ML20211N423
| ML20211N423 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 05/24/1999 |
| From: | Boyce T NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned) |
| To: | NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned) |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 9909100189 | |
| Download: ML20211N423 (27) | |
Text
May 24, 1999 MEMORANDUM TO:
File FROM:
Thomas H. Boyce, Senior Reactor Operations Engineer inspection Program Branch (Original signed by:)
Division of Inspection Program Management Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
SUBJECT:
SUMMARY
OF MEETING WITH THE NUCLEAR ENERGY INSTITUTE REGARDING THE DEVELOPMENT OF PERFORMANCE ASSESSMENT PROCESS AND INSPECTION PROGRAM IMPROVEMENTS The NRC held a meeting with the Muclear Energy Institute (NEI) on March 23,1999, at the NRC's offices in Rockville, Maryland. The purpose of the meeting was to discuss the development of information technology requirements to support ongoing improvements to the NRC's performance assessment process and inspection program. The agenda used for the meeting is in Attachment 1 and a list of attendees is in Attachment 2. Meeting handouts are in.
John McIntyre of NEl opened the meeting by providing an overview of industry activities to develop information technology. Terry Rutledge of Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA) then discussed a TVA initiative to develop a database for industry Performance Indicators (Pis).
Tom Boyce of the NRC presented an overview of the requirements for Pls and NRC assessment reports that would be displayed on the NRC web site.
The discussion focused on the requirements for server (s) that would accept Pi data from licensees, how the server (s) would submit data to the NRC, and how the information would be displayed on the NRC's web site. Representatives from the NRC's Office of Chief Information Officer identified issues that needed to be addressed such as security and long term ownership of the database.
Attachments: 1. Agenda
- 2. List of Attendees
- 3. Meeting Handouts Distribution:
PUBLIC Central Files j
PIPB R/F F. Gillespie W. Dean M. Johnson D. Hickman T. Boyce a
Y_6O C. See, O-5A4 M. MacWilliams, O-5A4 L. Barnett, O-5A4 J. Main, 0-6E7 9909100189 990524 O 4 r1 - 1 Pj g 1 PDR REVGP ERGNUNRC PDR iH bMoh b X
DOCUMENT NAME: G:\\SECY2\\MTG0323. SUM To receive a copy of this document, indicate in the box: "C" =,C(py without enclosures "E" = Copy with enclosures "N" = No copy OFFICE PIPB: DISP M PIPB: DISP lN Pl% DISP ['
l l
NAME TBoyce A/6 MJohnson M WDeX DATE 05/ G) /99 05/ 2.T /99 DEST
/99\\
OFFICIAL RECORD COP
_ _ _ @ /F bhN N
)
e5%
g k
UNITED STATES s
j
- NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 4
WASHINGTON, D.C. 20065 4 001 May 24, 1999 MEMORAN,DUM TO:
File
. FROM:
Thomas H. Boyce, Senior Reactor Operations Engineer inspection Program Branch Division of Inspection Program Management Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
SUBJECT:
SUMMARY
OF MEETING WITH THE NUCLEAR ENERGY INSTITUTE REGARDING THE DEVELOPMENT OF PERFORMANCE ASSESSMENT PROCESS AND INSPECTION PROGRAM IMPROVEMENTS The NRC held a meeting with the Nuclear Energy Institute (NEI) on March 23,1999, at the NRC's offices in Rockville, Maryland. The purpose of the meeting was to discuss the
.- development of information technology requirements to support ongoing improvements to the
- NRC's performance assessment process and inspection program. The agenda used for the meeting is in Attachment 1 and a list of attendees is in Attachment 2. Meeting handouts are in
- Attachment 3.
John McIntyre of NEl opened the meeting by providing an overview of industry activities to develop information technology. Terry Rutledge of Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA) then d;scussed a TVA initiative to develop a database for industry Performance Indicators (Pis).
Tom Boyce of the NRC presented an overview of the requirements for Pls and NRC assessment reports that would be displayed on the NRC web site.
The discussion focused on the requirements for server (s) that would accept Pl data from i
licensees, how the server (s) would submit data to the NRC, and how the information would be i
displayed on the NRC's web site. Representatives from the NRC's Office of Chief Information Officer identified issues that needed to be addressed such as security and long term ownership l
of the database.
Attachments: 1. Agenda
- 2. List of Attendees
- 3. Meeting Handouts l
3 Performance Indicator Software March 23,1999 - 1:00pm - 3:00pm NEI / NRC Meeting Agenda 1:00 Introductions - all 1:15 Overview ofindustry activities and status of project - John McIntire, Terry Rutledge 2:00 Discussion of system requirements and process for NRC - Tom Boyce 2:30 Discussion of system timetable and next steps - all 3:00 Adjourn l
J
F Performance Indicator Software Meeting March 23,1999 - NEI Offices PARTICIPANTS i
Nuclear Energy Institute John McIntire Director, IT 202.739.8041 idm@nei. ore Phyllis Rich Sr. Dir., Info Res. 202.739.8079 omr@nei. ore Adrian Heymer Proj. Mgr.
202.739.8094 anh@nei. ore Steve Floyd Dir. Reg Reform 202.739.8078 sdf@nei. ore Tom Houghton Reg Reform 202.739.8107 th@nei. ore John Butler Proj. Mgr.
202.739.8108 ich@nei. ore Tennessee Valley Authority Terry Rutledge Nuclear Engineer 423.843.6969 tlrutledee@tva.cov Steve Reasor Information Sys.
423.751.4887 swreasor@tva.cov Russell Lee Programmer 423.751.6439 relee@tva.cov Lamont Rogers Database / Security 423.751.3769 firocers@tva.cov Nuclear Regulatory Commission Tom Boyce IT Task Force 301.415.1130 thb@nrc.cov Michael Johnson Perf. Eval. Asst.
301.415.1241 mrii@nrc.cov Conchita See Systems Analyst 301.415.1306 css @nrc.cov J
JeffMain Webmaster 301.415.6845 idm1@nrc.cov Tim Sullivan NRC/CSC 301.415.6157 tus@nrc.cov Donald Hickman NRC 301.415.8541 deh2@nre.cov David Allsopp NRC 301.415.3073 dka@nrc.cov NUSIS Dave Perky NUSIS 727.669.3041 duerkv@nus.com J
)
e 4
\\
T r
,2 I
'e s
i
=
. g-eP m
h 4
O O
0 CU cg 3
u) g CE D
D y
O Q
O *O O
6 e x '
C.
E W QS O-O r.b ' > ~C h
3 O_ t O
O g
q) u o
O CU U
_o cc ra v
D WB v3 O. D e
g q)
W
.u)
O c) w C
C m
C C
N cc ct O
O E
CU ct Q
r f 'D C
D 2
O
- ~'
W W O
O
=
_~c
~5 m
O) al.,e O_ ' V O
D q
O U) 3 cc)&'
C U)
CU CO 0) q).E
s
~
ag,,,
O ct +
g g
t-'
U)
~
(D f D @
O' O h
n 1
C O
O C
0
.-Ok3r m '@3 O
-(A mmm E
=
.f O
Q_ _C
.9 u)
Q.
D E. O-C
$E (U
N
- 4 ct B.E O
U) oc C
u) o' 3 m
cc V C0
(
(0 -~
CO
~
ct 8
2V 3
c
~C O
C C
..@ m COO 3
ct u
y G) o O 'O E +@'
D
'C G-c) a)
E S
3 0
Q)
~
u)
?
- EO C f cc tt o2 E
CU U
Q O
ZO d
i sg 8 ~8 = $ {E d 4 @-
h o_
O
.t ' V o
O cg g, O
.E m V
E O) E O
m' m o
C.c O =Q.G J
CU Q)
O to
+ --
m m-O mC Or r~
o _O O o O_
F
.E cL.E
[.E.
1
]
31 4
n7 gg er g,
m7 2
eiWl r
mmm_
a s
eY u s wUnRRVCC g
o t
n H n e
t l
m r
a o
e c p
ui m t
t in e
a i o r
v na y+ i d
7;a o
ns,-
v,"
t4 r
7:
gc.
h m-a.~
m_.
t 3c
,.s y;-
e M
y(i.
7 wN-a f.
n -.
mp mt sm~'
u; e,
n n r
r o
t t
io ei
+
e p a e
a t
y,. '
qi.
. #r mi l
ym h r r
r w
c u nJ t
t e
a i
a e
r n
t e
a e lc m=iY-
~,
nd a
s Y
,gr H
i.
o r a
MO mb u
pb;
~ :c 3
DC 1
1 g;=.
e s
yt t
y~.
s i
t e
o a
n r
t e
e e
oCS d m t
m r
r c d N n n c-o a d
t o o n g e e u pCN e
r i
y cA eii an S in t
e i
n s t
t n
k a a e t
t t
t pWWo lo S b ig n n n b c c c t
n o
a a e o o o r
oS u n o h
y PPl P WDL L T MMCCNTEC l
r 8-s
5 5
26 8 c #
'EeE5?S c
gc
.c_ob.Eu e m.c Ou e
k E. > E y5gEO-fo'mMZ"aOg$
u> GO u up o.* r o m E ne E o ~q r 'e ce m.
s me e e.
~C s m re
~O y
C U) W Z 'C.2 ; E ~O $ g r, C g)
O z E'3 m Ezrcg E,~ g o3 g',3 5 O> e E a
q; -
e-mE y
- S O '* *.E I '
o o ** O f 'C u
-Y a
E m
'C W.' m C '*C a) D a 2 u, m o. 3 a
- 0)c g.g o,~0 Q.
m'C O
e g
g o
o> -
s C ~e mG O *O c -Q.
e
.m e C e5 mO u
r-e - tt 6
E
-E O.O e'Ee u
m e
. o 3 _G Er $.S
- x> > f 3
- 2 N O
co
- ce 7
C C E
. Z,, m O m o 6 e o U => d.
m m
o
-c C
e O~
o_ g y,
g ;* 'o % O.
r.o O*C E.E' E*
' E a *B h 2 *E+m rEeEOu*5 g
-zC 5
- Ems ejD
- *C O c e O E E o e Q.'
O.*m.E V E E = 6 *> E o E C 5 z E w <C + u G Om o
- O (U
u C O o m u S m R u a a>) E o-t o
V c'
C E3 G
W O
n c
e.*
E
- o 3 n
m W
W n
G o
W 3
o G
o
.O. t o
e.*
m G.
m 3
3 G
V G
c m
~
Pi
9 _.,....
r.
. $. h. h.. b... _.
Mid 3
l'
)E 9$
5"5k ';j, s
.., j!
'{,
1 K
i
?. h"s.i
.a
. Qu.
di k
3 i
4
- ;! g y" l
titw i
hu@=
$gjl n
c, e
F
@M{,k m[-
- f]I s
E t
-ad!
i g
M Es nj d 5
$,1 l,
L r
y p
hl
'h
[M$
y q.,
1 1
- e l
k' 4
?
I j
-l t gi e
L e
g r
as j
l n,-
gli go 5
!S G'
-ph t a
O !
Il,E 2.$,,
f5 0
]
l I]f.
Ih-A l
adhyh l-y vg d.ll kn
+
~rp gi i
P f$al
" I; lk E
..a a"
a
+
M
f i i il LI e
4 i,
i a
g l II 1
i t i 1e c
I"l j
}
}
}
}
g j
n.1
! p E !l l
I f,
1
]
2 m
I
- di IE Ik i
jlllh li E
ijl u,rii (
ae
! o$
} I!
!!i li
~
e A
Ib a
T e
~a r
e t
i r
C e
c n
a a
m ro fre P
l
.b
/
- y
o
_t t
t t
i 1
c~
i s
iy_d i_i iii x
x nH a
i s a ss sss a
e e t
h n
g l,
l,
~f t
e is c Fp t
iz y
yy yyy r5 y
it i
e r
t i
l l
l l
h l
i a
i l
s uii i
it it l
it t
t u
r il l
r r
et m
pn d
d lc u
o i
cyd h
hb obb6iiibb n
o a a aa c la laaa a
_ eT o o
t s
iae m i
ino r
u lii o ia ia iaa i
r l
l l
a a a i
l r
n a
t i
r f
n r
f r 8 e
s s
v v v v v v v o u e d
d s
)
e s
h 1 s s
a a
, a a a a a t
c C p
e e i
t w ge e
n n n n n n n n r
n n c
u u e u u u u u t
t o
)
a a it mo c ppn q )s d i f a
r r
r r r r
r r
v r
r i
m ic i
t r
o l
i c
e e e e e ee e
t us 4 r p
ic qi l
e e pe e e e e t
m g
it t
o e e
f r
t r
t s
r r
r h
h h
hh h
h o
q
)
(
(
r r
p p
p a la4 e h
a h a w w d w ww w w t
e e a a p
el r
pat t
t e
e i
ss r
r g
y g
ys s d a v a o
n t
s s s s s k
le r
e e l
d r a y
e it r
n n in t
n i
inn i
n n
e a a l
n bl v
s i
si a
i a a ia a v
v 3
o n u n u a a h a
t g
h h
r le lar & s e a
s a
y l
i a
e c r
r t
r r
r r
r v
e m io eio e
t t
t t
t t
t t a
si k
t t
ich s
l a
v m v l
l r
l l
laa l
a a v a
s e e e aa a a is c h
h o 2 it l
1 e
e a
r r
r u u u
u uu u
t cc ga lp plp p d d
t e
d dd i
i d
d r
a a l
s s
t t
1 r ine i
i a
ii
- i t
l le m em e iv i
u i
h s s v v v v
v v
i i i i
i b
ts/(_i l
r i
hi h
d d
q d
dd d
d n
)s )s t
w w i
la) co l
n o
nc c n t
t e e c e 0(
a c i
r i
e i
in r
n n
n n nn n
0#
a r
ige e o r
r 4 i_i ii i
t e
s pp m c c
/
s s
e e s e e ee e
t a h 0) r igt o no h
h ahh h h h
v e S _S v
t t
t 7 _0 0
e n
t e
d 2
f i
c i
f v o e s e s f
f f
f f f
t t
l t
t t t t
h h
r 1
h h
f c
c s
s n o X0 o lo v t
f i
e m e m o o ef o oo o
v o
o e e s
g g
a s7 s d e
ey h
d y
y y
yy y
nTT a
n n m e t
t X
e a e oT r
p i
i r
d q
c rl s le t
i it r
it it i
it i
t t
t t
t i l
el i
i i i si i
i l
l l
l i
s n b
yb yi b
vb bbbb t
t 4_t e e r
a a o d t~p p
e r
r f
t r
c e n a sa s a a oa a
l l
t q
r e
r f
r f i l
l l
laaa a
a(
(
r r
v e e e s
uu o oo oa i
si i
iii t
t l
t d
d o
p p
pS la4 cl p
p a
aa a aa f(
t e e o o y
_M iyety v v n v
v v vv f
t c
f e
gia a
l
& & lu et it t
t a a e a a a aa A Ss o e r
l r i n nv n n n n n u
i fs a
i f
li u ue u u uu u
au l
bO O sR Ml f
f f
o o o b o b k laa c c laRR eCAN r
r r
la r la eef eeee e
a l
c_S RA e e e ia e ia ggo ggggg ia E_E c
e l
c c uS CRb bb b
a at a a a a a l
x x v f
f v
v r
r n
r r
r r
r a
a o o s_R S _T m m m a m a e e u e e e e e
a a t
- # u u u u
v v o v v v v v t;[
i o mm % %%
jl
- i
!nn%1jj%5l!a caa aaa
( (
n j
n jl' j[!
)
R
)
)iR n n e W
F o o c B )W W mi i
n r
t t
o
( R PB ea a a s
p m
f
(
t y
ip ic o s
oW (n n
g r
S ic it f s
_ r o
in e
o i B it lo t
t c(
int-r r
r
)
n t
n a ae ejyc e
R a
t eo io P P _P r
F n ajC m
W e i
r t
y o_l n
(
a e ee a
n t
p p
t P
i n v i
is s s mis n(
e nS c
iicM a
c u
s e
t i o G
a f
c r q e
r e etam i
r r
r o e e e A gE cm e lo r
f t
l t
a E EE R
o op a e o o a lo e x x x N
i s
CC SsR r
y r
iP uw e l//C M
P t
i t /
i r
q e e e t
l l
u g E ~d ieD R
lell r
l a
i iiS A
lo y
r r
r ea r
r r u
u ur e R
it c n
5 y
t el e in y
n t
r~F k
a C nci c
s s sC it c S onb S
e a~
n e e e e
e s s ss i
d_.
r e s r
l a
a s
s s
sf C
aiae u
r r
r mlee c e ia g ePPP o u
L t
r c
ga e e eei et e
r i
r r
t luhhEa id n
c t
n SS l
e ed d
d d
d ign n r
r iR n n n n R A l
a n
s k
e e ee S
ieuo l
d e
x umiggge e
n aiii sf e r
md a
r r
r r
as oe n e n eAEFHH H R_R pn n5 e a a a ak l
aCL ppp pis n a pP n t
n r
l c
A x
o e o i
r e
s s s n s s s s t[Sr_r ee e eR U_T E r
r s
s t
sl r
o r
a m m mr mm m m r
no C PP P
la a e r
e ie e ee e ee e
y_ P _ t t
lePPP Vt t t CFRyy yn nn n
t t
t t
t t
t e e e i R y
yy y-}S S S S S s S S s
s s s s
s s s
T c c c c T
o e
- y yyyy yy y
n n n n vvvt
- ss s e e e e a
gEEE pe i
it t t t
r r
r g
g g
iiyyyyy yyy i
ie e ie r
r r
r t t t r
r r
r t
t t t t t t t ui u u u utee eee e e_fe r
r r
e e e en nn c s c c c c f
f f f i
wa a amm r
r r
EEPPPOOSS5S}@SSLSS5SS!
f f mml laa cf e e e e a aaa aaa a
l f
B~B B(E Ei
!I j!
1 J
i!
i[i
! j SP_
)
)
) )
R R
_R U _
N W
MW 4
6 2
3 MM 3
B hB T
L R R_RAAN 1
i
(
(
(
TK(
lCC5IS i C_R AP_ERRA I
E5 FRDI Ol C S P G
P CCR i
l S S_T_O d F P 5 V~F D APPPCH CFRNEEE AAAPPPPLLL_D'DCCyCT R ADDD_TTT hEFHH-SRR RFi-A E EEE5SSSS5S_S s B B B E E_E_E P P P_R i S S 5 S 5 S S S S 5 S S g
F
t 4
4 i
1 O
~
TO O '. '
'O fCO 'O 'C"O f c 1Of C ~ O O
e Y
t
$ e v g.
e e e e e e c:e e, e
e.
e t
.. +,..
1gg g
hgg.bg$$$$$$$$$'glgI$
k l
g g
g
..a a.....a.a. s.t.g g g g g g g g a a g
4 i
.k.
.k..k..
'k O.~.~.
.~:
~;O:~:-
.- ~ ~l~. :- -:~ ~.~:~: :-
$Dw3*
>e 5
5@2.e$8$$$et 22
%EE*
o-8*E.eo*
_ o. 3. s To 'E o a oEEE$
=me cr e
2E*$ca e
.e Op'oo-8 E
St..
. cf,
D
~
O (O
u u
C g
_C O
cc
~
5 g.
~
"3 E
.$.9 V
_ E cj u
O' C 'O O
CU > ~O O ~
O C
t O
'E P t
Q O
CO e'
e. O-
-O e e O.
e o.
h 6O O
C
~s X
O-O_ G O
C u
OCOm (D
Q
.C O
cc
~
'A m.,,,
b,,
E C
3 C
O O
O (U
O 3
o w
'9==a
=
C CD w
cc 0)
D
$r0 f
CD C
5E O_ O-O C
XV
~'
m
'9==8 O_ x
.9
_C O $C yO
- de.
3 Y.e o
0) 3 3
O cc D
O 3
g O
3 oC
+.
O CT S.9 U
o
~
O.
O cc t
t-D (0.9
.t g
C O
(U
~
o
= g y
u f ~0 D
O C
O m
O 3
O.
gO
'4==s nt
' + -
u
@ b 4
^__
<C ' r m o F-O N
C cc Hu
<[
O CU o
(5 C
QC c)
~
O c
O C
m 03 C
c) 3 O).-
.r 's
'E c.g cc
.g g
.E Q--@
O O
E E
O_
t e
t G
CL oO_
O m
O u
(D EC-O_ CD 0O EbE Q-C E8 C
gO O
E +o 5
ct
~
O a
C c)
O cE mO O
- ~
Q-
.9 E E 8$
8 To jg
~E.9 C r 8
E) E _^ 22
@ 'O O
X 3
O C
O (0
>E I
O_
Lu CD O
O LL q
q
.q.
q 3
W
,C
],,
r s
t n
. j y
e
... j. t h S3
[*
h i
e r
i p--
,. m :=, ", ku
=,
t-y
. c 7
n
" e t
a.'
S
-g l
]*
P.
',m",
~
[e[p.pg
,3gyO.>: '
.. 3 g
N e
e s
P e
E 2
R r
e 9
s me tsy i
S g
{
y te fa S
p
1 C'
o t
O es d P a
ns E
ai I
b E
a e
O t
Ec l
S a )e l
/
y d r No C
M i
hB O
A An t
h D
VIc t
iwm A
TM t
i o
eT w
g f
n c
e o
n h i
m a ;a c
so e
a c
uJ s
fr r
a er f
p m
r, o
r r
t a
e t
a n
i t
s a e a
o h
n a
gm r
c r
yc i
i a a y
s oy d
r P
r r e n
t e
n m
a n
t i
pH e
e n
m m
lo n c
i e
ri t
m Ps ir u
i a n
e
- e P
v Ts c
pir a
o
- d m
o s
)
I r
r e e
d nA r
o o
o oc e
f m
o S
o i d, f
f t
r sr ay e
n t p a
mlo p
' I t
n o
h ed it is o
d rF h
c mn c
s f e n
is a
n v a
r e
n im i e r s o
f e
i t
t v
u c C
b oS n
t u
e O
qu la (s m
ed d
s t
n c
ie s
x r
t o
a R
i ap n
me s
l r
o c
s o
bs e
t ig m
u n s
r n
t t
n a
c se s
r hi i
yl l
e i
a c
o ch l
e p
es i
l r
W ay n
i t
p l
c o
n io e
r b
l u
h b t
S s a a
f t
us c
b i t s l
T be M
s loo e
is l
)
t a
n vc p
s o
s o
t r e
e nt n
p I(
k so i
m oo v
Ef M
e s p.
b i
r r
y a
- d e
lo d a i
e v
(
r n
e t
u e
d e
lu o
ae n
n el e
q sio e
re d
e ns iz h
Le m
r h
o c
h es t
n w
m e
mt p
C T
ae l
R ic im a
o r r b
g m
S l
r n
ga e
N h
u o
e P
v t
o o
is t
rF e
l wf s
s R
i a
PT d
la t
t y
no n
s w
r m
T e
e ot e
t r
hf r
v in m
S e
a o
o g o_s w
ae t
P n
c e
i f
im n
sst r
R a
t h
r r n
f ee e o
is np iu g
s I
s l
uo q
n a
vb m
b O m.e S
a mle e
it l
r s
xer P
s mv vt t
s P
i e
r RMi R
E od a
x u
h q
C e o e
p p
ta p y
lo c
ye e
a Br r B
l l
t O
a r
u i
e f
t o PsT M
C Ei S
s d
v t
t r
uI l
o e
l o P d r P
O Nic h T M
D I
c no a
c I
i f f
A a
m o
r a
o e
c T
A
e its bew
)
m C
a R
rg N
)
o r
n m
p o
a r
t s
g o
re o
li r
p d
a p
l E
o ta t
l h
lo E
e d
i
/
t k
t s
p S
C a
lo e
E M
R t
t l
s ip l
E A
N a
r r
/
D y
e o
g S
f n
A b
h M
t
(
le iz i
ly o
Q l
A m
la H
n d
b i
D t
r is u
s A
o u
f n
d a
o d
(
c a
n p
e m
i ic y
r n
m a
l it is i
r s
o o
b i
,s l
m u
b r
e f
t t
ta d
c c
e n
p a
t e
h e
i e
s e
p n
w m
o e
y id l
h a
r s
s t
c o
i t
n e
e t
e r
s S
d y
c i
n r
N d
a le e
h e
o t
s e
c O
n e
es o
n s
la I
a s
n n
t o
n t
i e
T r
n ig e
ic 0
o a
ic i
t i
C c
0 p
E 0
e a
l d
e l
i t
r r
e y
y c
R 2
r d
o ttu b
b I
/
t 1
g e
s p
e le e
D
/
n e
t
/
o in l
s r
1 iy s
S p
e ib ib a
n N
n lp e
s s
b o
e b
s s
a O
p c
r I
i e
e T
m u
l t
n t
s c
c a
e e
im c
a a
l a
c c
d P
t f
v M
s o
ie n
a s
o y
e e
e r
U s
l c
a a
b b
t t
n S
l b
e r
S l
r t
u a
d t
o ts s
c f
p n
n r
r a
a a
e u
u A
t L
o c
c c
h m
m s
f t
u s
L n
m m
m o
m m
t A
r t
g e
e e
n e
o R
is s
s s
a s
p C
t t
t t
E e
y y
y y
e R
i V
D S
S S
P S
R N
O
g M
gmM n
s lao d
cit t
t leg ley n
c d
n a n ra m
is n
t o
e e
e e e ni ni it t
l r
u yt t
m m
nn ni ce n
r g
h o c
e Pr e
p Ap oe ob et ai i
se sia r
t e a
oe u lau r r rl P
t pa sc f
r r q i q ec ee su oe d
t S
3 4
g M
gmM e
e r
c ic u n
n s
lb a
o o
e r
up sm it t
s Px e
r ce n
t y
E it a o et r t e slef pa s c l
t f
r su oe u
e f
ee 8*
f s
a ORP InQ MR 2
3 4
e S
R n
M gmM o
S n
it g
o ia la T
i d
ne o
O L
t a
is c
R R
U t
n e
a e
o p
p Sir Oul r
t t
u n
cE T s o E ce n
s c>
ot et r
r t e O
Apn R pa sc I
xo su oe d
CEC n
e n I
NiQ MR 2
3" 4
a a D
O a
P s
N I
r T
e o I
g O
m ME mM t
t X
s C
a ys E
E i
t s c n
ce b
nn C
P i
n e d a
ed o
n S
ge N P it o
n l
n P
W r r ea AE a
di o
Nir I
t p
nam I
t t
t e
mp M D ic i t ac ce n
c e
f e
T et t e a
Er O
Oi r
t f t
ri r
t s N pa sc r n P
R R Ra le oy A nQ MR 2
3 4
F IF g
r gm I
M r
E G
g mM o
R N
f e
I P
e S
P t
y g
n r y t
a T n f
ei i
k e
t o
v Sir o
ir it a
m Oce n
t t
r g e
y a e c
e r
ng et A
L aa Mpa sc r
t e i
t Bn ra I
S S
t k su oe y
n a m
InQ MR 2
3 4
C C
o e te R
R CL m
a f
u S
r S
o g
E mW o
M gmE tcae n s R
o y
im c
n tae n
o gt s
ir is e
yme ce n
t t
it y
gr I
t r e er et MS ew S
R W
r t e et lu f si pa sc mo P
H F
aya su oe iQ MR 2
3 4
n EP H
R A
SSF yO M
gmM g s nt s
n it n t
o iae n
it t
r s
e it v ce n
InE m
is et r
t e a
n pa sc r
a su oe c
r InQ MR 2
3 4
S T
,y t
ir
)
u
?
c
)
(
e w
s s
e r
t N
a s
e e
(
y t
.c s
d t
e u
n o
a i
s v
e p
e v
u r
o p
lo s
r r
g o
e r
f r
e a
s s
e t
p a
O e
t u
n
,s d
l a
sd C
s i
s l
p )s n e P
O i
t h o e
/
l n
g?
a iop gr ncC i
i c
l a
e e d n n
iR i
pr r d uoN h
r g f
l lct o c
r o
f d oo e n nh n ct e
t r a o e ei i
t
,l e
u sk s em lv s
a i
Pob o
l t
r ce t
as t u s
eb p
f l
a d
o n s e
t i
e ht mn l iod r
(
r c(
oa ain t
d a m )s a
r s
c t
w a
t e
r n ids a e
)wf pe oo ma t
r e
gu eo os f i b ne s
n s s uis os Ns e
l r s s
v e hi s
(
dn pi ss eic pm yee n
t h e dl a m aii loo r r c i
r r
pc ac oo
/g o t ul it r
sC nqt pa t f a
gA yet c
loue Em a
r s r
dini s i
l t n v sD IEf t
r t i
i am f
n sbbr ee eI
/
ah aaf mm ner S /a o
ose Mh sppt eaa an ge yns Aa t
c do ng eu l
r r
c Do b g i
is na t
a yA s sid s
u a ul n Ad t er Vi n
l t
d ma h a apnTm iym n
iC dfrC it t
t ame gb l
ios w n, d aan u b
o s
aR nlaO ni r st t
i az mdii pN at P ea o
t l
c i
f t
t n a
si t
S d
R leol u o c n, t
r a mfo si n
il uf ul r so abt sa O
dt net isg us nv c
i l
a T
oiaNe ye psl o
i a
yn ct A
Mmmhe la o pia e a l
r t
C o pi p n e r
t I
l b d iot ID Pf owo ad p
cboMin l
/ el l
i N
Szeke Cs h
l Plivr v Rn it d wio ri I
o t
t C
UDWD No w aGN s a ie e
E Rt 0
C kH4 laic p
p r
o-o-
t t N
o-le w
me tin A
le M
v v
b h l
t R
e e
E uu O
D D
N Sa F
l r
r e
o P
ne s
f h
e u
n d
i c
r a
g e
g e".
n t
u i
a dl r a t
d np n
ot f a o
il ar a
a e
dD n
s v
4s e
e s
d o
l Ew nt P
r
)
i e
e v
g e
o e
I s
et r
o i
f r
sg o
t w
si f b s
n o
p en o
d a n
o (A s
t r
eb
)h o
s b
ce i
r ue s
t i
w ct mt mo n
(C a
s l
D n
n a
I i
o i
n Me d
t r
y o
r a
m oN lp
(
e t
s r
las ym e en i
f c
i p i r sv d g x
u u
t h li i
yig e
t t
t ein e
d e
ma b u t
e s
br aq S
sd x
a au e
t s /g pe bl t
u a
L s
ar g
.f c
s o bn d
d S
n r
cW it dle i
S i
es ei e
la l
b L
a t
t v
a a S S )e d
e a wl i
/.
a it vt Srt p
mt a
im e
P s
i u
ar h
l s
af os k
y o
e r o oc t
s b
C e
s ap n a h
f iaWb e
d pe t
oy d
R a
e e
p i
r/
e N
op pH w w
e r
nl e
e sr a
t aC e
n sd eo r
r it it is ol s
r ete ef g
m s
ad pnR p
a ht sd l
I b
e c
poN s
t t im et ne P
r i
u c
d o ai it y
it t
t s
c rb a
e hd m a
m o
ici s
n t
u m
le a
i t
o et id o d
b p
l r
s yb b
a waf 7
u e
a t
md s
rt b u a
d d
it l
r o
s i
soe t
d n d
a ne y
l e
e l
a n
e a a
r e
r a
it av sef d
in v
z t
t ae t
i iu e o wbd t a ae n
q r
r v
ud di l
ol e e
s,a p
t i
g e
ei rid p
i Dh i o Pr t
l f
f I
n a
o r
da b wa a
I t
c r
e d
s t
r a en ivm b el r
f a
o r
a eh b o o
r o
oe er n u
n y
w o
d st i
Ct r
t n
s pm we w us o a l
t x
h h
d
,D i
Re c
s l
s u nTo e
sI ef Nt o
s t
t o
d 4
n l
a u e m a. e e
me a
t l i 2
c er bt h
t i
p n
ot w
mr mt b a
r i s e
t i e
d m
m n
me odld a
o
,u ed sw t
r a
r t
bi r y t
d c
se e
or a
ev ct u e
e s
e e
ah ld t
t es v
pt t r i
r t
o e
se em o p
p i
s t o u
ui es y
m ys ubw it ae S
a Sn ut c
c dt os ri h y
h o R
n o
os a c
c laf sp ly r g t
h a
a i
ar en n
n ns t
ot let o
o it t m
o i
oi n
o r i l
t b)d t
me af aa t
t t
g it a e
it e
y id e
u le lb u
di q p r
e bd De u e t
a o
at a?i r
s c
L d e i
r b
n a e bteq a
a so S
it l
r e
y vi ae e
e gt a o it o t
t v mf l
t r
f sl b
b loro mp b
t r
o o
h r
r i
l t
t a e u
e r
a u
u t
t t p c
A e
it n m ob c
s s
se od us t
f l
sh 4y u
u ur mi s
t u sp i
m ea m
m mn uo dn a
S ba epm o
ph era l
e u x I
t e
e t
i m
s e s a m
m mi ns s ;g t
t cL e
e ep u
m e
i n
e am nd c
t a,
etsM n
p b
s t
t t
t e n s
s sc t r a
n u
y ae ceT y
y yx ao c
ia i
S S
D (.
LNX S
S Se DF Lb i
i m
a r
t o
a f
D re P
1
,e rh et t f o rau s g
n qier it tse e
a eu r
e q
e t
s a,d n
p l
e O
. e c
gr y
l
. u iL et h
c
(
t u
d n
sr e
o dt s M
o-lt i
ie t
r
(
e er k
e p p n
s e
i n
e n it l
o a
e m
s c
id b
r i
t e
e e
L 5 sa w
d 3
n s
t b
C u
r t
o ud R
e p
oe N
t e
by is r
Ala n
b t
e n
p o
. s e
w ee l
i mi Pd it t
s s
C s
hd R
sb cn?
h N
ee a ae c
sw e
g a
s rda e
e h
aC oter r
f e
o t
eR c v f
ae n
lcN t
l a
d o
y ae e
cn dsh e
t y
- o b
d t e n a
l iy sbo lp e
is md e
m c
nr lat is it s
a t o s
e de 2
d ele 1 h
h c
c ala hbg p
a a
laa a n a
e t
e ut g
i r
a el t
s s
nd nbo g
a l
i i
t n
y r
d t
s n
a n
h ak ald e
c o
pui a
it l
a Co soy e
m e
n a
u e
RB dwl i
l o
Nn p
b r
r f
a h
)
i o
o c. s u
f i
t c
oi a
d t t t d t
a leet n
e e
e s a b
,l e
r R
h k m
)
s nr a e u r
o a
o p gf e
f m
e l
l t
i i
f e
s a ae i
d b
f f
i t
a en c eD d
e r
t vi y
s b
s at ev a
a y
e e
h n ba e e
lp S
w s ).
dl d gs v
s a
r P
na a
i o
C e?
l l
g u
uib h
d a "c ta R
l e
od ol a l
e o
c N
pn wn wrt i
b l
a a
i ba e
ehd w
d
(
t n
t t
t t s
u em is I
n1 P
u I
i e
p wr st s
P o/
r t
o h o h mS h
m c
u wf cp c
r c
n O
ee ae a2 P a
s a
m a
NP ER E1 R E
lP t
r a
o D
fre P
l i
m,.
89
=
4Q m
89
=
3C
=
89
=
2Q
=
89
=
1 s
Q ruo H
=
79 l
=_
a 4
c 0
it ir 1 C 7
0 E0 9
3 0,
Q IC7 x
re UP
%=
79 s
Lm 2Q a
. r TSc Sd 79 e
1 n
Q
=
na N=
lp 6
n 9
U 4Q 69 3Q 69 2Q 306 69 a
1 Q
0 0 0
a, 0 0 0 5 0 s.
5 0 4 4 3 2 0
)
10 2
89 N
4Q 89 3Q 89 2Q 89 1
Q s
=
r 7
u 9
o 4
H Q
la 1 c it 7
Ei r 9
C 3
I Q
C00 U
0, 3
7 Lr 4
7 9
e 2
.P O
Ts St t
n e
w i
7
=
s 9
n 1
a Q
rT 69 4Q 69 O
3Q 69 2O r
r 69 1
Q 0
0.
0 0
0 0
0 0
6
[2,;6 20 1
s
89 N
4Q
_h 8
9 3Q 89
_[
2Q
/
89 1
Q a
79 4Q E
V 7 9
3 s
1e Q
\\
r u
Ei
\\
I l
I a 7
CF 9
m 2
Ue Q
t Ly s
.S m
7 N
y Tt 9
e 1
Sf Q
aS
=
69 4Q 3
6 5
9
=
3 Q
I b
3 6
e 9
=
2 k
Q s
E lu 3
6 Tr 9
=
t 1
Q D
G 5 3 2 5. i 5 0 3
1 0
t
8 e
i e
e O,
7 O
.5 g
O m
3 0
e 3
E yx t
.c y
N e
e
.t e E
<a DE 8
3
- f. 8 E'
$3 8
as 5
c I
8 og c
a g~
hm k "h y
a w
Ese i
E E8f ia }
ai
- ta8x 8
a s.us;M e
c z
e gxEB-5 m
i a sn b
$h e
~
2 2
e c
8
. e R $ j.G "E
EEw f
30 met ae y
mS%gg
Bo 80 O,
E227a k G.
e IIS48<d e6 Erg z
r S' $
E m
2 to m
0 D
2 E
w<
N
j 4,
i I
DRAFT Cover Letter P_lant Y Overall Performance i
Plant Y operated in a manner that preserved public health and safety.
f i
Performance Indicators As shown on the attached Plant Issues Matrix, the performance indic i
cornerstones were in the licensee response band j
AFW system availability in the mitigation systems cornerstone o
These indicators were in the increased regulatory response band.
o N_ RC Insucction Activity and Findines The areas inspected and the inspection hours e bl d
A contributed to a loss of reactor water level inven design basis for certain postulated accident sequences.
'l The licensee has performed a root cause anal assess the licensee's root cause determination a did not identify any findings of safety significance in other cornerstone ar N_ RC Actiona There were three cited violations as fouows:one violation for i
t systems during shutdown; dh tem one violation for a design error on the DC pow di i d
e one violation and civil penalty for falsification in a surveillance report.
e Future NRC Inspection I
The NRC oversight of Plant Y will be accom m
corrective actions to reduce initiating events and improve mitigation syne impec n
/
i lations availability as well as implementation of corrective actions for the two v o I
summarized above.
E
) J
,L
(
1 m/
i 2 n
i i
ms i
im i1 im/
s1 mu m
ms m1 u/
05m m2 a1 o
n or a
f i
t n
rs i
n ed n
wn i
cu 4
i n
o n
1 pw
/
a n 1 T
e i 1 n
d n
c I
a er N9 co s i
nn 9
uf e n
U/
deg m
R.
u r
m 1
ec o
m/
E 1
T3 rn n
e 0
sa a1 W
N/
acG n
i, 1
wi e r
s I
O r
ri O-n uc u
I t
y G P8 nh n m
P i
a u
9 Uoc n 1 t
n /
,(
Y/
4 ir i 9 n
er n
2 u
E1
/u u in 0
9dH a
K/
nnn R4 i
u i
in U
m/
ii 1 n
8 T
i un r
nn o
i f
i im t
n d
u n
m e e.
m c cg n 1 ur n a /
dei m7 t
n eps a
r e
m m
s%t m
a e
n 0v u
w4l m
u a
m1 tiov m/
nt 6
n Ur e nn 3 w,n e i m
a b
n 1
r
/ o m
u u
6 pt mm1 n/
m5 mm n
namm
,3),,(
na m1
- 4
/
0 0
0 0
9 0
/
0 0
6 4
1
e h
t fo trap e
da m
e b
ton l
b.
l i
e w
w
)
s e
V M h
CI t
NP n
/
o se e
Vh it t
I -
s Lo Sn h
y t
r c
a
/ i a
t d d e e e
n u
tat r
lo r
o t
la e f
r s
o v
csi le p
h n
e b
e g
y a
r u
f d
ia t
l e
o o a h
se v
a t
t r a
r nl a
n u a e
p m
v e
oe d
e cr a
s a
e a
r n
m a
g s
a a o
la e
e r
t e a b
c p
t sb d s
y iv n
it m
e dt c nn a
M io o a a m
I t
b c
t u
r v
P e
o r
n s
s e y
)
nl e
p p
e D
P d
a t
o e ln h
s e
B t
n ir ru s a
T e cf o
in r
t o
t t
d s
n n
t in B
n o
s o
m a s dt o
i in d
e e P
s t
i d
e e m e
s en it f
t e
e e
a e
d d
s e o
n r
t e
u n
r e
e s
s la s
m g
e e
t s
le e
a l
e iu c
m ig ic t
r t
a c
s n
A c s
r n
ic q
n m
s la n
o i
L e
a t
s r ns o
i p
y f
r o
e L
e r
n e s f
r d
o e a
c R
l e
l e
o a
n e
r l
A oa s
b c
s ru r
e t
i lc o
a
/
m na b
i i
lr n m f
r s
c od, e
l n
e t
f l
a e
r B
r w
a e
e d
n M
a t
s m
e m
e l
t o I(t t
a a
s F
P e e O
ig D
f a s u
l r
t t n n
a d
P ir d n
s r
e i
t s
aI
(
d k
ll u o o
B R
e lo T
a g
is A
a t
tu d.
t f
e B e
l it t
c i
p t r a
n R
R M g
ra P
S n no d
is p
a O k
d l
N it t
/
s o
ep u
a e
n t
n C
n i
E me n
r e
u n
R o
U o
r o
f e
c p
n c
e a
h S
a r n a
iL n
i it S
ct it r
it a
F w
in a
o o
p i
f c
I n oe g
o N
pe n r
in f
e o
in fnm le R
it h
s N
a u
R o a
e is n
E u Es lA c
D t
c l
n m
S O
B is p
it b
in s
e H
o e
a e
m r
o u
ia j
c Es A
o E
E M
T c
iL P
N P
r o
s r
O AOa A
P R
A O-T C
r
.