PL V33 76 TEC TIN .610 :8:A0 0 NI 73 PCT L1 P3 23 -79 Vt)3 .33 .580 :PUP2 76 Hj 46 87 1.19 43 92 .56 99 031 23 PL 3m2 -. 88 TEC TEN .619 3BAZC: 5 1 43 92 71 74, PCT 13 P3 V43 -1.02 0 was33 .500 PUFP as CjI 43 02 1.04 78 PCT 18 P3 94B1 - 98 SOC l83 .5890 :PU: 00 Cj 45 92 4, 133 D31 15 PI Bail - 94 TC TEN .619 2.BAC 5 Nj 45 92 .96 74 PCT 14 P3 941 - 081 Sa6 433 .500 ZPUF: 78 HI 47 92 .50 100 DO! 23 P11 82 - 78 TEC TIN .801 BA4.O s NgI 47 92 91 72 PCT 18 P3 842 -78 0OC V33 .500 :PFu a: CCJ 44 S3 84 117 DO1 27 PL Be1 - 92 TEC TEN .610 ZBA9C 5 "j 44 93 2.68 88 PCT 32, P3 8ow1 - .025 995 23. .500 ZPUFP 78 NI 44 93 05 72 PCT 19 P3 91 19 I0 0054 433 .580 ZPUF" 7 NJI 48 93 44 75 DZ! z9 P1 8411 1 01 TEC TEN .010 34:0C 25 "1 48 93 18 117 DOI 19 Pl V33 .8 TEC TEN .619 3. C 5 Nj 4,8 93 687 67 PCT 20 P3 811 -. 8-2 085 433 .538 ZPUF" 70 HN 48 93 78 75 PCT 11 P3 8HZ 1.00 08a4 433 .500 :PUFP 76 Nj 48 93 79 03 PCT 10 P3 V33 93 08a4 833 .500 ZPUF: 70 N 47 94 .17 105 D3Z 9 Pl 8o1w -1 92 TIC TIN .619 73A.C 6 11 47 94 1: 02 0D1 7 PL 433 - 72 TEC TEN .6190 "-A: 6 Nj 47 8094 0 77 PCT 1: P3 ONZ - 92 065 ws33 .500 ZPUFZ 78k H 47 94 .85 66 PC? 1 P3s 433 79 08a .3. .500 'PUPF 70 HI 1,49 94 26 87 DO! 13 PL V43 70 TEC TEN .610 84AzC 0 NJ 49 94 12 4 65 PCT 17 P3 wa33 66 Vt3 433 .500 2PUF"P 76 NjI 49 90 38 136 D3H 13 P1 841 - 86 TEC TEN .610 Z9AZC 5 NJI 46 97 94 97 D3O 31 PL 8Z -86 TEC TIN .010 ZB-CC 5 NJ 46 97 17 83 D! 19 PL V43 I 01 TEC TEN .019 284-2C 5 NJI 46 ST 3 09 65 PCT 35 P3 8411 -. 78 0844 433 .580 TPUFZ 70 5nOi 46 97 1 04 04 PCT 15 P3 V33 19 SO 0854 33 .500 2PUFC 70 Nj I 45 ,83

.o so0 1, 27 P1 8ON1 - 94 TEC TIN .10 :Z4:0 0 j1 1 45 08 50 121 DO! 20 P1 942 - .5 TEC TIN .19 ZA8:C a NJ I 45 90 1.95 74 PCT 28 P3 B91 -1.91 9H wa33s .500 :PUFZ 77 Nj I ROW COL VOLTS CEO INC PER CNN LOCN INCHI 1NC142 CRLEN BEGT ENDT PDIA PTYPE CAL L CONI

as - :I Percent Calls Palo VUro e C UZR13 P1N0113.ZH81001 10.2" .H.040 08:98:43

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . t......... . . . . ..............

. . . . . . . ................... p I ROM COL VOLTZ DE8 IND PEP CNN LOON INONI 1NC12 C.LEN BEG. END? PO.A PTYPE CAL L CORI 6 ..--.................-............- +---------------------------------------- -

45 94 .84 77 PCT P3 S33 -1 25 O8C V83 .599 ZPUF" a0 C I 45 94 .95 70 PCT P3 V3) SOC W83 .580 ZPUF: s4 C I 45 98 ."0 73 POT P3 awr2 -1 15 .580 ZPUF" 80 C I SOC W3S 47 94 31 111 DZ! PI Owll 99 TEC TEN .010 ZOA8O 0 NJ 47 9s 18 01 D3C PI U33 90 TEC TEN .010 "8A.C 0 Hi 47 98 1069 71 PCT P3 owl 94 SON Y33 .580 ZPUFt 77 "1 47 99 58 05 PCI P3 V*3 04 9PON V53 .580 ZPUF2 77 ItI P1 V33 04 16L .70 113 03! P3 133 - 94 TEC TEN .010 TCA-"C 07 Nj 04 161 1 39 73 PCT - 97 t)3 W33 .580 2PUF: 77 HI PS US) 59 102 .35 114 DSH as TEC TEN .010 ZBAIC 00 Hg PI V33 68 143 03 129 D31 - ,.80 TEC TEN .019 OACOC 03 HN Pi V33 00 103 .49 168 D11! 1 01 TEC TEN .010 2tACC 83 HI 1 08 143 1.81 00 PCT P3 W33 - 91 VU3 V33 .580 ZPUF: 77 NH 00 163 1 28 00 PCT P3 V33 155 UVS3 V3 .580 TPUFZ 77 HI 55 1"0 ,18 105 CS! PL 8"1l 105 TEC TEN .010 28AZC 20 Nj P3 SUL 55 1"0 PC 72 PCT 1 00 S9N V33 .580 2PUF- 77 NJ 48 167 29 157 D3014 PI V33 - 82 TEC TEN .019 Z8AZC 19 HI 45 164 15 134 DS!1 - 80 TEC TEN .010 2.A3CC 19 Nj P1 US) 45 10 39 95 PCT P3 BK-2 - .91 00C U3S .580 ZPUF: Do C I PI SKI 49 144 10 120 0)3! PI awl - 76 TEC TEN .G0D Z8A:C 19 NIDOAI 46 146 1.33 72 PCT P3 owl - 75 DSO V53 .580 ZPUF: 77 Hj I PI BUS 47 110 +35 114 0S! PI U!) - 70 TEC TEN .010 M1A=C 20 Nj  :

47 110 2 78 73 PCT P3 BV1 - 88 08* US3 .590 2PUF2 77 HIDOAI 44 111 .3. 90 D31 - 71 TEC TEN .010 ZBAZCO 19 H 44 111 87 109 DCS PL BUI 78 TEC TEN .010 ZBA3C 19 Nj P3 SuZ 44 111 1.35 78 PCT - 89 118" V53 .580 21PUF 77 NJ I 44 111 238 G0 PCT P3 Sul 80 SON U83 .584 2PUF: 77 j 1 43 112 9-" so 031 *70 TIC TEN .010 z5AcC 19 Nj 43 112 .25 122 DC! PI Bwl 8O TEC TEN .019 ZBA2C 19 NJI 43 112 1.74 72 PCT P3 IOw. -85 ONk V33 .580 TPUFr 77 NJI P3 DM2 43 112 91 09 PCT 95 0884 S33 .580 2PUFZ 77 Nj 45 112 .10 112 D3C PI B1wl - 89 TEC TEN .010 2BAZC 19 Nj 45 112 .47 124 CS! TEC TEN .010 29A:C 19 Nj 45 112 .25 112 D3H - 07 TEC TEN .010 ZBA28C 9 NJ I P3 DM1 45 112 .78 80 PCT P1 BDI - .99 SOH V33 .380 -PUF: 77 NJ I 45 112 1.10 73 PCT P3 V33 99 @Oak U3S .580 'PU4F- 77 NJ I 45 112 .77 02 PCT - 72 0814 '53 .580 ZPUFZ 77 NJ 47 112 .35 125 !31 PI Bill - .88 TEC TEN .010 IBACC 19 HN g

47 112 3C 117 DCI PI V-33 - 75 TEC TEN .010 28A'CC 19 NJI P3 Dm12 47 112 I18 94S PCI P3 SKI - 90 SoN S3) .580 2PUFZ 77 Nj I 47 112 1 73 a8 PCT P3 U.33 - 73 58N US) .580 .PP 7N

.28 127 PI V33 TIC TEN .010 2DlAC 20 Nj 42 113 D3C - 92 US) U2, .580 ZPUFP 77 NJI 42 113 I 19 01 PCY P2 V,33 - 95 TEC TEN .010 9BACC 20 j 1 44 113 .37 81 CS! PI V23 - .94 P3 D3M US) US) .580 PUUF2 77 NJ 44 113 2.20 04 PCT - 86 TEC TEN .010 28CZC 20 H 1 47 114 .34 123 DCS PI 8kZ 99 47 114 35 00 PCT SOC V3S .580 ZPUF2 80 C I PI 8DM 40 115 22' 93 CS! -. 98 TEC TIN .019 2BA.C 20 Nj 44 115 .38 128 11N PI V33 82 TEC TEN .010 Z8A2C 20 Nj 40 115 32 137 D31 78 TEC TEN .810 ZOA'C 20 Nj1 P3 133 46 11L I t1 09 PCT 94 S)3 VOL .580 2TPUF2 77 Nj 43 118 28 133 ,3S 11 P1 D1M 91 TEC TEN .010 ZAZO 19 Nj

• --------------------------------------------------+... ....... 4- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ....

I RON COL VOLT: DEG IWO PEP CNN LOON IHCHN INC.Z CRILEN BEGT ENOT PO!A PTYPE CAL L CORI

..-.......- -..-.. +- .......... -.......-..-.........

36 - CI Porcon Caltl Palo Vbrd. 2 UZ+/-113 PVHOCZ :m"0109o 1+/-e+/-,":914n *8:N:43 IRON COL VOLTT DEG IND PER CNN LOCH INCHI 1NCINZ C8ILEI BEBT MNOT POIA PTYPE CAL L COMj 43 116 0a. 00 PCT 11 P3 8132 16 leCc va-3 .580 ZPUr: 80 CI A8 117 16 105 O,21 12 PI W33 -1 11 TEC TEN .610 Z1ACC 17 HI 45 118 85 124 03! 29 P1 BDMl 77 TEC TEN .010 ZBA=C 17 HJI 45 116 1.70 71 PCT 24 P3 BWD 02 0DN W33 .560 ZPUF: 77 Nj 47 118 48 99 DT! 18 PI DM1 74 TEC TEN .610 8ZCC 20 HI I 47 118 1 51 71 POT *21 P3 DM1 08 0OD V23 .580 "PUF: 77 H1 40 118 .47 96 O!a 18 PI DM1 83 TEC TIN .010 Z84:0 20 1410GAI 4, 18 1 0" 7. PCT +/-3 P3 BD1 81 aDN 'W33 .580 .PUMFw .7 HI 85 118 44 1I1 OS! 7 P1 Dm1 95 TEN TEC .610 Z2A:C 70 C1 I 05 110 .78 07 PCI 1-2 P3 DM1 84 094 Vat .580 ZPUFZ 77 HI 36 119 91 01 DOS 24 PI W33 -1 07 TEC TEN .010 ZBA:C 17 HI I 30 119 1 90 73 POT +/-6 P3 V33 - 32 VS3 V33 .560 ZPUF: 77 HI I 38 Ill 1334 DOST 14 PI V33 -1 05 TEC TEI .610 ZBA: C 1" NJI 38 119 .8:- 75 POT 14 P3 V33 - 78 VI3 V33 .580 "PUFI 77 HI 35 120 31 30 D,! I: P1 DM2t - 82 TEC TEN .010 ZBACC 17 HI I 45 162 4C 123 D=1 13 PI V13 -1 01 TEC TEN .610 .A8C ID NJ H I 45 1:0 1517 05 PCT +/-. P3 V33 - 83 VI3 V33 .580 IPUF" 77 Hi I 47 120 44 1+/-5 031 14 P1 133 -1 00 TIC TEN .610 ZBA"C 18 NJ I 47 1+/-0 10.8 09 PCT .5 P3 V33 -1.00 V83 V33 .580 ZPUFZ 77 H" 1 38 121 53 129 DSH 10 P V-33 75 TIC TEN .010 ZBA-C i HI NJ 154 1+/-1 +/-2 141 D3! 9 PI V32 73 TEC TEN .610 Z1A8C .41 Hj 154 121 0 06 s PCT 10 P3 V32 80 Ve2 Vat .580 ZPUF 77 HI I 161 132 52 107 DOS! +/-3 Pi 131 Do TEC TEI .010 1BA-C 43 HI I 101 132 23 84 OS! 13 PI V34 88 TEC TEN .810 ZBACC 43 HI 101 132 1.77 70 PCT 24 P3 V11 9+/- V8+/- Val .560 ZPUF: 77 NI 101 +/-32 7-7 71 POT 14 P3 V.14 1 14 V94 V&4 .580 "PUFZ 80 Cj I 101 134 22 37 DOS 8 PI V31 88 TEC TEN .010 184:0 44 HI 101 134 +/- 125 DOS! 7 PI VZ3 80 TEC TEN .010 3BA8'C 44 HI 101 134 1 22 71 POT 17 P3 Val 84 Wei Vol .580 ZPUF1 77 HI 161 134 95 73 PCT 17 P3 V35 1 14 V25 W85 .580 ZPUFr: so CI 34 137 18 A1 DS! 0 PI "H - 09 TEC TEN .18D BAC. 22 HI 34 137 .04 81 POT 12 P3 DON - 78 CoN 0dM .60 IP2N: 73 HA RON COL VOLT. 0C6 INC PER CHN LOCO INCHI INCH.2 CLENI BEGT KNOT P0IA PTYPE CAL L CONI

- - 4- - .. --..

.... .. .. .. .. .. . 4 -...

Tubes:;50 RiCofdS: 136 3

APPENDIX C STEAM GENERATOR 22

SUMMARY

DATA SHEETS

. --+/-2 Percent calls Palo Verde 2 U11813 PV8*,02 20601016 19.26.+/-N8o w843 45 1 IO0 COL VOLT3 DES TWO PER CNN LOCH 2N*'1I NC08 CORLENBEST £N8T P81A PTVPE CAL LI C0M 4- ---4,-- - - - -- --------- ,--

35 1 .28 125 Ot1 19 PI mN .86 TEN "EC .610 :94:0 11 Cl 84 :9 13 1"1 D.al .96 TEN TEC :B420 30 Cl V22

+/-1 315 78 POT .83 882 .589

.610 -PUF-" NJ Doe 34 22 138 Del 980 -1.00 TEN TEC T'BA-C Cl 90 ZBA:: 19 I51 34 17 13',. O:1 V33 .112 TEN TEC .OLD 15 Cl

94:C Dow .,10 Cl 41 16 75 Del 35.60 TEN TEC 26 GI 9PUF:

137 48 65 07 #i! 4.52 821 832 .580 61 NI LAP 110 -1.06 152 .27 1+/-8 Del TEN TEC ZBAZC 34 Cl s5 11c 152 45 69 POT -1.01 110 11C .008 7o 01004

.ale 57 - .78 36 CI 113 19 V33 TEN TEC I118 35 Cl 57 Is 115 Del V3+/- TEN TEC .010 Z-BA:C

.77 .90 57 77 POT 83+/- C22 61 NJ

.589

.380 52 44 132 08] V33 .63 TEN lis 66 04 B7 72- POT 1133 .58 "23 01 NJ T22 . 810 :8CC 823 --PUFZ NJ 28 76 Del V33 , 74 TEC TEN 1 78 POT .7, E33 5*80 01 TEC .6010

.Ale ZBAZC 66 156 08 +/-6 081[ BtlZ :pnc "I TEC TEN 38 S31 as I156 60 78 POT V" :94:0 W,, NJ

-.PUF" 1158 0G 131 081 WZL I"C TEN 38 V31 .51 81 NI 150 83 POT 38 9S 110 Va3 .500 ZBA:'C 101 138 081 V33 .90 TEC . al e 37 NJ 77 TEN HN 161 79 POT V83 .51 V83 6l

+/-4 110 *"PUF:

14 73 147 D08 BWZ .900 TEC TEN .010 38 I 04 71 74 POT was 86 CI 821 .380 ZPUFZ ZB:ZC 101 I161 76 141 031 W31 - .03 TEC TEN 5010 .PU4F0 38 NJ 161 76 .91 72c POT -.-41070 29420 61 NJ 7I MBAZO

• 33 9l*4 -. 87 TEC 3 57 TEN NI

&S al 84 -PCT 823

.76 ZPMw:

d8 84 77 58 081 V32 *70 TEC TEN 6010 13 84 67 T.PtJ* NJ 77 77 POT V82 @8N TEC1 .580 6l NI

• 133 5300 NJ 34 60 081 - .84 TEC TEN :BAZC 3 NI 69 *5891 30 101 08!Z BW12 - .84 TEC TEN ZEU*ZC 3 81 23UF" NI 30 93 POT -. 60 V23 61 NI

+/-2 91 ZP9:0 30 81 75 POT wi2 - .84 W23 :Buv: 8s Cl al so w83 :BAZC 18 8.I 73 081 -. 94 TEN .010 go 81 79 POT W22 9*4+/- -. 73 823 .610 61 0NO .580 HIDD aw4l - .85 90*8 37 84 61. 74 Dal TEC TEC TEN ,580 "*BAZC I 37, 84 .54 "8+/-3 86 POT -. 88 61 233 .589 38 .38 V13 TEC 85 64 0Do TEN :BA9C 3 36 .2 .589 38 85 69 08! v*2 .87 TEN .610 3 1.00 "6 POT W23 as 38 79 POT 8142 -. 72 TEC ale3 -.PUFI- Cj as E33 Cl 47 88 27 V83 113 081i -. 95 TEN ZBAZO NJ 142 8 .38 128 Dl 19 PI awl - .87 TEC TEN .81: ZAZ: 3 NI 422 88 101 POT 1Z P3 9*1 -. 70 am814 3 .360 ZPPFU 61 NJ 4I 80 51 1+/-: 081 15 PI B*1 .71 TEC TEN .619 ZBA:4: 3 HN 48 89 1 18 79 POT = P3 94I .77 IN M8253 .ow 61 aM:

48 80 1 6 116 0D! 33 P1 DWI .06 TEC TEN .010 9 A9Z4 3N j 48 80 1.82 731 PT 30 P3 9*I .89 BI1 823 .580Mw: Ol NI 132 80 53 1360 081 1. PL 833 -. 97 TEC TEN 6 94g0AZ. 47 NJ 132 80 09 8o POT 18 P3 V33 -. 013 V83 M3 .589 :PU'Z 01 HI I RON C00 VOLT. DE0 IND PIR C1N LOCN 1NC*i IN= CR1EN BEST ENOT POIA PTYPE CAL L C004 4 - - -........-..-..-.-.. . . . . ..... .. .. .. .. -.. .. .. .. .. .. . .. .. .. .. .. .. . .. .. .. .- -. .. .

Se - `2 Percent Calls PANo Verda 2 UY3It PVNB2 2N0+/-01 10:20i,20 W8:43 45

.. . . . .+. . . . . . . . . . . . . -..........

..... . . .+..........

ROM COL VOLTS DES IND PER CNN LOON 1NCH41 IMCM2 CRLEN BEST KNDO PO1A PTYPE CA., L COM  :

-........ .......--.--......... ............. #.-......... ..... .. 4- - -

18 8a 4- 10 Dal P1 DM2 .91 TEO TEN .010 :AZC 8B .71 B-Z POT P3 BD2 .91 11C Wn .380 -BAZC 08

- .88 TEC TEN .010 4j 94 3 41 98 Cel :PUF:

Z".32 .80 TEC TEN .010 Ale 41 4.34 Ila oat :BAZC 41 90 64 PCT P31 M1 -. 79 V03 ZPUF 41 .550 DBCC

.05 S7 POT .10 "m

-41 94 P3 DlM 08M Yea3 90 3.17 09 POT .7.9 3580 41 P3 DM41 TEN I.. 47 08D TEC .010 90 1.80 113 41 90 70 POT P3 PI ow4l 8WL -. 79 .358 T£N TEN Val 90 33 98 Dal TEC .019 4, 90 73 01 POT PI BMil 35" TEN 45 91 1.04 94 Del P1 BDl -. 14 TEC TEN .010

.015 4, 91 70 107 Del TEO M.AZC 47 91 2 13 73 P3 eml V23*

POT --PUFf.

91 +/- 33 75 Pa B"il .89 V93 .380 ZPLJP-42 PCT 144 Pl Swii .94J

- -3.1 TEN 44 91 PI" 08D TEC 91 .90 P3 Bmi -. 94 VTa 44 POT P3 DM1 .380 91 POT .83 YVa ZBAZC 44 .5`2 --. .a4 89J 92 B3 Del PI P1 SMil DM1

- . SB: TEC TEN

.010 :tcc

- .80 .580 :PUv:

ZPUF:

92 .4, 3: POT TaE Vt3 ZBAZ.

P3 BMId AT .010 38 99 - .90 TEC 48 92 0I1 PI DM1 w4 104 * .890 amN TEN .580 92 POT Vt3 P3 Bill ZBAZ.C 93 40 110 .73 TEC TEN .a01 44 BIl Dal 93 78 POT 73 am14 V*3 ZB:ZC P3 DM1 Vt)3 ZPUF1:

93 24 08! PI BMI TEC TEN 4j

.4. B8 P3 owl *580 48 93 POT P1 DM1 :84:0 167 Pl BMI awl TEC .010 93 .41 08! TEN 45 99 P3 BMil Vt4 Vt) .580

.010 9" POT 44 48 93 33 111 0Da Pl P1 VU4 DM1 -7. 5 TEC TEN ZPUF:

B7 70 P3 V3:4 -. 894 am .010 j8 93 PCT 76 ZRAZC 32 Del PI BMil - . 9+/-,

T7

.74 77 POT - .82 .010 94 Pa BMI Vt.'

-7.8 TEN 94 '3 127 cam TEC 14 94 *S)

TEO .010 1.0) O9¢ VTE 4- 33 PL V33 TEC 97 .7G TEC 79 P2 Val 1.03 VD3 40 Go POT .,I TEN .010 ZPUF:

PL Val .91 :8CC0 48 63 197 PCT :PU:0 27 B0 08!

081 1.92 TEC TEN 104 P1 P3 DM1d 81d2 ZPUFZ L.e .'3 9L 09C YVt 145 .Sao PCT 72 07 POTt PI V'33 .ale ZBAZ:C 148 OS! TEC TEN 47 110 7, P3 Val3 Val Vt3 .010 POT *.77 :PUCC 102 PI awl1 -,.8+/- :PUFr" 48 .07 1+/-3 UCT TEC TEN 78 ZBA.ZC 40 LAI 93 PCT P3 SUL3 Vt) .010 7? -. 71 +/-.8*CC 46 PCT e9H Val 380 +/-8CCIF 11: P3 V33 .77 I0V.

104 1 73 DCa P1 BDM TEO TEN

.17 70 .79 Vt) .0110 POT Vt) IZPUFZ Wt3 .010 -+/-B4+/-0 104 45 71 IGO Del PI 61dl TEC TEN .010 ZPUF:-

154 1 .07 123 .88 TEN Cal P3 DM1 TEC TEN 3800 so - .80 Vtl I47 104 POT P3 D1w IDA 1.37 POT .81 104 78 14" 164 TEN .010 -BAZC 153 *9-"

4*0 Del P3 012 TEC 70 .982 .380 POT IS P1 owl -. 598 100 4-" Del TEC 049 100 .42 128 Del 11 P1 DlM -. 91 TEC TEN .010 +/-84+/-0C 13 N1 I ON COM. VOMTS CEO IN PER CNN LOCH 1NCHI 1NC4H CALEN BELT ENDT PO0A PTYPE CAL L COi

..---------- 4- - - - - - - - - - - - - - + - - - - - ..- ..- -

ZG - 22 Percent Calls Palo Vera&eZ U1213 PWIGS2 20,01001 10,'285.,20 8:43 43 I ROW OL VOLT3 DES IND PER CHN LOCH IlCu INOII CALEN BEST INDT POZA PTYPI 0  ;.CON I 40 100 53 BC POT 11 P3 wl .93 09e W3 .ySa ZPLu: 01x Hx 4a 137 1.03 119 oar 24 P1 owl - 80 TEC TEN .010 3 48 ZB:ZC NJ 107 1. 4a 80 POT 25 Pa owll -. 94 VD3 .580 60 48 ZPLFFZ NJ 107 .70 113 on] 20 P1 V133 .82 TEC TEN .019 48 ZBA:Z 13 107 1 01 83 POT 20 P3 'Z3 .82 YT3 VS3 ,583 00 NJ 44 NJDO lie 107 .30 10r9 oal 13 P1 .85 TEC TEN .010 118 69 POT 17 owl .583 ZPU*FZ

Puv:

92 P3 .88 ION 1123 60 CI NJ awl sm:

B0 62 20 P1 TEC TEN .010 0 Nj 0137 0D! - .94 I45 DM2 - .81 43 Ile .97 94 Dal 28 P1 TEC TEN .010 60 HI 106 S*5 'SO 1.49 a3 POT 25 PS

• 99 V13 ZP*IF" 4.3 .580 ZPUF: 04 I 9, 73 POT 29 Pa DM2 -. 81 ECN 1133 47 P1 -. 94,f ZBAZC 38 120 PCT 13 Sul TEC TE0 TEN 47 78 f1 POT 15 P3 oM1 -. 94 .583 :zco NJ DM1

--PLFZ BAZC HI 51 lee 73 08D 11 pl, .488 TEC TIN .010 60 NJ aill 51 1le 57 77 POT 11 P3 D14 .80 1123 .580 so 490 ZB3ZC 43 99 P1 awl Sil -. 79 TEC TEN .010 MIDO 43 112 10 P1 .79 TEN .010 0 0a HN

.20 07 TEC 112 Dal 49 NJ

.31 90 Del 13 P1 WM2 .83 TEC TEN .010 NI 36 112 4 51 64 49 P3 owl - .91 ¥Z3 .580 -ZPL9FF 040 112 ,0 B5 POT 13 P3 BMI .92 V23 43 ZPt*FF 43 83 07" POT 10 P3 .83 112 08C V213 . 583 SO CI 00 112 150 ZPtUFZ 13 P1 .75 45 57 Bll MN1 TEN TEC .010 10 NI HtI 43 .71 88 POT 14 P3 -.9' aM V213 HI 112 HI 113 08D BMil 48 113 93 POT 10 Pi .85 TEC TEN 60 NI 13 BMl 01 148 113 45 95 P3 But V13 .583 ZB&:O HI 33 Dal ZPUF:

190 10 01 H ClI i11 113 POT PI V34 - .91 TEN TEC .013 110 1,09 73 19 P3 V134 - .91 1124 V14 .583 84 Dal ZBAZC 41 114 1.4,3 109 31 Pi DM1 .77 TEC TEN .010 S NI

.013 41 114 131 Dal 13 PI - .91 TEN Z'B*ZC 5 HI POT '33 TEC 41 113 2.49 71 35 P3 Swil am ¥V3 .580 ZPUFZZ 04 NI PCT 5a 41 114 1.18 77 21 P3 W33 - .91 call W'83 .589 ZPtUF: 00 as 114 33 73 11 Pi DM1 .77 TEC TEN .013 :BAZC S 43 POT ClI

.03 13 P3 DM1 am 113 ,563 00 43

.80 NJ ZPV/FZ 114 .34 132 OeT 9 P1 DM2 TEC TEN .810 CI 4" POT 31 -. 910 47 114 *,55 31 11 P3 DM2 V13 .583 CI 038 5

.54 110 10 ZBWZ 80 40 115 110 0Da Pi 1133 TIC TEN .010 NI Cl 114 .04 18 P1 DM2 .8" TIC TEN ZBAZC 40 POT 441 115 1. 09 71 19 P3 V33 .82 806 WZ3 PCT ZPUF: CI 40 114 1 03 19 P3 DM2 1W13 84 08C 58 NJ 115 POT Is .010 04 6a 115 34 96 Dal P1 V$3, -. 80 TIN TEC oa - .80 .580 ZPUFZ.

58 74 P3 I33 11+/-3 11+/-3 4- 110 1.+/-- 150 081 23 PI DM1 -. 81 TEC TEN .010 34:0z 0 NJ 45 110 1 21 80 POT 21 P3 OD1 -. 90 MN 113 . W3 ZPUFI 60 HINOA 40 117 38 96 0814 14 P1 V13 .79 TEC TEN .010 0 a54:0NJ

42. 117 .09 113 0WH 21 P1 V33 .79 TEC TEN .019 B-z0 a NJ 110 117 .19 112 02! 8 P1 1124 - .90 TEC TEN .010 Z:34:0 56 NJ 110 117 73 79 POT 14 P3 1184 -. 90 V1-4 V14 .380 P.PUF: 80 C 39 116B 9 115 081 24 P1 wlM -. 91 TEC TEN .010 :BA:C 5 NJ 38 118 1.85 71 POT 29 P3 Bul -. 099 MN ye3 *  :,-PUFF: 0 NJ 30 119 .67 13,0 08 15 P1 D14 -. 93 TEC TEN .010 Z:B0Z 5 NJ 34 119 1 32 89 POT 23 PS DMI -. 92 MN W23 .583 TMPUFZ 60 NJ 45 120 34 19 081 9 P1 1*33 -. 81 TEC TEN .01a  :.A,: 0 NJ 45 1Ic 02 79 POT 12 P3 V33 -. 85 V11 2313 .80 ZPU-F" as NJ 44 11 4-4 152 0Da 13 PL 1101 .79 TEC TEN .013 -:B34 a NJ RON COL VOLTS DES IND PER CNN LOCK IN141 I MOM CA1LENBEST INDT PO14 PTYPE CAL L C0064 3

I.- +/-2 Percent Cells Palo Yore. Z U+/-R13 PV1G48 2061601 1o':'/2znh 08:43 45 AON COL VOLTS CEO IND PER CHN LOON 1INC841 184CK2 RLEN DEBT ERECT PC14 PTYPE CAL LCOiN 33 1 62 121 08! 10 Pi DML - .95 TEC TEN .610 BAXC s HJ 33 1IZ- IN 0 8^

80 PCT 19 P3 OWL -. 87 0m Vt.) .3O ZPuF-C NHJ 19 1^4 51 139 Del 19 Pi DM1 -. 92 TEC TEN .010 ZSAZC 6 NJ as 1+/-*4 43 5+/-_ 8!1 14 P1 SWI .90 TEC TEN .010 Z+/-A3C a NJ 2 1:=4 00 so PCT 11 P3 SUL -. 92 WM8 V23 .so -- PUF: 60 NJ

^S 1+/-*,4 85 PCT 18 P3 41 .so M8M4 Vt) .583M TPU- 60 NJ 165 1+/-4 1 50 70 SV! 24 P3 TIC .37 TIC TIC .600 ZPSIC 74 CIMN PLPi 167 1+/-4 +/- 78 68 IV! 30 P3 T:C .40 TCIt TiC 609, ZPIC' 74 CwO PLPFP 160 1+/-15 54 94 IVI 10 P3 TIC .13 TIC TIC .600 ZPt1tZ 74 OjIN PLP, IG10 1n 5.3 S8 VI 19 P3 TIC .59 TIC TIC .6009 ZPClCI 74 OpNC PLP

+/-E 1:7* - 10*9 01! 10 P1 VI3 1.00 TEO TEN .619  :.10 C 5 N

. 1+/-"7 41 70 PCT 10 P3 VI3 1.00 VV) Vt3 .398 :PuF: 60 Wi 118 133 21 N goD 7 P1 V83 .81 TEN TEC .60ll 3A4: 55 cj 118 133 57 88 POT 11 P3 V33 .81 V)3 V.)3 .580 :PuF: 60 NJ 10G 13" 57 143 08! 16 P1 DM2 - .80 TEC TEN .013 ZBAZC 41 NI 10 135 1.11 71 POT 20 P3 DM2 -. 80 11C VSII .13"0 :epuu 0 CI 162 135 53 128 08! 15 Pl Dm2 - .79 TEC TEN .61011.:C 41 NJ 102 135 Of 79 PCT 15 P3 DM2 -. 79 11 VI" .58" ZPuFF: 80 Cj 11- 14)3 G8 101 03] 10 P1 VSI .88 TEN TEC .019 ZBA+/-C 54 O1 102 143 .65 79 POT 13 P3 VI+/- .84 V=" VCf .589 ZPLIF: 00 NJ 113 140 37 06 01£ 11 PI V3: - .73 TEN TEC .6019 :ACC 38 Cj 113 140 1.01 B", POT I P3 VI32 -. 85 V312 VIZ .583 ZPuF: 00 NjOOA 190 181 .24 03 O8I 8 P1 V33 -. 94 TEN TEC .613 -BZC 51 0I 10N 181 7 80 POT 14 P3 VI3 - .94 V3'3 VM) .58 ZPU: 60 NI T3 Ze 35 150 08a a P1 V'3 .27 TEN TEC .019 ZAZC 12--01

---

-------------------------------------------------- 4 ---- 4---- .....

I ROM COL VOLTS LE, IND PEN CNN LOON IN£8041 INCH1 CRLEN BEAT ERDT P1tA PTYPE CAL CON

... ............ +................ 4 ................. + ......... ............. +...... .........

TuaL;: 87 Recor4s: 1B3

APPENDIX D PLI & PLP DATA SHEETS

30 - 21 PLP Calls Palo Verde 2 U2R13 PVMe=2 :90*001 1@,20.'KO 07:40:515 BE .T T.... .........

T.P ..............

IROW cat VOLTY 0O0 INO PER CNN LOON INOHI INCIIZ÷ LEN BEST [N.. PO.A PTYPE CAL. L. CO.

---

------------------------------------------ 4----------------- --......

38 7 1 00 142 PLP 8 De 14 14 TEN TEO .010 Z8AZC 47 CjZR I 58 7 1.30 93 PLP 0 saC 14 14 00e @90 .060 PCIHZ 79 Cl3R I 08 15 1.91 83 PLP 8 10c 1 92 Die @ic .coQ TPSH: 84 C13R I 00 15 1.09 B8 PLP 8 sic 1 20 Die @10 .000 ZPCH: 84 CgZR I 87 10 1 0 84 PLP 8 tic 1 10 010 10c .000 ZPONZ 84 CI3R I I 31 30 23 I1 PLP 8 17H 18.48 TEN TEC .010 ZBAZC 30 C03R 152 57 23 93 PLP 8 97H 18 24 TEN TEC .610 ZHACC 30 C;IR am 79 .37 110 PLP B TON 0 17 TEC TEN .010 89ZCC 11 HISR 38 79 2 18 89 PIP 8 TOM d 24 TON GIN ae00ZPSN2 73 klR I 39 so 20 100 PLP 8 TIN 5s9 TEC TEN .010 ZBA=O a Hj:R I 39 so 1.55 81 PLP 8 TV 0 681 TSH G1 .000 ZPCH: 73 NI3R 157 1422 11 91 PLP a 97H 27 03 TEC TEN .010 ZBAC 42 "13K1 157 142 .94 07 PLP 9 67H 27 01 07H @0a .800 ZPSHN 73 NI3R 143 150 24 09 PLP a 062 i8 03 @2C 030 .000 YPON: 84 C3RI 143 150 10 76 PLP 8 20C 10 97 @20 @3C .000 TPNH: 84 CgR I 142 111 19 75 PLP 8 920 10 17 02C 030 .000 ZPCHZ 84 CIR I 144 151 .15 70 PLP 8 920 19 16 02C 030 .000 ZPPH: 79 C3RI 143 132 Z8 07 PLP 8 90C 19 13 02C @30 .000 YPNHZ 79 CI3R 145 152 28 09 PLP 8 920 19 02 TEN TEC .010 ZBA=C 30 CIZR 145 1252 .95 73 PLP 8 *2C 19 9 920C 030 .000 SPONZ 79 C1R I 144 153 77 00 PLP 8 02c 18.84 0zc 030 .000 zPNH: 79 CI3R 140 153 10 03 PLP a 02c 19s08 TEN TEC .010 Z9A:C 39 C[d I 8 9z 2 1 00 9 2c 0S 0 .0 0 6 P C 79 C:Y 14 8 1 53 45 08 PLP 145 154 .19 98 PLP 8 *zC 19 93 TEN TEO .010 ZUA:C 39 CR I 145 154 .4 71 PLP 8 92c 10 93 OzC 930 .000 :PON 79 C0ZY 144 155 18 03 FLP 8 92C 196 3 @20 030 .060 ZPCNz 79 CI39 143 150 98 70 PLP 8 820 19 70 02C 030 .800 zPWz 84 C01R I 145 150 00 74 PLP a SIC 10 02 020 630 .000 TPSWZ 84 CISR 145 15a 21 07 PLP 8 92c 17 23 062 030 .600 ZPCHZ 84 CI0R I I ROW COL VOLTV DE0 ING PER CHM LOOCN INCHI INCHN CMLEN BEGT ENOT POZA PTYPE CAL L CO1I Tuba 19 Racor4d: 29

+/-

30 -  :: PLP Calls Palo Verde 2 UJ+/-R13 PV63. MH0II01 LI;2,'Z 6 O68:Z.0:29 Row COL voLT: DEG ING PER CNN LOON INCNI 1MON2 CALE* hOT ElIOT POZA PTYPI CAL L COs4I

+- . *- -- - - - -- ------------------------------------ .. .. .... .. .. ..... .. .. .. .. ..... .. .. .. ..

9+/- 105 1 so 67 PLP 8 FOP 80 FOP FOP .000 ZPSNZ 01 CIRI 34 125 2 09 913 PLP 8 FOP 89 FOP FOP .000 ZP3H: 81 Cj13r I 3, 125 2 18 92 PLP 8 FOP 60 FOP FOP .000 ZPSN: 81 C135I 15 120 75 00 PLP 8 FOP 63 FOP 01C .860 PCl : 8 SL C13f.

1 170 1 05 80 PLP & TZC 11 T8C TOCO .000 .P-IHC 01 C1 3R I 0 185 34 5? PLP a SOm :4 40 TEN TIC .010 "8:AC 04 CI3R I 8 1815 7 "39 PLP 8 SON 24.70 TEN TEC .010 2BA8CC 04 CI;R I I

0 187 .1 74 PLP a 90H 24.71 TEN TEC .010 ZBA-C 0a CI0". I 0 188 +/-7 60 PLP a SON 24 50 TEN TIC .010 28ACC 04 CIR. I 9 1S9 1 98 81 PLP a 02C L4 02C 020 .000 ZP3H: 01 CI03 I 7 Z00 1 SO6 05 PIP a 020 15 020 020C .000 ZPCIC 01 013:I C --.. V--- --- -- ---C- P-- CNN- O.- N- ..... - N.. ...... ... OT. P..A...-..

E.T.......... TYP . .CL 0 ROWd COL. VOLTC: DEG IOD PEJR CNN LOON INCHL INCH2 ORLENI BEGT ENOT PDIA PTYPE CAL L COt41

• ... . . *.. . . . . ÷ . . ., . . . . . ÷ . . ..,, . . . . . . . ............. 4.

TuLam 11 Records: 11

APPENDIX E PLUG Lists PLUG Maps PLUG HISTORY

SO - 21 TOP Tubes with Currant Cycle D0at Palo Verde 2 UZR13 PVI462 3110N11 l0:ItO;.20 07 35:30 I RM ..

CA VOLTS DES IND PER CNN LOCN IN3340*4 I441Z4 CLEN BEST ENDT POIA PTYPE CAL L÷ CCII

.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ÷ . . ...* . . ***

50 7 16 D 142 PLP a leC 14.14 TEN TEC .013 2BACC 47 CI3P 5a 7 P1V a 320 5.62 . TEN TEC .016 28420C 47 C I 7 1 . WJ 93 PLP a Doc 14.14 08c 09C .800 2PM1C 72 Cj I TelP TEN TIN .013 2ENC 10LD CjSY 56 7 58 7 IPLP I 34 £3 50 170 Dal 21 Pi BM9 -1.@0 TEC TEN .610 ZBCC 8 Nj I

34. 83 39 117 091 14 PI BM1 .04 TEC TEN .6109 2 2C 8NJ I 34 81 P01 PI BM91 -1.60 TEC TEN .010 :AI0 65 NJ 34 83 183 DO PCT 24 P3, OW -. 85 a8m VI3 .5 63 2PUF: 70 NJ 34 83 1 82 69 POT 24 P3 3*1 .81 DOW V83 .5680 9 PLUC 3A 83 Tap TEC TEC .610 -"4:0 10070 NJ Oj.l 34 £3 I ImCi 30 £5 1.J 16" DI 43 P1 941 -. 8l.U TEC TEN .6019 28C 7 NI I 30 85 PlD P1 awl -. 87 TEC TEN A019 :1AC 51 NJ 38 85 3.46 63 POT 38 P3 Bl1 -. 95 084 We" .580 PUF" 76 NI I 30 85 TBP TEC TEC 6019 AzC 10o6 C I Sr 30 £5 1 2C01 43 91 50 99 Del 23 P1 3M*2 -. 98 TEC TEN .013 TZACC 5 NI I 43 92 IWO PI 8912 .88 TEC TEN .019 .3AZC 5 NJ I 92 PlD PI 9M2 -. 90 TEC TEN .619 25410 8 Nj 43 43 91 .71 74 PCT 13 P3 V83 -1.35 08C W03 .580 ZPM5 80 Cj I 43 92 1. 04 78 PCT 18 P3 SM2 -. 99 080 VM .580 ZPUF: 8 Cj I 41 92 TBP TEC TEC .019 ZBAZC 1006 CIr I I 43 92 I B1d01 I I 47 921 .581 0L01Da 23 PI B1 2 -. 78 TIC TEN .010 .BAZC 5 NJ I 147 9"1 P[D PI BM1 -. 78 TEC TEN .61 :BAIC 05N I j47 92 91 7Z PaT ie P3 9*2 -. 78 98C y33 .589 2PUF: 80 CjI I 47 922 TaP TIC TEC .A19 :84C 1006 CIem00 44 93 B4 117 081 27 PI OWL -. 92 TEC TEN .010 ZBAC 5 NI I 4I t3 Plo PI But -. 22 TEC TEN .616 BA9IC 05 NI 44 93 Z.68 68 POT 32. P3 But - 85 584 MI .589 2PLPFZ 70 NJ 44 93 05 7t POT 10 P3 8*1 1.00 084 VIM .89 S :P1F 70 NJ 44 93 T&P TEC TEC .610 ZBAZC 1000 COIj1 I S 93 15*4801 48 03 44 75 D01 20 p1 B91 -1.61 TEC TEN .019 23BAC 5 Nj 48 93 .18 117 031 10 P1 4413 .88 TEO TIEN .013 zwC 5 Nj 48 93 P1D P1 8aw1 -1.01 TEC TEN .019 2A4C 05 NI 48 03 07 07 PCT 26 P3 BMI -. 82 68*441 soPUtF:

.UK 7"a NJ 48 93 70 75 PCT 11 P3 awl 1.00 8SH M43 .S8O"2PC ONJ 48 93 70 63 POT 18 PS V23 .93 S8 YS 3 .58 P MWI: 7a NN 48 93 TSP TEC TEC .10O Z@.C 16o Clem=SI 40 97 014 97 Del 31 PI B1i1 -. 8 TEC TEN .6L6 ZCC 5NJ I 48 97 17 83 0*1 1I PI "13 1.01 TEC TEN .61 2BAZC 5 NJ I 48 97 Plo P1 001 -. 80 TEC TEN .610 2A81C 6 NJ I 40 97 3 00 05 POT 35 P3 9*L -. 78 WN V.N .58 3PUF1: 76 HNjOA I 40 97 1,04 64 PCT 15 P3 V22 1.06 98*4 VI3 .580 ZPUF" 70 H I As 97 TBP TEC TEC .010 2B42C 160 CjSt I 4a 97r 16*4201

4. 91 83 so 08! 27 PI 81 :94

-. TEC TEN .610 22A:C a Nj I 45 99 0 121 13 20a P1 B0 2 95 TEC TEN 6l1 ZB9C 0 Nj 45 98 PlO PI But - .24 TEC TEN .616 23AIC 05 NJ I 45 91 PRC 68* M-23 580 PPLi: ?77 Nj I 4 96 10 5 74 POT 226 P3 8M1 -1.61 6844 M3 .58H 2PLPF" 77 Nj I 45 96 84 77 POT 1 P3 V83 -1.25 060 V93 .588 ZPUPZ as Cj I 45 98 93 7O PCT 17 P3 V83 -. 22 0804411 58s0 PsLC PUF: I 45 96 06 73 PCT 17 P3 8M2 -1.1 D8c V113 .586 "PU: 80 Cj I 45 9e TBP TEC TEC .010 9AZC 16OW C131 I

.,45 96 10,c21 47 116 .M 114 0CI 27 PI B6*4 - .70 TEC TEN .010 2CC --0 Nj 47 110 PRD Pi 9l - .76 TEC TEN .010 ZBIC 05 Nj I 47 110 278 73 POT 33 P3 8011 -. 88 08M Yes .13 D PLUF- 77 HIDOAI 47 110 TSP TEC TEC .010 WCC 100N Cj3KI 47 110 I12I0I 4.4 11 30 90 GO I 17 P1 B*41 -. 71 TEC TEN .015 2BAC 19 NJ 4I4 111 87 1@9 013 30 P1 OWL ."' TIO TEN .61 :WC 19 NJ I I 4 111 PlO P1 00l .78 TEC TEN .013 ZBA21 05 Nj I I 4" 111 1 34 78 PCT 19 P3 B01 -. 86 W8* VI3 .530 "P: 77 NJ I ION C. VOS E 0PN NLC1.................41...................40....4......... LI9....... T......... ............ O....

IPONi COtL VOLTS DEG 100 PER CNNl LOON ][NCHI INCHM ORLEN BEST ENDT MOA PTrYPE CAL ,. OI

'M 21 TSP TULe: utth Cur'ent Cycle Data Palo Verde 2 U11. PVNI41S 3001K1 10:!0:f 07 35:31

-- -- *....... +....4 . .4- . . . . . .. *.---- . ---.- ....---

I Raw COL. VOLT3 DES IWO PER CNN LOON 1110111 IN=1 CR113 SLOT ENDOT PCA PTYPE CAL. L CONI I 44- 111 C,38 68 PCT 30 P3O M1 .84 CM VE3 ,5i4O Z:P'FZ 77 N I 44 111 TSP TEC TEC .013 S'BAZC Is" Oj3K 44 111 WBI42cj 43 112 92 90 02! 32 PI Dil -. 70 TEC TEN .010 --BA.C 19 NJ I 43 112 12 12!- act 14 P1 DML .86 TEC TEN .010 ZBA1C 19 HI I 43 112 PID PI DM1 -. 70 TEC TEN .010 ZRAIC 0O NJ 43 112 1 74 7Z PCT 23 P3 DM1 -. 85 GM4 V3 .580  :.PUF: 77 NJ 43 112 31 09 PCT 14 P3 DM1 .9, 01 VW23 .580 IPUN: 77 NJ I 43 112 TSP TEC TEC aie ZA0zC iow CJzt 43 112 ON=i 45 112 .30 1LZ 021 10 P1 OD1 -. 8O TEC TEN .010 ZAZC 19 NsIN 425 112 .47 124 021 21 P1 DM1 .72 TEC TEN .010 ZDA-C 19 Nj I 4-5 112 25112 0"Of 15 PL V33 -. 07 TEC TEN .010 DA.c 19 NJ I 4.5 11 PID P1l DM1 .72 TEC TEN .+10 SBAIC 5 NJI 4A, 112 .78 80 PCT 12- P3 MIl -. 99 SON VS3 58 ZPLIN: "77NJ 45 112 1.10 73 PCT 20 P3 DML .99 0814 113 .580 IPUPI 77 NJ I 45 112 77 Oc PCT 1! PS V3. -. 72 08H4 V23 .500 ZPUF" 77 NJ I 45j 112 TOP TEC TEC .010 :54A:Z 1og ClS.0Cl 45 i18 82 124 031 29 PI DM1 .77 TEC TEN .010A -BA-C 17 NJ I 45 119 PID PI DM1 .77 TEC TEN .010 ZAI0 05 NJ I 451 118 1,70 71 PCT 24 P3 DM1 .92 08DOH f3 .506 -fPLFP" 77 NJ I 4a 118 TSP TEC TE0 .0101 ZA,2C ion Clis I 45 119 1D01 RON COL VOLT3 DE5 IND PER CNN LOON NC341 lINCH2 CRLEN DEBT MNOT PO1A PTYPE CAL L CON I

....-....-.........-.-..............-................... ........................... * ............-. *........4.....

Tube;: 14 Rcrds: 79

SG - 21 Tubes to be Plugged Based on U2R13 Eddy Current Results Palo Verde I2R1 3 PVNGS2 2RSG lo Is to f$ le 24 40 a4 40 4 Go w4 70 is 00 or, go 95 ISO 1432 lie lit 32 I 1"0 214 160 1t4 10 1M sops 170

'£4f ISO 145 240 145 130 its IM1 110 214 Jos IMS 2S 6 10 is 1s Il 's 40 45 4 s o0 4 04 07 4 £4 as a "0 5 100 1Olls 120 224 1301o 4 1its 14 SA 4 24 14 2s014 I$*

94*G10*I810 IIJ

M- 22 T1P Tubal1 with Current CyCle Date Palo Verde 2 012R3 PUIRGS2 S001001 I020/12N06 W:23 14 POW COL VOLTS 0ES lIND PER" CHN LOCN "'"44 INCI CRLEN BEST ENDT POIA PTYPE CA L CON  ;

309 B NOo TEC TEN .010 ZBAC 4 NJ 80 a0 PIV 0 T"C 17.88 TEC TEN .010 28L20 4 NJ 30 804 TBP TEN TEN .010a M3AX2 100 Cj23 39 80 j PVT" 48 88 1 00 110 Da8 33 P1 8O1 .00 TEC TEN .010 2.ATC INJ 48 89 PlD P1 SU1 .00 TEC TEN .010 8BAIC 55 Nj 48 88 1.8I 70 PDT 30 P3 981 .89 awl W23 .50 .PUWF: S1 NJ 48 89 TBP TEO TEC .010 ZB3C 100 Cj m 48 as IBM=C 41 90 3,41 90808! 50 P 1381 -. 88 TEC TEN .010 2a-Cc 4 "1 41 90 2.32 118 08! 4: PI 381 .80 TEC TEN .010 ZAzc A Nj 4l 90 Plo P1 981 -. 88 TIC TEN .010 ZBAIC 525 Nj 41 90 4.34 04 PCT 48 P3 OW1 -. 79 08c VM3 .260 ZPUF2 01 HI 41 90 65 87 PCT 13 P3 981 .10 a"N V93 .280  : PutF: 01 NJ 41 90 3.17 09 POT 4l P3 38l .7"5 amN V3 .580 ,PUFZ 01 Nj 41 90 TBP TEC TEC .013 28CA.C 100 CjIU.

I1 390 Ismec 43 90 1.47 115 081 34 PI 381 -.94 TEC TEN .010 2BAZC 4 Nj 43 90 PlO PI BMI -+.94 TEC TEN .010 ZBA1C 55 NJ 43 90 1 DO 70 POT 29 P3 8U1 -. 79 D8M VT3 .503 2PU#F" 01 NJ 43 30 TBP TIC TEC .010 2BAZC 100low CjBc 4- 91 1.04 94 08! 38 PI 3l8 - .94 TEC TEN .010 ZCAZc 4 NJ 422 91 .70 107 08! 228 P1 381 .90 TEC TEN .010 ZA8C 4 Nj 42 91 PRO P1 38L .. 94 TEC TEN .010 1BAIC 55 NJ C.2 91 Z.13 73 PCT 33 P3 38l - .70 08 V23 .580 2PUF: 01 NI 42 91 1 33 75 PCT 24 P3 381 .89 DON V23 .580 ZPUFZ 01 NI 42 91 TBP TEC TEC .019 2BAZC 1000 CO31 42 91 le382c 45 104 1.73 1t". De 37 PI 381 .7T TEC TEN .010 Z,4.ZC 0 Nj 45 104 2.01 177 ON PI 030 -. 79 TEC TEN .010 Z3CC 0 Nj 4.5 104 5.31 17, DNN Pi 920 2513.00 TEC TEN .010 ZB.40 0 Nj 40 104 .40 294 IMP B 2C M.7 7 TEC TEN .010 ZBAZC 0 Nj 40 104 2.31 177 OWN P1 92C 22.84 TEC TEN .010 28C 0 Nj 45 104 P[D P1 B3I .77 TEC TEN .010 8ID1 52. HNI 45 104 2.17 70 POT 33 P3 MI .79 004 VZ3 .580 ZPMF: 01 Nj 423 104 TBP TEC TEC .010 Z2AZC 1330 C03K 45 104 18ju2 47 1*4 .71 13 081 23 P1 OWL -.14 TEC TEN .01028420 0 Nj 47 104 1 07 123 08D 27 P1 O81 .88 TEC TEN .010 4BAZC 0 Nj 47 104 Plo P1 381 .s8 TEC TEN .010 ZB1C 55 NJ 47 104" .8 0 POT 10 P3 aw1 -. 80 08m V23 .280 2PUF: 0l NJ 47 I04 1 37 78 POT 24 P3 38l -.8+/- 0O8 V83 ,52 ZPUF: 01 Nj 47 104 TBP TEC TEC .010 ZBZC 1000 IjUN3*

48 107 1.05 119 08! 24 P1 381 -. 80 TEC TEN .010 ZBAZC 5 Nj

4. 107 PIO PI 381 -. 80 TEC TEN .010 2A10C 52 NJ 48 107 1 40 S0 PCT 25 P3 BMI -. 94 068 VM3 .580 ZPVFl 00 Nj 48 107 TOP TEC TEC .01 28420 1000 CIZ.

40 107 I0B,0C 4,5 lee Be 8: 08-! 0 Pi wl -94 TEC TEN .010:I: 2 .2 ONJ 45 18 07 94 081 28 Pl B32 - .81 TEC TEN .010 ZBA4C 0 Nj 45 108 1PO P1 8*2 -. 81 TEC TEN .010 Z2A41 52 NJ 42 108e 1 4 BSOPCT 25 P3 8O1 -. 99 0, VS3 .580 ZPUF- 0 NJ 45 108 1.94 75 PCT 29 P3 382 -. 81 OC V3 *

.580 2P1JP 84 Cj 42 l0e TBP TEC TEC .010 28ZC IO00 CIfU 45 108 18MaC 43 112 4 90 99 0! 20 PI a81 -. 79 TEC TEN .010 :BA4C 0 Nj 43 112 28 07 0!l 10 P1 8ol .79 TEC TEN .010 240ZC 0 Nj 43 112 39 go Del 12 P1 Buz .83 TEC TEN .010 ZA8.2 0 NJ 43 112 PLO P1 381 -. 79 TEC TEN .010 2841C 52 Nj 43 112 4.51 04 PCT 40 P3 3M1 .91 O8M M83 .580 "PUF- 00 NJ 4.3 1.1- 00 85 PCT 13 P3 B91 .92 084 V133 .500 ZPUFZ 00 Nj 43 112 853 07 PCT 10 P3 082 .83 680C Y3 .580 ZPUPFZ so Cj 43 112 TBP TEC TEC .010 B24ZC 1030 Cj2V 43 112 18cc:

41 114 1.43 109 OS! 31 PI BMI .75 TEC TEN .01: 2B4ZC 5 Nj 41114 A 52131 08 13 Pi Vas -.91 TEC TEN ,010 BAC 2 Nj 41 114 PlO PI 3W1 .75 TEC TEN .010 Z8A41 28. NJ

+....+ .... +..........*.....,,.....*.....÷.....+.....+......... . ......... . ........ * .... ....

.4 +.......,,.......+..........- ....... +

ROW COL VOLT3 DES INO PER CNN LOON 1NC104 £CH:2 ORLEN BEST ENOT PO1 PTYPE CAL I. CO 22 TOP TU.,e: with Cureant Cyolo Data Palo Vera* 2 U213 PVNW: :0111160491 10.;2(52000 0:.23 14 1 REMN COL VOLTY DEG IND PER §440 IDCN 14041 I140014 CR1140 BSlT INDT POIA PTYPE CAL J.CON 41 114 Z.49 71 POT 35 P3 Ba4l .80 GeN V83 .5se IPUFz SO NJ 41 14 +/-118 77 POT -1 P3 Va3 -. 91 06N V33 .5640 ZPUFz 00 NJ 41 114 TSP TEC TEC .01+/- 15BAZC 10W C13 41 114 8141C 40 1+/-5 .54 119 031 16 PL V33 .82 TEC TEN 0+/-9 1A8ZC 5 NJ 40 115 4. 11i 0c1 La PI 8w2 .80 TEC TEN .01 ZBA9C 5 NJ 44 115 PI a TEC 2.10 TEC TEN .016 Z1A9C 5 NJ 40 1+/-5 1.09 71 PCT 19 P3 VY3 .82 aw Vt3 .583D 5P2.Z 80 Cj 40 115 1 03 S4 POT 19 P3 8B2 .80 98C ON ) .50 zPUF: 80 C 40 115 TSP TEN TEN .0+/-9 ZRA"C 1000 CSK.

40 115 ObbdC 45 1+/-0 1.-IS 156 DZI 23 P1 SUL1 -. 81 TEC TEN .0R ZBAZC 0 NJ 45 110 PlO P1 94l1 " .81 TEC TEN . .0113MG 55 NJ

'45 116 1.21 B POT 2+/- P3 3m1 -. 96 08ai YB) .8we zPUCF S0 HIDOA 45 1+/-0 TSP TEC TEC 018 z1A3C 160o0 cjl 3

45 110 IB* c 30 18 .09 115 0De 24 PL SUL -. 91 TEC TEN .019 Z14AZ 5 NJ 30 118 Pro P1 6401 -. 91 TIC TEN .A01e Z.AC 55 NJ 3N 118 18.! 71 POT LI P3 9M1 -. 96 amN Y3 .586 ZPUF: 0 HNJ 30 1+/-8 TSP TEC TEC .A1 Z1A9zC 10s C.SY 3N 118 i B111C 15 114 1 94 137 NO0 PI TSC .29 TIC TEN . 019 .AZC 32 NJ 105 12.4 PIV 0 TIEC 13.34 TIE TEN .019 ZBA1Z 32 NJ 105 1.24 1 5a 70 .VY 24 P3 TSC .37 TIC T8C .A09 ZPiP. 74 CINQ PLP 160 1,Z. TSP TEN TEN .019 Z12 10ow C a 11603 IZA I RLP 1 16"5 14 ISV!

107 124- 1 51 91 NO! Pi Toe .54 TEC TEN .019 zBACC 32 HI 107 124 PIV P1 TIC 19.609 TEC TEN .01 ZBACC 32 NJ 107 V2 124 78 08 ZV 30 P3 TIC .40 TIC TIC .080 ZPsI: 7A CJIO PLP

.107. 12.4 TBP TIN TEN .019 BRAzC 1600 0I1s C

167 124 NLIP 1017- +/-24 laW!

160 1253 41 B7 MO! 3 TSC .82 TEC TEN .0+/-aI.AIC 31 NJ 10e 12s PlY Z TIEC 15.44 TEC TIN .019 Z1AZC 31 NJ 100 125 54 94 3V1 10 P3 TIC .63 TIC TOC .099 IPISc 74 CjlO PLP 100 125 53 88 382 I6 P3 TIC .56 TIC TIC .000 zPrsm 74 CJNO PLP:

160 125.3 TSP TEN TEN .010 13ZCC 100o CI t 1t 12.5 jMLP I( Lee Ic I SVI Snow4 COI VOLT3 DEG INO PER CNN LON 14NC041 I£801 CRLE BElT INOT PC1A PTYPE CAL L CON

. . . . . . ..---------------------------------------------------------- +

TubeS: 17 RaOCr4:: 8M

SG - 22 Tubes to be Plugged Based on U2R 13 Eddy Current Results Palo Verde U2R1 3 PVNGS2 2RSG 5 30 is 20 is 1 5 10 40 4a 55 4 45 Is 711 so So so too IS S no5 it It* US5 14 In5 I"0 In5 ISO M it 170 345 140 In 33.

226 320 115 320

...~~ ~ ~ ~ ... .- . -

95 so as

.* . ~ . .

is is m0 V-%..-. .

Of 44 :4L**

44 3.

2S to 20 5 1W 25 1W iS ~~105 4 5 S 5 0 W I S 5 4 W 2W252U25201520132035 is is to fS A is 46 so " " 05 is is 80 as " SS I" in lie %is I" 12S is* 1A I" 14S Ise ISS 16, W&*Wf*"thddr""%kkc -VN* 1.674411M trwte

PLUG HISTORY STEAM GENERATOR 21 STEAM GENERATOR 22 OUTAGE/YEAR NUMBER OF  % BOBBIN NUMBER OF  % BOBBIN PLUGS EXAMINED PLUGS EXAMINED FACTORY 2002 0 NA 1 NA BASELINE 2-03 10 100 12 100 U2M12 1 <1% 0 0 U2R12 8 100 7 100 U2R13 14 100 17 100 TOTAL 33 37

APPENDIX F FORM NIS-1

APS NIS -1 FORM OWNERS' DATA REPORT FOR INSERVICE INSPECTIONS

1. OWNER ARIZONA PUBLIC SERVICE COMPANY, et al la. ADDRESS P.O. BOX 52034; PHOENIX, ARIZONA 85072

2. PLANT PALO VERDE NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION 2a. ADDRESS 5801 SOUTH WINTERSBURG ROAD, TONOPAH, ARIZONA 85354

3. UNIT NUMBER 2

4. OWNERS CERTIFICATE OF AUTHORIZATION NONE

5. COMMERCIAL SERVICE DATE 9-19-86

6. COMPONENTS INSPECTED:

COMPONENT OR MANUFACTURER SERIAL STATE OR NATIONAL APPURTENANCE OR INSTALLER NUMBER PROVINCE BOARD NO 2MRCEE01A Ansaldo 212 NA 161 STEAM GENERATOR 21 2MRCEE01B Ansaldo 211 NA 160 STEAM GENERATOR 22

_ _ _ _ I _ __ I __ I __ I __

I. 4 a a I

APS NIS- 1 BACK OWNERS' DATA REPORT FOR INSERVICE INSPECTIONS

7. EXAM DATES October 2006

8. INSPECTION INTERVAL October 2006

9. ABSTRACT OF EXAMINATIONS. INCLUDE A LIST OF EXAMINATIONS AND A STATEMENT CONCERNING STATUS OF WORK REQUIRED FOR CURRENT INTERVAL.

Table I in the report summary section documents the number and type of each examination performed.

Several degraded/defective tubes were observed during these examinations. A summary of the tubes with indications of degradation is listed in Appendix B and C of this report for SG 21 and 22 respectively. The tubes identified on the following pages were plugged as a result of this examination.

The number of tubes plugged are as follows: SG 21 = 14 tubes SG 22 17 tubes WE CERTIFY THAT THE STATEMENTS MADE IN THIS REPORT ARE CORRECT AND THE EXAMINATIONS AND CORRECTIVE MEASURES TAKEN CONFORM TO THE RULES OF THE ASME CODE, SECTION XI.

DATE /--0 7 SIGNED: ARIZONA PUBLIC SERVICE COMPANY BY Y-D el772/-

CERTIFICATE OF INSERVICE INSPECTION I, THE UNDERSIGNED, HOLDING A VALID COMMISSION ISSUED BY THE NATIONAL BOARD OF BOILER AND PRESSURE VESSEL INSPECTORS AND THE STATE OF PROVINCE OF ARIZONA EMPLOYED BY HSB CT OF HARTFORD, CONNECTICUT HAVE INSPECTED THE COMPONENTS DESCRIBED IN THIS OWNERS REPORT DURING THE PERIOD ocr. 2"-v. TO ,-ct-, AND STATE THAT TO THE BEST OF MY KNOWLEDGE AND BELIEF, THE OWNER HAS PERFORMED EXAMINATIONS AND TAKEN CORRECTIVE MEASURES DESCRIBED IN THIS OWNERS REPORT IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE REQUIREMENTS OF THE ASME CODE, SECTION XI. BY SIGNING THIS CERTIFICATE NEITHER THE INSPECTOR NOR HIS EMPLOYER MAKES ANY WARRANTY, EXPRESSED OR IMPLIED, CONCERNING THE EXAMINATIONS AND CORRECTIVE MEASURES DESCRIBED IN THIS OWNERS REPORT. FURTHERMORE, NEITHER THE INSPECTOR NOR HIS EMPLOYER SHALL BE LIABLE IN ANY MANNER FOR ANY PERSONAL INJURY OR PROPERTY DAMAGE OR A LOSS OF ANY KIND ARISING FROM OR CONNECTED WITH THIS INSPECTION.

INSPECTOR ýý 4 7z--, COMMISSIONS ,- c.-FS! ",\ S,L(k, Az 244 NATL' BOARD, STATE, PROVINCE DATE

APS NIS- 1 FORM OWNERS' DATA REPORT FOR INSERVICE INSPECTIONS

1. OWNER ARIZONA PUBLIC SERVICE COMPANY, et al la. ADDRESS P.O. BOX 52034; PHOENIX, ARIZONA 85072

2. PLANT PALO VERDE NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION 2a. ADDRESS 5801 SOUTH WINTERSBURG ROAD, TONOPAH, ARIZONA 85354

3. UNIT NUMBER 2

4. OWNERS CERTIFICATE OF AUTHORIZATION NONE

5. COMMERCIAL SERVICE DATE 9-19-86 SG 21 Tubes Plugged SG 22 Tubes Plugged R58 C7 R39 C86 R34 C83 R48 C89-R36 C85 R41 C90 R43 C92 R43 C90 R47 C92 R42 C91 R44 C93 R45 C104 R48 C93 R47 C104 R46 C97 R46 C107 R45 C98 R45 C108 R47 Clio R43 C112 R44 Cll R41 C114 R43 C112 R40 C115 R45 Cl 12 R45 C116 R45 Cl 18 R39 ClG8 R165 C124 R167 C124 R166 C125