ML20235N109
| ML20235N109 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Millstone, Haddam Neck, 05000000, Fort Saint Vrain |
| Issue date: | 01/27/1987 |
| From: | Roberts, Zech L NRC COMMISSION (OCM) |
| To: | Asselstine, Bernthal, Roberts NRC, NRC COMMISSION (OCM) |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20235N034 | List: |
| References | |
| FOIA-87-299 870127, COMLZ-87-11, NUDOCS 8707170440 | |
| Download: ML20235N109 (16) | |
Text
__.
g January 27, 1987 cHAmuAN COMLZ-87-11 MEMORANDUM FOR: Commissioner Roberts Commissioner Asselstine Commissioner Bernthal Commissioner Carr FROM:
Lando W. Zech, Jr.
i
SUBJECT:
SECY-86-383; ENGINEERING EXPERTISE ON SHIFT NORTHEAST '
i UTILITIES, HADDAM NECK AND MILLSTONE UNITS 1 AND 2, AND FORT ST. VRAIN I
i l
I i
i l
l I agree that the NU program meets the intent of the Commission's Policy Statement and should be recognized.
I do not agree that all future candidates must meet the criteria specified in the policy statement.
The policy statement is not a requirement and as tuch allows greater flexibility than a regulation.
Therefore, I find it difficult to understand how we can grant exemptions from our regulations but require strict
" compliance" with a policy statement.g vVd 8707170440 070715 PDR FDI A STENCER87-299 PDR
g...
eme.. se e. swei se" a ec -m ce
' NORTHEAST UTILITIES c.a...
.,,...:.......-..n~
C D BOK 210 y
.,.. s.e,se s e.,:.s uw~
wAaTFCAD CONNECTICUT 061410270
.$. e.,....
. ce.. -
202, 665 5000
...... e s i.*u ec~
L t
e w
ENGINEERING EXPERTISE ON SHIFT
~
EDWARD J. MROCZKA SENIOR VICE PRESIDENT MARCH 6, 1987 1
l l
l I
J
't"
POLICY STATEMENT:
" ENSURE THAT ENGINEERING AND
. o.
ACCIDENT ASSESSMEN1 ' EXPERTISE IS POSSESSED BY OPERhTING STAFF."
POLICY STATEMENT:-
"THE COMMISSION PREFERS A COMBINED o
SR0/STA POSITION."
DEGREE REQUIREMENT HAS NOT BEEN DEMONSTRATED AS 0
MEANS TO ACHIEVE OBJECTIVE..
NU FOCUSED ON INTENT EARLY (DUAL-ROLE-SR0/STA PO O
FULLY IMPLEMENTED-1-1-84).
NU PROGRAM RESPONSIVE TO COMMISSION INTENT.
o NU MADE AGGRESSIVE, GOOD FAITH EFFORT THAT HAS BEEN o
SUCCESSFUL.
l l'
ln L
NU PROGRAM IS A PROVEN SUCCESS COMMENDABLE OPERATING-RECORDS o
HIGHLY EXPERIENCED AND STABLE STAFF - V4LUABL
.o o
(SEEuATTACHMENT A)
NU's SSs AND SR0s.HAVE INVALUABLE FAMILIARITY W o
PLANT:
GREW UP WITH PLANT a.
PROGRESSED FROM PE0 TO R0 TO SRO TO SS o
(SEE ATTACHMENT B)
INVOLVED WITH PDCRs, TESTING, PROCEDURES, o
TRAINING 9
s
1.:
rn r.
1' L
.SPECIFICALLY ADDRESSES NEEDS OF STAS
. THAMES. VALLEY PROGRAM CUSTOW DESIGNED.FOR STA l
0
.DIRECTLY-ADDRESSES ISSUE - NOT EDUCATION FOR ITS O o
. SAKE PROVIDES I.ENTIFIED EDUCATIONAL NEEDS OF STA PO D
o (SEE ATT4CHMENT'C)
PR0s OF THAMES VALLEY PROGRAM:
o EXCEEDS INPO RECOMMENDATIONS o
'o NEARBY LOCATION GREATER NU INFLUENCE OVER PROGRAM CONTENT AND 0
ADMINISTRATION HANDS-0N LABORATORY EXPERIENCE o
PROPER ACADEMIC ATMOSPHERE AND PACE o
~
[
1 T
. DEGR$E REQUIREMENT WOULD BE VERv DISRUPTIVE L
MOTIVATION AND MORALE IS VITAL.
.o-PROGRESSION OF R0s AND PE0s WOULD BE SEVE
'o IMPORTANT NOT TO IMPAIR TEAMWORK OF SHIFT COM o
SSs AND SR0s NEED. SHIFT RESPECT AND ACCEPTANCE o
STABILITY OF OUR ORGANIZATION WOULD BE JEOPAR o
MANY DEGREED INDIVIDUALS DO NOT STAY WITH SHI o
h
__.___________________o
1 NU COMMITTED TO SUPERIOR PROGRAM l
GOOD FAITH EFFORT TO BE RESPONSIVE T0' COMMISSIO o
I INTENT.-
NU's APPROACH BETTER ENHANCES SAFE OPERATIONS
~
L o
L DEDICAT5DSTAOPTION2'AVAILABLE.
CONTINUOUS ENROLLMENT OF SR0s.
o MANY SHIFTS HAVE MORE THAN ONE STA-QUALIFIED o
i (SEE ATTACHMENT D).
I L
i M
NU's ENGINEERING EXPERTISE ON-SHIFT PROGRAM.
NU MEETS OR. EXCEEDS INTENT 0F POLICY STATEMENT.
o NU PROGRAM IS A PROVEN SUCCESS.
. o SPECiFICALLYADDRESSESNEEDSOFSTAs.
o f.
. DEGREE REQUIREMENT WOULD BE VERY DISRUPTIVE.
L o
NU COMMITTED TO SUPERIOR PROGRAM.
o l
ATTACHMENT n..;.
{
Page 1 l
C5Us Ex:ER!ENCE.0; F'33W.E:
YRS C0(l). YRS SS/SC0(1)(2) EXSERiEMCE T3iiU 1
)
1 4
15 19 i
-A; i
15
.i B
4 2
9 C
-3.
1 4
3 11-
'D 4
2 4
lb lib 1 i
E
~ 4 1
4 1
10 l
4 L
F 1
.l.
12
-5 19 G
lb lb.
4 3
10 l
I 1
a 18h H
3 3h 12 12-1
'2b 2h 7
17 l
J' 2
2 13.
1 AVERAGE 14.3 I
N3TE 1: THE NUMBER OF YEARS INDICATED IS EXPERIENCE O H!
..THE INDIVIDUAL IS QUALIFIED STA, j
N3TE 2: -THE NUMBER OF YEARS INDICATED IS THE SUM 0F SS AN l
l EXPERIENCE.
l l
N3TE 3: ONLY RESPONSIBLE NUCLEAR EXPERIENCE IS INDICATED, l
4
ATTACllMENT'A Page 2
'EXPER!ENCE 0; Mll'_STG'!E 'S! T 'OS, i A>;;-2 574
:__3T:NE U'::T 1 AD;ii!3';AL(3) 2.5 NLD(1 YRS C0(1).
YRS'SS/SC0(1.)(2) E FER!E';CE TOTAL 2
'7 A.
1 4
'. 0 B
2
,4
'7 13 C
4 4
p 2
9
.5 0
h
'3 t0 b
b L
1 I
2 3
J 4
'b K
5 L
2 5
1-M 6
AVERAGE 15.3.
MIL _ STONE UNIT 2
'. 4 4
<g
- 5b
-A
.3 2
2 4
4 2
7 3
6 4
5 2
5 Sb sk
'0 4
5 4k G
4h 8
H 2
N 10b b
27 AVERAGE 15.2 THE NUMBER OF YEARS INDICATED IS EXPERIEN NOTE 1:
THE INDIVlDUAL IS QUAllFIED STA.
THE NUMBER OF YEARS INDICATED IS THE SUM OF S NOTE 2:
EXPERIENCE.
'; ~E 3: O'LY RESPONS!3LE NUCLEAR EXPERIE';CE IS l';:lCATED.
G N
OI R N I
~
SR O Y L
A R-2
=
N G
N O
I ON IS RI A S
R E
T R
G O
S R
R P
O Y L
LN 7 J
L A
2 I
C PY G
T N
OI L N I
NART G
N E
IN T
E IA A
C
) U N
R s D E
T L T' A IR L
EQR VEG E
A P
C E R D
L L
XR N I
Y MO N EO H A
RUO C
S TMH E
R T
NI C N
A E
I S
E S
M
( H Y
R G
A I
3 E
H Y
2 i
l li l
C T
2 3
1 s
1 S
6 8
4 2
2 3
3 r
8 4
7 8
4 uV 1
1 3
4 1
1 oT H
tca t
0 5
5 nO 4
1 N
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
oP 3
3 2
9 0
3 4
2 6
4 C
1 1
I 1
s me d
t e nt s
g g
y io n x
n n
i i
S mi y
t r
r t
l rcx t
e s
o eeR s
e e
r t
t t
y n
T y
i s s n
ned m
c c s
1 r
I r
i i
1 I t
gl e s
e o id n e
s a
h n n syy ni v o c nC ed i
m Er mir i
C f o a cr r i
sak i
t ne h s i) rh is ee e
e c r
oo af cs rRc l
t f t u
yhh h
oa u e
cSc c 1
f hs a e 1 1 r
h cn Mc crb ot o
ele e 1
s MHl M TT C
sMt Te a I 1 h
hh o
a l
s E
s s P
t t d
uu r r r
ar e dMrT CP dPe r
aa e
((
aD e
e(
s l
l l
coo o
i s s c c& e uu e
MM p
r idt D
z i
t t t
e e -
l a
/o ie i
i i tl cc mcc c
i sr hh c
l i
v c n pu t
t l
s s u
cc n
cp ep aa o aa a
a t ee e
u o pl e Cu a o l l yy o
ee r
hhl M N N AFH AA cb i
i C
TT P
e a 5
26 39 2 0 3
00 000 0
1 1
l 1 3 ph 3
1 21 3
2 3 33 C
00 2
l 1 5 31 2
2 2 2 22 22 st 1 2 2
l 22 i
T 1
1 i
2 AA H
HHT T AA SS5 S
FS F STT TT o
1 1 1 1 1 1
i1 2 w
S T
MM C
PPEM MM NNN N
MNM MMM EE N
V ar be g
s s
n a
c c
o l
l cA i
i i
t t
ny t
a a
it e ai t
yg y
h c m
s n
y e
l e
r ci e
r s
s c
e al r
l t
e h
t e
n m
nl s
t s
a o
mc y
t i
c A
i e
u i
a
,C m
e r
r n
m e
e c
i rl M
o
,l t o y
e t
e e
t r&
h a
e S
s i
h a
c nt
,)
g h
t y C
e s
er Hn m n
T C
M S
l I n d
a i
c r
l e
mt c
(
s r
ui r
r r
a aC i
n e
i e
o o
a sot m
e r
nm.n cse e
o i
t t
e t
l d l
a n
. c c
lc e
e ua r
c cn e
oo g
st i
n ig a
a d
ge r
yh g
iu iG o
h ga n
e e
u h
l r
n Pim E
R R
N T
E N
G T
I l
O 0
P N
2 3
4 5
6 7
8 9
1 1
I
l}ll ll 44>OOX1t' o
c r
o O4m t
C T
sS 8
r 4
3 0
uV 4
3 3
oT l
f t.
ta tnO oP C N 0
0 0
4 2
4 I
1 s
n C
o I
S i
ta nA h
t r
e n
oD l
i io t
e Rt l
w ns n a :g ae neioin c o
H P
amrtvin i
n meea um r
o a-ugpcmm HauinSnma i
t e
l u
r a
c
&a f
og i
a Ns
- MomCo d
u.
y i
gl sml r
y P
Rt n
oeeoa no s
e ii l nlpCico e
rfa a s
oni t
t n
sr eS c a hoccho r
csni u
l i
o cd pe yriscr op seraet u n n
C Na TO PPPBTI 0200 8 C
2 1
1 T
2 3
21 3 23 3 2
S 2
2 2221 1
SSP V
S S
S MM T
N N
AI AAO I
)
s s
l l
n sm i
o k
a l
S a r i
t t g y
c n o r
e er o
to mp s
i r
ae v
Ps ds r
c ni nn e )O s
ue p
oy Fc uP ith i
SN aP cl
/
I n
t i
i n-dh f
i n
i at s
c.
e o e
Rl e c mn a
n e
pn e e r
i aH S
g i
l o
am e
e t
s d
nl no d
lcn aa as iu ua G
N P
M(
l (
O P
1 2
3 N
1 1
1 I
llllt lllf1ll\\lll 11 lflj' i
ATTACHMENT C-Page 3 SCHEDULE A THAMES VALLEY STATE TECHNICAL COLLEGE NUCLEAR ENGINEERING TECHNOLOGY Effective September 1, 1985 FIRST YEAR SECOND YEAR.
Weekly Qtr Weekly Qtr FIRST QUARTfR CI Lab Cr FOURTH QUARTER CI Lab Cr DP 238-Basic
~Y 2'
3 NS 120 Reactor
~T 0
4 Theory I MA 110 Tech. Math.'I 4
0 4'
MA 210 Calculus II 4
0 4
.PH'111 Physics (Mech) 3 2
4 MT 231 Appl. Thermo. I 4
0 4
CH 122 Princ. of Chem.
3 2
4 MT 232 riuid Mechanics 3
2 4
XX XXX NET P01 4/3 0/0 4/3 AS 221 Psych. &
Hum. Rel.
4 2
4-Totals........ 16/15 6
19/1C Totals.........
19 2
2C SECOND QUARTER FIFTH QUARTER ET 225 Elec. & Electr.
3 2
4 NS 210 Reactor TheoryII 4 0
4 MA 120 Tech. Math. II 4
0 4
ET 213 AC/DC' Machinery _3 2
4:
PH 121 Physics (HSL) 3 2
4 MT_236 Heat _ Transfer 3
2 di
. AS 120 Basic. Comm.-
4 0
4 AS 212 Economics 31 0
NS 110 Atomic Physics 4
0 4
MT 133 Appl. Mechanics 4
0 Totals.........
18 4
20 Totals.......
17 4
15
~
THIRD QUARTER SIXTH QUARTER XX XXX NET P02 3/4 0/0 3,
MA 130 Calculus I 4
0 4
NS 220 Nuclear Mat.
3 2
AS 130 Tech. Comm.
4 0
4 ET 239 Auto. Proc.
3 2
NS 130 Rea'ctor Chem.
4 0
4.
Cont. Systems MF 212 Mat. of Engr.
3 3
4 NS 222 Rad. Health 3
2 4
NS 231 Topics in Nuc.
3 0
& Saf.
Power Ops.
AS 232 Sociology 3
0 Totals.........
18 5
20 XX XXX NET P03 3/1 0/3
- 3. '
Totals....... 18/17 4/7 20, l
i PROGRAM OPTIONS (PO)
Reactor Operator (RO)
P01 IM 210 Per Mgt 4
0 4
P02 Mr 115 NDT 3
0 3
TOTAL QUARTER CREDITS - 118/117 P03 IM 232 Prin'of Sup 3
0 3
Non-Reactor Operator (NRO) j P01 NS 221 Nuc Sys 3
0 3
j P02 As 110 Intro to Lit 4 0
4 P03 NS 232 Nuc Reac Sim 1 3
2 i
l' ATTACH!4ENT D t-QUAllFIED SHIFT -TECHNICAL ADVISORS AT HADDAM NECX MILLSTONE UNIT NO.l AND MILLSTONE UNIT N0.2(1)
HADDAM NECK MILLSTONE 1 MILLSTONE 2 QUALIFIED STAS (TOTAL) 10 13 8
SHIFT SUPERVISORS 6
6 6
SENIOR CONTROL ROOM OPERATORS LI 6
2 1
CONTROL ROOM OPERATOR (1)
A TOTAL OF SIX SHIFTS ARE UTILIZED AT EACH PLANT.
OF THE TOTAL OF 18 SHIFTS,11 StilFTs HAVE TWO DUAL ROLE QUALIFIED PERSONNEL,1 SHIFT HAS THREE, AND 6 SHIFTS HAVE ONE,
'h
. }
I I
bu J -
- 2 Y ff.?
N
/f
-fn4 pcf yf v
N SYJ s*
i p hd
~u &.~'
~
~
~-
us e t10 fL t-9.
l l
l
,p egem g
.-r e en
.e 4
y+
ws -* <. so e.
e-aw= wh w++**
- w ee.
me, w. me
-sh-neemm eme.
.-.w
..-qm-m---
,e gu,mm..
,a.
.-as
,----w o
__9-I s
+
'*d
'MO
, gg g
g g # @ ti e,J ;J..i.c. #_ _u @ g..u. A ps 4 x9.;.', E v's IA 4.
',.g 4
S
]
r
/,.. %yu ", peg,e.g.p n
s 3,
b
- 4. -
~
~
g
.a...'.
._ 2 Yew;. Q 3 ajeg ) Q A
.~s' =,
- i.
g I
V