ML20211G601
| ML20211G601 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Maine Yankee |
| Issue date: | 09/26/1997 |
| From: | Racquel Powell NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION (ADM) |
| To: | Barry D PIERCE, ATWOOD, SCRIBNER, ALLEN, SMITH & LANCASTER |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20211G606 | List: |
| References | |
| FOIA-97-154 NUDOCS 9710030116 | |
| Download: ML20211G601 (5) | |
Text
U A. fu '
- 44 HlGULAlVH T COMMtMION hht i viA hl @t at NoVM htsi R'
h FOIA - / 7 /W/
.l as, %
Q D U sie,ry~st mt RESPONLt TO FREEDOM OF xl nNat r~ l Iraatiat INFORMATIOh ACT (FOIA) REQUEST l' '"
W 26im 00( kii NuMM Hisi nr mutoes e
/
4 8
PAFIT 1.-AGENCY KYCOftDS FIE LE ASED OR NOT LOCAT ED I5w on Aed tioarst No apncy records sutyect to the request have been located No additional agency records sutyect to the request have been located Requested records are avadable through another pubhc distribution progtmm See Comments ection.
Aprity records subject to the reavest that are identified in Append.ates)
.,,,, are already available for pubhc inspection and copying at the NRC Pubhc Document Roc.
71?0 L Street, N W, Washington DC.
Agency records subject to the equest that are identshed in AppendialesL.
E are being made available for pubhc inspection and copying k,
at the NHC Pubhc Document R(,am,2120 L Street, N W., Washington, DC, m a folder under this F OI A number, The nonpropriet y version of the proposal (s) that you agreed to accept in a telephone conversation with a member of my staf f is now being made available for pubhc inspection and copymg at the NRC Pubhc Document Roum,2120 L Street, N W., Washington, DC, m a folder under this F OI A number.
Arncy records subject to the request that are identified in Append,a tesi, may be inspected and copied at the NRC Local Pubhc Document Room identified an the Comments section, Enclosed as information on how you may obtain access to and the charps for copying records located at the NHC Public Document Hoom,2120 L Street, N W. Washmgton, DC
/
Agency records subiert to the request are encloswt Flecords subject to the request have been referred to another Federal agc9cybest for review and direct response to you.
y r ees You will be billed by the NRC for fees totalmg S You will receive a refund from the NRC in the amount of $ (/
in view of N RC's response to tius request, no further action is bemg taken on appeat lettet dated
,No PART 11. A-tNF ORMATION WITHHELU F HOM PUBLrC DISCLOSURE Certain information in the reuvested records is being nithheld from public disclosure pursuant to the enemptions described in and for the reasons stated in Part li, B, C, and D. Any released portions of the documents tor which only part of the record is being withheld are being made available for public inspection and copying in the NHC Public Docurrent Hoom, ?I?O L Street. N W, Washington, DC in a folder under this FOI A number.
COMME NTS On July 15 1997: you scoped out of your request records originated by Maine Yankee or Yankee Atomic that were contained in the NRR Project Meneger's file. The remesning records contained in that file are identifed as F/5 through F/B and H/1, FEES:
/
Search - 7 3/4 hr, profewonel at $33 67 per br.
$ 227,22 gY /g^ \\.
[
Rowew 113/4 hr. profesasonal at $33,67 per br, 396.57 Dupication - 129 pages et $,20 per page
...... _25.00
$ 648,59 Advance payment
.1232001)
REFUND
$2,175,42 com oys leos Awa rusticAhoNS M HVICE S V{ Atus t oistctoR, % {i o*
- RL.- : A s
sic
%J_ -
W 'oll6 ;,
~
o
\\\\\\g%'%f;\\Q%f&
9710030116 970926 PDR FOIA BARRY97-154 PDR
,e
,w. tJh i unw RESPONSE TO FREEDOM OF s
!@ //'/
SEP 2 5 %
l INFORMATION ACT (FOIA) REQUEST g
(CONTINUATION)
PART 118-APPtlCABLE EXtMPilONS Records subject to the request that are descritied in the enclosed Appendia(e:1[4 N re being withheld in their entitety or it part uvider the e
E mornption Nols) and for the reason (s) given below pursuant to b U.S C. 652(b) and 10 CF H 9.17(a) of N RC regulations.
1 The withheld enformaten et property classited pu'euant to tascutive Decer. (f aemption il l2. ihe withse d info,n,aison oisies soie, io ihe mie.nai persunnoi rules and p.o edu es of NRC it.em,pon ei
,h. w _ _f _ a,_.os _.f.ca.,e..
..dI _ _ ds _ su..t.v.t....
c.t. m... -
Sections 141-146 of the Atomic E nergy Act, wNch proNbits the daciosues of Restricted Date of f ormedy Restricted Data (42 U S C. ?',6121661 Section 147 of the Atomac Enegy Act, which proNb.ts the disclosure of Unclassified Safer ords information (42 U $ C. 2104
- 4. The withheid eformation es a trede seceet or commercial oe financial mfoemation that is tioing mitt he6d for the reasontal and.eted. (Imemption 4)
The eformaten is creswiered to be conhdenoel t soment Ip'oprietare mformeten the mformaten is considered to be proprietssy mformation possuant to 10 Cf R 2 790tdll11 The enfurmaten was submitted and eeceived m conhrsence puesvant in 10 CFft 2 790idit7l l6. The withheld eformation consists of snievegency o' mteaagenc, rect ros that e e not svarab4e 'htough d4co e', donny hovet.on il semption 61. Appocab6e Privaepe.
D.ieber.ove e w ess D scio.a.e oi p.edec.sionai mfo,mation wouid t,3d io.nNoit ine pen and f.ns e. change of ide,a essen ei io the doisber.ove e,os e s Where records ese withheld in their entiiety. the f acts a'e inentric atu, mtertwined with the pepdecisionalirdormation The re also att no festonsbiy seJ'egatsie f adu8i portens tece ese the release of the f acts wou6d permit en mdetect enouiry mio the p'edecisional p+ot est of the agene s A ttorne y work peodut t privdege IDm umerits p# epa *evi tiv en attoency in t untempieto i of irtiu ition '
Attorney.chent priv0ege. (Cont dential communications between an ettorney and his'het thent.l 6 The withheid eto.maton is esempted bom putAc d4stiosu,e because its d4ciosuse would resuit m o clearly vaaa" anted invasion of forsonatpnvecy (t n emption (H y 7. The withhe6d informaten consists of records cornpded foe tan enforcenient purposes and is being withheid fc.s the 'essunts) erulicated (E nemption 7)
A Disclosure could reasonably be emp6cted to mtettert mth an enforcement p#oceeding betauge it couki reveal the accf* direcison. end focus of enforcement efforts, and thus could poss@y allow recip<ents to take atten to sNeld potent.at wronstoing or a teolatmn of NRC requirements from mv,,dtegators (E nemphon ? ( AH de,+sure would constitute en unmariented envasion of personal prevacy, (Emempt on ITCH The mformation consists of names of ind widuais an'I othe' i<do*mabon the d sciosu'e et wrw h c osd ' car,atuihiv be es pected to revesi i1ennbes of conhoennet sources (Enemption 7 (DH
[
PART li C-DENYING Of FICIALS Pursuant to 10 CF R 9 ?!qbl and or 9 ?$(ci e' the U $ Nac:es Regu story Comm won repanam et has been ricterm:ne<t that the mtwmaten *1th+d n e=cmpi t'o n o'o docton ur d ic!nsure. ni that its proctuct.pn p+ d u tosu*e <a conpa v to the putac nierest T he pensom respom ble for to den <ei a e t%se crc,s s edent>f ed beton as otmving otticiais and the D' rector. D1vis,c of Freedom of inf arrnsoon and Puencanon, herv.cei. OMce of Admmat st on for am oen,ais thei may be appesied to the E mecuove Dacctur far Operat'ons (f DOI l
DENY 1NG Of flCLAL Tlf LE 08 FICE I
RECORD $ DENilD I
APPELL Af t kFICIAL f
(Do
- WCRfwf
- G f
4 8
hY "J
O J$2
---y--
A - % h ew V4#
l L-l I
i l
b __
- + - _ - - - -
A i
p_
l l
l l.
i i
l PART 11. D - APPEAL R10 HTS.
The denial by each denymg off ciel idenOf.ed in Part il C may be appealed to the Appeilste 0%c+ edenol ed ttiere. Anv suct appes' m st tie inade m wr.t mg witNn 30 dava cf reca+t u
of this response. Appeats must be octdressed as appropriate, to t' e E secutrve D rector for Ope'ations. to the Secretsry of tne Commiss>on, of to the inipector Generat, V $ Nuew RQlatory Commission, Washmeton. DC 70665, and should clearly state on the envelope anti m the ietter that it is en " Appeal f<om an In't.at 501 A Decision?
N7C FORM 464 (Part 2)(191)
U S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSICN
O 4
Re: FOIA 97154 APPENDIX F RECORDS BEING RELEASED IN THElR ENTIRETY MQ.
DAIG DESCRIPTLQN((PAGE COUNT) 1.
Undated Draft memorandum from E. H. Trottier to Docket Files on Docket 50-039 (1 page) 2.
12/06/95 E-Mail from E. H. Trottier to S. Sun,
Subject:
MY Allegation Review and Assessment Status (1 page) 3, 12/18/95 Maine Yankee Allegation Review (6 pages) 4.
12/28/95 Fax from Ed Trottier to John Rogge (2 pages) 5.
Various Chronicle of Small Break LOCA Analyses.'nd ll.K.3.31 lasue for Maine Yankee (3 pages) 6.
03/16/88 Memo from P. Sears to R. Wessman,
Subject:
Summary '
Meeting Held on February 2,1988 Concerning Combus, Engineering Small Break LOCA Code (1 page) 7.
01/30/89 Letter ftom P. Sears to C. Frizzle,
Subject:
Acceptance for Referencing Topical Report YAEC-1300P, Volumes 1,2,3
'RELAP5YA: A Computer Program for Light Water Reactor System Thermal Hydraulic Analysis with attachrnents (12 pages)-
8.
02/20/89 Letter from M. Fairtile to G. Papanic,
Subject:
NUREG 0737 Item ll.K.3.31. Plant Specific Calculations to Show Compliance with 10CFR50 46 (TAC No. 48213) (2 pages) p
($ 00 f'/ A s
l Re: FolA.97154 APPENDIX G RECORDS BEING WITHHELD IN PART NO2 DAIE DESCRIPT10NF.P. AGE _C.QU NTl/E XE M PTION S 1.
12/05/95 Cover sheet (1 page release) of NRR Allegation Review Board Meeting with attached press release (1 page release), two letters.
(5 pages withheld), and an allegation summary prepared by T.
Collins (2 pages release) (4 pages) EX. 7A 2.
12/07/93 Cover sheet (1 page release) of NRR Aftegation Review Board -
Meeting with attached two lettern associated with meeting (5 pages withheld) (1 page) EX. */A I
0 Ret i.;4 97 154 APPENDIX H RECORDS BEING WITHHELD IN THEIR ENTIRETY MQ.
DAIE DESC RIPTIONt(PAGE_GQURDlEXEM P. TION S 1.
The Project Manager's, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation file (193 pages) EX. 7A 2.
12/26/95 Memo to P. F. McKee fiom C. H. Berlinger,
Subject:
Investigation Finding, Maine Yankee Containment Allegations (TAC M94194) (7 pages) EX. 7A 3.
12/13/95 Action item No. 95 228 (2 pages) EX,7A 4.
Undated Draft of two Fo mal Letters to individuals (2 pages) EX. 7A 5.
Undated Letter of Allegations (3 pages) EX. 7A 4
l '
F0WPAREQUECT a
w i:o:
JN1 i y,d(rq l! i U1 i:ec Ref!:
y 4 7, 3:
1 ATToRNLYS DAVID E. BARRY ~-
Dl" April 30,1997 207.791.2376
- s. Mart, VIA UPS OVERNIGIIT MAIL Drurrvo Pierec h " i m "
Director, Division of Freedom ofInformation and Publicahons Services Office of Administration U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington,DC 20555 Re:
Ergedom ofInformatlan Act Regucat
Dear Sir or Madam:
Pursuant to t',r twed im ofInformation Act,5 U.S.C. 552, and the Nuclear Regulatory Commiss.m np.vmenting regulations,10 C.F.R. Part 9, I hereby ecquest copies of or access to a:'.y information, including but not limited to: notes, letters, memoranda, drafts, minutes, diaries, logs, calendars, tapes, transcripts, I
summaries, interview reports, procedures, instructions, analyses, drawings, files, graphs, chart maps, photographs, agreements, handwritten notes, studies, data, notebooks, telephone messages, computations, interim and/or final reports, status reports, and any and all o'.her records or documents related to and/or generated in connection with:
- 1. The Yankee Atomic Electric Company RELAPSYA emergency core cooling system (ECCS) evaluation model,
- 3. - Three Mile Island Action items li.K.3.30 and II.K.3.31 as applied to the Maine Yankee plantt and One Monument
- 4. The 2630 MWt power uprate for the Maine Yankee plant and the 2700 port Mne 04toi uto MWt power uprate for the Maine Yankee plant.
207.
1100 9
207.791.135o r..mn inle therceAtwood mm i
6 l e Director, Division of Freedom ofInformation and Publications Services l
April 30,1997 Page 2 Pursuant to 10 C.F.R. { 9.23(b)(4)(i)(C), I specifically accept the cost involved in searching for and duplicating the information I have requested, and do not require advance notice of costs exceeding $25.
I look forward to hearing from you within the ten days required by statute.
cry truly yo. rs, sQ avid i. Barry DEB:bif n
'n
_______