ML20199B039

Discusses NRC & Science Applications Intl Corp in-progress Audit of Dcrdr & SPDS During Wk of 860127.Licensee Committed to Submit Dcrdr Summary Rept & SPDS SAR by 870301

ML20199B039
Person / Time
Site:	Big Rock Point File:Consumers Energy icon.png
Issue date:	06/02/1986
From:	Zwolinski J Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
To:	Berry K CONSUMERS ENERGY CO. (FORMERLY CONSUMERS POWER CO.)
Shared Package
ML20199B041	List: ML20199B039 ML20202J564
References
NUDOCS 8606160322
Download: ML20199B039 (4)

Text

'

• g g,*s 7 t o g y 4 33 UNITED STATES 8s,%C## [ ,g E NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION WASHINGTON, D. C. 20555

Qd5 j#l June 2, 1986 Docket 50-155 Mr. Kenneth W. Rerry Director, Nuclear Licensing Consumers Power CoTpany 1945 West Parnell Road Jackson, Michigan 49201

Dear Mr. Berry:

SURJECT: RIG ROCK POINT (RRP) IN-PROGRESS AUDIT OF THF DETAILED CONTROL ROOM DESIGN REVIEW (DCRDR) AND THE SAFETY PARAMETER DISPLAY SYSTEM (SPDS)

Re: Rig Rock Point Plant The NRC staff, supported by the technical assistance contractor, Science Anolica-tions International Corporation (SAIC), conducted an in-progress audit of the DCRDR and SPDS at Rig Rock Point during the week of January 27, 1986. The purpose of the audit was to clarify certain aspects of the DCRDR review process, to confirm that Consumers Power Company's (CPC'sl review is being conducted appro-priately, and to evaluate CPC's results of the review to that point in time.

Our staff audited CPC's methodologies and processes being used to conduct its DCRDR and concluded that with the incorporation of our comments contained in Enclosure 1, CPC should be able to complete a satisfactory DCRDR.

In addition, we discussed with CPC its plans for implementing the SPDS in tle control room in accordance with the requirements of Supplement 1 to NUREG-0737.

CPC had originally planned to request a deviation from the recuirement for the SPDS, with justification being provided by the results of the DCRDR. CPC, hecause of the small size of the RRP control room, proposes that the existing instrumentation on the main control panels are adequate to serve as an SPDS.

CPC suggested that it . night highlight instruments which display critical safety function information. The Audit Team informed CPC that this approach to pro-viding an SPDS will require a safety analysis report (SARI which should describe:

(11 the basis on which the selected parameters are sufficient to assess the safety status of the critical safety functions identified in Supplement 1 to NUDEG-0737 for a wide rance of events which include symptoms of severe accidents; (2)thelicensee'splanforverificationandvalidationoftheproonsedSPDS; (3) the isolation devices, if any, that will suitably isolate SPDS displays from electrical and electronic interference with equipment and safety systems; (4) the human factors enoineering program to be used to ensure that displayed information can be readily perceived and comprehended by the operator without any ambiguity; and (5) how this approach will adeouately support the functions of the Technical Support Center (TSC) and the Emergency Operations Facility (E0Fl. Enclosure 2, which was prepared by SAIC, presents notes taken during our SPDS discussions with CPC during the audit.

8606160322 860602 5 DR ADOCK 0500

I

, c w., .

Mr. Kenneth W. Berry June 2, 1986 ,

A list of Audit pari.icipents is included as Attachment N to Enclosure 1.

By submittal dated March 27, 1986, CPC committed to submit a DCRDR Surnary Report and an SPDS SAR by March 1, 1987. Integrated Plan Open Issues listing, Issue Numbers BN-005 and BN-006 have been updated to reflect this commitment.

If you have any questions concerning the information presented above, or the contents of the Enclosures, please contact your NRR Project Manacer.

Sincerely, 1 A 6 M "M ohn A, wulinski, Director BWR Power Directorate #1 (DivisionofBWRLicensing

Enclosures:

As stated cc w/ enclosures:

See next page DISTRIBilTION w/

Enclosures:

Docket Files' NRC PDR Local PDR TRotella BRP Service List RRameriz DISTRIBtJTION w/o

Enclosures:

BWD-1 r/f RBernero MFineberg, SAIC GJohnson, LLNL t'y EJordan MSrinivasan OELD BGrimes JPartlow CJamerson ACRS(10)

BWD-1: DBL D-1*C JZ olinski

[LA:BWD-1:DBLM CJamerson/em/hmc 6/1/86 TRotella 6/1/86 , 6/[/86

, , I

, , s.- .

Mr. Kenneth W. Rerry /, list of Audit participants is included as Attachment N to Enclosure 1.

Py submittal dated March 27, 1986, CPC committed to submit a DCRDR Summary Report and an SPDS SAR by March 1, 1987. Intearated Plan Open Issues listing, Issue Numbers BN-005 and RN-006, have been updated to reflect this commitment. l If you have any ouestions concerning the infonnation presented above, or the contents of the Enclosures, please contact your NRR Pro,iect Manager.

Sincerely,

\ 1 \ \

QCWidMT/r,

' .lohn A. Zwolinski, Director

, BWR Power Directorate #1 Division of RWR Licensing

Enclosures:

As stated cc: See next page

o s -

Mr. Kenneth W. Ferry Consumers Power Ccmpany Big Rock Point Plant cc:

Mr. Thomas A. McNish, Secretary Consumers Power Company 21? West Michioan Avenue Jackson, Michigan 49701 Judd L. Bacon, Esquire Consumers Power Company 212 West Michigan Avenue Jackson, Michigan 49201 Rig Rock Point Plant ATTN: Mr. David P. Hoffman Plant Superintendent Route 3 Post Office Pox 591 Charlevoix, Michigan 49720 Mr. I. Lee Moerland Chairman, Roard of Comissioners P. O. Rox 218 Charlevoix, Michigan 49720 Office of the Governor Room 1 - Capitol Puilding .

Lansing, Michigan 48913 Regional Administrator Nuclear Pegulatory Comission, Region III l 799 Roosevelt Road

! Glen Ellyn, Illinois 60137 l Nuclear Facilities and Environmental l Monitoring Section Office

! Division of Radiological Health l

P. O. Rox 30035 Lansing, Michigan 48909 Pesident Inspector  !

Big Rock Point Plant c/o U.S. NRC RR #3, Rox 600 Charlevoix, Michigan 497?O l

l 24 l

. _ . - _ - _ - _