ML17159A746: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
 
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
 
(7 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 5: Line 5:
| author name = Monatesti S
| author name = Monatesti S
| author affiliation = - No Known Affiliation
| author affiliation = - No Known Affiliation
| addressee name = Hawkens E R
| addressee name = Hawkens E
| addressee affiliation = NRC/ASLBP
| addressee affiliation = NRC/ASLBP
| docket = 05000387, 05000388, 07200028
| docket = 05000387, 05000388, 07200028
Line 14: Line 14:
| page count = 3
| page count = 3
}}
}}
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:From:              smonatesti@verizon.net To:                smonatesti@verizon.net; Bollwerk, Paul; Arnold, Gary; william.forehlich@nrc.gov; Docket, Hearing; beth.mizun@nrc.gov; cathy.scott@nrc.gov; jeremy.wachutaka@nrc.gov; david.lewis@pillsburylaw.com; Speiser, Herald; OCAAMAIL Resource; Alan.wase@nrc.gov; Mizuno, Beth; Newell, Brian; Sola, Clara; Julian, Emile; Rov Hawkins; OGCMailCenter.Resources@nrc.gov; OCAAMAIL.Resources@nrc.gov Cc:                "PatriciaPerluke"; "AmyElliott"; "BrianBusher"; "RobertE.Brown"; "Rev.ChadA.Hebrink"; "CynthiaLombard";
                    "DaveSuperdock"; "JamieDavis"; "RobertDeRonde"; "DaveAllard"; Tifft, Doug; "DavidSimpson"; "TedJacobsen";
                    "ErinSchloyer"; "GeneTrowbridge"; "JamesGresham"; "HeidiBiggs"; "JenniferSiani";
                    "CatherinStuccioMentrinkoski"; "KyleCarey"; "KevinWhite"; "LingardKnutson"; "KellyPetock"; "EricEpstein";
                    "LoraZimmerman"; "KevinMagerr"; "MikeCaverly"; "NateSnavely"; "OliviaMowery"; "PaulaBallaron"; "PatNaugle";
                    "BarbaraDeRonde"; "RichJanati"; "R.K.Temple"; "RobertM.Paley"; "RoccoR.Sgarro"; "GregRuppert";
                    "ShawnBeeler"; "RyanSearch"; "SteveMcDougal"; "SabatiniMonatesti"; "SteveMars"; "TondaLewis"; "TomPopko";
                    "TomShervinskie"; "VinceKelly"; "WalterHoltsmaster"; "WilburDennis"; "LarryWinker"; Bill Davenport; citydesk@citizensvoice.com; David Fallk; Erik_helbing_esq@yahoo.com; jsoprano@civitasmedia.com; marande07@aol.com; Michael Lester; mmizenko@CIVITASMEDIA.COM; susan.schwartz@pressenterprise.net; WILLIAM LEVINSON
==Subject:==
[External_Sender] RE: Nuclear Waste Storage Concern SSES 1 and 2 Date:              Tuesday, June 06, 2017 8:31:14 PM Attachments:        NRC open letter NOC 06062017.pdf
==Dear Mr. Hawkens:==
I apologize, I made a transcription error in my open letter, please note:
page 2 - calculated estimate on nuclear waste storage, 300,000 metric tons plus would apply to CONUS. And on page 7 - duplicate email addresses were inadvertently introduced during a copy and paste process. I attached a Notice of Correction document with this email.
: Regards, Sabatini Monatesti From: smonatesti@verizon.net [mailto:smonatesti@verizon.net]
Sent: Monday, June 05, 2017 12:29 AM To: 'AJ ASLBP 2'; 'AJ ASLBP 3'; 'Chairman AJ ASLBP'; 'NRC Office of Secretary'; 'Office of General Counsel 1'; 'Office of General Counsel 2';
'Office of General Counsel 3'; 'PWSP LLP'; 'Rulemakings Adjudications Staff'; 'US NRC'; 'Alan Wase'; 'Beth Mizuno'; 'Brian Newell'; 'Clara Sola';
'Emile Julian'; 'IMCEAIN'; 'Mail Center'; 'OCA Mail' Cc: 'ajlaquin@verizon.net (Patricia Perluke) ';
'Amy.H.Elliott@usace.army.mil (Amy Elliott) '; 'bbusher@pa.gov (Brian Busher) '; 'bob.brown@ge.com (Robert E. Brown) '; 'chebrink@localnet.com (Rev. Chad A. Hebrink) '; 'clombard@pa.metrocast.net (Cynthia Lombard) ';
'dasuper@verizon.net (Dave Superdock) '; 'davis.jamie@epamail.epa.gov (Jamie Davis)'; 'derddafdl@verizon.net (Robert DeRonde) '; 'djallard@pa.gov (Dave Allard)'; 'Doug.Tifft@nrc.gov (Doug Tifft) '; 'dsimpson@bloomu.edu (David Simpson) '; 'ecology3@gmail.com (Ted Jacobsen) '; 'eschloyer@yahoo.com (Erin Schloyer) '; 'etrowbridg@pa.gov (Gene Trowbridge)';
'greshaja@westinghouse.com (James Gresham) '; 'hbiggs@pa.gov (Heidi Biggs)
'; 'Jennifer_Siani@fws.gov (Jennifer Siani) '; 'kaysm@verizon.net (Catherin Stuccio Mentrinkoski) '; 'kcarey960@gmail.com (Kyle Carey)';
'kevwhite@pa.gov (Kevin White) '; 'knutson.lingard@epa.gov (Lingard Knutson)
'; 'kpetock@curtisswright.com (Kelly Petock) '; 'lechambon@comcast.net (Eric Epstein) '; 'Lora_Zimmerman@fws.gov (Lora Zimmerman) ';
'Magerr.Kevin@epamail.epa.gov (Kevin Magerr) '; 'mjcaverly@pplweb.com (Mike Caverly) '; 'nate@nathansnavely.com (Nate Snavely) '; 'omowery@pa.gov (Olivia Mowery) '; 'pballaron@srbc.net (Paula Ballaron) '; 'pnaugle@srbc.net
(Pat Naugle) '; 'psychndesign@verison.net (Barbara DeRonde) ';
'rjanati@pa.gov (Rich Janati) '; 'RKTemple@cpsenergy.com (R.K. Temple) ';
'rmpaley@pplweb.com (Robert M. Paley) '; 'rrsgarro@pplweb.com (Rocco R.
Sgarro) '; 'ruppert125@aol.com (Greg Ruppert) '; 'sbeeler@pa.gov (Shawn Beeler) '; 'signs@bellessigns.com (Ryan Search) '; 'smcdougal@pa.gov (Steve McDougal) '; 'smonatesti@verizonl.net (Sabatini Monatesti) ';
'steve_mars@fws.gov (Steve Mars) '; 'tolewis@pa.gov (Tonda Lewis) ';
'TomPopko@hotmail.com (Tom Popko) '; 'tshervinsk@pa.gov (Tom Shervinskie) ';
'vincekelly@gmail.com (Vince Kelly) '; 'wholtsmast@pa.gov (Walter Holtsmaster) '; 'wilburdennisjr@hotmail.com (Wilbur Dennis, Jr.) ';
'winker@pa.gov (Larry Winker) '; Bill Davenport (wdd@pa.metrocast.net);
citydesk@citizensvoice.com; David Fallk; 'Erik Helbing';
jsoprano@civitasmedia.com; marande07@aol.com; Michael Lester; mmizenko@CIVITASMEDIA.COM; susan.schwartz@pressenterprise.net; WILLIAM LEVINSON
==Subject:==
Nuclear Waste Storage Concern SSES 1 and 2 Importance: High
==Dear Mr. Hawkens:==
Mr. Davenport and I are concerned for our communities and our citizens. We believe the NRC is putting constituents at risk. The issues we introduced October 2016 continue today, they have not gone away. We need your help to reconcile and clarify each one through open hearings. We respectfully request these hearings to be held in the ten-mile Plume Exposure Zone or the fifty-mile Ingestion Pathway Zone of SSES 1 and 2.
We applaud President Trump's budget. We understand he included funding for Yucca Mountain nuclear waste repository and plans to use these funds for the management of nuclear waste storage. Talen Energy 2018 plans called for expanding nuclear waste storage at SSES 1 and 2. Please ensure that Yucca Mountain nuclear waste repository becomes a reality, and that SSES 1 and 2 do not become a waste dump.
: Regards, Sabatini Monatesti & Bill Davenport
Notice of Correction - June 4, 2017 Open Letter June 6, 2017
==Reference:==
Nuclear Waste Storage & Docket ID NRC-2016-0187 Docket Nos. 50-387, 50-388 & 72-28-LT-2 In the matter of:
Susquehanna Nuclear LLC Susquehanna Steam Electric Station, Units 1 and 2 Open Letter, Posted June 2017, Corrections To:      E. Roy Hawkens Chief Administrative Judge ASLBP No. 16-949-01-LT-BD01 Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D. C. 20555-0001`
Cc:      NRC Representatives, PA Representatives (State and Federal), NRC Oversight committees, Press Enterprise Editor, Citizen Voice Editor, Area Residents (NRC Hearing - Berwick HS Pre 2016)
Correction page 2, last paragraph: The sentence should read: We estimate the waste storage space requirements for SESS 1 and 2, plus the 100 or more additional CONUS sites to be about 300,000 metric tons of waste. Empire State Building about 365,000 metric tons NRC Representative, Dan Schroeder, April 27, 2016, reported that the SSES waste storage containers weigh tons, i.e., 61 rods per container, about 660 pounds per rod which equals 40,260 pounds per container or about 20 tons. Talen Energy planned to install in 2018, on a 22,000 square foot space, an additional 55 new waste storage units equaling a storage capacity of about 1,100 tons. Talen estimated, April 2016, they had between 1,800 and 2,000 tons of nuclear waste storage on site. Hence, total estimate given plan execution, about 3,000 metric tons of waste storage at SSES 1 and 2 locations. It is reported that CONUS has over 100 plants across the US, hence the estimate of over 300,000 metric tons of waste distributed throughout the US, not including military and miscellaneous waste.
According to an Empire State Building spokesperson and independent researcher John Tauranac, the Empire state Building 1
weighs 365,000 tons. In his 1995 book The Empire State Building: The Making of a Landmark, Tauranac says the 365,000 ton figure came from original architect Richmond Shreve.
New York Times, Diane Cardwell, Feb. 18, 2017, presents all of us with an additional concern, she said, But a remarkable confluence of events is bringing that nuclear age to an end, capped in recent days by Toshibas decision to take a $6 2
billion loss and pull Westinghouse, its American nuclear power subsidiary, out of the construction business. Does this mean the citizen will end up with owning the nuclear waste and the fallout from potential bankruptcies?
Correction page 7, email addresses: Due to copy and paste error some email address were presented in duplicate.
: Regards, Sabatini Monatesti 1
http://stupidquestionarchives.blogspot.com/2008/03/empire-state-building-weight.html 2
https://www.nytimes.com/2017/02/18/business/energy-environment/nuclear-power-westinghouse-toshiba.html?_r=0}}

Latest revision as of 02:15, 30 October 2019

Correction Notice for 6-5-17 Comment of Sabatini Monatesti and Bill Davenport Regarding Susquehanna License Transfer
ML17159A746
Person / Time
Site: Susquehanna  Talen Energy icon.png
Issue date: 06/06/2017
From: Monatesti S
- No Known Affiliation
To: Hawkens E
Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
SECY/RAS
References
50-387-LT-2, 50-388-LT-2, 72-28-LT-2, License Transfer
Download: ML17159A746 (3)


Text

From: smonatesti@verizon.net To: smonatesti@verizon.net; Bollwerk, Paul; Arnold, Gary; william.forehlich@nrc.gov; Docket, Hearing; beth.mizun@nrc.gov; cathy.scott@nrc.gov; jeremy.wachutaka@nrc.gov; david.lewis@pillsburylaw.com; Speiser, Herald; OCAAMAIL Resource; Alan.wase@nrc.gov; Mizuno, Beth; Newell, Brian; Sola, Clara; Julian, Emile; Rov Hawkins; OGCMailCenter.Resources@nrc.gov; OCAAMAIL.Resources@nrc.gov Cc: "PatriciaPerluke"; "AmyElliott"; "BrianBusher"; "RobertE.Brown"; "Rev.ChadA.Hebrink"; "CynthiaLombard";

"DaveSuperdock"; "JamieDavis"; "RobertDeRonde"; "DaveAllard"; Tifft, Doug; "DavidSimpson"; "TedJacobsen";

"ErinSchloyer"; "GeneTrowbridge"; "JamesGresham"; "HeidiBiggs"; "JenniferSiani";

"CatherinStuccioMentrinkoski"; "KyleCarey"; "KevinWhite"; "LingardKnutson"; "KellyPetock"; "EricEpstein";

"LoraZimmerman"; "KevinMagerr"; "MikeCaverly"; "NateSnavely"; "OliviaMowery"; "PaulaBallaron"; "PatNaugle";

"BarbaraDeRonde"; "RichJanati"; "R.K.Temple"; "RobertM.Paley"; "RoccoR.Sgarro"; "GregRuppert";

"ShawnBeeler"; "RyanSearch"; "SteveMcDougal"; "SabatiniMonatesti"; "SteveMars"; "TondaLewis"; "TomPopko";

"TomShervinskie"; "VinceKelly"; "WalterHoltsmaster"; "WilburDennis"; "LarryWinker"; Bill Davenport; citydesk@citizensvoice.com; David Fallk; Erik_helbing_esq@yahoo.com; jsoprano@civitasmedia.com; marande07@aol.com; Michael Lester; mmizenko@CIVITASMEDIA.COM; susan.schwartz@pressenterprise.net; WILLIAM LEVINSON

Subject:

[External_Sender] RE: Nuclear Waste Storage Concern SSES 1 and 2 Date: Tuesday, June 06, 2017 8:31:14 PM Attachments: NRC open letter NOC 06062017.pdf

Dear Mr. Hawkens:

I apologize, I made a transcription error in my open letter, please note:

page 2 - calculated estimate on nuclear waste storage, 300,000 metric tons plus would apply to CONUS. And on page 7 - duplicate email addresses were inadvertently introduced during a copy and paste process. I attached a Notice of Correction document with this email.

Regards, Sabatini Monatesti From: smonatesti@verizon.net [1]

Sent: Monday, June 05, 2017 12:29 AM To: 'AJ ASLBP 2'; 'AJ ASLBP 3'; 'Chairman AJ ASLBP'; 'NRC Office of Secretary'; 'Office of General Counsel 1'; 'Office of General Counsel 2';

'Office of General Counsel 3'; 'PWSP LLP'; 'Rulemakings Adjudications Staff'; 'US NRC'; 'Alan Wase'; 'Beth Mizuno'; 'Brian Newell'; 'Clara Sola';

'Emile Julian'; 'IMCEAIN'; 'Mail Center'; 'OCA Mail' Cc: 'ajlaquin@verizon.net (Patricia Perluke) ';

'Amy.H.Elliott@usace.army.mil (Amy Elliott) '; 'bbusher@pa.gov (Brian Busher) '; 'bob.brown@ge.com (Robert E. Brown) '; 'chebrink@localnet.com (Rev. Chad A. Hebrink) '; 'clombard@pa.metrocast.net (Cynthia Lombard) ';

'dasuper@verizon.net (Dave Superdock) '; 'davis.jamie@epamail.epa.gov (Jamie Davis)'; 'derddafdl@verizon.net (Robert DeRonde) '; 'djallard@pa.gov (Dave Allard)'; 'Doug.Tifft@nrc.gov (Doug Tifft) '; 'dsimpson@bloomu.edu (David Simpson) '; 'ecology3@gmail.com (Ted Jacobsen) '; 'eschloyer@yahoo.com (Erin Schloyer) '; 'etrowbridg@pa.gov (Gene Trowbridge)';

'greshaja@westinghouse.com (James Gresham) '; 'hbiggs@pa.gov (Heidi Biggs)

'; 'Jennifer_Siani@fws.gov (Jennifer Siani) '; 'kaysm@verizon.net (Catherin Stuccio Mentrinkoski) '; 'kcarey960@gmail.com (Kyle Carey)';

'kevwhite@pa.gov (Kevin White) '; 'knutson.lingard@epa.gov (Lingard Knutson)

'; 'kpetock@curtisswright.com (Kelly Petock) '; 'lechambon@comcast.net (Eric Epstein) '; 'Lora_Zimmerman@fws.gov (Lora Zimmerman) ';

'Magerr.Kevin@epamail.epa.gov (Kevin Magerr) '; 'mjcaverly@pplweb.com (Mike Caverly) '; 'nate@nathansnavely.com (Nate Snavely) '; 'omowery@pa.gov (Olivia Mowery) '; 'pballaron@srbc.net (Paula Ballaron) '; 'pnaugle@srbc.net

(Pat Naugle) '; 'psychndesign@verison.net (Barbara DeRonde) ';

'rjanati@pa.gov (Rich Janati) '; 'RKTemple@cpsenergy.com (R.K. Temple) ';

'rmpaley@pplweb.com (Robert M. Paley) '; 'rrsgarro@pplweb.com (Rocco R.

Sgarro) '; 'ruppert125@aol.com (Greg Ruppert) '; 'sbeeler@pa.gov (Shawn Beeler) '; 'signs@bellessigns.com (Ryan Search) '; 'smcdougal@pa.gov (Steve McDougal) '; 'smonatesti@verizonl.net (Sabatini Monatesti) ';

'steve_mars@fws.gov (Steve Mars) '; 'tolewis@pa.gov (Tonda Lewis) ';

'TomPopko@hotmail.com (Tom Popko) '; 'tshervinsk@pa.gov (Tom Shervinskie) ';

'vincekelly@gmail.com (Vince Kelly) '; 'wholtsmast@pa.gov (Walter Holtsmaster) '; 'wilburdennisjr@hotmail.com (Wilbur Dennis, Jr.) ';

'winker@pa.gov (Larry Winker) '; Bill Davenport (wdd@pa.metrocast.net);

citydesk@citizensvoice.com; David Fallk; 'Erik Helbing';

jsoprano@civitasmedia.com; marande07@aol.com; Michael Lester; mmizenko@CIVITASMEDIA.COM; susan.schwartz@pressenterprise.net; WILLIAM LEVINSON

Subject:

Nuclear Waste Storage Concern SSES 1 and 2 Importance: High

Dear Mr. Hawkens:

Mr. Davenport and I are concerned for our communities and our citizens. We believe the NRC is putting constituents at risk. The issues we introduced October 2016 continue today, they have not gone away. We need your help to reconcile and clarify each one through open hearings. We respectfully request these hearings to be held in the ten-mile Plume Exposure Zone or the fifty-mile Ingestion Pathway Zone of SSES 1 and 2.

We applaud President Trump's budget. We understand he included funding for Yucca Mountain nuclear waste repository and plans to use these funds for the management of nuclear waste storage. Talen Energy 2018 plans called for expanding nuclear waste storage at SSES 1 and 2. Please ensure that Yucca Mountain nuclear waste repository becomes a reality, and that SSES 1 and 2 do not become a waste dump.

Regards, Sabatini Monatesti & Bill Davenport

Notice of Correction - June 4, 2017 Open Letter June 6, 2017

Reference:

Nuclear Waste Storage & Docket ID NRC-2016-0187 Docket Nos. 50-387, 50-388 & 72-28-LT-2 In the matter of:

Susquehanna Nuclear LLC Susquehanna Steam Electric Station, Units 1 and 2 Open Letter, Posted June 2017, Corrections To: E. Roy Hawkens Chief Administrative Judge ASLBP No. 16-949-01-LT-BD01 Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D. C. 20555-0001`

Cc: NRC Representatives, PA Representatives (State and Federal), NRC Oversight committees, Press Enterprise Editor, Citizen Voice Editor, Area Residents (NRC Hearing - Berwick HS Pre 2016)

Correction page 2, last paragraph: The sentence should read: We estimate the waste storage space requirements for SESS 1 and 2, plus the 100 or more additional CONUS sites to be about 300,000 metric tons of waste. Empire State Building about 365,000 metric tons NRC Representative, Dan Schroeder, April 27, 2016, reported that the SSES waste storage containers weigh tons, i.e., 61 rods per container, about 660 pounds per rod which equals 40,260 pounds per container or about 20 tons. Talen Energy planned to install in 2018, on a 22,000 square foot space, an additional 55 new waste storage units equaling a storage capacity of about 1,100 tons. Talen estimated, April 2016, they had between 1,800 and 2,000 tons of nuclear waste storage on site. Hence, total estimate given plan execution, about 3,000 metric tons of waste storage at SSES 1 and 2 locations. It is reported that CONUS has over 100 plants across the US, hence the estimate of over 300,000 metric tons of waste distributed throughout the US, not including military and miscellaneous waste.

According to an Empire State Building spokesperson and independent researcher John Tauranac, the Empire state Building 1

weighs 365,000 tons. In his 1995 book The Empire State Building: The Making of a Landmark, Tauranac says the 365,000 ton figure came from original architect Richmond Shreve.

New York Times, Diane Cardwell, Feb. 18, 2017, presents all of us with an additional concern, she said, But a remarkable confluence of events is bringing that nuclear age to an end, capped in recent days by Toshibas decision to take a $6 2

billion loss and pull Westinghouse, its American nuclear power subsidiary, out of the construction business. Does this mean the citizen will end up with owning the nuclear waste and the fallout from potential bankruptcies?

Correction page 7, email addresses: Due to copy and paste error some email address were presented in duplicate.

Regards, Sabatini Monatesti 1

http://stupidquestionarchives.blogspot.com/2008/03/empire-state-building-weight.html 2

https://www.nytimes.com/2017/02/18/business/energy-environment/nuclear-power-westinghouse-toshiba.html?_r=0