ML20237A857
| ML20237A857 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Comanche Peak  |
| Issue date: | 08/10/1998 |
| From: | Woodlan D TEXAS UTILITIES ELECTRIC CO. (TU ELECTRIC) |
| To: | NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned) |
| References | |
| TXX-98184, NUDOCS 9808170186 | |
| Download: ML20237A857 (15) | |
Text
I i
==
- "" 7 O.-
.=
Log # TXX-98184 Z
C File # 10305 7UELECTRIC Ref. # 10CFR55.45(b)(5)
August 10, 1998 C. Lance Terry Senior Vice President
& PrincipalNuclear Officer U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission l
Attn: Director of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Washington, DC 20555
SUBJECT:
COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION (CPSES)
DOCKET NOS. 50-445 AND 50-446 TRANSMITTAL 0F THE CPSES 4-YEAR CONTROL ROOM SIMULATOR CERTIFICATION REPORT REF:
- 1) TV Electric Letter logged TXX 92166. from William J. Cahill Jr. to NRC dated April 1. 1992 i
- 2) TU Electric letter logged TXX-94214 from William J. Cahill, Jr. to NRC dated August 8. 1994 Gentlemen:
In accordance with the provisions of 10CFR55.45(b)(5)(ii) and (b)(5)(vi).
TU Electric herein submits the four year Simulator Certification Report. As explained in Reference 1 above. this submittal represents the combined four-year certification activities for both Units 1 and 2.
TV Electric's last submittal of this. required four-year report was per Reference 2.
There are no uncorrected performance test failures nor have the performance tests previously administered changed since the initial certification submittal. However, modifications to future malfunction tests as submitted with the enclosed NRC Form 474 " Simulation Facility Certification" will be 1
l in effect during the next four-year period, with approximately 25 percent of l
the performance tests administered per year. The simulator certification l
testing schedule remains the same as in Reference 2 except as noted in the 1
enclosed Four Year Halfunctior Test Schedule.
If you have any questions on this submitta'I please contact Mr. Steve Falley i
[
at (254) 897 5343.
I
\\
l i
9008170186 980810 Q
PDR ADOCK 05000445-n, \\
P PDR Or i
COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION P.O.E m 1002 Glen Rose Tesas 76043 1002 l
u_ _ _ _
)
I
- l..
TXX 98184-Page 2 of 2 This communication contains no new licensing basis commitments regarding CPSES Units 1 and 2.
Sincerely, i
l i.
C. L. Terr By:
D. R. Woodlan l
Docket Licensing Manager l
l CLW/grj Enclosure - NRC Form 474 & Simulator Certification Test Schedule
(
c-Mr. E. W. Merschoff. Region IV (w/o encl)
Mr. John Pellet. Region IV (w/ encl)
Mr. J. I. Tapia. Region IV (w/o encl)
Mr. T. J. Polich. NRR (w/o encl)
Document Control Desk (w/ encl)
Resident Inspectors. CPSES (w/o encl) i l-l I
.s.
n
..e i
J
",,,0W,3 .'*." "..,i,,,, T"""".' t E"*ar, '.f ".,,s.,e SIMULATION FACILITY CERTIFICATION b sus,s t vueWengi.sm OC am fac nisy not a. ems
.uf Oudge aps ans a see-seas ces a.s a.m.e us m s eussegun W Wenn.- isomme 4 essemy. 3.suergey e
a aseur.
T>ue 9.un e e Be ese our m.nl reestdanen (W se uft.us our cry as ge.a stuulshm W pere.munque ensig p.n. map star puess me.i af e6.s Prow.s wie summseg eia use.id.uusi sie appsuun.o een to see.as suusen tur mesenL m.n e me T e4JesgER PAcattTV 30-445 6 44f Comanche Peak Steam Flectric Station Uni n-1 x,,
om ucs set TU Electric g _, p g v=.
, m.e 1, fles 304.fi.nas femky hensees a 1.sg 8 6 4 em s.ely of a pWede ined N WI. m to see. unius. W 10 CPR N d5.
I
- 2. r -- _ __.. sweassen 9. OsRC s.as. h emi.E.tes ut8i,0 CPR M 40(b)
- 3. Tvus earn.sen tus.py s. outs Was paan.s e.mi d h Afegis40s H.9ge er nagginf5 3.s.1M an erut sed by 084C stepsma.y h 1.14e l
e
.ar excernces. sw --
- m.a
,castetwese[ }.nd ner.ssa :
e.,
l anus
_- _ iase LocAnon w samuritNG PACUfy, P.O. Box 1002, Hwy. 56 - 5 miles north of Glen Rose, Glen Rose, TX 76043-1147 l
l suvufoe raccrv Pe'E'o***sce Test Assimaets ATTAcuse.,*,,
n w.e.,
me,.m as mmmm.;
me,,no., o,,eara nuce.ww co wm = _ _,
s.-
e n.
l Not Applicable
/
smuutica sAcury Psapusmaames fus?.e ecesouis Arracneo er
.-ears
- y w wasa e e
,.ar er s a,,,,
y commune.ig usri o al.a W 8te c.Eueses*J DEI CAf DCae 08 Ptrurv=====A0Cs rs.
To se CopeuCTBC. (Aftuse _ T _ _,ggme er assess.y.uf af.egfy fue m _ __ __ _. e.g __
_-)
See Attached Test Schedule
/
esponmance TestusG PLAN CDMNGE. (Fer.9 n.seum.W e Aantmeme met.t pd. 4.Sud M e AmeW suGEEAA.L)
,_o,_
z.
See Attached Changes to the Four Year Malfunction Test Plan asesntwicanon passee nem.smenn amen
=se w.ent,.d m.evocpu ssamejrsw passa semaer sas=* as a*.ss.y **==* 8* ama ma==*= *ea. s.o 4
Not App 1icable w me,i n.
.i e nt senare _ x.
, e..a,
=> *e un iesnsr ces, pene,
,.,,y em ei. c1- _ r ca.
d
=
ans an.st asus rue, _ %_.- --, r, we bi mte,
Vice President of Nuclear Operations er?91
..,... m -
__s 97 DEUWEwy se pasteges gess yueSTE plaff potutDI ess e DY MA4, A00stssssD TO DelsC10st, 058405Op ***'.a man AS40 TENT suMRAATIOff To TIE leRC OPPICE At 199EfIWCItWE.Lt Pus US. asuctamm segutAtegry -
20EulWNJ. 410 WapesSYWI, DC m l
_U
Chanaes to the Four Year Malfunction Test Plan 1)
Malfunctions have been added to a new catagory labeled " test pr/or to use".
These malfunctions are seldom if ever used and do not reside in the CPSES Requal or initial programs. Any malfunction labeled as " test prior to use"will not be accessible from the instructor station, but can be seen in the Malfunction Cause and Effects book. If a malfunction is labeled as " test prior to use", the instructor building the scenario must generate a Simulator Action Request to have the malfunction formally tested prior to use by any of the classes. Once a malfunction is tested in this manner, the test sheets will be added to the Annual Test Report and vaulted as part of the Annual Test Program documentation. A significant portion of the malfunctions (83 of 143) moved to this catagory were RM, radiation monitoring, and simply caused a detector to fail to a specified severity with the remaining malfunctions (60 of 143) from various system catagories not regularly used for training. These changes do not violate the requirements of ANSI /ANS-3.5,1985 standard, section 3.1.2 Plant Malfunctions.
l 2)
Three malfunctions numbers have been deleted from the annual test program.
CV25 - BCMS failure, the BCMS system is no longer in use at CPSES.
FWO2 - Feedwater system leaks, this malfunction has been split into FW31A-D and FW32A-D to allow better training usage. Instead of simply having a feedwater leak inside containment, the instructor may now choose a location as well.
IA05 - Service Air Compressor trip, the service air compressor at CPSES i
I was removed and a dual unit service air compre,ssor installed. The new unit is only used between the hours of 07:00 and 15:30 Monday through Friday and this malfunction was deemed unnecessary.
3)
CPSES currently has 32 malfunctions "In Development". These malfunctions numbers have been selected as place keeping aides for the simulator group and will be implemented when our new containment, feedwater and heater drain models are completed.
l j
FOUR YEAR MALFUNCTION TEST SCHEDULE MALF.#
YEAR 1 YEAR 2 YEAR 3 YEAR 4 test prior to use AN01 X
AN02 X
ANO3 X
AN04 X
ANOS X
CC01 X
CCO2 X
CC03 X
CH01 X
CH02 X
CH03 X
l CH05 CH12 X
CR01 X
CR02 CR03 CS01 X
CS02 X
CS03 X
CS04 X
CS05 X
CS06 X
CS07 X
CS08 X
CSO9 X
CV01 X
CV02 X
CV03 X
CV04 X
CV05 X
CV06 X
CV07 X
CV08 X
CV09 X
CV13 X
CV14 X
l CV15 X
CV16 X
CV17 X
CV18 X
CV19 X
CV20 X
1
FOUR YEAR MALFUNCTION TEST SCHEDULE MALF.#
YEAR 1 YEAR 2 YEAR 3 YEAR 4 test prior to use CV21 X
CV22 X
CV23 X
CV24 X
CV26 X
CV27 X
CV28 X
CV29 X
CWO1 X
CWO2 X
CWO3 X
CWO4 X
ED01 X
ED02 X
{
ED03 X
l ED04A X
j ED04B X
J ED04C X
ED04D X
ED04F X
ED04G X
)
ED04H X
ED041 X
ED05A X
ED05B X
ED05C X
ED05D X
ED05E X
ED05F X
ED05G ED06A X
ED06B X
ED06C X
ED06D X
ED06E X
ED06F X
l ED06G X
l ED07A X
ED07B X
ED07C X
ED07D X
ED07E X
2
(
FOUR YEAR MALFUNCTION TEST SCHEDULE MALF.#
YEAR 1 YEAR 2 YEAR 3 YEAR 4 test prior to use ED07F X
ED07G ED07H ED071 X
ED07J ED07K EF07L ED08A X
ED08B X
ED08C X
ED08D X
ED08E X
ED08F X
ED08G X
ED08H X
ED081 X
ED08J X
ED08K X
ED08L X
ED08M X
ED08N X
ED080 X
ED08P X
ED09 X
l ED10 X
j ED11 X
ED12 X
i ED13 X
ED14 l
ED15 ED16 ED17 ED18 ED19 EG01 X
EG02 X
l EG03 X
EG04 X
EG05 X
EG06 X
EG07 X
EG08 X
3
FOUR YEAR MALFUNCTION TEST SCHEDULE MALF.#
YEAR 1 YEAR 2 YEAR 3 YEAR 4 test prior to use EG09 X
EG10 X
EG11 X
EG12 X
EG13 X
EN01 X
FWO1 X
FWO2 X
FWO3 X
FWO4 X
FWOS X
FWO6 X
FWO7 X
FWO8 X
l FWO9 X
1 FW10A X
FW10B X
FW10C X
FW10D X
FW11 A X
FW11B X
FW11C X
FW11D X
FW12A X
FW12B X
FW12C X
FW12D X
FW14A X
FW14B X
FW15 X
FW16 X
FW17 X
FW18 X
FW19 X
FW20 X
FW21 X
FW22 X
FW23 X
l FW24 X
I FW25 X
FW31 X
FW32 X
l 4
i l.
1 l
FOUR YEAR MALFUNCTION TEST SCHEDULE l
i MALF.#
YEAR 1 YEAR 2 YEAR 3 YEAR 4 test prior to use FW33 X
FW34 X
FW35 X
FW36 X
FW37 X
j FW38 X
iA01 X
IA02 X
IA03 X
l IA04 X
IA06 X
i LP01 X
l LP02 X
LP03 X
i MS01 X
l MS02 X
MS03 X
MSO4 X
MS05 X
MS06 X
MS07 X
MS08 X
MSO9 X
MS10A1/B1/C1/D1 X
MS10A2/B2/C2/D2 X
MS10A3/B3/C3/D3 X
MS10A4/B4/C4/D4 X
l MS10A5/B5/C5/D5 X
l MS11 X
MS12 X
MS13 X
N101 X
N102 X
N103 X
NIO4 X
NIOS X
N106 X
l N107 X
N108 N109 X
N110 X
N111 X
r 5
l
r l.
1 l
FOUR YEAR MALFUNCTION TEST SCHEDULE MALF.#
YEAR 1 YEAR 2 YEAR 3 YEAR 4 test prior to use N112 X
N113 X
N114 X
PC01 X
PCO2 X
PC03 X
PC04 X
PCOS X
PC06 X
PC07 X
RC01 X
RC02 X
RCO3 X
RC04 X
RC05 X
RC06 X
RC07 RC08A1/B1/C1h)1 X
i RC08A2/B2/C2/D2 X
{
RC09A1/B1/C1/D1 X
{
RC0(;A2/B2/C2/D2 X
RC10 X
RC11 X
RC12 X
RC13 RC14 RC15 X
RC16 RC17 RC18 RC19 RC20 RC21 RC22 l
RC23 RD01 X
RD02 X
RD03 RD04 X
RDOS X
RD06 X
RD07 X
l 6
._____a
FOUR YEAR MALFUNCTION TEST SCHEDULE MALF.#
YEAR 1 YEAR 2 YEAR 3 YEAR 4 test prior to use RD08 X
RD09 X
RD10 X
RD11 X
RD12 X
RD13 X
RD14 X
RH01 X
RH02 X
RH03 X
RH04 X
RHOS X
l RH06 X
l RH07 i
RH08 RM01A X
RM01B X
RM02A1 X
RM02A2 X
RM02A3 X
RM02A4 X
RM02A5 X
RM02A6 X
RM02A7 X
RM02A8 X
RM02A9 X
RM02B1 X
RM02B2 X
RM02B3 X
RM02B4 X
RM02B5 X
RM0286 X
RM02B7 X
RM02C1 X
RM02C2 X
RM02C3 X
RM02C4 X
RM02C5 X
RM02C6 X
RM02C7 X
RM02C9 X
RM02C10 X
l 7
l L______________.-------------
9 FOUR YEAR MALFUNCTION TEST SCHEDULE MALF.#
YEAR 1 YEAR 2 YEAR 3 YEAR 4 test prior to use RM02C11 X
RM02D1 X
RM02D2 X
RM02D3 X
RM02D4 X
j RM02D5 X
j RM02D6 X
l RM02E2 X
l
)
RM02F1 X
RM03A1 X
1 RM03A2 X
RM03A3 X
l l
RM03A4 X
RM03A5 X
RM03A6 X
RM03A7 X
RM03A8 X
RM03A9 X
RM03A10 X
l RM03A11 X
l RM03A12 X
RM03A13 X
RM03A14 X
RM03B1 X
RM03B2 X
l RM03B3 X
l RM03C1 X
RM03C2 X
RM03C3 X
RM03C4 X
RM03D X
RM03E X
RM03F X
RM03G X
RM03Q X
RM03R X
RM03U1 X
RM03U2 X
RM03U3 X
RM03U4 X
RM03V X
f RM03H X
8 L-
FOUR YEAR MALFUNCTION TEST SCHEDULE MALF.#
YEAR 1 YEhR 2 YEAR 3 YEAR 4 test prior to use RM031 X
RM03J1 X
RM03J2 X
l RM03J3 X
l RM03K1 X
l RM03K2 X
l RM03L X
l RM03M X
j RM03N X
RM030 X
RMO3P3 X
RM03S X
RM03T X
RM04 X
RP01 X
RP02 X
RP03 X
RPO4 X
RP05 X
RP06 X
RP07 X
RPOS X
RP09 X
1 RP10 X
I RP11 X
)
RP12 X
1 RP13 X
l RP14 X
j RP15 X
RP16 X
RP17 X
RP18 X
RP19 X
RP20 X
RP21 X
RP22 X
RP23 X
RP24 X
1 j
l RX01 X
l RX02 X
RXO3 X
RX04 X
9
FOUR YEAR MALFUNCTION TEST SCHEDULE MALF.#
YEAR 1 YEAR 2 YEAR 3 YEAR 4 test prior to use RX05 X
RX06 X
RXO7 X
RX08 X
RXO9 X
RX10 X
RX11 X
RX12 X
RX13 X
RX14 X
RX15 X
RX16 X
RX17 X
RX18 X
RX19 X
SG01 X
SG02 X
S10 1 X
S10 2 X
S10 3 X
S104 X
SWO1 X
SWO2 X
SWO3 X
TC01 X
TC02 X
TC03 X
TC04 X
TC05 X
TC06 X
TC07 X
TC08 X
TC09 X
TC10 X
TC11 X
TC12 X
TP01 X
TP02 X
TP03 X
TPO4 X
TP05 X
X TP06 X
10 L
1 l
)
FOUR YEAR MALFUNCTION TEST SCHEDULE i
l MALF.#
YEAR 1 YEAR 2 YEAR 3 YEAR 4 testprior to use l
l TUO1 X
X TUO2 X
X TUO4 X
X TUO5 X
X TUO6 X
X l
WD01 X
X Malfunction Test Distribution Totalneeding testing prior to Year 1 65 25%
use J
Year 2 70 26.9 %
Year 3 64 24.6 %
143 Year 4 61 23.5 %
TotalIn Use 260 100 %
in Development Deleted #'s CC04 FW26 CH13 MS15 CH04 FW27 CH14 MS16 CV25 CH06 FW28 CH15 MS17 FWO2 CH07 FW29 CH16 S10 5 lA05 CH08 FW30 CH17 SS01 l
CH09 IA07 CS10 SS02 l
CH10 IA08 CV30 SS03 CH11 MS14 CV31 WD02 Totalin Dev.
32 l
l l
11 i-
_ _ _ _