ML033250392
| ML033250392 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Harris  |
| Issue date: | 08/14/2002 |
| From: | Weiss E Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | Ogle C NRC/RGN-II |
| References | |
| FOIA/PA-2003-0358 | |
| Download: ML033250392 (7) | |
Text
,, I Charles D. Og!!e - MA!NUAL ACTIONS SPEACH Caes Oge M..UAL AC.IONSSEACH_
Pag
'-K!
/,
C' 7.
From:
To:
Date:
Subject:
Eric Weiss, e 4)
Charles R. Ogle Ie 8/14/02 9:24AM MANUAL ACTIONS SPEACH Chuck-Thank you for the heads up about Shearon Harris that will call HQ to inquire about the need for an exemption. I have attached some slides that I plan to use at the NEI fire Protection Information forum in Seattle August 27-30 for a speach on Manual Actions. I thought this might be useful because slide 5 says succintly what is a 'feasible' manual action.
-Eric CC:
Edward Connell; John Hannon; Phil Qualls e
4
I Charles.,ROgle - NRC VIEWS ON MANUAL ACTIONS.ppt
,.PPagf w~~~~~~~~
.V
-:;N- -NRC iViews on M a
rotectibh'In.M
. e.i
.;. Bifing ~for the NEI.;Fi~re;',
&~
- ProtectionInformation Forumb'
, EricdWeiss, Chief Fire; rotection Section, NRR "USNRC
-415-3264.,:
August 29, 2002
Chales ~. Ogle - NRC VIEWS ON MANrUAL ACbOS' p Pac NRCL Ltterto l-NEI May
-17; 0
'-(ML021410026) 4xi anual Actions a a, lle f
lll.G.III.
1 Ap R q i n in separate fire areas
..Normaly operate manual switches and' valves
-.. :4-By exemption or deviation.for ll lG 2 of:App R7.'
llI.G.3.of A'pp R
- Equipment.. :;
- alternative and dedicated shutdown August 29, 2002 2
[ Charles R. Ogle - NRC VIEWS ON MANUAL ACTIONS.ppt ft.
~~~~.
-Pap
:
.- ;d.-.1.
i..
-AppLn'dixR-t'o1O -CFR 50' Section Il.G.2 3-ho~u'rba-rrier'
- 3 o,,.
.1,.
i
- 1. hour barrier with suppression and detection
-..20 f eet with no inter ening combustibles and suppression.and detection..
2002 3
August 29,
I Charles f. Ogle - NRC VIEWS ON MANUAL ACT!ONS.ppt Pag I.
-N Ri N E I-M e~s' e
J June22002 :0:
h r:
- ha
~ibn-h
- 4-
- db-
- :M
.' NEI contends Manual Actions should be allowed'
-when-.feasible K NEI -contends:,.that'.Ma'nu'al Actio'ns'Allowed by'reg guidance,-safety,;evaluationsj'inspe-tions,':-'..',--
correspondence and eetings-
- NEI presented-'results of recent s'urv ey'..'-'.,A
- NRC' note8d.that violations'sh'ould be written"'-when manual actions..were not feasible
-a*
t
,ea*s,-
K NRC-doe's n'ot intendl to6suspend inspections NRC agreed to; consider alternatives -
August 29, 2002 4
'. Charles R. Ogle - NRC VIEWS ON MANUAL ACTIONS ppt, 4
I.. - -----
Paa
-sWhat NRC 'Insp'ctor Look for (When is :aj-'ik'f:7.
Manual ACTion :feasi be1 Procedures and -trainingfor manual
" actios to'be.performed
- -`'a,Thermal-hydraulic timeline or other.'
analysis to show:that thereis-,
adequate time,-staffing,:and,
-diagnostic instrumentation to' "Pertorm manual actions---.-.-.---
.-Acceptable-environmen'tal conditions-
.(;temp, radiation, lighting,
- -acces'sibility) -
August29,2002 5
'.Charles R. Ogle - NRC VIEWS ON MANUAL ACTIONS.ppt Pag S
~~~~:;.NRC-,Will
""fitin :e -;
j.. "
_nidndai litac ions:
4 Wchee are w ew.
~... :.'
..'--. NRC-.will.continue'.to ins'p'ec~t "..'
All manu~al actions musbe'easible- (ini
- procdurs, ith su~ppriga lys
'i 0 -'!-p-erform able)'
' !' *- '-!_'i
'...Licensees'; are. respon.siblb'f it e
plants4.
et their
-. '.NRC pos'ition in May 16 letter remains unchanged -at this;time NRC: is,.inhvestigating:alternativetsfor O
permitting feasible manual actions in' lieu of current ll I.G. 2. Provisions-' Perhaps.' !
rulemaking'. and Interim Enforcement Policy 6
August 29, 2002