ML20206B914

Refers to Open Mgt Meeting Conducted at Licensee Request in Atlanta,Ga on 990414 Re Recent Crystal River 3 Plant Performance.List of Attendees & Copy of Presentation Handout Encl

ML20206B914
Person / Time
Site:	Crystal River
Issue date:	04/20/1999
From:	Wert L NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION II)
To:	Cowan J FLORIDA POWER CORP.
References
NUDOCS 9904300121
Download: ML20206B914 (24)

Text

,.

April 20,1999 Mr. John P. Cowan, Vice President Nuclear Operations Florida Power Corporation ATTN: Manager Nuclear Licensing (SA2A)

Crystal River Energy Complex 15760 West Power Line Street .

Crystal River, FL 34428-6708

SUBJECT:

MEETING

SUMMARY

STATUS OF PLANT PERFORMANCE CRYSTAL RIVER 3 - DOCKET NO. 50-302

Dear Mr. Cowan:

This refers to the open rnanagement meeting that was conducted at your request at the Region ll officn 2.n Atlanta, Georgia on April 14,1999. The purpose of the meeting was to discuss recent Crystal River 3 plant performance. A list of attendees and a copy of your presentation handout are enclosed. It is our opinion that the meeting was informative and provided a candid assessment of Crystal River performance.

In accordance with Section 2.790 of NRC's " Rules of Practice," Part 2. Title 10 Code of Federal Regulations, a copy of this letter and its enclosures will be placed in the NRC Public Document Room.

Should you have any questions concerning this letter, please contact us.

Sincerely,

( Original signed by L. Wert )

Leonard D. Wert, Chief I Reactor Projects Branch 3 1 Division of Reactor Projects Docket No. 50-302 License No. DPR-72

Enclosures:

1. List of Attendees

2. Florida Power Corporate Handout cc w/encts: (See page 2) 9904300121 990420 PDR ADOCK 05000302 P PDR

)

)

.rtVS

FPC- 2 cc w/encis: Chairman -

Charles G. Pardee, Director Board of County Coramissioners

' Nuclear Plant Operations (NA2C) Citrus County

. Florida Power Corporation 110 N. Apopka Avenue i Crystal River Energy Complex inverness, FL 36250 '

15760 West Power Line Street Crystal River, FL 34428-6708 . Michael A. Schoppman Framatome Technologies Sherry L. Bernhoft, Director 1700 Rockville Pike, Suite 525 Nuclear Regulatory Affairs (NA2H) Rockville, MD 20852-1631

~ Florida Power Corporation Crystal River Energy Complex -

15760 West Power Line Street Crystal River, FL 34428-6708 Gregory H. Halnon, Director Quality Programs (SA2C)

Florida Power Corporation Crystal River Energy Complex 15760 West Power Line Street Crystal River, FL 34428-6708

~ R. Alexander Glenn Corporate Counsel

' Florida Power Corporation MAC - ASA P. O. Box 14042 -

St. Petersburg, FL 33733-4042 Attorney General Department of Legal Affairs The Capitol Tallahassee, FL 32304 William A. Passetti Bureau of Radiation Control Department of Health and Rehabilitative Services -

2020 Capital Circle SE, Bin #C21 Tallahassee, FL 32399-1741 Joe Myers, Director Division of Emergency Preparedness

. Department of Community Affairs 2740 Centerview Drive Tallahassee, FL 32399-2100

FPC 3 Distribution w/ encl:

L. Plisco, Ril L. Wert, Ril -

S. Ninh, Ril L. Wiens, NRR P. Steiner, Ril PUBLIC NRC Resident inspector U. S, Nuclear Regulatory Commission 6745 N. Tallahassee Road Crystal River, FL 34428 OFFICE RH:DRP .

SIGNATURE r NAME SN%

DATE _Wll, /99 4/ /99 4/ 199 & /99 - 4/ /99 W /99 & 199 COPY? IFE8 NO YES NO YES NO YES NO YES NO YES NO YES N OFFMAL RECORD COPY ' DOCUMENT NAME: G:\ CRYSTAL \ MEETING \41499. sum

LIST OF ATTENDEES

~ Florida Power Corooration J. Holden,- Vice President & Site Director C. Pardee, Director Operations R. Rodorick, Director, Engineering & Projects R. Davis, Assistant Plant Director, Operations M. Schiavoni, Manager, Maintenance G. Chick, Assistant Director, Outage / Work Controls L. McDougal, Manager, Regulatory Nuclear Reaulatory Commission L. Reyes, Regional Administrator, Region ll (Ril)

J. Johnson, Deputy Regional Administrator, Rll B. Mallett, Director, Division of Reactor Safety (DRS)

H. Berkow, Director, Project Directorate 11, Office Of Nuclear Reactor Regulations (NRR)

C. Casto, Deputy Director, Division of Reactor Projects (DRP)

L. Wert, Branch Chief, Branch 3, DRP S. Peterson, Section Chief, Project Directorate ll, NRR L. Wiens, Senior Project Manager, Project Directorate 11, NRR W. Rogers, Senior Reactor Analyst, DRS S. Ninh, Project Engineer, Branch 3, DRP l

Enclosure 1 l

1t{$s,c'1 1l1 o

5?;yi O

"D 1 4 3 @

y g

, O "D x h '

p m T \

s @ ~

.> @ 2

, $ m m $ L e

o 5 ,

e O c 2 z

- 1

, 4 --4 y

\

1 J

/ //

A

• .

• Q ,

g, g$,,{f6 3 @

p p

f, oy -

1 oo o

O. C ,. -

C '. O e,

• s G #

9 s C- 1 A G c 0 O, 1

4 G

h. O m

' 4 O

C O 4

O O4Qh 4 4 o e O 1 1 1O ?o s '

O stg@\

o O < -

O O

O

/

an E

i.au:3,ch 5 s d E$3 3;-

g_

8$, >% e e. + );

s *s. ,

{$t, "

M -

m 9

g a e%

&# 6 C

s ea g3 4 b, j o? g 4

-et 8"s g Ns 5 gj e

• o et s

.A s *t. gb^ i%t.

1 @

s

• a

>i c: t

. - %s m o A.

$ $i ' S Y 4

A

' k,A @

s$g T $'. Q 4

'\

. 9d sus s*tg,

% s Q

a a i t noi R s a es a

s.

e s

s e .a e

H e " e e san s s gf,

" "es

• c r

F i n4 al4P i

t hf o W g ay et EY%eW r h R 3

Y W p st C

H e h a r A r P

t t N U lP s s u ,

ys m r

e o oi r

o %O n 1 l

s ef f

ea ti ,4 e v ef o t I Us r v e C

mt .m n u ar eni a

sC

& a 9 1 r u%

h ,

I c al s3 p n o

t e v e eb r a

9 9 i t u ,

ai i el e t hn ea n a ui v

I m

aj n l

be n

ee r n g e

_ e sC

. R t b

i l

i -

3 mal bb eli I ic l

iti t

y o y r g

e ng g

y _ - s4 e

y F

a r i oei f

Ho t

s f

. n S

ee r n aer tio a

_ e rC 4

c t

o Pf 7 1m y ni t

_ - s3 e r i t s o t h r e 5 t n S ai t c o

e a c

nr l G m eC s ai n

s MS, t

{ o o

o a

0 0

0 mR a4 r

,. l t W

u p

R a a t s A

a e e e gk, e

it ni o m n s s s e m # U t

E e . e e n ho p e f t

'WA m 3 l

a Eh e W N

R Y Fe N r t ot a r A n Ws D g N n e oi r

s u y m e n f o ef MO e d

st ef o I C Uc ny r

eu nn 9

5C C mt

• a cp . R a

_O h >

t o e I

, v F el a 04 p t

hn u -

ae ie en n n 7

a eav l e

r e b

. n '

C ad g d S li u ia a bw y e i C i mal 4 i at g n d4R y t

I l

i e e N

b bi t e ng r i el r i y r ey L oei t

r al o -

f s S t o 9 s

. Eo ' y is os 7C s

,=

Ff s nes . R D

Wth ' , t 94 F t

r e , e 9 a at , l m E n

c t

ir eC c I n a si

• G o eC o o r

n s

> 5 o o SR 0 0 I

. a4 t

0 C

l r l t

s u

a a a a e 8 a *

• A s

m _ s e .

e

- 3

. t r YW a W E N r A N U n

T so A

N m p u em %O p f O e r

r b l n nt h g ,7 re a e e 0 0o 9 n 5C n O

l s .

. b u .C Un 0 u f

.R e

m - .R n yc hn 04 o-f

.,4 a v A opl u

r a I

7 d A

s n u aC R

t h n e .

i l o ed f

9 8C t

o

.C aP c R

. n u-a R

4 bo r i a i u 94 m v liw t

t 8 a

S co t H i e t am t

a-a W

,C R

y r y

S l a ot p i e

r c

I 9

7C

- A-ci S

c '

s

. e-s _ 4 s t

a ti r c I 93 9

a r

s o E e oa E f

c n

m nms n m t

h e c s e eC I f

t SR G 0

a r a4 t

r 0 0

4 p t

u p

t u I

[

e o s

t o

o j

i s

e , " t 9 *

[ gf #

e F

T o C h R ea 7

• s r o ay c+pP t t al 3 W

l ai v o i p s Y

el e Y" r t a

ac l

l mev ef ef t

i .

g r A A

. O N c t

i v

e a

r g b ees at d

ja o

f I.AN e ,

T h

r m

i l

1

,4 1

l r

i v

r ew 9

od 5C R u c 0 C a 9 u n o -

i s t

oe

- - R 94 a s hi t

e e 0 ,4 R l 9

9 n

ti r 7 d dv a P pdqe eui -

i a abl c

. e r

3 t t e v

9 i u g ,C 8 f e 5C o 9 o r a ar 4 s el o n

- ~ 93 - R-n l g s o

1 5

r nt 8 E r s o

m n

eec l

r ei

- 9 7C p

x o

s h se a ht i

1 0 C a

n c -

b v

e d

S i

_ - H-93 9

s u

r er a

t r e at a

t - l 0

0 0

g ue n e y t e o l

c e G Yg o

~

o ESau t

r o

W l

t p

j2I(1 1 g

0 0 o 1

Wt m0 ,m A

V a s t

o i

a V g E E E ol e s o 7

• o s o c 4 7

• 4 5 4

' a4  : 4 4 1 l

oS r

_ u 3 u r t

e R m W e a e e Y m c d e f

W N

r A t o N e ey r A e N s

f

%O o ds t a a c e

nO ol .

f nt de i

r di S F 9 np r 9 u O

e r 5C 8C a

d a

- - - R ol oi R e d 94 7

i d

r m m a - - Q 4

l f o ar 3 R

o yi-oa r ct di v

9 6C R

a ly zi e c d o e 9 e

li psi e - R d o 3C a

- oal - - R f

ow s a 94 8

i o r n - 0 4 b i

I N

t 4 as a pl 1 li i-l t c

- t e a 1 y 9 t n 3 9 n 7C i t v

o f i - - - R 94 e c 1 oa - lpG o

o 9C Q4

- R D

n nc t o al 9 1 f

o W

a di iivi t

oy t e

l r

• s n, m t s e I o

C

1. i N t e. 1 8 A

g f u o o

r m o

s o " N1 " 0 0 i t

o o

o o

o b m Ce Rr I I p C u o I O 4o Y W n r i m n

T f

' A N d ip t ' c p

e a I" O u ea Ng e c s sr r

s ci t t s i

T- C od r oo h h ne O

l n r o nn et 8 C y

S mo i

f 9 C R

o um e l s p[ 7M a i t t

i 7

4 g i gnhe

~

er r e f ht s

2t s e v c R

t r 0r y a o l n Sy

,0 ci u c l C

t e 0e t

8W 8 A ee 9 R eI a n 0 d c snt 8 4

c f r mdci S

0w o r a l mro i

t d t i

o ak l e h o n Gat

,r i C n s o l C

l G

e o 0

8 R

4 t ef 9 9 R- Y1 oo n r o 0 R

is me l 3 o e r

a l a p el l a

ww t u r t c t oro e iid t e o r k r e

k e da d y s L 5 ]

F x $2e a p

1 r ihWE 1 2 3 4 3 . 6 7 8 9 0 l 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1

,4

- - - - - - - - - - - 1 9

9 9

1 9

9 -

5 ~

I

~N l

1 NP DO 9

9

' 6 I

CP e

l AE 1

9 9 3 TR OF o 7 OO RO I

e n C d R-u s 3 o

t r

y I R NM 1

9 M oe 9

8 - d DA i

e - a n o

- EN S

i n

c e

V O

XC e S t

a r

t O

D

'n u

6 p

F i 8P a

p C

r l

1

,4 1

9 9

9 s

T 3

(

P R P E L L

A F RR LEHE P F_P er P o R A_E t

eRp D l

C Ca o mgi m c Dst r c: I r t_O /i l

S Se t f

w e S@

r al E I Pg_hel ma MN t

/ o eus aI Sy r r a R n cpa/aDEid Pg n n Pnt nr n ep r e

r s e_e l otdiOd! e i

! xmneyS r eti c e_e_e s n s c r e n s n cd es we n F O

r_y su _y id oSAnDN P is R I N T cnf f t u t aCoa i t ei ci e eFr Ar T hS r

nc el t s e Can ac M e ee aE Miri nr eld Amie f t i

r cc_PaeL nei n Lar A Rn ie _Spx ati R a pareka etcFjdj l i we Psio oe ss n N A P iu e enc lig u odsi ot f .k Wnc ay t ct a c wn s C

. o nioor t t p

b ir y Pti e a r r

ulgy_

oSnm a g t o nr o i oi et n SS n S> N7r ies_or f e E y

io_

l t

cE oa eq Cci nl s

t_

e _c n _e a yy Sy s0 l

Ft_sy s t s 2

e e%m0 t

o0 r

I N

D R E Psut r

go Pml r

sirp o are eEela_

Em__e f

f ul R e aeet i

l u.m m _m

r. .

r l

m pe _aHo 0

h er u I

C A

Y R e ___ T n f n

i s 7 nI U mf

/F f _

c o t c et b _ 0_a_s t

O tt RrC r

PmPteiOlcy_ _ 0 i

r h e y _

t ti 0 et R NO

_ i

. a ea r v _

s R r nf e c _ _

h mci S con o

f _

r er u s oa ee r d s r

m emsrn as e

__ C v_l a

ER p

Ro a n

_ r i_

l c

ge sn t

n_. c i c e e _

c_

. ul e e _

a l M

_ _ _ l a

t o Q u

M A r

y 1 1 1 1 444 2 4 4 84444 2222 4 2 4 a _

R e 000 0 00 00000 0 00 0 0 0re t A N

. s r p l.

s o 1 n 0 s

e l

8 9

! N U .C 2

O 9

8 E

A 3

. 0 9

8 i

0 9

4

)

L ~

7 8

y-,/

O i

dddf9 f6

,..m

@ o t 3gk w

$o0%T 9

1 , s, ,* '

d B do f, ,

4 9

9 o'" e o g9 0 y e g $ ^ 1 gp o,

$ o O Q c.

p O  %. 4 Ok e o g, g3 '

O #

,C 9 $

,. 5 o ti o O C t*

o C.

o

. C O

O O

O O

ll F

c r

P a yL9 p st r

ial l

C 1 r i

,4 v

' 1 r PDCTSAMh U 9

l e o r pp a 9

9 tieA n

3

• a v n a ep a l n e f n cl i i

l nl it n e O n

i n pog ug n ct ii i

f c a a P

i g ig n

ma Fe ia r

P ai t

oS e s E o

t i o n t r n o R r r t

n n sf t no on Oa Se u

l a r ig A t

m F T r

n a i

t n p u I Pd ug r o e r Ss su o n v d O oc C e a N nc o d m S

ne tn Te

. es o r e tn l

s c a O

l i

o h l n s n i c V

.E a

l R

V I

. E 9 W

F S

ay p st r

li a 1

,4 c

r r

i v

e 4P C H MTS u a a r c a Mt r 1

9 9

r tilA D

n e

9 3

mi ih t n

a t n e e r n .

n eng i

n d ig u a t M P a e n e Cs h l l A

I r

f c E o  :

N o e x n r

mR e d c t i T a s i

u t

i o .E n k c A i

o n n

N e s s

A e .N s

s C m

e E

n t

P

.O r

o V

. g r

E R

~

a m V I

E 1

0 W -

F ay c

r P

C p st r

li a 1 r

,4 1 r i4C e

l v

e MHSCh a 9

9 9

us ni a o u e t

r 3 c

we l

iu n l s c t

e e e s Cn

-M n e k s og .A a e in e n o s s I

cp e n P i n o  :

N Rg l l

i d

T u S a n a E l

t e a n io t

i N

Kn dg n n n a A o r N

. wds l

C e

d g

E:

e

. O V

E R

V I

E u W

u c

a ya P p st r mF S

r li a 1

,4 r

i v

e r

p lA 1

t mBJ T

~

I I 9 0 a CmiwCr 9 n e

9 ti p mt io 3 c Op hmn r k r e o l v o e Rov np Omgt l

i E ig n s e e d s en o h s N g Ro e

D d t e l

u Ds r

aP t

ir G

I s

e u i o s &o i o N ic t ng iQnr st g

n o i

n u a

i i

z E

n Cl t i a E

aBs hy t

i o R s a o n I n f

-N i

/

. s g i e S a

n P u m p G d r b o M om c t i r

t a O a e t n r

g s a s s l c V i

n e

F E

s a c

R t

o I V

r s E n W ~

l1l F

C ay p st r

i a l

1

,4 c

r r

i v

e iPC ls 1 r I

R P I h 9 U op ma n

t e - - - - r 9

9 t 3

n i

e f u

P R e

S n

F l l

g ig e

l a r r .

r a

e n l

t a

c u

b e

P r o a v n E t

e 1 1 C o

t o

r b

e r o

mign e N.

d Tr P mEn p

r s

t e

c Ug p O:

s G I

o e u p p g

i t

ig o p

. N.

t e n n r a e a r e r E Tr e d e a r i e at E

n t i n s ni

. P l

o n

g F

g R I

a u R

. n t

e l e l

N i

s P

u i

a b

G s r c i u l h

O i

e a t y

s s L

e L o

.V i

s n E t

g T

R e

r V

I m E 1

3 -

W ~

l 1lll1

~F T

yP C n 9 P

L P

- R e

f h

a l

D l

a e r u l e

n v o e n t e l

j e

l 1 g C 1 c t 1 e o

n S S O s S

d c h

u ma u

t ~P CE i

t i e mg o d n u a s e yr l

e HC AF I

O O v v LI e

r v

e r LC i v E N S e i e

ww T

. GA E T SI O

N u

Il

o

~

F P

• * - - ~ $~

$ 9 CI n RR RH O H l i

a s e e e gi u P >

b t g p p t I e a l

u a l a h a /

g S

l i

P l

s a a c l

r L s r e t tie e E P I G

i I o gn m s q /

n e s u E o T r

n t

u r

i p F N e

f C n o o s a

f T

u mW e S I

F n f o

V B r n y s

PIC e

t r

o mR r T b

i n

t H t e R A l

R e r 4

- e a t

c m ON o

o s B i

n U J E T h

d /

4 s p p g D CR D e r r c a TE i

. v "

t i d e o e S

A" n s SF p

a T a n

~

U o

r e

r a

i d E n L o 1 1

1 5 =

~

F

• * *

• TPC CI n P C RC MPr I@

o s a ol e o o o mt a t

f n

t r

omniv p o up S

l i i t

r l

a r n t l o d e t mu e te r e I s o e s i n R G i

i s n Ud o g o p Rn e r

s fo g r

R e

e q o C iu d N I

N a a u f r c n F

e e d c iA r u d w t o t

r ip n

g p ia t

s n PIC e S o B Ond e t y c R A t

a Ou o ON t i Sl d u i I i

n o i o Hi t

a x C P J n An g e R

" S o E T e

A S g " w CR i

r t L C e a a o C r TE o

n d n r i S

d d a e d c iu u SF o

r d s r

t i

ot i

p p U o

s a n

n s

l y E d

L o 1 1

1 6

~

~

F 6

R e

R @i R Mn F R I

B g o e a l

o s .

n wde c S

t ia t l k G o i Ss u u I r D t gip G

i r d n n i

g i

P e -

o i

t g a s n l

a d e w1 .

N I

S r 9

~

u i

n f o

7 F b

c s

t a

r Cp U PIC o

o o

l l

R g r

R A L

ON l

i n o D a e

g wL d e J E T i

P g M r h s o'

a r e t -

g i

n s

s s

CR -

e (

T-u r

e TE S

i n SF o

a t

j e

U o

) c t

i o

E n L o 1 1

1 7

~

~F P

a P M

l a

i Wp n p t r

'Un S l h 1 i

t u

t ,4 e d

' a c O o f

1 mR h t f

- w 9 T o l i n 9 r n 9 u

r B S e t

aDer h n nr e u n E ia a t d

e - mi n k o i m c w n

s H D iR o n p p P S e C n /

t S d S'

i e t e e H c

t r y

/

L e

a n s

a n n e

y d

P m H

i i

o o d e r n D t G n N r g

o a

i e U e R o v e UR s p B" n z a n n e g " e r

V z l

c u

d r a H e P l

F a D t e D u e W d e

e s o r a e m r o

TE o

r W s e F W

d m

x k P l l o & id u G o o r P i

n e e d k l a s F m t D F p n C c a l u

e e l R r a a n o l

a t

s h

E t a n i OU o l o F r

& H n e

U F u

a d

E e e L

1 1

l S

h u

f t

e n

d WE NL f

l e

O A" U D ,

T i e

A s e

G l G

E M

e n

e r

a H D R1 A

E1 t r o P a r i J K n O P C R

t T a n

a F W& U l

T A

EO R

S e m

K o v

S e LU

. I n

t N e o g z r z ,

a T

l t e e D d a

. E m S

HA D F e

4a r A &

w S I n

s E

t C e t o s a AG t l o n l d H i-o e n a e d e

TE r

U V n a o c u

U t

eDn u m

l i

n 1

8 e

P ~

7' ggg4i n' 3 aa e

nn %

car c hk:O S *1 BP' 1 b{*I g

It I 9

j  ;

t-1 1 1 d H

[1

~

5

[I s

//  :

3-l  ;

[

4

~

I wi i

. t 1 i

%u

" 4 \

a

~

h

- l

- 1{ '(slt i

5 10

/

'. .o t 4 dYrO nnr 5)*f

,e O

f O

\

f g '

9 \

' to \

5 y

f m

0 0

0 0

4