ML19212A555: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
 
Line 18: Line 18:
=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:-
{{#Wiki_filter:-
.
RESAR-3S AMENDMENT 15 INSTRUCTION SHEET The following instructional information and check list is being furnished to insert Amendment 15 into the RESAR-35 Reference Safety Analysis Report.
RESAR-3S AMENDMENT 15 INSTRUCTION SHEET The following instructional information and check list is being furnished to insert Amendment 15 into the RESAR-35 Reference Safety Analysis Report.
Since in most cases the original RESAR-35 contains information printed on both sides of a sheet of paper, a new sheet is furnished to replace sheets containing superseded material. As a result, the front or back of a sheet may contain information that is merely reprinted rather than changed.
Since in most cases the original RESAR-35 contains information printed on both sides of a sheet of paper, a new sheet is furnished to replace sheets containing superseded material. As a result, the front or back of a sheet may contain information that is merely reprinted rather than changed.
Line 32: Line 31:
7 912200
7 912200


.
_
APPENDIX 3B EXTENSION REbo, MATTERS FOR PRELIMINARY DESIGN APPROVALS The Connission's August 22, 1978, policy statement on standardization includes a provision which allows any Preliminary Design Approval (PDA) that had been previously issued for a three-year term to be extended for two additional years. This provision applies to PDA-7 issued for the RESAR-35 application on December 30, 1976, and when approved, will extend the PDA to December 31, 1981.
APPENDIX 3B EXTENSION REbo, MATTERS FOR PRELIMINARY DESIGN APPROVALS The Connission's August 22, 1978, policy statement on standardization includes a provision which allows any Preliminary Design Approval (PDA) that had been previously issued for a three-year term to be extended for two additional years. This provision applies to PDA-7 issued for the RESAR-35 application on December 30, 1976, and when approved, will extend the PDA to December 31, 1981.
As set forth in the policy statement, each application for a PDA extension will be subject to an assessment of the design with respect to the Cate-gory I, II, ard III matters approved since the regulatory requirement's cutoff date for the PDA in question and the Category IV matters scheduled for review by the RRRC. A tabulation of each Category I, II, III, and IV matter approved or scheduled for R3 C review since the regulatory requirement's cutoff date of October 30, 1975 for RESAR-35, is provided in the index tables which follow.
As set forth in the policy statement, each application for a PDA extension will be subject to an assessment of the design with respect to the Cate-gory I, II, ard III matters approved since the regulatory requirement's cutoff date for the PDA in question and the Category IV matters scheduled for review by the RRRC. A tabulation of each Category I, II, III, and IV matter approved or scheduled for R3 C review since the regulatory requirement's cutoff date of October 30, 1975 for RESAR-35, is provided in the index tables which follow.
Line 41: Line 38:
1634 034 AMEMDMENT 14 RESAR-3S                                3B-1                        DECEMBER, 1978
1634 034 AMEMDMENT 14 RESAR-3S                                3B-1                        DECEMBER, 1978


                                                                                      .'
INDEX CATEGORY I MATTERS APPROVED BY REGULATORY REQUIREMENTS 3
INDEX CATEGORY I MATTERS APPROVED BY REGULATORY REQUIREMENTS 3
REVIEWCOMMITTEE(RCl Effective    W NSSS
REVIEWCOMMITTEE(RCl Effective    W NSSS Applicant Item      Reg. Guide      Rev. Date          Scope      Scope 1          1.7            2      1/31/78      X 2          1.9            1      9/1/78                    X 3        '1.20            2      1/9/76        X 4          1.28            1      11/29/77      X 5          1.29            3      6/20/78      X 6          1.31            2      7/20/76      X 7          1.32            2      11/14/77                  X 8          1.33            1        10/21/76                X 9          1.35            2      8/15/75*                  X 10        1.38            2      5/77          X 11        1.39            2      7/12/77                  X 12        1.52            2'      11/29/77                  X 13        1.63            1      3/22/77                  X 14        1.64            2      1/9/76        X 15        1.68            2      6/20/78      X          X 16        1.68.1          0      9/26/75*      Not Applicable to PWRs 17        1.72            1      11/15//7                  X 18        1.84            12      3/78          X 19        1.85            12      3/78          X 20        1.90            1      5/26/77                  X 21        1.92            1      8/22/7['      X 22        1.94            1      2/6/76                    X                      )
_
Applicant Item      Reg. Guide      Rev. Date          Scope      Scope 1          1.7            2      1/31/78      X 2          1.9            1      9/1/78                    X 3        '1.20            2      1/9/76        X 4          1.28            1      11/29/77      X 5          1.29            3      6/20/78      X 6          1.31            2      7/20/76      X 7          1.32            2      11/14/77                  X 8          1.33            1        10/21/76                X 9          1.35            2      8/15/75*                  X 10        1.38            2      5/77          X 11        1.39            2      7/12/77                  X 12        1.52            2'      11/29/77                  X 13        1.63            1      3/22/77                  X 14        1.64            2      1/9/76        X 15        1.68            2      6/20/78      X          X 16        1.68.1          0      9/26/75*      Not Applicable to PWRs 17        1.72            1      11/15//7                  X 18        1.84            12      3/78          X 19        1.85            12      3/78          X 20        1.90            1      5/26/77                  X 21        1.92            1      8/22/7['      X 22        1.94            1      2/6/76                    X                      )
23        1.95            1        10/21/76                X 1/14/77            See Cat. III Response 24        1.99            1                    X 25        1.100          1      6/14/77      X 10/76                    X 26        1.103          1 27        1.106          1        1/28/77                  X 23        1.107          1        10/21/76                X 29        1.116          0-R    5/77                      X 30        1.118          1      9/27/77      X
23        1.95            1        10/21/76                X 1/14/77            See Cat. III Response 24        1.99            1                    X 25        1.100          1      6/14/77      X 10/76                    X 26        1.103          1 27        1.106          1        1/28/77                  X 23        1.107          1        10/21/76                X 29        1.116          0-R    5/77                      X 30        1.118          1      9/27/77      X
   *Date precedes regulatory requirement's cutoff date for RESAR-3S of October 30,1975.
   *Date precedes regulatory requirement's cutoff date for RESAR-3S of October 30,1975.
AMENDMENT 15 RESAR-3S                            38-2                              DECEMBER, 1979
AMENDMENT 15 RESAR-3S                            38-2                              DECEMBER, 1979
.


.
INDEX CATEGORY I MATTERS (Continued)
INDEX CATEGORY I MATTERS (Continued)
Effective    W NSSS      Applicant Item    Reg. Guide      Rev.      Date          Scope      Scope
Effective    W NSSS      Applicant Item    Reg. Guide      Rev.      Date          Scope      Scope 31      1.120            1        5/11/77                  X 32      1.122            1        11/15/77                  X 33      1.123            1        7/77          X 34      1.126          0          1/14/77        X 35      1.128            1        6/20/78                  X 36      1.129          0          2/18/77                  X 37      1.131          0          5/26/77                  X 38      1.132          1        10/19/78                  X 39      1.134          1        10/19/78                  X 40      1.135          0          7/12/77                  X 41      1.136          0          8/31/77                  X 42      1.137          0          9/27/77                  X 43      NUREG-0102      0          9/27/77      X (SRP 1.8) 44      1.138          0          11/15/77                  X 45      1.XXX          0          11/15/77                  X 46      1.140          0          11/29/77                X 47      1.142          0          1/31/78                  X 48      8.19            0          3/14/78      X 49      RSB 5-2        0          3/14/78      X    See Cat. III Response 10/19/78                  X R 035-2)
                                                          ,
SRP 13.1        1        10/19/78                  X SRP 13.4        1        10/19/78                  X ETSB 11-4                10/19/78                  X 1634 036 O!ENDMENT 15 RESAR-3S                                                      DECEMBER, 1979 38-3
31      1.120            1        5/11/77                  X 32      1.122            1        11/15/77                  X 33      1.123            1        7/77          X 34      1.126          0          1/14/77        X 35      1.128            1        6/20/78                  X 36      1.129          0          2/18/77                  X 37      1.131          0          5/26/77                  X 38      1.132          1        10/19/78                  X 39      1.134          1        10/19/78                  X 40      1.135          0          7/12/77                  X 41      1.136          0          8/31/77                  X 42      1.137          0          9/27/77                  X 43      NUREG-0102      0          9/27/77      X (SRP 1.8) 44      1.138          0          11/15/77                  X 45      1.XXX          0          11/15/77                  X 46      1.140          0          11/29/77                X 47      1.142          0          1/31/78                  X 48      8.19            0          3/14/78      X 49      RSB 5-2        0          3/14/78      X    See Cat. III Response 10/19/78                  X R 035-2)
SRP 13.1        1        10/19/78                  X SRP 13.4        1        10/19/78                  X ETSB 11-4                10/19/78                  X 1634 036
                                                            '
O!ENDMENT 15 RESAR-3S                                                      DECEMBER, 1979 38-3


                                                                                        -
j                                                                                              .
j                                                                                              .
INDEX CATEGORY II MATTERS APPROVED BY REGULATORY REQUIREMENTS                  g i
INDEX CATEGORY II MATTERS APPROVED BY REGULATORY REQUIREMENTS                  g i
REVIEW COMMITTEE (R  3 g Effective    W NSSS
REVIEW COMMITTEE (R  3 g Effective    W NSSS Applicant Item        Reg. Guide        Rev. Date          Scope    Scope 1          1.27              2        11/12/75                X 93 2          1.52              1        1/9/76                  X 3          1.59              2        8/77                    X 4          1.63              1        3/22/77                X 5          1.68.2            1        5/16/78                X 6          1.91              1        11/15/77                X 7          1.97              1        1/28/77      X 8          1.102              1        11/12/75                X 9          1.105              1        9/15/76      X 10          1.108              1        6/14/77                X 11          1.115              1        3/22/77                X 12          1.117              1        12/20/77                X 13          1.124              1        8/31/77      X 14          1.130              0        7/77          X 15          1.137              0        9/29/77                X 16          8.8                2        8/10/76      X 17          BTPASB                      8/18/76                X 9.5-1 18          BTP                        4/13/77                X MTEB 5-7 19          SRP 5.4.7          1        1/31/78      X  See Cat. III Response 20          1.141              0        1/31/78      X  See Cat. III Response BTP-ASB 9.5-1              8/18/76                X O) 1634 037 RESAR-3S N 15 9)
_
Applicant Item        Reg. Guide        Rev. Date          Scope    Scope 1          1.27              2        11/12/75                X 93 2          1.52              1        1/9/76                  X 3          1.59              2        8/77                    X
                                                                                          -
4          1.63              1        3/22/77                X 5          1.68.2            1        5/16/78                X 6          1.91              1        11/15/77                X 7          1.97              1        1/28/77      X 8          1.102              1        11/12/75                X 9          1.105              1        9/15/76      X 10          1.108              1        6/14/77                X 11          1.115              1        3/22/77                X 12          1.117              1        12/20/77                X 13          1.124              1        8/31/77      X 14          1.130              0        7/77          X 15          1.137              0        9/29/77                X 16          8.8                2        8/10/76      X 17          BTPASB                      8/18/76                X 9.5-1 18          BTP                        4/13/77                X MTEB 5-7 19          SRP 5.4.7          1        1/31/78      X  See Cat. III Response 20          1.141              0        1/31/78      X  See Cat. III Response BTP-ASB 9.5-1              8/18/76                X O) 1634 037 RESAR-3S N 15 9)
DECEMBER, 1979 38-4
DECEMBER, 1979 38-4
.. . ._              -


INDEX CATEGORY III MATTERS APPROVED BY REGULATORY REQUIREMENTS 3
INDEX CATEGORY III MATTERS APPROVED BY REGULATORY REQUIREMENTS 3
REVIEW COMMITTEE (R Cl Effective    W NSSS      Applicant Item      Reg. Guide        Rev. Date          tope      Scope 1        1.56              1        5/w/70        Not Applicable to PWRs 2        1.68.2            1        5 /1. , o                X 3        1.99              1        1/14/77      X 4        1.101              1        3/77                    X 5        1.114              1        11/76                    X 6        1.121              0        5/11/76      X 7        1.127              1        11/29/77                X 8        1.137              0        9/27/77                  X 9        SRP 5.4.7          1        1/31/78      X 10        1.141              0        1/31/78      X 11        RSB 5-2            0        3/14/78      X
REVIEW COMMITTEE (R Cl Effective    W NSSS      Applicant Item      Reg. Guide        Rev. Date          tope      Scope 1        1.56              1        5/w/70        Not Applicable to PWRs 2        1.68.2            1        5 /1. , o                X 3        1.99              1        1/14/77      X 4        1.101              1        3/77                    X 5        1.114              1        11/76                    X 6        1.121              0        5/11/76      X 7        1.127              1        11/29/77                X 8        1.137              0        9/27/77                  X 9        SRP 5.4.7          1        1/31/78      X 10        1.141              0        1/31/78      X 11        RSB 5-2            0        3/14/78      X
'
     )          NUREG-0460
     )          NUREG-0460
   -            Volume 3 1/2/79      X RESAR-3S                                                        DECEMBER,1979 3B-5
   -            Volume 3 1/2/79      X RESAR-3S                                                        DECEMBER,1979 3B-5


.
l INDEX CATEGORY IV MATTERS A. REGULATORY GUIDES NOT CATEGORIZED Issue            W NSSS  Applicant Item      Reg. Guide  Rev.          Date            Scope    Scope 1          1.13        1            12/75                    X 2          1.14        1            8/75*            X 3          1.75        1            1/75*          X 4          1.79        1            9/75*          X 5          1.83        1            7/75            X 6          1.89        0            11/74*          X 7          1.93        0            12/74*                    X 8          1.104      0            2/76                      X B. SRP CRITERIA SRP          Implemen-      W NSSS Applicant Item      Branch      Criteria      tation Date    Scope      Scope 1          MTEB        5.4.2.1      11/24/75      X 2          CSB          6.2.1        11/24/75      X 6.2.1A 6.2.18 6.2.1.2 6.2.1.3 6.2.1.4 6.2.1.5 3          CSB          6.2.5        11/24/75      X 4          CSB          6.2.3        11/24/75                  X 5          CSB          6.2.4        11/24/75      X 6          ASB          9.1.4        11/24/75      X 7          ASB          10.4.9        11/24/75                  X 8          SEB          3.5.3        11/24/75                  X
l INDEX CATEGORY IV MATTERS A. REGULATORY GUIDES NOT CATEGORIZED Issue            W NSSS  Applicant Item      Reg. Guide  Rev.          Date            Scope    Scope 1          1.13        1            12/75                    X 2          1.14        1            8/75*            X 3          1.75        1            1/75*          X 4          1.79        1            9/75*          X
* 5          1.83        1            7/75            X 6          1.89        0            11/74*          X 7          1.93        0            12/74*                    X 8          1.104      0            2/76                      X B. SRP CRITERIA SRP          Implemen-      W NSSS
_
Applicant Item      Branch      Criteria      tation Date    Scope      Scope 1          MTEB        5.4.2.1      11/24/75      X 2          CSB          6.2.1        11/24/75      X 6.2.1A 6.2.18 6.2.1.2 6.2.1.3 6.2.1.4 6.2.1.5 3          CSB          6.2.5        11/24/75      X 4          CSB          6.2.3        11/24/75                  X 5          CSB          6.2.4        11/24/75      X 6          ASB          9.1.4        11/24/75      X 7          ASB          10.4.9        11/24/75                  X 8          SEB          3.5.3        11/24/75                  X
     *Date precedes regulatory requirement's cutoff date for RESAR-3S of October 30, 1975.
     *Date precedes regulatory requirement's cutoff date for RESAR-3S of October 30, 1975.
A}ENDMENT 15 RESAR-3S
A}ENDMENT 15 RESAR-3S
Line 102: Line 79:
Interface information concerning the applicability of IEEE-308-71 requirements is given in Section 7A.
Interface information concerning the applicability of IEEE-308-71 requirements is given in Section 7A.
O O
O O
                                                                -
O O
O O
RESAR-3S                            38-13a                  AMENDMENT 15 DECEMBER, 1979 1634 041
RESAR-3S                            38-13a                  AMENDMENT 15 DECEMBER, 1979 1634 041


.
Category I
Category I
                                                                               )
                                                                               )
Line 134: Line 109:
===RESPONSE===
===RESPONSE===
RESAR 3S does not address Regulatory Guide 8.8 Rev. 2. However, the required information to address this regulatory guide is contained in a topical Westinghouse repnrt, WCAP 8872 [6], " Design, Inspection, Opera-tion and Maintenance Aspects of the Westinghouse NSSS to Maintain Occu-pational Exposures As Low As Reasonably Achievable", April 1977. The information in this report will be included in safety analysis reports referencing the RESAR-3S design.
RESAR 3S does not address Regulatory Guide 8.8 Rev. 2. However, the required information to address this regulatory guide is contained in a topical Westinghouse repnrt, WCAP 8872 [6], " Design, Inspection, Opera-tion and Maintenance Aspects of the Westinghouse NSSS to Maintain Occu-pational Exposures As Low As Reasonably Achievable", April 1977. The information in this report will be included in safety analysis reports referencing the RESAR-3S design.
1634 045 RESAR-3S
1634 045 RESAR-3S 38-35
                    .
38-35


Category II Item    BTP ASB 9.5-1        Guidelines for Fire Protection for Nuclear 8/18/76              Power Plants Under Review and Construction
Category II Item    BTP ASB 9.5-1        Guidelines for Fire Protection for Nuclear 8/18/76              Power Plants Under Review and Construction
Line 143: Line 116:
Design of fire protection systems is not within Westinghouse scope.
Design of fire protection systems is not within Westinghouse scope.
However, equipment supplied by Westinghouse will not preclude the applicant from designing a fire protection system to meet the require-ments of BTP-AS8 9.5-1.
However, equipment supplied by Westinghouse will not preclude the applicant from designing a fire protection system to meet the require-ments of BTP-AS8 9.5-1.
O
O 9
                                                                            ,
O O
9 O
1634 046 RESAR-35                          38-35a                  AMENDMENT 15 DECEMBER, 1979
O 1634 046
                                                      ,
RESAR-35                          38-35a                  AMENDMENT 15 DECEMBER, 1979


                                                                             )
                                                                             )
Line 176: Line 146:
1634 048 RESAR-35                          38-36a                AMENDMENT 15 DECEMBER, 1979
1634 048 RESAR-35                          38-36a                AMENDMENT 15 DECEMBER, 1979


.
9 Category III Item RSB 5-2 Rev. O        Reactor Coolant System Overpressurization 3/14/78              Protection
9 Category III Item RSB 5-2 Rev. O        Reactor Coolant System Overpressurization 3/14/78              Protection


Line 206: Line 175:
: 2. Interference Fit Stresses and Excessive Deformation Much of Revision 1 deals with stresses in the flywheel resulting f rom the interference fit between the flywheel and the shaf t.
: 2. Interference Fit Stresses and Excessive Deformation Much of Revision 1 deals with stresses in the flywheel resulting f rom the interference fit between the flywheel and the shaf t.
Because Westinghouse's design specifies a light interference fit      ;
Because Westinghouse's design specifies a light interference fit      ;
RESAR-3S
RESAR-3S 1634 051 38-44
_
1634 051 38-44


Category IV-C Applicable Item        Branch  SRP Section                Title 18          ASB    10.4.7        Casign Guidelines for Water Hammer 8/1/76                              in Steam Generators with Top Feedrign Design (BTP ASB-10.2)
Category IV-C Applicable Item        Branch  SRP Section                Title 18          ASB    10.4.7        Casign Guidelines for Water Hammer 8/1/76                              in Steam Generators with Top Feedrign Design (BTP ASB-10.2)
Line 216: Line 183:
     " Water Hanmer for Steam Generators with Preheaters (SRP 10.4.7 par.
     " Water Hanmer for Steam Generators with Preheaters (SRP 10.4.7 par.
I.2.b)"
I.2.b)"
,
1634 052 RESAR-3S 3B-77
1634 052 RESAR-3S
                    -
3B-77


Category IV-C Item 19      Environmental Control Systems for Safety Related Equipment
Category IV-C Item 19      Environmental Control Systems for Safety Related Equipment
Line 227: Line 191:
* 3.11 cover equipment located inside containment, outsida containment and in the control room.
* 3.11 cover equipment located inside containment, outsida containment and in the control room.
6 6
6 6
                                                                            .
O 0-,aa O
O 0-,aa O
1634 RESAR-35                          38-77a                  AMENDMENT 15 DECEMBER, 1979
1634 RESAR-35                          38-77a                  AMENDMENT 15 DECEMBER, 1979
Line 252: Line 215:
1634 054 RESAR-3S 38-78
1634 054 RESAR-3S 38-78


                                                                        .
REFERENCES (Continued)
REFERENCES (Continued)
: 16. Letter NS-TMA-2096, T. M. Anderson (Westinghouse) to R. J. Mattson (NRC), dated June 8, 1979.
: 16. Letter NS-TMA-2096, T. M. Anderson (Westinghouse) to R. J. Mattson (NRC), dated June 8, 1979.

Latest revision as of 03:41, 2 February 2020

Amend 15 to RESAR-3S
ML19212A555
Person / Time
Site: 05000545
Issue date: 12/31/1979
From:
WESTINGHOUSE ELECTRIC COMPANY, DIV OF CBS CORP.
To:
Shared Package
ML19211A665 List:
References
NUDOCS 7912200400
Download: ML19212A555 (23)


Text

-

RESAR-3S AMENDMENT 15 INSTRUCTION SHEET The following instructional information and check list is being furnished to insert Amendment 15 into the RESAR-35 Reference Safety Analysis Report.

Since in most cases the original RESAR-35 contains information printed on both sides of a sheet of paper, a new sheet is furnished to replace sheets containing superseded material. As a result, the front or back of a sheet may contain information that is merely reprinted rather than changed.

Discard the old sheets and insert the new sheets, as listed below. Keep these instruction sheets in the front of Volume I to serve as a record of changes.

Remove Insert (Front /BackJ (Front /Back) 3B-1/38-2 38-1/38-2 3B-3/38-4 3B-3/38-4 3B-5/38-6 38-5/38-6 38-13/38-14 38-13/38-13a

---/--- 38-14/---

---/--- 38-20al---

38-35/38-36 38-35/3B-35a

---/--- 38-36/38-36a 38-43/38-44 38-43/38-43t

---/--- 38-44/---

3B-77/--- 38-77/3B-77a 38-78/--- 38-78/38-78a 4

1634 033 RESAR-3S A15-1 AMENDMENT 15 DECEMBER, 1979 0

7 912200

APPENDIX 3B EXTENSION REbo, MATTERS FOR PRELIMINARY DESIGN APPROVALS The Connission's August 22, 1978, policy statement on standardization includes a provision which allows any Preliminary Design Approval (PDA) that had been previously issued for a three-year term to be extended for two additional years. This provision applies to PDA-7 issued for the RESAR-35 application on December 30, 1976, and when approved, will extend the PDA to December 31, 1981.

As set forth in the policy statement, each application for a PDA extension will be subject to an assessment of the design with respect to the Cate-gory I, II, ard III matters approved since the regulatory requirement's cutoff date for the PDA in question and the Category IV matters scheduled for review by the RRRC. A tabulation of each Category I, II, III, and IV matter approved or scheduled for R3 C review since the regulatory requirement's cutoff date of October 30, 1975 for RESAR-35, is provided in the index tables which follow.

Appendix 38 addresses each matter identified by the index as being within Westinghouse scope of supply. Matters not within Westinghouse scope will be addressed in the applicant's Safety Analysis Report.

As noted in Appendix 3A, throughout the text of RESAR-3S, commitments are made to comply with regulatory criteria, positions and guides. Compliance is based upon the Westinghouse inte;)retation of the statement of the requirement. Where the Westinghouse position differs from Westinghouse's understanding of the regulatory requirement, alternate positions are presented and defended as acceptable.

The regulatory require' ment's cutoff date for RESAR-3S is October 30, 1975, which precedes the effective dates and implementation dates of all of the Westinghouse NSSS scope PDA extension review matters in Category I, with the exception of Regulatory Guide 1.92 Revision 1. Therefore, according to present NRC policy on standardization, RESAR-35 compliance is not required for any of the Category I matters except for Regulatory Guide 1.92 Revision 1. However, as indicated in the individual responses which follow, compliance or an acceptable alternative position can be demon-strated for all of the Westinghouse NSSS scope PDA extension review natters in Categories I, II, III and IV, without the necessity for imple-menting RESAR-35 design changes.

1634 034 AMEMDMENT 14 RESAR-3S 3B-1 DECEMBER, 1978

INDEX CATEGORY I MATTERS APPROVED BY REGULATORY REQUIREMENTS 3

REVIEWCOMMITTEE(RCl Effective W NSSS Applicant Item Reg. Guide Rev. Date Scope Scope 1 1.7 2 1/31/78 X 2 1.9 1 9/1/78 X 3 '1.20 2 1/9/76 X 4 1.28 1 11/29/77 X 5 1.29 3 6/20/78 X 6 1.31 2 7/20/76 X 7 1.32 2 11/14/77 X 8 1.33 1 10/21/76 X 9 1.35 2 8/15/75* X 10 1.38 2 5/77 X 11 1.39 2 7/12/77 X 12 1.52 2' 11/29/77 X 13 1.63 1 3/22/77 X 14 1.64 2 1/9/76 X 15 1.68 2 6/20/78 X X 16 1.68.1 0 9/26/75* Not Applicable to PWRs 17 1.72 1 11/15//7 X 18 1.84 12 3/78 X 19 1.85 12 3/78 X 20 1.90 1 5/26/77 X 21 1.92 1 8/22/7[' X 22 1.94 1 2/6/76 X )

23 1.95 1 10/21/76 X 1/14/77 See Cat. III Response 24 1.99 1 X 25 1.100 1 6/14/77 X 10/76 X 26 1.103 1 27 1.106 1 1/28/77 X 23 1.107 1 10/21/76 X 29 1.116 0-R 5/77 X 30 1.118 1 9/27/77 X

  • Date precedes regulatory requirement's cutoff date for RESAR-3S of October 30,1975.

AMENDMENT 15 RESAR-3S 38-2 DECEMBER, 1979

INDEX CATEGORY I MATTERS (Continued)

Effective W NSSS Applicant Item Reg. Guide Rev. Date Scope Scope 31 1.120 1 5/11/77 X 32 1.122 1 11/15/77 X 33 1.123 1 7/77 X 34 1.126 0 1/14/77 X 35 1.128 1 6/20/78 X 36 1.129 0 2/18/77 X 37 1.131 0 5/26/77 X 38 1.132 1 10/19/78 X 39 1.134 1 10/19/78 X 40 1.135 0 7/12/77 X 41 1.136 0 8/31/77 X 42 1.137 0 9/27/77 X 43 NUREG-0102 0 9/27/77 X (SRP 1.8) 44 1.138 0 11/15/77 X 45 1.XXX 0 11/15/77 X 46 1.140 0 11/29/77 X 47 1.142 0 1/31/78 X 48 8.19 0 3/14/78 X 49 RSB 5-2 0 3/14/78 X See Cat. III Response 10/19/78 X R 035-2)

SRP 13.1 1 10/19/78 X SRP 13.4 1 10/19/78 X ETSB 11-4 10/19/78 X 1634 036 O!ENDMENT 15 RESAR-3S DECEMBER, 1979 38-3

j .

INDEX CATEGORY II MATTERS APPROVED BY REGULATORY REQUIREMENTS g i

REVIEW COMMITTEE (R 3 g Effective W NSSS Applicant Item Reg. Guide Rev. Date Scope Scope 1 1.27 2 11/12/75 X 93 2 1.52 1 1/9/76 X 3 1.59 2 8/77 X 4 1.63 1 3/22/77 X 5 1.68.2 1 5/16/78 X 6 1.91 1 11/15/77 X 7 1.97 1 1/28/77 X 8 1.102 1 11/12/75 X 9 1.105 1 9/15/76 X 10 1.108 1 6/14/77 X 11 1.115 1 3/22/77 X 12 1.117 1 12/20/77 X 13 1.124 1 8/31/77 X 14 1.130 0 7/77 X 15 1.137 0 9/29/77 X 16 8.8 2 8/10/76 X 17 BTPASB 8/18/76 X 9.5-1 18 BTP 4/13/77 X MTEB 5-7 19 SRP 5.4.7 1 1/31/78 X See Cat. III Response 20 1.141 0 1/31/78 X See Cat. III Response BTP-ASB 9.5-1 8/18/76 X O) 1634 037 RESAR-3S N 15 9)

DECEMBER, 1979 38-4

INDEX CATEGORY III MATTERS APPROVED BY REGULATORY REQUIREMENTS 3

REVIEW COMMITTEE (R Cl Effective W NSSS Applicant Item Reg. Guide Rev. Date tope Scope 1 1.56 1 5/w/70 Not Applicable to PWRs 2 1.68.2 1 5 /1. , o X 3 1.99 1 1/14/77 X 4 1.101 1 3/77 X 5 1.114 1 11/76 X 6 1.121 0 5/11/76 X 7 1.127 1 11/29/77 X 8 1.137 0 9/27/77 X 9 SRP 5.4.7 1 1/31/78 X 10 1.141 0 1/31/78 X 11 RSB 5-2 0 3/14/78 X

) NUREG-0460

- Volume 3 1/2/79 X RESAR-3S DECEMBER,1979 3B-5

l INDEX CATEGORY IV MATTERS A. REGULATORY GUIDES NOT CATEGORIZED Issue W NSSS Applicant Item Reg. Guide Rev. Date Scope Scope 1 1.13 1 12/75 X 2 1.14 1 8/75* X 3 1.75 1 1/75* X 4 1.79 1 9/75* X 5 1.83 1 7/75 X 6 1.89 0 11/74* X 7 1.93 0 12/74* X 8 1.104 0 2/76 X B. SRP CRITERIA SRP Implemen- W NSSS Applicant Item Branch Criteria tation Date Scope Scope 1 MTEB 5.4.2.1 11/24/75 X 2 CSB 6.2.1 11/24/75 X 6.2.1A 6.2.18 6.2.1.2 6.2.1.3 6.2.1.4 6.2.1.5 3 CSB 6.2.5 11/24/75 X 4 CSB 6.2.3 11/24/75 X 5 CSB 6.2.4 11/24/75 X 6 ASB 9.1.4 11/24/75 X 7 ASB 10.4.9 11/24/75 X 8 SEB 3.5.3 11/24/75 X

  • Date precedes regulatory requirement's cutoff date for RESAR-3S of October 30, 1975.

A}ENDMENT 15 RESAR-3S

  • 38-6 1634 039

Category I Item RG 1.31 Rev. 2 Control of Ferrite Content in Stainless Steel Weld Metal

RESPONSE

Regulatory Guide 1.31, Revision 2, Control of Ferrite Content in Stain-less Steel Weld Metal, describes a method for implementing General Design Criteria 1 of Appendix A 10CFR Part 50 and Appendix B 10CFR Part 50 with regard to control of welding austenitic stainless steel com-ponents and systems. The following paragraphs discuss the method to be used by Westinghouse to control delta ferrite in austenitic stainless steel welding; this method is in compliance with Revision 2 of the guide.

The welding of austenitic stainless steel is controlled to mitigate the occurrence of microfissuring or hot cracking in the weld. Although published data and experience have not confirmed that fissuring is detrimental to the quality of the weld, it is recognized that such ,

fissuring is undesirable in a general sense. Also, it has been well documented in the technical literature that the presence of delta ferrite is one of the mechanisms for reducing the susceptibility of stainless steel welds to hot cracking. Available data indicates that a minimum delta ferrite level (expressed in Ferrite Number (FN)), above which the weld metals commonly used by Westinghouse will not be prone to hot cracking, lies somewhere between 0 FN and 3 FN.

The scope of these controls discussed herein encompasses welding pro-cesses used to join stainless steel parts in components designed, fabricated or stamped in accordance with ASME B&PV Code,Section III Class 1, 2, and CS components. Delta ferrite control is appropriate for the above welding regirements except where no filler metal is used or for other reasons such control is not applicable. Thc:e exceptions include electron beam welding, autogenous gas shielded tungsten arc welding, explosive welding, and welding using fully austenitic welding materials.

Westinghouse components are fabricated utilizing welding procedures qualified in accordance with ASME Code Section III; also delta ferrite content verification is required for welding materials used for welding qualification testing and for each welding process used in the produc-tion of austenitic stainless steel components. Specifically, undiluted weld deposits of the " starting" welding materials are required to con-tain a minimum delta ferrite level of 5 FN. The ASME Code permits the use of either a chemical analysis method or a magnetic measurement method to determine the delta ferrite content; however, in the f abrica-tion of Westinghouse components, Ferrite Number is measured on an as-deposited weld pad using a calibrated magnetic measuring device, as recommended by Revision 2 of Regulatory Guide 1.31.

1634 040 RESAR-3S 3B-13

Category I Item RG 1.32 Rev. 2 Criteria for Safety-Related Electric Power 1/14/77 Systems for Nuclear Power Plants

RESPONSE

Electric Power Systems are not within Westinghouse NSSS scope; however, as noted in the response to RG 1.32 in RESAR-3S, Section 3A, interface information on Class 1E electric systems is provided in Section 8.3.

Interface information concerning the applicability of IEEE-308-71 requirements is given in Section 7A.

O O

O O

RESAR-3S38-13a AMENDMENT 15 DECEMBER, 1979 1634 041

Category I

)

Item RG 1.38 Rev. 2 Quality Assurance Requirements for Packaging, 5/77 Shipping, Receiving, Storage, and Handling of Items for Water-Cooled Nuclear Power Plants .)

R ESPONSE The Westinghouse position on compliance y Rev. 2 is presented in WCAP-8370 Rev. 8AL J and{th Regulatory WCAP-7800 Guide Rev. 5L 1.)g),

,)

)

)

)

l 1634 042 RESAR-3S 3B-14

Category I Item RG 1.32 Rev. 2 Criteria for Safety-Related Electric Power 1/14/77 Systems for Nuclear Power Plants

RESPONSE

Electric Power Systems are not within Westinghouse NSSS scope; however, as noted in the response to RG 1.32 in RESAR-35, Section 3A, interf ace information on Class 1E electric systems is provided in Section 8.3.

Interface information concerning the applicability of IEEE-308-71 requirements is given in Section 7A.

RESAR-3S 3B-13a AMENDMENT 15 DECEMBER, 1979 1634 043

Category I Item RG 1.106 Rev. 1 Thermal Overload Protection for Electric 1/28/77 Motors on Motor Operated Valves

RESPONSE

As noted in RESAR-3S, Section 7A, thermal overload protection for safety-related system M0V's is not provided by Westinghouse. Any thermal overload protection provided for safety reldted MOV's must be discussed by the applicant.

RESAR-3S 3B-20a AMENDMENT 15 DECEMBER, 1979 1634 044

Category II Item Information Relevant to Ensuring that Occu-RG 8.8 Rev. 2 8/18/76 pational Radiation Exposures at Nuclear Power Stations will be as low as Is Reasonably Achievable (Nuclear Power Reactors)

RESPONSE

RESAR 3S does not address Regulatory Guide 8.8 Rev. 2. However, the required information to address this regulatory guide is contained in a topical Westinghouse repnrt, WCAP 8872 [6], " Design, Inspection, Opera-tion and Maintenance Aspects of the Westinghouse NSSS to Maintain Occu-pational Exposures As Low As Reasonably Achievable", April 1977. The information in this report will be included in safety analysis reports referencing the RESAR-3S design.

1634 045 RESAR-3S 38-35

Category II Item BTP ASB 9.5-1 Guidelines for Fire Protection for Nuclear 8/18/76 Power Plants Under Review and Construction

RESPONSE

Design of fire protection systems is not within Westinghouse scope.

However, equipment supplied by Westinghouse will not preclude the applicant from designing a fire protection system to meet the require-ments of BTP-AS8 9.5-1.

O 9

O O

1634 046 RESAR-35 38-35a AMENDMENT 15 DECEMBER, 1979

)

Category III Item RG 1.99 Rev. 1 Effects of Residual Elements on Predicted 9/15/76 Radiation Damage to Reactor Vessel Materials

RESPONSE

Justification of the Westinghouse position on Rev. O and Rev. 1 of the Guide is detailed in references [7] and [8] respectively.

)

In summary, Rev. 1 of the Guide is substantially identical with Rev. O, with minor clarifications and inclusion of a new position C.2, which had previously been included in the Discussion section of Rev. O.

The Westinghouse letter of comment on Rev. 1 reiterates the comments of Rev. O and includes further clarification of hardship imposed by the Guide with respect to vessel material.

The Westinghouse position with respect to each of the Guide positions is as follows:

1. The basis as well as the scope of the Guide for predicting adjust-ment of reference temperature as given in Regulatory Position C.1 are inappropriate since the data base used was incomplete and included some data which were not applicable.
2. Westinghouse is in agreement with the Guide Position C.2a. However, T with respect to Guide Position C.2b, Westinghouse believes that /

Figure 2 of the Guide is incorrect since the upper shelf energy for six-inch thick ASTM A302B reference correlation monitor material reported by Hawthorne indjqates gssentially a constant upper shelf at fluences above e1 x 10 9 n/cn . [8]

3. The Westinghouse Nsition with reference to the Guide Position C.3, controlling residual elements to levels that result in a predicted adjusted reference temperature of less than 2000F at end-of-life, is that the stresses in the vessel can be limited during operation in order to comply with the requiremer,ts of Appendix G to 10CFR Part 50 even though the end-of-life adjusted reference temperature may exceed 2000F. By applying the procedures of Appendix G to ASME Section III, the stress limits including appropriate Code safety margin can be met.

}

4. Recent surveillance capsule data frgm the Point Beach and Connecticut Yankee reactor vessels L9] indicate a steady state condition of irradiation damage due to the annealing effect at operating temperature. As an alternative to R.G. l.99, operating limits for Westinghouse plants will be determined by using the cur-

)

rent radiation damage curves developed by Westinghouse [103. It is expected that, as more surveillance capsule data is accumulated, both the R.G. 1.99 and Westinghouse damage curves will prove to be overly conservative.

~)

1634 04/

RESAR-3S 38-36

Category III Item RG 1.114 Rev.1 Guidance on Being Operator at the Controls 11/76 of a Nuclear Power Plant Regulatory Guide 1.114 is not in Westinghouse scope. However, the design of the control panels for equipment supplied by Westinghouse will not preclude a control room design and layout in which all controls, instrumentation displays, and alarms required for the safe operation, shutdown, and cooldown of the unit are readily available to the operator in the control room.

O O

O O

1634 048 RESAR-35 38-36a AMENDMENT 15 DECEMBER, 1979

9 Category III Item RSB 5-2 Rev. O Reactor Coolant System Overpressurization 3/14/78 Protection

RESPONSE

The pressurizer power-operated relief valves will be supplied with additional actuation logic to ensure that a completely automatic and independent RCS pressure control backup feature is provided for the operator during low-temperature operations. This system provides the capability for additional RCS inventory letdown, to minimize the number of occurrences of pressure transients and to reduce the severity of such transients, should they occur.

The basic function of the system logic is to continuously monitor RCS temperature conditions, with the logic armed whenever plant operation is at low temperatures. An auctioneered system temperature will be con-tinuously converted to an allowable pressure and then compared to the actual RCS pressure. This comparison, when required, will provide an actuation signal to the power-ooerated relief valves.

1634 049 RESAR-3S 3B-43

Category III Item NUREG-0460 Anticipated Transients Without Scram Volume 3 1/02/79

RESPONSE

The most recent NRC position with regards to ATWS is defined in NUREG 0460 Volume 3 dated December, 1978. The required analyses needed to satisfy this position are presented in references 16, 17 and 18. Tuese analyses demonstrate that a Westinghouse PWR design is inherently self limiting and peak pressures are below emergency stress limits for alternative 3 plants.

O O

O 4

1634 050 RESAR-3S 3B-43a AMENDMENT 15 DECEMBER, 1979

Category IV-A

}

Item RG 1.14 Rev. 1 Reactor Coolant Pump Flywheel Integrity 8/75

RESPONSE

}

Since the issuance of Regulatory Guide 1.14, Revision 1, the NRC Staff has provided to Westinghouse a copy of Draft 2, Revision 2 of Regulatory Guide 1.14 (via on April 12, 1976 letter from Robert B. Minogne to C.

Eicheldinger). This draft was formulated from industry and concerned parties' comments. It is significant that the Draft 2 version incor- ')

porates several of the Westinghouse comments on Revision 1. Since /

Draft 2 has not been formally published as Revision 2 of Regulatory Guide 1.14, the exceptions and clarifications (from the original Westinghouse comments) are provided below:

1. Post-Spin Inspection Westinghouse has shown in WCAP-8163, " Topical Report Reactor Coolant Pump Integrity in LOCA,"[Il3"that the flywheel would not f ail at 290% of normal speed for a flywheel flaw of 1.15 inches or less in length. Results for a double ended guillotine break at the pump discharge with full separation of pipe ends assumed, show the maxi-mum overspeed to be less than 110% of normal speed. The maximum overspeed was calculated in WCAP-8163 to be about 280% of normal )

speed for the same postulated break, and an assumed instantaneous loss of power to the rea-tor coolant pump. In comparison with the overspeed presented above, the flywheel could withstand a speed up to 2.3 times greater than the flywheel spin test speed of 125% pro-vided that no flaws greater than 1.15 inches are present. If the maximum speed were 125% of normal speed or less, the critical flaw size for failure would exceed 6 inches in length. Non-destructive tests and critical dimension examinations are all performed before the spin tests. The inspection methods employed (described in WCAP-8163) provide assurance that flaws significantly smaller than the critical flaw size of 1.15 inches for 290% of normal speed would be detected. Flaws in the flywheel will be recorded in the pre-spin inspection program (see WCAP-8163). Flaw growth attributable to the g SPIN test (i.e., from a single reversal of stress, up to speed and I back), under the most adverse conditions, is about three orders of magnitude smaller than what non-destructive inspection techniques are capable of detecting. For these reasons, Westinghouse performs no post-spin inspection and believes that pre-spin test inspections are adequate.  ;

2. Interference Fit Stresses and Excessive Deformation Much of Revision 1 deals with stresses in the flywheel resulting f rom the interference fit between the flywheel and the shaf t.

Because Westinghouse's design specifies a light interference fit  ;

RESAR-3S 1634 051 38-44

Category IV-C Applicable Item Branch SRP Section Title 18 ASB 10.4.7 Casign Guidelines for Water Hammer 8/1/76 in Steam Generators with Top Feedrign Design (BTP ASB-10.2)

RESPONSE

The steam generators employed in the RESAR-3S design are of the preheater type and do not employ top feedring design. Therefore, BTP-ASB-10.2 is not applicable. For a discussion of water hanmer in RESAR-3S steam generators, refer to the response ta item IV.8.20, above,

" Water Hanmer for Steam Generators with Preheaters (SRP 10.4.7 par.

I.2.b)"

1634 052 RESAR-3S 3B-77

Category IV-C Item 19 Environmental Control Systems for Safety Related Equipment

RESPONSE

Environmental control systems for safety related equipment are not in Westinghouse scope. However, the environmental design of mechanical aM electrical equipment supplied by Westinghouse is discussed in RESAR-35 Section 3.11. Environmental design requirements described in Section

  • 3.11 cover equipment located inside containment, outsida containment and in the control room.

6 6

O 0-,aa O

1634 RESAR-35 38-77a AMENDMENT 15 DECEMBER, 1979

REFERENCES

1. " Westinghouse Water Reactor Divisions Quality Assurance Plan,"

WCAP-8370, Revision 8A, September 1977.

2. " Nuclear Fuel Division Reliability and Quality Assurance Plan,"

WCAP-7800, Rev. 5, December 6, 1977.

3. " Methodology for Qualifying Westinghouse PWR-SD Supplied FSSS Safety Related Electrical Equipment, WCAP-8587-R1, September 1977, Supple-ment 1, Rev. 1, November 1978.
4. " General Method of Developing Multifrequency Biaxial Test Inputs for Bistables," WCAP-8695, September 1975.
5. " Fuel Densification Experimental Results and Model for Reactor Appli-cation," WCAP-8218-P-A (Proprietary Class 2), WCAP-8219-A (Non-Pro-prietary, Class 3), March 1975.
6. " Design, Inspection, Operation, and Maintenance Aspects of the Westinghouse Nuclear Steam Supply System to Maintain Occupational Radiation Exposures as low as Reasonably Achievable," WCAP-8872, April 1977.

7 Letter of Corinent on Rev. O of Reg. Guide 1.99 to the Secretary of the Commission by C. E. Eicheldinger, NS-CE-784, September 22, 1975.

8 Hawthorne, J. R.,

" Radiation Effects Information Generated on the ASTM Reference Correlation - Monitor Steels," to be published.

9. Westinghouse RESAR-35, Chapter 16, Figure 83/4 4.2, Page 83/4.
10. Letter NS-TMA-1843 to the Secretary of the Commission by T. M. Anderson, June 23, 1978.
11. " Reactor Coolant Pump Integrity in LOCA," WCAP-8163, September 1973.
12. 'High >ressure Water Hammer Test of the Split Flow Preheat Stca n Generator," WCAP-9232, January 1978.
13. " Damping Valves of Nuclear Power Plant Components," WCAP-7921-AR, May 1974.
14. Marasco, F. W. and Siroky, R. M., " Westinghouse 7300 Series Process Control System Noise Tests," WCAP-8892-A, June, 1977.
15. Letter dated April 20, 1977 from R. L. Tedesco (NRC) to C. Eicheldinger (Westinghouse).

1634 054 RESAR-3S 38-78

REFERENCES (Continued)

16. Letter NS-TMA-2096, T. M. Anderson (Westinghouse) to R. J. Mattson (NRC), dated June 8, 1979.
17. Letter NS-TMA-2159. T. M. Anderson (Westinghouse) to S. H. Hanauer, dated November 15, 1979.
18. Letter to be written, December, 1979.

O O

O O

1634 055 RESAR-35 38-78a AMENDMENT 15 O

DECEMBER, 1979