ML21243A530

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Attachment 4 - Affidavit of Kimberly Manzione Pursuant to 10 CFR 2.390
ML21243A530
Person / Time
Site: HI-STORE
Issue date: 08/31/2021
From: Manzione K
Holtec
To:
Office of Nuclear Material Safety and Safeguards
Shared Package
ML21243A525 List:
References
5025069
Download: ML21243A530 (5)


Text

U.S.

Nuclear RegulatoryCommission ATTN:

Document Control Desk Document ID5025069 Non-Proprietary Attachment 4

AFFIDAVITPURSUANTTO10CFR2.390 I,Kimberly

Manzione, being duly sworn,depose andstate asfollows:

(1)Ihave reviewed the information described inparagraph (2) whichissought to bewithheld, and I am authorized toapply forits withholding.

(2)Theinformation sought to bewithheld isprovided inAttachments 2and3to Holtec Letter 5025069,which contain Holtec Proprietary Information.

(3)Inmaking this applicationfor withholding ofproprietary information of whichitistheowner,Holtec International relies upontheexemption from disclosure setforth intheFreedomof Infonnation Act("FOIA"),

5USCSec. 552(b)(4) andtheTradeSecrets

Act, 18 USC Sec.1905, andNRCregulations 10CFRPart9.17(a)(4),

2.390(a)(4),

and 2.390(b)(1) for"trade secrets and commercial orfinancial information obtained from apersonandprivileged or confidential" (Exemption 4).

Thematerial for which exemptionfrom disclosure isheresought isall "confidential commercial information",

and someportions alsoqualify underthenarrower definition of"trade secret",

within themeanings assigned tothose tennsfor purposes of FOIA Exemption 4 in,respectively, Commission, 975F2d871 (DCCir.

1992),

andW G.roup v.FDA,704F2dl280 (DCCir.1983).

1of5

U.S.

Nuclear RegulatoryCommission ATTN:

Document Control Desk Document ID5025069 Non-Proprietary Attachment 4

AFFIDAVITPURSUANTTO 10CFR2.390 (4)Someexamples ofcategoriesofinfonnation whichfit intothedefinition of proprietary information are:

a.

Information that discloses

aprocess, method, orapparatus, including supportingdata and analyses, whereprevention ofits usebyHoltec's competitors without license fromHoltec International constitutes a

competitive economic advantage overother companies; b.

Information

which, if used by a competitor,wouldreducehis expenditure ofresourcesor improve hiscompetitive position inthe
design, manufacture,
shipment, installation, assurance ofquality, or licensing ofasimilar product.

c.

Information whichreveals costor price information, production, capacities, budget

levels, or commercial strategies of Holtec International, its customers, orits suppliers; d.

Information whichreveals aspects

ofpast, present, orfutureHoltec International customer-funded development plans and programs of potential commercial value toHoltec International; e.

Information whichdiscloses patentable subject matterfor which itmay bedesirable toobtain patent protection.

Theinformation sought tobewithheld isconsidered tobeproprietary for the reasons setforth inparagraphs 4.b, 4d,and4.cabove.

(5)Theinformation sought tobewithheld isbeing submitted totheNRCin confidence.

Theinformation (including that compiled frommanysources) is ofasortcustomarily heldinconfidence byHoltec International, andisinfact soheld.

Theinformation sought tobewithheld has,tothebestofmy knowledge andbelief, consistently beenheldinconfidence byHoltec International.

Nopublic disclosure hasbeenmade,anditisnotavailable in public sources.

Alldisclosures tothird

parties, including anyrequired transmittals totheNRC,havebeenmade,ormustbemade,pursuant to 2of5

U.S.

Nuclear Regulatory Commission ATTN:

Document Control Desk Document ID5025069 Non-Proprietary Attachment 4

AFFIDAVITPURSUANTTO 10CFR2.390 regulatory provisions or proprietary agreements whichprovide for maintenance oftheinformation inconfidence.

Itsinitial designation as proprietaryinfonnation, andthesubsequent stepstaken to preventits unauthorized disclosure, areassetforth inparagraphs (6) and(7) following.

(6)Initial approval ofproprietary treatmentofa document ismadebythe managerofthe originating component, theperson mostlikely tobeacquainted withthevalueandsensitivity oftheinformationinrelation toindustry knowledge.

Access tosuch documents within Holtec International islimited ona"need toknow"basis.

(;7)Theprocedure forapproval ofexternal release ofsuchadocument typically requires review bythestaff

manager, project
manager, principal scientist or otherequivalent authority, bythemanager ofthecognizantmarketing function (or hisdesignee),

andbytheLegal Operation, fortechnical

content, competitive
effect, anddetermination oftheaccuracy oftheproprietary designation.

Disclosures outside Holtec International are limited toregulatory

bodies, customers, andpotential customers, andtheiragents, suppliers, and licensees, andothers withalegitimate needforthe information, andthenonly in accordance withappropriate regulatory provisions or proprietary agreements.

(8)Theinformation classified asproprietary wasdeveloped andcompiled by Holtec International ata significant costto Holtec International.This information isclassified as proprietary because itcontains detailed descriptions ofanalytical approaches andmethodologies not available elsewhere.

Thisinformation wouldprovide otherparties, including competitors, withinformation fromHoltec International's technical database andtheresults ofevaluations performed byHoltec International.

A substantial effort hasbeenexpended byHoltec Intemational todevelop this information.

Release ofthis information wouldimprove acompetitor's position because it wouldenable Holtec's competitor tocopyourtechnology andoffer itforsale incompetition withourcompany, causing usfinancial injury.

3of5

U.S.

Nuclear RegulatoryCommission ATTN:

Document Control Desk Document ID5025069 Non-Proprietary Attachment 4

AFFIDAVITPURSUANTTO 10CFR2.390 (9)Publicdisclosure oftheinformation sought tobewithheld islikely tocause substantial harm toHoltec International'scompetitive position andforeclose orreduce the availability ofprofit-makingopportunities.

Theinformation is partofHoltecInternational's comprehensive spentfuel storage technology

base, andits commercial valueextends beyond theoriginal development cost.

Thevalue ofthe technology basegoesbeyond theextensive physical database andanalytical methodology, andincludesdevelopment oftheexpertise to determine andapply the appropriate evaluation process.

Theresearch, development, engineering, andanalytical costscomprise a

substantial investment oftimeandmoney byHoltec International.

Theprecise value oftheexpertise todevise an evaluation process andapply thecorrectanalytical methodology isdifficult toquantify, butitclearly is substantial.

Holtec International's competitive advantage will belost ifits competitors are able tousetheresults oftheHoltec International experience tonormalize or verify their own process or iftheyareableto claim an equivalent understanding bydemonstrating that they canarrive atthesame orsimilar conclusions.

Thevalueofthis information toHoltec International wouldbelost if the information weredisclosed tothepublic.

Making such information available tocompetitors without their having beenrequired toundertake a similar expenditure ofresources wouldunfairly provide competitors withawindfall, anddeprive Holtec International oftheopportunity toexercise its competitive advantage toseekanadequate return onitslarge investment indeveloping these veryvaluable analytical tools.

4of5

U.S.

Nuclear RegulatoryCommission ATTN:

Document Control Desk Document ID5025069 Non-Proprietary Attachment 4

AFFIDAVITPURSUANTTO10CFR2.390 STATEOFNEW JERSEY

))

ss:

COUNTYOFCAMDEN

)

Kimberly

Manzione, being duly sworn,deposes andsays:

Thatshehasreadtheforegoing affidavit andthemattersstated therein aretrueand correct tothebest ofherknowledge, information, andbelief.

Executed

atCamden, NewJersey, this315 dayofAugust 2021 7

, v)/'

Kimberly Manzione Licensing Manager Holtec International p,

3 f

/

a lf

- a J

Erika Grandrimo NOTARY PUBUC STATE OFNEWJERSEY MYCOMMISSION EXPlRES January 17,2022 5of5