ML15314A105

2015 Clinton Power Station Initial License Examination Submittal Comments

ML15314A105
Person / Time
Site:	Clinton
Issue date:	11/10/2015
From:	Division of Reactor Safety III
To:
Zoia, C D
Shared Package
ML15124A054	List: ML15313A055 ML15313A061 ML15313A062 ML15313A063 ML15313A064 ML15313A066 ML15313A201 ML15314A105
References
Download: ML15314A105 (3)

Text

Clinton Power Station ILT Class 14-1 Exam Date 3116/15 Operating Test 2015-301 I I tem# I UnSat/Editorial I JPM417 Editoria l JPM418 Editorial JPM429 Editoria l JPM247 Ed it orial JPM501 Editorial JPM531 Editor ial JPM534 Editorial JPM537 Editorial

-ILT 14-1 NRC Exam Submittal Comment s Date Received:

2/13115 Chief Examiner Comment Facility Action/Response Qperatina Test Chanoe estimated comoletion time from 15 minutes to 35 m i nutes. Chanoed as requested.

• Add action to simulator setup instructions to turn the synch scope on, verify Changed as requested.

clockwise rotation and adjust DG speed if necessary, and then turn the synch scope back off. . Step 8.2.12.6 -add comment that JPM can be terminated when VARS are with in ranae (500-0 KVAR\ and aenerator load is beina raised.

• General note -add steps for evaluato r to annotate performance of the A and Changed as requested.

B FCVs.

• Step 8.4.2.2. -add cue " If examinee requests to use "d ouble deten t, authorize use.

• Add a comment to step 8.4.2.2. to d i scuss the amount of FCV movement that is reauired to meet the th reshold of a minor reactiv i tv manaoement event.

• Typo on page 7 -step 4.1 -standard third bullet -remove the word "i s" in Changed as requested.

front o f MIA.

• Step 5.8 -add to the cue -If the operator sends an EO to the RCIC Room , cue him/her that there are no abnormalities i n the room and that the RCIC Turbine is rota tina slowlv.

• Move S imul ator Setup action #2 to after action to just before action 7 (Fr eeze Changed as requested.

the s i mu l ator)

• Add remaining TCVs (2, 3, 4) to JPM .

• Add cues that the plant is stable .

• Delete instructor stationed

@ P678 -NRC will orovide P678 cue .

• Add the first 3 steps (FC031A, 19A & 21A) to the i n iti al conditions.

Changed as requested.

• Add 8.3.2.3 to the initial conditions .

• Put a copy of 9000.01 in examinee binders Changed as requested. . Put a copy of the blank data sheet in the exam lnee binders

• Chanae Estimated Comoletion Time f rom 1 O to 20 minutes .

• Remove second sentence from INITIAL CONDITIONS (leaving ONLY, "Th e Inco r porated all 6 changes as requested. plant i s in Mode 1 ")

• Remove the following words from the INI TIATING CUE, " for MS IVs 1621-F022A and 1B21-F022B".

• Fix typo -8.1.1.3 shou ld be 8.1.2.3 .

• Add the fo llowi ng_ to the cue for step 8.1.1.3 -When examinee reoorts that ------.. -****-1B2f.F022B closed fully after the test push b utton was released, acknowledge

-*-the report and state, "Take appropr i ate action fo r the va lve closure".

• On the marked up copy of CPS 9031.10 , delete the N/A'ed steps .

• Step 8.2.5.2 -Standard -Change to read, "No action required.

Permission rece i ved in th e steo 8.2.5.1 Time Comoress io n cue" Clinton.Power Station ILT Cla ss 14-1 Exam Date 3/1 6/15 Operating Te st 2015-30 1 Item# UnSat/Editorial JPM423 Editori a l JPM532 Editorial JPM535 Un sat JPM536 Editorial JPM538 Ed it orial JPM244 Ed it orial J PM451 Editorial Scenario 1 Ed i tor i al ::;cenano 1 *---eai!Orlal Scenario 1 Ed it or ial Scenar i o 1 Ed i to ri al ILT 14-1 NRC Exam Submittal Comments Chief Examiner Comment . Step 8.3. 1 .1 #1 on page 8 -change the standard to read "E xaminee enters " Open and/or On" in t h e Or i g i na l Condition fie l d of CPS 3512.0 1 F002".

• Step 8.3.1.1 #2 on page 8-change the standard t o read "Examinee enters "Not Ooen and/or Off" in the Original Cond it ion field of CPS 3512.0 1 F 00 2". . A d d 'Today's date is 1 1/27/14" to t h e ini tial condit i ons block. . JPM Stec 3 Cue -Add " i f requested , prov i de RWP (Attachment

1)

• Change the f irst sentence of the init i a l cond ition s block to read , " The plant was operating at rated thermal power wi t h no out of service equ i pment."

• De lete the 2 00 sentence i n the Initial Cond i tions b l ock (NO L COs a r e i n effec t.)

• Change the f i rst bulleted i tem i n the Initia t in g cue block to read , T echnical Specification actions are requ i red to be entered , and if t h e event i s reportable, the reportability req ui rements. Delete the second bulleted li ne.

• JP M step 1 standard -Add ITS 3.6.1.3 A.1 and A.2 t o the list.

• Terminating Cues -Cha ng e the term i nating cue to read, " Examinee has evaluated I T S and determined repon lng r equireme nts for inoperablllty of the H i gh Pressure Core Sorav (HPCSl Svstem". Steo 4 Standard -add Channel 3 to the end of the first bu lle ted li ne. Step 1 Standard -soecilv reauirements for I TS 3.6.1.3 Act ion A.1 and A.2

• S t ep 8.5.8.3 Standard -change the standard to read, " S i mu l ates placing th e Main Control Switch i n MANUAL 1 and/or Ma nual 2. . S t ep 8.2.2 Cue -Add a cue that flow noise can be heard i f requested by t he exam i nee.

• Add alarms that are expected to be In to the i nit i al cond i tions b l ock.

• Step 8.4.6.1 -Add a cue that describes w h at alarms are in and i f they are expected to reset when steo 8.4.6.1 i s pe rf ormed. Event 4 TDRFP 'A' High Bearing Temperature

-the MDRFP. is started per sect i on 8.1.3 MDRFP Startup and section 8.1.6 Tra n s iti on from a TORFP to a MDRFP but the scena ri o quide onlv references section 6.1.3. -cFC'ommen!

-sFi OUT d we cna:riae lo soeea i.JDCfiTeT6 lransler lo A l ter computer po i nts CW-BA027 , 28, and 29 to simulator lesson p l an for event #7 to add realism. Event Tr i ggers and Role P l ay -Event #4 -add EO cue (i i d ir ec te d to raise cooling w ate r flow\ -"Flow Is hiah i n the band". Date Received:

2/13115 Facilit Action/Res onse Changed as requ ested . Cha n ged as re q uested . Cha ng ed as r eq uested . Cha n aed as requested.

Cha n aed as requested.

Cha n ged as requested.

C ha nged as requested.

<Cil-* . ...

.. ... Added CPS 3103.01 sec ti on 8.1.6 to the A T C act io ns b l ock. NO r eas 16 ie way lo ao llils=lefl as 1s. Added computer poin t s to the s imu lato r lesso n plan to cause them to ramp up -30°F over 1 O mi nutes. Added EO cue #6 to e vent 4 Clinton Power Station ILT Class 14-1 Exam Date 3/16/1 5 Operating Test 2015-301 Item# I UnSat/Editorial I Scenario 1 Editorial Scenario 1 Ed it orial Scenario 1 Ed i torial Scenario 2 Ed i torial Scenario 2 Editorial Scenario 2 Ed i torial Scenario 2 Editorial Scenar io 2 Editorial Scenario 3 Editorial Scenar io 3 Editorial Scenario 3 Editoria l Scenario 3 Ed i tor i al Scenario 1, Ed i tor i al 2, and 3 *-... ILT 14-1 NRC Exam Submittal Comments Chief Examiner Comment Event T r igge rs and Role Play -Event #4 -add EO cue (if directed to check TDRFP bearina bubbler flow) -"Bubb ler flow is normal." Event Tr igge rs and Role Play -Event #8 -add cue from field concern in g local gas boundary inspect i ons. Event Tr i ggers and Ro l e Play -Event #4 -add EO cue to repo rt no abnorma l ities if requested to check TDAFP 'A' room conditions on the camera. Event 7/8-the actions required to perform "Term i nate and prevent LPCS and L PCI inject ion" are not detai l ed in the scenario guide. Event 7/8 -t he crew may " Anticipate Blowdown" but those actions are not lis ted in the scenario gu i de. The c r itical tasks listing on page 4 of the scenario guide needs to be revised to reflect that EOP-6 does not require a blowdown on high Conta i nment Pressure unless contain.ment p r essure cannot be be low F ig. N. Even t 6 -the actions to terminate HPCS injection are reversed from those contained on the hard card. Event 4 -need to add r i sing trend to the CAD temperature reported from the area operator.

Event 6 -Validation crew swapped the runn i ng SPE b l owers; those actions are not li sted in the Annlicant's Actions or Behavior block of the scenario au i de. Event 8 -Validation c r ew entered ITS 3.4.5 RA B.1 but the ITS reference i s not lis ted in the scena r io au i de. The ITS 3.1.5 pressure lim it value for accumulator pressure is <: 1520 psig. In the scenar i o gu i de f or Event #7, the accumu l ator pressure is reported to be 1540 psig. Chanae the reported pressure to 1510 psig. Event B -Add SRO action to direct RR Loop emergency isolat i on Add MCA Baseline data to PPG 10 i n the simulator setup instr uctio ns. -.. -. Date Received:

2/13/15 Facility Action/Response Added EO cue #7 to event 4 Added EO cue #3 to event 8. Added EO cue #8 to event 4. Added actions required to Termina te and Prevent LPCS and LPC I injection to the BOP Actio n s for Event 7/8 in the Scenar i o 2 sim auide. Added " Anticipate Slowdown" to the ATC and SAO actions block for events 7/8. Mod i fied the PC-7.1 critical tas k listing in the scenario outline to ind i cate that a blowdow n i s not required if containment pressure can be lowered below EOP*6 Figure N after anticipating blowdown. Rev i sed critical task l isting PC-7.1 to state , 'W it hin 1 0 minutes of exceeding Figure N and conta in ment pressure continu i ng to r ise, the SAO will enter EO P*3 Emergency RPV Depressur i zation. If the crew Ant i c ip ates Slowdown using bypass valves , and in do i ng so Conta inme nt Pressure can be reduced I maintained be l ow Fig. N , then this critical task is considered to be met. IPAA\ Swapped actions t o shut 1 E22-F004 and Stop the HPCS oumo in the BOP actions b l ock of event #6. Added trend i nformation to event 4 EO cue 1a. Added open bullet action to the Event 6 BOP actions b l ock. Added ITS 3.4.5 to the SRO Actions block f or event 8. Changed all i nstances of 15 40 psig to 1510 ps i g. Added to ATC & SRO act i ons for event #8. Added to the S i mulator O perator Ini tial Se tup instructions.

• -

Clinton Power Station ILT Class 14-1 Exam Date 3116/15 Operating Test 2015-301 I I tem# I UnSat/Editorial I JPM417 Editoria l JPM418 Editorial JPM429 Editoria l JPM247 Ed it orial JPM501 Editorial JPM531 Editor ial JPM534 Editorial JPM537 Editorial

-ILT 14-1 NRC Exam Submittal Comment s Date Received:

2/13115 Chief Examiner Comment Facility Action/Response Qperatina Test Chanoe estimated comoletion time from 15 minutes to 35 m i nutes. Chanoed as requested.

• Add action to simulator setup instructions to turn the synch scope on, verify Changed as requested.

clockwise rotation and adjust DG speed if necessary, and then turn the synch scope back off. . Step 8.2.12.6 -add comment that JPM can be terminated when VARS are with in ranae (500-0 KVAR\ and aenerator load is beina raised.

• General note -add steps for evaluato r to annotate performance of the A and Changed as requested.

B FCVs.

• Step 8.4.2.2. -add cue " If examinee requests to use "d ouble deten t, authorize use.

• Add a comment to step 8.4.2.2. to d i scuss the amount of FCV movement that is reauired to meet the th reshold of a minor reactiv i tv manaoement event.

• Typo on page 7 -step 4.1 -standard third bullet -remove the word "i s" in Changed as requested.

front o f MIA.

• Step 5.8 -add to the cue -If the operator sends an EO to the RCIC Room , cue him/her that there are no abnormalities i n the room and that the RCIC Turbine is rota tina slowlv.

• Move S imul ator Setup action #2 to after action to just before action 7 (Fr eeze Changed as requested.

the s i mu l ator)

• Add remaining TCVs (2, 3, 4) to JPM .

• Add cues that the plant is stable .

• Delete instructor stationed

@ P678 -NRC will orovide P678 cue .

• Add the first 3 steps (FC031A, 19A & 21A) to the i n iti al conditions.

Changed as requested.

• Add 8.3.2.3 to the initial conditions .

• Put a copy of 9000.01 in examinee binders Changed as requested. . Put a copy of the blank data sheet in the exam lnee binders

• Chanae Estimated Comoletion Time f rom 1 O to 20 minutes .

• Remove second sentence from INITIAL CONDITIONS (leaving ONLY, "Th e Inco r porated all 6 changes as requested. plant i s in Mode 1 ")

• Remove the following words from the INI TIATING CUE, " for MS IVs 1621-F022A and 1B21-F022B".

• Fix typo -8.1.1.3 shou ld be 8.1.2.3 .

• Add the fo llowi ng_ to the cue for step 8.1.1.3 -When examinee reoorts that ------.. -****-1B2f.F022B closed fully after the test push b utton was released, acknowledge

-*-the report and state, "Take appropr i ate action fo r the va lve closure".

• On the marked up copy of CPS 9031.10 , delete the N/A'ed steps .

• Step 8.2.5.2 -Standard -Change to read, "No action required.

Permission rece i ved in th e steo 8.2.5.1 Time Comoress io n cue" Clinton.Power Station ILT Cla ss 14-1 Exam Date 3/1 6/15 Operating Te st 2015-30 1 Item# UnSat/Editorial JPM423 Editori a l JPM532 Editorial JPM535 Un sat JPM536 Editorial JPM538 Ed it orial JPM244 Ed it orial J PM451 Editorial Scenario 1 Ed i tor i al ::;cenano 1 *---eai!Orlal Scenario 1 Ed it or ial Scenar i o 1 Ed i to ri al ILT 14-1 NRC Exam Submittal Comments Chief Examiner Comment . Step 8.3. 1 .1 #1 on page 8 -change the standard to read "E xaminee enters " Open and/or On" in t h e Or i g i na l Condition fie l d of CPS 3512.0 1 F002".

• Step 8.3.1.1 #2 on page 8-change the standard t o read "Examinee enters "Not Ooen and/or Off" in the Original Cond it ion field of CPS 3512.0 1 F 00 2". . A d d 'Today's date is 1 1/27/14" to t h e ini tial condit i ons block. . JPM Stec 3 Cue -Add " i f requested , prov i de RWP (Attachment

1)

• Change the f irst sentence of the init i a l cond ition s block to read , " The plant was operating at rated thermal power wi t h no out of service equ i pment."

• De lete the 2 00 sentence i n the Initial Cond i tions b l ock (NO L COs a r e i n effec t.)

• Change the f i rst bulleted i tem i n the Initia t in g cue block to read , T echnical Specification actions are requ i red to be entered , and if t h e event i s reportable, the reportability req ui rements. Delete the second bulleted li ne.

• JP M step 1 standard -Add ITS 3.6.1.3 A.1 and A.2 t o the list.

• Terminating Cues -Cha ng e the term i nating cue to read, " Examinee has evaluated I T S and determined repon lng r equireme nts for inoperablllty of the H i gh Pressure Core Sorav (HPCSl Svstem". Steo 4 Standard -add Channel 3 to the end of the first bu lle ted li ne. Step 1 Standard -soecilv reauirements for I TS 3.6.1.3 Act ion A.1 and A.2

• S t ep 8.5.8.3 Standard -change the standard to read, " S i mu l ates placing th e Main Control Switch i n MANUAL 1 and/or Ma nual 2. . S t ep 8.2.2 Cue -Add a cue that flow noise can be heard i f requested by t he exam i nee.

• Add alarms that are expected to be In to the i nit i al cond i tions b l ock.

• Step 8.4.6.1 -Add a cue that describes w h at alarms are in and i f they are expected to reset when steo 8.4.6.1 i s pe rf ormed. Event 4 TDRFP 'A' High Bearing Temperature

-the MDRFP. is started per sect i on 8.1.3 MDRFP Startup and section 8.1.6 Tra n s iti on from a TORFP to a MDRFP but the scena ri o quide onlv references section 6.1.3. -cFC'ommen!

-sFi OUT d we cna:riae lo soeea i.JDCfiTeT6 lransler lo A l ter computer po i nts CW-BA027 , 28, and 29 to simulator lesson p l an for event #7 to add realism. Event Tr i ggers and Role P l ay -Event #4 -add EO cue (i i d ir ec te d to raise cooling w ate r flow\ -"Flow Is hiah i n the band". Date Received:

2/13115 Facilit Action/Res onse Changed as requ ested . Cha n ged as re q uested . Cha ng ed as r eq uested . Cha n aed as requested.

Cha n aed as requested.

Cha n ged as requested.

C ha nged as requested.

<Cil-* . ...

.. ... Added CPS 3103.01 sec ti on 8.1.6 to the A T C act io ns b l ock. NO r eas 16 ie way lo ao llils=lefl as 1s. Added computer poin t s to the s imu lato r lesso n plan to cause them to ramp up -30°F over 1 O mi nutes. Added EO cue #6 to e vent 4 Clinton Power Station ILT Class 14-1 Exam Date 3/16/1 5 Operating Test 2015-301 Item# I UnSat/Editorial I Scenario 1 Editorial Scenario 1 Ed it orial Scenario 1 Ed i torial Scenario 2 Ed i torial Scenario 2 Editorial Scenario 2 Ed i torial Scenario 2 Editorial Scenar io 2 Editorial Scenario 3 Editorial Scenar io 3 Editorial Scenario 3 Editoria l Scenario 3 Ed i tor i al Scenario 1, Ed i tor i al 2, and 3 *-... ILT 14-1 NRC Exam Submittal Comments Chief Examiner Comment Event T r igge rs and Role Play -Event #4 -add EO cue (if directed to check TDRFP bearina bubbler flow) -"Bubb ler flow is normal." Event Tr igge rs and Role Play -Event #8 -add cue from field concern in g local gas boundary inspect i ons. Event Tr i ggers and Ro l e Play -Event #4 -add EO cue to repo rt no abnorma l ities if requested to check TDAFP 'A' room conditions on the camera. Event 7/8-the actions required to perform "Term i nate and prevent LPCS and L PCI inject ion" are not detai l ed in the scenario guide. Event 7/8 -t he crew may " Anticipate Blowdown" but those actions are not lis ted in the scenario gu i de. The c r itical tasks listing on page 4 of the scenario guide needs to be revised to reflect that EOP-6 does not require a blowdown on high Conta i nment Pressure unless contain.ment p r essure cannot be be low F ig. N. Even t 6 -the actions to terminate HPCS injection are reversed from those contained on the hard card. Event 4 -need to add r i sing trend to the CAD temperature reported from the area operator.

Event 6 -Validation crew swapped the runn i ng SPE b l owers; those actions are not li sted in the Annlicant's Actions or Behavior block of the scenario au i de. Event 8 -Validation c r ew entered ITS 3.4.5 RA B.1 but the ITS reference i s not lis ted in the scena r io au i de. The ITS 3.1.5 pressure lim it value for accumulator pressure is <: 1520 psig. In the scenar i o gu i de f or Event #7, the accumu l ator pressure is reported to be 1540 psig. Chanae the reported pressure to 1510 psig. Event B -Add SRO action to direct RR Loop emergency isolat i on Add MCA Baseline data to PPG 10 i n the simulator setup instr uctio ns. -.. -. Date Received:

2/13/15 Facility Action/Response Added EO cue #7 to event 4 Added EO cue #3 to event 8. Added EO cue #8 to event 4. Added actions required to Termina te and Prevent LPCS and LPC I injection to the BOP Actio n s for Event 7/8 in the Scenar i o 2 sim auide. Added " Anticipate Slowdown" to the ATC and SAO actions block for events 7/8. Mod i fied the PC-7.1 critical tas k listing in the scenario outline to ind i cate that a blowdow n i s not required if containment pressure can be lowered below EOP*6 Figure N after anticipating blowdown. Rev i sed critical task l isting PC-7.1 to state , 'W it hin 1 0 minutes of exceeding Figure N and conta in ment pressure continu i ng to r ise, the SAO will enter EO P*3 Emergency RPV Depressur i zation. If the crew Ant i c ip ates Slowdown using bypass valves , and in do i ng so Conta inme nt Pressure can be reduced I maintained be l ow Fig. N , then this critical task is considered to be met. IPAA\ Swapped actions t o shut 1 E22-F004 and Stop the HPCS oumo in the BOP actions b l ock of event #6. Added trend i nformation to event 4 EO cue 1a. Added open bullet action to the Event 6 BOP actions b l ock. Added ITS 3.4.5 to the SRO Actions block f or event 8. Changed all i nstances of 15 40 psig to 1510 ps i g. Added to ATC & SRO act i ons for event #8. Added to the S i mulator O perator Ini tial Se tup instructions.

• -