ML031600788
| ML031600788 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Indian Point  |
| Issue date: | 05/21/2003 |
| From: | Adragna M US Federal Judiciary, Court of Appeals, 2nd Circuit |
| To: | Cummings D NRC/OGC |
| References | |
| 03-4313, DD-02-06 | |
| Download: ML031600788 (12) | |
Text
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE SECOND CIRCUIT UNITED STATES COURT HOUSE 40 FOLEY SQUARE NEW YORK 10007 ROSEANN B. MACKECHNIE CLERK David Cummings, Esq.
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Office of the General Counsel Mail Stop 0-15D21 Washington, DC 20555-0001 NOTICE Date: May 21, 2003 Docket No.: 03-4313 Re: Riverkeeper, Inc. v. Collins
Dear Counsel:
This is to advise you that the Agency record in the above referenced case is being temporarily retained in the Agency.
We have received the certified index to the record, and the record is deemed filed with this Court.
This will not affect your scheduling order or the time for filing your briefs.
If you have any need to examine the Agency record, please contact the Agency before contacting the Court of Appeals.
ROSEANN. MACKECHNIE, Clerk By: U h
A Michael Adragna Deputy Clerk, USCA
bb02- 0(0 IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE SECOND CIRCUIT
)
RIVERKEEPER, INC.,
)
Petitioner,
)
)
- v.
)
)
COLLINS, et a)
)
Respondents
)
Docket No. 03-4313 CERTIFIED INDEX OF THE RECORD I hereby certify that the documents listed and described below in the Certified Index Record constitute the record of the decision by the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission t respondent herein, in the above-captioned case.
GePA REG&
Respectfully submitted, 0%.~~
Annette L. Vietti-Cook Secretary of the Commission I
Dated at Rockville, Maryland this 15' day of May, 2003.
coPYO.....
b -
.y A
w14 LIEU Or S=CC'.O
F--
DATE:
BMCShlcf c
CERTIFIED INDEX OF THE RECORD Thursday, May 1 2003 RAS DOCKET ID NO. NUMBER PLANT NAME DESCRITON DOCUMENT DOCKET RELATED ACCESSION DATE DATE CORRES.
NO.
5001 50-003/2471286 INDIAN POINT 1 2 (2.206) AND 3 DD-02 LETTER FROM SAMUEL J.
COLLINS TO ALEX MATllIESSEN ENCLOSING DIRECTORS DECISION (ADAMS PACKAGE) 5101 50-003/247t2B6 INDIANPOINT 1,2.
(2.206) AND 3 6391 50-003/247/286 INDIAN POINT1.2, (2.206) AND 3 6392 50-003/247/286 INDIAN POINT 1.2.
(2.206) AND 3 6393 50-003/247/286 INDIAN POINT 1. 2, (2.206) AND 3 DD-02 LE1TER SECY TO MATHIESSEN IMFORMING COMMISSION DECLINED ANY REVIEW; DECISION BECAME FINAL AGENCY ACTION ON IV13/02 -
SERVED SECTION 2.206 REQUEST FOR EMERGENCY SHUTDOWN OF INDIAN POINT UNITS 2 AND 3, DATED NOVEMBER S.2001 U.S. CONFERENCE OF MAYORS, IF U.S. CITY/COUNTY METRO ECONOMIES WERE NATIONS.' AT HTTP:..WWW.USMAYORS.ORG/ClTlES DRIVETHEECONO,MY/CHART2.DECAD B.PDF (LAST VISITED NOV. 7,2001).
PEITIONERS EXHIBIT I DANIEL RUBIN. "NUCLEAR TERRORISM THREAT GROWING."
(KNIGHT REDDER FOREIGN SERVICE.
NOVEMBER 3,2001). PETrIIONERS EXHIB rr 2 12/1812002 12118/2002 I1/01/2001 05/13f2003 05/13/2003 11/03/2001 05/13/2003 11/18/2002 11/19/2002 ML022630294 ML023520485 ML013480179 I
RAS DOCKET ID NO. NUMBER PLANT NAME DESCRIPON DOCUMENT DOCKET DATE DATE RELATED ACCESSION CORRES.
NO.
6394 50-0031247/286 INDIAN POINT 1. 2, (2.206) AND 3 6395 50-0031247/286 INDIAN POINT 1, 2, (2.206) AND 3 6396 50-0031247/286 INDIAN POINT 1, 2, (n206)
AND 3 6397 50-003P247/286 INDIAN POINT 1 2, (2106) AND 3 6398 50-003n47/286 INDIAN POINT 1.2, (2.206) AND 3 CNN. THREAT AT THREE MLE ISLAND CLOSES AIRPORTS.,
(OCTOBER 18. 2001). PETITIONERS EXHIBIT 3 NTRNATIONAL ATOMIC ENERGY AGENCY, "CALCULATNG THE NEW GLOBAL NUCLEAR TERRORISM THREAr (NOVEMBER, 2001)..
PETMONERS EXHIBIT 4 ERIC PIANIN AND DAN EGGEN,
'PREPARATIONS STEPPED UP FOR POSSIBLE NEW ATTACKS."
(WASHINGTON POST, NOVEMBER 1.
2001). PETlTIONERS EXHlBrr5 LARA MANSNERUS AND JUDrrH MILER TERRORiSTDETALS HIS TRANNG IN AFGHANISTAN," (N.Y.
TIMES. JULY 4. 2001). PETITIONERS EXHIBIT 6 NICHOLAS RUFFORD, DAVID LEPPARD AND PAUL EDDY,
'NUCLEAR MYSTERY: CRASHED PLANES TARGET MAY HAVE BEEN REACTOR." (SUNDAYTIMES:
LONDON, UK. OCTOBER 21,2001).
PETrrIONER'S EXHIBIT 7 10/182001 0511312003 11/01/2001 05/13/2003 11/01/2001 05/1312003 07104/2001 05/13/2003 10/21/2001 05113/2003 2
RAS DOCKET ID NO. NUMBER PLANT NAME DESCRIPTION DOCUMENT DOCKET DATE DATE RELATED ACCESSION CORRES.
NO.
6399 so-003r247/286 INDIAN POINT 1, 2, (2.206) AND 3 CNN. "FAA RESTRICTS FLIGHTS NEAR 10/30/2001 WORLD SERIES, NUCLEAR PLANTS" (OCTOBER 30.2001). PETITONERS EXHBIT 8 6400 50-03n47/286 INDIAN POINT 1, 2.
(2.206) AND 3 6401 50-003/247(286 INDIAN POINT 1. 2, (2.206) AND 3 WLLIAM BRANIGIN, IN AFGHAN JALe A TERRORIST WHO WONT SURRENDER." (WASHINGTON POST.
OCTOBER 30, 2001). PETIONEUS EaIBIT 9 NRC. PRESS RELEASE NO.01-112, "NRC REACTS TO TERRORIST ATTACKS" (SEPTEMER 21,2001).
PETITIONERS EXHIBIT 10 10/30r001 05/13/2003 09/21/2001 05/13/2003 6402 50-003/247n86 INDIAN POINT 1, 2.
(2.206) AND 3 NRC REPORT, TECHNICAL STUDY OF 10/31/2001 SPENT FUEL POOL ACCIDENT RISK AT DECOMMISSIONING NUCLEAR POWER PLANTS." (OCTOBER 2000).
PETrTIONERS EXHBIT I I 6403 50-003/247/286 INDIAN POINT 1, 2, (2.206) AND 3 US DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY, "HEALTH AND ENVIRONMENTAL CONSEQUENCES OF THE CHERNOBYL NUCLEAR POWER PLANT ACCIDENT, DOE/ER-0332 (JUNE 1987) 06/30/1987 05/13/2003 05113/2003 05/13/2003 3
RAS DOCKET ID NO. NUMBER PLANT NAME DESCRIPTION DOCUIENT DOCKET DATE DATE RELATED ACCESSION CORRES.
NO.
6404 50-0031247/286 INDIAN POINT 1, 2.
(2206) AND 3 6406 50-o3/247/286 INDIAN POINT 1,2 (2.206) AND 3 6407 so-0032472a6 INDIAN POINT 1, 2.
(2206) AND 3 V. L SALER ET AL SEVERE ACCDENT IN SPENT FUEL POOLS N SUPPORT OF GENERIC SAFETY ISSUES 82,' NUREGICR-4982 (JULY 1987)
ROGER WITHERSPOON. INDIAN POINT CHIEF: PLANT SAFE FROM POSSIBLE ATTACK,' (JOURNAL NEWS, OCrOBER 20,2001).
PETrlONERSEXHIBrr 12 VIBEKE LAROI "NUCLEAR PLANT SCARE ADDS TO U.S. SECURrY JITTERS." (REUTERS, OCTOBER 18.
2001). PTITIONERS' EXHIBIT 13 071311987 05113/2003 10/20/2001 05/1312003 10/1182001 05/13/003 6408 50-0031247/286 INDIAN POINT. 2, (2.206) AND 3 DOUGLAS PASTERNAK, A NUCLEAR 09/17/2001 NIGHTMARE," (U.S. NEWS & WORLD REPORT, SEPTEMBER 17, 2001).
PETrIONER'S EXHIBIT 14 6409 50-003n47/286 INDIAN POINT 1,2, (2.206) AND 3 PAULL LEVENTHAL COMMENCEMENT ADDRESS TO THE CLASS OF 2001 AT FRANKLIN &
MARSHALL COLLEGE (MAY 13, 2001).
PETITIONERS EXHIBIr 15 05/13/2001 05/13t2003 05/13=003 4
RAS DOCKET ID NO. NUMBER PLANT NAME DESCRIPTION DOCUMENT DOCKET DATE DATE RELATED ACCESSION CORRES.
NO.
6410 50-003/247/286 INDAN POINT 2, (2206) AND 3 6411 50003/247/286 INDIAN POINT 1. 2, (2206) AND 3 6412 s0-003247/26 INDLJN POINT 1.2, (2.206) AND 3 SHAWN COHEN. NRC FLAGS ConEd WITH RED TAG FOR INDIAN POrNT,'
(JOURNAL NEWS. NOVEMBER 21.
2000). PETITIONERS EXHIBrT 16 SANDIA LABS, NRC. CALCULATION OF REACTOR ACCIDENT CONSEQUENCES" ( 9B2) (CRAC-2 REPORI)
"AT INDIAN Pr. A HISTORY OF NUCLEAR POWER, PROBLEMS AND CONTROVERSY, (N.Y. TIMES, MAY 6, 1983). PETITIONERS EXHIBIT 17 11/2112000 0511312003 11/151/1982 05/13/2003 05/06/1983 05/132003 6414 50-003/247/286 INDLkN POINT 1. 2, (2.206) AND 3 6415 50-003/247/286 INDIAN POINT 1. 2, (2.206) AND 3 DECLARATION OF 20 DECEMBER 2001 12/20/2001 BY GORDON THOMPSON IN SUPPORT OF A PETITION BY RIVERKEEPER, INC, DATED DECEMBER 20,2001.
05/13/2003 LETTER FROM SAMUEL COLLINS 12/20/2001 05/13/2003 (NRC) TO ALEX MATTHIESSEN (RIVERKEEPER) ACKNOWLEDGING RECEFIPT OP RIVERKEEPER'S 2.206 PETITION AND DENYING IMMEDIATE CLOSURE OF INDIAN POINT 2 AND 3.
DATED DECEMBER 20,2001.
ML013610467 ML013510656
RAS DOCKET ID NO. NUhlBER PLANT NAME DESCRIPTION DOCUMENT DOCKET DATE DATE RELATED ACCESSION CORRES.
NO.
6416 50-003247/286 INDIAN POINT 1, 2.
(2.206) AND 3 UCENSEE'S RESPONSE TO RIVERKEPER, INC.S SECTION 2.206 REQUEST FOR EMERGENCY SHUTDOWN OF INDIAN PONT UNITS 2 AND 3. DATED FEBRUARY 11, 2002 021112002 05113/2003 6417 50-003/247/286 INDIAN POINT 1, 2.
(2.206) AND 3 6418 50-003/2471286 INDIAN POINT 1,2, (2206) AND 3 NRC SUPPLEMENTAL INSPECTION 04/112001 REPORT NO. 05000247/2001-002.
INDIAN POINr UNT 2 (APRIL 10.2001)
C511312003 AEC REGULATORY GUIDE 1.78 (JUNE 06/30/1974 05/1312003 1974) 6419 50-003/247286 INDIAN POINT 1,2, (2.202 AND 3 6420 50-003/247/286 INDIAN POINT 1, 2, (2.206) AND 3 NRC INSPECTION MANUAL INSPECTION PROCEDURE 1110, OPERATIONAL SAFEGUARDS RESPONSE EVALUATION (JULY 1, 1997)
LETTER FROM NRC CHAIRMAN RICHARD MESERVE TO SENATOR JAMES 3EFFORDS (DECEMBER 17.
2001) 07/0111997 05113/2003 12/17/2001 05/13/2003 ML020430500 ML011000373 ML003740298 ML013380256 6
RAS DOCKET ID NO. NMBER PLANT NAME DESCRIPTION DOCUMENT DOCKET DATE DATE RELATED ACCESSION CORRES.
NO.
6421 50-003247/286 INDIAN POINT 1. 2, (2.206) AND 3 LETTER FROM G. SCOTT BARBER (NRC) TO J. BARRETT (ENTERGY)
(DECEMBER 31,2001) (ENCLOSING NRC INSPECTION REPORT o/286101-09) 12I31/2001 0511312003 6422 50-003/247/286 INDIAN POINT 1 AND (2.206) 2 6423 50-003/2471286 INDIAN POINT 1. 2, (2.206) AND 3 NRC OFFICE OFNUCLEAR REACTOR 10/2512000 REGULATION, DIRECTIVE 8.11.
"REVIEW PROCESS FOR 10 C.F.R. 2.206 PETITONS" (OCTOBER 25. 2000)
'MALEVOLENT USE OF VEHICLES AT 001/1994 NUCLEAR POWER PLANTS" 59 FED.
REG. 38889 (1994) 6424 50-003/247/296 INDIAN POINT 1. 2.
(2.206) AND 3 "FIAL RULE: PHYSICAL PROTECTION FOR SPENT NUCLEAR FUEL AND HIGH-LEVEL RADIOACTIVE WASTE" 63 FED. REG.
26955 (1998) 05/15/1998 05/13/2003 6425 50-003/247/286 INDIAN POINT 1, 2 (2.206) AND 3 NUREG-0800, SECTION 3.5.1.6.
'STANDARD REVIEW PLAN FOR THE REVIEW OF SAFEY ANALYSIS REPORTS FOR NUCLEAR POWER PLANTS' ML013650345 05/13/2003 ML003670845 05/13/2003 05/13/2003 7
RAS DOCKET ID NO. NUMBER PLANT NAME DESCRIPTION DOCUMENT DOCKET RELATED ACCESSION DATE DATE CORRES.
NO.
6426 50-003/247/286 INDIAN POINT 1. 2, (2.206) AND 3 NUREG-0654/FEMA-REP-1 (REV. 1).
'CRrrERIA FOR PREPARATION AND EVALUATION OF RADIOLOGICAL EMERGENCY RESPONSE PLANS AND PREPAREDNESS N SUPPORT OF NUCLEAR POWER PLANTS.'
AVAILABLE ON USNRC ELECTRONIC READING ROOM 6427 50-003f247/286 INDIAN POINT 1. 2, (2.206) AND 3 NRC INSPECTION REPORT 95000286/2000.10 (DECEMBER S. 2000) 12/08nOOD 05113/2003 6428 50-003/2471286 INDIAN POINT 1. 2, (2.206) AND 3
- EVALUA:IION OF AIRCRAFr-CRASH-06/3(V1982 HAZARDS ANALYSES FOR NUCLEAR POWER PLANTS,' NUREGICR-2859 (JUNE 1982) 6429 50-003/247/286 DIAN POINT 1. 2.
(2.206) AND 3 PROPOSED DIRECTORS DECISION UNDER IOCFR 2.206, DATED MAY 16, 2002 05/16/2002 05/1312o3 6430 50-00312471286 INDIAN POINT 1. 2, (2.206) AND 3 RIVERKEEPERS COMMENTS ON MAY 08/09/2002 16 2002 PROPOSED DIRECTORS DECISION ON RIVERKEEERS NOVEMBER 8TH PETITION 2.206 REQUEST FOR EMERGENCY SHUTDOWN OF INDIAN POINT UNrrS 2 AND 3 DATED AUGUST 9 2002 05113/2003 MLD03175738 05/13/2003 ML021340261 05/13/2003 ML226304728
RAS DOCKET ID NO. NUMBER PLANT NAME DESCRIPTION DOCUMENT DOCKET DATE DATE RELATED ACCESSION CORRES.
NO.
6431 5-0031247t2g6 NDIAN POINT 1,2, (2.206) AND 3 6433 50-003/247J786 INDIAN POINT 2.
(2.206) AND 3 NATIONAL RESEARCH COUNCIL,
'MAKING THE NATION SAFER: THE ROLE OF SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY IN COUNTERING TERRORISM," (2002). PETMONER'S EXHBIT A ASSOCIATED PRESS, PLANES OFTEN 0410/2002 ENTER PROHIBIED AIR,' (APRIL 5.
2002). PETMONER'S EXHIBITB 6434 50-003/247286 INDIAN POINT 1,2, (2.206) AND 3 6435 50-003/2471286 INDIAN POINT 1 2.
(2.206) AND 3 6436 50-003/247/266 INDIAN POINT 1.2, (2.206) AND 3 ABC NEWS, SUBWAYS. SCUBA DIVERS AND LANDMARKS." (MAY 27.
2002). PETITIONER'S EXEIBT C CBS NEWS, DOZENS OF AIRPORT WORKERS ARRESTED," (APRIL 23, 2002). PETrrIONER'S EXHIBIT D CBS NEWS. "AIRPORT SECURITY GETS AN ?" (MARCH 25,2002).
PETrIONER'S EXHIBITE 05/27/2002 05/13/2003 04/3/2002 05/13/2003 03/25/2002 05113P2003 0511312003 0511312003 9
RAS DOCKET ID NO. NUMBER PLANT NAME DESCRIPTION DOCUMENT DOCKET DATE DATE RELATED ACCESSION CORRES.
NO.
6437 S0-003f2471206 INDLAN POINT 1, 2, (2.206) AND 3 NUCLEAR CONTROL INSTITUTE, "THE 02/1212002 IMPACT OF NUCLEAR PLANT SHUTDOWN ON SEVERE ACCIDENT CONSEQUENCES," (FEBRUARY 12, 2002) 6438 50-003/247/286 INDIAN POINT 1, 2.
(2.206) AND 3 6439 50-003/247/286 INDIAN POINTI 1. 2, (2.206) AND 3 REP. EDWARD MARKEY. SECURITY GAP. A HARD LOOK AT TH SOF SPOTS IN OUR CIVIIIAN NUCLEAR REACTOR SECURrrY." (MARCH 25, 2 02)
NRC, REGULATORY ISSUES
SUMMARY
(RIS) 2001-16. UPDATE OF EVACUATION TIME ESTIMATES' (AUGUST 1. 2001) 03/25/2002 05/13/2003 08101/2001 05/13/2003 05/1312003 ML012070310 10