ML20207T008

Partially Withheld Memo Re Response to Evaluation Memos S-F2:83-125 from Insp Rept 70-1113/83-20 Re Orifice Plate calibr,S-F2:83-134 from Insp Rept 70-1113/83-17 Re UF6 Cylinders & S-F2:84-196 Re Measurement Control Limits

ML20207T008
Person / Time
Site:	07001113
Issue date:	11/29/1984
From:	Casey Smith NRC OFFICE OF NUCLEAR MATERIAL SAFETY & SAFEGUARDS (NMSS)
To:	Mcalpine E NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION II)
Shared Package
ML20207S990	List: ML20207S989 ML20207T001 ML20207T008 ML20207T018 ML20207T025
References
FOIA-87-88 NUDOCS 8703230050
Download: ML20207T008 (8)

Text

c===-

< d t'

ib 1, o' OlSTRIBUTION:

Docket File ~- 70-1113 SGFF r/f

' 6@ n a g. ~*

SGFF s/f IMSS r/f SGFF:RLJ

• RLJackson E.11~.: CNSmith Case File /'

ESuarez

..... e..,....,_,.

. r- LICobb, IE

.....g q.1

. ......i . . . .

.. RFage, FC MCcotntaDility SEctiCn JPStohr, RII Safeguced: 6rcnch Divicien of Ercrgency Pr:[.cradness cnd i;:t: rials 5:foty Progrca, '.II FRO:': C. !!. Smith, Sc tion Clifef i:ucitsr i.:teritl Centrol

. L.icar.ri ; S.c i rues .-:.c .1. n...c. .: . S ca ortne.

tecnsir.; ..

Liviticn of 00.~cp:.rd:, :.".05 e

so.. ,,. J _ <~.~

T.1..:.v...

o v. . : r . v.. . e nn. s ns.~i~ AC.... . ..:,...

S-F2:L3 1^,.~. , S-F2:C3-10; cnd S-F2:N-072

... e-rc

. - ., .: .J. r, s -.n. 1.>c,,

o S-F2:03-125 (Inse.:::ica :.op:rt ::o. 70-1112/C5 '::')

%ne .-l Ele:tric Cr. . 'ilrin ton, ::C Suhiect - Orifice Pltte C: lit,rcticn.

Te date, cfferts to cr ca:a a r.i: stir. '.:hh 'ttiencl Cur.Hir of Stcadcrc:,

G:mercl Electric cnd ':.'.C parscnr.cl ns:ces:.ry to discuss: (1)the cnperiencs 7:in:d 170 '. ':sc of tha ::: v:1una fie.:

putt: (2)thoetct: cf cry n:t tcchnsic".y and (3) pr:vec sytto.- it:oft'it the frcc.uene.y ccli-brci: ion of the dificrantini pressur:. c:ii ci.' estt.c:nsi .lc:tronics, 6 ;i:.: nc; tscn succ::sful. '.:: rill centinu c/r efferte. to :.rr:nt the

-:.forarr.ntiened n:cesccry r.u:.tir.is tn.' e.. till n tii;- llou eSea t.;e Cq eppropricte arraigenints hcyc bcan ctic. U ,:il see:i tics, we consi.lcr y ,'~c th.

to be licta:t ad::;ucto.'s current c:librctica p occ.:u a: f r th; tyste . in quantica Df 2 [' c S-F2:03-134 (Ir.cpection P.eport i:c. 7.-1113/03-17)

General Electric Co., i:ilt.ngton, i:C h Subject - Statistically Sionificant Sr.Ds - UFgCylinders 3 ,

(10 CFR 70.57(gji3) and Section 8.2.3 - CE Fi :C Plan)

I]$V t<.4 1:c recoeni:c that, due to extenuating circumstancos, the licensee is d )p l l 2.7f

. 8703230050 870319 .., - .

"*'.m B

FOIA PDR m utis reco  ;

DAUMAN87-88 PDR .... ......... .. F d Was deleted i c

..................l....................

. . . . . .ggg, . .Ix.e.m.3

. A CIdEcel001 MW p tg@ tnuti

. . f Sc. .w. . . '

.m[ l

.....o

. . . . . . . . .p.s . . .~. . . { .

..................i................... .......... . ... ...

../0lA ,

7.Q. L.

..t....

,a ~

E. J. !;cAlpine I.: :.

rc:elt Of discussicas 1:ith the licen:c and a tcle::n bat::c "c-ien

'<-e-II's E.-itn ;'.ichtrd: :nd F eCLL': C:" Jcc!;sca en I.pril II, If.M. , ._

r h._hA3cv:0 -h:.t:

F 2, ff These particular types of ST'Ds have bc-en a long standing problea for 4 6)(

licensees ihich has not be:n resolved despite msetings bat een i'nt cnd Lf DOE personn:1.

Your suggestion th:t the DOE gaseous diffusica plants be i r:cuir:d to recor.cile st:tistically sirnificer.t SRDs on urcnica hexa-fluoride inals is c tash currcatly n:t in cur recir.:. !!e trill continue to sceh a resciutio. e.nd keep you infer. d of our efforts. -

In the meantir.:, we do not believe that the licenseo should be cited for a situatica t:hich they obviously have no control over, o

S-F2:33-103 (Inspoction Report ;o. 70-1115/03-2S)

Gencrcl Electric Co. , i:ilr.incten, :;0 Sub5cet - J.:c:rr :uat C:,r. rci Lic.its ct tb 0.05 cnd 0.031 Levels of Significance for Individer.1 Sttndctd liccsure..:nts (10 CFF. 70.57(L)(11) and Sectica 4.5.1 - GE F;U:0 Plan)

The natt:.r has cpparently been resolved as e consequence of the neeting held in t.tlanta (.:.agion II office) July 10, 1934, between GE, Region II and 53 !:2 dqu:rtors p rsonnel as evidenced by the resultant corresp:n-dan:e b:tt::n Cagien II and GE-!!ilr.ingtca (:icierence CE'c letter to J. P. D'.i.ailly dated t.u;u:t 29,102 cad J. Philip Stohr's response to GE dated 0:t:,hr 1,190'). i.s r;e enderstr.nd the situation, GE has ct.r:cd ta iigie:.unt systca cad procedural ravisicas by i:ovcabar 30,1904, t:hich trill s:tisfy the concerns e:: pressed in the cbove refercnced Region II doceP.:ntS .

In this instance, we feel no furth2r cc:m:nt on our part is needed restrding the contants of your Evaluaticr. i'amo S-F2:03-195. lle trust future inspection efforts, in regards to the subject stated in this memo-randua, vill lead to the conclusion that GE has taken the necessary corrective actions.

I CASEf,................. ...... .......... .. .............. . . .. ................ . . ................... ........ .. . .. ... . .. .. .

-*r'%ew 1.e iae* . oew**,-

n r r- e r* e a e r e r *== A r=s .=s s== ^ m a ^ * - " *

.c 4-.n E. J. IIcAlpine -h F-F2:0:-072 (Insps: tic:a F.e::crt iia:. 70-1112/00-22(nd70-1112/04-0-)

. .. :c.. Ei:.:cric C:.,1:ii:incten. Z 5/dect - D:ic:;ccicri ci *:2ccura:1:nt Control Functitt.s (10 CFR 70.58(b)(2), Section 1.7.4 - GE FiC:C Plan and i-05A Revieu Criteria Section 4.5.2)

Tiie licensea's procedures as described in the above referenced docu cnts, ts uall as our ! 0U. Pevieu Critoria, will be reviewed for consistency in recards to the intent of 10 CFR 70.5S(b)(2).

Dis tetion shot:ld b2 cc:'icted during this fisecl yecr.

/s/

. C. i!. Suith, Sectica Chief l:eclect ! teric1 Centrol Liccaring Section Fv;l Fccility SG Licensing Drcnch n > ..

m

.. .. e . . e ...

...c.c..........,

. . ..~.oe Closes: 07001113B10M, 07001113B30M 07001113880M, 07001113B90M t

c,. ,

q.......s

' .S G F F '. . . . . 1. . . . .S G f./. {'. . } . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

j +c... i s. . p.C. .li . 'g',. .......

.g .} .... .. ........

ci l, .R..LJ..a..c.k..s.o.n.

.b i

es c! 'I .11../.?..../.84

........ . ..11/{

. . .i./ 84

.=: - . au m ao e:, oc. ::.c OFFICIAL RECORD COPY f '5 "3 :" 2-"

yh

. E- uG:=:N_

o '

71 K.

u LE & Y

,- r a a s - .

f t

b Y

) , ) [,

a 1

'1

/ -

Vm C & ) .L 4 4 asx' V

M:s .

l

%:& I l h -

l ,g6 .

4' I

% w .

information in this record was deleted in accordance with th,g Freedom of information pg Act, exemptions - +.s .

F0lA- %9-%y j /[f[t t

Y

• e w-4- Y d .

y.g;*s,%

y

\

,r, O

t 1 u

t lettu

e, 8

% 2.=. % a. w s

=.

Y

~

~"~

YJ '

), a, _ s, g

\

4 f

e,

$oi

/

S-f f

i i

Ae --

i t/e(n

SCHEDULE FOR RAY J ACKSON' S ( NRC) VISIT TO NFMD

'2 ' . '

Tuesday, January 29, 1985 9:00 am m _^

{

p ] Overview ML Fa ri s ' ML Faris .__ ,' C Office DJ Kemppainen

\ [u /

-~

SW Dal~e

} 1 CM Vaughan I

/ GR Mallett

/

)' ,f RL Bruce DW Browri 3 9:30 am

• /

DJ Kemppainen A

~ SW Dale U GR Mallett RL Bruce )

DW Brown 12:00 Lunch Bldg J CM Vaughan Con f Room DJ Kemppainen ML Faris SW Dale GR Mallett RL Bruce DW Brown f

1:00 pm Discussion or , Bldg J CM Vaughan '

) Conf Room GR Mallett RL Bruce

) DJ Kemppainen SW Dale DW Brown

)

Wednesday, Janua ry 30, 1985 m _ /;

L--- V 8:30 am Discussion )V R Mallett's GR Mallett Office RL Bruce o 12/28/84 FNMCP PN Denison Submittal hl

)

o S/R Difference Letter

)

o IAEA o Limit of Error -

741 Forms f

3:00 pm Closeout Meeting ) JE Bergman's Conf Room WW McMahon (

RA Petelinkar JE Bergman ML Faris i

CM Vaug han DJ Kemppainen SW Dale GR Mallett nformationIin his record was deleted RL Bruce in accordand with t reedo ofIn!OrnQWorBrown Act, exempli ins / g}

F01A- '

N 7-N

• g,

N ' ,, ?" P * * ,

.< ,s .

e

.s < m, . . g ), 3.,

. , . v.

s . , ;. :

.m... - npg ys :.

n eia  ! ,

7 s

i k i <

l f

I' D

\

e l l

1

?

8/15/85  :

b , ( f l":E,*if , q a1 -

5' l'El$UINI)[lgif!fj]qp 2.f l