ML20216G359
| ML20216G359 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 09/22/1999 |
| From: | Combs F NRC OFFICE OF STATE PROGRAMS (OSP) |
| To: | Stoeckel M RHODE ISLAND, STATE OF |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20216G365 | List: |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 9910010024 | |
| Download: ML20216G359 (10) | |
Text
F.
i.
pa uru g
t UNITED STATES j
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION t
WASHINGTON, D.C. 30886-0001 September 22, 1999 Marie Stoeckel, MPH, ClH., Chief Office of Occupational and Radiological Health i
Rhode Island Department of Health Three Capitol Hill, Room 206 Providence, RI 02908-5097 i
Dear Ms. Stoeckel:
This is in reference to your June 14,1999 letter to Paul H. Lohaus in response to our June 3, 1999 letter which provided the Nuclear Regulatory Commission's (NRC) comments on Rhode 3
Island's proposed amendments to Rules and Reaulations for the Control of Radiation. The
. proposed regulations in question are in response to the two amendments identified in the enclosed Regulation Assessment Tracking System (RATS) Data Sheet. As a result of our review of yourJune 14,1999 letter, we have the following comments:
1.
Definitions of Occupational Dose and Public Dose (RATS ID 1995-5)
Based on your letter, it is our understanding that Rhode Island will adopt the additional language for the definitions of occupational dose and public dose to make them compatible with NRC regulations during your next round of proposed amendments. We find this approach acceptable and as noted previously, that if your proposed regulations were adopted incorporating the comments and without other significant change, they would meet the compatibility and health and safety categories established in OSP Procedure SA-200.
2.
Manufacture, preparation or transfer for commercial distribution of radioactive drugs containing byproduct materials for medical use (RATS ID 1995-1)
Based on the discussion in your letter and additional discussions with William Dundulis, we understand that the requirements of 10 CFR 32.72(b)(3)-(5) are contained in the rules and regulations of the Rhode Island Board of Pharmacy. Specifically, Section C.8.76(a) of the Rhode Island Rules and Reaulations for the Control of RadiatioD references the implementing regulations (R5-19-PHAR) for the Rhode Island Board of Pharmacy. After further review, we conclude that Rhode Island regulations would meet the compatibility category and withdraw our comment.
3.
Reports to individuals of exceeding dose limits (RATS ID 1995-5)
After review of Section A.5.18 of the Rhode Island Rules and Reaulations for the Control of Radiation, which is a final regulation separate from the draft amendments, we conclude that this section is compatible with 10 CFR 20.2205 and withdraw our comment.
9910010024 990922 PDR STPRO ESCRI PDR
Marie Stoeckel SEP 2 2 Jggg We have also summarized on the RATS Data Sheet our knowledge of the status of other Rhode Island regulations. In the review, we noted that RATS 1994-1 and 1992-1 were not reviewed previously. We have~ determined that they meet the compatibility and health and safety categories established in OSP Procedure SA-200. Please let us know if you note any
- inaccuracies or have any comments on the information contained in the RATS Data Sheet.
If you have any questions regarding these comments, please contact me or Duncan White, Regional State Agreements Officer, Region I at (610) 337-5042 or ADW@NRC. GOV.
Thank you for your cooperation.
' t i
F i eri' C. Co bs, Ddputy Director i
tate P ems
Enclosure:
As stated i-
w
' Marie'Stoeckel SEP 221993
- We have also summarized on the RATS Data Sheet our knowledge of the status of other Rhode Island regulations. In the review, we noted that RATS 1994-1'and 1992-1 were not reviewed previously. We have determined that they meet the compatioility and health and safety -
categories established in OSP Procedure SA-200. Please let us know if you note any inaccuracies or have any comments on the information contained in the RATS Data Sheet.
I If you have any questions regarding these comments, please contact me or Duncan White, Regional State Agreements Officer, Region I at (610) 337-5042 or ADW@NRC. GOV.
Thank you for your cooperation.
Sincerely, Original signed by:
Frederick C. Combs, Deputy Director Office of State Programs
Enclosure:
As stated -
Distribution:
' DIR RF (9-122)
DCD (SP05)
PHLohaus PDR (YES/)
SDroggitis BUsilton -
LBolling.
(
DSollenberger, ASPO g
Rhode Island File ~'
DOCUMENT NAME: G:\\SNS\\R19122.WPD N
n
. m:c.c ~.# g Wr. co. -- v. -
OFFICE OSR,dl 6 f6 OSP d l6
/ OGC l
6@P;DD l l
l NAME DWhiteh # 'SNSalomon:gd SATrebfM40 [ECCombs V
~ 09 7 /99 DATE-09/ W 09/$ /99 09r2V99 i
OSP FILE CODE: SP-AG-24 g g gg g/
7
)
e s -,-
11 D
v
/
Marie Stoeckel We have also summarized on the RATS Data Sheet our knowledge of t status of other Rhode island regulations. In the review, we noted that RATS 1994-1 and 199 1 were not reviewed 3
previously. We have determined that they meet the compatibility and alth and safety l
categories established in OSP Procedure SA-200. Please let us kno if you note any inaccuracies or have any comments on the information contained in e RATS Data Sheet.
If you have any questions regarding these comments, please cont ct me or Duncan White, Regional State Agreements Officer, Region I at (610) 337-5042 o ADW@NRC. GOV.
Thank you for your cooperation.
Sincerely, Frederick C. Combs, Deputy Director Office of, State Programs
Enclosure:
As stated
/
Distribution:
DIR RF (9-122)
DCD (SP05)
PHLohaus PDR (YES/)
SDroggitis BUsilton LBolling DSollenberger, ASPO Rhode Island File DOCUMENT NAME: G:\\SNS\\Rl9122.WP,D
- See previous concurrence.
Ta receive a cop i of this document, Indicate in the box: *C"* Copy without attachment / enclosure "E" = Copy with attachment / enclosure "N" = No co:ry OFFICE OSR;0hl6 j OSPct#l6 OGC l
NAME DWhiteM# 'SNSalomdn gd SATreby
[FCCombs 09 7 /99 DATE 09/$99 09/7//99 09/20/99
/
f:, jStephen Salesen-RERFReg Rwiew Letter
[
Pagp1]
g t.-
l. :+
l-From:
[
To:
" Stephen Salomon i-
- Date:
Thu, Sep 2,199911:49 AM
Subject:
. Re: RI Reg Review Letter.
. I concur with the letter as written.
.t
>>> Stephen Salomon 09/0211:38 AM >>>
- Duncan,
~
Thanks for your input.
This is what I am sending to Gwen now. Have you any ad ional comments? Do you concur?
Steve
)
)
l i
9 i
/
l U!
F e
O nt.)
T,SM_:rm.,7.,q..
q 4
e.
7 K
A -Ji g n $4 :;2 M
k'.'
Q 5:N
?
h d
ep
~
%~
3
.. g^* m y
3 c
f l -;
y k
m i:
'~
t D
cn
- y..
.,d yajA;' r
Q Q
_ ' ~* "jf;;. y
,:c:nua r
'.i; l g
b" JF?'l yw;a; g
s.
3 3ess 5p &
.htW;&d l
E sp.yp'77 (
se yQgO l
i r
eri.;M59 s
csj
- 0
' ;s
$h2E5.'w:jld
% $d
_.. h}{@ED wnnesww.1
.k 5*Yih[if '44? f,j
~ Uk')? d l
i t
^/
..; $~ b' *W MUM;))kj%':.':u. m._.y 3
si isfSI5t L
..____._____m-e g
pas om zs wrru brum A*'*v "
77/p /=rz. t C edd i
[, (. di G( --
.__r-o
REGULATION ASSESSMENT TRACKING SYSTEM RATS DATA SHEET State: Rhode Island Tracking Ticket Number: 9-122 2 proposed amendments (4/99) and 2 final amendments (6/95) identified by *] Date: September 22,1999 NRC Chronology identification -
FR Notice _
RATS' ID Proposed /
NRC Final
- (State Due Final-Review Regulation -
Dato)
Comment Date (Effective (Y/N)
Date)
Standards for Protection Against Radiation -
56 FR 23360 1991-3 F-N 10/16/97 2/94 Part 20 plus others (1/1/94)
Safety Requirements for Radiographic 55 FR 843 1991-1 RATSID Equipment - Part 34 (1/10/94) 1997-5 ASNT Certification of Radiographers -Part 34 56 FR 11504 1991 2 Not j
(none)
Required
- Notification of incidents - Parts 20, 30,31, 56 FR 64980 1991-4 F-N 9/22/99 6/95 34,39,40,70 (10/15/94)
- Quality Management Program and 56 FR 34104 1992-1 F-N 9/22/99 6/95 Misadministrations-Part 35 (1/27/95)
Eliminating the Recordkeeping Requirements 57 FR 45566 1992-2 Not required for Departures from Manufacturer's (none)
Instructions - Parts 30,35 Licensing and Radiation Safety Requirements 58 FR 7715 1993-2 Not for Irradiators - Part 36 (7/1/96)
Applicable Definition of Land Disposal and Waste Site 58 FR 33886 1993-3 Not QA Program - Part 61 (7/22/96)
Applicable Decommissioning Recordkeeping and 58 FR 39628 1993-1 P-N 6/3/99 License Termination: Documentation (10/25/96) i Additions [ Restricted areas and spill sites) -
Parts 30, 40 Self-Guarantee as an Additional Financial 58 FR 68726 1994 1 P-N 6/3/99 Not Mechanism - Parts 30,40, 70 59 FR 1618 required (none)
Uranium Mill Tailings Regulations:
59 FR 28220 1994-2 Not Conforming NRC Requirements to EPA (7/1/97)
Applicable Standards-Part 40 Timeliness in Decommissioning Material 59 FR 36026 1994-3 P-N 6/3/99 Facilities - Parts 30,40,70 (8/15/97)
- Preparation, Transfer for Commercial 59 FR 61767 1995-1 P-Y 6/3/99 Distribution, and Use of Byproduct Material 59 FR 65243 P-N 9/22/99 for Medical Use - Parts 30,32, 35 60 FR 322 (1/1/98)
Frequency of Medical Examinations for Use 60 FR 7900 1995-2 P-N 6/3/99 of Respiratory Protection Equipment - Part 20 (3/13/98)
Low-Level Waste Shipment Manifest 60 FR 15649 1995-3 P-N 6/3/99 Information and Reporting Parts 20,61 60 FR 25983 (3/1/98)
J Performance Requirements for Radiography 60 FR 28323 1995-4 P-N 6/3/99 Equipment - Part 34 (6/30/98)
~
l FR Notico.
[ RATS 11D Proposed /
NRC1 FinalL
- NRC Chronologyidentifloation
^,
f(State Duel Final-j Review RegulationM LDatef
- i Comment i atc h
.(Effective D
.w
- .V
=
W/NF
^
Dets):
- Radiation Protection Requirements:
60 FR 36038 1995-5 PY 6/3/99 Amended Definitions and Criteria Parts 19, (8/14/98)
P-Y 9/22/99 20 Clarification of Decommissioning Funding 60 FR 38235 1995-6 P-N 6/3/99 Requirements - Parts 30,40,70 (11/24/98)
Medical Administration of Radiation and 60 FR 48623 1995-7 P-N 6/3/99 Radioactive Materials-Parts 20,35 (10/20/98) 10 CFR Part 71: Compatibility with the 60 FR 50248 1996-1 Intemational Atomic Energy Agency - Part 71 61 FR 28724 (4/1/99)
One Time Extension of Certain Byproduct.
61 FR 1109 1996-2 Not required Source and Special Nuclear Materials (none)
Licenses - Parts 30,40,70 Termination or Transfer of Licensed 61 FR 24669 1996-3 P-N 6/3/99 Activities: Recordkeeping Requirements-(6/17/99)
Parts 20, 30, 40, 61, 70 Resolutionof DualRegulationof Airborne 61 FR 65119 1997-1 Effluents of Radioactive Materials; Clean Air (1/9/00)
Act - Part 20 Fissile Material Shipments and Exemptions -
62 FR 5907 1997-4 Not required Part 71 (none)
Recognition of Agreement State Licenses in 62 FR 1662 1997 2 Areas Under Exclusive Federal Jurisdiction (2/27/00)
Within an Agreement State - Part 150 Critoria for the Release of individuals 02 FR 4120 1997-3 P-N 6/3/99 Administered Radioactive Material -.
- (5/29/00)
Parts 20,35 Licenses for Industrial Radiography and 62 FR 28948 1997-5 P-N 6/3/99 Radiation Safety Requirements for Industrial (6/27/00)
Radiography Operations - Parts 30, 34, 71, 150 Radiological Criteria for License Termination -
62 FR 39057 1997-6 Parts 20,30,40,70 (8/20/00)
Exempt Distribution of a Radioactive Drug 62 FR 63634 1997 7 P-N 6/3/99 Containing One Microcurie of Carbon 14 (1/02/01)
Ursa - Part 30 Deliberate Misconduct by Unlicensed 63 FR 1890 1998-1 Persons - Parts 30,40,61,70,150 63 FR 13773 (2/12/01)
Self-Guarantee of Decommissioning Funding 63 FR 29535 1998-2 Not required by Nonprofit and Non-Bond-lesuing (none)
Licensees - Parts 30,40,70 License Term for Medical Use Licenses -
63 FR 31604 1998-3 Not required Part 35 (none)
f
[
s
'FR Notice _.
[ RATS ID
. Proposed /
NRC:i _
Final:l....
NRC Chronologyidentirloation Sf >
a*
sse th
[(State. Duei
_ Final-i.......
' Review :.
Regulation:-
L
- Date)1-Comment b Data h (Effective !
m '
(Y/NP Date) -
Licenses for Industrial Radiography and 63 FR 37059 1998-4 P-N 6/3/99 Radiation Safety Requirements for Industrial (7/9/01) l Radiographic Operations-Part 34 Minor Corrections, Clarifying Changes, and a 63 FR 39347 1998-5 P-N 6/3/99 Minor Policy Change-Parts 20,35,36 63 FR 45393 (10/26/01)
Transfer for Disposal and Manifests: Minor 63 FR 50127 1998-6 P-N 6/3/99 Technical Conforming Amendr. Part 20 (11/20/01) l l
l
.J
r
(
er-ry c z.-.-.
- p.......
-1..... -..
y.,
AWWD. MW!W%
q
_u,
,. +3 9 9gy
.~
v.-.
s,
, c..,n.y w 'T,'?
Q, y
~
s s
%y@nW tSTATE. PROGRAMS l OFFICE 7 RACKING SYSTEMWl(<9
?
hfWh
%OM G: %
% W'u m e & l W Y w M ly& %g Q.:& 9N @ & O l M Q'2b T M Q Q.g. % Y
&m W.m y w.W g. u*.
- ' er W.py.vmw;h v s
~\\ q &
cp w W W:Q Mmyw :.;-x:JN%y (rdhW ACTIVE' PROJ syr;;pf y un m 7
.s % fag a q :,a. w.* q ' w % w :y Q M W.
q m. y e,.;A.s. A=j p g A %,;g p : f v.4 g, e?,m %n,n n
p%w.:
.c...
An a
y o
o.;v g p
+
w a 97 4 pp a 3
....s.Q'hry%w%,;pff l lf '%nu.Ql l, p
4p ma n y + S] Q 4 = 'hh j W. Y.$W;&gCbfMWQll@%m^
e hf %.f AV4f.
W-6 4
.h l Q? f
+;
1 O'l '&
s N6 Date:
6/22/99 D W M M Rqi'yd Y 5
KgfQg %jplQ j[%'.3,_s 9.,:
A ' M&y%}gly 9r )7 y%pf, g 5 Q
r E,M.ms PengecgP; 9422--
M 1, N 4, 4, n. J Qg
- 9.,Q3 4:
u*
"an
,.t
'u. x c
w.c
- w,@nmW m* ~ % PtolecOceosDNon
Ltr to Poul Lohous from Marie Stoecket, Rhode island - Need i M[@% Q.d[JC ;
f9 i
k iMM [Qhg.
to address comments from the regulation review of Rhode p
y, eg s.,. b. land. mas.
F y. >
e-4
..y,.,-
- , f,.t; tu, wm, y...
%myg,.y -
..y
~
- x m-f I,3 y.a
+g
- }-
hw d
t
- . y. %,.' StorD., ate: '6/22/_99j c,
Os'lW' n'ed Date':?' _7/. 20. /.99
't P.' uoje'cu' se d:- WH._ITE_
l W'.%,.
Q x W y
- w-,..e~~s N
.:.. m.-
- 1.y psrvy ~ ~ m..
~' -
t-n n. -:.%nm u Duo Date:ilz.w/20/99 2#y. ;.,m i:s. e..-:rytm,,n,W py m.
w-w w-
.. f, m;f
... > CefnplSE0n Dcd,e:l: l... -. -
s 7
- M.
v.i g 2.
s f
i u
=.1 e aa
.v-a..
aa j, 3; /. - g'ggys:
)g 4,r pr. d f.t. n Ad n;s ww;; 4 y&.4 t
" %;.,t un
,v g c, wk,,
~
- , c 1
a n
m,
<?
s N
f.
. A' e ' l l,,
. k P.l N,._
y* mm's -_, ny m - -~ ~~ ~ ~~ymmm
',-. I. ESCIWGe00f/OSCO { LOhous/. O. SP..
..- _.j ?@ ?q;~myymns y;@pg x
- W.4 T.,.b M -sf
.d p
d
- M . - k h b g.,,y
- 'M6'.WM.%.--
TR%DN W-AW q
.Ty,%,.,
w w
tb le.e k e, (
5....N v,
~,
f i
N h
i.e4 5 A p,
,,, f '% w' w'c' g. y y g, y,/, ' ' ;_
c d W %
g W4( d.
'>.+ ~;> 4 4
' J " - 7.>W
<w q, M /j w ! M q'n 9 s 'V t, Ma'
,,*. d r...
u 7l"m m y, 9; ?p*y : ?;L %,'y' U 2; j d., "
- z. Qi;, f. d m
^
( g,s
- L. 7 t
i
- Ly
. mc :
i i
,(
'm.
4 y*
- p y 4 c u
< e
..i, eQ ;i Y
- p ~) ext,en000,n RSCluSSADd,:b' M EMiendlO,n Dalt:]
} M QP Q lM, y;, jj
-m-t m ', ',
wi,jgg e Q y
-w-.
--..,,., ne,,[. ~ r' c,
.,, ~,. + ~ ~,
,.y s e-..s
. og
-3 c 5 e
..s s
- gypggl g.m.w.m,J F2 ^4m>
s u.-
.I.02 O N: -l l.h FA No:.
1 Ob "
..<j
,s'
}
u.
y,. p,j, '
4 pg,.,
.m, m.
- p. n gm.p., m..4 4 yp, ;,
y< f
- p. E -
- w.w
, gt;* Y-'d'-
g
> e., a j,.. g,.
5 *
<-y e,.
3..,-g, e. f5 ' 'k,-;I;g 1
5
- 5y6
.f
,,'g.,i ~.', %"[
'?'!'#
n" ;, '+,
+
/
M.i '
4 k s;;lq,3: W't j
, 6'L s.,..
A 1
j f k e")'
I) y f / '
i13,W
.,e..
I. %
',6 s
..,g'
}
p
- w'w f
,, - e-x]
v
.p -
.e A
' U.
m 9, ;mV4 e &,. :{ #.. '
a f, c~u.. &,sv a..
c.&, wlo, &..L.h, # $- 4& ??,,s l
_-f. f.
&, f, s+>
f :.
.,3 g _,%.
a4 w.. %n, c.. -
. s.4..,
e.3ew.,
' '.s x
i.
e m ;n.
~._
r 3
Y1 i
A
,,p.
c
,,,,gsv
[ gfj(
m L sh 4'['. 7,,M, q-
y 4 i
- s. U 7+
r ja
. / E,
~---.'I
.,:f
- 1 U.+ f, x s
" 4.. ' *'. f,r O' 'y C -
'p
. J. L.- g. e f ' ) @f y [ g1*pi. Tt
]p f j' C f '
5
,ist*
m.Q,4^J
+
i t
M 4
iV D. O, s:q a
o u
6A.3L, t.,.m-
'"j,,.
'^~ ' ' ~ ~ " "
,m e.,.j'y;
,. -,../ t's W.M - 3
^?
r
- 3.
-..U%-
oy*
A bass mkas.edjeddi11:4pediebMSA.eddeMan# Eld 6as.M E#d M' iMad' h '
u v.
t 3
'L-m
^
W~
t 1
4