ML20214G871

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Summary of 771202 Meeting W/Ge Re Rev 1 to NEDO-10466, Power Generation Control Complex Design Criteria & Safety Evaluation. List of Meeting Attendees Encl
ML20214G871
Person / Time
Site: Nine Mile Point, Perry, Grand Gulf, Susquehanna, Columbia, Limerick, River Bend, Clinton, 05000000, 05000447, 05000552, Allens Creek, Skagit, Black Fox, Hartsville, Phipps Bend
Issue date: 01/11/1978
From: Pike W
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
To:
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
CON-WNP-0194, CON-WNP-194 NUDOCS 8605230002
Download: ML20214G871 (25)
v • d • e


Text

. ._

~

G .g i , '

i, JAN Il-JW} ~

3 . .

t Docnet :los. 50-352, 50-353, 50-387, 50-388, , 50-410 50-416, 50-417, 50-461, 50-462, 50-458, 50~459 50-440, 50-441, Sti-50-513, Sul-50-519, S21-50-520 S21-50-521, an}-50-552, S23-50-554, 50-522, 50-523 50-466' S21-50-556, S21-50-557, Sul-50-447 APPLICKC: General Electric FACILI':"l:. Lf crick 1, Li:aerick 2, Susg:ehanna 1, Sus-"ahmna 2, IGPSS Nuclear Project 2, Nine Mile Point 2, ,

-,",rmv' Mf 1, Grand Oulf 2, ClintOn 1, Clinten 2, River eenc 1, River Eend 2, Perry 1, Ferry 2,

, dartsville. A1, Sartsville A2, Hartsville 31, Hartsville B2, Paipps Eend 1, Phipps send 2, Skagit 1, 3kagit 2, Allens Creek, Black Fox station 1, i

i Black Fox Station 2, GES3,W Sb. DICT: SU:WulY OF DEC1BER 2,1977 ?!E::TEJG CouCERIE.'G HEEO-10466, Sev.1, "PCZR GRIEFATIOri CC.EL C3: PLEX DESIC:1 CRn'ERIA AND SAFETY EVALU.CICS" v4 :aet with representatives of General Electric cn recacter 2,1977, to discuss our review of USCC-10466, Rev.1, " Power Generation Control Cocplex Design Criteria and Safety Evaluation." A list of attancees is enclosed.

1.0 2ackgreur.d Cn Fectuary 29, 1972, we received a topical retort frca General Elec:ric (UE::O-104G6) concerning a factory-a-~~1ed arrangement of axiules,

' ter:iinals and panels for the installation of intsrconnecting wiring of ' control equi;Iaent witnin the control rocci. Otis raodularized pack:ging concept has been namec tne General clectric Power Generatica control O:c:nlex (PCCC). 22e AEC staff issued a report en June 1,1972, stating enat final conclusions concerning the adequacy of the ICCC decign would require a total review by the regulatory staff and una cc=pletien of the following activities: (1) development of separation criterion by the AEC; (2) cc=pletion of tne secaration safety guide I cy tne AEC; and (3) cc::!alation of an industry sta=iarc on separ3tica cy an IEEE wrking group. After numerous meetings with the AEC/NEC Ny tstf C4 succequently sua::itted ums10466, Rev.1, for cur review ,

on Cctccer 3, 1977. Car review of tais reviced report was the sucject Of tne .Leeting.

orrice w ove= Aess >

e 3ATEb NRC TORM 518 (9 74) NRCM 0240 W u. s. eovenmasent reenvine o,rters sore -en 8605230002 780111 PDR ADOCK 05000352 A PDR

~.. .

JAN 111978 og 9 2.0 Purcose and Sccce of the :1eetirs 2e purpcse of the taeeting was to achieve tne following:

. An exchange of infor: nation cetwen E and the NT4 staff cn NEDO-10466, itev.1.

. "Io indicate to G the additional infor=aticn necessary for the staff to ccuplete its review.

Es scope of the s:eeting included both the instrur.entation and control syste:ns and the auxiliary systems review of trcCC-10466, riev.1.

3.0 5tsiary of Meeting 3.1 Instrt:=encation ana Cbntrol systects Review 3.1.1 Cualification of electrical equi;=ent and ccmcenents.

General Electric shculd c.11 the following infor=ation to rr'~4-10456, rev. 1, :

1. An in31 cation of parts of the PGCC to be furnisced by 2 and those to ce furnished by other vencors.
2. Ccnnecter and termination devices qualification infer =ation.

G agreed to sc;;cly a ccpy of P.IL-C-5015 (Reference 4).

3. Mditional infor=stica should ce supplied concerning i=plerentation of IEF.E 32.',-74.

t

4. In section 4.2.4.2 it abould ce irdicated tnat "asscelated circuits" ::cet the sac.e requirements as Class I:: circuits.
5. In section 4.2.5.3 a clearer description of the relaticn betwen asscciated caules and Class It cables shculd be supplied.

3.1.2 Interfaces CE agreed to sucaly copies of neferances 26 and 27 ,

e.m e o.

.m ...

ne ronx sts c,. o not oz.o *w ..v..- - -mia...ms.i= -.

O JAh 11 iafd 1 ,

1 3.1.3 cliferences - B;a 4/5 vs 6 CE agreed to supply additional clarification on the differen::es

catween the Bim 4, 5, and 6 in section 6.0.

3.1.4 Typical .'tuting i

- 2 agreed to supply additional cacle rcuting infor=aticn on cables in cacinets that contain more than ene safety related divisicn.

3.2 Nuxilia_r'z_ Systems review .

3.2.1 Disclaimer of Responsioility Ceneral Electric should reacve the wrds " accuracy" and "co:pleteness" rrom tne Disclaimr of Kescensibility statament.

3.2.2 Ceneral Staff Fire Protection C::=ents on the Ifistory of fGCC

1. CE had a fixed Halen system included in the PGCC Tcpical sport of 1972. Ze currently prc csec system repcrt dcas not include suct a fire supprecsion system. STP 9.3-1, Rev.1 requires such a system. In additien aegulatcry Cuice 1.120, ouv. I rsquires unctr ficcr protection.
2. In :E::0-1046t ,ev. 1, it is stated enat no fixed fire suppression is ntwied for tM PCCC.
3. ca .iarca 2, 1977, an agreement was signed between ar. flarry
1erdon (CE) cnd
tr. Vic 3ensroys (:iEC) nich states that:
a. A :ixed, manual fire suppre:sion system will be installed in K.CC ficor sec:icas,
n. CC will investigata and recc. mend a design which will allow tha manual, local introductions of a fire suppressant into tne ficor sections.
4. Tests were to De perfor:ned to show that tre PGCC design is acceptacle to coet tne socve clauses. Oese tests were perfor:ed in May 1977. 23 tests ccnfirmed enac PCCC having Tefz.el wcuid ce acequately protected wits a timed system.

Ctnar tyca c cles croated a preolem. Z e taats wculd have been needed to qualify the unique barriers an*;wy.

099tCS D ewnwame >

e sava m NRC TORM 318 19 76) .VR O4 0240 W u. s. eovemament emmfine errics. eeve -ese e4 l

< . n -

.'. JAN 111978

5. On July 21, 1977 we had a =ceting to discuss the preliminary firdings. We reiterated enat:

a Se likelihood of accepting a PGCC withou fire detection ard suceression would be very remote unless it can be shown that none of the materials used in the PGCC will burn.

b. D e teste did not indicate that Ief:e1 doesn't curn.

Derefore, to ..aet the defense-in-depth pnilosopy, a fixed suppressica systcc is necessary.

c. . In actual practice tnere will be ec=e deviatiens frca tne configuratica used in tne test. C e grasence of ceaxial caoles, ar:cred ;cwer caoles, and tne effects of carpeting as a floor plate covering nas not been determined and we are not ready to =aka any fincings.

3.2.3 Fire Protecticn Recuirecants

1. 3;st 4/5 - a fi::ed fire suppressien systen vita automatic c;eration.
2. F.a 6 (with Tef:el inculated escle) - a fixed fire suppression system with manual cperation.
3. C stated that tneir tests Justified a fixed fire suppre=sicn system as not being nece:::ary. CE agreed to recensider tnis point in view at the staff require.Tants.

3.2.4 Section by Section Ccemnts en :CO-1046G, Pav.1 .

C:: chould .:udify each secticn as cppropriate.

Section 3.3.2.3 2e configuration of the two rignt angla clips is not clear; descriptive asterial and crawings co not cover tnis. G:: clarified the configuratica of tne clips and agreea to provide a figure.

oe.ic s

  • W o. eavsmaman, re,wvme oprica. teve -ese.ese

~

, n JAh 111978 .,

'With regard to fire tests for carpeting, GE agreed to irdily the -

report to either remove tne fire-exposure criteria or more specifically .

address underfloor-expcsure criteria. We inforced GE that we are in the process of reviewing carpeting on a generic casis, and may reje~ct carpeting in all nuclear plants as an acceptacle floor covering.

nwre may be, however, some justification to accept vinyl ascestos tile as an alternate. GE took this cosition under advisement.

Section 3.3.2.5

':he reasons for cmitting a fixed fire suppression system are not valid. Exclusive use is not made of Tefzel (or ec;uivalent) caoles.

See 6.3.1 c:xarent regarding the health na~ard.

GE's position is that a fixed fire suppression system is not appropriate for Tef::el-cased designs as shown cy their hignly cuccessful tests.

CE agreed to reevaluate the position or consicer appecling to higner NaC managecent. -

Secticn 3.3.2.6 A 'cetter s ecification or specific crands should be provided:

" fire retardant silicene ruccer" is a very general ter=. GE agreed to modify the report to ce more specific on silicene runcer specifi-caticas. ::ue to trMe restrictions, GC will not spify a manufacturer.

Section 4.2.1.1, 4.2.2 and Ap;endix 3 -

?.e everteat pessibility caly considers ner:a1 current flow, not current ficw in an electrical fault. Circuit breakers are not perfectly relisole, so overload conditicas enould be censidered.

Cu agreed to modify tna report to include overloM cerditions in the transient rangas.

Secticn 4.2.1.4b mat tire carrier tests were cenducted with ter=inatica cabinets?

No cocumentation of tnece tests is included.

cc agreed to revise the report to specify tne barrier maintenance and recair regairements.

CE also agreed to include a su:: mary of fire tests cenducted on the termination caainets and provide a copy of tne test repert.

GE stated that it was tneir po3ition that the terminatien cabinet 3 saculd c.e treated in tne same way that the other centrol reca panels will be treated for fire protection features.

orrie s >

sunname >

e eats e.

NRC FORM 51s (9 76) NRC4 0240 W w. e. eeven== sat e.,= vine oprics, sete - ae4:4

JAh 11 mio . *. -

r3

.. , . . >f Section 4.2.1.6 The topic of secaration within terminatica cabinets has not been previously considered. Ecwver, it appears tne fire risk =ay be censicerably greater tnere than in tne duct.

GE stated that divisional secaration is maintained witnin ter=ination cacinets and that there is never more than one division per bay.

Section 4.2.2, p 13, para 2 Tnere is no assurea automatic access to the location of fire in the duct just because a floor plate may ce removed. The removed -

plate may be recote fro = the point of fire not directly over it.

G agreed to enange tne word "autoc.atically "(page 13, paragraph 2) to "readily available".

An extinguishing agent will still accr nbte in the enclosed duct areas and, since IIalon 1301 is several timas as heavy as air, it will tend to remain in the duct even when a floor panel is removed.

!he Halen districution system coulo te designed to minimize losses.

ra mC staff's censultant indicated that tests wocid ce run ec.uetime in 1973 to provide cata en unat percentage of concentraticn of Halon d be surficient for deep-seated fires. IIe alto indicated that MFPA is really guidance for surface fires, and in tne

-meantiae 2 should uce a 20 mrcent cencentration to provide protection for deep-seated fires.

Section 4.2.2, p 4-14, para. 3 7.e discussions of Tef:e1 IEEE 383 test results does not inc1'd3 the test of a full tray cenducted at the same time. Infor=ation we received i:uicataa that unen tne test was recified using a tull tray, tne Tef:e1 canle curned readily.

CE agreed to codify the tnird paragraca (Page 4-14) on IEEE-333 tests to simply state that the cable meets the criteria.

Section 4.2.2, p 4-11, para 5 Tests at Sandia did not cover high resistance electrical faults whicn are anotner potential electrical ignition scurce. c.e state-cent en z.aximua pocsible loac is not 3ustified (see cements on 4.2.1.1)

G agreed to investigate a rocification to in.iicate tnat everload concitions are ccunded ay tne Scandia Mar.s.

o. rte s >

euenasse >

oatt >

.WCTORM 318 (944) NRCM 0240 t u. s. eov smaissat ..mnae ocrics. t eve - eae a.

2 .

,m )hh 1 L WO .

d Section 4.2.5 Smoke 'and toxic ccccustion gases are a concern for 2 minutes but Halon 1301 is a concern for 8 hrs. (per 6.2,1). cere seems to co an inconsistency.

V. Senaroya (IGC) ccamented that Regulatory Guice 1.78 was not appropriate for the scope of the PGCC. Since the overall control. room habitability is within the utility a!:clicant's responsibility, GE: agreed to modify tnis

, .i section to delete the 2-minute toxicity. requirement.

4 Section 6.3.1 The St Halon design is not necessarily adequate to extinguisa a deep seated fire.* 2e staterent that concentrations over 10% are not permitted in normally cccupied. areas does not apply since tne duct is not a normally occupied area. De ACGIH limit of .1% for a hcurs ex;csure to Halon 1301 is also used as a reason for limiting t.w Halon 1301 concentration. 'It is not clear whether tnic limit is cased on an 8 nour cay, 40 hour4.62963e-4 days <br />0.0111 hours <br />6.613757e-5 weeks <br />1.522e-5 months <br /> week centinuing exposure or en 8 nours ecergency exposure? Regardle s of the limit, it would apoear tne consequences of radicactive releases far outweigh a standara such as this. If tne fire is not quickly suppressed, the residual Halon 1301 will be of relatively minor significance. In addition, tne Halon 1301 wcula be concentrated in the ducts and it would be a long time before it diffused througnout the centrol roc w However, if Halon 1301 is of such a concern, there are other fire suppression agents suen as water.

A surface fire is defined as a fire in which only the outer surface of material is heated acove its ignition tecperature; comoustion would be largely in the vapor phase. A deep seated fire is defined as one in wnich cuch of the ec=custible is heated acove its auto-ignition temperature; cecbustion occurs in coth the solid a:d vacer phases. cere is no line of demarcation bet'een tne two types of i

fires. NFPA standards arbitrarily and somewnat circularly define a surface fire as one that can be completely extinguished by 5%

3alon 1301 within a scaxing time of 10 minutes. ' '

  • Se quantity of Halen 1301 or other gaseous agent required to suppress a fire decencs on tne comeustibles involved and wnether it is a surface fire or a ceep seated fire.

orric s >

sunnauc h e

D ATa b #

NRC FORM 318 (9 74 NRCM 0240 W u. s. sovsamassm? retavine orncsa sere-ese.eu l .

. +

+ *~~

JAh 111W8 m-

-8 A lialen 1301 system which would cnly extinguish surface fire is reasonable if reasonacle if either:

1. Deep seated fires will not cccur with the type'of ccmoustible material present

' or

2. ter fire cetection system will provide early warning and will actuate the Halon system before a deep seated fire can develop.

tielther of these are judged valid for cable spaces. .

Tests have shown that therneplastics in sora configurations did not procues deep seated fires, nowver, in cable fire tests glowing co2custica has been observed which is enaracceristic of a deep seated fire. In accition, rubcor base =aterials do produce a deeo seated fire; scme escle insulations are of synthetic rutcer base materials. A ceep seated fire involving a transient fire load is also pcssible.

Limited test cata indicates a 20-30% concentration of Halon 1301 is necassary to extinguisa deep seatec fire in cellulosic materials.

n.ere is no data on deep seated fires in ru=ter or polperic raterials. Although the design assumptions of tne Galen 1301 sys-taas may not be confirmed, there is experimental data to indicate that this fire extinguishing system may contain or retard a deep

- seated escle fire and any transient load fire. Fire tests in simlated aircraf t cargo ecmcart=ents have shown tnat 31/4% Halen 1301 will superess flaming coccustion and retard oeep seated ccro-testien sufficiently to keep the temperature below 400 F for accut 2 hours2.314815e-5 days <br />5.555556e-4 hours <br />3.306878e-6 weeks <br />7.61e-7 months <br />. Other tests have snown that 3-51 Halon 1301 will su gress fla:ing cc:tustion in fires involving cellulcsic =atarials although it wculd not suppresa deep seated gicwing and sac 1dering ccmoustica even witn icng scaking times.

CC agreed to investigate che percent nalen concentration and revise ene report with a more apcropriate nuccer. GE also agreed to revise the first paragrapo on Page 6-2 to indicate there is no prculem with decormcsition since the fire temperatures woi.nld in reality never reacn decompositica temperature (i.e., use the actual test results to show no proclem).

Additionally CZ will add some cocraents regarding Regulatory Guide 1.1.20 to indicate tnat the cable is capacle of being wetted down.

5ections 4.1.6 ars] 4.2.6 2.ese sections should r.e deleted because they are outside tne sc::ce of tne repcrt.

.ippendix C cae : pre ..u.aru .euysu o: ene m ricor section' snoula :e eresMeC3d srfeh rost_Janul* = In#m-7*"a suassa nes * ,

DATSW NRC PCRM 313 (9 76) NRCX 0240 W us s. novemsasse meme omesa s ore - ame .a4

I ,

. . f% ~

l JAN 11 LJ

$0 Conclusions General Electric has agreed to rescend to all the above staff u 4nts.

! Based on this agree:nent the staff will not issue formal cuestions but l instead use this caeting memry as the official transmittal of staff questions. Cn cecemoer 3,1977 CE phened to get core guidance on an ,

installed Halon suppression system. Ce staff informed GL that an l acceptanie concentration was 20% with a 20 minute soak time. W e staff i also informed GE that the GE test to be performed Friday Cececcer 9, at aerkeley, should be perfor=ed witn a tile covering installed on the flocr plate over the fire to achieve test results more closely recercling the installed system.

Odginal siened by Walter J. Pike, Project &!anager Lignt Water Reactors 3rancn i;o. 3 Civision of .'rc]ect !!anagement

Enclosure:

Attendees List cc: See next page i

t l

l 1

\ n (i

. . . . . L '. h1 l/M DSS'!1 L/A)3:BC

, _ , , , , , i$yec veenaraya oParr .

t

. . , , , Y/09/18 1/9/78 1/#d/78

v.,. m. o . . . ...... - ~ .. . . . . . - . .. _ . .._. ...

i

~~'- - . _ . . .

.. . ,m 50-522/50-523 SKAGIT NUCLEAR POWER PROJECT UNITS 1 & 2 Puget Sound Power and Light Company ATTN: Mr. J. E. Mecca, Manager Nuclear Licensing and Safety Puget Power Building Bellevue, Washington 98009 cc: Mr. F. Theodore Thomsen Perkins, Cole, Stone, Olsen & Williams 1900 Washington Building Seattle, Washington 98101 Mr. Robert Lowenstein Lowenstein, Newman, Reis

& Axelrad Suite 1214 1025 Connecticut Avenue, N. W.

Washington, D. C. 20036 Roger M. Leed, Esq.

Shroeter, Jackson, Goldmark & Bender 540 Central Building Seattle, Washington 98104 Mr. Lloyd K. Mar'et o

c/o Forelaws on Board Senator Building Portland, Oregon 97204 Mr. Nicholas D. Lewis, Chairman Energy Facility Site Evaluation Council 820 East 5th Avenue Olympia, Washington 98504 Richard M. Sandvik, Esq.

Assistant Attorney General State of Oregon Department of Justice 1133 S. W. Market Street Portland, Oregon 97201 Mr. Eugene Rosolie 732 S. W. Third Portland, Oregon 97204 e

e

. . n Tennessee Valley Authority ATIN: Mr . Godwin Wi11 f ams , Jr .

Manager of Power 830 Power Building Chattanooga, Tennessee 37401 cc: Mr. James A. Domer Tennessee Valley Authority 303 Power Building Chattanooga, Tennessee 37401 Mr . Herber t S. Sanger , Jr.

Attorney for Applicant Division of Law Tennessee Valley Authority El1B33 C-K 400 Conynerce Avenue Knoxville, Tennessee 37902 Mr. E. G. Beasley Tennessee Valley Authority W9C165 C-K 400 Conr.erce Avenue Knoxville, Tennessee 37902 Ms. Phyl1is Pierce 1913 Seaver Road Kingsport, Tennessee 37660 e

e e

--r 4-, .- -- - - - - - -- .--- --- -,--_a - , _ , , , , , , , - - - - - , . , , - . - - - ,

I -

. . n Philadelphia Electric Company cc: Troy B. Conner, Jr., Esq.

Conner, Moore & Corber 1747 Pennsylvania Avenue, N. W.

Washington, D. C. 20006 W. William Anderson, Esq.

Deputy Attorney General Room 512, Main Capitol Building ifarrisburg, Pennsylvania 17120

, Frank R. Clokey, Esq.

Special Assistant Attorney General

<oora 218, Towne House Apartments P. O. Box 2063 Imrrisburg, Pennsylvania 17105 Honorable Lawrence Cougnlin House of Representatives Congress of the United States Washington, D. C. 20515 Roger B. Reynolds, Jr. , Esq.

324 Swede Street Norristown, Pennsylvania 19401 Willard C. Hetzel, Esq.

312 Main Street Cast Greenville, Pennsylvania 18041 Lawrence Sager, Esq.

Sager & Sager Associates 45 High Street Pottstown, Pennsylvania 19464 Joseph A. Smyth Aasistant County Solicitor County of Montgomery Cour thouse Norristown, Pennsylvania 19404 Eugene J. Bradley Philadelphia Electric Company Associate General Counsel 2301 Market Street Philadelpnia, Pennsylvania 19101 ,,

Philadelphia Electric Company ATTN: Edward G. Bauer, Jr.

VP & General Counsel 2301 Market Street Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19101

  • m Illinois Power Company cc: Mr. Peter V. Fazio, Jr.

Schiff, Hardin & Waite 7200 Sears Tower .

233 South Wacker Drive Chicago, Illinois 60606 Mr. George Wuller, Licensing Coordinator Licensing Coordinator Illinois Power Company 500 South 27th Street Decatur, Illinois 62525 Illinois Power Company ATTN: Mr. L. J. Koch Vice President 500 South 27th Street Decatur, Illinois 62525 i

j

  • k.

..' ,'Ibe Cleveland Electric Illuminating Ompany Gerald Charnoff, Esq.

  • Shaw, Pittman, Potts & Trowbridge 1800 M Street,' N. W.

Washington, D. C. 20036 ,

Evelyn Stebbins, Chairman Coalition for Safe Electric Power 705 Elmwood Ibad Rocky Road, Ohio 44116 Mr. Darild B. Disbennett Acting Secretary Chio Power Siting Consission P. O. Box 1735 Coltabus, Ohio 43216 -

Donald H. Hauser, Esq.

Cleveland Electric Illtninating Company P. O. Box 5000 Cleveland, Ohio 44101 Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company ATTN: Mr. Dalwyn R. Davidson Vice President - Engineering ,

P. O. Box 5000 Cleveland, Ohio 44101 -

I 9

6 e

~

.m

,-

Alvin H. Gutterman, Esq.

Attorney for the Applicant Tennessee Valley Authority 400 Conserce Avenue Knoxville, Tennessee 37902 Mr. E. G. Beasley Tennessee Valley Authority W9C165, 400 Conserce Avenue Knoxville, Tennessee 37902 Ms. Tish Jenkins Tennessee Valley Authority 303 Power Building Chattanooga, Tennessee 37401 Mr. William Hubbard Assistunt Attorney General Supreme Court Building Nashville, Tennessee 37219 Leroy J. Ellis, III, Esq.

Omer, Ellis & Brabson Chancery Building 421 Charlotte Avenue Nashville, Tenriessee 37219 Raymond Gibbs, Esq.

111 Connerce Building -

316 West Lytle Street Murfreesboro, Tennessee 37130 Tennessee Valley Authority ATTN: Mr. Godwin Williams, Jr.

Manager of Power 830 Power Building Chattanooga, Tennessee 37401 e

. . .m

~

,, ,*)6ashington Public Power Supply System ces:

Joseph B. Nnotts, Jr., Esq. -

Debevoise Liberman 700 Shoreham Building 806 Fifteenth Street, N. W.

Washington, D. C. 20005 Richard Q. Quigley, Esq.

Washington Public Power Supply System P. O. Box 968 Richland, Washington 99352 Washington Public Power Supply System .

ATTN: Mr. Neil 0. Strand -

Managing Director 3000 George Washington Way Richland, Washington 99352 9

,m Niagara Mohawk .mer Corporation - -

ccs: -

Eugene B. Thomas, Jr.

LeBoeuf, Lamb, Leiby & MacRae .

1757 N Street, N. W.

Washington, D. C. 20036 Anthony Z. Roisman, Esq.

Roisman, Kessler & Cashdan 102515th Street, NW Washington, D. C. 20036 Mr. Richard Goldsmith Syracuse University College of Law E. I. White Hall Campus Syracuse, New York 13210 T. K. DeBoer, Director Technological Developme'.c Programs New York State Energy Office Swan Street Building Core 1 - 2nd Floor Enpire State Plazd Albany, New York 12223 Niagara Mohawk Power Corporation

. ATTN: Mr. Gerald K. Rhode Vice President - Engineering 300 Erie Boulevard West Syracuse, New York 13202

. . - ~ - . . . - - . .

n .'

Gulf States Ut. Aties Company - -

Troy B. Conner, Jr. Esq.

1747 Pennsylvania Avenue, N. W.

Washington, D. C. 20006 -

Mr . J . E. Booke r Safety and Licensing Gulf States Utilities Company P. O. Box 2951 Beaum nt, Texas 77704 Stanley Plettman, Esq.

Orgain, Bell & Tucker Beaumont Savings Building Beaumnt, Texas 77701 Karin P. Sheldon, Esq.

Sheldon, Harmon & Roisman 1025 15th Street, H. W.

Washington, D. C. 20005 William J. Guste, Jr. Esq.

Attorney General State of Louisiana P. O. Box 44005 State Capitol Baton Rouge, Louisiana 70804 ,

Richard M. Troy, Jr., Esq.

Assistant Attorney General in Charge State of Louisana Depart:nent of Justice 234 Loyola Avenue New Orleans, Inuisiarn 70112 Gulf States Utilities Canpany ATTN: S. L. Adams Senior Vice President P. O. Box 2051 Beaumont, Texas 77704 e

<m

- Ws:

Mr. P. A. Horn

  • Project Manager, ACNGS Houston Lighting & Power Company .

P. O. Box 1700 Houston, Texas 77001 R. Gordon Gooch, Esq.

Baker & Botts 1701 Pennsylvania Avenue, N. W.

Washington, D. C. 20006 Mr. John Durham -

The Houston Chronicle E Texas Avenue Houston, Texas 77002 Melbert Schwarz, Jr. Esq.

Baker & Botts 1 Shell Plaza Houston, Texas 77002 Kathleen Shea, Esq.

Iowenstein, Newman, Reis & Axelrad 1025 Connecticut Avenue, N. W.

Washington, D. C. 20036 Robert Pendergraft, Esq.

Office of the Attorney General Environmental Law Section P. O. Box 12548 Capitol Station Austin, Texas 78711 Mr. G. W. Oprea, Jr.

Group Vice President Houston Lighting & Power Company P. O. Box 1700 Houston, Texas 77001 o

5 e l

n ,

!!ichael I. Miller, Esq. Mr. Lawrence Borrell (shan, Lincoln 6 Beale Route 1, Box [97 One .st National Pliza Fairview, Oklahoma 73~M -

iuito 2600 Jiict.go, Illinois 00606 bli. Sherri I 11is 3228 Nortinest 44th Street sir. M. E. Fate, Jr. Oklahoma City, Oklahoma 7313:

Vice President - Power Public Service Company of Okhthoma Mr. John B. Axton P. O. B)x 201 P. O. Box 388 fula;, Oklahoma 74102 Coalgate, Oklahoma 7iS38

<r. Niaynard Ikanan Director Ocnerla Manager State Grant-In- Aid Clearinchon.<-

b'estern Farmers Electric Cooperative 4901 North Lincoln Boulveard P. O. Box 429 Oklahoma City, Oklahoma 73105 Anadarko, Oklahoma 73005 Mr. Tonw Dyer, Mayor Mr. Corald F. Diddle City of inola General Manager .

Inola City llall Associated Electri: Cooperative, Inc. Inola, Oklahoma 71036 P. C. Eox 754 Sprir gficid, Missouri 65801 Public Service Company of Oklahoma ATTN: fir. B. H. tiorphis R;. Cat ric Dickerson Assistant Vice President Citirens Action for Safe Fnergy, Inc. Nuclear P. O. Box 924 P. O. Box 201 Claremore, Oklahoma 74107 Tulsa, Ok1homa 74102 Ms. :lene 11. Younghcin 3)00 Cashicn Place Oklahona City, Oklahoma 73112 And::ew T. Dalton, Jr. , Esq.

2536 E. Sist Street -

lui rt, Oklahoma 74105 Wallace Byrd, M.D.

316 N. Byrd Coalga:c, Oklahoma 7438

>s. Ro')erta Ann Paris runnell

~113 lhtvey Parkway Oklahona City, Oklahoma 73118

- - ,s ,,

.e ..

fir. W. Gilbert, Manager *

~

Uafety and Standards renerel Electric Company

.75 C'itrtner Avenue ran ;<ee, California 95125 lir.1,. Gifford, Manager Hagulatory Operations Unit General Electric Company 4720 Montgomery Lane Bethesda, Maryland 20014

(;enertl Electric Company ATTN: P.r. Ivan F. Stuart, Manager Safety and Licensing Section lluclear Energy Division 175 Curtner Avenue

ian Jose, California 95114 r

9 I

e D

e y e b

e *

.s _

.s

. Pennsylvania powec and Light Company '

stTIN:' Mr. Norman W. Curtis Vice President - Engtheering and Construction 2 tiorth Ninth Street Allentown, Pennsylvania 18101 cc Mr. Earle M. Head Project Manager Pennsylvania Power & Light Company 2 North Ninth Street Idlentown, Pennsylvania 18101 Gerald Charnoff, Esq.

Shaw, Pittman, Potts, Trowbridge

& Madden

800 M Street,ti. W.

Itashington, D. C. 20036

!!r. William E. Barberich Incensing Engineer tennsylvania Power & Light Company 2 North Ninth Street Allentown, Pennsylvania 18101 lir. Robert J. Shovlin, Project flanager Susquehanna Pennsylvania Power & Light Company 2 North tainth Street Allentown, Pennsylvania 18101 ilubert Barnes, Esq.

?annsylvania Power & Light Company 101 Hamilton Street

.\1lentown, Pennsylvania 18101 Mward M. tiagel, Esquire General Counsel and Secretary Pennsylvania Power & Light Company 2 North Ninth Street

.tllentown, Pennsylvania 18101

a ..

,, * - ' Mississippi Power and Light Company cc: Mr. Robert C. Travis, Attorney Wise, Carter, Child, Steen &

Caraway P. O. Box 651 Jackson, Mississippi 39205 Troy B. Conner, Jr., Esq.

Conner, Moore & Corber 1747 Pennsylvania Avenue, N. W.

Washington, D. C. 20006 Bechtel Power Corporation ATIN: T. W. Habermas, Project Engineer Grand Gulf Nuclear Station Gaithersburg, Maryland 20760 Mississippi Power and Light Company ATTN: Mr. N. L. Stampley Vice President - Production a

P. 0. Box 1640 Jackson, Mississippi 39205 4

't

_ - . - - - . _ - - - _ . - - - . _ _ , _ - ~ _ - - - . _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ - - - . - . _-_ _ . _ - _ _ _ - . _ _ _ _ _ .

., . m, [

"s 7 ' * .,- ENCLOSURE

. i t

ATTENDEES LIST  !

.. s i

flRC  ;

P. Matthews W. LeFave i D. Thatcher l W. Pike .

V. Benoraya G. Harrison '

General Electric i R. Johnson Gage-Babcock J. Campbell PLP T. Hall J. Hanson Ebasco E.' Borelia e

e i

- . , - . , . . ~ , . , + . ~ . . . - - - - - , , - - -c------,---,--------~---e ~----------,ww c-- ------- -~~----* -'v'-*-

1

~

,. r m e

. ~

MEETING SLNMARY DISTRIBUTION Docket File NRC Particioants-NRC PDR P. Matthews Local PDR W. LeFave TIC D. Thatcher NRR Reading V. Benoraya LWR #3 File G. Harrison -

E. G. Case R. S. Boyd R. D. DeYoung .

D. B. Vassallo J. Stolz K. Kniel

0. Parr S. Varga L. Crocker D. Crutchfield F. Williams R. J. Mattson H. Denton D. Muller .

Project Manager W. Pike Attorney, ELD it. Rushbrook IE ( 3 )

ACRS (16)

L. Dreher L. Rubenstein i

.

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20214G871&oldid=3091276"