U-602613, Calcs for Functional Requirements for First & Second Level Undervoltage Relays at 4kV 1A1,1B1 & 1C1: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(StriderTol Bot insert)
 
(StriderTol Bot change)
 
Line 18: Line 18:
=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:,-
{{#Wiki_filter:,-
Attachment 2 to U-602613 LS-94-013 Page1 of18 Qi l
to U-602613 LS-94-013 Page1 of18 Qi l
l l
l l
l l
l l
l                                                   19-AN-19 l
l 19-AN-19 l
                                        "Cales For Functional Requirement L                                       For 1st & 2nd Level Undervoltage
"Cales For Functional Requirement L
;                                      Relays At 4 kV 1 A1, IB1, & IC1" l                                                                                       ,
For 1st & 2nd Level Undervoltage Relays At 4 kV 1 A1, IB1, & IC1" l
l l
l l
l l
l l
i l
i l
i 9608010082 960801 PDR ADOCK 05000461 p             PDR
i 9608010082 960801 PDR ADOCK 05000461 p
PDR


[
[
t-               .                                                                              Attachment 2 to U-602613, LS-94-013       ;
t-to U-602613, LS-94-013 Page 2 of 18 i
Page 2 of 18                 i l..
l..
CALCULATION COVER SHEET                                                   SHEET 1 OF         /7       !
CALCULATION COVER SHEET SHEET 1 OF
TITLE /DESCRII' TION:                                 DEPT /DIV             CALCULATION NO.
/7 TITLE /DESCRII' TION:
E/EPED                 19 AN-19                             l l          CALCS FOR FUNCTIONAL REQUIREMENTS FOR                                                                             )
DEPT /DIV CALCULATION NO.
l         1st & 2nd LEVEL UNDERVOLTAGE RELAYS AT               QUAUTY     SYSTEM CODE       TOPIC     BLDO/ELEV/ AREA     j 4kV 1 A1,181, & 1C1                                   RELATED       (or NA)                     (or NA)         l
E/EPED 19 AN-19 l
,                                                              (Q or N)                                                     !
CALCS FOR FUNCTIONAL REQUIREMENTS FOR
l                                                                   O               AP           E90             N/A l
)
l                                                                                                                             \
l 1st & 2nd LEVEL UNDERVOLTAGE RELAYS AT QUAUTY SYSTEM CODE TOPIC BLDO/ELEV/ AREA j
!          APPROVALS - NAME/ SIGNATURE /DATE l
4kV 1 A1,181, & 1C1 RELATED (or NA)
CORP PREPARING      REVISION  VOLUME    READY FOR INCORPORATION:
(or NA) l (Q or N) l O
l PREPARED BY     Al Haumann               THIS   V.
AP E90 N/A l
YES     d   NO         N/A 2         C
l
          $ 1m if (ld )H                                                                             MICROFICHE ATTACHED:
\\
!              DATE              SIGNATURE      CONFIRMATION REQUIRED U YES            NO PAGE NO(s)                             YES     d     NO CHECKED BY PR M         VOL. INCORP. ASSGNMNT.                         Engineering DATE                             MOD.
APPROVALS - NAME/ SIGNATURE /DATE l
1 siaNAtuRE                    AP-28             ECN                   CR                     l i                                                                                                                             l W $g(,s               COMMENTS:                                            MWR                    I l
READY FOR INCORPORATION:
REVIEWED BY THIS VOLUME IS TO MAKE MINOR EDITORIAL CHANGES WHICH kgJg 'io     (D ,+             s     CLARIFY THE CALCULATION
l CORP PREPARING REVISION VOLUME PREPARED BY Al Haumann THIS V.
                              \j SiONATURE                                                                                   j l
YES d
i l
NO N/A 2
CORP PREPARING     REVISION VOLUME     READY FOR INCORPORATION:
C
l PREPARED BY                             THIS REV.
$ 1m if (ld )H DATE SIGNATURE CONFIRMATION REQUIRED MICROFICHE ATTACHED:
l                                                                                              YES         NO         N/A PRwr
NO PAGE NO(s)
                  '                                                                                  MICROFICHE ATTACHED:
YES d
DATE SIGNAME       CONFIRMATION REQUIRED l   lYES l     l NO   PAGE NO(s)
NO U YES CHECKED BY PR M VOL. INCORP. ASSGNMNT.
YES           NO CHECKED BY PR Nr         VOL. INCORP. ASSGNMNT.
Engineering 1
[ ATE             SiONATURE COMMENTS:                                           MWR REVIEWED BY PRINT
DATE siaNAtuRE MOD.
,    ?         ' '
AP-28 ECN CR l
DATE               SIGNATURE l   w T
i COMMENTS:
    #                                          CORP PREPARING      REVISION  VOLUME    READY FOR INCORPORATION:
MWR l
7 u.,   PREPARED BY -                           THis REY.
W $g(,s REVIEWED BY THIS VOLUME IS TO MAKE MINOR EDITORIAL CHANGES WHICH kgJg 'io (D,+
YES         NO         N/A Z                             PRINT
s CLARIFY THE CALCULATION
              / /
\\j SiONATURE j
DATE             sioNATuRE     CONFIRM ATION REQUIRED                                 MICROFICHE ATTACHED:
l i
l   l YES                                                   YES          NO NO PAGE NO(s)
l READY FOR INCORPORATION:
CHECKED BY -
l CORP PREPARING REVISION VOLUME l
PREPARED BY THIS REV.
YES NO N/A PRwr DATE CONFIRMATION REQUIRED MICROFICHE ATTACHED:
SIGNAME l
lYES l l NO PAGE NO(s)
YES NO CHECKED BY PR Nr VOL. INCORP. ASSGNMNT.
[ ATE SiONATURE COMMENTS:
MWR REVIEWED BY PRINT
?
DATE SIGNATURE l
w T
READY FOR INCORPORATION:
CORP PREPARING REVISION VOLUME 7
u.,
PREPARED BY -
THis REY.
YES NO N/A Z
PRINT
/ /
DATE sioNATuRE CONFIRM ATION REQUIRED MICROFICHE ATTACHED:
l l YES NO PAGE NO(s)
YES NO CHECKED BY -
PRINT VOL. INCORP. ASSGNMNT.
PRINT VOL. INCORP. ASSGNMNT.
              / /
/ /
DATE             stoNATURE       MOD.                           ECN                   CR COMMENTS:                                           MWR
DATE stoNATURE MOD.
(         REVIEWED BY
ECN CR COMMENTS:
!                                    nwr I I DATE               SIGNATURE i
MWR
(
REVIEWED BY nwr I I DATE SIGNATURE i
i
i


l
l to U-602613 LS-94-013 l
              ,                                                                                      Attachment 2
~'
            ,        ,                                                                              to U-602613                 ;
Page 3 of 18 REVISION HISTORY Page 2 l
    ~'
i Dept./Div. E/EPED Calc. # lH:AN-19 Revision 2 Volume (if applicable)
LS-94-013                   l Page 3 of 18 Page 2 REVISION HISTORY l
C i
i Dept./Div. E/EPED             Calc. # lH:AN-19 Revision 2                                 Volume (if applicable)     C l
Objective: Ihe.Surpose of this volume Calculation is to make minor _aditorial changes to clarify _the_ calculation __
i Objective: Ihe.Surpose of this volume Calculation is to make minor _aditorial changes to clarify _the_ calculation __ l sn_that.it is clearer _for_those_ reviewers and. auditors _who_are_not fam!!iar_with the degraded _ Voltage             l issuesllor_the_ set.pointanethodology                                                                                   1 l
l sn_that.it is clearer _for_those_ reviewers and. auditors _who_are_not fam!!iar_with the degraded _ Voltage issuesllor_the_ set.pointanethodology 1
Reason: Reviews.hyEuclear_Assassment_ indicated that_there were areas of the_calculatioIL1 hat _were unclear or required _Ininor_aditoriaLcorrections. This_yolume incorporates _theitcomments._No numericalnor_lechntcatchanges to volume Bare made by this volume.
l Reason: Reviews.hyEuclear_Assassment_ indicated that_there were areas of the_calculatioIL1 hat _were unclear or required _Ininor_aditoriaLcorrections. This_yolume incorporates _theitcomments._No numericalnor_lechntcatchanges to volume Bare made by this volume.
List of Affected Pages: pages 5 through 8 of the base calculation. This.yolumaJiupersedes_vnlume_B
List of Affected Pages: pages 5 through 8 of the base calculation. This.yolumaJiupersedes_vnlume_B
                                                                                                                                )
)
l        Revision                                     Volume (if applicable)                                                     ,
Revision Volume (if applicable) l l
l                                                                                                                               !
Objective:
Objective:
!                                                                                                                                i l                                                                                                                               l l
i l
Reason:
l Reason:
l l
l l
l       List of Affected Pages:
l List of Affected Pages:
Revision                                     Volume (if applicable) l l       Objective:
Revision Volume (if applicable) l l
l
Objective:
!        Reason:
l Reason:
List of Affected Pages:
List of Affected Pages:
i NF-303 (10/95)
i NF-303 (10/95)


Attachm nt 2 i
~
~
Attachm nt 2      i to U-602613       ;
to U-602613 LS-94-013 hAGE 3 !f 17 CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REV. 2 VOL. C
      ,-                                                                          LS-94-013         !
hAGE 3 !f 17   ;
CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REV. 2 VOL. C
[ Dept./Div. E/EPED]
[ Dept./Div. E/EPED]
l i
l i
TABLE OF CONTENTS PAGE COVER SHEET                                                                 1 REVISION HISTORY                                                           2 TABLE OF CONTENTS                                                           3 PURPOSE                                                                     4 DISCUSSION                                                                 4 INPUTS                                                                     5 ASSUMPTIONS                                                                 8 METHODOLOGY                                                                 8 EVALUATION                                                                 13 REFERENCE LIST                                                             17         ,
TABLE OF CONTENTS PAGE COVER SHEET 1
ATTACHMENTS
REVISION HISTORY 2
              ~ Attachment 1   Probability table                             1page Attachment 2      ABB instruction IB 7.4.1.7-7 issue D         12 pages Attachment 3      ABB Descriptive Bulletin 41-233S September   2 pages 1990 Attachment 4      ABB Type Test Certificate Number RC-6004     6 pages Revision 0 dated 2/10/89.
TABLE OF CONTENTS 3
Attachment 5      HP 3458A Multimeter Data Sheet dated May     7 pages 1991 & Test and Measurement Catalog 1994.
PURPOSE 4
Copies of selected pages Attachment 6      Westinghouse Electric Corporation Product     2 pages I
DISCUSSION 4
bulletin 44-215 D WE A dated July 15,1976 for type PCO-60 Voltage transformers I
INPUTS 5
i 1
ASSUMPTIONS 8
i
METHODOLOGY 8
EVALUATION 13 REFERENCE LIST 17 ATTACHMENTS
~ Attachment 1 Probability table 1page ABB instruction IB 7.4.1.7-7 issue D 12 pages ABB Descriptive Bulletin 41-233S September 2 pages 1990 ABB Type Test Certificate Number RC-6004 6 pages Revision 0 dated 2/10/89.
HP 3458A Multimeter Data Sheet dated May 7 pages 1991 & Test and Measurement Catalog 1994.
Copies of selected pages Westinghouse Electric Corporation Product 2 pages bulletin 44-215 D WE A dated July 15,1976 for type PCO-60 Voltage transformers i
1 i


                  .                                                                                  Attachmsnt 2
Attachmsnt 2 to U-602613 LS-94-013 P g fgof 1g g7 4
      .'                                                                                            to U-602613 LS-94-013 P g fgof41g g7 CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REV. 2 VOL C
CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REV. 2 VOL C
[DeptJDiv. E/EPED]
[DeptJDiv. E/EPED]
PURPOSE
PURPOSE
                  'The purpose of this Calculation is
'The purpose of this Calculation is To evaluate the use of an ABB 27N undervoltage relay in the Second Level Under-Voltage (also called degraded voltage) protection scheme.
                    . To evaluate the use of an ABB 27N undervoltage relay in the Second Level Under-Voltage (also called degraded voltage) protection scheme.
Determine the relay trip (drop-out) and reset (pick-up) bands based on the loop accuracy methods described in CI-01.00 Instmment Set-point Calculation Methodology (Reference 10).
                    . Determine the relay trip (drop-out) and reset (pick-up) bands based on the loop accuracy methods described in CI-01.00 Instmment Set-point Calculation Methodology (Reference 10).
The analytical limits (AL) for the second level under-voltage relay pick-up are as follows:
                    . The analytical limits (AL) for the second level under-voltage relay pick-up are as follows:
: 1. The maximum pick-up voltage is equal the minimum 4KV ESF bus voltage under steady-state LOCA loading with the off-site voltage at the minimum expected
: 1. The maximum pick-up voltage is equal the minimum 4KV ESF bus voltage under steady-state LOCA loading with the off-site voltage at the minimum expected value,
: value,
: 2. The minimum pick-up voltage is equal to the minimum 4KV ESF bus voltage required to start and run the LOCA required equipment.
: 2. The minimum pick-up voltage is equal to the minimum 4KV ESF bus voltage required to start and run the LOCA required equipment.
                    . The allowable value (AV) will also be established by this volume and this number will be used in the Tech Spec revision which is being prepared to support the new relay settings.
The allowable value (AV) will also be established by this volume and this number will be used in the Tech Spec revision which is being prepared to support the new relay settings.
DISCUSSION The second level under voltage relay scheme has a two fold function. It must ensure that there is adequate voltage following the LOCA block start initiation for the ESF required equipment to start and mn. It must also prevent the ESF buses from transferring to the on site source if there is adequate voltage from the o'f-site source to operate the ESF equipment. Therefore the second level under voltage relay pick-up voltage (accounting for the various instrumentation errors) must fall between these values.
DISCUSSION The second level under voltage relay scheme has a two fold function. It must ensure that there is adequate voltage following the LOCA block start initiation for the ESF required equipment to start and mn. It must also prevent the ESF buses from transferring to the on site source if there is adequate voltage from the o'f-site source to operate the ESF equipment. Therefore the second level under voltage relay pick-up voltage (accounting for the various instrumentation errors) must fall between these values.
In addition, we want to prevent spurious transferring of the ESF buses to the onsite source and allow for minor changes to the off site grid with out impacting the degraded voltage relay settings. We have therefore based on engineering judgment chosen (for LER avoidance) to limit the maximum relay pick-up to 0.75% below the 4160 volt bus 1 Al voltage found in Calculation 19-AQ-02 Rev. 3 attachment 10.2. This setting will provide a degree of margin below the minimum expected 4KV Bus voltage under steady state LOCA conditions with the 345 Kv switch-yard at the minimum expected value.
In addition, we want to prevent spurious transferring of the ESF buses to the onsite source and allow for minor changes to the off site grid with out impacting the degraded voltage relay settings. We have therefore based on engineering judgment chosen (for LER avoidance) to limit the maximum relay pick-up to 0.75% below the 4160 volt bus 1 Al voltage found in Calculation 19-AQ-02 Rev. 3 attachment 10.2. This setting will provide a degree of margin below the minimum expected 4KV Bus voltage under steady state LOCA conditions with the 345 Kv switch-yard at the minimum expected value.
Calculation 19-AQ-02 Rev. 3 Attachment 10.2 lists the steady state minimum voltage at the Bus l Al as 3938 volts. 100%-0.75% of 3938 than equals 3908 volts. The minimum reset point will be the minimum voltage at the 4KV bus which will ensure that all the ESF equipment required for LOCA will start and run. The minimum voltage required by the ESF equipment will be taken from 19-AQ-02 Rev. 3 volume P Attachment 8.1 (3870 volts). The nominal second level under-voltage relay pick-up point has therefore been chosen to be mid way between the maximum and minimum reset-points or 3889. We will call this nominal value NTSP. This calculation will assure that there is adequate margin for NTSP between the maximum and minimum allowable values when the total relay loop error is considered.
Calculation 19-AQ-02 Rev. 3 Attachment 10.2 lists the steady state minimum voltage at the Bus l Al as 3938 volts. 100%-0.75% of 3938 than equals 3908 volts. The minimum reset point will be the minimum voltage at the 4KV bus which will ensure that all the ESF equipment required for LOCA will start and run. The minimum voltage required by the ESF equipment will be taken from 19-AQ-02 Rev. 3 volume P Attachment 8.1 (3870 volts). The nominal second level under-voltage relay pick-up point has therefore been chosen to be mid way between the maximum and minimum reset-points or 3889. We will call this nominal value NTSP. This calculation will assure that there is adequate margin for NTSP between the maximum and minimum allowable values when the total relay loop error is considered.
to U-602613 LS-94-013 Page 6 of 18 PAGE 5 of 17 CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REV. 2 VOL. C l
[DeptJDiv. E/EPED]
INPUTS 11.
The relays utilized in the Second Level Under-Voltage schen.e will be ABB type 2' N catalog number 41 IT6375-HF(or 410T6375-HF which has the same characteristics). The relay pickup range is from 70 to 120 volts, the dropout range is 70% to 99%, the pickup time delay is instantaneous. The drop out time delay will be set at minimum (= 0.1 sec) The relay requires a 125 volt nominal DC source to operate. The relay will include the harmonic distortion filter. The published relay tolerances from Reference 3,4 and 5 EXPRESSED AS A l
PERCENT OF SETTING are as follows:
a)
Pickup and dropout setting repeatability with respect to temperature with a constant control voltage and the relay operating in an environment where the ambient temperature could vary between +10 to +40 C is 0.4 %. W e' will call this 26 value ATE.
b)
Pickup and dropout setting repeatability at a constant temperature and constant control voltage is 0.1%. We will call this 2S value VA.
l c)
Pickup and dropout setting, repeatability over " allowable" de control power range is 10.1%. The allowable de control power range for a 125 volt nominal relay is 100 to 140 V DC. The Tech Spec. requires that when AC power is available to supply the battery charger the DC buses must l
operate between 121 and 139 volts. The published DC supply error is l
considered linear over the operating range per Reference 10, Engineering l
standard Cl 01.00. Therefore, the published error of+0.1% can be divided by 40 volt allowable range. In addition, data in the ABB type test Certificate Reference 5 shows that this is conservatL e. ~he variation then l
equals *0.0025%/ volt.
We will call this 26 error PSE ad consider it to l
be +0.045% for our operating range.
d)
The radiation and humidity effects are considered negligible because the relays are not subjected to an environment with humidity or radiation above normal atmospheric conditions.
e)
The 27N relay has been subjected to 6g ZPA either axis biaxial broad band multifrequency vibration with out malfunction or damage per ANSI /IEE C37.98 (reference 4). Therefore there is no seismic impact to the relay accuracy.
f)
ABB tests indicate that there is no RFI interference effect associated with the relay. Therefore it is not considered a factor in this calculation (Reference 5).


            .                                                    Attachment 2 to U-602613 LS-94-013 Page 6 of 18 PAGE 5 of 17 CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REV. 2 VOL. C l              [DeptJDiv. E/EPED]
to U-602613 LS-94-013 Page 7 of 18 PAGE 6 of 17 j
INPUTS
CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REV. 2 VOL C
: 11. The relays utilized in the Second Level Under-Voltage schen.e will be ABB type 2' N catalog number 41 IT6375-HF(or 410T6375-HF which has the same characteristics) . The relay pickup range is from 70 to 120 volts, the dropout range is 70% to 99%, the pickup time delay is instantaneous. The drop out time delay will be set at minimum (= 0.1 sec) The relay requires a 125 volt nominal DC source to operate. The relay will include the harmonic distortion filter. The published relay tolerances from Reference 3,4 and 5 EXPRESSED AS A l                    PERCENT OF SETTING are as follows:
[ Dept./Div. E/EPEDj.
a)      Pickup and dropout setting repeatability with respect to temperature with a constant control voltage and the relay operating in an environment where the ambient temperature could vary between +10 to +40 C is 0.4 % . W e'          ;
I2.
will call this 26 value ATE .
The relay calibration setup will consist of a low noise variable AC power supply, the ABB 27N relay and a Hewlett Packard Model HP3458A Digital Multimeter.
b)      Pickup  and dropout setting repeatability at a constant temperature and constant control voltage is 0.1%. We will call this 2S value VA.
HP3458A
l                    c)      Pickup and dropout setting, repeatability over " allowable" de control power range is 10.1%. The allowable de control power range for a 125 volt nominal relay is 100 to 140 V DC. The Tech Spec. requires that when
\\
!                            AC power is available to supply the battery charger the DC buses must l                            operate between 121 and 139 volts. The published DC supply error is l                            considered linear over the operating range per Reference 10, Engineering          l l                            standard Cl 01.00. Therefore, the published error of+0.1% can be divided by 40 volt allowable range. In addition, data in the ABB type test Certificate Reference 5 shows that this is conservatL e. ~he variation then l                            equals *0.0025%/ volt.      We will call this 26 error PSE ad consider it to l                            be +0.045% for our operating range.
Varable AC Multimeter 3
d)      The radiation and humidity effects are considered negligible because the relays are not subjected to an environment with humidity or radiation above normal atmospheric conditions.
Power supply e
e)      The 27N relay has been subjected to 6g ZPA either axis biaxial broad band multifrequency vibration with out malfunction or damage per ANSI /IEE C37.98 (reference 4). Therefore there is no seismic impact to the relay accuracy.
ABB 27 N Relay Relay test set-up figure 1 The HP 3458A Specification and accuracy from Reference 6 are as follows:
f)      ABB tests indicate that there is no RFI interference effect associated with the relay. Therefore it is not considered a factor in this calculation (Reference 5).
a)
 
Minimum resolution at 100 volt range is 10 micro volts b)
*        .                                                        Attachment 2 to U-602613 LS-94-013 Page 7 of 18 PAGE 6 of 17 j           CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REV. 2 VOL C
The Accuracy coefficient in %/ degree C is 0.001% of reading plus 0.0001% of range (with the meter set on the 100V range). We will call this 36 value C1 ATE c)
!          [ Dept./Div. E/EPEDj .
The AC accuracy with the meter set on the 100 V range is (a 36 value) 0.02% of reading plus 0.004% of range and will be called C1 VA.
I2.     The relay calibration setup will consist of a low noise variable AC power supply, the ABB 27N relay and a Hewlett Packard Model HP3458A Digital Multimeter.
d)
HP3458A Varable AC
The meter is calibrated using a 10 volt DC test cell traceable to US NIST with an added error of 2 ppm or 0.0002%. We will call this 36 value ClSTD.
                                                    \
Multimeter 3
Power supply e                     >
ABB 27 N Relay Relay test set-up figure 1 The HP 3458A Specification and accuracy from Reference 6 are as follows:             i a)     Minimum resolution at 100 volt range is 10 micro volts b)     The Accuracy coefficient in %/ degree C is 0.001% of reading plus 0.0001% of range (with the meter set on the 100V range). We will call this 36 value C1 ATE c)     The AC accuracy with the meter set on the 100 V range is (a 36 value) 0.02% of reading plus 0.004% of range and will be called C1 VA.
d)     The meter is calibrated using a 10 volt DC test cell traceable to US NIST with an added error of 2 ppm or 0.0002%. We will call this 36 value ClSTD.
i.
i.


i
i i,
      ,                                                      Attachment 2 i, ,                                                            to U-602613 L   -
to U-602613 L
LS-94-013 L*                                                             Page 8 of 18 PAGE 7 of 17 CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REY. 2 VOL. C
LS-94-013 L*
Page 8 of 18 PAGE 7 of 17 CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REY. 2 VOL. C
[ Dept./Div. E/EPED]
[ Dept./Div. E/EPED]
13 _   The detection loop consists of the 4KV bus which we wish to measure, a potential           .
13 _
transformer (PT) to convert 4KV to 120 volts and the ABB 27N relay.
The detection loop consists of the 4KV bus which we wish to measure, a potential transformer (PT) to convert 4KV to 120 volts and the ABB 27N relay.
The pts for DIV. I & II are Westinghouse PC-60 and, for DIV. III, GE type                 '
The pts for DIV. I & II are Westinghouse PC-60 and, for DIV. III, GE type JVM-3. Both PT models have a ratio of 4200 - 120 volts and are class lE. They conform to ANSI C57.13-1968 metering accuracy class for.03 class standard burdens W, X, M, & Y. The pts were purchased to Westinghouse drawing l
JVM-3. Both PT models have a ratio of 4200 - 120 volts and are class lE. They conform to ANSI C57.13-1968 metering accuracy class for .03 class standard
EN005, and GE data sheet 317A6131, and S&L form 1815-L (Reference 1). The i
;              burdens W, X, M, & Y. The pts were purchased to Westinghouse drawing l               EN005, and GE data sheet 317A6131, and S&L form 1815-L (Reference 1). The i               PT burden was established using E02-1 AP12 SH I1 R/W, E02-1 AP99 SH 36                   .
PT burden was established using E02-1 AP12 SH I1 R/W, E02-1 AP99 SH 36 l
l              R/D, E02-1 AP99 SH 38 R/U E02-1 AP12 SH 13 R/V, E02-1 AP12 SH I5 R/T, and E02-lHP99 SH 107 R/L (Reference 7), and the load data from the vendor
R/D, E02-1 AP99 SH 38 R/U E02-1 AP12 SH 13 R/V, E02-1 AP12 SH I5 R/T, and E02-lHP99 SH 107 R/L (Reference 7), and the load data from the vendor manuals (Reference 1). The PT burden consists of a CV2 relay, the 27N relay, a voltage transducer, a lamp and a voltmeter (Note: the EMTs shown on E02-1 AP12 SH 13 R/V are being disconnected from the pts by mods AP-027,28,
;              manuals (Reference 1). The PT burden consists of a CV2 relay, the 27N relay, a voltage transducer, a lamp and a voltmeter (Note: the EMTs shown on E02-1 AP12 SH 13 R/V are being disconnected from the pts by mods AP-027,28,
&29). The total burden on the PT is 7.5VA with a possible change in burden l
                &29). The total burden on the PT is 7.5VA with a possible change in burden l               (caused by switching the voltmeter between phases) of 1 VA. From the j               performance curve found in reference 9, we can see that for a change in burden of 12.5 VA the turns ratio correction changes 0.1%. Therefore, if the actual change
(caused by switching the voltmeter between phases) of 1 VA. From the j
,              is i VA the change in PT turns ratio would be .008% of rating. The curve also shows that the PT ratio correction factor should be .997.
performance curve found in reference 9, we can see that for a change in burden of 12.5 VA the turns ratio correction changes 0.1%. Therefore, if the actual change is i VA the change in PT turns ratio would be.008% of rating. The curve also shows that the PT ratio correction factor should be.997.
: 14. Two relays will be installed in Div. I & II (one between phase AB and one between phase BC). The relay trip functions are wired in series so that both               j relays must trip in order for the protective action to be initiated. Only one relay l
14.
Two relays will be installed in Div. I & II (one between phase AB and one between phase BC). The relay trip functions are wired in series so that both j
relays must trip in order for the protective action to be initiated. Only one relay l
must reset for the timer to reset, preventing transferring ofload to the diesel.
must reset for the timer to reset, preventing transferring ofload to the diesel.
l               Reference E02-1 AP12 sheets 11 & 13 (Reference 7).
l Reference E02-1 AP12 sheets 11 & 13 (Reference 7).
: 15. Two relays will replace the present single three phase relay in Div. III . The new single phase relays will monitor phase AB and BC. The trip contacts are wired in           !
15.
series. All the elements must sense a degraded voltage for the protective function         l l              to be initiated. Only one relay must reset for the timer to reset, preventing transferring ofload to the diesel. Reference E02-lHP99-sheets 107,103, & 102A             '
Two relays will replace the present single three phase relay in Div. III. The new single phase relays will monitor phase AB and BC. The trip contacts are wired in series. All the elements must sense a degraded voltage for the protective function l
l l              (Reference 8).
to be initiated. Only one relay must reset for the timer to reset, preventing transferring ofload to the diesel. Reference E02-lHP99-sheets 107,103, & 102A l
(Reference 8).
i l
i l
l' l-                                                                                           _
l' l -


b           -
b Attachmsnt 2 l.
Attachmsnt 2 to U-602613
to U-602613 E,.
: l.  -
LS-94-013 Page 9 of 18 PAGE 8 of 17 CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REV. 2 VOL. C
E, .                                                               LS-94-013 Page 9 of 18               PAGE 8 of 17 CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REV. 2 VOL. C
[DeptJDiv. E/EPED]
[DeptJDiv. E/EPED]
ASSUMPTIONS i
ASSUMPTIONS i
l l             Al. The accuracy's published by the instrument manufactures are considered as a 95% probability value, equal to two standard deviations (2a). This assumption does not require verification based on engineering judgment i                   and direction given in Engineering Standard CI 01.00 Instrument Set-point Calculation Methodology (Reference 10).
l l
A2   All accuracy data is considered to be a normal distribution.
Al.
l             A3   The ABB 27N relay drift for 6 months is assumed to be equal to relay accuracy of l                   .1%. For an 18 month suiveillance period the drift error (VD) is equal to the j                   following:
The accuracy's published by the instrument manufactures are considered as a 95% probability value, equal to two standard deviations (2a). This assumption does not require verification based on engineering judgment i
r                                                                     i VD:= E0.1               VD=0.1732 % Error     26 3 6 l
and direction given in Engineering Standard CI 01.00 Instrument Set-point Calculation Methodology (Reference 10).
l This assumption does not require verification based on engmeenng               j judgment and direction given in Engineering Standard CI 01.00 Instrument Set-point Calculation Methodology (Reference 10)
A2 All accuracy data is considered to be a normal distribution.
METHODOLOGY
l A3 The ABB 27N relay drift for 6 months is assumed to be equal to relay accuracy of l
!          M. I . The accuracy for the ABB27N relay (A27N) will be calculated by the square root l                   of the sum of the squares method.
.1%. For an 18 month suiveillance period the drift error (VD) is equal to the j
M.2       The nominal relay pick-up point will be calculated by taking the nominal relay l                   pick-up voltage at the 4KV bus and reflecting it to the low voltage side of the PT Potential transformer primary           ratio correction low side voltage                               voltage 3889               35     0.997     111.4486 Table 1
following:
 
r i
        ,                                                          Attachment 2
VD:=
.    ,        ,                                                    to U-602613 LS-94-013 Page 10 of 18 PAGE 9 of 17 CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REV. 2 VOL C
E0.1 VD=0.1732 % Error 26 l
3 6 This assumption does not require verification based on engmeenng j
judgment and direction given in Engineering Standard CI 01.00 Instrument Set-point Calculation Methodology (Reference 10)
METHODOLOGY M. I.
The accuracy for the ABB27N relay (A27N) will be calculated by the square root l
of the sum of the squares method.
M.2 The nominal relay pick-up point will be calculated by taking the nominal relay l
pick-up voltage at the 4KV bus and reflecting it to the low voltage side of the PT Potential transformer primary ratio correction low side voltage voltage 3889 35 0.997 111.4486 Table 1 to U-602613 LS-94-013 Page 10 of 18 PAGE 9 of 17 CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REV. 2 VOL C
[DeptJDiv. E/EPED]
[DeptJDiv. E/EPED]
M3     The loop calibration error will be calculated as follows:
M3 The loop calibration error will be calculated as follows:
a) First the calibration instrument error Cl must be determined a.D The HP3485A accuracy error CIVA from the inputs above at 111 A4V can be is 111.44.0002 + 100 00004.100 = 0.0236% error 111.44 a.2) The temperature error contribution Cl ATE can be expressed as follows, noting that the Calibration lab temperature is kept at 72' F 2F or within 1.l*C . The temperature of the test instrument can be read directly by the HP3485A and the requirement that the test instrument be calibrated and used at 72* F
a) First the calibration instrument error Cl must be determined a.D The HP3485A accuracy error CIVA from the inputs above at 111 A4V can be is 111.44.0002 + 100 00004.100 = 0.0236% error 111.44 a.2) The temperature error contribution Cl ATE can be expressed as follows, noting that the Calibration lab temperature is kept at 72' F 2F or within 1.l*C. The temperature of the test instrument can be read directly by the HP3485A and the requirement that the test instrument be calibrated and used at 72* F
* 2'F will be controlled by the relay calibration procedure. From the input data for the temperature error would then be expressed as
* 2'F will be controlled by the relay calibration procedure. From the input data for the temperature error would then be expressed as 1.1 "
                                          +
-100 - 0.0012
1.1 "                           -100 - 0.0012   % error t11.44 a.3) The calibration instrument error Cl then becomes 2          2 Cl :=dCIVA + C1 EAT                 C1 =0.0236       % ERROR b) The next step is the calibration of the relay using the set-up shown above in figure 1. The calibration loop error (CL) is determined as follows:
% error
b.1) Based on conversation with the Waterford plants, the ABB 27N relay         -
+
can be set to a resolution of.005 volts AC. This will be considered the           l calibration resolution for the calibration. Therefore the resolution error R       j will be determined as follows:
t11.44 a.3) The calibration instrument error Cl then becomes Cl :=dCIVA + C1 EAT 2
R :=       -100-     R = 0.0045         % ERROR 111.44
2 C1 =0.0236
% ERROR b) The next step is the calibration of the relay using the set-up shown above in figure 1. The calibration loop error (CL) is determined as follows:
b.1) Based on conversation with the Waterford plants, the ABB 27N relay can be set to a resolution of.005 volts AC. This will be considered the calibration resolution for the calibration. Therefore the resolution error R j
will be determined as follows:
R :=
-100-R = 0.0045
% ERROR 111.44


I
I to U-602613 LS-94-013 Page 11 of 18 PAGE 10 of 17 i
            ,                                                                Attachment 2 to U-602613 LS-94-013
CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REV. 2 VOL. C (DeptJDiv. E/EPED]
**                                                                          Page 11 of 18 PAGE 10 of 17       i CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REV. 2 VOL. C (DeptJDiv. E/EPED]
b.2) The new ABB 27N relay calibration procedure will allow for an acceptance band of*0.04 volts. Therefore the calibration as-left tolerance error (ALT) will be determined as follows:
b.2) The new ABB 27N relay calibration procedure will allow for an acceptance band of*0.04 volts. Therefore the calibration as-left tolerance error (ALT) will be determined as follows:
ALT :=           -100         ALT = 0.0359         % ERROR 111.44 b.3) The calibration instrument error Cl is taken from a) above b.4) the calibration loop error than becomes f fALTI l'   f1 8 fCI   I CL := 2 J I           +!
ALT :=
                                                            -      l'      CL -0.0288       % ERROR ii 3 i           i )l + l13 )
-100 ALT = 0.0359
% ERROR 111.44 b.3) The calibration instrument error Cl is taken from a) above b.4) the calibration loop error than becomes ff LT l' A I f1 8 fCI l' I
+ ! )l + l13 )
CL := 2 J I CL -0.0288
% ERROR ii 3 i i
This is considered to be 25 c) The next step is to determine the channel instrument accuracy (AI). This will take into consideration the various errors associated with operating temperature, DC voltage etc. From the inputs section above the errors are restated and the instrument accuracy determined:
This is considered to be 25 c) The next step is to determine the channel instrument accuracy (AI). This will take into consideration the various errors associated with operating temperature, DC voltage etc. From the inputs section above the errors are restated and the instrument accuracy determined:
VA := .1       %            ATE := A       %        PSE := .045   % VD =0.1732             %
VA :=.1 ATE := A PSE :=.045
ffVAI
% VD =0.1732 ff I A! := 2. j
* f          IPSE)2      IVD3 2                                            ,
; VA *
A! := 2. j ;
+ lATE 3 2i 2 ;l +.
(i 2;
l + 1 l
                                              +l ATE 3'l 2i   -
f IPSE)2 IVD3 2 AI -0 4495 (i 2;
2; 2 '2; l+1 ;l + .
'l 2;
i l          AI -0 4495   %
'2; i
This is considered to be 25 I
This is considered to be 25 I
i
i


i
i 1'.,
                '                                                        Attachment 2 1'                                                             to U-602613 LS-94-013                                       l
to U-602613 LS-94-013 l
    **                                                                  Page 12 of 18 PAGE 11 of 17 CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REV. 2 VOL C
Page 12 of 18 PAGE 11 of 17 CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REV. 2 VOL C
[DeptJDiv. E/EPED]
[DeptJDiv. E/EPED]
l, d) The loop accuracy AL can now be determined the inputs are as follows:
l, d) The loop accuracy AL can now be determined the inputs are as follows:
d.1) From b) above the calibration loop error CL = .028 %
d.1) From b) above the calibration loop error CL =.028 %
d.2) From c) above the channel instrument error AI = .4495 %
d.2) From c) above the channel instrument error AI =.4495 %
d.3) From Input I3 above the PT error or EPT== .008%
d.3) From Input I3 above the PT error or EPT==.008%
2 f C          '' I AL := hfI 13:+{     l + i2j
fI 13:
: EPfl2    AL = 0.2252 qi 2 ;    i j This is a 16 value M.4 -Illinois Power uses the GE methodology (Engineering Standard CI 01.00 - Reference #
2
'' I
+{
l + : EPfl2 C
f AL := h 2 ;
AL = 0.2252 qi i j i2j This is a 16 value M.4 -Illinois Power uses the GE methodology (Engineering Standard CI 01.00 - Reference #
: 10) for determining critical set points based on instrument errors. This methodology is statistically based. The desired probability for relay actuation is 95% (per Reg. Guide 1.105 -Reference # 11). In order to determine the 95% probability of either 2 relays actuating together or 1 of 2 relays resetting, the table Attachment I was set up. The table was established by plotting the probability distribution that one relay would actuate assuming a normal distribution curve (see Assumption # A2). The equation for that plot was:
: 10) for determining critical set points based on instrument errors. This methodology is statistically based. The desired probability for relay actuation is 95% (per Reg. Guide 1.105 -Reference # 11). In order to determine the 95% probability of either 2 relays actuating together or 1 of 2 relays resetting, the table Attachment I was set up. The table was established by plotting the probability distribution that one relay would actuate assuming a normal distribution curve (see Assumption # A2). The equation for that plot was:
1     5
1 5
                                                          *e 2 f(x) = Er The probability that two will actuate together was determined by multiplying the probability of each of them together and plotting that curve accordingly. In this case that meant squaring the probability of one relay (since the probability for both relays is the same). The point on the Table in attachment I which equaled .95 was then found. This came out to be 1.96.
f(x) = Er
                                                                                                ~
*e 2 The probability that two will actuate together was determined by multiplying the probability of each of them together and plotting that curve accordingly. In this case that meant squaring the probability of one relay (since the probability for both relays is the same). The point on the Table in attachment I which equaled.95 was then found. This came out to be 1.96.
To determine the same o multiplier for when only one of the two relays needed to change state, the probability that the relays would fail to actuate was considered. To do this, I minus the probability squared was tabulated (attachment 1). From this table the value for 95% confidence was found. This corresponds to a value of.76.
To determine the same o multiplier for when only one of the two relays needed to change
~
state, the probability that the relays would fail to actuate was considered. To do this, I minus the probability squared was tabulated (attachment 1). From this table the value for 95% confidence was found. This corresponds to a value of.76.
1 Therefore, the 1.96 Sis to be used for a 95% probability that two relays will actuate together and 0.76 6 that at least one of the two will reset.
1 Therefore, the 1.96 Sis to be used for a 95% probability that two relays will actuate together and 0.76 6 that at least one of the two will reset.
t.
t.
I l
I l


              .                                                      Attachment 2                                1
1 to U-602613 LS-94-013
            .      .                                                to U-602613
~.
  ~.                                                                  LS-94-013 Page 13 of 18                 PAGE 12 of 17 CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REV. 2 VOL C
Page 13 of 18 PAGE 12 of 17 CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REV. 2 VOL C
[ Dept./Div. E/EPED]
[ Dept./Div. E/EPED]
M.4a     Two 27N relay contacts (in series) are required to initiate the time delay relay and       l 1
M.4a Two 27N relay contacts (in series) are required to initiate the time delay relay and 1
the subsequent protective action. We have, therefore, determined that for a 1.96           i S deviation about the set point the relay loop will activate with 95% confidence           l level. We will call this Ado. It can be expressed as:
the subsequent protective action. We have, therefore, determined that for a 1.96 S deviation about the set point the relay loop will activate with 95% confidence level. We will call this Ado. It can be expressed as:
l l
Ado := 1.96 AL Ado = 0.4415 % of setting M.4b Only one of the two 27N relay contacts (in series) are required to reset the time delay relay and subsequently prevent the buses from transferring to the diesels.
Ado := 1.96 AL     Ado = 0.4415 % of setting M.4b Only one of the two 27N relay contacts (in series) are required to reset the time delay relay and subsequently prevent the buses from transferring to the diesels.
We have, therefore, determined that for a.76 6 deviation about the reset point the relay loop will activate with 95% confidence level. We will call this Apu. It can be expressed Apu :=.76. AL Apu = 0.1712 % ofsetting i
We have, therefore, determined that for a .76 6 deviation about the reset point the relay loop will activate with 95% confidence level. We will call this Apu. It can be expressed Apu := .76. AL     Apu = 0.1712 % ofsetting i
l M5 The loop Allowable error will be calculated as follows:
l M5       The loop Allowable error will be calculated as follows:
a) The calibration loop error will be the same as above ffALT32 y,2 f I CL := 2-
a) The calibration loop error will be the same as above ffALT32 y ,2 fC1I CL := 2- 'l       +l l + l :*       CL -0.0288     % ERROR                         !
'l
L3J     tj     (3i This is considered to be 2S b) The next step is to determine the channel instrument allowable accuracy with out the drift error (AV). This will take into consideration the various errors associated with operating temperature, DC voltage etc. From the inputs section above the errors are restated and the instrument accuracy detennined:
+l l + l C1 :*
VA := .1   %        ATE =.4
CL -0.0288
                                                                  %      PSE = .045   %
% ERROR L3J tj (3i This is considered to be 2S b) The next step is to determine the channel instrument allowable accuracy with out the drift error (AV). This will take into consideration the various errors associated with operating temperature, DC voltage etc. From the inputs section above the errors are restated and the instrument accuracy detennined:
A    ATE .g AV = 2          +                        AV = 0 4148 %
VA :=.1 ATE =.4 PSE =.045 A
di 2/     ( 2/     ( 2/
ATE.g AV = 0 4148 %
AV = 2
+
di 2/
( 2/
( 2/


l*   '
l*
Attachment 2
h.
: h. ,
to U-602613 l(,
to U-602613 l(,
* LS-94-013 Page 14 of 18 PAGE 13 of 17 l             CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REV. 2 VOL. C l_             [DeptJDiv. E/EPEDj This is considered to be 26 c) The loop allowable accuracy ALV can now be determined the inputs are as follows:
LS-94-013 Page 14 of 18 PAGE 13 of 17 l
l                             d.1) From b) above the calibration loop error CL = .028 %
CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REV. 2 VOL. C l_
d.2) From c) above the channel instrument error AV = .4148 %
[DeptJDiv. E/EPEDj This is considered to be 26 c) The loop allowable accuracy ALV can now be determined the inputs are as follows:
l                             d.3) From Input I3 above the PT error or EPT= .008%
l d.1) From b) above the calibration loop error CL =.028 %
2               32 ICL   AV32     EPT ALV:=   l - + -     I+ -         ALV = 0.2379 3(2         23      2 3 This is a 16 value M.6 Using the same methodoligy as above (Engineering Standard CI 01.00 - Reference # 10) for determining critical set points based on instmment errors, the probability that at least one of the two relays will reset is 0.76 6.
d.2) From c) above the channel instrument error AV =.4148 %
We have, therefore, determined that for a .76 6 deviation about the reset point the relay loop will activate with 95% confidence level. We will call the allowable value AVpu. It can be expressed as AVpu := .76 ALV     AVpu =0.158 % of setting EVALUATION The results can now be represented by a graph similar to the following:
l d.3) From Input I3 above the PT error or EPT=.008%
2 ICL AV32 32 EPT ALV:=
l - + -
I+ -
ALV = 0.2379 3(2 2 3 2
3 This is a 16 value M.6 Using the same methodoligy as above (Engineering Standard CI 01.00 - Reference # 10) for determining critical set points based on instmment errors, the probability that at least one of the two relays will reset is 0.76 6.
We have, therefore, determined that for a.76 6 deviation about the reset point the relay loop will activate with 95% confidence level. We will call the allowable value AVpu. It can be expressed as AVpu :=.76 ALV AVpu =0.158 % of setting EVALUATION The results can now be represented by a graph similar to the following:
f l
f l
l i
l i
Line 267: Line 347:


1 a
1 a
      ,*                                                        Attachment 2                              1 to U-602613 e-                                                             LS-94-013 Page 15 of 18               PAGE 14 of 17 CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REY. 2 VOL C
to U-602613 e-LS-94-013 Page 15 of 18 PAGE 14 of 17 CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REY. 2 VOL C
[DeptJDiv. E/EPEDj minimum off-site REAY ERROR RICION I
[DeptJDiv. E/EPEDj minimum off-site REAY ERROR RICION relay pick-up setting RELAYIRROR RECION 3870 volts probability In other words we will show that by setting the degraded voltage relay pick-up at 3889 the totalloop error will not cause (with a 95% probability) the relay to pick up below 3870 nor above the minimum off-site voltage as seen by the 4KV ESF buses. This can be represented by the following expressions:
relay pick-up setting           ;
We will call the upper limit of the permissible relay pick-up settings PUU and the j
1 RELAYIRROR RECION 3870 volts l
lower limit PUL. The calculation of these values is l
probability In other words we will show that by setting the degraded voltage relay pick-up at 3889 the totalloop error will not cause (with a 95% probability) the relay to pick up below 3870 nor above the minimum off-site voltage as seen by the 4KV ESF buses. This can be represented by the following expressions:
PUU := 3908-l 3908 A "l P
We will call the upper limit of the permissible relay pick-up settings PUU and the         j lower limit PUL. The calculation of these values is                                       l 1
PUU =39013104 Volts at the 4 KVlevel i
l P
100j PUU PUU120 :=
PUU := 3908- l 3908100jA "l   PUU =39013104         Volts at the 4 KVlevel i
PUU120 = 111.8014 Volts at the 120Vlevel
PUU PUU120 :=                       PUU120 = 111.8014     Volts at the 120Vlevel
(.997 35)
(.997 35)
PUL := 3870 + 3270. ^E"         PUL = 3876.6245       Volts at the 4 KVlevel 100                                                                   1 PUL120 :=                       PUL120 = 111.094     Volts at the 120Vlevel
PUL := 3870 + 3270. ^E" PUL = 3876.6245 Volts at the 4 KVlevel 100 PUL120 :=
(.997 35)                                                                       4 l
PUL120 = 111.094 Volts at the 120Vlevel
PUU>3889)PUL 3901.3104 > 3889 > 3876.6245 4
(.997 35) 4 PUU>3889)PUL 3901.3104 > 3889 > 3876.6245 4


k                 .                                                              Attachment 2
k to U-602613 l.
: l.    .-    '' ,
LS-94-013 Page 16 of 18 PAGE 15 of 17 CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REV. 2 VOL. C
                          ,                                                    to U-602613 LS-94-013 Page 16 of 18 PAGE 15 of 17 .
CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REV. 2 VOL. C                                                                   l
[DeptJDiv. E/EPED)
[DeptJDiv. E/EPED)
The lower limit of the Degraded voltage relay is dependent on the minimum voltage required to keep ESF equipment running. From calculation 19-AQ-02 we can show that the ESF equipment will run at 3832 volts. We will call this limit DOL. There is no upper limit for the drop-out except the physical restraints of the l
The lower limit of the Degraded voltage relay is dependent on the minimum voltage required to keep ESF equipment running. From calculation 19-AQ-02 we can show that the ESF equipment will run at 3832 volts. We will call this limit l
l                                relay which will allow it to pick up in the range described above. The drop out can be adjusted between 70% and 99 % of the pick-up. We want to provide the maximum voltage to our equipment and still keep the relay pick-up as described above. Therefore we have chosen to set the drop-out at 99% of the pick-up or
DOL. There is no upper limit for the drop-out except the physical restraints of the l
>                                3850 volts.
relay which will allow it to pick up in the range described above. The drop out can be adjusted between 70% and 99 % of the pick-up. We want to provide the maximum voltage to our equipment and still keep the relay pick-up as described above. Therefore we have chosen to set the drop-out at 99% of the pick-up or 3850 volts.
DOL:=3832+ 3832                 DOL = 3848.9166       Volts at the 4 KV level 100 l
DOL:=3832+ 3832 DOL = 3848.9166 Volts at the 4 KV level 100 l
DOL l,                               DOL 120.=                       DOL 120= 110.2999     Volts at the 120V level l                                           (.99735)
DOL l,
DOL > 3832           3850>3848.9166 > 3832 L
DOL 120.=
o                                                                                                     .
DOL 120= 110.2999 Volts at the 120V level l
l                                We will call the upper lower limit of the allowable relay (Tech Spec) pick-up settings PULV. The calculation of these values is AVpu l                     PULV:= 3870+ 3870                  PULV = 3876.1153     Volts at the 4 KVlevel 100 PULV l                     PULV 120:                           PULV 120= 111.0794 Volts at the 120Vlevel
(.99735)
DOL > 3832 3850>3848.9166 > 3832 L
o l
We will call the upper lower limit of the allowable relay (Tech Spec) pick-up settings PULV. The calculation of these values is l
PULV:= 3870+ 3870AVpu PULV = 3876.1153 Volts at the 4 KVlevel 100 PULV l
PULV 120:
PULV 120= 111.0794 Volts at the 120Vlevel
(.99735)
(.99735)
:                    The critical requirement, from a plant safety standpoint, is that all the equipment required l
The critical requirement, from a plant safety standpoint, is that all the equipment required l
to support the LOCA block start receive sufficient voltage to start and run.- Therefore the critical degraded voltage relay parameter is that the relay must reset at or above 3870
to support the LOCA block start receive sufficient voltage to start and run.- Therefore the critical degraded voltage relay parameter is that the relay must reset at or above 3870
                    - volts. This is equivalent to the relay minimum reset accounting for the appropriate relay
- volts. This is equivalent to the relay minimum reset accounting for the appropriate relay
                    . errors.
. errors.
The following table listing settings and analytical limits will be used as inputs for a Tech Spec. change and the procedure for calibration of the relays. The voltage at the 120 volt
The following table listing settings and analytical limits will be used as inputs for a Tech Spec. change and the procedure for calibration of the relays. The voltage at the 120 volt
;L                   level reflects the required voltage at the.4KV bus as scaled (transformed) by the Potential l
;L level reflects the required voltage at the.4KV bus as scaled (transformed) by the Potential l
Transformer. The ratio of the 4KV voltage to the 120 volt level is 34.895:1. The Degraded Voltage relay senses and is calibrated for voltage at the 120 Volt level.
Transformer. The ratio of the 4KV voltage to the 120 volt level is 34.895:1. The Degraded Voltage relay senses and is calibrated for voltage at the 120 Volt level.
l-l l .,    . . . .            . . --                            _
l-l l


k                           o                                                                                         Attachment 2 f
k o
                          ,                      ,                                                                    to U-602613 y
f to U-602613 y
LS-94-013
LS-94-013
                                                                                                                          ^8 "
^8 PAGE 16 of 17 CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REV. 2 VOL C IDeptJDiv. E/EPED]
PAGE 16 of 17 CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REV. 2 VOL C                                                                                                                   .
IDeptJDiv. E/EPED]
The calibration limits are established by drawing E02-1 AP04 sheet 001 and in the CPS calibration procedure. They are used as inputs to this calculation. The calibration limits are 0.04 volts. They are taken from section M3b.2 and are added and subtracted from the relay set-point at the 120 volt level. The 4 KV level value is equal to the 120 volt value times the PT ratio (35*0.997).
The calibration limits are established by drawing E02-1 AP04 sheet 001 and in the CPS calibration procedure. They are used as inputs to this calculation. The calibration limits are 0.04 volts. They are taken from section M3b.2 and are added and subtracted from the relay set-point at the 120 volt level. The 4 KV level value is equal to the 120 volt value times the PT ratio (35*0.997).
mmmery of Emits                           PICK.UP                                                             DROP 0UT 4kVlevel                     120v level                             4kw level                       120v level nominal setpoint             3889                           111.45                                 3850                           110.33 Mn PICK-UP                 Max PICK UP                             Min DROP 0UT                           Max DROP 4UT 4ky level   120v level     4kw level         120v level             4ky level   120v level         4kw level   120v level calilwetion hmits     3888           111.41         3890                 111.48           3849           11029             3851           110.37 techspec limits       3876           111.08
mmmery of Emits PICK.UP DROP 0UT 4kVlevel 120v level 4kw level 120v level nominal setpoint 3889 111.45 3850 110.33 Mn PICK-UP Max PICK UP Min DROP 0UT Max DROP 4UT 4ky level 120v level 4kw level 120v level 4ky level 120v level 4kw level 120v level calilwetion hmits 3888 111.41 3890 111.48 3849 11029 3851 110.37 techspec limits 3876 111.08
(                                 The second level undervoltage relay minimum pick-up and minimum drop-out voltages, at l                                 4KV buses , which will be used by other calculations are 3870 volts and 3832 respectively.
(
The second level undervoltage relay minimum pick-up and minimum drop-out voltages, at l
4KV buses, which will be used by other calculations are 3870 volts and 3832 respectively.
l l
l l
l I
l I
i l
i l


J           '                                                                                              l Attachment 2 i'
J l
to U-602613 b-                                                               LS-94-013 Page 18 of 18             PAGE 17 of 17 CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REV. 2 VOL. C
i' to U-602613 b-LS-94-013 Page 18 of 18 PAGE 17 of 17 CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REV. 2 VOL. C
[ Dept./Div. E/EPED]
[ Dept./Div. E/EPED]
l l
l Reference 1 Westinghouse drawing EN005-6A REV 5, and GE data sheet 317A6131 REV. 2. The PT were all purchased per S&L form 1815-L. These documents are found in the purchase specifications 1
Reference 1   Westinghouse drawing EN005-6A REV 5, and GE data sheet 317A6131 REV. 2. The PT were all purchased per S&L form 1815-L . These documents are found in the purchase specifications             1 and vendor manuals for K-2801 and K-2968.
and vendor manuals for K-2801 and K-2968.
            . Reference 2   E02-1 AP12 sheets.ll R/W& 13 R/V.
. Reference 2 E02-1 AP12 sheets.ll R/W& 13 R/V.
Reference 3   ABB instruction IB 7.4.1.7-7 issue D
Reference 3 ABB instruction IB 7.4.1.7-7 issue D
            - Reference 4   ABB Descriptive Bulletin 41-233S September 1990 Reference 5   ABB Type Test Certificate Number RC-6004 Revision 0 dated j                             2/10/89.                                                                     l 1
- Reference 4 ABB Descriptive Bulletin 41-233S September 1990 Reference 5 ABB Type Test Certificate Number RC-6004 Revision 0 dated j
1 Reference 6   HP 3458A Multimeter Data Sheet dated May 1991 Reference 7   E02-1 AP12 SH I1 R/W, E02-1 AP99 SH 36 R/D, E02-1 AP99 SH 38 R/U E02-1 AP12 SH 13 R/V, E02-1 AP12 SH 15 R/T, and                       ,
2/10/89.
E02-1HP99 SH 107 R/L.
1 Reference 6 HP 3458A Multimeter Data Sheet dated May 1991 Reference 7 E02-1 AP12 SH I1 R/W, E02-1 AP99 SH 36 R/D, E02-1 AP99 SH 38 R/U E02-1 AP12 SH 13 R/V, E02-1 AP12 SH 15 R/T, and E02-1HP99 SH 107 R/L.
l Reference 8     E02-lHP99-SH 107R/L,103 R/H, & 102A R/H.
l Reference 8 E02-lHP99-SH 107R/L,103 R/H, & 102A R/H.
Reference 9   Westinghouse Electric Corporation Product bulletin 44-215 D WE A dated July 15,1976 for type PCO-60 Voltage transformers.
Reference 9 Westinghouse Electric Corporation Product bulletin 44-215 D WE A dated July 15,1976 for type PCO-60 Voltage transformers.
Reference 10 Engineering Standard CI 01.00 Instrument Setpoint Calculation Methodology REV 0                                                             1 1
Reference 10 Engineering Standard CI 01.00 Instrument Setpoint Calculation Methodology REV 0 1
Reference 11 Reg. Guide 1.105 INSTRUMENT SETPOINTS REV.1.
Reference 11 Reg. Guide 1.105 INSTRUMENT SETPOINTS REV.1.
l t
l t
I
I
                                                                  -}}
-r
,,.}}

Latest revision as of 22:49, 12 December 2024

Calcs for Functional Requirements for First & Second Level Undervoltage Relays at 4kV 1A1,1B1 & 1C1
ML20116C719
Person / Time
Site: Clinton Constellation icon.png
Issue date: 06/25/1996
From: Haumann A
ILLINOIS POWER CO.
To:
Shared Package
ML20116C590 List:
References
19-AN-19, 19-AN-19-R02, 19-AN-19-R2, U-602613, NUDOCS 9608010082
Download: ML20116C719 (17)


Text

,-

to U-602613 LS-94-013 Page1 of18 Qi l

l l

l l

l 19-AN-19 l

"Cales For Functional Requirement L

For 1st & 2nd Level Undervoltage Relays At 4 kV 1 A1, IB1, & IC1" l

l l

l l

i l

i 9608010082 960801 PDR ADOCK 05000461 p

PDR

[

t-to U-602613, LS-94-013 Page 2 of 18 i

l..

CALCULATION COVER SHEET SHEET 1 OF

/7 TITLE /DESCRII' TION:

DEPT /DIV CALCULATION NO.

E/EPED 19 AN-19 l

CALCS FOR FUNCTIONAL REQUIREMENTS FOR

)

l 1st & 2nd LEVEL UNDERVOLTAGE RELAYS AT QUAUTY SYSTEM CODE TOPIC BLDO/ELEV/ AREA j

4kV 1 A1,181, & 1C1 RELATED (or NA)

(or NA) l (Q or N) l O

AP E90 N/A l

l

\\

APPROVALS - NAME/ SIGNATURE /DATE l

READY FOR INCORPORATION:

l CORP PREPARING REVISION VOLUME PREPARED BY Al Haumann THIS V.

YES d

NO N/A 2

C

$ 1m if (ld )H DATE SIGNATURE CONFIRMATION REQUIRED MICROFICHE ATTACHED:

NO PAGE NO(s)

YES d

NO U YES CHECKED BY PR M VOL. INCORP. ASSGNMNT.

Engineering 1

DATE siaNAtuRE MOD.

AP-28 ECN CR l

i COMMENTS:

MWR l

W $g(,s REVIEWED BY THIS VOLUME IS TO MAKE MINOR EDITORIAL CHANGES WHICH kgJg 'io (D,+

s CLARIFY THE CALCULATION

\\j SiONATURE j

l i

l READY FOR INCORPORATION:

l CORP PREPARING REVISION VOLUME l

PREPARED BY THIS REV.

YES NO N/A PRwr DATE CONFIRMATION REQUIRED MICROFICHE ATTACHED:

SIGNAME l

lYES l l NO PAGE NO(s)

YES NO CHECKED BY PR Nr VOL. INCORP. ASSGNMNT.

[ ATE SiONATURE COMMENTS:

MWR REVIEWED BY PRINT

?

DATE SIGNATURE l

w T

READY FOR INCORPORATION:

CORP PREPARING REVISION VOLUME 7

u.,

PREPARED BY -

THis REY.

YES NO N/A Z

PRINT

/ /

DATE sioNATuRE CONFIRM ATION REQUIRED MICROFICHE ATTACHED:

l l YES NO PAGE NO(s)

YES NO CHECKED BY -

PRINT VOL. INCORP. ASSGNMNT.

/ /

DATE stoNATURE MOD.

ECN CR COMMENTS:

MWR

(

REVIEWED BY nwr I I DATE SIGNATURE i

i

l to U-602613 LS-94-013 l

~'

Page 3 of 18 REVISION HISTORY Page 2 l

i Dept./Div. E/EPED Calc. # lH:AN-19 Revision 2 Volume (if applicable)

C i

Objective: Ihe.Surpose of this volume Calculation is to make minor _aditorial changes to clarify _the_ calculation __

l sn_that.it is clearer _for_those_ reviewers and. auditors _who_are_not fam!!iar_with the degraded _ Voltage issuesllor_the_ set.pointanethodology 1

l Reason: Reviews.hyEuclear_Assassment_ indicated that_there were areas of the_calculatioIL1 hat _were unclear or required _Ininor_aditoriaLcorrections. This_yolume incorporates _theitcomments._No numericalnor_lechntcatchanges to volume Bare made by this volume.

List of Affected Pages: pages 5 through 8 of the base calculation. This.yolumaJiupersedes_vnlume_B

)

Revision Volume (if applicable) l l

Objective:

i l

l Reason:

l l

l List of Affected Pages:

Revision Volume (if applicable) l l

Objective:

l Reason:

List of Affected Pages:

i NF-303 (10/95)

Attachm nt 2 i

~

to U-602613 LS-94-013 hAGE 3 !f 17 CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REV. 2 VOL. C

[ Dept./Div. E/EPED]

l i

TABLE OF CONTENTS PAGE COVER SHEET 1

REVISION HISTORY 2

TABLE OF CONTENTS 3

PURPOSE 4

DISCUSSION 4

INPUTS 5

ASSUMPTIONS 8

METHODOLOGY 8

EVALUATION 13 REFERENCE LIST 17 ATTACHMENTS

~ Attachment 1 Probability table 1page ABB instruction IB 7.4.1.7-7 issue D 12 pages ABB Descriptive Bulletin 41-233S September 2 pages 1990 ABB Type Test Certificate Number RC-6004 6 pages Revision 0 dated 2/10/89.

HP 3458A Multimeter Data Sheet dated May 7 pages 1991 & Test and Measurement Catalog 1994.

Copies of selected pages Westinghouse Electric Corporation Product 2 pages bulletin 44-215 D WE A dated July 15,1976 for type PCO-60 Voltage transformers i

1 i

Attachmsnt 2 to U-602613 LS-94-013 P g fgof 1g g7 4

CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REV. 2 VOL C

[DeptJDiv. E/EPED]

PURPOSE

'The purpose of this Calculation is To evaluate the use of an ABB 27N undervoltage relay in the Second Level Under-Voltage (also called degraded voltage) protection scheme.

Determine the relay trip (drop-out) and reset (pick-up) bands based on the loop accuracy methods described in CI-01.00 Instmment Set-point Calculation Methodology (Reference 10).

The analytical limits (AL) for the second level under-voltage relay pick-up are as follows:

1. The maximum pick-up voltage is equal the minimum 4KV ESF bus voltage under steady-state LOCA loading with the off-site voltage at the minimum expected
value,
2. The minimum pick-up voltage is equal to the minimum 4KV ESF bus voltage required to start and run the LOCA required equipment.

The allowable value (AV) will also be established by this volume and this number will be used in the Tech Spec revision which is being prepared to support the new relay settings.

DISCUSSION The second level under voltage relay scheme has a two fold function. It must ensure that there is adequate voltage following the LOCA block start initiation for the ESF required equipment to start and mn. It must also prevent the ESF buses from transferring to the on site source if there is adequate voltage from the o'f-site source to operate the ESF equipment. Therefore the second level under voltage relay pick-up voltage (accounting for the various instrumentation errors) must fall between these values.

In addition, we want to prevent spurious transferring of the ESF buses to the onsite source and allow for minor changes to the off site grid with out impacting the degraded voltage relay settings. We have therefore based on engineering judgment chosen (for LER avoidance) to limit the maximum relay pick-up to 0.75% below the 4160 volt bus 1 Al voltage found in Calculation 19-AQ-02 Rev. 3 attachment 10.2. This setting will provide a degree of margin below the minimum expected 4KV Bus voltage under steady state LOCA conditions with the 345 Kv switch-yard at the minimum expected value.

Calculation 19-AQ-02 Rev. 3 Attachment 10.2 lists the steady state minimum voltage at the Bus l Al as 3938 volts. 100%-0.75% of 3938 than equals 3908 volts. The minimum reset point will be the minimum voltage at the 4KV bus which will ensure that all the ESF equipment required for LOCA will start and run. The minimum voltage required by the ESF equipment will be taken from 19-AQ-02 Rev. 3 volume P Attachment 8.1 (3870 volts). The nominal second level under-voltage relay pick-up point has therefore been chosen to be mid way between the maximum and minimum reset-points or 3889. We will call this nominal value NTSP. This calculation will assure that there is adequate margin for NTSP between the maximum and minimum allowable values when the total relay loop error is considered.

to U-602613 LS-94-013 Page 6 of 18 PAGE 5 of 17 CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REV. 2 VOL. C l

[DeptJDiv. E/EPED]

INPUTS 11.

The relays utilized in the Second Level Under-Voltage schen.e will be ABB type 2' N catalog number 41 IT6375-HF(or 410T6375-HF which has the same characteristics). The relay pickup range is from 70 to 120 volts, the dropout range is 70% to 99%, the pickup time delay is instantaneous. The drop out time delay will be set at minimum (= 0.1 sec) The relay requires a 125 volt nominal DC source to operate. The relay will include the harmonic distortion filter. The published relay tolerances from Reference 3,4 and 5 EXPRESSED AS A l

PERCENT OF SETTING are as follows:

a)

Pickup and dropout setting repeatability with respect to temperature with a constant control voltage and the relay operating in an environment where the ambient temperature could vary between +10 to +40 C is 0.4 %. W e' will call this 26 value ATE.

b)

Pickup and dropout setting repeatability at a constant temperature and constant control voltage is 0.1%. We will call this 2S value VA.

l c)

Pickup and dropout setting, repeatability over " allowable" de control power range is 10.1%. The allowable de control power range for a 125 volt nominal relay is 100 to 140 V DC. The Tech Spec. requires that when AC power is available to supply the battery charger the DC buses must l

operate between 121 and 139 volts. The published DC supply error is l

considered linear over the operating range per Reference 10, Engineering l

standard Cl 01.00. Therefore, the published error of+0.1% can be divided by 40 volt allowable range. In addition, data in the ABB type test Certificate Reference 5 shows that this is conservatL e. ~he variation then l

equals *0.0025%/ volt.

We will call this 26 error PSE ad consider it to l

be +0.045% for our operating range.

d)

The radiation and humidity effects are considered negligible because the relays are not subjected to an environment with humidity or radiation above normal atmospheric conditions.

e)

The 27N relay has been subjected to 6g ZPA either axis biaxial broad band multifrequency vibration with out malfunction or damage per ANSI /IEE C37.98 (reference 4). Therefore there is no seismic impact to the relay accuracy.

f)

ABB tests indicate that there is no RFI interference effect associated with the relay. Therefore it is not considered a factor in this calculation (Reference 5).

to U-602613 LS-94-013 Page 7 of 18 PAGE 6 of 17 j

CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REV. 2 VOL C

[ Dept./Div. E/EPEDj.

I2.

The relay calibration setup will consist of a low noise variable AC power supply, the ABB 27N relay and a Hewlett Packard Model HP3458A Digital Multimeter.

HP3458A

\\

Varable AC Multimeter 3

Power supply e

ABB 27 N Relay Relay test set-up figure 1 The HP 3458A Specification and accuracy from Reference 6 are as follows:

a)

Minimum resolution at 100 volt range is 10 micro volts b)

The Accuracy coefficient in %/ degree C is 0.001% of reading plus 0.0001% of range (with the meter set on the 100V range). We will call this 36 value C1 ATE c)

The AC accuracy with the meter set on the 100 V range is (a 36 value) 0.02% of reading plus 0.004% of range and will be called C1 VA.

d)

The meter is calibrated using a 10 volt DC test cell traceable to US NIST with an added error of 2 ppm or 0.0002%. We will call this 36 value ClSTD.

i.

i i,

to U-602613 L

LS-94-013 L*

Page 8 of 18 PAGE 7 of 17 CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REY. 2 VOL. C

[ Dept./Div. E/EPED]

13 _

The detection loop consists of the 4KV bus which we wish to measure, a potential transformer (PT) to convert 4KV to 120 volts and the ABB 27N relay.

The pts for DIV. I & II are Westinghouse PC-60 and, for DIV. III, GE type JVM-3. Both PT models have a ratio of 4200 - 120 volts and are class lE. They conform to ANSI C57.13-1968 metering accuracy class for.03 class standard burdens W, X, M, & Y. The pts were purchased to Westinghouse drawing l

EN005, and GE data sheet 317A6131, and S&L form 1815-L (Reference 1). The i

PT burden was established using E02-1 AP12 SH I1 R/W, E02-1 AP99 SH 36 l

R/D, E02-1 AP99 SH 38 R/U E02-1 AP12 SH 13 R/V, E02-1 AP12 SH I5 R/T, and E02-lHP99 SH 107 R/L (Reference 7), and the load data from the vendor manuals (Reference 1). The PT burden consists of a CV2 relay, the 27N relay, a voltage transducer, a lamp and a voltmeter (Note: the EMTs shown on E02-1 AP12 SH 13 R/V are being disconnected from the pts by mods AP-027,28,

&29). The total burden on the PT is 7.5VA with a possible change in burden l

(caused by switching the voltmeter between phases) of 1 VA. From the j

performance curve found in reference 9, we can see that for a change in burden of 12.5 VA the turns ratio correction changes 0.1%. Therefore, if the actual change is i VA the change in PT turns ratio would be.008% of rating. The curve also shows that the PT ratio correction factor should be.997.

14.

Two relays will be installed in Div. I & II (one between phase AB and one between phase BC). The relay trip functions are wired in series so that both j

relays must trip in order for the protective action to be initiated. Only one relay l

must reset for the timer to reset, preventing transferring ofload to the diesel.

l Reference E02-1 AP12 sheets 11 & 13 (Reference 7).

15.

Two relays will replace the present single three phase relay in Div. III. The new single phase relays will monitor phase AB and BC. The trip contacts are wired in series. All the elements must sense a degraded voltage for the protective function l

to be initiated. Only one relay must reset for the timer to reset, preventing transferring ofload to the diesel. Reference E02-lHP99-sheets 107,103, & 102A l

(Reference 8).

i l

l' l -

b Attachmsnt 2 l.

to U-602613 E,.

LS-94-013 Page 9 of 18 PAGE 8 of 17 CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REV. 2 VOL. C

[DeptJDiv. E/EPED]

ASSUMPTIONS i

l l

Al.

The accuracy's published by the instrument manufactures are considered as a 95% probability value, equal to two standard deviations (2a). This assumption does not require verification based on engineering judgment i

and direction given in Engineering Standard CI 01.00 Instrument Set-point Calculation Methodology (Reference 10).

A2 All accuracy data is considered to be a normal distribution.

l A3 The ABB 27N relay drift for 6 months is assumed to be equal to relay accuracy of l

.1%. For an 18 month suiveillance period the drift error (VD) is equal to the j

following:

r i

VD:=

E0.1 VD=0.1732 % Error 26 l

3 6 This assumption does not require verification based on engmeenng j

judgment and direction given in Engineering Standard CI 01.00 Instrument Set-point Calculation Methodology (Reference 10)

METHODOLOGY M. I.

The accuracy for the ABB27N relay (A27N) will be calculated by the square root l

of the sum of the squares method.

M.2 The nominal relay pick-up point will be calculated by taking the nominal relay l

pick-up voltage at the 4KV bus and reflecting it to the low voltage side of the PT Potential transformer primary ratio correction low side voltage voltage 3889 35 0.997 111.4486 Table 1 to U-602613 LS-94-013 Page 10 of 18 PAGE 9 of 17 CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REV. 2 VOL C

[DeptJDiv. E/EPED]

M3 The loop calibration error will be calculated as follows:

a) First the calibration instrument error Cl must be determined a.D The HP3485A accuracy error CIVA from the inputs above at 111 A4V can be is 111.44.0002 + 100 00004.100 = 0.0236% error 111.44 a.2) The temperature error contribution Cl ATE can be expressed as follows, noting that the Calibration lab temperature is kept at 72' F 2F or within 1.l*C. The temperature of the test instrument can be read directly by the HP3485A and the requirement that the test instrument be calibrated and used at 72* F

  • 2'F will be controlled by the relay calibration procedure. From the input data for the temperature error would then be expressed as 1.1 "

-100 - 0.0012

% error

+

t11.44 a.3) The calibration instrument error Cl then becomes Cl :=dCIVA + C1 EAT 2

2 C1 =0.0236

% ERROR b) The next step is the calibration of the relay using the set-up shown above in figure 1. The calibration loop error (CL) is determined as follows:

b.1) Based on conversation with the Waterford plants, the ABB 27N relay can be set to a resolution of.005 volts AC. This will be considered the calibration resolution for the calibration. Therefore the resolution error R j

will be determined as follows:

R :=

-100-R = 0.0045

% ERROR 111.44

I to U-602613 LS-94-013 Page 11 of 18 PAGE 10 of 17 i

CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REV. 2 VOL. C (DeptJDiv. E/EPED]

b.2) The new ABB 27N relay calibration procedure will allow for an acceptance band of*0.04 volts. Therefore the calibration as-left tolerance error (ALT) will be determined as follows:

ALT :=

-100 ALT = 0.0359

% ERROR 111.44 b.3) The calibration instrument error Cl is taken from a) above b.4) the calibration loop error than becomes ff LT l' A I f1 8 fCI l' I

+ ! )l + l13 )

CL := 2 J I CL -0.0288

% ERROR ii 3 i i

This is considered to be 25 c) The next step is to determine the channel instrument accuracy (AI). This will take into consideration the various errors associated with operating temperature, DC voltage etc. From the inputs section above the errors are restated and the instrument accuracy determined:

VA :=.1 ATE := A PSE :=.045

% VD =0.1732 ff I A! := 2. j

VA *

+ lATE 3 2i 2 ;l +.

l + 1 l

f IPSE)2 IVD3 2 AI -0 4495 (i 2;

'l 2;

'2; i

This is considered to be 25 I

i

i 1'.,

to U-602613 LS-94-013 l

Page 12 of 18 PAGE 11 of 17 CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REV. 2 VOL C

[DeptJDiv. E/EPED]

l, d) The loop accuracy AL can now be determined the inputs are as follows:

d.1) From b) above the calibration loop error CL =.028 %

d.2) From c) above the channel instrument error AI =.4495 %

d.3) From Input I3 above the PT error or EPT==.008%

fI 13:

2

I

+{

l + : EPfl2 C

f AL := h 2 ;

AL = 0.2252 qi i j i2j This is a 16 value M.4 -Illinois Power uses the GE methodology (Engineering Standard CI 01.00 - Reference #

10) for determining critical set points based on instrument errors. This methodology is statistically based. The desired probability for relay actuation is 95% (per Reg. Guide 1.105 -Reference # 11). In order to determine the 95% probability of either 2 relays actuating together or 1 of 2 relays resetting, the table Attachment I was set up. The table was established by plotting the probability distribution that one relay would actuate assuming a normal distribution curve (see Assumption # A2). The equation for that plot was:

1 5

f(x) = Er

  • e 2 The probability that two will actuate together was determined by multiplying the probability of each of them together and plotting that curve accordingly. In this case that meant squaring the probability of one relay (since the probability for both relays is the same). The point on the Table in attachment I which equaled.95 was then found. This came out to be 1.96.

To determine the same o multiplier for when only one of the two relays needed to change

~

state, the probability that the relays would fail to actuate was considered. To do this, I minus the probability squared was tabulated (attachment 1). From this table the value for 95% confidence was found. This corresponds to a value of.76.

1 Therefore, the 1.96 Sis to be used for a 95% probability that two relays will actuate together and 0.76 6 that at least one of the two will reset.

t.

I l

1 to U-602613 LS-94-013

~.

Page 13 of 18 PAGE 12 of 17 CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REV. 2 VOL C

[ Dept./Div. E/EPED]

M.4a Two 27N relay contacts (in series) are required to initiate the time delay relay and 1

the subsequent protective action. We have, therefore, determined that for a 1.96 S deviation about the set point the relay loop will activate with 95% confidence level. We will call this Ado. It can be expressed as:

Ado := 1.96 AL Ado = 0.4415 % of setting M.4b Only one of the two 27N relay contacts (in series) are required to reset the time delay relay and subsequently prevent the buses from transferring to the diesels.

We have, therefore, determined that for a.76 6 deviation about the reset point the relay loop will activate with 95% confidence level. We will call this Apu. It can be expressed Apu :=.76. AL Apu = 0.1712 % ofsetting i

l M5 The loop Allowable error will be calculated as follows:

a) The calibration loop error will be the same as above ffALT32 y,2 f I CL := 2-

'l

+l l + l C1 :*

CL -0.0288

% ERROR L3J tj (3i This is considered to be 2S b) The next step is to determine the channel instrument allowable accuracy with out the drift error (AV). This will take into consideration the various errors associated with operating temperature, DC voltage etc. From the inputs section above the errors are restated and the instrument accuracy detennined:

VA :=.1 ATE =.4 PSE =.045 A

ATE.g AV = 0 4148 %

AV = 2

+

di 2/

( 2/

( 2/

l*

h.

to U-602613 l(,

LS-94-013 Page 14 of 18 PAGE 13 of 17 l

CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REV. 2 VOL. C l_

[DeptJDiv. E/EPEDj This is considered to be 26 c) The loop allowable accuracy ALV can now be determined the inputs are as follows:

l d.1) From b) above the calibration loop error CL =.028 %

d.2) From c) above the channel instrument error AV =.4148 %

l d.3) From Input I3 above the PT error or EPT=.008%

2 ICL AV32 32 EPT ALV:=

l - + -

I+ -

ALV = 0.2379 3(2 2 3 2

3 This is a 16 value M.6 Using the same methodoligy as above (Engineering Standard CI 01.00 - Reference # 10) for determining critical set points based on instmment errors, the probability that at least one of the two relays will reset is 0.76 6.

We have, therefore, determined that for a.76 6 deviation about the reset point the relay loop will activate with 95% confidence level. We will call the allowable value AVpu. It can be expressed as AVpu :=.76 ALV AVpu =0.158 % of setting EVALUATION The results can now be represented by a graph similar to the following:

f l

l i

l l

1 a

to U-602613 e-LS-94-013 Page 15 of 18 PAGE 14 of 17 CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REY. 2 VOL C

[DeptJDiv. E/EPEDj minimum off-site REAY ERROR RICION relay pick-up setting RELAYIRROR RECION 3870 volts probability In other words we will show that by setting the degraded voltage relay pick-up at 3889 the totalloop error will not cause (with a 95% probability) the relay to pick up below 3870 nor above the minimum off-site voltage as seen by the 4KV ESF buses. This can be represented by the following expressions:

We will call the upper limit of the permissible relay pick-up settings PUU and the j

lower limit PUL. The calculation of these values is l

PUU := 3908-l 3908 A "l P

PUU =39013104 Volts at the 4 KVlevel i

100j PUU PUU120 :=

PUU120 = 111.8014 Volts at the 120Vlevel

(.997 35)

PUL := 3870 + 3270. ^E" PUL = 3876.6245 Volts at the 4 KVlevel 100 PUL120 :=

PUL120 = 111.094 Volts at the 120Vlevel

(.997 35) 4 PUU>3889)PUL 3901.3104 > 3889 > 3876.6245 4

k to U-602613 l.

LS-94-013 Page 16 of 18 PAGE 15 of 17 CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REV. 2 VOL. C

[DeptJDiv. E/EPED)

The lower limit of the Degraded voltage relay is dependent on the minimum voltage required to keep ESF equipment running. From calculation 19-AQ-02 we can show that the ESF equipment will run at 3832 volts. We will call this limit l

DOL. There is no upper limit for the drop-out except the physical restraints of the l

relay which will allow it to pick up in the range described above. The drop out can be adjusted between 70% and 99 % of the pick-up. We want to provide the maximum voltage to our equipment and still keep the relay pick-up as described above. Therefore we have chosen to set the drop-out at 99% of the pick-up or 3850 volts.

DOL:=3832+ 3832 DOL = 3848.9166 Volts at the 4 KV level 100 l

DOL l,

DOL 120.=

DOL 120= 110.2999 Volts at the 120V level l

(.99735)

DOL > 3832 3850>3848.9166 > 3832 L

o l

We will call the upper lower limit of the allowable relay (Tech Spec) pick-up settings PULV. The calculation of these values is l

PULV:= 3870+ 3870AVpu PULV = 3876.1153 Volts at the 4 KVlevel 100 PULV l

PULV 120:

PULV 120= 111.0794 Volts at the 120Vlevel

(.99735)

The critical requirement, from a plant safety standpoint, is that all the equipment required l

to support the LOCA block start receive sufficient voltage to start and run.- Therefore the critical degraded voltage relay parameter is that the relay must reset at or above 3870

- volts. This is equivalent to the relay minimum reset accounting for the appropriate relay

. errors.

The following table listing settings and analytical limits will be used as inputs for a Tech Spec. change and the procedure for calibration of the relays. The voltage at the 120 volt

L level reflects the required voltage at the.4KV bus as scaled (transformed) by the Potential l

Transformer. The ratio of the 4KV voltage to the 120 volt level is 34.895:1. The Degraded Voltage relay senses and is calibrated for voltage at the 120 Volt level.

l-l l

k o

f to U-602613 y

LS-94-013

^8 PAGE 16 of 17 CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REV. 2 VOL C IDeptJDiv. E/EPED]

The calibration limits are established by drawing E02-1 AP04 sheet 001 and in the CPS calibration procedure. They are used as inputs to this calculation. The calibration limits are 0.04 volts. They are taken from section M3b.2 and are added and subtracted from the relay set-point at the 120 volt level. The 4 KV level value is equal to the 120 volt value times the PT ratio (35*0.997).

mmmery of Emits PICK.UP DROP 0UT 4kVlevel 120v level 4kw level 120v level nominal setpoint 3889 111.45 3850 110.33 Mn PICK-UP Max PICK UP Min DROP 0UT Max DROP 4UT 4ky level 120v level 4kw level 120v level 4ky level 120v level 4kw level 120v level calilwetion hmits 3888 111.41 3890 111.48 3849 11029 3851 110.37 techspec limits 3876 111.08

(

The second level undervoltage relay minimum pick-up and minimum drop-out voltages, at l

4KV buses, which will be used by other calculations are 3870 volts and 3832 respectively.

l l

l I

i l

J l

i' to U-602613 b-LS-94-013 Page 18 of 18 PAGE 17 of 17 CALCULATION 19-AN-19 REV. 2 VOL. C

[ Dept./Div. E/EPED]

l Reference 1 Westinghouse drawing EN005-6A REV 5, and GE data sheet 317A6131 REV. 2. The PT were all purchased per S&L form 1815-L. These documents are found in the purchase specifications 1

and vendor manuals for K-2801 and K-2968.

. Reference 2 E02-1 AP12 sheets.ll R/W& 13 R/V.

Reference 3 ABB instruction IB 7.4.1.7-7 issue D

- Reference 4 ABB Descriptive Bulletin 41-233S September 1990 Reference 5 ABB Type Test Certificate Number RC-6004 Revision 0 dated j

2/10/89.

1 Reference 6 HP 3458A Multimeter Data Sheet dated May 1991 Reference 7 E02-1 AP12 SH I1 R/W, E02-1 AP99 SH 36 R/D, E02-1 AP99 SH 38 R/U E02-1 AP12 SH 13 R/V, E02-1 AP12 SH 15 R/T, and E02-1HP99 SH 107 R/L.

l Reference 8 E02-lHP99-SH 107R/L,103 R/H, & 102A R/H.

Reference 9 Westinghouse Electric Corporation Product bulletin 44-215 D WE A dated July 15,1976 for type PCO-60 Voltage transformers.

Reference 10 Engineering Standard CI 01.00 Instrument Setpoint Calculation Methodology REV 0 1

Reference 11 Reg. Guide 1.105 INSTRUMENT SETPOINTS REV.1.

l t

I

-r

,,.