ML20236N736
| ML20236N736 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Beaver Valley |
| Issue date: | 07/31/1987 |
| From: | Carey J DUQUESNE LIGHT CO. |
| To: | NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION & RESOURCES MANAGEMENT (ARM) |
| References | |
| RTR-NUREG-1057 2NRC-7-188, NUDOCS 8708120083 | |
| Download: ML20236N736 (10) | |
Text
.
--s'
}Vg,,
Tf A
'2NRC-7-188 Beaver Valley No. 2 Unit Project Organization S.E.G. Building Telecopy 64 Ex L 100 P.O. Box 328 July 31,.1987.
Shippingport, PA 15077 United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission ATTN:
Document Control Desk Washington, DC 20555 I
1
SUBJECT:
Beaver Valley Power Station Unit No. 2 Docket No. 50-412 Duquesne Light Company Comments on the Safety Evaluation Report (NUREG-1057)
Gentlemen:
Duquesne Light Company has reviewed SER Supplement
- 5.
provides several comments 'which we believe are appropriate for your consider-ation. provides a DLC comment on the original SER.
We will con-
- tinue to work with the NRC staff to appropriately resolve these comments.
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY l
By Sr. Vice President (f
%Y. WCarey JD0/1,jr NR/JD0/SER/S5
. Attachment AR/NAR cc: Mr. P. Tam, Project Manager
- w/ attachment Mr. J. Beall, NRC Sr. Resident Inspector
- w/ attachment j
Mr. L. Prividy, NRC Resident Inspector
- w/ attachment Mr. W. T. Russell, NRC Region I Administrator
- w/ attachment INP0 Records Center
- w/ attachment i
l QB12OOB3G70731 n
l E
ADOCK 0500041p
\\
\\
PDR y
7 I I
United States Nuclear Regulatory Comission Duquesne Light Company Comments 'on the Safety Evaluation Report (NUREG-1057)
Page 2 COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA )
)
SS:
COUNTY OF BEAVER
)
On thit_ hM/ day of b /4[cf/
/M[, before me, a Notary Public in and for said Commonwealth and County, personally appeared J.
J. Carey, who being duly swarn, deposed and said that (1) he is Senior Vice President of Duquesne Light, (2) he is duly authorized to execute and file the foregoing Submittal on behalf of said Company, and (3) the statements set forth in the Submittal are true and correct to the best of his knowledge, U K lll NW
/
Notary Public
$NERA 5. PAftstE, morary pggug SNIPPIEGPEINW. REAVER COUNIf 57 COBMSBION tilPfgES 007. 23,1989 bber, Peassylvesis.bsestice of setarias
o h
n o n
Tl
-)
e e
(i o
s i i e
e2 g
h x
t t l
r -
a t
guiH f
1 aa e
P n aFW l r h
i ef e a t
5 rp d
n h o ea".
e o
t l
9 e
ht e
) s i
r c
4 ut ar d
e rA h
e a
b e
a a
vp
(
c e
1 :
f o
f peo p
m i
h
.s e oe ro a
b dt".
5 w n
s gr a
t d".
n c
i r o
i a
e a
F p s
d y 9l b n r
S ro h( e i rs nl l
a
)
p ee ae no uic r
b f
v of tti ai k pi
(
o ah ef rpr i
8t i
t t s ev wr t
oue 4i h
s c c a h e an s
w s
e a
t p
sie e
t l d e
p Sd e
l c
n a
eV s
a ensb u
i h
r u
m ac d
t e
e g
s f
o i
e e
T a
er r
t st o
rh) s h
ewr o
N r
I f c 5 yn t
h oa i,
d n
h tl E
a M
p Ss hl
)i Ap s f :
M y
t pu 5 -
et r
a o 6
h h w
o h
P a
os fb a O
nn t
C ot o e rh r
ain gs 8
s at o
t d
o a
5
,el 1 el n
mt n
a -
cl o
s i
cp r e at r a
f r em ac oAeB no i
r t o pn e
h T ef t
e i
o r
es f
t r4 p o c e
f e r
d t e a n s o - m A
h w n
r t o o Pn n n 3
h e ea pB a C
w o e e 7 t r s
Sd i
l 7 (F A
d h
fl o
c s r
a c
r oo d e i
d e
d a
t st F
m e r e n
u f
nr o
e ai u s
(
eg r
r i
o i
r d
F r
f i.
A h 1
S s
h r
.h n i
s ei ti F
td 2
7 n a T
e h
T N
s f
d l
2 t
N 5E d
.' e l 5 m u
ee/
f
- o eo h r1 o
E
- M ea
.Rf e
.di e
M D W:
h e Ra nh nuAr hh Ti -
H cT T r
" Ns I t
" abPf Ts
" F1 1
C A
e T
C ga T
L P
A D
4 4
N O
1 1
1 I
T C
5 5
5 E
S 9
9 9
E G
2 2
3 A
P 9
9 9
G N
I K
C CA 1
2 3
LRO 0
0 0
DTN 2
2 2
n.
n ot ut g mb sge i
rsjaa oanis eiab d d a p
ur cl oge gmra e et psol a eini a
al t in a
ait ap t rt el P
pe fi t ia h
v n
a b
s r
s mLt ned ast nm nr s d
U o
n c rn ae o oi n o
i oe s
oh a
,i go sm oe)t nc omms h dt h l
i t r p
e pd ura p
t 6
i y
a o
2 r s p
co a
n tt aeof r r ei ir 1
e h
r r o ee hd ro g
i s
s t
e rA' nh et eo a
r h
u i t h
epd r
e s
,croo 5. C t
L t el a
i r
4 g
f o
e ed s
9 Dn virl p
l o
o f
s af oa r
o 9
r e o h
u d
asd ul e
eet a e l
g e
n ;d n
ee d
n cu u n e b
odi o o vd gh a
a at ad l
c a:
ev ci eie fi P c n
l gn vi e
ct i
t P
uv( nye n
od s
n af i
p ni eni ibt g
a rn i
i e
T n vad 8 n
n w pi e
srd t
c N
o amn1 o e
o np h
eo i
x t m ts s sl i ay t ed E
h i
e M
h t
sl a f
el -
e i
o mLi f
t ay M
p t nd h
i O
aoh aee l
s mf Ut o e e t
t t b t w
s hl di h md mn C
r o
e;eu et eer g
t d n ee e
r a
y na sv r
l h
rj c
dt u d
r bnep l
t e a n
pc e
se a
r a
omx as o o
eh eee t
p iA e f
f u st t t b c s td t ot r ni c
t ie a
er es a
c on s "w d e
ag d ml R
t b oh a h e a l
n oo nme A
n ot t
f n
di u
i oob S
u s
o t
t o ay cca eF dd
,da s
n m
l f
l a ssh h e
l a
u u
ee r o au ads i
s e
n e
s r c o
rr od m ul l r t
S a
o oh s o
d a o
o Cs h
d s
fd d o eiv e w "s R e
u 7
T e
h h
Nj el th ve h
l N
s d
t t
5E reet ru r
t t
e f
i
- M Col sn eo od d g eb er o
RM nL oiaeyhh F eynn nh ah o EO I DdfB mfT s tbii I tl tf 2
SC S
e C
g L
a D
P 4
4 N
O I
1 1
T, C
5 5
E S
9 9
E G
4 4
A P
9 9
G N
I K
C CA 4
5 LRO 0
0 DTN 2
2 I
i rw p
pa t u r
h h
r nt go d
t c
g e
nf e n
h i
i a
d ei l
o g
w h
hd sb c
u aw i
r l r a e
o n
a t
ol s
r oot p
i i
s h
i t a snu s a
t t
iib s e
e d
v h
d s
c,,
s e
n yser a t
s i
w s
nnF o
uw*
w v
o k
c rnp l
e oimb n
o o
l n
s j o0 a
e n sb o i
l r
l a
w nd5 s
l p
o t
o ol 3 a src eu d
e o
f l
co e
l f
s d
l oo rt r d
h sp u
n s
i o
nct i
a d mea m
s e
a c
f i
t o
roh w
a t
a gl s
d s
) na n:
a ct i s z
nm e
b n
y a
c a
siu w
a oo i
s e
i erq rnio g
r r
d vue o
h e
i i t r d
e e
o a
l d l
c a
a l
T l
b v
d b
e a
r n
u N
o e
et l
o l
r vmo e
s E
f n r o
o d
b u
e e
t r
h M
oi r
l a
o h
d pt n n
i s
M s
f if et u
h t
l msa e a t
h n o
e s
u u yh O
s C
a t o s
h h
f o
d st a
t c
e s
t e
o h
- d t a es g
c s
crs h
,f s e oe n
e f
n e
i es t
r h
a c
o e
n e
rt e a r de e t
h n
t o
c eal l
v e c
s e
n n
n h w d
,t e
t u nl w u e t
i e
m e
pdf a
ol c
g n
a s
o t
seo o
oe o n
n e
r r
n oe rh ei i
s t
h f
e mf e h
i d
s t -
rs w
t s
t r
ayu".
n i
y;i o
d e
n r
o 5 dt gu n l
r l
e o
t
( rt c
d enqw l
i g
v s
aa.
S e
T 9
afi e o o:
h n
e a
.i r 7
s r
f N
ad d
h t
i s
l l e.
5E e
sl t
p s
.i pe f
- M eg nnit u ea e
e e
xmm o
RM h a I ouoh h r h
A h
h
" nb ns T g T
T T
" att 3
SC S
e C
g L
a D
P N
4 4
O I
1 1
T C
5 5
E S
9 9
E G
5 6
A P
9 9
G N
I K
C 6
7 CA LRO 0
0 DTN 2
2
s t
a h
e e
s t
e p
e r
h n
v o
t p
h e
l
(
a p
n a
e d
r a
o V
s l
l e
u e
g r
p i
d o
l a
g m
l a
o o
s h
b r
s a
a r
c r
a h
l p
a t
p h
i p
e n:
l a
p a
d h
os i
r a
v n
t t
C w a
g r
a o
s o
f a
g c
F r
o rl r
a f
e i
t el s
a.
r i
s 0
f t o e
a 5
d af v
p "r p
e 3
e n
w l
d e s
h h
a d s a
rw d
r t
t ea v
n e
i o n
e o".
h p o
t f
o f
Fd e
t n c
a o
t o
i s a
h a
e e
t r ye t
T ei s
h e
s e
ae rr n
N h
c l
c l g a
E tl e
r n
l n
i n i d l
M a
h e
e a
e t a l l i
M f n t
z t :
f t
nh i u o
O oo i
ns n
ec xo C
i f
r ew e
e vx uh c
et o
u so r
s e
As i
ci s
l u
p l
nd e
s tl t
e mt e
u ed c
e s o a
t ua gc a
t a n
r af r
e:
pe nn r
n e
p l
e l s h
i e d
et t
s p
pw R
dt y
su n
e o a m
mo H r an h
o e
h t
e ol R e ee th s
t d
t cl t
h s f
st d a o
ra o
ai h
f ne S
d f ow ed o
or C
r f
h r s
w t :
l i s g
ti s
R.
f s c
e" S
h a
. n h
o 7
w ed T
i N
h s f o sl t
i rt l
5E td l
u d
.l e
f M
r el eo ea o
d e n
o hh h e
.o nh O
" c Ut 4
SC e
S g
C a
L P
D 4
4 4
4 N
O 1
1 I
1 1
T 5
5 5
5 C
E S
9 9
9 9
E 0
2 G
7 9
1 1
A P
9 9
9 9
G N
I K
C 8
9 0
1 CA LRO 0
0 1
1 DTN 2
2 2
2
b l
rtt.i r f
M e
dd p
unnnl e gd ds nl :
d e
se o e yd n neeee l
r smC pc n a eer rh a u "s o
u eu o
i rt r e ut l
shV o
e r r r y(o xh w s esI h
b pt
. si et on c
l S
s sV ea pe hsM i
d anI v s
ss a
ae n
l I S l eh e en e tf e
Mah c v nir n V gl o
u na i
o z
vt al i a a pan t
h e
e a el i
l t ucg n
nt e n v
ml mhi a
s
.h l
nh ei i o h e ti t h od t ocgw D
i g
s s
t n cin gr i
e ut w
i mno s
c n
o e h a i
ve w r s ai e
n esV e n
r n
u ss ewe d
e pp e
,ab V o I n l l i I p oeSi t oh t
Sl t s
n eMl oel S
s r
l V
e rk sl s
Me e
l t e e
cof I
s i
h w
f o S) vd yd ani h i
ec o
r MC h
el n l e re r ra e Tp T
eet Y
t pai uepsav s
N hh n eH x
yvl pop t
ys ul h
y E
pt e h
i ss n
.c M
s m
t s s
l c scoc ee i
o e
e eo
- wa sn M
m "s c rs l TE ue O
,c d
b re por
,b g
C t ea ea n
ot v i
Avl cl a
l nl a
s r
l i goar caf eye l p np ae ee
,g cvi v
m srl c e
gV r t r h n n
age o n
ee a h
n h w n
n ti e
ro i d v i ne eV f w et c iTt rn gr t r d oh s0 i o a
re t
ei d ait A
fl e np h sl eh t r es et t(
l t
i a e m
yo mt h ao s
,o p
o u
.i c
ei wn n
e l t r"
hf d t l
n - r d
i e
eo iV t
a h se f0 re eie t e
rl e s ct d omf".
S tI u A
uh yl r i
e)i T
d e*
ot wyu n n
asao N
rm hS f
c i
e d e d
7 n
s s
a i l v
5E eae tS h
e s
h v ph n s
f M
d ed M
et h resc orceeso o
RM nt a n2 hi Ti ruesruaph ol EO USm I "
T w
" apomippeotl c 5
SC S
e C
g L
a D
P N
4 O
I 1
T C
5 E$
9 E
2 G
1 A
P 9
G N
I K
C CA 2
LRO 1
DTN 2
t u
t e t
sP u m e
so7 ab e s
dT h oa t
l l
n
- c s
y eB e
S re b
u Ci d e S
e u
f r a
rRf h
cf F
l A
C g
Ni ut y
xo e
e f
f 2 r l
e d
n o
e e ie ah n p
)
t l
a t a
n rdl si p
h 7 n
S r
ei c
r nc u
c(
e:
i.
e a
S pe F
nd i b.
l h
Sd r e.
c,
e ny
,d oe n
rs w6 a
t gd i d ew m
c S.
or7 a n
d ti d
e ct8 t o gC n
i n
e i v al n
a e d
a.
l C i9 sd o Wl in b
b a
8 E
nu1t nr o
c o
" e oc n op e
,1 b
i r
,eC nf ai ad hd l 6t g
ti4 m n
is sc ru o
pt el u1 n nd i
c2 m eo eh o e
i l d
o t a e
Ao S
h h
m d u n
si c
t ec nt ed o
t t
s d
ao om s
n eh C e n ea a
n n
l t
o e
e h s t uC cm oe f
u e e
r i
s T
ed m esJL 1 m i r rr s y DL o d
F g
d A
e b.
nSd f
d 7
N P
0 T n h
e n
E n
M uP eR e
ers n t
wa M
mA t S.
el 3
t oi i u
a eh c
r naf h o
a c N c aA S rC i
O e
od t e F
i h
i C
e F
e L
c i
s d
g n rR d ".
h A Ar n
e
,7 nt gn n
t e
t S e u
h c6 8 o e
ni gi p
t e6 gc nw i
9 t
n d
neF t
i 1
n g
o e
o1 gc i
i er e
n dl si d
n.
o i
t r7 ne d
v al t
i F re
,il P -
a o
n c
eo ed l
t pd n
t C 6df e e r
h f re h
p a".
s,
a t o ceR yor s
p N
s1 at pi 2l et s
e e a "y n e si e r w
h h
l u
o h s ut5 rob l c sF t t ti u
e sJRt s t r h o S
e itd er r
r E
t l
i o9 7
T h
ual ht d ed S d a rf
.f r "a N
t e
f 5E ciu t s h et e et e
B
- M rvo n
t stt ett d e 0E d e o
RM nieh no ii eah ai nh 5M nr EO icd s I C WvLdTd m Ut
" 2C UA 6
SC S
e C
g L
a D
P 4
4 5
5 6
N O
1 1
1 1
1 I
T C
5 5
5 5
5 E
S 9
9 9
9 9
E 3
3 5
5 6
G 1
1 1
1 1
A P
9 9
9 9
9 G
N I
K C
3 4
5 6
7 CA LRO 1
1 1
1 1
DTN 2
2 2
2 2
r t
r,
t t1 c d omrneie s
s i e R nh astd o
at A
n.
P
,l c
2
.itJeo f
i o T
f B e8pn
- ea (h n e vn 7
n f
h1 pa Sl tR t
s n
e oC a
t at Pb net se o
d,
i p
V aoSit sh i
d t
t n y
t e
n si e
BCC saet e
a oam c
t o
c eihl
((
h n
tMo t
i C
c e
hVt nt e
p i
S e
t d
r m
R f a h) t ua c
c edd t2) ed h
a N
c ee P
(
1 t c e
i nt e
,t t
aa S
f it sR
- e. ) i
(
f it e n
h eifanS) o
- 5. k.
o h
Sa re t e B
tid o g
- 5. (1 e c om c
t nt i
e 97 r
E e (4 cC ad ni f u e
a M
es0t h
.a od es BC e
D C
,d u3 at 3 an7 n
min rs t
m.
"s ij1 i
i E
t ea a
dP
- v n0 t o Mt aB e sd 7 ei 5 pi C n c h
Co c7 nT a
eesTl i
P C
r en d
R et n
et r d
l F
cc n
d aC d
nb o e T1 e
A i
C ce 0
aS o r w w
i e
o R d e B.
d t
t c
N ei isP e d
1 n
a l
T 7
t a i e s
2 i f N
e d a c
a e
C1 C
vl fi ch e a
rAi h
R -
eb L.
E hC l
w i
M t
u1 d
eP f ric e
r add N5.S)i t
r d
et e t
e n
nFi M
e o
a i
i eN t t npw f9 nF G
o o
R p
,t O
,b h7 R
nt es eCp C
e s
e B diR R cd C
d e ed cRe nt N
l i e od c
nE ti r
a R
cNc nl l
n oM cN a
c eu es gu g
C y a
iC e
e a
a t o cn no n
h e
nh n o ih se Ll d
t
)t et eh i
e n
d nb Dl t r nP r h
rt es ei d s a a o eTe D t e
s t t.
a ao nmh c mbt
,e a
n e
c m.
ee ei d irt c a
t w yb a
)
t e e e h n ht o
a cmw e 7
b l
sr sS7 i
a u f s A 8 s e
i o r
ra l
i e
e od en f r A
9nev t hC i
h h vh e di if 1 osa fl st t
t e st s o c
sl.
t iih on s
d aa c,
S e
a l
th esvaS
,t w
T eu b o a.
r 1
a pn r
0ars m.
i rl N
hf s
et -
Ai so eR3i en 5E t
mt e
CP r i 2nE vh o a 5. s L F
- M w
eoc d e7 d
e otOeS7 eti RM ne h re nh nh EO I n TfS UtC Ut9ADNt NaCGS2d ot SC S
C L
D 6
6 7
N O
1 1
I 1
T C
5 5
5 E
S 9
9 9
E 7
7 7
G 1
1 1
A P
9 9
9
)
deun i
t G
n N
o I
c K
(
C 7
8 9
0 CA LRO 1
1 1
2 DTN 2
2 2
2 l
l
d) n aP S
es
,E
(
h w 1
t o l
tl rl i e eo nn df Ua n
p us n
a i
n h
w pd l o aa ed re nt gr au a
ph rd s
al n
pu w y o
o dh d
c rs n
t i
e u
h "m T
h gr N
t s
E e
e M
et n
M h s ye r
O t y a
C S
i e f
l h oy i t t
x er u f R
ca a
E nP o
S e
t e e
h y l
ng tt a
ea i
n sP t n i
ai".
g t
c 2
i sg r
an
.i 2
1 v
T O
l i t
f N
d E
e ea ei o
M h
h e
.h n
H t
Th
" tU 1
C e
A n
g T
o a
T P
A tne m
N 1
m O
2 o
I C
T C
5 C
E L
S 9
D E
56 G
55 A
P 99 G
N I
K C
CA LRO DTN 1
2 2