ML041620089

NRC Acknowledgement Dated 6/10/04 to Ucs Regarding Closure of Nuclear Plants

ML041620089
Person / Time
Site:	Salem, Hope Creek
Issue date:	06/10/2004
From:	Blough A Division Reactor Projects I
To:	Lochbaum D Union of Concerned Scientists
Shared Package
ML041620012	List: ML041620021 ML041620027 ML041620034 ML041620047 ML041620089 ML041620560 ML041740294 ML041810035 ML041810045 ML042240039 ML042240045 ML042580160
References
2.206
Download: ML041620089 (1)

Text

From: A. Randolph Blough To: Dave Lochbaum Date: 6/10/04 9:33AM

Subject:

Re: UCS recommendations for Salem / Hope Creek

Dear Dave Lochbaum,

Thank you for providing the UCS views well in advance of next weeks meeting. We will review the letter carefully. I will need to consult with other staff on whether or not your request, based on its content, must be treated under 10CFR2.206. However, regardless of that determination, I assure you that I, along with other staff members, will consider your views in the very near term as we deliberate about our next steps with respect to Salem and Hope Creek.

Your email refers to worsening problems; as you may recall, I mentioned to you after the meeting in March that I did not share your view that the conditions are worsening. This is a question that I will continue to revisit frequently with the inspectors involved in these projects.

On an administrative matter, I believe I should place your incoming email to me into ADAMS, since it documents your wish that the UCS recommendations of 6/9/2004 not be labeled as a 2.206 request.

Would you have any objections to NRC placing your incoming email into ADAMS, publicly available?

Thank you again for your timely input.

Randy Blough

>>> "Dave Lochbaum" <dlochbaum@ucsusa.org> 06/09/04 08:31AM >>>

Hello Randy:

Attached is an electronic copy of a letter thats in the mail to you.

The letter contains our evaluation of the publicly available information about conditions at Salem and Hope Creek and our recommendations on what the NRC should do about the myriad and worsening problems.

Simply put, PSEG does not have a legal right to operate Salem and Hope Creek. NRC inspection reports and mid-cycle assessment letters over the past 18 months have chronicled programmatic breakdowns in PSEGs corrective action program. The recent independent assessments by Synergy, Utility Services Alliance, and the Independent Assessment Team reinforce NRCs findings.

Federal regulations - specifically, 10 CFR 50, Appendix B, Criterion XVI - require operating nuclear power plants to be supported by effective corrective action programs. When the NRC issued operating licenses to PSEG for Salem and Hope Creek, the licenses contained an explicit condition that the reactors be operated safely AND in compliance with federal regulations - not

one or the other.

The NRC should order PSEG to shut down Salem and Hope Creek until the defective corrective action program is repaired and made functional.

If the NRC bows, again, to industry pressure and allows Salem and Hope Creek to operate outside the law, at least the NRC should do for safety what it recently did for security ---

establish some desired end point and Order PSEG to get there by a specified date. The safety hazard at Salem and Hope Creek is far more credible and substantial than the security threat. The public must be protected from that safety hazard as it has been from the security hazard.

As you well know, PSEG has a long, long history of making promises it cant or wont keep. Just go back and review your files for the various promises made by PSEG in order to trick NRC into allowing them to restart the Salem units in the late 1990s. How many of those promises were kept? NRC must not accept any more promises and instead must Order PSEG to shape up its act.

Please note that while UCS strongly recommends NRC Order PSEG to fix the unacceptable performance at Salem and Hope Creek, we do not view these recommendations as a request under 10 CFR 2.206 for enforcement action and hope NRC will not construe the letter as such.

Thanks, Dave Lochbaum Nuclear Safety Engineer Union of Concerned Scientists 1707 H Street NW Suite 600 Washington, DC 20006-3962 (202) 223-6133 x113 (202) 223-6162 fax CC: Daniel Holody