ML20210A763
| ML20210A763 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Comanche Peak  |
| Issue date: | 04/03/1985 |
| From: | Noonan V NRC - COMANCHE PEAK PROJECT (TECHNICAL REVIEW TEAM) |
| To: | Bosnak R Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20210A760 | List: |
| References | |
| FOIA-85-614 NUDOCS 8512310063 | |
| Download: ML20210A763 (3) | |
Text
h.
Q ma aseo
'9, UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION n
g WASHINGTON, D. C. 20666
%...../
APR-3 1985 MEMORANDUM FOR: Robert J. Bosnak, Acting Assistant Director Components & Structures Engineering Division of Engineering FROM:
Vincent S. Noonan, Director Coinanche Peak Project
SUBJECT:
x ASSISTANCE TO COMANCHE PEAK PROJECT You are being requested to provide assistance to the Comanche Peak Project under the newly formed Engineering Group led'by Larry Shao.
You will be responsible for the following technical areas: the CYGNA review, Walsh Doyle design concerns and related sumary dispositions. Reporting to you are David Terao, John Fair, Paul Chen and Don Landers and you will be expected to manage the ~ development of their technical positions as part of the Engineering Groups ifcensing activities. If you detennine that additional resources are required, you should request such with Larry Shao's concurrence.
I recently reviewed two memoranda from Dave Teran concerni_ng discrepancies in the applicant's U-Bolt Test Results and an alleged misleading statement by the applicant regarding AWS/ASME weld design (attachments 1,2).
Since these memoranda have not been reviewed by management, I request that you review these memoranda and take appropriate action. These are my coments on each of them.
Concerning the discrepency in U-Bolt Test Results, whatever action the staff
. decides that the utility must take, should eventually be documented by the
' applicant in a revised Sumary Disposition. Our subsequent finding should then be provided in a sumary disposition.
Concerning the AWS/ASME Weld Design, it is unclear in the memorandum why this is in fact a misleading statement or why the staff should be responding to a request from CASE to look into this matter. After your review of this material, please meet *ith me and L. Shao to discuss thi.s matter further.
w In the future, any request from CASE should come directly to me for
., appropriate action.
/
~,If[6ctor e
n o
- Comanche eak Ptoject O
9 cc: See next page 1-IU [
l
~
O W53If@f af J
r t
cc:
D. Eisenhut J. P. Knight L. Shao S. Treb1 J. Scinto D. Terao J. Fair P. Chen D. Landers g
s a
s O
G e
I
(
l l
l I
s.,
4 N..,
L APR 3 195 MEMORANDUM FOR: Robert J. Bosnak, Acting Assistant Director Components & Structures Engineering Division of Engineering FROM:
Vincent.S. Noonan, Director Comanche Peak Pro.iect
SUBJECT:
ASSISTANCE TO C0PANCHE PEAK PROJECT Youiere @ing requested to provide assistance to the Comanche Peak Project unde'r the newly fomed Engineering Group led by Larry Shao.
You will be responsible for the following technical areas: the CYGNA review, Walsh Doyle design concerns and related sumary dispositions. Reporting to you are David Terao, John Fair, Paul Chen and Don Landers an.f you will be
' expected to manage the development of their technical positions as part of the Engineering Groups licensing activities.
If you determine that additional resources are required, you should request such with Larry Shao's concurrence.
-I recently reviewed two memoranda from Dave Terao concerning discrepancies in the applicant's U. Bolt Test Results and an alleged misleading statement by the applicant regarding AWS/ASME weld design (attachments 1,2).
Since these memoranda have not been reviewed by management, I request that you review these memoranda and take appropriate action.
These are my coments on each of them.
Concerning the discrepancy in U. Bolt Test Results, whatever action the staff decides that the utility must take, should eventually be documented by the applicant in a revised' Summary Disposition.
Our, subsequent finding should then be provided in a sumary disposition.
Concerning the AWS/ASME Weld Design, it is unclear in the memorandum why this is in fact a misleading statement or why the staff should be responding to a request from CASE to look into this matter. After your review of this material, please meet with me and L. Shao to discuss this matter further.
In the future, any request from CASE should come directly to me for appropriate action.
Vincent S. Noonan, Director Comanche Peak Project
,U "
0FC :C
\\)
- CPP
~ ~ '
__S3._____:_______
NAME :CPo asny
- VSNoo,n
___ ___ : _y__2 /85
..b__85 DATE :L i /,/,
/ /
y OFFICIAL RECORD COPY