ML18018A536

Changes to Section 1.8 (QA Program) of PSAR

ML18018A536
Person / Time
Site:	Harris
Issue date:	05/09/1983
From:	CAROLINA POWER & LIGHT CO.
To:
Shared Package
ML18018A533	List: ML18018A532 ML18018A536
References
NUDOCS 8305170285
Download: ML18018A536 (27)

Text

Changes to Section 1.8 of the SHNPP PSAR 83051702285 830509 OCZ 05000~00 '

PDR Ql

~

~

\

t l

(

f I,

J

1) The second sentence on page 1.8-1 of the PSAR should be revised to read, "This plan will not be affected by the decision to delay inservice operation of the Harris Units until 1986 and 1990."

2) At the end of Item 2 on page 1.8-1i of the PSAR add the following, "This procedure has been replaced by CPAL's Corporate Quality Assurance Department procedure CQAD-80-1 titled 'Procedure for Corporate QA Audits'", which became effective January 19, 1982.

3) Paragraph 3a and 3b on pages 1.8-1), 1.8-1k, and 1.8-11 should be replaced with the following:

Qualit Assurance Services Section Procedures - Listed below are the subject procedures.

t

a. Engineering QA and Vendor Surveillance Units Procedures:

AQAS-1 Quality Assurance Document Control 29,44,49 AQAS-2 Initiation, Revision, and Withdrawal of QS1-38 Procedures AQAS-3 Contractor and Vendor Evaluations AQAS-4 Quality Assurance Records AQAS-5 Handling Reportable Items Under 10CFR50.55(e)

AQAS-9 Training and Qualification of Engineering QA and Vendor Surveillance Personnel EQA-1 Review of Documents for Quality Assurance Requirements VQA<<2 Vendor Shop Surveillance VQA-5 Preparation and Maintenance of Approved Suppliers List Listed below is a cross reference of the 10CFR50 Appendix B Criteria to the procedures covering the criteria.

QA Section Procedures NRC Criteria Coveri Qualit Assurance Criteria Criterion II AQAS-1, AQAS-2, AQAS-3, AQAS-4, AQAS-5, AQAS-9, EQA-1, VQA-2, VQA-5 Criterion III EQA-1 Criterion IV EQA-1, VQA-5, AQAS-3 Criterion VI AQAS-1, AQAS-2

~ t r

PI 0 e

\

f H

0 Criterion VII VQA-2, VQA-5, AQAS-3 Criterion XVII AQAS-4

b. Site Qualit Assurance/Qualit Control Unit Procedures - The following is a list of procedures included in the Site QA/QC Procedures.

CQA General Section CQA Appendix A Quality Assurance Forms CQA-1 Personnel Training and Qualification CQA-4 QA Records CQA-24 Procument Control CQA-27 System/Structure Turnover CQA-28 QA Surveillance CQC-1 Tool and Measuring Device Control CQC-2 Nonconformance Control CQC-6 Receiving Inspection CQC-7 Marking and Tagging CQC-10 Cleanliness Control of Fluid Systems and Components CQC-13 Concrete Control CQC-15 Cadweld Control CQC-19 Weld Control CQC-20 Post Weld Heat Treatment Nondestructive Examination Procedures contained in the following sections of the Corporate Nondestructive Examination Manual:

Section 1 - General Section II Training, Qualification and Certification of NDE Personnel Section IV Examination Procedures, 100 Series (Radiographic Method) 200 Series (Penetrant Method) 300 Series (Magnetic Particle Method) 400 Series (Ultrasonic Method) 600 Series (Visual Method)

The following is a cross reference of the 10CFR50 Appendix B Criteria to the procedure covering the Criteria.

Site QA/QC Procedure NRC Criteria Coverin Qualit Assurance Criteria Criterion I CQA General Section Criterion II CQA General Section, CQA-1 Criterion IV CQA-24 Criterion VI CQA-28

be 0

Sb II I I

~ I' l

0 r 0 I , 0

)f Ii I "II0~

• I' I'I bh'0 I ~ I ~ r I b

Criterion VII CQC-6 Criterion VIII CQC-7 Criterion IX CQC-19, 20, NDE Procedure Manual Criterion X CQA 28~ CQC 1 ~ 6~ 7~ 10~ 13~

20, Procedure Manual 15'9, NDE Criter ion XI CQA 28, CQC 13, 15, 19, 20, NDE Procedure Manual Criterion XII CQA-28, CQC-1 Criterion XIII CQA-28, CQC-10 Criterion XIV CQC-9, CQC-19 Criterion XV CQC-2 Criterion XVI CQC-2 Criterion XVII CQA-4

4) Last paragraph, seventh and eighth lines from the bottom of page 1.8-1m of the PSAR should read ". . . the CP&L Manager Engineering Harris Plant Section and the Director-Quality Assurance/Quality Control Harris Plant.

5) In the first and second paragraphs on page 1.8-1n of the PSAR the title of the CP&L Manager - Engineering & Construction Quality Assurance has been changed to the CP&L Manager Quality Assurance/Quality Control-Harris Plant. The responsibilities outlined in the third paragraph on pages 1.8-1n to the Manager - Engineering & Construction Quality Assurance have been transferred to the CP&L Manager - QA Services Section. Also, reference to "Power Plant Engineering" in the second paragraph should be changed to "Harris Plant Engineering."

6) Paragraphs a, b, and c on page 1.8-2 of the PSAR should be replaced 'with the following:

a) Quality Assurance and Inspection The component manufacturers and/or CP&L, as applicable is responsible for providing appropriate quality control procedures, systems, and inspection personnel for assuring and demonstrating that the end product has the specified degree of quality as defined in the appropriate specifications, drawings and/or purchase documents. The actual quality control effort will be executed by the equipment manufacturer. Quality Assurance/Quality Control activities are the responsibility of the CP&L Harris Plant Quality Assurance/Quality Control Section 'of the Corporate Quality Assurance Department. The inspection of construction activities is shared

H H

Al P

A m A F',

c

'A 'I F ~

l' H ~

s q rc

~ '

cq H .

between the Harris Plant Quality Assurance/Quality Control Section and the Harris Site Management Section. Carolina Power 5 Light Company's Corporate Quality Assurance Program reflects this sharing of responsibilities. The Harris project procedures delineate the activities and responsibilities for each section. At the present time, the following summarizes the QC inspection activities performed by the Harris Site Management Section.

a. Soils all

b. Concrete - all, except production testing

c. Reinforcing Steel and Embedded Items Installation - all, except cadweld inspection

d. Structural Steel all, except welding and NDE

e. Structural Steel - all, except welding and NDE

f. Electrical Items Installation all

g. Instrumentation Installation - all

h. Protective Coatings all Lifting Equipment - all, except NDE All other QC inspections of construction activities are the responsibility of the Harris Plant QA/QC section.

The Harris Plant QA/QC Section will be responsible for inspection of assembly/disassembly of ASME Section III Class 1, 2, and 3 pressure boundary items.

b) Quality Assurance Surveillance The CPEL Quality Assurance Services Section and Ebasco Material Engineering and Quality Assurance Department personnel will have surveillance responsibility on the quality control systems, procedures, and efforts of component manufacturers and service contractors, in accordance with their respective endeavors.

Surveillance of construction contractors will be the responsibility of the CPAL Harris Plant Quality Assurance/Quality Control Section.

Two major functions are accomplished by these personnel. The first is during the design phase where the various specifications and procurement documents are reviewed for proper inclusion of applicable code and quality control requirements. The second function occurs during the actual fabrication and construction operations. During this phase the component manufacturer's and construction quality control procedures and programs are reviewed as meeting the requirement of the specification and/or procurement

. documents, and a physical surveillance action is performed to ensure that the quality requirements are in fact being met.

I>>

Il h

<<C

>>

I C C

<<f I hl JV I' a hI I, ~

<<

<<

~ '>>f= I' ~

f v =

I ~ IC hr

, rc C<<

f>> F I F D C I

C 'l

~ I<<

I '

f<<V Af f<< I

(<< r r I V C<< I ~ I V)f

The Harris Plant QA/QC Section is responsible for performing surveillance only in those areas where the section has no responsibility for the QC inspections. The QC inspections performed by the Harris Site Management Section are subject to surveillance by the Harris Plant QA/QC Section. This eliminates the dual QA/QC functions for a given activity being performed by any one QA supervisor.

Quality Assurance Audit J

To ensure that the CP&L Quality Assurance Program is functioning as planned, periodic audits are performed by the CP&L Quality Assurance Services Section, Performance Evaluation Unit and/or its authorized consultants. The quality assurance activities of manufacturers and contractors are audited to ascertain if they are actually functioning as required.

It should be noted that the changes reflected in the above paragraphs a) and b) regarding the division of responsibility between the site QA/QC organization and the Harris Site Management was previously accepted by the NRC by letter to CP&L dated February 25, 1981.

References on page 1.8-3 and 1.8-4 of the PSAR for CP&L's Power Plant Engineering, Technical Services and Power Plant Construction Departments should be revised to reflect CP&L's Nuclear Plant Engineering, Corporate +ality Assurance and Nuclear Plant Construction Departments respectively. Also, the first sentence of paragraph 1.8.3.1.3 should be revised to read as follows, "The Manager Corporate Quality Assurance has overall responsibility for quality Assurance activities during the engineering, design, procurement, construction, and testing phases as delegated through the Manager QA Services Section and the Manager QA/QC Harris Plant. Also, reference to the Engineering & Construction Quality Assurance Section on pages 1.8-3, 1.8-4, and 1.8-4a should read QA Services Section and the Harris Plant QA/QC Section.

The paragraph just above section 1.8.3.1.4 on page 1.8-4 of the PSAR should be revised as follows:

"The CP&L Site Quality Assurance/Quality Control personnel report directly to the Manager +ality Assurance/Quality Control Harris Plant. The Manager QA/QC Harris Plant is responsible for direction of Construction Quality Assurance/+ality Control through the CP&L Director Harris QA/QC Unit. The Director Harris QA/QC will work closely with Ebasco regarding Ebasco purchased equipment. The Principal NDE Specialist at the Harris Site is responsible for providing the necessary NDE support and reports directly to the Manager QA/QC Harris Plant."

Reference to the System Planning and (bordination Department at the start of section 1.8.3.1.4 on page 1.8-4 of the PSAR should be deleted and the first four lines at the start of section 1.8.3.1.4 should read as follows: "The Principal QA Specialist of the

Performance Evaluation Unit which is part of the QA Services Section of the Corporate Quality Assurance Department is responsible for conducting quality assurance audits and is responsible for ( 1) establishing .

10) Reference in the first paragraph of page 1.8-4a of the PSAR to the Company Chairman/Chief Executive Officer, Executive Vice-President and Chief Operating Officer should be changed to read "Company Chairman/President and Executive Vice President, Power Supply and Engineering and Construction." Also the last sentence in this paragraph should be revised to read "As shown by figure 1.8-1, the Performance Evaluation Unit of the QA Services Section is independent from the Departments responsible for the Engineering &

Construction of the plant.

11) Reference in paragraph 1.8.3.2.5 on page 1.8-8 to the Ebasco Site Quality Assurance Coordinator should be deleted. These activities will be performed by off-site Ebasco QA personnel and on-site CP&L QA personnel.

12) Reference in the third paragraph on page 1.8-15a to the CP&L Site Manager should be changed to the CP&L Project General Manager-Harris Plant.

13) Page 1.8-20 of the PSAR should be revised as follows:

"1.8.3.4.1 Harris Plant Quality Assurance/Quality Control Section The Manager - Quality Assurance/Quality Control - Harris Plant is responsible for:

1) Surveillance and direction of construction site QA program

2) Surveillance of site construction activities

3) Preparation and implementation of Quality Assurance/Quality Control procedures for Site QA/QC Assuring all persons concerned that the site QA program is being performed as per the Corporate Quality Assurance Program and Quality Assurance Procedures

5) Providing inspectors and quality assurance services requir ed by the site quality assurance program. As discussed in paragraph 1.8.2(a), the Harris Site Management Section is also responsible for providing construction inspection.

The Manager Quality Assurance/Quality Control Harris Plant will be responsible for staffing and directing the quality

.assurance/quality control functions at the site. He will be directly accountable to the CP&L Manager of the Corporate Quality Assurance Department in the implementation of this Quality Assurance Program.

m mt ~

e, le ~I ~

I 'll I,'

Ih

~ 0 t F I e n

e

+r m m'hthl m m

'mes h

r m I'

~

m Q

~ 'he Harris Quality Assurance/Quality Control Unit reports to the Manager - Quality Assurance/Quality Control - Harris Plant. They will work closely with the Ebasco regarding Ebasco supplied equipment. The CP&L Director Harris QA/QC Unit has authority to stop any phase of construction work where he finds quality or procedures are questionable. Deficiencies noted by the site Quality Assurance/Quality Control personnel are reported to the Manager-Quality Assurance/Quality Control - Harris Plant.

1.8.3.0.2 Field The Harris Quality Assurance/Quality Control Unit is supervised by the Director - Harris QA/QC Unit, who reports directly to the Manager Quality Assurance/Quality Control - Harris Plant.

Administ'ratively, he will report to the Project General Manager-Harris Plant at the site for scheduling, coordination and administrative services. Carolina Power & Light Company's Harris Plant Quality Assurance/Quality Control Section is responsible for surveillance of the construction quality assurance program.

Quality Assurance/Quality Control Inspectors shall be assigned to various phases of the project as directed by the Director - Harris QA/QC Unit.

Quality Assurance/Quality Control personnel will be qualified in accordance with the Harris Plant Quality Assurance/Quality Control procedure requirements.

The Director - Harris QA/QC Unit shall:

a) Work cooperatively with and set up definite lines of communication with the Westinghouse NSSS Site Representative and Ebasco for routine flow of information and for special problems."

14) Reference in paragraph f on page 1.8-21 to Engineering and Construction Quality Assurance Procedures should be changed to Harris Plant QA/QC Section procedures.

15) Paragraph g on page 1.8-21 should be revised to read "Any differences of opinion between the Director Harris QA/QC Unit and the Project General Manager - Harris Plant shall be referred to the Vice President of Nuclear Plant Construction and the Manager Harris Plant QA/QC Section."

16) All reference to CP&L's Manager - Engineering & Construction Quality Assurance on page 1.8-23a should be changed to indicate CP&L's, Manager - QA Services Section and CP&L's Manager Harris Plant QA/QC Section. Reference to CP&L Manager - Project Engineering in the second paragraph should be changed to CP&L's Manager-Engineering, Harris Plant. The first line in the third paragraph on this page should read "The Harris Plant Quality Assurance/Quality Control Section and the Harris Site Management will be responsible for . . ." The fifth paragraph on this page should read

,,

n%

,h 4 r hf ~ ~

V I V I 4

r "f v 4

V'I I I' P h

f 4 I

'l

\

I 4 Ifl,,

4 h l* ~

4

'

( I" I h P i ., ~

I ~P P ~ I 4 fl I Vhl I 4 4'll l V, I" I thl =

'

~4 P

~ 44

~ 4 II h "Ib 4 ~

) 4 4 h h,

4 4

"Ebasco/CPEL quality assurance representatives spot check quality assurance records of selected Westinghouse safety related components." The first line in the eighth paragraph on this page should read "CPAL also reviews the applicable portion of Ebasco's quality .

17) Reference to CPAL's Engineering and Construction Quality Assurance Section in the sixth paragraph on page 1.8-23a should be changed to CPAL QA Services Section.

18) The first line in the third prargraph on page 1.8-23d should be revised to read Mhe Harris Plant Quality Assurance/Quality Control Section and Harris Site Management will prepare .

19) All references to CPAL's Engineering 5 Construction Quality Assurance Section on pages 1.8-23h and 1.8-23i should be changed to CP&L's Harris Plant Quality Assurance/Quality Control Section.

20) The existing figures 1.8-1 and 1.8-2 should be replaced with the new attached figures. Also figure 1.8-4 should be deleted.

21) The existing Table 1.8-4 should be replaced with the new attached table.

I I

I d It I*

I 1 d'I f ft) d- ~

of I '/I I d

r dt d I d .

I' it,'I I'i 1 I , tl'

~,g,',diA)dd ' d ft Ii' C', dd ddd 1 d'

0 ~ I I Il, C

Table 1.8-4 Carolina Power & Light Company Quality Assurance/Quality Control Personnel Personnel Assigned*

Full-Time Functions

1. Harris Plant

~l a) Management Formal Education Manages the CP&L and/or Experience Harris Plant Quality Assurance/Quality Control Program b) Engineering Unit

1) Principal QA Formal Education Supervise QA Engineer and/or Experience Engineering Activites

2) Project QA Formal Education Coordinate Project Engineer and/or Experience QA Engineering Activities; Review Specifications, Procedures for QA Requirements c) Harris QA/QC Unit

1) Director Formal Education Supervise QA/QC Harris QA/QC and/or Experience Activities

2) QA/QC Formal Education Supervise Superintendents and/or Experience Construction/

Operations QA/QC Surveillance/

Inspection Activities

3) QA/QC 70 Formal Education Perform QA/QC Supervisors and/or Experience Inspections and Specialists Tests and Assist Inspectors/ Other QA Personnel Technicians d) NDE Unit

1) Principal QA Formal Education Supervise NDE Unit Specialist NDE and/or Experience Activities

~ ~

Personnel As signed*

Full-Time Part-Time ualifications Functions NDE Unit (Cont'd)

2) Project QA Formal Education Coordinate/Supervise Specialist NDE and/or Experience NDE Support Activites for SHNPP and Other CP&L Facilities

3) QA Specialist Formal Education Supervisor of NDE NDE and/or Experience Technicians Performing SHNPP Construction Site NDE Activities O) QA/QC 17 Formal Education Perform NDE Technicians and/or Experience Activities

2. QA Services Section a) Management Formal Education Manages the CPRL and/or Experience QA Services Section b) Engineering Unit

1) Principal QA Formal Education Supervise Engineer and/or Experi'ence Engineering QA Activities

2) Project QA Formal Education Coordinate Project Engineer and/or Experience Engineering QA Activities

3) Engineers Formal Education Perform Engineering and/or Experience Audits and Review Specifications for QA Requirements c) Vendor Surveillance Unit

1) Principal VS Formal Education Supervise Vendor Specialist and/or Experience Surveillance Activities

2) Project VS Formal Education Participate in and Specialist and/or Experience Review Vendor Surveillance Activities

Personnel As signed*

Full-Time Functions Vendor Surveillance Unit (Cont'd)

3) Specialists Formal Education Participate in and and/or Experience Review Vendor Surveillance Activities d) Performance Evaluation Unit

1) Principal QA Formal Education Supervise the CPGL Specialists and/or Experience Corporate Audit Program

2) Project QA Formal Education Coordinate Audit Specialists and/or Experience Activities

3) Specialists Formal Education Perform Audits in and/or Experience Accordance with approved procedures

• Additional personnel will be assigned as needed NOTE: All QA personnel are full-time QA personnel; however, the personnel indicated as part-time work on other power plant projects as well as SHNPP.

(6 7 24 JDKpgp)

~ ~ ~

M

EBASCO COL DANIEL EXECUTIVE VICE.PRESIDENT CHAIRMAN/ PRESIDENT OPERATIONS SENIOR VICE PRESIDENT SENIOR VICE PRESIDENT PROJECTS ENGINEERING AND AND PROCUREMENT CONSTRUCTION GENERAL MANAGER EXECUTIVE VICE PRESIDENT POWER SUPPLY AND VICE PRESIDENT VICE PRESIDENT VICE PRESIDENT ENG'G AND CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS ENGINEERING MATERIALS ENGINEERING 8r QUALITYASSURANCE MANAGER MANAGER OF CHIEF SENIOR VICE PRESIDENT SENIOR VICE PRESIDENT PROJECTS ENGINEERS I'ORPORATE POWER SUPPLY QUAIJTY ASSURANCE ENG'G AND CONSTRUCTION GROUP DEPARTMENT GROUP CHIEF QUALITY CHIEF VENDOR ASSURANCE QUALITYASSURANCE PROJECT VICE ENGINEER REPRESENTATIVE MANAGER MANAGER VICE PRESIDENT VICE PRESIDENT PRESIDENT TECHNICAL SERVICES IIUCLEAR PLANT NUCLEAR PLANT I ENGINEERING CONSTRUCTION CONSTRUCTION DEPARTMENT ," DEPARTMENT DEPARTMENT WESTINGHOUSE WESTINGHOUSE PROJECT MANAGER MANAGER MANAGER LICENSING & PERMITS QA SERVICES SECTION SECTION PROJECT MANAGER MANAGER QA /QC HARRIS PLANT DIRECTOR MANAGER PROJECT GENERAL QA / QC UNIT 'NGINEERING MANAGER HARRIS PLANT IHARRIS PLANT HARRIS PLANT SECTION LEGEND:

COMPANY ORGANIZATION I INTERCOMPANY COMMUNICATION CAROLINA POWER 8E LIGHT COMPANY SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR PLANT INTERCOMPANY BOUNDARIES UNITS1,2,3&4 NOTE: INFORMALCOMMUNICATIONAND COORDINATION CHANNELS ARE NOT SHOWN QUALITYASSURANCE ORGANIZAT'QhI

).8 1

'

~ ~ ~ W la 8~

1~

I t ~ y ~ I e la

MANAGER Ill O

~ CORPORATE QUAUTY ASSURANCE DEPT.

C} 0I

~

cy+xz Z Z 'll

~>

v)

O 5

MANAGER QA SERVICES MANAGER QA/QC ROBINSON AND

(/)

"Zm SECTION BRUNSWICK PLANTS PCp

~rr0 Q

P mx PRINCIPAL QA ENGR. PRINCIPAL QA SPECIALIST ENGINEERING VENDOR SURVEILLANCE gO QA UNIT UNIT z

PRINCIPAL QA SPECIALIST PRINCIPAL C}A SPECIALIST PERFORMANCE EVALUATION TRAINING & ADMINISTRATION UNIT UNIT GENERAL OFFICE O

0 SITE MANAGER QA/QC HARRIS PLANT Om vP hC I I DIRECTOR QA/QC PRINCIPAL OA ENGR. HARRIS PLANT Ol 0 ENGINEERING OA PRINCIPAL QA Z UNIT SPECIALIST NDE

~ V)

PROJECT aa PROJECT QA z ENGINEERS QA SUPERINTENDENT QC SUPERINTENDENT SPECIALIST NDE O

QA SPECIALISTS NDE QA SUPERVISORS QC SUPERVISORS SPECIALISTS SPECIALISTS QA/QC INSPECTORS/TECHNICIANS QA INSPECTORS/ QC INSPECTORS/

TECHNICIANS TECHNICIANS (CIVII MECHANICAl (CIVII MECHANICAI ELECTRICAI WELDING. ELECTRICAL, WELDING, RECEIVING & RECORDS) RECEIVING & RECORDS)

~o i

i