TXX-6299, Forwards Response to 870218 Request for Addl Info on Ofc of Inspector & Auditor Rept 86-10 Re Piping Spool Piece. Drawings 1210E59 & 1457F27 W/Component Mod Card 4260,Rev 1 & Design Change Authorization 16,813,Rev 8 Also Encl
| ML20211H524 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Comanche Peak  |
| Issue date: | 02/19/1987 |
| From: | Counsil W, Keeley G TEXAS UTILITIES ELECTRIC CO. (TU ELECTRIC) |
| To: | NRC OFFICE OF INFORMATION RESOURCES MANAGEMENT (IRM) |
| References | |
| TXX-6299, NUDOCS 8702260199 | |
| Download: ML20211H524 (16) | |
Text
.
ammmmmmme
==
Log # TXX-6299 File # 10115 2
C
=
=
1UELECTRIC
% imam G. Coumil em um, n, anse,,,
February 19, 1987 U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Attn:
Document Control Desk Washington, D.C.
20555
SUBJECT:
COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION (CPSES)
DOCKET NOS. 50-445 AND 50-446 REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION ON OIA REPORT 86-10 REGARDING A PIPING SPOOL PIECE REF: NRC letter from V. S. Noonan to W. G. Counsil dated February 18, 1987.
Gentlemen:
We have reviewed your letter, referenced above, requesting additional information on a piping spool piece. We hereby respond to the requests for additional information in the attachment to this letter.
In addition, during the February 17, 1987 telephone call referenced in the above referenced letter, you also requested the enclosed drawings:
1210E59 and 1457F27 with Component Modification Card 4260, Rev. I and Design Change Authorization 16,813, Rev. 8.
Very truly yours, wntlL W. G. Counsil By:
A, I, f
/
- 6. S. Keeley
/
Manager,Nuclearbgtensing JDS/ef Attachment Enclosures c - Mr. R. D. Martin, Region IV Mr. D. L. Kelley, RI - Region IV Mr. H. S. Phillips, RI - Region IV 8702260199 870219 fy PDR ADOCK 05000445 PDR A
gk
.soo wrih one street i..a 8i natias. iesas 7520
Attachment to TXX-6299 February.19, 1987 Page 1 of 1 Information Request on OIA Report 86-10
'01A Report 86-10, provided by Board Notification No. 86-24 refers on page 5 to an issue " Failure to Properly Identify a Spool Piece." This issue is mentioned again on page 6 and page 9.
Page 9 states "...the utility located a mark on the spool piece and showed it to the inspectors."
If possible, please identify the size of the piping spool piece, the location of the spool piece within the chemical volume control system (CVCS), the type of material (e.g.,
stainless' steel), and the consequences of a failure of spool piece.
Response
The subject spool is located between field weld 1) and 6) on drawing BRP-CS RB-076.
The spool consists of 4 pieces:
Piece 2 - 6' 6-5/16" - 3" Sch. 160, SA 376, Type 304 Piece 6 - is a 45 degree elbow 3" Sch.160, SA 403 WP 304 Piece 3 - is a 10-3/16" - 3" Sch. 160, SA 376, Type 304 Piece 5 - is a 90 degree elbow - 3" Sch. 160, SA 403 WP 304 The spool is located between valves 2-8085 and 2LCV-460 on the CVCS letdown line from the suction of No. 3 RC pump. The spool is Class 1.
This line can be found on drawing 2323-M2-0250 and 2323-M2-0253.
Valve 2-8085 is "open" during normal plant operation. Therefore, the spool would be part of the RCS. pressure boundary.
If the spool failed, a 3" leak would occur within containment. This size leak is within the analyzed condition for design basis LOCA (postulated line break).
r I
l
n Enclosure to TXX-6299 Page 1 of 14 Assemble drawings as shown below.
IA 2A 4A 3A NOTE: Use same sequence for 1B through 48.
I i
i 4
i
!l
n gj i
i l'
I, 1 a
1 s
9 4
e I
n 4'
z
~
e x
e t'
r b
W de f
t R
g s
$h 5
3 3
-A (1
\\
/
~
( K-l a
N--
-s
'1 /
N.
s.
g I
's C
s N
'J r
u N
I 31 m
N Y
.,e T
NN
.__,a m
-m.
_2
-.-s h
A-
-.a---
--.ma m
G k
4 !!l t3 lf_
!L!
a
,4, e
I-
.am m +
h\\ 99 b
h
=m.
m, m
i y
>l 2 I
P
~ T j,, f,iI-li glL_Ja
/g.'i 4
4
.i :
A l-
)
.,s t l L.
.s i I"l{m 3glg)g 6
3 j.
_t.
- 5. l"4 2
"/
j/
7')
~
g
.?.
=
/%
J EI I
b<
J:-- 1 l
$g a-E l
1 a u a a
- na 4
I
~
e
/s
--m u.I t_
TE I5 t
E U
g S afs~
A n
a e
I8
)
l 1j j
B I
o a
1 I,
3g a
4 5l Q
R g
2 4
-l=-)
l pl 4
g g
{
Ed ylim'p_:w._.\\.8'g rd 5
+
2
- /;
s@ r q /
l 1%
is 1 /
i ns
,Apu
-"T"T" 7 $
l 4
[
g
.y.
ts z...y_4
.. s...;.;
, we-s s
4 g-y.. pg, h
f r ~'
r k N E>.f 3u a
il' h I
--_..a" 1
4 4
LanL&uid W il e --- l m
r' t
g d
ll'Ill!c!!!!!llg!
l l! I. !Illl$
5 I' 5
l!!]lli'lll!l
!ll li l
r 13 I
h
{fIII!l'E 11!!!l,l1ll 1 i
D 8
ei
!iil l i
l!!!!
A
.n Q
c t
%w,-!+ Iw i,t, 2
i i.
l
$j J
.it
=
T 1-l
- t ){
[q[slgijs Ci e
y
['-
si l di 1r
- 5. *.bl?
!!33ll-e em tl
' ! =.
1 1 I
T: :=
~
a>.
n 2 ---
W_6 =
s tl
- p g
h
- bl!
t
.e
.~
e n a.
___-________________-__________________S i5n
'k
5 g
- M j
~
/
/
l'
["$ #
N N._
rum.c-rs = omr>
CgtB'. !
(
= = = =c= -
}
b
'I B O p o I3M.
se. am_-x AVYEgqED
{
r!
,, g. n N e, $ F Gi i
1 I
d r
GENERAt_ ARRANGEMENT 4 EL 82A*-O
~
i s
1 coo co mana o==
l DCC N0. W !
sc e -p..-.
THis DOC' PET l
..s _
" " ~ = " ~
A3 Oy pm u *
?0R 0 hic '
_ ~
ENGNtdlh..,ui i
[
GEteERAL seOTES ConsT.
T TMf I-W 9d l N es. Seems reases==narmTgg(marr einmaa zgpet$ seemA, eenwa mee seasTat.tATwose :
OF + " AfeO
.OEO'"
Se**e.es adav SE Sue.ceveOED AS reggcEp T30erass l
\\
$ 5? *f -
A M*+R'n
,n E
=E _ =_
h somooam.'s;:NJ'.:^Ji'E #. ear====W=ehr "I' gy, J.,
c nv=
i M MW KET j
l sg)
- =
i
[
d ide I 8 nlP,;teil dI b
hI
.k#
i h
$)*
i i
g h,
.3 I s
- 84
+ g;
)
g
.i].1~%Qt.f!g!
adj *94Ejp 2
i
-5 t
7 r
y 4 :35$ a :;l I x
k k$ !;[A!k!!$fhd $$!!.
t F
=
N UbNkN bbil
!t i
1 i
c..
=.
c
]
FEB 17 '87 13:56 CPSES SITE SERVICES PAGE.03 g
><t__
______j 5 ll 8
y
_,l a
+
N h
- e g
s r
j e
y' 8
- __-. 4 7
3 d
!T
!c J
e l-g o
c 2-I =,
E
(
5 f a -*
I u
ei l
.)
)y!
g h-c
\\
h) 4
+
I O
I l
a 8
.gn=. _.
5 r---
^'V
/
y
^
E 6
(j)
__c a
n g [a 7- - -
a
<: t>
u..
e
.3'-la 9le T
t cg' e
9 j
j
+-
jg'!!!
, a-
'} ---,
g M
P-t _--I
/
1 e
0
/
O
'- ~
4 u
e x
.,g..
[
k b
a g
e
~~
w
.9.9 o
-g -
h l
!??
y I
8d G
b N
\\
' N
. Pi p!
a.I 1.
h2
FEB 17 '87 13:57 CPSES SITE SERVICES PAGE.04 p
s, I
e
=
N FU pf 1
,1 l,ilI ll e
I p
lb. !!fN I; l li l j l !l !
l l lil i p!_!
- i l
mn inn!
h l
' i.;I I
=
l lL l :I i
illilsit.l il 1
I i
';3 4
8
- 1 7, h i
l
<lI l!"i!Inll r S! l l s j f W b
i E El" 3
t yg a,sl
,athlI'gll<
fii S yJg i I
I
,ir
@ i a u b4 ga ssz u sxx l
..,,j I
l l
llh3l 1
5 31 i
t' h.
i c
};
3-wI p
b g
L--
4 Il! f p-g [j s
r-lI
- 6 I
a g!?;
g t, J h
g wN o
r.
l
.c 9;
O i
(6 i
8 'N
.t.
?.$?S ll u.
s
=
ci
,5
=:
i
.,_. y
_ U -
n --
~-7 d
ca 1l
t
- r. M. % W 2
- m. me.c.m,.. - =,.4.-
- - ~
-a = f gfe y a iy m.,,
a.=
. =
y tom.
ut cw o, _as. r esse y saac :ss sinss. c.+sa
-~
I w
/ e ar.r,
/
f M
i m
l TEIAS UTILITIES OERVICES INC.
PLAMT:
f-f CO*tANCHE FEAK STEAN E'.,ECTRIC STATION i
(
f
[.
' "' I T :
1 &2 4
SPIN:
RCESRS L
ATUS:
CERTIFIED FOR CONSTRUCTION '
g g
g rm g
g ERTIFICATICE.LTR. NO..WPT-6960 a
\\
AUINORITY :
T.
R. FURTEAR 9
\\
Ew E-E g
.ma,_ c ecu p 142
.~ g g e h---
li 4
n 1
1 o
270
{
E LTww r.
m
~l or. Os - #42.5 L A l
ir. or - ivsast< L g
,,. o.s -
- u. s i. s w
st.os -
- 55. S tak j
m sneve sw sa*** a
~
.r. o o.s o
(
5 nco
(
ast; ir.a7
,I aeu m
.co.e.. -..sa.o u s
m n..so t
y 1
,eo
-o-l es.ar - rses.o' g
e; a
I
=,====.. "=::::l:,=::
1
- l":::: ".:....r ?.':'?=-
en-ez
- E E
=..;" :'.'."".'" ".*l"3. L."."J. -
90*
,="""""" " " "
I
~
E
.am-. -
=aw I
REACTOR VESSEL PLAN W.7"'
.o n
W 6 WEW.C48 9 6 N sg waslu WN m
T Spess= M FEIr Ib%
ISP8E I".~---
t 0
M E.k s-P' * ^, 831 M
A
_.mm.= =.a m Mn s ene W Ns sesa.w WJI 9
m m:% c 'repK FL L me fy7 sen %,y W = =rp m
.=.2 y
c,c r=, um g
G.
- IZlDEAS, m
=
l l *myr.e r
=
k~
O.
l l
a 1
J:
5 4
l s'
B a
3 l
e 1
FEB 17 '87 13:59 CPSES SITE SEPVICES PAGE.06 3,,
?
'4 g
gw o
-.i
,_ q., _,
@s %. - ~.- -.
N 'g s
e g --
=
o s
i 4
j b
l k6 g
y f
jh lb.
h 6li d
d.m i a
I
.i 5
.i s
f Y
8
~
(
q
\\
g.
e x
e y
~
s v
N 9
x 5
88
-l 8
ti f
.J y
?
- l N
e p
+
i u -
j o
i 4 -- -
y y
I Oi 3
i h
l.}
I-'
$f.
O I
]
x As 3e
_n
.,b,
/
2 tt$3""
M i
/
j s
. __b,
.e o
=N" mcl t.
y v-g
.)
e 10o:( /pf s
WESTbHS E GRSE WNES NOLF, 3
4/7/78 a
W WEUSTERFELD TWX NO 910-890-8661 COMANCME PF.4M SITE (TRX)
CC/
C E B4LL4RD T C RSSELMAN SUBJECT R.V. SUPPORT MODIFICATIONS EE-SSD-4816 i
REF8 W DRAWING 1457F27 SPECIAL NOTE R SHIM M4Y PE CUT TO AVO!D WELD DVERLAP 0F A V SUPPORT MOX.
M4!NT4!N FULL SURFACE CONTACT WITH EMBEDMENT.
--MP 8--W-DR4 WING 1467FS-?
- 16) 9-1/e-4UNC-24 X 10 LG 90LTS M4Y BE SunSTITUTED WITH EDUIVALENT AV4ILAPLE BOLTS.
C E P4LLARD SUPPORT STRUCTURE DESIGN W MONPOEVILLF. NUCLEAR CENTER P!TTSBUROM PA TWM 710-797-3658 y...
4,4;. ;
Fib _..,.
a p.
" i 4
'{.
- J T4 -
ggS Pag e n 04 !v f-..
/
l MDEXED O'
commene een suru i
b" COMPONENT MODIFICATION CARD (CM%'seu no.
N?
4260
~
arcynic sTAnow tcesesi
@ AreocAToeL"*g wto noo. Eiik
- EB ioEs.ca mmt ye,.X_ no_, _h REQUESMD/PREeAMD BY-m
@ owa.no. W caev'
- E'- S
@ acason ron cuamoe:
G Ot.seo 3
Ms,7 5 m (s. ase - @)
wEm h
\\uTEst.fpo_, cr (
MAME gj C
wre m>eeoax w eca,suc..
g _ _ss.av _-os,o.
("EE h *-
'us
[
m-
-Tu e_c.
r,oa,og
@ msTauenous:
@ m ercu pg{ 3l,q74.,
%i 4
S.
aag e.Jc,k UA fon. A bon.n.(0 h N3=
'^
D 0 3M dam.
THIS DOC I ?'T 'UEENT w %~s DATc trve-3
"+
A'J OF Fra 1ti we-DATE g
TOR Ut PN "
~
>j EflGINEEiqidUSSOiG$c'
's w menouTum CNTL Orr p
I No-Wo u; eotsoo 7
w.
s u
6 t
i,A i nx v
i ae
- c. 4 ATr su m il q a_p,,
\\
6@fenct THIS REVISIUN VOIDS i
AND sut't:.R((DEjANb g ggg g
g \\ g" x f *>
Documsm sn.,
Cij f - 4 2 (. G M(
I e
O S,/ig % E,- G%
gg cuwe,o
=
- w. 2iu GSMCE Gusenucui -nc GHT AT mc corum os.
2t* r est. has un s-5z. sea erm itt-so c os.rs Ps, (bot. Ae.ze(F CarTAr.r.
YL e < >. ( t y.
3
. TUGC0 (2-)
i vaaE i Cr 4 CCMAN3E PEAK STDM ILECTRIC STATICN CESIGI GANGE AmMORI2ATICN (WILL) (ggxWEP) BE INCDIGOBATED IN CESIGt COCDENT DG PC.16,813 Rev.
1.
SAFETY RELATE CCCENINf: _XX TI3 No 2.
CRIGINMQRa CPPg XX CR20!NAL cESIGIER 3.
DESCRIPTICNr A
APPLIchBLE SIBI/TNG/tXXIl91gNr See Attached List REv'.
THIS REVISION VOIDS AND SUPERSEDES DCA-16,813 Rev. 7.
B.
DI2LILS
.m u
.- PROBLEM:. Welding information for attaching shims to the NSSS support / restraints
=
is not well defined.
PA SOLUTION: Revise the drawings as indicated.
{/[g/
f.,
//1g.,,
//[O /
...-. -....JUSTIFICAIION: Most time and cost effective solution.
h/[/[
REVISION &c As noted.
_ _ _,1,9 53 5 1
n c v c.
v 6 u i
JAN 311985 4.
sapasma ceCDenT;or, DOCUMENT CONTROL
-- - - Westinghouse letter WPT-7534 GLM:CCD:tw January 21, 1985 APPICUAL SIGNMCRES:lC 5.
(
d enz//g/gg N. mm=s
-a. caszan aEPas5zmrIvendJV#/ Jars >_'42-> F
$M4~
enz i y 4s
- c. -ex5mu aEvun mcR x 1ssus,
~
GGBS 8: If!LL, INC.
8-5"*""
5828:8":c":
m e r,g p_,qn g p
\\
AFMS (CRIGD EL)
(1) Chris Dupre' q,
g g 41965 CNT""t DIIINEERDU (1) Westinghouse Lb O Comhlettohs
[
ecx = 2 u a
+.,
~,
=-
a
~_ z
/L),'IJof/9 DCA-16,813 Rev. 8
~
Page 2 of 3 APPLICABLE DRAWINGS:
1457F27 Rev. 7 1457F30 Rev. 12 1457F31 Rev. 9 1457F33 Rev. 7 1457F34 Rev'. 5 1457F36 Rev. 4 1457F37 Rev. 6 1462F75 Rev. 6 1457F27 1.
Add Note 14 in " General Notes" to read as follows: Shim gaps indicated (including zero) shall have an installation tolerance of +0 and
.020".
Shims may be sub-divided as needed to obtain the desired thickness.
Welding infonnation is general. Specific weld details shall be given on installation documentation. Shims sufficiently captured do not require welding.
1457F30 t
2.
Revise Note 4 to read:
... weld shim to shim and shim to support with 3/16" fillet as specified on installation documentation. Reduce the size of one shim sufficiently to perfonn the welding.
I 3.
Revise Notes 5 and 6 to read:
... weld shim to shim and shim to support with 3/16" fillets on short sides or 3/16" fillets as specified on installati-document. Reduce the size of one shim :ufficiently to perform the welding.
l'457F31 i
4.
In Zone C-11 delete field weld symbol and beneath "1-x 14-1/8" shim plate (4or8ifneeded) state:
"fiele weld, see 1457F30".
1_457F33 5.
Revise Note 2 to read: Machine shim bar to 0" clearance in hot position.
Field weld in slot: TR-1 Groove weld, TR-2 Fillet weld.
1457F34
[6.
Revise Note 3 to read:
"... weld shim to shim and shim to support strut with 3/16" fillets as specified on installation documentation. Reduce the size of one shim sufficiently to perform the welding.
i 7.
Revise Note 4 to read:
... weld shim to shim and shim to support strut I
with 3/16" fillets as specified on installation documentation. Reduce the size of one shim sufficiently to perform the welding. Shims 1/8" or less in thickness shall be attached with full size tacks spaced approximately every 5" all-around.
i 1457F36 l
l 8.
Revise Notes 2 and 3 to read:
... weld with 3/16" fillets, top and l
bottom.
l l
R e tv J sy DCA-16,813 Rev 8 3
Page 3 of 3 1457F37 9.
In view B-B and P-P, change weld details to show 3/16" fillets as specified on installation documentation.
- 10. Revise Note 4 to read:
" Machine in field to 0" clearance in cold position.
Weld shim sets together with 1" long 3/16" fillets centered on two sides.
Weld shim set to saddle with 3/16" fillet one side only.
1457F75
- 11. Revise the shim note in View A-A to read as follows:
"... tack weld with 3/16" fillets as specified on installation documentation.
GENERAL NOTE i
- 12. Anywhere a specified weld size is called out, and the shim plate is too thin for this size weld, the weld size shall be governed by the shim thickness. Weld length are to be increased to account for reduced l
weld sizes.
1 I
I 4
I 1
++ TOTAL PAGE.12 ++
. - - _ _ _.. - _. - _ _ - _ _____- - _.,_-, _ ______ =
-