ML20247H079
ML20247H079 | |
Person / Time | |
---|---|
Site: | Byron, Braidwood, 05000000 |
Issue date: | 06/22/1989 |
From: | ROBERT L. CLOUD ASSOCIATES, INC. |
To: | |
Shared Package | |
ML20247H068 | List: |
References | |
P182-001-APP, P182-1-APP, NUDOCS 8907280271 | |
Download: ML20247H079 (308) | |
Text
{{#Wiki_filter:, Robert L. Cloud and A ssociates,' hsc. 4 1
)
DESCRIPTION ANDVERIFICATION ,
SUMMARY
OF COMPUTER l PROGRAM, GAPPIPE l 1 APPENDIX P182-001 June 22,1989 Submitted to: l Office of Nuclear Regulatory Regulation United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission By: > Commonwealth Edison Company for the application at Byron and Braidwood Nuclear Facilities ( Prepared by: e Robert L Cloud & Associates,Inc.
- f. l 125 University Avenue 105 Summerwood Way, Suite B j Berkeley, California 94710 Aiken, South Carolina 29801 1 f- (415) 841 9296 (803) 648-8801
?
p:$072$$$[h $$0bdds4 I p FDC __ j
~
ATTACHMENT 2 DESIRLET10N AND VERIFICATION SUMAEY OF COMPILTEE EERGBAM,_GAEflEI APPENDIX i l I j - T,12 ]
i I' Robert L. Cloud and Associates, Inc l RLGA . DESCRIPTION AND VERIFICATION
SUMMARY
OF COMPUTER PROGRAM, GAPPIPE APPENDIX P182-001 June 22,1989 Submitted to: Office of Nuclear Regulatory Regulation United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission By: l Commonwealth Edison Company J for the application at Byron and Braidwood Nuclear Facilities Prepared by: .:- Robert L. Cloud & Associates, Inc. 125 University Avenue 105 Summerwood Way, Suite B l Berkeley, California 94710 Aiken, South Carolina 29801 j i (415) 841 9296 (803) 648-8801
I 1 h APPENDIX A: ) Input Listing of Uniform Benchmark Problems l (
.l l
4 A-1 l 1 l,
l BENCHMARK PROBLEM - UNI BM1 APPENDIX A PAGE: UNI-BM1-1 i BENCHMARK PROBLEM NO. I j UNIFORM RESPONSE SPECTRUM RUN 12 1- 0 5 5 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 1 5 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0.000 0.000 0.000 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.000 54.450 0.000 0 0.00f 0.00e 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.000 108.900 0.000 0 0.003 4 0 0 0 0 0 0 10.632 134.568 0.000 0 0.001 5 0 0 0 0 0 0 36.300 145.200 0.000 0 0.00j 6 0 0 0 0 0 0 54.150 145.200 0.000 0 0.00@ 7 0 0 0 0 0 0 72.000 145.200 0.000 0 0.00@ 8 0 0 0, 0 0 0 97.668 145.200 10.632 0 0.00 9 0 0 0 0 0 0 108.300 145.200 36.300 0 0.00]g 10 0 0 0 0 0 0 108.300 145.200 56.800 0 0.003 11- 1 1 1 1 1 1 108.300 145.200 77.300 'O 0.00@ 12 1 1 1 1 1 1 150.00 145.20 36.3 0 0.00j 12 10 1 1 1 0 3 1 1 ALIDY STEEL
- 0. 24000000. .3 0.0000071 1 7.288 .2410 0.0000 0.0 0.0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 -
0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 1T 1 2 1 1- 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 2T. 2 3 1 1 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 3B 3 4 1 1 0.0 0.0 36.3 CC 36.3 108.9 0.0 0.1 4B- 4 5 1 1 0.0 0.0 36.3 CC 36.3 108.9 0.0 0.1 ST' 5 6 1 1 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 6T 6 7 1 1 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 7B 7 8 1 1 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 36.3 CC 72.0 145.2 36.3 0.1 - 8B 8 9 1 1 0.0 0.0 36.3 CC 72.0 145.2 36.3 0.1 9T 9 10 1 1 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 10T 10 11 1 1 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 2 0 0.03988 0.03988 0.03988 0.0 0.0 0.0 3 0 0.05032 0.05032 0.05032 0.0 0.0 0.0 4 0 0.02088 0.02088 0.02088 0.0 0.0 0.0 5 0 0.01698 0.01698 0.01698 0.0 0. 0. .. 0.0 6 0 0.01307 0.01307 0.01307 0.0 0.0 0.0 7 0 0.01698 0.01698 0.01698 0.0 0.0 0.0 8 0 0.01044 0.01044 0.01044 0.0 0.0 0.0 9 0 0.01795 0.01795 0.01795 0.0 0.0 0.0 10 0 0.01501 0.01501 0.01501 0.0 0.0 0.0 e 00000 00000 A-2
N. BENCHMARK PROBLEM - UNI BMI APPENDIX A PAGE: UNI-BM1 I O O O 0.0 0.0 p' 1 1 0.02- 2 4 1 1.0 1 0.6667- 1 1.0 i IMPERIAL VALLEY, EL CENTRO 1940, BENCHMARK PROBLEM No.1 11' . !. 0.001698 145.0 ) 0.02860 380.0 0.05800- 775.0 0.07100 775.0 + [ 0.0911 440.0 . E 0.114 1188.0 0.1410 1188.0 ' 0.172 700.0 O.2 871.0 ! 0.25 871.0 . 0.323 400.0
.300 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 9 12 10000. 10000. 10000. 10000. 1000.
1.0 0.05- 0.05 0.0 0.0 2- 1 .1 1 -1 0 10 0 1 12 9 10000. 10000. ( ) l- }-
.~
l' i 1 ) A-3
1 f BENCHMARK PROBLEM - UNI BM2 APPENDIX A 'PAGE: UNI-BM2-1 i BENCHMARK PROBLEM NO. 2 l NRC UNIFORM RESPONSE SPECTRUM ANALYSIS d 19 1 0 5 5 0 0 0 0 1 00 0 1 5 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.000 -30.000 0.000 0-0.Of 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 27.250- -30.0 0.0 0 0.04 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 27.250 -30.0 17.25 0 0.05 4 0 'O O O O O 0.0 .-30.0 17.25 0 0.02 5 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0 18.625 17.25- 0 0.0 6 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0 18.625 8.625 0 0.0 7 0 0 0 0' O O 0.0 18.625 0.0 0 0.0v 8 0 0 0. 0 0 0 8.625 18.625 .0.0 0 0.02 9 0 0 0 0 0 0 18.625 18.625 0.0 0 0.0Z 1C 0 0 0 0 0 0. 27.250 18.625 0.0 0 0.03 11 0 0 0 0 0 0 27.250 18.625 8.625' 0; 'O.08 12 0 0 0 0 0 0 27.250 18.625 17.25 0 0.08 13 0 0 0 0 0 0 18.625 18.625 17.25 0 0.02 14 0 0 0 0 0 0 8.625 18.625 17.25 0~ 0.02 15 1 1 1 1 1 1 0. -60.0 0.0 0 0.03 16 1 1 1 1 1* 1- 27.250 -80.0 .. 0.0 0 0.03 17 1 1 1 1 1 1 27.250 -80.0 17.25 0 0.0$ 18 1 .11 1 1 1 1 0.000 -80.0 17.25 0 0.08 19 1 1 1 1 1 1 35.00 18.625 17.25 0 0.08 12- 18 1 1 1 0 0 1 1 STEEL PIPE , 0.0 27900000. 0.3 0.0
, 1 2.375 0.154 0.0 0.0 0.0 PIPE P5t0PERTY 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 .0. 0 0.0 . j 1T 15 1 1 1 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 2T 1 7 1 1 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 '0.0 3T 7 6 1 1 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 ,
4T 6 5 1 1 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 l ST 5 4 1 1 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 6T 4 18 1 1 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 7T 16 2 1 1 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 ST 2 10 1 1 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 9T 10 11 1 1 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 10T 11 12 1 1 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 11T 12 3 1 1 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 12T 3 17 1 1 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 13T 12 13 1 1 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 14T 13 14 1 1 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 IST 14 5 1 1 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 16T 7 8 1 1 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 , 17T 8 9 1 1 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 18T 9 10 1 1 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 l l A-4 l
BENCHMARK PROBLEM - UNI BM2 APPENDIX A PAGE: UNI-BM2-2 1 0 0.0447 0.0447' O.0447 0.0 0.0 0.0 ) 2 0 0.0447 0.0447 0.0447 0.0 0.0 0.9 I 3 0 0.0447 0.0447 0.0447 0.0 0.0 0.0 4 0 0.0447 0.0447 0.0447 0.0 0.0 0.0 -
~ - , - 5 0 0.04327 0.04327' O.04327 0.0 0.0 0.0 6 0 0.00894 0.00894 0.00894 0.0 0.0 0.0 7 0 0.04327 0.04327 0.04327 0.0 0.0 0.0 .
E O' O.00894 0.00894 0.00894 0.0 0.0 0.0 9 0 0.00894 0.00894 0.00894 0.0 0.0 0.0 10 0 0.04327 0.04327 0.04327 0.0 0.0 0.0 11 0 0.00894 0.'00894 0.00894 0.0 0.0 0.0 12 0 0.04327. 0.04327 0.04327 0.0 0.0 0.0 13 0 0.00894 0.00894 0.00894 0.0 0.0 0.0 l 14 0 0.00894 0.00894 0.00894 0.0 0.0 0.0 j l 00000 00000 0 0 0 0.0 0.0 l 1 1 0.02 2 4 1 1.0 1 0.6667 1 1.0 IMPERIAL VALLEY, EL CENTRO 1940, BENCHMARK PRO'BLEM NO. 2 11 0.001698 145.0 0.02860 380.0 0.05800 775.0 l 0.07100 775.0 O.09100 440.0 0.1140 1188.0 0.1410. 1188.0 0.1720 700.0 . 0.2000 871.0 0.2500 871.0 - 0.3230 400.0 300 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 12- 19 10000. 10000. 10000. 10000. 1000. 1.0 0.05 0.05 0.0 0.0 2 1 1 1 -1 0 10 0 1 19 12 10000. 10000. l I I l A-5
. q s
a 1 BENCH' MARK PROBLEM - UNI BM3 APPENDIX A .PAGE: UNI-BM3-1 I
' BENCHMARK PROBLEM NO. 3 - RESPONSE SPECTRUM ANALYSIS' I
NRC UNIFORM RESPONSE SPECTRA 30 2 0- 10 5 0 0- 60- 0 1 0 0 1. 10 1- 'O- 0 0 1- 1 1 0.000 0.000 0.000 { 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.000 54.45 0.000 1 0 0 0 3 0 0. 0' '0.0 108.9 'O.0
~4 .0 0 0 0 0 O! -10.632 134.568 0.0 5 0 0 0 0~ 0 0- 36.3 145.2 0.0 6 'O .0 0- 0 0 0 54.15 145.2 0.0 7 0 0 0 0 0 0 72.s 145.2 0.0 8 0 0 ' O. 0 0 0 97.668 145.2 10.632 9' 0- 0 0 0 0 0. 108.3 145.2 36.3 l 10' O O O O O O 108.3 145.2 56.8 1 11 0 0 0 01 0 0 108.3 145.2 77.3 '
12 0 0 0 0 0 0 108.3 145.2 97.8 i 13 0 0 0 0 0 0 108.3 145.2 118.3 '] 14 0 0 0 0 0 0 108.3 145.2 188.8 15 0 0 0 0- 0 0 108.3 181.5 225.1' 16 0 0 0 0 0 0 108.3 236.0 225.1 ; 17- 1 1 1 0 0 0 108.3 290.0 225.1 18- 0 0 0 0 o' O 148.3L 145.2 97.8
~19 .0 0 0 0 0 0 188.3 145.2 97.8 i 120 0 0 0. ~0 0 0 224.'6 145.2 61.5-21 , 1 1 1 1 1 1 224.6 145.2 20.0 i ~f 22 1- 1 1 1 1 1 1.0 0.0 0.0 23- l' 1 1 1. 1. 1 0.0 1.0 0.0 24 l' 1 1- 1 1 1 0.0 0.0 1.0 25 .1- 1- 1 1 1 1 72.0 145.2 -1.0 26 1 1 1 1- 1 1 109.3 145.2 36.3 27' 1 1 1 1 1 1 108.3 146.2. 77.3 j 28 1 1 1 1 . :L 1 108.3 146.2- 118.3 {
29 1 1 1 1 1 1 107.3 182.5 226.5 30 'l 1 1 1 1 1. 148.3 145.2 110.0 , 7 8 ; 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0- - 1 22 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 0.1E11 1 23 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 0.1E11 1 24 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 0.1E11 ; 25 7 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 0.1E09 9 26 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 0.1E09 11 27 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 0.1E05 13 28 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 0.1E05 l 15 29. 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 0.1E09 12 20 1 1 1 0 3 1 , 'O ALLOY STEEL j 0.0 24000000. 0.3 0.0000071 ' L 1 7.288 0.241 0.0 2.179 0.005639 ,, 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 a L 1.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 i L I A-6
>ll BENCHMARK PROBLEM - UNI BM3 APPENDIX A PAGE: UNI-BM3-2 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 i 1.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 1.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 1T 1 2 1 1 0.0 350.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 ~
2T 2 3 1 1 ,0 . 0 350.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 350.0 I 3B 3 4 1 1 36.3 CC 36.3 108.9 0.0 0.1 4B 4 5 1 1 0.0 350.0 36.3 CC 36.3 108.9 0.0 0.1 ST 5 6 1 1 0.0 350.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
- 5. 6T 7B 6
7 7 8 1 1. 1 1 0.0 0.0 350.0 350.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 i 36.3 CC 72.0 145.2 -36.3 0.1 L 8B 8 9 1 1 0.0' 350.0 ! 36.3 CC 72.0 145.2 36.3 0.1 9T 9 10 1 1 0.0 350.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 l 10T 10 11 1 1 0.0 350.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 I 11T
*13T 12T 11 12 13 12 13 14 1
1 1 1 1 1 0.0 0.0 0.0 350.0 350.0 350.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 14B 14 15 1 1 0.0 350.0 188.8 0.1 I 36.3 15T 15 CC 108.3 16 1 1 181.5 0.0 350.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 , 16T 16 17 1 1 0.0 350.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 17T 12 18 1 1 0.0 350.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 18T 18 19 1 1 0.0 350.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 19B 19 20 1 1 0.0 350.0
; 36.3 CC 188.3 145.2 61.5 0.1 20T 20 21 1 1 0.0 350.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 18 0 1.518 1.518 1.518' O.0 0.0 0.0 000000 I 000000 0
1 0 1 0 0.02 0.0 2 0.0 4 1 1.0 1 0.6667 1 1.0 SPECTRUM TABLE (IMPERIAL VALLEY E. Q. EL CENTRO 1940 SE) 11 0.001698 145.0 I 0.02860 380.0 0.05800 775.0
, 0.07100 775.0 0.09100 440.0 I 0.1140 0.1410 0.1720 1188.0 1188.0 700.0 O.2000 871.0 I 0.2500 0.3230 300 0 871.0 400.0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ,O 1 18 30 10000. 10000. 10000. 10000. 1000.
'll A-7 I
k BENCHMARK PROBLEM - UNI BM3 APPENDIX A PAGE: UNI-BM3-3 ! i 1.0 0.05 0.05 , 0.0 0.0 2 1 1 1 -1 0 l ( J l 10 0 ! 1 30 18 10000., 10000. ! 4 i A-8
BENCHMARK PROBLEM - UNI BM4 APPEND'X A PAGE: UNI-BM4-1 BENCHMARK PROBLEM No.4 - TWO LOOP SYSTEM, RESPONSE SPECTRUM ANALYSIS NRC UNIFORM RESPONSE SPECTRA 98 2 0 30 5 0 0 250 0 1 0 0 1 30 . 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 384.000 696.000 0.000 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 384.000 552.000 0.000 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 384.000 456.000 0.000 4 0 0 0 0 0 0 384.000 276.000 0.000 5 1 1 1 1 1 1 383.000 276.000 0.000 6 1 1 1 1 1 1 384.000 276.000 1.000 7 1 1 1 1 1 1 385.000 276.000 0.000 8 1 1 1 1 1 1 384.000 276.000 -1.000 ! 9 0 0 0 0 0 0 384.000 96.000 0.000 10 1 1 1 1 1 1 384.000 -180.00'O 0.000 11 0 0 0 0 0 0 399.000 26.900 -56.000 12 0 0 0 0 0 0 338.800 42.100 0.000 13 0 0 0 0 0 0 399.000 26.900 56.000 14 0 0 0 0 0 0 402.600 -11.600 -69.500 15 0 0 0 0 0 0 248.400 0.000 0.000 16 0 0 0 0 0 0 402.600 -11.600 69.500 17 0 0 0 0 0 0 402.600 -72.000 ~69.500 18 0 0 0 0 0 0 402.600 -72,000^ 69.500 19 0 0 0 0 0 0 354.700 -132.000 -105.600 20 0 0 0 0- 0- 0 354.700 -132.000 105.600 21 0 0 0 0 0 0 335.900 -132.000 -119.900 22 0 0 0 0 0 0 335.900 -132.000 119.900 23 0 0 0 0 0 0 288.000 -72.000 -156.000 24 0. 0 0 0 0 0 288.000 -72.000 156.000 25 0 0 0 0 0 0 288.000 0.000 -156.000 26 0 0 0 0 0 0 288.000 0.000 156.000 27 1 1 1 1 1 1 288.000 -180.000 -156.000 28 1 1 1 1 1 1 288.000 -180.000 156.000 29 0 0 0 0 0 0 288.000 126.000 -156.000 30 0 0 0 0 - 0 0 288.000 126.000 156.000 31 0 0 0 0 0 0 253.200 0.000 '-146.700 ) 32 0 0 0 0 0 0 253.200 0.000 146.700 33 0 0 0 0 0 0 187.300 0.000 -128.500 34 0 0 0 0 0 0 177.000 0.000 0.000 35 0 0 0 0 0 0 187.300 0.000 128.500 36 0 0 0 0 0 0 121.400 0.000 -110.200 37 0 0 0 0 0 0 121.400 0.000 110.200 i 38 0 0 0 0 0 0 94.600 0.000 -94.600 39 0 0 0 0 0 0 96.000 0.000 0.000 40 0 0 0 0 0 0 94.600 0.000 94.600 41 1 1 1 1 1 1 95.600 0.000 -93.600 ) 42 1 1 1 1 1 1 96.000 0.000 1.000 ) 43 1 1 1 1 1 1 93.600 0.000 95.600 44 1 1 1 1 1 1 94.600 -1.000 -94.600 45 1 1 1 1 1 1 96.000 -1.000 0.000 46 1 1 1 1 1 1 94.600 -1.000 94.600 l ) ) A-9
) ~k BENCHMARK PROBLEM - UNI BM4 APPENDIX A PAGE: UNI-BM4-2 i
r 47 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.000 0.000 0.000 1 48 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.000 -192.000 0.000 49 0 0 0 0 0 0 ( 0.000 84.000 0.000 50 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.000 156.000 0.000 51 0' O O O o 0 0.000 288.000 0.000 { 52 1 1 1 1 1 1 -94.600 -1.000 -94.600 -l 53 1 1 1 1 1 1 -96.000 -1.000 0.000 54 1 1 1 1 1 1 -94.600 -1.000 94.600 55 1- 1 1 1 1 1 -95.600 0.000 .-93.600 l 56 1 1 1 1 1 1 -96.000 0.000 1.000 I 57 1 1 1 1 l' 1 -93.600 0.000 95.600 58 0 0 0. 0 0 0 -94.600 0.000 -94.600 59 0 0 0' O O O -96.000 ~0.000 0.000- . 60 0 0 0- 0 0 0 -94.600- 0.000 94.600 61 0 0 0 0 0 0 -121.400. 0.000-.-110.200 62 0 0 0 0 0 0 -121.400 0.000 110.200 63 0 0 0 0 0 0 -187.300 ;0.000 -128.500 l 64 0 0 0 0 0 0 -177.000 0.000 0.000 65 0 0 0 0 0 0 -187.300 0.000 128.500
~66 0 0 0 0 0 0 -253.200 0.000 -146.700 67 0 0 0 0 0 0 -253.200 0.000 146.700 68 0 0 0 0 0 0 -288.000 '126.000 -156.000
- 69. O O O O O O -288.000_ 126.000 156.000 ,
70 1 .1 1 1 1 1 -288.000 -180.000 -156.000 ; 71 1 1 1 1 1 1 -288.000 -180.000 156.000 ' 72 0 0~ 0 0 0 0 -288.000. 0.000 -156.000 - 73 0. 0 0 0 0 0 -288.000 0.000 156.000 74 -0 0 0 0 0 0 -288.000 -72.000 -156.000 75 0 0 0 0 0 0 -288.000 -72.000 156.000 76 0 0 0 0 0 0 -335.900 -132.000 -119.900. 77 0 0 0 0 0 0 -335.900 -132.000 119.900 78 0 0 0 0 0 0 -354.700 -132.000 -105.600 79 0 0 0 0 0 0 -354.700 -132.000 105.600 80 0 0 0 0 0 0 -402.600 -72.000 -69.500 81 0 0 0 0 0 0 -402.600 ' -72.000 69.500 ; 82 0 0 0 0 0 0 -402.600 -11.600 -69.500 83 0 0 0 0 0 0 -248.400 0.000 0.000 84 0 0 0 0 0 0 -402.600 -11.600 69.500 85 0 0 0 0 0 0 -399.000 26.900 -56.000 86 0 0 0 0 0 0 -399.000 26.900 56.000 87 0 0 0 0 0 0 -338.800 42.100 0.000 88 1 1 1 1 1 1 -384.000 -180.000 0.000 89 0 0 0 0 0 0 -384.000 96.000 0.000 90 0 0 0 0 0 0 -384.000 276.000 0.000 91 1 1 1 1 1 1 -383.000 276.000 0.000 92 1 1 1 1 1 1 -385.000 276.000 0.000 93 1 1 1 1 1 1 -384.000 276.000 1.000 94 1 1 1 1 1 1 -384.000 276.000 -1.000 , 95 0 0 0 0 0 0 -384.000 456.000 0.000 96 0 0 0 0 0 0 -384.000 552.000 0.000 A-10
BENCHMARK PROBLEM - UNI BM4 APPENDIX A PAGE: UNI-BM4-3 97 0 0 0 0 0 0 -384.000 696.000 0.000 98 1 1 .1 1 1 1 121.40 100.0 -110.20 7 20 I 1.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 . 4 5 1 0.1E11 ~ l 4 6 1 0.1E11 j 4 7 1 0.1E11 4 8 1 0.1E11 38 44 1 0.5E08 l 39 45 1 0.5E08 1 40 46 1 0.5E08 39 42 1 . 0.1E08 40 43 1- 0.1E08 38 41 1 0.1E08 I 59 53 1 0.5E08 59 56 1 0.1E08 60 54 1 0.5E08 i 60 57 1 0.1E08 58 52 1 0.5E08 58 55 1 0.1E08 90 91 1 0.1E11 L 90 92 1 0.1E11 90 93 1 0.1E11 90 94 1 . 0.1E11 l 12 80 1 1 7 7 8 I 1 1 STAINLESS STEEL 70.0 29000000. 0.3 0.00005 l 1 144.0 3.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 SI i 2 36.0 2.5 0.0 G2.0 0.2122 PI 3 48.0 3.75 0.0 164.0 0.4244 PI 4 72.0 4.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 PU 1 5 192.0 8.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 RE i 6 135.0 0.4 0.0 0.0 0.0 SU 7 100.0 0.38 0.0 0.0 0.0 9 25 26 47 72 73 89 1.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 1.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 1.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 l 1.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 1T 1 2 1 1 0.0 2400.0 2T 2 3 1 1 0.0 2400.0 3T 3 4 1 1 0.0 2400.0 4T 4 9 1 1 0.0 2400.0 ST 9 10 1 6 0.0 0.0 6T 9 11 1 1 0.0 2400.0 I l 7T 9 13 1 1 0.0 2400.0 BT 9 12 1 1 0.0 2400.0 9B 11 14 1 2 0.0 2400.0 - ) 60.0 TI 402.6 10.2 ~69.5 0.1 l l A-11 L
... j k
BENCHMARK PROBLEM - UNI BM4 APPENDIX A PAGE: UNI-BM4-4 f i 10B' 12. 15 1 3- 0.0 2400.0 q 117.9 TI 303.4 0.0 0.0 0.1 11B 13 16 1 2 0.0 2400.0 l 60.0 TI 402.6 10.2 69.5 0.1 12T 14 17 l' 2 0.0 2400.0 f 13T 16 18 1 2 0.0 2400.0 ( 14B 17 19 1 2 0.0 2400.0 60.0 TI 402.6 -132.0 -69.5 0.1 . ISB 18 20 1 2 0.0 2400.0 ) 60.0 TI' 402.6 -132.0 69.5 0.1 - 1 16T 19 21 1 2 0.0 2400.0 17T 20 22 1 2 0.0 2400.0 18B 21 23 1 2 0.0 2400.0 60.0 TI 288.0 -132.0 I
-156.0 0.1 198 22 24 1 2 0.0 2400.0 .
60.0 TI 288.0 -132.0 156.0 0.1 20T 23 25 1 4 0.0 2400.0 .q 21T 24 26 1 4 0.0 2400.0 22T 25 27 1 7 0.0 0.0 23T 26 28 1 7 0.0 0.0 24T 25 29 1 4 0.0 2400.0 i 25T 26 30 1 4 0.0 2400.0 26T 25 31 1 4 0.0 2400.'O 27T 26 32 1 4 0.0' 2400.0 1 28T 31 33 1 2 0.0 2400.0 29T 15 34 1 3 0.0 2400.0 30T 32. 35- 1 '2 0.0 2400.0 1 31T 33 36 1 2 0.0 2400.0 32T- .34 39 1 3 . 0. 0 2400.0
'33T 35 37 1 2 0.0 2400.0 34B 36 38 1 2 0.0 2400.0 60.0 TI 106.0 0.0 -106.0 0.25 i 35B 37. 40 l' 2 0.0 2400.0 60.0 TI 106.0 0.0 106.0 0.25 36T 38 47 1 5 0.0 2400.0 j 37T 39 47 1 5 0.0 2400.0' '
38T 40 47 1 5 0.0 2400.0 39T 47 4S 1 5 0.0 2400.0 40T 47 49 1 5 0.0 2400.0 41T .49 50 1 5 0.0 2400.0 42T 50 51 1 5 0.0 2400.0 43T 47 58 1 5 0.0 2400.0 44T 47 59 1 5 0.0 2400.0 1 45T 47 60 1 5 0.0 2400.0 46B 61 58 1 2 0.0 2400.0 60.0 TI -106.0 0.0 -106.0 0.25 47B 62 60 1 2 0.0 2400.0 60.0 TI -106.0 0.0 106.0 0.25 ,- 48T 61 63 1 2 0.0 2400.0 l 49T 59 64 1 3 0.0 2400.0 A-12
1,
%e ' BENCHMARK PROBLEM - UNI BM4 APPENDIX A PAGE: UNI-BM4-5 1 SOT- 62 65 1 2 0.0 '2400.0 SlT 63 66 1 2 0.0 2400.0 52T 64 83- 1 3 0.0 2400.0 53T 65 67 1 2 0.0 2400.0 54T 66 72 1 4 0.0 2400.0 "
SST 67 73 1 4 0.0 2400.0 56T- 68 72 1 4 0.0 2400.0 57T 69 73 1 4 0.0 2400.0 58T 70 72 1 7 0.0 0.0 59T 71 73 1 7, 0.0 0.0 60T 72 ~ 74 1 4 0.0 2400.0 61T 73 75 1. 4 0.0 2400.0 62B 76 74 1 2 0.0 2400.0 60.0 l TI -288.0 -132.0 -156.0 0.25 63B 77 75 1 2 0.0 2400.0 ' 60.0 TI ~288.0 -132.0 156.0 0.25 64T 76 -78 1 2 0.0 2400.0 65T 77 79 1 2 0.0 2400.0 66B 80 78 1 2 0.0 2400.0 60.0 TI -402.6 -132.0 -69.5 0.25 67B 81 79 1 2 0.0 2400.0 60.0 TI -402.6 -132.0 69.5 0.25 68T 80 82 1 2 0.0 2400.0 69T 81 84 1 2 0.0 2400.0 70B 85 82 1 2 0.0 2400.0 60.0 TI -402.6 10.2 -69.5 0.25 71B 87 83 1 3 0.0 2400.0 117.9- TI -303.4 0.0 0.0 0.1 72B 86 84 1 2 0.0 2400.0 60.0 TI -402.6 10.2 69.5 0.25 73T 85 89 1 1 0.0 2400.0-74T 87 89 ll 1 0.0 2400.0 . ! 75T 86- 89 1 1 0.0 2400.0 76T 88 89 1 6 0.0 0.0
- 77T- 89 90 1 1 0.0 2400.0
) -' 78T 90 95 1 1 0.0 2400.0 79T 95 96 1 1 0.0 2400.0 80T 96 97 1 1 0.0 2400.0 1 0 518.0 518.0 518.0 2 0 259.0 259.0 259.0 3 0 259.0 259.0 259.0 4 0 906.0 906.0 906.0 i 9 0 233.0 233.0 233.0 ) 25 0 130.0 130.0 130.0 26 0 130.0 130.0 130.0 29 0 389.0 389.0 389.0 I 30 h 0 389.0 389.0 389.0 47 0 2073.0 2073.0 2073.0 48 0 1943.0 1943.0 1943.0 # 49 0 1295.0 1295.0 1295.0 I f L l A-13
e
- BENCHMARK PROBLEM l- UNI BM4 APPENDIX A PAGE: UNI-BM4-6 50 0 518.0 518.0 518.0 51 0 389.0 389.0 389.0 68 0 389.0 389.0 389.0 69 0 389.0- 389.0 389.0 72 0 -130.0 130.0 130.0 73 0 130.0 130.0 130.0 )
89 0 233.0 233.0 233.0 90 0 906.0 906.0 906.0 95 0 259.0 259.0 259.0 96 0 259.0 259.0 259..O I 97 0 518.0 518.0 518.0 00000 t 00000 , I 00000 1 1 0.02 2 4 1 1.0 1 =0.6667 1 1.0 SPECTRUM TABLE - (BENCHMARK PROBLEM RESPONSE SPECTRUM) l 38 1.0 0.005 160.0 0.0102 160.0 0.01391 243.0 0.017 243.0 0.01923 170.0 0.02164 255.0. .I 0.02439 255.0 0.02667 407.0 0.04202 475.0- i 0.04609 555.0 0.05528 652.0 0.05882 755.0 0.06711 755.0 I 0.0711 865.0 i 0.1 865.0 0.1156 1222.0 0.1413 1222.0 ( O.1482 1150.0 0.1534 1399.0 0.1876 1399.0 0.1923 1140.0 0.2268 1140.0 0.2392 1057.0 0.2924 1057.0 0.3049 1023.0 0.3175 855.0 i 0.3460 855.0 t O.3571 812.0 0.3922 812.0 0.4167 914.0 .- 0.5208 914.0 { L 0.5263 865.0 i i i A-14 I ( .__ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ -
.i
!c ,
. BENCHMARK PROBLEM - UNI BM4' APPENDIX A PAGE: UNI-BM4-7 1.
O.6173-. 865.0 [ 0.6250 '905.0 l-
- 0.7813 905.0
'O.8696: 662.0 ~
,- 0.9524 '662.0 -
-1.0: 600.0
( 300 0 0 0 -0 0 0 0 O O' 0 0 0 0 0- 0 1 36. 98 10000. 10000. 10000. 10000.' 1000. >. 1.0 0.05 0.05 [.. 0.0. 0.0 2 1 1 1 -1 0 10 0 1 98 36 10000. 10000. l e t . l. 4 l . i l i 1 i 1 M i j
) )
l I A-15 ; l l j
l BENCHMARK PROBLEM - UNI BMS APPENDIX A PAGE: UNI-BM5 i BENCHMARK PROBLEM NO. 5 - RESPONSE SPECTRUM ANALYSIS l
~ NRC UNIFORM RESPONSE SPECTRA 40 2 0 11 5 0 -0 100 0 1 0 0 1 11 i 1- .1 1 1 1 1 1 0.0 0.0 0, 0 l 0 0 0 l 2 0 0 0 18.636 0.0 -4.368 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 23.424 0.0 -4.920 4 0 0 0 0 0 0 26.400 0.0 -4.920 1 5 0 0 0 0 0 0 47.400 0.0 -25.920 )
6 0 0 0- 0 0 0 47.400 0.0 -79.920 7 0 0 0 0 0 0 68.400 0.0 -100.920 8 0 0 0 0 0 0 89.400 0.0 -79.920 1 9 0 0 0 0 0 0 89.400 0.0 -25.920 .i 10 0 0 0 0 0 0.110.400 0.0 -4.920 11 0 0 0 0 0 0 146.400 0.0 -4.920 12 0 0 0 0 0 0 206.400 0.0 -4.920' , 13 0 0 0 0 0 0 245.400 0.0 -4.920 ( 14 0 0 0 0 0 0 266.400 0.0 -25.920 15 0 0 0 0 0 0 266.400 0.0 -72.480 4 16 0 0 0 0 0 0 266.400 0.0 -87.732 j 17 0 0 .0 0 0 0 272.436 -1.452 -102.636 18 0 0 0 0 0 0 323.280 -13.680 -154.560
.19 0 0 0 0 0 0 327.960 -14.760 -159.360 1 20 0 0 0 0 0 0 336.816 -16.944 -168.396 {
21 0 0 0 0 0 0 349.884 -18.264 -173.856 22 -0 0 0 0 0 0 370.884 -18.264 -173.856 23: 0 0 0 0 0 0 370.884 30.696 -173.856~ l 24 0 0 0 0 0 0 391.884 -18.264 -173.856 1 25 0 0 0 0 0 0 404.844 -18.264 ~~173.856 26 0 0 0 0 0 0 417.804 -18.264 -173.856 l 27 0 0 0 0 0 0 438.804 -18.264 -173.856 j 28 0 0 0 -0 0 0 438.804 30.696 -173.856 29 0 0 0 0 0 0 459.804 -18.264 -173.856 - 30 0 0 0 0 0 0 472.236 -18.264 -173.856 ) 31 0 0 0 0 0 0 485.148 -18.264 -179.316 i 32 0 0 0 0 0 0 507.300 -18.264 -202.128 33 1 1 1 1 1 1 519.840 -0.264 -215.040 34 1 1 1 1 1 1 245.400 12.000 -4.920 35 1 1 1 1 1, 1 404.644 12.000 173.856 36 1 1 1 1 1 1.485.148 12.000 179.376 37 1 1 1 1 1 1 68.400 12.000 -100.920 38 1 1 1 1 1 1 323.280 12.000 -154.560 ; 39 1 1 1 1 1 1 323.280 -13.680 -166.560 l 40 1 1 1 1 1 1 206.4 10.0 -4.92 7 6 ( 1.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 i 7 37 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 0.1E08 18 38 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 0.1E08 18 39 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 0.1E08 ! 13 34 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 0.45E03 1 4 i A-16 l
~ BENCHMARK PROBLEM . UNI BMS APPENDIX A PAGE: UNI-BMS-2 .25 35 1 0. 0 l0.0 0.0 0.8E03 31 36 -1 0 0 0.0 0.0 0.6E03 -12 32 3: 1- 4 0 4 l 1 1 304 SS .,
0.0 26.2E06 0.3 0.0 2 1 -316 SS-0.0 25.2E06 0.3 0.0 3 1 316 SS VALVE
'0.0 75.6E06 0.3 0.0 1 14.00 0.438 ^
2 12.75 0.375 3 12.75 1.312' 4 12.75 2.000 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0
~1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1T 1 2. 1' 1 2B 2 3 1 1 21.0 21.0 0.0 -4.92 0.1 3T 3 4 1 1 4B 4 5 1. 1 21.0 47.4 0.0 -4.92 0.1-ST 5 6 'l 1 6B' 6 7 '. 1 1 21.0 47.4 0.0 -100.92 0.1 75 7 8 1 l' 21.0 89.4 0.0 -100.92 0.1 ST 8 9 1 1 --
9B 9 10 1 1 21.0 89.4 0.0 -4.92 0.1 10T 10 11 1 1 11T 11 12 1 1 12T 12 13 1 1 I' 13B 13 14' 1 .1
.21.0 266.4 0.0 -4.92 0.1 14T 14 15 1 1 IST 15 16 1 1 16B 16 17 1 1 21.0 266.4 0.0 -96.48 0.1 17T 17 18 1 1
- 18T 18 19 1 1 19T 19 20 1 1 20B 20 21 1 2
)- 18.0 342.144 -18.264 -173.856 0.1 ) '21T' 21 22 3 3 22T 22' 23 2 4 23T 22 24 3 3 24T 24 25 2 3 f 1 A-17 )
L. i ) I
"- BENCRMARK PROBLEM - UNI BMS APPENDIX A PAGE: UNI-BM5-3 l I
25T 25 26 2 3
.26T 26 27 3 3 l 27T 27 28 2 4- i 28T 27 29 3 3 29T 29 30 2 3 )
300 30 31. 2 3 j 18.0 479.844 -18.264 -173.856 0.1 31T 31 32 2 3 32B 32 33 2 3 j 18.0, 519.84 -18.264 -215.040 0.1 4 0 2.8116 2.8116 2.8116 7 'O 4.0432 4.0432 4.0432 10 0 2.5489 2.5489 2.5489
.11 - 0 1.4063 1.4063 1.4063 i
- 12. O 1.4503 1.4503 1.4503 13 0 1.8685 1.8685 1.8685 15 0 2.8566 2.8566 2.8566 18 0 i
2.0246- 2.0246 2.0246 22 0 6.7857 6.7857 6.7857
.23- 0 0.63406 0.63406 0.63406 l 25 0 0.59369 0.59369 0.59369 27 0 6.9539 6.9539 6.9539 28 0 0.63406 0.63406 0.63406 31 0 3.7396 3.7396 3.7396 l 000000 000000 0 0 0 0.0 0.0 ;
1 1 0.02 2 2 ' 1 386.4 1 257.613 1 386.4 RESPONSE SPECTRUM DATA - 13 0.000 0.096 , 0.025 0.096 0.085 0.120
.0.140 0.300 0.155 0.500 I 0.155 1.100 0.190 1.100 0.190 0.480 0.200 0.300 "
0.250 0.120 0.330 0.072 < 0.600 0.024 < 1.000 0.012 300 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 12 40 10000. 10000. 10000. 10000. 1000. i 10 0.05 0.05 ' O.O 0.0 2 1 1 1 -1 'O ,, A-18
BENCHMARK PROBLEM - UNI BMS APPENDIX A PAGE: UNI-BMS-4 l 6 10 0 1 40 12 10000. 10000. ., ( e 0 8 8 lI L8-I l'I . I 8 8 8 I .. E 9 lt ^-- I
- \
. BENCHMARK PROBLEM - UNI.BM6 APPENDIX A PAGE: UNI-BM6-1 l
l BENCMMARK-PROBLEM NO.6 (X, Y, AND Z SPECTRA) ., NRC UNIFORM RESPONSE. SPECTRA # 61 2 0 31 5 0 0 150 0 1 0 0 l' 31 .. 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 126.000 483.996 705.840 i 2 0 0 0 0 0' O 126.000 483.996 704.640 i 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 126.000 528.996 659.640 is 0 0 0 0 0 0 126.000 567.996 659.640 5 'O O O O O O 126.000 651.996 659.640 ) 6 0 0 0 0 'O O 126.000 735.996 659.640 4 7 0~ 0 O d 0 0 126.000 802.596 659.640 , 8 0 0 Q. 0 0 0 126.000 869.196 659.640 ; 9 0 0 0 0 0 0 126.000 917.196 " 659.640 10 0 0' O O O O 126.000 965.196 659.640
.11 0 0 0 0 0 0 126.000 968.196 659.640 12 0 0 0 0 0 0 169.860 1013.196 649.560 13 0 -0 0 0 0 0 173.928 1013.196 648.624 l 14 0 0 0 0 0 0 229.836 1013.196 630.996 15 0 0. O O O O 283.992 1013 196 608.556 16 0 0 0 0 0 0 335.988 1013.196 581.484 i 17 0. O O O O O 385.428 1013.196 550.080 1 18 0 0 0 0 0 0 431.940 1013.196 514.392 19 0 0- O' O O O 475'.164 1013.196 474.780
- 20. 0 0 0 0 0 0 514.776 1013.196 431.556 21 0 0 0 0 0 0 550.464 1013.196 385.044 i
'22 O O O O O O 581.964 1011.196 335.604 23~ O O O O O 0- 609.036 1013.196 283.608 24 0 0 0 0 0 0 631.474 1013.196 229.452 l 25 0 0 0 0 0 0 649.104- 1013.196 173.544 26 0 0 0 0 0 0 661.788 1013.196 116.304 27 0 0 0 0 0 0 669.444 1013.196 58.176 28 0 0 0 0 0 0 672.000 1013.196 -0.396 i 29 0 0 0 0 0 0 669.444 1013.196 -58.968 30 0 0 0 0 0 0 661.788- 1013.196'*-117.096 4 31 0 0 0 0 0 0 649.104 1013.196 -174.336 -('
32 0 0 0 0 0 0 631.476 1013.196 -230.244 33 0 0. 0 0 0 0 609.036 1013.196 -284.400' 34 0 0 0 0 0 0 581.964 1013.196 -336.396 ; 35 0 0 0 0 0 0 550.596 1013.196 -385.572 36 0 0 0 0 0 0 375.312 1013.196 -446.736 37 0 0 0 0 0 0 345.576 1013.196 -436.500 38 0 0 0 0 0 0 262.368 1013.196 ~407.844
,, 39 0 0 0 0 0 0 221.700 1013.196 -393.840 40 0 0 0 0 0 0 179.160 968.196 -379.188 41 0 0 0 0 0 0 179.160 968.172 -379.188 ;
J42 1 1 1 1 1 1 127.000 965.196 659.640
'43 1 1 1 1 1 1 126.000 965.196 660.640 44 1 1 1 1 1 1 515.776 1013.196 431.556 e 45 1 1 1 1 1 1 514.776 1014.196 431.556 1 46 1 1 1 1 1 1 514.776 1013.196 432.556 ;
l A-20 a i _1_____.__________.______..___.____..
). ! [ ] l BENCHMARK PROBLEM - UNI BM6 APPENDIX A PAGE: UNI-BM6-2 ?^ 47 1 1 1 1 1 1 662.788 1013.196 116.304 48 1 1 1 1 1 1 661.788 1014.196 116.304 t ! 49 1 1 1 1 1 1 661.788 1013.196 117.304' 50 1 1 1 1 1 1 661.788 1014.196 -117.096 51 1 1 1 1 ~1 1 582.223 1013.196 -337.362 ) 52 1 1 1 1 1 1 180.160 968.196 -379.188. I 53 1 1 1 1 1 1 179.160 969.196 -379.188 54 1 1 1 1 1 1 179.160 968.196 -378.188 55 1 1 1 1 1 1 180.160 968.196 -379.188 I 56 1. 1 1 1 1 1 179.160 969.196 -379.188 57 1 1 1 1 1 1 179.160 968.196- -378.188 58 1 1 1 1 1 1 127.000 483.996 705.840 59 1. 1 1 1 1 3 126.000 484.996 705.840
- 60 1 1 1 1 .1 1 126.000 483.996 706.840 61 1 1 1 1 1 1 581.964 1050.0 335.604 7 19 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0
> 1 58 1 1 0.1E20 1 59 1 1 0.1E20 3 1 60 1 1 0.1E20 10 42 1 0 0.1E07 10 43 1 0 0.1E07 20 44 1 'O 0.25E06 20 45 1 0 0.2807 20 46 1 0 0.25E06 26 47 1 0 0.45E06 26 48 1 0 0.2507 26 49 1 0 0.45E06 30 50- 1 0 0.2E07 34 51 1 0 0.8E06 41 52 1 0 0.1E10 41 53 1 0 0.1E10 41 54 1 0 0.1E10 41 PS5 0 1 0.1E1? 41 56 0 1 0.1E12 41 57 0 1 0.1E12 12 40 2 1 2 0 3 1 1 MATERIAL NO. 1 301.0 29900000. 0.3 0.0 2 1 MATERIAL No. 2 320.0 29900000. 0.3 0.0 1 30.0 0.85 0.0 0.0 0.0 2 32.0 0.905 0.0 0.0 0.0 1.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 1.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 1.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 IT 1 2 1 1 0.0 0.0 2B 2 3 1 1 A-21
-i BENCHMARK PROBLEM - UNI BM6 APPENDIX A PAGE: UNI-BM6-3 45.0 'TI 126.0 483.96 659.64 0.1 3T. 3 4 1 1 4T 4 5 1 .1 ST 5 6 1 1 ..,
6T 6- 7 1 1 . 7T 7 8 1- 1 BT 8 9 1 1 9T 9 10 1 1 3 10T 10 11 1- 1 . , 11B 11. 12 1 1 45.0 TI 126.0 '1013.196 659.64 0.1-
'12T 12 13 1. 'l 13T 13 14 l' 1 -i 14T 14 15 1 1 15T 15 16 1 1 16T 16 17 1 1 17T 17 18- -1 1 i 18T 18 19 1 1 19T 19 20 1 1 20T 20 21 1 1 I i
21T 21 22 1 1 22T 22 23 1 1 23T 23 24 1 1 - 24T 24 25 1 1 ,i 25T 25 26 1- 1 26T 26 27 1 1 27T 27 28 1 1 28T 28 29 1 '1 1 29T 29 30 1 1 30T 30 31 1 1 - 31T 31 32 1 1 ; 32T 32 33 1 1 33T 33 34 1 1 34T 34. 35 1 1 1 35B -35 36 1 1 i 150.0 TI 487.056 1013.196 -485.196' O.1 36T 36 37 1 1 37T 37 38 1 1 38T 38 39 1 1 l 39B 39 40 2 2 45.0 TI 179.16 1013.196 -379.188 0.1 40T 40 41' 2 2 4 0 9.925 9.925 9.925 5 0 5.453 5.453 5.453 6 0 4.888 4.888 4.888 ( 7 0 5.888 5.888 5.888 9 0 5.373 5.373 5.373 11 0 3.95 3.95 3.95 # 12 0 2.43 2.43 2.43 I 13 0 3.941 3.941 3.941 } l i A-22
1
. BENCHMARK PROBLEM - UNI BM6 APPENDIX A PAGE: UNI-BM6-4 1
l 15 0 '7.6092 7.6092 7.6092 17 0 ~ 7.6092 7.6092 7.6092 19 0 7.612 7.612 7.612 21 0 7.611 7.611 7.611 23- 0 7.611 7.611 7.611 .~ 25 ~ . O .7.611 7.611 7.611 27' O 7.611 7.611 7.611
.29 0 7.611 7.611 7.611 31 0 7.611 7.611 7.611
, 33 0 7.601 7.601 7.601 ) 35' O 10.293 10.293 10.293 36 .0 .7.518 7.518 7.518 37 0 3.877- 3.877 3.877 38 0 10.528 10.528 10.528 y C0000 C0000 C0000 3 1 0.02 2 4
'l 1.0- 2 1.0 3 1.0 SPECTRUM TABLE IN X-DIRECTION 6 1.0 '
O.O 54.1 0.1249 81.14 0.1250 649.1
- 0.899 649.1
- O.9 135.2 2.0 27.05' SPECTRUM TABLE IN Y-DIRECTION 6 '1.0.
0.0 73.42 0.21 .73.42 0.21 1190.0 0.64 1190.0 O.64 143.0 2.0 108.2 1 SPECTRUM TABLE IN Z-DIRECTION l 6 1.0 0.0 54.1 0.1249 81.14 0.125 649.1 0.899 649.1 0.9 135.2 2.0 27.05 300 0' O O O O O O O O O O O O O O 1 22 61 10000. 10000. 10000.
.1.0 10000. 1000.
0.05 0.05 ) 0.0 0.0 2 1 1 1 -1 0 ) i f. }- i A-23 l )
I k BENCHMARK PROBLEM - UNI BM6 APPENDIX A PAGE: UNI-BM6-5 i i 10 0 1 61 22 10000. 10000. -1 i a i ( 4 l i ( l ( ( A-24 l
11 BENCHMARK PROBLEM - UNI BM7 APPENDIX A PAGE: UNI-BM7-1 BENCHMARK PROBLEM No. 7 - RESPONSE SPECTRUM ANALYSIS NRC UNIFORM RESPONSE SPECTRA I 171 2 0 22 5 0 0 200 0 1 0 0 1 22 - 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0.0 0.0 0.0 1 0.0 140 1 1 1 1 1 1 0.0 0.0 140.000 1 0.0 8 2 4 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0 0.0
-6.000 -12.000 0.0 -6.000 0
0 0.0 0.0 5 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0 -12.000 -38.040 0 0.0 6 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0 -12.000 -54.000 0 0.0 8 8 10 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0 0.0
-18.000 -36.000 -60.000 0 0
0.0 0.0 Q -60.000 11 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0 -65.040 -60.000 0 0.0 13 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0 -71.040 -54.000 0 0.0 8 15 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0 -71.040 -36.000 0 0.0 16 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0 -71.040 -6.000 0 0.0 18 0 0 0 0 0 0 -6.000 -71.040 0.0 0 0.0 1' 20 25 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 -21.960 0 -57.960
-71.040 -71.040 0.0 0.0 0
0 0.0 0.0 30 0 .0 0 0 0 0 -117.000 -71.040 0.0 C O.0 31 0 0 0 0 0 0 -139.680 -71.040 -22.680 0 0.0 8 33 35 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 -141.000 0 -141.000
-71.040 -71.040 -25.860 -46.560 0
0 0.0 0.0 40 0 0 0 0 0 0 -141.000 -71.040 -82.560- 0 0.0 41 0 0 0 0 0 0 -141.000 -71.040 -102.060 0 0.0 I 44 0 0 0 0 0 0 -136.500 -71.040 -106.560 0 0.0 45 0 0 0 0 0 0 -122.460 -71.040 -106.560 0 0.0 46 0 0 0 0 0 0 -97.440 -71.040 -106.560 0 0.0 48 0 0 0 0 0 0 -92.940 -75.540 -106.560 0 0.0 I 50 0 0 0 0 0 0 -92.940 -91.080 -106.560- 0 0.0 55 0 0 0 0 0 O' -92.940 .-107.040 -106.560 0 0.0 60 0 0 0 0 0 0 -165.000 -71.040 0.0 0 0.0 8 65 70 0
'O 0
O 0 O 0 O 0 O 0 -213.000 O ~255.000
-71.040 -71.040 0.0 0.0 0
0 0.0 0.0 71 0 0 0 0 0 0 -277.680 -71.040 -22.680 0 0.0 73 0 0 0 0 0 0 -279.000 -71.040 -25.860 0 0.0 5 75 0 0 0 0 0 0 -279.000 -71.040 -46.560 0 0.0 80 0 0 0 0 0 0 -279.000 -71.040 -82.560 0 0.0 I 81 0 0 0 0 0 0 -279.000 -71.040 -102.060 0 0.0 84 0 0 0 0 0 0 -274.500 -71.040 -106.560 0 0.0 85 0 0 0 0 0 0 -260.460 -71.040 -106.560 0 0.0 86 0 0 0 0 0 0 -235.440 -71.040 -106.560 0 0.0 88 0 0 0 0 0 0 -230.940 -75.540 -106.560 0 0.0 I 90 0 0 0 0 0 0 -230.940 -91.080 -106.560 0 0.0 95 0 0 0 0 0 0 -230.940 -107.040 -106.560 0 0.0 98 0 0 0 0 0 0 -259.080 -71.040 0.0 0 0.0 100 0 0 0 0 0 0 -263.040 -71.040 0.0 0 0.0 t 105 0 0 0 0 0 0 -315.000 -71.040 0.0 0 0.0 110 0 0 0 0 0 0 -375.000 -71.040 0.0 0 0.0 e 111 0 0 0 0 0 0 -412.500 -71.040 0.0 0 0.0 8 A-25 ll .
l BENCHMARK PROBLEM - UNI'BM7' APPENDIX A PAGE: UNI-BM7-2 113 0 0 0 0 0 0 -417.000 -71.040 -4.500 0 0.0 l 115 0 0 0 0 0 0 -417.000 -71.040 -18.120 0 0.0. 120 0 0 0 0 0 0 -417.000 -71.040 -78.120 0 0.0 # 121 0 0 0 0 0 0 -417.000 -71.040 -102.180 0 0.0' .. 124 0 0 0 0 0 0'-412.500 -71.040 -106.680 0 0.0 J 125 0 0 0- 0 0 0 -398.460 -71.040 -106.680 0 0.0 ( 126 0 0 0 0 0 0 -373.440 -71.040 -106.680 0 0.0 128 0 0 0 0 0 0 -368.940 -75.540 -106.680 0 0.0 , c- 130 0 0 0 'O O O -368.940 -91.080 -106.680 0 0.0 j L 140 0 0 0 0 0 0 -368.940 -107.040 -106.680 0 0.0- 1 141 1 1 1 1 'l 1 .0.0 -37.000 -60.000 0 0.0 142 1 1 1. 1 1 1 -141.000 -72.040 -82.560 0 0.0 143 1 1 1 1 1 1 -279.000 ~72.040 -82.560 0 0.0 144 1 1 1 1 1 1 -417.000 -72.040 -78.120 0 0.0- ' 145 1 1- 1 1. I 1 -21.960 -72.040 0.0 0 .0.0
,146 1 1 1 1 1 1 -375.000 -72.040 0.0 .0 0.0 ;
147 1 1 1 1 1 1 -93.940 -107.040 -106.560 0- 0.0 j 148 1 1 1 1 1 1: -93.940 -107.040 -106.560 0 0.0 149 1 1 l' 1 1 1 -92.940 -108.040 -106.560 0 0.0 150 1 1 1 1 1 1 -92.940 -108.040 -106.560 0 0.0. -1 151 1 1 1 1 1 1 -92.940 -107.040 -107.560 0 0.0 . 152- 1. 1 1 1 1 1 -92.940 -107.040 -107.560 30 0.0
-153 1 1 1 1 1 1 -214.000 -71.040. 0.0 0 0.0 154 1 1 1 1- 1 1 -214.000 -71.040 0.0 0 0.0 -i 155 1 1 1 1 1 1 -213.000 -72.040 0.0 0 0.0- i 156 1 1 1 1 1 1 -213.000 -72.040 0.0 0 0.0 157 1 1 1 1 1 1 -213.000 ~71.040 -1.000 0 0.0 j 158 1 1 1 1 1 1 -213.000 -71.040 -1.000 0 0.0 ;
159 1 1 1 1 1 1 -231.940 -107.040 -106.560 0 0.0 160 1 1 1 1- 1 1 -231.940 -107.040 -106.560 0 - 0. 0 . 161 "1 1 1 1 1 1 -230.940 -108.040 -106.560 0 0.0 162 1 1 1 1 1 1 -230.940 -108.040 -106.560 0 0.0 i 163 1 'l 1 1 1 1 -230.940 -107.040 -107.560 0 0.0
-164 .1 1 1 1. 1 1 -230.940 -107.040 -107.560 0 0.0 165 1 1 1 1 1 1.-369.940 -107.040 -106.680 0 0.0 i 166 1 1 1 1 1 1 -369.940 -107.040 -106.680 0 0.0 167 1 1 1 1 1 1 -368.940 -108.040 -106.680 0 0.0 168 1 1 1 1 1 1 -368.940 -108.040 -106.680 0 0.0 169 1 1 1 1 1 1 -368.940- -107.040 -107.680 0 0.0 170 1 1 1 1 1 1 -368.940 -107.040 -107.680 0 0.0 171 1 1 1 1 1 1 -57.96 -50.0 0.0 0 0.0 7 30 1.0 .
0.0 0.0 0.0 ,
- 10. 141 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 0.1E01 40 142 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 0.1E01 80 143 1 O O 0.0 0.0 0.1E01 (
120 144 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 0.1E01 20 ~145 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 0.1E10 ,- 110 14 F; 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 0.1E10 55 14? 1 0 ( 0 0.0 0.0 0.1E10 l ( A-26 i
r BENCHMARK PROBLEM - UNI BM7 APPENDIX A PAGE: UNI-BM7-3 55 149 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 0.1E10 55 151 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 0.1E10 65 153 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 0.1E10 65 155 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 0.1E10 65 157 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 0.1E10 ~~ 95 159 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 0.1E10 I 95 161 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 0.1E10. 95 163 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 0.1E10 140 165 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 0.1E10 y 140 167 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 0.1E10 140 169 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 0.1E10 55 148 0 1 0 0.0 0.0 0.1E12 55 150 0 1- 0 0.0 0.0 0.1E12 55 152 0 1 0 0.0 0.0 0.1E12 65 154 0 1 0 0.0 0.0 0.1E12 65 156 0 1 0 0.0 0.0 0.1E12 65 158 0 1 0 0.0 .0.0 0.1E12 95 160 0 1 0 0.0 0.0 0.1E12 95 162 0 1 0 0.0 0.0 0.1E12 95 164 0 1 0 0.0 0.0 0.1E12 140 166 0 1 0 0.0 0.0 0.1E12 140 168 0 1 0 0.0 0.0 0.1E12 140 170 0 1 0 0.0 0.0 0.1E12 12 54 2 1 2 0 4 J 1 1 PIPE 0.0 27.OE06 0.3 0.0 2 1 VALVE 0.0 81.OE06 0.3 0.0 1 4.50 0.337 2 3.50' O.300
.1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1T 1 2 1 1 2B 2 4 1 1 6.0 0.0 -12.00 0.0 0.1 3T 4 5 1 1 4T 5 6 2 1 5B 6 8 1 1 6.0 0.0 -12.00 -60.00 0.1 6T 8 10 1 1 7T 10 11 1 1 8B 11 13 1 1 6.0 0.0 -71.04 -60.00 0.1
) 9T 13 15 1 1 10T 15 16 1 1 11B 16 18 1 1 ,. 6.0 0.0 -71.04 0.0 0.1 ) 1 A-27
BENCHMARK PROBLEM - UNI BM7 APPENDIX A PAGE: UNI-BM7-4 12T 18 -20 2 'l 3 13T 20 '25 1 .1 14T 25 30 1 1 IST 30 31- 1 2 16B 31 33 1 2 4.5 -141.00 -71.04 -24.00 0.1 'q
.17T 33 35 1 2 18T .35 40 1 2 19T 40' 41 1 2 q 20B 41 44 1 2 i 4.5 -141.00 -71.04 -106.56 0.1 21T 44 45 2 2 22T 45 46 1" 2 23B 46 48 1 2 .
i 4.5 -92.94 -71.04 -106.56 0.1 24T 48 50 1 2 25T 50 55 2 2 26T '30 60 1 1 ! 27T 60 65 1 1 28T 65 70 1- 1 q
'29T 70 71 1 2 -30B 71 73 1 2 ]
4.5 -279.00 .-71.04 -24.00 0.1 31T 73 75 1 2 (
'32T 75 80 1 2 (
33T 80 81 1 2 34B 81 84 1 2 4.5 -279.00 -71.04 -106.56 0.1 35T 84 85 2 2 36T $85 86 1 2 37B 86 88 1 2 4.5 -230.94 -71.04 -106.56 0.1 j 38T 88 90 1 2 39T 90 95 2 2 40T 70 98 1 1 1 41T 98 100 1 1 l 42T 100 105 1 2 43T 105 110 1 2 44T 110 111 1 2 45B 111 .113 1 2 4.5 -417.00 -71.04 0.0 0.1 46T 113 115 1 2 47T 115 120 1 2 1 48T 120 121 1 2 49B 121 124 1 2 4.5 -417.00 ~71.04- -106.68 0.3 ( SOT 124 125 2 2 51T 125 126 1 2 52B 126 128 # 1 2 4.5 -368.94 -71.04 -106.68 0.1 $ 1 ( A-28 I i
a e + l .- 1 BENCHMARK PROBLEM - UNI BM7 APPENDIX A PAGE: UNI-BM7-5 l
'53T 128 130 1 2 j 54T. 130 140 2 2 j 5 0 .47179 .47179 .47179
- 10. 0 .37604 .37604 .37604 i 15' O .40399 .40399 .40399 -
20 0 .35016 .35016 .35016 ] 25 0 .22179 .22179 .22179 ): 30 0 .33799 .33799 .33799 35 0 .14441 .14441 .14441 1 i) 40 0 .26889 .26889 .26889 L 45 0 .29011 .29011 .29011 a f 50 0 .12733 .12733 .12733 l 60 0 .22386 .22386 .22386 65 0 .20990 .20990 .20990 _ ]l
- {
70 0 .28620 .28620. .28620 ! 75 0 . 14441 .14441 .14441 [ 80 0 .33799 .33799 .33799 85 0 :.29011 .29011 .29011 l 90 0 .12733 .12733 .12733 { 105 0 .19358 .19358 .19358 110 0 .18737 .18737 .18737 ,a I 115 0 .18737 .18737 .18737 120 0 .31366 .31366 .31366 125 0 .29736- .29736 .29736 130 0 .12733 .12733 .12733 I' 000000 1 000000 0 0 0 0.0 0.0 2' 1 0.02 2 -4 1 386.4 2 386.4' 1 386.4 OBE RESPONSE SPECTRUM - X & Z DIRECTIONS 11 0.010 0.130 0.100 0.130 0.310 1.650 0.350 0.350 0.500 0.550 0.580 1.900 0.805 1.700 0.900 0.450 1.000 0.180 1.100 0.100 1.200 0.070 OBE RESPONSE SPECTRUM - Y DIRECTION 11 0.010 0.200 0.100 0.200 ? 0.220 0.300 0.320 1.000 . 0.370 2.150 ' ). . l l ! i ) A-29 ). I
.w . i h: i f o r BENCHMARK PROBLEM - UNI BM7 APPENDIX A' PAGE: UNI-BM7-6 -1 0.420 2.150 0.520 2.550 4
0.600 0.600 0.700- 0.300 .. 0.800 0.200 1.100 , 0.120 j 300 'O O' 0 0 0 0~ 0~ 0 0 0 'O O O O O' 1- 25- 171 10000. 10000. 10000. 10000. 1000. 1.0 0.05 0.05' 'i 0.0s 0.0 2 1' 1 1 -1 '0 '( 10 0- j 1 171 25 10000. 10000. { q k
.I i
i l
..~
l ( I A-30 i
i L L l ) ) i
, APPENDIX B:
l Input Listing of ISM Benchmark Problems i ) ) l , i t ) ) i I ) y B-1 l )
BENCHMARK PROBLEM - ISM BM-1 APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM1-1 5
' INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION BENCHMARK PROBLEM 1 g NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEM, SRSS SOLUTION 53 2 0 15 6 0 0 0 0 1 0 2 1 15 .
5:' 1 0 0 0 1 1 1 0.000 0.000 0.000 0 0.000 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.000 12.000 0.000 0 0.00 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 35.687 60.000 32.110 0 0.00 4 0 0 0 0 0 0 55.000 60.000 49.500 0 0.000 l 5 0 0 0 0 0 0 74.329 60.000 66.882 0 0.00 6 0 0 0 0 0 0 110.000 12.000 99.000 0 0.00 7 0 0 0 0 0 0 110.000 0.000 99.000 0 0.00 8 0 0 0 0 0 0 110.000 -24.000 99.000 0 0.000 9 0 0 0 0 0 0 110.000 -48.000 99.000 0 0.00 ' 10 0 0 0 0 0 0 110.000 -72.000 99.000 0 0.00 0 11 0 0 0 0 0 110.000 -96.000 99.000 0 0.00 12 0 0 0 0 0 0 110.000 -120.000 99.000 0 0.000 13 0 0 0 0 0 0 110.000 -144.000 99.000 0 0.00 14 0 0 0 0 0 0 110.000 -168.000 99.000 0 0.00 15 0 0 0 0 0 0 110.000 -198.000 99.000 0 0.000 16 0 0 0 0 0 0 110.000 -228.000 99.000 0 0.00 17 0 0 0 0 0 0 110.000 -252.000 99.000 0 0.00 18 0 0 0 0 0 0 110.000 -276.000 99.000 0 0.00 19 0 0 0 0 0 0 110.000 -300.000 99.000 0 0.000 20 0 0 0 0 0 0 110.000 -324.000 99.000 0 0.00 21 0 0 0 0 0 0 99.600 -349.400 99.000 0 0.00 22 0 0 0 0 0 0 89.200 -374.800 99.000 0 0.00 23 0 0 0 0 0 0 78.800 >400.200 99.000 0 0.000 24 0 0 0 0 0 0 68.400 -425.600 99.000 0 0.0003 ! 25 0 0 0 0 0 0 58.000 -451.000 99.000 0 0.00g 26 0 0 0 0 0 0 58.000 -475.000 99.000 0 0.000 27 0 0 0 0 0 0 58.000 -487.000 99.000 0 28 0 0 0 0 0 0 103.537' -535.000 114.179 0 0.000l 0.000 29 0 0 0 0 0 0 124.269 -535.000 121.100 0 .0.00 3 30 0 0 0 0 0 0 145.000 -535.000 128.000 0 0.000 31 0 0 0 0 0 0 184.975 -535.000 123.615 0 0.00 32 0 0 0 0 0 0 214.800 -535.000 102.800 0 0.00 33 0 0 0 0 0 0 254.585 -535.000 81.849 0 0.000 ' 34 0 0 0 0 0 0 279.312 -535.000 75.000 0 0.000 35 0 0 0 0 0 0 331.000 -535.000 36 0 0 0 1 1 1 75.000 0 0.0003 383.000 -535.000 75.000 0 0.0005 37 1 1 1 1 1 1 10.000 0.000 0.000 0 0.000 38 1 1 1 1 1 1 0.000 10.000 0.000 0 0.000 39 1 1 1 1 1 1 0.000 0.000 10.000 0 0.000 f 40 1 1 1 1 1 1 55.000 70.000 49.500 0 0.000 41 1 1 1 1 1 1 110.000 0.000 109.000 0 0.000 42 1 1 1 1 1 1 120.000 0.000 99.000 0 0.000 , 43 1 1 1 1 1 1 110.000 -168.000 109.000 0 0.000 44 1 1 1 1 1 1 120.000 -168.000 99.000 0 0.000 45 1 1 1 1 1 1 110.000 -324.000 109.000 0 0.000 3 46 1 1 1 1 1 1 120.000 -324.000 99.000 0 0.000 t B-2 I
N l. BENCHMARK PROBLEM - ISM BM-1 APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM1-2 47 1 1 1. I 1 1 G8.000 -475.000 109.000 0 0.000 48 1 1 1 1 1 1 68.000 -475.000 99.000 0 0.000 } 49 1- 1 1 1 1 1 103.537 -545.000 114.179 0 0.00.0 50 1 1 1 1 1 1 103.537 -535.000 104 179 0 51 0.00_0 1 1 1 1 l' 1 393.000 -535.000 75.000 0 0.000 L 52 1 1 1 1 1 1 383.000 -545.000 75.000 0 ', O.000 ). 53 1 1 1 1 1 1 383.000 -53F.000 85.000 0 0.000 7 17 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1 37 1 0 0 0. O. .2C at 1 38 1 0 0 c. O. .200L - 1 39 1 0 0 0. O. .2000E+08 4 40 1 0 0 0. O. .2000E+08
- ~ 7 41 1 0 0 0. O. .2000E+08 7 42 1 0 0 0. O. .2000E+08 14 43 1 0 0 0. O. .2000E+05
- l. 14 44 1 0 0 C. O. .2000E+05
> 20 45 1 0 0 0. *0. .2000E+05 20 46 1 0 0 0. O. ,2000E+05 26 47- 1 0 0 0. O. .2000E+08 1 26 48 1 0 0 0.. O. .2000E+08 - ) 28 49 1 0 0 0. O. .2000E+08 - 28 50 1 0 0 0. O. .2000E+08 36 51 1 0 0 0. O. .2000E+08 f 36 52 1- 0 0 0. O. .2000E+08 36 53 1 0 0 C.- 0. .2000E+08 12 35 2 1 2 0 3 0 0 0 1 1 METAL r 60.00 .258E+08 .300 0. 2 1 DUIDE i 60.00 .100E+01 .300 0. 1 3.500 .2160 0.0 .8980E+00 .2324E-02 I 2 3.500 .2160 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 ! 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 ; IT 1 2 1 1 0.00 0.00 1 1 2B 2 3 1 1 0.00 0.00 l 48.000 TI O.000 60.000 0.000 .1000 3T 3 4 1 1 0.00 0.00 1 4T 4 5 1 1 0.00 0.00 1 SB 5 6 1 1 0.00 0.00 48.000 TI 110.000 60.000 99.000 .1000 ) 6T 6 7 1 1 0.00 0.00 1 7T 7 8 1 1 0.00 0.00 0 8T 8 9 1 1 0.00 0.00 ,0 9T 9 10 1 1 0.00 0.00 'O 10T 10 11 1 1 0.00 0.00 0 ) ) B-3
i BENCHMARK PROBLEM - ISM BM-1 APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM1-3 11T 11 12 1 1 0.00 0.00 o, 12T 12 13 1 1 0.00 0.00 0; 13T 13 14 1 1 0.00 0.00 0; 14T 14 15 1 1 0.00 0.00 ,0 IST 15 16 1 1 0.00 0.00 6, 16T 16 17 1 1 0.00 0.00 Oj 17T 17 18 1 1 0.00 0.00 0 18T 18 19 1 1 0.00 0.00 0 19T 19 20 1 1 0.00 0.00 04 20T 20 21 1 1 0.00 0.00 Oj 21T 21 22 1 1 0.00 0.00 0 22T 22 23 1 1 0.00 0.00 0 23T 23 24 l' -1 0.00 0.00 0 24T 24 25 1 1 0.00 0.00 Oi 25T 25 26 1 1 0.00 0.00 0 26T 26 27 1 1 0.00 0.00 0 27B 27 28 1 1 0.00 0.00 48.000 TI 58.000 -535.000 99.000 .1000 28T *28 29 1 1 0.00 0.00 . 1 29T 29 30 1 1 0.00 0.00 1; 30B 30 31 1 1 0.00 0.00 1 48.000 TI 166.000 -535.000 135.000 .1000 31T 31 32 1. 1 0.00 0.00 1 32T 32' 33 1 1 0.00 0.00 Il 33B 33 34 1 1 0.00 0.00 { 48.000 TI 266.000 -535.000 75.000 .1000 34T 34 35 1 1 0.00 0.00 1 35T 35 36 1 1 0.00 0.00 1 I 00000 00000 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 1 0.0000 2 2 1 < 37 1 1.0 1.0 1.0 38 1 1.0 1.0 1.0 39 1 1.0 1.0 1.0 I 40 1 1.0 1.0 1.0 I 41 1 1.0 1.0 1.0 42 1 1.0 1.0 1.0 43 2 1.0 1.0 1.0 44 2 1.0 1.0 1.0 45 2 1.0 1.0 1.0 46 2 1.0 1.0 1.0 ; 47 2 1.0 1.0 1.0 ; 48 2 1.0 1.0 1.0 49 2 1.0 1.0 1.0 50 2 1.0 1.0 1.0 { 51 2 1.0 1.0 1.0 52 2 1.0 1.0 1.0 53 2 1.0 1.0 1.0 , B-4 ( t (
i' BENCHMARK PROBLEM - ISM BM-1 APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM1-4 1 1.0 1 0.6667 1 0.0 2' 1.0 2 0.6667 2 0.0 SPECTRUM TABLE (SPECTRUM GROUP 1) 10 386.40 . I
.2900E-01 .8750E+00 - .3400E-01 .1000E+01 ,
[ .4300E-01 .1000E+01
.4800E-01 .8000E+00 .5900E-01 .9250E+00 l .7400E-01 .9250E+00 l
[ .8100E-01 .8000E+00
- 1
.1250E+00 .1000E+01. .2000E+00 .2275E+01' .4000E+00 .2275E+01 SPECTRUM TABLE (SPECTRUM GROUP 2) 11 386.40 i .2900E-01 .6000E+00 .3200E-01 .7000E+00 .3700E-01 .7500E+00 - .4300E-01 .7500E+00
- . .4600E-01 .6000E+00
.6300E-01 .7000E+00 .7100E-01'.7000E+00 i .8000E-01 .6750E+00 .
[ .1430E+00. 7500E+00 7
.2500E+00 .1400E+01 .3330E+00 .1400E+01 300 0. 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0- 0 0 0 0 0 0
- 3. 1 20 45 10000. 10000. 10000. 10000. 1000..
1.0. 0.05 0.05 0.0 0.0 2 1 1 1 -1 0 6 ) \- l f' B-5 l l 1 a
\\
BENCHMARK PROBLEM - ISM BM-2 APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM2-1 INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION BENCHMARK PROBLEM 2 NRC BENCHMARK 35 2 0 2L 6 0 0 0 0 1 0 4 1 25 1 0 0 0 1 1 1 0.000 0.000 0.000 0 0.0d - 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.000 54.450 0.000 0 0.00 3 0 . 0 0 0 0 0 0.000 108.900 0.000 0 0.000 4 0 0 0 0 0 0 10.632 134.568 0.000 0 0.00 5 0 0 0 0 0 0 36.300 145.200 0.000 0 0.00 6 0 0 0 0 0 0 54.150 145.200 0.000 0 0.00 7 0 0 0 0 0 0 72.000 145.200 0.000 0 0.000 8 0 0 0. 0 0 0 97.668 145.200 10.632 0 0.00 9 0 0 0 0 0 0 108.300 145.200 36.300 0 0.00 10 0 0 0 0 0 0 108.300 145.200 56.800 0 0.00 11 0 0 0 0 0 0 108.300 145.200 77.300 0 0.000 12 0 0 0 0 0 0 108.300 145.200 97.800 0 0.00 13 0 0 0 0 0 0 108.300 145.200 118.300 0 0.00 14 0 0 0 0 .. O O 108.300 145.200 188.800 0 0.00 15 0 0 0 0 0 0 108.300 181.500 225.100 0 0.00 16 0 0 0 0 0 0 108.300 236.000 225.100 0 0.00 17 0 0 0 0 0 0 108.300 290.000 225.100 0 0.00 18 0 0 0 0 0 0 148.300 145.200 97.800 0 0.000 19 0 0 0 0 0 0 188.300 145.200 97.800 0 0.00 20 0 0 0 .0 0 0 224.600 145.200 61.500 0 0.00 21 0 0 0 1 l' 1 224.600 145.200 20.000 0 0.00 22 1 1 1 1 1 1 1.000 0.000 0.000. 0 0.000 23 1 1 1 1 1 1 0.000 1.000 0.000 0 0.00 24 1 1 1 1 1 1 0.000 0.000 1.000 0 0.00 25 1 1 1 1 1 1 72.000 145.200 -1.000 0 - 0.00 26 1 1 1 1 1 1 109.'300 145.200 36.300 0 0.000 ' 27 1 1 1 1 28 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 108.300 108.300 146.200 14~6.200 77.300 0 0.00$ 29 1 118.300 0 0.00 @ 1 1 1 1 1 107.300 182.500 226.'500 0 0.000 30 1 1 1 1 1 1 109.300 290.000 225.100 0 0.00 31 1 1 1 1 1 1 108.300 291.000 225.100 0 0.00 32 1 1 1 1 1 1 108.300 290.000 226.100 0 0.00 33 1 1 1 1 1 1 225.600 145.200 20.000 . 0 0.000 34 1 1 1 1 1 1 224.600 146.200 20.000 0 0.00 35 1 1 1 1 1 1 224.600 145.200 21.000 0 0.000 7 14 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 1 1 22 23 1 1 0 0 0 0 0. 0. O. .1000E+11 O. .1000E+11 h 5 1 24 1 0 0 0. O. .1000E+11 7 25 1 0 0 0; ~ 0. .1000E+09 9 26 1 0 0 O.
)'
- 0. .1000E+09 .
11 27 1 0 0 0. O. .1000E+05 13 28 1 0 0 0. O. .1000E+05 15 29 1 0 0 0. O. .1000E+09 17 30 1 0 0 0. O. .1000E+11 t ! B-6 i l Il! 4 L___-___--_-__. _ _ _ . - - _ _ . _. 1
4 i BENCHMARK PROBLEM - ISM BM-2 APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM2-2 17 31 1 0 0 0. O. .1000E+11 1l5 17 21 32 33 1 1 0 0 0 0 0. 0. O. O.
.1000E+11 .1000E+11 21 34 1 0 0 0. O. .1000E+11 -
21 35 1 0 0 0. O. .1000E+11 12 0 5 1 20 1 1 ALLOY STEEL 1 1 0 3 0 0 0.00 .240E+08 .300 .710E-05 I 1 7.288 .2410 0.0000 .2179E+01 .5639E-02 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 *0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 1 1T 0.000 1 2 0.000 1 0.000 0.000 ( 1 0.00 350.00 ' 1 2T 2 3 1 1 0.00 350.00 1 3B 3 4 1 1 0.00 350.00 5-s 36.300 CC 36.300 108.900 0.000 .1000 4B 4 5 1 1 0.00 350.00 36.300 CC 36.300 108.900 0.00 .1000 3 8 ST 6T 5 6 6 7 1 1 1 1 0.00 0.00 350.00 350.00 1 7B 7 8 1 1 0.00 350.00 36.300 CC 72.000 145.200 36.300 .1000 3 8B 36.300 8 9 CC 1 72.000 1 0.00 350.00 145.200 36.300 .1000 ST 9 10 1 1 0.00 350.00 1 10T 10 11 1 1 0.0 350.0- 0.0 0.0 0.0 11T 11 12 1 1 0.0 350.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 12T 12 13 1 1 0.0 350.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 13T 13 14 1 1 0.0 350.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 8 14B 36.3 14 15 CC 108.3 1 1 0.0 181.5 350.0 188.8 0.1 15T 15 16 1 1 0.0 350.0 0.O' O.0 0.0 Ig 16T 16 17 1 1 0.0 350.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 y 17T 12 18 1 1 0.0 350.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 18T 18 19 1 1 0.0 350.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 19B 19 20 1 1 0.0 350.0 36.3 CC 188.3 145.2 61.5 0.1 I 20T 20 21 1 1 0.0 350.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 g 18 0 1.518 1.518 1.518 0.0 0.0 0.0 00000 1 00000 0 0 0 0 0 0 12 1 2 2 1 22 1 ,1 23 1 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 24 1 1.0 1.0 1.0 ,, 25 t 2 1.0 1.0 1.0 26 2 1.0 1.0 1.0 t t 0., 8
i BENCHMARK PROBLEM - ISH BM-2 APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM2-3 27 2 1.0 1.0 1.0 (- 28 2 1.0 1.0 1.0 j 29 2 1.0 1.0 1.0 30 3 1.0 1.0 1.0 . 31 3 1.0 1.0 1.0 32 3 1.0 1.0 1.0 33 4- 1.0 1.0 1.0 34 4 1.0 1.0 1.0 35 4 1.0 1.0 1.0 f ! 1 386.4 2 '386.4 3 386.4 4 386.4 5. 386.4 6 386.4 7 386.4 8 386.4 9 386.4 ! 10 386.4 11 386.4 12 386.4 SPECTRUM TABLE (SPECTRUM GROUP 1 X-DIRECTION) 17 1.0 :
.2560E-01 .2200E+0'O ! .2860E-01 .2200E+00 .3030E-01 .2500E+00 .9090E-01 .4200E+00 i l .1166E+00 .8500E+00 .1515E+00 .1290E+01 .1748E+00 .2137E+00 .1420E+01 .1420E+01 'j j .2849E+00 .1150E+01 .3704E+00 .7500E+00 .4545E+00 .6300E+00 . .5555E+00 .6300E+00 I .7407E+00 .3800E+00 .9091E+00 .5700E+00 , .1111E+01 .5700E+00 ;
I
.1389E+01 .2200E+00 .2500E+01 .1300E+00 SPECTRUM TABLE ~(SPECTRUM GROUP 1 Y-DIRECTION) j 18' 1.0 i .2560E-01 .1900E+00. .3130E-01 .1900E+00 .3510E-01 .2050E+00 .6250E-01 .2050E+00 .6490E-01 .2200E+00 .1069E+00 .4200E+00 ' .1149E+00 .6800E+00 I .1515E+00 .9000E+00 .1818E+00 .9980E+00 .2222E+00 .9980E+00 j .2857E+00 .7700E+00 -
4
.5555E+00 .4200E+00 .6061E+00 .3500E+00 .. .6993E+00 .7150E+00 .9091E+00 .9950E+00
( i B-8
I i BENCHMARK PROBLEM - ISM BM-2 APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM2-4 i
.1111E+01 .9950E+00 .1563E+01 .1800E+00 8 .2500E+01 .1800E+00 SPECTRUM TABLE (SPECTRUM GROIIP 1 Z-DIRECTION) ~
15 1.0
.2560E-01 1700E+00 .3850E-01 .1700E+00 .4555E-01 .2000E+00 .6990E-01 .2400E+00 8 .1242E+00 .4700E+00 .1818E+00 .6300E+00 .2222E+00 .6300E+00:
I .2778E+00 .5100E+00'
.4000E+00 .3000E+00 .4545E+00 3000E+00 .6494E+00 .7800E+00 .7273E+00 .1600E+01-8 .8889E+00 .1600E+01 .1667E+01 .1700E+00 . tf( .2500E+01 .1700E+00-t, SPECTRUM TABLE (SPECTRUM GROUP 2 X-DIRECTION) 11 1.0 .2560E-01 .2300E+00 .4550E-01 .2300E+00 t' .5680E-01 .3000E-01 .3030E+00 .3800E+00 - .5000E+00 .7500E+00 .6061E+00 .1070E+01 t .6993E+00 .2250E+01 .8547E+00 .2250E+01 ' - .1852E+01 .2300E+00 I- .2083E+01 .1700E+00 .2500E+01 .1700E+00 SPECTRUM TABLE (SPECTRUM GROUP 2 Y-DIRECTION) 11 1.0
- 5 .2560E-01 .3700E+00
.6450E-01 .3700E+00 . .1250E+00 .6500E+00 l
V
.1818E+00 .8500E+00 .2222E+00 .8500E+00 .4041E+00 .9000E+00 .5682E+00 .1500E+01 t .7273E+00 .2870E+01 .8889E+00 .2870E+01 .1639E+01 .3000E+00 .E $ .2500E+01 .1700E+00 ' SPECTRUM TABLE (SPECTRUM GROUP 2 Z-DIRECTION) ~
14 1.0 , .2560E-01 .5500E+00
.5710E-01 .5500E+00 I
B-9 ll
BENCHKARK PROBLEM - ISM BM-2 APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM2-5
.7690E-01 .6500E+00 .1254E+00 .1000E+01 .1538E+00 .1300E+01 .1818E+00 .1380E+01 .i .2222E+00 .1380E+01 1 .3704E+00 .1080E+01 .5682E+00 .1950E+01 .7273E+00 .3550E+01 ; .8889E+00 .3550E+01 i .1667E+01 .3620E+01 " .2000E+01 .2000E+00 .2500E+01 .2000E+00 SPECTRUM TABLE (SPECTRUM GROUP 3 X-DIRECTION) 15 1.0 .2560E-01 .6500E+00 .6060E-01 .6500E+00 .6610E-01 .7700E+00 .1010E+00 .9000E+00 .1515E+00 .1750E+01 .1748E+00 .2050E+01 j .2137E+00 .2050E+01 ' .2924E+00 .1600E+01 .3636E+00 .1460E+01 j .4132E+00 .1700E+01 1 .5865E+00 .2400E+01 .7273E+00 .4150E+01 .8889E+00 .4150E+01 .1661E+01 .4200E+00 .2500E+01 .1800E+00 SPECTRUM TABLE (SPECTRUM GROUP 3 Y-DIRECTION) 14 1.0 j .2560E-01 .2300E+00 .3640E-01 .2300E+00 .4040E-01 .2500E+00 .9090E-01 .4200E+00 { .1136E+00 .7300E+00 .1515E+00 .1320E+01 * .1852E+00 .1320E+01 .3831E+00 .5600E+00 * .5555E+00 .5300E+00 .9259E+00 .2800E+00 _< .1111E+01 .1700E+00 .1420E+01 .2800E+00 .1736E+01 .2800E+00 .2500E+01 .1400E+00 <
SPECTRUM TABLE (SPECTRUM GROUP 3 Z-DIRECTION) 18 1.0
.2560E-01 .1120E+00 *. .3130E-01 .1120E+00 ( .3490E-01 .1250E+00 !
( B-10 1 (
Y
' BENCHMARK PROBLEM - ISM BM-2 APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM2-6 A .5880E-01 .1350E+00 .7130E-01 .1800E+00 J i' .1136E+00 .3460E+00 1' .1515E+00 .5500E+00. ] .1852E+00 .5500E+00 ~.2778E+00 .3300E+00
- l. .3759E+00 .2140E+00
.6173E+00. 1700E+00 ) .7017E+00 .1250E+00 l 1 . 7273E+00 .1950E+00
[- ^. 9091E+00 .2500E+00 *
]' .1070E+01 .4980E+00.. .1357E+01'.5350E+00 L .1658E+01 .5350E+00 . 2500E+01. 2240E+00 - SPECTRUM Lia TABLE '(SPECTRUM GROUP 4 X-DIRECTION) n 1.0 p .2560E-01 .1260E+00 .5550E-01 .1260E+00 .6730E-01 .1400E+00 .1136E+00'.2150E+00 f, .1515E+00 .3100E+00 .1852E+00. 3100E+00 .3704E+00 .2650E+00 .4914E+00 .3350E+00 .7576E+00 .5360E+00 .1070E+01 . 8500E400 .1307E+01 .8500E+00 y .1587E+01 .8140E+00 .2500E+01 .2700E+00 -
SPECTRUM 15 TABLE -(SPECTRUM GROUP 4. Y-DIRECTION) 1.0
- t. .2560E-01 .2100E+00
.3570E-01 .2100E+00 .5410E-01'.2600E+00- !
). .6730E-01'.3600E+00
.1033E+00 .4200E+00- .1212E+00 .7300E+00 , .1515E+00 .1020E+01 .1852E+00 1020E+01 . 2315E+00 8500E+00 .4914E+00 .6800E+00. . .6006E+00 .6800E+00 , .7273E+00 .8500E+00 .1070E+01 .1200E+01 .1307E+01'.1200E+01
(
.2500E+01'.3400E+00 4 SPECTRUM 15 TABLE (SPECTRUM GROUP 4 E-DIRECTION) -
1.0 '
.2560E-01 .2100E+00
\ B-11 l
( l l l' BENCHMARK PROBLEM - ISM BM-2 APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM2-7
.3570E-01 .2100E+00 .5410E-01 .2600E+00 .6730E-01 .3600E+00 .1033E+00 .4200E+00 .1212E+00 .7300E+00 'I .1515E+00 .1020E+01 ' .1852E+00 .1020E+01 .2315E+00 .8500E+00 .4914E+00 .6800E+00
{
.6006E+00 .6800E+00 i .7273E+00 .8500E+00
- l .1070E+01 .1200E+01
.1307E+01 .1200E+01' .2500E+01 .3400E+00 i
- l. 300 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 .0 0 0 0 0- 0 1 11 27 10000. 10000. 10000. 10000. 1000. i 1.0 0.05 .0.05 1 0.0 0.0 2 1 1 1 -1 0 f
i 1 0 B-12
V l D BENCHMARK PROBLEM - ISM BM-3 APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM3-1 I INDEPENDENT SUPPORT NOTION BENCHMARK PROBLEM 3 l NRC 77 3 0 15 6 0 0 0 0 1 0 4 1 15 _ l 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.000 1226.875 0.000 0 0.000= I h 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 30.021 1226.875 .30.550 0 0.000 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 60.042 1226.875 61.100 0 0.000 i 4 0 0 0 0 0 0 90.064 1226.875 91.651 0 0.000 j 5 0 0 0 0 0 0 105.154 1226.875 102.817 0 0.000 J
- f. 6 0 0 0 0 0 0 _139.302 1226.875 120.593 'O 0.000 7 0 'O O O O O 181.878 1226.875 142.757 0 0.000 q 8 0 0 0, 0- 0 0 224.435 1226.875 164.922 0 0.000. i 9 0 0 0 0 0 0- 243.383 1226.875 174.774 0 0.000
! 10 0- 0 0' O O- 0 262.311 ~1226.875 184.628 0 0.000 11 0 0 0 0 0 0 292.798 1226.875 191.342 0 0.000 l 12 0 0 0 0 0 0 334.171 1226.875 189.421 0 0.000 L 13 0 0 0 0 0 0 375.543 1226.875 187.500 0 0.000 14 0 0 0 0 0 0 405.511~ 1226.875 186.110 0 0.000 19 0.. -0 0 0 0 0 431.483 1226.875 184.904 0. 0.000
'15 0 0 0 0 0 0' 501.172 1226.'875 181.669 0 0.000 p .- 16 -0 0 0 -0 0 0 570.860 1226.875 178.433 0 0.000 17 0 0 0 0 0 0 579.777 1226.875 178.683 0- 0.000-18 0 . 0 0 0 0 0 615.118 1226.875 .182.316 0 0.000:
( 20 0 C. 0 0- 0 0 633.028 1226.875 184.156 0 0.000 l /. 21 0 0 -0 0 0- 0 678.227 1226.875 188.802 0 0.000 22 0 0 0 0 0 *0 723.426 1226.875 - 193.448 0 0.000
*23 0 0 0 0 0 0 768.625 1226.875 198.095 - 0 0.000 24 0 0 0 0 0 0 809.602 1226.875 187.256 0 0.000 I
25 0 0 0 0 0 0 '814.057- 1226.875 184.079 :0 0.000 26 0. p 0 0 0 0 852.626 1226.875 156.568 0 - 0.000-27' O O O O O -0 891.195 1226.875 129.058 0 0.000-i 28 0 0 0 0 0 0 929.764 1226.875 101.547 0 0.000 29 0 0 0 0 0 0 968.332 1226.875- 74.036 0 0.000 30 0 0 0 0 0 0 978.101 1226.875 67.'067 0 0.000 31' O O O O O O 1012.600 1226.875 42.430 0 0.000 { 32 0 0 0 0 0 0 1047.098 1226.875- 17.793 0 0.000 34 0 0 0 0 0 0 1061.752- 3244.875 7.340 . 0 0.000 35 0 0 0 0 0 0 1061.752 1272.375 7.340 0 0.000-36 0 0 0 0 0 0 1072.214 1290.375 -7.307 0 0.000 37 0 0 0 0 0 0 1081.623 1290.375- -20.480 0 0.000 38 0 0 0 0 0 0 1108.850 1290.375 -58.399 0 0.000 39 0 0 0 0 0 0 1136.077 1290.375 -96.317 0 0.000 40 0 0 0 0 0 0 1163.304 1290.375 -134.236 0 0.000 41 0 0 0 0 0 0 1190.531 1290.375 -172.154 0 0.000 43 0 0 0 0 0 0 1197.006 1290.375 -182.019 0 0.000 g 44 0 0 0 0 0 0 1207.729 1290.375 -209.536 0 0.000 45 0 0 0 0 0 0 1211.630 1290.375 -241.111 0 0.000 46 0 0 0 0 0 0 1215.531 1290.375 -272.687 0 0.000 47 0 0 0 0 0 0 1219.432 1290.375 -304.262 0 0.000 [ '48 0 0 0 0 0 0 1223.333 1290.375 -335.873 .0 0.000 e B-13
BENCHMARK PROBLEM - ISM BM-3 APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM3-2 49 0 0 0 0 0 0 1227.234 1290.375 -367.413 0 0.@ 51 0 0 0 0 0 0 1232.144 1290.375 -407.155 0 0.@ 52 0 0 0 0 0 0 1233.704 1295.647 -419.787 0 0.@
'53 0 0 0 0 0 0. 1234.945 _1305.772 -429.836 O O.@
55 0 0 0 0 0 0 1254.329 1318.500 -439.952 -0 0.@ 56 0 0 0 0 0 0 1279.579 1318.500- -436.387 0 0.@ 57 0 0 0 0 0 0 1304.829 1318.500 -432.823- 0 0.@ 58 0 0 0 'O O- 0 1330.078 1318.500 -429.258 0 .0.@ 59 'O O O O O O 1355.328 1318.500 -425.693 0 0.@ 61 1 1 1 1 1 1 431.943 1226.875- 194.899 0 -0.@ 62 1 1 1 1 1 1 616.140 1226.875 172.368 0 0.@ 63 1 1 1 1 -1 1 974.139 1226.875 82.176 0 0.@ 65 1 l' 1 1 1 1 1227.234 1300.375 -367.413 0 0.@ 66 1 1 1 1 1 1 1255.726 1318.500 -449.852 0 0.@ 67 1 1 1 1 1 1 ~1182.401 1290.375 -177.966 0 0.@ 68 1 1 1 1 1 1 105.154 1236.875 102.817 0 0.@ 69 1 1 1 1 1 1 224.435 1236.875 164.922 .0 0.@ 70 1 1 1 1 1 1 .405.511 '1236.875 186.110- 0 0.@ 71 1 1 1 1 1 1 633.028 1236.875 184.156 0 0.O
'72 1 1 1 1 1 1 814.057 1236.875 184.079 0. 0.@
73 1 1 1 1 .1, 1 978.101 1236.875 67.067 0 0.0 74 1 1 1 1' 1 1 1081.623 1300.375 -20.480 0 0.0 33 1 1 1 1 1 1 10.000 1226.875 0.000 0 0.0
-42 1 1 1 1 1 1 0.000 1236.875 0.000 0 0.8 50 1 1 1 1 1 l' O.000 1226.875 10.000 0 0.0 54 -1 1 1 1. 1 1 1345.328 1318.500 -425.693 0 00 60 1 1 1 1 .1 1~ 1355.328 1328.500 -425.693 0 0.8 64 1 1 1 1 1 1 1355.328 1318.500 -415.693 0 0.0; 75- 1 1 1 1 1 1 1190.531 1300.375 -172.154 0 0. 0; 76 1 1 1 1 1 1 334.171'~1226.875 189.421. 0 0. 0(
77 1 1 1 1 1 1 1012.600- 1226.875 42.430 0 0. 0: 7 28 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 - 49 65' 1 0 0 0. O. .1000E+02
- 55. 66 1 0 0- O. O. .1000E+13 41 67 1 0 0 C. O. .1000E+13 41 75 1 0 0 0. O. .1000E+13 5 68 1 0 0 0. 0.'.1000E+13 8 69 1 0 0 0. O. .1000E+13 14 70 1 0 0 D. O. .1000E+13 20 71 1 0 0 0. O. .1000E+13 25 72 1 0 0 0. O. .1000E+13 30 73 1 0 0 0.- O. .1000E+13 37 74 1 0 0 0. O. .1000E+13 1 33 1 0 0 C. O. .1000E+13 1 42 1 0 0 0. O. .1000E+13 1 50 1 0 0 0. O. .1000E+13 .
1 33 0 1 0 c. O. .1000E+13 .. 1 42 0 1 0 0. O. .1000E+13 1 50 0 1 0 0. O. .1000E+13 l B-14
p BENCHMARK PROBLEM - ISM BM-3 APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM3-3 I 59 54 1 0 0 0. O. 59 60
.1000E+13 1 0 0 0. O. .1000E+13 59 64 1 0 0 O.
59 54 0
- 0. .1000E+13 1 0 0. O. .1000E+13 59- 60 0 1 0 C. O.
59 64
.1000E+13 -
0 1 0 C.
- f. 13 76
- 0. . 1000E+13 1 0 0 C. O. .1000E+13 19 61 1 0 0 0. O. .1000E+13 18 62 1 0 0 0. O. .1000E+13 29 63 1 0 0 0 0. .1000E+13 f 32 77 1 0 0 C. O. .1000E+13 12 54 1 1 1 0 3 0 0 0 1 1 0.00 .277E+08 .300 0.
1 12.750 .3750 1.000 0.0000 .8708E+01 .2254E-01 1.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 f 1.000 1.000 1.000: 1.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 IT 1 2 1 1 400.00 615.00 ) 2T 2 3 1 1 1 400.00 615.00 1 3T 3 4 1 1 400.00 615.00 ' ' 4T 5 6 1 1 1- 400.00 615.00 1 \ ST 6 7 1 1 400.00 615.00 / 6T 7 8 1 1 1 400.00 615.00 1 7T 8 9 1 1 400.00 615.00 ST 9 10 1 1 1 400.00 615.00 1 9T 11 12 1 1 400.00 615.00 10T 12 13- 1 1
- 1. 400.00 615.00 .
11T 13 14 1 1 1 400.00 615.00', 1 12T 14 19 l' 1 400.00 615.00 13T 19 15 1 1 { 1 400.00 615.00 1 14T 15 16 1 1 400.00 615.00 IST 17 18 1 1 1 400.00 615.00 1 16T 18 20 1 1 400.00 615.00 17T 20 21 1 1 1 400.00 615.00 1 18T 21 22 1 1 400.00 615.00 ' 19T 22 23 1 1 1 400.00 615.00 1 20B .23 24 1 1 400.00 615.00 60.000 TI 791.160 1226.875 200.411 21T- 24 .1000 25 1 1 400.00 615.00 22T 25 26 1 1 1 400.00 615.00 1 23T 26 27 1 1 400.00 615.00 24T 27 28 1 1 1 400.00 615.00 25T 28 29 1 1 1 400.00 615.00 1 ( 26T 29 30 1 1 400.00 615.00 L 27T 1 30 31 1 1 400.00 615.00 28T 31 32 1 1 1 400.00 615.00 1 ** 29T 34 35 1 1 400.00 615.00 1 B-15
BENCHMARK PROBLEM - ISM BM-3 -APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM3-4 ) 30T 36 37 1 1 -400.00 615.00 1 !' 31T 37 38 1 1 400.00 615.00 ~ 1' 32T 38 39 1 1 400.00 615.00 1 33T 39 40 1 1 400.00 615.00 1 - 34T 40 41 1 1 400.00 615.00 1- i 35T 41 43 1 1 400.00 615.00 1 36T ,44 45 1 1 400.00 .615.00 1 37T 45 46 1 1 400.00 615.00 1 < 38T 46 47 1 1 400.00 615.00 1 ( 39T .47 48 1 1 400.00 615.00 1 40T 48 49 1 1 400.00 615.00 1. 41T 49 51 1 1 400.00 615.00 1 42T 52 53 1 1 400.00 615.00 1 43T 55 56 1- 1 400.00 615.00 1 44T 56 57- 1 1 400.00 615.00 1 45T 57 58 1 1 400.00 615.00 1 l 46T 58 59 1 1 400.00 615.00 1 47B 4 5 1 1 400.00 615.00-60.000 TI 96.725 1226.875 98.428 .1000 48B. 10 11 1 1 400.00 615.00 60.000 'TI 276.650 1226.875. 192.029 .1000 { 49B 16 17 1 1 400.00 .615.00 60.000 TI- 575.328 1226.875 '170.226 .1000 / 50B 32. 34 1 1 400.00 615.00 \ 18.000' TI 1061.752 1226.875 7.340 .1000 515 35 36 1 1 400.00 615.00 18.000 TI 1061.752 1290.375 7.340 .1000 52B 43 44 1 1 400.00 615.00 .I 60.000 TI 1205.861 1290.375 -194.416 .1000 533 51 52 1 1 400.00 615.00 , j 18.000 TI 1233.058 1290.375 -414.555 .1000 54B 53 55 z 1 1 400.00 615.00 - 18.000 TI 1236.506 1318.500 -442.468 .1000 00000 00000 { 00000
~
0 0 0 C. O. 12 1 0.0 2 2 1 0 77- 1 1.0 1.0 1.0 54 1 1.0 1.0 1.0 60 1 1.0 1.0 1.0 61 1 1.0 1.0 1.0 63 1 1.0 1.0 1.0
)'
64 1 1.0 1.0 1.0 68 1 1.0 1.0 1.0 71 1 1.0 1.0 1.0 s 73 1 1.0 1.0 1.0 . 76 2 1.0 1.0 1.0 ** 62 2 1.0 1.0 1.0 ( 65 2 1.0 1.0 1.0 i i 1 B-16
BENCHMARK PROBLEM - ISM BM-3 APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM3-5 67 2 1.0 1.0 1.0 70 2 1.0 1.0 1.0 75 2 1.0 1.0 1.0 69 3 1.0 1.0 1.0 72 3 1.0 1.0 1.0 - 74 3 1.0 1.0 1.0 33 4 1.0 1.0 1.0
- 8. 42 4 1.0 1.0 1.0 l 50 4 1.0 1.0 1.0 66 4 1.0 1.0 1.0 5 1 386.4 2 386.4 3 386.4 i
4 386.4 5 386.4 6 386.4 7 386.4 8 ! 386.4 9 386.4 10 386.4 11 386.4 12 386.4 SPECTRUM TABLE (SPECTFUM GROUP 1 X-DIRECTION) 78 1.0 0.0 .7710E+00 R .1300E-01 .8300E+00
.2500E-01 .8930E+00 .3500E-01 .9560E+00 8 .3600E-01 .9669E+00 .3700E-01 .9823E+00 .3800E-01 .1004E+01 .3900E-01 .1049E+01 5 .4100E-01 .1070E+01 .4200E-01 .1073E+01 . .4400E-01 .1090E+01 .5300E-01 .1335E+01 l .5600E-01 .1472E+01 .6400E-01*.1512E+01 I .6500E-01 .1524E+01 .7000E-01 .1855E+01 .7200E-01 .2064E+01 .7400E-01 .2399E+01 .7410E-01 .2560E+01 8 .7500E-01 .2687E+01 .7600E-01 .2975E+01 * .7800E-01 .3116E+01 I' .8000E-01 .3134E+01 .8200E-01 .3134E+01 .8500E-01 .3112E+01 .8600E-01 .3077E+01 I .9200E-01 .2931E+01 .9600E-01 .2781E+01 .1030E+00 .2627E+01 .1040E+00 .2674E+01 t' .1050E+00 .2744E+01 .1120E+00 .2797E+01 ~ .1200E+00 .2807E+01 ..
i B-17 I
; BENCHMARK PROBLEM - ISM BM-3 APPENDIX B- PAGE: ISM-BM3-6 1 .1260E+00 .2755E+01 .1270E+00 .2685E+01 ( .3280E+00 .2635E+01
[
.1340E+00 .2667E+01 . .1510E4 00 .2761E+01 .1670E+00 .2844E+01 .1680E4 00 .2249E+01 L .1740E+00 .2873E+01 .1870E+00 .2900E+01 ( .1970E+00 .2923E+01 '- .1980E+00 .3002E+01 .2090E+00 .5152E+01 .2130E+00 .5227E+01' .2330E+00 .5232E+01 .2550E+00 .5224E+01 .2570E+00 .5189E+01' ; .2620E+00 .4793E+01 ) .2680E+00. 4189E+01 .2730E+00 .3766E+01 .2770E+00 .3532E+01 .2800E+00 .3384E+01 j- .2860E+00 .3215E+01 .2950E+00 .3066E+01 .3090E+00 .2951E+01 .3390E+00 .2782E+01 .3760E+00 .2639E+01 .3840E+00 .2640E+01 .4040E+00 .2644E+01 i .4390E+00 .2592E+01 .4820E+00 .2479E+01 .5180E+00 .2382E+01 J .5610E+00 .2304E+01 I .5900E+00 .2246E+01 .6430E+00 .2084E+01 .6970E+00 .1904E+01 f .7090E+00 .1869E+01 .7200E+00 .1839E+01 * .7450E+00 .1774E+01 .7730E+00 .1704E+01 .7850E+00 .1676E+01 .8150E+00 .1606E+01 .8400E+00 .1549E+01 .9070E+00 .1399E+01 .9590E+00 .1282E+01 .1000E+01 .1162E+01 SPECTRUM TABLE (SPECTRUM GROUP 1 Y-DIRECTION) i 18 1.0 ~ .1667E-01 .7500E+00 ,. .4167E-01 .1200E+01 .5650E-01 .3050E+01 q l
B-18
l 4 BENCHMARK PROBLEM - ISM BM-3 APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM3-7
.6900E-01 .3050E+01 .7090E-01 .~3620E+01 .8680E-01 .3620E+01- .1010E+00 _ .3250E+01 )' .1230E+00 .3250E+01 '- .1280E+00 .2580E+01 i .1850E+0'O .2580E+01 .1930E+00 .2780E+01 } .2350E+00 .2780E+01 j .2630E+00 .2610E+01 1 .4830E+00 .2610E+01 ~ j .5260E+00 .1800E+01 .6170E+00 .1600E+01 .6670E+00 .1450E+01 .2000E+01 .3500E+00 SPECTRUM 78 TABLE (SPECTRUM GROUP 1 Z-DIRECTION) 1.0 0.0 .7710E+00 .130DE-01 .8300E+00 .2500E-01 .8930E+00 .3500E-01 .9560E+00 .3600E-01 .9669E+00 ! .3700E-01 .9823E+00 .3800E-01 .1004E+01 i .3900E-01 .1049E+01- 1 .4100E-01 .1070E+01 .4200E-01 .1073E+01 . 4400E-01 .1090E+01 .5300E-01 .1335E+01 .5600E-01 .1472E+01 .6400E-01 .1512E+01- - "
t-
.6500E-01 .1524E+01 .7000E-01 .1855E+01 .7200E-01 .2064E+01 .7400E-01 .2399E+01
)-
' -.7410E-01 .2560E+01 .7500E-01 .2687E+01 . .7600E-01 .2975E+01 .7800E-01 .3116E+01 .8000E-01 .3134E+01 .8200E-01 .3134E+01 .8500E-01 .3112E+01 .8600E-01 .3077E+01 .9200E-01 .2931E+01 ~~
9600E-01 .2781E+01 1030E+00 .2627E+01
- f. .1040E+00 .2674E+01
.1050E+00 .2744E+01 * .1120E+00 .2797E+01 .1200E+00 .2807E+01 B-19
)
1 BENCHMARK PROBLEM - ISM BM-3 APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM3-8 { l
.1260E+00 .2755E+01 .1270E+00 .2685E+01 1 .1280E+00 .2635E+01 .1340E+00 .2667E+01 .1510E+00 .2761E+01 .1670E+00 .2844E+01 .1680E+00 .2849E+01 .1740E+00 .2873E+01 .1870E+00 .2900E+01 .1970E+00 .2923E+01 ( .1980E+00 .3002E+01 .2090E+00 .5152E+01. .2130E+00 .5227E+01' ! .2330E+00 .5232E+01 .2550E+00 .5224E+01 .2570E+00 .5189E+01 .2620E+00 .4793E+01 k .2680E+00 .4189E+01 .2730E+00 .3766E+01 .2770E+00 .3532E+01 .2800E+00 .3384E+01 { .2860E+00 .3215E+01 .2950E+00 .3066E+01 .3090E+00 .2951E+01 .3390E+00 .2782E+01 ' .3760E+00 .2639E+01 .3840E+00 .2640E+01 .4040E+00 .2644E+01 I .4390E+00 .2592E+01 .4820E+00 .2479E+01 .5180E+00 .2382E+01 $ .5610E+00 .2304E+01 # .5900E+00 .224EE+01 .6430E+00 .2084E+01 .6970E+00 .1904E+01 .7090E+00 .1869E+01 .7200E+00 .1839F+01 - * .7450E+00 .17741'+01 .7730E+00 .1704E+01 .7850E+00 .1676E+01 .8150E+00 .1606E+01 .8400E+00 .1549E+01 .9070E+00 .1399E+01 i .9590E+00 .1282E+01 .1000E+01 .1162E+01 SPECTRUM TABLE (SPECTRUM GROUP 2 X-DIRECTION) 78 1.0 {
0.0 .7710E+00 .
.1300E-01 .8300E400 ' .2500E-01 .8930E+00 {
t ( B-20
p BENCHMARK PROBLEM - ISM BM-3' APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM3-9
.3500E-01 .9560E+00 .3600E-01 .9669E+00 p' .3700E-01 9823E+00 .3800E-01..'1004E+01 . .3900E-01;.1049E+01 ~
p .4100E-01 .1070E+01 /-
.4200E-01 .1073E+01 .4400E-01 .1090E+01 .5300E-01 .1335E+01-
):. .5600E-01 .1472E+01
.6400E-01 .1512E+01 .6500E-01'.1524E+01. .7000E-01 .1855E+01-
- f. . 7200E-01 .2064E+01
.7400E-01 .2399E+01 .7410E-01. 2560E+01 .7500E-01 .2687E+01
) .7600E-01 .2975E+01'
.7800E-01 ;3116E+01 . 8000E-01 .3134E+01 .8200E-01 .3134E+01 b .8500E-01'.3112E+01 .8600E-01 .3077E+01 .9200E-01 .2931E+01 .9600E-01 .2781E+01 ..1030E+00 .2627E+01 .1040E+00 .2674E+01 .1050E+00 2744B+01. .1120E+00'.27973+01: .1200E+00 .2807E+01 .. .1260E+00 .2755E+01
- y. .1270E+00 .2685E+01 *
.1280E+00 .2635E+01 .1340E+00 .2667E+01
,' . 1510E+00. 2761E+01 L .1670E+00'.2844E+01
.1680E+00 .2849E+01 ~ .1740E+00'.2873E+01 .1870E+00 .2900E+01 .1970E+00 .2923E+01 ! .1980E+00 .3002E+01 . 2090E+00 .5152E+01 .2130E+00 .5227E+01 f .2330E+00 .5232E+01 i ^ .2550E+00 .5224E+01 .2570E+00 .5189E+01 l' ..2620E+00 .4793E+01 1 .2680E+00 .4189E+01 - '] .2730E+00 .3766E+01 ' .2770E+00 .3532E+01 i
B-21
. BENCHMARK PROBLEM - ISM BM-3 APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM3-10 ( .2800E+00 .3384E+01 .2860E+00 .3215E+01 < .2950E+00 .3066E+01 .3090E+00 .2951E+01 .3390E+00 .2782E+01 .3760E+00 .2639E+01 .3840E+00 .2640E+01 .4040E+00 .2644E+01 .4390E+00 .2592E+01 l .4820E+00 .2479E+01 .5180E+00 .2382E+01 .5610E+00 .2304E+01,' .5900E+00 .2246E+01' .6430E+00 .2084E+01 .6970E+00 .1904E+01 .7090E+00 .1869E+01 .7200E+00 .1839E+01 ( .7450E+00 .1774E+01 .7730E+00 .1704E+01 .7850E+00 .1676E+01 .8150E+00 .1606E+01 k .8400E+00 .1549E+01 .9070E+00 .1399E+01 .9590E+00 .1282E+01 .1000E+01 .1162E+01 f SPECTRUM TABIE (SPECTRUM GROUP 2 Y-DIRECTION) 17 1.0 .2000E-01 .1050E+01 .4760E-01 .1850E+01 .5230E-01 .4490E+01 .6250E-01 .4490E+01 j .7100E-01 .5950E+01 .8680E-01 .5950E+01 .9170E-01 .4820E+01 ~ .1176E+00 .4820E+01 k . .1316E+00 .3030E+01 .2000E+00 .3030E+01 . .2016E+00 .3170E+01 .2460E+00 .3170E+01 .3440E+00 .2680E+01 .4830E+00 .2680E+01 .5260E+00 .1800E+01 .6670E+00 .1800E+01 .2000E+01 .3500E+00 SPECTRUM TABLE (SPECTRUM GROUP 2 Z-DIRECTION) 78 1.0 0.0 .7710E+00 { .1300E-01 .8300E+00 " .2500E-01 .8930E+00 * .3500E-01 .9560E+00
{~ J B-22 f
~
DENCHMARK PROBLEM - ISM BM-3 APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM3-11
.3600E-01 .9669E+00 .3700E-01 .9823E+00 8 .3800E-01 .1004E+01 .3900E-01 .1049E+01 . .4100E-01 .1070E+01 .4200E-01 .1073E+01
_= .4400E-01 .1090E+01 g .5300E-01 .1335E+01
.5600E-01 .1472E+01 I .6400E-01 .1512E+01 .6500E-01 .1524E+01 * .7000E-01 .1855E+01 .7200E-01 .2064E+01 .7400E-01 .2399E+01 .7410E-01 .2560E+01 .7500E-01 .2687E+01 l
5
.7600E-01 .2975E+01 .7800E-01 .3116E+01 .8000E-01 .3134E+01 .8200E-01 .3134E+01 I .8500E-01 .3112E+01 .8600E-01 .3077E+01 .9200E-01 .2931E+01 .9600E-01 .2781E+01 I .1030E+00 .2627E+01 .1040E+00 .2674E+01 .1050E+00 .2744E+01 .1120E+00 .2797E+01 1 .1200E+00 .2807E+01 .1260E+00 .2755E+01 - .1270E+00 .2685E+01 t .1280E+00 .2635E+01 .1340E+00 .2667E+01 .1510E+00 .2761E+01 .1670E+00 .2844E+01 I .1680E+00 .2849E+01 .1740E+00 .2873E+01 - .1870E+00 .2900E+01 I .1970E+00 .2923E+01 .1980E+00 .3002E+01 .2090E+00 .5152E+01
- .2130E+00 .5227E+01 I .2330E+00 .5232E+01 L
.2550E+00 .5224E+01 .2570E+00 .5189E+01 g .2620E+00 .4793E+01 g .2680E+00 .4189E+01 .2730E+00 .3766E+01 ~ .2770E+00 .3532E+01 , .2800E+00 .3384E+01 I
B-23 I
BENCHMARK PROBLEM - ISM BM-3 APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM3-12
.2860E+00 .3215E+01 .2950E+00 .3066E+01 $ .3090E+00 .2951E+01 .3390E+00 .2782E+01 s .3760E+00 .2639E+01 .3840E+00 .2640E+01 { .4040E+00 .2644E+01 .4390E+00 .2592E+01 .4820E+00 .2479E+01 '( .5180E+00 .2382E+01 .5610E+00 .2304E+01 .5900E+00 .2246E+01. .6430E+00 .2084E+01 l .6970E+00 .1904E+01 .7090E+00 .1869E+01 .7200E+00 .1839E+01 .7450E+00 .1774E+01 < .7730E+00 .1704E+01 .7850E+00 .1676E+01 .8150E+00 .1606E+01 .8400E+00 .1549E+01 { 4 .9070E+00 .1399E+01 .9590E+00 .1282E+01 .1000E+01 .1162E+01 SPECTRUM TABLE (SPECTRUM GROUP 3 X-DIRECTION) 78 1.0 0.0 .7710E+00 l .1300E-01 .8300E+00 I .2500E-01 .8930E+00 .3500E-01 .9560E+00 .3600E-01 .9669E+00 .3700E-01 .9823E+00 .3800E-01 .1004E+01 .3900E-01 .1049E+01 .4100E-01 .1070E+01 %
i
.4200E-01 .1073E+01 .4400E-01 .1090E+01 * .5300E-01 .1335E+01 .5600E-01 .1472E+01 .6400E-01 .1512E+01 .6500E-01 .1524E+01 .7000E-01 .1855E+01 .7200E-01 .2064E+01 .7400E-01 .2399E+01 .7410E-01 .2560E+01 .7500E-01 .2687E+02 .7600E-01 .2975E+01 .7800E-01 .3116E+01 * .8000E-01 .3134E+01 .8200E-01 .3134E+01
( B-24 I.
l' l., BENCHMARK PROBLEM - ISM BM-3 APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM3-13
.8500E-01 .3112E+01 .8600E-01 .3077E+01
- p. .9200E-01 .2931E+01
.9600E-01 .2781E+01 .1030E+00 .2627E+01 - .1040E+00 .2674E+01 f .1050E+00 .2744E+01 .1120E+00 .2797E+01 . 1200E+00 .2807E+01 .1260E+00 .2755E+01 .1270E+00 .2685E+01 .1280E+00 .2635E+01 .1340E+00 .2667E+01'
) .1510E+00 .2761E+01
.1670E+00 .2844E+01 .1680E+00 .2849E+01 .1740E+00 .2873E+01
) ; .1870E+00 .2900E+01 -
.1970E+00 .2923E+01 .1980E+00 .3002E+01 .2090E+00 .5152E+01 l .2130E+00 .5227E+01 .2330E+00 .5232E+01 .2550E+00 .5224E+01
) .2570E+00 .5189E+01
.2620E+00 .4793E+01 . .2680E+00 .41895+01 .2730E+00 .3766E+01
)
.2770E+00 .3532E+01 " .2800E+00 .3384E+01 .2863E+00 .3215E+01 I .2950E+00 .3066E+01 .3090E+00 .2951E+01 .3390E+00 .2782E+01 .3760E+00 .2639E+01
,~ .3840E+00 .2640E+01
.4040E+00 .2644E+01 .4390E+00 .2592E+01 . .4820E+00 .2479E+01 .5180E+00 .2382E+01 .5610E+00 .2304E+01 .5900E+00 .2246E+01 .6430E+00 .2084E+01 .6970E+00 .1904E+01 i .7090E+00 .1869E+01 ! .7200E+00 .1839E+01
> .7450E+00 .1774E+01
.7730E+00 .1704E+01 . .7850E+00 .1676E+01 ' .8150E+00 .1606E+01 B-25
'i i i
BENCHMARK PROBLEM - ISM BM-3 APPENDIX B' PAGE: ISM-BM3-14 d
.8400E+00 .1549E+01 .9070E+00 .1399E+01 <
9590E+00 .1282E+01
.1000E+01 .1162E+01 i
SPECTRUM TABLE - (SPECTRUM GROUP 3 Y-DIRECTION) j 17 1.0
.2000E-01 .1550E+01 .4760E-01 .2250E+01 .5650E-01 .5920E+01 I .6330E-01 .5920E+01 .6490E-01 .6390E+01 .7400E-01 .6390E+01. .7910E-01 .8180E+01 ! .9660E-01 .8180E+01 .1050E+00 .7210E+01 .1230E+00 .7210E+01 .1390E+00 .3820E+01 .2020E+00 .3420E+01 .2470E+00 .3420E+01 .3330E+00 .2720E+01 .4830E+00 .2720E+01 {' .5260E+00 .1888E+01 . 2000E+01 .4000E+00 q
SPECTRDN TABIE (SPECTRUM GROUP 3 Z-DIRECTION) 78 1.0 ; 0.0 .7710E+00
.1300E-01 .8300E+00 * .2500E-01 .8930E+00 'i ' .3500E-01 .9560E+00 .3600E-01 .9669E+00 .3700E-01 .9823E+00 .3800E-01 .1004E+01. $ . 3900E-01 .1049E+01 .4100E-01 .1070E+01 .4200E-01 .1073E+01 ( .4400E-01 .1090E+01 .5300E-01 .1335E+01. * .5600E-01 .1472E+01 .6400E-01 .1512E+01 .6500E-01 .1524E+01 .7000E-01 .1855E+01 .7200E-01 .2064E+01 ! .7400E-01 .2399E+01 .7410E-01 .2560E+01 .7500E-01 .2687E+01 .7600E-01 .2975E+01 )
i
* .7800E-01 .3116E+01 .8000E-01 .3134E+01 . .8200E-01 .3134E+01 .8500E-01 .3112E+01
( B-26 '
~ ll BENCHMARK' PROBLEM - ISM BM-3 APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM3-15 11
.8600E-01 .3077E+01 .9200E-01 .2931E+01 .9600E-01 .2781E+01 .1030E+00 .2627E+01 - .1040E+00 .2674E+01 ~ .1050E+00 .2744E+01 Il .1120E+00 .2797E+01 .1200E+00 .2807E+01 .1260E+00 .2755E+01 .1270E+00 .2685E+01 E. .1280E+00 .2635E+01 .1340E+00 .2667E+01 .1510E+00 .2761E+01' I .1670E+00 .2844E+01 .1680E+00 .2849E+01 .1740E+00 .2873E+01 .1870E+00 .2900E+01 .1970E+06 .2923E+01 .1980E+00 .3002E+01 .2090E+00 .5152E+01 I .2130E+00 .5227E+01 .2330E+60 .5232E+01 .2550E+00 .5224E+01 .2570E+00 .5189E+01 .2620E+00 .4793E+01 I .2680E+00 .4189E+01 .2730E+00 .3766E+0L .2770E+00 .3532E+01 I .2800E+00 .3384E+01 .2860E+00 .3215E+01 .2950E+00 .3066E+01 I .3090E+00 .2951E+01- .3390E+00 .2782E+01 .3760E+00 .2639E+01 .3840E+00 .2640E+01 I .4040E+00 .2644E+01 .4390E+00 .2592E+01 .4820E+00 .2479E+01 -
g, .5180E+00 .2382E+01
.5610E+00 .2304E+01 .5900E+00 .2246E+01 .6430E+00 .2084E+01 I .6970E+00 .1904E+01 .7090E+00 .1869E+01 .7200E+00 .1839E+01 .7450E+00 .1774E+01 .7730E+00 .1704E+01 .7850E+00 .1676E+01 .8150E+00 .1606E+01 ~ .8400E+00 .1549E+01 I
B-27
ll BENCHMARK PROBLEM - ISM BM-3 APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM3-16 1
.9070E+00 .1399E+01 E' .9590E+00 .1282E+01 5 .1000E+01 .1162E+01 SPECTRUM TABLE (SPECTRUM GROUP 4 X-DIRECTION) 78 1.0 l 0.0 .7710E+00 5 1 .1300E-01 .8300E+00 ) .2500E-01 .8930E+00 g j .3500E-01 .9560E+00 .3600E-01 .9669E+00 g .3700E-01 .9823E+00 .3800E-01 .1004E+01. .3900E-01 .1049E+01 5l g .4100E-01 .1070E+01 .4200E-01 .1073E+01 .4400E-01 .1090E+01 .5300E-01 .1335E+01 l' E .5600E-01 .1472E+01 .6400E-01 .1512E+01 .- .6500E-01 .1524E+01 .7000E-01 .1855E+01 .7200E-01 .2064E+01 .7400E-01 .2399E+01 5 .7410E-01 .2560E+01 .7500E-01 .2687E+01 E .7600E-01 .2975E+01 .7800E-01 .3116E+01 l .8000E-01 .3134E+01 m .8200E-01 .3134E+01 .8500E-01 .3112E+01 g .8600E-01 .3077E+0 . 92 00E-01 . 2931E+01 E .9600E-01 .2781E+01 .1030E+00 .2627E+01 .1040E+00 .2674E+01 E .1050E+00 .2744E+01 3 .1120E+00 .2797E+01 * .1200E+00 .2807E+01 .1260E+00 .2755E+01 .1270E+00 .2685E+01 .1280E+00 .2635E+01 E .1340E+00 .2667E+01 l _ .1510E+00 .2761E+01 E i .1670E+00 .2844E+01 .1680E+00 .2849E+01 .1740E+00 .2873E+01 E' .1870E+00 .2900E+01 E!
j . i
.1970E+00 .2923E+01 '- .1980E+00 .3002E+01 .2090E+00 .5152E+01 l
I l B-28 I I
a
- J
- i
)? BENCHMARK. PROBLEM - ISM BM-3 APPENDIX B PAGE5 ISM-BM3-17
.2130E+00 .5227E+01
- .2330E+00 .5232E+01
.2550E+00 .5224E+01 .2570E+00 .5189E+01 .2620E+00 .4793E+01 - .2680E+00 .4189E+01 .2730E+00 .3766E+01 .2770E+00 .3532E+01 ') . 2800E+00 .3384E+01 ] .2860E+00 .3215E+01 1 .2950E+00 .3066E+01 ] i .3090E+00 .2PS1E+01~ .3390E+00 .2782E+01- .3760E+00 .2639E+01 .3840E+00 .2640E+01 * .4040E+00 .2644E+01- .4390E+00 .2592E+01' .4820E+00 .2479E+01 .5180E+00 .2382E+01 .5610E+00:.2304E+01 ' .5900E+00 .2246E+01- 1 .6430E+00 .2084E+01 . .6970E+00 .1904E+01 ~l .7090E+00 .18698+01 .7200E+00 .18398+01 .7450E+00 .1774E+01 .7730E+00 .1704E+01 .7850E+00 .1676E+01 .8150E+00 .16063+01 .8400E+00 .1549E+01 .9070E+00 .1399E+01 .9590E+00 .1282E+01 I .1000E+01 .1162E+01 SPECTRUM TABLE (SPECTRUM GROUP 4 Y-DIRECTION) 14 1.0 .2000E-01 .1500E+01 l* .4500E-01 .1800E+01 .5700E-01 .2700E+01 . .7100E-01 .1070E+02 .8700E-01 .1070E+02 .9600E-01 .1210E+02 ! .1230E+00 .1210E+02 . .1430E+00 .4500E+01 .2020E+00 .3500E+01 .2470E+00 .3500E+01 .3330E+00 .2750E+01 .5000E+00 .2750E+01 f .~7690E+00 .1400E+01 .2000E+01 .5000E+00
- SPECTRUM TABLE (SPECTRUM GROUP 4 Z-DIRECTION) f-p i
B-29 i
f BENCHMARK PROBLEM - ISM BM-3 APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM3-18 78 1.0 0.0 .7710E+00
.1300E-01 .8300E+00 .2500E-01 .8930E+00 .3500E-01 .9560E+00 i .3600E-01 .9669E+00 i .3700E-01 .9823E+00 .3800E-01 .1004E+01 .3900E-01 .1049E+01 ; .4100E-01 .1070E+01 , .4200E-01 .1073E+01 .4400E-01 .1090E+01 .5300E-01 .1335E+01- .5600E-01 .1472E+01 .6400E-01 .1512E+01 .6500E-01 .1524E+01 .7000E-01 .1855E+01 .7200E-01 .2064E+01 .7400E-01 .2399E+01 .7410E-01 .2560E+01- j .7500E-01 .2687E+01 ! .7600E-01 .2975E+01 .7800E-01 .3116E+01 .8000E-01 .3124E+01 ) .8200E-01 .3134E+01 l .8500E-01 .3112E+01 .8600E-01 .3077E+01 .9200E-01 .2931E+01 .9600E-01 .2781E+01 .1030E+00 .2627E+01 .1040E+00 .2674E+01 .1050E+00 .2744E+01 .1120E+00 .2797E+01 .1200E+00 .2807E+01 .1260E+00. 2755E+01 .1270E+00 .2685E+01 .1280E+00 .2635E+01 - .1340E+00 .2667E+01 .1510E+00 .2761E+01 .1670E+00 .2844E+01 .1680E+00 .2849E+01 .1740E+00 .2873E+01 .1870E+00 .2900E+01 .1970E+00 .2923E+01 .1980E+00 .3002E+01 .2090E+00 .5152E+01 .2130E+00 .5227E+01 .2330E+00 .5232E+01 * .2550E+00 .5224E+01 .2570E+00 .5189E+01 B-30 l
l w__-_ - - -- -- - -
i l GENCHMARK PROBLEM - ISM BM-3 APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM3-19 l-
.2620E+00 .4793E+01
(' .2680E+00 .4189E+01 l .2730E+00 .3766E+01
.2770E+00 .3532E+01 .2800E+00 .3384E+01 .2860E+00 .3215E+01 .2950E+00 .3066E+01 .3090E+00 ~ .2951E+01 .3390E+00 .2782E+01 .3760E+00 .2639E+01 * .3840E+00 .2640E+01 .4040E+00 .2644E+01 .4390E+00 .2592E+0i .4820E+00 .2479E+01 .5180E+00 .2382E+01 .5610E+00 .2304E+01 ') .5900E+00 .2246E+01 .6430E+00 .2084E+01 .6970E+00 .1904E+01 .7090E+00 .1869E+01 . . . .7200E+00 .1839E+01 .7450E+00 .1774E+01 .7730E+00 .1704E+01 L .7850E+00*.1676E+01 * .8150E+00 .1606E+01 * .8400Ev00 .1549E+01 .. . .9070E+00 .1399E+01 .9590E+00 .1282E+01 . .1000E+01 .1162E+01 300 0 0. O. O 0 -- 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 25 72 10000. 10000. 10000. 10000. 1000.
1.0 0.05 0.05 . 0.0 0.0 2 1 1. 1 -1 0 . k 1 B-31
BENCHMARK PROULEM.- ISM BM-4 APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM4-1 INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION BENCHMARK PROBLEM 4 NRC 195' 2 0 50 6 0 0 0 0 1 0 4 1 50 1 0 0 0 1 1 1 -203.808 4715.952 139.224 0 0 . @4 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 -215.~ 8 08 4715.952 139.224 0 0 . -@' 3 1 1 1 1 1 1 -203.808 4703.952 139.224 0 0 . @1 4 1 1 1 1 1 1 -203.808 4715.952 127.224 0 0.@ 5 0 0 0 0 0 0 -203.268 4719.852 154.860 0 0.@ 6 0 0 0 0 0 0 -202.308 4726.800 182.748 0 0.@ 7 0 0 0 0 0 0 -202.008 4730.948 191.340 0 0.@ 8 0 0 0 0 0 0 -201.876 4729.392 194.916 0 0.@ 9 0 0 0 0 0 0 -201.888 4729.392 194.988- 0 0.@ 10 0 0 0 0 .0 0 -205.908 4729.392 205.740 0 0.@ 11 0 0 0 0 0 0 -210.036 4729.392 210.168 0 0.@ 12 0 0 0 0 0 0 -212.160 4729.392 -212.436 0 0.@ 13 0 0 0 0 0 0 -213.324 4729.392 213.684 0 0.@ 14 0 0 0 0 0 0 -220.968 4729.392 221.868 0 0.@ 15 0 0 0 0 0 0 -220.968 4734.492 221.868 0 0.@ 16 0 0 0 0 0 0 -231.888 4729.392 233.568 0 0.@ 17 0 0 0 0 0 0 -233.952 4729.392 235.776 0 0.@ 18 1 'l 1 1 1 1 -233.952 4741.392 235.776- 0 0. @! 19 0 'O O O 0 0 -235.980 4729.392 237.936 0 0.@ 20 0 0 0 0 0 0 -246.204 4714.392 248.904 0 0.@ 21 0 0 .0 0 'O O -246.204 4705.860 248.904 0 0.G 22 0 0 0 0 0 . 0- -246.204 4686.792 248.904 0 0.G 23 0 0 0 0 0 0 -246.204 4676.952 248.904 0 0.G 24 0 0 0 0 0 0 -246.204 4665.900 248.904 0 0.@ 25 0 0 0 0 0 0 -246.204 4638.876 248'.904 0 0.G 26 0 0 0 0 0 0 -246.204 4631.628 248.904 0 0.@ 27 0 0 0 0 0 0 -246.204 4628.952 248.904 0. O.@ 28 0 0 0 0' O O -256.812 4613.952 238.296 0 0.@ 29 0 0 0 0 0 0 -263.004 4613.952 232.104 0 0.@ 30 1 1 1 1 1 1 -263.004 4625.952 232.104 0 0. @( 31 0 0 0 0 0 0 -264.048 4613.952 231.060 0 0.@ 32 0 0 0 0 0 0 -275.352 4613.952 219.744 0 0.@ 33 0 0 0 0 0 0 -275.352 4619.052 219.744
- O 0.@
34 0 0 0 0 0 0 -286.668 4613.952 208.440 0 0.@ 35 0 0 0 0 0 0 -291.996 4613.952 203.112 'O 0.@ 36 0 0 0 0 0 0 -302.604 4613.952 198.720 0. O . @( 37 0 0 0 0 0. 0 -314.988 4613.952 198.720 0 0.@ 38 1 1 1 1 1 1 -314.988 4613.952 186.720 0 0.@ 39 0 0 0 0 0 0 -340.380 4613.952 198.720 0 0.@( 40 0 0 0 0 0 0 -366.000 4613.952 198.720 0 0. 0( 41 0 0 0 0 0 0 -381.000 4628.952 19E.720 0 0. 0( 42 0 0 0 0 0 0 -381.000 4630.560 198.720 0 0. 0C 43 0 0 0 0 0 0 -381.000 4655.952 198.720 0 ,
- 0. 0(
44 1 1 1 1 1 1 -369.035 4655.952 197.800 0 0.,0( 45 0 0 0 0 0- 0 -381.000 4689.588 198.720 0 0. 0( 46 0 0 0 0 0 0 -381.000 4756.872 198.720 0 0. 0( B-32
i BENCHMARK PROBLEM - ISM BM-4 APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM4-2 I' 47 0 0 0 0 0 0 48 0 0
-381.000 4760.952 198.720 0 0.000 0 0 0 4775.952 49 .0 0 0 0 0 ' -396.000 198.720 0 0.000 0 0 -399.000 4775.952 50 1 1 1 1 1 198.720 0 0.000 1 -399.000 4787.952 198.720 51 0 0 0 0 0 0.000 )
0 0 -402.600 4775.952 52 1 1 1 1 1 198.720. 0 0.000 {' 1 -402.600 4776.872 210.685 53 0 0 0 0 0.000-0 0 0 -440.904 4775.952 198.720 54 0- 0 0 0.000
.0 0 0 0 -450.612 4775.952 55 0 0 0 0 0 198.720 0 0.000 56 0 0 0 0 0 -465.612 4790.952 198.720 0 0.000 '
0 0 -465.612 4796.592 198.720 0 57 1 1 1 1 1 0.000 1 -453.643' 4796.592 197.860 0 0.000-58 0 0 0 0 0 59 0 0 0 -465.612 4840.068 198.720 0 0.000 0- 0 '. 0 0 -465.612 4927.032 198.720 0 60 0 0 0 0 0 0.000 61 0 0 0 0 0 -465.612 4943.952 198.720 0 0.000 0 0 -459.864 4958.952 212.568 0 62 0' O O O 0.000 63 1 1 1 1 O O -458.712 4958.952 215.340 0 0.000 64 0 0 0 0 1 1 -458.712 4970.952 215.340 0 0.000 65 0 0 0 0 0 0 -455.748 4958.952 222.480 0 0.000 0 0 -463.860- 4958.952 242;076 0 0'.000 66 0 0 0 0 0 67 .0; O O
- 0. -484.044 4958.952 250.452 0 0.000 O O O -533.124 4958.952 68 1 1 1 1 270.828 0 0.000 l 1 1 -537.724 4958.952 259.745 0 69 0 0 0 .0 0 0.000 70 0 0 0 0 0 -552.516 4958.952 278.880 0 .0.000 0 0 ,-552.600 4958.952 278.916 0 71 0 0 0 0 0 0.000 72 0 .-560.652 4958.952 298.392 0 0.000 0 0 0 0 0 0 -559.464 4958.952 73 1 1 1 1 301.248 0 0.000 1 1 ~559.464 4970.952 301.248 0 74 0 '0 'O O 0.000 75 1 1 O 'O ~558.312 4958.952 304.020 0 0.000' 1 1 1 1 -553.866 4961.957- 293.28'6 76 0 0 0 0.000-0 0 0 s 0 '-554.868 4958.952 312.324 77 0 0 0 0.000 0 0 0 0 .-548.736 4958.952 327.108
.7 8- 0 0 0 0.000 0 0 0 0 -548.736 4981.752 327.108 0 79 0 0 0 0 0.000 80 0 0 0 0 0 -546.708 4958.952 331.992 0 0.000 0 0 0 -542.604 4958.952 341.880 81 0 0 0 0 0 'O.000 82 0 0 0 0 0 -538.152 4958.952 '352.620 0 0.000 0 0 *O -532.404 4973.952 366.468 0
- 83 -0 0 0 0 0.000 0 'O ~532.404 4988.628 366.468 . 0 O.000 84 0 0 0 0 85 0 0 0 0 0 -532.404 5039.952 366.468 *0 0.000 0 0 0 -532.404 5040.048 366.468 0 86 0 0 0 0.000 0 0 0 -546.168 5054.952 372.180 0 87 0 0 0 0.000 0 0 0 -551.904 5054.952 374.568 0 88 1 1 1 1 0.000 89 0 0 1 1 -551.904 5066.952 374.568 0 0.000 0 0 0 0 -560.988 5054.952 378.336 90 1 1 1 1 0' O.000 1 1 -560.988 5066.952 378.336 0 91 0 0 0 0 0.000 0 0 -565.128 5054.952 380.052 0 92 0 0 0 0 0.000 0 0 -578.988 5069.952 385.812 0 93 0 0 0 0.000 0 0 0 -578.988 5091.924 385.812 0 94 0 0 0 0.000 1 1 1 -578.988 5141.940 385.812 0 95 1 1 1 4.000 1 1 1 -590.988 5141.940 385.812 0 96 1 1 1 0.000 1 1 1 -578.988 5129.940 385.812 0 0.000-B-33
r , j I BENCHMARK PROBLEM - ISM BM-4 APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM4-3 97 1 1 1 1 1 1 -578.988 5141.940 373.812 0 0.0 98 0 0 0 0 0 0 -242.400 4676.952 252.708 0 0.0 99 0 0 0 0 0 0 -242.382 4676.952 252.720 0 0.0 . 100 0 0 0 0 0 0 -238.434 4676.952 256.680 0 0.000 101 0 0 0 0 0 0 -232.056 0 102 0 0 4667.952 263.052 0. 0$ 103 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
-232.056 -232.056 4665.936 4622.952 263.052 0 0 .0.05 l 263.052 0.000 104 0 0 0 0 0 0 -225.696 4613.952 256.692 0 0.0 105 0 0 0 0 0 0 -218.688 46.1.3.952 249.684 0 0.0 106 0 0 0 0 0 0 -216.048 4652.952 243.312 0 0.0 107 0 0 0 0 0 0 -216.048 .4613.952 208.800 0 0.000 1 108 0 0 0 0 0 0 -216.048 4613.952 181.644 0 0.0 109 1 1 l' 1 1 1 -216.048 4625.952 181.644 0 0.0 110 0 0 0 0 0 0 -216.048 4613.952 155.748 0 0.0 l
111 0 0 0 0 0 0 -216.048 4613.952 103.944 0 0.000 l 112 0 0 0 0 0 0 -216.048 4613.952 78.048 0 .0.0 113 1 1 1 1 1 1 -204.048 4613.952 78.048 0 0.0 114 0 0 0 0 0 0 -216.048 4613.952 34.980 0' O.00 115 0 0 { 0 0 0 0 -216.048 4613.952 27.048 0 0.0 1 116 0 0 0 0 0 0 -225.048 4613.952 18.048 0 0.0 ! 117 0 0 0 0 0 0 -231.048 4613.952 18.048 0 0.0 118 1 1 1 1 1 1 -231.048 4616.447 29.785 0 0.000 119 0 0 0 0 0 0 -246.048 4613.952 18.048 0 0.0 120 1 1 1 1 1 1 -246.048 4625.952 18.048 0 0.0 121 0 0 0 0 0 0 -267.048 4613.952 18.448 0 0.0 l 122 0 0 0 0 0 0 -276.048 4613.952 27.048 0 0.000 123 0 0 0 0 0 0 -276.048 4613.952 40.452 0 0.0 124 0 0 0 0 0 0 -276.048 4613.952 137.544. 0 0.0 125 0 0 0 0 6 { 0 -276.048 4613 952 168.948 0 0.0 j 126 0 0 0 0 0 0 -276.048 4622.952 177.948 0 O.0 l 127 0. 0 0 0 0 0 -276.048 4625.952 177.948 _0 0.0 128 1 1 1 1 1 .1 -274.814 4625.952 189.884 % .O 0.0 129 0 0 0 0 0 0 -276.048 4668.492 177.948 0 0.000 130 0 0 0 0 0 0 -276.~048 4753.560 177.948 0 0.0 131 0 0 0 0 0 0 -276.048 4766.952 177.948 0* 0.0 132 0 0 0 0 0. 0 -285.048 4775.952 177.948 0 0.0 l 133 0 0 0 0 134 1 1 1 1 0 0 .-288.048 4775.952 177.948 -
- 0 0.000 j 1 1 -288.048 4787.952 177.948 0 0.0 135 0 0 0 0 0 0 -300.048 4775.952 177.948 0 0.0 136 1 1 1 1 1 1 -300.048 4781.441 188.620 0 0.0 137 0 0 0 0 0 0 -350.532 4775.952 177.948 0 0.00 138 0 0 0 0 0 0 -451.512 4775.952 177.948 0 0.~00 139 0 0 0 0 0 0 -472.020 4775.952 177.948 0- 0.00 140 0 0 0 0 0 0 -481.020 4784.952 177.948 0 0.000 141 0 0 0 0 0 0 -481.020 4800.792 177.948 0 0.00 l 142 1 1 1 1 1 1 -469.580 4800.792 181.571 0 0.00 l 143 0 0 0 0 0 0 -481.020 4855.320 177.948 0 0.00 '
144 0 0 0 0 0 0 -481.020 4964.388 177.948 0 0.000 145 0 0 0 0 0 0 -481.020 4979.592 177.948 0 0.U'O 146 1 1 1 1 1 1 -481.020 4979.592 189.948 0 0.00 , B-34 I
1 BENCHMARK PROBLEM - ISM BM-4 APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM4-4 5 147 0 0 0 0 0 0 -481.020 5000.592 177.948 0 0.000 148 0 0 0 0 0 0 -489.336 5009.952 181.392 0 0.000 149 0 0 0 0 0 0 -492.876 5009.952 182.868 0 0.000 150 1 1 1 1 1 1 -492.876 5021.952 182.868 0 0.00p 151 0 0 0 0 0 0 -520.044 5009.952 194.148 0 0.000 152 0 0 0 0 0 0 Ii 153 154 155 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
-558.600 0 -566.916 0 -566.916 0 -566.916 5009.952 5018.952 5021.892 5048.952 210.156 213.600 213.600 213.600 0
0 0 0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 1 I 156 157 158 159 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 0 1, 0 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 -563.472 0 -562.320 1 -562.320 5057.952 5057.952 5069.952 221.916 224.688 224.688 0 0 0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0 0 0 0 -558.864 5057.952 233.004 0 0.000 I 160 161 162 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 -556.716 0 -553.884 0 -553.884 5057.952 5057.952 5062.044 238.188 245.004 245.004 0 0 0 0.000 0.000 0.000 163 0 0 0 0 0 0 -548.904 5057.952 257.016_, 0 0.000 4 I. 164 165 166 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
-546.600 -545.436 5057.952 5057.952 262.560 265.368 0-0 0.000 0.000 3
1 1 1 1 -556.148 5060.878 260.821 0 0.000 167 I 168 169 170 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
-534.588 -512.880 5057.952 5057.952 ' 502.020 5057.952 291.528 343.824 369.984 0
0 0 0.000 0.000 0.000 1 1 1 -502.020 5069.952 369.984 0 0.000 I 171 172 173 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 0 0 -500.988 5057.952 0 -496.392 5045.952 0 -496.392 5037.192 372.468 383.544 383.544 0 0 0 0.000 0.000 0.000 174 0 0 0 0 0 0 -496.392 5033.952 I 383.544 0 0.000 175 0 0 0 0 0 0 -506.700 5021.952 389.676 0 0.000 176 0 0 0 0 0 0 -539.784 5021.952 409.356 0 0.000 177 1 1 1 1 1 1 -596.976 5059.452 495.504 0 0.000 178 I 179 180 181 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 -588.540 5021.952 0 -588.624 5021.952 0 -595.416 5029.848 438.372 438.420 442.464 0 0 0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0 0 -595.416 5035.452 442.464 0 0.000 I 182 183 184 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 -605.748 5047.452 0 -610.896 5047.452' 0 -615.072 5047.452 448.596 451.668 468.120
- 0 0
0 0.000 0.000 0.000 185 0 0 0 0 0 I 186 187 188 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 -613.716 5047.452 0 -603.960 5047.452 0 ~597.504 5047.452 0 -596.976 5047.452 470.388 486.792 494.988 495.504 0 0 0 0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 I 189 190 191 192 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 -570.048 5047.452 0 -516.180 5047.452 0 -462.312 5047.452 521.736 574.200 626.676 0 0 0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0 1 1 1 -435.384 5047.452 652.920 0 0.000 I 193 194 195 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 -447.384 1 -435.384 1 -435.384 5047.452 5035.452 5047.452 652.920 652.920 640.920 0 0 0 0.000 0.000 0.0,00 7 36 I B-35 I
BENCHMARK PROBLEM - ISM BM-4 APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM4-5 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1 2 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 .1000E+09 1 3 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 .1000E+09 1 4 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 .1000E+09 17 18 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 .1080E+04 29 30 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 .6001E+05 37 38 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 .6001E+0S 43 44 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 .6001E+05 49 50 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 .7541E+06 51 52 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 .7541E+06 56 57 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 .6001E+05 62 63 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 .6000E+03 67 68 1- O' O 0.0 0.0 .6001E+05 72 73 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 .7601E+05 74' 75 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 .6001E+05 87 88 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 .8000E+03 89 90 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 .6001E+05 94 95 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 .1000E+09 94 96 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 .1000E+09 94 97 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 .1000E+09 108 109 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 .2600E+03 112 113 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 .5901E+05 117 118 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 .2400E+05 119 120 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 .7601E+05 127 128 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 .2801E+05 133 134 1 0 0 0. 0 ' O.0 .2460E+06 . 135 136 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 .6001E+05 141 142 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 .6001E+05 145 146 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 .7501E+05 149 150 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 .4660E+06 157 158 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 .3400E+03 165 166 1 0 0 l 0.0 0.0 .6001E+05 4 169 170 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 .5000E+06 188 177 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 .5000E+06 192 193 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 .1000E+09 192 194 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 .1000E+09 192 195 1 0 0 0.0 0.0 .1000E+09 . 12 162 1 1 13 0 3 0 0 0 1 1 0.00 .283E+08 .300 .911E-05 1 32.250 2.2500 0.0 0.0 0.0 2 15.625 3.4400 0.0 0.0 0.0 3 10.750 1.0000 0.0 0.0 0.0 i 4 16.030 2.6400 0.0 0.0 0.0 5 160.300 74.7750 0.0 0.0 0.0 6 10.750 1.0000 0.0 0.0 0.0 4 7 16.030 2.6400 0.0 0.0 0.0 8 6.625 .7180 0.0 0.0 0.0 - 9 9.870 1.6200 0.0 0.0 0.0 10 98.700 46.0350 0.0 0.0 0.0 1 l B-36
,s -
I BENCHMARK PROBLEM - ISM BM-4 APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM4-6 I 11 12 6.625 .7180 0.0 0.0 00 8.625 .9060 0.0 0.0 0.0 ' 13 10.750 .3650 0.0 0.0 0.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 . 1 1.0 1.0 1.0 I 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 l IT 1 5 1 1 0.00 0.00 1 I 2T 3T 4B 15.000 5 6 7 6 7 8 1 1 1 2 3' 3 0.00 O.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 1 1
-201.948 4729.392 193.128 .1000 I ST 6B 15.000 S
9 9 10 1 1 3 3
-201.672 4729.392 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 201.204 .1000 1
7T 10 11 1 3 0.00 I 0.00 1 ST 11 12 1 4 0.00 0.00 9T 12 13 1 1 4 0.00 0.00 10T' 13 14 1 1 4 0.00, 0.00 I 11T '14 15 1 1 5 0.00 0.00 12T 14 16 1 1 4 0.00 0.00 13T 16 17 1 1 6 0.00 0.00 14T 17 19 1 6 1 0.00 0.00 1 I 15B 16T 15.000 19 20 20 21 1 1 6
-246.204 4729.392 6-0.00 0.00 0.00 248.904 0.00 .1000 1
17T 21 22 1 6 0.00 I 0.00 1 18T 22 23 1 6 0.00 0.00 19T 23 24 1 6 1 0.00 0.00 1 20T 24 25 1 6 0.00 0.00 21T 25 26 1 6 1 0.00 0.00 1 22T 26 27 1 8 23B 27 28 1 6 6 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 1 15.000 -246.204 4613.952 248.904 .1000 I 24T 25T 26T 28 29 31 29 31 32 1 1 1 6 6 4 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 1 1 1 27T 32 33 1 5 0.00 I 28T 29T 30B 32 34 35 34 35 36 1 1 1 4 6 6 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 1 1 1 I 15.000 -296.388 4613.952 198.720 31T .1000 36 37 1 6 0.00 0.00 32T 37 39 1 6 1 0.00 0.00 33T 39 40 1 6 1 0.00 0.00 I 34B 35T 15.000 40 41 41 42 1 1 6
-381.000 4613.952 6
0.00 0.00 0.00 198.720 0.00
.1000 -
1 1 36T 42 43 1 6 0.00 0.00 1 I B-37 I
-BENCHMARK PROBLEM"- ISM BM-4 APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM4-7 ,37T 43 ' ;4 5 1 6 0.00 0.00 38T 45- 46 1 6 0.00 0.00 39T 46 47 1 6 0.00 0.00 40B 47 48 1 6- 0.00 0.00 15.000 -381.000 4775.952 .198.720 .1000 41T 48 49 1 6 0.00 0.00 42T 49 51 1 6 0.00 0.00 43T 51 53- 1 6 0.00 0.00 "44T 53' 54 1 6 0.00 0.00 45B 54 55 1 6 0.00 0.00 15.000- -465.612 4775.952 198.720 .1000 46T 55 56 1 6 0.00 0.00 47T $6 58 l' 6 0.00 0.00 48T 58 59 1 6 0.00 0.00 49T 59 60 1 6 0.00 0.00 508 60 61 1 6 0.00 0.00 15.000 -465.612 4958.952 198.720 .1000 51T 61 62 1 6 0.00 0.00 '52T 62 64 1 6 'O.00 0.00 53B 64 65 1 6 0.00 0.00 15.000 -450.000 4958.952 236.328 .1000 54T. 65 66 1 6. 0.00 0.00 55T 66 67 1 6 0.00 0.00 56T 67 69 1 6 0.00 0.00 57T 69. 70- 1 6 0.00 0.00 SSB 70 71 1 6 0.00 0.00 14.900 -566.364 4958.952 284.628 .1000 59T 71 72 1- 6 0.00 0.00 ;
60T 72 74 1 6 0.00 0.00 .; 61T 74 76 1 6 0.00 0.00 'l 62T 76 77 1 7 0.00 0.00 ! 63T' 77 78 1 5 0.00 0.00 1 64T 77 79 1 7 0.00
- 0.00 l 65T 79 80 1 7 0.00 0.00 1 66T 80 -81 1 13 0.00 0.00 1 67B 81 82 1 13 0.00 0.00 15.000 -532.404 4958.952 366.468- .1000 .
68T 82 83 1 13 0.00 0.00 { 69T 83 84 1 13 0.00 0.00 5
'70T 84 85 1 13 0.00 0.00 {
71B 85 86 .1 13 0.00 0.00 14.900 -532.404 5054.952 366.468 .1000 72T 86 87 1 13 0.00 0.00 'E 73T 87 89 1 13 0.00 0.00 1 74T 89 91 1 13 0.00 0.00 75B 91 { 92 1 13 0.00 0.00 15.000 -578.976 5054.952 385.812 .1000 76T 92 93 1 13 0.00 0.00
- 77T 93' 94 1 13 78T 23 98 1 8 0.00 0.00 0.00 ' {[
0.00 [ B-38
i BENCHMARK PROBLEM - ISM BM-4 APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM4-8 ) I 79T. 98 99 1 8 0.00 0.00 80T 99 100 1 8 1 0.00 0.00 } 81B '100 101 1 8 0.00 0.00 1 9.000 -232.056 4676.952 263.052 .1000 82T 101 102 1 8 0.00 0.00 , 83T 102 103 1 8 0.00 -0.00 1) 84B 103 104 1 8 0.00 0.00 1l 9.000 -232.056 4613.952 263.052 .1000 85T 104 105 1 8 0.00 0.00 86B 105 106 .1 8 0.00 0.00 1i 9.000 ))
-216,048 4613.952 247.044 .1000 l-87T 106 107 1 8 0.00 0.00 88T 107 108 11 8 0.00 0.00 1 1 )
I 89T 108 110 1 8 0.00 0.00 ; 90T 110 111 1 1 ' 8 0.00, 0.00 91T 111 112 1 1 8 0.00 0.00 92T 112 114 1 8 1 0.00 0.00 93T 114 115 1 8 1 0.00 0.00 94B 115 116 1 8 1 0.00 0.00 9.000 -216.048 4613.952 18.048 .1000 95T 116 117 1- 8 0.00 0.00 96T 117 119 1 1 8 0.00 0.00 97T 119 121. 1 8 1 0.00 0.00 1 988 121 122 1 8 0.00 0.00 - 9.000 -276.048 4613.952 18.048 .1000 99T 122 123 1 8 0.00 0.00 100T 123 124 1 8 1 0.00 0.00 1 101T 124 125 1 8' O.00 'O.00 1025. 125 -126 1 1 8 0.00 0.00 9.000 -276.048 4613.952 177.948 .1000 103T 126 127 1 8 0.00 0.00 104T: 127 129 1 8 0.00 0.00
- l' 1,
105T 129 130 1 8 0.00 0.00 106T 130 131 1 1 8 0.00 0.00 107B 131 132 1 8 1-0.00 0.00 ' 9.000 -276.048 4775.952 177.948 .1000 108T 132 133 1 8 0.00 0.00 109T 133 135. 1 1 8 0.00 0.00
- 110T 135 137 1 8 1
0.00 0.00 1 111T 137 138 1 8 0.00 0.00 112T 138 139 1 8 1 0.00 0.00 1 113B 139 140 1 8 0.00 0.00 9.000 -481.020 4775.952 177.948 .1000 114T 140 141 1 8 0.00 0.00 lL 115T 141 143 1 8 0.00 0.00 116T 143 '144 1 1 8 0.00 0.00 117T 144 145 1 8 1 0.00 0.00 1 118T 145 147 1 8 0.00 0.00 119B 147 148 1
. 1 8 0.00 0.00 .-
9.000 -481.020 5009.592 177.948 .1000 B-39 l i I
BENCHMARK PROBLEM - ISM BM-4 APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM4-9 120T 148 149 1 8 0.00 0.00 121T 149 151 1 8 0.00 0.00 122T 151 152 1 8 0.00 0.00 123B 152 153 1 8 0.00 0.00 e 9.000 -566.916 5009.952 213.600 .1000 124T 153 154 1 8 0.00 0.00 125T- 154 155 1 8 0.00 0.00 126B 155 156 1 8 0.00 0.00 9.000 -566.916 5057.952 213.600 .1000 127T 156 157 1 8 0.00 0.00 128T 157 '159 1 8 0.00 0.00 129T 159 160 1 9 0.00 0.00 130T 160 161 1 9 0.00 0.00 131T 161 162 1 10 0.00 0.00 132T 161 163 1 9 0.00 0.00 133T 163 164 1 8 0.00 0.00 134T 164 165 1 12 0.00 0.00 135T 165 167 1 12 0.00 0.00 136T 167 168 1 12 0.00 0.00 137T 168 169 1 12 0.00 0.00 138T 169 171 1 12 0.00 0.00 139B 171 172 1 12 0.00 0.00 12.000 -496.392 5057.952 383.544 .1000 , 140T 172 173 1 12' O.00 0.00 1 141T 173 174 1 12 0.00 0.00 l 1428 174 175 1 12 0.00 0.00 12.000 ~496.392 5021.952 383.544 .1000 143T 175 176 1 12 0.00 0.00 i 144T 176 178 1 12 0.00' O.00 . l 145T 178 179 1 12 0.00 0.00' " l 146B 179 180 1 12 0.00 0.00 7.900 -595.416 .5021.952 442.464 .1000 - 147T 180 181 1 12 0.00 0.00 ! 148B 181 182 1 12 0.00 0.00 12.000 -595.416 5047.452' 442.464 .1000 149T 182 183 1 12 0.00 0.00- ! 150B 183 184 1 12 0.00 0.00
- 12.000 -621.204 5047.452 457.800 .1000 151T 184 185 1 12 0.00 0.00 1 152T 185 186 1 12 0.00 0.00 l 153B 186 187 1 12 0.00 0.00 40.000 -601.272 5047.452 491.316 .1000 154T 187 188 1 12 0.00 0.00 1 155T 188 189 1 12 0.00 0.00 l 156T 189 190 1 12 0.00 0.00 *
{ 157T 190 191 1 12 0.00 0.00 { 158T 191 192 1 12 0.00 0.00 . { 159T 15 14 1 5 0.00 0.00 .1 160T 78 77 1 5 0.00 0.00 { 161T 33 32 1 5 0.00 0.00 { B-40
BENCHMARK PROBLEM - ISM BM-4 APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM4-10 162T 162 161 1 10 0.00 0.00 12 0 1.69306 1.69306 1.69306 3: 15 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 5.07505 5.07505 5.07505 0.0 21 0 1.69306 0.0 0.0 1.69306 1.69306 0.0 0.0 25 0 1.69306 1.69306 0.0 1.69306 0.0 0.0 0.0
~
33 0 4.96894 4.96894 4.96894 34 0 1.20212 0.0 0.0 0.0 1.20212 1.20212 0.0 0.0 39 0 1.42495 1.42495 0.0 1.42495 0.0 0.0 0.0 42 0 1.42495 1.42495 1.42495 45 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 1.88768 1.88768 1.88768 0.0 46 0 0.0 0.0 1.88768 1.88768 1.88768 0.0 0.0 0.0 53 0 2.18323.. 2.18323 2.18323 58 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 2.43970' 2.43970 2.43970 0.0 59 0 2.43970 0.0 0.0 2.43970 2.43970 0.0 0.0 0.0 66 0 2.98188 2.98188 2.98188 69 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 1.41874 1.41874 1.41874 0.0
.78 0 10.4943 0.0 0.0 10.4943 10.4943 0.0 0.0 0.0 79 0 0.930124 0.930124 0.930124 ~
83 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 0.930124 0.930124 0.930124 0.0 0.0 84 0 0.930124 0.0 93 0.930124 0.930124 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 1.61180 1.61180 1.61180 0.0 102 0.0 0.0 104 0 0.674431 0.674431 0.674431 0.0 0.0 0.0 l 107 0 0.674431 0.674431 0.674431 0.0 0.0 0.0 110 0 0.674431 0.674431 0.674431 0.0 0.0 0.0 l' 111 0 0.643116 0.643116 0.643116 0.0 0.0 0.0 114 0 0.643116 0.643116 0.643116 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 1.06962 1.06962 1.06962 0.0 0.0 123 0 1.20549 1.20549 1.20549 0.0 124 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 1.20549 1.20549 1.20549 0.0 0 9 ., 129 0 1.05642 1.05642 1.05642 0.0 130 0.0 0.' O 0.0
.0 1.05642 1.05642 1.05642 0.0 0.0 137 0 1.25388 0.0 1.25388 1.25388 0.0 0.0 0.0 138 0 1.25388 1.25388 1.25388 143 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 1.35430 1.35430 1.35430 0.0 144 0.0 0.0 0 1.35430 1.35430 1.35430 0.0 0.0 151 0.0 154 0 0.666149 0.666149 0.666149 0.0 0.0 0.0 160 0 0.666149 0.666149 0.666149 0.0 0.0 0.0 162 0 0.666149 0.666149 0.666149 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 2.27769 2.27769 2.27769 0.0 0.0 167 0 1.15217 0.0 1.15217 1.15217 0.0 0.0 0.0 168 0 1.15217 1.15217 1.15217 i 173 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 1.23214 1.23214 1.23214 0.0 0.0 176 0 1.23214 0.0 1.23214 1.23214 0.0 0.0 0.0
> 178 0 1.23214 1.23214 1.23214 185 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 1.23214 1.23214 1.23214 0.0 0.0 189 0 1.52976 0.0 1.52976 1.52976 0.0 0.0 0.0 ! 190 0 1.52976 1.52976 1.52976 1 191 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 1.52976 1.52976 1.52976 0.0 0.0 00000 0.0 ,, i 00000 1 B-41 ' 1 ) i
BENCHMARK PROBLEM - ISM BM-4 APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM4-11
-j 0 0 0 0 0 0 12 1 0.0 2 2. 1 i 2 1 1.0 1.0 1.0 3 1 1.0 1.0 1.0 .
4 1 1.0- 1.0 1.0 , 1.0 2 18 1 1.0 1.0 1 30 2 1.0 1.0 1.0 38 2 1.0 1.0 1.0 109 2 1.0 1.0 '1.0 q 113 2 1.0 ^ 1.0 1.0- j
-118 2 1.0 1.0 1.0 120 .2 1.0 1.0 1.0 128 2 1. 0 ' 1.0 1.0 1 134 2 1.0 1.0 1.0 44 3 1.0 .1.0 1.0 50 3 1.0 1.0 1.0 52 3 -1.0 1.0 1.0 57 3 1.0 1.0 1.0 i 136- 3 1.0 1.0 1.0 142 3 1.0 1.0 1.0 :;
146 3 1.0 1.0 1.0 63 4 1.0 1.0 1.0 68 4 1.0 1.0 1.0 - 73' 4 1.0 1.0 1.0 ) 75 4 1.0 1.0 1.0 i SS 4 1.0 1.0 1.0 90 4 1.0 1.0 1.0 y 95 4 1.0 1.0 1.0 1 96 '4 1.0 1.0 1.0 1 97 4 1.0 1.0 1.0 150 4 1.0 1.0 1.0 - j 158 4 1.0 1.0 '1.0 166 4 1.0 1.0 1.0 170 4 1.0 1.0 1.0 177 4 1.0 1.0 1.0 193' 4 1.0 1.0 1.0 194 4 1.0 1.0 1.0 - 195 4 1.0 1.0 1.0 1 1.0 2 1.0 3 1.0 4 1.0 5 1.0 6 1.0 7 1.0 8 1.0 9 1.0 10 1.0 11 1.0 12 1.0 y SPECTRUM TABLE (SPECTRUM GROUP 1 X-DIRECTION) 30 386.00
.1000E-01 .2520E+00 i .2000E-01 .2520E+00
- i
.3000E-01 .5000E+00 .3700E-01 .1222E+01 .5100E-01 .1222E+01 B-42 1 1
BENCHMARK PROBLEM -' ISM BM-4 ' APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM4-12
.5600E-01 .1000E+01- .72OOE-01 .1000E+01- .7800E-01 .9950E+00 .. .1050E+00 .9950E+00 , . 1100E+00 .9350E+00 .1300E+00 .9350E+00 . 1750E+00 .4500E+00 .2000E+00 .1360E+01 .3000E+00 .1360E+01 .3350E+00 .6500E+00- * .4450E+00-.6500E+00 .4550E+00 .5550E+00 . .5000E+00 .5550E+00 .5200E+00'.5250E+00 .5800E+00 .5250E+00 .6570E+00. 3950E+00 .7200E+00 .3950E+00 .8000E+00 3050E+00 -.9050E+00 .3050E+00 . 9450E+00 .3390E+00 .1290E+01;.3390E+00 1425E+01'.2350E+00 .1900E+01 .1950E+00 .2000E+011.1600E+00 .5000E+01 1600E+00 CPECTEDBE TABLE (SPECTRUN GROUP 1 Y-DIRECTION) 33 as6.'00 1.1000E-01 .1650E+00 '.2000E-01 .1650E+00 . .. .3000E-01 .2950E+00 .3300E-01:.2950E+00 . 3500E-01 .4150E+00 .3800E-01. 4150E+00 - .4200E-01 .6000E+00 .4500E-01 .6000E+00 .5000E-01 8750E+00 .6800E-01 .8750E+00 . .7700E-01 .6250E+00 i' .8500E-01. 1000E+01 .8900E-01 .1000E+01 .9500E-01 .1400E+01 .1280E+00 .1400E+01 .1570E+00 .4000E+00
) .18COE+00 .4000E+00
.1850E+00 .5000E+00 .2510E+00 .5000E+00 .2550E+00 .4520E+00 .2880E+00 .4520E+00 - .3360E+00 .3600E+00 /
[ .4200E+00 .3600E+00 ) [ B-43
BENCHMARK PROBLEM - ISM BM-4 APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM4-13 l
.4400E+00 .3400E+00 .5000E+00 .3400E+00 , .5450E+00 .2650E+00 .6000E+00 .2550E+00 .6450E+00 .2550E+00 .1290E+01 .1410E+00 j .1643E+01 .1150E+00 l .1650E+01 .1150E+00 . 2000E+01 .8000E-01 .5000E+01 .8000E-01 i SPECTRUM TABLE (SPECTRUM ' GROUP 1 Z-DIRECTION) j 30 386.00 . .1000E-01 .2250E+00
) .2000E-01 .2250E+00
.3100E-01 .5000E+00 l .3700E-01 .1100E+01 .4000E-01 .1150E+01 .5800E-01 .1150E+01 .6300E-01 .8500E+00 .7100E-01 .7550E+00 .7900E-01 '.6200E+00 .8800E-01 .6200E+00 .1040E+00 .1050E+01 .1350E+00 .1050E+01 .1520E+00 .8750E+00 .1590E+00 .7000E+00 .1700E+00 .7000E+00 .1750E+00 .6400E+00 ; .1900E+00 .6400E+00 i .2000E+00 .1150E+01 . 3000E+00 .1150E+01 .3850E+00 .4960E+00 .4750E+00 .4960E+00 .5250E+00 .4350E+00 .5750E+00 .4350E+00 .6300E+00 .2800E+00 .6410E+00 .3050E+00 * .9600E+00 .3050E+00 .1050E+01 .2400E+00 .1900E+01 .1670E+00 .2000E+01 .1500E+00 .5000E+01 .1500E+00 SPECTRUM TABLE (SPECTRUM GROUP '2 X-DIRECTION) 19 386.00 .1000E-01 .9000E-01 .3000E-01 .9000E-01 .5200E-01 .2500E+00 .6000E-01 .3000E+00
- i
.8000E-01 .3000E+00 , .1000E+00 .2300E+00 B-44
( BENCHMARK PROBLEM - ISM BM-4 APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM4-14 I 11
.1300E+00 .3500E+00 t .1800E+00 .3500E+00 .1950E+00 .2900E+00 .2200E+00 .3500E+00 .3100E+p0 .3900E+00 .-
I .4300E+00 .4700E+00
.5700E+00 .4700E+00 .8000E+00 .3100E+00 .1050E+01 .3100E+00
~l .1100E+01 .2500E+00 5 .1750E+01 .2200E+00
.2000E+01 .1500E+00 .50COE+01 .1500E+00 I SPECTRUM TABLE (SPECTRUM GROUP 2 Y-DIRECTION) 17 386.00 .1000E-01 .1940E+00
~
-r .3400E-01 .1940E+00 .3600E-01 .8500E+00 .4500E-01 .8500E+00 .4700E-01-.7600E+00 I .5800E-01 .7600E+00 ' .6000E-01 .5000E+00 .7500E-01 .5000E+00 .9100E-01 .2600E+01 I .1200E+00 .2600E+01 .1800E+00 .4700E+00 .2200E+00 .4700E+00 2
l
.2300E+00 .5250E+00 I. .2700E+0.0 .5250E+00 .1500E+01 .1250E+00 .2000E+01 .8500E-01 I .5000E+01 .8500E-01 SPECTRUM TABLE (SPECTRUM GROUP 2 Z-DIRECTION) 19 386.00 .1000E-01 .9000E-01 .3000E-01 .9000E-01 I. .5200E-01 .2500E+00 .6000E-01 .3000E+00 .8000E-01 .3000E+00 I .1000E+00 .2300E+00 .1300E+00 .1800E+00 .3500E+00 .3500E+00 I .1950E+00 .2200E+00 .2900E+00 .3500E+00 .3100E+00 .3900E+00 .4300E+00 .4700E+00 I- .5700E+00 .4700E+00 .8000E+00 .3100E+00 * .1050E+01 .3100E+00 .1100E+01 .2500E+00 I
B-45 Il
1 BENCHMARK PROBLEM - ISM BM-4 APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM4-15
.1750E+01 .2200E+00 q .2000E+01 .1500E+00 .5000E+01 .1500E+00 SPECTRUM TABLE (SPECTRUM GROUP 3 X-DIRECTION) 4 18 386.00 ' .1000E-01 .1100E+00 .2600E-01 .1200E+00 . 3200E-01 .2700E+00 j .4000E-01 .2700E+00 i .4200E-01 .3000E+00 , .5600E-01 .3000E+00 .7000E-01 .8000E+00, 1 .9500E-01 .8000E+00 j .1200E+00 .3200E+00 .1850E+00 .3400E+00 .2100E+00 .2800E+00 .2400E+00 .7300E+00 .3300E+00 .7300E+00 .3400E+00 .5000E+00 .5800E+00 .5200E+00 .1730E+01 .2300E+00 l .2000E+01 .1600E+00 .5000E+01 .1600E+00 i SPECTRUM TABLE (SPECTUM GROUP 3 Y-DIRECTION) j 18 386.00 .1000E-01 .1200E+00- .4300E-01 .1400E+00 ( .6000E-01 .1400E+00 a .8000E-01 .4700E+00 .1200E+00 .4300E+00 ; .1600E+00 .4300E+00 .1700E+00 .4000E+00 I .1850E+00 .5200E+00 .2500E+00 .5200E+00 i .2950E+00 .4200E+00 . .4100E+00 .4000E+00 .43COE+00 .3500E+00 .5200E+00 .3500E+00 .7000E+00 .2000E+00 .8000E+00 .1900E+00 .1720E+01 .1100E+00 .2000E+01 .8000E-01 .5000E+01 .8000E-01 SPECTRUM TABLE (SPECTRUM GROUP 3 Z-DIRECTION) 18 386.00 i .1000E-01 .1100E+00 l .2600E-01 .1200E+00 - .3200E-01 .2700E+00 .4000E-01 .2700E400 .4200E-01 .3000E+00 l B-46 i
i w
- BENCHMARK PROBLEM ' - ISM BM-4 ' APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM4-16 1
I
.5600E-01 .3000E+00 .7000E-01 .8000E+00 ' .9500E-01 .8000E+00 .1200E+00 .3200E+00 .. .1850E+00 .3400E+00- .2100E+00 .2800E+00 i .2400E+00'.7300E+00 " ~.3300E+00 .7300E+00 * *
- )
.3400E+00 .5000E+00 .5800E+00 .5200E+00 . ] .1730E+01 .2300E+00 -.2000E+01 .1600E+00. .5000E+01. 1600E+00: .i . SPECTRUM TABIZ - (SPECTRUM GROUP 4 X-DIRECTION) 19 386.00 .1000E-01 .1600E+00. .2600E-01 .1700E+00 .3100E-01:.3000E+00 .3800E-01 .3000E400 .4200E-01'.4600E+00 .5900E-01 .4600E+00 .7100E-01 .1310E+01' .9600E-01 .1310E+01 .1300E+00 .3000E+00 .1950E+00 .2900E+00 .2400E+00. 1500E+01 3 . 3200E+00. 1500E+01 .3400E+00 .8100E+00 l . 4500E+00=.5500E+00 , .5800E+00 .5500E+00 .8000E+00 .3200E+00 .1730E+01 .2300E+00 ' .2000E+01 .1600E+00 .5000E+01 .1600E+00 = SPECTRUM' TABLE (SPECTRUM GROUP 4 Y-DIRECTION) 18 386.00 .1000E-01. 1400E+00 .5500E-01 .1900E+00 .8000E-01 .9000E+00 .1100E+00 .9000E+00 .1250E+00 .5200E+00 .1600E+00 .5200E+00 .1750E+00 4500E+00 .1870E+00'.5400E+00 .2500E+00 .5400E+00 .2900E+00 .4300E+00
- r. .3300E+00 .4300E+00 .
.4100E+00 .4000E+00 .4300E+00 .3600E+00 .5200E+00 .3600E+00 l
l B-4:7
BENCHMARK PROBLEM - ISM BM-4 APPENDIX B PAGE: ISM-BM4-17
.6400E+00 .2000E+00 .1710E+01 .1100E+00 .2000E+01 .8000E-01 , .5000E+01 .8000E-01 SPECTRUM TABLE (SPECTRITM GROUP 4 Z-DIRECTION) 19 386.00 .1000E-01 .1600E+00 . .2600E-01 .1700E+00 ; .3100E-01 .3000E+00 .3800E-01 .3000E+00 * .4200E-01 .4600E+00 . 59 00E-01 . 4 600E+00- .7100E-01 .1310E+01 .. .9600E-01 .1310E+01 .1300E+00 .3000E+00 .1950E+00 .2900E+00- .2400E+00 .1500E+01 1 .3200E+00 .1500E+01 .3400E+00 .8100E+00 .4500E+00 .5500E+00 . 5800E+00 .5500E+00 .8000E+00 .3200E+00 .1730E+01 .2300E+00 .2000E+01 .1600E+00 j .5000E+01 .1600E+00 300 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 17 18 q
10000. 10000. 10000. 10000. 1000. 1.0 0.05 0.05 I 0.0 0.0 2 1 1 1 -1 0 l l 4 I I l B-48 1
), ) I i { ) ) 4 1 l APPENDIX C: { 1 Comparison Summary of Uniform Benchmark Problems l I e i I _l i i l I l l
)
1 1 i l C-1 i
By: Date: Chkd: Date: I e-BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.1, PAGE:BM1-1 i 1 I BENCHMARK-PROBLEM NO.1 GAPPIPE VERSION 2.0 l l NATURAL FREQUENCIES ______________________________________________________- 3 l MODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE i NO. (1) (2) ( (2)-(1) )/ (1) *100% . , 1 28.53 28.54 0.02 ! 2 55.77 55.77 0.00 4
-3 81.50 81.50 0.00 4 141.70 141.74 0.03 5 162.80 162.82 0.01 I --- MODAL PARTICIPATION FACTORS ---- .
_____________________________________________ i l 'X-DIRECTION 'l MODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE I NO. (1) (2) ((2)-(1) )/(1) *100% a 1 0.1752 -0.17525 0.03 , 2 0.3628 -0.36281 0.00 3 -0.05397 -0.05397 0.00 4 .0.08361 0.08361' O.00 d 5 -0.07925 -0.07925 0.00
--- MODAL PARTICIP5 TION FACTORS ---- 3 l Y-DIRECTION l MODE ' NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE NO. (1) -(2) ((2)-(1) )/(1) *100%
1 -0.02593 0.02593 0.00 2 -0.002074 0.00207 -0.19 3 -0.2582 -0.25818. -0.01 o 4 -0.05268 -0.05268 0.00 l 5 0.06605 0.06606 0.02 C-2
'By: Date:' ,,Chkd: Date:
b BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.O, ' UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.1, ' PAGE: BM1-2 i --- MODAL PARTICIPATION FACTORS ---- l 'Z-DIRECTION l MODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE , j NO. (1) (2) ( (2)-(1) ) / (1) *100% 1 -0.3308 0.33031 0.00 2 0.1478 -0.14775 -0.03 ) 3 0.02793 0.02793 0.00
- i. 4- -0.01174 -0.01174- 0.00 ~
5 -0.01115 -0.01115 0.00 l i
,l L- >
j
, NODAL DISPLACEMENT -
J l X-DIR. DISPLACEMENT l NODE NUREG GAPPIPE ~
% DIFFERENCE :
NO. (1) (2) ____ ______ ______ ______ ((2)-(1))/(1) *100% 1 0.00000E+00 .. N/A 2.2.04357E-03 0.0020 -2.13 3 5.89413E-03 0.0059- 0.10
.4.7.41387E 0.0074 -0.'19 -
5 7.83967E-03 0.0078 -0.51 ' 6 7.83822E-03 0.0078 -0.49 ) 7 7.83621E-03 0.0078 -0.46
.8 5.82150E-03 0.0058.. -0.37 9 2.2306?E-03 0.0022 -1.37. .
10 6.24073E-04 0.0006 -3.86 11 0.00000E+00 N/A NODAL DISP 1ACEMENT l Y-DIR. DISPLACEMENT l NODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE NO. (1) (2) ((2)-(1) )/(1) *100% 1 0.00000E+00 N/A 2 2.10823E-06 0.0000 N/A 3 4.20722E-06 0.0000 N/A 4 6.12191E-04 0.0006 -1.99 5.1.63235E-03 0.0016 -1.98 6 2.11587E-03 0.0021 -0.75 '
.7 2.49629E-03 0.0025 0.15 8 1.99362E-03 0.0020 0.32 9 7.39284E-04 0.0007 -5,31 10 1.98397E-04 0.0002 0.81 11 0.00000E+00 Id/A C-3
By: 'Date: Chkd:__ Date: 1 BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.1, PAGE:BM1-3 4 NODAL DISPLACEMENT l Z-DIR. DISPLACEMENT- l NODE- NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE. 4 NO. (1) (2) ((2)-(1) )/ (1) *100% i 1 0.00000E+00 M/A . 2 4.86378E-03. 0.0049 0.74 ' 3 1.46073E-02 0.0146 -0.05 4 4 1.74471E-02 0.0174 -0.27 5 1.42699E-02 0.0143 0.21 6 f.05968E-02 0.0106 0.03 J 7 6.83757E-03 0.0068 -0.55 8 1.68145E-03 0.0017 1.10
. 9 7.69032E-06 0.0000 N/A 10-3.84537E-06 0.0000 N/A~
11 0.00000E+00 N/A' NODAL ROTATION l X-DIR. ROTATION l 1 NODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE No. .(1) (2) ((2)-(1))/(1) *100% z 1 0.00000E+00 N/A 2 1.53224E-04 0.0002 30.53 3.1.84130E-04 0.0002- 8.62 . 1 4 1.44572E-04 0.0001 -30.83 , 5 1.13684E-04 - 0.0001 -12.04 6 1.01589E-04 0.0001 -1.56 7 8.95652E-05 0.0001 11.65 8 6.93439E-05 0.0001 44.21 9 3.35482E-05 0.0000 N/A 10 1.83133E-05' O.0000 N/A ) 11 0.00000E+00 N/A o 1 C-4 i. _..__.m._._ _ _ _ . . . _ . . _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _
By:' Dato: Chkd: Date: BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.1, PAGE:BM1-4 ) i NODAL ROTATION ) l Y-DIR. ROTATION l NODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE ' ) NO. (1) (2) ( (2) -(1) )/ (1) *100% 1 0.00000E+00 N/A 2 5.60049E-05 0.0001 78.56 L 3 1.12010E-04 0.0001 -10.72 i 4 1.51908E-04 0.0002. 31.66 5 2.02321E-04 0.0002 -1.15 6 2'.10497E-04 0.0002 -4.99 7 2.12142E-04 0.0002. -5.72 8 1.80566E-04 0.0002 10.76 - 9 9.65399E-05 0.0001 3.58 10 5.57923E-05 0.0001 79.24 11 0.00000E+00 N/A NODAL ROTATION - l Z-DIR. ROTATION l l NODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE NO. (1) (2) ((2)-(1))/(1) *100% ). 1 0.00000E+00 N/A 2 6.29377E-05 0.0001 58.89 3 7.01236E-05 0.0001 42.61 4 5.07153E-05 0.0001 97.18 . 5 3.02036E-05 0.0000 N/A ,, 6 2'.43603E-05 0.0000 N/A . 7 1.86710E-05 0.0000 N/A 8 8.62004E-06 0.0000 N/A 9 7.56499E-06 0.0000 N/A 10 3;78250E-06 0.0000 'N/A > 11 0.00000E+00 N/A C-5
Dy: Date: Ded: Oste: SENCNwKIM', C#WM 2.0, LAIF001 $MCTRA PIEBLfM DO.1 -**----*-PAE.*st1-5 BEND 9WK PEOBLDt 10.1, QBeff STIE35ES CAPPIPE 90tstCN 2.0 ILREG RERATS ElJM PM(1) W(I) W I) TM(1) Mf(I) It(I) PM(4/C) W(J/C) V2(J/C) TX(J/C) Nf(J/C) MZ(J/C) *f
- 10. PN(J) W(J) W J) TX(J) Mr(J) SE(J) 14.95SM10 3.60E41 1.7BEMM 6.296E4R 1.3ME4 3.227E4 4.958E*00 34GE*01 1.7tBE416.29eE@ 4.732E@ 1.3o0E4 2 4.936E*00 2.967E*01 1.3f4416.296E*02 4.732E41.200E6 4.15dE*00 2.967E41 1.344E*016.296E*02 3A86E*02 4.50E*02 3 4JB1E*00 7.318E400 7A5E*00 6.2NE*02 4 AGE *02 3A86E*G2 5.05dE*00 7.19E@ 7E5E400 4.279E*02 6.53EMI2 3.00E412 5.915E*00 6.511E400 7R5E*001A21E@ 8.2BGE4I2 2 AGE *02 4 9.300EG 9.25DE*C01.00041 1 A21E4 SAIEeGt 2 AGE 41.157E41 L154E*001.0EIE*01 1.GME*02 7.3EEG 2.542E4 1.25E414.3tBE4001.0GE414.2571!412 5A1EE4 2AMG
,51.71E3E451A2BE*001J8BE*014.257E4It 5A10E6 241E*G21.750E417JanF4001J8BE414.257 EMIT 4.207E4 2A4E4 6 2.23dE41 1J52E*00 2.06dE414.257E4 4.2D7EeG2 2A4E*G2 2.2BIE41 1 A2E*00 2.06dE414.257E*G2 4.914E4 2ASIE@
7 2J20E412.3d7E413.919E*00 4.257E4 2ASIE*02 4.994E*G2 2AME412.531E*013.919E40 4444E*G2 8A5E416JdlE@ 2A7EE412.725E*013.919EMID 4.23dEeG2 2.180F4G2 8.731E4 8 2ACBE412.973E415.706E@ 4.23lEeG2 L180E@ 8.735E4 2JtE413.1daE415.70$E*00 3.0 DIE *G2 4.05EEG 1.1T7E4 2A01E413.1M4015.70dE401.130E*02 5A57E41.'EtE4 9 2AGEE417.11dE*00 3A10E41 1.133MI21.3BOE4 5A57E4 2AGIE45 7.11dE*00 3A10E41 1. TIE @ 1 AIE4 L50tE4 10 2.4GE417A72E*00 3A7tE411.130E41.STIE4 L50tE*G2 2AGIE41 TA72E400 3A7BE411.150E*02 2A77E*C5 7.7tdE432 j 1 apFPIPE M5tS10N 2.0 IEELis i R BI PN(!) W(I) tit (I) Ill(t) ge(I) st(I) PM(J/c) W(J/t} WJ/Q IX(J/t} str(J/C) SIf(J/C) 8E2. PM(J) W(J) idt(J) III(J) fer(J) 8E(J) 15A00E40 3J40E41 1.79tE41 L3lEeG21.31EeG5 3.*"2405 5.00E6 3J4Gi+01 1.7B0E41 L300E4 4.730E41.200E6 ( 2 4.900E40 2.970E451.34401 L'RIW402 A73E41.310E4 A900E*00 L970E4011.34tE41 L300E4 3A80E4 4 AGE 42 1
, 3 4.900E@ 7.30E*00 7.900E@ L300EeGt LORE *Gt 3ASIE4 5.10tE*00 7.200E40 7.90tE*00 4.EE*G2 6.55DE4 3AGtE*G2 5.900E@ A500E*00 7.900E401A20E*02 82EE4 2.90E4 q
4 9.310E@ 9.200E*001.060E411A20E*G2 8AEeC2 2.900E*G21.1 DOE 41 L20mM101.050E41 1.810E6 7.310E4 2.54GMI2 j 1.2ECE414.30E4001.000E*014.360E*G2 5A30E*G2 2410E412 51.780E41 EJ00E*001 A0E*014.3GCE*G2 5A20E6 2410EMI21.780E412J00E4101A0E4014.360E@ 4.21E*G2 2 AGE 4 6 2.250E41 1.7 TEE *00 2 AGE 414.3GOE*G2 4.21tE*G2 2ADE412 2.2EE41 1.700E*00 2ADE45 4.34GHI2 4.910E4 2AdGE@ 7 2A20E412.370E413.900E*00 4.360E4 2AdGE*02 4.990E*02 2 ACE *012.550E413.900E*00 4A40E*G2 8.7EDE416ADE412 I 2A80E412.720E413.900E400 4.2EIE4 2.1EE*G2 8.730E42 8 2A10E412.970E415.700E*00 L250EeG2 2.1EDE4 8.730aC 2.EltE413.1dGE415.700E*00 3.000E4 4 AGE *021.117E4 j 2A00E413.140E*015.700E+001.130E*G2 5A40E*021.381E45 j 9 2A00E41 7.100E410 3A10E*01 1. TIE *021.3EE*G5 5 A4E402 2 Acte 417.10mMID 3A1E41 1. TIE *G21.8 PIE 4 L501E*02 10 2A00E417.500E40 3A80E411.1XIE*G21A1E4 L500E*G2 2A00E417.5tDE*00 3A80E41 1.1XE*02 2A7EE4 7.760E*G2 1 ( ~ 1 1 C-6 l l
By: Date: Okf: Date: CDofWKlec (#PIFZ 2.0, istifGN SP2CTRA MWLIM W.1 - - - PAE:Df1-6 I 1 PetCDnAE DifFTROGS ECTWIN 801G Ao C#91K ERSICN 2.0 (BA2D of autEr.): = ELDi PX(I) W(1) V2(1) TX(I) *(I) N(1) PX(J/C) W(J/C) VZ(J/C) TX(J/C) M(J/C) NZ(J/C)
- m. PX(J) W(J) VZ(J) TX(J) M(J) N(J) 1 DE 0.M 0.11% 0.0SL -0.07% -05 OR -0.05K 0.17% 0.06% -0.06% 0.02 '.
I 2 3
-0.73%
0.37% 0.25% 0.12
-0.25% -0.17%
4 335 0.32% 0.32K 0.0SE 0.06E
-0.07% -0.06%
0.02
-os 0.02 0.11%
0.a5K
-CR CJI?%
WA 0.10E 0.tBK WA
-0.32 0.32%
WA 0.06% 0.021 WA
-0.15 f.tBK WA 0.00%
0.10K WA 4 0.05E I 0.02 -0.42K -0.25K 4.07% -0.tEK 0.05% 0.25K 0.75% 0. 2 55 0.22% -0.07% 0.1&. 4 12% -0.25E 0.07% 0.02% -0.11% WA WA WA WA WA M - 5 0.GR -1.07% 0.12% 0.07% 0. tex 415 0.00K -1,07% 0.12% 0.07% 0.07% -0.15K 6 0.18K 2.9tX 4.08E 0.19% 0.07% 0.07% -0.15K 0.18K 2.91% 0.19% 0.07% 0.06% 7 0.00E 0.1R 445E 0.07% 0.06% 40SE ' 0. m 0.0EX -0.6 -0.09% 0.06K 0.tBK
.8 0. m 0. m -0.655 OR 0.Gx 40sE WA WA WA WA WA e 8 0.08K -0.10K -0.11% 0.095 0.00K 4 0sK 0.17% -0.ost -0.11% -0.tBK 0.0S% 0.00K
- 0. M I
0.06% 4 .10% -0.11% 0.00% 0.0$K WA WA WA WA WA WA g 9 4.055 -0.22% 0.00E 0.00K C.0E 0.05E -0.08E -0.22% 0.00E 0.GE 0.00E -0.02% %__ 10 -0.0 55 0.37% 0.06K 0.00E 0.00E 0.02% 0.0BK 0.37% 0.0SK 0.GR -0.04% 4 0SE I I I I I I 1 8 I I I I C-7 I
,= _ _ _ - _ - - - _ _ - - _ _ - _ - - - _ _ _ _ _ - _ . - _ _ _ - _ - - - _ - . - - . - - _ _ - _-- -
.By: .Date: :Chkd: Date: f BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM No.2, PAGE:BM2-l' BENCHMARK-PROBLEM NO.2 .GAPPIPE VERSION 2.0 NATURAL FREQUENCIES MODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE i'
NO. (1) (2) ( (2)-(1) ) / (1) *100% l 1 8.712 8.712 0.00 l 2 8.806 8.806 0.00. 3 - 17.510 17.508 ' -0.01 4' '40.370 40.367 -0.01 5 41.630 41.626 -0.01
---- MODAL PARTICIPATION FACTORS ---- 4 l X-DIRECTION
______________________________________________________l . MODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE t i
' NO . (1) -(2) ((2)-(1) )/(1) *100%
1 6.0660E-01 0.60657 -0.004 ( 2 3.7490E-08 0 N/A j 3 -3.2360E-11 0 N/A 5
~ 4 -2.7810E-14 0 N/A. ,
5 2.1920E-15 0 N/A l I
---- NODAL PARTICIPATION FACTORS ----
l Y-DIRECTION l ; MODE NUREG GAPPIPE 4 DIFFERENCE NO. (1) (2) ((2)-(1) )/(1) *100% :
. _____,________________ _____________________________ t 1 4.8140E-17 0 N/A 2 -9.5410E-18 0 N/A i 3 3.4480E-17 0 N/A i 4 -8.7280E-03 -0.00873 0.02% -
5 2.4500E-03 -0.00245 0.00% 1 1 C-8 I
- _ - _ _ = _ - _ _ _ _ _-__._ - - __-__ _ -_-__ _ _____ - - _ - _ - _ - _ - _ 'By: .Date:
- Chkd: Date:
b BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.2, PAGE:BM2-2 )' p
---- MODAL PARTICIPATION FACTORS ----
l l Z-DIRECTION l l MODE NUREG GAPPIPE 4 DIFFERENCE I- NO. (1) (2) ( (2) -(1) )/ (1) *100% 1 2.1940E-07 0 N/A f 2 -6.0740E-01 -0.60741 0.00% P 3 6.0860E-12 0 N/A 4 -9.5470E-16 0 N/A-f 5 '9.0420E-14 0 N/A i NODAL DISPLACEMENT l X-DIR. DISPLACEMENT l NODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE
~
NO. (1) (2) ((2)-(1) )/ (1) *100% ,, - 1 2.30252E-01 0.2302 -0.02% > 2 2.30252E-01 0.2302 -0.02% 3 2.30252E-01 0.2302 -0.02% 4 2.30252E-01 0.2302 -0.024' 5 4.61837E-01 0.4618 -0.01% 6 4.61880E-01 0.4618~ -0.02% 7 4.61837E-01 0.4618 -0.01% 8 4.61839E-01 0.4618 -0.01% > 9 4.61839E-01 0.4618 -0.01% > 10 4.61837E-01 .0.4618 -0.01% ,, 11 4.61880E-01 0.4618 -0.02% 12 4.61837E-01 0.4618 -0.01%
-13 4.61839E-01 0.4618 -0.01%
14 4.61839E-01 0.4618 -0.01%- 15 0.00000E+00 N/A 16 0.00000E+00 N/A 17 0.00000E+00 N/A 18 0.00000E+00 N/A C-9
- _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _L
By: Date: Chkd: Date: / p BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.2, PAGE:BM2-3 3 J NODAL DISPLACEMENT l Y-DIR. DISPLACEMENT
--_-_---_---__---__-__-----_-___-----_-____-__-_-_--_l NODE- NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE i 4 NO- (1) (2) ( (2)-(1) ) / (1) *100%
_____-__-____,-__-___--_-___--__--__--__-_----_-_--__ j 1 1.27820E-03 0.0013 1.71% 2 1.2782CE-03 0.0013 1.71% 3 1.27820E-03 0.0013 1.71% )i 4 1.27820E-03 0.0013 1.71% 5 2;52097E-03 0.0025 -0.83% 6 9.78271E-04 0.001 2.22% j 7 2.52097E-03 0.0025 -0.83% 8 3.32646E-03 0.0033 -0.80% 9 3.32647E-03 0.0033 -0.80% 10 2.52097E-03 0.0025 -0.83% - 11 9.78271E-04 0.001 2.22%
- 12 2.52097E-03 0.0025 -0.83% 1 13'3.32646E-03 0.0033 -0.80%
14 3.32647E-03 0.0033 -0.80% 15 0.00000E+00 N/A 16 0.00000E+00 N/A 17 0.00000E+00 N/A 18 0.00000E+00 N/A 1 NODAL DISPLACEMENT i ____- _- _____ = = _ - - __________ l Z-DIR. DISPLACEMENT l NODE- NUREG GAPPIPE .% DIFFERENCE NO. (1) (2) ((2)-(1) )/(1) *100% 1 2.25121E 0.2251 -0.01% 4 2 2.25121E-01 0.2251 ' -0.01% 3 2.25121E-01 0.2251 -0.01% 4 2.25121E-01 0.2251 -0.01% 5 4.46230E-01 0.4462 -0.01% 6 4.46231E-01 0.4462 -0.01% 7 4.46230E-01 0.4462 '- 0.01% 8 4.46391E-01 0.4463 -0.02% i 9 4.46391E-01 0.4463 -0.02% 10 4.46230E-01 0.4462 -0.01% 11 4.46231E-01 0.4462 -0.01% i 12 4.46230E-01 0.4462 -0.01% 13 4.46391E-01 0.4463 -0.02% 14 4.46391E-01 0.4463 -0.02% 4 15 0.00000E+00 N/A 16 0.00000E+00 N/A 17 0.00000E+00 N/A 18 0.00000E+00 N/A C-10
;By: Dato: ,,,Chkd: Date: ' BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM' NO.2, PAGE:BM2-4
)- I: NODAL ROTATION l X-DIR. ROTATION l l NODE- NUREG GAPPIPE -- % DIFFERENCE i
~
NO. (1) (2) - ( (2)-(1) ) / (1) *100% p _____________________________________________________ ) 1 6.53920E-03 0.0065 -0.60% 2 6.53920E-03 0.0065 -0.60% g -3 6.53920E-03 0.0065.; -0.60% [' 4 6.53920E-03. 0.0065 -0.60% 5 8;.85610E-04 0.0009 1.62% 6 5.29316E-05. 0.0001 GB.92% l 7 8.85610E-04 0.0009 1.62% I . 8 S.85601E-04 0.0009 1.63% 9 8.85602E-04 0.0009 1.63% > 10 8.85610E-04 0.0009 ' 1.62% 11 5.29316E-05 0.0001' 88.92% 12 8.85610E-04 0.0009 1.62% 13 8.85601E 0.0009 1.63% 14 8.85602E-04 0.0009 ,7 1.63% 15'O.00000E+00 N/A 16 0.00000E+00 N/A ? 17 0.00000E+00 N/A 18 0.00000E+00 .N/A , MODAL ROTATION l Y-DIR. ROTATION l ) NODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE ) NO. (1) (2) ((2)-11) )/ (1) *100% 1 7.38496E-06 0 N/A 2 7.38496E-06 0 N/A 3 7.38496E-06 0 N/A 4 7.38496E-06 0 N/A : 5 1.45668E-05 0 N/A 6 2.89914E-06 0 N/A 7 1.45668E-05 0 N/A 8 1.37162E-05 0 N/A ! L 9 1.37161E-05 0 N/A l 10 1.45668E-05 0 N/A l 11 2.89914E-06 0 N/A {' 12 1.45668E-05 0 N/A 13 1.37162E-05 0 N/A - 14-1.37161E-05 0 N/A 15 0.00000E+00 N/A 16 0.00000E+00 N/A .. 17 0.00000E+00 N/A 18 0.00000E+00 N/A C-11
f l By : ' Date: Chkd: Date: BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.2, PAGE:BM2-5 NODAL ROTATION l Z-DIR. ROTATION l NODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE - NO. (1) (2) ( (2)-(1) ) / (1) *100% i 1 6.72097E-03 0.0067 -0.314 2 6.72097E-03 0.0067 -0.31% 3 6.72097E-03 0.0067 -0.31% 4 6.72097E-03 0.0067 -0.31% 5 1;.11330E-03 0.0011 -1.19% 6 1.11324E-03 0.0011 -1.19% < 7 1.11330E-03 0.0011 -1.19% - 8 1.71920E-04 0.0002 16.33%. 9 1.71920E-04 0.0002 16.33% 10 1.11330E-03 0.0011 -1.19% 11 1.11324E-03 0.0011 -1.19% 12 1.11330E-03 0.0011 -1.19% 13 1.71920E-04 0.0002 16.33% 14 1.71920E-04 0.0002 , 16.33% 15 0.00000E+00 N/A -x 16 0.00000E+00 N/A 17 0.00000E+00 N/A 18 0.00000E+00 N/A 4
\
1 b C-12
er: Date: chi- Dett CoomtKluc CN9IPE 2.0, udlFoM mcTaA mnIM m.2 -~~~ PA&:se-6 i l l CNOMtK MREN so.2. neon sMssEs CW91PE WRSICN 2.0 tulEG ItERATS EfM PX(1) W(I) VZ(1) TX(1) M(I) MZ(1) PX(J/C) W(JK) V2(J/C) TX(J/C) M(J/C) SE(J/C) ~
- 10. PX(J) W(J) V2(J) 1X(J) M(J) SE(J) i 1 TR4E41.052E4321.(PJE*02 2.110E*C0 5.225E4 5. TEE *G5 7&4E*G21.082E4321.075EMI2 2.110E@ 2.352E*02 2.1BGE402
) 2 TA62E+02 7.M4E417.844E*012.110E*00 2.352E*02 2.1EGE*02 7.652E432 7.M4E41754E412.110E*00 4.0G9E*GI 4.062E405 3 7.334E*G) 4.66?E*021.275E*019.621E-02 7.39fl414.062E*G5 7.334E*00 4JdDE*G21.45E*019.621E4I2 3J00E415.550E41 ) 4 7.334E*00 4J67E41.275E*019421E4I2 3JdDE415.550E-017.354EMID 4.687E*021.275E419.621E412 7.33GE414.0G2E4 5 7.662E*02 7.M4E417.864E412.110E*00 4.0nGE4 4.062E4 7.652E*02 7.M4E*017A4E412.110E*00 2.352E*G2 2.1ESE*02 { 4 7A64E*021.05E*G21.075E4 Lt10EG 2.352E432 2.1EGEMI2 7.66fd*G21.052E41.0DE*02 2.110E*00 5.225E4 5. TEE 4 7 7.664E*G21.082E*021.0PE*02 2.110E@ 5.22EE4 5. TEE 4 7J64E4021.082EG 1.095E402 2.110E*00 2.352E*G2 2.1EGE4 8 7A62E*02 7.M4E*017.864E*01 L110E4D 2.312E*G2 2.1EGEMI2 7.652E4 7.154E*017.8G4E412.110E*00 4.0GGE4 4A2E4 ) 9 7.354EMD 4 A67E*021.275E*019J21E4It 7.39fd*014.062E405 7.354E*00 4E7E41.27E419.621E4It 3J00E*015.5EE41 10 7.354E*G) 4JdDEMI21.275E*019421E4It 3J00E4015.550E417.354EMID 4E7E*G21.275E4l 9.621E412 7.39EE4014.062E4 r 117A62E4 7.M4E*017.864E*012.110E400 4.0fAE*GI 4.0G2E4 TJ62E4 7.M4E417.864E*012.110E400 2.352E4 2.1EGE4 l 12 TJ64E*021.082E*G21.095E*02 2.110E410 2.352E4 LIBGE4 7J64E41.052E*021.095E4 L110E40 5.22EE4 5. TEE 4 0155E412.92*G21.34SE41 1 ACBE 02 7AEE*014E9E4125E*012.912E*G21.345E*01 1 A0BE4 5.3dSE41 1 A8dE4 , 4
% 6.560E*00 2.912EMI21.23BE@ 1ACBE4 5.345E4011A8dE4 6.560E*00 2.912E41.22E*001 AOBE4I2 5.34SE411 A8dE4 151.8P5*01 L972E*G21.345E41 1 ACBE4It 5.345E41 1 A8dE4'125E412.912 Edit 1.348E41 1 AGBE432 TA80E414.064E4 16 125E41 2.972EMI2 1.345E41 1 ACBE4It 7A80E41 4.014E4 155E41 2.972E4 1.345E41 1 ACBE-02 5.345E41 1 A8dE*05 17 6.56CE410 E972E*021.228E*001 ACBE412 5.345E41 1 AtlE*G5 6.5dGE*00 L972E41.22E*001 ACBE412 5.345E41 1 A85E*G5
) S 155E41253E*G21.345E41 1 AGE 02 5.3G401 1 A9dE41.8BE4l 2.9241.545E*01 1 AGE 4 7AEE414.0GGE*G5 1 etPPIPE igitBION 2.0 IERAT5 IIJM PHCI) W(I) ist(!) IM(I) ser(I) DE(I) PM(A C W(4Q idE(J/C) 1X(4Q Sir (J/C) flE(J/C) ,
- 10. PIGCJ) W(J) ilz(J) TX(J) ser(J) IPXJ)
! 17A65E*G21.052E4021M5E*G2 220E*00 5.22EE4 5. TEE 4 7A65E@ 1.052E@ 1.095E@ 2.000E*00 2.35GHI2 2.7/DE*02 1 2 7J61E*02 7.M0E*017.860E41 L000E40 2.31GKI2 2.770E*02 7J61E*02 7.MGE*017.860E*012.000E*00 4.0G9E4 4.0G2E*G5 3 7.3DE@ 4J85E*021.270E410.00tE*00 7A00E*014.062E*05 7.3XE40 4J8dE*021.270E410.000E400 3J0E411.000E@ 4 7.330E*00 4A8dE*G21.270E*010.000E40 3J00E481.GXE*00 7.30CE*00 4A85E*021.270E*010.000E*00 7A00E414.0G2E4 5 7461E*G2 7.M0E41 TAGE412.000E*00 4.0fdtMI5 4.042E4 TA61E*02 7.M0E417 AGE 412.000E40 250E4 2.770E*G2 6 7A6E*G21.05E*021E5E4 LOODE*00 2.310E402 2.770E*G2 TA6MMI21.082EMI21.0DE4 2.000E*00 5.22E4 5. TEE 4 7 TJ65E41.052E*G21R5E42 2.00tE@ 5.22EE4 5. TEE 405 7J65EMI21.CS2E*021.095EMI2 2.000E*00 2.390E*G2 2.770E4 8 7461E*02 7.M0E417.860E+012.000E410 2.3iE4 2.77tE*02 7.661E*G2 7.MOE417 AGE *012.000EMID 4.0GGE4 4.0G2E4 9 7.332KD 4A8dE41.270E410.0CCE*00 7A00E*014.0G2E*03 7.300E*UD 4JedE*021.270E*010.000E*00 3J00E*011.000Edl0 10 7.300E*C0 4A8dE*021.270E*01020E@ 3.600E411.000E*00 7.300E@ 4JBIEG 1.270E410.000E410 7A00E4014.062E*G5 117A61E402 7.MOE*017.84(E412.000E*00 4.0G9E4 4AE4 7J61E*G2 7.MOE417.860E45 2.002400 2.3 ICE 42 2.770E*02 f 12 7.65E4G21.052E*021.095E*02 2.000E*00 2.350E42 2.710E*02 7J65E*G21.!EI@ 155E@ 2.M@ 5.22E*G5 5. TEE *G5 j 13150E412.972E*021.34E410.00Z*00 7.500E414A9E*05150E412.972E*G21.3ME410.000E*00 5.3DE41 1 A85E4 14 6J00E4X) 2.972E4021.200E*00 0.00E400 5.300E41 1 A86E*05 6J00E*G) 2.912E*021.200E*00 0.0CCE*GO 5.3DE41 1 A85E*G5 15150E412.972E*021.340E410.GXE*00 5.3XE41 1 A85E+G51.8XE412.972E*021.340E410.000E+00 7.500E*014.0G9E+G5 16150E412.972E*021.340E*01 CEDE *C0 7.500E414A9E4150E412.972E*G21.340E410.00I*00 5.300E41 1 A85E4 17 6J00E*00 2.972E*021.200E*CD 02E400 5.300E41 1 A85r*G3 6J01400 2.972E4021.200E400 0.0CDE*00 5.30141 1 A8dE*G5 16 t I
. i
Dy: Date: DM Deta: k SOOMtKiC CMPIN 2.0, Lk!FON SMCTRA HGLIN 60.2 -- --- PAI:942.T 1 PIXDITAE DIFFDDrIs aEELIN NMC #O CMP 14 MR$10i 2.0 (PA7D Od itREC): ElIM PX(I) W(1) V2(l) TX(t) Mr(l) MZ(I) PX(J/C) Vr(J/C) VZ(J/C) TX(J/C) Mr(J/C) MZ(J/C) to. PX(J) W(J) VZ(J) TX(J) Mr(J) NZ(J) 1 -0.01% 0.00t 0.00E -5.2t% -0. TEE 0.02 -0.01% 0.00E 0.00E -5.21% -0.09% 0.or,X .< 2 -0. m -0. m 0. m -5.2:1 .cm 0.0Gx 0.01% 0.m -0.csx -5.21: 0.ca 0. m j s -0. a -Om 0.wx WA 02 0.02 0.6 -0.WK WA
-0.02% 0. M 80 R 4 -0. M 4 .02% -0.37E WA Om 80.83E 0. 6 4.02K -0.3PX WA 0. M 0.00E 5 -0.0t% -0.t5x -0.051 -5.21% Om 0.00K 4 .01% 4 .05% -0.05x 4.2n -0.0PX 0.0G1 6 4.0tx 0.00E 0.00K +5.21% -0.0E 0.06% 0.011 0.00K 0.00K -5.21% 0.02% 0.00E 7 -0.01% 0.05 0.m -5.2tK -0.tEK 0.m 4 .01% 0. M 0.02 -5.21% -0.0PX 0.tMX 8 4 .011 4.0SE 4.05K 0.09E 4.05K 4m 0.02 5.21% 0.0GK 4 .01% -5.21% 0. m 9 4.6 -0.02K 4.3R 'WA 0.0K 0.03 -0M 4.02% -0.3R WA 0.00E 80.85K {
10 -0. 6 4. TEE 4.3PK WA 0.0E CM ED.83E 4. TEE 4.3PX WA 0.08K 0.0tK 11 -0.01% 4R 0.05E -5.215 0.0K 0.00E 4 .01% 4.05K 0m ,5.21% 4.0PK 0.tMX 12 -0.011 0.00K 0.00K 5.21% 0.0K 0.0GX 0.0tX 0.00K c.03 -5.21x -0. TEE 0.00K 13 -0. m 0.tXK 0.37% WA 0.27% 0.00E 0.idK 0.00E 4.3PX WA 4.8GE 0.00K M 041E 0.00K -2 31E WA 0.8CE 0.00E Catz 0.00K -2.3K WA 4.8GK 0.05 15 0.1dz 0.02 -0.37% WA -0.8G1 0.tIK -0.1dK 0.00K 4.37% WA 0.2?E 0.03 16 0.idt 0.00E 4.371 WA 0.27% 0.00E -0.idK 0.EK -0.3 71 WA 0.8GK 0.CtX 17 041% 0.00E -2.2EE WA 0.8GE 0.00E 041% 0.CtX -2.2EE WA 0.8GK 0.05 16 WA ' WA WA WA WA WA WA WA WA WA WA WA ; i l i t I l C-14
By: Date: 'Chkd: D:te: BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0,'UN.tFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.3, PAGE:BM3-1 1 1 f l BENCHMARK PROBLEM NO.3 GAPPIPE VERSION 2.0 NATURAL FREQUENCIES r , MODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE NO. (1) (2) ( (2)-(1) ) / (1) *100% 1 9.360 9.36 0.00%
-0.03%
l 2 12.710 12.706 3 15.380 15.377 -0.02% 4 : 17.800 17.797 -0.02%
'S 21.600 21.604 0.02%
6 25.100 25.099 -0.00% 7 32.030 32.035' O.024 -l 8 38.070 38.07 0.00% 9 40.290 40.294 0.01% 10 48.900 48.899 -0.00%
---- MODAL PARTICIPATION FACTORS ----
j X-DIRECTION l MODE NUREG GAPPIPE 4' DIFFERENCE NO. -(1) -(2) ((2)-(1))/(1) *100% F 1 1.0040E+00 1.00399 -0.00% 2 -2.5240E-01 0.25242 0.01% 3 -1.4270E+00 1.4269 -0.01% ) 4 -2.0130E-01 -0.20124 -0.03% ) 5.-4.6520E-01 -0.46521 0.00% 6 -1.3140E-01 0.13142 0.02% 7 -2.2580E-01 0.2258 0.00%- 8 1.0610E-01 -0.10605 -0.05% l 9 -8.3230E-01 0.82229 -0.00% 10 -4.5520E-01 -0.4552 0.00% I l ? )- . I f ) C-15 l'
By: -Date: Chkd: Data: BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.3, PAGE:BM3-2
---- MODAL PARTICIPATION FACTORS ----
r l Y-DIRECTION l MODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE : No. (1) (2) ( (2)-(1)-)/ (1) *100% 1 -7.0240E-02 -0.07024 0.00% l' 2 -1.8320E+00 1.83163 -0.02% l 3 2.0450E-01 -0.20444 -0.03% ! 4 -2.2590E-01. -0.22594 0.02% 5 -2.7860E -0.02787 0.04% 6 '9.3270E-02 -0.09327 0.00% 7 2.3630E-01 -0.23634' O.02% 8 1.7370E-03 -0.00173 -0. 4 0% 9 1.8010E-02 -0.01801 0.00% 10 -2.1880E-01 -0.2188 0.00%
---- MODAL PARTICIPATION FACTORS ---- ; ~
l Z-DIRECTION l MODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE No. (1) (2) ((2)-(1))/(1) *100% 1 9.7390E-01 0.97393 0.00% . 2 4.4220E-02 -0.04423 0.02% 3 2.2540E-01 -0.22545 0.02%
'4 -5.0950E-02 -0.05096 0.02% .I 5 ~7.7750E-01 -0.77748 -0.00% I 6 -1.3370E+00 1.33732 0.02%
7 4.6930E-01 -0.4693 0.00% ) 8 1.0920E-01 -0.10916 -0.04% 1 9 4.2070E -0.42067 -0.01% 10 1.6010E-01 0.16015 0.03% i i 4 C-16 I
ey I By: Date: .Chkd: Dato:
' BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.3, PAGE:BM3-3 l NODAL DISPLACEMENT
_______________-__________________-_______-- \ l X-DIR. DISPLACEMENT l NODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE .
'NO. (1) (2) ( (2 )-(1) )/ (1) *100%
2 2.74424E-02 0.0274 -0.15% 3 8.47772E-02 0.0848 0.034 ) 4 1.13928E-01 0.1139 -0.02% 5 1.25322E-01 0.1253 -0.02% j 6 1.25311E-01 0.1253 -0.01% 7 1.25294E-01 0.1253 0.00% 8 7.40846E-02 ,0.0741 0.024 l 9 1.13534E-05 0 N/A i 10 2.89916E-02 0.029 0.03% 11 5.41993E-02 0.0542 0.00% l 12 7.66464E-02 0.0766 -0.06% l 13 9.98969E-02 0.0999 ' 0.00% ! 14 2.24130E-01 0.2241 -0.01% 15 2.35596E-01 0.2355 -0.04% l 16 1.25693E-01 0.1257 0.01% l 17 0.00000E+00 0 N/A ! 18 7.68156E-02 0.0768- -0.02% l 19 7.66454E-02 0.0766 -0.06% 1 ) 20 3.M621E-02 0.0354 0.11% 21 0.00000E+00 N/A 22 0.00000E+00 N/A 23 0.00000E+00 N/A ) 24 0.00000E+00 N/A 25 0.00000E+00 N/A 26 0.00000E+00 N/A 27 0.00000E+00 N/A 28 0.00000E+00 N/A 3 29 0.00000E+00- N/A ' l C-17 1
By: Dste: ~ Chkd: Date:_. j BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.3, PAGE:BM3-4 NODAL DISPLACEMENT l Y-DIR. DISPLACEMENT _____________________________________________________l NODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE 1 1.54402E-08 0 N/A1 2 6.56707E-05~ 0.0001 52.274 3 1.31246E-04 0.0001 -23.81% l 4 1.29359E-02 0.0129 -0.28% 5 4.44900E-02 0.0445 0.02%
'6 i.59767E-02 0.066 0.04%
7 8.65619E-02 0.0865 -0.074 # 8 9.80058E-02 0.098 -0.014 9 7.92374E-02 0.0792 -0.05% 10 6.26359E-02 0.0626 -0.06% 11 5.13220E-02 0.0513 -0.04% 12 4.59076E-02 0.0459 -0.02% 13 4.06248E-02 0.0406 -0.06% 3 14 2.15424E-02 0.0215 -0.20% 15 4.24471E-04 0.0004 -5.774 16 2.11373E-04 0.0002 -5.38% 1
'17 0.00000E+00 0 N/A 18 7.87802E-02 0.0788 0.03%
19 8.17353E-02 0.0817 -0.04% . 20 2.35840E-02 0.0236 0.07% f 21 0.00000E+00 N/A 22 0.00000E+00 N/A 23 0.00000E+00 N/A $ 24 0.00000E+00 N/A . i 25 0.00000E+00 - N/A 26 0.00000E+00 N/A 27 0.00000E+00 N/A 28 0.00000E+00 N/A 29 0.00000E+00 N/A 1 4 ( I i C-18
Date:
'Chkd:
_ Date: W By: _ PAGE:BM3-5 ; BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.3, \
.l -_-_.."23^'._SI8"_S'"5"T Z-DIR. DISPLACEMENT l .
l GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE NODE NUREG E. NO. (1) (2) ( (2)-(1) )/ (1) *100%
- - . . . . . - - - - . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .0 . . - - - . . .N/A ....--.........--
1 4.63322E-08 -0.08% 0.0659 5 2 6.59521E-02 3 2.03664E-01 0.2036 -0.03% 0.2394 -0.04% 4 2s39490E-01 -0.00% 5 5 1.6640SE-01 0.1664 g 6 8.62422E-02 0.0862 -0.05% 7 1.85498E-05 0 N/A 0.1295 -0.06% i I 8 1.29572E-01 9 1.66289E-01 10 1.66533E-01 0.1663 0.1665 0.1667
-0.02% -0.04%
0.01% 11 1.66766E-01 I 1h'1 66987E-01 13 1.67132E-01 0.167 0.1671 0.1675
-0.02% -0.03%
0.01%
'14 1.67543E-01 -0.01%
15 1.68024E-01 0.168 0.1058 -0.07% 8 16 1.05872E-01 0 N/A 17 0.00000E+00 -0.07% 18 1.11073E 0.111 0.0476 -0.04% I 19 4.76205E-02 -2.55% 20 2.05242E-04 0.0002 21 0.00000E+00 N/A N/A I 22 0.00000E+00
- N/A 23 0.00000E+00 N/A 24 0.00000E+00 N/A 25 0.00000E+00 N/A 26 0.00000E+00 N/A 27 0.00000E+00 N/A 28 0.00000E+00 I 29 0.00000E+00 N/A E
8 . E I C-19 I _ _ - - - - - ~ - - - _ - - - _ _ _ _ _ _ , _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
i- . .- i . By: _ Date: 'Chkd: Date: BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO. 3, PAGE:BM3-6 NODAL ROTATION l X-DIR. ROTATION _____________________________________________________l . s NODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE NO. (1) (2) ((2)-(1)) _ _ _ _ __ _ _ _ _ _ _ _6_ _( 1 0.00000E+00 _ 0 N/A 2 2.10534E-03 0.0021 -0.25% !
'3 2.71028E-03 0.0027 -0.38%
4~2.37044E-03 0.0024 1.25% 5 f.94809E-03 0.0019 -2.47% , 6 1.79088E-03 0.0018 0.514-7 1.63618E-03 0.0016 -2.21% 8 1.42107E-03 0.0014 -1.48% S 1.09581E-03 0.0011 0.38% 10 9.25098E-04 0.0009 -2.71% 11 6.96896E-04 0.0007 0.45% 12 4.82658E-04 0.0005 3.59% j 13~4.55125E-04 0.0005 9.86% ' 14 4.41202E-04 0.0004 -9.34% 15'7.29864E-04 0.0007 -4.09% 16 1.65392E-03 0.0017 2.79% 17 2.10208E-03 0.0021 -0.10% 18 4.75351E-04 0.0005 5.19% < 19 8.44524E-04 0.0008 -5.274 20 9.290678-04 0.0009 -3.13% 21 0.00000E+00 N/A 22 0.00000E+00 .N/A i 23 0.00000E+00 N/A i 24 0.00000E+00 N/A 25 0.00000E+00 N/A 26 0.00000E+00 N/A. 27 0.00000E+00 N/A 28 0.00000E+00 N/A 29 0.00000E+00 N/A a i ( C-20
-By: Dste:
Chkd: -Date: [ BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM No.3, PAGE:BM3-7 NODAL ROTATION I
- l Y-DIR. ROTATION l
-NODE NUREG GAPPIPE 4 DIFFERENCE .
NO. (1) (2) ( (2)-(1) )/ (1) *100% l h 1 0.00000E+00 0 N/A l > '2 1.20018E 0.0012 '
-0.01%
- f. 3 2.40035E-03 0.0024' -0.01%
4 3.17197E-03 0.0032 0.88% 5.,4.31735E-03 0.0043 -0.40% 6 4.66347E-03 0.0047 0.78% 7 4.99380E-03 0.005 0.12% 8 4.37353E-03 0.0044 0.61% 9 1.60941E-03 0.0016 -0.58% l 10 1.36094E-03 . 0,0014 2.87% . 11 1.44345E-03 0.0014 -3.01% 12 1.51083E-03 0.0015 -0.72% f
-2.27%
! 13 1.84177E-03 0.0018 4 14 2.36092E-03 0.0024 ., 1.66% 15,2.29732E-03 0.0023 0.12% 1 16 2.29732E-03 0.0023 0.12% 17 2.29732E-03 0.0023 0.12% 18 1.58059E-03 0.0016- 1.23% - 19 1.69163E-03 0.0017 0.49% 20 1.28508E-03 '0.0013 1.16% 21 0.00000E+00 N/A-22 0.00000E+00 N/A ! . 23 0.00000E+00 N/A i l' 24'O.00000E+00 N/A 25'0.00000E+00 . N/A 26 0.00000E+00 N/A 27 0.00000E+00 N/A 28 0.00000E+00 N/A-
. 29 0.00000E+00 N/A i
l 1 C-21 l l t j
o By: Date: Chkd: Date: , i BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.3, PAGE:BM3-8 i NODAL ROTATION l Z-DIR ROTATION l ; NODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE. NO. (1) (2) ( (2) -(1) ) / (1) *100% { _______________________._____________________________ t 1 0.00000E+00 0 N/A 2 8.74451E-04 0.0009 2.92% 3 1.15789E-03 0.0012 3.64% 1 4 1.22819E-03 0.0012 -2.30% 5 1.24172E-03 0.0012 -3.36% 6 1.20837E-03 0.0012 -0.69% 7 1.14563E-03 3 0.0011 -3.98% I 8 9.52113E-04 'O.001 5.03% - 9 8.82206E-04 -0.0009 ' 2.02%
- 10 8.76265E-04 0.0009 2.71% >
11 9.06201E-04 0'.0009 -0.68% 12 9.68695E-04 0.001 3.23% 13 9.60229E-04 0.001 4.14% ) 14 1.34865E-03 .O.'0013 '-
-3461% .
I
'15 1.90095E-03' O.0019 - -0. 05% - -
16 2.19279E-03 0.0022' _0.3 3 % - ( 17 2.39003E-03 0.0024 0.42% .. j 18 5.55182E 0.0006.- '8.07% ' 19 2.99037E-04 0.0003 0.324 - 20 3.88065E-04 0.0004 3.08% I 21 0.00000E+00 w/A i l 22 0.00000E+00 'Njot 23 0.00000E+00 N/A - - ( 24 0.00000E+00 - N/A i
'25 0.00000E+00 N/A '
- 26 0.00000E+00 N/A 27 0.00000E+00- N/A * "
28 0.00000E+00 - N/A 29 0.00000E+00 - N/A - - - -
. 1 r
( i ( C-22 l i
S y: Date: DM: Deto: I EDO+WtKIC C#71PE 2.0, (NIFON SK MOBLEM NO.3 **"---+-* Pnm:sp04 sootwx futmLIM 80.3, Eteori sTEssr3 CAPPIM WR$1(N 2.0 NJtEG 80L11S I ELEM FW(t) W(t) v2(I) TX(1) Mr(I) W I) Px(JK) Vr(JK) vz(J/t) TX(JK) Mr(JK) MZ(JK) .. to. PX(J) W(J) VZ(J) TX(J) Mr(J) MZ(J) 12.092E4I2 0.000E410 I 21.544E4X2 0.000E410 ) 3 4.6BE412 CA00E+00 4 1.85X 4 5 0.000E410 5 51.1EiE405 0.000E*00 6 5.t32E402 OA00E4
- j 7 4.06EMI2 OADE410 .
8 9.6NIE432 0.000E*00
'I ' 1 1.54@G2 4AISE*02 2.092E*G21.3HE41.lDE4 4.313E41.544E*G2 4 ADE*G2 2.ORIEW 1.3HE4 S.09B051EEE4 21.543E4 342BE*021.58E*G21.3HE4 8.095E451AtES 1.5E4 EdHE*021.5 NIL 4321.3WE4 5.560E4 4.541E4 I
31.539E*021.005E4 LOT 1E41.3HF4 4.541E4 5.5ddE41.*3I41.027E4 2.GPIE41.164E4 SmdE4 5J58E4 1.390E41.2DE4 2.0rIEW 7.230E61A59E4 SEtE4 41.533E41.013EMI2 2.104E*02 7.23dE*C51 A$9E4 SEIE41.352E41.3GCE4 2.10GF41JD7E41 AdEE4 5.GS7E4 . . 1.1GIE41A61E4 2.106E+G2 5ABEE41J87E4 4RIE4 - 51.50GE4021.1FIE4 Ld25E4 5.825E41.dSPE4 4A1E*G51.50GE41.19tE412 242SE*02 5.82241ABE4 4.lB9E4 * . I-.. 6121E4 8.729E*012A23E4 5A25E41ABE*06 4. WEE 45 251E*02 L729E*01 ZA22E4 SA25E4 2J0GE4 5A59E4 7 2JQdE*021 JOE 4 3.915E*01525E4 5A59E*G5 2J0EE4 L11dE41J29E4 3.915E4 7.30DE4 3.361E41.250E4 . l I I 1J00E41.3RdE4 3.915E*017J10E6 2J5E4 3.91dH06 S 1.141E41.364E4 TJ5E*017AIE4 L25E4191Ee041J5eeG5 8.501EeSt 7J5Ee017.154E4 3J90E4 4 AGE 4 . . 1JUEsis 3AIES 7.25E40153lE4 &AINes 5Alme86 . 91R5E412N*C81A61E4 5JBIEsS SJMH06 4AfDS 1ASE41.3EE41J6915 53lE4 3.913H06 7A5E915. 101 AIE41JEM4 SJEE4 53W4 LSWEe86 7JtMe51 AGE *051JUE41AIE4 5.5plEsts 3.1mH061A$es06 . . 111.SEE4 L2154 9.713HG2 5.35EE4 3.imH061A2041.51905 3 JOE 4 9.7FDet 5.35@t5 3RIE4 SREE4
*
- I 121.000E4 3.755*02 L9FIE4 tad 7E*G51.990E*061J25E41.000E6 3J5dE*G2 L9FIE4 7A671HG51R9E4 AA14ENG5 15 L87&G21A40E4 2J96E4 7 ADDE *G51R9E*04 6414E*G5 85719021 A40E*02 23E4 TA67E4 SRIE*05 8.5GE4 I 16 7AdGE*02 9A39E*01 L375E902 7A67E*05 SRIE4 8.50E4 5.360E*02 5.388E4 2R5E4 4.360E4 5.2BOE4 5.310E*05 9A3sE4 7AoGE*G2 2.31WG2 2.860 Hap 7.32E*05 2A2E4 .
I 15 5.007E*G21.250E*G2 7.39dE*017A1E 10 7.REE4 2R2E*04 5.007E41.250E432 7.3ME4 7.361E-10 7.272E451A3BE4 16 5.012E*G2 2Jd5E*021.3GE412 5.275E-10 7.272E41AME4 5.012E4 2J65E4I21.30E4It 5.275E 10 3J99E4lP 1JEPE41P 17 L35@G2 A19EE*02 6AeE4 7JOBE4 2.550E4 5.3205 LIlect L11eE*02 4 AGE 4 7J0EE41.553E42JBIE4 16 TJ61E412 2J571HG2 L17E*02 7JOBE41.5DE4 LOSE 4 7.661E4 2.757E4 L125E4 TJOBE41.3EGE4 9AGdE*G5 ' I, 19 9.222 Edit L327E*G2 4.253E412 TJ08E4 9AldE41JEGE*061.0$1E*C51357E*02 4.253E412dGE*G51.558E41.779E404 6.327E*G2 9.222E402 4.255E*G2 5J2EE4 8.136E4 9.9 TEE 4 20 6.3 DEMI 2 4.712E41.012E*G5 5J3GE4 9.9 TEE 4 L12EENG5 4.3DE4 4.712E*021.0t2E*G5 5.724E*05 4A68E4 L757E4 I I E I I I
py: Date: ou _ Dete: ! DOOMtK14 (APP!PE 2.0, LNIFOM SKCTRA NTKIN W.3 - ------- PRE:!PO 10 l 1 CAPPIPE VDtS104 2.0 RESATS . ElfM PX(1) W(1) WZ(1) TX(!) m(!) MZ(I) PX(JK) W(JK) V2(JK) TX(JK) m(JK) MZ(JK)
- 40. PX(J) W(J) V2(J) TX(J) M(J) MZ(J) 12.071E*02 0.000E400 1 21.544E42 0.000E*00 3 3 4452E*02 0.t00E+00 41E5E4 0.000EMX) 51.135E+G5 0.000E+00 6 5.131E*02 0.000E4 7 4M2E42 0.0XE400 8 946dE*G2 0.0aE40 11.544E*02 4433402 2.071E+021.34K404 t.JZE*04 4.312E4061.544E42 4452E*G2 2.071E4021.349E4 8.095E41E8E406 y 21.542E+02 3.CBE*021.596E4021.3R*04 8.075E41SEE4061.542E@ 3.62EE421.598E4021.34W+04 5.560E405 4.540E403 31.53E@ 1.02iE402 2.07E4021.3E4 4.540E@ 5.560E41.530EG 1.02?E+02 2.020E+021.164E404 856E4 5.79?E*G5 1.'.990E4021.212E+02 LO72+02 7.22'E4051 A5R4 5.dGCE@
41.532E41.012EG 2.120E*(2 7.225E41A59E404 5AGGE41.352E*021.23B02 2.120EG 1.ID?E405146?E4 5.0tDE*05 1.1(BEG 1 AdOE42 2.1 TOE *02 5/d22E41A6?E404 4 RUE 4 51.520E*021.195E+02 2424E*G2 5.822E41JtDE406 440E4051.St0E41.191EG 2424E*G2 5.822E4051.80SE4 4.858E405 6 221E402 8.73B012R2E*02 5.822E41.lD5E4 08SEE4 2E1E402 8.75E*012.822E402 5.822E4 2.005E+06 5A35E4 l 5 7 2.70dE+G21.813G4 3.?t0E4015.522E405 5A38E4 2RIE406 6.115E*G21.72EE4 3.91E4017.30?E405 3.360E41.250E4 1.20:E+Q31.386E*05 3.910EKF17.EDBE*05 2.255EG 3.172406 81.140E41.363E4 7.2EE4017.83E*G5 2.25dE4 3.172+041.55dE4 8.5tDEG 7.230E4017.152E+G5 3.75?E*G5 4E0E406 1.7QE412EEG 7.250E4 5.333E4 6411EG 5AQlE*06 91A5E41."II5E4021.060E4 5.35BG5 5J0B06 L411E41A5E41.35tE4021.0GE4 L353E4190lE4 7.911E4 101 Aide *G51.795E*021.SB0E6 5.353E*G51902E*06 7.911E*051 Aide 41.795E41.lEDE4 5.333E4 3.16?E41.861E*06 11 1.591E41212E*G2 9.TJUE*G2 5.3EB05 3.16?E41.261E41.551E41212EG 9.7ME*02 5.35BG5 L5FIE4 S.SP/E4 *
. 121.006E4 I.75dE*G2 2.971E402 TA6dEe 1.99tE41.222061.005E4 3.75dE*02 2.971E*02 7A6dE41AIE4 L413E4 I
I 13 8EllE41A4E*G2 2.29dE*G2 TA6dE41A8E4 6A13E4 SEtE*G21440E402 2.25tSE*02 7 Adde *05 8J20E*G5 8.545E4 14 7A6?E4 9A4E4012.325E*G2 7A6dE*05 SJ2E*05 8.545E*G5 5.258E4G2 5.3 TEE 402 2.375E*02 4.260E4 5.275E4 5.29K4 9A40E+017A6?E402 2.375E*02 0.000E*00 7.332E4 2.ONE406 15 5.(D6E*021.264002 7A(CE4010.000E+00 7.332E*g5 2.0ME4 5.035E4021.269b4G2 7A00E4010.0%E400 7.271E41A38E406 - 16 5.011E4 2J62E*021.346E*02 0.000E*00 7.2ME41A35E4 5.011E4 2J62E*021.34dE*(2 0.00'E*00 0.0%E@ 0.GJ0E+00 17 6.'EIB02 L19?E4G2 6E7E*G2 7A0?E4 2.549E*06 5.XLQ5 L15EG 6.19?E+G2 6E?E*02 7Jo?E+051.552E*06 223E406 18 7460E*G! 2.78$E402 L172E4G! TJ0?E*G51.552E4 2.CE3E*06 7A60E4G2 2.7hlEG L172E*G2 TJa?E4051.240E4 9.8G4E*G5 19 9.220E4 6.'52EE*02 4.252E4 7.60?E4 9.lE4E@ 1.30E+041.05E*05 3.2BSE*G2 4.252EG 3.269E41.55tE*051.715E406 6.32fE42 9.22E+02 4.252E*02 5.72E4Q5 8.12BQ5 9.923E4 itT 2D 6.332E*G2 4.712E421.012E4 5.72GE4 9.912405 8.125E405 6.332E@ 4.712EG 1.012E405 5.72GE+05 4 AGE 4 2.75dE404 E I I I t C-24 I
Ded: Dete:
' Dy:,_,, _ Date:
CDOMWtKING C#71F2 2.0, u(IFON SMC11tA PR3 LIM N3.3 - --- --- PAE:9611 1 MAIN 7AG Of f FDtDGS BEntDi KMG #D GMPIM WRSICN 2.0 (BASED On WJIEC): 0> tten Px(i) w(i) v2ci) tx(i) Kr(s) wct) extax) vr(Jn) vz(Jn) rx(;/c) wrcJs) w(Jg>
- 30. Px(J) Vr(J) VZ(J) Tx(J) Kt(J) w(J)
WA WA WA WA #. WA WA WA 8VA 1 4R WA WA h/A WA WA WA WA WA II/A WA I 2 -0.02% WA WA st/A WA II/A WA WA 81/A WA 3 0.021 WA BL/A II/A II/A II/A 81/A II/A WA al/A SI/A II/A 81/A WA WA II/A $VW 4 -0.GK WA WA WA WA A/A WA WA WA WA al/A 0 5 0.ct1 WA evA wA WA WA WA WA WA . 6 4 0t% WA WA WA wA WA si/A WA WA WA WE WA 7 4.M WA IVA IVA WA st/A il/A 54 II/A II/A WA WA II/A M WA 0 -0.021 WA WA 0.0S1 0.00K 4 821 0.00K 1 0.0E -0.021 0S CAE 40SE 4.021 0.00K -C.021 t 8' 2 3 0.tXE CAOK CAE 0.GE DER 42 C.00K CAE
-0.02% -0.G2K 0.GE 0.05 DAE 0.00E 0.0E 0.00E 0.05 0.051 0.00K 0.cIE 4 02E 02 -0.021 -0.021 4 021 II/A WA IVA 81/K WA CAOK -0.0F -0.t51 4 0tK C.00K IVA 'I 4 -0.07%
0.GE
-0.065 0.00C -0.0?%
0.00E
-0.051 4.tBE 4 0GK 4 021 4A11 4tBL 02 0.00K 0.05 -C.021 -0.021 -0.G5 cm 40E II/A 4.05G al/A 0.00E 4tEIK II/A 4 0EK C.00K WA 4.021 -GASE II/K SAE 4 021 0.00K 88/A 5
CAE 4.G2K 0.GE 0.011 0.0E 4.02E 4JHE -0A2K
,I 6 7
0.(1E CAE CAtz 0.GE 0.00K 4 .131 4 02E
-C.021 4 05 AOSE 4 021 0.tdL 40E IVR 0.0$E II/A 415E WA 4.011 WA 4 55E al/A OAK II/A 0.00E 0.0E +0.13E -0.05E CJDK 4 0t1 4tBE -0.05K 4 G55 4.021 0 0.00K -0.075 -0.tHE 4 05E CAE 0.115E II/L II/A II/E II/n 4 02E 4tEK 0.0G ti/K IVA 8 9 0.05 SJOE 0.GE 0.05 -0.tBE -0.1EE 4JIE A SEE 4JBE SAE Sm 41tE 41stK 45 4 Att 10 SATE SAE SAE 4 TEE 4JBE 4 0tX SAE SAE SAE 48K 4AFI SAR SAE 4B 4AK =0A21 SAE 4 8tE 11 0.00K 4tBE 45 ASK 4AE SAE =' 12 SAE SAE SAE 0AE SAE 0.0E BAE 0.0E BAE 4 ate 4AE 4 821 13 4 At1 CAOK SAE Acts 40$K -0A21 4 811 OAE CAE 4 DIE 48tE 4 02K 14 -0.tRE CAE CAE 40K 0At1 4.02K 4*K -0. TEE 0.00K 0.00E 4A21 ASK 0.0a WA wm WA Wn svn WA CAs 0.aK Wa 0.Os1 I 15 -0.021 -0.als 0.05E C.051 WA 0.0tE 0.15E 4 TEE -0RIK Cm al/A 4 011 0.05 -0.011 0.00K 4 TEE 4AE 4 .0 71 WA WA ll/A 16 -0.021 -0.0GK 4 .071 WA 17 -0A2K -0.021 4 0tX -0.01% 4 0GK 4G5 4.021 0.02E 4.011 4.0t% ANK OAK 5 18 -0At1 4 0GK -0.tEK -0.011 4.0SK 0.00E 0.td1 4 0EK 0.02E 4 At1 OADE 40K CAR 4 021 0.00K CAE -0.tBE 4.021 0.05 CAE 19 4tE% 0.02E -0.021 -0.011 ti/n WA ti/R ll/A -0.021 -0.02K 8).021 0.00E 4.011 4 021 st/n al/A 4G5 4 0GK iR 2D -0.02E CAR 0.0E 0.00K 0.025 4 01% 4A!E C.05 0.00K 0.00K 8
I I E E - l
By: _ ._ Date: chkd: Date: j' BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.4, PAGE:BM4-1 i BENCHMARK PROBLEM NO.4 GAPPIPE VERSION 2.0 NATURAL FREQUENCIES MODE NUREG GAPPIPE 4 DIFFERENCE NO. (1) (2) ( (2)-(1))/ (1) *100% 1 6.133 6.133 0.00% 2 6.183 6.183 0.00% 1 3 6.557 6.557 0.00%- 4 6.571 6.571 0.00% 5 6.632 6.632 0.00% 6 6.636 6.636 0.00% I 7 6.722 6.722 0.00%
, 8 7.984 7.984 0.00%
9 10.21 10.213 0.03% 10 11.73- 11.733 0.03% 11 13.4 13.4 0.00% 12 13.89 13.895 0.04% , 13 14.25' 14.247 -0.02%
.14 14.5 14.495 -0.03%
15 14.71 14.709 -0.01% i 16 15.57 15.569 -0.01% { 17 17.1 17.097 -0.02%' 18 18.9 18.905 0.03% - 19 28.29 28.289 -0.00% f'
. 20 28.31 28.313 0.01%
8 21 29.52 29.524 0.01% 22 29.8 29.796 -0.01% j 23 30.32 30.318 -0.01% ' 24 30.49 30.488 -0.01% 25 30.5 30.496 -0.01% 26 31.83 31.834 0.01% 27 31.86 31.857 -0.01% 28 39.5 39.503 0.01% 29 40.42 40.418 -0.00% . i 30 40.73 40.734 0.01% I l C-26
By: __ Date: .Chkd: Date: BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.4, PAGE:BM4-2' I J
---- MODAL PARTICIPATION FACTORS ---- !
j X-DIRECTION l .
-)
MODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE ! NO. (1) (2) ( (2)-(1) ) / (1) *100%
~
1 5.1020E-11 0 N/A 2 1.3830E-09 0 N/A 3 -1.6570E+01 16.57427 0.03% 4 2y1980E-09 0 N/A i 5 -2.~2430E-10 0 N/A ;] !- 6 1.1500E-07 0 N/A 2 1 7 8.7450E+00 -8.74494 -0.00% 8 2.6070E-10 0 N/A 9 -9.4700E+01 94.69537 -0.00% i 0 N/A ! 10 4.7330E-11 11 -5.7210E-11 0.,, N/A ,. 0 N/A 12 -1.1430E-11 ? 13 -1.2980E-02 -0.01303 0.39% 14 4.1850E-12 0 N/A 15 4.9310E-10 0 N/A 16 4.4490E-09 0 N/A l 17 3.9980E+01 -39.98182 0.00%. 18 9.7710E-01 -0.97723 0.01% 19 ~3.6480E-11 0 N/A } I 20 -1.0980E-11 0 N/A 21 4.3030E-11 0 N/A 1 22 -1.3670E+00 -1.36614 -0.06% 0 N/A f 23 -3.8840E-11 24 3.6790E-12 0 N/A 25 -1.9420E-11 0 N/A - 26 2.1610E-08 0 N/A 27 1.9110E+00 -1.91071 -0.02% 28 2.9100E-11 0 'N/A ! 29 -5.5600E+00 -5.55976 -0.@0% 30 -4.0130E-11 0 N/A l . k ) C-27
.I By: Date:- Chkd: Dato: ; BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.4, PAGE:BM4-3 I ---- MODAL ' PARTICIPATION FACTORS ----
l Y-DIRECTION l MODE NUREG GAPPIPE' % DIFFERENCE- '* NO. (1) (2)' ( (2)-(1) )/ (1) *100% l'-3.7160E-13 0 N/A 2 6.9320E-12 0 N/A
.3'-7.7670E-11 O N/A 4 -1.2270E+00 1.22699 -0.00%
5 -3s2490E-11 0 N/A .j 6 9.6500E-12 0 N/A 1 7 3.7530E-09 0 N/A 8 -1.7500E+00 1.7504 0.02% , 9 1.6410E-11 0 N/A 10 1.5350E-11 0 N/A 11 3.6100E-11 0 N/A 12 -2.8790E+01 -28,79015 0.00% ; 13 2.5500E-07 0 N/A ! 14 6.4580E+01 64.58418 0.01% 15 3.8050E-09 0 N/A 16 -5.6330E-12 0 N/A j 17 -3.2870E-11 0 N/A 18 1.72903-11 0 N/A 19 -7.3950E-11 0 N/A l 20 4.CS60E-09 0 N/A 21 7.8510E+01 -78.51977 0.01%
! 22 6.5580E-09 0 N/A 23 4.4460E+01 -44.44325 -0.04%
24 -1.8900E-11 0 N/A 25 -6.2290E-10 0 N/A , 26 9.7680E+00 -9.76858 0a01%
'27 -2.3590E-08 0 N/A 28 -1.7700E-11 0 N/A 29 1.6810E-11 0 N/A ;
30 -1.3750E+00 -1.37518 0.01% i O t C-28
By: Date: 'Chkd: Date: BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.4, PAGE:BM4-4
---- MODAL PARTICIPATION FACTORS ----
MODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE - ' NO. (1) (2) ( (2)-(1) ) / (1) *100% I --------------------------------------------- -------- 1 2.1650E-10 0 N/A 0.07% I 2 2.9210E-01 -0.29229 3 -5.5140E-12 0 N/A 4 1.4210E-0G 'O N/A 5 -6;1610E+01 -61.61077 0<004 6 ~6.2070E-07 0 N/A 7 2.410CE-10 0 N/A 8 7.9440E-13 0 N/A I 9 4.0380E-11 10 v7.0610E+01 11 1.3740E-11
-70.60767 0
0 N/A
-0.00%
N/A 12 7.7080E-12 0 N/A 13 4.1970E-10 0 N/A 14 3.5140E-08 0 N/A iS -3.5120E+01 35.12436 0.01% 16 9.9420E+00 9.94201 0.00% I 17 3.2060E-10 0 N/A 18 9.8030E-11 0 N/A' 29 1.9110E-09 0 N/A 20 2.3180E+01 -23.1832 0.01% 8 21 2.3910E~11 0 N/A 22 7.0410E-11 0 N/A 23 -6.9180E-11 0 N/A 24 9.5950E-07 0 .N/A 25 -8.1710E+00 -B.1731
- 0.07%
26 -3.0220E-11 0 N/A - i 27 3.3570E-11 0 N/A 28 -1.1680E-09 0.00989 8.4675E+05 29 -4.3960E-11 0 N/A j I 30 9.5110E-12 0 , N/A l
)
l I . t I I ' i I C-29 1 i } L
By: Date: Chkd: Date: BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.4, PAGE:BM4-5 . NODAL DISPLACEMENT l X-DIR. DISPLACEMENT l NODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE 'E NO. (1) (2) ( (2)-(1) ) / (1) *100% 5! 1 3.53522E-01 0.3533 -0.06% ! 2 2.09547E-01 0.2094 -0.07% , 3 1.21051E-01 0.1209 -0.12% 4 1.20778E-04 0.0001 -17.20% 5 0.00000E+00 N/A 6 0.00000E+00 N/A 7 0.00000E+00 N/A 8 0.00000E+00 9 6.41472E-02 N/A g 0.0641 -0.07% gl 10 0.00000E+00 N/A 11 1.09091E-01 0.109 -0.08% 12 8.83701E-02 0.0883 -0.08% 13 1.09091E-01 0.109 -0.08% 14 1.09395E-01 0.1093 -0.09% 15 1.19602E-01 16 1.09395E-01 0.1196 -0.00% g 0.1093 -0.09% 3 17 9.01020E-02 0.09 -0.11% 18 9.01020E-02 0.09 -0.11% 19 1.20800E-01 0.1207 -0.08% 20 1.20800E-01 0.1207 -0.08% 1 21 1.14317E-01 0.1142 -0.10% 22 1.14317E-01 0.1142 -0.10% l 23 1.24518E-01 0.1244 -0.09% 24 1.24518E-01 0.1244 -0.09% 2S 2.38773E-01 0.2385 -0.11% ! 26 2.38773E-01 0.2385 -0.11% , 27 0.00000E+00 N/A 28 0.00000E+00 N/A 29 5.35547E-01 0.5351 -0.08% l 30 5.35547E-01 0.5351 -0.08% i 31 2.24894E-01 0.2247 -0.09% j 32 2.24894E-01 0.2247 -0.09% 33 1.83245E-01 0.1831 -0.08% 1 34 1.26534E-01 0.1265 -0.03% 35 1.83245E-01 0.1831 -0.08% 36 1.45296E-01 0.1452 -0.07% 37 1.45296Ee01 0.1452 -0.07% , l 38 1.33095E-01 0.1331 0.00% 39 1.34420E-01 0.1344 -0.01% $ 40 1.33095E-01 0.1331 0.00% W 41 0.00000E+00 N/A 42 0.00000E+00 N/A 43 0.00000E+00 N/A 44 0.00000E+00 N/A C-30 1
By: Date: lChkd: Date: BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.4, PAGE:BM4-6
.W 45 0.00000E+00 N/A 46 0.00000E+00 N/A g 47 1.35475E-01 0.1354 -0.06% ,3 48 1.55439E-01 0.1554 -0.03%
49 1.37775E-01 0.1577 -0.05% -
~
SO 1.38582E-01 0.1385 -0.06% ! 51 1.39343E-01 0.1393 -0.03% 52 0.00000E+00 N/A i 53 0.OC000E+00 - N/A I ' 54 0.00000E+00 55 0.00000E+00 56 0.00000E+00 N/A N/A N/A a 57 0.00000E+00 N/A g 58 1.33095E-01 59 1.34420E-01 0.1331 0.1344 0.00%
-0.01%
60 1.33095E-01 0.1331 0.00% 61 1.45296E-01 0.1452 -0.07%
.I 62 1.45296E-01 63 1.83245E-01 0.1452 0.1831 -0.07% -0.08%
64 1.26534E-01 0.1255' -0.03%
<65 1.83245E-01 0.1831 -0.08% i 66 2.24894E-01 0.2247 -0.09% !
67 2.24894E-01 0.2247 -0.09% I 68 5.35547E-01' 69 5.35547E-01 70 0.00000E+00 O.5351 0.5351
-0.08% -0.08%
N/A , 71 0.00000E+00 N/A a 72 2.38773E-01 73 2.38773E-01 0.2385 0.2385
-0.11% -0.11%
74 1.24518E-01 0.1244 -0.09% I 75 1.24518E-01 76 1.14317E-01 77 1.14317E-01 0.1244 0.1142 0.1142
-0.09% -0.10% -0.10% ;
I 78 1.20800E-01 79 1.20800E-01 80 9.01020E-02 0.1207 0.1207 0.09
-0.08% -0.08% -0.11% -0.11%
I 81 9.01020E-02 0.09 82 1.09395E-01 0.1093 -0.09% 1 83 1.19602E-01 0.1196 -0.00% l 84 1.09395E-01 0.1093 -0.09% I 85 1.09091E-01 86 1.09091E-01 87 8.83701E-02 0.109 0.109 0.0883
-0.08% -0.08% -0.08%
88 0.00000E+00 N/A
.I 89 6.41472E-02 90 1.20778E-04 0.0641 0.0001 -0.07% -17.20%
j l
.m 91 0.00000E+00 N/A g 92 0.00000E+00 93 0.00000E+00 N/A N/A J
i
. 94 0.00000E+00 N/A I 95 1.21051E-01 0.1209 -0.12%
l C-31 I
By: Date: Chkd: Date: BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.4, PAGE:BM4-7 96 2.09547E-01 0.2094- -0.07% 97 3.53522E-01 0.3533 -0.06%
.I-I g
I I I I I B!
. I I
I I C-32
By: Date: 'Chkd: Date: BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.4, PAGE:BM4-8 I NODAL DISPLACEMENT NODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE . I NO. (1) 1 7.63799E-02 (2) 0.0764 ( (2 )-(1) ) / (1) *100% 0.03% i 2 7.52134E-02 0.0752 -0.02% I 3 4 7.40533E-02 7.11737E-02 5 0 00000E+00 0.074 0.0712
-0.07%
0.04% N/A 6 0.00000E+00 N/A i I. 7 0.00000E+00 8 0.00000E+00 N/A N/A 9 6.59306E-62 0.0659 -0.05% 10 0.00000E+00 N/A 11 7.70045E-02 0.077 -0.01% 12 6.41949E-02 0.0642 ' 0.01% 13 7.70045E-02 0.077 -0.01% 1 14 7.80424E-02 0.078 -0.05% 15 5.56852E-02 0.0557 0.03%
-0.05%
I 16 7.80424E-02 0.078 17 7.77114E-02 0.0777 -0.01% 18 7.77114E-02 0.0777 -0.01% 19 6.85143E-02 0.0684 -0.17% I . 20 6.85143E-02 21 22 7.12521E-02 7.12521E-02 0.0684 0.0712 0.0712
-0.17% -0.07% -0.07% -0.05%
I 23 24 25 2.29123E-02 2.29123E-02 2.28652E-02 0.0229 0.0229 0.0229
-0.05%
0.15% 26 2.28652E-02 0.0229 0.15% 27 0.00000E+00 N/A 28 0.00000E+00 N/A 29 2.39140E-02 0.0239 -0.06% I, 30 31 32 2.39140E-02 4.78673E-02 4.78673E-02 0.0239 0.0479 0.0479
-0.06%
0.07% 0.07%
-0.05%
I 33 7.47348E-02 34 2.5:3t4SE-02 35 7.473f8E-02 0.0747 0.0252 0.0747
-0.12% -0.05%
36 3.18595E-02 0.0319 0.13% I 37 3.18595E-02 38 39 1.54223E-02 7.18936E-03 0.0319 0.0154 0.0072 0.13%
-0.14%
0.15% I 40 41 42 1.54223E-02 0.00000E+00 0.00000E+00 0.0154 -0.14% N/A N/A 43 0.00000E+00 N/A 44 0.00000E+00 N/A I C-33 I 1
i By: Date: Chkd: Date: BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.4, PAGE:BM4-9 g g; 45 0.00000E+C0 N/A 46 0.00000E+00 N/A 47 8.13214E-03 0.0081 -0.40% l W 48 8.97273E-03 0.009 0.30% 49 8.53109E-03 0.0085 -0.36% 50 8.67402E-03 0.0087 0.30% 51 8.78733E-03 0.0088 0.14% 52 0.00000E+00 N/A 53 0.00000E+00 N/A 54 0.00000E+00 N/A 55 0.00000E+00 N/A 56 0.00000E+00 F/A 57 0.00000E+00 h/A 4 58 1.54223E-02 0.0154 -0.14% 59 7.18936E-03 0.0072 0.15% 60 1.54223E-02 0.0154 -0.14% 61 3.18595E-02 0.0319 0.13% 62 3.18595E-02 0.0319 0.13% 63 7.47348E-02 0.0747 -0.05% 64 2.52305E-02 0.0252 -0.12% 65 7.4734DE-02 0.0747 -0.05% 66 4.78673E-02 0.0479 0.07% 67 4.78673E-02 0.0479 0.07% . 68 2.39140E-02 0.0239 -0.06% 69 2.39140E-02 0.0239 -0.06% 70 0.00000E+00 N/A g 71 0.00000E+00 N/A 3 72 2.28652E-02 0.0229 0.15% 73 2.28652E-02 0.0229 0.15% 74 2.29123E-02 0.0229 '
-0.05%
75 2.29123E-02 0.0229 , -0.05% 76 7.12521E-02 0.0712 -0.07% 77 7.12521E-02 0.0712 -0.07% l 78 6.85143E-02 0.0684 -0.17% B 79 6.85143E-02 0.0684 -0.17% l 80 7.77114E-02 0.0777 -0.01% l 81 7.77114E-02 0.0777 -0.01% B2 7.80424E-02 0.078 -0.05% 83 5.56852E-02 0.0557 0.03% 84 7.80424E-02 0.078 -0.05% 85 7.70045E-02 0.077 -0.01% 86 7.70045E-02 0.077 -0.01% 87 6.41949E-02 0.0642 0.01% g 88 0.00000E+00 N/A B 89 6.59306E-02 0.0659 -0.05% ' 90 7.11737E-02 0.0712 0.04% 91 0.00000E+00 N/A 92 0.00000E+00 N/A 93 0.00000E+00 N/A 94 0.00000E+00 N/A l 95 7.40533E-02 0.074 -0.07% 5, C-34 11
By: Date: Chkd: Date: BENCIOiARKING-GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.4, PAGE:BM4-10 96 7.52134E-02 0.0752 -0.02% i 97 7.63799E-02 0.0764 0.03% I . I I I
.I I .
I I I I . I I I c-35 I
I By: Date: Chkd: Date: l BENC104ARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.4, PAGE:BM4-11 1 NODAL DISPLACEMENT l Z-DIR. DISPLACEMENT l NODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE '- 1 7.03018E-01 0.7019 -0.16% 2 4.38002E-01 0.4373 -0.16% I 3 2.68808E-01 0.2684 -0.15% I 4 9.38550E-05 0.0001 6.55% { 5 0.00000E+00 N/A 6 0.00000E+00 N/A j 7 0.00000E+00 N/AJ 8 0.00000E+00 N/A 9 1.26979E-01 0.1268 -0.14% 3l 10 0.00000E+00 N/A E 11 1.76855E-01 0.1766 -0.14% 12 1.29991E-01 0.1298 -0.15% 13 1.76855E-01 0.1766 -0.14% 14 1.74329E-01 0.1741 -0.13% 15 8.90760E-02 0.089 -0.09% 16 1.74329E-01 0.1741 -0.13% l 17 1.33817E-01 0.1336 -0.16% g 18 1.33817E-01 0.1336 -0.16% 19 1.00800E-01 0.1008 0.00% B 20 1.00800E-01 0.1008 0.00% g 21 9.64466E-02 0.0964 -0.05% 22 9.64466E-02 0.0964 -0.05% 23'2.26213E-01 0.2259 -0.14% 24 2.26213E-01 0.2259 -0.14% 25 5.73150E-01 0.5723 -0.15% 26 5.73150E-01 0.5723 -0.15% g 27 0.00000E+00 N/A 28 29 0.00000E+00 1.24560E+00 1.2437 N/A
-0.15%
El; 30 1.24560E+00 1.2437 -0.15% l 31 5.04800E-01 0.504 -0.16% 32 5.04800E-01 0.504 -0.16% 33 3.08565E-01 0.3081 -0.15% g, 34 8.81893E-02 0.0882 0.01% 3l 35 3.08565E-01 0.3081 -0.15% 36 1.22921E-01 0.1228 -0.10% 37 1.22921E-01 0.1228 -0.10% 38 1.08506E-01 0.1085 -0.01% 1 39 1.06723E-01 0.1067 -0.02% 40 1.08506E-01 0.1085 -0.01% 41 0.00000E+00 N/A 42 0.00000E+00 N/A 43 0.00000E+00 N/A 44 0.00000E+00 N/A 1 C-36 I
By: Date: Chkd: Date: BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 3.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.4, PAGE:BM4-12 I 45 0.00000E+00 46 0.00000E+00 N/A N/A -lW 47 1.11953E-01 48 1.56964E-01 0.1119 0.1569
-0.05% -0.04% '
49 1.06481E-01 0.1065 0.02% . 0.1013 -0.04% I 50 1.01344E-01 51 9.37290E-02 52,0,00000E+00 0.0937
~ -0.03%
N/A 3 53'-0.00000E+00 N/A-I 54 0.00000E+00 55 0.00000E+00-56 0.00000E+00 N/A N/A N/A 57 0.00000E+00 N/A I 58 1.08506E-01 59 1.06723E-01 0.1085 0.1067
-0.01% -0.02%
60 1.08506E-01 0.1085 -0.01% I 61 1.22921E-01 62 63 1.22921E-01 3.08564E-01 .. 0.1228 0.1228 0.3081
-0.10% -0.10% -0.15%
64 8.81893E-02 0.0882 0.01% I. 65 3.08564E-01 0.3081 -0.15% 66 5.04800E-01 0.504 -0.16% 67 5.04800E-01 0.504 -0.16% I 68 1.24560E+00 69 1.24560E+00 70 0.00000E+00 1.2437 1.2437
-0.15% -0.15%
N/A I F 71 0.00000E+00 72 5.73150E-01 73 5.73150E-01 0.5723 0.5723 V/A
-0.15% -0.15% -0.14%
0.2259 I 74 2.26213E-01 75 2.26213E-01 76 9.64466E-02 O.2259 0.0964
-0.14% -0.05% -0.05%
77 9.64466E-02 0.0964 I 78 1.00800E-01 79 80 1.00800E-01 1.33817E-01 0.1008 0.1008 0.1336 0.00% 0.00%
-0.16% -0.16%
I 81 82 1.33817E-01 1.74329E-01 83 8.90760E-02 0.1336 0.1741 0.089
-0.13% -0.09%
84 1.74329E-01 0.1741 -0.13% 85 1.76855E-01 0.1766 -0.14% 86 1.76855E-01 0.1766 -0.14% 87 1.29991E-01 0.1298 -0.15% I 88 89 90 0.00000E+00 1.26979E-01 9.38550E-05 0.1268 0.0001 N/A
-0.14%
6.55% 91 0.00000E+00 N/A I- 92 93 0.00000E+00 0.00000E+00 N/A N/A 94 0.00000E+00 N/A 95 2.68808E-01 0.2684 -0.15% C-37 I
B, . >
- - By: Date: - _
Chkd: Date: BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0; UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM'NO.4, PAGE:BM4-13 96 4.38001E-01 0.4373 -0.16% - 97-7.03017E-01 .0.7019 -0.16% l
.. l 1
( i f i
, i .)
i e 6 l 1 a. C-38
By: -Date: .Chkd: Date: 1 BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.4, PAGE:BM4-14 : l . ) NODAL ROTATION _ _ _ _ _ l_ _ _ _ .X-DIR. ____ ROTATION _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _l _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _] _ NODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE , j NO. (1) (2) ( (2)-(1) )/ (1) *100% ] L 1 1.77795E-03 0.0018 1.24% 2 1.70955E-03 0.0017 -0.56% g 3-1.57849E-03 0.0016 1.36% ! 4 1.09777E-03 0.0011 0.20% 5 0.00000E+00 N/A 6 0.00000E+00 N/A E 7 0.00000E+00 N/A l 8 0.00000E+00 N/A 9 6.13108E-04 0.0006 -2.14% i 10 0.00000E+00 N/A 11 5.95152E-04 ~ 0.0006 0.81% 12 6.00493E-04 0.0006 -0.08% 13 5.95152E-04 0.0006 0.81% 4'.44% 14 1.05325E-03 0.0011 15 3.17339E-04 0.0003 -5.46% 16 1.05325E-03 -0.0011 4.44% 17 1.30768E-03 0.0013 -0.594 18 1.30768E-03 0.0013 -0.59% 19 1.43389E-03 0.0014 -2.36% 20 1.43389E-03 0.0014 -2.36% 21 1.80492E-03 0.0018- -0.27% 22 1.80492E-03 0.0018 -0.27% 23 4.83634E-03 0.0048 -0.75% 24 4.83634E-03 0.0048 -0.75% 25 4.86020E-03 0.0049 0.82% 26 4.86020E-03 0.0049 0.82% a 27 0.00000E+00 N/A 28 0.00000E+00 N/A 29 5.33244E-03 0.0053 -0.61% 30 5.33244E-03 0.0053 -0.61% 31 4.78029E-03 0.0048 0.41% 32 4.78029E-03 0.0048 0.41% 33 2.84233E-03 0.0028 -1.49% 34 2.29164E-04 0.0002 -12.73% 35 2.84233E-03 0.0028 -1.49% 36 1.02129E-03 0.001 -2.08% 37 1.02129E-03 0.001 -2.08% 38 1.66288E-04 0.0002 20.27% 39 1.70155E-04 0.0002 17.54% . 40 1.66288E-04 0.0002 20.27% 41 0.00000E+00 N/A 42 0.00000E+00 N/A 43 0.00000E+00 N/A 44 0.00000E+00 N/A C-39 1
By: _ Date: Chkd: Date: BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.4, PAGE:BM4-15 1 I 45 0.00000E+00 N/A 46 0.00000E+00 N/A 47 1.70003E-04 0.0002 17.64% 48 2.18694E-04 0.0002 -8.55% 49 1.61145E-04 0.0002 24.11% 50 1.58973E-04 0.0002 25.81% ) 51 1.57989E-04 0.0002 -26.59% 4 52 0.00000E+00 N/A 53 0.00000E+00 N/A l 54 0.00000E+00 N/A j 55 0.00000E+00 N/A 56 0.00000E+00 N/A y 57 0.00000E+00 N/A J 58 1.66288E-04 0.0002 20.27% l 59 1.70155E-04 0.0002 17.54% 60 1.66288E-04 0.0002 20.27% 61 1.02129E-03 0.001 -2.08% 62 1.02129E-03 0.001 -2.08% 63 2.84233E-03 0.0028 -1.49% ; 64 2.29164E-04 0.0002 -12.73% 65 2.84233E-03 0.0028 -1.49% 66 4.78029E-03 0.0048 O-41% 67 4.78029E-03 0.0048 0.41% 68 5.33244E-03 0.0053 -0.61% i) 69 5.33244E-03 0.0053 -0.61% 70 0.00000E+00 N/A 71 0.00000E+00 N/A ; 72 4.86020E-03 0.0049 0.82% 73 4.86020E-03 0.0049 0.82% 74 4.83634E-03 0.0048 -0.75% l 75 4.83634E-03 0.0048 -0.75% I 76 1.80492E-03 0.0018 -0.27%- 77 1.80492E-03 0.0018 -0.27% i 78 1.43389E-03 0.0014 -2.36% 79 1.43389E-03 0.0014 -2.36% 80 1.30768E-03 0.0013 -0.59% 81 1.30768E-03 0.0013 -0.59% I 82 1.0532SE-03 0.0011 4.44%. 83 3.17339E-04 0.0003 -5.46% 84 1.05325E-03 0.0011 4.44% 1 85 5.95152E-04 0.0006 0.81% i 86 5.95152E-04 0.0006 0.81% 87 6.00493E-04 0.0006 -0.08% 88 0.00000E+00 N/A j 89 6.13108E-04 0.0006 -2.14% 90 1.09777E-03 0.0011 0.20% 91 0.00000E+00 N/A l 92 0.00000E+00 N/A 1 l 93 0.00000E+00 N/A l 94 0.00000E+00 N/A 1 95 1.57849E-03 0.0016 1.36% 1 1 l C-40
[-l - By: ~ Dato: Chkd: D$te:' b F BENCHMARKING: GAPPIPE 2.0, . UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.4, ^ PAGEs BM4-1G
'96 1.70955E-03: 0.0017 -0.56%-
97.1.77795E-03 . 0.0018 1.24% i r (.- t D G 0 C-41 I j
E' t -: A By:- 'Dste: Chkd: Date:
; BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.4, PAGE:BM4-17
[ NODAL ROTATION l Y-DIR. ROTATION l
& NODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE ~~
NO. (1) (2)- ( (2)-(1) )/ (1) *100% l
.1 6.85165E-04 0.0007 2.17%
2 6.85165E-04 0.0007- 2.17%
, 3 6.85165E-04 0.0007 2.17%
4.6.85165E-04 0.0007 2.17% 5 0.00000E+00 N/A 6 0.00000E+00 N/A 7 0.00000E+00 N/A 8 0.00000E+00 N/A 9 6.85165E-04 0.0007 2.17% 10 0.00000E+00 N/A 11 6.89101E-04 0.0007 1.58%
'12 6.99422E-04 0.0007 0.08%
13 6.89101E-04 0.0007 1.58% 14 7.88419E-04 0.0008 1.47% 15 9.40693E-04 .0.0009 -4.33% 16 7.88419E-04 0.0008 1.47% 17 1.09383E-03 0.0011 0.56% 18 1.09383E-03 0.0011 0.56% 19 7.83650E-04 0.0008 2.09% 20'7.83650E-04 0.0008 2.09% ! 21 7.17481E-04 0.0007 -2.44% 22 7.17481E-04 0.0007 -2.44% 23 1.74657E-03 0.0017 -2.67%
. 24 1.74657E-03 0.0017 -2.67% -
25 1.86211E-03 0.0019 2.03% 26 1.86211E-03 0.0019 2.03% 27 0.00000E+00 N/A ; 28 0.00000E+00 N/A 29 1.86211E-03 0.0019' 2.03% 30 1.86211E-03 0.0019 2.03% 31 1.97228E-03 0.002 1.41% 32 1.97228E-03 0.002 1.41% 33.3.30590E-03 0.0033 -0.184 34 6.76240E-04 0.0007 3.51% i 35 3.30590E-03 0.0033 -0.18% 36 2.70194E-03 0.0027 -0.07% i 37 2.70194E-03 0.0027 -0.07% I 38 2.35309E-05 0 *4 N/A 39 1.52306E-05 0 N/A , 40 2.35309E-05 0 N/A 41 0.00000E+00 N/A I 42 0.00000E+00 N/A 43 0.00000E+00 N/A 1 44 0.00000E+00 N/A l C-42 I 1
By: Date: Chkd: Date: BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.4, PAGE:BM4-18' 45 0.00000E+00 N/A 46 0.00000E+00 .N/A' 47 8.62406E 0- N/A l 48 8.62406E-12 0 N/A
'49 8.62406E-12 0 N/A: "
50,8.62406E-12 0 N/A 51 8.62406E-12 'O N/A 52.0.00000E+00 N/A 53 0.00000E+00 N/A ! 54 0.00000E+00 N/A 55 0.00000E+00 N/A 56 0.QOOO0E+00 N/A
-57 0.00000E+00 N/A 58.2.35309E-05 0 N/A 59 1.52306E-05 0 N/A 60 2.35309E-05 0 N/A 61 2.70134E-03 0.0027 -0.07%
62 2.70194E-03 0.0027 -0.07% 63 3.30590E-03 0.0033 -0.18% 64 6.76240E-04 0.0007< 3.51% 65 3.30590E-03 0.0033 -0.18%
-66 1.97228E-03 0.002 1.41%
67 1.97228E-03 0.002 1.41% 68 1.86211E-03 0.0019 2.03% 69 1.86211E-03 0.0019 2.03% 70 0.00000E+00 N/A 71 0.00000E+00 N/A 72 1.86211E-03 0.0019 2.03% 73 1.86211E-03 0.0019 2.03% 74 1.74657E-03 0.0017 -2.67% 75 1.74657E-03 0.0017 -2.67% 76 7.17481E-04 0.0007 -2.44% 77 7.17481E-04 0.0007 -2.44% 78 7.83650E-04 0.0008 2.09% 79 7.83650E-04 0.0008 2.09% 80 1.09383E-03 0.0011 0.56% , 81 1.09383E-03 0.0011 0.56% 82 7.88419E-04 0.0008 1.47% 83 9.40693E-04 0.0009 ~4.33% 84 7.88419E-04 0.0008 1.47% l 85 6.89101E-04 0.0007 1.58% 86 6.89101E-04 0.0007 1.58% ; 87 6.99422E-04 0.0007 0.08% i 88 0.00000E+00 l N/A t 89 6.85165E-04 0.0007 2.17% - 90 6.85165E-04 0.0007 2.17% [ l 91 0.00000E+00 N/A L 92 0.00000E+00 N/A 93 0.00000E+00 N/A 94 0.00000E+00 N/A ( 95 6.85165E-04 0.0007 2.17% l C-43 l \
;r i'". . . , . L ' ' ' l-By: Date: _ chkd:
Data: ;
.1 ' BENCHMARKING-. GAPPIPE 2. O , UNIFORM SPECTRA. PROBLEM NO.4,'PAGE:BM4-19 .i . a- . 96 6.85165E-04. 0.0007 2.17% , 97 6.85165E-04 0.0007 2.17% -
4
*9 e*
1 1 i i i 1
;1 '. j I .q 4
l i .~ l C-44
! 1By: Date:
- Chkd: Date:
BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.4, PAGE:BM4-20 b l NODAL ROTATION j l Z-DIR. ROTATION l NODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE ' i NO. (1) (2) ( (2)-(1) )/ (1) *100% j 1 9.42045E-04... 0.0009 -4.46% 2 8.76306E-04 0.0009 2.70% l l 3 7.52539E-04 0.0008 6.31% 1 1 4 3.53310E-04 0.0004 13.22% 5 0.00000E+00 N/A ; 6 0.00000E+00 N/A l 7 0.00000E+00 N/A 8 0.00000E+00 N/A 9 2.90896E-04 0.0003 3.13% 10 0.00000E+00 N/A ; 11 2.89241E-04 0.0003 3.72% ' 12 3.25465E-04 0.0003 ., -7.82% : 13 2.89241E-04 0.0003 3.72% 1 14 7.30852E 0.0007 -4.22% 1 15 3.24422E-04 0.0003 -7.53% 1 16 7.30852E-04 0.0007 -4.22% I 17 1.07365E 0.0011 2.45t I 18 1.07365E-03 0.0011 2.45% l 19 1.38527E-03 0.0014 1.06% i 20 1.38527E-03 0.0014 1.06% ! 21 1.41851E-03 0.0014 -1.30% i 22 1.41851E-03 0.0014 -1.30% 23 1.97270E-03 0.002 1.38% 24 1.97270E-03 0.002 1.38% 25 2.04576E-03 0.002 -2.24% j 26 2.04576E-03 0.002 -2.24% i 27 0.00000E+00 N/A d 28 0.00000E+00 N/A { 29 2.47273E-03 0.0025 1.10% 1 30 2.47273E-03 0.0025 1.10%- l 31 1.95717E-03 0.002 2.19% l 32 1.95717E-03 0.002 2.19% ' 33 8.12854E-04 0.0008 -1.58% 34 3.50185E-04 0.0004 14.2*%4 35 8.12854E-04 0.0008 -1.58% 36 5.98622E-04 0.0006 0.23% 37 5.98622E-04 0.0006 0.23% 38 4.49766E-05 0 N/A . 39 3.47639E-05 0 N/A 1 40 4.49766E-05 0 N/A l 41 0.00000E+00 N/A j 42 0.00000E+00 N/A 43 0.00000E+00 N/A 44 0.00000E+00 N/A C-45 l l l J
By: Date:- Chkd: Dcte: BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.4, PAGE:BM4-21 a 45 0.00000E+00 N/A
'46 0.00000E+00 N/A 47~4.00182E-05 0 N/A ! -48 7.44163E-05 0.0001- 34.38% '
49 3.29628E-05 0 N/A - 50-3.29880E-05 0 N/A 51 3.36407E-05 0 N/A 52 0.00000E+00 N/A' 53 0.00000E+00 N/A . 54.0.00000E+00 N/A , 55'O.00000E+00 N/A 56 0.00000E+00 N/A d 57 0.00000E+00 N/A 58 4.49766E-05 0 N/A ! 59 3.47639E-05 0 N/A 60 4.49766E-05 0 N/A 61 5.98622E-04 0.0006 0.23% 62 5.98622E-04 0.0006 0.23% 63 8.12853E-04 0.0008 -1.58% 64 3.50185E-04 0.0004 14.23% 65 8.12853E-04 0.0008 -1.58% 1 66 1.95717E-03 0.002 2.19% 67 1.95717E-03 0.002 2.19% 68 2.47273E-03 0.0025 1.10% 69 2.47273E-03 0.0025 1.10% 70 0.00000E+00 - N/A
'71.0.00000E+00 M/A 72 2.04576E-03 0.002 -2.24%
73 2.04576E-03 0.002 -2.24% 74 1.97270E-03 0.002- 1.38% l 75 1.97270E-03 0.002 - 1.38%. ! 76 1.41851E-03 0.0014 -1.30% 77 1.41851E-03 0.0014 -1.30% , 78 1.38527E-03 0.0014 1.06% : 79 1.38527E-03 0.0014 1.06% 80 1.07365E-03 0.0011 2.45% 81 1.07365E-03 0.0011 2.45% ) 82 7.30852E-04 0.0007 -4.22% 83 3.24422E-04 0.0003 -7.53% 84 7.30852E-04 0.0007 -4.22% 1 85 2.89241E-04 0.0003 3.72% ; 86 2.89241E-04 0.0003 3.72% 87 3.25465E-04 0.0003 -7.82% 88 0.00000E+00 N/A 1 0.0003 3.13% - I 89 2.90896E-04 90 3.53310E-04 0.0004 13.22% 91 0.00000E+00 N/A j 92 0.00000E+00 N/A J 93 0.00000E+00 N/A 94 0.00000E+00 N/A ; 95 7.52539E-04 0.0008 6.31% j i C-46 i
By: Date: Chkd: Date: i BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 3.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.4, PAGE:BM4-33 l. 96 8.76306E-04 0.0009 2.70% 97 9.42045E-04 0.0009 -4.46% i i I, . lI I \ I I-
~
1I
'i
- lI l .
T
- l
~
I ~ I I g c_47 I !
c , sy: ~ Dets: ' Osti: DMM i secews:tec C#91pt 2.0, LN!FON SPECTRA PamuM DOA -- - - PoE:IMr. 25 eENCMWWC PROBLEM 80A, E190ff STRES3ES GAPPIPE witslCN 2.0 stBEC MEA.TS BAM PN(I) WC1)' W(I) TX(1) m(1) - te(l) - PM(J/C) W(J/C) W(J/C) 1H(J/C) M(J/C) IS(J/C) i 80. PN(J) W(J) W(J) TX(J) IW(J) IE(J) 11.208E4 CADDE410 2 9.386E45 0.0DDE*00 31JDBE*06 0.00DE*00 4 7.3dE4 OADWHOD 5 T.711E4 0.00E*00 4 3.9P5E4 0.00DEe00 7 7.711E 4 0.0DDE*00 81.0RE*06 0.00DE*00 . 9 1.251E 4 8.0DDE*00 to 1.251E4 0.0 DOE *00 . 113.9PSE4 0.00DE*00 , 121.0mH06 0.0DDE*00 . . .. 15 7.711E*05 OAODE*00 , 141.251E*06 0.00E*00 15 7.711E*G5 0.0DDEe00 - 161.251E4 0.000E4 - . 171JDGE4 OADOE4 . . , l 1B 1Ame06 S.Elme0D - . . . . . J W 9.EE4 S.SIEe8 . . . . B9.nE46234 . . . 13.54e4 6.BBS 4.EEe5 8.8Enes 1Ame 1.1m4 3.15dE4 6.3534 63E4 0.8D54 9.1954 9.11Ee0F . 2 4 JOE 4 83Ne5 8.EIEst5 2.354 9.1pmetr 9.11st 4 JOE 4 83OE4 S.3EE4 22lE41JWE41.M . 3 a.25E4 9.5DE4 9JEE4 3.3HE41JWE41 JOE 4 6.254E4 9.5054 9.381E4 324E43Jue05 3A1E*08 41.15E*06 9254G51ABWO6 9.71E 0T 3.33EH0B 1A19E41.15EH06 9EEH051 AGE *06 9.7tlE4IT 7.T'5E*071.75dE*05 )
~ 51.112E*C6 4A9E4 2.3HE4 L121E*07 4.56@07 8.953H071.1ME4 4A9E4 2.3HE4 2.121E*07 2.G5E*07 4.011E4 )
6 7.811E*04 221E41ABE*051.0EE*071.90EHOT 3.ME40F 7ETE4 2.251E41.01541.00E4 9AEE*061J3EH07
- 7 7.811E406 221E41ASE41ADee071.9090T 3.MaHGT 7AX4 2.251E41 AGE 41 AtIE*0T 9.85E41.2EE4 81211H061.115E4 2.215E4 3AEE4 3J2EH071.08EH181EIE41.11EH06 2.213H05 3ABE41.965H073.155e07 9 7. AWE 4 IJGHG51 ADE41.00@07 9AIE4061J3EHOT 93EE4 2.18541 ADE4 7.36@061 ADIE41.2M*0T 1ASEH45129E*G51ADE4 4A1@06 9.55Ee06 S.5GE*06 . . .
I ( 101.380E41.10E4 2.30E4 3Ad@061.9dBE43.12lINGT 1414E4 4JEE*Gi 221E4 4.25dE4 7JEIE41.51WOT 1 AdOE4 2AdCeG5 2.30E4 4.5GH06 5.198E412tE*0T . 117.aEE*04 2.3G41AM4051Acascr 9AIEe061J3 BOT 93EE4 2.18E*051 ADE4 7.360E41.004E*0F 120E6 . 1 ASEE41 AGE 41.0DE4 4A11E4 9.55I906 8.5ME*06 . 121 ADEe05 2 ADDE 4 8AIE*04 4AODE*06 7AE*061.021E40F 1AME*05 2 ADDE 4 8.tE3904 4A09E4 4.3BDE4 3.964E*06 l D 1ATIE*05 2 ADDE 4 sal 2E4 4AODE4 7ABE*061At@0F 1 AME4 2 ADDE *05 4.tE2E4 4A0lE4 6.2BDE43.99@06 141.50dE41A52E41.551E4 4AODE4 5.95@06 4JEE*061.16@051J52E41.551E4 9A9EE*06 7.541E4 5.0BdE*06 i 1 A52E4 1.50$E4 1.551E4 1 Adde *07 5.19@061.119E*07 . ll ' 151.501E*051 A52E41.51E4 4A00E4 5.95@06 4.3B061.16@051J52E41.551E4 9AGEE4 7.561E4 5A88E4 1 A52E4 1.50$E*05 1.551E4 1 A6 DEMIT 5.194641.119E4 16 1 A65E4 1.50& *05 1.549E4 1 A61E4 5.19@06 1.12SE*07 1 A63E4 1.506E4 1.549E4 1 A61 EMIT 8.158E4 1 A0@0F { t 17 1 Ad3E4 1.50$E4 1.549E4 1 A61E*0F 5.19@06 1.125E*07 1 A65E4 1.50dE4 1.54SE4 1 A61 EMIT 8J58E*06 1 A0@07 18 1 AME45 1.502E*G5 1.586E4 1 AGE 40T 8J5EE4 1.39tE407 1.73dE4 1.115E4 1.582905 1.918E*07 3 RIE4 1JtDE*07 1.502E*05 1.4ME*05 1.586E4 1.8EE*07 6.05E41.7ME*07 ( 191 AME41.502E41.586E41 AGE *0F 8J58E*061.398E*071J3dE+051.125E41.586E*051.918E+07 3RIE4m 1.lt9E*07 l I C-48 I (
I sy: Date: Odd Date: 800wAKIE C#91PE 2.0, WIFORM SMCTRA FMLEN M14 *"-- --** PAE:8P4-2f. I 1.502E+05 1.474E+05 1.58M+05 1.8COE+07 6.QWE+06 1.7M+07 I 201.50f.E+05 2.025E4 7.548E40f.1EK4071.278E*071.I58E*071.50fE+05 2.025E405 7.548E41.803E+071R9E+071.0W5E+07 211.50Ge05 2.025E4 7.548E40f.1.82E4071.278E+071.138E+071.504405 2.03E*05 7.548E+061.803E*071R9E*071.CNE*07 22 4.381E+05 3.71[Y4 2.745E*05 3.4GiE407 421E407 8.57E*07 4.381E4 3.753E405 2.KSE4 3A05E407 6.tNEE*071N2E406
- 23 4.381E4 3.753E+05 2.MSE+05 3.405E*07 4.861E407 8.57tE407 4.351E4 3.?E5E4 2.RSE4 3A05E+07 6EEE*07142E405 26 2.50WE*05 8.01E4 8.302E4 5A86E41.0fdE*051.08SE*06 2.50fE4 SEIE4 8.302E4 5A85E4143OE4 4.525E4 25 2.50GE4 8.01E405 8.3G2E4 8.00E41.0fdE*061.088E*08 2.50GE4 SE1E4 SE2E4 8.00E-06 2.025E41E8E4 I 261.025E4 2E6E4 4.3NE+05 2.36dE*07 5.18R*07 4RGE4071.05E4 ZEdE4 4.3ddE4 2.3ddE407 341tE*07 3E7E*07 271RSE4 2EdE405 4.368E4 2.36dE*07 5.18DE407 4RBE4071.025E4 2EdE405 4.368E*05 2.36dE*07 3418E407 3E7E*07 8 261.02EE4 2EdE*05 4AI5E405 2.361E*07 3418E*07 3.ddOE@ 1.028E4 ZEdE4 4A35E*05 2.361E907 5.9ME41.7117.407 291 AGE *06 2.918E405 2.22EE*05 4E1E4 5.11BE406121E+07140E*06 2.918E4 2.2N405 4.551E4 2.1ME*07 TRIE406 I 301.028E406 N405 4A35E4 2.361E4073418E407 3JdOE*071.018E4 2EGE4 4A55E4 2.361E407 5.9NE41.790E*07 31 123E4 2.998E4 4.50fE4 2.361E*07 5.971E*061.711E*071.053E4 2.918E4 4.50EE4 2.361E*07 2A68E*07 3 ADDE 406 32 IJ28E4 L95BE4 2.1GE*05 4.551E4 2.1ME407 7.021E41J28E4 L95EE905 2. IGE 4 4E1E4 3Rh*07 2RIE*07 33125E4 L918E4 4.30fE4 2.361E*07 5.9E*061.711E*071.053E405 2.918E4 4.5 DIE 4 2.361E*07 2AOBE4073AdBE4 341.057E406 4.500E6 2.935E4 2.3dlE43,55BE*06 2 AGE *071.03E*05 5.%1E4 2.155E*05 2.355E407 72E4 L19EE*07 l 9.23E4 &51E+05 2.955E405 2.253E*071.395E*07 3.922E*07 351.057E*06 4.509E4 2.955E*c5 2.30tE43.53DE*06 2AE9071.007E*06 5.%1E4 2.955E4 2.355E*07 '
7R5E4119EE*07 . 'I 9.258E4 L514E405 2.955E4 2.257E*071.395E4073.922E407 36 9.250E+05 0410E*051.192E406 2.257E*071922E4071.3R2EM 9.2BE4 L410E41.192E4 2.257E+071.757E*06 8.363E*07 371419E406 4EEE41.199E4 4.951E*06 3RSE407 2RIE4071419E406 4EEE41.199E406 4.551E4061 A61E408 L83dE407
- 3B 9.250E4 L410E41.192E4 2.257E*07 3.922E*071.3R2E+07 9.250E405 641E*051.192E405'2.257E*071.757E*06 8.2EE*07 3P 5.9 TEE +051E3E4061.273E4 5.952E4 2A44E*06 3.2DE*05 5.1EDE*051 A3E41.273E406 5.952E-06 3E1E41.314E4 40 L491E*051.2ZFE41.32E4 2JGE41EIEWIB 1 AGE 408 6APIE41.227E41.325E4 2.1GE4 7.3dBE*07 L180E*07 412.710E6 4.STIE4 5.591E4153E4 T.31IE*07 L1EE*0F 2.790E4 4RIE4 LSEEE41.EDE4 3E4E*07 25dE4 g
I 421.171E4 2.0GE4 2AISE41.515E4 L3HE*07 258E*0F 1.179E4 2.00E4 2A38E41.515E-061. AWE 4 3.35E4 43 9.250E4 6410E61.1EIE406 2.253E*0F 1J53E*0B 8.3GE*0F 9.250E405 4A10E41.11EE4 2.257E*07 3REW 1.EIE*07 441419E4 LE53E41.199E4 4.551E*061A61E4 083SE*0714f9E4 425E4051.199E4 L551E406 3.9EE40F 2RIE*0F I 45 9.250E*05 L410E41.19BE*06 2.257E*071.757E*06 8.265EM 9.250E4 6410E41.192E406 2.253E*07 3.112aE*071.3DGE*07 46127E405 4.509E4 2.955E4 2.3dDE*073.539E4 2A98EW 1.1D71906 5.%1E4 2.955E4 2.355E*07 7R5E406 3.198E+07 9.258E+05 ASME4 2.955E+05 2.257EW 1.395907 3.922E@ 471.057E4 4.50E*05 2.935E*05 2.3 DOE *073.53E4 2A9EE*071.007E+06 5.%1E4 2.955E4 2.355E+07 7.825E4 3.19tE*07 9.25EE*05 &514E4 2.955E+05 2.25719071.395907 3R2EW 481.053E*0$ 2.918E4 4.50f4+05 2.361E407 2A98E*073A5E4051.053E*05 2.918E4 4.50fE405 2.361E+07 5.97tE41.711E407 491J28E406 2.95BE+05 2.1GE405 4.551E41125907 2R1E*07142EE*06 2.95EE*05 L19E4 4.S51E*06 2.17M907 721E+06 I i 50123E4 2.918E4 4.50fE+05 2.361E*07 2A9BE4071450E*06125E405 2.918E405 4. Sore 405 2.361E*07 5".97tE9061.711E*07 51 1.02EE*06 2EdE4 4AIIE*05 2.361E*C7 5.978E4061.710EW 1.005E4 2EdE4 4AIIE*05 2.361E+07 3418E+07 3J60h407 52140E6 2.918E4 2.22EE405 4.551E*06 2.17t4@ TRIE4061.60E406 2.918E405 2.22KE405 4.551E+06 5.920E41E1E407
- 531.02EE+06 2EdE405 4A53E405 2.361Eic7 5.9?EE4061.710E4071.02EE406 2EdE4 4A53E4 2.361E+07 3418E907 3JdOE407 I 541RSE+05 2EdE4 4.36dE*05 2.36dF407 3418E+07 3EEE4071.025E4 2.85dE4 4.368E4 2.36dE*07 5.189E+07 4B8E907 551.025E+06 2EdE*05 4.368E405 2.35dE407 3418E*07 3EFE4071R5E406 2EdE405 4.368E405 2.366E*07 5.189E407 4E8E407 56 2.50GE405 8E1E405 8.302E4 0.03]E4CD L551E4 2.905E4 2.50fE4 SE1E4 8.302E405 0.00'E@ 1.0fdE4081. GEE 908 I 57 2.50r44 SE1E+05 8.33E4 0.030E*00 4A89E-06 3.1tSE-06 2.50GE+05 8E1E4 8.32905 0.(00E4001.046E40S 1.0BDE*06 58 4.32ME405 3.7tDE905 2.M5E4 3AEiE407 LOR 2E*071 A72E*05 4.381E4 3.7tDE405 2.K5E*05 3A05E*07 451E407 8.579E*07 59 4.381E405 3.7tDE405 2.7G405 3 AGE 407 LO92E*071.02E*05 4.3tnE4 3JtDE4Gi 2.MSE4 3 ace 407 421E*07 8.571E407 I 601.50GE4 2.025E*05 7.548E+041.20E*071B9E4071.05fE4071.504405 2R5E+05 7.54tE40r.1.tu5E+071.27tE4071.35EE+07 611.50GE405 2RSE405 7.54tE4041E59071R5E4071.QWE+071.50GE4 2.025E4 7.548E*0f.1E3E4071.27tE4071.35E407 621 A7&E+051.5G2E*Qi 1.58fE*051.457E*07 8.752E41.33SE4071.73E+Qi 1.185E*Ci 1.52E*051.918E407 3E3E4061.79E+07 1.502E41.CLE41.52E4051E5E407 A05E+051.772E*07 63 1 A74E+05 1.5GE405 1.585E4 1.45?E*07 8.75tE4051.3;EE4071.73E405 1.185E4Gi 1.52E405 1.92E407 3E3E4051.79E+07 lW 1.5G2E405 1 A74E405 1.5&M905 1 E5E407 6.0%E+06 1.772E*07 I
~.
C-49 I
py: Date: Desi:. Det2: 8EAOMWKjNG CAPPIPE 2.0, UtifolM 9TCTRA MEAL 94 M).4 ---*----
- PpE:W. 25 i
W.1.M3E4 1.50ff4 1.549E4 1 A61E*07 8.758E4 1 AOLE*07 1.MX4 1.506E4 1.54K4 1.M1EW 5.19r.E4 1.125E*07 d6 1.M3E4 1.506E4 1.549E4 1 A61EW R.75dE4 1 A0le07 1 AG4 1.50fe05 1.549E*r5 1 A61E*07 5.19GE4 1.125EM ; 461.506E41 A52E41.551E*05 4A00E4 5.954E4 4.21BE41.164E41.752E*051.551E4 9A92E*06 7.541E4 5.GedE4 1 1 A52E*05 1.505E4 1.551E4 1 Adde *07 5.19EE4 1.111E@ 471.50SE41 A52E41.551E*05 4A0GE4 5.954E4 4.EBE41.16fe051.752E41.551E4 9AGGE*06 7.541E4 5.08dE*06 # 1 A52E4 1.506E4 1.551E4 1 A6dE*07 5.19fe06 1.119E@ j 481A71E4 2.000E4 8.052E*0f 4A0DE4 6.EEE4 3.15e061A71E4 2.00E4 8.052E4 4A0DE4 7.8f&41.lE9E*07 491A744 2.000E4 8.Gi2E4 4A00E4 6.EEE4 3.1 BEE 41A71E4 2.000E4 S.052E4 4A09E4 7.8faE41.tE9EM 70 7.sglE*06 2.2OE41.0DE41.00dE*07 9AIE41.73E@ 9.3ME*06 2.185E41.0DE*05 Y.2ME41.00fe071.50E*07 1 A5E41 AB0E41 ADE4 4A11Ea06 9.5EE*06 S.540E406 l 731.300E41.10BE4 2.3fR4 3.0ddE41.9ME*073.15E*0F 1414E4 4.182E4 2.30E4 4.25dE*06 7.aEIE41J1dE*0F 1.ddGE4 22dE4 2.2ME4 4.50E4 5.1aE41EEe0P i 72 72154 2JGie 1ARE*051.EDE*0F 9Afe061.13E40P 9.3ME4 L1EE*051ADE4 7.3EGE41.004EM 1.50E40r j 1 ABBE 41.EllE41ARE4 4Atue06 95fE406 S.54E406 B 7JUE*06 LSIE41.0GE41ADEe07 9.SE*061.15E@ 7.Sf7E4 2.251E41.0f54051.OWEW 1.912073. MEW M 1.2F1E41.115E4 2.2154 3.OBE41.9EE*073.15E4071.2 TIE 41.115E4 2.2154 3.OBE4 3.521E@ 1AIE4 5 7ADE4 2.251E41.068E41.80E40F 9.SEe061.13E*0F 7. SUE 4 2.251E41 ALAE 41 ADEM 1.90BE@ 3.MEM M 1.17JE4 4ASE4 2.314E4 L12Ee072AEedf 4 AGE @ 1.17E*06 4AIE4 2.314E4 2.121EW 4.36EE*07 8.95E6 771.15dE4 9.2FM41A0fe06 2J19E4 7mE*071.75E41.15dE4 9.27241A9fe06 2.519E4 3.3M*08 3A1BE4 4 X 6.254E4 9.50dE4 9.3dE4 22EE4 3.37tE*05 3A19E4 6.254E*05 9.50dE4 9.210E4 2.299E41.10BE41.10E*0B i 79 4.10dE4 S.299E4 S.22BE41.182E41.10DE41.10E6 4.?DdE4 8.299E4 8.229E41.182E4 9.19E6 9.11AMIT 80 3.154E4 4.350E6 6.M2E*05 2.0GE4 9.190E8079.11dE*073.154E*05 6.35E4 6.352E4 2.0G2E4 9.13EE41.54dE4 l l 8 . . q i i I I l c-5o (
ey: Date: Dad: Date: ' * * (DONAKING G4FPIPC 2.0, tNIF0et 5FIECTRA HCIM NO.4 ----*-+--* PAT:D44 215 1 CAPPIM WERSICN 2.0 MESA.TS I EIAM PX(1)
- 80. PKCJ)
W(I) W(J) 11.2DEE*06 0.0GE+00 VZ(I) V2(J) TX(1) TX(J)
*(l)
NT(J) Mt(l) PK(J/C) W(J/C) VZ(J/C) TX(J/C) M(J/C) MZCJ/C) Mt(J) I 2 9.3nC*05 0.000E400 31.200E*06 0.000E+00 4 9.371E*05 0.000E*00 5 7JUIE*05 0.IIIE*00 lI 6 3.SIEE 4 0.000E*00 7 7J0se4 0.0aE4 l 81.00E*06 0.00DE*00 . l 9 1 351E 4 0.03E*00 101.251E*06 OAGE4 113.SIEE*G5 0.00tE4 - 121.057E4 CADIEe00 - U TJUBE4 0.05E*00 W 14 1.251E 4 0.000E 6 . .* O 7JUDE*05 0.00Ee00 - - " * 'g M 1.251E*06 0.000Er00 - g 171.20BE*06 0.000E400 - - 161.208E*06 OAutF4 19 9.371E4 0.000E*00 - * *
. E 9.37tE4 CA01Ee00
- 13.1544 L3Elel5 4.30E6 6AIEEe00 8.0EEe00 0.000E*00 3.154E4 L330E4 6JIGE4 SAREE 00 9.15tl@ 9.1 DIES . .
2 4JOEst5 8.NES SJalE4 S.00Ee00 9.157E807 910tE*0F 4J0dE4 8.BSE4 8.23E4 0.0EEe001JEHe051JOEeIB
, 3 6253E4 9Af0Ee05 9.2ME4 8.00Ee001JIIE41J00E*05 L253E4 f. WOE 4 9.BIE4 aany*00 3.35 pets 3A1Ee05 lI 41.1554 9.25IE41ASE806 8.00343.3P5 stb 5414E*081.13E4 9.259Ee051ADE806 SA10Ee00 TAEW 1J5EstB . . - .
51.1754 4E9E4 2.315E4 2.110E407 4J6tE*07 8.1tRE*071.172E4 4EIE4 2.3M4 L11dE*07 2.191E4 4AllE*07 I 6 7ADE4 2J2EE41.00E41.tDGE*071.900E*073J5dE407 7.St3E4 2.23E41.00E41.000E*07 9A7E41J50E*0F 7 TAGE4 2.2EE41.00E61.00dE4071.901E43J5dE*07 7.8DE4 2.23E41.00E41.000E*079R7E4061JIE40F 81.271E41.114E*06 2.21tE4 3.GNE406 3.517E*071.081E*061.271E41.114E*06 2210E4 LOBEE4061.98E*07113E407 ,
- 9 7.88E4 2.25lE41.t5dE41A0 GEM 9.dEE*061J31E*07 9.30E4 2.18E4051A5dE405 7.229E4 j.OEE4071.2ddE*07 I 1A57E4051.0BIE41.05dE4 4405E*06 9R3E406 8.537E*06 .
101.260E*061.10BE*05 2.261E41964E41.9hE*07 3.13E*071AS4E4 4JEE*05 2.341E4 4.250E*05 7EIE41.5M4 1AIE*06 2.85dE4 2.341E4 4.53dE4 5.9tE41.051E407 -
- I 117.85E*06 2.25E*051.05dE41.00E*07 9.dB2E41J31E*07 9.38BE4 2.18]E*C51 A5dE*05 7.23E41.GIE40F 1.308E4 1A57E41.0kE41.05dE*05 4Af5E406 9.57E*06 8.537E406 121.47EE4051.99FE405 LOQE4 4A02E4 7.BBE41.019EM 1A7tE4051.99?E405 8.00E4 4 AGE 4 L271E4 3.922E4 I
U 1.47EE41.9PPE*05 8.00E*06 4AG2E4 7.05lE41.0t9E*071 A7tE41.9P7E4 8.00E406 4AGRE405 6.271E*06 3.922E*06
% 1.50GE4051 A50E*051.549E4 4Ad2E*06 5.90E4 4.2BE41.MIE41.M9E41.549E*05 9A77E*06 7.529E*06 5.081E4 1 A50E4 1.50E*05 1.549E405 1 A64E*07 5.18E+05 1.117E*07 51.50GE*051A50E*051.549E4 4A02E4 5.1QE406 4.2BE41.10E41JME41.56EE*05 9AT/E406 7.529E4 5AB1E*06 8
I 1 A50E6 1.50GE*05 1.549E4 1 A64E407 5.18E4 1.117t*07
- 16 1 A61E4 1.5GE*05 1.5CE*Gi 1 A59E*075.10$E*06 1.13E*071 A61E4 1.5GIE405 1.5CE405 1 A99EM37 LM5E4 1 AME407 17 1 A61E*05 1.505E405 1.50E*:5 1 AS9E+07 5.18dE*061.124C407 1.E9E4 1.505E4 1.5CE4 1 A95E4 8.M5E405 1 AGE 907 g 18 1.472E4 1.50E405 1.566E405 1 Ad5E*07 8.M5E4 1.3;tE*07 1.733E4 1.1 TEE 4 1.5tKE4 1.915E+07 3.4529E*06 1J54E+07 g 1.500E41 A7E*051.5tKE4051.80E*07 &lBIE41J70EW 19 1 A72E4 1.500E*05 1.5t%E4 1 Ad5E407 8.M5E4 1.3ME407 1.7I3E*05 1.18GE4 1.St%E4 1.9tSE*07 3425E406 IJIME*07 1.50141 A72E41.55.E41.80T*07 6051E41.710E*07 201.502E*C6 2.022E*05 7.543E41.tKE4071.271E+071.331E*071.502E4 2.E2E+05 7.543E41.800E+071B7E*071.09E+07 C-51 I
g sy: Dete: CNrt Date: soomtric cwn 2.0. unta Mcm isostrM mA --~~--- PsaE:W.-27 211.502E+05 2.022E+05 7.50E*0f.1.10CD071.2RE*071.15?E*071.502E4 2R2E*05 7.5G41.80CD071.677E*071E7EATI 22 4.320E*05 3.77tE4 2.7a4 3A00E437 4.M407 835'D07 4.320E405 3J/IE4 2.70E*05 3.400E<T7 6.0tkD071.4MD05 23 4.3tDE*05 3.77BE45 2.7G4 3A00E407 4.M407 8.5R407 4.350E4 3.77tE405 2.7aM5 3AaIM37 6.096E*0714RE*05 24 2.$or.E4 8.6M+05 8.30tE4 0.000E+001.0ME+061.CB6E408 2.50W5 84M4 8.300E4 020EM10 0.000E400 0.000E430 25 2.50GE4 8.6M45 8.3t0E4 0.000E4101.0WeOS 1.08D05 2.504E4 84M4 8.300E4 0.000E*00 0.000E4 0. FEE *00 261.025E4 2.836E+05 4.361E4 2.3E407 5.181E*07 4REE+071R5E406 7M4 4.361E405 7 W<l7 3412E*07 3E7E*07 m 271.025E*05 2E6E+05 4.361E4 2.3E+07 5.181E+07 4R8E*071.G5E+06 2.85deGi 4.361E4 2.30E407 3412E4 3E7 EMIT 261REE+06 2E604 4A36E4 7 YM*07 3412E407 3A60E*071.GHE406 2EdE+05 4A2EE4 2.358E+07 5.1EGE41.710E*07 29140E4 2.91dE4 2.221E4 4.544E+06 5.912E4121E*071AG+06 2.918E4 2.221E4 4.544E+06 2.171E*07 7.GDE*06 301RGE4 2.856E4 4A26E4 2.358E4IT 3412E*07 3A60E*071.G8E4 22dE4 4A26E4 2.358E+07 5.989E41.710E*07 31 1.053E4 L918E*05 4A97E4 2.358E*07 5.9eSE41.710E*071.153E4 2.918E4 4AF1E405 2.358E+07 2A9EE*073 Adde 4 321427E*05 2.95lE4 L160E4 4.544E*06 2.17tE*07 7.GOE*061J2?E4 2.9EE4 2.160E4 4.544E41918 EMIT 2J21EW 351EE*06 2.918E4 4AP7E4 2.35EE+07 5.98DE41.710E*071. TEE *06 2.911E4 4A97E4 23EE+07 2A04E*07 3 Adde 406
- 341.tE7E*06 4.5GEMIS E954E*05 227E4073.557E*06 2AGEE+071.03E406 5.135E4 2.154805 2.352E407 T.820E6 3.196E407 9.25dE*G5 6.510E4 2.954E+Gi 2.25E*071.30EE*0719tdE*07 g 351.05?E406 4.5GE4 2.954E4 237E*073.553E*06 2.40E8071.007E4 5.tIIE4 L154E4 232E*07 7.83)E406 3.194E*07 g 9.25dE*05 A510E405 2.954E4 2.25lE@ 1.302E4 3. fide *07 .
36 9.2E8E+05 4ACBE41.192E406 2.254E*07 3.9tdE*071.3PIEW 9.2E8E4 L408E41.192E4 2.2546071.757E*05 8.361E407 371419E406 4.852E41.199E406 4.544E*06 3.918E*07 2R1E*07141EE4 4.853E41.199E*06 4.544E4061 A61E4 6A3BE*07 - .- 35 9.368E4 6AOBE41.192E406 2.22073.9tdE*071.3P1E*0T 9.2EBE4 6AOBE412192E4 2.254E*071.757E*06 8.261E*07 - 39 5.980E4051R3E41.273E*05 0.000E*00 2A44E*05 3.20E*06 5.980E41B3E*061.273E*06 0.000E*00 0.000E400 0.000E@ 40 6A91E4G51.2Z7E4061.3i!I*06 0.00(E 001.857E+0S IJ42E*08 6A91E+051.227E4051.325E*06 0.00E*00 7.26dE407 L18EW 412.710E4 4 RUE 4 5.9P1E+05 0.000E*00 7.268E+07 L18E4 2.710E4 4RDE*Gi 5.9 PIE *05 0.000E+00 3.2E4E*07 2J06E@ l W 421.TTIE4 2.0E4 2A57E4 IL000E6 3.364E4 2AE*071.171E4 2AG2E4 2A57E4 0.00E*00 6.00E*00 ILaulE*00 43 9.3EEM5 L40E*051.19EE*06 2.254E*071.757E*08 8.361E*07 9.3EdE*05 64m8051.1RE4 2.254E*07 3.9tE*071.WlE*07 441419E4 4.852E41.199E4 4.544E*061.461E4 L830E*071419E*06 4A53E*051.19EE4 4.544E*06 3.918E4 2RIE4IT 45 9.368E4 L40E41.1EEE4 2.25d*071.757E*08 8.36tE407 9.3EE4 L40E41.182E4 L254E*073.9 TEM 1.WlE*07 461.057E*06 4.5054 2.9205 237E*0F3.557E4 2ADEE*071.03E*06 5.13lE4 224E*05 2.352E*07 7.8EE*06 3.194E*07 h 9.256E4 L510E+Gi 2.954E4 2.25E*071.392E*0719tdE*CF 471.t37E4 4.5GE4 2.954E4 2.357E4071557E4 2A9EE*071.007E+06 5.135E+05 2.954E4 232E*07 T.8ME4 3.796E407 W 9.23dE4 6.510E405 2.95GE4 2.25E@ 1.3GK4073.9tdE*CF 481.053E*06 2.918E+05 4AME+05 2.358E*07 2A9Ce073A6dE*061.153E4 2.918E+Gi f A9?E4 238E4 5.969E+061.710E407 491427E+06 2.958E*05 2.162+05 4.544E4 3.9EE+07 2.821E*071J2?E+06 2.95lE4 2.160E*05 4.544E4 2.171E*07 7.GRE4QS 501.GUE+06 2.918E+G5 4ANG 2.350E407 2A9GE4 3A6dE*061.055E4 2.91dE4 4JWE4 2.358E407 5.9sE 061.710EM 511.fl8E4 2EdE4 4A2de05 2EEE*07 5.98DE41.750 EMIT 1.02E*06 2EdE405 4A35E4 238E*07 3412E4073AdOE+07 5214240$ 2.912E4 2.2?tE+Gi 4.544606 2.171EW 7.03E*051AM406 2.91tE+05 2.221E4 4.544E4 5.9CE4061.851E407 531.028E406 2EdE405 4A26E4 238E+07 5.96EE*061.710E+071REE*06 2J6dE4 4A26E4 2.3SEE*07 3412E*07 3.90E407
- 541RSE4 2EdE*C5 4.361E4 2.32407 3412E*073AS7E*GT 1RSE406 2EdE*05 4.361E4 PM407 5.181EW 4R8E*07 551R5E*06 2EdE4 4.361E4 2.3E4073412E*07 3E7E+071.025E4 2.83dE4 4.361E4 2.32W 5.181E*07 4REE*07 g 56 2.50GE4 8419E4 8.3EE405 020E*00 0.0ZIE4 0.000E*00 2.5024 8.619E405 8.3EE4 0.00E4001.0GdE4081.Gl6E*05 3 57 2.50GE4 8479E4 8.300E4 0.00EE*00 0.tDDE4 0.000E400 2.50E4 8419E*05 8.3024 0.000E*001.0GdE*051.086E*06 58'4.3824 3.77tE4 2.70E45 3A0E*07 008dE*071470E408 4.3tl0E4 3.77EE405 2.7G+05 3A00E407 4.Iti9E407 8.559E+07 59 4.35I+05 3.77tlE+05 2.70E6 3A00E*07 6.08f4071.4ME*06 4.35I4G5 3.77tE4G5 2.A3E4 3 AGE 407 4.tD5E407 8.SR407 601.502E4 2.022E+05 7.50E+061.800E*071RK+071.06?E4071.502E4 2K2E4 7.50E4061.EDOE+071.271E4071.33?E+07 611.502E4 2R2E405 7.50E+041.200E4071B7E4071.02071.502E4 2R2E4 7.50E*061.fDOE+071.27K+071.357E*07 62 1 A72E4 1.500 EMS 1.58GE4 1 Ad2iE*07 8.A5E406 1.3sEE4071.735E405 1.184E405 1.52%E405 1.91SE407 3.625E*061.764EW 1.50I45 1 A72E4 1.554E4 1.800E407 LCB1E41.770EW W 65 1 A72E+05 1.500E405 1.584E*05 1 A85E+07 8.ASE41.396E*071.733E4 1.18GE45 1.51%E4 1.915907 3 A29E4061.764E407 1.500E405 1 A72E+05 1.584E4 1.tDE+07 6.081E405 1.770E+07 64 1 A61E4 1.505005 1.547E4 1 A59E*07 8.ASE405 1 A02E+07 1 A61E4 1.5EB05 1.547E4 1 ASGE*07 5.18de05 1.124E407 65 1 A61E+G5 1.5GBQi 1.547E4 1 A5T407 8.A$e051.402E4071 A61E4 1.505E4 1.547E+05 1 A59607 5.186605 1.124E407 C-52 I
I.
~^
en Dete:- ced: Oste: NING WP!PE 2.0, (WON sicTRA pamtm so.4 .......... g.g.g 661.50GE41 A50E41.5'W4 4 AGE 406 5.90E4 4.*441.1a41.7WE41.54W4 9ATM4 7.52We 5 081E4 1 A50E*051.50r4 051.MW41A64E437 5.18E.061.11M47 6F 1.506E+051 A50E451.MW45 4 AGE 4 5.90E416 4.29GE41.1G41.7WE451.%9E4 9ATM4 7.529 1 A50E4 1.50r44 1.%%05 1.464e+0F 5.1a6E4 1.11MMIT l O 1 AME41.99FE4 8.00E+0f. 4A08E*06 6.27tE4 3.1EaE41AME41.9PM4 8.0644 4A03E4 7.EIBE41. ' eP 1AME41.994*05 8.0f.7E4 4 AGE 4 6.271E4 3.1EIE41 AME41.9PR4 S.00E4 4.402E*06 7.55BE41 10 7.setE4 2.23DE41.EdE41.0ME*07 9.dS2E41.731 EMIT 9.35BE4 2.1SIE*051.05dE4 7.229E*061. 1 ASM41 ABdE41.056Em 4AGEEnos 9.5724 855M416 l 71 1.269E41.10BE4 2.341E4 3.084E*061.9ddE4r 3.13dE*071414EC 4.152E4 2.361E4 4.2EE4 TRIE 1.dS9E4 2. Ride 4 2.361E4 4.55dE*06 3.fleMI61.ES1E807 72 7.880E41.250F41.15dE41ADEEe07 9.ddiE41.75tE*0F 9.3BE4 L1RE41AldE4 7.229E41AEE*071.B 1A57E41.8BIE*051.GidE4 4AdlEe06 9.572406 8.55D66 73 7.SDE4 2.31E451.00E61.00dE*0F 9JFMe061.13OE40F 7J1I4 2.EEE41.00E*051. code *0F 1.90d ! M 1.271E41.11@06 2.210E4 3.0BIE*061.9dIEe0F3.13fE4f 1.271E41.114E*06 2.210E4 3.CBEEC 3.51 f 75 TAGE*06 2.2BIE41.0GE41.CtblEsdr 9AFR*061.75lE*0F 7.813E4 2.23BE41.00E41.00dE4r 1.900E4 M 1.17E4 4EIE4 2.3M4 2.11Ee072AMEe0F 4.010E*0P 1.172E4 4RIE4 231EM5 7.11E4P 4.361E4 S.1 771.15dE4 9.239E41A9fd*06 OA00E*00 7.87BEWIT 1.755*051.15dE*06 9.2HE41AME*06 0.Q0tE*00 75 6.255EG 9A80E4 9.25BE4 3.00D00 3.3P24 3A14Ee0B 6.25B05 9A00E4 9.25EE4 0.000E41.70BE4 79 0.101E4 8.EdE4 S.230E4 0.00Ee001.1tIEe0B 1J0dE4 4.10E*05 S.BIE4 E.23T45 0.00 tee 00 9.1EF 82 3.15@05 6.3EIE4 6.3EE4 0.00(E4 9.187E*0T 9.101E4 3.15@05 6.32DE4 6.3EE4 0.00WedD 0.00E*00 l I I f I l C-53 1
m . Dy: Date: 04d: Date: EDO9WKING CM98K 2.0, udlFON SYCTRA PatBUM 80.6 -..---~ PNE:ENG 29 1 PetGWIA'E DifFUDES 3CMDd putEG A80 C#914 WtSION 2.0 (IESED Of auEC): 9 99 PM(t) W(1) WCI) TX(1) M(1) 8E(I) PM(JK) W(J/C) W(JK) TM(JK) *(JK) K(JK)
- 10. ~ PM(J) W(J) W(J) TX(J) *(J) M(J) q 1 4.06E WA II/A WA WA WA al/A II/A II/A II/A St/A II/A 1 2 4.1d5 II/A si/A st/A st/A IL/A II/A II/A II/A IL/A II/A II/A 3 4 .061 syA II/A II/A WA II/A II/A II/A II/A II/A St/A II/A 4 4.M WA WA tyA II/A ti/A WA II/A II/A II/A WA IIM j 5 4M WA IVA WA fl/A 81/A IVA 84/A WA WA WA WA I 6 4.EEE WA st/A II/A II/A II/A II/A II/R 91/A al/A II/A II/A 7 -0. M WA II/A st/R II/A 'st/A st/A syn IFA st/A - II/A II/A q 0 4.M ~ al/A 81/A II/A II/A II/A II/A IVA N/A II/A II/A II/A 9 4.tBK II/A II/A 91/ 4 II/A 81/A II/A 81/A II/A WA h/A II/A $
10 - 4M II/A II/A IBM II/A Ilm al/A 84/A II/A II/A 81M llM 11 4.6 ' II/A II/A II/A II/A II/A al/A syn II/A II/A IIM II/A 12 405 WA II/A sl/A syn al/A II/A 81/A alm ti/A II/A II/A 13 41EE II/A 81/A IVA II/A II/A 11/A II/A tt/A II/A II/A II/A
' M 4M II/A al/A alm II/A st/A II/A II/A II/A al/A Ilm al/A y
b 4M 81/A bl/A al/A II/A 81/A II/A N/A al/A II/A ti/A IVA 16 4.GIE II/A GVA II/A IyA alm al/A IIM alm II/A al/A $1/A 37 40E IyA II/A st/A II/A II/A 31/A II/A II/A li/A N/A 81/A 16 40E al/A N/A alm II/A stM alm 81/A II/A II/A II/A Iyn 19 4W 8VA II/A alm syA N/A II/A al/A II/A II/A II/A II/A El 4.18E II/A IIM alm IWA IIM EM al/A SVA II/A 11 4 IWA 1 0.05 Als 4 IRE EM II/A 34 cm 41E 40E II/A 4JEE 4W 2 0.05 0.M 40s llA 48E 41E Sm 41E 4AIE al/A 4 0dK 4M j
'3 4aEE 4.M 4.05 11 4 40E 4 11E 4M 4M 4KZ 'IVA 45 4M 4 0.0E 0.1R tu n/R 4 GIE 4 15E 0.0E 4 15E 0.EE IWA 4 01E 4M $ 5 OAK 0.M 44.? 4 14E A SPE 0.15 0.03 0. M 405 -0.1GC -0.05E 4M l l
6 4.05E . 4.tX 4.10E 433 -0.10E $l.1R 4.GIK -0.tX 0.10E 435 4 125 4 .121
- 7 4 05E 4 13E 4.10E 420E 4.10E 41st 4 05E 4.tB 4.10E 4.31E 4 125 4 12K 8 0.0E 4 0PE 4 14K 4tBE 4 111 , 4 0PX 0.00K 4 095 -0.%% 4.05E 4 15E 4.lBK j e 0.05 e.10E -0.05 -Om 0. M 0.M 0.0E 0. m 0.05 0.M -0.zE 0. m -
4 0PE 4.1d5 4 005 4 15 AM 4 14E IIM II/A alm IVA II/A II/A 10 0.8E 0.4E 4 0P1 4 0Pt 4.15 4EIE 0.05 0.05 4 0PE 4 14E 4M 4 0PE 4 0EE 0.0E -0.0PX 4 15K 4.15K 0.0E ILM II/A ti/A II/A II/A N/A 11 4 0SK 4 18E 4.0PK 0.35 4 125 4 12E 4.01E 0.%% -0.0PK -0,19E 4m 4.10E 4 0PE 4.idt 4 0PK 4 14E 4.15E 4 14E II/A al/A IVA fA R/A II/A 12 ORE -0.15E 4.0E 4 15 -0.15E 43K 0.0PE 4.15E 4 05 42 4 14E 4 05E ) is 0.M 4 1sE -0.05 0.15 4tX -e m 4 0rE 4.M -0.0E 0.15 -0. m ace 1
% 41R AME 4.13E 41E 4.125 0.125 4 09E 4.M -0.15E 4 1dt 4.15 4 15 4.MK 4.1R 4. tit 4 .14% 415K 4 18K II/A II/A II/A IIM ILM IBM 15 0.13E 4.MX 4 13K A idt 4 125 4.121 4 09E -0. M 4.15E 4.idE 4 .18% 4.1(K j 0.14E 4tX -0.tX -0.ME 4 1st -0.1st IWA n/A IyA aM IvA . aim 16 -0.%% 4.071 41R 0.14E 415E 4 09E 4 14E 0.071 4 13E 4.14K 4 15E 4%%
17 4%E 4 071 4 13K 4 *'% 4 155 -0.0PK -0.%E 4 07E 4 t35 4%% 4 15E 4%% i I 16 -0.%% 4.tX 4 13E -0 %E 415E 4.M% Am 4.05E 4 13E A idE -0.11% 4M
-0.tX - -0.%E -0.1X 0. M -0.13E -0.11% IyA IVA st/A IVA WA 81/A -0. M j 19 0.%% 4.1R -0.13E -0.%% 4.15E -0.%E 0. M 40BE 4tX -0.16K 4 111 -0.1R -0.%E -0.tX -0.M 4tX -0.111 II/A II/A II/A M/A II/A N/A 20 -0.1R -0.151 -0.075 -0.M 4GIE -0.071 -0.tR 4 151 -0.0?E -0. M 4 .121 -0.091 l
C-54 1
1 I 1 er: CAte: tNet ' Onte: CDotwettac rAPPIPE 2.0) WIFOst SPECTRA PEEBt.fM M).4 --~~ Pnot:per. 30 21 0.1R 0.13% -0.074 -0.171 -0.055 -0.07% -0.1R -0. m 4 .07% -0.17% -0. 3 -0.OR M 4.2 ' 0.12 0.071 -0.15E -0.0f.% 4%% -0. M 4.1R 0.071 -0. m 4M 4%% 25 -0.02E -0. m -0.07% -0.m 0.0r.1 0.%% -0.02E -0.1R -0.07% -0.15% 4.101 -0.%% 3f. 0.90E 4.%% -0.02E WA 0.M -CE 0.02 0.%% 4 02E WA WA WA 25 0.0R -0.%% 0. M WA 0.00E 4.18E 0.03 -0.%% -0. M et/A st/A wA - 1 a 02 Om 4.m -Om 0. M 0.0a em cm -0.ss -0.tm 4m 0.0a l w Om 0. 6 Aia 4m 4M em em 0. M Aim AM Am 0.M { m 0.0a om 0.is -0.tm -0. m om 0.0a 0.ca -Om 0.tn -Om . 0.0m i ap 0.0a 0.Oz 0.tm 0. m 4.ME 0.aK Om 0m 0.tm -0.m" -0.uK com l E 0.05 0.GE ' 4 idt 03 4M 0.05 0.M 0.6 4 1dE -0.M 4 15E em j 31 0.03 0. 6 4 18L 0.1R -0.15K 4.05 0.IEE 0.M -0.1dK AM 415 4.0E j 32 4.0$K 0.00K -0.ME 4.15E 4 141 4 01E 40S 0.05 0.MX 43 4.tB 0.0E . B 0.05 0.05 4 18 4m 4.5 40E 0.0K 0.5K AM 4 15K Ata 40m . 34 0. M 4M 4.tBK 43 4.05 41E 0.00e; -0.12E 4tBE -0.13E 4 04E 4.1R AM 0.0SL -0.tBK -0M 40m 4 15E N/A II/R . el/R al/A II/A ein i 35 0.0a 0.is -em 0.tm 40s -0.1m 0.0a -0.ta 0.GK 4tm 40a -0.tm /
-0.G2K -0.0a -0.GK 4.3 4 0rs 0. 3 WA m WA WA e n/A 36 ' 4.M 4 05E CAtX 43 415E 4 0FE 4GIE -0.tBK 0.M 43 02 4.M 37 0. M 46 0.tIX OR 4tR 0. 6 0.M 4M 0. M 4tE CAIR OM M 46 4.tFX 0.03 -4M 4R 4.0PX 4 GEE 4tBK 0.CtX 415E. ODE 0.M 3P 0.GE 0. M 0.GE WA 0.05 0.GE 0.aK 0.0E 0.03 WA al/A II/A i 40 0. TIE 0.GK 0.M ' WA 0.tRE 0.05 0.GE 0.05 0.tIK WA 4 0tE -0. 6 41 0.05 4.021 4 02K II/R 405 0.02E 0.03 4 02K 46 E/A 0B 0.00E 42 0. DIE 40E 400E II/R OM em 0.gE 44BK 4 0(% aWA II/R II/A 4 46 4dBE 0.0E 41E em 4EE 42 4 IRE em AM AM '40PE 3 46 0.05 4W 0. M 4 15 0M 0.mE 6.NE 4 02E 6.03 4M 4M 0.05 0 4EE 445E 0.03 4M 0.05 4dEK - ' 4 SEE 4alK SJ0E 4M 4M 4 0FE 46 0.SK 4M AIBK 43 40E 4M 0.0K 4 12E 4EE 4M 4 0EE 4.15E 4 TEE 4 0SK AIBK 415 40rk 4 15E II/R II/n WA WA II/A II/A 47 0.0E 4 15 0.tBE 4tB 40K 4 15 0.0K 4 125 -0.tBK -05 A OLE 4 15E 4 G2K 4 0$K 4.tBK 4.1R 4.0PE 0.15E ft/A II/A WA WA WA II/A d6 0.05 0.05 -0.tsK 0.tBK 4 15 0.0R 0.05 0.6 4M 4.13K A ISE 4 0SE 4P 4.05 0.GE -0.14E AM 43 0.GE -0.0K ' O.GE 4.14E -0.15E 4 142 4 011 50 0. TIE 0.CtX A 1dt 41R 4.1st -0.071 0.00K 0.03 4.idt 4R 4 15K 40s 51 0.00E 0.00E 4 1st 0.1x Als 0.05 0.00K 0.05 0.ist 4 13K Am 0.005 52 0.aI c. TIE 4 15K 4 15E 4 14E 4 011 0.0K 0.GE 4 15K 4 151 4ME 0.03 53 0.GE 0.ttE 0.idt 4.tX 4.15E 0.05 0.0tE 0.0K 4 1st 4 15K -0.m 0.00E E 0.0K 0.ttX 0.18K . -0.t3E 0.m 0.05 02 Om 42 43 43 0.03 5 0.03 0.05 0.1R 43 0. m 0.as 0.0E 0.0E -0.1R 4 15K 4 15K 0.05 l 56 0.GE 4.16E 4.02K II/A II/R II/A 0.GE 0.14E 42 al/A 0.03 -CM 4 l 57 0.00K 4.%% 4.02K II/A al/A syn 0.00K ANK -0. TEE WA 0.0E 4.18K 58 0.025 0. M 4 0PE 4.15K 4 10E -0.%% 4.6 -0.13K 4. ore 0.15E 4R 4%% f SP -0.025 4.M ~ 4 0PE AM 4.10E 4.MK -0.G2K 4 13K 4 071 4.15E 4 0GE AME !
40 -0.tm Om -0.m 0. m -0.m Om 0.tm 0. M -0.Orx -0. m Om 0.Grx ) 61 4 15E 4 15E 0.07X Am 4 121 4.UE 4.13E 4 15E 4 07X 4 1?E -0.0BK -0.07E 1 42 - -0.M% -03 -0.tX 4%% 4 151 -0.%% 4.m -0.05 4tX 4M 413 4m 4.13E -0.%% 4 15E -0. m 4.tX -0.11% WA II/A WA WA al/A II/A , 63 -0.EX 4.tX 0. m 4.%% 4 15E 4%% -0. m 4 0BE 4.13E -02 -0.11% 4.1?E
-0.tX -0.%% 0.13E -0. m AtX 4 11% 11/A 81/A M. WA II/A et/A
) s 4M% -0.Grx -0.tn 4 %t -0 m c.%x -0.%% 0.07x -0.c. -0.%x -0. m -Om j j s -0.Ex -0.07E -0.tn -n.ux -0. m aux 0.%% -0.Orx 4t2 -0.%x -0. m 4m J C-55 l _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _. _ _ _. _]
Bf'. Datt: y M NW 2.0, mirom sMCTRA McatM en,4 -.---..... mg.33 66 -0.12 -0.143 0.12 -0.1a -0.121 -0.12K -0.0PK 4 17% -0.12 -0.1M 0.16K -0.101
-0.14 0.12 -0.12 -0.%% -0.tSK 4.18K WA WA WA WA WA WA 67 -0.12 0.%% -0.12 -0.16K 4 121 4 12% l -0.0PK 4 17% 41R +0.14 -0.16K -0M 4 10E 4.12 -0.12 -0.%% 4 15K 4 tat WA WA (A 4.04 WA WA WA WA -0.15% -0.02 -CE 4 142 4G 0.071 4.151 40 4.M -0.16K AIR 0.201 -0.07% -0.15% 4.06K 4 1st 4MK .
70 -0.06K
- 0. R 4 071 4 15K 4 0SK -0.16K -0.13K -0.20K 0.18E 4,09% 4R 0.12K 4 12% -0.08L 414 40PI 4.15K -02 4 165
-0.071 -0M 4.09K 4.ME 4 15E AMX WA WA WA WS WA WA 71 0. M 0.001 -0.09% 4.U71 -0.1E -02K 0. M 0. M 40PK 4.K% -0.12K 0.07%
4.fdlK 0.00L 40PX 415K 41R 0.0K WA WA WA WA WA WA 72 0. M 4M 4.0PK 02 4.07E -0.idt 0.12K 4M 4 08K AME 4/JM 4.151 4.M 4.16K 40PX 0.01 41E 4MX WA WA WA WA WA WA 73 4tEK -0.1X 4.10E -0.2K 74, 4.12E 4 12K -Omt c0.13K 41tti, 4.20K 410E 4.18K 0.00K -0.0P4 4.%E 0.45E 41E 485K 0.035 4mE 4.%% 0. M 4 11K 40PX 75 4.M 0.13K 4.10K 0.2K ! 76 4 12K 4 12K 4mE 41X 4.10tt 0.L1K 4 10E 4.idt o KOK -0. M 4 .04% 4%1 0.sE AM OmE Am 4M1 l 77 0.orjE 0.1SK 0.QE 0.14: 4 071 4 1dK WA 40K -0. M 0.00K 4 15K 0,% WA 4 05E -0.15K 76 4.M 4.M 4.fEK WA 4J2M -0.15K 44EK 3 79
- 0. M 402K WA -d.0st -0.12% I 0.6 , 4.1EL -0.M3 WA 40E AM O 4M Aidt 4 .06% WA 4.05K A idt OMX 4.16K 4.0EK WA 4.tBK 4 16K 0. M 42 -0.05K WA WA WA I
i l 1 l ) ) l I c-56 i i
By: Date: Chkd: Date: BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.5, PAGE:BMS-1 BENCHMARK PROBLEM NO.5 GAPPIPE. VERSION 2.0 NATURAL FREQUENCIES MODE NUREG GAPTIPE % DIFFERENCE NO. (1) (2) ( (23 -(1) )/ (1) *100% 1 4.036. 4.036 0.00% 2 4.257 4.257 0.00% 3 9.116 9.116 0.00% 4 4 11.190 11.188 -0.02% 5 17.110 17.107 -0.02% 6 18.170 18.173 0.02% 7 22.380- 22.379 -0.00% 8 27.190 27.194 0.01% 9 28.010 28.011 0.00% 10 37.980 37.984 0.01% 11 40.970 40.975 0.01% , MODAL PARTICIPATION FACTORS ---- l X-DIRECTION l : MODE NUREG GAPPIPE 4 DIFFERENCE NO. (1) (2) ((2)-(1) )/ (1) *100% , i 1 1.5990E-01 -0.15995 0.03% 2 3.3160E+00 -3.31642 0.01% 3 1.0360E+00 1.0362 0.02% ! 4 2.4590E-01 0.24588 -0.01% 5 -2.3830E+00 -2.3829 -0.00% , 6 -1.5750E-02 0.01575 0.00% ' 7 -2.6550E+00 2.65524 0.01% 8 1.1580E+00 1.15772 -0.02% 9 -2.5e908_01 0.25995 0.02% 10 -1.6520E+00 -1.65193 -0.00% 1 11 1.3610E+00 1.76114 0.01% i 1 i C-57 4
'1 1 ~
By: _ Date: Chkd:_ Date: 1 l BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.5, PAGE:BM5-2 l
---- MODAL PARTICIPATION FACTORS -- --
Y-DIRECTION l l ,
-]
HODE NUREG GAPPI.PE % DIFFERENCE j NO. (1) (2) ((2)-(1) )/(1) *100% 1 1 -2.8350E+00 2.83505 0.00% 2 2.2890E-01 -0.2289 0.00% 3 -2.5270E-01 -0.25268 -0.014 ; 4 '6.9200E-01 -0.69201 0.00% 1 5 1.2520E+00 1.25219 0.024 l 6 3.5110E+00 -3.51141 0.014 1 7 ~7.0440E-01 0.70441 0.00% l 8 5.1260E-01 0.51262 0.00% ? 9 '1.4380E+00 -1.43811 0.01% 10 1.1000E+00 1.10038 0.03% 11 1.3740E+00 1.37363 -0.03% MODAL PARTICIPATION FACTORS l E-DIRECTION l MODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE No. (1) (2) ((2)-(1))/(1) *100% 1 2.8830E-01 -0.28828 -0.01% 2 1.2920E+00' -1.29158 -0.03% 3 -1.3940E+00 -1.39381 -0.01% 4 -7.0060E-02 -0.07006 0.00% 5 -8.2490E-01 -0.82492 0.00% l 6 4.0780E-03 -0.00408 0.05% 7 -3.1060E+00 3.10558 -0.01% , 8 -2.3930E+00 -2.39268 -0.01% 9 6.8060E-01 -0.68062 0.00% 10 2.2650E+00 2.26521 0.01% i 11 -1.8220E+00 -1.82229 0.02% 1 f i 1 l 1 ) C-58 i
By: Date: Chkd: Date: BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, . UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.5, PAGE:BMS j NODAL DISPLACEMENT
- j. X-DIR. DISPLACEMENT l NODE NUREG GAPPIPE %-DIFFERENCE 1' NO. (1) (2) ( (2)-(1))/ (1) *100%
1 0.00000E+00 N/A 2 2.21050E-04 0.0002 -9.52% 3 3.01482E-04 0.0003 -0.49% 4 3.04674E-04 0.0003 -1.53% 5 II.71982E-02 0.0172 0.01% 6.7.62039E-02 0.0762 -0.01% 7 9.76006E-02 0.0976 -0.00% 8 8.93296E-02 0.0893 -0.03% 9 8.21535E-02 0.0821 -0.074-10 8.12776E-02 0.0813 0.03% 11 8.12862E-02 0.0813 0.02% 12 8.12900E-02 0.0813 0.01% 13 8.12853E-02 0.0813 0.02%
-14 7.31445E-02 0.0731 -0.06%-
15 4.87774E-02 0.0488 0.05% ! 16 ' 4.05812E-02 0.0406 0.05% 4 17 3.25487E-02 0.0325 -0.154 18'6.50794E-03 0.0065 -0.12% 19 4.45592E-03 0.0045 0.99% 1 20'1.45711E-03 0.0015 2.94%
- . 21 1.78068E-03 0.0018 1.08%
22 1.78118E-03 0.0018 1.06% ! 23 2.87394E-03 0.0029 0.91% i 24 1.78080E-03 0.0018 1,08% 25 1.78012E-03 0.0018 l'.12 % . i 26 1.77931E-03 0.0018 1.16% I 27 1.77888E-03 0.0018 ' 1.19 % ' 28 2.73128E-03 0.0027 -1.15% 29 1.77757E-03 0.0018 1.26% I 30 1.77525E-03 0.0018 1.39% 31 1.51834E-03 0.0015 -1.21% 32 5.03316E-04 0.0005 -0.66% ! 33 0.00000E+00 N/A i 34 0.00000E+00 N/A 35 0.00000E+00 N/A ; 36 0.00000E+00 N/A j 37.0.00000E+00 N/A 38 0.00000E+00 N/A 39 0.00000E+00 N/A ! l 1 i C-59 i
By: Date: - chkd: Date: BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 3.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.5, PAGE:BMS-4 NODAL DISPLACEMENT l Y-DIR. DISPLACEMENT 8 _____________________________________________________ l NODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE ' I NO. 1 (1) 0.00000E+00 (2) ( (2 ) -(1) )/ (1) *100 % N/A 2 1.70586E-04 0.0002 17.24% 3 3.16029E-04 0.0003 -5.07% 8 4 4.50415E-04 39.0005 11.01% 5 2.27511E-03 0.0023 1.09% 6 5.20205E-04
- t. 7 8
3.42656E-06 9.11604E-03 0.0005 0.0091 0
-3.88%
N/A
-0.18%
! 9 3.04978E-02 0.0305 0.01% 10 4.31106E-02 0.0431 -0.02% I 11 4.86624E 0.0487 0.08% ! 12 5.63395E-02 0.0563 -0.07% 13 6.00532E-02 0.06 -0.09% I 14 5.16441E-02 0.0516 -0.09% 15 3.14926E-02 0.0315 0.02% 16 2.51241E-02 0.0251 -0.10% 17 1.91967E-02 0.0192 0.02% 18 2.98912E-05 0 N/A 19 1.5't873E-03 0.0015 -1.88% - 20 4.30115E-03 0.4043 -0.03% 21 5.33602E-03 0.0053 -0.68% 22 4.48439E-03 0.0045 0.3S% 23 4.48458E-03 " 0.0045 0.34% 8 24 3.69432E-03 25 3.24128E-03 0.0037 0.0032 0.15%
-1.27%
26 2.80563E-03 0.0028 -0.20% 27 2.19753E-03 0.0022 0.11% 8 28 2.19791E-03 0.0022 0.10% 29 1.83849E-03 0.0018 -2.09%
.3 30 1.78654E-03 0.0018 0.75%
5 31 1.51347E-03 0.0015 -0.89% 32 4.03796E-04 0.0004 -0.94% 33 0.00000E+00 N/A 8 34 0.00000E+00 N/A 35 0.00000E+00 N/A 36 0.00000E+00 N/A I 37 0.00000E+00 38 0.00000E+00 39 0.00000E+00 N/A N/A N/A 8 I l C_60 I
-By:. Date: Chkd: Date: ' BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.5, PAGE:BM5-5 NODAL' DISPLACEMENT l Z-DIR. DISPLACEMENT -------------------- _-------------------------------l NODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE NO. (1) (2) ( (2)-(1) )/ (1) *100%
1 0.00000E+00 N/A 2 8.69034E-04 0.0009 3.56% 3 1.65039E-03 0.0017 3.01% 4 2.37555E-03 0.0024 1.034 5 1;.45882E-02 0.0146 0.08%- 6 1.46217E-02 0.0146 -0.15% 7 3.40378E-02 0.034 -0.11% 8 4.58765E-02 0.0459 0.05% 9 4.58977E-02 0.0459 0.01% 10 4.65745E 0.0466 0.05% , 11 4.48091E-02 0.0448 -0.02%. 12 3.93405E-02 0.0393 -0.10%' 13 3.39890E-02 0.034 0.03% 14 2.80479E-02 0.028 -0.17% - 15 2.80468E-02 0.028 -0.17% s : 16 2.80442E-02. 0.028- -0.16% l 17 2.48456E-02 0.0248 -0.18% 18 5.01935E-05 0.0001 99.23% 19 1.97455E-03 0.002 1.29%' 20 5.593785-03 0.0056 0.114 21 7.77122E-03 0.0078 0.37% y 22 7.06520E-03 0.0071 0.49% - i 23 9.58944E-03 s.0096 0.11% i 24 6.26105E-03 0.0063 0.62% 25'5.68741E-03. 0.0057 0.22% , 26 5.02989E-03 0.005 -0.59% ; 27 3.90974E-03 0.0039 -0.25% 28 5.93835E-03 0.0059 -0.65% 29 2.80607E-03 0.0028 -0.22% ( 30 2.17710E-03 0.0022 1.05% 31 1.54346E-03 0.0015 -2.824 32 5.50544E-04 0.0006 8.98% z 33 0.00000E+00 N/A j 34 0.00000E+00 N/A 35 0.00000E+00 N/A 36 0.00000E+00 N/A I 37 0.00000E+00 N/A ! 38 0.00000E+00 N/A 39 0.00000E+00 N/A ! i 1 1 4 C-61 1 (
By: Date: ,
.Chkd: Date:
BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.5, PAGE:BMS-6 NODAL ROTATION l X-DIR. ROTATION l NODE NUREG GAPPIPE %-DIFFERENCE -
~
NO. (1) (2) ( (2)-(1) ) / (1) *100% 1 0.00000E+00 N/A-2 5.26798E-06 0 N/A 3 4.023552-06 0 N/A 4 4.79588E-06 0 N/A 5 1.83584E-05 0 N/A 6 5.63405E-05 0.0001 77.49% 7 2.04845E-04 0.0002 -2.37% 8 3.75297E-04 0.0004 6.58% 9 4.07519E-04 0.0004 -1.85% 10 4.14824E-04 0.0004 -3.574 11 4.14484E-04 0.0004 -3.49% , 12 4.14339E-04 0.0004 '
-3.46%
13 4.14528E-04 0.0004 -3.50% 14 4.42117E-04 0.0004 -9.53% 15 4.28556E-04 0.0004 ~6.66% 16-4.20416E-04 0.0004 ' -4.8.6% 17 3.55812E-04 0.0004 12.'42% 18 2.64274E-04 0.0003 13.52% 4 19 2.53918E-04 0.0003 18.154 - 20 2.34614E-04 0.0002 -14.75% *
)
21 1.46242E-04 0.0001 -31.62% 22 1.39723E-04 0.0001 / -28.43% 23 1.40334E-04 0.0001 -28.74% 24 1.32955E-04 0.0001 -24.79% ' 25 1.20501E-04 0.0001 -17.01% - 26 1.08175E-04 -0.0001 -7.56% 27 1.01587E-04 0.0001 -1.56%, i 28 1.02154E-04 0.0001 -2.11% 29 9.47955E-05 0.0001 5.49% 30 8.29114E-05 0.0001 20.61% ! 31 6.91974E-05 0.0001 44.51% 32 4.26654E-05 0 N/A 33 0.00000E+00 N/A L 34 0.00000E+00 N/A ) 35 0.00000E+00 N/A 36 0.00000E+00 N/A 37 0.00000E+00 N/A [. 38 0.00000E+00 N/A 39 0.00000E+00 N/A i L C-62 l __ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ ___m-._____.___-__ _ -
By: Date:- Chkd: Date: BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.5, PAGE:BMS-7
.)
NODAL ROTATION l Y-DIR. ROTATION _____________________________________________________l NODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE - NO. (1). (2) ( (2)-(1) ) / (1) *100% - 1 0.00000E+00 N/A 2 8.20246E-05 0.0001 21.914 3 2.34923E-04 0.0002 -14.874 4 2.45988E-04 0.0002 :* ~18.70% 5 1.05256E-03 0.0011 4.51% ! l' 6 1.09853E-03 0.0011- 0.13% 7 7.64853E-04 0.0008 4.604 8-2.91741E-04 0.0003 2.83%
'9 2.36141E-04 0.0002 -15.304 10 6.51676E-05 0.0001 53.454 11 1.03655E-04 0.0001- -3.53%
12 1.62877E-04 0.0002 22.79% 13 1.99470E-04 0.0002 0.274 4 14 5.08418E-04 0.0005 -1.66%
" 15 5.40307E-04 0.0005 . .-7.46%
- 16 5.42365E-04 0.0005 -7.81%' -
i 17.5.18010E-04 0.0005 -3.48% 18 4.32654E-04 .0.0004 -7.55%
- 19 4.19270E 0.0004 -4.60%
20 3.93229E-04 0.0004. 1.72% 21 3.852865-05 0 N/A 22 4.39334E-05 0 N/A 23 4.39334E-05 0 N/A 24 4.77723E-05 0 N/A 25 5.29935E-05 0.0001. 88.70% 26 5.72610E-05 0.0001' 74.64% ; 27 5.85619E-05 0.0001' 70.76% 4 28 5.85619E-05 0.0001 70.76% . 29.5.83187E-05 0.0001 71.47% i 30 5.58615E-05 0.0001 79.01%. 31 4.99568E-05 0 N/A 32.4.01221E-05 0 N/A 33 0.00000E+00 ' N/A 4 34 0.00000E+00 N/A
.35 0.00000E+00 N/A 36 0.00000E+00 N/A 37'O.00000E+00 N/A 38 0.00000E+00 N/A 39 0.00000E+00 N/A l
C-63
)
.T I
By: Date: ' Chkd: Date: BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.5, PAGE:BMS-8 NODAL ROTATION l Z-DIR. ROTATION _______________________________________________l q NODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE "- -I NO. (1) (2) ! ((2)- 1 _ _ _ . _ ___ _______ __ _____ _ _ __ _ _( _ _) _ _ .)./ _ _ _(_ 1 _ .)_ *_ 10 _ 0% 1 0.00000E+00 N/A 2 1.62174E-05 -0 N/A 3 4.28988E-05 'O N/A - 4 4.48521E-05 0 N/A
~5 ,1.08936E-04 0.0001 -8.20%
) 6 1.38278E-04 0.0001 -27.68% 7 1.03316E-04 0.0001 -3.21% i 8-1.95557E-04 0.0002 2.27%' j 9 1.90765E-04 10.0002 4.84% 4 10 1.66397E-04 0.0002 20.19% 11 1.51517E-04 0.0002- 32.00%.
- t 12 1.15364E-04 0.0001 -13.32%- t . -
13 9.08410E-05 0.0001 10.08% 14 4.39059E+ 05 0- - N/A . - 15'6.61742E - 0.0001 - 51.12% - p .. 16 7.54367E-05 !
. 0.0001. 32.56%- .
) 17 8.08394E-05 0.0001*- 23.70% . 18 9.95245E-05 0.0001 0.48% 19 9.93199E-05 0.0001 0.68%- . i t
'20 9.81462E-05 0.0001 1.89%- -
21 4.94522E-05 - 0 N/A - 22 4.93289E-05 0 N/A 23 4 94977E-05 - 0 N/A - - j 24 4.87179E-05 .0 - N/A - 25 4.73357E-05
- 0. N/A : - -
. 26 4.61427E-05 0 N/A - - -
{ 27 4.54707E-05 0 N/A 28 4.56146E-05 O. N/A- - 29 4.44631E-05 0 N/A- - - - )- 30 4.21039E-05 '0 N/A 31.3e89650E-05 , 0 N/A 32 2.63656E 0 N/A > 33 0.00000E+00 N/A - p 34 0.00000E+00 N/A - 35 0.00000E+00- N/A 36 0.00000E+00 N/A - L L 37 0.00000E+00 N/A 38 0.00000E+00 N/A 39 0.00000E+00 N/A - . L l 1 ) C-64
Dy: Oste: Odst ests:.. IDOMMKl* C@ PIPE 2.0. LWlFOlM $PECTM MEELIM 00.5 ~~-==.* Ppg:36-9 800MMK PEBLIN 80.5, ELDOIT STES5ES GAPPIM wts10W 2.0 aulEG llESAf$ EU M PM(1) W(!) W(1) ~ TM(1) Nr(I) M(!) PN(J/C) W(J/C) W(JK) TM(J/C) Mr(J/C) MZ(J/C)
- 10. PM(J) W(J) W(J) TM(J) Mr(J) NE(J) I 14.73dE41.200E4 4.6ME*02 3.97R4 5.25DE4 9.M1E4 4.73dE4It 1.2DDE*G2 4AdE+02 3.9ME4 4A11E4 7A34E4 2 4.7J8 EMIT 4.6DE*G21.200E*02 3.972E4 7.GE4 4A11E4 5.109E4 4.221E*021.200E*G2 3.114E*05 7J52E4 4J15E4 5A34EMI2 3.7P3E*021.200E*02 2.51E*G5 7.5GE4 4.25E906 3 5A32E41.2D9E4 3J9dE4 2.257E4 4.252E4 7.5eE4 5.GE41.2D9E4 3.79dE*02 2.2NE4 4.M1E*04 7.200E4 4 5A29E4 3J5dE*021.199E4 2.257E4 7.IIE4 4.941Ee06 2.7EE*02 5.M4E41.199E4It 5.MIE41.MdE4 3.3F7E4 345dE*G2 5A29E41.199E*02 4.790E*G5 4.75E4 2J00E4 5 345dE*GE 1.199E4It 5A29 EMIT 4.700E*W 2 AGE 4 4.75E4 3AdE*G21.199E4 5A29E4 4.710EMI5 4ABE41.119E*04 6 345dE4 5A29541.199E*02 4.710E41.199E*06 LSIE4 2.7I54 5.964E*021.19BE41.199E4 4J98E41.550E6 '
5A29 Edit 345dE41.199E41.3FIE*06 2.200E6 2.2iEFG 7 3.029E*Gt 2.2EEect 1A541.3FIE4 2.310E4 2.2NE*06 3.57N41.214E*021AE*Gt 9.07E4 9A2E4 2 AGE *06 2.215E*02 3.029E*G21ANE*G21.253E41ASE*06 LUBE 4 8 2.255E41 A3W*Gt 3.G5E41.25E4 L159E41ASE*06 2.2EEG 1 A8 EMIT 3JEEdit 1.25E41.15E4 3.II5E4 9 2.255E4 3A9E*Gt 1A7E*Gt 1.25Eem 3.3EE*G51.15Ee06 3JF5E*021.214E*GE 1AE4It 1.99E*G5 2.155E41.210E*04 3.029E*02 2.255E*021ARE*02 2.15dE4 4.15BE41.359Ee06 101J12E4It 7.564Ee011.554EeG2 L15E*G51.IHE*06 4.159E4ft ?J13902 7.564Ee011.554E4 2.15dE41.342E*06 A554E4 11 1A1E4 4.164E*01 1 AME*Gt 2.13dEeG51.543806 LSiere 1.05tE*02 4.164E*01 1 ANE4 2.158*G51A4SE4 4.EE*G5 121.311E*Gt 3J61E*01 1.525E*G2 2.158*51A45E4 8.35E41.311E4 3.561E*01 1.52E4G2 Lt384141dE4 7.51dE4 i G 2.35EsGt 1JEdIE4 9J13 01 L15E4 TJte*S 1Jte*06 2Af9EeGE 1ASIE*Gt 9JIWe01 SAWeG5 4.313 051.54dH06 1.MdE4 2.3354 9JIW4dl 6.M 2AEe51.EWS M l.Me4 9Ame0I 2.35EeE 6M 1Jees06 2m541.MES 9Au*012JEE4 LEmelE L314E4 5.M , 15 2J40E61A13eGt LEGedt LEW4 8.31Nes 5JWHS 2J40E41A11EeSt LNES L3mes 7.184 TAENG5 ' 16 2J40E4 2 AGE *Gt 1.59EE*GE LEIEE4 7. nee 5 7.31EedE 2JOBE4 L7HEeG21.595 02 SJ3E4 5.9E9E4 TAEE*05
?AmS*G2 2JUE*GE 1.59E4 9.9EIF.45 3.9EE4 TAge5 17 2J0341ASE*Gt 2.7NE*G2 9.9EE4 TA5lE4 4.2EE4 2AEG 1ASE*G2 2.7BE4 9.91W905 2.2ERH041.35E4 1 f M 4.187E*02 L15M4 2.015E*G2 9ASHG5 2.253E41.3EE4 4.187tHG2 2.157E4 2.0124 9mE4Il 2.252E41.31dE4 19 4.186E*Gt Ltd3HG2 L0ldE*Gt 9.9EE41.2iOE*061.EEH06 4.10lE4 L1GEHG2 2AldE*02 9.9EE*05 2.299E41.2EEG
- 23 4.10GE*Gt 2AbdE*02 2.154E*Gt 9.9EE41JDOE4 23NE4 3 REG 2.54dE4 L154E*G21.312E406 7AS4 2.312E*06 j 3.168E*G2 3AG3HG2 2.154E*G21.50dE4 4A1GHG5 2.21E*06 . .
213.189E*GE L15E4 3J01E*Gt 1.5EE4 2.2154 4ASIE4 3.189E4 2.15E*02 3JIGHG21.5tIEH061.9ME4 8. GEE 4 2214EEH015.2EE*011AIMH01 FAla 10 9A09EeSt 2.5dE41ARE*015J5E*011.1E39017AdE-10 9.GNE 10 4.191E-09 l B 4.081E412 7.9BE*012A57E*021J19E41.9EE*06 8.1BE4 4ABIE*Gt 7.9BdE*012JIN*Gt IJ19E*061.5ptE*06 SJ55E4 . 36 4AstE*Gt 7.9BdE*012A335*021.519E41.5 PIE *06 8.75E4 4ABIE4It 7.9BdE*0I 2J57E41.519E*061 AdGE4 9.30E*G5 5 4.182E4 7.585E*012.TAIE*GE 1.519E41AdtE4 9.30bHG5 4.183H02 7JBEH012.73EH021J19E*061JP7E4 9AM*G5 1 36 4.182E*G2 7.5SE4012.7NE*021.519E41.3P7E4 9AN*W 4.182E*G2 TJE9E*01 L7NINGt 1J19E4061A87tH061.061E4 j 2T 1.587E*014A19EH012.0PMH01 1.279E OP 1 ABE4 L164E41.55t*014A101H012A5E*01 1.279E-OP 1 A2E4IF 3.3DdE-GP B 5A81E*021.75lE*Gt 3.09E*021.561E41AEFE41.GIE4 5A1E41.759E4 3AlkdHG21.561E41.3GE*06 S.GIOE*G5 2P SAetE*021.759E4IP 3AE*G21.561E41.3GE*06 4. WOE 4 5A1E41J59E*02 3.09EE41.561E41 AdE4 7.19EE4 3D 5 A01E*Gt 3.0ME4It 1.759E4021.561E4 7.19EE41AldE4 5.712E*G2 2JE2E*G21J59E41A4E*06 3.95E*G51A59E4 5.18164 3A4E*021J5R*021J19E4 TA12E41.311E4 315.259E*GE 2.3EE*G2 4.972E*G21.518E41311E4 7.OldE4 5.259tHG2 2.35BEMIt 4.973'*G21J18E41.190E*04 7.3EIE4 .i 32 5.259E*GE 2.35BE*G2 4.972E*021J1dE4061.190E4 7.325E4 335E*02 4.25lE*02 4.972E*G21A29E*041.52E4 9A00E4 j 2.3BE*G2 5.259E*02 4.972E*021 A61E*061AdEE41.35dE4 13 A27E*010.00E*00 1 2 2.90DE*02 0.000E*00 3 5.019E*02 0.QIE*00 1 i C-65 i
I 4: Det3:' ' 044: Date:_ socamic cam 2.0, won mera mas o.s .......... ,,a:e6 io l i 4 2.702E*010.000EHX) 5 4.5eM410 0.00240 6 9.524E-01 0,000EM10 e i 1 i e e O . j 1 e , l 1
~
s e t e , e O
- e e
9 g 9 9 e 8 i ). s 1 h l l C-66
! By: Date: ced: Osta
( IDOMa*ING CN914 2.0, LAf FOM $McTRA PeauttM 80.5 - ~~~ PAm:e611 1 CAPPIPE WtSICN 2.0 aEstlis ELEM PX(I) W(1) WZ(1) TM(I) M(I) MZ(1) PK(JK) W(J/C) W(JK) TM(J/C) M(JK) Mt(JK)
- 80. PK(J) W(J) WZ(J) TM(J) M(J) MZ(J) 14.735E*021.20BE*02 4.635E@ 3.97EE45 5.238E4 9.M0E4 4.735E*021.20DE*G2 4.GE+02 3.9711E4 4.41E*0r. 7 AIM 415 2 4.73EE@ 4.632E*G21.20E*02 3.972E*05 TA37E*G5 4 A10E4 5.100E432 4.221E*021.200E*02 3.114E*G3 7.551E4 4.3ME4 5A53E*G2 3.793E*021.20EE*G2 2.251E*G5 7.5ddE4 4.252E4 3 5A31E*G21.20E*02 3.79dE*02 2.257E4 4.25E406 7.5d5E*05 5A31E*021.20E*02 3.79dE*02 2.257E4 4.%1E4 7.207E4 4 SABE*G2 343dE*021.191EMI2 2.25?E4 7.3NE4 4.%1E4 2.713E*02 5.9WE*021.199E4 5.9f4E41.?taE4 3.377E*06 3AdE*02 5ABE*G21.199E4 4.710E6 4.737E4 2A0dE4 5 3.45dE*G21.19EE*G2 5A2BE402 4.710E*G5 2AQlE4 4.737E4 3AdE*021.199E4 5A2E@ 4.710E4 6ABE41.119E4 i
6 345dE*02 5A2EE*G21.199E*02 4.790E41.119E4 6AIE*G5 2.?EIE*02 5.964E*021.199E*021.197E4 6.3P7E*G51.3554 SAalE*G2 3.61dE*021.199E41.371E4 2.3 ICE 4 2.2NE4 73.GME412 2.254E*G21A7E*G21.371E4 2.30E4 2.2NE4 3.575E*021.214E*G21A7E*02 9s0F7E*G5 9.0 PIE 4 2 AGE 4 2.254E*02 3.GIE*021A7E*021.25E4051.ORIE*06 2.159E4 8 2.254E*Gt 1 A7Ei+02 3.0IIE*G21.2554 L15BE41. Gale 4 2.254EMI21 A7EEMI2 3.02EE@ 1.253E41.150E4 3.2DfE*G5 9 2.254E*G2 3.GRE*G21A7E*021.25E4 32nE*051.15lE4 3.575E*G21.214EMI21 A7EE*021.967E*G5 2.132E41.200E*06 i 3 GHE*G2 2.254E*G21 A71E*02 Et5dE4 4.15EE41.330E4 . 101.512E*02 7.5dfE*011.55E*G2 2.13dE41.35lE4 4.158E41.512E@ 7.5 DOE 411.553E*02 2.13dE451.342E4 6.55E*G5 11 1.051E4 4.1dGE*01 1 ANE*G2 2.15dE41.3434 6.55E*G5141EG 4.1dGE41 1 ANE*G2 2.13dE41 A44E*06 825E405 121J11E432 3JdtE*01 1.522402 L13dfeG51 A44E4 8.2EE41.311E*G2 3.5dCE*01 1.525E*G2 2.13dE41 A15E*06 7.515E4 j 15 2.329E*G21JEasG2 9JAE*01 L15dE4 7.51541A15E4 2A09E41 A9fE*02 9AME*015A71E4 4.361E41.5ER*06 1JE44 LINE4 9.EE*016.M LM 1.BIEe06
~ % 1JIING 9. nee 012JEE4 6.M 1.BIE*06 2AW41JE4*02 942E412.329E*G2 6.EEE4 8.3EE4 SJEE*tB 15181541A13ste L9554 6.M a.3me SJEE4 2AIDEC 1A194 L9lEE*G2 6.51514 7.144E4 7AmeG5 16 2AIE4 Ladme 1.5154 6.EMetB Tale *tB 7.3DE45 2JUES 2.795EG 1.5MES SA25E4 5.92E4 7A1154 ,l 2J00E412 LIGE*G21.5NE4 9.WeG5 3.GWiets TAIIE*ls 1T 2 AXE *G21 A64E*Gt 2.74E4 9.927E*G5 7AIE4 (JDGE4 2.800E61A64E*G2 L771E*G2 9.927E4 2.251E41.35E!4 16 4.187E*02 L157E*G2 2.015EG 924E4 IJ57E4,1.3EE4 4.187E*G! 2.157E412 LC15E412 924E*G5 7.79f*061.adE*06 19 4.1EM*G2 L16E*02 2.01464 9.962E4 2JfdE*06125E*06 4.185E*02 2.1G402 L0ldEMI2 9.962E*G5 22P9E*061. ZEE *06 B 4.184E4 2.GBGE*G2 2.15E*G2 9.95lEsG51.30E*06 2.31dE4 3.85E*G2 2.548E*G2 2.15E41.352E4 7.dl5E4 2J134 3.1d8E@ 3A01E402 2.15E*021.5lEE4 4A17E*G5 2.2W*06 213.1dsE4 2.15E*G2 3.39E41.51154 2.2fM*06 4A59E*G5 3.1ddE*G2 2.15lE@ 3.39tE*G21.505E*061.93E*06 8.010E4 221.d40E415.36CE*01 1.9BIE*010.000E4 9A10E 02 2.5GE41.d40E4015.360E*01 1.9EE*010.000E4 0.000E4 0.000E4 j 25 4.081E402 7.990E412AdE*021.519E41.M4 L18E*G5 4.0B1E*02 7.990E412AdE4121.519E41.5 PIE 4 8.754E4 26 4.081E*G2 7.990E*012AdE*G21J19E41.5P1E4 8J54E4 4.081E*02 7.990E412AdE*021.519E41A59E4 9.362E4 25 4.182E412 7.500E412.7NE*021J11E41ASBE4 9.362E4 4.182E4 7.5BCE412.7NE*G21.515E41.3PN4 9A2K*G5 ;
36 4.182E*G2 7.58X4012.7NE*021.519E41JP7E4 9J22E*G5 4.182E+02 7.580E*012.74E*021319E41 A87E41.061E*06 271.590E414A20E412.000E410.000E*001.GIEE4 2.165E*GI 1.500E414A20E412.090E410.000E*00 0.000E400 0.tXME*00 2B 5. dale *G21.75GE*02 3.096E4121.561E41 AS7E41 GEE *06 5.edEE*021.759E*02 3.09EE@ 1.561E41.3GE4 8.Gl5E4 2P 5.68E4021J$9E402 3.096E*G21.561E*061.3GE4 8.0290405 5JEE*G21.759E*02 3.01E'4121.561E41 A3dE4 7.19tE4 l 30 $JSOE@ 3.09EE*021J59E4121.561E4 7.1 PIE 41A3dE4 5.7tlE*02 2.921E*021.759E*021.d54E4 3.954E41 A39E*06 5.18I412 3EEE*02 IJ59E4121.519E4 7.011E41.311E4 315.25eE432 2.337E*G2 4.972E*021J18E*061J11E4 7.015E4 5.258E*02 2.33?E*02 4.972E4021J18E41.190E4 7.325E*G5 j s2 5.25aE@ 2.357E*02 4.9ra41.51E41.iG0e4 7J25E4 3.sa@ 4.2see@ 4.9ra40e 1 Ased 1.5zM4 9AG7Ee j 2.337E*G2 5.259E*02 4.97E4321.860E41 AddiE413I5E4 13A2EE410.GIE*GO 2 2.989E+02 0.tX10E@ 3 5.01bO2 0.000E+00 I 1 C-67 I {
.D . Detn m. htn NIC CAc5 iPE 2.0, LN!FOIM SFTCTRA PaGRIN 80.5 -- - - wm.y ,
l I j 4 2.?D2E.010.00(100 5 4.5a2 00 c. car.co ; 6 9.523E-01 0.(D E.co { f 1 l I i ) I 4 I t i i l I I I' ) . ) I ) s i 1 C-68 { \ I 3
L. s Dy: Dets: OM Osta: 900MMKilC CAPPIPE 2.0, LN!FOM $RCTRA MGLIM F).5 -- PnE:s613 1 PUlGbt!AE DIFFBIENES GEND RAEC Aa0 r# PIPE wtslol 2.0 (sem of euus): EfM PK(1) W(1) W(1) 1x(t) Nr(I) se(I) Pu(J/C) W(JK) W(J/C) Tx(JK) Nr(JK) Mt(JK)
- 60. PK(J) W(J) W(J) Tx(J) Mr(J) pe(J) 1 -0. 2 4 0SE 4 TEE 0.0x 0. TEE 40fE AM -0.00E 0.025 -0. 5 0.021 4 011 2 0.03 -0.025 0.0E 0.05 0.03 0.025 0.02K 0.05 0.0E 0.00K 4.011 42 4M 0.05 4.05E 0.03 4 0tX Om WA II/A II/A WA WA WA 3 0.02E -0. 5 0.ax 0.ax 0. tin 0. ten 4 02E 4.5 0. M 0. 5 0. M 4 011 4 0.02E Om 0.05 0,03 4 0tE 0.coK 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.03 Om 4 025 0.00K Om em 0.03 WA WA li/A WA WA WA 5 0.05 0.03 -0.02E 0.05- 02 0.05 0.03 - 0.00K 0.021 0.05 0.00K 0.00K 6 Om 0.025 0.05 Om em em 0.05 0.05 0.00K 0.0E . Om 0.03 !
-0.021 0.05 cm 0.coK 0.cos em WA WA WA WA WA WA 7 4.5 -0.0f4 0.05 0.05 0.03 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.03 -0.015 0.011 0.00E 40f4 4.M 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.tix II/A WA WA WA WA WA 8 4.0fA 0. tex 4.M ' 0.0E 0.05 0.03 4 061 0.0E 4 101 0.05 0.00K 02 l 9 4 0f2 46 0.05 0.03 -0.tBE 6.05 0.00E 0.03 0.05 0. 5 05 0.03 I -0.6 -0.0f4 0.05 0. tim 4 02E 0. ten II/A II/A WA WA WA WA 10 0.03 40E -0.071 0.0E 0.0E 4 02E 0.00E 4.05E -0.orX 0.ax 0.05 4 02K 1 11 0.00K 0. M Om em 0.0aK 40a 0.03 4.15 0.0aK 0.00K 4.OrX 0.00K 4 12 0.0aK 0.aK 0.coK e03 torX em 0.03 40E 0.05 e.coK 4 0sE 4 0tX B 0.0E e.Em e.tes e.am 4 01E 40E em em 0. TEE 0.mx 4 025 40E 0.05 -0.06K 0.05 4.am 4dBE e.03 II/A II/A II/A 14 4 II/A II/A ,
14 0.05 0.025 4 0GE 8.05 a.05 4 IRE 4.0G Om 4 00K 0.03 4 015 4 025 l s .e.0E 0.0aK .e.0E 0.03 -e.es -e.as e.0E em .em 0.ax 40s 0.0aK - u 0.0fs om 0.0aK 0.03 -e m A cts e.mx 0.05 0.coK 0.0a 0.03 Om i 0.05 0.03 0.05 4 05 0.05 4 01E II/A IIM WA II/h II/A WA i 17 02 0.orX 0. tim 4 015 4 011 4 05 0.00K 42 0.00K -0.011 0.coK 0.00E l 16 0.ax 0.(Ix OM 4 015 0.05 0. M 0.00E 0.ax 0.ax 4 .011 0m 0.00K 4 w -Om 0.ax 0.ax 0.0a 0.05 0.0E .e.0a 0.ax 0.03 -Om 0.03 c.05 ( ao 0.am 0.am 0.6 4em aan o.am 0.ax 0.03 Om 0.ax 40s 0.am 0.05 4tBE 4 TEE 4 SPE 4 801 0.03 II/A II/A II/A II/A II/A WA 25 0.005 0.ax 0.0E 0.03 40E S.II 0.00K 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.0aK 0.03 f l = 0.= 0. M 4. .A em 0.ax 0. = 0. = 4. WA WA WA < 5 0.05 0.tBE 0.0GE 0.am 0.03 -0.01K 0.05 0.tBE 4 06K 0.005 0.tta 0.015 36 0.ax 0.05E 40f4 0.0E 0.05 -0.01E cm 0.6 -0.0E 0.ax -0.OrX 4 011 ( s e.05 0.071 0.0a em .e.orX 0.0:5 0.0aK 4 0rX 0.05 0.05 0.03 0.0a j m 0m Os1 Om Om 0.03 0.015 0.03 OsE Om Om em 0.03 27 0.195 0.02E 0.3f4 II/A 0.03 0.GE 0.19X 0.a21 -0.3f4 WA WA II/A , m -Om 0.05 0.ax 0.am 0.am em -0.0a 0.as 0.05 cm 0.03 -0.0is 4 a .em 0.ax em 0.05 0.am 40s Om 0.ax 0.05 0.05 0.ax -Om 1 30 -0.021 0.ax 0.05 0.05 4 cts 0.sta 4 02E -0.05E 0.ax 0.05 0.00K 0.05 0.025 0.ax 0.0x 0. tim 4 01E 0.05 II/A II/A WA WA WA WA I si 0.0a -0. 5 Om 0.ax 0.am .e.0:5 Om Om 0.05 0.ax 0.am -0.011 i 52 -Om Om 0.ax Om em om -0. M -Om 0.am em 0.03 4 cts
-0.061 0.am 0.00E -0m 0.00K 4 07E II/A WA WA WA WA WA ]
i 1 -0.02K WA WA WA II/A WA WA 4(/A 81/A WA WA WA 2 0.011 WA WA WA- WA st/A WA WA WA WA WA WA k C-69 l 1 - - -___ _ _ - - -
W: Det3: _ Odid: Oute: N!W CAPPIM 2.0, wifoot McTRA MKatipi m.5 - ---- - pos:o6 %
.3 0.011 ' WA WA. WA' WA ' WA WA WA WA WA WA WA 14 0.01% 'WA WA WA WA WA WA WA . WA WA WA WA 1 5 -0.C2% WA WA WA WA WA WA WA WA WA WA WA y 6 -0.GK WA- WA WA WA WA' WA WA WA WA WA ' WA L' +
l e p l l i ) )- i r h i h .l. \- l F i s 1 I- ) C-70 1
^h' . -
By: Date: Chkd: Date:
' BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.6, PAGE:BM6-1 d
BENCHMARK PROBLEM NO.6 GAPPIPE VERSION 2.0 NATURAL FREQUENCIES ' MODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE NO. (1) (2) ( (2)-(1) ) / (1) *100% 1 6.3910E+00 6.391 0.00% 2 9.9930E+00 9.993 0.00% 3 1.3270E+01 13.274 0.034 4 '1.4490E+01 '14.486 -0.03% , 5 1.5330E+01 15.327 -0.024 L 6 1.7500E+01 17.5 0.00% ; 7- 1.9090E+01 .19.091 0.01% 8 1.9620E+01 19.625 0.03% 9 2.1440E+31 21.437 -0.01% 10 2.8710E+01~ 28.709 -0.00% 11 2.9860E+01 29.864 0.01% 12 3.1480E+01 31.462- 0.01% 13 '3.2010E+01 32.007 -0.01% i 14 3.6370E+01' 36.367 "
-0.014 (
15 4.0980E+01 40.9S3 0.01% 16 4.1370E+01 41.365 -0.01% 17 4.7390E+01 47.393 0.01%- 18 4.9770E+01 49.767 -0.01% ' 19 5.0130E+01 50.125 -0.01% 20 5.2930E+01 52.933 0.01% 21 5.6900E+01 56.899 -0.00% i
. 22 5.8510E+01 58.508 -0.00% .
23 6.7470E+01 67.467 -0.00% - 24 7.0460E+01 70.46 0.00%- 3 q 25 7.5410E+01 . 75.407 -0.00% -
- 26. 7.9180E+01' 79.184 0.01%
27 8.0740E+01 80.741 0.00% i 28 8.6110E+01 86.106 -0.00% 29 8.8280E+01 88.285 0.01% 30 9.2740E+01 92.736 -0.00% < 31 9.9360E+01 99.361 0.00% j 1 k l 4 ' C-71 i I
By: Date: ' Chkd: Date: BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.6, PAGE:BM6-2 8 .
---- MODAL PARTICIPATION FACTORS ----
gg _____________________________________________ l X-DIRECTION l . MODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE I NO. (1) (2) ( (2) -(1) )/ (1) *100%
-0.01%
1 6.0810E-01 -0.60805 2 ~5.7610E+00 5.7611 0.00% < i 3 -5.5830E-01 -0.55836 0.01% h 4 :2.0360E+00 -2.03628 0.01% I s. 5 6 7
-3.3120E+00 4.7900E+00 3.7120E+00 3.31161 -4.78987 -3.71157 -0.01% -0.00% -0.01%
!3 8 1.3750E+00 1.37477 -0.02% . 7 'g 9 -5.8720E+00 -5.87183'- -0.00% 1 10 5.5800E-01 0.04%
-0.55824 11 1.5680E-01 -0.15681 0.01%
12 9.4260E-01 -0.94264 ' O.00%
,I 13 1.0520E+00 -1.05201 0.00%
14 -1.9430E+00 1.94283 -0.01% 15 -3.1990E+00 -3.19914 0.00% 5 16 4.5830E-03 17 7.4300E-01 0.00462 0.74318 0.81% 0.02% 18 -1.3910E+00 -1.39128 0.02% - 19 1.4050E+00 -1.40517 0. 01% . 8 20 -2.7030E-03 -0.00264 -2.33% 21 -8.6380E-01 0.86371 -0.01% -
- 22,,1.7180E-01 -0.17176 -0.02%
8 23 -6.1760E-01 -0.61761 0.00% . 24 -5.0350E-01 0.50354 0.01% . 25 4.8930E-01 0.48928 -0.00% 26 8.7000E-01 -0.87004 0.00% I 27 -9.4970E-01 -0.94974 0.00% 14, , 28 -7.1540E-01 0.71547 0.01% 29 -1.4050E+00 -1.40537 0.03% I 30 4.0650E-01 0.40653 0.01%
, 31 -7.9800E-01 -0.79782 -0.02%
8 I I I I C-72 , I
4 4 By*~ Date: Chkd: Date: BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, ' UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.6, PAGE:BM6-3 ..
'l
- ---- MODAL PARTICIPATION FACTORS ---- , l Y-DIRECTION ____________________________________ _________________l .n MODE NUREG GAPPIPE 4 DIFFERENCE NO. (1) (2) - ( (2)-(1) )/ (1) *100% 1 -5.9770E+00 5.9769 -0.00% 2 -1.9950E-01 0.19942., -0.04% 3 -3.1560E+00 -3.15568 -0.01% 4 ;9.9300E-02 -0.0993 0.00% 5 -4.2610E-04 0.00048 12.65% 6 -3.0240E+00 3.02442 0.01% 7 1.2870E-01 -0.1285 -0.16% 1 8- 2.0150E-02 0.0201 -0.25% 9 -1.7970E+00 -1.79679 -0.01% 10 -4.2980E-01 .-- 0.42993 0.03%' .
.. 11 6.7800E+00 -6.77996 -0.00% z 12 8.8410E-01 -0.88414 0.00%-
13 -1.1750E-01 0.11747 -0.03% 14 -1.1150E-01 0.11148 ,
-0.02%
15 1.0910E+00 1.09111 0.01% i 16 -6.1780E-01. -0.6178 .0.00% 17 1.7110E+00 1.71102 0.00% 18 -4.4450E+00 -4.44514 0.00% 13 -2.1580E+00 2.15781- -0.01% 20 5.1160E-01 0.51153 -0.01% 21 2.1370E+00 -2.13669 -0.014 I 22 -2.1280E+00 2.12806 0.00% I 23 7.9440E-01 0.79439 -0.00% 24 -3.0200E-01 0.302 0.00% 25 1.0080E-01 0.10078 -0.02% 5 26 ( 1.0940E+00 -1.09449 0.04% 27 -1.1410E-01 -0.11408 -0.02% 28 2.1760E-01 -0.21751 -0.04% i 29 -1.3930E+00 -1.39287 -0.01% i 30 3.4290E-01 0.34291 0.00% 31 -1.6210E-01 -0.16231 0.13% ( 1 k i I i 1 ( C-73
By: Data: ' Chkd: Date: BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.6r PAGE:BM6-4 )- L k ---- MODAL PARTICIPATION FACTORS'---- l Z-DIRECTION l NO. (1) (2) ( (2)-(1) )/ (1) *100% I 1 -1.2340E-01 0.12336 -0.034 'l4 1
'2 -2.9960E+00 2.99643 0.01% !
3 el.9510E+00 -1.95061 -0.02% )
- l. 44 -3.5400E+00 3.54021 0.014 5 ~7.3890E+00 7.3886 -0.01%
6 -2.9980E+00 2.99749 -0.024 - 7 3.6370E+00 -3.6367 -0.01% 1 8 -3.4650E-01 -0.34665 0.04% l 9 4.2620E+00 4.2622 0.00% 10 -2.9920E+00 2.9916 -0.01% ! 11 -8.9200E 0.89207 0.01% 12 1.0590E+00 -1.05885 -0.01% : 13 1.5330E+00 -1.53339 0.03% 14 1.5640E+00 -1.564 0.00% [ 15 1.9810E+00- 1.98129 0.01% 16 -7.5250E-04 -0.00078 3.65% 17 -1.'7770E+00 -1.77749 0.03% - 18 -3.8220E-01 -0.3823 0.03% 19 1.5770E-01 -0.15776 0.04% - 20 -1.0920E+00 -1.09198 -0.00%~ -
" 21 -3.5190E-01 0.352 0.03%
)' 22 -9.0820E-02 0.0909 0.09% 23 -1.3880E+00 -1.38834 0.02% 24 6.6440E-02 -0.06645 0.02% i [ 25 -2.7740E-01 -0.27745 0.02% 26 -8.9190E-01 0.89197 0.01% 27 -6.4710E-01 -0.64709 -0.00% 28 -9.1480E-01 0.91478 ~'J . 00 % 29 6.9690E-01 0.69689 -0.00% 30 -2.2160E-01 -0.2216 0.00% > 31 2. f> 620E-02 0.02861 -0.03% i I J i C-74
By: Date: Chkd: Date: BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO. 6, PAGE:BM6-5 NODAL DISPLACEMENT a l X-DIR. DISPLACEMENT 5 l NODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE ' NO. (1) (2) ( (2) -(1) )/ (1) *100% 1 1.26463E-16 0 N/A 3 2 3.51510E-06 0 N/A 3 3.53403E-03 0.0035 -0.96% 5 4 5.95074E-03 0.006 0.83% 5 17.01500E-02 0.0101 -0.49% h 6 1.16506E-02 0.0116 -0.43%
- 7 1.04447E-02 0.0104 -0.43%
8 7.38815E-03 0.0074 0.16% g 9 4.65783E-03 0.0047 0.91% 3 10 2.82519E-03 0.0028 -0.89% 11 2.83429E-03 0.0028 -1.21% g 12 5.49012E-03 0.0055 0.18% 13 5.53077E-03 0.0055 -0.56% 5 14 6.25490E-03 0.0063 0.72% 15 6.97823E-03 0.007 0.31% l 16 7.32918E-03 0.0073 -0.40% W 17 7.21881E-03 0.0072 -0.26% 16 6.49778E-03 0.0065 0.03% g 19 5.G3988E-03 20 5.33042E-03 0.0056 0.0053
-0.71* -0.57% 5 21 6. 09781E-03 0.0061 ~
0.04% 22 6.92264E-03 0.0069 -0.33% 23 7.16222E-03 0.0072 0.53% 24 6.39288E-03 0.0064 0.11% 25 5.17212E-03 0.0052 0.54% g 26 5.47920E-03 0.0055 0.38% g 27 9.36678E-03 0.0094 0.35% 28 1.45382E-02 0.0145 -0.26% 29 1.91767E-02 0.0192 0.12% 30 2.23085E-02 0.0223 -0.04% 31 2.35964E-02 040236 0.02% 32 2.28097E-02 33 2.03531E-02 0.0228 0.0204
-0.04%
0.23% g 5 34 1.66653E-02 0.0167 0.21% 35 1.26220E-02 0.0126 -0.17% 3 36 8.05821E-03 0.0081 0.52% 37 7.54892E-03 0.0075 -0.65% 5 38 6.11695E-03 0.0061 -0.28% 39 5.67559E-03 0.00'57 0.43% 40 2.10253E-06 0 N/A 41 1.99268E-06 0 N/A 42 0.00000E+00 N/A 3 43 0.00000E+00 N/A g 44 0.00000E+00 N/A C-75 I I
.By: Dato: Chkd:_ Date:
BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM No.6, PAGE:BM6-6 45 0.00000E+0D N/A i 46 0.00000E+00 N/A 47 0.00000E+00 N/A 48 0.00000E+00 N/A 49 0.00000E+00 N/A 50 0.00000E+00 N/A l 51 0.00000E+00 N/A 52 0.00000E+00 .. N/A 53 0.00000E+00 - N/A 54 0.00000E+00 N/A 55 0.00000E+00 N/A 56 0.00000E+00 N/A 57 D.00000E+00 N/A l 58 0.00000E+00 N/A 59 0.00000E+00 ) N/A ! 60 0.00000E+00 N/A i k q t i i l ) ) ) C-76 ) i
By: Date: Chkd: _ Date:_ BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, ' UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.6, PAGE:BM6-7 I NODAL DISPLACEMENT l .Y-DIR. DISPLACEMENT l NODE. NUREG GAPPIPE %-DIFFERENCE :l NO. (1). (2) ( (2)-(1) )/ (1) *100%. 1 2.39762E-16 .0' N/A 2 6.65254E-06 0 N/A . i 3 2.48298E-03 0.0025 0.69% 4 2.51196E-03 0.0025 -0.484 5 2.56237E-03 0.0026 1.474 6 2.60621E-03 0.0026 -0.24% 7 2.63597E-03 0.0026 ' -1.36% 8 2.65934E-03 0.0027 1.53% l 9 2.67635E-03 0.0027 0.884 10 2.68891E-03 0.0027 0.41% 11'2.68970E-03: .0.0027 0.38%- q 12 3.94319E-03 0.0039- -1.10% 13 4.15232E-03 0.0042 1.15% 14 7.12625E-03 0.0071 -0.37% 15 9.32086E-03 0.0093 -0.22% 16 9.99370E-03 0.01 0.06%
.{'
17 9.15026E-03 0.0091 -0.55% 18 6.83550E-03 0.0068 -0.52% 19 3.73636E-03 -0.0037 -0.974 20 8.95130E 0.0009 0.54%' R21 2.56509E-03 0.0026- 1.36% 22 4.21841E-03 23 4.79948E-03 0.0042 0.0048
-0.44%
0.01%
]
24 4.03224E-03 0.004 -0.80% 25 2.41430E-03 0.0024 ' 0.59%
- 1 26 1.38210E-03 0.0014 1.30% !
27 3.50079E-03 0.0035 -0.02% 28 4.86452E-03 0.0049 0.73% 3 29 3.64204E-03 0.0036 -1.15% 30 2.04181E-03 0.002 -2.05%
-31 1.29860E-02 0.013 0.11%
32 2.78413E-02 0.0278. -0.15% . I 33 4.47641E-02 0.0448 0.08% i 34 6.19400E-02 0.0619 -0.06% 35 7.78999E-02 0.0779 0.00% ; 36 6.88953E-02 0.0689 0.01% 1 37 5.79666E-02 0.058 0.06% 38 2.62188E-02 0.0262 -0.07% 39.1.08711E-02 0.0109 0.27% ( I 40 1.76633E-06 0 N/A 41 1.75046E-06 0 N/A 42 0.00000E+00 N/A 43 0.00000E+00 N/A i i C-77 1 1
By: Date: Chkd: Date: BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.6, PAGE:BM6-8 )- 44 0.00000E+00 45 0.00000E+00 N/A 46 0.00000E+00 N/A 47 0.00000E+00 N/A 48 0.00000E+00 N/A 49 0.00000E+00 N/A - ) 50 0.00000E+00 N/A 51 0.00000E+00 N/A 52 0.00000E+00 N/A 53 0.00000E+00 N/A
'54 0.00000E+00 N/A i 55 0.00000E+00 N/A 56 0.00000E+00 N/A i 57 0.00000E+00 N/A 58 0.00000E+00 N/A ,
- i. 59 0.00000E+00 N/A '
N/A 60 0.00000E+00 N/A 1 ? _ 4 ) ) ) C-78 l )
i By: Date:' Chkd: Date: F BENCHMARKING' GAPPIPE 2. 0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.6, PAGE:BM6-9 NODAL DISPLACEMENT l- Z-DIR. DISPLACEMENT _____________________________________________________l NODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE i (1) (2) _' NO . ( (2) -(1) )/ (1) *100% 1 1.17072E-16 0 N/A 2 6.03608E-07 0 N/A i
-3 3.21784E-03 0.0032 -0.55%
4 5.96432E-03 0.006 0.60% 5 1.06031E-02 0.0106 -0.03% 6 1.22425E-02 'O.0122 -0.35% 7 1.09824E-02 0.011 0.16%
-8'7.70700E-03 0.0077- -0.09% .9:4.61549E-03 0.0046 -0.34%
l h 10 1.67264E-03 0.0017 1.64% 11 1.59099E-03' O.0016 0.57% .. 12 5.18481E-03 0.0052 0.29% 1 13 5.37087E-03 0.0054 0.54% 14 8.08800E-03 0.0081 0.15% 15 1.00587E-02 0.0101 0.41%
'3 i
16.1.07055E-02 0.0107 -0.05% i 17 1.01690E-02 0.0102 0.30% 18 8.59146E-03 0.0086 0.10% 19 6.92659Z-03 0.0069 -0.38% 20 5.557732-03 0.0056 0.76% t 21 4.95995E-03 O.005- 0.81% 22 4.71683E-03 0.0047 -0.36% 1 23 4.56117E-03 :0.0046 0.85% I 24 4.35831E-03 - 0.0044 0.96% 25 4.20812E-03 0.0042 -0.19% 26 4.19021E-03 27 4.34384E-03 0.0042 0.23% j 0.0043- --1.01% , 28 4.43812E-03 0.6044 -0.86% 29 4.37135E-03 0.0044 0.66% ! 30 4.16712E-03 0.0042 0.79% 31 3.88593E-03 0.0039 0.36% 32 3.56892E-03 0.0036 0.87% 1 33 3.63759E-03 0.0036 -1.03% ! 34'4.94681E-03 0.0049 -0.95% 35 7.60864E-03 0.0076 -0.11% 36 1.51271E-02 0.0151 -0.18% 37 1.35240E 0.0135 -0.18% f 38 7.89545E-03 0.0079 0.06%
'39 5.33171E-03 0.0053 -0.59% 4 40 9.98795E-07 0 N/A i 41 9.47747E-07 0 N/A 42 0.00000E+00 N/A 43 0.00000E+00 N/A 44 0.00000E+00 N/A l
C-79 I l
By: Date:
'Chkd:_
Dat@: BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.6, PAGE:BM6-10
)
45 0.00000E+00 N/A 46 0.00000E+00 N/A 47 0.00000E+00 N/A 48 0.00000E+00 N/A 49 0.00000E+00 N/A 50 0.00000E+00 N/A t 51 0.00000E+00- N/A 52 0.00000E+00 N/A 53 O.00000E+00 N/A 54 0.0000DE+00 N/A I 55 0.00000E+00 N/A {' 56 0.00000E+00 N/A-57 0.00000E+00 N/A Ss 0.00000E+00 N/A 59 0.00000E+00 N/A 60 0.00000E+00 N/A - 4 4 e f~ } l , C-80 ,
BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.6, PAGE:BM6-11 NODAL ROTATION E X-DIR. POTATION g - . . - - - l l NODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DI)? EPJENCE . NO.- (1) (2) ( (2)-(1))/ (1) *100% 5 ------------------ --- ----- .----..--------- ------- 1 9.17393E-15 0 N/A 2 4.38908E-07 0
~
N/A I- 3 7.30078E-05 4 6.77268E-05 0.0001 0.0001 36.97% 47.65% 5 4.05964E 0 w/A 6 1.04696E-05 0 N/A I 7 3.5432SE-05 0 N/A 8 5.90339E-05 0.0001 69.39% 9 6.83144E-05 0.0001 46.38% 10 7.02871E-05 0.0001 42.27% I. 11 7.01561E-05 0.0001 42.54% i 12 4.96127E-05 0 . N/A !5 'E 13 4.92058E-05 14 4.67340E 05 0 0 N/A N/A 15 4.75436E-05 0 N/A 16 5.26596E-05 0.0001 89.90% 17 5.84703E-05 0.0001 71.03% *
. 18 6.18867E-05 0.0001 61.59%
19 5.94890E-0$ 0.0001 68.10% '3 20 4.97321E-05 0 N/A 5 21 3.57154E-05 0 N/A 22 2.09694E-05 0 , N/A 23 1.32558E-05 0 N/A 24 2.11958E-05 0 N/A 25 2.95525E-05 0 N/A 26 3.39056E-05 0 N/A , 27 2.92603E-05 0 N/A 28 2.85320E-06 0 N/A 29 5.21131E-05 0.0001 91.89% 30 1.31747E-04 0.0001 -24.10% 1 31 2.11995E-04 0.0002 -5.66% 32 2.68271E-04 0.0003 11.83% 33 3.02331E-04 0.0003 -0.77%
$ 34 3.18163E-04 35 3.19637F-04 0.0003 0.0003 -5.71% -6.14%
36 2.40091n-04 0.0002 -16.70% 37 2.33043E-04 0.0002 -14.18% 5 38 2.05821E-04 0.0002 -2.83% 39 1.87781E-04 0.0002 6.51% 40 2.33649E-06 0 N/A 41 1.32653E-06 0 N/A 42 0.00000E+00 N/A 43 0.00000E+00 N/A 44 0.00000F+00 N/A ,g C-81 I
By: Date: Chkd: Date: BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE'2.0, UNIFORM' SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.6,.PAGE:BM6-12 45 0.00000E+00 N/A 46 0.00000E+00 N/A 47 0.00000E+00 N/A 48 0.00000E+00- N/A 49 0.00000E+00 N/A , 50 0.00000E+00 N/A 6 51 0.00000E+00 N/A 52 0.00000E+00 N/A
.53 0.00000E+00 N/A 54 0.00000E+00 N/A ss 0.00000E+00 N/A 56 Q.00000E+00 N/A 57 0.00000E+00 N/A 1 58 0.00000E+00 N/A 59 0.00000E+00. N/A 60 0.00000E+00 N/A !
i i I l i i l 8 L l l l 4 1 i C-82 l l
By: Date: Chkd: Date: __ { BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.6, PAGE:BM6-13 4 1 NODAL ROTATION l Y-DIR. ROTATION NODE
----------------------------------l ,
NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE NO. (1) (2) ((2)-(1) ) / (1) *100% 1 4.80721E-15 0 N/A 2 2.29684E-*07 0 N/A 3 6.23650E-05 0.0001 60.35% 4 6.09055E-05 0.0001- 64.19% 5 5.85385E-05 0.0001 70.83% 6 5.73339E-05 0.0001 74.42% 7 5.76108E-05 0.0001 73.58% 8 6.00030E-05 0.0001 66.66% 9 6.22885E-05 0.0001 60.54% 10 6.47331E-05
- 0.0001 54.48%
11 6.48909E-05 O.0001 54.10% 12 5.78536E-05 O.0001 72.85% 13 5.74263E-05 ! 0.0001 74.14% i 14 4.68615E-05 0 N/A i 15 2.85755E-05 0 N/A ' 16 1.40981E-05 0 N/A 17 2.53628E-05 0 N/A 18.4.29778E-05 0 N/A 19 5.14692E-05 0.0001 94.29% 20 4.92143E-05 0 N/A 21 3.83477E-05 0 N/A 22 2.43993E-05 0 N/A J 23 1.76448E-05 0 N/A 24 3.19700E-05 0 N/A
"" 25 5.18304E-05 0.0001 92.94%
26 7.33149E-05 { 0.0001 36.40% 27 8.80436E-05 0.0001 13.58%
- 28 8.59545E-05 0.0001 16.34%
29 6.90101E-05 0.0001 44.91% 30 4.29293E-05 O N/A 31 2.32058E-05 0 N/A ) 32 4.02386E-05 0 "/A 33 6.63891E-05 0.0001 50.63% 34 8.64178E-05 ' O.0001 15.72% 35 9.58014E-05 0.0001 4.38% 36 5.38743E-05 0.0001 85.62% 37 6.51668E-05 0.0001 53.45% ' 38 8.19391E-05 0.0001 22.04% 39 7.98573E-05 0.0001 25.22% 40 9.87977E-07
' 1 0 N/A I 41 9.78206E-07 0 N/A 42 0.00000E+00 N/A f- 43 0.00000E+00 N/A C-83 j
By: Dsto: Chkd: Dnte: BENCHMARKING GAppIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.6, PAGE:BM6-14 44 0.00000E+00 N/A 45 0.00000E+00 N/A 46 0.00000E+00 N/A 47 0.00000E+00 N/A 48 0.00000E+00 N/A 1 49 0.00000E+00 N/A 50 0.00000E+00 N/A 51 0.00000E+00 N/A 52 0.00000E+00 N/A 53 0.00000E+00 N/A 54 0.00000E+00 N/A 55 0;00000E+00 N/A 56 0.00000E+00 N/A 57.O.00000E+00 N/A 58 0.00000E+00 N/A 59 0.00000E+00 N/A 60 0.00000E+00 N/A 1 5 1 e i 4 f C-84
.I i
l By: Data: Chkd: Dato: i BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.6, PAGE:BM6-15 1. }. NODAL ROTATION l- Z-DIR. ROTATION. l l (' . NODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE / NO. (1). (2) ((2)-(1))/(1) *100% ,, 1 6.82590E-15 0 N/A
, 2 4.30378E-07 0 N/A 3 6.07458E-05 0.0001 64.62%.
4 ,5.87153E-05 0.0001 70.31% t 5 3.57321E-05 0 N/A 6 5.92377E-06 0 N/A 7 3.33548E-05 0 N/A l 8 5.58273E-05 0.0001 79.12% I 9 6.48832E-05 0.0001 54.12% 10 6.81833E-05 0.0001- 46.66% 11 6.82244E-05 0.0001 46.58% 12 6.99458E-05 0.0001 42.97% F 13 6.97507E-05 0.0001 43.37% 14 6.27054E-05 0.0001 59.48% 15 4.74893E-05 0 N/A f 16 2.94019E-05 0 N/A 17 2.04509E-05 0 N/A 18 2.63370E-05 0 K/A 19 3.09753E-05
- O N/A 20 3.21447E-05 0 N/A 21 3.05575E-05' O N/A 22 2.78611E-05 0 N/A
) 23 2.61900E-05 0 N/A 24 2.85912E-05 0 N/A 25 3.5560fE-05 0 N/A ' > 26 4.40371E-05 0 - N/A' 27 5416005E-05 0.0001 93.80% 28'5.66990E-05 0.0001 76.37% i 29 6.08786E-05 0.0001 64.26% 30 6.56501E-05 0.0001 52.32% 31 6.70580E-05 0.0001 49.12% 32 6.06732E-05 0.0001 64.82% 33 4.59309E-05 0 N/A 34 2.57543E-05 0 N/A 35 2.42365E-05 0 N/A , 36 2.77611E-04 0.0003 8.06% 37 2.92441E-04 0.0003 2.58% 38 3.10753E-04 0.0003 -3.46% 39 3.04684E-04 0.0003 -1.54% I 40 1.66058E-06 0 N/A - 41 1.64813E-06 0 N/A 42 0.00000E+00 N/A 43 0.00000E+00 N/A C-85
l By : _ Date: Chkd: Data: BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM' SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.6, PAGE:BM6-16 I 44 0.00000E+00' N/A 45 0.00000E+00 N/A , 46 0.00000E+00' N/A 47 0.00000E+00 N/A 48 0.00000E+00 N/A , 49 0.00000E+00 N/A ( SO 0.00000E+00 N/A 51 0.00000E+00 N/A 52 0.00000E+00 N/A 53 0.00000E+00 .{ N/A " 54.0.00000E+00 N/A 55 0;.00000E+00 N/A
.56 0.00000E+00 N/A 57 0.00000E+00 N/A Ss 0.00000E+00 N/A 59 0.00000E+00 N/A !
60 0.00000E+00 N/A I '
* . .j
( i C-86
b Br* Date' ' Oed: Date: moeWElec C#93PE 2.0, (N!Km SPECTitA Pimse 80.6. --- -+ PAE:IM6-17 ) I WOeWE MORD4 80.6, E1 Doff STRESIES ~ CAPPJPE 16tslot 2.0 , auEC aEntis l 5 EL94 PX(!) W(t) - W(I) TX(!) per(I) IEE(I) PW(J/C) W(4/C) W(J/C)' TM(J/C) ' M(J/C) MZ(J/C) - )-
- 80. PX(J) W(J) W(J) TX(J) Mr(J) id(J) .j 1 1.315E4 9.17@0f. J 2 2.39tE*05 4.SIFE4 31.171645 6ARIE4 L 4 2 A 5E*G5 0.CIEE 4 5 1ArX
2JDDS 1.1FDtB 1. HSE 4 2J5Ee061Ame86 3.71 Ele 06
- 3 2 JOIE 41.1/We51.35E*5 2251Ee061ABEe06 3.73BE4 2 JOE 41.1FIE41.3m!4 L2EIEs06 4.01906 6448E*06 .
41.99E*t5 7A0fd!4 7.51EeG2 2.2EE4 4.0 ECEE 06 AJ44E*061 AGEstB 7J01E*G2 TJ11E*GE 2.255E4 9.9M4061.15dE4 51.75E4 4.202E*02 3.140E4 L2EE4 9.995E41.15dE41.7BE4 4.3EEG 3.140E*02 2.2EE41.222E41.321E4
' 6 f.51dE4 3.55lE4 3.@4 2J55E41.222E41.321E4131dE4 3.55DG2 3.130E4 L255E41.0BP41.171E4 71.29Ei4 TJ0lE*02 8.00bedt 2. ZEE 41ARE41.1 TIE 41.2EE*l5 7J0DG2 SABDG2 2.25E*06 671@06 6915F4 l
) 81.298FeG5 TJ0WG2 LOODGE 2.2EEe061790E4 L9E5Ee041.291 keg 5 FJBIE*G2 8.0GE*G2 2.2EIE*06 5.35E46 3.9815 06 91.125E41.064E*t51.tEdE4 2.2EIE4 5.3EE4 3.981L*061.1BE*G51.064E*051 Aleet5 2.25lE*06 7.EEE4 3.561E4
' t31.125E41.tBIE4 2.idGE4 2.2EIE4 7,AEE606 3J61E41.121E41.WEEG LidlE4 2.2BE4 L570E4 3.213i4 l
11 1AEE41.98@G5 9A2E*G2 IJ5Ee04 4.152E4 L362E*041.73E41AE4 9A2E4 2.151Ee061.34tE4 3.25B06 1.986E*G51.tEEE4 9A2E*G2 2.2BIE4 3.061E4 3.90@06 121J55E4 9.217E*G2 8.05E*Gt 2.31E*06 3.041E*06 3.90DE*061.3lE*05 9.2f7E4 8.08BE*G2 2.31E4 3.3'dE4 3.981E4 ) 151.57N405 TJESE*Gt L733E*tP 2.2DBE4 3.IldE4 3.9BIE41.577E4 725E4 67EE*02 2.3EE4 6.MIE*06 5.950E*06 l % 1.567E4 TJBIE4 TA17E*G21.90E*04 6J01E4 4.022E41.567E*G5 7.855E4 7A17E41.902E41 arf 6 9.915E4 151.185E4 3.2DBE4 2.3rlE*021A87E*041.0ME*051ADIE*051.181E4 3.200E*G2 2.3 TIE *021 A87E*061A29E*05 9477E*06
- 161.18164 3JDBE*02 2.548E*G21457E41ABE4 9AE4041.18tE*G5 3.30lE*02 2.5W41457E41.GBE*05 9J81E*06 j h 171.6 8.554E*G2 8.G52E4 L170E41.tB5E4 9.573E*041AEE*G5 8.154F42 8.052E4 L110E6 5.90E404 5Al@04 j 93 L f 29E4 8.554E4 7.314E*G2 2AdlE4 5.9E9E4 5.29dE4041.15EeG5 8.55@C2 TJ14E*G2 2AdlE4 3.tK5E4 4.2 BEE *04 !
D 1 raE*G51.212E41.106E*G5 2A21E4 3 AGE 4 4.317E41.318E41.212E41.10lE4 2A21F4 5.000E*00 f.OpWO4 20 4. tout *G21.ON64 L70E4021.953E*04 5.tD9E4 9.20BE*04 9.9 pie *021.GME*G5 8.745EME ?.953E*06 6A81E4 7.677E*04 219.782E+G2 5.9tBE*02 5.01dE*021.3 PIE *04 L481E4 7.792E*04 9.752E*G2 5.90E*G2 5.01dE*021.3 PIE *04 7.90GE4 8.1GIE*06
' 22 9.70E*02 5.90'IE4 5.132EMI21.012E4 7.90@04 8.160E4 9.70E*G2 5.905E*02 5,152E41.012E4 9.868E*06 9.803E46 251.096E4 L1162E+02 LG52E*021.200E4 9.ad8E*06 9.78GE*041.096E*G5 4A62E*02 LG52E*G! 1.200E40G 9.200E*04 7.27tlE404 261.tB1E*05 6.862E*02 6.5E3E*021.713E406 9.20E404 7.173E+041.081E*05 6.8EE*02 6.585E4321.713E*04 9.lDEE*04 6.395E*04 C-87
eDowartK; CMPIPE 2.0, LMIFUN SPECDA FERIM ML6 - - +- + PAGE:9618 251.322EMB 1.197EMB 1.17E*G3 2.3DE4 9.ID8E4 6.20E41.322EMB 1.197E41.1MMIS 2.3DE41.240E4 9.186&4 261.20E*c5 2.13eEMD 1.557E*05 2.60E41.4.CE4 9.05dE4041.200E4 2. TEE *G31.567E4 2.f43E4K 4.36E4 6.tpE4 27 9.6ME41.963E41.3DE+05 2.16dE4 4.36EE4 6.9KE*04 9R7E*G21.9514B 1.3BE4 2.168E4 5.3R41.68P54 j 281.014EMB 1.9tDE41.164E4 8.87K 2 2.3P7E45 4.EPE4 d 31.171E*G5 6.825E*06 4 2A5E*G5 0.005410 51RIE45 0.00E*00 1 I 61.352E4 0.005400 71.790E6 OAtIEeG3 813BE4 0.00E*03 I r' 9 2AmeG5 QA00E410
.10 L1E@t5 OADDEe00 111 ABIE4 CADDE400 12 4.05E4 OADIEs00 I;
131.MIE*05 0.00E*00
, ' M 1.990E4 CAEE410 131.75m*G5 0.000E*00 16 9.447E*02 0.000E*00
[' 17 0.000E*001.35*G5 18 OADE*00 9.191E4 *
~
19 0.000t.Mio 1 A IE 4 1 1.171E4 IJM41.3EEd5 LEINe06 4Alpt*06 9.175e061.1FIE4 2JHE*GI 1.354 4A206 4A4E*06 8.11ED06 21.1FIE4 L3HIS 1.3SE4 4Am*06 4JfBEe06 &9Eme061.515e051 AIDE 41.3d54 3mme 3Ame06 3Ame06 IJpfE41.1FIE41.3EE4 2.2IdE41ABl4 3.7M4 b 2JNBe51.1FIE41.3mes 22EEe061ABE4 3.72ee06 IJH941.1F341m 223 06 4 Ales 06 &JWe06 41.9954 7Ameet 7J1N4 223 06 Amme 44We06 8.995e5 7AREleG2 7.51Nedt LEEge06 9 AID 061.1554
' 51.13E4 4.3I54 3.14202 2.2EEs06 9.91Ee061.U@51.13E4 4258G2 3.MIE4 2J5D061M 1.3RW4 l 61J1884 3.557E4 3.12EEdit P_Futr*061.22E4051.321E41.51Ee5 3.5 meg 2 3.1BEeG2 2.2EE41.IM!41.TM*05 71.2P7E*G5 7.9E902 8.001E*02 L255E41AME41.1NE41.2NEeG5 7.925EMI2 8.001E4 2.2EE4 4.710E4 6.9EIE4 41JP7E45 T.92E4 8A01E4 2.2EE4 L71CES L922E41JN1MB 7.9EE4 4ADIE4 2.255E4 5.3BE4 3.981E4 ' 91.123141 A6@G51.05dE4 2J515806 5.38E4 3.981E41.12251A6@G51AdE4 2.2EE4 7.MD06 3J6906 f
101.125E41.tBOE4 2.idE4 2.2EE406 7.lullE4 3.561E41.12E41AHE4 2.1dE4 2.2EE4 L58E4 325404
' 11 1RE41.90GE45 9A1 Edit L25NMI6 4.151E*06 L361E41.72451AR*G5 9A1E4 2.151E41.3ED06 3.25@06 1.10GE+G51.GIDG5 9A1E4 221E4 3.04@06 3.90D06 I' .121.E5@G5 9.21dE*G2 8.08E4 2JB1E4 3.06@06 3.900E412@G5 9.21E*G2 8.0EE4 221E4 3 JOE 4 3.98E4 151.577E*05 TA2E*02 L73lE*02 2.2DBE406 3.IldE4 3.981E*061.57?E*G5 7AEMI2 L73lE4 2.20E4 4J00E4 5.95EEe06 M 1.50E4 7A2E4 YAt@G21.9EE406 4J0DE4 LG2541.5GEeG5 722E402 7AldE41.9 TIE 41AlW5 9.9NE4 l 151.15E4 3JDE*02 2.33EE41A87E406 imiE451.401E*051.1EE4 3.3IIE4 2.33EE*G21 A57E*061ARE4 9ARE4 1 l
161.181E4 3.20EE4 2.56@G21457E41.GRE4 9A2E*061.181E4 3JDBE4 2.541E*C21AFE*061AIE4 9JBE*06 1T 1mIE4 8J53E4 821E402 2.1dE41. GEE 4 9.572E41ARIE4 8.555E*02 L51E4 t.1 DIE 4 5.960E6 5ADE4 O 1.129E4 8.555tMI2 7.313E*02 2ASE4 5.969E4 5.29dE41.129E*05 8.555E402 7.3DE4 2ASE4 3.00E4 4.3@06
- f. 191.357E451.212E41.10GE4 2AftE*06 3.00E4 4.311E*06127E41.212E*051.104E*G5 2A21E4 5ADE4 9.0PB06 70 9.989E*G21.0?EE4 8.MWG21.95lE4 5.0 TEE 4 9.2]E*06 9.98lE*021.07EEMS 8.1ME41J55E4 6A80Ee06 7AllE4 i 219.752E402 5.902E402 5.012021.3 PIE 4 4AEE4 7.791E4 9.752EMI2 5.902E*G2 5.DISE*G21JP1E*06 7.90E4 8.1GIE4 f'/
22 9.M2E402 5.9EE412 5.131E*021.012E*06 7.905E4 8.191E4 9.M2E*02 5.9EE*G2 5.91E41AL2E4 9.89E*06 9mlE*06
. 251.OGdE*G3 09iWE*02 621E*021.EIDE*06 9.89E4 9.15E41A6E4 L862E*G2 6.t51E*021.200E4 9.19tE4 7.275E4 261.081E4 6.862E*02 6.562E*021.712E*06 9.19lE*06 7.172E41AB1E4 L852E*02 4.55lEMI21.712E4 9.857E4 63EE*06 l 251.322E41.19?E41.17EE*05 2.202E4 9.E57E4 4.262E*061.323Mll 1.197E*G51.17EE4 222E41.36@05 9.185E4 y- a 1.anMS 2.ts7Ee tasnE4 2.6W41.260E4 9.065E41.200E*G5 2.B7E41.557E*G5 2 AGE *06 4.3ddE4 A80EE*04 q
C-89 1 1
}
I
. _ . . . . ~ . . _ _ . . . , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .
o :< By: Dete: Okt Detr: SDONMKlaC f# PIPE 2.0, tWIFON $PECTRA PUGEBt 804.----- - . PpE:96-20 ( 27 9.4EEME 1.90E41.203E4 2.168E4 4.368E4 6.970E4 9.480E*021.153E*051.2mE4 2.16 erg 5.305E41.68DE4 281.015E41.9tDE*G51.16f44 8.808E4 5.35E41.701E41.015E41.9EE41.164E4 8.8RK4G f.166E4 2.8ZE4 29 9.175EME 2.08304 5.?NE*021.95E41.166E4 2.81E4 9.175E4 2.089E*G5 5.783E4R 1.935E41.3RE4 3.957E4 30 9.46f44E 2.0(4E4 5.303E*02 5.250E41.35E4 3.907E4 9.444EME 2.0f4E4 5.3GE*02 5.250E61.629E4 2.700E4 318.486E*G21.786E*G5 5A2E*02 FA20E41 A2EE4 2.7124 8Ae!E41.18dE4 5.8f.2E*G2 T.420E61.42E41 A83E4 3 32 4A57E4R 1.78dE*G5 6.162E*G2 9.tB7E*0f.1.42E41412E4 8.457EME 1.189905 6.162E4R 9.C;1:41.2i.X4 6.43dE4 35 8.3 PIE *021.289E41.11dE4 9.4dEE*0f,1.361E4 5.754E*06 8.3ME*021.EDE41.11dE4 9.485E*0f. 9.EdE4 3.253E*06 34 6.45dE4R 1.2BGE41.OR4*G5 9.25dE*0f 9 afdE4 3.900E6 6.45dE*G21.EDE*G51.0RE*G5 9.254E*0f. 4.911E*0f.1.GUE4 . E 6.8M*G21.262E*G5 2.581E*G2 9.254E41.057E4 4.911E41.187E4 8.tM0E4 2MBIE41.9GRE*061.341E4 T.821E4 f 1.330E4 5.3ddE4 2.581E*G2 7ARE*0f,1.0BCE41.115E4 361 AMHG5 9.3ERE4 6.73lE*G2 7JNE*061.115E41.0BGE41AM45 9m 6.13lE4 7.6ME*0f 9A58E4 8.0R64 371.50dE41.29eE4 SR9E*G2 7AE406 9A51E*06 &A59061.5WE41.298HE5 8.E79E*G2 7.67590f. 4.290E4 4JNIH0f. f 381.773E41.M9E41. NEE 4 7E9E4 4.290E4 4REE41.713E41.M8F451.35E*G5 7.479E4 5.057E*6 1.114E4 371.713E41.154E*G51.XIIE4 I'ARH06 5.057E41.114E41.7Rf451.751E41.3BE4 9.47EE404 5.9BBE41J43E4 1.1 TOE 41.715451.3EE41.00E4 8.1ME*Cf 1.9Pc405 401.148E*G5 9Ad4E*021.990E41.GBE41ABE41.3DE41.159E4 9A64E*G21.990E61.005E41.899E41.327E4 f ( ( l . . . ( 1 I l l d i C-90 i l
I _9y: Date: Oed: Detr. } ODomeAK14 CAPPlfT 2.0, LMIFUM SECMA Pt(RDI NO.6 . --
- PpE:g>6-21
/
)- 1 PotaxtMI DIFFDDGS ETWIN MKG 40 CArylft WtSIOi 2.0 (BASED ON KAEC): I l ELEM PX(I) W(!) VZ(I) TX(1) Mr(I) ME(1) PK(JK) W(JK) V2(JK) TX(JK) Mf(J/C) MZ(JK) j
- 80. PM(J) W(J) WZ(J) TX(J) W(J) Mt(J) 1 0.0f.% 4 01% UA II/A M/A WA II/A II/A WA WA II/A WA
- 2 4 (32 % -0 # 11 IL/A II/A WA II/A WA II/A II/A WA II/A 81/A
) 3 +0. M 4 01% II/A II/A WA II/A al/A II/A WA II/A* al/A 88/A
/, -0.00E bl/A WA II/A WA al/A II/A II/A II/A 14/A II/A II/A 5 -0. M :t WA II/A WA II/A 86/A ~al/A al/A al/A II/A WA 6 -0.0GX WA WA al/A SI/A II/A al/A WA II/A WA al/A 81/A f 7 0.01% II/A 31/A II/R al/R 81/A II/R WA 94/ 4 II/A II/A II/A 8 0.021 alrA al/A al/A II/A II/n IVR al/R al/A II/A WA al/A 9 4 02K II/A ti/n el/n al/A II/n st/n II/A si/A WA WA II/A '
) to 4 0tX WA WA IVA IVA 31/ 4 WR II/R II/A 81/ 1 II/A II/A 11 -0.02K 11/A 81/A Il/A II/A 81/A alrA WA 88/A al/A al/A II/A 4 12 45 WA al/n il/A al/A 31/A Iyn II/A II/A al/A pl/n II/A n Am1 WA = WA WA u WA = WA = = = ) M 0.06K 81/A al/A II/A II/n II/A II/A II/A II/A ) 81/A II/A II/A 15 0.0t1 II/A WA II/A WA st/A II/A II/n al/A WA WA II/A
% 4 .01% al/A 8L/A II/A II/A st/A WA WA II/A II/A 81/A II/A 17 II/A 4R II/A 8L/A Iy* II/A II/A WA . WA WA II/A II/A O II/A 4 0tX al/A . II/n WA WA II/A II/A WA 88/A WA WA l 19 II/A 4GE II/A al/n - al/A 88/A al/E II/A WA II/A al/A WA {
1 0.00E 4 0EX Cm A ctX 6.05 4 01E 0.0tg 4 0GK 0.00K 4 0tE 8.a0K 4 011 2
)
0.att 4 0EE 4.e5 401 em 4 0tx 0.01E 0.aE 0.GK 0.01E S.EIK 0.dEE I 4 0EK 0.01E 0.25 OJIE 6.05 8nX II/R II/n II/R II/n el/n IIA l 3 4 08E C.aK 0.05 S.EE e.aK t.83 4 SEE CJIE 0.HE OB SJRb 4m1 4 8.81E 4 01E 4 01E Sm em 4 EEE 4.EE 46. stb 4 0tE 0.aK 4 015 0.85 5 RADE 0.05 0.05 4.as 40s e.as 0.00E a t.05 CJEE 0.85 0.c3 4 0.CtX 4M 0M OJEE OJIE 0.CtX 0.03 -Om -0.05E 0.00K 0.05 4G1E l 7 Om 0.0t% -0.01x 0.05 0.GE -0.05 .em 0.0t% Om 0.05 0.05 0.01% s -Om
-0.0t% -0.0ts 0.05 0.05 0.0tX Om 0.0t% -0.0t1 Om Om 0. 2 9 0.00K 0.01E 0.GE 0.00E 4 02% 0.GE 0.00K 0.00K 0.03 Om 0.05 0.0E 10 0.CtX 0.00K 4 05K 0.05 0.02 0.05 0.00E 0.00K -0m 0. 2 0.02% 0.03
- 1) 0.00K 0.00E 4 01E 0.03 4 02% 4 02% 0.GE 0.00K 4 0t1 0.GE 0.00K 0.00K 1JXE 0.GE 4 01% 0.00E 0.ttsE 0.tXE II/n al/A II/A WA II/A WA i 12 -0. TEE 4.0:1 4 01% 0.00E AM 0.03 0.05E 4 01% -0.0!% 0.00E 0.GE 0.00K l 13 0.00K -0.01% 4 011 0.00E 0. LIE 0.GE 0.00K 4.01% 4 01% CJXE 4 02% 0.00K
% 0.0E 4 01% 4 01% 0.0E 0.02E 0.00K 0.0E 4 01% 0.01% 0.00K 0.00K -0.0t%
15 0.0E 0.03 4 0GK 0.GE 0.00K 0.00K 0.00K 0.00K 4 0GK 0.00E 4 105 4 0t% ) % Cm 0.00E 0.05 0.00s 0.10s 0.01% 0.00s 0.00K 0.00K C.05 0.oK -0.01% 17 0.CtX 4 01% -0.01E -0.05% 0.GE 4 0t% 0.00t 4 01% 4 0t% -0.05% 0.00K -0.02% 18 0.00E -0.01% 4 01% 0.0E 0.05 0, .0E 0.05 -0.011 -0.01% 0.00E 0.00K 0.00E 19 4 07% 0.00K 0.0K 0.tXE 0.0E G.G;% -0.07x 0.00K 0.05 0.005 4 02% -0.0t% f 20 0.00K 0.0E 0.01% 0.05 4G21 0.05 0.GE 0.0E -0.01% 0.03L 4 025 -0.0t% 21 0.QE -0.025 4 02% 0.GE 4 02K -0.01% 0.0 %02t 0.02% 0.005 4 0!% 0.03E 22 -0.0tX -0.021 -0.02% 0.GE -0.01% -0.0tX 0.01% 04 3 4 02% 0.00E 4 01% -0.01% 23 0.02 0.QE -0.G2K 0.00E 4 01% -0.0t% 0.0E 0.(XE -0.02% 0.00% 4B -0.01% l x Cm 0.= -0. 4, 4. -0. Om 0, 0. . 4. 4. -0 1 25 0.aK Cm 0m -Om -0.e:% -Om 0m om 0.aR 4m om -0.01% 1 ) 26 0.aK -0.or c Om om 0.aK 4 0t% Om -0.05% 0.00E 0.aR -0.021 -0.01% l > C-91 1 ) i i l i
Dy: Dett: Odd: Datn t , tl . DOewrtec (WPM 2.0, LNiroipt stcraA PIKELDt 8C. 6 -----+--- PAE:Ep622 k 27 On 0.0aK 0.0aK 0.0a -0.02K 0.0a om 0.0m 0.005 0.0a 0.02K 0.0a 18 0.12 ~ 0.05 0.02 -0.0t% 0.02K 0.00L 0.101 0.00L cm -0.0t% 0.00E 4. Ora 29 0. M 0.15% - -0.02% -0.05K 0.00L 4.0f.E , Om -0. M -0.021 -Om 0.00t -0.05K 30 . 0.0f.E 0.00t -0.02K -0. M .. 0.02 -0.05K 0.0f.K 0.00t 0. M -0. M 0. M 0. M 31 W.02% 0.00E 0.00K -0.M 0.001 0.02 0. M 0. R 0.00L 0.05K 0.05 -0.0E sr 0.01% 0.ca 0.on -o.a2K 0.ca 0.ca 0.0tX 0.ca 0.0a -o.M em o.a2K i 33 0.0tX -Om - 0.0a .c.m 0.0 a . -o.azz e.0tx -em 0.coK -e.atz 4.tBK 0.00K 34' 0.05K 4.08K 4.09K 4.*** -0. M -03BK 0.05K -0. M 4.0K -0.01E 4.EEE 0.0E 3r -0.01% . 0.005 0.00K 4/G 0.0E -4.G2K 0.00L 4.M 0.00E 0.M 0.05 4.01K ( 0.00L -0.02K 0.00L 4.0tK 4.00K 4.05 al/A al/A II/A al/A st/A al/A
~ 36 0.00L 443 -0X.E 0.05K 0.03 0.CIE 0.03 0.02K -0.C1K -0.05K 0.02K 4.02K 37- 4.07K 0.M -0.0tX 0.1BK 4.02K 4.Gts 4.07K 0.IIK c.01% 0.05K -0.12K 0.6 2 0.0fA 0.03 0.03 0.01K 4.M 4KK 0.GE 0.6 - 0.03 4.015 0.EEK em 3P 0.05 0.005 0.ca -0.0tK HLIEK 0.tm 0.0E 0. M 0. M -0.0tx 4.12K 0.05-
- 0. M 0. M 0. M -0. M A DIE 0. 6 II/A al/A al/A II/A al/A 81/A 40 0.6 e.0tX 0.ca e. M 4.om 0.ca 0.0a 4.0iK 0.0a e. M 0. M 0.coK j
. i i
( i a, C-92 i
By: Date: Chkd:- Date: BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.7, PAGE:BM7-1 l BENCHMARK PROBLEM NO.7 GAPPIPE VERSION 2.0 NATURAL FREQUENCIES MODE NUREG GAPPIPE' % DIFFERENCE
~
L E NO. (1) (2) (.(2)-(1) )/ (1) *100% l 3 ---____------_______________-___-____-_-_-____________ 1 5.034 5.034 0.00% i 's 2 7.813 7.813 0.00% ! g- 3 8.193 8.193 0.00% l 4 - 8.977 8.977 0.00%
-5 9.312 9.3L2 0.00%
l 6 9.895 9.895 0.00% 7 \ 13.22 13.222 0.02% S 14.96 { 14.957 -0.02% j I 10 11 9 15.07 17.75 18.21 15.067 17.755 18.209
-0.02%
0.03%
-0.01%
i i' 12 I 13 14 15 22.9 25.02
.25.85 22.9 25.023 25.855 0.00%
0.01% O.02% 26.94 26.943 0.01% 16 28.13 28.133 0.01% I'- 17 30.3 30.299 -0.00% 18 35.22 35.218 -0.01% 19 I 20 21 37.1 42.61 44.42 37.096 42.614 44.418 ..
-0.01%
0.01%
-0.00%
22 48.09 48.09 0.00% I ' d I ! I 1 I l I I E c-93 I
By: Date: Chkd: -Dato: BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.7, PAGE:BM7-2 .
---- MODAL PARTICIPATION FACTORS ----
l- X-DIRECTION l u ______________________________________________________ MODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE NO. (1) (2) ( (2)-(1) )/ (1) *100% 1 1 1.7670E-01 0.17674 0.02% 2 2.6400E-02 0.0264' O.00% 3 1.0750E-01. O.10748 -0.02% 4 8.7500E-01 0.87504 0.00% 5 ,;2.0130E-01 0.20134 0.02% 6 2.3130E-01 -0.2?l25 0.02% ' 7 5.1610E-01 0,5161 0.00% 8 '2.3760E-02 -0.02376 0.00% 9 1.0170E-01 -0.10168 -0.02%. 10 -1.0310E-01 -0.10312 0.02% 11 8.2670E-02 0.08267 0.00% 12 -7.4940E-01 -0.74936 -0.01% 13 -E.7780E-01 -0.57776 -0.01% l 14 2.9970E-01 -0.29972- .O.01% 15 -1.2100E-02 0.0121 0.00% - 16 5.2590E-01 -0.52594 0.01% ..j 17 -8.3140E-01 -0.83136 -0.00%
. 18 -5.6670E-02 -0.05667 0.004 19 -1.7510E-01 -0.17514 -
0.01% . 20 2.7160E-01 0.27158 -0.01% 21 -1.3990E-03 -0.0014. 0.07%
/ 22 1.1500E-01 0.11514- 0.12%
1 l. i t i 4 l k l C-94 i l F. GJ - _ _ _ _ - _ _ _
By: Date: .Chkd : - Date: BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.7, PAGE:BM7-3 T .
] .5 i ---- MODAL PARTICIPATION FACTORS ----
_____________________________________________ ) l Y-DIRECTION l ) g- ______________________________________________________ MODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE . NO. (1) (2) ( (2) -(1) )/ (1) *100%
~
I ______________________________________________________ 1 -5.8590E-01 2 -2.5090E-01
-0.58585 -0.25089 -0.01% -0.00%
{ 3 4.3320E-01 0.43324 0.01% - I-- 4 -1.6270E-01 -0.16271 0.01% ) 5 1.1080E+00 1.10845 0.04% 6 '.9.2980E-01 -0.9298 0.00%. I 7- 4.3290E-01 0.43291 0.00% 8 -4.1440E-02 0.04144 0.00% 9 6.8040E-02 -0.06804 0.00% 5 10 -3.0960E-01 -0.30959 -0.00% g 11 -1.0110E+00 -1.01137 0.04% 12 2.2690E-01 0.22692 0.01% 13 ~ 1.3730E-01 0.13725 -0.04%
- I 14 15 16
-3.9320E-01 -3.4340E-03' 0.39324 O.00343 0.01% -0.12%
3.9050E-02 -0.03905 0.00% 17 -1.2320E-01 -0.1232 0.00% I . 18 -2.9740E-01 -0.29738 -0.01% 19 2.1750E-01 0.21754 0.02% 20 -1.3340E -0.13342 0.01% I. - 21 -2.0310E-01 22 1.5090E-01
-0.20315 0.15081 0.024- -0.06% . 1 I.
LI II l Lj I I C-95 g
By: ___ Date: Chkd: Date: BENCHMARKING.GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.7, PAGE:BM7-4
---- MODAL PARTICIPATION FACTORS ----
l Z-DIRECTION l MODE NUREG -GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE ' NO. (1) (2). ( (2 )-(1) )/ (1) *100 % ! 1 1.1580E+00 1.15771 -0.03% 2 1.0870E+00 1.08672 -0.03% 3 4.4660E-01 0.44656 -0.01% 4 -5.3890E-01 -0.53885- -0.01% 5 -3. 663 0E-02 0.03663 0.00% 6 26.9300E-03 0.00693 0.00% l 7 7.9820E-01 0.79824 0.01% 8 -6.6440E-01 0.66444 0.01% 9 7.4620E-02 -0.07462 0.00% ( 10 7.9960E-02 0.07996 0.00% 11 -1.5860E -0.15858 -0.01% 12 4.4770E-01 0.4477 0.00% 13 2.7720E-01 0.27725 'O.02%' i 14 1.6930E-01 -0.1693' O.00% 15 2.1380E-01 -0.'21383' O.01% 16'-2.9700E 0.0297- 0.00% ( 17 -2.2180E-01 -0.22176 -0.02% 18 -1.4530E-01 -0.1453 0.00% 19 -1.0070E-01 -0.10072 0.02%
- 20. 1.6140E-01 0.16143 0.02%
21 -2.2720E-02 -0.02271 -0.04% 22 2.6000E-02 0.0261 0.38% i W4 a ! I l l x l-C-96 { l L -. _ ----_-__-- -
,r By: Date: . Chkd: , 'Date:
BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA ' PROBLEM' NO.7, PAGE: BM7-5 , I l' NODAL DISPLACEMENT l .X-DIR. DISPLACEMENT l NODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE .. NO. (1) (2) ( (2)-(1) )/ (1) *100% l' O.0000E+00 N/A 2 1.5547E-04 0.0002 28.64% 3 0.0000E+00 N/A 4 3.4377E-03 0.0034 -1.10% 5 12.9812E-02 0.0298 -0.04%
- 6 '4.5900E-02 0.0459 0.00%
l 7 0.0000E+00 N/A 8 5.5673E-02 0.0557 0.05% 9 0.0000E+00 N/A 10 6.6947E-02 0.0669- -0 07% 11 8.4820E-02 0.0848 -0.02% 12 0.0000E+00 - N/A
~
13 8.0124E-02 0.0801 -0.03% 14 0.0000E+00- N/A 15- 5.4967E-02 0.055 0.06%- i 16 9.7873E-03 0.0098 0.13% l- 17 0.0000E+00 N/A . I 18 6.4978E-05 0.0001 53.90% 19 0.3000E+00 N/A . 20- 6.3349E-05 0.0001 57.86% 21 0.0000E+00 N/A ! 22 0.0000E+00 N/A l 23 0.0000E+00 . N/A ! 24 .0.0000E+00 N/A
'25 5.2360E-05 -0.0001 -
90.99% -
- 26 0.0000E+00 N/A l 27 0.0000E+00 N/A 28 0.0000E+00 N/A -
29 0.0000R+00 N/A 30 3.4825E-05 0 N/A 31 3.3013E-02 0.033 -0.04% 32 0.0000E+00 N/A 33 3.5608E-02 0.0356 -0.02% 34 0.0000E+00 N/A 35 4.2436E-02 0.0424 -0.08% ! 46 0.0000E+00 N/A i 37 0.0000E+00 N/A ) i 38 0.0000E+00 N/A 39 0.0000E+00 N/A . I 40 2.6313E-02 0.0263 -0.05% I 41 6.8867E-03 0.0069 0.19% i 42 0.0000E+00 N/A 43 0.0000E+00 N/A l' 44 5.1200E-03 0.0051 -0.39% l C-97
By: Dato: Chkd: Date: BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.7, PAGE:BM7-6 45 5.1203E-03 0.0051 -0.40% 46 5.1196E-03 0.0051 -0.38%- 47- 0.0000E+00 N/A 48 3.3789E-03 0.0034 0.63% 49 0.0000E+00 'N/A-50 6.1398E-04 0.0006 -2.28% 51 0.0000E+00 - N/A
.52 0.0000E+00 N/A 53 0.0000E+00 N/A 54 0.0000E+00 N/A 55 3.4300E-08 0 N/A 56 .0.0000E+00 N/A 57 "O.0000E+00 N/A 58 0.0000E+00 N/A 59 0.0000E+00 N/A 60 1.7441E-05 0 N/A 61 0.0000E+00 N/A 62 0.0000E+00 N/A 63 0.0000E+00 N/A 64, 0.0000E+00 N/A 65 6.9086E-08 0 N/A 66 0.0000E+00 N/A -
67 0.0000E+00 N/A 68 0.0000E+00 N/A 69 0.0000E+00 N/A 70 1.7603E-05 0 N/A . 71 3.7432E-03 0.0037 ~1.15%
- 72. 0.0000E+00 N/A 73 3.9369E-03 0.0039 -0.94%
74 0.0000E+00 N/A 75 4.4190E-03 0.0044 -0.43% 76 0.0000E+00 N/A 77 0.0000E+00 N/A 78 0.0000E+00 N/A 79 0.0000E+00 N/A 80 5.4341E-03 0.0054 -0.63% 81 6.2293E-03 0.0062 -0.47% 82 0.0000E+00 N/A 83 0.0000E+00 N/A 84 6.3786E-03 0.0064 0.34% 85 6.3781E-03 0.0064 0.34% 86 6.3732E-03 0.0064 0.42% 87 0.0000E+00- N/A ; 88 4.3035E-03 0.0043 -0.08% ' 89 0.0000E+00 N/A 90 8.1040E-04 0.0008 -1.28% 91 0.0000E+00 N/A !- 92 0.t t,00E+00 N/A l 93 0.0000E+00 N/A l- 94 0.0000E+00 N/h 95 2.9319E-08 0 N/A I C-98 L _
By: Date: .chkd: Date: BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.7, PAGE:BM7-7 j I l 96 0.0000E+00 N/A 97 0.0000E+00 N/A 98 1.8851E-05 0 N/A 99 0.0000E+00 N/A 100 2.0063E-05 0 N/A '. 101 0.0000E+00 N/A I. 102 103 0.0000E+00 0.0000E+00 -
,, N/A N/A 104 0.0000E+% N/A I 105 4.3439E-05 106 0.0000E+00 107 .,0. 0000E+00 0 N/A N/A N/A g 108 0.0000E+00 N/A g 109 0.0000E+00 N/A 110 7.0486E-05 0.0001 41.87%
111 8.7379E-05 0.0001 14.44% I 112 113 114 0.0000E+00 1.241GE-03 0.0000E+00 0.0012 N/A
-3.31%
1 j 1 N/A I 115 116 117 5.5974E-03 0.0000E+00 0.0000E+00 0.0056 0.05% N/A N/A
*118 0.0000E+00 N/A I 119- 0.0000E+00 120 1.4778E-02 0.0148 N/A 0.15%
121' 6.8606E-03 0.0069 0.57% 122 0.0000E+00 N/A ) I. 123 124 0.0000E+00 9.8402E-03 0.0098 N/A
-0.41%
l
~
125 -0.40% I 126 127 9.8390E-03 9.8307E-03 0 0000E+00 0.0098 0.0098 -0.31% N/A 128 6.6620E-03 0.0067 0.57% I 1 129 0.0000E+00 N/A I 130 1.2579E-03 0.0013 3.35% 131 0.0000E+00 N/A , I 132 133 134 0.0000E+00 0.0000E+00 0.0000E+00 N/A N/A N/A 135 0.0000E+00 N/A
'I 136 137 138 0.0000E+00 0.0000E+00 N/A N/A 0.0000E+00 N/A l
I 139 140 141 0.0000E+00 3.4767E-08 0.0000E+00 0 N/A N/A N/A l l l g 142 0.0000E+00 N/A g 143 0.0000E+00 N/A 144 0.0000E+00 N/A 145 0.0000E+00 N/A 146 0.0000E+00 N/A
.I c-9, LI L
By: Date: 'Chkd: Date: BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.7, PAGE:BM7-8 147 0.0000E+00 N/A I 148 0.0000E+00 N/A 149 0.0000E+00 N/A 150 0.0000E+00 N/A 151 0.0000E+00 N/A g 152 0. 0000E4 00 N/A g 153 0.0000E+00 N/A 154 0.0000E+00 N/A 155 0.0000E+00 N/A l 156 20.0000E+00 N/A B 157 0.0000E+00 N/A 158 J0.0000E+00 N/A 159 0.0000E+00 N/A 160 0.0000E+00 N/A 161 0.0000E+00 N/A 162 0.0000E+00 N/A 163 0.0000E+00 N/A 164 0.0000E+00 N/A 165 0.0000E+00 N/A 3 166 0.0000E+00 N/A g 167 0.0000E+00 N/A 168 0.0000E+00 N/A 169 0.0000E+00 N/A 170 0.0000E+00 N/A I I E I I I C-100 I
!. 'By:_ Date: * 'Chkd: f D3te: BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.7, PAGE:BM7-9 j ) I NODAL DISPLACEMENT j. g l Y-DIR. DISPLACEMENT ______________________________________..______________l NODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE NO. (1) (2) ( (2)-(1) )/ (1) *100% f 1 0.0000E+00 N/A - 2 1.1943E-05 0 N/A ). 3 0.0000E+00 N/A ! ! 4 1.2626E-02 0.0126 -0.21% 5 1.3710E-01 0.1371 -0.00% j 6 2.1288E-01 0.2129 0.01% (~ 7 0.0000E+00 8 N/A 2.4383E-01 -0.01% 9 0.0000E+00 0.2438 . j 10 N/A ' L 4386E-01 0.2438 -0.02% 11 2.4388E-01 , 0.2438 -0.03% 12 0.0000E+00 E 13 N/A 2.1412E-01 0.2141 -0.01% - l 14 0.0000E+00 15 N/A 1.3426E-01 0.1342 -0.04% 4
.16 1.5598E-02 0.0156 0.02%
17 0.0000E+00 18 4 3568E-03 N/A 0.0044 0.99% 19 0.0000E+00 - 20 5.4549E-08 N/A 0 N/A 21 0.0000E+00 22., 0,0000E+00 ,
.. N/A 'f N/A ~ '~
23 0.0000E+00 , N/A 24 0.0000E+00 'l N/A-25- 6.6019E-03 0.0066 -0.03% 26 0.0000E+00 27 N/A :; 0.0000E+00 N/A 28 0.00005+00 29 N/A 0.0000E+00 N/A 30 9.0729E-03 0.0091 0.30% 31 2.6793E-02 0.0268 0.03% 32 'O.0000E+00 N/A 33 2.8586E-02 0.0286 0.05% 34 0.0000E+00 35 N/A 3.5129E-02 0.0351 -0.08% 36 0.0000E+00 - N/A i 37 0.0000E+00 38 0.0000E+00 N/A N/A 39' 0.0000E+00 N/A 40 3.6328E-02 0.0363 -0.08% 41 3.3668E-02 0.0337 0.10% 42 0.0000E+00 43 0.0000E+00 N/A 44 2.9760E-02 N/A 0.0298 0.14% C-101 j
g. By: Date: Chkd: Date: BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.7, PAGE:BM7-10 45 1.9342E-02 0.0193 -0.22% 46 2.1563E-03 0.0022 2.03% 47 0.0000E+00 N/A 48 1.2546E-05 0 N/A 49 0.0000E+00 N/A ' 50 3.2359E-06 0 N/A 51 0.0000E+00 N/A 52 0.0000E+00 N/A 53 0.0000Et00 N/A 54 0.0000E+00 N/A i 55 4.8784E-08 0 N/A 56 .C.0000E+00 N/A 57 0.0000E+00 N/A 58 0.0000E+00 N/A 59 0.0000E+00 N/A 60 4.4227E-03 0.0044 -0.51% 61 0.0000E+00 N/A 62 0.0000E+00 N/A 63 0.0000E+00 N/A 64 0.0^00E+00 N/A 65 5.3381E-08 0 N/A 66 0.0000E+00 N/A 67 0.0000E+00 N/A 68 0.0000E+00 N/A 69 0.0000E+00 N/A 70 5.8988E-03 0.0059 0.02% 71 1.7980E-02 0.'018 0.11% 72 0.0000E+00 N/A
/. 73 1.9502E-02 0.0195 -0.01% !
74 0.0000E+00- N/A 75 2.6305E-02 0.0263 -0.02% 76 0.0000E+00 N/A , 77 0.0000E+00 N/A 78 0.0000E+00 N/A 1 79 0.0000E+00 . N/A 80 3.5424E-02 0.0354 -0.07% ! 81 3.7510E-02 0.0375 -0.03% 82 0.0000E+00 N/A 83 0.0000E+00 N/A 84 3.4077E-02 0.0341 0.07% 85 2.2168E-02 0.0222 0.15% 86 2.5241E-03 0.0075 -0.95% 87 0.0000E+00 N/A ! 88 1.2952E-05 0 N/A 89 0.0000E+00 N/A 90 3.3406E-06 0 N/A ; 91 0.0600E+00 N/A 92 0.0000E+00 N/A 93 0.0000E+00 N/A 94 0.0000E+00 N/A 95 5.0365E-08 0 N/A i C-102
" By: Date: s 'Chkd: Date:
BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.7, PAGE:BM7-11 o 96 0.0000E+00 N/A 97 0.0000E+00 N/A I 98 99 100 6.8591E-03 0.0000E+00 7.7882E-03 0.0069 0.0078 0.60% N/A 0.15% ' _l I 101 102 103 0.0000E+00 0.0000E+00 0.0000E+00 N/A N/A N/A 104 0.0000E+00 N/A I " 105 106 1.6231E-02 0.0000E+00 107 l0.0000E+00 0.0162 -0.19% N/A N/A 3 108 'O.0000E+00 N/A g 109 0.0000E+00 Ih/A 110 5.1417E-08 0 N/A 111 3.2014E-02 0.032 -0.04% I 112 11'3 114 0.0000E+00 3.8590E-02 0.0000E+00 0.0386 N/A 0.03% N/A I 115 116 117 4.4797E+02 0.0000E+00 0.0000E+00 0.0448 0.01% N/A N/A < 118 0.0000E+00 I 119 120 0.0000E+00 6.0182E-02 0.0602 N/A N/A 0.03% 121 5.7435E-02 0.0574 -0.06% 122 0.0000E+00 . M/A 123 0.0000E+00 ~ N/A 124 5.0766E-02 0.0508 0.07% I 125 3.2820E-02 126 127 3.7553E-03 0.0000E+00 0.0328 0.0038
-0.06%
1.19% N/A 128 1.5603E-05 0 N/A I 129 0.0000E+00 130' 4.0246E-06 131 0.0000E+00 0 N/A N/A N/A I 132 133 134 0.0000E+00 0.0000rS00 0.0000E+00 N/A N/A N/A 135 0.0000E+00 I 136 137 0.0000E+00 0.0000E+00 N/A N/A N/A 138 0.0000E+00 N/A 139 0.0000E+00 I. 140 6.0673E-08 0 N/A. N/A 141 0.0000E+00 N/A I 142 143 144 0.0000E+00 0.0000E+00 0.0000E+00 N/A N/A N/A 145 0.0000E+00 N/A 146 0.0000E+00 N/A C-103 I
L.h-: By:. D2te: Chkd: Date: BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE .2.0, . UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.7, PAGE:BM7 '147 0.0000E+00 N/A 148 0.0000E+00 N/A 149 0.0000E+00 N/A-150 0.0000E+.00 N/A 151 0.0000E+00 N/A j D 152 0.0000E+00 -N/A i
.153 0.0000E+00 N/A 154 0.0000E+00 N/A ,
155. O.0000E+00 N/A ' 156 'O.0000E+00 N/A 157 0.0000E+00 N/A 158 .$.0000E+00 N/A l 159 0.0000E+00 N/A { 160 0.0000E+00 -N/A
.t 61 0.0000E+00 N/A ;
162 0.0000E+00 N/A ! 163 0.0000E+00 N/A 164 -0.0000E+00 N/A 165 0.0000E+00 N/A -l 166. 0.0000E+00 N/A 167 0.0000E+00 .N/A 168 0.0000E+00 N/A 4 169. 0.0000E+00 N/A . ! 170 0.0000E+00 N/A e l i 1 3 l j 1 i I C-104 l
By: Dnto: Chkd: Date:
- l. <
BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.7, PAGE:BM7-13 NODAL DISPLACEMENT l l Z-DIR. DISPLACEMENT _____________________________________________________l NODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE I NO. ._ (1) (2) ( (2 )-(1) )/ (1) *100% [ I 1 0.0000E+00 N/A 2 1.5704E-03 0.0016 1.88% ) 3 0.0000E+00 N/A E 4 1.0175E-02 0.0102 0.24% 5 a.0246E-02 0.0102 -0.45% 6 '1.0258E-02 0.0103 0.41% 7 0.0000E+00 N/A 8 4.2529E-02 0.0425 -0.07% 9 0.0000E+00 N/A 10 1.4599E-01 0.146 0.01% ) 11 3.1155E-01 0.3115 , -0.02% 12 0.0000E+00 N/A 13 3.4272E-01 0.3427 -0.00% 14 0.0000E+00 15 3.4275E-01 N/A 0.3427 -0.01% 16 3.4276E-01 0.3427 -0.02% 17 0.0000E+00 N/A-18 3.3296E-01 0.3329 -0.02% 19 0.0030E+00 N/A 20 3.0513E-01 0.3051 -0.01% 21 0.0000E+00 N/A 22 0.0000E+00 - N/A i I 23 -0.0000E+00 N/A 24 0.0000E+00 N/A 25 2.3497E-01 0.2349 -0.03% 26 0.0000E+00 N/A i 27 0.0000E+00 N/A 28 0.0000E+00 { N/A l 29 0.0000E+00 N/A i 30 1.1216E-01 0.1121 -0.05% 31 7.9233E-02 0.0792 -0.04% 32 0.0000E+00 N/A 33 7.8076E-02 0.0781 0.03% j 34 0.0000E+00 N/A 35 7.8062E-02 0.0781 0.05% 36 0.0000E+00 N/A 37 0.0000E+00 N/A 38 0.0000E+00 N/A 39 0.0000E+00 N/A 40 7.8033E-02 0.078 -0.04% 41 7.8011E-02 0.078 -0.01% 42 0.0000E+00 N/A 43 0.0000E+00 N/A 44 7.1388E-02 0.0714 0.02% I C-105 l
By: Otto: Cukd: Date: BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.7, PAGE:BM7-14 i 45 4.9073E-02 0.0491 0.05% 46 1.1821E-02 0.0118 -0.18% 47 0.0000E+00 N/A 48 5.2949E-03 0.0053 0.10% 49 0.0000E+00 N/A 1 50 1.2978E-03 0.0013 0.17% 51 0.0000E+00 N/A
- 52. 0.0000E+00 N/A 15 3 0.0000E+00 N/A '
i 54 0.0000E+00 N/A e 55 1.0634E-07 0 N/A 56 40.0000E+00 N/A 57 0.0000E+00 N/A 58 0.0000E+00 N/A 59 0.0000E+00 N/A 60 3.3988E-02 0.034 0.03% 61 0.0000E+00 N/A 62 0.0030Et00 N/A 63 0.0000E+00 N/A 64 0.0000E+00 N/A 65 9.6922E-08 0 N/A 66 0.0000E+00 N/A . ; 37 0.0000E+00 N/A l 68 0.0000E+00
- N/A
. 69 0.0000E+00 N/A F
70 6.6275E-03 0.0066 -0.41%
'71 1.0294E-02 0.0103 0.06%
72 0.0000E+00 N/A 73 1.0368E-02 0.0104 0.31% l 74 0.0000E+00 N/A i 75 1.0367E-02 0.0104 0.32% 76 0.0000E+00 N/A 77 0.0000E+00 N/A 78 0.0000E+00 N/A 79 0.0000E+00 N/A 80 1.0364E-02 0.0104 0.35% 81 1.0360E-02 0.0104 0.39% 1 82 0.0000E+00 N/A 83 0.0000E+00 N/A B4 9.7800E-03 0.0098 0.20% 85 7.2066E-03 0.0072 -0.09% 86 2.1734E-03 0.0022 1.22% , 87 0.0000E+00 N/A l 88 1.1610E-03 0.0012 3.36% 89 0.0000E+00 N/A 90 2.9753E-04 0.0003 0.83% i 91 0.0000E+00 N/A 92 0.0000E+00 N/A 93 0.0000E+00 E/A 94 0.0000E+00 F/A 95 2.7215E-08 0 h/A l C-106
By: __ Dato:- ~" Chkd: D2te: BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.7, PAGE:BM7-15 96 0.0000E+00 N/A 97 0.0000E+00 98 7.7922E-03 N/A 0.0078 0.10% 99 0.0000E+00 100 9.0227E-03 N/A 0.009 -0.25% " 101 0.0000E+00 102 0.0000E+00 N/A 103 0.0000E+00 N/A 104 0.0000E+00 N/A 105 3.7942E-02 N/A 0.0379 -0.11% 106 0.0000E+00 107 ,0.0000E+00 N/A N/A 108 ~0.0000E+00 N/A 109 0.0000E+00 110 N/A 6.6414E-02 0.0664 -0.02% ,, 111 6.7065E-02 0.0671- 0.05% 112 0.0000E+00 113 N/A 6.6159E-02 0.0662 0.06% 114 0.0000E+00 115 N/A - 6.6157E-02 0.0661 -0.09% 116 0.0000E+00 117 N/A 0.0000E+00 N/A 118 0.0000E+00 119 N/A 0.0000E+00 N/A 120 6.6125E-02 0.0661 -0.04% 121 6.6097E-02 0.0661 0.00% 122 0.0000E+00 N/A 123 0.0000E+00 124 N/A 6.1337E-02 0.0613 -
-0.06%
125 4.3511E-02 0.0435 -0.02% 126 1.1506E-02 0.0115 -0.05% 127 0.0000E+00 N/A 128 5.5821E-03 0.0056 0.32% 129 0.0000E+00 130 N/A 1.4202E-03 0.0014 -1.43% 131 0.0000E+00 N/A 132 0.0000E+00 133 N/A 0.0000E+00 N/A 134 0.0000E+00 135 N/A 0.0000E+00 N/A 136 0.0000E+00 137 N/A 0.0000E+00 N/A 138 0.0000E+00 139 N/A 0.0000E+00 N/A 140 1.2653E-07 0 N/A 141 0.0000E+00 N/A l 142 0.0000E+00 N/A 143 0.0000E+00 N/A 144 0.0000E+00 N/A 145 0.0000E+00 N/A 146 D.0000E+00 N/A I C-107 l
+, .!
n By: Date: Chkd: Date: 4 BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.7, PAGE:BM7-16 -] 147 0.0000E+00 N/A i 148 0.0000E+00 N/A .j
'149 0.0000E+00 N/A 150 0.0000E+00 N/A , ~
151- O.0000E+00 N/A 152 'O.0000E+00 N/A 153 0.0000E+00
- N/A 154 0.0000E+00 N/A ~. j 155~ 0.0000E+00 N/A -l
~156 0.0000E+00 N/A~
157 0.0000E+00 N/A ; 158 r0.0000E+00 N/A i 159 0.0000E+00 N/A I 160 0.0000E+00 N/A 161 0.0000E+00
- N/A !
162 0.0000E+00 N/A i 163 0.0000E+00 *
. N/A-164 0.0000E+00 'N/A ;
165 0.0000E+00 N/A j 166 0.0000E+00 N/A 167 0.0000E+00 N/A
'168 0.0000E+00- N/A i 169 -0.0000E+00 N/A i 170 0.0000E+00 N/A .
i l ,
'l i
l C-108
1 By: Date: '"Chkd: Date: , BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.7, PAGE:BM7-17 NODAL ROTATION i l X-DIR. ROTATION l 3 NODE NUREG GAPPIPE . % DIFFERENCE ~. ) NO. (1) (2) ( (2)-(1) )/ (1) *100% 1 0.0000E+00 N/A j 2 4.9439E-04 0.0005 1.13% j 3 0.0000E+00 . N/A ) 4 2.9433E-03 0.0029 -1.47% 5 4.6516E-03 0.0047 1.04% 6 4.8306E 0.0048 -0.63% 7 0.0000E+00 N/A 8 5.6235E-03 0.0056 -0.42% 9 0.0000E+00 N/A 10 5.7956E-03 0.00'58 0.08% 11 5.4779E-03 0.0055 0.40% 12 0.0000E+00 N/A 13 4.6526E-03 0.0047 1.02% 14 0.0000E+00 N/A 15 4.2457E-03 0.0042 -1.08% 16 3.6891E-03 0.0037 0.29% 17 0.0000E+00 N/A 18 3.3305E-03 0.0033 -0.92% 19 0.'0000E+00 N/A 20 3.2150E-03 0.0032 -0.47% 21 0.0000E+00 N/A 22 0.0000E+00 . N/A 23 0.0000E+00 N/A 24 0.0000E+00 N/A 25 2.4341E-03 0.0024 -1.40% 26 0.0000E+00 N/A 27 0.0000E+00 N/A 28 0.0000E+00 N/A l 29 0,0000E+00 N/A ; 30 1.1605E-03 0.0012 3.40% 1 31 5.7443E-04 0.0006 4.45% 32 0.0000E+00 N/A 33 4.5943E-04 0.0005 8.83% 34 0.0000E+00 N/A 35 2.7554E-04 0.0003 8.88%
- 36 0.0000E+00 N/A 37 0.0000E+00 N/A 38 0.0000E+00 N/A 39 0.0000E+00 N/A
) 40 3.0980E-04 0.0003 -3.16% 41 3.7324E-04 0.0004 7.17% 42 0.0000E+00 N/A ; 43 0.0000E+00 N/A l 44 4.0394E-04 0.0004 -0.98% \ l C-109 l f
= +
1 By:. Date:- Chkd: Date: I k-; BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.7, PAGE:BM7-18 i 45 4.1044E-04 0.0004 -2.54% 46 4.4760E-04 0.0004 -10.63% 47- O.0000E+00. .N/A 1 48 3.1672E-04 0.0003.- -5.28% 49 0.0000E+00 N/A i l - 50 1.4378E-04 0.0001 -30.45% l 51 0.0000E+00 N/A 52 0.0000E+00 N/A # 53 0.0000E+00 N/A 54 0.0000E+00 N/A l 55 3.6891E-08 0- N/A N/A 56 ,:0.0000E+00 57 0.0000E+00 N/A 58 0.0000E+00 N/A 59 0.0000E+00 N/A ' 60 5.8029E-04 0.0006 3.40%
'61 0.0000E+00 N/A i
62 0.0000E+00 N/A 63 0.0000E+00 N/A 64 0.0000E+00 N/A 65 .2.5646E-08 0 N/A 66 0.0000E+00 N/A 67 0.0000E+00 N/A ! 68 0.0000E+00 N/A 69 0.0000E+00 N/A
'70 1.7154E-04 0.0002 16.59% )
71 3.3022E-04 0.0003 . -9.15% ; 72 0.0000E+00 N/A 73.-3.6026E-04 0.0004 11.03% q 74 0.0000E+00 N/A. l 75 3.4994E-04 0.0003' -14.27%- 76 0.0000E+00 N/A , 77 0.0000E+00 N/A ! 78 0.0000E+00 N/A ! 79 0.0000E+00 N/A 80 1.7775E-04 0.0002 12.52% 81 9.8463E-05 O.C001 1.56% 82 0.0000E+00 N/A 83 0.0000E+00 N/A , 84 7.0382E-05 0.0001 42.08% l 85 6.8260E-05 0.0001 46.50% 86 7.6284E-05 0.0001 31.09% 87 0.0000E+00 N/A 88 6'.5462E-05 0.0001 52.76% 89 0.0000E+00 N/A 90 3.2497E-05 0 N/A j 91 0.0000E+00 N/A ; 92 0.0000E+00 N/A 93 0.0000E+00 N/A 94 0.0000E+00 N/A 95 8.5776E-09 0 N/A J C-110
By: Date: Chkd: Date: 3ENCRMARKING GAPPIPE . 2. 0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.7, PAGE:BM7-19 96 0.0000E+00 N/A 97 0.0000E+00 N/A 98 1.7147E-04 0.0002 16.64% 99 0.0000E+00 N/A " 100 1.7140E-04 0.0002 16.69% - L 101 0.0000E+00 N/A I 102~ 0.0000E+00 N/A 103 (, . 0000E+00 N/A l- 104 0.0000E+00 N/A 1 l 105 2.2970E-04 0.0002 -12.93% 106 0.0000E+00 N/A 107 -;0.0000E+00 N/A 108 0.0000E+00 N/A 109 0.0000E+00 N/A 110 3.6095E-04 0.0004 10.82% 111 4.5364E-04 0.0005 10.22% 112 0.0000E+00 N/A 113 4.8421E-04 0.0005 3.26% , 114 0.0000E+00 N/A 115 4.6192E-04 0.0005 8.24% 116 0.0000E+00 N/A' 117 0.0000E+00 N/A l . 118 0.0000E+00 N/A 119 0.0000E+00 N/A 120 1.1193E-04 0.0001 -10.66% l 121 2.0558E-04 0.0002 -2.71% 122 0.0000E+00 N/A 123 0.0000E+00 N/A 124 2.4733E-04 0.0002 -19.14% 125 2.5894E-04 0.0003 15.86% 126 3.9052E-04 0.0004 2.43% 127 0.0000E+00 N/A ! 128 3.1589E-04 0.0003 ~5.03% 129 0.0000E+00 N/A 130 1.5554E-04 0.0002 26.59% 131 0.0000E+00 N/A 132 0.0000E+00 N/A 133 0.0000E+00 N/A 134 0.0000E+00 N/A I 135 0.0000E+00 N/A 136 0.0000E+00 N/A 137 0.0000E+00 N/A l 138 0.0000E+00 N/A i 139 0.0000E+00 N/A 140 4.0828E-08 0 N/A
- . 141 0.0000E+00 N/A 142 0.0000E+00 N/A 143 0.0000E+00 N/A 144 0.0000E+00 N/A
[ 145 0.0000E+00 N/A i 146 0.0000E+00 N/A l C-111 l
ri
.. I By:~ Date: Chkd: Date: 1 l BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0,' UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.7, PAGE:BM7-20 i
147 0.0000E+00 N/A 148 0.0000E+00 N/A l 149 0.0000E+00 N/A i 150 0.0000E+00 N/A 151 0.0000E+00 N/A 152 q 0.0000E+00 N/A 4 153 0.0000E+00 N/A 154 0.0000E+00 N/A , 155 0.0000E+00 N/A i 156 0.0000E+00 N/A I 157 0.0000E+00 N/A 158 20.0000E+00 N/A j 159 0.0000E+00 N/A 160 0.0000E+00 N/A 161 0.0000E+00 N/A , 162 0.0000E+00 N/A 1 163 0.0000E+00 N/A -8 164 0.0000E+00 - N/A 165 0.0000E+00 N/A i 166 0.0000E+00 . N/A i 167 0.0000E+00 N/A 168 0.0000E+00 N/A ., 169 0.0000E+00 N/A !
.170 0.0000E+00 N/A 1
m 5 C-112
'BY: Dats: Chkd: Dato:
I
' BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.7, PAGE:BM7-21 L
i. NODAL ROTATION NODE NUREG GAPPIPE % DIFFERENCE ' J. NO. (1) (2) ( (2)-(1) )/ (1) *100% ) 1 0.0000E+00 N/A 2 1.4871E-04 j 0.0001 -32.75% l [ 3 0.0000E+00 N/A 4 5.9654E-04 0.0006 0.58% 5 0.0010 0.94% ! 6 ~.$.9068E-04 1.0207E-03 0.0010 -2.03% r 7 0.0000E+00 N/A 8 1.1197E-03 0.0011 -1.76% 9 0.0000E+00 N/A 10 1.1803E-03 0.0012 1.67% 11' '1.2787E ,03 0.0013 1.674 12 0.0000E+00 ' N/A 13 1.3679E-03 0.0014 2.35% 1 14 0.0000E+00 N/A 15 1.4385E-03 0.0014 -2.68% l 16 1.5752E-03 0.0016 1.58% 17 0.0000E+00 N/A 18 1.7575E-03 . 0.0018 2.42% 19 0.0000E+00 N/A 20 1.8046E-03 0.0018 -0.26% 21 0.0000E+00 N/A 22 0.0000E+00 .. N/A
.23 0.0000E+00
- N/A 24 0.0000E+00 N/A 25 2.1106E-03 0.0021 -0.50%
26 0.0000E+00 N/A 27 0.0000E+00 N/A 28 0.0000E+00 N/A 29 0.0000E+00 N/A j l 30 1.8626E-03 0.0019 2.01%
-31 9.9997E-04 0.0010 0.00%
32 0.0000E+00 N/A 33 6.5024E-04 0.0007 7.65% 34 0.0000E+00 N/A 35 7.6983E-05 0.0001 29.90% 36 0.0000E+00 N/A 37 0.0000E+00 N/A 38 0.0000E+00 N/A 39 0.0000E+00 N/A 1 40 8.8744E-04 0.0009 1.42% 41- 1.2562E-03 0.0013 3.48% 42 0.0000E+00 N/A i 43 0.0000E+00 N/A 44 1.5708E-03 0.0016 1.86% C-113 ___- _ _ - - - - - - - - - - . - _ = . .
BY: Date: ~" Chkd: Date: BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.7, PAGE:BM7-23 J 97 0.0000E+00 N/A 98 2.9814E-04 0.0003 0.62% 99 0.0000E+00 N/A 100 3.2251E-04 0.0003 -6.98% 101 0.0000E+00 N/A 102 0.0000E+00 N/A ~i 103 0.0000E+00 N/A i 104 0.0000E+00 N/A 105 6.4667E-04 0.0006 -7.22% < 106 0.0000E+00 N/A { 107 0.0000E+00 N/A 108 0.0000E+00 N/A , 109.*0.0000E+00 N/A 1 110 2.3777E-04 0.0002 -15.89% 1 111 1.8081E-04 0.0002 10.61% 112 0.0000E+00 N/A 113 2.9634E-04 0.0003 1.24%
- 114 0.0000E+00 N/A 115 3.3064E-04 0.0003 -9.27%
116 0.0000E+00 N/A ! 117 0.0000E+00 N/A 118 0.0000E+00 N/A 119 0.0000E+00 N/A i 120 2.2S42E-04 0.0002 -12.44% i 121 7.2680E-04 0.0007 -3.69% 122 0.0000E+00 N/A l 123 0.0000E+00 N/A ! 124 1.2296E-03 0.0012 -2.41% 125 1.2964E-03 0.0013 0.28% 126 1.1215E-03 0.0011 -1.92% l 127 0.0000E+00 N/A 128 7.4204E-04 0.0007 -5.66% 129 0.0000E+00 N/A 130 1.8927E-04 0.0002 5.67% 131 0.0000E+00 N/A i 132 0.0000E+00 N/A 133 0.0000E+00 N/A - 134 0.0000E+00 N/A 135 0.0000E+00 N/A 136 0.0000E+00 N/A 137 0.0000E+00 N/A 138 0.0000E+00 0.0000 N/A [. 139 0.0000E+00 N/A 140 2.8770E-08 N/A 141 0.0000E+00 N/A 142 0.0000E+00 N/A 143 0.0000E+00 N/A i 144 0.0000E+00 N/A 145 0.0000E+00 N/A 146 0.s000E+00 N/A 147 0.0000E+00 N/A 148 0.0000E+00 N/A C-114 (.
q BY: ~'! Dato: Chkd: Dato: I
' BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.7, PAGE:BM7-24 p
149 0.0000E+00 N/A l 150 0.0000E+00 N/A 151 0.0000E+00 N/A 152 0.0000E+00 N/A' 153 0.0000E+00 N/A 154 0.0000E+00 N/A . L 155 0.0000E+00 N/A ) 156 0.0000E+00 N/A 157 0.0000C+00 N/A ) 158 0.0000E+00 N/A 159 0.0000E+00 ) [ N/A ' 160 0.0000E+00 N/A 161 10.0000E+00 N/A I 162 0,0000E+00 N/A i 163 0.0000E+00 N/A 164 0.0000E+00 N/A 165 0.0000E+00 N/A 166 0.0000E+00 N/A 167 0.0000E+00 1,. N/A 168 0.0000E+00 N/A 169 0.0000E+00 N/A I 170 0.0000E+00 N/A 1 l l l l l l 1 C-115
lBY: Date: os Chkd: Date:
~ ~ BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2. 0? UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM ' NO.7, ' PAGEi BM7-25 l
NODAL - ROTATION l ROTATION. l l __________________Z-DIR. ___________________________________ i NODE NUREG' GAPPIPE 4 DIFFERENCE' , NO. (1)- (2) ( (2)-(1) )/ (1) *100% 1 0.0000E+00 N/A , 2 '4.3453E-05~ O N/A ; 3 -0.0000E+00 N/A l 4 2.8785E-04 0.0003- 4.22% ' 5 ~ 4.8167E-04 0.0005 3.814 6 45.1415E-04 0.0005 -2.75% 1 7 0.0000E+00 N/A i 8 6.2890E-04 0.0006 -4.60% 9 0.0000E+00 N/A 10- 6.5629E-04 0.0007' 6.66% 11 6.0289E-04 0.0006 -0.48% 12 0.0000E+00 N/A 13' 4.9990E-04 0.0005 0.02% l 14 0.0000E+00 N/A. I 15 4.0873E-04 0.0004 -2.14% 16 2.6385E-04 0.0003 13.70% ; 17 0.0000E+00 N/A 18 2.8414E-04 0.0003 5.58%
- 19 0.0000E+00' , M/A ,
20- 2.6031E-04 ' 0.0003 15.25%- ! 21 0.0000E+00
.N/A 22 0.0000E+00 N/A 23- 0.0000E+00 N/A. {
24 0.0000E+00- N/A 25 1.2807E-04 0.0001 -21.92%
. 26 0.0000E+00 N/A 27 0.0000E+00 N/A ' "- 28 0.0000E+00 N/A '
29 0.0000E+00 N/A 30 6.5295E-05 0.0001 53.15% l 31 2.2404E-04 0.0002 -10.73% ! 32 0.0000E+00 N/A 33 2.4192E-04 0.0002 -17.33% 34 0.0000E+00 N/A 35 3.5426E-04 0.0004 12.91% 36 0.0000E+00 N/A - 37 0.0000E+00 N/A 38 0.0000E+00- N/A i 39 0.0000E+00 N/A 40 5.5886E-04 0.0006 7.36% ! 41 6.7143E-04 0.0007 4.25% 42 0.0000E+00 N/A 43 0.0000E+00 N/A 44 7.3746E-04 0.0007 -5.08% 45 7.4283E-04 0.0007 -5.77% l C-ll6
BY: D2to: Chkd: Data:
)
s .. 1
=j BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.7, PAGE:BM7-25 l
1 46' 5.7791E-04. 0.0006 3.82% j 47 0.0000E+00 N/A .l
.48 2.8368E-04 0.0003 5.75% 'l 49 0.0000E+00 N/A-
!- i 50~ 7.5058E-05 0.0001- 33.23% 51 0.0000E+00 J N/A 52 0.0000E+00 , N/A 53 0.0000E+00 -- N/A 54 0.0000E+00 N/A 55 1.5794E-08 0 N/A 56 0.0000E+00 e- N/A 57 0.0000E+00 N/A 58 .*0.0000E+00
' N/A f 59* O.0000E+00 N/A 60- 1.3447E-04 0.0001 -25.63%
61 0.0000E+00 N/A 62 0.0000E+00 N/A 63 0.0000E+00 N/A 64 0.0000E+00 N/A 65 2.8675E-08 0 N/A 66 0.0000E+00 N/A
- 67 0.0000E+00 N/A
- 68. 0.0000E+00 'N/A g 69 0.0000E+00 N/A 70 2.3499E-04 0.0002 -14.89%
71 4.1539E-04 0.0004 -3.70% 72 -0.0000E+00 N/A 73 4.3969E-04 0.0004 -9.03% . 74 0.0000E+00 N/A
' 75 5.3226E-04 0.0005 -6.06%
l 76" 0.0000E+00 N/A 77 0.0000E+00
- N/A 78 0.0000E+00 N/A 79 0.0000E+00 N/A 80 6.9980E-04 0.0007 0.03%
81 7.9250E-04 0.0008 0.95% 82 0.0000E+00 N/A 83 0.0000E+00 N/A 84 8.4502E-04 0.0008 -5.33% 85 8.4779E-04 e 0.0008 -5.64% 86 6.6708E-04 0.0007 4.94% 87 0.0000E+00 N/A 88 3.4554E-04 0.0003 -13.18% 89 0.0000E+00 N/A
~
90 9.8093E-05 0.0001 1.94% 91 0.0000E+00 N/A 92 0.0000E+00 N/A ) 93 0.0000E+00 N/A 94 0.0000E+00 N/A l 95 2.0975E-08 0 N/A , 96 0.0000E+00 N/A i 97 0.0000E+00 N/A C-117
' BY: Date: .. Chkd: .Date:
BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2.0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBNEM NO.7, PAGE:BM7-27 98 2.-3482E-04 0.0002 -14.83% 99 0.0000E+00 N/A 100 2.3419E-04 0.0002 -14.60% 101 0.0000E+00 N/A I 102 0.0000E+00 N/A 103 0.0000E+00 N/A
- 104 0.0000E+00 N/A 105 9.1896E-05 0.0001 8.82%
106 0.0000E+00 N/A 107 0.0000E+00 N/A 108 0.0000E+00 N/A 109 0.0000E+00 N/A 110 ~6.4295E-04 0.0006 -6.68% 111 "9.8722E-04 0.001 1.30% 112 0.0000E+00 N/A 113 1.0294E-03 0.001 -2.85% 114 0.0000E+00 N/A. 115 1.0585E-03 0.0011 3.92% 116 0.0000E+00 N/A 117 0.0000E+00 N/A 118 0.0000E+00 N/A 119 0.0000E+00 N/A 120 .1.1943E-03 0.0012 0.474 121 '1.2515E-03 0.0013 3.88% 122 0.0000E+00 N/A 123 0.0000E+00 N/A 124 1.2803E-03 0.0013 1.54% l 125- 1.27128-03 0.0013- 2.274 - 126 9.8498E-04 0.001 1.52%
'127 0.0000E+00 N/A 1 128 5.2935E-04 0.0005 -5.54%
129 0.0000E+00 N/A' 130 1.5226E-04 0.0002 - 31.35% 131 0.0000E+00 N/A- 1 132 0.0000E+00 N/A i 133 0.0000E+00 N/A 134 0.0000E+00 N/A 135 0.0000E+00 N/A 136 0.0000E+00 N/A 137 0.0000E+00 N/A 138 0.0000E+00 N/A 139 0.0000Z+00 N/A 140 3.2507E-08 0 N/A 141 0.0000E+00 N/A J 142 0.0000E+00 N/A 143 0.0000E+00 N/A, 144 0.0000E+00 N/A q 145 0.0000E+00 N/A 146 0.0000E+00 N/A 147 0.0000E+00 N/A 148 0.0000E+00 N/A I 149 0.0000E+00 N/A C-118 i _L__--_.___:___---____ --_ _--
- BY: Date: Chkd: Date:
? ' BENCHMARKING GAPPIPE 2. 0, UNIFORM SPECTRA PROBLEM NO.7, PAGE:BM7-28 h-l 150 0.0000E+00 N/A 151 0.0000E+00 N/A j 152 0.0000E+00 N/A 153 0.0000E+00 N/A I
154 0.0000E+00 N/A . 155 0.0000E+00 N/A l 156 0.0000E+00 N/A i s 157 0.0000E+00 N/A 158 0.0000E+00 ) N/A 1
. 159 0.0000E+00 N/A 'l l 160 0.0000E+00 N/A 161 0.0000E+00 N/A 162 /0.0000E+00 -
N/A i ! 163 'O.0000E+00 N/A > 164 0.0000E+00 - - N/A 165 0.0000E+00 N/A
- 166 0.0000E+00 N/A .
- 167 0.0000E+00 N/A 168- 0.0000E+00 N/A-169 0.0000E+00 N/A -
170 0.0000E+00 N/A
- ~
). .
, . . . e 0 0 $ . . -
g ) . . e
. e . I l
) . t I C-119
Cy:' Date: Oed: Date: EDOMutKinc GMelPE 2.0, t.ktfoqM SMCTRA MGL9 90.7 .~ ~ ~ ~~ PnE:ec.29 j OBOMutK PIGL9410.7, 0.907 StilESSES GAPP18E witstCW 2.0 tuEC IERATS ELEM PM(I) W(1) W(I) TM(1) Mr(!) M(1) PK(J/C) W(J/C) W(J/C) TM(J/C) M(J/C) M(J/C) l
- 10. PN(J) W(J) W(J) TX(J) Sif(J) IS(J) i 12.360E*G2 2.dd6E*G2 8.GME414.947E4 2.106E4 2.217E4 2.3dGE*02 mr432 8.GNE*014.90E*G51.dEdE4 2.tBEE4 2 2.3dGE*G2 2Ad5E*G2 8.GGE4014.90E*G51.d5dE*05 2.tBEE4 5.aldE413.52R*G2 8.02412.54dE4 4.2PM41.90dE4 4 2Ad5E*02 2.3dSE4 8.GNE*01 1.25E4 4 Adde 41.1EEE*06 3 2Ad8E*G2 2.3dEE*02 8.GGE*01 1.255E*G5 4 Adde 41.7EtE4 2A815eG21.3dBE*G2 8.0FE4011.25E41.90E41.011E*04 4 2419E*G21.701E*02 5.51E*01 1.25E41.90E61.011E4 2A19E41.701E*G2 5.751E41 1.25BG51 AIE4 7A44E*05 5 2419E41.7 DIE *G2 5.51E41 1.25E**21.M*G5 7A4dE*G5 7.291Ee013.15M*G2 5.751E4l 24544121.36BG5 L2BIE4 l 1.7DIEMI2 2419E*G2 5.51E417.tB1E4 9.15E4 4ABIB i 61.701E4 2419E4 5.751E*017.tB1EeG2 9.18lE*G2 42E8G51.701E*02 2419E4 5.75901721E4 4 AGE 4 2.75E*02 7 7.799E412.GRE*02 3.15B017.IB1E4 429E4 '2.7554 7.790E412 ACE 4 3.15E*017A1E4 8.960E4 5 AGE 45 8 7.799E*012 AGE *02 3.15E4i TA1E4 8 96tE4 5.8WE4 2.014E*G2 9.151E*013.15B012Ad5E41.254E4 6.5EE4 2AGEMIt 7.799E413.155E*011.0EE45 AJadr4E &J2WeG5 9 2 ACE 4 7.790E401115Ee01 1.GSIE4 8 Adde 4 Ld21E4 2SE4 7.799E*01115EH01 1AltE4137E*G5 5.221E4 .
10 6.95dE413.351E*01 LMB 01 1.asI*05137E4 5.221E*G5 LedEH013.351E*013.7W4011.000E4 LOWE4 4A79E*05 - j i 114.95dE413.XIE413.351E411.0dGE4 4A?9E4 2.03E*G5 5.155E*015.9EE413.351E9013EdE4 2.355E4 2.215E4 LMBE416.95dE*013.351E*014.35451.191E4 2AEE4
- 12 3.7W4013.351E41195dE414.1G4 2A0lE41.191E4 LM3E413.351E41195dE*014.3M*05 3AtBGB 1 AIE*05 <
13 3.755E412.ME414.354E414.343E4 3AtMeG51J3E4 3.755E412.35aE414.354E414.354 2.144E41.tE!E4 l 14 3.11b1E411.9ERH019.3PE*014.33405 L144Ests 1.M*05 3.151Ee011RB019.3Psect 4Ja*G5 3.9111E 15 4A64E*te 15 5.3 nee 01 L3Elte013.1dEsel 1.3fEHIB 223E41Jssets 5.EEH012.3pEsel 3.1EEsel 1.37E*05 3JteHis 1m 16 53EEsel 3.1 gee 012.395s01 12EHIB 1.ERHI5 3JtE4 L15E*01 1.1ERHel 2.3Gire el 9AIDG21 A171945 32D45 f 5.9dAE41 1 A11Ee012.395414.7McG21411E4 3J64EstB > 17 5.900E*05 L3GEeCl 1JEE*014.M8HG2 3J64HGI 1411E*05 5.989E45 2JGIN01 1.EIE414.MIE4 LtBBG51.3FIE*05 18 4.9EEH011.949E412.251E*014.MSEMI2 3.tB2E41.3FIE45 L9HE411.9E8E41221E414.M8E4 2.281E4 SEN*G2 { 19 9.050E413.23E413.0d8E*014.MSHG2 2.351E4,827E4 9.tBEH01 LZEE413.0SE414.M8E41.M2E4 2EIE4 j 20 9.150E4013.068E413.23E414.7EJE*02 2A2E*G21.M2E4 4.500E41 SAfBE413.23EH012.253E4 4.217EMI21.540E6 3.058E*019.153:413.23E41 1.7/IE*02 3.362E*021.22E*G5 ,, , a 213.0NE*013.22E*019.G10E41 1.77tE*G21.22dE4 3.362E*02 LO58E45 3.2EE419.010E41 1.7NE4 2.5GING21.821E*02 ; 22 L35E*014REH01 1.061E*G21.771E*02 2.5GE*021.825E*02 3.357E414REH01 1.061EMI21.771E4 2.711E41.319E4 25 3.3919014RE*01 1.061E*Gt 1.771E*02 2.711E41.319E4 4.M4E413.5FE41 1.061E4 2.154E*G5 L159E41 A57E4 4RIE41 3.3571H01 1.061E*G! 3.187E4 3.511E*G21 AmeG5 l 34 4RIE41 1.061 Edit 3.357E*011187E*G51ARE*GI 3.39902 4RIE41 1.061E*G2 L357E45 3.11DE41 AIE41.9BE405 1 25 4RIE41 1.0$DG2 3.GE41'3.187E*t51AIE41.99E4 4RIE41 1.0DE4 3A50E413.1EDE41.579E4 3ASIE*G5 35 4.310E412.587E417.861E412A15E41.919E41.325E4 4.310E412.587E417.861E412A15E4 4.M39G51.EBE4 j 27 4J12E*013.2EdE418.771E412A13E4 4.90E41.885H02 4.312E413.36dE418.771E412A15E4 8.982E41A95E4 28 4.972E413.lD9E*013.950E*018.152E42 2ASE*G5 2.3WdHG5 4.9DE4118 DOE 413.95GH018.152E4 952E*G2 6.71DE*G2 2P 1.7AdH01 2A5?E41 1.905E41 1.152E*02 9.710E*G21.2NE41.7NE*012A57E41 1.905E*01 1.152E*G2 5.172E4 5.011E*G2 301.7ME*01 1.9GiE412A57E4' 1.152E*02
. 5.011E*G2 5.172E4 2.022E41 1J41E412A57E41221E*G2 3.835E412 4.9BIE*G2 l 2.1G41 1 A53E*012A57E414.027E4 2.0 DOE *G2 4.772E*G2 312.1G412A57E*01 1 A54E414R5E*G2 4.7NE*G! 2.054E*02 2.13412A57E41 1 AS4E414.025E4 2.992E*G2 3.EEE*G2 321.751E41 1.254E41 1 A4dE414.02902 2.993902 3.3EiE*G21.781E41 1.254E41 1 AE414RBG2 3.579EME 7A75E*G2 {
351.9KE412.lB1E412.QDE*014.02B02 3.5?W4G2 7A75E*G21.97DE41221E412.053E*014.025E+(E 5.950E+G2 235E*02 341.970E+012.0SIE412.EB1E*014.02202 255E*02 5.950E*G2 2AfEE419A771900 2.881E4011.941E*02 3.625E*G2 6.225EMI2 2.055E41 1.970E+012.881E+01 1.551E*G2 2.840E+G2 5.8eGE402 1 35 2.065E412.881E41 1.970E41 1.551E+G2 5.850E*02 2 AGE +02 2.0SIE41221E41 1.970E*01 1.951E*02 3.36E+02 2.GIEE*G2 36 2.853E415.056E412.702E+01 1.951E402 3.36E*02 2.0351902 2.853E*015.GkE+012.702E41 1.551E+02 3.652E41.39?E4 I c-120
j cy: Oste: f.%d _. Date:_ CDO+Watl4 CNPIPE 2.0, LAIFGM 9TCTRA FEBL64 80.7 **"*~==* PfE:DF-30 I I 37 2.M+015.M412.?c2E411.55M402 3.63&+T 1.W7bG5 3.6 tie 414.54&+012.7029013.874602 2.574E+021.56E*G3 l 5.M+01 2.853t+01 2.MII+01 4RDE*02 9.6R41 1.645E*05 38 5.M+012.7TE412.853E+014.820E+G21.645E4 9RGE415.M4012.7TE412.853E414.820E*021.79E*03 4.251402 8 39 5.03E+012.721E+012.932E4014 ROP 021.79E405 4.2SI4 5.Gl6E412.721E412.952E414.82E402 2.07/PG5 8.5756G2 40 3.678E4012.20K4013.661E412.200BG21.905E@ 7.219E+02 3RBE+012.200E41341E412.20E4021.758E4 6.544E+G2 - I 413.6R+012.2DE4013&E412.2DE+G21.758E*C5 0544E*G2 3RIIE4012.2DE413A6E4012.200E+0214tSE*05 5.%M4m 42 3.67eE4012.2DE+013.661E412.200E40214tSE4 5.90E+G2 3RBE412.209E413A61E412.* DOE 4G2 3.150E*G2 8J80E*02 43 3475E+01 1.759E+01 1.754E412.2*E4G2 3.E50EG 8.8SE@ 3R5E*01 1.759E41 1.754E412.20E+02 1.25?E+G51.665E4 44 3.671E413.550E*01 1.4GE*012.200E41.25?E41.6E4 3RY413.550E41 1J06E412.20E432 7.925E+02 3JQE*02 8 45 3471E41 1.606E*013.55E4012.200E*G2 340E@ 7.925E*021.886E*013.582E413.550E*01 1.235E4 2.995E+02 7.155E402 1.692413R)E*013.550E4012.354E4 L521E415.9GIE@ 461.606E413.55E413R1E45 2.354E+G2 5.90?E@ A521E411JBIE413.550E413RIE45 2.354E402 2.199E*G2 4A05E*G2 l I 47 4 AGiE41 1.3DE+013.35E4012.3%E*02 2.1PE*02 4AGIE4 4AG5E41 1.5DE413.355E*012.354E4021.968E41.212E4 48 9.42?E*013.529E412Jo?E4012.3iE4021.968E41.212E*G5 9A2R413.52BE412J09E412.3ME4 2A9E405 4A6dEG 49 9.42?E412J0?E413.52E412.354E+02 4A6dE@ 2A&lE405 L3GiE*015.1GE*011.529E4013Jp?E*02 3.200E*G2 2.459E4 l l I 2AG7E419A2?E+013.529E414.EE4021.NEMI2 2.1ME*G5 50 2J0?E4013.529E419A2?E+014JG2E402 2.170E61.390EG 2Jo?E4" 3.529E419A2?E414.402E402 8.5FE4G2 4.75K+02 513A0241009E*01 1.261E*G2 4JEEE@ 8.5NE@ 4.759E*02 3 AGE 4 LA9E41 1.351E*G2 4.dGQE4G2 2.310E41.961E*05 52 3A00E+016.09E+011.251E402 4J02E402 2.310E+G51.961E*05 2.955E41 L215E*011.261E4G2 2.128E4051.7D?E405 2.15?E4 6.09E413 AGE 411.261E*G2 2JDE*05 2.GDE*02 2.348E4 5 53 6.05?E41 1.261E+02 3 AGE 4012JDE4 2.348E4 2.GDE*G2 6.09E*01 1.351E432 3A00E+012.8DE+05 2.773E4 2.0%E4 54 6.09E401 1.255E+02 3A7/E*012.8DE*G3 2.77E405 2AME405 009E401 1.2tBE+02 3ADE*012JUE405 3.251E*G5 4.055E4 12.4NE410.1XCE*00 8 2 3.63r412 0.00CE+00 3 3.542EHI2 0.000E*GO 4 LD18E-G2 0.000E*00 I - 7 3A314010.CGI+00 5 5A55E41 OJOE*GO 4 5.%2E410.000E4 t 8 4.8?eE4010.(EDE*00 91.053E402 0.000E@ 10 6.90E4010.00E400 115.3RIE4010.1XXE*00 12 9.6G2E410.03I400 8 13 2.952E4010.001400
% 5.GME*010.000E*00 15 2.721E410.02E400 8 16 3.47/E+010.000E4D 17 4.00E+010.002400 I
181.2tSSE+02 0.GIE+(D 19 3.65K4G5 0.000E400 20 3.187E+G5 0.03I400 211.57E4 0.03I4CD I 22 2.565E4 0.C00E+CD 25 9.I54E*03 0.00E+00 24 2.85?E4G5 0.03I+CD I 25 8.57E402 0.00I+00 2th 4.820E402 0.0%E400 27 2.ONE4G3 0.GEEMD 28 4.m3EHI5 0.0EDE400 29 2.8DE413 0.tE0E+00 I em I
Sy: Dati: OM: Datt: 8Do*WKl4 CW' PIPE 2.0, tutfG@t SFCCUtA F9na m 30,7.......... pwg;gg.3) 30 3.251E4 0.002<20 i
. I
( i l
. , . . . i . s )
J
..k e ,
i
* * . 4 , e O - i 5
i 1 C-122
.u " Ey: Octe: Ded: Date:
ROOheJirluc camlM 2.0. tNIFON SPECTaA PiratfM so.7 4-.~.~* PME:ev 32 1 GAMIM wtslod 2.0 RESLLTS ElaM PK(1) W(1) Vl(!) TX(1) m(l) IE(I) PN(J/C) W4J/C) VZ(J/C) TX(J/C) M'J/C) MZ(J/C) ac. PN(J) W(J) v2(J) TX(J) m(J) MZlJ) 12.368E*G2 2.6d6E*02 8.tmE*014.9WE4 2.106E*05 2.217'!*06 2.36dE4 2Ad6E4 8.GME*014.9WE*G51.didE4 2.059E4K 2 2.3ddE*02 7 MM*G2 SROE414.9EdE41 Aide 4 2.GME4 5.2mE413.526E*02 8.GHE*012.54dE4 4.295E41.906E4K 2Ad6E+02 2.36fE4 8ADE*01 1.25E4 4 AGE 41.1EGE4 3 2Ad6E*02 2.368E*G2 8.GME*011:25E4 4.4GE41JEGE4 2Ad6E*02 2.368E*02 8.0RE*011.25E41.90E41.011E4 4 2A19E41.7DlE4 5.750E4011.255E41.90E*G51.011E*06 2419E41JDtE*02 5.75Gi4011.253E41. GIBE 4 7AG4 5 2419E*Gt 1JDtE*02 5J5GE*011.25EE41AIBE4 7AG4 7.290E*013AldE4 5J50E*012#0E*021.3GE4 6.2BIE4 IJ01E*G2 2419E*G2 5J5Gi+0! 7ARE4 9.100E4 4EIE4 61JDtE*02 2419E*G2 5J50E*017.EEE*02 9.1EEeG2 421E41RIE*G2 2419E*G2 5J5tE41 TARE 4 4.90lE4 2.75LE4 7 720E412ADE4 3.150E*017 AIDE *G2 4.90DE4 2J5tE*G2 7.8DDE*012AIES 3.15tE45 7AllE4 8.940E4 5 AGE 4 8 7.800E*012ADE*02 3.15EE*017AIE4 L910E*02 5JGE4 2.054 9.15tE41 L15tE*012AdGE*G21.25E4 05B7E4 2ADE4 TAKE*01 L15EE*01 1 A0tE4 SAE4 6A1E4 ' 9 2AIE*G2 7.800E41115 tee 011 AGE 4 SAE4 6AIE4 2ADE*Gt 7JOII*013.15tE411AdE4130E4 5.2EE4 10 L950E*013.3ME*013JEEE*011AllE41AIE4 5.2EE4 69EE*013.35DE413JudE451AdGE4 2AEid 4R9E4 - 11 A930E*013JEEE45 3.3EE411AltE4 4A79E4 2ADBE4 5.150E415.9EE413.3EE*01325E4 2JEE4 2.215E4 L1EGE*01 A910E4l 3.3EE414.3G*G51.19BE4 2AEBE4 . . l . 12 3JitdE413.3EE*0109EIEs014JG4 2AEE41.19EE*G5 3.1EGE*013.35DE41095DE*014.3G4I5 3AG41JMiG 15 3J5GE4l 2.390E414.3EE414.3G*G5 3AG41 ARE4 3.750E412 AGE 414.350E414.3G4 2.ME*G51 ARE4
% L1EGE*01 1.920E419.3ME*014.3G4I5 2.1G*G51 AIE+G5 3Jil0E*01 1.9EE419.3RE414.3G4 3.9Mdi405 SA60:*G2 13 5.380E412.270E413.iddE411.3DE4 2.3NE41.dWE4 5.310E412.2ME413.1dfE411.3DE*G5 3.31dE41. GEE 4 16 5.3EE45 3.idtEdl 2.2MEe011.3DE41AE*G5 3J1dE4 L15E411.140E45 2ADE*019AStE*G21 Aide 4 3JilE4 5.9RE*01 1ASE412.2RE414JIldEeG21Amed5 3JGE4 L ' 175 AGE *012Ame011Jtesset 4J5EeSt 3.3 mets 1 AGE 4 5.990E45 2ADE411 AIDE 41 L75DE4 321E41JFIE4 l O A9Eul41,1.9154l 22tE*014J5EeG23AIE41.371E4 L9EE4l 1J5tE412J5tE*014.75tE4 22E4 8A054 9 9ARE41323*013ADE414J5E4 221E4 S.800E4 9AME*01125DE4013AIE414J5DE41J4 meg 5 2AEG E 9ARIE*013ADE413.250E414J5DE4 2 AGE 41JE*G5 4J10E*01 SACDE413.255412.3EE*02 4.22DE41.540E4
) 3ADE419AEE4112EE411JEDE*02 3.360E*Gt 1.22E4 213.GmE413.2EE419.050E41 1JIDE*021.225E4 3.3 DOE 4 3.GNt:413. ZEE 419.050E41 1JEDE4 2.570E*021 ADE4 22 3.390E414.8EI41 1.061E*G21JEE*02 2.570E*G21 ADE4 3.390E*014AEE41 1.061E*021Jtl0E4 2.711E*G51.319E*G5 ! 25 L390E414ADE41 1.051E*G21Jil0E42 2.711E41J19E4 4JEGE413.5RE41 1.061E*G2 2.154E4 2.15EE41 A57E4 4.8EE*011390E411.061E*02 3.186E*G5 3.590E41ASE4 36 420E41 1 A61E*02 3.390E413.18dE41 A8BE4 3.99tE4 4JEE41 1.061E*G21390E41 L186E41 A3E41.91EE4 25 4AME41 1ASIE4 3A30E413.18dE*G51A33EeG51.99554 4ADE41 1AIE4 3A30E41 L188E41.579E4 3JEE4 ) 26 4J1GE412.590E417.lM0E412A*JE*G51.918E41.32E*G5 4.310E412J00E41 TAdE*012AG4 4.9QE*051 ACE 402 27 4J10E41 L250E418.710E412At3E*05 4.9GE41J00E*G2 4.310E413.25E418.770E412At3E*G5 8.9BtE41A95E4 25 4.9EE*013A10E413.950E418.150E4 2A53E4 2.234 4.9mE413A10E413.950E418.150E4 9.dK0E*G2 6J90E4 2P 1JIME4l 2AdOE41 1.900E41 1.150E4 9.710E*021.2715E*G51.750E412AdOE41 1.900E401 1.150E*G2 5.1ME*G2 5.010E*02 301Jt0E41 1.9tDE4012AdGE*01 1.150E4 5.010E4 5.170E4 2ADE41 1.640E*012AdCE412AEEG 3 AGE *02 4.990E4 2.140EMPI 1 A50E412A60E+014.050E*02 2.060E*02 4.770E402 ) 31 L14GE*012JdQE*01 1 A50E414.020E4 4.770E*G2 2.060E*G2 2.140E*012AdGE+01 1A50E414.020E4 2.590E402 3.380E*02 ) 321JIEE41 1.250E41 1 A5Gi414ADE*02 2.590E*02 3.EGE41JHE41 1.260E*01 1 A50E414A20E*G21580E4 7A70E*G2 331.9mE41 ?mrF412.060E414.020E*G2 3.5EE*G2 TA70E*G21.970E412.8EE412.060E414.020E402 5.950E*G2 2.39GH12 341.9EE*012.060E412ADE*014ADE*02 2J90E4 5.950E402 2A80E419JU0E*C0 2A10E*011.960E*G2 3A20E*G2 6.220E*02 ). 2.060E41 1.9mE412.8EE41 1.55GE402 2 AGE 4 5.860E*G2 ) 35 2.060E41220E411.970E*011.55E*G2 520E*02 2.840E+02 2.050E412AEE411.9EE*011.550E*G2 3.3 DOE 4 2A50E*G2 36 2.25E415.040E412J0E*011.550E*02 3.360E432 2.05I4G2 2.150E+015.040E*012J00E4011.550E+02 3AEE*G21.377E4 37 2J50E415.040E412J00E41 1.550E4 3A30E41.3 pie 405 3420E414.550E412J00E413.8KE*G2 2.570E*G21.562E*G5 5.040E+01 2.850E+01 2.705401 4.82EE*02 9)DE41 1.645E4 f C-123 l l
Dr: ~ ODte: Dad: Oste: soo*Wectic twem 2.0, atfoN SPEcraA paaetsi m.7.... ~.. rea:sa 33 l 3B 5.04]E*012.70E412.850E414.82E*G21.645(4 9.70CE415.0WE412.700E*012EE414.520E4021.795E4 4.35E*02 ' 39 5.0f.0E*012.720E+012.930E414.820E@ 1.795E*05 4.281402 5.0WE*012.720E-'012.930E4014.820E402 2.077E*05 8.58E4 40 3.480E*012.21E413.660E+012.200E@ 1.906E+G5 7.220E402 3.6EE4012.210E*013.edE412.20E+021.758E4 6.54E*G2 413.68I412.210E413.660E412.200E*G21.758E4 6.54E4 3.68E*012.210E*013.660E412.200E421.614E4 5.950E402 42 3.FA4012.21E+013.660E412.200E*G21414E4 5.950E4 3.680E412.210E413.660E412.200E*G2 3.850E4 8.800E*G2 43 3.670E41,1,,7E0E41 1.750E412.200E*G2 3.EioE402 8.8sE*G2 3.6 mea 01 1.7E0E41 1.750E*012.200E*G21.25441.463E*G5 44 3.670E413.550E+01 1.7C*.24012.200E*G21.257E41 A63E*05 3EDE413.550E401 1.70ri+012.200E402 7.920E4 3 AGE *02 45 3ADE41 1.700E*013.550E412.200E@ 3 ACE *G2 7.920E*G21 AGE 413.580E4013.550E41 1.2EE*02 2.99E*02 7.130E*02 1.700E*013ADE413.550E412.35E*G2 E500E415.910E4 461.700E413.55E413ADE412.35E*G2 5.910E@ 8.500E41 1.700E413.95E413EDE41230E@ L160E@ 4 AGE 4 47 4 A00E41 1.MOE413.350E412.350E42 2.1dGE*02 4A00E*02 4J0E41 1.3sE413.3EE41230E421.9EE41.213E4 48 9A3E413.53E41241E4012.35GHG21.98EH051.212E4 9A50E*013.53E41241E412.EIGHG2 2A00t4 4ARE*G2 de 9A30E412410E413.550E41230E4 4ADE*G2 2AEE4 8.300E415.170E4l 3.550E413.700E4 3.21E4 2A5DE4 2410E419AEE4013.530E414ADE*G21.3RE4 2.17E*G5 50 24ME*013.5EE419A3E414AGHG2 L1RE413E42 241E413.550E419AIE414 AGE 4 8.540E@ 4.7EE*G2 513AGOE414.070E41 1.261E*02 4 AGE *G2 8.540E*G2 4.7E0E*G2 3A00E414. ORE 41 1.261E4 4 JOE 4 2.310E41.961E4 52 3 AGE 416.0RE*01 1.361E*G2 4ADE*G2 2.31GHG51.961E*G5 2.960E416.253901 1.2b1E4 2.taE*G51.70FE4 2.181E4 6.GRE413 AGE 41 1.261E402 2E7E4 2.GIDE@ 2.3ME4 1 55 6.070E41 1.261E*G2 3A00E412E7E*05 2.3ME*G5 2.GICE*G2 6.GRE41 1.261E*02 3A00E412R7E*G5 2.773E4 2.064E4 54 6.GPUE*01 1.3dEE*02 3A80E412E7E4 2.773E4 2.064E4 6ADE411.2dEE*02 3ASE412R7tW5 3.250E4 4.0EE4 12AME 010.000E*00 2 3452E4It 0.00E*00 ( 3 3.542E G2 CA33H00 4 6.017E42 OADEe00 5 5A5 eel 0.00E*00 6 5.141E41 O m mH00 7 3ARE410AR3H00 8 4E89010.00340 9.1.0SMHG2 0.00E*00 10 6.90se.01 0.00E 4 115.3P?E410.00GH00 12 9J91E410.00E*00 1 13 2.952E401 0.G30E400 14 5.056E401 OADEe00 15 2.721E*010.003H00 16 34?EE*010.005400 17 6.067E410.000E*00 101.3SiE*02 0.000E*00 19 0.000E40 3ASDE4 ' 20 0.000E400 3.186E4 / 210.000E4001.579E4 22 0.000E4 2.564Ee j Zs 0.000e*00 9.3ssE 4 34 0.000E4 2.857E4 ( 25 0.000E40 8.577E*02 26 0.0GE@ 4.819E*G2 { 270. axe 4 2.0m 4 < 2B 0.000E+00 4.052E4 29 0.030E400 2.87?l905 ( 30 0.00Ee 3.25E4 k i C-124 i
Dr: Date: Omai: Date: Knotwet1ME, CpIM 2.0, LMIFON SMCTRA MGLEM ET --- --- ME.-99 E 1 fEEDfrAE c17fpons En(IN buEG #0 GWIK WtSlau 2.0 (3450 as suec): ELIM Pz(l) W(l) VZ(I) TX(I) m(!) Nt(l) PE(JK) W(J/C) W(JK) n(JK) m(JK) MZ(JK)
- 80. Pz(J) W(J) W(J) TX(J) M(J) Nt(J) 1 4.02 0.001 -0.02K -0.02E O.00L 0.05 402 0.RK 0.0E 4.02E 0.0E 0.00E -
2- -0.0f.E 0.GK -0.021 0.G2K 0.05 0.05 0. M 0.tBK 4.IEE 0.IIK CAR CAGE 0.III 40E 4 02K 0.M 4.6 0.0E Ilm II/A WA ILM WA IPA 3 0.05 -0.0E 402E 0.03 4 02K 0.05 CAGE 4.02 4 TEE CADE 0.05 0.0m 4 0.M OJEE 4 TEE 0.03 CAR 0.05 0M 0.III 0. M 0. M 0. M 4.05 1 5 0.03 0.00K 0.02K 0.05 0.05 4.01E 4EE 4tBE ASE 0.15 CAR -0A2K ! 0.03 SAR -0.tEK 4 0tX -0.IEE 4. TEE em II/A II/A II/A WA II/A 6 CAR CADE 4AIK 0.Dit 42 4 02K Sm 0.0E 4 GIE 0AE 0.02E 4.15 7 0.01E 0.0K 41E 4AE em 415 OAtt 0.03 415 4 0tX 0.03 CAE S 0.05 02 0.1E 0.0E Sm 0.03 4GE 405 0. M 0.zK 0.05 0.a2K OJIK 0.01E 0.11E 0. M 02 SAE Ilm Ilm Ilm al/A WA al/A 9 OAK 0.011 4.1E CAR em 0.00E 0.05 0.0tE 41E 0.0E 4.0m 4 02E 10 4.03 44BK 4.tBL 0.0E 4 0FE 4 02E 4.03 4RE 4.05 OAK 0.05 0.05 11 0.0K 4 GaK 4GE 0.0E 0.03 GAE 40E SAE 4.15E - 44BK 0.00K 0.03 0.tBK -0JBE 0AE CAE CAE 0.03 N/A II/A 81/A 11/ 2 II/A 81/ 2 12 42 4m 4.05 0.GE SAE em 4tBE 4R 40s 0.0K 0.05 OAE 13 41E 0.175 -0.05 0.05 0.03 CAE 4 15K 0M 0.00E CAR -Om 0.05
% 4tBK 4 10L 0.01K 0.03 -0.tBE 0.0E 4tBE 4 1dK 4tBE 0.05 0.00E -0.tBE 13 0.0FE 0.13E tutK -0.07E 40E 0.05 0.0K 0.07E 0.tB 0.GPE 0. TIE CAE 16 OJIFE GAR 0. M 4 SFE OB SAE 4mt 4X 0.tB 4m 4 0FE SAE SJRE 4AK 0.tB 0,0EE SAE em em em em em O/A em 17 Sm 0. M GX SAE 4B 48E 0 NE 0.tB OX GAEK 4R SAE O' O.EE 0.mE 4 0EE 0,0EK 4m GAE em 0.5E 4 0GE SAEK SAE OB 19 OAE SAE O. OPE 6.0EE SAE SJRE SAE SAE SAFE 0 AGE 0.05 ASPE E CAR OJIPX OASE 0.0EE 4 05 CAR OJIEE 4 0EE CAR 4tB 0.0FE 0.ctX l 0.0PE 0.03 0.0$K 0.15 4.0EE 0. TEE II/A II/A al/A II/A WA II/A 21 0.0PE 0.06K 0.05 0.15 0.00K -0.05 0.07E 0.0$K 0 00K 0.111 0.125 4.271 22 0.07E 0.02 0.00K 0.15 0.125 0.2 75 0.tBE 0.0E 0.00K 0.111 0.GE 0.00K 23 0.0PE 0.0E 0.05 0.11E 0.0E CAR GAR 405 0.05 0.03 4m 0.03 0.0E 0.0PK 0.00K 4.tBE 4.0BK 0.05 II/A II/A WA al/A WA II/A 36 0.0EK CAE 0.03 4JBK OAE 4M OAE OAK 0.03 4tBE 0. TEE OAK 25 CJKE CAOK 0.0E 4JBK CAE JAR SAEK SAIK OAE 4tBE CAE CAIK 36 0.00E 4.125 -0.0E CAGE 4JIE 0.05 OAK 0.125 0AE 0.0K 0.02K 0.15 k
27 -0.GSE 0.121 4 .011 0.00E -0.02K 0.11E 0.tBE 0.121 4Att 0AK 0.01E 0.00K 23 4.0GE 0.tBK 0. TIE 4 TEE CAE 4.0GK 4 0GE CJBE 0.03 4 02% 4AIK 0.0GK ? 29 0.2E 0.121 0.aK -0. m 0.00K OAK 0.2E 0.121 -0.35 AM 0.02 4 02E i 3 0.255 0.25 0.1a -0. m 0.02E 0.asK -0.10E 0.ost 0.ta 0.GE C.15 0.02K 4ME -0.215 0.125 0.071 0.00E 4 0EK Ilm tL/A WA II/A II/A II/A
- y 31 4%E 0.12E 43E 0.121 -0.0GK 0.19E -0.14E 0.12E 4.28K 4 125 4m 4.15K 32 4 0$K -0.32K 0.%E 4 121 0.OBE 0.15K 4 0$E 432K 0.14K 4 125 0m 0.07E 33 0.05 0.05K 4.tSK 0.124 0.tBE 4.07E OAE -0.05K 4 15K 4 12K 0.tIK 4 2tX .
34 CAOK 0.15E -0.05K 4 12K -0.215 0 GX 4 19E 0.3GE 0.0E 4 05E 4.%E 4.0BK 4 15% 0.00E 4 GIK 4.0$K 0.05 0.GE ) al/A ti/A II/A WA II/A II/A 25 -0.155 -0.05K 0.GE 0.0dK 0.GE 0.00L -0.tSK -0.05K 0.0E -0.0$K 0.05 0.20L 36 4.15 0.05E 4 071 -0.05K 02 0.3X 4.15 0.05K 4.07E 406E -0m 0.00K 37 -0.1tX 0.05E 4.075 0.061 -0.0$K 0.00E 0.05K 0.071 -0.071 -0.10K -0.16K 0.00K l l Om 0.15 -0.07E 0.03 0.32K Om WA WA WA WA WA WA C-125
Sr: ' Date: Deaf: Dato: SENCmWKING GM914 2.0. 04f0lM SPECTRA P90BLBt 10.7 - - PnE:sF.35 j 3B 0.051 -0.0 K 0.1u 0. M 0.05 0.32E cm -0.07K 41u 0.02 -0.0S1 0.00K 3P 0. M -0.or.K -0.07K 0.M -0.06E 0.M Om -0. M 4 07E cm 0. M 0. 6 40 0.05K 0. M -0.M 0.M CM 0.011 0.M OR -0. M 0.0E 0.05 -0m 41 0.M ' O. M -0S 0. M 0.taE -0.00K 0.EBE OR -0R 0.Est -0.06E 0.05K 42 0.05K 0. M -0 B 0. M 4 067. OR 0.tBK 0.tBK -0. M OM 0. TEE 0.00L H 43 -0.Mt ' O.06E -03 0.tKE 0. M 0. M 0.M1 0.01E 4R 0.M 0.M 0.00E i 44 -0. M 0. M 0.M 0.05 0.05 0.M 4R 0. M 0.34% 0.M -0.0f.% 0.tBE 45 4.tBK 0.261 0.005 0.005 Om 40E 0.215 0.01E 0.00L 03 4.17K 4 07E ;
- 0. M 4.15K -0.05 -0.M -. 0.25K 0. S IVA tyA st/A II/A II/A II/A 46 0.M 0.0E AM -0. M 0.15E -03 0.3EE 0.M 0.tBE 4.M CR 4.07K 47 -0.111 0.22K 4 05 4.M 0.tBE 4.6 41R 0.22K 405 AM 0.00K 0.05 48 0.tBE 0.15E 0.12E 4,M 0.5 CARE 0. 5 OR 0.121 4 171 4.0EE 0.0K 4P 0.lBE 0.12E 0.0E 4.M 0.EE 0.011 405 0.05 0.tBE 0.tBE 0.85E 0.05 1 0.125 0.tBE 0.tBK 4 0EE 0.BE 4.EEE Iyn al/A . N/A II/A II/A II/A 50 0.12E 4.tBE 0.tBE 4 0EE 6.05 0.05 0.12E 0. M 0.tBK 40E 0.05 0.EEE
$1 0.4EE 6.dBE 0.05 4 0EE 0.01E 0. 6 8.aK 0.tBE - 0.M 4.06E 0.05 0.00E j 0.GE OM -0.01E - 0.05 OR 0. M 0.03 0.03 52 0.15E 0. M 46 0.6 O.tBE 0. M 0.EEE 0.05 0.1E 0. TEE . II/A WA II/A II/A lim II/A 55 0.tBE 0.05 0.M 4.05 0.05 0.15E 0.tBK 0.tRE 0. TEE 0.00E Om 0.00E f 54 0.tBE 0.0tE 0.tNE 0.GE 4.05 0.05 0.GIE 0.03 0.09E 0.05 -0.EBE -0.02E 1 1 4.IBK WA WA II/A . II/A syn . II/A N/A II/A II/A II/A WA 2 4 02K IIM II/A - al/A st/A IIM si/A IIM 81/A II/A II/A 81/A 3 0.05 II/A IVA N/A ti/A syn m/A II/A ILM II/A WA IIM ,
4 4 0tE ti/A IIA st/A Ilm em 04 Iyn M/A II/A II/A ILS 5 4Att Ilm syn 11 4 tim sin Ilm aim aim 11 4 al/A syn 6 4dBE Iim aim aim 11 4 11 4 - sig sim 11 4 IIM II/A stM T 4 DIE Ils 9L4 Ilm sim sim sim tim Ilm lim al/A al/A I 4 4ARE al/A syn aim 04 Om al/A syn II/A IIM II/A II/A 9 OAIK alm tim II/A II/A - si/A WA IVA II/A WA Ilm WA { 10 0.025 st/A If/A II/A ILS al/A N/A tyA II/A al/A II/A II/A i 11 4.01E II/A st/A WA lim WA II/A II/A WA WA WA II/A 12 4 01E al/A IIM alm alm tim II/A IL/A WA 31/A WA WA 13 44BE IIM Ilm al/A alm II/A II/A Ilm WA WA st/A II/A 16 405 Iyn llM ti/A sim II/A slm II/A IyA II/A IVA IIM 15 0JEE II/A st/A li/A lim liA si/A st/A IyA WA II/A WA 16 402K IIM II/A II/A 11 4 II/A II/A II/A IVA IL/A II/A II/A 17 4 0tE 01/A II/A II/A II/A II/A ILM II/A WA WA II/A II/A i 16 0.01E IIM II/A II/A 31 4 sq/A IIM II/A II/A IL/A IIM II/A 19 II/A II/A II/A II/A II/A Iyn st/A 31/A II/A lim IL/A II/A q E al/A IVA tVA WA IlM IIM II/A IIM st/A IVA II/A IVA j 21 syA IIM II/A II/A NA slM IIM st/A II/A . II/A WA II/A 22 II/A II/A II/A IIM 8lM IyA tlM II/A II/A IL/A II/A WA 25 WA II/A II/A syA II/A st/A *'WA st/A ILM II/A II/A II/A af. WA II/A IIM II/A syn ti/A Ilm IVA II/A II/A WA WA 25 IVA IIM ll/A st/A IIM syA II/A IVA 8VA II/A IVA II/A 26 81/A IIM IVA IIM IIM II/A IVA IVA II/A N/A 81/A IVA { 2T II/A II/A II/A II/A II/A IVA ti/A WA II/A IVA WA WA j 2B WA II/A II/A N/A II/A IL/A 81/A II/A II/A IVA N/A N/A 2P 81/A IVA WA alm WA WA WA II/A IVA IVA IVA WA E WA IVA N/A IVA WA IyA WA IVA IVA WA WA WA I C-126
4 I 1 i l APPENDIX D: Comparison Summary of ISM Benchmark Problems i 1 ! ) )
\
i D-1 i l 4
Ldy: Date: Chkd: Date: _,
/ INDEPENDENT SUPPORT. MOTION PROBLEM NO.1, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE:1SM1-1 J BENCHMARK ISM-1 ABS' .GAPPIPE 2.0
.E i FINAL FREQUENCY (Hz) RESULTS MODE GAPPIPE NUREG % DIFFERENCE l { NO. (1) .(2) ((1)-(2) )/ (2) *100% 1 6.0419 6.042 -0.00% 2 6.2557 6.256 -0.00% 3 7.7596 7.760 -0.01%
; 4 8.9426 8.943 -0.00%-
5 12.4440 12.440 0.03%' 6 12.8300 12.830 0.00% 7 14.3030; 14.300 0.02% i 8 15.4860 15.490 -0.03% 4 9 16.3710 16.370 0.01% ' 10 18.5430 18.540 0.02% 11 19.4990 19.500 -0.01% ! 12 23.2430 23.240 0.01% i 13 24.1050 24.100 0.024 14 32.6360' 32.640 -0.01% 15 33.8370 33.840 .-0.01% 4
-(
I ( i i i i ( i NRC BENCEMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, 1bs) D-2
By- Date: - Chkd: Date: INDEPENDENT SUPPORT NOTION PROBLEM NO.1, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 1-2 i NODAL DISPLACEMENT X-TRANSLATION NODE GAPPIPE NUREG % DIFFERENCE i NO. (1) (2) ( (1)-(2) ) / (2 ) *100% ,
. I l 1 0.0000 0.0000 0.00% i
) 2 0.0030 0.0030 0.00% 3 0.0724 0.0724 0.00% ! 4 0.0856 0.0856 0.00% l 5' O.0908 0.0908 0.00% 6 0.0147 0.0147 0.00% 7 0.0000 0.0000 0.00% ? 8 0.0230 0.0230 0.00% 9 0.0374 0.0374 0.00%
.10 0.0432 0.0432 0.00%
> 11 0.0404 0.0404 0.00% i 12 0.0303 0.0303 0.00% 13 0.0160 0.0160 0.00% 14 0.0033 0.0033 0.00% ! 15 0.0154 0.0154 0.00% 16 0.0248 0.0248 0.00% 17 0.0256 0.0256 0.00% 18 0.0204 0.0204 0.00% ) 19 0.0114 0.0114 0.00% 20 0.0032 0.0032 0.00% I 21 0.0120 0.0120 0.00% 22 0.0227 0.0227 0.00% 23 0.0281 0.0281 0.00% I 24 0.0256 0.0256 0.00% t-
- 25 0.0155 0.0155 0.00%
26 0.0000 0'.0000- 0.00% ; 27 0.0100 0.0100 0.00% ' 28 0.0574 0.0574 0.00% 29 0.0499 0.0499 0.00% 30 0.0508 0.0508 0.00% 31 0.0443 0.0443 0.00% l 32 0.0307 0.0307 0.00% i l 33 0.0122 0.0122 0.00% 34 0.0002 0.0002 0.00% > 35 0.0001 0.0001 0.00% 36 0.0000 0.0000 0.00% ) ) s I ) NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) D-3
By:: Date: Chkd:- -Date: i
' INDEPENDENT SUPPORT NOTION PROBLEM NO.1, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 1-3 4 t, ! ~- NODAL DISPLACEMENT Y-TRANSLATION NODE 'GAPPIPE NUREG % DIFFERENCE I NO. (1) (2) ( (1)-(2) )/ (2) *100%
1 0.0000 0.0000 0.004-2 0.0000 0.0000 ~0.00% 3' O.0095 0.0095 0.00% 4 0.0000 0.0000 0.00% ! 5- 0.0329 0.0329- 0.00% ' 6 0.0779 0.0779 0.00% 7 .0.0779 0.0780' -0.13% ! 8 0.0780 0.0780 0.00% 9 0.0780 0.0781 -0.13%- 10 0.0781 0.0781 0.004
'11 0.0781 0.0781 0.00% !
12 0.0782- 0.0782 0.00% 13 0.0782 0.0782 0.00% - - 14 0.0782 0.0782 0.00% ( 15 0.0782 0.0782 0.00% 16 0.0782 0.0783 -0.13% 17 0.0783 0.0783 0.00% 18 ~0.0783 0.0783 0.00% 1 19 0.0783 0.07834'- 0.004 ' 20 0.0783 0.0783 0.00% 21 0.0772 0.0772 0.00% 22 0.0759 0.0759 0.00% i 4 23 0.0746 0.0746 - 0.00% 24 0.0737 0.0737 0.00% g 25 0.0746 0.0747 -0.13%, ' 26 0.0746 0.0746 0.00% < 27 0.0746 0.0746 ~ 0.00% 28 0.0000 0.0000 0.00% i 29 0.0526 0.0526 0.00% ' 30 0.1098 0.1098 0.00% 31 0.2118 0.2118 0.00% 32 0.2634 0.2634 0.00% 4 33 0.2600 0.2600 0.00% 34 0.2173 0.2173 0.00% 35- 0.0807 0.0807 0.00% 3 36 0.0000 0.0000 0.00% i i i ( i l I 1 ( NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) D . _ _ - _ _ _ _ _
By:' Date: '
- Chkd:- Date:
INDEPENDENT: SUPPORT HOTION PROBLEM NO.1, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 1-4 NODAL DISPLACEMENT Z-TRANSLATION NODE' GAPPIPE NUREG % DIFFERENCE NO. (1) (2) . ( (1)-(2) )/ (2) *100% . 1 0.0000 0.0000 0.00% 2 0.0030 0.0030 .0.00% 3 0.0800- 0.0800' O.00% 41 0.0948 0.0948 0.00% 5 0.1005 0.1005 0.00% 6 0.0161'- 0.0161 0.00%
'7 0.0000 0.0000 0.00%
8 0.0250 0.0250 0.00% 9 .0.0404 0.0404. 0.00% 10 0.0462 0.0462 0.00%.
- 11. 0.0429 0.0429 0.00%
12 0.0322- 0.0322 0.00% 13 0.0170 0.0170 0.00% 14 0.0022 0.0022 0.00% 15 0.0142 0.0142- 0.00%- 16 0.0227 0.0227 0.00% 17 0.0239 0.0239 0.13% 18 0.0199, 0.0199 0.00% 19 0.0114 0.0114 0.00% 20 0.0017 0.0017- 0.00% 21 0.0181 0.0181 0.22% 22 0.0332 0.0332 0.06% 23 0.0412 0.0412 'O.00% ~ 24' O.0383 0.0383 0.00% 25 0.0220 0.0220 0.00% 26 0.0000 0.0000 0.00% 27 0.0149 0.0149 -0.27%- - 28 0.0000 0.0000- 0.00%
'29 0.0593 0.0593 0.00%
30 0.1239- 0.1239 0.00% 31 0.2325 0.2325 0.00% ) 32 0.2758 0.2759 -0.03% 33 0.2652 0.2652 0.00% >' 34 0.2214 0.2215 -0.02% 35 0.0840 0.0840 0.00% 36 0.0000 0.0000 0.00% Y L e l-NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) D-5
i
~~ 'By: . Data:- Chkd: Date:
INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.1, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 1-5 ; I NODAL DISPLACEMENT X-ROTATION NODE GAPPIPE NUREG % DIFFERENCE I NO. (1) (2)' ( (1)-(2) )/ (2) *100% " 5 1 0.0041 0.0000 0.00% 2 0.0005 0.0005 0.00% 3 0.0013 0.0013 0.00% E .4' O.0015 0.0015 0.00% 5 0.0018 0.0018 0.00% i
.. 6 0.0014 0.0014 0.00%
7 0.0012- 0.0012 0.00% i 8 0.0000 0.0008 0.00% 9 0.0005- 0.0005 0.00% 10 0.0002 0.0002 0.00% 11 0.0003 0.0003 0.00% I 12 0.0006 0.0006 0.00% i 13 0.0007 0.0007 0.004 14 .0.0006 0.0006 0.00% ( 15 0.0004 0.0004 0.00% l 16 0.0002 0.0002 0.00% 17 0.0001 'O.0001 0.00% 18 0.0003 0.0003 0.00% I 19 0.0004 0.0004 0.004 I 20 0.0005 0.0005 0.00% 21 0.0006 0.0006 0.00%. { 22 0.0004 0.0004 0.00% i 23 0.0002 0.0002 0.00% 24' O.0003 0.0003 0.00% q 25 0.0007 0.0007 0.00% ; 26 0.0011 0.0011 0.00% ' 27 0.0013 0.0013 0.00% 28 0.0015 0.0015 0.00% ! 29 0.0014 0.0014 0.00% i 30 0.0014 0.0014 0.00% 31 0.0015 -0.0015 0.00% 32 0.0015 0.0015 0.00% k 33 0.0012 0.0012 0.00% 34 0.001 0.0010 0.00% ; 35 0.0005 0.0005 0.00% ' 36 -0.0976 0.0000 0.00% I i ( i 1 NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) D-6
I By: Date: Chkd: Date: INDEPENDENT SUPPORT NOTION PROBLEM NO.1, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 1-6 NODAL DISPLACEMENT Y-ROTATION NODE GAPPIPE NUREG % DIFFERENCE ] 8 NO .. (1) (2) ( (1)-(2) )/ (2) *100 % 1 0.0001 0.0000 0.00% 2 0.0003 0.0003 0.00% 3 0.0010 0.0010 0.00% 4 0.0006 .0.0006 0.00% I- 5 6 0.0002 0.0006 0.0002 0.0006 0.00% 0.00% 7 0.0006- 0.0006 0.00% I 10 8 9 0.0006 0.0006 0.0005 0.0006 0.0006 0.0005 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 11 0.0005 0.0005 0.00% I 12 13 14 0.0005 0.0005 0.0005 0.0005 0.0005 0.0005 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 15 0.0005 7.0005 0.00% I 16 0.0005 0.0005 0.00% 17 0.0005 0.0005 0.00% l'8 0.0005 0.0005 '0.00% 19 0.0005 8 20 0.0005 0.0005 0.0005 0.00% 0.00% 21 0.0005 0.0005 0.00% 22 0.0004 0.0004 0.00% I 23 0.0003 0.0003 0.00% 24 0.0004 0.0004 0.00% 25 0.0006 0.0006 0.00% - I 26 0.0009 0.0009 0.00%
- 27 0.0011 0.0011 0.00%
28 0.0026 0.0026 0.00% 29 0.0031 0.0031 0.00% I 30 0.0031 0.0031 0.00% 31 0.0023 0.0023 0.00% 32 0.0013 0.0013 0.00% 8 33 34 0.0015 0.0015 0.00% 0.0023 0.0023 0.00% 35 0.0026 0.0026 0.00% 36 0.0001 0.0000 0.00% I I NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) I D-7 I
~~
By.: Date:~ Chkd: Date: INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.1, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 1-7 i NODAL DISPLACEMENT Z-ROTATION NODE GAPPIPE NUREG % DIFFERENCE < NO. (1) (2) ( (1)-(2) )/ (2) *100% 1 -0.0046 k 0.0000 0.00% 2 0.0004 0.0004 0.00% { 3 0.0012 0.0012 0.00% 4 0.0014 0.0014 0.00% 5 0.0018 0.0018 0.00% 6 0.0013. 0.0013 0.00% 7 0.0011- 0.0011 0.00% 8 0.0008 0.0008 0.00% 9 0.0005 0.0005 0.00% 10 0.0002 0.0002 0.00% 11 0.0003 0.0003 0.00% i 12 0.0005 0.0005 0.00% $ 13 0.0006 0.0006 0.00% 14 0.0006 0.0006 0.00% ( 15 0.0004 0.0004 0.00% 16 0.0002 0.000?. 0.00% " 17 0.0001 0.0001 0.00% 18 0.0003 0.0003 0.00% I 19 0.0004 0.0004 0.00% 20 0.0004 0.0004 0.00% 21 0.0005 0.0005 0.00% i 22 0.0004 0.0004 0.00% 23 0.0002 0.0002 0.00% - 24 0.0003 0.0003 0.00% 25 0.0006 0.0006 ' 0.00% 26 0.0008 0.0008 O.00% 27 0.0009 0.0009 0.00% 28 0.0024 0.0024 0.00% j 29 0.0027 0.0027 0.00% 1 30 0.0028 0.0028 0.00% 31 0.0021 0.0021 0.00% 32 0.0007 0.0007 0.00% q 33 0.0014 0.0014 0.00% 34 0.0023 0.0023 0.00%
.35 0.0026 0.0026 0.00% I 36 -0.0251 0.0000 0.00%
i NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) D-8 l
l., By: Date: Chkd: Date: 1 INDEPENDENT SUPPORT NOTION PROBLEM NO.1, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 1-8 L l 1
SUMMARY
OF SUPPORT FORCES / MOMENTS l (GAPPIPE-NUREG)/NUREG ,. ELEMENT GAPPPIPE NUREG % DIFFERENCE , NO. FORCE (1) MOMENT (2) FORCE (3) MOMENT (4) FORCE MOMENT _ i 1 116.5026 0 117 0 -0.43% 0.00% , f 2 127.6792 0 128 0 -0.25% 0.00% '4 3 108.9885 0 109 0 -0.01% 0.00%
- l. 4 277.7376 0 278 0 -0.09% 0.00%
5 99.92927 0 100 0 -0.07% 0.00% 6 113.2801 0 113- 0 0.25% 0.00% 7 43.61157 0 44 0 -0.88% 0.00% 0.00% 8 65.44733- 0 65 0 0.69% 9 34.81493 0 35 0 -0.53% 0.00% 10 63.39456 0 63 0 0.63% 0.00%: ) 11 71.56131 0 72 0 -0.61% 0.00% f 12 184.9536' O 185 0 -0.03% 0.00% 13 204.3696 0 204 -0 0.18% 0.00% y 14- 130.8126 0 131 0 -0.14% 0.00% 15 115.5689 0 116 0 -0.37% 0.00% 16 91.79897 0 92 0 -0.22% 0.00% 17 102.5921 0 103 0 -0.'. 4 0 % 0.00% f . f i f I. ) ) ) t 1 ' NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) > D-9 )
By:. Date: Chkd: Date: INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.1, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 1-9 l ELEMENT FORCES AND MOMENTS (GAPPIPE) ELEMENT PX(I) VY(I) VZ(I) TX(I) MY(I) MZ(I)' SRSS(I)l
-NO. PX(C) VY(C) VZ(C) TX(C) MY (C) MZ(C) SRSS(C)
PX(J) VY(J) VZ(J) .TX(J) MY(J) MZ(J) SRSS(J)i
)
L 1 127.7- 109 116.5 1522 3502. 3548'3023.231
- l. 1 127.7 109 116.5- 1522 2315 2449 2145.012.
2 127.7 147.7 51.9 1522 2836 1822 2145.012i 2 191.6 37.6- 51.9 202 '1330 1619 1221.126' !' 2 147.7 127.7 51.9 382 ', 987 1588 1107.069 3 125.8 132.9 21.9 382 987 1588.1107.069! 3 125.8 132.9 21.9 382 1528 4352 2684.767; 4 121.1 157 6.1 382 1528 4352 2684.767 4 121.1 157 6.1 382 1608 , 1065 1140.192 4 5 127.2- 145.1 34.5 382- 1608 1065 1140.1921 5 190.4 -31 34.5 421 -252 2986 1754.908 5 145.1. 127.2 34.5 86 1324 1167 1024.861 6 127.1' 92.5 101.4 86 1249 1247 1024.861( 6 127.1 92.5 101.4 86 1646 1623 1341.724i 7 120.1 21.5- 27.4 86- 1646 1623 1341.724 7 120.1 21.5 27.4 86 1371 1455 1160.297 8 111.2 20.6 25.3 86. 1371 1455 1160.297;i 8 111.2 20.6 25.3 86 1282 1371 1089.914' 9 102.9 17 19.2 86 1282 1371 1089.914 9 102.9 17 19.2 86 1257 1293 1047.18! 10 95.4 14 14.6 86' 1257 1293 1047.181 10 95.4 14 14.6 86 1088 1094 896.278 11 88.9 18.8 20.8 86 1088 1094 896.278q
- 11 88.9 18.8 20.8 -
86 695 694 571.929l 12 83.6 26.9 30.6 86 695 694 571.929 12 83.6 26.9 30.6 86 473 287 324.904, 13 79.8 32.3 36.7 86 473- 287 324.904 13 .79.8 32.3 36.7 86 1135 829 816.485 i 14 77.5 17.4 33.4 86 1135 829 816.485 14 77.5 17.4 33.4 86 657 662 543.081 15 77.6 13.3 21.8 86 657 662 543.081{ 15 77.6 13.3 21.8 86 913 729 679.595 16 80.1 8.2 9.1 86 913 729 679.595< 16 80.1 8.2 9.1 86 911 745 684.587.' 17 84.1 9 17.9 86 911 745 684.587 17 84.1 9 17.9 86 614 654 522.805 18 89.5 13.9 29.6 86 614 654 522.805I. 18 89.5 13.9 29.6 86 555 544 453.482i 19 96.1 17.4 35.6 86 555 544 453.482 19 96.1 17.4 35.6 86 1228 639 20 104.2 37 26.1 209 609 1228 804.204( 804.204j 20 104.2 37 26.1 209 311 457 343.044 21 113.1 29.5 22 209 311 457 343.044 , 21 113.1 29.5 22 209 797 762 650.781 i 22 122.6 15.7 16.4 209 797 762 650.781 ' 1 NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, 1bs) i D-10 i
^'
l
'By: Date: Chkd: Dato:
INDEPENDENT' SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.1, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 1-10 f' 22 122.6 15.7 16.4 209 1186 1050 926.803 23 132.6 18.7 14.5 209 1186 1050 926.803 23 132.6 18.7 14.5 209 1429 994 1016.685
; '24 143 31.9 16.7 209 1429 994 1016.685 24 143 31.9 16.7 209- 1621 1184 1170.401'-
! 25 139.6 18.2 72.6 769 1184 1442-1170.401 ) 25. 139.6 18.2 72.6 769' 2099 1661 1615.314 26 146.5 62.9 119.8 769 2099- 1661 1615.314 26 146.5 62.9 119.8 769 1557 1181 1218.292 27 163.8 123.3 41.3 769 '1365 1399 1218.292 27 197.2 56.1 41.3 990 1109 2609'1843.269 27 123.3 163.8 41.3 1033 2691 3665 2704.783 28 102.9 78.4 88 1035 2691 3665-2704.783 28 102.9 78.4 88 1035 1040 2152 1510.482 29 100.1 75.6 85 1033 -1040 2153 1510.482 )' 29 100.1 75.6 85 1033 1491 1220 1267.757 i, 30 99.4 73.6 65.8 1033 1219 .1491 1267.757 30 107.3 61.5 65.8 784 1653 2622 1854.258 30 102.2 69.6 65.8 1322 2306 3381 2494.407 31 100.6 ~' 4 0 56.1 1457 3381 2223 2494.407 31 100.6 40 56.1 1457 3803 3232 3015.868 32 110.1 22.7 46.3 1060 3803 3384 3015.868 ) 32 110.1 22.7 46.3 1060 3755 3169 2915.607 i 33 114.8 55.6 41.8 1222 3110 3755 2915.607 33 118.8 46.5 41.8 552 2820 3501 2627.275 33 115.5 .54.3 41.8 583 2340 3041 2250.92 34 115.5 73.1 81.5 582 3041_ 2340 2250.92_ 1 34 115.5 73.1 81.5 582 1615 1543 1338.936 : 35 115.6 91.8 102.6 582 1615 1543 1338.936 - ) 35 115.6 91.8 102.6 582 6547 6197 5239.839
)
c 1 I l I L f h NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE.2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) D-11 1 1
I By: ~ Date: Chkd: Date: INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.1, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 1-11l ELEMENT FORCES AND MOMENTS (NUREG) 1 ELEMENT- PX(I) VY(I) VZ(I) TX(I), MY(I) MZ(I)' NO. PX(C) VY(C) .VZ(C) TX(C) MY(C) MZ(C) PX(J) VY(J) VZ(J) TX(J). MY(J) MZ(J)~ l' 127.7- 109 116.5 1522 3503' 3548'
.1 127.7 109 116.5 1522 2316 2450 2-2 2 .y 3 4 3
4 4 < 5 127.2 145.1 34.54 381.7 1608 1065 I 5 190.5 30.97 '34.54 421.2 251.7 2986 5 '145.1 :127.2 34.54 86.23 1324- 1167 g 6 ; 6 ' 7 7 -(
'8 i 8 ' 1 9
10 95.4 14.04 14.59 86.23 1257 1294. 10 '95.4 l14.04 14.59 86.23 1088 1094 11 1 11' ( 12 12 j
. .. - 13 1 13 14 14 15 77.6 13.33 21.81 86.23 656.8 661.9 15 77.6 13.33 21.81 86.23 913.5 728'.9' 16 1 -16 17 17 18 .{
18 19 , 19 t 20 104.2 36.96 26.12 209.4 609.5 1228 l 20 104.2 36.96 26.12 209.4 311 457.5 21 ! 21 22 i NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPf_Ig 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) i _ _ = _ - _ ____ __ _ _ - - _ _ - _ _ - _ _ . ._ _ .__ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ . _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ - - - - _ _ _ - _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ -
By: Date: Chkd: Date: INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.1, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 1-12 22 23 8 23 24 24 ;; i 25 139.6 18.19 72.64 769.1 1184 1442 4 25 139.6 18.19 72.64 769.1 2099 1661 26 , 26 27 27 27 / I- 28 28 I 29 29 I 30 99.39 73.65 65.81 1034 1220 1491 30 107.4 61.48 65.81 .783.9 1654 2622 30 102.2 69.56 65.81 1322 2306 3381 I 31 31 32 " 32 8
- 33 ** l 33 3 33 5 34 3#
35 115.6 91.81 102.6 582.5 1615 1544 35 115.6 91.81 102.6 582.5 6548 6198 I 8 - I I I I I NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) D-13 I
p By: Date: Chkd: Date: INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.'1, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 1-13q ELEMENT FORCES AND MOMENTS (% DIFFERENCE) (GAFPIPE-NUREG)/NUREG*100% ELEMENT PX(I) VY(I) VZ(I) TX(I) MY(I) MZ(I)
,9 NO. PX(C) VY(C) VZ(C) TX(C) MY(C) MZ(C)
PX(J) VY(J) VZ(J) TX(J) MY(J) MZ(J) , i 1 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% -0.03% 0.00% 1 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% -0.04% -0.04% 2 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A-2 N/A N/A N/A N/A- N/A N/A i 2 N/Ad N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 3 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 3 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 4 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A < 4 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A' N/A j 5 0.00% 0.00% -0.12% 0.08% 0.00% 0.00% 5 -0.05% 0.10% -0.12%. -0.05% 0.12% 0.00% 5 0.00% -0.00% -0.12% -0.27% 0.00% 0.00% ( 6 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A i 6 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 7 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A { 7 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A z 8 N/A N/A N/A N/A- N/A N/A 8 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 9 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 9 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 10 0.00% -0.28% 0.07% -0.27% 0.00% -0.08%
$ 10 0.00% -0.28% 0.07% -0.27% 0.00% 0.00% (
11 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A i 11 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 12 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 12 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 13 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 13 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 14 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A l 14 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A l 15 0.00% -0.23% -0.05% -0.27% 0.03% 0.02% 15 0.00% -0.23% -0.05% -0.27% -0.05% 0.01% .j 16 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A l 16 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 17 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A-i 17 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 18 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 18 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 19 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A .j 19 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A < 20 0.00% 0.11% -0.08% -0.19% -0.08% 0.00% 20 0.00% 0.11% '
-0.08% -0.19% 0.00% -0.11%
21 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 21 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) D-14
By: Date: Chkd: Date: INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.1, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 1-14 22 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 22 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 23 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 23 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A .N/A , 24 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 24 N/A- N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 25 0.00% 0.05% -0.06% -0.01% 0.00% 0.00%
- 25. 0.00% 0.05% -0.06% -0.01% 0.00% 0.00%
26 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 26 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 27 N/A N/A. N/A N/A . .. . N/A N/A 27 N/Ai" N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 27 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A - N/A 28 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 28 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 29 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 29 N/A N/A N/A N/A. N/A N/A 30 0.01% -0.07% -0.02% -0.10% -0.08% 0.00% 30 -0.09% 0.03% -0.02% 0.014 -0.06% 0.00% 0.00% 30 0.00% 0.06% -0.02% 0.00% 0.'00% 31 N/A N/A N/A' 'N/A ' N/A N/A 31 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A- N/A f 32 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 32 N/A N/A N/A N/A
- N/A N/A 33 ' N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 33 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 33 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 34 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 1 34 N/A N/A N/A' N/A N/A N/A
! 35 0.00% -0.01% 0.00% -0.09% 0.00% -0.06% 35 0.00%. -0.01% 0.00% -0.09% -0.02% -0.02% ) l l f I NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) D-15 i
i By: Date: Chkd: Date: INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.2, ABS' COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 2-1 .] BENCHMARK ISM-2 ABS GAPPIPE 2.0 j FINAL FREQUENCY. (Hz) RESULT , MODE GAPPIPE NUREG % DIFFERENCE NO. (1) (2) ( (1)-(2) ) / (2) *100% l 1 9.3603 9.360 0.00% 2 12.7060 22.710 -0.03% { 3 15.3770 15.380 -0.02% 4 17.7970 17.800 -0.024 5 21. 604 Q- 21.600 0.02% 6 25.0990 25.100 -0.00% H 7 32.0350 32.030 0.02% 8 38.0700 38.070 0.00% 1 9 40.2940 40.290 0.01% 4 10 48.8990 48.900 -0.00% 11 57.5160 57.510 9.01% 12 61.5010 61.500 0.00% I 13 62.5420 62.540 0.00% 4 14 69.3500 69.350 0.00% 15 77.4460 77.440 0.01% / 16 78.8820 78.880 0.00% 1 17 101.7200 101.700 0.02% 18 103.5800 103.600 -0.02% 19 107.9700 108.000 -0.03% i 20 115.1000 115.100 0.00%
'21 135.2500 135.200 0.04%
22 155.2200 155.200 0.01% 23 160.6000 160.600 0.00% { 24 203.7900 203.800 -0.00% . 25 209.9300 209.900 0.01% i i f NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) D-16 l
By: Dsts: ' chkd: Date:
. INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.2, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 2-2 NODAL DISPLACEMENT X-TRANSLATION NODE .GAPPIPE. NUREG % DIFFERENCE NO. (1) (2) ( (1)-(2) ) / (2) *100% ~
l 1 0.0000 0.0000 0.00% 2 0.0090 0.0090 0.00% 3 0.0276 0.0276 0.00% i 4 0.0373 0.0373 0.00%
- f. 5 0.0411 0.0411 0.00%
6 0.0411 0.0411 0.00% i 7 0.0411 0.0411 0.00% 8 0.0237 0.0237 0.00% 9 0.0000 0.0000 0.00%
.10 0.0043 0.0043 0.00%
11 0.0077 0.0077 0.00% 12 0.0148 0.0148 0.00% 13 0.0251 0.0251 0.00% 14 0.0741 0.0741 0.00% I 15 0.0789 0.0789 0.00%. . 16 0.0420 0.0420 0.00% 17 0.0000- 0.0000 0.00% ( 18 0.0148 0.0148- -0.00% f 19 0.0148 0.0148 0.00% 20 0.0049 0.0049 0.00% 21 0.0000 0.0000 0.00% ). I (
\
l ) I J NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) D-17 : l i'
By: Date: _1 Chkd: Date: INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.2, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 2-3 NODAL DISPLACEMENT Y-TRANSLATION NODE GAPPIPE NUREG % DIFFERENCE NO. (1) (2)' ( (1)-(2) ) / (2) *100% 1- 0.0000 0.0000 0.00% 2 0.0000 0.0000 0.00% 3 0.0001 0.0001 0.00%
- 4. 0.0044 0.0044 0.00%
5 0.0157 0.0157 0.00% '4 6 0.0235 0.0235 0.00% 7 0.0310 0.0310- 0.00% 1 8 0.0355 0.0355' O.004 9 0.0288 0.0288 0.00% 10 0.0227 0.0227~ 'O.00% 11 0.0184 0.0184 0.00% 12 0.0164 0.0164- 0.00%- 13 'O.0146 0.0146. 0.00% 14' O.0074 -0.0074 0.00% 1 15 0.0001 0.0001 0.00% 16 0.0001 0.0001 0.00% 17 0.0000 - 0.0000 0.00% 18 0.0281- 0.0281 0.00% 19 0.0292 0.0292 0.00% ]
- 20 0.0085 0.0085- 0.00%
21 0.0000 0.0000 0.00% { 1 I l NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) D-18 i
Chkd: Date: t By:_ Date: INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO 2, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 2-4 NODAL DISPLACEMENT Z-TRANSLATION l ! NODE GAPPIPE NUREG % DIFFERENCE NO. (1) (2) ( (1)-(2) ) / (2 ) *100% 1 0.0000 0.0000 0.00% 2 0.0220 0.0220 0.00% 3 0.0680 0.0680 0.00% 4 0.0800 0.0800 0.00% 8 5 0.0557 0.0557 0.00% 0.00% 6 0.0289 0.0289 7 0.0000: 0.0000 0.00% 8 0.0434 0.0434 0.00% 9 0.0556 0.0556 0.00% 10 0.0556 0.0556 0.00% I' 11 12 13 0.0557 0.0558 0.0558 0.0557 0.0558 0.0559 0.00% 0.00%
-0.18%
0.00% I 14 0.0560 0.0560 15 0.0563 0.0563 0.00% 16 0.0355 0.0355 0.00% 17 0.0000 0.'0000 0.00% 18 0.0372 0.0372 0.00% 5 19 0.0155 0.0155 0.00% 20 0.0001 0.0001 0.00% 21 0.0000 0.0000 0.00% 5 E I E I E E NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) D-19 E
U / By:. Date: 'Chkd: Date: l- INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.2, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 2-5 j NODAL ~ DISPLACEMENT X-ROTATION i
-NODE' GAPPIPE' NUREG % DIFFERENCE NO. (1) (2) ( (1)-(2) ) / (2) *100%
, 3
- 1 - -0.0029 ~ 0.0000 0.00%- 1 2 0.'0007' 0.0007 0.00%
3 0.0009 0.0009 0.00% 4 0.0008 0.0008 0.00% l 5 0.0007 0.0007 0.00% 6 0.0006 0.0006. 0.00% 7 0.0006 0.0006 0.00% I 8 0.0005 0.0005 0.00% 9 0.0004 0.0004 0.00%: 10 0.0003 0.0003' O.00% j 11 0.0003 '0.0003 0.00% i 12 0.0002 0.0002 0.00% 13 -0.0002 0.0002 0.00% 14 0.0002 0.0002 0.00% I 15 0.0002 0.0002 0.00% ! 16 0.0006 0.0006 0.00% . 17 0.0007 0.0007 0.00% - 18 0.0002 0.0002 0.00% 19 0.0003 0.0003 0.00% 20 0.0003 0.0003 0.00% 21 -0.1085 0.0000 0.00%
.g' I 4 1
I i i 1 l NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) l D-20
- g By
- .Date: Chkd: Date:
INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.2, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 2-6 NODAL DISPLACEMENT Y-ROTATION NODE GAPPIPE NUREG % DIFFERENCE No. (1)- (2) ( (1)-(2) )/ (2 ) *100% , 1 0.0686 0.0000 0.00% 2 0.0004 0.0004 0.00% 3 0.0008 0.0008 0.00% 4 0.0011 0.0011 0.00% 8 5 0.0014 0.0014 0.00% 6 0.0016 0.0016 0.00% 7 0.0017- 0.0017 0.00% 8 0.0015 0.0015 0.00% 8 9 0.0004 0.0004 0.00% j 10 0.0002 0.0002 0.00% I 11 12 13 0.0004 0.0005 0.0006 0.0004 0.0005 0.0006 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% I 14 15 16 17 0.0007 0.0007 0.0007 0.0007 0.0007 0.0007 0.0007 0.0007 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 18 0.0005 - 0.0005 0.00% 8- 19 0.0006 0.0006 0.00% 20 0.0002 0.0002 0.00% 21 -0.0059 0.0000 0.00% i E 5 I I E E UNITS IN (inches, lbs) NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAGE 2.0, E
By: Date: Chkd: Date:- !
. INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.2, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 2-7' i
NODAL DISPLACEMENT Z-ROTATION NODE GAPPIPE NUREG % DIFFERENCE NO. (1) (2) ( (1)-(2 ) )/ (2) *100 % , 1 -0.1566 0.0000 0.00% 2 0.0003 0.0003 0.00% 3 0.0004 0.0004 0.00% 4 0.0004 0.0004 0.00% q 5 0.0005 0.0005 0.00% ' 6 0.0004 0.0004 0.00% 7 0.0004~ 0.0004 0.00% s 0.0003 0.0003 0.00% 9 0.0003 0.0003 0.00% 10 0.0003 0.0003 0.00% 11 0.0003 0.0003 0.00% i 12 0.0003 0.0003 0.00% 13 0.0003 0.0003 0.00% 14 0.0005 0.0005 0.00% j 15 0.0006 0.0006 0.00% q 16 0.0007 0.0007 0.00%
~
17 0.0008. 0.0008 0.00% 18- 0.0002 0.0002 0.00% 19 0.0001 0.0001 0.00% f-20 0.0001 0.0001 0.00% 21- 0.0002 0.0000 0.00% i 1 I i j k 1 i NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, 1bs) i D-22 j
By: Dato: 'Chkd: Date: INDEPENDENT SUPPORT NOTION PROBLEM NO.2, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 2-8
SUMMARY
OF SUPPORT FORCES / MOMENTS (1) (2) ( (1)-(2 ) )/ (2 ) *100% ELEMENT GAPPIPE NUREG % DIFFERENCE NO. FORCE MOMENT FORCE MOMENT FORCE MOMENT'. l 1 76.37347 0 76 0 0.49% 0.00% 2 69.60243 0 70 0 -0.57% 0.00% 3 155.6137 0 156 0 -0.25% 0.00% 4 607.2324 0 607 0 0.04% 0.00% 5 ,- 350.4273 0 350 0' O.12% 0.00% , 6 ' 184.2968 0 184 0 0.16% 0.00% ! 7 146.2008 0 146 0 0.14% 0.00% 8 301.1752 0 301 0 0.06% 0.00%' 9 45.19272 0 45 0 0.43% 0.00% 1 10 169.0093 0 169 0 0.01% 0.00% 11 90 87854 0 91 0 -0.13% 0.00% 12 151.6581 0 152 0 -0.22% 0.00% j 13 169.8482 0 170 0 -0.09% 0.00% , ) 14 157.5729 0 158 0 -0.27% 0.00% ) i l l
)
h - i
. l l
i i l I
'l l
) l l l l NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAgPgE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs)
By: Date: Chkd: Date: INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM No.2, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 2-9 i ELEMENT FORCES ' AND MOMENTS (GAPPIPE)
. ELEMENT' PX(I) VY(I) VZ(I) TX(I) MY(I) .MZ(I) SRSS(I)
NO. PX(C) VY(C): VZ(C) TX(C) MY (C) MZ(C) SRSS(C) PX(J) VY(J) VZ(J) TX(J) MY(J) MZ(J) SRSS(J)* 1 69.6 155.6 76.4 4497 5957 14377 1780.262 1- 69.6- '155.6 76.4 4497 -2787 6316 905.425 2- 69.1 121.7 56 4497 2787 6316 905.425 2 69.1 121.7 56 4497 2193 1542 575.39{ 3 68.5- 41.6 70.6 4497 1542 2193 575.39 3 69.6 39.7 70.6 3897 2962 2275' 593.189 3 63.,6' 48.7 70.6 2448 4885 21~62 645.757q 4 66.7 41.7 69.7 2448 4885 2162 '645.757; 4 57.4 53.8 69.7 772 5597 1856 653.595 4 44.9 64.6 69.7 2026 5660 1626 684.377
'S 60.1 51.5 83.1 2026 '5660 1626- 684.377{
5 60.1 51.5 83.1 2026 6008 1715 721.835 6 75.5 - 37.5 89.9 2026 6008 1715 721.835 6 75.5 37.5 89.9 2026 6587 1991 788.32i 7 97.4- 596.6 21.4 2026 1991 6587 788.32l 7 199.2 570.8 21.4 2463 1472 3824 525.371-7 392 460.2 21.4 2633 1268 10305 1177.122 8 368.5 '453.2 '33.8 2633 1268 .,-10305 1177.122 8 506.4 291.1 33.8 2466 1434' 15417 1722.976 8 571.6 120 33.8 1936 2187 17933 1996.746
'9 544.8 56.8 269.6 1936 17933 2187 1996.746-9 544.8 56.8 269.6 1936 12966 2734 1471.676i 10 522.5 74.6 268.6 1936 12966 2734 1471.676 10 522.5' 74.6 268.6 1936 8650 3829-1061.127 ,
11 500.4 116.2 264.1 1936 8650- 3829 1061.127'l 11' 500.4 116.2 264.1 1936 6356 3364 818.48 12 332.6 132.1 95.6 2424 5947 4411 856.182 12 332.6 132.1 95.6 2424 4200 24.62 597.637i l 13 290.4 44.9 74.5 2424 4200- 2462 597.637 13 290.4 44.9 74.5 2424 1878 2699 448.933 14 238.7 52.9 51.7 2424 1878 2699 448.933-14 169.2 176.5 51.7 1399 1714 1642 302.825 14 52.9 238.7 51.7 0 1998 6896 789.052 15 168.4 50.8 32.6 0 1998 6896 789.052' 15 168.4 50.8 32.6 0 2440 4907 602.309' 16 169 90.9 45.2 0 2440 4907 602.309 16 169 90.9 45.2 0 0 0 0-17 182 220.6 204.5 2695 4761 1861 635.051 ; 17 182- 220.6 204.5 2695 4677 7445 1010.61' 18 130.3 101.3 137 2695 4677 7445 1010.61 18 130.3 101.3 137 2695 2118 3532 540.875 , 19 140.3 157.3 151.6 2695 3532 2118 540.875 4 19 201 63.7 151.6 1178 566 3997 462.196 19 157.3 140.3 151.6 2041 2934 3191 526.535 20 157.6 169.8 151.7 2041 3191 2934 526.535 20 157.6 169.8 151.7 2041 6078 9903 1296.431 NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) )- D-24
'By: Data: Chkd: Date:
INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.2, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 2-10 ELEMENT FORCES AND MOMENTS (NUREG) ELEMENT PX(I)- VY(I) VZ(I) TX(I) MY(I) MZ(I)
~NO. PX(C) VY(C) VZ(C) 'TX(C) MY(C) _MZ(C) ,
PX(J) VY(J) VZ(J) TX(J) MY(J) MZ(J) - 1 1 2 2 3' 3 3 . 4 66.73 41.69 69.76- 2449 4886 2162 4 57.38 53.84 69.76 772.2 5598 1856 4' 44.9 '64.61 69.76 2026 5661 1626 . 5 5 6 6 7 ,
.. 7 -
7 8 8 8 9 9 10 10 11 500.4 116.2 264.2 1937 8651 3830 11 500.4 116.2 264.2 1937 6357 3365 12 r '12 , 13 13 I 14 238.8 52.88 51.74 2424 1878 2700 14 169.2 176.5 51.74 1400 1714 1642 i 14 52.88 238.8 51.74 0 1999 6898 15 15 16 16 {. 17 f 17 18 18 19 140.4 157.3 151.5 2696 3532 2118 19 201 63.7 151.,'i 1179 566.3 3998 19 157.3 140.4 151.6 2041 2935 3192 J 20 l 20 NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAgPfgE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, 1bs)
l i
'By: Date:- Chkd: Date: ' INDEPENDENT SUPPORT NOTION PROBLEM NO.2, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 2-11j i
ELEMENT FORCES AND MOMENTS (4 DIFFERENCE BETWEEN GAPPIPE AND NUREG) (GAPPIPE-NUREG)/NUREG*100% ELEMENT' PX(I) ~ VY(I) VZ(I)- TX(I) MY(I). MZ(I) NO. PX(C). VY(C) VZ(C) TX(C) MY(C) MZ(C) PX(J) VY(J) 'VZ(J) TX(J) MY(J) MZ(J) 9 1 N/A. N/A N/A N/A N/A -N/A 1 N/A N/A .N/A N/A N/A N/A 2 N/A N/A N/A N/A -N/A N/A 2 N/A- N/A N/A N/A -N/A N/A 4 3 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 3 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A .N/A , 3 _N/A ' N/A N/A N/A- N/A N/A I 4 -0.04% 0.02% -0.09% -0.04% -0.02% 0.00% 4 0.03% ' -0.074 -0.09% -0.03% -0.02% 0.00%' 4 0.00% -0.024 -0.09% 0.00% ' -0.02% 0.00% I 5 N/A' N/A N/A N/A N/A 'N/A 5 N/A- N/A N/A N/A N/A 'N/A 6 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 6 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A' N/A- ( 7 N/A' N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 7 N/A. N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 7 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A j 8 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A j 8 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A. 8 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A- N/A , 9 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A' N/A {'
.9 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A z g' 10 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A -N/A 10 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A d 11 0.00% 0.00% -0.04% -0.05% -0.01% -0.03%
11 0.00% 0.00% -0.04% -0.05% -0.02% -0.03% 12 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A _ 12 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 13 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 13 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 14 -0.04% 0.04% -0.08% 0.00% 0.00% -0.04% 14 0.00% 0.00% -0.08% -0.07% 0.00% 0.00% 14 0.04% -0.04% -0.08% N/A -0.05% -0.03% 15- N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A ; 15 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A ; 16 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A ( 16 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A- 4 l 17 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A d d 17 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A- N/A 18 N/A N/A' N/A N/A N/A N/A I' 18 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 'j 19 -0.07% 0.00% 0.00% -0.04% 0.00% 0.00% i 19 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% -0.08% -0.05% -0.03% 19 0.00% -0.074 0.00% 0.00% -0.03% -0.03% 20 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 20 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A i NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GA g E 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) 1
1 By: Date: Chkd: Date: INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.3, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 3-1 d BENCHMARK ISM-3 ABS
'GAPPIPE 2.0 FINAL FREQUENCY (Hz) RESULTS ,
MODE GAPPIPE NUREG % DIFFERENCE I NO. .(1) ' (2) ( (1)-(2) )/ (2) *100% ! 1 7.237 7.238 -0.01% 2 10.144 10.140 0.04% ' 3 14.577 14.580 1
-0.02%
4 15.990 15.990 0.00% 5 17.196- 17.200 -0.02% 6 17.985 17.990 -0.03% 7 22.280 22.280 0.00% 8 23.630 23.630 0.00% 9 27.861 27.860 0.00% 10 29.209 29.210 -0.00% 11 29.512 29.510 0.01% 12 31.552 31.550 0.01% 13 34.015 34.020 -0.01% 14 34.775 34.780 -0.01% 15 35.119 35.120 -0.00% i i l l - NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAgP g 2.0, UNITS IN (irches, lbs) } l
- a
- s. ..
By: Date: Chkd: Date: INDEPENDENT SUPPORT NOTION PROBLEM NO.3,. ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 3-2 NODAL DISPLACEMENT X-TRANSLATION NODE' 'GAPPIPE NUREG % DIFFERENCE NO. .(1)- (2) . ( (1)-(2) )/ (2 ) *100% 1 0.0000 0.0000 0.00% 2 0.0090 0.0090 0.00% 3 'O.0264 0.0264 0.00% 4 0.0417 0.0417 0.00% I 5 0.0442 0.0442 0.00% 6 0.0427' O.0427 0.00% 7 0.0346 0.0346 0.00% 8 0.0204 0.0204 0.00% 9 0.0130 0.0130 0.00% 10 0.0058 0.0058 0.00% 11 0.0022 0.0022 'O.00% '! ! 12 U.0018 0.0018 'O.00% 13 'O.0010 0.0010 0.00% 14 0.0006 0.0006 0.00% j 15 'O.0020 0.0020 0.00% ' 16 0.0029 0.0029 0.00% 17 0.0030 0.0030 0.00% 18 0.0043 0.0043 0.00% ] 3 19 0.0007 N/A N/A 20 0.0051 'O.0051 0.00% 21 0.0068 0.0068 0.00% 22 0.0076 0.0076 0.004
'23- 0.0068 0.0068 0.00%
24 0.0199 0.0199 0.00% / 25 0.0241 0.0241 0.00% 26 0.0587 0.0587 0.00% 27 0.0757 0.0757 0.00% , . 28 0.0596 0.0596 0.00% ( 29 0.0008 0.0008 0.00% 30 0.0245 0.0245 0.00%- 31 0.1266 0.1266 0.00%
'32 0.2359 0.2359 0.00%
34 0.4053 0.4053 0.00% 35 0.6728 0.6729 -0.01% 36 0.8271 0.8272 -0.01% 37 0.7846 0.7847 -0.01% 38 0.6235 0.6236 -0.02% 39 0.4102 0.4103 -0.02% 40 0.1699 0.1699 0.00% 41 0.0930 0.0930 0.00% 43 0.1437 0.1437 0.00% 44 0.2592 0.2593 -0.04% {i 45 0.3408- 0.3408 0.00% 46 0.3880 0.3880 0.00% ' 47 0.4012 0.4012 0.00% 48 0.3839 0.3839 0.00% NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) i D-28 I
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~ ~ - - ~
l
.By: DEte:- Chkd: D3to' INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTICN PROBLEM NO.3, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE:ISH3-3 l
49 0.'3434 0.3434 0.00% l - 51 0.2773 0.2773 0.00% 52 0.2119 0.2119 0.00% 53 0.1106 0.1107 -0.09%
'~ '55 0.0010- 0.0010' O.00%- -
56- 0.0011 0.0011 0.00% 57 0.0008 0.0008 0.00% 58 0.0004 0.0004 0.00% 59 0.0000 0.0000 0.00% i [ I NRC DENCIDiARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) D-29
+ e.
By: Date: chkd: Date: 1 INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION - PROBLEM NO.3,. ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 3-4 NODAL DISPLACEMENT Y-TRANSLATION NODE GAPPIPE NUREG % DIFFERENCE NO. (1) (2) ( (1)-(2) ) / (2 ) *100% 9 1 0.0000 0.0000 0.00% ) 2 0.0007 0.0007 0.00% 3 0.0017 0.0017 0.00% 4- 0.0017 0.0017 0.00% 5 0.0000 0.0000 0.00% 6 -0.0076 0.0076 0.00% 7 0.0111' O.0111 0.00% 8 0.0000 0.0000 0.00% 9 0.0113 0.0113 0.00% 10 0.0248 0.0248 0.00%
.11 0.0358 0.0358 0.00%
12 0.0306 0.0306 0.00% 13 0.0162 0.0162 0.004 14 0.0000 0.0000 0.00% 15 0.0545 0.0545 0.00% 16 0.0465 0.0465 0.00% 17 0.0414 0.0414 0.00% . 18 0.0138 0.0138 0.00% ! 19 0.0173 N/A N/A 20 0.0000 0.0000 0.00% 21 0.0262 0.0262 0.00% i 22 0.0356 0.0356 0.00% 23 0.0294 0.0294 0.00% 24 0.0062 0.0062 0.00% 25 0.0000 0.0000 0.00% 26 0.0350 0.0350 0.00% 27 0.0425 0.0425 0.00% 28 0.0296 0.0296- 0.00% 29 0.0065 0.0065 .0.00% 30 0.0000 0.0000 0.00% 31 0.0259 0.0259 0.00% 32 0.0436 0.0436 0.00% 34 0.0329 0.0329 0.00% 35 0.0328 0.0328 0.00% 36 0.0130 0.0130 0.00% 37 0.0000 0.0000 0.00% 38 0.0290 0.0290 0.00% 39 0.0423 0.0423 0.00% i 40 0.0337 0.0337 0.00% l 41 0.0000 0.0000 0.00% 43 0.0140 0.0140 0.00% 44 0.0923 0.0923 0.00% 3 45 0.2307 0.2307 0.00% } 46 0.3532 0.3532 0.00% 47 0.4494 0.4494 0.00% 48 0.5140 0.5140 0.00% t NRC. BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) e D-30
1 M/By: 'r- Date:- '
;Chkd: Date: i . INDEPENDENT SUPPORT' MOTION PROBLEM NO.3, ABS COMBINATIONS,-.PAGE: ISM 3-5' 49 0.5460 0.5460 0.00%
51 0.5475 0.5475 0.00% 52- 0.5330 0.5330 0.00% 53- 0.5144. 0.5144 0.00% 55 0.3721 0.3721. 0.00% f. 56- 0.2318 022318 0.00% 57 0.1139 0.1139 0.00%- 1 58 0.0320 0.0320 0.00% 1 59 0.0000 'O.0000 0.00% L I ( } NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) J D-31
] .a -_--..-._._----_-.m
Byi. Date: Chkd: Date:
'e ' ' INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION _ PROBLEM NO.3, ABS COMBINATIONS, - PAGE: ISM 3-6 NODAL DISPLACEMENT Z-TRANSLATION NODE GAPPIPE NUREG % DIFFERENCE NO. (1) (2) ( (1)-(2) )/ (2) *100% . .
1 0.0000 0.0000 0.00% 2 0.0087 0.0087 0.00% 3 0.0257 0.0257 0.00% 4 0.0408 0.0408 0.00%
- 5 0.0442 0.0442 0.00%
6 -0.0443 0.0443 0.00% 7 3.037.8 0.0378 0.00% 8 3.0297 0.0297 0.00% 9 0.0305 0.0305 0.00% 10 0.0350 0.0350 0.00% 11 'O.0407 0.0407 0.00% 12 0.0360- 0.0360 0.00% 13 0.0226 0.0226 0.00% 14 0.0102 0.0102 0.00% 15 0.0163 0.0163 0.00% 16 0.0134 0.0134 0.00% 17 0.0114 0.0114 0.00% 18 0.0004 0.0004 0.00% 19 0.0000 N/A' N/A 20 0.0057 0.0057 0.00% 21 0.0182 0.0182 0.00% 22 -0.0205 0.0205 0.00% j; 23 0.0074 0.0074 0.00% i 24 0.0326 0.0326 0.00%' ' i 25 0.0385 0.0385 0.00% j 26 0.0863 0.0863 0.00% 27 0.1093 0.1093 0.00% 28 0.0859 0.0859 0.00% l 29 0.0006 0.0006 0.00% ' 30 0.0330 0.0330 0.00% 31 0.1766 0.1766 0.00% ! 32 0.3303 0.3304 -0.03% 1 34 0.4818 0.4819 -0.02% 35 0.6539 0.6539 0.00% ; 36 0.7618 0.7619 -0.01% 37 0.7313 0.7314 -0.01% { 38 0.6154 0.6155 -0.02% 39 0.4626 0.4626 0.00% 40 0.2901 0.2901 0.00% 41 0.1301 0.1301 0.00% 43 0.1009 0.1009 0.00% 44 0.0741 0.0741 0.00% 45 0.0724 0.0724 0.00% 46 0.0729 0.0729 0.00% 47 0.0740 0.0740 0.00% 48 0.0751 0.0751 0.00% NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) D-32 L -- _ -____--- _ _- _ ~. _ _
By: Date:. Chkd: Dato: INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.3, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 3-7 49 0.0763 0.0762 0.13% 51 0.0780 0.0780 0.00% 52' O.0678 0.0678 0.00% 53 0.0423 0.0423' O.00% 55 0.0001 0.0001 0.00% '. 56 0.0038 0.0038 0.00% 57 0.0036 0.0036 0.00% - 58 0.0015. 0.0015 0.00% 59 0.0000 0.0000 0.00% i h } NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) D-33
- Cy : - lDate: __
. Chkd:: .Date:
o x INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MDTION PROBLEM NO.3, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 3-8 NODAL DISPLACEMENT X-ROTATION
' NODE GAPPIPE NUREG % DIFFERENCE NO. (1) (2) ( (1)-(2))/ (2) *100% ,
1 ,0.0000 0.0000 0.00% 2 '0.0001- -0.0001 0.00%- 3 0.0003 0.0003 0.00% 4 0.0004 0.0004 0.00% 5 0.0005 0.0005 0.00% 6 0.0006 0.0006 0.00% 7- 0.0009 0.0009' O.00% l -. 8 .0.0012 0.0012 0.00% L 9 0.0014 0.0014 0.00% 10 0.0015 -0.0015L 0.004
, 11 0.0017 'O.0017 0.00%
12 0.0019 0.0019 0.00% 13 0.0021 0.0021 0.00% 14 0.0023 0.0023 0.00% i 15 0.0028 0.0028 0.00% ' 16 0.0032 0.0032 0.00% 17- 0.0032 0.0032 0.00% ! 18- 0.0034 0.0034 0.00% a 19 0.0024 N/A N/A 20 0.0035 0.0035 0.00% 21 0.0038 0.0038 0.00% i 22 0.0041 0.0041 0.00% ' 23 0.0044 0.0044 0.00%
.N 24 '0.0045 0.0045 0.00%- l 25 0.0046- 0.0046 0.00% i 26 0.0050 0.0050 0.00%
27 0.0056 0.0056 0.00% ; 28 0.0064. 0.0064 0.00% -l ' 29 0.0074 0.0074 0.00% 30 0.0077 0.0077 0.00% 31' O.0085 0,0085 0.00%'
- 32 0.0091 0.0091 0.00%
34 0.0076 0.0076 0.00% 35 0.0076 0.0076 0.00% - 36 0.0066 0.0066 0.00% 37 0.0065 0.0065 0.00% 38 0.0061 0.0061 0.00% 39 0.0058 0.0058 0.00% 40 0.0057 0.0057 0.00% f 41 0.0057 0.0057 0.00% 43 0.0057 0.0057 0.00% 44 0.0055 0.0055 0.00% 45 0.0051 0.0051 0.00% 46 0.0044 0.0044 0.00% 47 0.0035 0.0035 0.00% 48- 0.0026 0.0026 0.00% NRC BENCHMARK PROBlaY.S W. GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) D-34
By: Date: Chkd: Date: I INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.3, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 3-9 l . 49 0.0017 0.0017 0.00% i
'51 0.0013 0.0013 0.00%
! 52 0.0025 0.0025 0.00% 53 0.0026 0.0026 0.00% . 55 0.00% 0-0018 0.0018 - 56 0,0014 0.0014 0.00% 57 0.0009 0.0009 0.00% 58 0.0005 0.0005 0.00% 59 0.0000 0.0000 0.00% I I I , I I I I I . I I I II I NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAgPgPg 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) I o_ I _
By:- Date: Chkd: Date:' ((
. INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.3; ABS' COMBINATIONS, .PAGE: ISM 3-10 l
NODAL' DISPLACEMENT Y-ROTATION n h NODE GAPPIPE NUREG 4 DIFFERENCE NO. (1) (2) ((1)-(2) )/ (2) *100% , u- ~ 1 ~ 0.0000 0.0000 0.00% 2 0.0005- 'O.0005 0.00% 3 0.0006 0.0006 0.00%- 4 0.0004 0.0004 0.00%. 5 0.0004 0.0004 0.00% 6' 0.0005- 0.0005 0.00% 7- 0.0006" 0.0006' O.00% 8 .0.0007 0.0007. 0.00% 9 0.0007- 0.0007 0.00% ' 10 0.0007 0.0007- 0.00% 11 0.0002 0.0002 0.00% 12 0.0002 0.0002' O.00% 13 0.0004 0.0004 0.00% 14- 0.0004- 0.0004, 0.00% 15 0.0001 0.0001' O.00% 16 0.0002- 'O.0002 0.00% 17 .0.0003 0.0003 0.00% i-18 0.0003- 0.0003- 0.00% 19- 0.0003 N/A N/A g 20 0.0003 0.0003 0.00% 21 0.0002' O.0002 0.00%-
- 22 0.0001 0.0001 0.004 23 0.0005 0.0005- 0.00% .24 0.0013 0.0013 0.00% ! , u25 0.0013. 0.0013 0.00% l 26 -0.0010 0.0010 0.00%
a 27 .0.0002 .0.0002 0.00% i 28 'O.0014 0.0014 0.00%- j
- 29 - 0.0031 0.'0031 0.00%- .
30 0.0036 0.0036 0.00% 31- 0.0044 0.0044 0.00%- 32 0.0042 0.0042- 0.00% 34 0.0022 0.0022 0.00% 35 0.0014 0.0014 0.00% { 36 0.0030 0.0030 0.00% .{^ 37 0.0035 'O.0035 0.00% 38- 0.0050 0.0050 0.00% , 39 0.0062 0.0062 0.00% l 40 0.0065- 0.0065 0.00% . I 41 0.0058 0.0058 0.00% 43 0.0055 0.0055 0.00% 44 0.0033 0.0033 0.00% 45 0.0022 0.0022 0.00% 46 0.0013 0.0013 0.00% , 47 0.0010 0.0010 0.00% 48 0.0014 0.0014 0.00% I NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) { D-36 I l
.Cy:' Date: Chkd: Date:
INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.3, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 3-11 49 0.0020 0.0020 0.00% 51 0.0023 0.0023 0.00%- 52 0.0021 0.0021 0.00% 53 0.0021 0.0021 0.00% 55 0.0003 0.0003 0.00% ' 56 0.0001 0.0001 0.00% 57 0.0000 0.0000 0.00% 58 0.0001 0.0001 0.00% 59 0.0000 0.0000 0.00%' f L l NRC BENCHMARX PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) D-37
-- ------ - - - = . .- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - . - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
By: .D2to: Chkd: Data: INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.3, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 3-12 NODAL DISPLACEMENT Z-ROTATION NODE GAPPIPE NUREG % DIFFERENCE NO. (1). (2) ( (1)-(2) )/ (2 ) *100 % 1 0.0000 0.0000 0.00% 2 0.0001 0.0001 0.00% 3 0.0003 0.0003 0.00% 4 0.0004 0.0004 0.00% 5 0.0004 0.0004 0.00% 6 0.0005 0.0005 0.00% 7 0.0004 0.0004 0.00% 8 0.0004 0.0004 0.00% 9 0.0004 0.0004 0.00% 10 0.0004 0.0004 0.00% 11 0.0002 0.0002 0.00% 12 0.0002 0.0002 0.00% 13 0.0004 0.0004 0.00% 14 0.0006 0.0006 0.00% 15 0.0002 0.0002 0.00% 16 0.0005 0.0005 0.00% 17 0.0006 0.0006 0.00% 18 0.0008 0.0008 0.00% 19 0.0006 N/A N/A 20 0.0007 0.0007 0.00% 21' O.0006 0.0006 0.00% 22 0.0003 0.0003 0.00% 23 0.0004 0.0004 0.00% 24 0.0021 0.0021 0.00% 25 0.0022 0.0022 0.00% 26 0.0033 0.0033 0.00% 27 0.0042 0.0042 0.00% 28 0.0049 0.0049 0.00% , 29 0.0054 0.0054 0.00% j 30 0.0054 0.0054 0.00% - 31 0.0059 0.0059 0.00% 32 0.0067 0.0067 0.00% l 34 0.0100 0.0100 0.00% 1 35 0.0103 0.0103 0.00% 36 0.0085 0.0085 0.00% J 37 0.0084 0.0084 0.00% i 38 0.0083 0.0083 0.00% 39 0.0082 0.0082 0.00% 40 0.0081 0.0081 0.00% 41 0.0079 0.0079 0.00% f 43 0.0078 0.0078 0.00% 44 0.0078 0.0078 0.00% j l 45 0.0079 0.0079 0.00% 4 l 46 0.0079 0.0079 0.00% l 47 0.0080 0.0080 0.00% 48 0.0081 0.0081 0.00% NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, ~JNITS IN (inches, lbs) D-38 I
By: Date: Chkd: Date: INDEPENDENT. SUPPORT NOTZON PROBLEM NO.3, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 3-13 49 0.0082 0.0082 0.00%
'51 0.0084 0.0084 0.00%
52 0.0085 0.0085 0.00% 53 0.0085 0.0085 0.00% 55 0.0058 0.0058 0.00% . 56 0.0051 0.0051 0.00% 57 0.0040 0.0040 0.00% 58 0.0023 0.0023 0.00% 59 0.0000 0.0000 0.00% I I I I NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) D-39 I _-__-_ -____ _
'By:~ 'Date: ., Chkd: Dsta:
INDEPENDENT SUPPORT NOTION PROBLEM NO.3, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 3-14
SUMMARY
-OF SUPPORT FORCES / MOMENTS (1) (2) ( (1)-(2) ) / (2) *100%
. ELEMENT 'GAPPIPE NUREG % DIFFERENCE NO. FORCE MOMENT FORCE MOMENT- FORCE MOMENT, 1 5.459633 'O 5 0 9.19% 0.000 2 9479.749 0' 9479 0 0.01% 0.000 3 4251.179 0 4251 0 0.00% 0.000
- 4. 4011.183. 0 4011 0 0.00% 0.000 5 832.3217 0 832 0 0.04% 0.000 6 1827.962 0 1828 0 -0.00% 0.000 7 J 1689.149 0 1689 0 .0.01% 0.000 8 2148.599 0 . 2149 0 -0.02% 0.000 9 2466.408' O 2467 0 -0.02% 0.000 10 4061.455 0 4062 0 -0.01% 0.000 11 2536.333 -
0 2537 0 -0.03% 0.00Q 12' 4353.188 ' O 4353 0 0.00% 0.000 13 167.9237 0 168 0 .-0.05% 0.000 14 3375.557 0 3376 0 -0.01% 0.000. 15 0 19333.01 0 19332 0.00%. 0.010! 10 0 122098.8 0 122089 0.00% 0.010 17 0 18505.20., 0 18507 0.00% , ~0.010 18 3937.363 0 3937 0 0.01% 0.000; 19 6819.237 0 6819 0 .0.00% 0.0001 20 1068.737 0 1069 0 -0.02% 0.000
'21 0 121091.5 0 121079 0.00% 0.01%
22 0 36545.43 OL 36536 0.00% . 0.03%! i 23 0 765895.4 0 '765904 0.00% -0.00% 24 6866.436 0 6866 0 0.01% 0.00% 25 1276.453 0 1276 0 0.04% 0.00%) 26 492.4600 0 . 492 0 0.09% 0.00%f 27 6331.753 0 6332- 0 -0.00% 0.004 28 8415.156 0 8416 0 -0.01% '0.00%! i 4 i i ( NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) I D-40
By: Date: Chkd: Date: INDEPENDENT SUPPORT NOTIOW PROBLEM NO.3, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 3-15 ELEMENT FORCES AND MOMENTS (GAPPIPE) ELEMENT PX(I) VY(I) VZ(I) TX(I) MY(I) MZ(I) SRSS(I) NO. PX(C) VY(C) VZ(C) TX(C) MY(C) MZ(C) SRSS(C), PX(J) VY(J) VZ(J) TX(J) MY(J) MZ(J) SRSS(J)~~ 1 5222.2 167.9 1753.1 25592 122099 7826 2852.69 1 5222.2 167.9 1753.1 25592 49886 1214 1279.879 2 5203.9 149.4- 1568.3 25592 49886 1214 1279.879 2 5203.9 149.4 1568.3 25592 29109 5988 895.058 3 5167.3- 112.6 1065.4 25592 29109 5988 895.058 3 5167.7 112.6 1065.4 25592 68773 10734 1692.517 805.8 1417.9 25642 70844 12003 1741.132 I 4 4867.2 4 4867.2 805.8 1417.9 25642 69219 20723 1749.757 5 4748.2 633 1052.4 25641 69219 20726 1749.757
- 5 4748.2 633 1052.4 25641 75850 50805 2164.099
. 6. 4608.4 395.9 989.2 25634 75850 50808 2164.099 l
6 4608.4 395.9 989.2 25634 52512 68507 2054.962 1 7 4503.1 1497.8 1433.7 25669 52512 68494 2054.962 1497.8 1433.7 25669- 39500 41494 1432.696 I 7 8 8 4503.1 4437.7 4437.7 1371.1 1371.1 1718.9 1718.9 25650 25650 39500 45227 61636 41596 1432.696 28048 1348.252 37179 1818.544 9 4764.5 487.6 490.1 34179-9 4764.5 487.6 490.1 34179 47079 52989 1795.912 I. 10 4779.3 537.4 731.1 34179 47079 52989 1795.912 50074 1484.125 10 4779.3 537.4 731.1 34179 23523 23523 50074 1484.125 I 11 11 12 5060.3 5060.3 5058 731.5 731.5 1672.2 917 917 989.2 34178 34178 34179 21723 21723 49780 1466.542 49779 1464.542
.g. .
12 5058 1672.2 989.2 34179 41351 204G5 1309.928 g' 13 5050.5 1324.1 631.7 34179 41351 -20405 1309.928 13 5050.5 1324.1 631.7 34179 37767 90862 2377.266 14 ~5026.6- 549.9 444.1 34179 37767 90862 2377.266 - I 14 15 15 5026.6 4982.4 4982.4 549.9 1717.6 1717.6 444.1 768.5 768.5 34179 38461 38461 34510
.31863 16944 66278 1875.274 55014 1695.758 40679 1334.87 38459 16944 40680 1334.87 I 16 16 17 4965.6 4965.6 4944.3 1882.1 1882.1 1379.5 810.3 810.3 741.6 38459 38461 15197 15197 40845 63748 1734.156 63747 1734.156 67629 2005.393 17 4944.3 1379.5 741.6 38461 I 18 18 19 4908.9 4908.9 4868.6 1265.5 1265.5 1435 568.8 568.8 672.7 38461 38461 38459 40845 60804 60804 67629 2005.393 95865 2735.444 95865 2735.444 130859 3576.278 I 19 20 20 4868.6 4824.8 4711.3 1435 799 1311.8 672.7 1781.8 1781.8 38459 38464 85759 77153 130857 132140 77153 3576.278 68929 3924.239 4000.6 2812.9 1781.8 131162 123779 28797 4167.988 I
20 21 4018.8 1812.2 2678.1 131146 28797 123795 4167.988 21 4018.8 1812.2 2678.1 131146 19028 132280 4273.224 22 4037.8 1244.3 2517.5 131160 19028 132267 4273.224 22 4037.8 1244.3 2517.5 131160 110959 104426 4588.284 NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches,1bs) I D-41
~ I e , By: _Date: Chkd: Data: __ INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.3, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 3-16 23 4067.1 1057 2005.4 131158 110959 104428 4588.284 201323 23 4067.1- 1057 .2005.4 131158 80328 5781.942 24 4091 1259.1 1683.2 131159 201323 80327 5781.942 24 4091 1259.1 1683.2 131159 267172 52309 6896.607 25 4109.3 1622.6 1655.7 131159' 267172 52309?6896.60i' 25- 4109.3 1622.6 1655.7 131159 323059' 79778 8162.955-26 4117.1 1668.6 5040.4 131156 323059 79783 8162.955 26 4117.1. 1668.6 5040.4 131156 263015 95889 7055.418 27 4125.5 2806.1 4955.9 131119 263015 95940 7055.418 27 4125.5 2806.1 4955.9 131119 60252 43368.3438.721' 28 4130.4 2729.1 4316.9 131119 60252 43367 3438.721 28 4130.4 2729.1 4316.9 131119. 132912 146360 5414.108 < 29 2652 1950.2 5239.7 192779 123679 38427 5300.257 29 2652 1950.2 5239.7 192779 58208 25808 4633.374 30 3668 2723 1631.9 80877 235816 75215 5942.828. 30 3868 2723 1631.9 80877 256789 71187 6355.39 31 3861.9 1274.5 933.8 80855 256789 71212 6355.39 31 3861.9 1274.5 933.8 80855 245848 67122 6101.814 32 4001.1 1008.8 2370.6 80855 245848 67122 6101.814 ; 80855 154178 84552 4416.956';
- 32. 4001.1 1008.8 2370.6 33 4305.6 966.7 3662.4 80855 154178 84552 4416.956-33 4305.6 966.7 3662.4 80855 94600 96898 3599.515 ,
34 4743 1169 4323.1 80856 94600 96898 3599.515.: 34 4743 1169 4323.1 80856 252697 117048 6618.134 35 5193.2 3301.7 4074.1 77039 252697 119595 6618.134 35 5193.2 3301.7 4074.1 77039 266013 88896 6638.037 1
.36 6529.8 2977.5 2226 47198 294580 88787 7103.777 36 6529.8 2977.5 2226 47198 293609 -146244 7563.052 3
37 6826.4 2354.9 1802.1 47198 293609 146244.7563.052 i 211027 8210.605 j 37 6826.4 2354.9 1802.1 47198- 287528 38 7140.5 1490.2 1555 47198 287528 211027 8210.605 38 7140.5 1490.2 1555 47198 265042 253113 8433.059 39 7469.2 679.7 1819.4 47206 265042 253112 8433.059 I 39 7469.2 679.7 1819.4 47206- 219330 263020 7889.733 I 40 7810.6 1183.2 2455.2 47188' 219330 263023 7889.733 40 7810.6 1183.2 24!55.2 47188 149843 238034 6508.866 j 41 8207.'3 2517.9 3245.8 47195 149843 238032 6508.866 l 41 8207.3 2517.9 3245.8 47195 55574 167448 4168.046 42 6803.4 6784.1 3864.6 36693 73906 105490 3056.5 , 42 6803.4 6784.1 3864.6 36C93 113574 19375 2759.55j 43 3911.3 5935.8 1097.3 123857 78179 157004 4900.23 43 3911.3 5935.8 1097.3 123857 50198 275921 6996.829 44 3913.5 6472.7 1118.2 123850 50198 275924 6996.829 ( l 123850 21683 428942 10201.22 J l 44 3913.5 6472.7 1118.2 45 3914.9 6742.3 1137.7 123860 21683 428940 10201.22-45 3914.9 6742.3 1137.7 123860 7328 594948 13870.04 j 46 3915.6 6819.2 1145.9 123859 7328 594949 13870.04 j' 46 3915.6 6819.2 1145.8 123859 36545 765453 17716.03 47 5127.9 557.3 96.7 25592 10733 68773 1692.517 47 5096.8 792.9 96.7 25838 10930 71516 1753.231 ! 47 4941.5 1478.9 96.7 25641 12003 70844 1741.132 l NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) D-42 i
l By: Dnto: Chkd: Date: INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.3, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 3-17 48 4364.5 1941.8 1042.2 25740 27966 45227 1348.252 48 4711.7 786.9 1042.2 30999 27077 57946'1622.095 48 4737.1 615.7 1042.2 34206 37154 61636 1818.544
- 49. 5006 589.3 1310 34181 66276 34510 1875.274 49 5013.9 517.7 1310 36169 60774 33795 1788.844 3-49 4994.3 681 1310 38464 55012 31863'1695.758 50 4942.3 2638.1 3536.4 131053 132912 146419 5414.108-50 5289.5 1845.8 3536.4 197685 66509 153181 5905.898 3 50 2638.1 4942.3 3536.4 192779 73540 106608 5300.257 51 j 2690.2 3922.3 2752.5 192779 47722 42152 4633.374 51 4518.8 1484 2752.5 120739 179622 75222 5229.187 51 3922.3 2690.2 2752.5 80877 235816 75216 5942.828 52 5332.2 4145.3 3265 79987 86253 266013 6638.037 52 5944.7 3205.8 3265 62318 77478 286132 6913.143 -
52 6261.7 2531.2 3265 47198 88787 294580 7103.777 f 53 8512.8 3594.5 3689.3 47195 55575- 167448 4168.046 1 53 7981.4 4656.8 3689.3 38643 61799 144329 3690.054 , 53 6529.1 6539 3689.3 36694 73908 105488 3056.5 i 54 7247.6 3937.2 7115 36693 18929 113649 2759.55 j 54 6603.9 4941.4 7115 56866 72033 134832 3722.305 i 54 3937.2 7247.6 7115 122614 109764 137914 4900.23 j l 1 \ l 1 f f NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) > D-43
By: Dzta: Chkd: Date: INDEPENDENT SUPPORT NOTION PROBLEM NO.3, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 3-1C ELEMENT FORCES ' AND MOMENTS (NUREG) ELEMENT PX(I) VY(I) VZ(I) TX(I) 'MY(I) .MZ(I) NO. PX(C) VY(C) VZ(C) TX(C) MY(C) MZ(C) PX(J) VY(J) VZ(J) TX(J) MY(J) MZ(J) 1 1 2 2 , 3 1 3' -
- l 4 4
5 4749 632.9 1052 25640 69210 20720 5 4749 632.9 1052 25640 75850 ~50800 6 6 7 7 8 8 9 9 10 4780 537.3 731.1 34180 47070 52980 10- 4780 537.3 731.1 34180 23520 50070 ' 11 11 ,
#g . 12 12 i 13 13 14 1 14 15 4982 1717 768.5 3847'0 31860 55010 15 4982 1717 768.5 38470 16940 40680 16 16 17 ;
17 , .i 18 18 19 19 20 4825 799 1782 38470 130900 77150 20 4711 1312 1782 85770 132200 68930 1 20 4001 2813 1782 131200 123800 28800 1 21 21 j 22 ] 22' NRC BENCHMARK PROBIED rs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, 1bs) D-44 (
1 By:- Dits:_ Chkd: D ta:
-INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.3, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 3-19 23 23 I 24-24 25' .
25 26 26 2'7 27 I 28 28 29 29 30 30 31 31 1 32 32 33 33 34 34 35 5193 3302 4074 77040 252700 119600 35 5193 3302 4074 77040 266000 88890 36 36 37 37 ' 38 38 39 39 40 7811 1183 2455 47190 219300 f63000 t 40 7811 1183 2455 47190' 149800 238000 l- 41 1 41 1 42 ! 42 I 43 43 ) 44 i 44 45 3915 6742 1137 123900 21680 428900 45 3915 6742 1137 123900 7326 595000 ) 46 46 l 47 l 47 l 47 ) j NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) j D-45 l )
u By: Dzta: Chkd: Dato: INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.3, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 3-20 48-48 48 49' - 49 49 50 4942 2638 3537 131100 132900 146400 50- .5290 1846 3537 197700 66510 153200 50 2638 4942 3537 192800 73550 106600 51 51 -
~51 .:
52 52. 52 . 53 53 53 54 54 54 l .
?
i j l k l 1 , 1 1 B NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) - D-46
By: Date: Chkd: Date: _ INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.3, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 3-21 ELEMENT FORCES AND MOMENTS (% DIFFERENCE BETWEEN GAPPIPE AND NUREG) ~ (GAPPIPE - NUREG)/NUREG*100% ELEMENT PX(I) VY(I) VZ(I) TX(I) MY(I) MZ(I) NO. PX(C) VY(C) VZ(C) TX(C) MY(C) MZ(C) '
. PX(J) VY(J) VZ(J) TX(J) MY(J) MZ(J) -
M w 1 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 1 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A -- g 2 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A
, 2 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 3 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 3 N/A/ N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A I 4 5
4 N/A' N/A
-0.02%
N/A N/A 0.02% N/A N/A 0.04% N/A N/A 0.00% N/A N/A 0.01% N/A N/A 0.03% I 5 6 6
-0.02%
N/A N/A 0.02% N/A N/A 0.04% N/A N/A 0.00% N/A N/A 0.00% N/A N/A 0.01% N/A N/A {_ f 7 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A I 7 8 8 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A
'N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A I 9 9
10 N/A N/A
-0.01%
N/A N/A 0.02% N/A N/A 0.00% N/A N/A
-0.00%
N/A N/A 0.02% N/A N/A 0.02% I 10 11 11
-0.01%
N/A N/A 0.02% N/A N/A 0.00% N/A N/A
-0.00%
N/A N/A 0.010 N/A N/A 0.01% N/A N/A 12 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A I 12 13 13 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A I 14 14 15 N/A N/A 0.01% N/A N/A 0.03% N/A N/A 0.00% N/A N/A
-0.02%
N/A N/A 0.01% N/A N/A 0.01% 1 3 15 0.01% 0.03% 0.00% -0.02% 0.02% -0.00% g 16 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 16 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 17 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A I 17 18 18 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A I 19 19 20 N/A N/A
-0.00%
N/A N/A 0.00% N/A N/A
-0.01%
N/A N/A
-0.02%
N/A N/A
-0.03%
N/A N/A 0.00% 20 0.01% -0.02% -0.01% -0.01% -0.05% -0.00% 20 -0.01% -0.00% -0.01% -0.03% -0.02% -0.01% 21 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 21 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A I 22 22 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAP 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) I
By: Date: Chkd: Date: INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.3, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 3-28 23 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 23 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 24 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A
'24 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A ,
25 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 25 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 26 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 26 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 27 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 27 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A .N/A 28 N/i- N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 28 UA N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 29 N/s N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 29 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 30 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 30 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 31 N/A N/A N/A' N/A N/A N/A 31 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 32 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 32 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 33 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 33 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A , 34 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 34 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 35 0.00% -0.01% 0.00% -0.00% -0.00% -0.00% 35 0.00% -0.01% 0.00% -0.00% 0.00% 0.01% 36 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A i 36 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A j
, 37 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A j 37 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A i 38 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A l 38 N/A - N/A- N/A N/A N/A N/A 4 39 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A j 39 N/A N/A N/A N/A, N/A N/A 40 -0.01% 0.02% 0.01% -0.00% 0.01% 0.01%
. 40 -0.01% 0.02% 0.01% -0.00% 0.03% 0.01% i 1 41 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 41 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 42 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A { 42 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A t 43 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 43 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 4 l 44 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A j 44 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 45 -0.00% 0.00% 0.06% -0.03% 0.01% 0.01% , 45 -0.00% 0.00% 0.06% -0.03% 0.03% -0.01% { 46 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 4 1 46 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 47 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 47 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 47 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) D-48
By: Date: Chkd: Date: INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION. PROBLEM No.3, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 3-23 48- N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 48 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 48 N/A , N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 49 N/A N/A' N/A N/A N/A N/A . 49 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A
~
49 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 50 0.01% 0.00% -0.02% -0.04% 0.01% 0.01% 50 -0.01% -0.01% -0.02% -0.01% -0.00% -0.01% 50 0.00% 0.01% -0.02% -0.01% -0.011- 0.01% 51 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 51 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 51 N/K - N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 52 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 52 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 52 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A I 53 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 53 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 53 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 54 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A ; 54 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A . . . N/A 54 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A ' N/A l l l l } ) ) ) f ) f NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) D-49 j
, By: ' _ Date: 'Chkd: Dste:
INDEPENDENT. SUPPORT MOTION - PROBLEM NO.4, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 4-1 BENCHMARK ISM-4 ABS GAPPIPE 2.0 FINAL FREQUENCY (Hz) RESULTS . MODE GAPPIPE NUREG % DIFFERENCE NO. (1) (2) ( (1)-(2) )/ (2) *100% 1 2.6121 2.612 0.00% 2 2.9144 2.914 0.01% 3 -4.3375- 4.337 0.01% 4 4.6597 4.660 -0.01% 5 5.7338 5.734 -0.00% 6 5.8325 ~5.833 -0.01% 7 7.3587 7.359 -0.00% 8 .7.7690 .7.769 0.00% 9 9.9521 9.952 0.00% 10 10.3290 10.330 -0.01% 11 10.6790 10.680 -0.01% 12 10.9430 10.940 0.03% 13 '12.0300 12.030 0.00% 14 12.2860 12.290 -0.03% 15 13.2510 13.250 0.01% 16 13.4070 13.410 -0.02% 17 14.4290 14.430 -0.'01% 18 14.7200 14,720 0.00% 9 19 15.2530' 15.250 0.02% 20 15.5530 15.550 0.02% I 21 16.1720 16.170 0.01% , 22 16.7970 16.800 -0.02% 1 23 17.2300 17.230 0.00% 24 17.2750 17.280 -0.03% 25 17.4540 17.450 0.02% 26 18.7100 18.710 0.00% L 27 18.8980 18.900 -0.01% . 28 19.9930 19.990 0.02% f 29 '21.4600 21.460 0.00% 30 21.5230 21.520 0.01% 31 22.7360 22.740 -0.02% 32 23.2810 23.280 0.00% / 33 24.0670 24.070 -0.01% 34 24.5930 24.590 0.01% p 35 25.1170 25.120 -0.01% 1 36 26.5160 26.520 -0.02% i 37 26.9350 ~26.940 -0.02% 38 27.5090 27.510 -0.00% I 39 28.6620 28.660 0.01% 40 29.5420 29.540 0.01% 41 30.5960 30.600 -0.01% 42 31.2740 31.270 0.01% ( 43 32.2830 32.280 0.01% NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) f D-50 L
1 By: Date: Chkd: Dator INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.4, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 4-2 44 35.4830 35.480. 0.01%
- 45. 36.0220 36.020 0.01%
46 36.3940 36.390' O.01% 47 36.7690 36.770- -0.00% ~ 48 37.9990 38.000 -0.00% 49 38.4200- 38.420 0.00% 50 40.1850- 40.180 0.01% l i l ). i
)
)- I l' ) 1 ) i l NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAgP PE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, 1bs)
7
'By:- Dato: Chkd: Date:
INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.4, ABS COMBINATIU.lS,-PAGE: ISM 4-3 NODAL DISPLACEMENT X-TRANSLATION NODE GAPPIPE NUREG % DIFFERENCE NO. (1) .(2) ( (1)-(2 ) ) / (2) *100% 1 0 5 0.0001
'6- 0.0016 7 0.003 8 0.0041 9 0.0041 10 0.0099' 11 0.0131 12 0.0148 13 0.0157 14 0.0218 15 0.0209 16 0.0306 17 0.0323 0.0323 0.00%
19 0.034 0.034 0.00%
.- 20 0.05 21 0.0558 22 0.07 23 0.0777 24 0.0862 25 0.105 26 0.1094 , 27 0.1109 28 'O.1102 29 0.1068 -
31 0.1063-32 0.1015 33 0.1011 2 34 0.0987 35 0;0982 - 36 0.0983 0.0983 0.00% 37 0.0983 0.0983 0.00% 1 39 0.0982 I 40- 0.0981 0.0981 0.00% 41 0.0895 j 42 0.0884 ) 43 0.071
- 45. 0.0544 -
46 0.0369 f 47 0.0361 0.0361 0.00% 3 48 0.0326 49 -0.0326 0.0326 0.00% ( 51 0.0326 1 53 0.0326 54 0.0326 0.0326 0.00% 4 55 0.0281 I i NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs)
~
{ D-52 i
By: Date: Chkd: Date: INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.4, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 4-4
- 56. 0.0289 58 0.0673 59 0.1882 60 0.2149 0.215 -0.05% .
61 0.1738 62 0.1619 l 64 0.1358 6$ 0.1317 66 0.1648 67 0.2848 l 69 0.3394 70 0.3397 0.3397 0.00% 71 0.4721 72 0.4911 74 0.5095 76 0.5644 77 0.6618 78 0.5872 79 0.694 8Q 0.759 81 0.8279 0.828 -0.01% 82 0.8042 83 0.6883 > 84 0.2649 85 0.2641 0.2641 0.00% 86 0.1638 87 0.1659 0.166 -0.06% 89 0.169 91 0.1703 0.1703 0.00% 92 0.1201 . 93 0.0645
- 94 0 98 0.0806 99 0.0806 '
100 0.0837 0.0837 0.00% 101 0.0989 102 0.1015 103 0.1778 0.1778 0.00% 104 0.1936 105 0.1899 0.1899 0.00% 8 106 0.1865 107 0.1667 108 0.1463 0.1463 0.00% 8 110 0.1206 111 0.0439 112 0.032 8 114 115 0.1513 0.1748 0.1749 -0.06% 116 0.2002 117 0.2002 8 119 0.2002 NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) D-53 I
By: Date: Chkd: Date: INDEPENDENT SUPPORT NOTION. PROBLEM NO.4, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: IGM 4-5 121 0.2003 0.2003 0.00% 122 0.1875 123 0.1724 124 0.2247 ~
~>
125 0.2802 0.2802' O.00% 126 0.2808
.,127 0.2756 129 0.2239 130 0.2691 131 0.2873 0.2873 0.00%
132 0.2987 133 0.2987: 0.2987 0.00% 135 0.2987-137 0.2987 138 0.2987-139 0.2986 0.2987 -0.03% 140 0.2947
-141 0.2905 143 0.3179 . i 144 0.5033 145 0.5314 147 0.5695 0.5695 0.00%
148 0.5601 149 0.5491 0.5492 -0.02% 151 0.4667 152 0.3645 0.3645 0.00% 153 0.3547 154 0.357 155 0.3831 0.3832 -0.03% 156 ""0.382' i 157 0.3796 159 0.3757 160 0.3751 161 0.3751 162 0.3826 - 163 0.3776 164 0.3806 1l 165 0.3829 167 0.4159 z 168 0.522 j i 169 0.5835 171 0.5894- 0.5895 -0.02% j 172 0.6021 i 173 0.5933 174 0.5901 0.5902 -0.02% 175 0.593 j 176 0.6345 j 178 0.6777 1 179 0.6777 0.6778 -0.01% I' 180 0.6846 f i l- '181 0.6873 0.6874 -0.01% b NRC BENCKMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) 4 D-54 i L
-l -By: Dato: ,
Chkd: 'D2ta: .I JNDEFENDENT', SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.4, ABS COMBINATIONS,,PAGE ISM 4-6 I i 182 .0.6883. 183 'O.6847 0.6848 -0.01% ' 184 0.6511 185 0.6448 186 0.5935' O.5936 -0.02% I. 187 0.5644 188 0.5625
.189 0.454 3 190 0.2108 j 191 0.029 l 192 0 i
i 1 i l ). 1 l NRC BENCID4 ARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) D-55 l J'
By: 'Dsts: Chkd:' Date: INDEPENDENT SUPPORT NOTION PROBLEM No.4, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 4-7' NODAL DISPLACEMENT Y-TRANSLATION NODE GAPPIPE NUREG % DIFFERENCE NO. (1) (2) ( (1)-(2) )/ (2 ) *100% 1 0 5 0.0001 6 0.0011 7 0.0022 8 0.003 9 0.003 10 0.0075 11 0.011 12 0.0127 13 0.0137 14 0.02 15 0.02 16 0.0293 17 0.0311 0.0311 0.00% i 19 0.0329 0.0329 0.00% 20 0.0437 21 0.0437 22 0.0437 23 0.0437 24 0.0437
- 25 0.0437 26 0.0437
,j 27 0.0437 4
w 28 0.0367 29 0.0336 31 0.0332 32 0.0296- ! 33 0.0296 s 34 0.0284 ' 35 0.0287 36 0.0285 0.0285 0.00%- 37 0.0265 0.0265 0.00% 39 0.0214 40 0.0149 0.0145 0.00% 41 0.0108 1 42 0.0108 43 0.0108 j 45 0.0108 ' 46 0.0108 47 0.0108 0.0108 0.00% 48 0.0023 4 49 0.0039 0.0039 0.00% 51 0.0071 53 0.0482 1 54 0.0591 0.0591 0.00% 55 0.0749 NRC BENCEMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) i D-56 (
.I By: Dnte: Chkd: Date:
INDEPENDENT SUPPORT NOTION PROBLEM NO.4, ABS COMBINATIONS,'PAGE: ISM 4-8 i 56 0.0749 H58 0.075 59 'O.0751 60 0.0751 0.0751 0.00% 61 0.0733 - 62 0.0788 64 0.0982 0.0982 0.00% 65 0.1331-66 0.1082 67* 0.0443 69 0.0462 70 0.0463 0.0463 0.00% 71 0.0331 72 0.0325 74-0.035 76 0.0542 17 7 0.1025 78 0.1025 79 0.1195
.60 0.1544 "B1 0.1926 0.1926 0.00%
82 0.2411 83 0.2411 84 0.241 85 0.241 86 0.1511 87 0.1207 89 0.074~ 91 0.0537 0.0537 0.00% 92 0.0009 93 'O.0007 94 0 98 0.0468 99 0.0469 i 100 0.0503 0.0503 0.00% . 101 0.0563 102 0.0563 ; 103 0.0564 104 0.0645 I I 105 0.0834 . I 106 0.097 ) 107 0.1524 ). 108 . 0.1946 0.1946 0.00% , )- 110 0.2254 1, 111 0.2428 ' 112 0.2288 114 0.185 f- 115 0.1756
)
j 116 0.1185 ; 117 0.087 119 0.012 f ) a j . NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, 1bs) i D-57 J l
, % lBy: Date: Chkd: Date:
INDEPENDENT SUPPORT NOTION PROBLEM NO.4, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 4-9 121 0.101 0.101 0.00% 122 0.1372 123 0.1258 124 0.0389 ~ 125 0.0212 126 0.0223 127 0.0223 129 0.0223 130 0.0222 131 0.0222 0.0222 0.00% 132- 0.0058 133 0.0029' 135 0.0189 '
- 137- 0.0732 138 0.0678 139 0.0504 0.0504 0.00%
140 0.0421 141' O.0421 143 0.0421 144 0.0421 1 145 0.0421 147 0.0421-148 0.0125 ; 149 0.0025 0.0025 0.00% i 151 0.0979 152 0.232
- 1 153 0.259 154 0.259 155 0.259 156- 0.2557 i i
157- 0.2534
'159 0.2449 - -
160 0.2388 j 161 0.2305
- 162 0.2305 163 0.2151 4
164 0.2073 I 165 0.203 i 167 0.158 l 168 0.0537 169 0.0021 -( 171 0.0034 0.0034 0.00% 172 0.023 i 173 0.023 174 0.023 175 0.0175 176 0.0266 ( 170 0.0427 i 179 0.0427 180 0.0431 ( 181 0.0431 0.0431 0.00% l NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE-2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) { D-58 f
By: D to: - Chkd: Dato
'3- ' INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.4, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 4 182- 'O.0408 .j 183 0.0395- ! .184 0.0256 i 185 0.0233 186 0.0083 '. !
187 0.0017. ) 188 0.0013 : 189 0.0142 190 0.0176 191 0.0036'.
'192- 0,
) 1- [ NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) D-59
/- By:- Date: Chkd-- Date:
INDEPENDENT SUPPORT NOTION PROBLEM NO.4, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 4-11: NODAL' DISPLACEMENT 'Z-TRANSLATION i NODE. GAPPIPE NUREG % DIFFERENCE NO. (1) -(2) ( (1)-(2) )/ (2 ) *100% ,_.
'1 0 5 0 6 0.0003-7 0.0005 '
8- - 0.0006 9 0.0006 .q 10 0.0023 11 . 0.0052 12 0.0068 13 0.0076 14 .0.0133 15 0.0138 16 'O.0216 0.0231 0.0231 0.00% ] 19' 0.0247.
^20 0.0324 21 ' '0.0345 i 22 0.0452 23 0.0529 24 'O.0625 j '25 0.0872 26 0.0937 }; 27 0.0961 j
28 0.0982
-l 29 4 0.0919 '
31 0.0908 32 0.0797 d
-33 -0.0774 (
34 0.0698 . 35 0.0657 4
- 36. 0.0594 0.0594 0.00% !
37 0.058 39 0.08 40 0.1217 0.1217 0.00% i 41 0.1414 i 42 0.1402 43 0.1182 ( 45 0.082 i 46 0.0406 ' 47 0.0464 48 0.0231 $ 49 0.0129 0.0129 0.00% 51 0.0038 53 0.1391 54 0.1753 55 0.192 NRC' BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPPIPE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, 1bs) D-60 i
By: Date: Chkd: Date: 4 INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.4, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 4-12 56 0.1771 58 0.1308 59 0.4013
- 60 0.4635 0.4635 0.001 ,
61 0.5496 l 62 0.5564 1 64 0.574 65 0.5218 66 0.3886 l 67 0.0903 l 69 0.1374 i 70 0.1379' O.1379 0.00% ) 71 0.1877 I 72 0.1806 ; 74 0.1738 l 76 0.1544 77 0.1236 , 78 0.1183 4 79 0.1149 < 80 0.1006
'81 0.0921 0.0922 -0.11%
82 0.0991 83 0.0974 84 0.079 1 85 0.079 86 0.0539 87 0.0494 89 0.0434 91 0.0412 0.0412 0.00% 1 92 0.0241 I 93 0.0129 94 0 98 0.0537 , 99 0.0537 ' 100 0.0546 0.0546 0.00% 101 0.0649 102 0.0668 103 0.1087 104 0.1158 105 0.1141 8 106 0.1134 107 0.1134 108 0.1134 0.1134 0.00% 5 110 111 0.1134 0.1133 112 0.1132 114 0.1132 8- 115 0.1131 116 0.091 117 0.0778 119 0.0509 NRC BENCHMARK PROBLEMS Vs GAPg_gE 2.0, UNITS IN (inches, lbs) I
l ( &s0576HBy: Date: , Chkd: Date: j. L INDEPENDENT SUPPORT NOTION PROBLEM NO.4, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE:ISN4-k9 i
*121 0.038 0.038 0.00%
- 122 0.0433 123 0.:G33 124 0.0432 125- 0. tM 'u 126 0.0408 127 0.0402 129 0.0432 130 0.0867.? 'l 131 0.100.i 0.1003 0.00% . .
132 0.069 133 0.0545 135 0.0176 137 -0.2838 138 0.857 139 0.9702 0.9703 -0.01% l l 140 0.9776 141 0.9018 143 0.6247 4 144 0.0738 145 0.0271 147 0.0937 . L 148 0.1511 l'
'149 0.1683 0.1683 0.00%
151 0.3486 152 0.6063 l 153 0.6653 4 154 0.67 155 0.7101 0.7102 -0.01% i 156 0.7152 ( 157 0.7148 ' 159 0.7147 160 0.7153 1 161 0.7162 ' 162 0.7163 163 0.7185 i 164 0.7201 . I 165 0.7211 167 0.7341 ; 168 0.773 169- 0.7962 171 0.7935 0.,986 -0.01% 172 0.8166 j 173 0.822 ' 174 0.024 175 0.8069 1 176 0.7306 178 0.6486 179 0.6485 180 0.6361 I 181 0.6308 0.6308 0.00% I D-62 l
By: Date: Chkd: Date: INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.4, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 4-14 182- 0.6266'
- 183 0.6324 r.
!: 184- 'O.'6373 185 0.6335
- 186 0.'603 0.603 C.00%
187 .. 0.5799
- 188 0.578 - 189- 'O.4666 y 190 0.2167 191 0.0299 192 0
\ ). 4 ( -l ) .-- s r q F i-D-63
- i
+ By: 'Date: Chkd: Date:
INDEPENDENT' SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.4, ABS COMBINATIONS, . PAGE: ISM 4-15 i NODAL DISPLACEMENT X-ROTATION , NODE GAPPIPE NUREG % DIFFERENCE NO. (1) (2) ( (1)-(2) )/ (2) *1004 l
.1 0 l 5 ~0 l- 6 0.0001 7 0.0002' t 8 0.0003 i 9 0.0003 10 'O.0006 11 0.0006 -12. 'O.0006 13- 0.0006 14 0.0006 {
i 15 0.0006-
.16 0.0007 l 17 0.0007 0.0007 0.00%
19 0.0007 . 20- 0.001 21 0.001 22 0.0011 U- 23 0.0011 24 0.0011 25 0.001 j 26 0.001' ( 27 0.001 28 .O.0009- , z 29 0.0008 ( 31: 0.0008 ,
-32 0.0008 33 0.0008 !
34- 0.0008 35 0.0008 36 0.0007 0.0007 0.00% ; 37 0.0006 1 ' 39 0.0006 40 0.0007 0.0007 0.00% 41 0.0008 ( 42 0.0008 4 43 0.001 45 0.0013 j
'46 0.0019 1 47 0.0019 48 0.0023 .
I 49 0.0024 0.0024 0.00% 51 0.0024 53 0.003 54 0.0031 ! 55 0.0036 D-64 j k
By:- Date: Chkd: Date: INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.4, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 4-16 56 0.0036 ' 58 0.0039 50 0.0039 60 0.0038 0.0038 0.00% 61 0.0035 62 0.0035 ! 64 0.0035 65 0.0031 66 0.0029' 67 0.0026 69 0.0025 70 0.0025 0.0025 0.00% 71 0.0024
.72 0.0024 . . 74 0.0023 76 0.0023 77 0.0023 78 0.0023 .
79 0.0023 80 0.0023 81 0.0021 0.0021 0.00% 82 0.0004 83 0.0004 84 0.0006 85 0.0006 86 0.0012 87 0.0011 89 0.0011 91 0.0011 0.0011 0.00% 92 0.0006 93 0.0004 94 -0.0002 , 98 0.0011 99 0.0011 100 0.0011 0.0011 0.00% 101 0.0011 102 0.0011 l 103 0.0013 ; 104 0.0016 105 0.0017 ) 106 0.0018 > 107 0.0018 108 0.0015 0.0015 0.00% }- 110 0.001 J 111 0.0006 112 0.001 114 0.0014 115 0.0014 116 0.0013 117 0.0013 119 0.0012 , ) J
By: Date: Chkd: Date: INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.4, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 4-17 121 0.001 0.001 0.00% ~ 122 0.001 123 0.001 ; 124 0.001 125 0.0009 126 0.0008 127 0.0008 129 0.0006 130 0.0012? I 131 0.0013 0.0013 0.00% 132 0.0015 133 0.0016 135 0.0018 137 0.0025 138 0.0041 139 0.0045 0.0045 0.00% 140 0.0048 141 0.0049 143 0.0053 144 0.0045 i' 145 0.0043 147 0.004 148 0.0036 149 0.0036 0.0036 0.00% 151 0.003 152 0.0025 z 153 0.0021 j 154 0.0021 155 0.0015. 0.0015 0.00% 156 0.0006 6 157 0.0006 ' I 159 0.0005 160 0.0005 < 161 0.0005 162 0.0005 163 0.0006 164 0.0008 d 2 165 0.0008 167 0.0011 168 0.0014 ( 169 0.0013 z I 171 0.0013 0.0013 0.00% 172 0.0011 173 0.001 k 174 0.001 175 0.001 176 0.0011 i 178 0.0012 179 0.0012 180 0.0012 ( ( 181 0.0012 0.0012
- D-66 1
'l I
By: Date: Chkd: Date: ) INDEPENDENT SUPPORT NOTION PROBLEM NO.4,. ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 4-18 I 182 0.'001
- I 183 0.001 .
184 0.0009 185 0.0008 186 0.0007 0.0007 0.00%
'187 0.0007 .188 .0.0007 189 'O.0004 190 0.0001:
191 0.0001 192 0.0024 \. . } ) i p i D-67 ;
g i By: . Date: Chkd: Date: INDEPENDENT SUPPORT NOTION PROBLEM NO.4, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 4-12
' NODAL ' DISPLACEMENT. Y-ROTATION NODE GAPPIPE NUREG '% DIFFERENCE ,
NO. ,(1) (2)' ((1)-(2) )/ (2) *100% 4 1 0. ! 5 0 i 6 0.0001 7 0.0002 8 0.0003 i
- 9. 0.0003 10 0.0007 11 0.0007 12 0.0007
.13 0.0007 14- 0.0007 <
15 0.0007 16' O.0008 17 0.0008 0.0008 0.00% 19- :0.0008 ( 20 'O.0008. < 21 0.0008 22 0.0008 .; 23 0.0008
; 24' O.0009 25 0.0009 26' O.001 .
I 27 0.001 28- 0.0012
-29 0.0013
- 1 31 0.0013 (
32- 0.0013
- 33 0.0013 ;
34 0.0013 ' 35 0.0014 ' 36 0.0016 0.0016 0.00% 37 0.0017 39 0.0019 .i 40 0.002 0.002 0.00% 41 0.0022 42 0.0022 4 43 0.0024 45' O.0027
'46 0.0032 -
47 0.0033 48 0.0035 49 0.0035 0.0035 0.00% 1 51 0.0035 ' 53 0.0037 54 0.0038 0.0038 0.00% z' 55 0.004 D-68 i k
-By: Date: Chkd: Date:
INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.4, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE; ISM 4-20
-56 0.004 58- 0.0044 59 0.0055 60 0.0057 0.0057 0.00%
61 0.006 62 0.0061 64 0.0061 65 0.0066 66 0.0068' 67 0.0072 69 0.0073 70 0.0073 0.0073 0.00% 71 0.0068 72 0.0068 74 0.0068 76 0.0067
- 77. 0.0067 78 0.0067 79 0.0067 80 0.0067 81 0.0064 0.0064 0.00%
82 0.003 83 0.0027-84 0.0019 85 0.0019 86 0.0012 87 0.0012 89 0.0011 91 0.001 0.001 0.00% 92 0.0007-93 0.0005 ) 94 0.0004 . 98 0.0009 90 0.0009 100 0.0009 0.0009 0.00% 101 0.0008 102 0.0008 103 0.0007 ) 104 0.0008 105 0.0008 ). 106 0.0009 3 107 0.001 108 0.0011 0.0011 0.00% 110 0.0012 111 .0.0019
- f. 112 0.0025 114 0.003
- f. 115 0.0029 l 116 0.0026 117 0.0025 119 0.0022 D-69 ;
4 .I By: Date: Chkd: Date:
. INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.4, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 4-21 121 0.0019 0.0019 0.00%
122 0.0019 ' 123 0.002 { 124 0.0024 125 0.0024 126 0.0024 1 ' 127 0.0025 129 0.0029 130 0.0044' {
.131 0.0046 0.0046 0.00%
132 0.005 133 0.005 135 0.0052 137 0.0056 138 0.0057 139 0.0056 ( 140 0.0055 J41 0.0056 143 0.0058 144 0.007 ( 145 0.0072 147 0.0076 0.0076 0.00% 148 0.0079 149 0.0079 151 0.0076 152 0.0061 f 153 0.0047 ( 154 0.0045 155 0.0028 0.0028 0.00% .
. 156 0.0021 157 0.0021 {
159 0.0021 160 0.0021 ' i 161 0.0021 4 162 0.0021 163 0.0021 164 0.0021 < 165 0.0021 167 0.0023 168 0.0024 j 169 0.0024 1 171 0.0024 0.0024 0.00% 172 0.0024 j 173 0.0024 1 174 0.0024 175 0.0024 176 0.0023 178 0.0015 179 0.0015 180 0.0011 i 181 0.0011 0.0011 0.00% D-70 {
1 i l By: Date: Chkd: Date: I
' INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBT.EM NO.4, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 4-22 182 0.0014 .,
183 0.0016 184 0.0028
.185 0.0029 186 0.0034 0.0034 0.00%
187 0.0037 188 0.0037 189 0.0045 190 0.0044' 191 0.0021 192 -0.0014 ). l-t ) o ) )- t t D-71
E' (" J By: Date: Chkd: Date: 1 l INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.4, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 4-23 NODAL DISPLACEMENT- Z-ROTATION p ..
' NODE GAPPIPE. NUREG % DIFFERENCE 'f NO. (1) (2) ( (1)-(2) )/ (2) *100%
l 1 0 ! 5 0 6 0 7 0.0001 { 8 0.0001 9 0.0001 10 0.0002 ; 11 0.0003
. 12 0.0003 13 0.0003 14 0.0003 (
15 0.0003 16 0.0003 17 0.0003 0.0003 0.00% q 19 0.0003 j 20 0.0007 21 0.0008 22 0.0008 23 0.0008 24 0.0008 25 0.0007 - j 26 0.0006 1 27 0.0006 28 0.0002 4
~
29 31 0.0002 0.0002
]
32 0.0002 33 0.0002 I
-34 0.0002 4 35 0.0002 36 0.0002 0.0002 0.00% !
37 0.0002 j 39 0.0003 40 0.0004 41 0.0008 ! 42 0.0008 i 43 0.0008 45 -0.0006 ( 46 0.0005 t 47 0.0005 0.0005 0.00% 48 0.0009 49 0.0009 51 0.001 53 0.0011 54 0.0011 I 55 0.0011 4 D-72 J i
l I By: Date: Chkd: Date: { o INDEPENDENT SUPPORT'HOTION PROBLEM NO.4, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 4-24 56 0.0012 58 0.0013 59 0.0017 60 0.0018 0.0018 0.00% I 61 0.002 62 0.002 64' O.0021' I , 65 .0.0024 66- 0.0026 67 0.003 ) 69 0.0031 70 0.0031 0.0031 0.00% 71 0.0033 3 72 0.0033 i 74 0.0033 - 76 0.0034 77 0.0034 ) 78 0.0034 79 0.0034
- 80. 0.0034
)' 81 0.0039 0.0039 0.00% 82 0.0077 83 0.008 84 0.0082 85 0.0082 . 86 0.0055 87 0.0053 I ? 89 0.0051 ! ). 91 0.005 0.005- 0.00% 92 0.0027 > 93 0.0022 ) 94 0.0007 I 90 0.0009 99 0.0009-
'100 0.0011 0.0011 0.00%
101 0.0017 . 102 0.0018 103 0.0024 i 104 0.0026 105 0.007.7 106 0.0028 I 107 0.003 108 0.0032 110 0.0035 l I
.- 111 0.0041 112 0.0044 -]
114 0.0049 115 0.0051 0.0051 0.00% i 116. 0.0052 l 117 0.0053 119 0.0052 ) D-73 i i J
;,, ,: I By: Date:- Chkd: Date:
INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.4, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 4-25 121 0.005 122 0.0047 123. 0.0045 l 124 0.0033 125 'O.0031- 0.0031 0.00% 126 0.003 j 107 0.003 129 0.003 ( 130 0.0024' 131 0.0022 132 0.0017 133 0.0016 ; 135 0.0015 137 0.0007 138 0.001 139 0.0013 0.0013 0.00% 4 140 'O.0019 141 0.0021 143 0.0026 { 144 0.0025 l 145 0.0025 147 0.0025 148 0.0025 149 0.0026 0.0026 .O.00% 3* 151 0.0027
'152 0.0026 l 153' O.0027 (
154 0.0027 155 0.0028 < 156 0.0029 ( 157 0.0029 159 0.002!J i 160 0.0028 161 0.0028 162 0.0028 163 0.0028 164 0.0027 2 165 0.0027 167 0.C026 I 168 0.0022 l 169 0.002 171 0.002 0.002 0.00% 172 0.0018 173 0.0017 . 174 0.0017 175 0.0014 1 176 0.0012 178 0.001 179 0.001 180 0.0007 I [ l 181 0.0007 0.0007 0.00% < D-74 i (
By: Date: Chkd: Date: g i' INDEPENDENT SUPPORT HOTION PROBLEM NO.4; ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 4-26 182 0.0005 183 0.0004 - 184 0.0003 185 0.0003 } 186 0.0002 0.0002 0.00% 187 0.0002 188 0.0002 7 189 0.0001 190 0.0002 191 0.0002 ) 192 -0.2238 ) , ) 4 I ) L-7 D-75 [
l' . 1 By: Date: 'Chkd: Date:- INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.4, ABS COMBINATIONS,.PAGE: ISM 4-27
SUMMARY
OF SUPPORT FORCES / MOMENTS .. ELEMENT GAPPIPE(1) NUREG(2) 4 DIFFERENCE j NO. FORCE MOMENT FORCE- MOMENT FORCE MOMENT ( (1)-(2) )/ (2) *100% 1 3032.368. 0 3033 0 -0.02% ' O. 00%, 2 2119.294 0 2119 0 0.01%" 0. 00%; 3 1917.281 'O 1917 0 0.01% 0.00% 4 / 33.58949 0 34 0 -1.21% 0.00% 5 2018.200 0- 2018 0 0.01% 0.00%i 6 3482.024 0 3482 0 0.00% 0.00%I 7 4131.578 0 4132 0 -0.01% 0.004 8 -2969.651 0 2970 0 -0.01% 0.00%,
.9 2882.387 0 2883 0 -0.02%- 0.004' 10 1739.656 0 1740 0 -0.02% 0.00%
11 47.25870 0 47 0 0.55% 0.00% 12 6204.677 0 6205 0 -0.01% 0.00%( 13 2468.251 0 2469 0 -0.03%. 0. 00% ' 14 6489.434 0 6490 0 -
-0.01% 0.00%
15 96.56588 0 97 0 -0.45% 0.00%l 16- 4443.400 0 4444 0 -0.01% 0.00%; 17 2943.160 0 2944 0' -0.03% 0.00% 18 4207.348 0 4208 0 -0.02% 0.00% 19 822.9708 0 823 0 -0.00% 0.00%! 20 50.60014 .0 51 0 -0.78% 0.00% 21 1887.266 0 1887 0 0.01% 0.00% 22L 1752.476 0 1753 0 0.03% 0.00%j 23 914.0880 0 914 0 0.01% 0.00%i 24 1258.759 0 1259 0 -0.02% 0.00% 25 702.9718 0 703 0 -0.00% 0.00%i 26 626.4021 0 626 0 0.06% - 0.00%( 27 1363.916 0 1364 0 -0.01% 0.00% 28 2030.564 0 2031 0 -0.02% 0.00% 29 1181,,971 0 1182 0 -0.00% 0.00%i 30 86.15583 0 86 0 0.18% 0.004
'31 3971.532 0 3972 0 -0.01% 0.00% $2 1058.216 0 1058 0 0.02% 0.00%j 33 665.3549 0 665 0 0.02% 0.00%t 34 833.5613 0 834 0 -0.05% 0.00%
35 431.1024 0 431 0 0.02% 0.00%4 36 2295.608 0 2296 0 -0.02% 0.00%! < D-76
e- ' I By:_ Date: Chkd: Date: INDEPENDENT SUPPORT NOTION PROBLEM NO.4, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 4-28 l
. ELEMENT FORCES AND MOMENTS (GAPPIPE) I 4 ? - 5' ELEMENT PX(I) VY(I) VZ(I) TX(I) MY(I) MZ(I) SRSS(I)
NO. PX(C) VY(C) VZ(C) TX(C) MY(C) MY(C) SRSS (C) PX(J) VY(J) VZ(J) TX(J) MY(J) MZ(J) SRSS(J) ,
-: 1 2021.3 '2044.4' 3016.2 82253 290200 '200728 243.526 )
1 2021.3 2044.4 3016.2 82253 241758 172082 206.975 2 2021.1'. 2044.6 3016.2 82199 241775 172085 911.698 8 2 3 2021.1 2021.9 2044.6 2044.2 3016.2 3016 82199 82312 155673 155623 126325 641.508
.126313 3166.436 3 2021.9 2044.2 3016 82312 129265 114643 2796.821 4 2020 2017.9 3034.9 82114 129791 114191 2796.821
_8 4 1982.7 2054.6 3034.9 70101 131325 111853 2721.1 4 1946.9 2088.6 3034.9 59348 131157 109291 2641.346
.g' 5 5
1842.6 2119.3 3078.3 3078.3' 52641 52641 130902 130680 112970 2641.346 112866 2638.042 s 1842.6 2119.3 6 1942.9 3016 2119.3 59182 109578 130680 2638.042' 6 1866.5 3063.9 2119.3 52064 105196 112870 2379.668 l 64870 91281 96380 2159.138 8 6 7 2219.2 2218 2818.9 2119.3 2119.3 2819.9 64824 96380 91314 2159.138 7 2218 2119.3 2819.9 64824 81547 86949 1982.947 8 2220.7* 2119.3 2817.8 64906 81547 86888 420.617 8 2220.7 2119.3 2817.8 64906 74320 85318 404.348 9 2190.4 2004.9 2618.3 64841 74320 85367' 404.348
.9 2190.4 2004.9 2618.3 64841 70729 84842 397.03 84825 8 10 _ . 2191.2 10 2191.2 2004.9 2004.9 2617.7 2617.7 64862 64862 70729 50764 84795 397.03.
366.437 11 318.1 325.2 516.9' O 2636 1659 0.008 11 318.1 325.2 516.9 0 0 0 0 12 2152.1 1548.1 1819.5 65098 50764 84789 -366.824 12 2152.1 1548.1 1819.5 65098 42546- 96019 383.017 13 2152.6 1548.1 1819 65098 42546 96019 1805.685
.8 13 2152.6 1548.1 1819 65098 43082 '98697 1838.938 4 14 2153.8 1563 1817.6 65092 43082 98*/01 1838.938 14 2153.8 1563 1817.6 65092 44280 101428 1876.326 -
1563 65111 44280 101416 1876.326 l 8 15 15 2151.8 2236.7 1438.9 1819.9 1819.9 73811 27740 103311 1899.255 4 15 1563.3 2151.5 1819.9 58105 44020 87826 1667.97 : 16 1563 1678.3 2264 58093 69862 69079 1667.97
-I .16 1563 1678.3 2264 58093 55214 59018 1454.511 i 17 1372.3 1522.8 1934.7 58093 55214 59018 1454.511 !
17 1372.3 1522.8 1934.7 58093 36591 41505 1172.409 8 18 18 1372.3 1372.3 1522.8 1522.8 1934.7 1934.7 58093 58093 36591 39005 41505 1172.409-38392 1166.352 19 1549.5 1404.4 1452.6 59519 48622 58288 1409.597 i 19 1549.5 1404.4 1452.6 59519 51139 53697 1389.535 ! 8 20 1549.5 1404.4 1452.6 59519 51139 53697 1389.535 20 1549.5 1404.4 1452.6 59519 73488 60464 1640.305 21 1708.8 1117.5 994.1 59519 73488 60464 1640.305 ' 8 21 1708.8 1117.5 994.1 D-77 59519 77162 62187 1689.365 l il
-r s By: Date: Chkd: Date:
INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.4, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 4-29 22 1708.8 1117.5 994.1 59519 77162 62187 1689.365 22 1708.8 1117.5 994.1 59519 78642 63075 1710.8345 23 1708.8 804.1 1261.1 59519 66522 75749 1710.834 ( 23 1215.3 1445.5 .1261.1 44219 86812 74257 1790.143 23 804.1 1708.8 1261.1 80448 65654 70197 1831.669 , 24 804.1 1708.8 1261.1 80448 65654 70197.1831.669 24 804.1 1708.8 1261.1 80448' 71342 69225 1868.816 i 25 804.1 1768.5' 1261.1 80448 .71342 69225 1868.816 25 804.21 1768.5. 1261.1 80448 72423 67429 1863.662 ( 26 804.2 1768.5 1261.1 80439 72423 67439 395.314 , 26 804.2 1768.5 1261.1 80439 85865 52563 399.456
- 27 - 563.5- 948.5 1083.3 0 5525 4837 0.018 27 563.5 948.5 1083.3 0 0 0. OI 28 2275.3 1200.3 1491.7 75367- 85865 44288' 379.83 28- 2275.3 1200.3 1491.7 75367 93645 40831 393.526 29 2813.9 1175 1776.2 75353 93645 4'0857 1855.233 (
29 2813.9 1175 1776.2 75353 99258 41572 1919.814
. 30 2813.9 1776.2 1175 .75353., 41572 99258 1919.814 30 2623.9 2046.3 1175 82587 25499 104024 1976.459 30 2250 2451.5 1175 79567 -
33387 1083822024.514f 31 '2249.8 1175 2451.7 79562 108382 33398 2024.514 31 2249.8 1175 2451.7 79562 120793 34345 2172.514 32 2249.8 1175 1415.2 79562 120793 34345-2172.514-32 2249.8 1175 1415.2 79562 ,96129 51338 1971.842 33 '2860.2 1155 1000.9 79562 96129 51338 1971.842 33 2860.2 1155 1000.9 '79562 81989 74587 1993.871 ; 34 2860.2 1155 1000.9 79562 81989 74587 1993.871 j 34 2738.4 1419.8 1000.9 97348 56697 '73188 1963.225-34 1155 2860.2 1000.9 ' 76538 86613 49363 1836.713 , 35 1155 1000.9 2860.2. , 76538 49363 '866131836;713-{ 35 1155 1000.9 2860.2 76538 45267 87488 1822.988 36 1155 739.4 3420.3 76533 45267 87488 1822.988-36 1155 739;4 3420.3 76528 51444 91284 A896.254 < 37 1155 769.8 1212.1 7f538 51444 91284 1896.254 4 37 11$5 765.8 1212.1 76538 42360 99184 1932.647. 38 1164.8 1008.2 881.6 76538 42360 99184 1932.647 , 38 1164.8 1006.2 881.6 76538. 87225 120849 2448.432 : 39 1184.8 1050.2 754.9 76538 S7225 120849 2448.432 ' 39 1184.8 1050.2 754.9 76S?S 89712 123294 2493.234 40 1184,8 754.9 1050.2 76$38 123294 8971.2 2493.234 i 40 IV32.6 952.6 1050.2 130328 73886 95196 2593.946 J 40 754.9- 1104.8 1050.2 133084 69844 96417 2603.5 41 754.9 1184.8~ 1050.2 133084 69844 96417 2609.5 41 754.9 1184.8 1050.2 133084 68061 962582602.654f 42 754.9 2576.3 1050.2 133004 68861 96258 2602.654 42 754.9 2576.3 1050.2 133084 67855 89497 2544.844 43 754.9 2606.7 2333.5 133084 67855 89497 2544.844 43 754.9 2606.7 2333.5 133084 88343 71441 2557.164 ' 44 1006.5 2145.6 1663.3 133084 88343 71441 2557.164 44 1006.5 2145.6 1663.3 133084 103185 83937 2749.691 < 45 1006.5 2145.6 1663.3 133084 103185 83937 2749.691 1 D-78 l
By: Date: Chkd: Date:
]
INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.4, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 4-30 45 1964.7 1325.4 1663.3 171635 31762 99776 2938.131-45 2145.6 1006.5 1663.3 126747 112751- 105261 2917.518' 46 2145.6 1663.3 1006.5 126747 105261 112751 2917.518 46 2145.6 1663.3 1006.5 126747 104620 105619 2854.921 47 12145.6 1661.9 1234.3 126747 104620 105619 2854.921' 47 2145.6 1661.9 1234.3 126747 81397 72584 2443.526 48 1441.6 1270.8 904.9 126747 81397 72584 2443.526 48 1441.6 1270.8 904.9 126747 92587 61236 2462.174 49 905.2' 1270.9 728.2 126747 92587 61236 2462.174 49 905.2 1270.9 728.2 126747 96143 65$41 2514.394 50 905.2 1068.6 1001.7 126747 110037 37829 2514.394 50 780.3 1163 1001.7 159600 56970 43135 2555.436 50- 1068.6 905.2 1001.7 116599 121052 48822 2557.7 51 1068.4 905.2 1002 116605 121052 48806 2557.7 51 1068.4 905.2 1002 116605 120106 49932 2552.816 52 1068.6 920.2 1001.7 116600 120106 49945 2552.816. 52 1068.6 920.2 1001.7 116600 117988 .53486'2547.032 53 1068.6 1001.7 920.2 - 116599 53487 117988.2547.032 53 1330.2 613.1 920.2 85676 96999- 113894 2519.363 53 1002 1068.4 920.2 62121 111598 108760 2451.526 7 54 1001.6. 920.2 1068.7 62132 108760 111592 2451.526 1 54 1001.6 920.2 1068.7 62132 103085 107097 2354.414 55 1407.8 852.5 1828.4 62126 103085 107100.2354.414 55 1407.8 852.5 1828.4 62126 99450 79656 2071.585 56 1407.4 852.5 5604.6 62124 99450 79658 2071.585' 56 1407.4 852.5 5604.6 62124 49372 73836 1583.994- j 57 1786.5 839.5 5157.2 61619 49372 74257 1583.994 i )' 57 1786.5 839.5 -5157.2 61619- 49637 74236-1585.551
., 58 '1792.7 5155 839.5 62133 73807 49637 1585.551 *
- 58. 3713.6 3999.7 839.5 42412 85094 92550.1939.016 58 5155.1 1792.5 839.5 71407 63315 116914 2205.489-f.
59 5155.2 839.5 1792.2 71433 116914 63286 2205.489 59 5155.2 H39.0 1792.2 71433 118535 63839 2227.259 60 5155.1 238f 1792.4 71421 118535 63852 2227.259 60 5155.1 2385 1792.4 71421 120337 67566 2270.862 61 6016.7 2017.4 3183.5 71393 120337 67596 2270.862 61 601(.7 2017.4 3183.5 71393 126829 72402 2375.546
- 62 6016.6 2017.4 3183.5 71394 126829 72401 503.894 1 62 6016.6 2017.4 3183.5 71394 151647 89822 589.466 63 1357 2740.5 2338.3 0 53312 62483 0.203 ;
) 63 1357 2740.5 2338.3 0 0 - 0 0 L 64 523.9 1282.9 1897 158340 151647 73790 717.076 64 523.9 1282.9 1897 158340 141899 67177 691.192 65 437.9 1482.7 2275.3 158341 141899 67173 691.192 ) 158341 118066 52056 633.162 l' 65 437.9 1482.7 2275.3 l 66 437.1 1482.7 2275.4 158345 118066 52047 6830.449 ! 66 437.1 1482.7 2275.4 158345 92493 36370 6251.691 j 67 437.9 1482.7 2275.3 158343 92493 36378 6251.691 ! ) 67 1128.4 1056.8 2275.3 61067 152438 24278 5551.07 67 1482.8 437.8 2275.3 60580 125535 21797 4717.816 68 1482.7 593.6 2239.7 60630 114003 56846 4717.816
- D-79
By: Date: Chkd: Date: INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.4, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 4-8 68 1482.7 593.6 2239.7 60630 82463 52009 3839.28 69 1801.7 590 2688.9 60630 82463 52009 3839.28 69 1801.7 590 2688.9 60630 62861 .30115 3089.8 70 2137.6 744 2860 60630 62861 30115 3089.8 70 2137.6 744 2860 60630 63113 30067 3094.40 71 2137.6 2835.5 832.4 60630 40396 57056 3094.40 71 2584.3 2435.4 832.4 72448 12975 79594 3625.; 71 2835.5 2137.7 832.4 48445 50381 87300 3739.60 72 2834s8 2137.6 834.8 48554 50368 87246 3739.60 72 2834.8 2137.6 834.8 48554 46382 87463 3687.8 73 2835.6 2101.6 832.1 48441 46382 87526 3687.9 73 2835.6 2101.6 832.1 48441 40663 90936 3704.00 74 2835.8 .4206.3 831.6 48418 40663 90949 3704.00 74 2835.8 4206.3 831.6 48418 38358 74100 3225.0 75 2835 4206.5 833.1 48506 38336 74054 3225.0 75 4976.3 984.5 833.1 58611 18336 49023 2627.78 75 4206.9 2834.5 833.1 32571 58196 57735 2949.9 76 4206.3 744 . 2860 32582 '73128 37036 2949.9 76 4206.3 744, 2860 32582 130816 33446 4644.89 77 4207.3 823 2943.2 32582 130816 33446 4644.89 77 4207.3 823 2943.2 32582 274902 55454 9441.09 78 823.5 1173 995.7 49907 12934 41663 3723.28 78 823.5 1173 995.7 49907 9004 39283 3603.8 79 877.4 1173 948.5 45671 9004 44136 3603 8
?g 79 877.4 1173 948.5 45671 8993 44127 3602.60 j - 80 823.1 1173 -
996 49934 8993 39238'3602.60 37743 3539.28 80 823.1 1173 996 49934 7233 81 823.6 1173 995.6 49901 7233- 37786 3539.28 81 987.8 1038.5 995.6 35832 34228 35454 3422.4& 81 1173.1 823.5 595.6 11678 45866 31191 3183.8% l 82 1273 792.3 1020.8 11687 43786 34047 3183.89
$2 1173 792.3 1020.8 11587 42403 33593 3108.78 83 1020e5 673.9 842.5 11687 42403 33593 3108.79 i 83 1020.5 673.9 842.5 11687 29345 35359 2663.10 84 1020.5 862.8 647.6 2.1687 11877 44388 2663.1G 84 1105 751.5 647.6 7213 15429 44307 2666.28 64 862.8 3020.3 647.6 13457 11422 39500 2430.10 85 613.5 863.6 399.? 13457 11417 3D500 2470.10 85 613.5 863.6 399.2 13457 10616 31596 2010.OR 86 613.5 399.2 863.6 13457 31896 10616 2019.09 86 562.3 468.6 863.6 13949 28592 10397 1879.99 86 477 555.2 863.6 19497 22261 9909 1752.80 87 477.3 863.6 555 19482 9909 22274 1752.8@
87 477.3 863.6' 555 19482 18912 16653 1789.0@ 88 484.6 512.6 432.7 19482 18912 16653 1789.09 88 484.6 512.6 432.7 19482 25475 27154 2360.3@ 89 484.6 558.9 432.7 19482 25475 27154 2360.3@ 89 484.6 558.9 432.7 19482 34409 40462 3177.7@ 90 669.4 144.4 462 19482 34409 40462 3177.7@ 90 669.4 144.4 462 19482 48918 42143 3788.29: 91 928.7 506.7 546.3 19482 48918 42143 3788.29 D-80
By: Date: Chkd: Date: INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.4, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 4-32 . { 91 928.7' 506.7' 546.3 19482 58617 29G26 3847.991 92 928.7 506.7 1513.2 19482 58617 29626 3847.991' 92 928.7 506.7 1513.2 19482 20689 12090 1734.667 93 1412.5. 1116.6 897.1 19482 20689 12090 1734.667 93 1412.5 1116.6 897.1 19482 24946 .7841'1831.599 94 1412.5 897.1 1116.6' 19482 7841 24946 1831.599 94 877.3 1424.9 1116.6 15514 12533 29419 1996.408
- 94. 897.1 1412.5 1116.6 12466 12165- 34026 2147.088 95- 897.1 1116.6 1412.5 12466 34026- 12165 2147.088 95 897.1 1116.6 1412.5 12466- 38283 10288 2334.155
.96 897.1 1108 690.2 12466 38283 10288 2334.155.
96 -897.1 1108 690.2 12466 35941 19123- 2391.55 97 897.1 553 690.2 12466 35941 .19123 2391.55 97 897.1 553 690.2 12466 37530 25233 2634.932 98 897.1 690.2 553 12466 25233 37530 2634.932- l 98 722.1 871.7 553 26316 14922 37278 2696.638 98 '690.2 897.1 553 28903 11449 34213 2596.577 99 690.2' 553 897.1 28903 34213 11449 2596.577
- 99. 690.2 553 897.1 28903 28136' 13665 2392.168 y 100 826.8 126 434.6 28903 28136 13665 2392.168 100 826.8 126 434.6 28903 22558 11219 2153.677 101 1076.2 374.7 278.8 28903 22558 11219 2153.677-101 1076.2 374.7 278.8 2890.1 27886 -
13780 2385.008 102 ' 1076.2 374.7 278.8 28903 27886 - 13780 2385.008 102 845 764.5 278.8 30635 27068 14128 2429.473 102 374.7 1076.2 278.8 29714 28083 14005 2427.497 L 103 374.7 1076.2 278.8 29714 28083 14005 2427.497
~'
103 374.7. 1076.2 272.8 29714 27855 ~14724 2432.601 104 374.7 314.4 303.4 29714 27855 14724 '2432.601 ) 104 374.7 314.4 3 03.4 29714 29056 15770 2496.767 105 443.1 179.8 459.9 29714 29056 15770 2496.767-105 443.1 179.6 459.9 29714 28979 18266 2547.113 , 106 519 39L,1 628.1 29714, 28979 18266 2547.113 )' 106 S19 391.1 628.1 29714 33482 -19182 2735.588 107 519 620.1 391.1 - 29714 .19182 33482 2735.588 107 454.6 676 391.1 34174 9847 36168 2849.151 107 678.1 519 391.1 20538' 28602 37734 2898.998 108 628.1 519 391.1 20538 28602 37734 2898.998 10S 626a1 519 391.1 -20538 28319 38013 2901 723 l' 109 428.1 581.9 391.1 20538 28319- 38013 2901.723 j t '309 G28.1 581.9 391.1 20538 27661 35209* 2766.97 j 110 628.1 497 453.8 20538 27661 35209 2766.97 g 110 628.1 497 453.8 20538 21915 31416 2441.336 ! h 111 876.8 366.9 290.2 20538 21915 31416 2441.336 f 111 876.8 366.9 290.2 20538 27632 34745 2747.479 1 112 1195.1 455.2 403.9 20538 27632 34745 2747.479 L' 112 1195.1 455.2 403.9 20538 28657 37969 2910.371 J L 113 1195.1 455.2 403.9 20538 28657 37969 2910.371 113 951.7 854.3 403.9 24135 26271 37791 2919.082 ) 113 455.2 1195.1 403.9 29831 19383 35522 2823.839 } 114 455.2 403.9 1195.1 29831 35522 19383 2823.839 D-81
By: Date: Chkd: Date: INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.4, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE:ISH4-33 114 455.2 403.9 1195.1 29831 35063 18940 2796.124 115 455.2 355.3 594 29831 35063 189402796.124k 115 455.2 355.3 594 29831 25012 19743 2451.789' 116 491.3 487.2 323.9 29831 25012 19743 2451.789 116- 491.3 487.2 323.9 29831 *4108 54947 3897.816, i 117 538.3 551.4 677.5 29831 30108' 54947 3897.816; 117 538.3 551.4 677.5 29831 28219 62296 4190.949 118 538.3 1651.2 677.5 29831- 28219 62296 4190.949 118 538.3' 1651.2 677.5 29831 31514- 40072 3317.705i 119 538.3 1048.2 1444.5 29831' 37614 34411 3317.705 119 894 767.7 1444.5 .31684 28431 37446 3184.551
.119 1048.2 538.3 1444.5 32028 19657 38685 3029.375 120 1050.8 538.3 1442.7 31996 19657 38712 3029.375 120' 1050.8' 538.3 1442.7 31996- 16571 38645 2967.844 121 1049.2 1101.6 1443.8' 32017 16571 38628-2967.844, 121 1049.2 1101.6 '1443.8 32017 38152 20273 3020.4621 122 1242.2 1041.2 1370.5 32017 38152 20273 3020.462,'
122 1242.2 1041.2 1370.5 32017 92894
- 47336 6126.119' 123 1241.7 1041.2 1371 32015 92894 47337 6126.119j 123 1550.6' 470.8 1371 81222 68321 50514 6602.3241 123 1041.1- 1241.8 1371 105047 30508' 46286 6671.64-124 .1041.2 1539.7 1025 105047 44993 -32385 6671.64 124 1041.2 1539.7 1025 105047 42067 32713 6616.218 325 935.6 1363.1 1377.4 105047 42067 32713 6616.218.
125 935.6 1363.1 1377.4 105047 11232 53163 6643.026 126 935.6 1274.1 1460.1 105047 21381 126 1109.7 1125.8 1460.1 86206 62309 499536643.J26{ 56169 6756.428 126 1274.1 935.6 1460.1- 26036 100688 58542 6703.536 127 1273.9 935.6 1460.3 26093 100688-127 1273.9' 935.6 1460.~3 .26093 99574 585176703.536f 58492'6650.109 128 1273.9 951.6 1460.3 26693 99574 58492 6650.109 128 1273.9 951.6 1460.3 26093 97345 59915 6585.663' 129 1274,1 951.6 1460.1 26047 97345 59935 1559.618 ' 129 1274.1 951.6 1460.1 26047 96845 62412 1564.267 130 1223.2 838 1505.6 76003 96845 61395 1564.267 130 1223.2 838 1505.8 26080 98297 63248 1593.09; 131 248.1 458.7 318.5 0 1303 1877 0.024 i 131 248.1 458.7 318.5 0 0 0 0 132 1482.3 562.8 1702.5 27442 98297 63119 1596.205 132 1482.3 562.8 1702.5 27442 109857 62592 1721.028 I 133 1483.5 562.8 1701.5 27475 109857 62S77 7267.244 i 133 1483.5 562.8 1701.5 27475 116227 62623 7574.62 134 1482.2 562.8 1702.6 27442 116227 62638 3505.706: 134 1482.2 562.8 1702.6 27442 119660 62730 3583.983 135 1327.8 776.6 1307.8 27447 119660 62728 3583.983 L 135 1327.8 776.6 1307.8 27447 87276 41816 2615.076 136 1108.3 905.2 1116.8 27455 87276 41810 2615.076 l 136 1108.3 905.2 1116.8 27455 54280 14847 1627.735 137 1071.3 958.3 891.9 27455 54280 14847 1627.735 137 1071.3 958.3 891.9 27455 59207 38867 1974.693 4 138 1071.4 219.7
- Dkh*
l
By: Date: Chkd: Date:
-INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION' PROBLEM NO.4,' ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 4-34 138 1071.4 219.7 891.7 27449 60208 38661 1992.273 139 1071.2 219.7 892 27458 :60208 38655 1992.273 2 139 712.6 829.4 892 45912 52093 34767 2018.751 139 219.4 1071.2 892 65554 28346 27193 1986.685 j 140 219.7 858.4 1098.3 <5560 29883 25478 1986.685 140 219.7 858.4 1098.3 65560- '29346 23777 1966.93 141 214.3 1189.4 690.6 65560 29346 237V7 1966.93 141 214.3 1189.4 690.6 65560 29529 24731 1976.708 142 214.3 608.7 1233.4 65560 19642 33134 1976.708 142 504.1 402.9 1233.4 54767 38315 37394 1991.027 ,
142 608.7 214.3. 1233.4 21725 60505- 38679-1950.415
.143 608.7 214.3 1233.4 21726 60505 38678 1950.415 143 608.7 214.3 1233.4 21726 67630 36762 2079.267 144 611.8 246.3 1428.3 21722 67630 36764 2079.267 144 611.8 246.3 1428.3 21722' 123019 29981 3339.764 145 '846.7 -434.6 1590.3 21967 123019 29803 3339.764 145 846.7 434.6 1590.3 21967 123147 29781 3342.799 146 871.2 434.6 1577 21720 123147 29961 3342.799.
146 693.1- 683.7 1577 95926 90657 27029 3502.394 146 434.6 871.2 1577 133617 17018- 22506 3550.168 r 147' 434.6 1756.3 401.6 133615 21800- 17929'3550.168 147 434.6 1756.3 401.6 133615 22039 14822 3541.47 148 434.6 869.3 1578.1 133615 18690 18870 3541.47 148 692.2 682.2 1578.1 82512 114360 13484 3682.712-148 869.3 434.6- 1578.1 31657 150112 9309 3995.562 149 872.6 434.6 1576,3 31669 150112 9269 3995.562 149 872.6 434.6 1576.3 31669 158546 7275 4207.323 ? 150 870.7 1577.3 434.6 31662 7303 158546 4207.323 150 167872 655.6 434.6 25890 19135 167738 4440.189 150 1577.7 870 434.6 5313 32180 165754 4391.65 , 151 1575.6 434.6 873.7 5237 165754 32193 4391.65 l f 151 1575.6 5237 163550 32419 4336.583 434.6 873.7 ! 152 1638.2 564.2 1203.3 5301 163550 32409 4336.583 152 1638.2 564.2 1203.3 5301 141524 36441 3802.636 153 1638.6 1202.8 564.2 5313 36440 141524 3801.636 153 1497.2 2374.E 564.2 3542 38208 135029 3649.27 153 1336.5 1531.5 564.2 6933 39449 127604 3476.847 154 1337.6 564.2 1530.6 6904 127604 39454 3476.847 154 1337.6 SG4.2 1530.6 6904 126498 39704 3451.344 1 155 .1335.0 275.7 1532.4 6959 126498 39694 3451.344 1 155 1325.5 275.7 1532.4 6959 71041 33301 2047.667 1 156 1336.2 256 1842.1 6963 71041 33300 2047.667 i 156 1336.2 256 1842,1 6963 73138 17004 1960.'409 l g 157 1336.9 386.7 2014.5 6961 73138 17004 1960.409 l /~ 157 1336.9 386.7 2014.5 6961 221387 12281 5766.974 158 1337.5 431.1 2043.4 6963 221387 12280 5766.974 158 1337.5 431.1 2043.4 6963 297673 28302 7775.459 159 318.1 325.2 516.9 0 0 0 0 ; ) 159 318.1 325.2 516.9 0 2636 1659 0.008 160 1357 2740.5 2338.3 0 0 0 0 ; 160 1357 2740.5 g_3gy.3 0 53312 62483 0.203 b
By: Date: Chkd: Date: -l INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION-PROBLEM NO.4, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE:.ISN4-35 161 563.5 948.5 1083.3 0 0 0. 0 161 563.5 948.5 1083.3 0 5525 4837 0.018'{ 162 248.1 458.7 318.5 0 0 0 0 162 248.1 458.7 318.5 0 1303 1877 0.024
.]
1, 1 k-( 1 D-84
.0 .1 By: Date: Chkd: Date:
INDEPENDENT SUPPORT NOTION PROBLEM NO.4, ABS COID3INATIONS, PAGE: ISM 4-36 ELEMENT FORCES AND MOMENTS (NUREG) ., j ' 1 ELEMENT PX(I) VY(I) VZ(I) TX(I) MY(I) MZ(I) ; NO. PX(C) VY(C) VZ(C) TX(C) MY(C) MY(C) ! PX(J) VY(J) VZ(J) TX(J) MY(J) MZ(J) ) 1 1 t i 2 2 \ 3 j 3 j 4 .] 4 4 i 5 , 5 6 , 7 ; 7 ' 8 8 9 9 10 2191 2005 2618 64870 70740 84830 10 2191 2005 2618 64870 50770 84800 11 f 11 12 12 13 13 14 14 15 15 15 i 16 16 17 17 18 18 19 19 20 20 S 21 D-85 b
l By: Date: Chkd: Date: INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.4, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 4-37 22 , 22- -] 23
. . '23 23 24 f 24 25 804.2 1769 1261 80460 71350 69230 25 804.2' 1769 1261 80460 72430 67440- j 26 26 27 27 28 28 29 4 1
29 30 30 30 .k 31 31 32 32 .- 33 33 q-34
'34 34 35 l 35 36 36 37 '
37 38 38 39 39 40 1185 755 1050 76550 123300 89720 1 40' 1033 952.7 1050 130300 73890- 95210 i 40 755 '1185 1050 133100 69850 96430 41 . L 41 42 42 l 43 43 44 44 ! l' 45 D-86
By: Date: Chkd: Date: INDEPENDENT SUPPORT NOTION PROBLEM No.4, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 4-38 45 , 45
~
46 46 47 47 48 48 49 49 50 50 50 51 51 52
..- 52 53 53 -
53. 54 54 55 1408 852.6 1829 62130 103100 107100 55 1408 852.6 1829 62130 99460 79670 56 56 ) 57 57 58 58 )' 58 59 59 , j 60 J 60 j 61 j
- 61 J L
62 62 ) -1 63 j /. 63 ; 64 -l 64 -) f 65 65 66 66 67 67 l 67 l )f J 68 D-87 i
i By: Date: Chkd: Date: I
. INDEPENDENT SUPPORT NOTION PROBLEM NO.4, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 4-39 8
68 69 69
]
70 2138 744.1 2860 60640 62870 30120 70 2138 744.1 2860 60640 63120 30070 71 71 71
- 72 f
'72 73 73 i 74 74 75 I
75 75 76 76 i 77 \ 77 78 78 79 79 80 { 80 81 81 81 {- 3 82 82 83 83 84 84 j 84 85 613.5 863.7 399.2 13460 11420 39500
.85 613.5 863.7 399.2 13460 10620 31600 I
86 ' 86 86 87 ( 87 88 88 l 89 89 90 g 90 ; D-88 i f
Y By: Date: Chkd:- Date: INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.4, ' ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 4 91 s. 92 92 93
.93 '94-94 94 ~~
- 95
.95.
96 96 97-97-98 7 98 98' " 99 '
~99 I
100 826.8 126 434.6 28910 28140 13670 100- 826.8 126 434.6 28910 22560 11220 101 101
- 102- .
102~
.102 103
~ 103 1 , 104 ' ) 104 105 105 106 106 107 5 107 J. 107 108'- 108 li 109 109 110 110 , 111 111 F 112 i 112 113 113 113 114 D-89
- /
i By: Date: Chkd: Date: ! l.
- , INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.4, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE
- ISM 4-41.
I I l 114 115 455.3 355.2 594.1 29840 35070 18940 h I 115 455.3 355.3 594.1 29840 25010 19750 116 116 117 l{ 117 118 ' 118 '
- i l
119
'119 . 119 120 j 120 121 121 ;
122 1 122 ., 123 , 123 ( 123 124 124 125 125 , I 126 - 126 i 126 127 127 { 128-128 129 - 129 130 1223 83C.1 1506 26090 96860 61400 130 1223 838.1 1506 26090 98310 63260 131 f 131 132 132 133 1 133-134
, 134 135 135 ,
136 136 137 137 138 (! D-90 i i
)'
*By:
Date: .Chkd: Date: _ ?< , '1
. INDEPENDENT SUPPORT NOTION PROBLEM NO.4, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 4-42 138' 139 ',
139 2: 139 140 140' k -141 141 j 142 - 142 ) 142 143 143 }. '144 , 144 145- 846.8 .434.7 .1591 21970 123000- 29810 1 145 846.8 434.7 1591 21970 123200- 29780 f -146 . I 146-146 h :147 147 148 148 148 149 149 ? 150 150 .. 150 )f 151 151 152 152 153 153 153 f 154 154 155 155 I 156 156 3' 157 157. 158 158 159 159 160 1357 2741 2339 0 0 0 )' 160 1357 2741 D-hf l
- ___________________o
1.- ... r n 4 'By: Date: Chkd: Date: i INDEPENDENT SUPPORT NOTION PROBLEN NO.4, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 4-43..
. s 161 ~1 2 ,
162 l, 1 l t'
<l i
L
'l l
7 j, P
> j I
By: Date: Chkd: Date: INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.4, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 4-44
)
l ELEMENT FORCES AND MOMENTS (% DIFFERENCE BETWEEN GAPPIPE AND NUREG) ,. (GAPPIPE-NUREG)/NUREG*100%- - ELEMENT PX(I) VY(I) VZ(I) TX(I) MY(I) MZ(I) ') NO. PX(C) VY(C) VZ(C) TX(C) MY(C) MY(C)- PX(J) VY(J) VZ(J) TX(J) MY(J) MZ(J)
)
1 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 1 N/A ,' N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A ]j 2 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A ' 2 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 3 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 3 r g.i N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 4 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 4 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 4 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 5 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 5 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 6 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 6 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A ; 6 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 7 '[ N/A N/A. N/A N/A N/A N/A 7 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 8 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 8 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A . 9 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 9 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 10 0.01% -0.00% -0.01% -0.01% -0.02% -0.01% ; 10 0.01% -0.00% -0.01% -0.01% -0.01% -0.01% ! 11 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 11 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 12 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 12 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A > 13 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 13 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 14 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 14 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A f 15 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 15 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 15 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A ) 16 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 16 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 17 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 17 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 18 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 18 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A > 19 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 19 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 20 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 20 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 21 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A D-93
By: ,Date: Chkd: Date: ; INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.4, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 4-45 4 21 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A .- 22 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A
'22 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A i 23 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 23 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 23 N/A N/A N/A' N/A' .N/A N/A 24 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 24 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 25 -0.01% -0.03% 0.01% -0.01% -0.01% -0.01%
25 -0.01% -0.03% 0.01% -0.01% -0.01% -0.02% i 26 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 26 N/A- N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 27 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 27 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A- N/A I 28 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 28 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A , 29 N/A N/A' N/A N/A N/A N/A ( 29 N/A .N/A N/A N/A N/A' N/A 30 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 30 N/A N/A N/A . N/A N/A N/A q 30 N/A. N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 31 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A .N/A 31 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A' N/A 32 N/A N/A N/A N/A .N/A. N/A 32 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 33 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 33 N/A N/A .N/A N/A N/A N/A j' 34 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 34 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 34 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A . 35 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A ( 35 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 36 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 36 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A ( 37 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 37 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 38 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A q 38 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A - 39 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 39 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 40 -0.02% -0.01% 0.02% -0.02% -0.00% -0.01% { 40 -0.04% -0.01% 0.02% 0.02% -0.01% -0.01% 40 -0.01% -0.02% 0.02% -0.01% -0.01% -0.01% 41 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A ( 41 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 42 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 42 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 43 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 43 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 44 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 44 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A ( D-94 1
By: Date:- Chkd: Date: INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.4, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE:. ISM 4-46 45 N/A N/A. N/A N/A N/A N/A 45 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A - 45 N/A N/A. N/A N/A N/A N/A 46' N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 46 N/A N/A .N/A' N/A N/A N/A' 47 N/A N/A N/A N/A' N/A N/A
'47 N/A N/A N/A .N/A .N/A N/A 48 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 48 N/A # N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 49 N/A N/A- N/A N/A N/A N/A 49 N/A N/A N/A N/A. N/A N/A 50 N/A N/A. N/A N/A N/A N/A 50 N/A. N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A L;
50 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 51 N/A N/A N/A .N/A N/A N/A 51 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 52 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A [. 52 N/A N/A- N/A N/A .N/A N/A 53 N/A N/A-N/A N/A N/A N/A 53 N/A N/A 'N/A N/A N/A N/A ,. 53 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 54 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 54 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A g 55- -0.01% -0.014 -0.034 -0.014 -0.01% 0.00% 55 -0.01% -0.014 -0.034 -0.014 -0.01% -0.024
.56 N/A
- N/A N/A N/A N/A- N/A 56 N/A ~N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A
> 57 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A
- 57. N/,A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 58 N/A N/A .N/A N/A N/A N/A 58 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 58 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 59 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 59 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A
) 60 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 60 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 61 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 61 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 62 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 62 N/A N/A N/A N/A* N/A N/A 63 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A >. 63 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 64 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 64 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A > 65 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 65 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 66 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A ! 66 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A l 67 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 67 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 67 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A Ng 1 i
l
-By: Date:. Chkd: Date: . INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.4, ' ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 4 ,
68 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A ,, 68 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A .' i 69 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A' N/A 69 N/A- .N/A N/A N/A N/A- N/A
-70 -0.024 -0.01% 0.00% -0.02% -0.01% -0.02% ; .70 -0.02% -0.01% 0.00% -0.024 -0.014 -0.01% '
71 N/A- N/A- N/A N/A N/A N/A 71' N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 71 N/A P N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A' '4 72' -N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 72 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A ! -?3 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A .N/A 73 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 74 N/A N/A. N/A N/A N/A N/A 74 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 75 N/A .N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A ( 75 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A-75 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 76 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A q N/A N/A 76 N/A N/A N/A N/A 77 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 77 N/A. N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 78 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 78 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 79 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A .N/A 79 N/A. N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A i 1 80 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 80 N/A N/A ~ N/A N/A N/A N/A 81 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 81' i N/A N/A N/A N/A- N/A N/A 81 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 82 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 82 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 4 83 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 83 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A
'84 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A, (
84 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 84 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 85 0.00% -0.01% 0.00% -0.02% 0.02% 0.00% 85 0.004 -0.01% 0.00% -0.02% -0.04% -0.01% { 86 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 86 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 86 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A i 87 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 87 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 88 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 88 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 89 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 89 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 90 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 90 N/A N/A /A N/A N/A N/A i l
e
\
i By: Date: Chkd: Date: INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.4, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 4-48 1 91 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 91 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 92 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 92 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 93 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 93 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A
.8 94 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 1 94 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 94 N/A N/A I
N/A N/A N/A N/A 95 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 95 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 96 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 96 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A B 97 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 97 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 98 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A . 98 N/A N/A N/A 3 I 98 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A { J 99 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 99 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 100 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% -0.02% -0.01% -0.04% 100 0.00% 0.00% -0.00% -0.02% -0.01% .0.01% 101 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A I' 101 102 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 102 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 102 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A i 103 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 103' N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 104 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A q i 104 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 105 N/A, N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 105 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A i 106 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A i 106 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A ! 107 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 1 i
'I 107 107 108 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A i
i 108 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 109 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 109 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A ] 110 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A j 110 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A ' I 111 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 111 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A l I 112 112 113 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A l 113 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A i 113 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 'N/A D-97 8
4 ' h - t By: Date: Chkd: .Date:- j INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.4, ABS COMBINATIONS,-PAGE: ISM 4-49 i i 114 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A' 114 N/A N/A- N/A N/A N/A N/A 9 115 -0.02% 0.03% -0.02% -0.03% -0.02% 0.00% 1 ' 115 -0.02% 0.00% -0.02% -0.03% 0.01% -0.04% 116 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 116 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A j 117- N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 117 N/A N/A N/A 'N/A N/A N/A 118 N/A 1 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A , 118 N/A' N/A N/A N/A N/A ~ N/A i 119 N/A- N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 119 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 119 N/A' N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A { 120 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 120 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 121- N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A, 121 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A $ 122 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 122 N/A- N/A N/A. N/A N/A' N/A 123 N/A N/A 'N/A N/A N/A N/A 123 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A. N/A 123 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A
'124 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 124 N/A .N/A N/A N/A N/A 'N/A 125 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/7 125 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 126 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A j 126 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 126 N/A N/A N/A N/A: N/A N/A 127 N/A N/A .N/A N/A N/A N/A I 127 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 128 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 128 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 129 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A (
129 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 130 0.02% -0.01% -0.01% -0.01% -0.02% -0.01% 130 0.02% -0.01% -0.01% -0.01% -0.01% -0.02% < ' 131 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 131 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 132 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 132 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A I 133 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 133 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 134 N/A N/A N/A N/A i N/A N/A 134 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 135 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A l 135 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 136 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 136 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 137 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 137 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A f D-98 l ( l L
l I 1 By: Date: Chkd: Date: INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.4, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 4-50 138 N/A N/A N/A N/A 138 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A .. I 139 'N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 139 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 139 N/A i N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 140 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 140 N/A N/A N/A N/A 141
'N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A - N/A N/A 141 N/A / N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 142- N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 142 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A !
142 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 143 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 143 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 144 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 144 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 145 -0.01% -0.02% -0.04% -0.01% 0.024 -0.02% 145 -0.01% -0.02% -0.04% -0.01% -0.04% 0.00% . 146 'N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 146 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 146 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 147 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 147 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 148 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 148 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 148 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 149 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 149 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 150 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 150 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 150 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 151 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 151 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 152 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 152 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 153 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 153 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 153 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A ) 154 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 154 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 155 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A f 155 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 156 N/A N/A N/A N/A F/A N/A , 156 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 157 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 157 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 158 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A ) 158 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A i 159 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 159 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 160 0.00% -0.024 -0.03% N/A N/A N/A D-99 )
/
I-By: Date: Chkd: Date: INDEPENDENT SUPPORT MOTION PROBLEM NO.4, ABS COMBINATIONS, PAGE: ISM 4 160 0.00% -0.02% -0.03% N/A -0.02% -0.01%
,- l' 161 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 161 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A g.
162 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A E 162 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A I I I 4 3 t g! I il e I I I I D-1oo i II >}}