ML20245J419
| ML20245J419 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Comanche Peak  |
| Issue date: | 08/09/1989 |
| From: | Milhoan J NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION IV) |
| To: | William Cahill TEXAS UTILITIES ELECTRIC CO. (TU ELECTRIC) |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20245J424 | List: |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8908180024 | |
| Download: ML20245J419 (4) | |
Text
%epW; %Q W MP j
+
g m,
% gp!M ^
e
- y
. HUG 91989 ~I
.['
F QM'M
,I bA
- In Reply Refer.Tet Q41 LDocket
- ,50-445/0L'89-01 gs p: < ]; m
"[,
W, g
a-
<V 5.' 4 TU Electric;.
j@k y ATTN:
W. J. Cahill, Jr., Executive Vice President, Nuclear-Skyway-Tower
~
, c400 North Olive, L.B. 81,
- Dallas, Texas 75201.
t IGentlemen:-
p y
n
SUBJECT:
~ REQUALIFICATION EXAMINATION REPORT, COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC f
STATION (CPSES)-
k
+
WH - During the week of JulyL3,1989,~ NRC adininistered requalification written, walk-through, and simulator examinations to 12 TU Electric employees currently.
' licensed to operate your CPSES Unit 1 facility. At.the conclusion of the examinations,;the results of the examinations and audit were discussed with t
,^
a the facility staff.~ All crews were evaluated to be satisfactory. All operators
- passed all phases of the' examination;and have been sent individual notification fof this' fact.. Overall performance during the audit met the requirements of s
6 :s
- NUREG 1021, " Operator l Licensing Examiner Standards," Section 601- (ES-601) for y
nthe. facility l licensed'operatorrequalificationprogramtobedeclared-m-
- satisfactory.A hThelPSESl'icensedoperatorrequalificationprogrammettherequirementsfora j
l
~
- satisfactory evaluation, and demonstrated substantially better performance than-
' had been observed on prior requalification program audits. However, we are concerned about the' number of problems-noted in your test development. These W
problems occurred-frequently throughout the facility generated Job Performance
. Measures and written examination items. Your data bank contained items which we.believe would have placed'an' unfair-burden on examinees because of their
. construction if these items had been used. We recommend that you conduct an
$A '
' extensive review and. upgrade of:the examination material data base before the C,.j anext requalification examination and audit. These problems were discussed with
. your staff.
Crew performance in' the simulator, while judged to be satisfactory, revealed significant weaknesses in cowand and communications. Communications among crew members were frequently m sn ended because the recipient of a message i.or order did not confirm or acknowledge receipt to the sender. Also, during
,,M,'~
?several evolutions, there did not appear to be a single individual in s"'
lunambiguouscontrolofcrewactions.
RIV:0LS*
C:0LS*
AD:DRS*
- DRP
'JWhittemore/cjg JPellet JJaudon JLMilhoan
- 4
~ "/ /89l
/ /89
/ /89 g/g /89
[W'
- previously concurred I )
s l
890so9 g_
V 05000445 PNU m9 7
N..
NLe -
8 gy mmy rm
- r;-
n '
n g
.-q h*
r $$k. c r
s.
- -a,.-
a sgp T
3, 1t t.,
e g.,.7 q[
, (TUTElectric1 -
gf 1
P s ShouldLyou'have any. questions concerning this report, please contact us.
j f
' Sincerely.
OdginalSigned By:
q[$e.
Thomas P.Gwynn I
a
- James L. Milhoan, Director-Division of. Reactor Projects DR
Enclosure:
- # Examination Report.50-445/0L 89-01 N
L_
- ccw/ enclosure
- '
'TU Electric' ATTN:
Roger Di Walker, Manager.
- Nuclear Licensing Skyway. Tower 400* North-Olive Stre'et L.B; 81
- Dallas,)TX'75201
'Juanita Ellis President --CASE 3 E
1426 South Polk Street
. Dallas 1TX4 75224 c
I GDS: Associates, Inc.
?
' Suite 720
,j 1850 Parkway Place.
' f, Marietta, GA 30067-8237.'
Susan M. Theisen Assistant Attorney General' O'
Environmental Protection Division P.O. Box 12548 Capitol Station Austin,5TX 78711-1548-(Christic' Institute ATTN: Lanny A. Sinkin
' 1324 N. Capitol. Street Washington, DC 20002
. Billie Pirner Garde -Esq.
Government Accountability, Project Midwest Office 00 '
.104 East Wisconsin Avenue Appleton, WI 54911 g
s
'. c-y 7
,][
wmcrw
+
Mi - '
f y,
3 a o y.
+
"g ysu V-; j v ;-
g, ; c ',.
g, h;i,if,, [qf E
- M
)'
& " y.y i.
&jfl;;$ll)l?
n-
'g,,"+
.TU. Electric-
~
X
- -3 gt
~
@ @z.
- 6 u;
. Fulbrigh't!.h Jaworski ATTN: ' Joseph-F.L Fulbrighte s
1301 McKinney Street' J V
Houston, TX:-77010:
a'
.TU' Electric 4-
.p
. Bethesda. Licensingi.
P '- V-3 Metro Center, Suite 610 :
L Bethesda',' MD : :. 20814 -
s
- Senior Citizens Alliance of.Tarrant
?
. CountybInc.
' ATTN: ; George: A. Parker, Chairitan 4 Public Utility Consnittee
.g 6048' Wonder Drive 2
L
" Fort Worth,'TX276133, q w_.;,-
Heron', Burchette..Ruckert, & Rothwell-
/ ATTN: William A.,Burchette Esq.
4 Counsel:for. Tex-La Electric-I 1025 Thomas Jefferson St.. N.W.
,t
' Washington,'DC,20007; a
Yt E.:F. 0ttney P.O.:, Box : 1777-
. Glen Rose, TX676043 u.
" Newman &:Holtzinger,:P.C.
E, v
ATTN:- Jack R.iNewman, Esq.'
,1615 L. Street; N.W.
1 Washington, D.C. "20036-o '
g TV Electric J c-ATTN:
J. McMahon,. Director
- Nuclear Training 7
~
T Comanche Peak Station P10.. Box.2300 Glen Rose TX 767431
.g bec to,DMB;(IE42)
'bec dist. by RIV:
CPPD:0SP Reading (MS: 7-H-17)
.ff,'
RIV Files Local PDR 4 i ADSP Peading (MS: 7-D-24)
Site Reading MIS System, RIV NRC-PDR C. Grines, OSP DRP.
J. Dyer, NRR LFMB Facilities Section P. McKee,.OSP J. Lyons. OSP t
k Z. _... __. U 2_..
.TU Electric -
J. Wilson, ADSP, NRR M. Malloy, OSP J. Moore 0GC-WF--
J. Gilliland M. Fields, OSP E. Jordan B. Grimes, NRR-WF B. Hayes R. Martin RPB-DRSS D. Crutchficid, OSP R. Warnick, CP J.:Wiebe, CP H. Livermore, CP
-CPPD-LA, OSP J. Whittemore J. Pellet J. Whittemore Reading File E. Haycraft DRS File j
1 l
___ __