ML21027A384

NRC-2018-000513 - Resp 3 - Interim. Agency Records Subject to the Request Enclosed, Part 4 of 8

ML21027A384
Person / Time
Issue date:	01/25/2021
From:	NRC/OCIO
To:
Shared Package
ML21027A378	List: ML21027A379 ML21027A380 ML21027A381 ML21027A382 ML21027A384 ML21027A385 ML21027A386 ML21027A387 ML21027A389
References
FOIA, NRC-2018-000513
Download: ML21027A384 (157)

Text

{{#Wiki_filter:From: EOIA Resource To : LSCriscione@hotmail com Cc : Stevens Margo Subject : FO IA/PA-20 16-0725 Final Response Date: Monday, Ma rch 20 , 20 17 11 :02:22 AM The attached final response is publicly available Attachments: 2016-0725#2 Released Set.pd! in ADAMS as ML20294A126.

Dear Mr. Criscione:

Please find attached NRC's final response to your FOIA request, FOIA/PA-2016-00725 . Please take a moment to help us improve our FOIA processes , and let us know what your experience has been . Just click on this embedded link: http *//www ore gov/read jng - rm/foja/fo ja-user- su rvey .ht ml. Once you have completed the survey , just click the "SUBMIT" button and your survey response will be returned t o us . Thank you , Freedom of Information, Privacy & Information Collections Branch Customer Service Division , Office of the Chief Information Officer Mail Stop: T-5F09 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington , D.C. 20555-0001 FOIA .Resource@nrc.gov Ph: 301 -415- 7169 Fax : 301 -415- 5130

From: Stevens Margo To: APAMS IM Subject : RE: Changing Profile/Availability of Records Responsive to FOIA-2016-0725 Date: Monday, March 20, 2017 10:45:00 AM Thanks! Jvtar-go £. Stevens J'OI.J\. .J\.na(ysl/Team Lead"er (Conlraclor) OCIO/(i/EJvtS/Information Services 'Branch 'U.S. :Nudear Regu{atory Commission 11545 'Rocflvi((e 1'1ke, :Mai{ Stoy T-2:f7 Rockviffe, :Mary(antf 20855 Te(eyfwne #: (301) 415-8148 From: ADAMS IM Sent: M onday, March 20, 2017 10:45 AM To: Stevens, M argo <Margo.Stevens@nrc.gov>

Subject:

RE : Changi ng Profile/Availa bility of Records Responsive to FOIA-2016-0725 Done ML1010271591 & M L102910480 have been changed to publicly available.

Thanks, Wendy DeWolfe, Acting on behalf of ADAMS IM From: Stevens, Margo Sent: M onday, March 20, 2017 6:12 AM To: ADAMS IM <ADAMSSupport Email @nrc.gov>

Subject:

RE: Changi ng Profile/Availabilit y of Records Responsive to FOIA-2016-0725 Yes! (Sorry, I had already left for the day when you sent your reply back.) .Margo£. Stevens

fOI.51.. .J\.na{yst/Team Lea<,{er (Contractor)

OCIO/(j'IJvtS/Information Services 'Branch '!LS. :Nuc(ear 'Regu(atory Commission

11545 R.ockvi((e 'Pike, Jvt.ai{ Stoy T'-2)'7 'R.ockv1ffe, Jvt.aryCana 20855 T'efeyfione #: (301) 415-8148 From: ADAMS IM Sent: Friday, March 17, 2017 3:04 PM To: Stevens, M argo <Margo.Stevens@nrc.gov>

Subject:

RE: Changi ng Profile/Availability of Records Responsive to FOIA-2016-0725 Importance: High Hi Margo, We just saw your email and believe this is the request - you are asking for ML100271591 and ML102910480 to be released ..... is this the request you are waiting for? From: Stevens, Margo Sent: Friday, March 17, 2017 1:09 PM To: ADAMS IM <ADAMSSupport Email@n rc gov>

Subject:

Changing Profile/Availability of Records Responsive to FOIA-2016-0725 Good afternoon. As a result of a release of documents under FOIA/PA-2016-0725, please change the ava ilability to public, sensitivity to non-sensit ive, t he release date to immediate release, and add SU NSI Review Complete and FOIA to the keyword field of the following records: ML100271591. Not e th is record was previously released with redact ions du ri ng t he processing of FOIA/PA-2012-0128 as ML12363A085. It has been determined that the concurre nce page previously redacted as "outside scope" shou ld be restored, and t hat the exact text of item 3, which had been redacted under 7F, had been released in ML103430047. Please strike-out t he restrictive header/footer. ML102910480. Note this record was previously released as ML102990064, as part of FOIA/PA-2013-0213 (web package is ML14154A304). Perhaps it was given a new ML# just to accommodate the st rike-out of t he restrictive header/footer. Maybe t hat was t he practice a f ew years back, but since t his requester has asked for t he document by its original M L#, and consistent with our current practice, we wanted to change its profile/ava ilability as well. Thanks.

Margo L. Stevens J'OI.'A .'Ana{yst/Team Leaaer (Contractor)

OCIO/(j'E:MS/Information Services 'Branen 'U.S. Nudear 'Regu{atory Commission 11545 'Rockvi((e 'Pike, :Mai{ Stoy 'T'-2:J7 'Rockviffe, :M.ary{ana 20855 Te[eylione #: (301) 415-8148

From: Suttenberg Jeremy To: Stevens Margo Subject : RE: FOIA_2016-0725 Date: Friday, March 17, 201 7 12:30:20 PM Yes, you have my NLO. From: Stevens, Ma rgo Sent: Friday, March 17, 2017 11:00 AM To: Suttenberg, Jeremy <Jeremy.Sutt enberg@ nrc.gov>

Subject:

FOIA_ 2016-0725 Importance: High Jeremy, I wanted to drop a quick note of thanks for this one. I now have it back from the OGC mailroom with your NLO. I note that during the time when it was sent over to OGC for concurrence review, and now, the revision to Form 464 (which reflects the 90 days in which to appeal adverse determinations) has been completed. So, when I thought the package was lost, I recreated the response on the newly revised Form 464 (which eliminates all the verbiage we had to use while the rule was finalized to implement the 90 day period); can I ask you for a quick email confirming your NLO, which I can include in the file? That way I can use the revised Form 464 response (which won't have your handwritten concurrence in the grid). Thanks.

Margo L. Stevens

fOI..'A. ..'A.na[yst/'T'eam £.ead'er (Contractor)

OUO/(i1":M.S/Informatwn Services 'Brandi 'U.S. Nudear 'Regufotory Commission 11545 'Rocl?.vi((e Til?.e, Jvtai{ Stoy 'T'-2_f7 'Rocl?.viffe, Jvtaryfanc{ 20855 'T'e{eylione #: (.~01) 415-8148

From: Admio Adm i To: LSCriscione@hotmail com Cc: Stevens Margo Subject : FOIA/PA-2016-0725 Interim #1 The attached interim #1 response is publicly Date: Friday, February 24, 2017 7 :27:02 AM Attachments: Interim Response #1 .pdf available in ADAMS as ML20294A125.

Dear Mr. Criscione:

We are pleased to inform you that we have completed some work on your request , FOIA/PA-2016-00725. We are continuing to process your request. Thank you . Freedom of Information , Privacy & Information Collections Branch Customer Service Division , Office of the Chief Information Officer Mail Stop: T-5F09 U.S . Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555-0001 FO IA.Resource@nrc.gov Ph : 301 -415-7169 Fax: 301-415-5130

From : Stevens Margo To : RidsNrrMai!Cen ter Resource Cc : Kauffman Usa : Stevens Margo Subject : FOIA/PA-2016-00725 Action Item/ Instructions Review of Referred Records Date: Tuesday, February 21, 20 17 12:48:42 PM

                                                                                        ~------------------~

The attached request is publicly Attachments: 2016-0725-r.pdf available in ADAMS as ML20294A123. A referral for FOIA/PA-2016-00725 is being assigned to NRR on February 2 1, 201 7. The due date is March 6, 2017, which is ten ( 10) working days from the date of this e-mail. The action needing to be taken: _ _ Provide your office's concurrence or non -concurrence in the originating office's recommendations for disclosure or withholding of each record; or _xxx Provide a disclosure determination/recommend ation for each record that was identified by another office as a record for which your office is responsible and which is subject to this request: or _ _ Provide a di closure determination/recommendation for eac h record that was referred to the NRC for review or consul tation by [insert name of other agency]. (b)(5) The Government Information Specialist for this request is Margo Stevens, who can be reached at 30 1-4 15-8 148. or Margo.Stevens@ nrc.gov. Thank you.

From : Stevens Margo To : Blaney Stephanie Subject : FO IA-2016-0725 Date: Friday, February 17, 2017 2:57:00 PM (b)(5) JvlaYEJO L. Stevens ]'OIJ\. :Ana[yst/I'eam Leaaer (Contractor) OCIO/(j'EMS/Infonnation Services 'Brandi 'lLS. :Nudear 'Regu{atory Commission 11545 1{ockvi((e Pike, Jvl.ai[Stoy I'-2]'7 Rockvi((e, Jvt.ary[ana 20855 I'e[eyfwne #: (301) 415-8148

From: Blaney Stephanie To: Stevens Margo Subject : RE: FOIA-2017-0725 Date: Wednesday, February 15, 2017 8:33:00 AM I will look at this today after our clean up. Stephanie From: Stevens, Margo Sent: Tuesday, February 14, 2017 2 :20 PM To: Blaney, Stephanie <Stephanie.Blaney@nrc.gov>

Subject:

FOIA-2017-0725 Stephanie, this is one of the "Criscione" group from Larry himself. It asks for 13 records, all of which pre-existed the whistleblower matter and all werP. already in ADAMS, so the Mls remain correct. ( (b)(5) But otherwise, it's ready to go!

Margo .£. Stevens J'OI.:A .:Ana(yst/Team Leader (Contractor) 0O0/(jl:MS/'USer Services&J'OI.'A/'Pnvacy 'Brandi

'I.LS. Nudear '.Regufotory Commission 11545 '.Rockvi((e Tike, :Mai[ Stoy 'T-2:f7

1wc~viffe, Jvf.ary[anc[ 20855 'T'efeyfwne #: (301) 415-8148

From: Stevens Margo To: NRO EOIA Resource: RidsNrrMai!Center Resource : EO IAPARES Resource Cc: Correa Yessie: Kauffman Lisa : Warner Deanna Subject : FOIA_2016 -0725 Date: Thursday, January 19, 2017 1:57:00 PM Attachments: ML15356A158 /redaction auestionsl.odf Hello again, ladies. Here is the document that corresponds to the referral tasking I just sent through FOIA Xpress. The attached record reflects the internal Jvt.argo L. Stevens deliberations as to the manner in which the

JOJ..'A. ..'A.na[yst/T'eam Leaaer (Contractor) record should be processed and , accordingly, is OCIO/CS'IJ/TPI'B withheld in its entirety under FOIA exemption 5.

The record (as ultimately processed) is 'U.S. :Nudear 'Regufatory Commission addressed in multiple FOIA responses, including 11545 'RocR.vi((e 'PiR.e, Jvf.ai{ Stoy T-2:J7 interim response# 3 to your NRC-2018-000096. XocRvi((e, Jvf.ary{ana 20855 This response is publicly available in ADAMS as T'efeyfwne #: (301) 415-8148 ML20288A414.

From: Stevens Margo To : NRO EO IA Resource Cc : Correa Yessie: Kauffman Lisa: Warner Deanna : Stevens Margo Subject : FOIA/PA-2016-00725 Action Item/ Instructions Review of Referred R e c o r d s ~ - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~ Date: Thursday, January 19, 2017 1:55 :43 PM The attached req uest is publicly available in Attachments: 2016-0725. odf ADAMS as ML20294A123. A referral for FOIA/PA-2016-00725 is being assigned to NRO on January 19, 2017_ The due date is February 2, 2017, which is ten (10) work.ing days from the date of this e-mail. The action needing to be 1aken: (b)(5) I know you are working on the earlier tasking (although with one less document to deal with given OGC's role) . SO, I have given you a full 10 days to work wi th this one. NRC Form 496, "Report of Staff Resources for Proce sing FOIA Request" is available in the RC Forms Library for your use. The Government Information Specialist for this request is Margo Stevens, who can be reached at 301-415-8148. or Margo.Stevens@ nrc.gov. Thank you.

From: Stevens Margo To : RidsNrrMai!Cen ter Resource Cc : NRO FOIA Resource : Correa Yessie: EOIAPARES Resource : Warner Deanna Subject : Referral in FOIA-2016-0731 (and 2016 -0725) Date: Tuesday, January 10, 2017 9 :38:00 AM Attachments: ML112430114 re-review 7F lcomoressedLodf Hopefully, this will be the last email , wh ich attaches the sixth record. This is email #3. The attached record reflects the internal Jvt.argo L. Stevens deliberations as to the manner in which the

fOI.Jl .Jlna[yst/'J'eam Leaaer (Contractor) record should be processed and, OCJO/CS'lJ/:fTI'B accordingly, is withheld in its entirety under

'lLS. :Nudear 'Regu[atory Commission FOIA exemption 5. The record (as 11545 1wclivi((e Tilie, Jvl.ai[ Stoy Y:.2:f7 ultimately processed) is addressed in 1wcliviffe, Jvl.ary[ana 20855 multiple FOIA responses, including interim 'J'e[eyfione #: {301) 415-8148 response# 3 to your NRC-2018-000096. This response is publicly available in ADAMS as ML20288A414.

The attached record reflects the internal deliberations as to the manner in which the record should be processed and, accordingly, is withheld in its entirety From: Stevens Margo under FOIA exemption 5. The record To : RidsNrrMai!Cen ter Resource (as ultimately processed) is addressed Cc: NRO EO IA Resource : Correa Yessie: EOIAPARES Resource : Warner Deanna Subject : Referral in FOIA-2016-0731 (and 2016 -0725) in multiple FOIA responses, including Date: Tuesday, January 10, 2017 9:36:00 AM interim response# 3 to your NRC-2018-Attachments: ML15356A158 re-review 7F /compressedl.odf 000096. This response is publicly - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - available in ADAMS as ML20288A414. Here is one of the two remaining records (I had to compress it to be able to send it, even by itself). This is email #2. There should be one more email ......

Margo L. Stevens

[OJ.JI.. .Jl..na{yst/Team Leader (Contractor)

OCIO/CS'D/:f'PI'B 'U.S. J\fudear 'ReguCa.tory Commission 11545 'Roclivi((e 1'ike, :Mai{ Stoy T-2:[7 'Roclivi((e, Jvlary{and 20855 Te{eyfwne #: (301) 415-8148

From : Stevens Margo To : RidsNrrMai!Cen ter Resource Cc : NRO EO IA Resource : Correa Yessie: EOIAPARES Resource : Warner Deanna: Kauffman Lisa Subject : Referral in FOIA-2016-0731 (and also 2016-0725) Date: Tuesday, January 10, 2017 9 :3 1 :00 AM Attachments: ML13063A170 re -review 5.pdf ML14325A850 re-review Zf odf ML1002z1591 re-review ZE odt ML100780084 re -review 7F.odf Ladies, as the tasking email just sent through FOIAXpress promised, here are the referred records for your staff's re-consideration . Outlook is telling me they are too large to send in one email, so I will be sendi ng a total of two emails. You should end up with six records. This is email #1 .

M.aYgo L. Stevens The four attached records had been processed under prior

fOI.J\. .J\.na{yst/Team Leaaer (Contractor) F0IA requests and were revisited in the course of multiple OCIO/CS'D/]"'PI13 requests, including your NRC-2018-000096; they reflect the

'U.S. Nudear negu{atory Commission internal deliberations as to the manner in which the record 11545 'Rockvi((e Pike, Jvt.ai{ Stoy T-2:f7 should be processed and, accordingly, are withheld in their 'Rockviffe, Jvt.ary{ana 20855 entirety under F0IA exemption 5. The records (as ultimately processed) are addressed in multiple F0IA responses, Te{eylione #: (301) 415-8148 including interim response# 3 to your NRC-2018-000096; This response is publicly available in ADAMS as ML20288A414.

From: Stevens Margo To: BidsNrrMai!Center Resource Cc: Kauffman usa: Correa Yessje: warner Deanna: Stevens Margo

Subject:

FOIA/PA-2016-00731 Action Item/ Instructions Review of Referred Records ~ - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~ Date: Tuesd ay, January 10, 2017 9:25:18 AM The attached request is publicly Attachments: 2016-0731 .pdf available in ADAMS as ML20294A139. A referral for FOI A/PA-2016-0073 1 is being t1ssigned to NRR on January 10, 20 17. The due dale is January 25, 2017, whic h is 1en ( 10) working days from 1he dale of 1his e-ma il. The Govemme111 ln forma1ion Specialist for this request is Margo S1eve11s, who can be reached at 30 1-4 15-8148, or Margo.Stevens@nrc.gov. Of 1hc many records requested in the attached request arc six (6) records that have been processed previo usly under the FOIA (in some instances, more than once). Due to the ir size, I will attempt to email them to you directly from my Outlook, rather than lhrough FO!A Xpress; olherwise, I will bring you a CD wi1h 1hc m. The seven records are: (b)(5), (b)(6) NRC Form 496, "Report of Slaff Resources for Processing FOIA Request" is available in lhe NRC Forms Library for your use.

• • I hav e not included ML110740482, the preliminary version, dat ed 07/05/11, Screening An alysis Report on Flooding due to Upstream Dam Failures since the redacted text is the same)

Thank you.

From: fOIAPASECY Resource To: EOIA Resource Cc: Stevens Margo: Bates Andrew: Lewjs Antojnette: craver Patti: Mcc1oskey Brjdjn: Bavol Rochelle

Subject:

FOIA/PA-2016-00725

• SECY Response Date: Thursday, October 13, 2016 3:38:54 PM Attachments: FQIA 2016-0725: Memo pdf Harm Statement tor EQIA201 s-oz2s docx Good Afternoon, IPlease see attached memo. \

(b)(5) This closes SECY action. I Thanks, Kristy Kristy Remsburg Correspondence and Records Office of the Secretary U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Office: 301-415-1667 From: Stevens, Margo resource@nrc.gov Sent: Friday, Se ptember 23, 2016 8:25 AM To: FOIAPASECY Resource <FOIAPASECY.Resource@nrc.gov> Cc: Stevens, Margo <Margo.Stevens@nrc.gov>

Subject:

FOIA/PA-2016-00725 Act ion Item/Instructions Sea rch for Records in Perfected Request Offices Assigned Action on September 23, 2016; SECY The requester has either agreed to pay the estimated fees, or has provided an advance payment, or there are no billable fees. The request is now considered "perfected." Please provide the Government Information Specia.list. who is named below, with the responsive records on o r before October 6, 2016, which is ten (IO) working days from the date of thi s e-mai l. The Government Information Specialist for this request is Margo Stevens, who can be reached at 301-415-8148 or Mar~o Stcvcos@ncc ~oy. (b)(5) Note also that this same record has been requested in FOIA-2016-07~ I from Lucas Hixson. Enformable. I will not be send in a separate task in' for ii' if you need a CO!)Y of that re uest for your files. please let me know and I will send it to you. If there are no responsive records, please respond with "No records." If you believe any other office, not copied on this e-mail, may have responsive records, please let the assigned specialist know. The FO\A request s hould be processed in accordance with the standard instructions (How to Respond to a FOIA Request) at ML16123Al64. NRC Form 5 1 I, "Program Office Response to a FOIA Request" is available in the NRC Forms Library for your use.

In order to document the search conducted, in the event of an appeal challenging the adequacy of the search, please also have each member of your staff who conduc ts a search complele NRC Form 5 I !A. "Doc umen1a1ion of a FOIA Search," which is also avai lable in lhe RC Forms Library for your use. Please review these forms 10 ensure that an adeq uate, and consistenl, search has been performed within your office. Then inc lude copies of the completed NRC Forms 5 11 A along wi1h the NRC Form 51 1 you return to 1he assigned specialist. Allernatively, you may complete the RC Form 51 1A on behalf of your office, based upon the descriptions of searches provided to you by your office staff. You are encouraged to ask fo r assistance in performing adequate ADAMS searches if you have any difficulty doing a search. NRC Form 496, "Report of Slaff Resources for Processing FOIA Requests" is also available in the NRC Forms Library for your use. When you respond, please make sure that you are sendi ng your response 10 F0 IA.Resource@nrc. gov , as well as the ass igned spec ialist. Thank you.

NRC FORM 51 1 U.S. NUCLEA R REGULATORY COMMISSION (11-2015) PROGRAM OFFICE RESPONSE TO A FOIA REQUEST TO: Government Information Spedallst I FOIA, Privacy & Information

• Margo Stevens Collections Branch (FPIB)

FROM: FOIA Coordinator IKristy Remsburg, Office of the Secretary

SUBJECT:

FOIA - 201 6-0725 Section 1. Is this a partial D or final response [ZJ to this request? (Check only one). Section 2. DISCLOSURE RECOMMENDATION: How do you recommend the responsive records be handled? (b)(5) Section 3. PERSONAL RECORDS: Did anyone in your office identify personal records that pertain to this request? If so, make sure the employee completes NRC Form 510, Personal Records Checklist, attach a copy, and note in Section 9 whether the employee or FOIA Coordinator is retaining the records, which must be kept for six years. Section 4. SEARCH: Staff in your office must undertake a search that is reasonably calculated to locate all records responsive to the request. Each person in your office that is asked to search must complete the attached NRC Form 511A, FOIA Search. You should review the forms to ensure that they are completed properly and reflect a consistent and adequate search. Attach all NRC Forms 511A. (b)(5) NRC FORM 511 (11 -2015) Page 1 of 2

NRC FORM 511 U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION (11-2015) PROGRAM OFFICE RESPONSE TO A FOIA REQUEST (Continued) SUBJECT : FOIA - . _ I_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ 2_0_1_6-_0_7_ 25_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _.I Section 7. INCLUDE IN PUBLIC ADAMS: The NRC places FOIA responses (including released records) in public ADAMS unless the records contain information personal to the requester, involve matters that are not Ii <P.lv tn ho nf n, ,h i ;~ int<>rP.* t, or contain privileged or confidential information that should only be disclosed to the requester. (b)(5) Do any of the records fall under one of these three exceptions to public availability? Section 8. fEES..;_ If the actual time spent searching or reviewing records, or number of pages, u1uers 1rom me ,ee esumate given previously, complete and attach NRC Form 496, Report of Staff Resources for Processing FOIA Requests. Section 9. COMMENTS: Please include any other comments that we should know about. In lieu of bracketing the responsive records, you may include a description of the records, or information within the records, that you recommend be redacted, including the exemption(s) that should be claimed. (Attach separate pages, if needed). NRC FORM 511 (11 -2015) Page 2 of 2

(b)(5) From: Stevens Margo To: Remsburg Kristy Subject : RE: FOIA 2016-0725 Date: Thursday, September 29, 2016 8:21 :00 AM The attached request is publicly available in ADAMS Attachments: Hixson incoming reauest.doc)( as ML20294A139. voila Jvlargo L. Stevens ]'01.'A. .Jlna(yst/Team Leaaer (Contractor) OCIO/CS'D/J"Pl'B 'U.S. :Nudear 'Regulatory Commission 11545 1{ocw.vi((e JJ//;.e, :Mai{ Stoy T-2]"7 'Rockviffe, :Mary(ana 20855 Te(epfrone #: (301) 415-8148 From: Remsburg, Kristy Sent: Thursday, September 29, 2016 8:11 AM To: Stevens, M argo <M argo.St evens@nrc.gov>

Subject:

FOIA 20 16-0725 Good Morning, I need Lucas Hixson's request for the SECY FY 2013 Operating Plan please.

Thanks, Kristy Kristy Remsburg Correspondence ond Records Office of the Secretary U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Office: 301-415-1667

From: Stevens Margo To: Blaney Stephanie Cc: Argent Nina This response is publicly available in ADAMS as

Subject:

FW: FOINPA-2016-0451 Final Response Date: Friday, September 23, 2016 2:52:00 PM ML16273A128. Attachments: FQIA-2016-0451121 odl (b)(5) Assuming there isn't any reason , I assume we can now ask whomever to get it to DPC?

Margo L Stevens J'OI.Jt .Jl na(ysl/'T'eam Leaaer (Contractor)

OCIO/CS1J/J'1'l'B 11.S. :Nudear Regu(atory Commission 11545 'Rocfvi((e Ttfie, Jvlai{ Stoy 'T'-2;*1 'l{ocli'v1((e, Jvlary(ana 20855 'T'e{eyfrone #: (301) 415-8148 From: Francis, Lezlie Sent: Friday, September 23, 2016 10:59 AM To: Stevens, M argo <M argo.St evens@nrc.gov>

Subject:

FW: FOIA/PA-2016-0451 Final Response Here is the final response. I will work with Cynthia to get it into ADAMS. Lezlie J Francis FOIA Analyst (Contractor) OCIO/CSD/FPIB U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 11545 Rockville Pike, Mail Stop T-2F15 Rockville, Maryland 20855 301-415-5966 From: Adm in, Admin [mailto*foia resource@nrc gov] Sent: Wednesday, August 17, 2016 2:09 PM To: pmblanch@comcast net Cc: Francis, Lezlie <Lezlie Francis@nrc gov>

Subject:

FOIA/PA-2016-0451 Fina l Response

Dear Mr. Blanch:

Please find attached NRC's final response to your FOIA request, FOIA/PA-2016-00451. Please take a moment to help us improve our FOIA processes, and let us know what your experience has been. Just click on this embedded link: http-//www nrc gov/readjng-rm/foja/foja-user-survey.htm). Once you have completed the survey, just click the "SUBMIT" button and your survey response will be returned to us. Thank you, Freedom of Information, Privacy & Information Collections Branch Customer Service Division, Office of the Chief Information Officer Mail Stop: T-5F09 U.S. Nuclear Regu latory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555-0001 FOIA.Resource@nrc.gov Ph: 301-415-7169 Fax: 301-415-5130

From: Stevens Margo To: Stevens Margo Subject : FW: FOIA/PA-2016-00725 Action Item/Instructions Search for Records in Perfected Request The attached request is publicly Date: Friday, September 23, 2016 8:25:00 AM available in ADAMS as Attachments: 2016-0725-r.od( ML20294A123. Also at issue in 2016-0731 Jvlargo L. Stevens J"Ol.'A. .'A.na(yst/Team Leaaer (Contractor) OCIO/CS'D/J"Pl'B 'U.S. :Nudear 'Regulatory Commission 11545 1{oc/;,vi((e JJ//;,e, :Mai{ Stoy T-2]"7 'Rockviffe, :Mary(ana 20855 Te(epfrone #: (301) 415-8148 From: Stevens, Margo resou rce@nrc.gov Sent: Friday, September 23, 2016 8:25 AM To: FO IAPASECY Resource <FOIAPASECY.Resource@nrc.gov> Cc: Stevens, Margo <Margo.Stevens@n rc.gov>

Subject:

FOIA/PA-2016-00725 Action Item/Instructions Sea rch for Records in Perfected Request Offices Assi2ned Action on September 23 2016: SECY The requester has either agreed to pay the estimated fees, or has provided an advance payment. or there are no billable fees. The request is now considered "perfected." Please provide the Government Information Specialist, who is named below, with the responsive records on or before October 6, 2016, which is ten ( 10) working days from the date or this e-mail. The Government Information Specialist for this request is Margo Stevens, who can be reached at 301 -4 15-8148 or Margo.Stevcns@nrc.gov. (b)(5) If there are no responsive records, please respond with "No records." If you believe any other ol'lice. not copied on this e-1m; il. may have responsive records, please let the assigned specialist know. The FOlA request should be processed in accordance with the standard instructions (How to Respond to a FOlA Request) at ML16123Al64. NRC Form 511, "Program Office Response to a FOIA Request" is available in the NRC Forms Library for your use. ln order 10 document the search conducted, in the event of an appeal challenging the adequacy of the search, please also have each member of your staff who conducts a search complete NRC Form 511A, "Documentation of a FOTA Search," which is also available in the NRC Forms Library for your use. Please review these forms to ensure that an adequate, and consistent, search has been performed wi thin your ol'lice. Then incl ude copies of the completed NRC Forms 5 11A along with the NRC Form 511 you ret urn to the

assigned specialist. Alternatively, you may complete the RC Form 51 l A on behalf of your office, based upon the descriptions of searches provided to you by your office staff. You are encouraged to ask for assistance in performing adequate ADAMS searches if you have any difficulty doing a search. NRC Form 496, "Report of Staff Resources for Processing FOIA Reques ts" is also available in the NRC Forms Library for your use. When you respond, please make sure that you are sending your response to FOIA Resource@nrc gov , as well as the assigned specialist. Thank you.

From : Stevens Margo To : NRO EO IA Resource: RidsNrrMai!Center Resource Cc : Correa Yessie: Kauffman Lisa: Stevens Margo The attached request is publicly Subject : FOIA/PA-2016-00725 Action Item/ Instructions Search for Records in Perfected Request available in ADAMS as Date: Tuesday, September 20, 2016 12:07:37 PM Attachments: 2016-0725-r.pdf ML20294A123. Offices Assigned Action on September 20, 20 I6; NRO ;NRR The requester has ei ther agreed to pay the estimated fees, or has provided an advance payment, or there are no bill able fees. The request is now considered "perfected." Please provide the Government Information Specialist, who is named below, with the responsive records on or before October 3, 2016, which is ten ( I 0) working days from the date of this e-mail. The Government Info rmation Specialist fo r this request is Margo Stevens, who can be reached at 30 1-4 15-8 148 or Margo_Stcvcns@nrc.gov. (b)(5) The FOIA request should be processed in accordance with the standard instructions (How to Respond to a FOIA Request) at ML16123A164 . NRC Form 5 11 , "Program Office Response to a FO[A Request" is available in the NRC Forms Library for your use. In order to document the search conducted , in the event of an appeal challenging the adeq uacy of the search, please also have each member of your staff who conduc ls a search complete RC Forni 51 lA , "Doc umen1ation of a FOIA Search," which is also available in the RC Forms Library for your use. Please review these forms 10 ensure that an adequate, and consistent, search has been performed within your office. Then include copies o f the completed NRC Form 51 1A along with the NRC Form 51 1 you return to the assigned specialist. Alternatively, you may complete the RC Form 51 1A on behalf of your office, based upon the descriptions of searches provided to you by your office staff. You are encouraged to ask for assistance in performing adequate ADAMS searches if you have any difficulty doi ng a search. NRC Form 496, "Report of Staff Resources for Processing FOIA Requests" is also avail able in the NRC Forms Library for your use. When you respond, please make s ure that you are sending your response 10 FOIA.Resource@nrc.iov, as well as the ass igned spec ialist. Thank you.

From: Stevens Margo To : Dennis Suzanne Subject : More of "those" requests Date: Thursday, September 15, 2016 11 :05 :00 AM Importance: High Suzanne, if I may impose on you for two things. First, can you check with Janene about the St. Lucie flooding video clip that she was going to put on a CD for me? I need to send it to NRR and RII for their views .. . (b)(5) Thanks. Jvt.argo L. Stevens

JOIJ\. ..'A.na(yst/'Team Leaaer (Contractor)

OCIO/CS'D/f'PI"B 'U.S. J\fudear 'Regu{atory Commission 11545 'Rockvi((e 'Pike, :Mai{ Stoy T-2f7 'Rockvi[(e, :Mary(anc( 20855 'Te[eyfione #: (301) 415-8148

From: Dennis Suzanne To: Stevens Margo Subject : RE: New FOIA Request (FOIA_2016-0725 Date: Thursday, September 15, 2016 8:17:21 AM Looking at it - I'm thinking that there must have been a printing error - I don't remember seeing it. It's 92 pages, so I'll bring a copy down this morning. Suzanne From: Stevens, Margo Sent: Thursday, September 15, 2016 8:11 AM To: Dennis, Suzanne <Suzanne.Denn is@nrc.gov>

Subject:

RE: New FOIA Request (FOIA_2016-0725 Good point! _l (b_)(_5)_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ Also - the package you gave me yesterday. I don't seem to see: ML16242A333 - 2016-Sep-8 Criscione et.al. comments submitted under 5USC1213(1)(e) regarding the NRG Chairman's 2016-June-30 response to the US Special Counsel concerning OSC File No. DI-15-5252 on flooding at reactor sites due to upstream dam failures

Margo L Stevens

fOI.Jl. .Jl.na[yst/'T'eam Leacfer (Contractor)

OCIO/CS1J/:f'PI'B 'U.S. :Nudear 1{eguuitory Commission 11545 '.Rocfi.vi[{e 'Pifi.e, Jvt.a1{ Stoy 'T'-2J"7 'Rocfi.vi((e, :Ma ry(and 20855 'T'e{eyfwne #: (301) 415-8148 From: Dennis, Suzanne Sent: Thursday, September 15, 2016 8:10 AM To: Stevens, M argo <Margo Stevens@nrc gov>

Subject:

RE: New FOIA Request (FOIA_2016-0725 ML16238A005 - Interview ofl(b)(7)(C) ~ redacted - has the first page "This the FOIA release of the document.. ." October 19, 2012 ML16238A006 - Interview of (b)(7)(C) - redacted - October 23, 2012 ML16238A007 - Interview of redacted - October 24, 2012 ML16238A008 - Interview of (b)(?)(C) - redacted - November 29, 2012

From: Stevens, Margo Sent: Thursday, September 15, 2016 8:07 AM To: Dennis, Suzanne <Suzanne Denn js@nrc gov>

Subject:

RE: New FOIA Request (FOIA_ 2016-0725 Suzanne, since the interviews are all redacted, I can't differentiate. Can you tell me the dates of them?

Margo L Stevens J'OI.'A Jlna(yst/'ream £.eaaer (Contractor)

OCIO/CS1>/]Pl'B '11.S. :Nudear 'Regu(atory Commission 11545 'Rockvi[(e 1'1ke, :Mai{ Stoy 'J'.-2:[7 'R.ockv,((e, :.Mary(anlf 20855 're(eyfrone #: (301) 415-8148 From: Dennis, Suzanne Sent: Thursday, September 15, 2016 7:55 AM To: Stevens, M argo <Margo Stevens@nrc gov>

Subject:

RE: New FOIA Request (FOIA_ 2016-0725 ML16238A005 - Interview of (b)(l)(C) - redacted ML16238A006 - Interview of (b)(7)(C) redacted ML16238A007 - Interview of b 7 c - redacted ML16238A008 - Interview of (b)(7)(C) - redacted ML16242A333 - 2016-Sep-8 nscIone et.a . comments submitted under 5USC1213(1 )(e) regarding the NRG Chairman's 2016-June-30 response to the US Special Counsel concerning OSC File No. DI-15-5252 on flooding at reactor sites due to upstream dam failures ML16244A008 - 2012-Dec-10 email from Criscione to Commissioner Ostendorff and follow up correspondence arranging an Open Door policy meeting on the Oconee flooding issues ML16252A004 - 2016-Sep-9 Cover Letter for 5USC1213(1 )(e) comments submitted regarding the Chairman's 2016-June-30 response to the US Special Counsel concerning OSC File No. DI-15-5252 Does that help? Thanks Margo!! From: Stevens, Margo Sent: Wednesday, September 14, 2016 1:24 PM

To: Dennis, Suzanne <Suzanne.Dennis@nrc.gov>

Subject:

RE: New FOIA Request (FOIA_2016-0725 Suzanne, I've been working on the "matrix" but I do think it would ease things for me if you could associate the 7 docs you handed me with the ML#s to which they belong ..... Thanks.

Mar-go L Stevens

fOIJl. Jl.na(yst/'I'eam Lea<.fey (ContrnctoY)

OCIO/CS'D/:f'PI'B 'l.LS. Nudear 'Regu(atory Commission 11545 'Rodivi((e 'Pike, :Mail Stoy 'T'-2:[7 'Rockvi((e, Jvtary(ana 20855 'J'e(eyfrone #: (301) 415-8148 From: Dennis, Suzanne Sent: Wednesday, September 14, 2016 9:53 AM To: Correia, Richard <Bichard.Correja@nrc.gov>; Stevens, Margo <Margo.Steveos@nrc.gov> Cc: Littlejohn, Jennene <Jennene Ljttleiobn@nrc gov>; Peters, Sean <Sean Peters@nrc gov>; Thagga rd, Mark <Mark.Thaggard@nrc.gov>

Subject:

RE: New FOIA Request (FOIA_2016-0725 These are the 7 I printed yesterday. © Suzanne From: Correia, Richard Sent: Wednesday, September 14, 2016 9:48 AM To: Stevens, Margo <Margo.Stevens@nrc.gov> Cc: Littlejohn, Jennene <Jennene Ljttlejohn@nrc gov>; Peters, Sean <Sean Peters@nrc gov>; Thagga rd, Mark ; Dennis, Suzanne <Suzanne Dennis@nrc gov>

Subject:

RE : New FOIA Request (FOIA_2016-0725 I'll ask Jennene if she can access these. Richard P. Correia, P.E Director, Division 0£ Risk AnaltJsis OHice 0£ Nuclear Re5ula..tory Research U.S.NRC

From: Stevens, Ma rgo Sent: M onday, September 12, 2016 12:01 PM To: Correia, Richard <Richard .Correia@ nrc gov>

Subject:

RE: New FOIA Request (FOIA_ 2016-0725 Actually, since I wrote this, I learned that Lochbaum and Darth Vader also filed new requests; I have Larry's, Karen has been assigned the other two. There's a total of 35 more records he has added to ADAMS. I can access most, but not, all of them at the moment. Quite a few are audio files (which I didn't even know could be added to ADAMS) ; they are excerpts of his interview by OIG so I will be letting Stephanie know that we have more to tell Joe McMillan. Can you see whether your Administrative Assistant has access to the following items: ML16238A005 ML16238A006 ML16238A007 ML16238A008 ML16242A333 ML16244A008 ML16252A004 Jvlargo L Stevens JOI.'A .'Ana(ysl/Team £.eaaer (Contractor) OCIO/CSV/:f'PI13 'U.S. :Nudear 'ReguCatory Commission 11545 1?..ocuviffe 1Jtke, Jvla1{ Stoy T-2]"7 1{ocfi.vi((e, Jvlary(anc[ 20855 'Jdeyfwne #: (301) 415-8148 From: Correia, Richard Sent: M onday, September 12, 2016 11:57 AM To: Stevens, M argo <Margo.Stevens@nrc gov>

Subject:

RE : New FOIA Request (FOIA_ 2016-0725 Let me check Margo and I'll get back to your asap. Best

Richard P. Correia, P.E Director, Division of Risk Anal-ysis 0£fice of Nuclear Re5ulator-y Research U.S.NRC From: Stevens, Margo Sent: M ond ay, September 12, 2016 9:30 AM To: Corre ia, Richard <Ric hard.Correia@ nrc.gov>

Subject:

New FOI A Req uest (FOIA_2016-0725 Importance: High Good morning (again). I can do this through the proper channels but I wanted to let you know that Larry has fi led a new FOIA request for the 13 documents that he included in a single ADAMS package, with ML#16195A365. I know that it's all tied to the OSC matter because he added it to the privacy waiver he signed . So - I know th at you restricted access to the items he added . Can you (1) confirm that this package has also been restricted and (2) if so, can I get copies? Again, I'd like to be able to see whether they implicate the same OIG and OSC equities. Then , once I task RES , your staff can do its "SUNSl"/FOIA review per the usual 1O working day metric. Jvlargo L. Stevens

fOI.Jl .'Ana{yst/Team Lead"er (Contractor)

OCIO/CS'D/:f'Pl'B 'lLS. :Nudear 'Regu{atory Commission 11545 'RocR.vi((e 'PiR.e, Jvlai{ Stoy T-2:f7 'RocR.viffe, Jvlary{ana 20855 Te{eyfwne #: (301) 415-8148

From: Correia Richard To: Stevens Margo Cc: Thaggard Mark: warner Deanna: Pennis Suzanne

Subject:

RE: New FOIA Request (FOIA_20 16-0725 Date: Wednesday, September 14, 201 6 9:46:50 AM I have the list and my AA Jennene is moving these to a secu re drive and then remove them from ADAMS. I'll get a copy of ML16216A711 for you. Best Richard P. Correia, P.E Director, Division of Risk AnahJsis OHice of Nuclear Reaula.tory Research U.S.NRC From: Stevens, Margo Sent: Tuesday, September 13, 2016 9:10 AM To: Correia, Richard <Richard.Correia@ nrc.gov> Cc: Thaggard, Mark <M ark.Thaggard@nrc.gov>; Wa rner, Deanna <Deanna.Warner@nrc.gov>; Denn is, Suzanne <Suza nne.Den nis@ nrc.gov>

Subject:

RE: New FOIA Request (FOIA_ 2016-0725 If I may add one additional document that I cannot access in ADAMS - it's ML16216A711 , which LC describes as a March 13, 2015 UCS briefing package for Chairman Burns and Commissioner Baran. I received a new FOIA request assignment, in which LC asks for six of the records he included in ADAMS package ML16195A365. All but this document are included in one or more of the other requests we have been working on together, for which I already have access, or have requested it below.

Margo .£. Stevens J'OI.Jl .Jlna(ysl/Team I.ead'er (Contractor)

OCIO/CS'D/JPI'B 'U.S. :Nudear 'Regu{atory Commuswn 11545 'Rockvi((e 'Pike, Jvta 1( Stoy T-2:J7 1tockvi((e, Jvtary(ancf 20855 Te{e_plione #: (301) 415-8148

From: Correia, Richard Sent: M onday, Septem ber 12, 2016 12:17 PM To: Stevens, M argo <Margo.Stevens@nrc.gov> Cc: Thaggard, Mark <Mark.Thaggard@nrc.gov>; Warner, Deanna <Deanna.Warner@nrc.gov>; Denn is, Suzanne <Suzanne.Dennis@orc.gov>

Subject:

RE: New FOIA Request (FOIA_ 2016-0725 Will do Margo Richard P. Correia, P.E Director, Division of Risk Anall:Jsis Office of Nuclear Reaula.tory Research U.S.NRC From: Stevens, Ma rgo Sent: M onday, September 12, 2016 12:0 1 PM To: Correia, Richard <Richard .Correia@ nrc.gov>

Subject:

RE: New FOIA Request (FOIA_ 2016-0725 Actually, since I wrote this, I learned that Lochbaum and Darth Vader also filed new requests; I have Larry's, Karen has been assigned the other two. There's a total of 35 more records he has added to ADAMS. I can access most, but not, all of them at the moment. Quite a few are audio files (which I didn't even know could be added to ADAMS) ; they are excerpts of his interview by OIG so I will be letting Stephanie know that we have more to tell Joe McMillan. Can you see whether your Administrative Assistant has access to the following items: ML16238A005 ML16238A006 ML16238A007 ML16238A008 ML16242A333 ML16244A008 ML16252A004

Jvlargo £.. Stevens J'OI.Jl. .Jl.na{yst/'l'eam Leaaer (Contractor)

OCIO/CS1J/TPI'B 11.S. :Nudear 'Regu[atory Commission 11545 'Rockvi{(e 'Pike, :Mai{ Stoy '1-2:[1 1wckvi((e, :Mary{ana 20855 'J'e{epfione #: (.w1) 415-8148

From: Correia, Richard Sent: M onday, Septem ber 12, 2016 11:57 AM To: Stevens, M argo <Margo Stevens@nrc gov>

Subject:

RE: New FOIA Request (FOIA_ 2016-0725 Let me check Margo and I'll get back to your asap. Best Richard P. Correia, P.E Director, Division of Risk AnallJsis OHice of Nuclear Reaula.tory Research U.S.NRC From: Stevens, Ma rgo Sent: Monday, September 12, 2016 9:30 AM To: Correia, Richard <Richard.Correia@ nrc.gov>

Subject:

New FO IA Requ est (FOIA_2016-0725 Importance: High Good morning (again). I can do this through the proper channels but I wanted to let you know that Larry has filed a new FOIA request for the 13 documents that he included in a single ADAMS package, with ML#16195A365. I know t hat it's all tied to the OSC matter because he added it to the privacy waiver he signed. So - I know that you restricted access to the items he added. Can you (1) confirm that this package has also been restricted and (2) if so, can I get copies? Again, I'd like to be able to see whether they implicate the same OIG and OSC equities. Then, once I task RES , your staff can do its "SUNSl"/FOIA review per the usual 1Oworking day metric.

Margo L Stevens J'OIJ\ J\na(yst/'T'eam Leaaer (Contractor)

OCIO/CS1)/J'PI'B 'U.S. :Nudear 1{egu{atory Commission 11545 'Rocllvi{(e Tille, :Mai{ Stoy 'T'-2:f7 1wcuv1{(e, Jvtaryfanaw855 'T'e(epfione #: (301) 41.c;-8148

From: Stevens Margo To: Dennis Suzanne Subject : RE: New FOIA Request (FOIA_2016-0725 Date: Wednesday, September 14, 2016 6:18:00 AM I can come pick them up from you (or you, or someone on RES's staff, can deliver them to me at my cubicle, which is T-2F7). I have a meeting from 9-10 but otherwise should be around. Thanks.

Jvlargo L Stevens

.TOJ.J\ .J\.na(yst/'leam Leaaer (Contractor) OUO/CS'D/:f'PI'B 'U.S. :Nudear 'R.egufotory Commission 11545 'Rocl?.vi((e Til?.e, Jvtai{Stoy '1-2]'7 'Rockvi((e, Jvtary{ana 20855 'Je{eyfwne #: (301) 415-8148 From: Dennis, Suzanne Sent: Tuesday, September 13, 2016 3:29 PM To: Stevens, M argo <Margo.Stevens@nrc.gov>

Subject:

RE: New FOIA Request (FOIA_ 2016-0725 Hi Margo, I have print-outs of the below - what's the best way to get them to you?

Thanks, Suzanne From: Stevens, Ma rgo Se nt: M onday, Septem ber 12, 2016 12:01 PM To: Correia, Richard <Richard Correja@ nrc gov>

Subject:

RE : New FOIA Request (FOIA_ 2016-0725 Actually, since I wrote this, I learned that Lochbaum and Darth Vader also filed new requests; I have Larry's, Karen has been assigned the other two. There's a total of 35 more records he has added to ADAMS. I can access most, but not, all of them at the moment. Quite a few are audio files (which I didn't even know could be added to ADAMS) ; they are excerpts of his interview by OIG so I will be letting Stephanie know that we have more to tell Joe McMillan. Can you see whether your Administrative Assistant has access to the following items:

ML16238A005 ML16238A006 ML16238A007 ML16238A008 ML16242A333 ML16244A008 ML16252A004 Jvt.argo L Stevens ]'OIJl .'Ana[ysl/Team £.earier (Contractor) OCIO/CST>/TPI'B 'U.S. :Nudear 'Regu(atory Commission 11545 'Roclivil[e 1)i/~e. :Mai{Stoy T-2J*1 'Rocli:viffe, :Mary(ana 20855 Tdeyfione #: (301) 415-8148 From: Correia, Richard Sent: M onday, September 12, 2016 11:57 AM To: Stevens, M argo <Margo.Stevens@nrc gov>

Subject:

RE : New FOIA Request (FOIA_ 2016-0725 Let me check Margo and I'll get back to your asap. Best Richard P. Correia, P.E Director, Division of Risk A11altJsis Office of Nuclear Reaula.torl} Research U.S.NRC From: Stevens, Margo Se nt: M onday, September 12, 2016 9:30 AM To: Correia, Richard <Richard.Correja@nrc.gov>

Subject:

New FO IA Request (FOIA_2016-0725 Importance: High Good morning (again). I can do this through the proper channels but I wanted to let you know that Larry has filed a new FOIA request for the 13 documents that he included in a single ADAMS package, with ML#16195A365. I know that it's all tied to the OSC matter

because he added it to the privacy waiver he signed . So - I know that you restricted access to the items he added . Can you (1) confirm that this package has also been restricted and (2) if so, can I get copies? Again, I'd like to be able to see whether they implicate the same OIG and OSC equities. Then, once I task RES, your staff can do its "SUNSl"/FOIA review per the usual 1O working day metric. Jvt.argo L. Stevens

JOI.JI. .J\.na{yst/Team Leaaer (Contractor)

OCIO/CSD/TPI13 'U.S. J\fudear 'Regu{atory Commission 11545 'RocRvif{e 'PiRe, Jvlai{ Stoy T-2:[7 'Rocliviffe, Jvlaryrana 20855 Te{eyfwne #: (301) 415-8148

From: Stevens Margo To: Correia Richard : Clark Michael Cc: Ammon Beroiw Kirkwood Sara: Albert Michelle: Blaney stephanje: MorganButier Kjmyata B

Subject:

RE: Release of certain documents t o OSC Date: Monday, September 12, 2016 2 :57:00 PM (b)(5) J'vlargo L Stevens J"OJ.Jl Jlna{ysl/T'eam .lead"er (Contractor) OCIO/CS1J/]"PI13

 'U.S. :.Nudear 'Regu(atory Commission 11545 'Rockviffe Pike, :M.ai{ Stoy T'-2:J7 1?.ncli.viffe, :M.ary{ana 20855 T'efeyfwne #: (301) 415-8148 From: Correia, Richard Sent: M onday, September 12, 2016 2:52 PM To: Stevens, M argo <Margo.St evens@nrc.gov>; Clark, Michael <M ichael.Cla rk@nrc.gov>

Cc: Ammon, Bernice <Bern ice.Ammon@ nrc.gov>; Kirkwood, Sara <Sara.Kirkwood@nrc.gov>; Albert, M ichelle <Michell e.Albe rt@nrc.gov>; Blaney, Stephanie <Stephanie.Blaney@ nrc.gov>; Morga nBut ler, Kimyata R <Kimyata.MorganButler@nrc.gov>

Subject:

Re: Release of certain documents to OSC Mr Criscione wants to give OSC the documents he references in his rebuttal report\ ~b)(5) Rich Richard Corre ia, P.E. Director, Division of Risk Analysis

Office of Nuclear Regulatory Research USNRC On: 12 September 2016 14:36, "Stevens, Margo" <Margo Stevens@nrc.gov> wrote: If I may clarify a few points. (b)(5)

Margo L Stevens J'OI.'A .'Ana(yst/'Team Leatfer (Contractor)

OUO/CS'D/:f'PI'B 'U.S. :Nudear 1{egu{atory Commission 11545 'Rocfi.vi{(e Pili.e, Jvt.ai{Stoy 'T-2:[7 'RocRviffe, Jvt.ary(ana 20855 'Te(eylione #: (301) 415-8148 From: Clark, M ichael Sent: M onday, September 12, 2016 2:29 PM To: Correia, Richard <Richard Correja@nrc gov> Cc: Ammon, Bernice <Bernice Ammon@nrc gov>; Kirkwood, Sara <Sara Kirkwood@nrc gov>; Albert, M ichelle <Michelle Albert@nrc gov>; St evens, Margo <Margo Steveos@nrc.gov>

Subject:

RE : Release of certain documents to OSC Hi Rich, 5 Michelle forwarded me your question below. t_(b_)_( _) _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __

Thanks, Mike From: Correia, Richard Sent: Monday, September 12, 2016 2:08 PM To: Stevens, Margo <Margo Steveos@nrc gov>; Albert, Michell e <Michelle Albert@nrc gov> Cc: Thaggard, Mark <Mark.Thaggard@nrc.gov>; Denn is, Suzanne <Suzanne .Dennis@nrc.gov>; Warner, Deanna <Deanna .Warner@nrc.gov>

Subject:

Release of certain documents to OSC Michelle, Margo. Your counsel and advice on \ (b)(S) Rich Richard Correia, P .E. Director, Division of Risk Analysis Office of Nuclear Regulatory Research USNRC

From : Stevens Margo To : Danoff Karen Subject : New Requests Date: Monday, September 12, 2016 1:44 :00 PM When you return on Wednesday, I can fi ll you in on our newest requests from Messrs. Lochbaum and Vader fo r more records LC placed in ADAMS.

Margo L. Stevens

JOI:A. :A.na{yst/Team .£ead'er (Contractor)

OCIO/CS'D/:J"PI13 'l.1.S. :Nudear 'Regu{atory Commission 11545 'Rocli.vi((e 'Pi/i.e, Jvlai{ Stoy 'T'-2:J7 'Rocli.vi((e, Jvlary{and' 20855 Te{eyfwne #: (301) 415-8148

From: Stevens Margo To : LSCriscione@hotmail com Cc : Stevens Margo Subject : [2016-0725) ACK Memo Base

• Email Date: Monday, September 12, 2016 10 :50:35 AM Attachments: (20 16-07251 ACK Memo Base* Email.docx

thiUNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULA TORY COMMISSION WASHINGTON, D.C. 20555-000 I September 12, 2016 FOIA/PA-2016-00725 Mr. Lawrence Criscione 1412 Dial Court Springfield, IL 62704

Dear Mr. Criscione:

We received your Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request on September 12, 2016. Your request, which seeks access to thirteen enumerated documents, each of which carry its own ML#, but which have also assembled into a single ADAMS package under ML#16195A365, has been assigned the following reference number that you should use in any future communications with us about your request: FOIA/PA-2016-00725. To ensure the most equitable treatment possible of all requesters, the NRC processes requests on a first-in, first-out basis, using a multiple track system based upon the estimated time it will take to process a request. Based on your description of the records you are seeking, we estimate completion of your request will be on or before October 25, 2016. Please note that we are estimating that completion will take more than 20 working days because we expect that we will have to: D search for, collect, and appropriately examine a voluminous amount of records IZl consult with multiple program and/or regional offices within the NRC IZl consult with other Federal agencies having equities in the records D refer records to a licensee, or other business submitter D undertake a declassification review of classified records; or D retrieve records from Federal Records Centers or other off-site facilities. Please know that this date roughly estimates how long it will take us to close requests ahead of yours in the respective track and complete work on your request. The actual date of completion might be before or after this estimate, based on the complexity of all of the requests in the complex track. We will advise you of any change in the estimated time to complete your request. In an effort to process your request promptly, you may wish to narrow the scope of your request to limit the volume of potentially responsive records. For purposes of assessing fees in accordance with our regulations (10 CFR 9.33), we have placed your request in the following category: Non-Excepted. If applicable, you will be charged appropriate fees for: Search and Duplication of Records. However, since you have requested that we issue our response to you electronically, you will not incur duplication charges_

2 - The following person is the Government Information Specialist who has been assigned responsibility for your request: Margo Stevens at 301-415-8148 or Margo.Stevens@nrc.gov. If you have questions on any matters concerning your FOIA request, please feel free to contact the assigned Government Information Specialist or me at (301) 415-7169. Sincerely, Stephanie Blaney Acting FOIA Officer Office of the Chief Information Officer

From: Admio Adm i To : Stevens Margo Subject : Request Assignment Date: Monday, September 12, 2016 7 :57:59 AM Details Request Number: FOIA/PA-2016-00725 Request Type : FOIA/PA Requested By : Criscione, Lawrence Requested Date: September 11 , 2016 Primary User: Margo Stevens Notes:

From: Admio Adm i To: LSCriscione@hotmail.com Cc: Stevens. Margo The attached final response and released records

Subject:

FOIA/ PA-2016-0727 Final Response are publicly available in ADAMS as ML20294A132 Date: Wednesday, February 22, 2017 9:34 :14 AM and ML20294A133, respectively.

Dear Mr. Criscione:

We are pleased to inform you that we have completed work on your request, FOIA/PA-2016-00727. Because the size of the file, consisting of the Form 464 response, and set of released records, is too large to be emailed to you, we are holding the Form 464 response, accompanied by a CD contain ing the released records, to be picked up by you at our new location 0-4A15. Once you have received the response, we would appreciate your taking a moment to help us improve our FOIA processes, and let us know what your experience has been . Just click on the embedded link: http ://www .nrc.gov/reading -rm/fo ia/fo ja- user- suryey .htm l. Once you complete the survey, just click on the "SUBMIT" button and your survey response will be returned to us. Thank you . Freedom of Information, Privacy & Information Collections Branch Customer Service Division, Office of t he Chief Information Officer Mail Stop: T-5F09 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555-0001 FOIA.Resource@nrc .gov Ph : 301 -415-7169 Fax : 301-415- 5130

From: FOIA Resource To: Lawrence Crjscjone Cc: Stevens. Margo The attached final response and released

Subject:

FOIA/PA-2016-0727 Final Response records are publicly available in ADAMS as Date: Wednesday, February 22, 2017 8: 11 :46 AM ML20294A132 and ML20294A133, respectively. Attachments: Final Response. odf

Dear Mr. Criscione:

Please find attached NRC's final response to your FOIA request, FOIA/PA-2016-00727. Please take a moment to help us improve our FOIA processes, and let us know what your experience has been. Just click on this embedded link: http://www.nrc.gov/readjng-rm/foja/foja-user-survey.html. Once you have completed the survey, just click the "SUBMIT" button and your survey response will be returned to us. Thank you, Freedom of Information, Privacy & Information Collections Branch Customer Service Division, Office of the Chief Information Officer Mail Stop: T-5F09 U.S . Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555-0001 FOIA .Resource@nrc .gov Ph: 301-415-7169 Fax: 301-415-5130

From: Danoff. Karen To: Stevens. Margo

Subject:

RE: 464 language for your 2016-0727 Date: Friday, February 17, 2017 9:48:27 AM I just sent you a "ignore" email, where I realized this document wasn't responsive to one of yours. Our emails crossed. Thanks for the draft language. I'm first working on my non-OIG interim response. From: Stevens, Margo Sent: Friday, February 17, 2017 9:45 AM To: Danoff, Karen <Karen.Danoff@nrc.gov>

Subject:

RE: 464 la nguage for your 2016-0727 I don't have that document in any of mine (remember, this is the one that Hixson skipped the # about). My idea was to say something along the lines of like this (b)(5) Jvlargo L Stevens _ro1:A !Ana(yst/Team Leacfer (Contractor) OC10/(j'I:M.S/Informalwn Services 'Branch 'U.S. :Nudear 1{e9u{alory Commission 11545 'Rockvi((e 'Pike, Jvlai( Stoy 'T-2:f7 'Rocle.vif{e, Jv1.ary{and' 20855 Te{e_plione #: (301) 415-8148 From: Danoff, Karen Sent: Friday, February 17, 2017 9: 15 AM To: Stevens, M argo <Margo.Stevens@nrc.gov>

Subject:

464 language for your 2016-0727 Since you and I are both responding to the same document, I can borrow your 464 language for the ML16216A703 document so we can be consistent. What's the language that you used? From: Stevens, Margo Sent: Thursday, February 16, 2017 1:34 PM To: Danoff, Karen <Karen Danoff@nrc gov>

Subject:

RE: Following up on yest erday's ca ll w it h Stephan ie You're welcome. When Stephanie returns tomorrow, she should be able to sign my final to FOIA-2016-0727 so I can close out another one! Matrix up to date from my end (including Lisa's concurrence below). Jv1.argo £.. Stevens J'OI.J\ .J\na(yst/'T'eam Lead"er (Contractor) OCIO/(j'EM.S/Information Services 'Brandi 'U.S. :Nudear negufatory Comm1sswn 11545 'Rocli.vi((e 'Pili.e, Jvtai( Stoy 'T'-2]"7 'RocR.vi({e, .'Mary(ana 20855 'T'e{eyfwne #: (301) 415-8148 From: Danoff, Karen Sent: Thursday, February 16, 2017 1:21 PM To: Stevens, M argo <Margo Stevens@nrc,gov>; Blaney, Stephanie <Stephanie Blaney@nrc gov>

Subject:

RE: Fol lowing up on yesterday's ca ll w it h Stephanie Thanks, Margo, for receiving clarification on this record . I can now proceed with my interim responses. From: St evens, Margo Sent: Thursday, February 16, 2017 1:01 PM To: Clark, Lisa <Usa.Clark@nrc,gov> Cc: Blaney, Stepha nie <Stephan ie.Blaney@nrc.gov>; Danoff, Karen <Karen.Danoff@nrc.gov>

Subject:

RE: Following up on yesterday's ca ll w it h Stephanie Great! Glad we"re on the same page. Thanks for responding so quickly.

Jvlargo L Stevens

]'01.Jl .Jlna(yst/'T'eam Leaaer (Contractor)

OUO/(;i'£Jv1.S/Informatwn. Services 'Branch

'U.S. :Nudear neau(atory Comm1sswn 11545 'Rocfivi((e 'Pi fie, Jvtai{ Stoy 'T'-2:r1
'Roclevi([e, Jvtary(ana 20855
'T'e(epfwne #: (301) 415-8148 From: Clark, Lisa Sent: Thursday, February 16, 2017 12:58 PM To: Stevens, M argo <Margo Steveos@nrc gov>

Cc: Blaney, Stephanie <Stephanie.Blaney@nrc gov>

Subject:

RE: Fol lowing up on yesterday's ca ll w it h Stephan ie Margo ,~)15) Lisa From: Stevens, Ma rgo Sent: Thursday, February 16, 2017 11:50 AM To: Clark, Lisa <Lisa Clark@nrc gov> Cc: Blaney, Stepha nie <Stephanie Blaney@nrc gov>; Danoff, Karen <Karen Danoff@nrc gov>

Subject:

Following up on yest erday's cal l with St ephanie Hi Lisa. Yesterday, Karen and I discussed with Stephanie the attached document, which is the subject of one or more of the "Criscione-group" of requests. (b)(5)

(b)(5)

Margo L Stevens

fOI..'A. .Ana{ysl/Team Leader (Contractor)

OCIO/(j1:Jv1.S/Information Services 'Brandi

'lLS. :Nudear 'Regu{atory Commission 11545 'Rocli.vi((e 'Pili.e, Jvt.ai( Stoy T-2:f7
'R,oc/i.viffe, Jvt.aryfanc( 20855
'T'efe_pfwne #: (301) 415-8148

From: Stevens Margo To: Blaney. stephanie

Subject:

FOIA-2017-0727#3 (FINAL) The attached response is publicly available in Date: Thursday, February 16, 2017 1:13:00 PM ADAMS as ML20294A132. The concurrence is Attachments: NRC 464 Part I .2016-0727# 3 (FINAL).odf included herein. Stephanie, given the upheaval with the move, I thought if you had the time, you could review the Form 464 I've prepared as the final response to the above-referenced request. This is one of the "Criscione group" from Larry himself. He asked for six items; we dealt with items 1 and 2 in #1 ; items 5 and 6 in #2; and now this is dealing with items 3 and 4.

                                     ,-l (b-)(5-) - - - - - - - - - - -

Item 3 is a Linked-In page, .__ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ Item 4 is a briefing book that Lochbaum prepared; c..;ar:a.tlCJ$ar.J.0Jo..cQ.Q.1~l-'""...tt:1.::u..tb.Q.- - - - ,

                             *ssioner Baran had received it, (b)(5)

Both documents have already been addressed in the same way in 2016-0731#6 to Hixson. If you want to view them, go into FX, 2017 file drawer, "2017-0731 (MLS )" folder, add my layer, look in the "same docs as 2017-0727 (program offices)" section, and they're on pages 2-65, then 68-76. Then, if you're good with it, once you're ready for it tomorrow morning, I can swing by your "new temporary home" and bring you the Form 464 to sign, and do the close-out. Thanks. J'Vlargo L Stevens

]"01..'A. ..'A.na[ysl/'leam Leaaer (Contractor)

OCIO/(i'I:MS/Informatron Servrces 'Brancfi

'U.S. J\fudear 'Regu(atory Commission 11545 'Rocl?.vi((e 1Jif?.e, J'vt.ai{Stoy T-2:J7
'R.ocllvi((e, :Mary[anrf 20855
'T'e(eyfwne #: (301) 415-8148

NRC FORM 464 Part I U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION FOIA RESPONSE NUMBER (12-2015) {¥\.......

              \. ';/)

RESPONSE TO FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT (FOIA) REQUEST I 2016-0727 11 3 I [Z]

RESPONSE

INTERIM FINAL TYPE REQUESTER: DATE: IL awrence Criscione 11 I DESCRIPTION OF REQUESTED RECORDS: Records corresponding to items 3 (ML! 62 16A704) and 4 (MLI 62 I 6A711 ), as further explained in the Comments Section, below. PART I. -- INFORMATION RELEASED Agency records subject to the request are already available in public ADAMS or on microfiche in the NRC Public Document Room. 0 Agency records subject to the request are enclosed. Records subject to the request that contain information originated by or of interest to another Federal agency have been referred to that agency (see comments section) for a disclosure determination and direct response to you. We are continuing to process your request. 0 See Comments. PART I.A -- FEES AMOUNT' II You will be billed by NRC for the amount listed. 0 None. Minimum fee threshold not met.

       $  II
       *see Comments for details You will receive a refund for the amount listed.         Fees waived.

PART I.B -- INFORMATION NOT LOCATED OR WITHHELD FROM DISCLOSURE We did not locate any agency records responsive to your request. Note: Agencies may treat three discrete categories of law enforcement and national security records as not subject to the FOIA ("exclusions"). 5 U.S.C. 552(c). This is a standard notification given to all requesters; it should not be taken to mean that any excluded records do, or do not, exist. We have withheld certain information pursuant to the FOIA exemptions described, and for the reasons stated, in Part II. Because this is an interim response to your request, you may not appeal at this time. We will notify you of your right to appeal any of the responses we lhave issued in response to your request when we issue our final determination. You may appeal this final determination within 30 calendar days of the date of this response by sending a letter or email to the FOIA Officer, at U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Washington, D.C. 20555-0001, or FOIA.Resource@nrc.gov. Please be sure to include on your letter or email that it is a "FOIA Appeal." PART I.C COMMENTS ( Use attached Comments continuation page if required) In conformance with the FOIA I mprovement Act of2016, the NRC is informi ng you that you have the right to seek assistance from the NRC's FOI A Public Liaison. I n our interim responses dated D ecember 22, 20 16 and January 26, 20 17, we addressed item s 1 (ML I 6236A0 19), 2 (ML16236A02l), 5 (ML16238A0I3) and 6 (ML16238A014). Thi s final response addresses the remaini ng two record s requested i n your request. Since the date of your request, all of these records have been removed from ADAM S. [con ti nued on next page] SIGNATURE - FREEDOM OF INFORMATION A CT OFFICER DISTRIBUTION lsteyfianie ..'A. 'B{aney I lsEcY I OFFICE ACTION OFFICER FOIA OFFICER NAME Margo Stevens Stephanie Blaney PUBLIC ADAMS DATE 02/16/2017 02/ 17/20 17 NON-PUBLIC ADAMS NRC Form 464 Part I (12-2015) Pag e 1 of 3

NRC FORM 464 Part I U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION FOIA RESPONSE NUMBER (12-2015) RESPONSE TO FREEDOM OF INFORMATIION I 2016-0727 11 3 I ACT (FOIA) REQUEST Continued [Z]

RESPONSE

INTERIM FINAL TYPE REQUESTER: DATE: ILawrence Criscione 11 I PART I.C COMMENTS (Continued) However, because the NRC was able to locate these records by the accession numbers when your request was received, we have processed the records (except as noted, below). Item 3 (MLI 6216A704) appears to be a Linked ln page of an individual when he was employed by NRC. Given its personal nature, and since NRC has not located other copies of this record in any of its record systems, we have determined that it is a personal record. As such, it is not subject to the FOIA and has not been processed. Item 4 (ML! 62 l 6A7 l I) is a copy of a briefing package prepared by David Lochbaum of the Union of Concerned Scientists, ahead of meetings that were scheduled with Chairman Burns and Commissioner Baran, which the Commission confirmed was received. It is enclosed. NRC Form 464 Part I (12-2015) Page 3 of 3

From: Admio Admio To: LSCrjscjone@hotmail com Cc: Stevens. Margo The attached interim # 2 response is publicly

Subject:

FOIA/PA-20 16-0727 Interim # 2 available in ADAMS as ML20294A130 . Date: Thursday, January 26, 2017 11:18:43 AM Attachments: Interim#2 Response.pdf

Dear Mr. Criscione:

We are pleased to inform you that we have completed more work on your request, FOIA/PA-2016-00727. We are continuing to process your request. Thank you . Freedom of Information, Privacy & Information Collections Branch Customer Service Division, Office of the Chief Information Officer Mail Stop : T-5F09 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555-0001 FOIA.Resource@nrc.gov Ph : 301-415-7169 Fax: 301-415-5130

From: Blaney Stephanie To: Stevens. Margo

Subject:

RE: Review of next interim response in FOIA_2016-0727 Date: Thursday, January 26, 2017 8:44:50 AM No issues with this. Stephanie From: Stevens, Margo Sent: M onday, Ja nuary 23, 2017 2:44 PM To: Blaney, Stepha nie <Stephanie.Blaney@nrc.gov>

Subject:

Review of next interi m response in FOIA_2016-0727 Stephanie, this is one of the "group". It is from Criscione. It asks for 6 records. We've already done interim #1 to deal with two records. This next interim addresses two more records. The final response, which I expect we'll get out very soon, will deal with the other two records, which are addressed in the interim response #6 in FOIA-2016-0731 that we sent over to OGC today. (b)(5)

Margo.£. Stevens

fOJ.:A .:Ana[yst/'leam Leaaer (Contractor)

OCJO/CS1J/JPI'.B

'U.S. :Nudear 'Regu(atory Commission 11545 'Rocli.vi((e 'Pili.e, Jvtai{Sto_p '1-2:[7
'Rociviffe, Jvtary[anrf 20855
'J'e(eyfi.one #: (301) 415-8148

The1 st attachment is an interim response that is publicly available in ADAMS as ML20294A130. The 2d and 3rd From: Stevens. Margo To: attachments are records (as ultimately processed) Blaney Stephanie Cc: Danoff Karen addressed in response to multiple requests, including

Subject:

Review of next interim response in FOIA_2016-0727 interim responses# 5 and 3, respectively, to your NRC-Date: Monday, January 23, 2017 2:46:00 PM 2018-000096. These interim responses are publicly Attachments: NRC 464 Part I 2016-0727#2pdf.pdf ML16238A013 pdf available as ML20288A415 and ML20288A414, ML1623BA014 oof respectively. Stephanie, this is one of the "group". It is from Criscione. It asks for 6 records. We've already done interim # 1 to deal with two records. This next interim addresses two more records. The final response, which I expect we'll get out very soon, will deal with the other two records, which are addressed in the interim response #6 in FOIA-2016-0731 th.at we sent over to OGC today. The two records were given to Criscione in their entirety previously by us. So, it should be simple. I've attached the draft of the Form 464 and copies of the two records (you'll see that ML16238A014 has the F464 that released the ADM memo in arguably reverse order) .. I toyed around with the idea of including in the Comments Section something about the records being made public. For now, I didn't check either the public or non-public ADAMS boxes. Under the regs, they pertain to him, so arguably not made public (and they weren't made public in the prior requests, 2014-0236 and 2014-0269 (because both came out of OIG investigation files but referred to ADM/FOIA for response). But we have his waiver, allowing the records to be made publicly available. And, we know we have 3 or more requests for it (assuming we don't aggregate) anyway. But I figured that since we don't know what we're doing, it makes better sense to be silent. Of course, if you think otherwise, let me know and I can make changes accordingly.

Margo L Stevens

fOI:A :Ana(yst/'T'eam Leaaer (Contractor)

OCIO/CS1J/:f'PI13 11.S. Nudear Regu(atory Commission 11545 Rock.vi((e 'Pike, :Mai[ Stoy T-2J-7 'R,,ock.vi((e, Jvlary(and' 20855 'T'e(eyfwne #: (301) 415-8148

From: Stevens Margo To: Travjck. Vanette

Subject:

FW: RE: FOIA-2016-0721, FOIA-2016-0723, FOIA-2016-0727, and FOIA-2016-0731 Date: Friday, January 13, 2017 8:33:00 AM Per discussion. Jvt.argo L Stevens

fOI.'A. .'A.na{ysl/'T'eam Leader (Conlraclor)

OCIO/CS'D/J'1'113 'I.LS. :Nuc(ear 'Regu(atory Commission 11545 'Rockviffe 1Jike, :M.ai{ Stoy 'T'-2:F1 1wckv1((e, :M.ary{anrf 20855 'T'e{eyftone #: (301) 415-8148 From: Stevens, Ma rgo Sent: Tuesday, October 18, 2016 8:25 AM To: 'Snyder, Mike' <M ike.Snyder@fpl.com>

Subject:

RE: RE: FOIA-2016-0721, FO IA-2016-0723, FOIA-2016-0727, and FOIA-2016-0731 Thank you . I'm so glad we were able to finally get it to you! Jvt.argo L Stevens _rOI.'A. .'A.na(ysl/'T'eam Leaaer (Contractor) OCIO/CS'D/J'TJ13 'U.S. :Nudear 'Regu[atory Comm1sswn 11545 'Rocli.vi((e 'Pili.e, :M.ai{Stoy 'T'-2:F1 'Rockvi((e, :M.ary{anrf 20855 'T'e{eyfwne #: (301) 415-8148 From: Snyder, M ike [1] Sent: Tuesday, October 18, 2016 8:06 AM To: Stevens, M argo <Margo.Stevens@nrc.gov>

Subject:

[Externa l_Sender] RE: FOIA-2016-0721, FOIA-2016-0723, FOIA-2016-0727, and FOIA-2016-0731

Margo,

I have reviewed the video that you sent and it does not contain any proprietary or safeguards information. M ike Snyder From: Stevens, Margo [2] Sent: Friday, October 14, 2016 2:03 PM To: Snyder, Mike

Subject:

RE: FOIA-2016-0721, FOIA-2016-0723, FOIA-2016-0727, and FOIA-2016-0731 CAUTION - EXTERNAL EMA IL Good afternoon Mike - do you know whether the CD with the video clip arrived at your home?

.Margo£.. Stevens J'Ol.'A. .'A.na(ysl/'T'eam Leaaer (Conlraclor)

OCIO/CS1J/]"'PI'B 'l.LS. :Nudear 'Regu(atory Commission 11545 'Rockvi((e Tike, :Mai{ Stoy '1-2J'7 'R.ock1nffe, :M.ary(ana 20855 'T'e(eyftone #: (301) 415-8148 From: Stevens, Margo Se nt: Thursday, October 13, 2016 1:35 PM To: 'M ike.Snyder@fpl.com' <Mike.Snyder@fpl.com>

Subject:

FW: FOIA-2016-0721, FOIA-2016-0723, FOIA-2016-0727, and FOIA-2016-0731

.Margo£.. Stevens

.TOI.Jl .Jlna(ysl/'T'eam Leacfer (Contractor) OCIO/CS'D/J"PI'B 'U.S. :Nudear 'Regu.fatory Commuswn 11545 'Rockvi((e 'Pike, :M.aff Stoy 'T'-2:J7 'Rockvi({e, :M.ary(ana 20855 'T'e{eyftone #: (301) 415-8148 From: Stevens, Margo

Sent: Friday, September 23, 2016 10:20 AM To: 'M ike.Snyder@ f pl.com' <M ike .Snyder @fpl.com > Cc: Danoff, Karen <Karen Danoff@nrc gov>

Subject:

FOIA-2016-0721, FOIA-2016-0723, FOIA-2016-0727, and FOIA-2016-0731 Good morning Mr. Snyder. The NRC's Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) Office has received several requests (their reference numbers are identified in the Subject line of this email) that seek copies of, inter alia, a video clip taken by an NRC resident inspector (on his cell phone camera) of flooding that occurred at the St. Lucie nuclear power plant on January 9 [no year given] . In searching the Licensee Event Report database NRG makes available to the public, I came across a LER that appears to coincide with the events shows in the video clip . It is also attached . Our office has made a preliminary determination that there is no basis on which to withhold the video clip from these requesters. We wanted to let you know. Should you have any questions, or concerns, please contact the undersigned at your earliest opportunity. We expect to start issuing responses to this aspect of the above-referenced requests next week. My colleague, Ms. Danoff, and I are assigned these requests and appreciate your attention. Jvlargo L. Stevens ]'OI.'A. .'A.na[yst/'Team Leaaer (Contractor) OCIO/CS'D/TPI'B 'U.S. :Nudear 'Regu[atory Commission 11545 'Rocli.vi((e Tili.e, Jvlai{ Stoy 'T'-2]'7 'Rocli.vi((e, Jvlary(ana 20855 T'e[eyfwne #: (301) 415-8148

The attached record is addressed in response to multiple requests, From: Stevens Margo To: McMillan Joseph including interim response # 5 to Cc: Hines. Ashley: Danoff. Karen : Bartley. Malian: FOIAPAOIG Resource your NRC-2018-000096. This Bee: Blaney. Stephanie response is publicly available in

Subject:

Group of FOIA Requests related to the Documents added to Adams by RES Employee ADAMS as ML20288A415. Date: Friday, December 30, 2016 10:28:00 AM Attachments: ML16216A711 UCS Briefing Book.pelf Good morning. Happy New Year. (b)(5) J\11.argo L Stevens J'OI.'11. .'11.na[yst/'Team Leaaer (Contractor) OCIO/CSD/JPI'B 'I.LS. Nudear 'Reguratory Commission 11545 'Rockvi((e 'Pike, Jvt.ai[ Stoy T'-2]'7 'Rockviffe, Jvt.aryrana 20855 Te[eyfwne #: (301) 415-8148

From: Argent. Nina To: Stevens. Margo

Subject:

RE: here! Date: Thursday, Decem ber 22, 2016 1:41:01 PM Include it. From: Stevens, Ma rgo Sent: Thursday, December 22, 2016 1:34 PM To: Argent, Nina <Nina.Argent@nrc.gov>

Subject:

RE: here! Also - I believe when Stephanie was acting, when I did an interim, we didn"t include any of the 2016 language since it wasn't done yet (but I may be misremembering). What is your view of its inclusion? Jvlargo L Stevens J'OI.'A .'Ana(ysl/Team .Lead'er (Contractor) OCIO/CS1>/J'1'l'B 'U.S. :Nudear 'Regu(atory Commission 11545 'RocRvit[e 'Pike, :Mai{ Stoy T-2J-7 'R.ockvz{(e, :Mary(and' 20855 Tde_pfrone #: (301) 415-8148 From: Argent, Nina Sent: Thursday, December 22, 2016 1:33 PM To: Stevens, M argo <Margo.Stevens@nrc gov>

Subject:

RE: here! Thanks! I will take a look. From: Stevens, Margo Se nt: Thursday, December 22, 2016 1:25 PM To: Argent, Nina <Nina Argent@nrc gov>

Subject:

RE: here ! Easy enough. The one page email exchange may be found in the 2016 folder, under "FOIA-2016-0731 (MLS)". Once you open the folder and all the sections. choose the "Same Docs as 2016-0727" and it's the first page. Jvlargo L Stevens J'OI.'A .'Ana(yst/Team .Leaaer (Contractor)

OCIO/CS'D/]'PI'B

'U.S. :Nudear 'Regu(atory Commission 11545 JlocRvLlTe 'P1Re, :Mai{Stoy 'T'-2:f7
'Rocli.vi((e, :Mary{antf 20855 1"'efepfwne #: (301) 415-8148 From: Argent, Nina Sent: Thursday, December 22, 2016 1:15 PM To: Stevens, M argo <Margo Steyens@nrc gov>

Subject:

RE: here ! From: Stevens, Margo Sent: Thursday, December 22, 2016 1:07 PM To: Argent, Nina <Nina Argent@nrc gov>

Subject:

RE: here ! l _ (b)(6) I Here's what I hope is a quick question. Now that Karen has done the F464 for 2016-0723, I'd like to do the first interims in 2016-0727 (Criscione) and 2016-0731 (Hixson) for the video. (b)(5) .Jvlargo £.. Stevens J'Ol.J\. .Jlna(yst/'leam .leaaer (Contractor) OC10/CS'D/:f'Pl13

'U.S. :Nucfear 1?.egu{atory Commission

11545 1wcli.vi((e Tike, Jvlai{Stoy 'l-2:f7 Rockviffe, Jvlaryrana 20855 Te{eyfwne #: (301) 415-8148 From: Argent, Nin a Sent: Thursday, December 22, 2016 12:16 PM To: Burkhalter, Corne lia <Cornelia Burkhalter@nrc.gov>; Blaney, Stephanie <Stephan ie.Blaney@nrc.gov>; Danoff, Kare n <Karen.Danoff@nrc.gov>; Ch idi chimo, Gabriele <Gabriele.Chidichimo@nrc.gov>; Ennis, Tina <TINA.ENNIS@nrc.gov>; Stevens, Margo <Margo Steveos@nrc.gov>; Britt, Scott <Scott.Britt@nrc.gov>; Francis, Lezl ie <Lez lie.Francis@nrc .gov>

Subject:

here! Good afternoon . r_)(- I am on line this afternoon . ... 5)_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ___. If you need me, I'm here . I ca n review and Karen can sign . Than ks.

From: Danoff. Karen To: Stevens Margo The final response and released record are publicly

Subject:

FW: FOIA/PA-2016-0723 Final Response Date: Thursday, December 22, 2016 7:46:43 AM available in ADAMS as ML20294A078 and Attachments: Final Response.pdf ML20294A079, respectively. In order to not hog up email space , I've deleted the video - but obviously the video was attached here as well. Attached is the 464 with the approved verbiage . From: FOIA Resource Sent: Thursday, December 22, 2016 7:44 AM To: darth.vader.four20@gmail.com Cc: Danoff, Ka ren <Karen.Danoff@ nrc.gov>

Subject:

FOIA/PA-2 016-0723 Fin al Response

Dear Mr. Vader:

Please find attached NRC's final response to your FOIA request, FOIA/PA-2016-00723. Please take a moment to help us improve our FOIA processes, and let us know what your experience has been. Just click on this embedded link: http://www.nrc.gov/reading-rm/foia/foia-user-su rvey .html. Once you have completed the survey, just click the "SUBMIT" button and your survey response will be returned to us. Thank you, FOIA/Privacy Act Inform ation Co llections Bra nch Customer Service Divis ion Office of the Chief Information Officer U.S. Nuclear Regul ato ry Commiss ion EOIA Resource@nrc !NY

From: Danoff. Karen To: Stevens. Margo

Subject:

closed out Vader request for video yesterday Date: Thursday, December 22, 2016 7: 11:34 AM (b)(5) I'll also add the close out to the matrix. for now in bold, but the color can be changed later. From: Stevens, Margo Sent: Thursday, December 22, 2016 6:22 AM To: Danoff, Karen <Ka ren.Danoff@nrc.gov>

Subject:

RE: updat ing matr ix Noted. I am going to try to look through the parts of Hixson's request asking for OIG records that may be ready to put into interim #1 , along with the one group of records for which OIG previously invoked 7A. to get Joe's attention.

Margo L Stevens

fOIJ\ .Jl.na[yst/'T'eam Leacfer (Contractor)

OCIO/CS1J/:f'PI'B 'U.S. :Nudear 1{eguuitory Commission 11545 '.Rocfi.vi[{e 'Pifi.e, Jvt.ai{ Stoy 'T'-2:f7 'Rocfi.vi((e, :Ma ry(and 20855 'T'e{eyfwne #: (301) 415-8148 From: Danoff, Karen Sent: Wednesday, December 21, 2016 4:16 PM To: Stevens, M argo <Margo Stevens@nrc gov>

Subject:

updati ng matrix I couldn"t get to updating the matrix today with everything else going on, I have it on my list to do tomorrow. I also need to read the rest of your edits and compare them with my notes. Karen

From: Stevens Margo To: Pennis. Suzanne

Subject:

The "Group of 12 FOIA"s" (FOIA-2016-0727) Date: Wednesday, December 21, 2016 2:28:00 PM Hi Suzanne. Hope all is well. Sorry I wasn't able to join you for yesterday's meeting regarding the group of 12 FOIA requests submitted by Criscione and others for the records he added to ADAMS and others .. .. (b)(5) Not sure your schedule given the holiday season, but I would like to try to get the ball rolling on these docs. Thanks - and happy holidays!

Margo L. Stevens J'OI.'A .'Ana{yst/ Team Leaaer (Contractor)

OCIO/CSD/JTI'B 'U.S. Nudear 'Regu{atory Commission 11545 'Rockvi((e 'Pike, :Mai{ Stoy 'T'-2:J7 'Rockviffe, :M.ary{ana 20855 Te[eylione #: (301) 415-8148

From: Stevens Margo To: Travjck. Vanette

Subject:

RE: Status on FOIA-2016-0727 Date: Monday, October 31, 2016 1:56:00 PM 5 l(b-)( -) _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ___.I Thanks. Stay tuned. OK. .... Jvt.argo L. Stevens

fOI.'A. .'A.na{ysl/'T'eam Leader (Conlraclor)

OCIO/CS'D/J'1'l'B

'I.LS. :Nuc(ear 'Regu(atory Commission 11545 'Rockviffe 1Jike, :M.ai{ Stoy 'T'-2:F1 1wckv1((e, :M.ary{anrf 20855
'T'e[e_pftone #: (301) 415-8148 From: Travick, Vanette Sent: Monday, October 31, 2016 1:53 PM To: Stevens, M argo <Margo.Stevens@n rc.gov>

Subject:

RE: Status on FOIA-2016-0727 From: Stevens, Margo Sent: Monday, October 31, 2016 1:14 PM To: Travick, Vanette <Vanette Trav jck@nrc.gov>

Subject:

RE: Status on FOIA-2016-0727 Hi Vanette. This request, along with about ten others, are being coordinated togethe~ b)(5) Jvt.argo L. Stevens

.rOIJ\ J\na(yst/'T'eam Leader (Contractor)

OUO/CS'D/:fFI'B

'U.S. Nudear 'J{egu{alory Commission 11545 'Roc/ivi((e 'Pirie, :Mai(Stoy 'T'-2:J7
'Rockviffe, :Mary(and 20855

 'I'e{eyfwne #: (301) 415-8148 From: Travick, Vanette Sent: Monday, October 31, 2016 1:07 PM To: Stevens, Margo   <Margo.Stevens@nrc gov>

Subject:

Status on FOIA-2016-0727 Hi Margo, Can you J)rovide a statu s update on this request? I (b)(5) Regards Yanette Travic.k Information Jvt.anagement SyeciaCist J-fuman 'Resources 'Brandi

'Region II (404) 997-4827 vanette. travick@nrc.9ov "J-fR Partnering for Success"

From: Stevens Margo To: MorganButler. Kimyata R Cc: Blaney. Stephanie

Subject:

RE: FOIA/PA-2016-00727 - SECY Response Date: Friday, October 21, 2016 6:59:00 AM I had not apparently. SECY had already advised me - before the recent meeting - that it confirmed it had the document and that it was reviewing it based on the record it located.

Margo .£. Stevens J'OLJl .Jlna(ysl/Team Leader (Contractor)

OCIO/CS'D/J"1>J'B '!LS. :Nudear 'Regu(atory Commission 11545 'Rocl?.vi((e 'Pike, Jvtai{Stoy T-2:f7 'lwcli.vi((e, :.tvtary(ana 20855 Te(eyftone #: (301) 415-8148 From: MorganBut ler, Kimyata R Sent: Thursday, October 20, 2016 5:10 PM To: Stevens, Margo <Margo.Stevens@nrc.gov> Cc: Blaney, Stephanie <Stephanie.Blaney@nrc.gov>

Subject:

FW: FOIA/PA-2016-00727 - SECY Response Have you closed the taskings for t his case? From: FOIAPASECY Resource Sent: Wednesday, October 19, 2016 3:01 PM To: FOIA Resource <FOIA.Resource@nrc gov> Cc: Stevens, Margo <Margo.Stevens@nrc.gov>; Bates, Andrew <Andrew.Bates@nrc.gov>; Lewis, Antoinette <Antoinette.Lewjs@nrc.gov>; Craver, Patti <Patti.Craver@nrc.gov>; Mccloskey, Bridin <Brjdjn.McCloskey@nrc.gov>; Bavol, Rochel le <Rochelle Bavol@ nrc.gov>; Danoff, Karen <Karen Danoff@nrc gov>

Subject:

FOIA/PA-2016-00727 - SECY Response Good Afternoon, Please see attached memo. The Commission determined that the record should be released in full. The hard copy record maintained in the Chairman and Commissioner files will be sent to you via interoffice mail. Please use this copy as the official record and provide to the req uester(s). This closes SECY action.

Thanks, Kristy Kristy Remsburg Correspondence and Records Office of the Secretary U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Office: 301-415-1667 From: Stevens, Margo [3] Sent: Friday, Se ptem ber 23, 2016 9:58 AM To: FOIAPASECY Resource <FOIAPASECY.Resou rce@nrc.gov> Cc: Stevens, Margo <Margo.Stevens@nrc.gov>; Danoff, Karen <Karen.Danoff@nrc.gov>

Subject:

FOIA/PA-2016-00727 Action Item/Instructions Sea rch for Records in Perfected Request Offices Assi211ed Action on September 23, 2016; SECY The requester has either agreed to pay the estimated fees, or has provided an advance payment, or there arc no billable fees. The request is now considered "perfected." Please provide the Government lnfonnation Specialist, who is named below, with the responsive records on or before October 6, 201 6, which is ten (10) working days from the date o f thi s e-mail. The Government Information Specialist for this request is Margo Slcvens, who can be reached at 301-41 5-8148 or Mar~o Stcvcns@nrc ~oy. (b)(5) The FOIA request s hould be processed in accordance with the standard instructions (How to Respond to a FOIA Request) at MLl6123Al 64. NRC Form 5 11, "Program Office Response to a FOlA Request" is available in the NRC Forms Library for your use. ln order to document the search conducted, in the event of an appeal c hallenging the adequacy of the search, please also have each member of your staff who cond ucts a search complete NRC Form 51 IA, "Documentation ofa FOIA Search," which is also available in the NRC Forms Library for your use. Please review these forms to ensure that an adequate, and cons istent, search has been perforn1ed within your office. Then include copies of the completed NRC Fonns 51 IA along with the NRC Fonn 51 l you return to the assigned specialist. Alternatively, you may complete the NRC Form 51 1A on behalf of your office, based upon the descriptio ns of searches provided to you by your office s taff. You are encouraged to ask for assistance in performing adequate ADAMS searches if you have any difficulty doing a search. NRC Form 496, "Report of Staff Resources for Processing FOIA Requests" is also available in the NRC Forn1s Library for your use. When you respond, please make sure that you are sending your response to FO)A Resourceralmc gov. as well as the assigned specialist. Thank you.

From: FOIAPASECY Resource To: EOIA Resource Cc: Stevens. Margo: Bates. Andrew: Lewis, Antoinette: craver. Patti: McCloskey. Bridjn: Bayot Rochelle: Qa.n2ff.

                      ~

Subject:

FOIA/PA-2016-00727

• SECY Response Date: Wednesday, October 19, 2016 3:01:17 PM Attachments: EOIA 2016-0727 final Response pd[

Good Afternoon, Please see attached memo. The Commission determined that the record should be released in full. The hard copy record maintained in the Chairman and Commissioner files will be sent to you via interoffice mail. Please use this copy as the official record and provide to the requester(s). This closes SECY action.

Thanks, Kristy Kristy Remsburg Correspondence and Records Office of the Secretary U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Office: 301-415 -1667 From: Stevens, Margo resource@nrc.gov

Sent: Friday, September 23, 2016 9:58 AM To: FO!APASECY Resource <FO!APASECY.Resource@nrc.gov> Cc: Stevens, M argo <Margo.Stevens@n rc.gov>; Danoff, Karen <Karen.Danoff@ nrc.gov>

Subject:

FOIA/PA-2016-00727 Action item/Instructions Search for Records in Perfected Req uest Offices Assigned Action on September 23 2016: SECY The requester has either agreed to pay the estimated fees, or has provided an adv,rncc payment, or there arc no billable fees. The request is now considered "perfected." Please provide the Government lnfonnation Specialist, who is named below, with the responsive records on or before October 6, 2016, which is ten (I 0) working days from the date of tl1is e-mail. The Government Information Specialist for this request is Margo Stevens, who can be reached at 301-415-8148 or Margo Stcvcns@nrc gov. (b)(5) The FOIA request should be processed in accordance with the standard instructions (How to Respond to a FOIA Request) at MLl6 I 23A 164. N RC Fonn 5 1 I, "Program Office Response to a FOIA Request" is available in the NRC Forms Library for your use.

In order to document the search conducted, in the event of an appeal challenging the adequacy of the search, please also have each member of your staff who conducts a search complete NRC Forn1 51 1A, "Documentation of a FOIA Search," which is also available in the RC Forms Library for your use. Please review these fom1s to ensure that an adequate, and consistent., search has been perforn1ed within your office. Then include copies of the completed NRC Forn1s 51 1A along with the NRC Forni 511 you return to the assigned specialist. Alternatively, you may complete the RC Form 51 1A on behalf of your office, based upon the descriptions of searches provided to you by your office staff. You arc encouraged to ask for assistance in performing adequate ADAMS searches if you have any difficulty doing a search. NRC Form 496, "Repmt of Staff Resources for Processing FOIA Requests" is also ava ilable in the NRC Forms Library for your use. When you respond, please make sure that you are sending your response to FO)A Resource@nrc gov, as well as the assigned spec ialist. Thank you.

NRC FORM 51 1 c>>>'-"tOllt, U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION (11-2015) l~;{J,

                   \, .....iii'
                                  . PROGRAM OFFICE RESPONSE TO A FOIA REQUEST
                    +,,        +O TO:              Government Information Specialist FOIA, Privacy & Information                 I Margo Stevens Collections Branch (FPIB)                                                                                                I FROM:             FOIA Coordinator                            IKristy Remsburg, Office of the Secretary                                   I

SUBJECT:

FOIA- 201 6-0727 I I 0 Section 1. Is this a partial or final response to this request? (Check only one). Section 2. DISCLOSURE RECOMMENDATION: How do you recommend the responsive records be handled? (Check all that apply). No records subject to the request. Records already publicly available. Group Records to have ADAMS profile changed to public. Group 0 Records to be released or withheld. Group A Ongoing investigation - NRC Form 656, Exemption ?(A) Certification, Records that have to be referred. Group attached. Note: An e-mail, with its attachment(s), is considered one record and should not be broken apart when you're assembling groups. Section 3. PERSONAL RECORDS: Did anyone in your office identify personal records that pertain to this request? If so, make sure the employee completes NRC Form 510, Personal Records Checklist, attach a copy, and note in Section 9 whether the employee or FOIA Coordinator is retaining the records, which must be kept for six years. Section 4. SEARCH: Staff in your office must undertake a search that is reasonably calculated to locate all records responsive to the request. Each person in your office that is asked to search must complete the attached NRC Form 511A, FOIA Search. You should review the forms to ensure that they are completed properly and reflect a consistent and adequate search. Attach all NRC Forms 511A. Section 5. WAIVER: Records, or information within records, that may be withheld from release based upon an applicable exemption are subject to release if the NRC has officially disclosed that information previously. For any record, or information within records, that you are recommending be withheld , please confirm that staff has checked public ADAMS and www.nrc.gov to determine that such information has not previously been disclosed. By checking the box at the end of Section 5, you are confirming that your staff did not find that the information recommended to be withheld has been publicly released by the NRC. Section 6. IDS.C_REtlOti!ARY RELEASEIFORSEEABLEJ:IARM DE1'.ERMINAT.10N: We are recommending that exemption 2 and/or exemption 5 be claimed for certain records (or information within We are making a discretionary release. Briefly describe the records (or information within records) for which such records} and a particularized harm statement, signed by the Office Director or delegate, is attached. discretion was made. NRC FORM 511 (11 -2015) Page 1 of 2

NRC FORM 511 U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION (11-2015) PROGRAM OFFICE RESPONSE TO A FOIA REQUEST (Continued) SUBJECT : FOIA - . _ I_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ 2_0_1_6-_0_7_ 27_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _.I Section 7. INCLUDE IN PUBLIC ADAMS: The NRC places FOIA responses (including released records) in public ADAMS unless the records contain information personal to the requester, involve matters that are not likely to be of public interest, or contain privileged or confidential information that should only be disclosed to the requester. Do any of the records fall under one of these three exceptions to public availability? Yes [Z] No Section 8. fEES..;_ If the actual time spent searching or reviewing records, or number of pages, differs from the fee estimate given previously, complete and attach NRC Form 496, Report of Staff Resources for Processing FOIA Requests. Section 9. COMMENTS: Please include any other comments that we should know about. In lieu of bracketing the responsive records, you may include a description of the records, or information within the records, that you recommend be redacted, including the exemption(s) that should be claimed. (Attach separate pages, if needed). Group A - to be released in full. Please use the hard copy provided to respond to the requester(s). Thanks! NRC FORM 511 (11 -2015) Page 2 of 2

From: Stevens Margo To: lcrjscione@hotmail.com Bee: Blaney. Stephanie: Danoff, Karen

Subject:

FOIA-2016-0727; 2016-0780; 2016-0785; 2017-0002; and 2017-0005 Date: Thursday, October 06, 2016 7:59:00 AM Good morning Larry. In reviewing the above-referenced requests from you that have been assigned to me, I noted that upon their receipt, they were placed in the "simple track. " However, in light of the coordination efforts involved (both internally and externally) for most, if not all , of the requested records, these requests have now been placed in the "complex track. " The new estimated dates of completion for each request may be found below: Request# Original Due Date New Due Date 2016-0727 10/12/2016 10/26/2016 2016-0780 10/28/2016 11/14/2016 2016-0785 10/31/2016 11/15/2016 2017-0002 11/01/2016 11/16/2016 2017-0005 11/02/2016 11/17/2016 Thank you . Jvt.argo L. Stevens

JOIJ\. ..'A.na(yst/'Team Leaaer (Contractor)

OCIO/CS'D/f'PI"B 'U.S. J\fudear 'Regu{atory Commission 11545 'Rockvi((e 'Pike, :Mai{ Stoy T-2f7 'Rockvi[(e, :Mary(anc( 20855 'Te{eyfione #: (301) 415-8148

From: Blaney. Stephanie To: Stevens Margo

Subject:

RE: FOIA-2016-072.7 (and a few others) Date: Friday, September 23, 2016 7:52:20 AM Attachments: imaaeoo1.ona Works for me. From: Stevens, Margo Sent: Friday, September 23, 2016 7:52 AM To: Blaney, Stepha nie <Stephanie.Blaney@nrc.gov>

Subject:

RE: FOIA-2016-0727 (and a few others) The video clip is in the G drive (it's the first item in the folder marked "FOIA-2016-0721 &727" in the Electronic Case Files folder). if you want to view it

 )(5)

Yes, since RII gave me the POC for the licensee, I'll send an email alerting it to them and our preliminary view that it should be released and see what I get back. Jvt.argo L. Stevens

JOI.A .'A.na(yst/Team Leaaer (Contractor)

OCIO/CS'D/:f'PJP, 'U.S. :Nudear 'Regu[atory Commission 115451{ock:vi{(e 'Pike, :Mai{ Stoy T'-<f1 Rockvi((e, :Ma ry(ana 20855 Te[eylione #: (301) 415-8148 From: Blaney, Stephanie Sent: Friday, September 23, 2016 7:47 AM To: Stevens, M argo <Margo Stevens@nrc gov>

Subject:

RE : FOIA-2016-0727 (and a few others) (b)(5) From: Stevens, Margo

Sent: Thursday, September 22, 2016 11:13 AM To: Blaney, Stepha nie <Stepha nie Blaney@nrc gov>

Subject:

FW: FOIA-2016-0727 (and a few ot hers) See below. This is one of the documents responsive to Criscione's, Hixson's, and Vader's requests. It's a 22 second video clip.) (b)(5)

A1argo L Stevens J"OI.JJ. .JJ.na(yst/Team £.ead"er (Con l ractor)

OCIO/CS'D/]"PI13

'U.S. :Nudear 'ReguCatory Commission 11545 'RocRv1((e 'PiRe, :Ma1{Stoy 'T-2:f7
'R.ocfi.vi((e, :Mary{ana 20855 Tefeyfwne #: (301) 4 15-8148 From: FOIAPAR2 Resource Sent: Thursday, September 22, 2016 11:06 AM To: Stevens, Margo <Margo.Steyens@nrc gov>; FOIAPAR2 Resource <EOIAPAR2 Resource@nrc gov>

Subject:

RE: FOIA-2016-0727 (and a few ot hers) See the response below. Vanette - My understanding is that this video was taking by a resident inspector with a cell phone camera. I/Vm711e.rl Regards, LaDonna B. Suggs I Chief, Reactor Projects Branch 3 - RII / DRP / RPB3 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commiss ion - RII I 245 Peachtree Center Ave. NE !Suite 1200 I Atlanta, GA 30303 wo: 404.997.45391 :§iF: 404,997.45151 :BJ: Laponna,suaas@nrc,aov I www.nrc.gov From: Stevens, Margo

Sent: Thursday, September 22, 2016 10:55 AM To: FOIAPAR2 Resource <FOIAPAR2.Resource@nrc gov>

Subject:

RE: FOIA-2016-0727 (and a few others) Please ask your SMEs how we came to have the video, before I go back to the licensee .... then once I hear back from you , I can close you out. Jvt.argo L. Stevens J'OI.'A .'Ana(yst/Team Leacfer (Contractor) OCJO/CS1J/J:PJ13 'U.S. :Nudear 'Regu{atory Comm1sswn 11545 1?.ocw.v i((e 11 1~e. Jvt.a i( Stoy T-2)'7 'Rock'vi((e, Jvt.ary(antf 20855 'I'efeyfwne #: (301) 415-8148 From: FOIAPAR2 Resource Sent: Thursday, September 22, 2016 10:46 AM To: Stevens, Margo <Margo Stevens@nrc gov>; FOIA Resource <EOIA Resource@nrc gov> Cc: FOIAPAR2 Resou rce <F0IAPAR2.Resource@nrc.gov>

Subject:

FW: FOIA-2016-0727 (and a few others) Importance: High

Margo, See Region II response to the email and short video pertaining to this request below. This is Region II Final Response.

Thank you, Yanette Travicfi. Information Jvt.anagement SyeciaCist Jfuman Resources 'Brandi Region II (404) 997-4827 v anette.trav ick@nrc.gov "J-{'R, Partnering for Success"

From: Suggs, LaDonna Sent: Tuesday, September 20, 2016 5:32 PM To: FO IAPAR2 Resource <FOIAPAR2.Resource@nrc.gov>

Subject:

RE: FOIA-2016-0727 (and a few others) Vanette - The licensing contact for St. Lucie is: Mark Snyder Site Licens ing Manager Mike.Snyder@fpl com 772-467-7036 l(b)(6)  !'cell) From: Suggs, LaDonna Sent: Tuesday, September 20, 2016 4:05 PM To: FO IAPAR2 Resource <EOIAPAR2 Resource@nrc gov>

Subject:

RE: FOIA-2016-0727 (and a few others) (b)(5) ll7t11111est Regards, LaDonna B. Suggs I Chief, Reactor Projects Branch 3 - RII / DRP / RPB3 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission - Rll I245 Peachtree Center Ave. NE !Suite 1200 I Atlanta, GA 30303 tro: 404.997.45391 ~ F: 404.997.45151 ~ : Laponna.suaas@orc.gov I www.nrc.gov From: FOIAPAR2 Resource Sent: Tuesday, September 20, 2016 7:27 AM To: Suggs, La Donna <La Donna Suggs@nrc gov>

Subject:

FW: FOIA-2016-0727 (a nd a few others) LaDonna,

Please review the video clip and make a determination on it should or should not be released . I will send you the email between Vic Mccree and Bill Dean. Thank you Yanette T'ravick Information Jvlanagement Syecia{ist Jfuman 'Resources 'Branch 'Region II (404) 997-4827 vanette. travicknrc.9ov "J-{R Partnering for Success" From: Stevens, Margo Sent: Friday, September 16, 2016 12:09 PM To: RlFOIAPA RESOURCE <RlFOIAPA RESOURCE@nrc gov>; FOIAPAR2 Resource <EOIAPAR2 Resource@nrc gov> Cc: Danoff, Karen <Karen Danoff@nrc gov>

Subject:

FOIA-2016-0727 (and a few others) OK. HERE (at last, I hope) is the video clip to accompany the email that I tasked to both regions earlier this week, and just a few moments ago. Jvlargo L Stevens J"OIJl .Jl.na(yst/'I'eam Leader (Contractor) OGO/CS1J/J'PI'B 'U.S. :Nudear 'Regu(atory Comm1sswn 11545 'Rockvi((e 'Pike, :Mai( Stoy 'T'-2:[7 'Rockvi((e, Jvtary(ana 20855 T'e(eyfione #: (301) 415-8148

From: Littlejohn. Jeanene To: Stevens. Margo

Subject:

FW: Rights to a Documents Date: Tuesday, 5eptember 20, 2016 1:13: 16 PM Hi Margo, Please see below.

Thanks, Jennene From: ADAMS IM Sent: Tuesday, September 20, 2016 12:19 PM To: Littlejohn, Jennene <Jenn ene.Littlejohn@nre.gov>

Cc: ADAMS IM <ADAMSSupport.Email@nrc.gov>

Subject:

RE: Rights to a Documents Hi Jennene, I think Rochelle Bavol can assist you with this. Thanks Gloria Saint On behalf of ADAMS IM From: Littlejohn, Jennene Sent: Tuesday, September 20, 2016 12:00 PM To: ADAMS IM <ADAMSSupport Email@orc gov>

Subject:

RE: Rights t o a Docum ents Hi Gloria, Do you have a contact person in SECY that I could contact?

Thanks, Jennene From: ADAMS IM Sent: Tuesday, September 20, 2016 11:55 AM To: Littlejohn, Jennene <Jennene.Littleiohn@nrc.gov>; ADAMS IM <ADAMSSupport.Ema il@nrc gov>

Subject:

RE: Rights to a Documents Good day, SECY is the owning office for this document. I am allowed to provide access with written consent.

Thanks Gloria Saint On behalf of ADAMS IM From: Littl ejohn, Jen nene Sent: Tuesday, Septem ber 20, 2016 10:37 AM To: ADAM S IM <ADAMSSupport Ema il @nrc gov>

Subject:

Righ ts t o a Docu ment s

Hello, Can you tell me if I am an owner or viewer to ML13149A079? If not who is. I need to have access to this document.

Thank you, Jennene Littlejohn Lead Administrative Assistant RE S/ORA 30 1-415-0428 (office) 301 -415-6671 (fax) TWFN- 10-A06 Mailstop: T10-A12

From: Dennis Suzanne To: Stevens. Margo

Subject:

RE: FOIA-2017-0727 Date: Tuesday, 5eptember 20, 2016 12:15:03 PM Yep - I think I was confusing this with your other request on 0725 . © Thanks! Suzanne From: Stevens, Margo Sent: Tuesday, September 20, 2016 12:11 PM To: Dennis, Suzanne <Suzanne.Denn is@nrc.gov>

Subject:

RE: FOIA-2017-0727 Jennene found it for mel (b)(5) l L . ._ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _,I 'hanks. (vvas mat w11ac you 1,au,, Jvt.argo L Stevens

fOI.:A .:Ana(yst/'T'eam Leader (Contractor)

Oc.10/CS'D/:f'PI'B

    'U.S. :.Nudear Regu(atory Commission 115451?.ocfivi((e 'Pirie, Jvlai{Sto_p T-2:f7
    'Rocli.v1((e, Jvlary(amf 20855 T'e[eyfwne #: (101) 415-8148 From: Dennis, Suzanne Sent: Tuesday, September 20, 2016 12:08 PM To: Stevens, M argo <Margo Steyens@nrc gov>; Littlejohn, Jennene <Jennene Littlejohn@nrc gov>

Subject:

RE: FOIA-2017-0727 I wonder if you meant ML16216A711 ... I have a hard copy of t hat Suzanne From: Stevens, Margo Sent: Tuesday, September 20, 2016 7:05 AM To: Lit t lej ohn, Jen nene <Jeanene Littleiohn@nrc gov> Cc: Dennis, Suza nne <Suzanne.Dennis@nrc.gov>

Subject:

FOIA-2017-0727 Importance: High

Good morning ladies. One of the records that Mr. Criscione uploaded into an ML package he created (MLL 16195A365) was a briefing package bearing the ML#16216A611. It is described as "Union of Concerned Scientists' briefing package for NRC Chairman Burns and Commissioner Baran." Do you still have access to it? It is one of the documents I couldn 't access when I first received the request (and before RES took steps to remove the items from ADAMS). Feel free to email it to me, as I suspect that's the easiest and fastest way. Thanks.

Margo L. Stevens

fOI.Jl .'Ana{ysl/Team Leader (Contractor)

OCIO/CS'D/TPI'B 11.S. Nudear 'ReguCatory Commission 11545 'RocR.vi((e Pike, Jvlai{ Stoy T-2:f7 'RocRviffe, Jvlary{ana 20855 Tdeyfzone #: (301) 415-8148

From: Stevens Margo To: Littlejohn. Jeanene

Subject:

RE: Rights to a Documents Date: Tuesday, 5eptember 20, 2016 11:58:00 AM Does ADAMS IM have a contact in SECY to ask for that consent then? I have a call into the SECY FOIA Coordinator on some other issues so if Gloria can't get us the permission we need, I can follow up with my POC once I hear back from her.

M.argo L Stevens

.TOJ.J\ .J\.na(yst/'leam Leaaer (Contractor) OUO/CS'D/:f'PI'B 'U.S. :Nudear 'R.egufotory Commission 11545 'Rocl?.vi((e Til?.e, Jvtai{Stoy '1-2]"7 'Rockvi((e, Jvtary(ana 20855 'Je(eyfwne #: (301) 415-8148 From: Littlejohn, Jennene Sent: Tuesday, September 20, 2016 11:56 AM To: Stevens, M argo <Margo.Stevens@nrc.gov> Cc: Dennis, Suza nne <Suzanne.Dennis@nrc.gov>

Subject:

FW: Rights to a Documents Hi Margo, This is the response I've received from ADAMS IM. How would you like to proceed.

Thanks, Jennene From: ADAMS IM Sent: Tuesday, September 20, 2016 11:55 AM To: Littlejohn, Jen nene <Jennene.Uttle john@nrc.gov>; ADAMS IM <ADAMSSupport Email@nrc.gov>

Subject:

RE: Rights to a Documents Good day, SECY is the owning office for this document. I am allowed to provide access with written consent. Thanks Gloria Saint On behalf of ADAMS IM

From: Littlejohn, Jennene Sent: Tuesday, September 20, 2016 10:37 AM To: ADAMS IM <ADAMSSupport.Ema il @nrc.gov>

Subject:

Rights to a Documents

Hello, Can you tell me if I am an owner or viewer to ML13149A079? If not who is. I need to have access to this document.

Thank you , Jennene Littlejohn Lead Administrative Assistant RES/ORA 301-415-0428 (office} 301 -4 15-6671 (fax} TWFN-10-A06 Mailstop: T10-A12

From: Kauffman Lisa To: Stevens. Margo

Subject:

RE: FOIA-2016-0727 Date: Tuesday, 5eptember 20, 2016 10:30:06 AM Right.l...(b-)(5_) _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __. From: Stevens, Ma rgo Sent: Tuesday, September 20, 2016 10:29 AM To: Kauffman, Lisa <Lisa.Kauffman@nrc.gov>

Subject:

RE: FOIA-2016-0727 (b)(5) I l ...._ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __. right? Jvt.argo L. Stevens JOI.J\ .J\na(yst/'T'eam Leader (Contractor) OUO/CS'D/J"PI'B

   'U.S. :Nudear 1{egu[atory Commission 11545 'RocRvi((e 'Pike, Jvtai{ Stoy 'T'-2]"7
   'Rock:viffe, Jvtary(ana 20855
   'T'e[eyfwne #: (301) 415-8148 From: Kauffman, Lisa Sent: Tuesday, September 20, 2016 10:25 AM To: Stevens, Margo <Margo Stevens@nrc gov>

Subject:

RE: FOIA-2016-0727 5 Thanks. I'll let them know._l(b-)(- )_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ From: Stevens, Margo Sent: Tuesday, September 20, 2016 10:25 AM To: Kauffman, Lisa <Lisa Kauffman@nrc gov>

Subject:

RE: FOIA-2016-0727 (5) done! I rYou"re

M.argo L. Stevens J"OI.'A. .'A.na[yst/'T'eam Leader (Contractor)

OCIO/CS1)/:J'PI13

   'U.S. :Nudear negu(atory Commission 11545 'Rockvi[{e 1)ike, :Mai{ Stoy 'T'-2:J7

1wcfi:vi((e, Jvt.ary{ancf 20855 'J'e(eyfwne #: (301) 415-8148 From: Kauffman, Lisa Sent: Tuesday, September 20, 2016 10:23 AM To: St evens, M argo <Margo Steyens@nrc gov>

Subject:

RE: FOIA-2016-0727 So you don't want us to respond for the video or the e-mail. Is that right? From: Stevens, Ma rgo Sent: Tuesday, September 20, 2016 10:21 AM To: Kauffma n, Lisa <Lisa Kauffman@nrc gov>

Subject:

RE: FOIA-2016-0727 Lisa - last Friday I included NRR's Resource book on my email to Regions 1 and 2 that the video and email were theirs to provide input on, since Bill Dean was still R1 Regional Administrator. (He became NRR's Director a few months later). I've attached a copy of the email I sent here.

Margo L Stevens

fOI.Jl .Jlna(yst/'J'eam Leaaer (Contractor)

OCIO/CS'D/:f'Pl'B 'U.S. :Nudear R.egufatory Commrmon 115451{ocli.vi({e 1Jf/i.e, Jvt.ai{Stoy 1'-2]'1 1Wckvi((e, Jvt.ary{ancf 20855 'I'eleyfwne #: (301) 415-8148 From: Kauffman, Lisa Sent: Tuesday, September 20, 2016 10:14 AM To: Stevens, M argo <Margo.Steveos@nrc gov>

Subject:

RE : FOIA-2016-0727 Hi Margo, Are we on hold until we get a copy of the video? I don't think anyone in my office has seen it except for myself and possibly a TA.

Also, did RII get a tasking to review this as well?

Thanks, Lisa From: Stevens, Ma rgo Sent: Thursday, September 15, 2016 10:34 AM To: Rids Nrr M ailCe nter Resource <RidsNrrMa ilCenter .Resource@nrc .gov>; FOIAPAR2 Resource

<EOIAPAR2,Resource@nrc gov>

Subject:

FOIA-2016-072 7 Ladies - I am still waiting for RES to get me an electronic copy of the St. Lucie flooding video to share with you . But here's the ema il in question .

From: Kauffman Lisa To: Stevens. Margo

Subject:

RE: FOIA-2016-O727 Date: Tuesday, 5eptember 20, 2016 10:21:47 AM Thanks, I didn"t see this! From: Stevens, Margo Sent: Tuesday, September 20, 2016 10:21 AM To: Kauffman, Lisa <Lisa.Ka uffma n@nrc.gov>

Subject:

RE: FOIA-2016-0727 Lisa - last Friday I included NRR's Resource book on my email to Regions 1 and 2 that the video and email were theirs to provide input on, since Bill Dean was still R1 Regional Administrator. (He became NRR's Director a few months later). I've attached a copy of the email I sent here. Jvlargo L Stevens J'OIJl Jlna(ysl/Team Leaaer (Contractor) OCIO/CS'D/J:PI13 'U.S. :Nudear 1?.egu(alory Commission 11545 1{ocfi.vi((e 111/i.e, :Mai[ Slo_p T-2]'7 'Rockviffe, :Mary(ana 20855 TeCeyfwne #: (301) 415-8148 From: Kauffman, Lisa Se nt: Tuesday, September 20, 2016 10:14 AM To: Stevens, M argo <Mamo Stevens@nrc gov>

Subject:

RE: FOIA-2016-0727 Hi Margo, Are we on hold until we get a copy of the video? I don't think anyone in my office has seen it except for myself and possibly a TA. Also, did RII get a tasking to review this as well?

Thanks, Lisa From: Stevens, Margo Sent: Thursday, September 15, 2016 10:34 AM To: Rids NrrMailCenter Resource <RidsNrrMailCenter.Resource@nrc.gov>; FOIAPAR2 Resource

<FO IAPAR2 .Resource@nrc.gov>

Subject:

FOIA-2016-0727 Ladies - I am still waiting for RES to get me an electronic copy of the St. Lucie flooding video to share with you. But here's the email in question.

From: Stevens. Margo The attached record is addressed in response to multiple To: RidsNrrMailCenter Resource; EOIAPAR2 Resource

Subject:

RE: FOIA-2016-072.7 requests. including interim# 5 to your NRC-2018-000096. Date: Friday, September 16, 2016 11:40:00 AM This record (video) is publicly available in ADAMS as Attachments: D43 MOV03976-ML16236A019 mpg ML20294A133. Ladies - thanks for your patience. I've now received a copy of the 22-second video , for your views. And, given the question about the accompanying email - which is between Bill Dean and Vic Mccree back in the April-May 2014 time period, I did some digging into their history here at NRC. It looks like Bill Dean was the Regional Administrator, Region I (he became NRR Director later that same year -in October 2014) and Vic McCree was Regional Administrator, Region II (he became EDO sometime in the Fall of 2015). So - NRR - you may be off the hook! I'll now have to task Region I. Jvt.argo £.. Stevens J'OI:A .'A.na(yst/Team .£.ead'er (Contractor) OCIO/CS'D/JPI'B 'U.S. :Nudear 'Regufatory Commission 11545 'RocRvi((e 1JiRe, Jvt.ai{ Stoy T-2T1 'RocRviffe, Jvt.ary{anc( 20855 Te{eylione #: (301) 415-8148 From: Stevens, Margo Sent: Thursday, September 15, 2016 10:34 AM To: Rids NrrMailCenter Resource <RidsNrrMailCenter.Resource@nrc.gov>; FOIAPAR2 Resource <F0IAPAR2.Resource@nrc.gov>

Subject:

FOIA-2016-0727 Ladies - I am still waiting for RES to get me an electronic copy of the St. Lucie flooding video to share with you. But here's the email in question.

From: Stevens Margo To: Littlejohn. Jeanene

Subject:

RE: FOIA-2017-0727 Date: Tuesday, 5eptember 20, 2016 10: 15:00 AM Thank you . Jvt.argo L Stevens

fOI.'A. .'A.na{ysl/'T'eam Leader (Conlraclor)

OCIO/CS'D/J'1'l'B 'I.LS. :Nuc(ear 'Regu(atory Commission 11545 'Rockviffe 1Jike, :M.ai{ Stoy 'T'-2:F1 1wckv1((e, :M.ary{anrf 20855 'T'e[eyftone #: (301) 415-8148 From: Littlejohn, Jennene Sent: Tuesday, September 20, 2016 10:06 AM To: Stevens, M argo <Margo.Stevens@n rc.gov> Cc: Dennis, Suzanne <Suzanne.Den nis@nrc.gov>

Subject:

RE: FOIA-2017-0727 Hi Margo, Please find attached the document It has been removed from ADAMS. From: Stevens, Margo Sent: Tuesday, September 20, 2016 7:05 AM To: Littlej ohn, Jen nene <Jennene.Uttle john@nrc.gov> Cc: Dennis, Suzanne <Suzanne.Dennis@nrc.gov>

Subject:

FOIA-2017-0727 Importance: High Good morning ladies. One of the records that Mr. Criscione uploaded into an ML package he created (MLL 16195A365) was a briefing package bearing the ML#16216A611 . It is described as "Union of Concerned Scientists' briefing package for NRC Chairman Burns and Commissioner Baran." Do you still have access to it? It is one of the documents I couldn't access when I first received the request (and before RES took steps to remove the items from ADAMS). Feel free to email it to me, as I suspect that's the easiest and fastest way. Thanks.

Margo L. Stevens J'OI.'A .'Ana{yst/ Team Leaaer (Contractor)

OCIO/CSD/JTI'B 'U.S. Nudear 'Regu{atory Commission 11545 'Rockvi((e 'Pike, :Mai{ Stoy 'T'-2:J7 'Rockviffe, :M.ary{ana 20855 Te[eylione #: (301) 415-8148

From: Stevens Margo To: EOIAPAR2 Resource; Icavick. Vaoette

Subject:

FW: FOINPA-2016-00727 Action Item/Instructions Search for Records in Perfected Request due by COB 9/23/16 Date: Tuesday, 5eptember 20, 2016 7:06:00 AM Good morning Vanette.

Margo L. Stevens JOI.JI. .Jlna(yst/Team Leaaer (Contractor)

OCIO/CS'IJ/]PI'B 'U.S. Nudear 'Regu{atory Comm1sswn 11545 1{oclivi((e 1'ilie, Jvlai[Stoy '1-2:[7 'Rocfi:vi({e, Jvlary(ana 20855 Te(eyfione #: (301) 415-8148 From: Klukan, Brett Sent: Monday, September 19, 2016 3:53 PM To: Holt, Dennis <Dennis. Holt @nrc.gov>; St eve ns, Ma rgo <Ma rgo.St evens@ nrc.gov>

Subject:

RE: FOIA/PA-2016-00727 Action Item/Inst ructions Search for Records in Perfected Request due by COB 9/23/16

Margo, (b)(5)

Let me know if you need anything else from RI re this.

Cheers, Brett From: ODaniell, Cynt hia Sent: Monday, September 19, 2016 8:39 AM To: Lew, David <David Lew@nrc gov>; Dorman, Da n <Dan Dorman@nrc gov>; Klukan, Brett

<Brett.Kiukan@nrc.gov>; Screnci, Diane <Diane.Screnci@nrc.gov>; Sheehan, Neil <Nei!.Sheehan@nrc gov>; Bicket t, Brice <Brice Bickett@nrc gov>; Tifft, Doug <Doug Iifft@nrc gov>; Crisden, Cherie X <Cher je.Crjsden@nrc.gov>: McLaughlin, M arjorie <Marjorie.McLaughlio@nrc.gov>:

Bolger, Allyce <Allyce.Bolger@nrc.gov>; Warnek, Nicole <Nicole.Warnek@nrc.gov>

Subject:

FW: FOIA/PA-2016-00727 Action Item/Instructions Search for Records in Perfected Req uest due by COB 9/23/16 Importance: High See details in yellow below. From: Holt, Dennis Sent: M onday, September 19, 2016 7:51 AM To: ODaniell, Cynthia <Cynthia ODaoiell@orc gov>; Cowan, Grace <Grace Cowa n@nrc gov>; Heater, Keit h <Keith Heater@nrc gov>; Powell, Gerry <Gerry Powell@nrc gov>; M cKenzie, Kieta <Kieta McKenzie@nrc gov>: Pinkham, Laurie <Laurie Pinkham@nrc gov> Cc: Manning, Louis <Lou is Manning@nrc gov>; Dean, Michael <Michael Dean@nrc gov>

Subject:

FW: FOIA/PA-2016-00727 Action Item/Instructions Search for Records in Perfected Req uest due by COB 9/23/16 Importance: High Good Day, Please search for and provide records responsive to the attached FOIA. The FOIA is due by COB 9/23/16. The FOIA request should be processed in accordance with "How to Respond to an Initial FOIA Request" at ML060590485. Also, please complete the attached processing sheet, and confirm receipt of this FOIA. Please pay extra attention to the section marked in 1feiiow. Thank you.

Regards, Dennis Holt Region I Help Desk/FOIA 610.337.5050 From: RlFOIAPA RESOU RCE Sent: Friday, September 16, 2016 12:00 PM To: Dean, M ichael <M ichael.Dea n@nrc.gov>; Ma nning, Louis <Lou is.Mann ing@nrc.gov>; Holt, Denn is <Denn is.Holt@nrc.gov>; Skomsky, April <April.Skoms.ky@nrc.gov>; Moretto, Matthew

<Matthew Moretto@nrc gov>

Subject:

FW: FOIA/PA-2016-00727 Action Item/Instructions Search for Records in Perfected Req uest From: Stevens, Margo Sent: Friday, September 16, 2016 11:59:59 AM (UTC-05:00) Eastern Time (US & Canada) To: RlFOIAPA RESOURCE Cc: Stevens, Margo; Danoff, Karen

Subject:

FOIA/PA-2016-00727 Action Item/Instructions Search for Records in Perfected Request Offices Assigned Action on September 16, 2016; RI The requester has either agreed to pay the estimated fees, or has provided an advance payment, or there are no billable fees. The request is now considered "perfected." The Government Information Specialist for this request is Margo Stevens, who can be reached at 301-415-8148 or Mac~o Stcvcns@ncc ~ov.

(b)(5) The FOIA request should be processed in accordance with the standard instructions (How to Respond to a FO IA Request) at ML 16123 A l64. NRC Form 511, "Program Office Response to a FOIA Request" is available in the NRC Forms Library for your use. You are encouraged to ask for assistance in performing adequate ADAMS searches if you have any di fficulty doing a search. RC Form 496, "Report of Staff Resources for Processing FOIA Requests" is also avail able in the NRC Forms Library for your use. When you respond, please make s ure that you are ending your response to FOI A.Resource@nrc ~ov, as well as the ass igned spec ialist. Thank you.

From: Stevens Margo To: Klukan. Brett; Holt. Dennis

Subject:

RE: FOIA/PA-2016-00727 Action Item/Instructions Search for Records in Perfected Request due by COB 9/23/16 Date: Tuesday, September 20, 2016 6:44:00 AM Thanks. That's what I needed from RI. I'll close out your tasking . Jvt.argo L Stevens

fOI.'A. .'A.na{ysl/'T'eam Leader (Conlraclor)

OCIO/CS'D/J"1'l'B 'I.LS. :Nuc(ear 'Regu(atory Commission 11545 'Rockviffe 1Jike, :M.ai{ Stoy 'T'-2:F1 1wckv1((e, :M.ary{anrf 20855 'T'e[e_pftone #: (301) 415-8148 From: Klukan, Brett Sent: Monday, September 19, 2016 3:53 PM To: Holt, Den nis <Denn is.Holt@nrc.gov>; St eve ns, Margo <Ma rgo.St evens@ nrc.gov>

Subject:

RE: FOIA/PA-2016-00727 Action Item/Instructions Search for Records in Perfected Request due by COB 9/23/16

Margo, (b)(5)

Let me know if you need anything else from RI re this.

Cheers, Brett From: ODaniell, Cynt hia Sent: Monday, September 19, 2016 8:39 AM To: Lew, David <David Lew@nrc gov>; Dorman, Da n <Dan Dorman@nrc gov>; Klukan, Brett

<Brett Klukan@nrc.gov>; Screnci, Diane <Diane Screnci@nrc.gov>; Sheehan, Neil <Nei l Sheehan@nrc gov>; Bickett, Brice <Brice Bickett@nrc PY>; Tifft, Doug <Doug I ifft@nrc gov>; Crisden, Cherie X <Cherie Crisden@nrc gov>; McLaugh lin, Marjorie <Marjorie Mclaughlin@nrc gov>; Bolger, Allyce <Allyce Bolger@nrc gov>; Warnek, Nicole <Nicole Warnek@nrc gov>

Subject:

FW: FOIA/PA-2016-00727 Action Item/Instructions Search for Records in Perfected Req uest due by COB 9/23/16 Importance: High

See details in yellow below. From: Holt, Dennis Sent: M onday, September 19, 2016 7:51 AM To: ODaniell, Cynthia <Cynthia ODaniell@orc gov>; Cowan, Grace <Grace Cowa n@nrc gov>; Heater, Keith <Keith Heater@nrc gov>; Powell, Gerry <Gerry Powell@orc gov>; M cKenzie, Kieta <Kieta McKenzie@nrc gov>: Pinkham, Laurie <Laurie Pinkham@nrc gov> Cc: Manning, Louis <Lou is Manning@nrc gov>; Dean, Michael <Michael Dean@nrc gov>

Subject:

FW: FOIA/PA-2016-00727 Action Item/Instructions Search for Records in Perfected Req uest due by COB 9/23/16 Importance: High Good Day, Please search for and provide records responsive to the attached FOIA . The FOIA is due by COB 9/23/16. The FOIA request should be processed in accordance with "How to Respond to an Initial FOIA Request" at ML060590485. Also, please complete the attached processing sheet, and confirm receipt of this FOIA. Please pay extra attention to the section marked in ~ - Thank you.

Regards, Dennis Holt Region I Help Desk/FOIA 610.337.5050 From: RlFOIAPA RESOU RCE Sent: Friday, September 16, 2016 12:00 PM To: Dean, M ichael <M ichael.Dea n@nrc.gov>; Ma nning, Louis <Louis.Mann ing@nrc.gov>; Holt, Denn is <Denn is Holt@nrc gov>; Skomsky, April <April Skomsky@nrc gov>; Moretto, Matthew

<Matthew Moretto@nrc gov>

Subject:

FW: FOIA/PA-2016-00727 Action Item/I nstr uct ions Search for Records in Perfected Req uest From: Stevens, Margo Sent: Friday, September 16, 2016 11:59:59 AM (UTC-05:00) Eastern Time (US & Canada) To: R1FOIAPA RESOURCE Cc: Stevens, Margo; Danoff, Karen

Subject:

FOIA/PA-2016-00727 Action Item/Instructions Search for Records in Perfected Request Offices Assigned Actjon on September 16, 2016; RI The requester has either agreed to pay the estimated fees, or has provided an advance payment, or there are no billable fees. The request is now considered "perfected." The Government Information Specialist for this request is Margo Stevens, who can be reached at 301-4 15-8148 or Mac~o Stcycns@orc i:ov.

The FOIA request should be processed in accordance with the standard instructions (How to Respond to a FOIA Request) at ML l 6 123A l 64. NRC Forni S 11, "Program Office Response to a FOIA Request" is available in the RC Forms Library for your use. You arc encouraged to ask for assistance in performing adequate ADAMS searches if you have any difficulty doing a search. NRC Form 496, "Repmt of Staff Resources for Processing FOIA Requests " is also available in the NRC F01111s Library for your use. When you respond, please make sure that you are sending your response to FO)A Resource@nrc gov, as well as the ass igned spec ialist. Thank you.

From: Stevens Margo To: Danoff. Karen

Subject:

RE: FOIA-2016-0727 (and a few others) Date: Friday, September 16, 2016 12:40:00 PM I also placed it in the G drive. No worries about the excel spreadsheet. It'll get done. Jvt.argo .£. Stevens

fOI.'A. .'A.na{ysl/'T'eam Leader (Conlraclor)

OCIO/CS'D/J'1'l'B 'I.LS. :Nuc(ear 'Regu(atory Commission 11545 'Rockviffe 1Jike, :M.ai{ Stoy 'T'-2:F1 'Rockv1((e, :M.ary{anrf 20855 'T'e[e_pftone #: (301) 415-8148 From: Danoff, Karen Sent: Friday, September 16, 2016 12:14 PM To: Stevens, Margo <Margo.Stevens@nrc.gov>

Subject:

RE: FOIA-2016-0727 (and a few others) I'm able to view the video attached to this email. © I can try to copy it to the G drive. With the preparation for our meeting Monday morning, and with other assignments, I may not be able to finish the Excel matrix before I leave today. I couldn't find an easy way to save the color, so I'm doing it by hand, plus there's other formatting cleaning up to do. I know the color is important in this file, so I want to maintain it the best I can. I know how/what to do, just finding the time is difficult. From: Stevens, Margo Sent: Friday, September 16, 2016 12:09 PM To: RlFOIAPA RESOURCE <RlFOIAPA RESOURCE@nrc gov>; FOIAPAR2 Resource <EOIAPAR2 Resource@nrc.gov> Cc: Danoff, Ka ren <Karen Danoff@nrc gov>

Subject:

FOIA-2016-0727 (and a few others) OK. HERE (at last, I hope) is the video clip to accompany the email that I tasked to both regions earlier this week, and just a few moments ago. Jvt.argo .£. Stevens J"OI.'A .'A.na(ysl/'T'eam Lead"er (Conlraclor) OCIO/CS'D/J"'Pl13

'U.S. Nudear 'Regu{atory Commission 11545 'Rock:vi((e 'Pike, Jvl.ai{ Stoy 'T'-2J"7 'Rockviffe, Jvt.ary(ana 20855 Te{eyfione #: (301) 415-8148

From: Stevens Margo To: R1FOIAPA RESOURCE; FOIAPAR2 Resource Cc: Danoff, Karen The attached record is addressed in response to multiple

Subject:

FOIA-2016-0727 (and a few others) requests, including interim # 5 to your NRC-2018-000096. Date: Friday, September 16, 2016 12 :08: 00 PM Attachments: D43 MOV03976-ML16236A019.mpg This record (video) is publicly available in ADAMS as ML20294A133. OK. HERE (at last, I hope) is the video clip to accompany the emai l that I tasked to both regions earlier this week, and just a few moments ago. Jvlargo L. Stevens

JOJ.:A. .:A.na{yst/Team .Leacler (Contractor)

OCJO/CSD/TPI'B 'U.S. :Nudear 'RR.gu{atory Commission 11545 'RocR.vi((e 'PiR.e, Jvlai{ Stoy T-2:f7 'RocR.vi((e, JvlaryCancl 20855 Te{eyfwne #: (301) 415-8148

The 1st attachment (request) is publicly available in ADAMS as ML20294A128 . The 2d attachment is one of the records From: Stevens Margo (as ultimately processed) To: R1FOJAPA RESOURCE addressed in response to multiple Cc: Stevens. Margo: Danoff. Karen requests, including interim # 5 to

Subject:

FOIA/PA-2016-00727 Action Item/Instructions Search for Records in Perfected Request Date: Friday, September 16, 2016 12:00:01 PM your NRC-2018-000096. This Attachments: 2016-0727-r.odf response is publicly available in ML16236A021.odf ADAMS as ML20288A415. Offices Assigned Action on September 16, 2016; RI The requester has either agreed to pay the estimated fees, or has provided an advance payment, or there arc no billable fees. T he request is now considered "perfected." Please provide the Government Jnfom1ation Specialist, who is named below, with the responsive records on or before September 29, 2016, which is ten (10) working days from the date of this e-mai l. The Government Info nnation Specialist for this reque tis Margo Stevens, who can be reached at 301-4 15-8148 or Margo.Stevens@nrc.gov. (b)(5) The FOIA request should be processed in accordance with the standard instmctions (How to Respond to a FOIA Request) at MLI6123AI64. NRC Form 51 I, "Program Office Response to a FOLA Request" is available in the RC Forms Library for your use. You are encouraged to ask for assistance in performing adequate ADAMS searches if you have any difficulty doing a search. NRC Form 496, "Report of Staff Resources for Proce sing FOIA Requests " is also avail able in the NRC Fom1s Library for your use. When you respond, please make sure that you are send ing your response to FOIA Resource@nrc ~ov , as well as the ass igned spec ialist. Thank you.

The attached record is addressed in response to From: Stevens Margo To: multiple requests, including interim # 5 to your R1FOJAPA RESOURCE

Subject:

FOIA-2016-0727 NRC-2018-000096 . This record (video) is Date: Friday, September 16, 2016 12:00:00 PM publicly available in ADAMS as ML20294A133. Attachments: D43 MOV03976-ML16236A019.mpg As the tasking I just sent via FOIAXpress noted, here is the video clip for which we'd appreciate Region l's views. Jvlargo L. Stevens JOI.Jl .Jlna{yst/Team ieaaer (Contractor) OCIO/CS'D/:f'Pl'B 11.5. Nudear 'Regu{atory Commission 11545 'Rockvi((e 'Pike, Jvlai{Stoy T-2]'7 'Rocfiviffe, Jvlary{anc{ 20855 'J'e{e_plione #: (301) 415-8148

From: Stevens. Margo To: RidsNrrMailCenter Resource; EOIAPAR2 Resource

Subject:

RE: FOIA-2016-072.7 Date: Friday, September 16, 2016 11:40:00 AM Attachments: D43 MOV03976-ML16236A019 mpg Ladies - thanks for your patience. I've now received a copy of the 22-second video , for your views. And, given the question about the accompanying email - which is between Bill Dean and Vic Mccree back in the April-May 2014 time period, I did some digging into their history here at NRC. It looks like Bill Dean was the Regional Administrator, Region I (he became NRR Director later that same year -in October 2014) and Vic McCree was Regional Administrator, Region II (he became EDO sometime in the Fall of 2015). So - NRR - you may be off the hook! I'll now have to task Region I. Jvt.argo £.. Stevens J'OI:A .'A.na(yst/Team Leaaer (Contractor) OCIO/CS'D/JPI'B 'U.S. :Nudear 'Regufatory Commission 11545 'RocRvi((e 1JiRe, Jvt.ai{ Stoy T-2T1 'RocRviffe, Jvt.ary{anc( 20855 Te{eylione #: (301) 415-8148 From: Stevens, Margo Sent: Thursday, September 15, 2016 10:34 AM To: Rids Nrr MailCenter Resource <RidsNrrMailCenter.Resource@nrc.gov>; FOIAPAR2 Resource <F0IAPAR2.Resource@nrc.gov>

Subject:

FOIA-2016-0727 Ladies - I am still waiting for RES to get me an electronic copy of the St. Lucie flooding video to share with you. But here's the email in question.

From: Stevens Margo To: Campbell, Andy

Subject:

RE: ML14090A406 (USACE Report) Date: Friday, September 16, 2016 6:35:00 AM The POC would be me. Jvt.argo L Stevens

]"01.'A. .'A.na{ysl/'T'eam Leader (Conlraclor)

OCIO/CS'D/J'1'l'B

'I.LS. :Nuc(ear 'Regu(atory Commission 11545 'Rockviffe 1Jike, :M.ai{ Stoy 'T'-2:F1 1wckv1((e, :M.ary{anrf 20855
'T'e[eyftone #: (301) 415-8148 From: Campbell, Andy Sent: Thursday, September 15, 2016 6:23 PM To: Harvey, Brad <Brad.Harvey@n rc.gov>; Stevens, Margo < Margo.Stevens@nrc.gov>

Cc: Cook, Christopher <Christopher.Cook@ nrc.gov>; See, Kenneth <Kenneth.See@ nrc.gov>; Rivera-Varona, Aida <Aida.Rivera-Varona@nrc.gov>; Ammon, Bern ice <Bernice.Ammon@nrc.gov>; Imboden, Andy <Andy. lmbod en@nrc.gov>

Subject:

RE: M L14090A406 (USACE Report) Hi Margo, (b)(5)

Thanks, Andy Andrew C. Campbell, Ph.D.

Deputy Director Division of Site Safety & Environmental Analysis Office of New Reactors mail stop T7-F3 US Nuclear Regulatory Commission Rockville, MD 20852

email: Andy.Campbell@nrc.gov phone: 301-415-7566 From: Harvey, Brad Sent: Thursday, September 15, 2016 2:47 PM To: Stevens, M argo <Margo.Stevens@nrc.gov> Cc: Campbel l, Andy <Andy.Campbell@orc gov>; Cook, Christop her <Christopher Cook@nrc gov>; See, Kenneth <Kenneth See@nrc gov>; Rivera-Varona, Aida <Aida Rivera-Yarona@nrc gov>

Subject:

RE: ML14090A406 (USACE Report) Margo: (b)(5) Hope this helps. Please let me know if there are any questions. Brad 415-4118 From: Stevens, Margo Sent: Thursday, September 15, 2016 12:05 PM To: Harvey, Brad <Brad Harvey@nrc gov>

Subject:

ML14090A406 (USACE Report) Importance: High (b)(5) ,____ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _1we issued a full denial to the report on the basis of FOIA exemptions 7E and F, and informed Mr. Lochbaum that if he wished to administratively appeal that determination, he should direct it to the USAGE. (I don't know that he ever did that). (b)(5)

Margo L. Stevens J'OI.'A .'Ana{yst/ Team Leaaer (Contractor)

OCIO/CSD/JTI'B 'U.S. Nudear 'Regu{atory Commission 11545 'Rockvi((e 'Pike, :Mai{ Stoy 'T'-2:J7 'Rockviffe, :M.ary{ana 20855 Te[eylione #: (301) 415-8148

From: Stevens Margo To: Harvey. Brad

Subject:

RE: ML14090A406 (USACE Report) Date: Friday, September 16, 2016 6:27:00 AM (b)(5)

Margo L Stevens JOI.JI. .Jlna(yst/'Team Leader (Contractor)

OUO/CS'D/J"PI'B

'I.LS. :Nudear 1Zegu(atory Commission 11545 'Rocfi.vi((e 'Pifi.e, Jvlai{ Stoy 'T-2:f7
'Rocfi.vi(fe, Jvlary(ana 20855 Te(eyn.one #: (.w1) 415-8148 From: Harvey, Brad Se nt: Thursday, September 15, 2016 2:47 PM To: Stevens, M argo <Margo.Stevens@nrc.gov>

Cc: Campbel l, Andy <Andy.Campbell@nrc.gov>; Cook, Christopher <Christopher.Cook@nrc.gov>; See, Kenneth <Kenneth.See@nrc.gov>; Rivera-Varona, Aida <Aida.Rivera-Varona@nrc.gov>

Subject:

RE : ML14090A406 (USACE Report ) Margo: (b)(5) Hope this helps. Please let me know if there are any questions. Brad 41 5-411 8 From: Stevens, Ma rgo Sent: Thursday, September 15, 2016 12:05 PM To: Ha rvey, Brad <Brad Harvey@nrc gov>

Subject:

ML14090A406 (USACE Report) Importance: High

(b)(5) L,------------------------=---------____,J Iwe issued a full ....denial to the report on the basis of FOIA exemptions 7E and F, and informed Mr. Lochbaum that if he wished to administratively appeal that determination, he should direct it to the USACE. (I don't know that he ever did that). (b)(5) Jvlargo L. Stevens

f'OI.Jl Jlna{yst/I'eam Leaaer (Contractor)

OCIO/CSV/TPI13

   'U.S. :Nudear 'Regu{atory Commission 11545 'Rockvi((e 'Pike, Jvlai{ Stoy 7-2:J7 1wckviffe, Jvt.ary{ana 20855
   'T'e{e_pfwne #: (301) 415-8148

From: Littlejohn. Jennene To: Stevens. Margo

Subject:

Video Date: Thursday, 5eptember 15, 2016 5 :43 :43 PM Hi Margo, I've made a copy of the video, would you like for me to put it interoffice mail or drop it off? Thank you, Jennene Littlejohn Lead Administrative Assistant RES/ORA 301 -415-0428 (office) 301 -415-6671 (fax) TWFN- 10-A06 Mailstop: T10-A12

From: Littlejohn. Jennene To: Pennis. Suzanne Cc: Stevens Margo

Subject:

RE: More of "those" requests Date: Thursday, September 15, 2016 5:33:08 PM Margo, I actually don't have access to this file. From: Dennis, Suzanne Sent: Thursday, September 15, 2016 5:13 PM To: Littlejohn, Jen nene <Jenn ene. Littlejohn@ nre.gov> Cc: Stevens, M argo <M argo.Stevens@nrc.gov>

Subject:

FW: More of "t hose" request s Importance: High Jennene, Can you help Margo? Thanks! Suzanne From: Stevens, Margo Sent: Thursday, September 15, 2016 11:05 AM To: Denn is, Suzanne <Suza nn e Dennjs@nrc.gov>

Subject:

More of "those" request s Importance: High Suzanne, if I may impose on you for two things. First, can you check with Janene about the St. Lucie flooding video clip that she was going to put on a CD for me? I need to send it to NRR and RII for their views ... Second, in 2016-0725, Larrv has asked for 13 ore-existino records.I (b)(5) He says it's ML13149A079, Second Quarter Operating Plan FY-2013. Can you access it? Feel free to send it to me electronically if that's easier. Thanks.

.Margo£.. Stevens J"OI.51.. .51..na[yst/'leam Lea<,{er (Contractor)

OCIO/CS'D/JTI'B

'!LS. :Nuc{ear 'Regu[atory Commission

11545 1wcli.vi((e Tike, Jvlai{Stoy 'l-2:f7 Rockviffe, Jvlaryrana 20855 Te{eyfwne #: (301) 415-8148

From: Littlejohn. Jennene To: Pennis. Suzanne Cc: Stevens Margo

Subject:

RE: More of "those" requests Date: Thursday, September 15, 2016 5:30:22 PM Hi Margo. I am in the process now of putting the video on the CD, I can check to see if I have access to this ML number. Jennene From: Dennis, Suzanne Sent: Thursday, September 15, 2016 5:13 PM To: Littlejohn, Jen nene <Jennene.Litt lejohn@ nrc.gov> Cc: Stevens, M argo <M argo.Stevens@n rc.gov>

Subject:

FW: More of "those" request s Importance: High Jennene. Can you help Margo? Thanks! Suzanne From: Stevens, Margo Sent: Thursday, September 15, 2016 11:05 AM To: Denn is, Suzanne <Suzanne Denn js@nrc gov>

Subject:

More of "those" requests Importance: High Suzanne, if I may impose on you for two things. First, can you check with Janene about the St. Lucie flooding video clip that she was going to put on a CD for me? I need to send it to NRR and RII for their views .. . Second, in 2016-0725, Larry has asked for 13 pre-existing records. [ (b)(5) He says it's ML13149A079, Second Quarter Operating Plan FY-2013. Can you access it? Feel free to send it to me electronically if that's easier. Thanks.

Margo L Stevens

J'OI:A :Ana{yst/'Team .£eaaer (Contractor) OCIO/CSJJ/]"PI'B 'U.S. Nudear 'Regu{atory Commission 11545 'RocRvi((e 'Pike, Jvlai{ Stoy T-2]'7 'RocRviffe, Jvlary[ana 20855 'Te{eylione #: {301) 415-8148

From: Kauffman Lisa To: Stevens. Margo

Subject:

RE: FOIA/PA-2016-00727 Action Item/Instructions Search for Records in Perfected Request Date: Thursday, September 15, 2016 9:28:27 AM Hi Margo. You are right, I no longer have access to the video or the e-mail. Can you send me a PDF of the e-mail? I should have printed it or saved it on Tuesday when I looked at it, but I didn't! I suspect I will also need a copy of the video when you get one.

Thanks, Lisa From: Stevens, Margo [4]

Sent: Tuesday, September 13, 2016 1:28 PM To: Rids NrrMailCenter Resource <RidsN rrMa ilCenter.Resource@nrc.gov> Cc: Kauffman, Lisa <Lisa.Ka uffman@nrc.gov>; Stevens, Margo <Margo.Stevens@ nrc.gov>

Subject:

FOIA/PA-2016-00727 Action Item/Instructions Search for Records in Perfected Request Offices Assjpned Action on September n 201 6* NRR The requester has either agreed to pay the estimated fees, or has provided an advance payment, or there arc no billable fees. The request is now considered "perfected." Please provide the Government lnfonnation Specia.list, who is named below, with the responsive records on or before September 26, 201 6, whic h is ten (10) wo rking days from the date o f this e-mail. The Government lnformation Specialist for this request is Margo Stevens, who can be reached at 301-415-8148 or Mar~o Stcveos@nrc ~oy. (b)(5) The FOlA request s hould be processed in accordance with the standard instructions (How to Respond to a FOlA Request) at MLI6 123AI64. NRC Form 511, "Program Office Response to a FOIA Request" is available in the NRC Forms Library for your use. In order to document the search conducted, in the event o fai, appeal challenging the adequacy of the search, please also have each member of your staff who conducts a search complete NRC Fonn SI I A, "Documentation of a FOIA Search," which is also available in the NRC Forms Library for your use. Please review these forms to ens ure that an adequate, and cons istent, search has been performed within your office. Then include copies of the completed NRC Forms 511 A along with the NRC Form 51 1 you return to the assigned specialist. Alte rnatively, you may complete the NRC Form 5 11A on behalf o f your o ffice, based upon the descriptions of searches provided to you by your office staff. You are encouraged to ask for assistance in performing adequate ADAMS searches if you have any difficulty doing a search. NRC Form 496, "Report of Staff Resources for Processing FOIA Requests" is also available in the NRC Fonns Library for your use. When you respond, please make s ure that you arc sending your response to FOIA Rcsourcc@nrc gov. as well as the assigned specialist. Thank you.

From: Stevens Margo The attachment is one of the records (as ultimately To: Jrayjck Yanette

Subject:

Document you need processed) addressed in response to multiple requests, Date: Wednesday, September 14, 2016 8:33:00 AM including interim# 5 to your NRC-2018-000096. This Attachments: ML16236A021.pdf response is publicly available in ADAMS as - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ML20288A415. Jvlargo L. Stevens

fOI.'A. .'A.na{yst/ Team iead"er (Contractor)

OCIO/CS'D/:f'PJ'B 11..S. :NucCear 'ReguCatory Commission 11545 'RocR.vi((e 'PiR.e, Jvlai{ Stoy T-2:f7 'RocR-vi((e, JvlaryCand" 20855 Te{eylione #: (301) 415-8148

From: FOIAPASECY Resource To: fOIA Resource Cc: Stevens Margo: Bates Andrew: Lewis, Antoinette: craver. Patti: Mcc1oskey. Brjdin

Subject:

FOIA/ PA-2016-00727 - SECY Response Date: Tuesday, September 13, 2016 2:36:09 PM Hi Margo. (b)(5)

Thanks, Kristy Kristy Remsburg Correspondence and Records Office of the Secretary U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Office: 301-415-1667 From: Stevens, Ma rgo [mailt o:foia. reso urce@nrc.gov]

Sent: Tuesday, Septem ber 13, 2016 11:32 AM To: FO IAPASECY Resou rce <FOIAPASECY.Resource@nrc.gov> Cc: Stevens, M argo <Margo.Stevens@n rc.gov>; Remsburg, Kristy <Kristy.Remsburg@nrc.gov>

Subject:

FOIA/PA-2016-00727 Act ion Item/Inst ructions Sea rch for Records in Perfected Request Offices Assigned Action on September 13. 2016; SECY The requester has either agreed to pay the estimated fees, or has provided an advance payment, or there are no billable fees. The request is now considered "perfected." Please provide the Government lnfom1ation Specia.list, who is named below, with the responsive records on or before September 26, 201 6, which is ten (10) working days from the date of this e-mail. The Government Information Specialist for this request is Margo Stevens, who can be reached at 301-415-8148 or Macao Stevens@nrc aov. If there are no responsive records, please respond with "No records." If you believe any other office, not copied on th is e-mail, may have responsive records, please let the assigned specialist know. The FOIA request should be processed in accordance with the standard instrnctions (How to Respond to a FOIA Request) at ML l6 123Al 64. NRC Form 5 11, "Program Office Response to a FOIA Request" is available in the NRC Forms Library for your use. ln order to document the search conducted, in the event ofan appeal challenging the adequacy of the search, please also have each member of your staff who conducts a search complete NRC Forni 51 IA, "Documentation of a FOIA Search," which is also available in the NRC Forms Library for your use. Please review these fonns to ensure that an adequate, and consistent, search has been performed within your office. Then include copies of the completed NRC Forms S 11 A along with the NRC Fonn 51 1 you return to the assigned specialist. Alternatively, you may complete the NRC Form 51 1A on behalf of your office, based upon the descriptions of searches provided to you by your office staff. You are encouraged to ask for iissistance in performing adequate ADAMS searches if you have any difficulty doing a search.

NRC Form 496, "Report of Staff Resources for Processing FOlA Requ ests" is also avail able in the NRC Forms Library for your use. When you respond, please make sure that you are sending your response to FOIA.Resource@nrc gov, as well as the assigned specialist. Thank you.

From: Stevens Margo To: BidsNrrMai!Center Resource Cc: Kauffman. usa: Stevens. Margo

Subject:

FOIA/PA-2016-00727 Action Item/Instructions ,,,_..,_,_,__,___,,,"----'-'"""'"--"'-'Llll-'--'-1..l.S.!""'---'-""""=~- - - - - - - - - - ~ Date: Tuesday, September 13, 2016 1:28:20 PM The attached request is publicly available in ADAMS as Attachments: 2016-0727-r.pdf ML20294A128. Offices Assjpned Action on September 13, 2016; NRR The requester has either agreed to pay the estimated fees, or has provided an advance payment, or there are no bi llable fees. The request is now considered "perfected." Please provide the Government Information Specialist, who is named below, with the respons ive records on or before September 26, 2016, which is ten (10) working days from the date of th is e-mail. The Government Information Specialist for this request is Margo Stevens, who can be reached at 301-415-8148 or Margo.Stevens arc.go,*. (b)(5) The FO[A request should be processed in accordance with the standard instmctions (How to Respond to a FOIA Request) at MLl6123Al64. NRC Fom1 511, "Program Office Response to a FOIA Request" is available in the RC Forms Library for your use. ln order to document the search conducted, in the event ofan appeal challenging the adequacy of the search, please also have each member of your staff who conducts a search complete NRC Fom1 51 IA, "Documentation ofa FOlA Search," which is also available in the R Form Library for your use. Please review the e forms to ensure that an adequate, and consistent, search has been performed with in your office. Then include copi es of the completed NRC Forms 511 A along with the NRC Form 51 1 you return to the assigned specia list. Alternatively, you may complete the NRC Form 511 A on behalf of your office, based upon the descriptions of searches provided to you by your office staff. You are encouraged to ask for assistance in performing adequate ADAMS searches if you have any difficulty doing a search. RC Form 496, "Report of Staff Resources for Processing FOlA Requ ests" i also avai lable in the NRC Fom1s Library for your use. When you respond, please make sure that you are sending your response to FOIA Resource@nrc JlOV , as well as the ass igned speciali st. Thank you.

From: FOIAPASECY Resource To: Stevens. Margo

Subject:

RE: FOIA/PA-2016-00727 Action Item/Instructions Search for Records in Perfected Request Date: Tuesday, September 13, 2016 12:06:17 PM

Margo, (b)(5)

Kristy Kristy Remsburg Correspondence and Records Office of the Secretary U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Office: 301-415-1667 From: Stevens, Margo [5] Sent: Tuesday, September 13, 2016 11:32 AM To: FOIAPASECY Resource <FOIAPASECY.Resource@nrc.gov> Cc: Stevens, Margo <Margo.Stevens@nrc.gov>; Remsburg, Kristy <Kristy.Remsburg@nrc.gov>

Subject:

FOIA/PA-2016-00727 Action Item/Instructions Search for Records in Perfected Request Offices Assigned Action on September 13. 2016: SECY The requester has either agreed to pay the estimated fees, or has provided an advance payment, or there arc no billable fees. The request is now considered "perfected." Please provide the Government lnfonnation Specialist, who is named below, with the responsive records on or before September 26, 201 6, wl1ich is ten (10) work ing clays from the elate of this e-mail. The Government Information Specialist for this request is Ma rgo Stevens, who can be reached at 3 01-415-8148 or Margo Stevens@nrc gov. If there are no responsive records, please respond with "No records." If you believe any other office, not copied on this e-mail, may have responsive records, please let the assigned specialist know. The FOIA request should be processed in accordance with the standard instructions (How to Respond to a FOIA Request) at ML16123Al64. NRC Form 5 11, "Program Office Response to a FOIA Request" is available in the NRC Forms Library for your use. In order to document the search conductted, in the event ofan appeal challenging the adequacy of the search, please also have each member of your staff who conducts a search complete NRC Forni 51 !A, "Documentation of a FOIA Search," which is also available in the NRC Forms Library for your use. Please review these fom1s to ensure that an adequate, and consistent, search has been performed within your office. Then include copies of the completed NRC Fonns 51 1A along with the NRC Form 51 1 you return to the assigned specialist. Alternatively, you may complete the NRC Form 51 1A on behalf of your office, based upon the descriptions of searches provided to you by your office staff. You are encouraged to ask for assistance in performing adequate ADAMS searches if you have any difficulty doing a search.

RC Form 496, "Report of Staff Resources for Processing FOLA Requ ests" is also ava ilable in the NRC Forms Library for your use. When you respond, please make sure that you are sending your response to FOIA Re~ource@nrc gov, as well as the ass igned spec iali st. Thank you.

From: Stevens Margo To: EP1APAR2 Resource Cc: Stevens. Margo

Subject:

FOIA/PA-2016-00727 Action Item/Instructions Search for Records in Perfected Request Date: Tuesday, September 13, 2016 11:28:47 AM The attached request is publicly Attachments: 2016 -0727 -r.odf avaI*1abl e .in ADAMS as - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- ML20294A128. Offices Assjpned Action on September 13, 2016; Rll The requester has either agreed to pay the estimated fees, or has provided an advance payment, or there are no bi llable fees. The request is now considered "perfected." Please provide the Government Information Specialist, who is named below, with the respons ive records on or before September 26, 2016, which is ten (10) working days from the date of th is e-mail. The Government Information Specialist for this request is Margo Stevens, who can be reached at 301-415-8148 or Margo.Stevens arc.go,*. r )(SJ The FOlA request should be processed in accordance with the standard instructions (How to Respond to a FOlA Request) at l\llL16123Al64. NRC Forni 5 11, "Program Office Response to a FOlA Request" is available in the NRC Forms Library for your use. In order to document the search conducted, in the event ofan appea l challenging the adequacy of the search, please also have each member of your staff who conducts a search complete NRC Forni 5 I I A, "Documentation of a FOIA earch," which is also ava il able in the RC Fornis Library for your use . Please review these fomis to ensure that an adequate, and consistent, search has been pcrfonned within your office. Then include copies of the completed NRC Forms 511 A along with the NRC Form 51 1 you return to the assigned specialist. Alternatively, you may complete the RC Form 511 A on behalf of your office, based upon the descriptions of searches provided to you by you r office staff. You are encouraged to ask for assistance in performing adequate ADAMS searches if you have any difficulty doing a search. R Form 496, " Report of Staff Resources for Processing FO IA Requests" is also available in the NR Fom1s Library for your use. When you respond, please make sure that you are sending your response to FOIA Rcsourcc@nrc i:ov, as well as the assigned spec ialist. Thank you.

From: Stevens Margo To: LSCriscione@hotmail.com Cc: Stevens. Margo Subj ect: FOIA/ PA-2016-00727 Acknowledgment Letter Date: Tuesday, September 13, 2016 8:49:13 AM Attachments: FOIA-PA-2016-00727 Acknowledgment Letter.docx Acknowledgment letter signed by Stephanie Blaney, Acting FOIA Officer. No hard copy to follow. If you are unable to open the document, please let us know by return email (FOIA.Resource@nrc.gov) or call 301-415-7169. If you are interested in receiving information from the NRC FOIA program, subscribe to ow-distribution list.

UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION WAS HINGTON, O.C. 20555-1100 I September 13, 2016 FOIA/PA-20 16-00727 Mr. Lawrence Criscione 1412 Dial Court Springfield, IL 62704

Dear Mr. Criscione:

We received your Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request on September 13, 2016. Your request, which seeks access to several documents identified by their ML accession numbers in ADAMS, has been assigned the following reference number that you should use in any future communications with us about your request: FOIA/PA-2016-00727. To ensure the most equitable treatment possible of all requesters, the NRC processes requests on a first-in, first-out basis, using a multiple track system based upon the estimated time it will take to process a request. Based on your description of the records you are seeking, we estimate completion of your request will be on or before October 12, 2016. Please know that this date roughly estimates how long it will take us to close requests ahead of yours in the respective track and complete work on your request. The actual date of completion might be before or after this estimate, based on the complexity of all of the requests in the simple track. We will advise you of any change in the estimated time to complete your request. In an effort to process your request promptly, you may wish to narrow the scope of your request to limit the volume of potentially responsive records. For purposes of assessing fees in accordance with our regulations (10 CFR 9.33), we have placed your request in the following category: Non-Excepted. If applicable, you will be charged appropriate fees for: Search and Duplication of Records. In light of our practice of providing you our response electronically, you will not incur any duplication fees.

                                             -   2 -

The following person is the Government Information Specialist who has been assigned responsibility for your request: Margo Stevens at 301-415-8148 or Margo.Stevens@nrc.gov. If you have questions on any matters concerning your FOIA request, please feel free to contact the assigned Government Information Specialist or me at (301) 415-7169. Sincerely, Ste,p~ 13 lct+wy Iw Stephanie Blaney Acting FOIA Officer Office of the Chief Information Officer

From: Admio Adm i To: Stevens. Margo

Subject:

Request Assignment Date: Tuesday, September 13, 2016 8:21 :28 AM Details Request Number: FOIA/PA-2016-0072 7 Request Type : FOIA/PA Requested By : Criscione , Lawrence Requested Date: September 12, 2016 Primary User: Margo Stevens Notes:

CASE NO: 2016-0723 DATE REC'D: 09/23/2016 SPECIALIST: From: Darth Vader RELATED CASE: To: FOIA Resource

Subject:

[External_Sender) Freedom of Information Act Request for ML16236A019 Date: Saturday, September 10, 2016 10:1 1:46 PM Please accept this email as a request for records under the Freedom of Information Act. Per the FOIA I would like a copy of NRC ADAMS record ML16236A019. It is my understanding that this record is a video from the St. Lucie reactor plant showing flooding in the Reactor Auxiliary Building about one year AFTER Florida Power & Light completed their post-Fukushima flooding walkdowns and reported that all deficiencies had been corrected.

UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION WASHINGTON, D.C. 20555-000 I September 12, 2016 FOIA/PA-2016-00723

Dear Mr. Vader:

We received your Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request on September 12, 2016. Your request, which seeks access to ML#16236A019, has been assigned the following reference number that you should use in any future communications with us about your request: FOIA/PA-2016-00723. To ensure the most equitable treatment possible of all requesters, the NRC processes requests on a first-in, first-out basis, using a multiple track system based upon the estimated time it will take to process a request. Based on your description of the records you are seeking, we estimate completion of your request will be on or before October 11, 2016. Please know that this date roughly estimates how long it will take us to close requests ahead of yours in the respective track and complete work on your request. The actual date of completion might be before or after this estimate, based on the complexity of all of the requests in the simple track. We will advise you of any change in the estimated time to complete your request. In an effort to process your request promptly, you may wish to narrow the scope of your request to limit the volume of potentially responsive records. For purposes of assessing fees in accordance with our regulations (10 CFR 9.33), we have placed your request in the following category: Non-Excepted. If applicable, you will be charged appropriate fees for: Search and Duplication of Records. A sheet has been enclosed that explains in detail the fee charges that may be applicable. Please do not submit any payment unless we notify you to do so.

2 - The following person is the Government Information Specialist who has been assigned responsibility for your request: Karen Danoff at 301-415-5072 or Karen .Danoff@nrc.gov. If you have questions on any matters concerning your FOIA request, please feel free to contact the assigned Government Information Specialist or me at (301) 415-7169. Sincerely, Stephanie Blaney Acting FOIA Officer Office of the Chief Information Officer

Enclosure:

Explanation of Fees

EXPLA NATION OF FEES Requester Fee Categories Commercial: Fees are charged for document search. duplication. and review. when records are requested for commercial purposes. Fees (above the minimum fee charge) ca nnot be waived for this category of requester. Educational, Non-Commercial Scientific, News Media and Privacy Act: Fees may be charged only for document duplication when records are* not sought for commercial use and the request is made by an Educational or Non-Commercial Scientific Institution, whose purpose is scholarly or scientific research; or a Representative of the News Media; or a person requesting his/her own records that are in a Privacy Act system of records. No fee is charged for the first one hundred pages of duplication for this category of requester. Non-Excepted: For any request not described above (Non-Excepted), fees may be charged for document search and duplication. No fee is charged for the first two hours of search time or for the first one hundred pages of duplication for this category of requester. Fee Schedules Fee schedules provide only for the recovery of the direct costs of search, duplication, or review. Review costs Include only the costs for initial examination of a document to determine whether it must be disclosed and to determine whether to withhold portions that are exempt from disclosure. The fee schedule is as follows: Search & Review Conducted By Rate

          ! SES/COMMISSIONER                        $90.53/hour        (ES-maximum)
          ! PROFESSIONAL                            $56.36/hour        (GG-1'.>, Step 6)
          ! CLERICAL                                $25.16/hour        (GG-7, Step 7)

Du1;1licatlon Charges $.20 per page Fees for non-standard search or duplication will be charged at the actual cost (e.g. providing copying of audio tapes or conducting computer searches). Minimum Fee: No fee will be charged unless the fee is equal to or greater than $25.00. When to Pay Fees If we estimate that fees will not exceed $25.00 or you have stated in your request a higher amount that you are willing to pay, we assume your willingness to pay up to $25 or the amount stipulated and you will be billed after we have completed your request. If we estimate that fees will e-xceed $25.00 or any amount that has been stated by you in your request, we will not proceed with your request until we have notified you and obtained your agreement to pay the estimated fees. If we estimate fees will exceed $250, you will be required to pay the estimated fees in advance before we proceed further with your request. If, while processing your request, we find that the actual fees exceed the esti mated fee, we will obtain your consent to pay the additional fees before continuing to process your request. If the actual fees to process your request are less than any advance payment you have made, you will be refunded the overpayment amount. Fee Waivers A waiver or reduction of fees may be granted for furnishing documents if a requester, by fully addressing the eight factors in 10 CFR 9.41, clearly demonstrates that disclosure of the information is in the public interest because it is likely to contribute significantly to public understanding of the operations or activities of the government and is not primarily in the commercial interest of the requester.

From: Stevens Margo To: Danoff. Karen

Subject:

FW: RE: FOIA-2016-0721, FOIA-2016-0723, FOIA-2016-0727, and FOIA-2016-0731 Date: Wednesday, December 21, 2016 12: 26: 10 PM VOILA. Jvt.argo L Stevens

fOI.'A. .'A.na{ysl/'T'eam Leader (Conlraclor)

OCIO/CS'D/J'1'l'B 'I.LS. :Nuc(ear 'Regu(atory Commission 11545 'Rockviffe 1Jike, :M.ai{ Stoy 'T'-2:F1 'Rockv1((e, :M.ary{anrf 20855 'T'e[eyftone #: (301) 415-8148 From: Stevens, Ma rgo Sent: Tuesday, October 18, 2016 8:25 AM To: 'Snyder, Mike' <M ike.Snyder@fpl.com>

Subject:

RE: RE: FOIA-2016-0721, FO IA-2016-0723, FOIA-2016-0727, and FOIA-2016-0731 Thank you . I'm so glad we were able to finally get it to you! Jvt.argo L Stevens _rOI.'A. .'A.na(ysl/'T'eam Leaaer (Contractor) OCIO/CS'D/J'TI'B 'U.S. :Nudear 'Regu[atory Comm1sswn 11545 'Rocli.vi((e 'Pili.e, :M.ai{Stoy 'T'-2:F1 'Rockvi((e, :M.ary{anrf 20855 'T'e{eyfwne #: (301) 415-8148 From: Snyder, M ike [6] Sent: Tuesday, October 18, 2016 8:06 AM To: Stevens, M argo <Margo.Steyens@nrc.gov>

Subject:

[Externa l_Sender] RE: FOIA-2016-0721, FOIA-2016-0723, FOIA-2016-0727, and FOIA-2016-0731

Margo,

I have reviewed the video that you sent and it does not contain any proprietary or safeguards information. M ike Snyder From: Stevens, Margo [7] Sent: Friday, October 14, 2016 2:03 PM To: Snyder, Mike

Subject:

RE: FOIA-2016-0721, FOIA-2016-0723, FOIA-2016-0727, and FOIA-2016-0731 CAUTION - EXTERNAL EMA IL Good afternoon Mike - do you know whether the CD with the video clip arrived at your home?

.Margo£.. Stevens J'Ol.'A. .'A.na(ysl/'T'eam Leaaer (Conlraclor)

OCIO/CS1J/]"'PI'B 'l.LS. :Nudear 'Regu(atory Commission 11545 'Rockvi((e Tike, :Mai{ Stoy '1-2J'7 'R.ock1nffe, :M.ary(ana 20855 'T'e(eyftone #: (301) 415-8148 From: Stevens, Margo Se nt: Thursday, October 13, 2016 1:35 PM To: 'M ike.Snyder@fpl.com' <Mike.Snyder@fpl.com>

Subject:

FW: FOIA-2016-0721, FOIA-2016-0723, FOIA-2016-0727, and FOIA-2016-0731

.Margo£.. Stevens

.TOI.Jl .Jlna(ysl/'T'eam Leacfer (Contractor) OCIO/CS'D/J"PI'B 'U.S. :Nudear 'Regu.fatory Commuswn 11545 'Rockvi((e 'Pike, :M.aff Stoy 'T'-2:J7 'Rockvi({e, :M.ary(ana 20855 'T'e{eyftone #: (301) 415-8148 From: Stevens, Margo

Sent: Friday, September 23, 2016 10:20 AM To: 'M ike.Snyder@ f pl.com' <M ike .Snyder @fpl.com > Cc: Danoff, Karen <Karen Danoff@nrc gov>

Subject:

FOIA-2016-0721, FOIA-2016-0723, FOIA-2016-0727, and FOIA-2016-0731 Good morning Mr. Snyder. The NRC's Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) Office has received several requests (their reference numbers are identified in the Subject line of this email) that seek copies of, inter alia, a video clip taken by an NRC resident inspector (on his cell phone camera) of flooding that occurred at the St. Lucie nuclear power plant on January 9 [no year given] . In searching the Licensee Event Report database NRG makes available to the public, I came across a LER that appears to coincide with the events shows in the video clip . It is also attached . Our office has made a preliminary determination that there is no basis on which to withhold the video clip from these requesters. We wanted to let you know. Should you have any questions, or concerns, please contact the undersigned at your earliest opportunity. We expect to start issuing responses to this aspect of the above-referenced requests next week. My colleague, Ms. Danoff, and I are assigned these requests and appreciate your attention. Jvlargo L. Stevens ]'OI.'A. .'A.na[yst/'Team Leaaer (Contractor) OCIO/CS'D/TPI'B 'U.S. :Nudear 'Regu[atory Commission 11545 'Rocli.vi((e Tili.e, Jvlai{ Stoy 'T'-2]'7 'Rocli.vi((e, Jvlary(ana 20855 T'e[eyfwne #: (301) 415-8148

From: FOIA Resource Sent: Thursday, December 22, 2016 7:44 AM The attached response and released video To: darth.vader.four20@gmail.com are publicly available in ADAMS as Cc: Danoff, Karen ML20294A078 and ML20294A079,

Subject:

FOIA/PA-2016-0723 Final Response respectively. Attachments: Final Response.pdf; D43 MOV03976-M L16236A019.mpg

Dear Mr. Vader:

Please find attached NRC's fina l response to you r FOIA request, FOIA/PA-2016-00723. Please take a moment to help us improve our FOIA processes, and let us know what your experience has been. Just click on this embedded link : http://www.nrc.gov/reading-rm/foia/foia-user-survey.html. Once you have completed the survey, just click the "SUBMIT" button and your survey response will be returned to us. Thank you, FOIA/Privacy Act Information Collections Branch Customer Service Division Office of the Chief Information Officer U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission FOIA.Resource@nrc.gov

From: Admio Adm i To: LSCriscione@hotmail.com Cc: Stevens. Margo The records addressed in this response (ML20294A157) are also Subj ect: FOIA/PA-2016-0780 Final Response the subject of multiple requests including interim response # 2 to Date: Friday, January 13, 2017 2: 17:38 PM your NRC-2018-000096. This response is publicly available in Attachments: Final Resoonse.odf ADAMS as ML202350B581 .

Dear Mr. Criscione:

Please find attached NRC's final response to your FOIA request, FOIA/PA-2016-00780. Please take a moment to help us improve our FOIA processes, and let us know what your experience has been. Just click on this embedded link: http-//www nrc gov/reading-rm/foia/foia-user-survey.html. Once you have completed the survey, j ust click the "SUBMIT" button and your survey response will be returned to us. Thank you, Freedom of Information, Privacy & Information Collections Branch Customer Service Division, Office of the Chieflnformation Officer Mail Stop: T-5F09 U.S. Nuclear Regu latory Commission Washington, D .C. 20555-000 1 FOIA.Resource@nrc.gov Ph: 301-415-7169 Fax: 30 1-415-5 130

Dear FOIA Requester:

The FOIA Improvement Act of 2016, which was enacted on June 30, 2016, made several changes to the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA). Federal agencies must revise their FOIA regulations to reflect those changes by December 27, 2016. In addition to revising our regulations, we intend to update the Form 464, which we use to respond to FOIA requests. In the interim, please see the comment box in Part I.C of the attached Form 464. The comment box includes information related to the recent changes to FOIA that is applicable 10 your FOIA request, including an updated time period for filing an administrative appeal with the NRC. Sincerely yours, Stephanie Blaney FOIA Officer

NRC FORM 4&4 Part I (OIG) U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COlalSSION FOIA RESPONSE NUM BER (12-2015) l

                 ~
                    ¥'.,..
                           )'

RESPONSE TO FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT (FOIA) REQUEST 2016-0780

RESPONSE

TYPE 11 INTERIM I FINAL I I REQUESTER: Lawrence Criscione DESCRIPTION OF REQUESTED RECORDS: T en ( 10) enumerated documents, including w hat appears to be an annotated, partial transcr ipt of your interview conducted by O IG, and n ine (9) mp3 audio clips created by you from an audio transcript of that sam e interview. 11 DATE: 13 ~z I PART I. - INFORMATION RELEASED Agency records subject to the request are already available in public ADAMS or on microfiche in the NRC Public Document Room. Agency records subject to the request are endosed. Records subject to the request that contain information originated by or of interest to another Federal agency have been referred to that agency (see comments section) for a disdosure detemiination and direct response to you. We are continuing to process your request [Z] See Comments. PART I.A - FEES AMOUNT' II You will be billed by NRC for the amount listed. [Z] None. Minimum fee threshold not met.

      $     11
      *see COmmerits for detatls You will receive a refund for the amount listed.

Fees waived. PART 1.8 - INFORMATION NOT LOCATED OR WITHHELD FROM DISCLOSURE We did not locate any agency records responsive to your request Note: Agencies may treat thr,ee discrete categories of law enforcement and national security records as not subject to the FOIA ("exclusions"). 5 U.S.C. 552(c). This is a standard notification given to all requesters. it should not be taken to mean that any excluded records do, or do not. exist. We have withheld certain information pursuant to the F0IA exemptions described, and for the reasons stated, in Part II. Because this is an interim response to your request. you may not appeal at this time. We will notify you of your right to appeal any of the responses we have issued in response to your request when we issue our final determination. You may appeal this final determination within 30 calendar days of the date of this response by sending a letter or email to [Z] the F0IA Officer, at U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Washington DC. 20555-0001 , or FOIA.Resource@nrc.goy. Please be sure to indude on your letter or email that it 1s a "F0IA Appeal." PART I.C COMMENTS ( Use attached Comments continuation page If required) In conforman ce with the FOIA Improvement Act of 20 16, the NRC is informing you that: (I) you have the r ight to seek assistance from the NRC's FOIA Public L iaison; (2) you have the right to seek dispute resolution services from the N RC's FOIA Public Liaison or the Office ofGovemment Information Services; and (3) notwit hstandi ng the language in Parts 1.8 and JI .B o f this form, you may appeal this final determination wi thin 90 calendar d ays of the date of this response by sending a letter or email to the FOIA Officer, at U .S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, W ash ington, D .C. 20555-000 I , or FOI A.Resource@ nrc.gov. Please be sure to include on your letter or email that it i s a "FOIA Appeal." [continued on next page)

          , ,.. *-I  ASSISTANT INSPECTOR GENERAL FOR INVESTIGATIONS, 010
 -~

,~Jt:.pn J'\.. JYt l...J

• NRC FOITTI -4&4 Part I (DIG) (12-2015)

I..,... Coillll **,.,... P1ge2 of3

NRC FORM 464 Part I (OIG) U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY ca...SSION ,.F;_O;.;.IA...;.__ _ _ _~ RESPONSE NUMBER (12-2015) I 2016-0780 11 I RESPONSE TO FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT (FOIA) REQUEST Continued

RESPONSE

INTERIM FINAL TYPE REQUESTER: DATE: I Lawrence C riscione 11 JAN 1 3 ~,, PART I.C COMMENTS (Continued) The NRC was able to locate these items by the ADAMS accession numbers when your request was received. Since the date of your request, however, these ten items have been removed from ADAMS. Each of the items was determined to be a personal, rather than agency, record. As such, they are not subject to the FOIA. NRC Form 464 Part I (DIG) ( 12-2015) Page 3 of 3

NRC FORM 4'4 Part I (OIG) U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY C~SSIOM FOIA RESPONSE NUMBER (12*2015) I I

                   '~.....¥.'

2016-0780 1 i

• 1 RESPONSE TO FREEDOM OF 11

                   \,      /       INFORMATION ACT (FOIA) REQUEST                               RESPONSE INTERIM             FINAL TYPE REQUESTER:                                                                                                             DATE:

JLawrence Criscione DESCRIPTION OF REQUESTED RECORDS: 11 JIN 1 3 2017 I Ten (10) enumerated documents, including what appears to be an annotated, partial transcript of your interview conducted by OIG. and nine (9) mp3 audio clips created by you from an audio transcript of that same interview. PART I. - INFORMATION RELEASED Agency records subject to the request are already available in public ADAMS or on microfiche in the NRC Public Document Room. Agency records subject to the request are enclosed. Records subject to the request that contain information originated by or of interest to another Federal agency have been referred to that agency (see comments section) for a disdosure determination and direct response to you. We are continuing to process your request 0 See Comments. PART I.A - FEES AMOUNT' II

          $  II You will be billed by NRC for the amount listed.

0 None. Minimum fee threshold not met.

          *see Comments for detab You will receive a refund for the amount listed.

Fees waived. PART 1.8 - INFORMATION NOT LOCATED OR WITHHELD FROM DISCLOSURE We did not locate any agency records responsive to your request. Note: Agencies may treat three discrete categories of law enforcement and national security records as not subject to the FOIA ("exclusions"). 5 U.S.C. 552(c). This is a standard notification given to all requesters, it should not be taken to mean that any excluded records do, or do not. exist. We have withheld certain information pursuant to the FOIA exemptions described, and for the reasons stated, in Part II. Because this is an interim response to your request, you may not appeal at this time. We will notify you of your right to appeal any of the responses we have issued in response to your request when we issue our final determination. You may appeal this final determination within 30 calendar days of the date of this response by sending a letter or email to 0 the FOIA Officer, at U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Washington. D.C. 20555-0001 , or FOIA.Resource@nrc.goy. Please be sure to include on your letter or email that it is a "FOIA Appeal.* PART I.C COMMENTS ( Use attached Comments continuation page If required) In conformance with the FOIA Improvement Act of20 16, the NRC is informing you that: ( 1) you have the rig ht to seek assistance from the NRC's FOIA Public Liaison; (2) you have the right to seek dispute resolution services from the NRC's fOIA Public Liaison or the Office of Government lnfonnation Services; and (3) notwithstanding the language in Parts 1.8 and 11.B of this fonn, you may appeal this final determination within 90 calendar days of the date of this response by sending a letter or email to the FOIA Officer, at U .S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Washington. D .C. 20555-0001, or FOIA.Resource@ nrc.gov. Please be sure to include on your letter or email that it is a " FOIA Appeal." [continued on next page]

 ...,..,.,. w *u:: -ASSISTA.NT IN~~v * =               FOR INVESTIGATIONS, OIG     DISTRIBUTIOM

' !Joseyfi A v~!!..._~a,iun 11 OFFICE ACTION OFFICER *-

                                      ,~ -
                                                    ,/
                                            ~ , * ~-- ' c,--

PUBLIC ADAMS NAME (b)(6) ~/'"'th>/J, DATE t\ l~ \ \1 1 /1 J / 1-: 0 NON-PUBLIC ADAMS NRC Form 4~ Part I (OIG) (12-2d1s) Page 1 of 3

NRC FORM 4&4 Part I (OIG) U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMlolSSION FOIA RESPONSE NUMBER (12-201~) RESPONSE TO FREEDOM OF INFORMATION 1 2016-0780 II I ACT (FOIA) REQUEST Continued RESPONSE INTERIM FINAL TYPE REQUESTER: DATE: ILawrence Criscione 11 ~ 1 3 201r PART I.C COMMENTS (Continued) The NRC was able to locate these items by the ADAMS accession numbers when your request was received. Since the date of your request, however, these ten items have been removed from ADAMS. Each of the items was determined to be a personal, rather than agency, record. As such, they are not subject to the FOIA. NRC FDfm 64 Part I (OIG) ( 12-2015) Page 3 of 3

From: Stevens Margo To: Blaney. stephanie

Subject:

RE: FOIA-2016-0780 Date: Friday, January 13, 2017 11:39:00 AM Works for me. I'll finish that one up right now. YAY. Jvt.argo L Stevens

fOI.'A. .'A.na{ysl/'T'eam Leader (Conlraclor)

OCIO/CS'D/J'1'l'B 'I.LS. :Nuc(ear 'Regu(atory Commission 11545 'Rockvitre 1Jike, :M.ai{ Stoy 'T'-2:F1 1wckv1((e, :M.ary{anrf 20855 'T'e[eyftone #: (301) 415-8148 From: Bla ney, Stephanie Sent: Friday, Ja nuary 13, 2017 11:39 AM To: Stevens, Margo <Margo.Stevens@nrc.gov>

Subject:

RE: FOIA-2016-0780 Yes we will still give them appeal rights. I confirmed with DOJ since it was a proper request it is technically a denial. From: Stevens, Ma rgo Sent: Friday, Ja nuary 13, 2017 11:06 AM To: Blaney, Stephanie <Stephanie Blaney@nrc gov>

Subject:

FOIA-2016-0780 (b)(5) Jvt.argo L Stevens

-01.'A. .'A.nalysl/'T'eam Leader (Contractor)

OCIO/CS1>/]"PI'B 1-1.S. :Nudear 'Regu(atory Commission 11545 'Rockvi((e 'Pike, :M.ai{ Stoy 'T'-2:f7 'R,ocf:t.vitre, :M.ary{anrf 20855 'T'deyftone #: (301) 415-8148

From: Stevens Margo To: Danoff. Karen

Subject:

RE: new 2016-0780 folder on G drive Date: Wednesday, January 04, 2017 1:54:00 PM

Margo L Stevens JOI.JI. .Jlna(yst/'Team Leader (Contractor)

OUO/CS'D/J"PI'B 'I.LS. :Nudear 1Zegu(atory Commission 11545 'Rocfi.vi((e 'Pifi.e, Jvlai{ Stoy 'T-2:f7 'Rocfi.vi(fe, Jvlary(ana 20855 Te(eyn.one #: (.w1) 415-8148 From: Danoff, Karen Sent: Wed nesday, Ja nuary 04, 2017 1:48 PM To: Stevens, M argo <Margo.Stevens@n rc.gov>

Subject:

new 2016-0780 folder on G drive I created a new "2016-0780" folder in G:\Customer Service Division\FOIA.Privacy. Info Collections Branch (FPIB)\FOIA\ELECTRONIC CASE FILES and saved this file there. From: Littlejohn, Jennene Sent: Wednesday, January 04, 2017 12:49 PM To: Da noff, Karen <Karen Danoff@nrc gov>; Stevens, Margo <Margo Steveos@nrc gov>

Subject:

Requested file Hi Karen, Please find attached the requested file. Thank you , J ennene Littlejoh n Lead Adminis trative Assistant RES/ORA 301 -415-0428 (office) 301 -415-6671 (fax) TWFN- 10-A06 Mailstop: Tl0-A1 2

From: Stevens Margo To: Danoff. Karen

Subject:

RE: new 2016-0780 folder on G drive Date: Wednesday, January 04, 2017 1:49:00 PM OK. Thanks.

Jvt.argo L Stevens

fOI.'A. .'A.na{ysl/'T'eam Leader (Conlraclor)

OCIO/CS'D/J'1'l'B 'lLS. :Nuc(ear 'Regu(atory Commission 11545 'Rockviffe 1Jike, :M.ai{ Stoy 'T'-2:F1 'Rockv1((e, :M.ary{anrf 20855 'T'e[eyftone #: (301) 415-8148 From: Danoff, Karen Sent: Wednesday, January 04, 2017 1:48 PM To: Stevens, Margo <Margo.Stevens@nrc.gov>

Subject:

new 2016-0780 folder on G drive I created a new "2016-0780" folder in G:\Customer Service Division\FOIA,Privacy, Info Collections Branch (FPIB)\FOIA\ELECTRONIC CASE FILES and saved this file there. From: Littlejohn, Jennene Sent: Wednesday, January 04, 2017 12:49 PM To: Danoff, Karen <Karen,Danoff@nrc,gov>; Stevens, Margo <Margo,Stevens@nrc,gov>

Subject:

Requested file Hi Karen, Please find attached the requested file. Thank you, J ennene Littlejohn Lead Administrative Assistant RES/ORA 301 -415-0428 (office) 301 -4 15-6671 (fax) TWFN- 10-A06 Mailstop: T10-A12

From: Danoff. Karen To: Littlejohn. Jeanene Cc: Stevens. Margo: Dennis. Suzanne

Subject:

Can you send us a copy of the audio fi le at ML16244A0027 Date: Wednesday, January 04, 2017 11:51:46 AM Hi Jennene, I am a FOIA specialist in the FOIA office in OCIO , and working with Margo on the 12 FOIA cases regarding the documents that L. Criscione placed into ADAMS . We've just discovered that we did not receive a copy of one of the OIG investigation audio files , it was under ML16244A002, and only respons ive to FOIA 2016-0780 . We were told that you may still have access to these files. We no longer have access to this document in ADAMS. Can you email us a copy? If you can no longer access ML16244A002, please let us know who to contact.

Thanks, Karen Karen Danoff Government Information Specialist OCIO/CSD/F PIB/FOIA Team TWFN-5 F06 Mail Stop: TWFN-5 F09 301-415-5072 Karen Danoff@nrc gov

From: Stevens Margo To: LSCriscione@hotmail.com Cc: Stevens. Margo

Subject:

FOIA/PA-2016-00780 Acknowledgment Letter Date: Thursday, 5eptember 29, 2016 2:02:19 PM Attachments: FOIA-PA-2016-00780 Acknowledgment Letter.docx Acknowledgment letter signed by Stephanie Blaney, Acting FOIA Officer. No hard copy to follow. If you are unable to open the document, please let us know by return email (FOIA.Resource@nrc.gov) or call 301-415-7169. If you are interested in receiving information from the NRC FOIA program, subscribe to ow-distribution list.

UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION WAS HINGTON, O.C. 20555-1100 I September 29, 2016 FOIA/PA-20 16-00780 Mr. Lawrence Criscione 1412 Dial Court Springfield, IL 62704

Dear Mr. Criscione:

We received your Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request on September 29, 2016. Your request, which seeks access to ten records, which you stated could be found ADAMS package ML16195A365, has been assigned the following reference number that you should use in any future communications with us about your request: FOIA/PA-2016-00780. To ensure the most equitable treatment possible of all requesters, the NRC processes requests on a first-in, first-out basis, using a multiple track system based upon the estimated time it will take to process a request. Based on your description of the records you are seeking , we estimate completion of your request will be on or before October 28, 2016. Please know that this date roughly estimates how long it will take us to close requests ahead of yours in the respective track and complete work on your request. The actual date of completion might be before or after this estimate, based on the complexity of all of the requests in the [simple] [complex] track. We will advise you of any change in the estimated time to complete your request. In an effort to process your request promptly, you may wish to narrow the scope of your request to limit the volume of potentially responsive records. For purposes of assessing fees in accordance with our regulations (10 CFR 9.33), we have placed your request in the following category: Non-Excepted. If applicable, you will be charged appropriate fees for: Search and Duplication of Records. Since you have requested that we provide our response, including any released records, to you electronically, and the records are all centrally located, we do not expect you to incur any fees in the processing of this request. A sheet has been enclosed that explains in detail the fee charges that may be applicable. Please do not submit any payment unless we notify you to do so.

The following person is the Government Information Specialist who has been assigned responsibility for your request: Margo Stevens at 301-415-8148 or Margo.Stevens@nrc.gov. If you have questions on any matters concerning your FOIA request, please feel free to contact the assigned Government Information Specialist or me at (301) 415-7169. Sincerely, Stephanie Blaney Acting FOIA Officer Office of the Chief Information Officer

Enclosures:

Explanation of Fees

EXPLANATION OF FEES Requester Fee Categories Commercial: Fees are charged for document search duplication and review when records are requested for commercial purposes. Fees (above the minimum fee charge) cannot be waived for this category of requester. Educational, Non-Commerc ial Scientific, News Media and Privacy Act: Fees may be charged only for document duplication when records are* not sought for commercial use and the request is made by an Educational or Non-Commercial Scientific Institution, whose purpose is scholarly or scientific research; or a Representative of the News Media; or a person requesting his/her own records that are in a Privacy Act system of records. No fee is charged for the first one hundred pages of duplication for this category of requester. Non-Excepted : For any request not described above (Non-Excepted), fees may be charged for document search and duplication. No fee is charged for the first two hours of search time or for the first one hundred pages of duplication for this category of requester. Fee Schedules Fee schedules provide only for the recovery of the direct costs of search, duplication, or review. Review costs include only the costs for initial examination of a document to determine whether it must be disclosed and to determine whether to withhold portions that are exempt from disclosure. The fee schedule is as follows: Search & Review Conducted By Rate 1 SES/COMMISSIONER $90.53/hour (ES-maximum) 1 PROFESSIONAL $56.36/hour (GG-13, Step 6) I CLERICAL $25.16/hour (GG-7, Step 7) Du(!lication Charges $.20 per page Fees for non-standard search or duplication will be charged at the actual cost (e.g. providing copying of audio tapes or conducting computer searches). Minimum Fee: No fee will be charged unless the fee is equal to or greater than $25.00. When to Pay Fees If we estimate that fees will not exceed $25.00 or you have stated in your request a higher amount that you are willing to pay, we assume your willingness to pay up to $25 or the amount stipulated and you will be billed after we have completed your request. If we estimate that fees will exceed $25.00 or any amount that has been stated by you in your request, we will not proceed with your request until we have notified you and obtained your agreement to pay the estimated fees. If we estimate fees will exceed $250, you will be required to pay the estimated fees in advance before we proceed further with your request. If, while processing your request, we find that the actual fees exceed the estimated fee, we will obtain your consent to pay the additional fees before continuing to process your request. If the actual fees to process your request are less than any advance payment you have made, you will be refunded the overpayment amount. Fee Waivers A waiver or reduction of fees may be granted for furnishing documents if a requester, by fully addressing the eight factors in 10 CFR 9.41, clearly demonstrates that disclosure of the information is in the public interest because it is likely to contribute significantly to public understanding of the operations or activities of the government and is not primarily in the commercial interest of the requester.

From: Admio Adm i To: Stevens. Margo

Subject:

Request Assignment Date: Thursday, 5eptember 29, 2016 11 :31 :17 AM Details Request Number: FOIA/PA-2016-00780 Request Type : FOIA/PA Requested By : Criscione , Lawrence Requested Date: September 29, 2016 Primary User: Margo Stevens Notes:

CASE NO: 2016-0780 DATE REC'D: 09/29/2016 SPECIALIST: From: Lawrence Crjscjone To: EOIA Resource RELATED CASE: Subject : (External_Sender] FOIA request for a transcript and nine audio clips Date: Thursday, September 29, 2016 4:57:14 AM Under the Freedom of Information Act, I request copies of the following records:

1. MML16244A000, 2013-Jan-17 Transcript

2. ML16244A001, 2013-Jan-17 mp3 recording corresponding to transcript pp. 70 to 75 regarding the Inspector General's agents concern that Criscione did not adequately work through internal NRC channels prior to contacting Congress with his flooding concerns

3. ML16244A002, 2013-Jan-17 mp3 recording corresponding to t ranscript pp. 44 to 46 concerning protecting Official Use Only information

4. ML16244A003, 2013-Jan-17 mp3 recording corresponding to transcript pp. 58 to 64 concerning the need to seek approval from NRC supervision, licensees, and other federal agencies prior to providing information to Congress

5. ML16244A004, 2013-Jan-17 mp3 recording corresponding to transcript pp. 79 to 83 concerning Inspector General's agents understanding that NRC employees do not have an inherent need-to-know about nuclear safety issues not formally assigned to t hem

6. ML16244A005, 2013-Jan-17 mp3 recording corresponding to transcript pp. 98 to 103 concerning motivation of Perkins' complaint to the IG regarding redactions to the Gl-204 Screening Analysis

7. ML16244A006, 2013-Jan-17 mp3 recording corresponding to transcript pp. 95 to 98 concerning speaking with Tom Zeller of the Huffington Post and David Lochbaum of the Union of Concerned Scientists

8. ML16244A007, 2013-Jan-17 mp3 recording corresponding to t ranscript pp. 153 to 159 concerning NRC po licy with regard to speaking to the media

9. ML16238A010, 2013-Jan-17 mp3 Recording of Interrogation of Lawrence Criscione corresponding to transcript pp. 87 to 95 on the topic of speculating who in Congress shared the Gl-204 screening analysis with Greenpeace

10. ML16238A011, 2013-Jan-17 mp3 recording corresponding to pp.116-144 demonstrating the agent's lack of understanding of the relationship between classified information and information administratively restricted from public release under informal extralegal processes All of the above records can be found in ADAMS package ML16195A365.

Please provide the records and any correspondence to me electronically at LSCriscione@hotmail.com.

Thank you, Larry Lawrence S. Crisci one a}}