ML17157B693
| ML17157B693 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Susquehanna  |
| Issue date: | 06/05/2017 |
| From: | Monatesti S - No Known Affiliation |
| To: | Hawkens E Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| SECY/RAS | |
| References | |
| 50-387-LT-2, 50-388-LT-2, 72-28-LT-2, License Transfer | |
| Download: ML17157B693 (8) | |
Text
From: smonatesti@verizon.net To: Bollwerk, Paul; Arnold, Gary; "Chairman AJ ASLBP"; Docket, Hearing; "Office of General Counsel 1"; "Office of General Counsel 2"; "Office of General Counsel 3"; "PWSP LLP"; Speiser, Herald; OCAAMAIL Resource; "Alan Wase"; Mizuno, Beth; Newell, Brian; Sola, Clara; Julian, Emile; "IMCEAIN"; "Mail Center"; "OCA Mail" Cc: "ajlaquin@verizon.net (Patricia Perluke) "; "Amy.H.Elliott@usace.army.mil (Amy Elliott) "; "bbusher@pa.gov (Brian Busher) "; "bob.brown@ge.com (Robert E. Brown) "; "chebrink@localnet.com (Rev. Chad A. Hebrink) ";
"clombard@pa.metrocast.net (Cynthia Lombard) "; "dasuper@verizon.net (Dave Superdock) ";
"davis.jamie@epamail.epa.gov (Jamie Davis)"; "derddafdl@verizon.net (Robert DeRonde) "; "djallard@pa.gov (Dave Allard)"; Tifft, Doug; "dsimpson@bloomu.edu (David Simpson) "; "ecology3@gmail.com (Ted Jacobsen) ";
"eschloyer@yahoo.com (Erin Schloyer) "; "etrowbridg@pa.gov (Gene Trowbridge)";
"greshaja@westinghouse.com (James Gresham) "; "hbiggs@pa.gov (Heidi Biggs) "; "Jennifer_Siani@fws.gov (Jennifer Siani) "; "kaysm@verizon.net (Catherin Stuccio Mentrinkoski) "; "kcarey960@gmail.com (Kyle Carey)";
"kevwhite@pa.gov (Kevin White) "; "knutson.lingard@epa.gov (Lingard Knutson) "; "kpetock@curtisswright.com (Kelly Petock) "; "lechambon@comcast.net (Eric Epstein) "; "Lora_Zimmerman@fws.gov (Lora Zimmerman) ";
"Magerr.Kevin@epamail.epa.gov (Kevin Magerr) "; "mjcaverly@pplweb.com (Mike Caverly) ";
"nate@nathansnavely.com (Nate Snavely) "; "omowery@pa.gov (Olivia Mowery) "; "pballaron@srbc.net (Paula Ballaron) "; "pnaugle@srbc.net (Pat Naugle) "; "psychndesign@verison.net (Barbara DeRonde) ";
"rjanati@pa.gov (Rich Janati) "; "RKTemple@cpsenergy.com (R.K. Temple) "; "rmpaley@pplweb.com (Robert M.
Paley) "; "rrsgarro@pplweb.com (Rocco R. Sgarro) "; "ruppert125@aol.com (Greg Ruppert) "; "sbeeler@pa.gov (Shawn Beeler) "; "signs@bellessigns.com (Ryan Search) "; "smcdougal@pa.gov (Steve McDougal) ";
"smonatesti@verizonl.net (Sabatini Monatesti) "; "steve_mars@fws.gov (Steve Mars) "; "tolewis@pa.gov (Tonda Lewis) "; "TomPopko@hotmail.com (Tom Popko) "; "tshervinsk@pa.gov (Tom Shervinskie) ";
"vincekelly@gmail.com (Vince Kelly) "; "wholtsmast@pa.gov (Walter Holtsmaster) ";
"wilburdennisjr@hotmail.com (Wilbur Dennis, Jr.) "; "winker@pa.gov (Larry Winker) "; Bill Davenport; citydesk@citizensvoice.com; David Fallk; "Erik Helbing"; jsoprano@civitasmedia.com; marande07@aol.com; Michael Lester; mmizenko@CIVITASMEDIA.COM; susan.schwartz@pressenterprise.net; WILLIAM LEVINSON
Subject:
[External_Sender] Nuclear Waste Storage Concern SSES 1 and 2 Date: Monday, June 05, 2017 12:29:46 AM Attachments: NRC Open Letter 06052017-signed.pdf Importance: High
Dear Mr. Hawkens:
Mr. Davenport and I are concerned for our communities and our citizens. We believe the NRC is putting constituents at risk. The issues we introduced October 2016 continue today, they have not gone away. We need your help to reconcile and clarify each one through open hearings. We respectfully request these hearings to be held in the ten-mile Plume Exposure Zone or the fifty-mile Ingestion Pathway Zone of SSES 1 and 2.
We applaud President Trumps budget. We understand he included funding for Yucca Mountain nuclear waste repository and plans to use these funds for the management of nuclear waste storage. Talen Energy 2018 plans called for expanding nuclear waste storage at SSES 1 and 2. Please ensure that Yucca Mountain nuclear waste repository becomes a reality, and that SSES 1 and 2 do not become a waste dump.
- Regards, Sabatini Monatesti & Bill Davenport
Open Letter, Posted June 2017 June 4, 2017
Reference:
Nuclear Waste Storage & Docket ID NRC-2016-0187 Docket Nos. 50-387, 50-388 & 72-28-LT-2 In the Matter of:
Susquehanna Nuclear, LLC Susquehanna Steam Electric Station, Units 1 and 2 To: E. Roy Hawkens Chief Administrative Judge ASLBP No. 16-949-01-LT-BD01 Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D. C. 20555-0001 Cc: See Attachment 2 for NRC Representatives, PA Representatives (State and Federal), NRC Oversight committees, Press Enterprise Editor, Times Leader Editor, Citizen Voice Editor, Area Residents (NRC Hearing - Berwick HS Pre 2016, Attachment 3)
Mr. Davenport and I are concerned for our communities and our citizens. We believe the NRC is putting constituents at risk. The issues we introduced October 2016 continue today, they have not gone away. We need your help to reconcile and clarify each one through open hearings. We respectfully request these hearings to be held in the ten-mile Plume Exposure Zone or the fifty-mile Ingestion Pathway Zone of SSES 1 and 2. We applaud President Trumps budget. We understand he included funding for Yucca Mountain nuclear waste repository and plans to use these funds for the management of nuclear waste storage. Talen Energy 2018 plans called for expanding nuclear waste storage at SSES 1 and 2.
The NRC Adams database has all of Mr. Monatesti inquiries; however, we believe it was missing the original FAX to the NRC requesting that an open hearing be held in our area to review health and safety issues. Mr. Monatesti submitted this FAX document October 11, 2016,
Reference:
https://www.nrc.gov/site-help/search.html?q=monatesti&site=allSites#gsc.tab=0&gsc.q=monatesti&gsc.sort=date we include in Attachment 1 previously issued notes, i.e., areas of concern.
1
Mr. Davenport would like to make it clear that he hasnt been able to review or read the Salem Township zoning law in total that applies to nuclear waste, PA Zoning class Nuclear Waste 4, Chapter 236, enacted march 28, 1995, Amended September 23, 1997, Amended March 23, 2004, Salem Township Board of Supervisors, http://elibrary.pacounties.org/Documents/luzerne/795. However, most of the information available through attendance at the zoning hearing board meeting on the subject implies we are dealing with hazardous substances, high-level waste (HLW) or used nuclear reactor fuel that resides within one-half mile of our streams, major water ways, and wells that are used for drinking water.
Mr. Davenport reports, Some people may not be aware, Salem Township Changed the zoning of the nuclear power plant and the land they own to a new zoning called Nuclear 4 under the provision regulated waste. This along with some new federal laws, he believes, allows for the permanent storage of nuclear waste on site. He further states, There has also been the suggestion that nuclear waste from other areas may be moved to SSES 1 and 2 for storage.
Congress was considering the closing of Yucca Mt. and limiting total storage space available. This position is unacceptable. We estimate the waste storage space requirements for SSES 1 and 2 to be 300,000 metric tons of waste. This waste is equivalent in size to the weight of the Empire State Building. Mr. Davenport and I wish to combat local nuclear waste storage at SSES 1 and 2 thus stopping our community and surrounding area from becoming a permanent nuclear waste dump. We need more ideas from you, our representatives, and a lot of help from communities around the country if we are going to stop this travesty. Please ensure that Yucca Mountain nuclear waste repository becomes a reality.
Sincerely:
Mr. Bill Davenport & Mr. Sabatini Monatesti Sabatini Monatesti Beach Haven PA and Berwick PA residents 2
Attachment 1 The NRC noted, in past response, that Mr. Monatesti did not comply with their regulations; hence, the NRC denied him any standing regards the transfer of license of SSES 1 and 2 during the sale of Talen Energy to Riverstone Holdings LLC.
Refusal to hold open hearings in our area regarding NPP SSES 1 and 2 license transfer, denying Citizen right to Due Process, Due Process Clause, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment, is unethical and inconsistent with our oversight as citizen. The outstanding issues include:
Failure to invoke Executive Order 12,898 and Title VI along with section 311 of the Stafford Act, EPA to include environmental justice as a factor in review of state permits pursuant to Clean Air and Clean Water Acts Planned nuclear waste storage exceeds regulatory limit in Salem Township and concern regarding the distribution and handling of nuclear waste throughout the Continental United States, 102 NPP US sites to host 300,000 metric tons of waste and numerous DOD facilities with unknown amounts, reference Nuclear Waste Policy Act, March 2004, page 42 Ethical lapse by NRC/Talen Energy LLC regarding their handling of Salem Township, Planning Board Meeting and citizen participation, misrepresented jurisdiction argument regarding health and safety issues Business operations planning misrepresentations by Riverstone Holdings LLC, Talen Energy and the NRC, regarding investment and decimating of resources and facilities where profit might be impacted Possible misrepresentation of fact on Securities and Exchange Commission 10K regarding profit and loss, $700 Million concurrent risk, along with altering potential investments (adjustments) in area power generation technology and facilities following commitment of licensing given Talen CEO, CIO and CFO had prior knowledge of capital investment decisions Potential RICO Act 109, causality, violations by Talen Energy LLC personnel, executive payoff of $25 Million severance at deal close after denial of planned $70 Million investment, Washingtonville Withholding of SUNSI information, thus denying citizen the opportunity to ascertain survivability and operational integrity of NPP, twenty year SSES 1 and 2 renewal license granted based on a five year business case 3
Attachment 1 Talen Energy LLC misrepresenting area escape possibilities and omitting health and safety issues regarding limits to egress from the area and possible health implications at decontamination facilities, minimum one hour wait times on Route 11, possible hours at decontamination site, families in chaos Denial of discussion regarding the impact seismic activity, due to fracking, could have on operational integrity of NPP SSES 1 and 2, PA DEP notes increased seismic activity April 2016, 1.8 and 2.3 on the Richter scale Potential Berwick area loss of property and life, minimum estimate $500 million, without FEMA oversight or insurance policy to cover loss to citizen due to nuclear disaster incident, NRC & Sandia Study, CRAC-2 and NUREG-0340.
Repair of failure modes at NPP SSES 1 and 2, emergency ventilation installed after 40 years of operation, and repair of Exelons 2012 event not existent 4
Attachment 2 ATTACHMENT 2 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Office of Commission Appellate Adjudication Office of the Secretary of the Commission Mail Stop: O-7H4 Mail Stop: O-4F00 Washington, DC 20555-0001 Washington, DC 20555-0001 OCAA Mail Center Hearing Docket E-mail: ocaamail@nrc.gov E-mail: hearingdocket@nrc.gov Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Office of General Counsel Mail Stop T-3F23 Mail Stop -O-14A44 Washington, DC 20555-0001 Washington, DC 20555-0001 Beth Mizuno, Esq.
William J. Froehlich, Chairman Cathy Scott, Esq.
Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel Jeremy Wachutka, Esq.
Administrative Judge E-mail: beth.mizun@nrc.gov U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission cathy.scott@nrc.gov Washington, DC 20555-0001 jeremy.wachutka@nrc.gov E-mail: william.forehlich@nrc.gov G. Paul Bollwerk, III Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman LLP Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel 2300 N Street NW Administrative Judge Washington, DC 20037-1122 Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel David Lewis, Esq.
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission E-mail: david.lewis@pillsburylaw.com Washington, DC 20555-0001 E-mail: paul.bollwerk@nrc.gov Dr. Gary S. Arnold Herald M. Speiser Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel Rulemakings and Adjudications Staff Administrative Judge Office of the Secretary U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555-0001 (301) 415-1675 E-mail: gary.arnold@nrc.gov Herald.Speiser@nrc.gov OCAAMAIL.Resources@nrc.gov IMCEAINVALID-Roy+20Hawkens@nrc.gov Catherine.Scott@nrc.gov Beth.Mizuno@nrc.gov Alan.wase@nrc.gov Emile.Julian@nrc.gov OGCMailCenter.Resources@nrc.gov Brian.Newell@nrc.gov Clara.Sola@nrc.gov Erik_helbing_esq@yahoo.com Susan.schwartz@pressenterprise.net Marande07@aol.com citydesk@citizensvoice.com jsoprano@civitasmedia.com wdd@pa.metrocast.net mmizenko@CIVITASMEDIA.COM doublle@aol.com wlevinson@verizon.net mike.l@pressenterprise.net sachetti@pressenterprise.net 5
Attachment 2 Representative Lou Barletta Senator Robert P. Casey, Jr.
Pennsylvania - 11th District 393 Russell Senate Office Building 2049 Rayburn House Office Building Washington, D.C. 20510 http://barletta.house.gov https://www.casey.senate.gov FAX: 202-226-6250 FAX: 202-228-0604 Senator Patrick Pat Toomey Hon. David R. Millard 248 Russell Senate Office Building 316 Main Capitol Building Washington, D.C. 20510 PO Box 202109 https://www.toomey.senate.gov/?p=contact Harrisburg, PA 17120-2109 FAX: (610) 434-1844 http://www.legis.state.pa.us/cfdocs/legis/home/me mber_information/House_bio.cfm?id=1033 FAX: 570-759-4527 Representative Tarah Toohil 1 West Broad Street U.S. Representative Kevin Brady Suite 100 1011 Longworth House Office Building Hazleton, PA 18201 Washington, DC 20515 http://www.facebook.com/RepToohil w&mweekahead@mail.house.gov FAX: 570-459-3946 Emily.Schillinger@mail.house.gov tarahtoohil@pahousenews.com Lauren.Aronson@mail.house.gov Contact List (Berwick HS - NRC Hearing, pre 2016) 6
Attachment 3 - NRC Hearing - Berwick HS Pre 2016 ajlaquin@verizon.net (Patricia Perluke) kcarey960@gmail.com (Kyle Carey)
Amy.H.Elliott@usace.army.mil(AmyEiliott) kevwhite@pa.gov (Kevin White) bbusher@pa.gov (Brian Bushe) knutson.lingard@epa.gov (Lingard Knutson) bob.brown@ge.com (Robert E. Brown) kpetock@curtisswright.com (Kelly Petock) chebrink@localnet.com (Rev. Chad A. Hebrink) Magerr.Kevin@epamail.epa.gov (Kevin Magerr) ciombard@pa.metrocast.net (Cynthia Lombard) mjcaverly@pplweb.com (Mike Caver dasuper@verizon.net (Dave Superdock) nate@nathansnavely.com (Nate Snavely) davis.jamie@epamail.epa.gov (Jamie Davis) omowery@pa.gov (Olivia Mowery) derddafdl@verizon.net (Robert DeRonde) pballaron@srbc.net (Paula Ballaron) djallard@pa.gov (Dave Allard) pnaugle@srbc.net (Pat Naugle)
Doug.Tifft@nrc.gov (Doug Tifft) psychndesign@verison.net (Barbara DeRonde) dsimpson@bloomu.edu (David Simpson) psychndesign@verison.net(BarbaraDeRonde) ecology3@gmail.com (Ted Jacobsen) rjanati@pa.gov (Rich Janati) eschloyer@yahoo.com (Erin Schloyer) RKTemple@cpsenergy.com (RK. Temple) etrowbridg@pa.gov (Gene Trowbridge) rmpaley@pplweb.com (Robert M. Paley) greshaja@westinghouse.com (James Gresham) rrsgarro@pplweb.com (Rocco R Sgarro) hbiggs@pa.gov (Heidi Biggs) ruppert125@aol.com (Greg Ruppert)
Jennifer_Siani@fws.gov (Jennifer Sian i) sbeeler@pa.gov (Shawn Beeler) kaysm@verizon.net (Catherin Stuccio Mentrinkoski) signs@bellessigns.com (Ryan Search) kcarey960@gmail.com (Kyle Carey) smcdougal@pa.gov (Steve McDougal) kevwhite@pa.gov (Kevin White) smonatesti@verizonl.net (Sabatini Monatesti) knutson.lingard@epa.gov (Lingard Knutson) steve_mars@fws.gov (Steve Mars) kpetock@curtisswright.com (Kelly Petock) tolewis@pa.gov (Tonda Lewis) lechambon@comcast.net (Eric Epstein) Popko@hotmail.com Lora_Zimmerman@fws.gov (Lora Zimmerman) tshervinsk@pa.gov (Tom Shervinskie) ajlaquin@verizon.net (Patricia Perluke) vincekelly@gmail.com (Vince Kelly)
Amy.H.Elliott@usace.army.mil(AmyEiliott) wholtsmast@pa.gov (Walter Holtsmaster) bbusher@pa.gov (Brian Bushe) wilburdennisjr@hotmail.com (Wilbur Dennis, Jr.)
bob.brown@ge.com (Robert E. Brown) winker@pa.gov (Larry Winker) chebrink@localnet.com (Rev. Chad A. Hebrink) ciombard@pa.metrocast.net (Cynthia Lombard) dasuper@verizon.net (Dave Superdock) davis.jamie@epamail.epa.gov (Jamie Davis) derddafdl@verizon.net (Robert DeRonde) djallard@pa.gov (Dave Allard)
Doug.Tifft@nrc.gov (Doug Tifft) dsimpson@bloomu.edu (David Simpson) ecology3@gmail.com (Ted Jacobsen) eschloyer@yahoo.com (Erin Schloyer) etrowbridg@pa.gov (Gene Trowbridge) greshaja@westinghouse.com (James Gresham) hbiggs@pa.gov (Heidi Biggs)
Jennifer_Siani@fws.gov (Jennifer Sian i) kaysm@verizon.net (Catherin Stuccio Mentrinkoski) 7