ML20055G666: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
VisualWikitext
StriderTol Bot insert
 
StriderTol Bot change
 
Line 16: Line 16:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:'
{{#Wiki_filter:G lR '
G lR '
g.a.pc s *;,
g.a .pc                 '
:9:
s *;,       :9:                       ,
t QN.'
t       '
+
QN.'                                             <
(y A
                                                          +                   '
7 Y'
A    7 (y                                                                     '
M et
et  Y'   M (e mg         y-
( mg
                                                                                , y+.                                           ,
, y+.
p ._                 .
e y-p._
F ,- ,
F,-,
p                                        m-                ,
. w.
                                                                .              +
JA 18 tm p
                                                                                  . w.               JA 18 tm
m-
    ~
+
                            -Docket No. 50-454.-
~
-Docket No. 50-454.-
DocketiNo. 50-455.
DocketiNo. 50-455.
s                   lEA 90-082
s lEA 90-082
                            . Commonwealth Edison Company:
. Commonwealth Edison Company:
: f.                 AfTN:- Mr.-Cordell Reed N                                         : Senior Vice President-a                         . Opus WestLIII-                                                                                        '
f.
$                            11400 Opus Place -              .            -
AfTN:- Mr.-Cordell Reed N
                            ' Downers Grove, IL _60515 Gentlemen:
. Opus WestLIII-
                            !This confirms our-plans'as' discussed between Mr. T. K.-Schuster of your_ staff-
: Senior Vice President-a$
          ,                  and Mr. M. A. Ring of'this 'officel to have a meeting with you and members of'                           ,
11400 Opus Place -
our staff at the NRC Regional Of fice in Glen Ellyn, Illinois, on August 2,~ '199.0, >
' Downers Grove, IL _60515 Gentlemen:
                                    ~
!This confirms our-plans'as' discussed between Mr. T. K.-Schuster of your_ staff-and Mr. M. A. Ring of'this 'officel to have a meeting with you and members of' our staff at the NRC Regional Of fice in Glen Ellyn, Illinois, on August 2,~ '199.0, >
-s         >
~
                            -at 1:00 p.m.-(CDT). This meeting is'an: enforcement conference to discuss.
-s
                            'Regionaliand Office of: Investigation. findings related-to'the apparent lack of                                         ,
-at 1:00 p.m.-(CDT).
^
This meeting is'an: enforcement conference to discuss.
                              ' control-of operability determinationsJinvolving the emergency diesel                                             ,A1
'Regionaliand Office of: Investigation. findings related-to'the apparent lack of
                            - generators at Byron.. During this meeting you are requested to present'to"the;'                                 -    i staff:
^
$                            L 1. .                                                                 the. role and-responsibilities-
' control-of operability determinationsJinvolving the emergency diesel
:Discussionofthe_                     CECO: process (including (S&L)or-CnoperIndustries)'for of contractors such as.Sargent-'and.Lundy ensuring that potential operability, concerns,Ldiscovered at any point in
,A1
                                              ~
- generators at Byron.. During this meeting you are requested to present'to"the;'
O,                                      the process, are/were promptly evaluated and -communicated to thecaffected' plant. 'This should: include both the procedures, people,:and practices''in g                . place today and in place:in December.1986.                   <
i staff:
s '
L 1.. :Discussionofthe_ CECO: process (including (S&L)or-CnoperIndustries)'for the. role and-responsibilities-of contractors such as.Sargent-'and.Lundy ensuring that potential operability, concerns,Ldiscovered at any point in O,
~
the process, are/were promptly evaluated and -communicated to thecaffected' plant. 'This should: include both the procedures, people,:and practices''in
. place today and in place:in December.1986.
g s
a
a
                            .2.       Discussion of the responsibility of individual Ceco engineers with respect to detenaining operability upon learning of a potential _ issue,                                     j L                         familiarity with Technical Specifications and' design drawings for the engineer's systems,; appreciation of the need for: prompt action, and                                       jl ir documentation requirements.
.2.
: 13.      ' Discussion of item 2, aboy'e, for S&L engineers and Cooper engineers.                         '              I
Discussion of the responsibility of individual Ceco engineers with respect to detenaining operability upon learning of a potential _ issue, j
      $                    14. .     Discuss why 'a-potential _ emergency diesel generator _ operability is_ sue _ . ,
L familiarity with Technical Specifications and' design drawings for the ir documentation requirements.
initially discovered on December 4,1986, was not communicated to the Byron-3                                    and'Braidwood plants until December 17, 1986, including the following:                                     1
jl engineer's systems,; appreciation of the need for: prompt action, and 13.
: a.       Why the process permitted Cooper to take no action between                                         !
' Discussion of item 2, aboy'e, for S&L engineers and Cooper engineers.
initial notification on' December 5, 1986, and the preset                                         i teleconference date of December 17, 1986.                                                         3
I
                                      .b.         Why CECO Engineering did not contact the plant immediately                               ,O l following the 11:00 a.m. conference call when it was established that the affected switches were not seismically qualified?                                       l 9007240043 900718 PDR 'ADOCK 05000454 Q                               PDC JA
: 14..
Discuss why 'a-potential _ emergency diesel generator _ operability is_ sue _.,
initially discovered on December 4,1986, was not communicated to the Byron-and'Braidwood plants until December 17, 1986, including the following:
1 3
a.
Why the process permitted Cooper to take no action between initial notification on' December 5, 1986, and the preset i
teleconference date of December 17, 1986.
3
.b.
Why CECO Engineering did not contact the plant immediately
,O l following the 11:00 a.m. conference call when it was established that the affected switches were not seismically qualified?
l 9007240043 900718 PDR 'ADOCK 05000454 Q
PDC JA


(~ .,.-
(
                                                                                          )
)
~
U r
U r
L f            '
f L
            -Conrnonwealth Edison Company,             2             JUl.181990 In addition, discuss the corrective actions you have or should have taken' to' prevent the occurrence of the apparent violations.
JUl.181990
-Conrnonwealth Edison Company, 2
In addition, discuss the corrective actions you have or should have taken' to' prevent the occurrence of the apparent violations.
We appre61 ate your cooperation in this matter, and will gladly discuss any questions you may have concerning this meeting.
We appre61 ate your cooperation in this matter, and will gladly discuss any questions you may have concerning this meeting.
Sincerely, OrighaTsignedbyE.G.Creenman Edward G. Greenman, Director
Sincerely, OrighaTsignedbyE.G.Creenman Edward G. Greenman, Director t.
: t.                                                   Division of Reactor Projects-CC' T. J. Maiman, Vico President, PWR Operations
Division of Reactor Projects-CC' T. J. Maiman, Vico President, PWR Operations
:T. Kovach, Nuclear Licensing. Manager R. Pleniewicz,1 Station Manager DCD/DCB (RIDS)                                                               1 Licensing Fee Management Branch Resident Inspectors, Byron, j
:T. Kovach, Nuclear Licensing. Manager R. Pleniewicz,1 Station Manager DCD/DCB (RIDS) 1 Licensing Fee Management Branch j
Braidwood, and Zion D. W. Cassel, Jr.. Esq.
Resident Inspectors, Byron, Braidwood, and Zion D. W. Cassel, Jr.. Esq.
Richard Hubbard J. W. McCaffrey, Chief, Public Utilities' Division Diane Chavez,.DAARE/ SAFE                                                     l S. P. Sands, Acting NRR LPM                                                   '
Richard Hubbard J. W. McCaffrey, Chief, Public Utilities' Division Diane Chavez,.DAARE/ SAFE l
H. S. Taylor, Quality Assurance Division                                                                   i
S. P. Sands, Acting NRR LPM H. S. Taylor, Quality Assurance Division i
          ' Robert Newmann,-0ffice of Public Counsel, State of Illinois Center
' Robert Newmann,-0ffice of Public Counsel, State of Illinois Center
          -bec: J.'Lieberman, OE L. Chandler, OGC                                                       !
-bec: J.'Lieberman, OE L. Chandler, OGC J. Partlow, NRR i
J. Partlow, NRR                                                         i 7                                                                                         :j h
7
:j h
T5EEfATTACHED'CONCURRENCESjp u
T5EEfATTACHED'CONCURRENCESjp u
RIII                   RIII     RIII     RIII       RII I
RIII RIII RIII RIII RII I
Farber/bs             Shafer   Ring     Miller     Greennul n i
Farber/bs Shafer Ring Miller Greennul n i
l
l


oc
oc a
,. , .i .. . ,
i
a                  '
,.,.i...,
i V
V JUL 18199 e
e                  .
[
JUL 18199
Cormionwealth Edison C' mpany 2
[                 Cormionwealth Edison C' ompany            2 L.
o L.
r In addition; discuss the corrective actions you- have or should have taken   '!
r In addition; discuss the corrective actions you-have or should have taken to prevent' the occurrence of the apparent violations.
to prevent' the occurrence of the apparent violations.
We appreciate your cooperation in this matter, and will g!cdly discuss any P
  .              We appreciate your cooperation in this matter, and will g!cdly discuss any P               . questions you may have concerning this meeting.
. questions you may have concerning this meeting.
* Sincerely,-                           ;
Sincerely,-
d Edward G. Grewanan, Director Division of Reactor Projects' cc:             .
d Edward G. Grewanan, Director Division of Reactor Projects' cc:
'                T. J. Maiman, Vice President, t
T. J. Maiman, Vice President, t
PWR- Opera tions'
PWR-Opera tions'
                'T. Kovach -Nuclear Licensing Manager     .
'T. Kovach -Nuclear Licensing Manager R. Pleniewicz,' Station Manager DCD/DCB-(RIDS)
R. Pleniewicz,' Station Manager                                                 .
Licensing fee Management Branch
DCD/DCB-(RIDS)
. Resident Inspectors, Byron,
Licensing fee Management Branch                                                 ,
:l Braidwood, and Zion-D. W. Cassel, Jr., Esq.
,                . Resident Inspectors, Byron,                                                 :l' Braidwood, and Zion-D. W. Cassel, Jr., Esq.
Richard Hubbard J. W. McCaffrey, Chief, Public Utilities ~ Division'
Richard Hubbard J. W. McCaffrey, Chief, Public Utilities ~ Division'                                                         .
. Diane Chavez, DAARE/ SAFE S. P.-' Sands, Acting NRR LPM H. S. Taylor, Quality Assurance
                . Diane Chavez, DAARE/ SAFE S. P.-' Sands, Acting NRR LPM H. S. Taylor, Quality Assurance                                             -i Division-Robert Newmann, Office of Public Counsel,' State of. Illinois Center
-i Division-Robert Newmann, Office of Public Counsel,' State of. Illinois Center
                  . bcc ; d. /..r(6cc r1.oq 06 7                           L Cruct, CGC i
. bcc ; d. /..r(6cc r1.oq 06 7
                          <). fhrno% NRR I
L Cruct, CGC
                        $5                         gD             #
<). fhrno% NRR i
RI; I     RII'   Rill   > R111
I
* we    rb r/bs                 a er *fhRin VStr Miller PWGreenn gow<               u m.   ,140 i}}
$5 gD RI; I RII' Rill R111
*fh VStr rb r/bs a er Rin Miller PWGreenn
* we gow<
u m. _
,140 i}}

Latest revision as of 14:34, 17 December 2024

Confirms 900802 Enforcement Conference in Region III Ofc to Discuss Ofc of Investigations & Regional Findings Re Lack of Control of Operability Determinations Involving Emergency Diesel Generators at Plant.Listed Items to Be Discussed
ML20055G666
Person / Time
Site: Byron  
Issue date: 07/18/1990
From: Greenman E
NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION III)
To: Reed C
COMMONWEALTH EDISON CO.
References
EA-90-082, EA-90-82, NUDOCS 9007240045
Download: ML20055G666 (3)
v • d • e


Text

G lR '

g.a.pc s *;,

9:

t QN.'

+

(y A

7 Y'

M et

( mg

, y+.

e y-p._

F,-,

. w.

JA 18 tm p

m-

+

~

-Docket No. 50-454.-

DocketiNo. 50-455.

s lEA 90-082

. Commonwealth Edison Company:

f.

AfTN:- Mr.-Cordell Reed N

. Opus WestLIII-

Senior Vice President-a$

11400 Opus Place -

' Downers Grove, IL _60515 Gentlemen:

!This confirms our-plans'as' discussed between Mr. T. K.-Schuster of your_ staff-and Mr. M. A. Ring of'this 'officel to have a meeting with you and members of' our staff at the NRC Regional Of fice in Glen Ellyn, Illinois, on August 2,~ '199.0, >

~

-s

-at 1:00 p.m.-(CDT).

This meeting is'an: enforcement conference to discuss.

'Regionaliand Office of: Investigation. findings related-to'the apparent lack of

^

' control-of operability determinationsJinvolving the emergency diesel

,A1

- generators at Byron.. During this meeting you are requested to present'to"the;'

i staff:

L 1.. :Discussionofthe_ CECO: process (including (S&L)or-CnoperIndustries)'for the. role and-responsibilities-of contractors such as.Sargent-'and.Lundy ensuring that potential operability, concerns,Ldiscovered at any point in O,

~

the process, are/were promptly evaluated and -communicated to thecaffected' plant. 'This should: include both the procedures, people,:and practicesin

. place today and in place:in December.1986.

g s

a

.2.

Discussion of the responsibility of individual Ceco engineers with respect to detenaining operability upon learning of a potential _ issue, j

L familiarity with Technical Specifications and' design drawings for the ir documentation requirements.

jl engineer's systems,; appreciation of the need for: prompt action, and 13.

' Discussion of item 2, aboy'e, for S&L engineers and Cooper engineers.

I

14..

Discuss why 'a-potential _ emergency diesel generator _ operability is_ sue _.,

initially discovered on December 4,1986, was not communicated to the Byron-and'Braidwood plants until December 17, 1986, including the following:

1 3

a.

Why the process permitted Cooper to take no action between initial notification on' December 5, 1986, and the preset i

teleconference date of December 17, 1986.

3

.b.

Why CECO Engineering did not contact the plant immediately

,O l following the 11:00 a.m. conference call when it was established that the affected switches were not seismically qualified?

l 9007240043 900718 PDR 'ADOCK 05000454 Q

PDC JA

(

)

~

U r

f L

JUl.181990

-Conrnonwealth Edison Company, 2

In addition, discuss the corrective actions you have or should have taken' to' prevent the occurrence of the apparent violations.

We appre61 ate your cooperation in this matter, and will gladly discuss any questions you may have concerning this meeting.

Sincerely, OrighaTsignedbyE.G.Creenman Edward G. Greenman, Director t.

Division of Reactor Projects-CC' T. J. Maiman, Vico President, PWR Operations

T. Kovach, Nuclear Licensing. Manager R. Pleniewicz,1 Station Manager DCD/DCB (RIDS) 1 Licensing Fee Management Branch j

Resident Inspectors, Byron, Braidwood, and Zion D. W. Cassel, Jr.. Esq.

Richard Hubbard J. W. McCaffrey, Chief, Public Utilities' Division Diane Chavez,.DAARE/ SAFE l

S. P. Sands, Acting NRR LPM H. S. Taylor, Quality Assurance Division i

' Robert Newmann,-0ffice of Public Counsel, State of Illinois Center

-bec: J.'Lieberman, OE L. Chandler, OGC J. Partlow, NRR i

7

j h

T5EEfATTACHED'CONCURRENCESjp u

RIII RIII RIII RIII RII I

Farber/bs Shafer Ring Miller Greennul n i

l

oc a

i

,.,.i...,

V JUL 18199 e

[

Cormionwealth Edison C' mpany 2

o L.

r In addition; discuss the corrective actions you-have or should have taken to prevent' the occurrence of the apparent violations.

We appreciate your cooperation in this matter, and will g!cdly discuss any P

. questions you may have concerning this meeting.

Sincerely,-

d Edward G. Grewanan, Director Division of Reactor Projects' cc:

T. J. Maiman, Vice President, t

PWR-Opera tions'

'T. Kovach -Nuclear Licensing Manager R. Pleniewicz,' Station Manager DCD/DCB-(RIDS)

Licensing fee Management Branch

. Resident Inspectors, Byron,

l Braidwood, and Zion-D. W. Cassel, Jr., Esq.

Richard Hubbard J. W. McCaffrey, Chief, Public Utilities ~ Division'

. Diane Chavez, DAARE/ SAFE S. P.-' Sands, Acting NRR LPM H. S. Taylor, Quality Assurance

-i Division-Robert Newmann, Office of Public Counsel,' State of. Illinois Center

. bcc ; d. /..r(6cc r1.oq 06 7

L Cruct, CGC

<). fhrno% NRR i

I

$5 gD RI; I RII' Rill R111

  • fh VStr rb r/bs a er Rin Miller PWGreenn
  • we gow<

u m. _

,140 i

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20055G666&oldid=4485928"